In this Artist Exploration, Merri Sugarman from Tara Rubin Casting and MTCA Director, Charlie Murphy discuss: How does a Casting Director has with Producer. How do build a relationship with a Casting Director. What makes a Casting Director bring an actor into the room... Read More
From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast
Featured Shows
About
In this Artist Exploration, Merri Sugarman from Tara Rubin Casting and MTCA Director, Charlie Murphy discuss:
- How does a Casting Director has with Producer
- How do build a relationship with a Casting Director
- What makes a Casting Director bring an actor into the room
- How to become a reader
To purchase Merri’s book visit: From Craft to Career: A Casting Director’s Guide for the Actor- Available April 20, 2023
Looking to hear more about MTCA? Join us on February 27th, 2023 from 8pm-9pm for the JUNIOR WORKSHOP, rsvp HERE!
Just want to get started with MTCA? Join us on March 18th and 19th, 2023 for Junior Weekend! More information HERE!
Want to get yourself some MTCA Swag? Get your MERCH here!
If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.
Follow Us!
Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition
YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)
TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions
Charlie Murphy:@charmur7
Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014
About MTCA:
Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.
About Charlie Murphy:
Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.
With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.
This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.
[0:19] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, director of MTCA, that's Musical Theater College Auditions. And today we have a well-cast show lined up for you.
[0:29] Charlie Murphy: Merri Sugarman from Tara Rubin Casting is on the show today and was a true delight to chat with. And I think really helpful to hear from a casting director who's done so much Broadway specifically as Merri does, given how many of our listeners are interested in musical theater. So I think you're really gonna enjoy.
[0:57] Charlie Murphy: Not a ton of housekeeping before the show, except, of course, to remind everyone about our upcoming junior workshop, which for our alumni listeners, please let any junior or sophomore or freshman or younger friends of yours know about it. It's this coming Monday, February 27th, from 8 p.m. to 9 p.m. Eastern. It is free and a great chance to get to know MTCA a little bit for those who have not yet met us.
[1:21] Charlie Murphy: And if you're already MTCA, I just want to make sure you haven't confused this with junior workshop with junior weekend, which is an easy mistake to make. But that junior weekend, that's March 18th and 19th, and is held both online and in person in New York City. An excellent stepping stone in your process toward preparing you for our faculty masterclasses, all leading to your pre-screens and your live auditions in the next year.
[1:44] Charlie Murphy: At Junior Weekend, you'll be working a song and monologue on your feet and getting individual feedback as well as dancing and hanging out in an informational meeting with me and Leo and one of our college advisors. That is not free, but also is available via our show notes or on our website, and that is a steal at any price at junior weekend, that is.
[2:02] Charlie Murphy: And for our MTCA alumni, have you all bought your merch yet? I posted a video of Solvi in an MTCA bucket hat on social media. And somehow it did better than my content, that is just me, or my content trying to sell people something. Social media is a strange, strange place.
[2:19] Charlie Murphy: Well, that's it. Let's dive into the interview with Merri Sugarman.
[2:29] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited and honored to be joined by Merri Sugarman. Uh Merri's at BFA in musical theater from Emerson College. She was initially an actress in tours of shows like Les Miserables, Aspects of Love, both with the great Ann L. Nathan, friend of the pod and MTCA coach. Um, then she's done so much wonderful casting. Um she was with Lieberman Hirschfeld, I'm sure you'll pronounce better than I just did, um, where she worked on shows such as News Radio, The Larry Sanders Show, and then Dreamworks, where she worked on shows like Spin City.
[3:02] Charlie Murphy: She's director of casting for dramas and movies at ABC, where she did stuff like Alias, NYPD Blue, and now with Tara Rubin, where there are just too many credits to name Tara Rubin casting, but Broadway shows like Ain't Too Proud and The Band's Visit and La Miz and Phantom of the Opera and Cats. I will tell you, all of these shows may come up a little relevantly in the game, Merri, as we move on later and play the game of what you've cast and not cast, God forbid. Um, Merri also wrote a book, much of the content of which I think we'll talk about today, which is called From Craft to Career, and it'll be available via link in the show notes. Uh, and we're gonna try to move some digital paper today. Merri, how are you doing? Welcome on the pod.
[3:40] Merri Sugarman: I'm good, I'm excited. I'm a little nervous.
[3:44] Charlie Murphy: Did you feel good about that condensing of your bio? I had to cut about 90% of your bio. But do you feel good with what got in? Is there anything else you'd want to be like, oh, but you I would have wanted you to talk about this?
[3:52] Merri Sugarman: No, no, you did great. I will say it's Lieberman Hirschfeld. Thank you. But now you know, and yeah, I actually think you did a pretty good job.
[4:01] Charlie Murphy: Well, thank you. I'll take pretty good. That's normally about as good as it gets for me. Um, let me ask the question that I start everyone off with, which is just to take me back a little bit to yourself around 16, 17 when we're often meeting MTCA students, and just thinking about like if you had been at the time precocious enough to have like a mission statement for what you wanted your college experience to be. So, what you were looking for in a school as you applied to schools, kind of what was that, and then how did that end up connecting or changing over the course of college and then your early career to see sort of where your career ended up veering?
[4:32] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, it's interesting because when I was doing it, there wasn't such a thing as showcase, so that wasn't anything that was on the table for me as far as a reason to make any decisions. Um, you know, there were an equal amount of schools where you had to audition to get into the program versus having to audition each year in order to stay in the program.
[4:56] Merri Sugarman: Like a cut program is what you're describing, a much feared cut programs. Yes. Um, you know, I know now they have both of those as well. And I think there are even some schools where you get into the program via audition, but you then have to audition for your showcase. Um that stuff was actually not on my mind. I did audition for a bunch of schools. I did like a full tour with my parents, Carnegie Mellon, Cincinnati Conservatory, you know, Cincinnati Conservatory of Music, Emerson, Boston Conservatory, NYU and quite a few others.
[5:33] Merri Sugarman: And oddly, the one that was probably the least state of the art, um, and the most sort of old school, even for that time was Emerson. And that was where I wound up, one of the schools that I wound up getting into where I just felt most at home. Um, I didn't have the language for it then, but now I know that that had to do with really what was right for me as an individual, and that knowing that that was the kind of environment that I was gonna thrive in, um, and not necessarily one of those other places.
[6:10] Merri Sugarman: My parents were sort of like this place, really, because it just was less impressive in general, right? Than you know, the other schools that maybe were a little more moneyed and a lot bigger. Um, but yeah, it was good that I sort of followed my heart.
[6:27] Charlie Murphy: I love that you're giving me, you know, it's a very modern take on the modern mean the past five to ten years, take on the process, not only in terms of numbers of schools. So many of our guests who are, you know, 31, 32 were like you're not that far away. We're like, I did three schools with all right, come on, that's not how you do the process. And but I also love that you're talking about the nuance of finding the school that was the right fit for you, right? Getting into multiple schools and deciding what's right. That's certainly a big thing that we advise on the MTCA side of things. Um, but I'd love to hear about so what was your Emerson experience like? Obviously, now we would call that a much more academic BFA than the average BFA. There's more academics than you would get at a Carnegie Mellon.
[7:02] Charlie Murphy: Um, and we have a wonderful Eric Weiss on to talk about Emerson specifically. Um, but how did that hit what you were looking for? And I'd love to then talk. I know you might not immediately in school have been known you were gonna go into casting, but did any of the Emerson training experience uh um influence what ended up being your casting experience?
[7:19] Merri Sugarman: I think that what Emerson prepared me for was knowing that whatever, wherever I wound up, I was gonna need to be sort of an expert in interpersonal communications. That's really what that school gave me. I mean, their BFA program was fantastic at the time and it still is, but um it was a much more uh although I concentrated, you know, uh on musical theater and acting the whole time. Um there were requirements then that I don't think exist anymore that kind of prepared me for life in general in a way that made that experience worth it.
[7:59] Charlie Murphy: Um tell me a little bit now. So as you graduate, what was the transition from acting to casting like, right? Was it one of those things that felt like it was always inevitable? Was it a hard-fought battle with your performer self to kind of relinquish that first part of the hyphens? I mean, so many of our students we know will end up not being only actors, they will be actors and, and some of them will be the other thing, will be the and and not the actors anymore, right? How did that journey go for yourself as you turned into actors slash casting director and then casting director?
[8:26] Merri Sugarman: Casting was not on my radar at all. Um I, you know, I was kind of born dancing and singing and acting, and it never occurred to me that I would do anything else. I um uh like I said, I went to college and as soon as I got out, I I I got the Les Mis tour pretty quickly. It was it was but quickly, you know, to me was two and a half years later, and I think to other people that wouldn't be so quick.
[8:55] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, that's quickly, yeah. But I was working, you know, as a non-equity actor, and then it was much harder once I got my card. Um I got my card doing uh an apprenticeship at the Burt Reynolds Dinner Theater in Jupiter, Florida. And uh I got the Les Mis tour pretty quickly after that.
[9:14] Merri Sugarman: Um I came home for a year. I went like right back to waiting tables because not one to rest on my laurels, and I wanted to make sure that I kept some money saved. And then pretty quickly after that, I got the Aspects of Love Tour, which just a little bit of trivia, I did not do with Ann L. Nathan.
[9:32] Merri Sugarman: I replaced Ann L. Nathan. You stepped into these beautiful, well-worn shoes of Ann L. Nathan. I stepped into the humongoid shoes of Ann L. Nathan. Um, and by the way, not as well.
[9:44] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, trust me. She's out of the office. And then, you know, Aspects uh was a tour that brought me to Los Angeles where, you know, it whereas in New York you can audition every day for something. In LA, it's a very different ball game. And that is not anything that's changed from then till now.
[10:02] Merri Sugarman: Um, but you know, as an actor, you're always kind of like, should I go to New York? Should I go to LA? Should I try Chicago? Um, and I was really interested in checking out film and television, at least, even though my background was in theater. And basically what happened was I was in the ensemble of that show and I was covering a lead, and I went on, and there was an agent there that night who got in touch with me and said, you know, if you want to live out here, I'd be interested in representing you.
[10:30] Merri Sugarman: And so it took me a little while to make that decision, but I did eventually move out to LA to give that a shot. I did pretty well in voiceovers. I booked a couple of like guest spots on some, you know, small TV shows, um, small parts on TV shows.
[10:47] Merri Sugarman: And um, you know, when I was hostessing and, you know, uh I I kind of had to start at least thinking about the fact that even though I was kind of a working actor, I wasn't happy. And that's a red flag for sure.
[11:01] Merri Sugarman: And um a really close friend of mine from college called me. He was uh line producing a sitcom at the time called Grace Under Fire and he said hey the company that casts my show is looking for an assistant. I know you're feeling a little at sea and maybe this is something that you'd be good at.
[11:23] Merri Sugarman: And I didn't even think twice because at the time it was like there's an opportunity you take it. Like you'll decide what comes of it later. But um I I took it and I kind of fell into that job. I got really lucky and um and I kind of never looked back.
[11:41] Merri Sugarman: I didn't miss acting for one second. I was not a very good auditioner. Uh I I didn't have access to that kind of vulnerability that it takes to have your job be to audition which is basically the case when you're not working as an actor and um I really loved this there was something creative about it that also appealed to my sense of you know administrative skills and organizational skills and and all of that.
[12:14] Merri Sugarman: So that's really how it happened. I I I love that you you talk about you know auditioning versus acting. I think some so many people who are so good at acting and what it is to be in a rehearsal room and work on a role, it's like, but are you actually good at the auditioning part of it? Because that is your job until you get the job. So you get famous enough that you're getting you know straight offers. But I I also think you know, it's something that you said that we often chat about um with our musical theater students, especially when they're thinking about musical theater school, is like the allure of LA almost certainly is gonna the allure of TV and film, I should say, almost certainly is gonna come up at some point because you're gonna reach a point when you want to make sustainable money, and unless you're in a Broadway show all the time, it's really hard to make a sustainable career in this business only doing theater if you're not also doing some TV, some film, doing some some other places.
[12:59] Merri Sugarman: That's where the bigger dollars often are. So at some point in your life, you're almost everyone's gonna reckon with maybe I want to be on TV, maybe I want to be in a film as opposed to just doing theater. I mean, that's where that's true. That's where the money is, but it's not true that the film and television auditions or work is so much more like concentrated in LA anymore.
[13:24] Charlie Murphy: Right.
[13:24] Merri Sugarman: There's just way too much going on here and in Minneapolis and in Chicago, and in absolute oh my god, Atlanta's huge, huge. Totally. Well, and we'll talk about self-tapes too, because you can kind of live a lot of different places often and do. I mean, I you know, I'm with my partner auditions all the time on self-tapes, and very little is in LA. I mean, in terms that she's auditioning for, but she's auditioning everywhere else in Toronto in Atlanta, and of course, New York, plenty of stuff films. So, yeah, total.
[13:51] Um, can we just take a little step back and just talk a little bit about what the role of a casting director is? So, what is your job as you see it? Um, you know, on a day-to-day basis. I mean, the short answer is I serve a creative team by putting talent in the room for them to decide whether they're the right people to tell the story that they want to tell. That's the very simple version of it.
[14:19] You know, the shepherding process that starts from the pre-screen and then goes to the studio test and the network test, if we're talking about television or the final callbacks. You know, that's a really long process with many different steps. And I'm really the only one who's there right from the beginning of it.
[14:42] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh. And can we talk through a little bit? I mean, I we'll get maybe a little more granular in the second half as we dive into some advice stuff, but just in terms of how that works on a large scale in different media. So what it's like in terms of a casting director through a TV process, through a film process, and then especially we haven't heard as much on the podcast about how it works in the Broadway process. Some of the actors have talked about, oh, and then I went to a final callback, but it seems like it works pretty differently in the Broadway world. So how does it work? Maybe especially with ABC, with DreamWorks, with Tara Rubin in terms of the different experiences of working with you and going from a first meeting to booking the role.
[15:17] Merri Sugarman: I mean, the biggest difference is that with film and television, sorry, not with film, but with television, the director has nothing to do with the audition. Um, it's the producers and the writers, and that basically starts the same way any audition does with what pretty much all casting directors call a pre-screen, um, whether it's via self-tape, whether now it's live but via Zoom, or whether it's actually in a room.
[15:43] Um you get material to read, you go in, you read it, hopefully, you get some feedback and some adjustments from the people in the room who are usually with television, the associate team, the line producer, who's the person who kind of really really runs the show, is sometimes also a writer. Um, the executive producers who are often the writers of the show, and then somebody from the studio or the network, depending on how big a role it is. I'm talking about guest star parts now. A series regular is like sort of a different ball game with a couple of added steps and work sessions.
[16:28] Um yeah, I mean, those are the people guest star. What is the role of a studio executive in that room? Are they just there overseeing? Are they voting on things that they're saying, hey, this is better for the brand of our network? I think she's really cute. Or what are they throwing in there, you know, in terms of their two sets?
[16:47] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, so that's an interesting question because the role of an executive casting director at a studio has a lot to do with the needs of the studio slash network. Those are the people who are funding the television show, and those people need to be really aware of what it is that's lacking, what the edict is that's come down from on high, where somebody says, you know, like I worked with JJ Abrams at ABC, he was just pitching lost, and we were working on alias together, and you know, to have to go to the really creative people and say, Hey, I see why you like that actor, but the reason we're spending a billion dollars to make your pilot is because you promised that that character would be relatable to men in the Bible belt between the ages of 35 and 55, and that guy doesn't speak to them.
[17:44] Right? So you can rob from Peter to pay Paul and have that actor, but then you need to change the trajectory of this other character to fulfill our needs because you have a contract with us, right? So that stuff is so interesting, I think, to hear from an actor perspective, but also frustrating because it's like, how do I use that information as an actor of like, how do I appeal more to certain men in the Bible belt? Like sometimes we'll talk that way to be like, like sometimes I'll give the advice of like, okay, but I think because it's a TV show, you need to be more likable. Like it's like, so you kind of can give a little thought or a little um toward that, but it feels like most of that stuff is really beyond our control of the case.
[18:21] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, no, I'll tell you exactly how to use that information. You admit you're powerless over it, and that frees you up to do your work.
[18:32] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, right. You know that everybody's gonna see you and make decisions and have emotions through different eyes, and they're never gonna have exactly the same reaction. And so spending any time trying to figure out what it is that anybody wants is really wasteful when it's like, oh, I have an audition today, I get to act. Let me make some bold, vivid choices here and show them what I bring to the table. You're never gonna be right, even if like you think you are, because there's never a unanimous thing behind the table where everybody wants the same thing or interprets things the same way.
[19:10] Totally. Um, can we talk a little bit about the dreaded self tape? What you've called the the pre screen, especially. Obviously, not new in the pandemic, but how has it shifted in the past couple years? How has it shifted your job and how has it changed maybe an actor's responsibility in the past couple of years of the increase of self-tapes?
[19:28] Merri Sugarman: Um how do I want to put this? There has always been the self-tape. I understand that it's newer for theater actors. Um, but you know, people have been self-taping long before the pandemic as a part of their initial audition. Um I think a lot of people are super hung up and spending a lot of money on super fancy equipment, and really all you need is, you know, a blank background with a color that makes your face pop and some decent lighting. You know, that's truly all you need, right? If we can see you and we can hear you, it's all good. I don't really want to see your unmade bed in the background.
[20:10] Charlie Murphy: This is a made bed, Mary.
[20:11] Merri Sugarman: This is a good idea. Your bed is made, Charlie. I knew you were gonna say something. But you know what I mean? Like, I think I get so many questions. I know that there's so much anxiety around this, and the bottom line is that it doesn't change what you should be doing or the acting choices you should be making. You might want to reframe something if you're gonna belt out a big old song. But I sort of feel like if you're a good actor and you're telling the truth, then you're making smart decisions and taking risks, and you do exactly the same thing in the room as you do for the camera.
[20:47] Charlie Murphy: I love it. All right, let's take a very short and early break because I want to get into a nice long nitty-gritty of a bunch of questions about casting that might be specific to our young actor. So we're gonna pay a couple bills with the ads, and we'll be right back.
[21:02] Charlie Murphy: All right, we are back with the wonderful Merri Sugarman. We've been talking a lot of nonsense on the break, and we're gonna try to bring that wonderful nonsense energy into the second half of the show. Um, I just want to talk a little bit about um the casting director's relationship with a young actor, and especially from the actor's perspective, what that looks like. With so many of our students being young, right? Maybe they're about to start college, they're in college or just out of college. How does that relationship begin on your end?
[21:28] Right? Obviously, with everyone listening to the podcast, they've already begun their relationship with you and somewhat, and they're gonna read your book and they're gonna begin and continue that relationship. But how do they come onto your radar most often as a young person?
[21:41] Merri Sugarman: I mean, it's kind of my job as much as it is theirs to get them onto my radar. So there's a lot of different ways to go. Mostly it's about trying to at least watch a few minutes of anything that is streaming, anything that's on prime time, going to showcases, going to plays as much as I possibly can, trying to do things that are a little off the beaten path. When I travel, I try and see something, you know, that's in the city where I'm traveling. Um, and I try and keep track of, you know, all of these workshops too, because I find that, you know, the teen workshops and um especially now, especially with the volume of work that's being written for teens and you know, actors in their 20s, the spring awakenings and the rents and the you know, all of those things that are so popular right now, that's kind of where it starts.
[22:41] So there's usually like space in between us um physically, and a lot of times I have a relationship with actors that the actors have no idea about.
[22:53] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh. Well, and when we taste attending showcases, so you kind of mentioned in your consideration of school, you know, there wasn't really that that idea of a showcase yet, or you weren't worried about which showcases are attended. Now I think a lot of um students kind of worry about, well, now so many schools have showcases. Which showcases actually get attended by which people. So what does it look like? You don't have to tell me all the exact specific ones that you do, but how many showcases do you attend? What kinds of are you going to the same schools again and again? Are you mixing it up? How what is your relationship with attending showcases for people who are right out of school?
[23:26] Merri Sugarman: I mean, there's uh, you know, the pandemic notwithstanding, there's like 11 of us at the office. So every single person doesn't go to every single showcase. Right. Usually as a senior casting director at Tara's office, I'll say, like, this is what I want to attend, this is what I would like to attend. It doesn't keep anybody else from going either. And, you know, those are the usual suspects, but I really try to make it my business to go to ones that are sort of off the beaten path, right? That aren't necessarily on the tips of people's tongues.
[23:58] But I will say that um I think a lot of people showcase long before they're ready to showcase. Um, and I think what nobody's really talking about is how many people get agents and you know, get dropped a year and a half later.
[24:13] Uh-huh. Or um my fear about showcasing is that senior year comes and you've spent like four years with these people and they're your family and they know everything about you and you've gone through so much with them, and then everybody just kind of stops learning and gets panicked about showcase and they kind of start looking around and people suddenly become your competition and stuff gets really awkward.
[24:39] Merri Sugarman: And I I think that there's a little too much emphasis put on the success of you know your showcase and and what that means. That said, I I do see them as sort of a necessary, you know, evil to my business. Of course I want to find people who nobody else has seen or heard of yet. You know, of course I want to um know what's out there and who's in a situation where they're ready, or who's in a situation where they're really raw, but maybe they're ready for this, but not for that. Or do you know what I mean? There's just so many new young actors to see and be aware of.
[25:25] And um casting directors go because so many people don't, or one of the reasons because so many people won't get agents. Like I could really care less if you have an agent or not.
[25:37] Merri Sugarman: It's not like only the talented people have representation. So if I know that you exist, I'll find you. I don't have to go through an agent. You know, the great thing about managers and agents, obviously, is that they're gonna know about stuff that the actor's not gonna know about, and hopefully they're gonna really shepherd your career and care about you know what you want to accomplish as an actor.
[26:02] Merri Sugarman: What if you are one of those 22-year-olds, maybe a young 22-year-old who graduates, does a showcase, and maybe wasn't totally ready to be seen by the world? And so you got you saw me, you got an impression it wasn't the thing that I wanted to show. Now I'm 25 and I'm kind of in a different place. I've grown, I've matured. I've done some shows regionally, and I go, Oh, I really feel like I now am ready to be seen by you. How does that 25, 26-year-old listener, how do they get on your radar now, newly again, if they're not yet on a prime time TV show or that kind of thing? How do they get found by you?
[26:34] Merri Sugarman: I mean, that happens the same way that it happens with every actor that's doing the work that they should be doing. That happens by creating your own work and inviting industry people to see it. It happens, especially with musical theater people by showing up at EPAs and chorus calls. It happens by putting yourself in classes where you can keep an ear to the ground and be around people of your same ilk. It happens by nurturing relationships with people that you have, you know, have the good fortune to meet who might be able to help you in another time. And you know, let's be clear like not being ready isn't the same thing as not being good. You know, good casting directors don't dismiss somebody who's not ready.
They go, ah, not ready. Let me keep an eye on this person for a year or two years. Do you know what I mean? Um, so the audition process in general, especially from showcase on, has to be about building that foundation. And I feel really strongly about, you know, knowing that that's what the auditions are actually for, even a little bit more so than booking.
[27:42] Charlie Murphy: Yep, totally. Well, and I want to talk about that relationship and building that relationship because I'm maybe it's helpful almost to jump to the place that everybody wants to get to, which is, you know, when I was told Leo, uh, our director, when I told him, you know, I'm having Mary on, he's like, Oh my god, I love Mary, she's casting me in so many things, she's the best. And it sounded like he was talking about his best friend, right? And I think a lot of young actors will notice that professionals will talk about casting directors like they're their friends, but it seems this like mystifying thing when you're 22 of being like this intimidating presence. How do I get to that place where like I'm besties? And maybe it's not ever truly besties for some people, but for some people it is. And Nathan is one of your best friends. How do you get to that place where you are um where you have that kind of a relationship with a casting director?
[28:26] Merri Sugarman: Yeah. How do you think it usually comes, I mean, it's not like I love Leo and I love his work, but he's also been in my room as an actor many, many, many times. And we have gone through an audition process together that it ceases to be strictly professional because acting is so personal, right? So as you sort of shepherd somebody through an audition process, you get to know people. You share things about yourself. Um, I think then, you know, the rest kind of speaks to personality. I'm somebody who's always gonna be pretty forthcoming about my own experiences because that's how I direct. And I think it's how um I help actors get where they need to be as far as you know, experience, as far as the choices that they're gonna make.
Other casting directors, not so much, and that's not a bad thing. You know, certain people decide to give of themselves in a way that other people aren't comfortable with. But I will say that I think that, like I mentioned before, your inner personal communication skills and your personality has a lot to do with creating a room that's warm and allows actors to do their best work because of that.
[29:46] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh. Yep, totally. Well, what what about when you first meet an actor? Let's say maybe it's a showcase or maybe it is a first audition. Now you're bringing them in. You know, what are you sniffing for as you're watching them work? And you know, maybe you'd say, This, they're a little too young, they're not ready here. Maybe they're a little green or whatever it is in terms of that. But what is the thing that would make you go, oh, I do want to bring them in? Or I am this person really is talented. What is the thing that, you know, from your perspective, that's kind of checking off those boxes for you?
[30:14] Merri Sugarman: Yeah. I mean, as far as young actors go, like I said before, of course I want to be the person where you know the director looks down the table at me and is like, oh my God, where did you find her? Great fun. We get that everybody has to start somewhere. We don't expect you to all come in with fully formed resumes at 22. Not only is it not possible, but nobody really cares about that. What I'm looking for is what I mentioned before is your readiness, how you talk to your accompanist, how you enter a room, how much thought you've put into what you're wearing, are you warmed up, and most importantly, your active listening skills? You know, if somebody isn't um doesn't have a huge body of work, that's different than somebody not being ready, right? And it's clear when somebody is ready to take that next step. They'll you'll learn on the job. That's not, you know, ever an issue. The issue is can that person take an adjustment?
[31:13] Merri Sugarman: And when you say active listening skills, is it more about in that like interview process with the director? Or is it more in the scene itself that you're seeing their active listening?
[31:21] Merri Sugarman: All of it. All of it. You know, what choices are you make based on what you're getting from your reader? You've been rehearsing something one way for a month, and now somebody behind the table says that doesn't work, please change it and do this instead. You know, many, many people aren't capable of that.
[31:40] Charlie Murphy: Totally. And how how often when when you bring a young actor in, how often are you looking just to kind of meet them and see how they are in the room versus really testing them for a specific project? Are you often just giving them a shot? Or is it because you're saying, hey, I think you're actually going to book this specific musical that I'm working on?
[31:56] Merri Sugarman: It's one and the same. I want to give them a shot, but it's very rarely general. Uh-huh. It is always for this project, even if you're saying, but I'm also interested in meeting you. Yes, and um, I do want to say that, you know, look, uh in New York, the beauty is that you can audition every day of your life if you want to. I will say that I do have a lot of um time for people who show up and who do their work. And sometimes non-equity people come to an equity call and they can't get slotted in and they leave a picture and resume. And then I might say to my assistant, hey, let's take two hours before we start auditions on Wednesday and bring these people in who left their pictures at the EPA who I didn't have a chance to see.
They look kind of interesting. I don't want to like leave any stones unturned. If they're not right for this, maybe they'll be right for something else. And I just ask them to come in and sing their own thing or do their own monologue or yeah.
[32:55] Charlie Murphy: That's awesome. I love that. Um, listeners to this pod will have very often gotten the advice to be a reader. And certainly I've said that before. Many guests have said, do it. How do you feel about young actors volunteering to be readers for you? How do they get those jobs?
[33:06] Merri Sugarman: I often sort of talk about it's not always so easy just to be like, Can I get into Terra Rubin and be a reader? But but talk to me about how does that happen, you know, to whereas you find your reader. Our readers go through a pretty rigorous, like non-disclosure situation. We all have to kind of have a feeling that this is somebody who can be trusted, that nothing will leave the room. Um, we like to use readers that um are sort of tried and true. So we usually try out readers at pre-screens. And then once we start using readers with the teams, we know which readers our directors and our music directors and people on the teams producers like. Different people are more right for different projects.
I very rarely use a musical theater person or anyone who could be up for the thing that I'm actually auditioning for because then it's weird and a conflict of interests. So I usually positioning while they read. It's like I kind of but I will say, you know, there are quite a few readers who have gotten jobs because the director went, he's great. Why can't we cast him? Um, you know, and um I try and cast the reader, like somebody who feels like they get the rhythm and can breathe the air of what it is that I'm auditioning for. You can certainly let me know that that's something that you're interested in. Um, and if it feels right, you know, chances are we would call you and give it a shot and see if it works out. Um, but I do find that while it has to be an actor because I need somebody good to be a reader, um I I try and stay away from the genre that I'm auditioning for when I'm choosing my reader.
[34:55] Charlie Murphy: Totally makes sense. Well, and and you're talking about let me know that you're interested in being a reader. That sort of gets to the next question of like, you know, actors also often get the advice, keep in touch, you know, keep everyone abreast of what's going on. And it's kind of their job to get into your inbox and stay fresh on your mind, right? How do you prefer that actors do that? And maybe I'm gonna say, how often do you prefer that you know to be contacted if if an actor were to you know just keep you up to date on what's happening in my world?
[35:10] Merri Sugarman: This is different for everybody by the way so it kind of behooves the actor to sort of keep track of what is what is best for each person unfortunately like and that's not about being you know princess y that's about you know what works for us as far as how is it actually going to be productive and effective that you're keeping in touch nobody wants to be in my inbox like trust me it is a hot mess in there and you just sort of get lost in the sauce um normally I would say a postcard like via snail mail like with your picture on it and all that but at the moment um that's a little more challenging because the lack of brick and mortar offices since the pandemic um for me I've been getting um correspondence through act from actors via our website you know and that's just a smart way to do things I understand that a lot of actors do things that feel like they get no response they get no feedback everything feels like it's going into a void you never know if somebody's getting something you're certainly can't they can't be expecting like a response um but everything gets forwarded to us through our website on a daily basis by the person who is checking it um and for me every eight weeks like every two months um is great and the more consistent, you know, the better.
If it's every two months for a year, that's great. But what happens like two years later? You know, and every single time, hey, we met at such and such a class, I sang blah blah blah. Just because there's only one of me and there's a lot of actors, and um, you know, the consistency allows us to go, oh yeah, oh yeah, oh, I'm so glad this came now because now I have something for them.
[37:16] Merri Sugarman: Uh-huh. Um, and I need help remembering everybody. And that's not about, you know, being like mean or cold, that's just about like math. You know, there's only so much that a person can remember, and the more consistently somebody gets put in the forefront of your brain, the better.
[37:34] Charlie Murphy: And do you mind if, you know, obviously it's great if they're saying, hey, I'm just about to do this cool um work that I put up, or I'm about to be saying it 54 below. But do you mind if they're sending you a thing that's also like, here's some cute pictures of me and my child or whatever? Like, does it need to be how how much would you want that to stay a really this is professional information versus sometimes I'll see actors' newsletters where it's really into the personal or into other projects that aren't actors?
[37:57] Merri Sugarman: That is what kind of stuff do you want? That's a mistake. You got to keep this business. You know, if you have any question about it, just ask what would you talk about at a job interview, right? If a person asks you about your kids or asks you to see pictures, that's a different story. Part of your story is going to be personal, but to just write for the sole purpose of saying, here's pictures of my kids, what I'd much rather hear is, you know, sometimes you're not gonna have something to invite me to, right?
[38:25] Merri Sugarman: Sometimes you're not gonna have anything particular to say, then you get to say the truth. You get to say, hey, just wanted to remind you that I'm out here. I know that you're casting blah, blah, blah. I hope you'll think of it for me.
[38:37] Charlie Murphy: Right. And you'll and would would you want them to say, I'm, you know, I'm in class, I'm in what kind of stuff would, you know, something that is professional, or would it just say it's just as simple as, hey, I want to be in Legally Blonde?
[38:44] Merri Sugarman: It's I think I'm great for it. And that's it. Yeah, I hope that you'll think of me. Or I mean, I think it should be polite. I think it should be in full sentences, and I think it should be able to fit on a post-it.
[38:55] Charlie Murphy: Fight on a post-it.
[38:56] Merri Sugarman: I love it. Um, all right, let's do just a little general advice. So, what's something that you rarely see in auditions that you really like when actors do? Is there something that somebody walks in the room and you go, uh, why do more actors not do that?
[39:08] Merri Sugarman: I feel very strongly about this, and I think the biggest issue is with younger actors, and that is your choice making. I feel like the only thing anybody's asking you to do to prepare is to have a point of view and be an actor. And you should know that what I'm thinking about is based on what you just did in my room. Would I ask somebody to pay $220 to watch it for two and a half hours?
[39:34] Charlie Murphy: Right.
[39:35] Merri Sugarman: So I think that even though maybe they're not thinking of it consciously like this, I think that a lot of young actors think, I think I'm gonna try and show that I do a lot of things kind of well, and then let her decide sort of what category I go in. But being non-specific just kind of makes me think you're a bad actor.
[39:56] Charlie Murphy: And the fear of being so specific that that's what you think I'm gonna think of you, and maybe that's gonna be limiting is kind of a falsehood.
[40:06] Merri Sugarman: Because if you're so specific and it's so wrong or off the mark, but truthful, all I'm gonna think is, oh, that person's a good actor, but that is so far from what I need. Let me see if we can make an adjustment, or just really not gonna be right for this, but I have to make sure to see them for blinkety blank.
[40:23] Charlie Murphy: That's such good advice.
[40:24] Merri Sugarman: Yes, it's not what they want to hear. They wanted to hear wear a certain kind of shirt, but it's great advice.
[40:28] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, sorry, nobody really cares about that.
[40:31] Merri Sugarman: Um, is there anything on the converse? Is there anything that you really bothers you that you know, uh just is there kind of red flag when you see an actor walk in the room and do X?
[40:40] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, for me, too much kibbitzing, too much extra stuff going on with the bags and the sides not being in order and the things and the phone ringing and the clothes needing adjust. Like, I just need you to be there in time to settle and focus yourself so that when you walk in the room, all of that is taken care of, and all you have to do is concentrate on telling the story.
[41:07] Charlie Murphy: I get concerned when somebody's like super flustered, and you know I know that there's a certain amount of nervousness that's unavoidable.
[41:18] Merri Sugarman: Um, but I do think that there's a way to walk into the room that's gonna give us confidence that you're ready to do the job. How are you talking to your accompanist?
[41:32] Merri Sugarman: If you do 16 bars for me and I say, you know what, let's do the whole song, and you say, Oh, I don't have the whole song, like amateur hour. You know what I mean?
[41:41] Merri Sugarman: Um, it's little things like that that sound like, you know, kind of bitchy, but like I don't mean it that way. I just mean like these are the things for young actors that make me go, that person is ready. That person has to be.
[41:58] Merri Sugarman: Oh, they're not ready. They're not, they're not at this place where they're I'm gonna pass them on to the next level. Or they haven't had a very good education if they don't know that they need to know the entire song. It's like doing a monologue without reading the play, you know, or having the play with you, or having a cut that is the full song, or you know, you should know how to be prepared for a professional situation now.
[42:21] Charlie Murphy: So true.
[42:21] Merri Sugarman: Um, let's talk a little bit, maybe to some quick hitters on self-tapes. Um I'll we can do some general advice too, but I have a couple specific questions about the self-tape that I know people that come up.
[42:31] Charlie Murphy: Um, you know, people often ask about like, how do I slate in a self-tape? Meaning, like, should I kind of be in character? If if I'm auditioning for like a cocky villain role, should I come in and kind of be like, hey, I'm Charlie Murphy? Or is it okay if I come and I'm like, hi, I'm Charlie, it's so nice to meet you all. And then I do the audition. Like, how do you feel about the slate in a self-tape?
[42:50] Merri Sugarman: I think it's smart to always be intimating the world of what it is that you're auditioning for. That is not a rule. Somebody else might say something totally different.
[43:01] Merri Sugarman: Um, but I think that it doesn't mean you come in, you know, slating with an accent if you're supposed to be speaking with an accent, or but I think rhythmically and pace-wise and how you're moving and all of that, even though it goes by in like six seconds, um, it is a moment for us to just sort of see a little bit of who you are.
[43:28] Merri Sugarman: So is this person really warm? Or they uh or are they um you know getting right down to business or whatever it is that you know is like a characteristic of the role that you're auditioning for, but without like, you know, doing doing a triple tour or you know in your slate. You know what I mean?
[43:50] Charlie Murphy: Totally.
[43:50] Merri Sugarman: What about like dress? So, you know, if if actors have maybe gotten the advice that you might like subtly suggest your character walking into the room, but you're not gonna be in full costume. Do you feel like does that shift at all for self-tapes? Like are you are you more excited about a seeing more uh someone in character or dressed in character for a self-tape, or is it still the idea of a subtle suggestion?
[44:11] Merri Sugarman: Subtle suggestion.
[44:13] Charlie Murphy: Great answer.
[44:14] Merri Sugarman: But but I do want to just say, like, important that you think about the carriage, right? The as a guy, Charlie, you know that you carry yourself differently if you're in dress pants and shoes and a sport coat versus flip-flops and cargo shorts, right?
[44:35] Merri Sugarman: So those are the things that you can actually can control that might just help you feel a little more part of the world. So without making it the end all be all, you know, if I don't care if you come in wearing something that you know intimates the world of the play or not for me, I care about it for you.
[44:53] Merri Sugarman: Whatever you can do to help yourself. But if I throw on a lab coat and I'm playing a doctor, is that gonna bother you? Is that how would you feel?
[45:00] Charlie Murphy: I think that's a bit much.
[45:02] Merri Sugarman: Yeah.
[45:03] Charlie Murphy: How do you feel about a prop, especially when people are at home? Sometimes they're like, I've got the phone right here.
[45:07] Merri Sugarman: Not no props for Mary. You don't need to come into like Pearl Studios and light a cigarette and hold an umbrella and take out your phone.
[45:14] Merri Sugarman: No, no, I only mean for self-tapes of going, you know, if you've got the stuff right there, how do you feel about someone using a wine glass?
[45:21] Merri Sugarman: I don't have a problem with that. I think that's that's different in person than it is via self tape.
[45:28] Merri Sugarman: But I will say, like, those are bits. You gotta call them what they are. If it helps you intimate the world of it, that's great, but there has to be a beginning, middle, and end.
[45:37] Merri Sugarman: And it has to be specific. You're not gonna get cast just because of the clipboard you're using or whatever.
[45:41] Charlie Murphy: For sure not.
[45:44] Merri Sugarman: All right, Mary, are we ready for our dumb game?
[45:47] Charlie Murphy: We've been anticipating.
[45:48] Merri Sugarman: I was scared of it a little bit.
[45:50] Charlie Murphy: It's scary.
[45:50] Merri Sugarman: Uh you're not wrong to be scared. I think it's good.
[45:52] Charlie Murphy: We're calling this game Casting a Wide MTCA net.
[45:56] Merri Sugarman: So you or at least your office has cast many amazing Broadway shows, including many MTCA coaches and Mapping the College Audition guests. I'm gonna try to name the show and some fun fact about the person to varying degrees of difficulty, and we'll see if you could name the MTCA coach or Mapping the College Audition guests.
[46:15] Charlie Murphy: So can I ask you? Did you do your research?
[46:18] Merri Sugarman: Are these shows that I was actually the point person on?
[46:21] Charlie Murphy: Absolutely not.
[46:21] Merri Sugarman: No, no, no.
[46:22] Charlie Murphy: There's very little research done.
[46:23] Merri Sugarman: No, I just did, I looked at the shows that your office cast, and then like I know people on that, and then we'll see how it goes.
[46:29] Charlie Murphy: All right. Are you ready to play casting a wide MTCA net?
[46:33] Merri Sugarman: No, I'm not, but yes, go ahead.
[46:35] Charlie Murphy: Okay, fantastic. Here we go. Yes, and all right, I'm gonna start off with a softball for you. Submissions only. You have said you're particularly proud of casting this web series, which features which MTCA coach as Linda Avery.
[46:48] Merri Sugarman: That would be Ann L.
[46:50] Charlie Murphy: Nathan.
[46:50] Merri Sugarman: See, we started off right. All right, for bonus points, and it's gonna get a little harder. Which Mapping the College Audition, friend of the pod and wife of MTCA coach Joe Tapper, plays the character of adorable girl, a bubbly actress who likes to compliment people on how thin they look.
[47:04] Merri Sugarman: Is that Annalie Ashford?
[47:06] Charlie Murphy: That is Annalie Ashford.
[47:07] Merri Sugarman: Two for two.
[47:08] Charlie Murphy: Spelling B. This friend of the pod was the original Logane Schwartz and Grubenier in Spelling B, and is also my real life real estate agent.
[47:20] Merri Sugarman: So, A, that was before my time at Tara Rubin casting, but I'm gonna say that is Sarah.
[47:28] Charlie Murphy: Oh, shoot. What is her last if you need it?
[47:32] Merri Sugarman: Salzburg.
[47:33] Charlie Murphy: This is fantastic. And you didn't need the hint.
[47:35] Merri Sugarman: Again, I'm giving you hints if you want them.
[47:36] Charlie Murphy: You're too. I haven't even asked a hint yet.
[47:39] Merri Sugarman: I'm so impressed by this part of it that you're not asking for the hands.
[47:41] Charlie Murphy: All right, Phantom of the Opera. This friend of the pod was the replacement for Christine Dae from 2019 to 2022. She began her career in the opera world before jumping over with roles in Candeed and Love Never Dies.
[47:57] Merri Sugarman: I'm gonna say that that would be Megan Picerno.
[48:00] Charlie Murphy: You are four for four.
[48:01] Merri Sugarman: Megan Picerno is right.
[48:02] Charlie Murphy: Absolutely right. All right, we're moving on to Aladdin. This longtime OG MTCA coach from way back in the day, starred at Aladdin from 2017 to 2019. He's a many time Broadway vet and the very first artist guest on this podcast after appearing in shows like Allegiance, Rent, Godspell, Flower Drum Song, and many more. He also happens to be besties with MTCA's other director.
[48:27] Merri Sugarman: That's Telly Leong.
[48:29] Charlie Murphy: You are perfect at this game. And one thing I have to also tell you is each time you give me a little suspense because your face does not look like you know them.
[48:35] Merri Sugarman: I'm nervous for you every time before you say it, but you've been perfect so far.
[48:39] Charlie Murphy: You know what that's called, Charlie?
[48:40] Merri Sugarman: Acting.
[48:41] Charlie Murphy: It is called acting.
[48:42] Merri Sugarman: That is Emerson training.
[48:44] Charlie Murphy: School of Rock.
[48:45] Merri Sugarman: Yes. This show had a plethora of MTCA participants in it, alongside director Leo Ash Evans. It also featured a replacement who made his Broadway debut in the ensemble, replacing Stanley slash Mr. Williams.
[48:59] Merri Sugarman: This longtime MTCA coach and friend of the pod is also an incredible musician and composer and went on to be in Be More Chill right afterward.
[49:07] Charlie Murphy: You had me at Hello, that is Joel Wagner.
[49:11] Merri Sugarman: You better believe it is. Also, shout out to MTCA dance coach Morgan Rose, who is a dance captain there.
[49:15] Charlie Murphy: We only have time for so many questions.
[49:16] Merri Sugarman: A lot of MTCA.
[49:17] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. Okay. This we're getting harder here. Jersey Boys. This long T longtime MTCA coach and my high school friend from Pittsburgh replaced Mary Delgado after swinging for this production. She's a Point Park graduate, proud mom of two, brilliant redhead, and her first name might be given out at Halloween by most, but not as likely by a mom in Brooklyn.
[49:42] Merri Sugarman: Uh Candy uh Candy Boyd, Candy Boyd, I love you.
[49:47] Charlie Murphy: I'm so sorry. I uh my mind was a blank, but I also forgot how to spell the word the this morning.
[49:52] Merri Sugarman: Have you discovered it?
[49:54] Charlie Murphy: Have we found it?
[49:55] Merri Sugarman: I have discovered it.
[49:56] Charlie Murphy: This is our last one.
[49:58] Merri Sugarman: Okay.
[49:59] Charlie Murphy: Mama Mia featured a number of MTCA connections, including our longtime coach Chris Peluso, our upcoming podcast guest, Sean Allen Krill, spoiler alert, coming along. And this replacement for Sophie Sheridan, circa 2005.
[50:14] Merri Sugarman: She's a friend of the pod. She's the godmother of my child, and has since moved on from acting to become a therapist. Her first name is what you might be accused of doing if you poorly dribbled a basketball.
[50:29] Merri Sugarman: Um There's only been 20 years of Mama Mia, and this person was in the show.
[50:34] Charlie Murphy: Not so much for me with Mama Mia.
[50:36] Merri Sugarman: Um You and me both.
[50:39] Charlie Murphy: Um Gary, Carrie.
[50:43] Merri Sugarman: Carrie Anderson.
[50:44] Charlie Murphy: Carrie Anderson is what we're looking for.
[50:46] Merri Sugarman: You've done fantastically in the game.
[50:48] Charlie Murphy: I am so impressed by you getting most of the questions right.
[50:53] Merri Sugarman: Unbelievable. We've reached the wrap-up section of the podcast.
[50:57] Charlie Murphy: Um, just a couple more questions. I just want to help you prognosticate a bit for me in terms of the future of this industry.
[51:05] Merri Sugarman: Uh my favorite thing to do.
[51:06] Charlie Murphy: Is it actually okay?
[51:07] Merri Sugarman: Great.
[51:07] Charlie Murphy: So I just hear a little bit generally like how do you feel? You know, here we are in 2023, we're entering our post pandemic phase.
[51:13] Merri Sugarman: What is this whole business gonna look like? Maybe especially for our students who are just now about to go to college. So five years from now, they're graduating into what kind of world? How is it different than the industry today? I don't know that it's gonna be that much different five years from now than it is right now, because everything that's happening right now is so is the beginning, right, of something that's so new. So hopefully everybody will be sort of getting their sea legs with it within the next five years. Um, you know, what I hope will be different is the lack of diversity and acknowledgement and um awareness of uh how things can be built and created and presented. Um, I feel like we're in a good place with that, you know, for shapes and sizes and colors and ages, and um I hope that that is something that will continue and stop actually being an issue.
I'd love to say that that will be different in five years. Um Do you feel like it's it is changing with shapes? I feel like that is that feels like a frontier that certainly I know people are pushing for, but I'm not sure that I've seen that. I mean, in some ways, of course it has. We've seen some shows with uh um people of different shapes in them. But is that something that you feel like the industry is, I don't know, commercially pushing for?
[52:39] Charlie Murphy: I do.
[52:40] Merri Sugarman: I love that. That's something you're hearing from the producing end that they're going, hey, we're open to seeing a romantic lead. Who's a larger person. I I uh not even a question. I love that. Um I and I guess I'm I'm really thinking a little bit more in the TV film world where it feels like there's not it's feels a little bit farther behind. So I think Broadway certainly seems to be leading that. We see Strange Loop, we see a lot, you know, but um yeah, I feel like in the TV film world it feels like it's lagging behind a lot. Don't see it as much on film and television. Um but you do when it kind of centers around that as being part of the story, right? Like Jane the Virgin, or um I think that it's becoming sort of universal that it's there's nothing like unpalatable here.
Right. Do you know what I mean? Like everybody's sort of starting to see things through eyes that are seeing a different interpretation of beauty. You know, what everybody thin what people think is beautiful is is very different. And I'm really talking about like the exterior because we don't really have time to to know what's going on internally as that person, a good person, a funny person, uh you know, consistently one thing. But I do think we have a certain expectation, and I don't even know if it's about your size. I think it has to, you know, I think everybody is struggling with it. I think it has to do with social media, I think it has to do with politics, I think it has to do with the foundation that you get at home, like when you're growing up.
It it's different for everybody, but um I do think that you know, people are are walking into my rooms at least with much more open mindedness and giving me much more freedom and much more rope to try things that aren't necessarily inside the boxes that they were before.
[54:30] Charlie Murphy: Super encouraging to hear. I hope you're right. I hope 10 years from now that we're gonna see network television and just all different kinds of romantic people who look completely different.
[54:39] Merri Sugarman: Um I hope so too.
[54:41] Charlie Murphy: If you could give a piece of advice out there to a young actor who's about to read your book, what kind of advice would you want to give to that young person, you know, who's gonna meet you a couple years from now?
[54:53] Merri Sugarman: I would say to keep studying, and I would say to really play the long game, to not, you know, give yourself uh a time limit to really do everything that you can, whether it's like finding your church or your gym or your whatever it is that sort of keeps you sane and being able to sort of contribute positively to society and to the people's lives whom you love, and to really make sure that you don't define yourself strictly as an actor and let stuff into your life that sort of feeds your soul so that you can so that you can be better. Do you know what I mean? So that you can be better at your craft, so that and and you know what I mean by the long game is to try to not compare yourself to other people and really try and believe that if you're actually working hard, and I mean like when I say hard, I'm not like saying that word lightly.
I mean like you're doing something every day to try and get a job, then that's you being exactly where you're supposed to be. You'll know when it's time to walk away from it. But you have to like have a thick enough skin to know that you're gonna be doing it into a void for a really long time, probably. And that's for film and television as well.
[56:13] Charlie Murphy: Um, we have, I fear not talked nearly enough about your book. So if they loved hearing you today, um, give me a little plug on why I should click this link that'll be in the show notes and buy from Craft to Career.
[56:25] Merri Sugarman: Yeah, so from Craft to Career, um Casting Director's Guide for the Actor is the full. Subtitle. Um, really was born of me watching people audition and you know, being very aware of all of the things that were out of their control and certainly out of my control, based on what the process is, which auditions are so flawed, like we all know that that process is flawed. Um, but realizing that there were so many things that actors could control that they didn't know that they could. So I was like, I should tell them. Um, and so that was part of what it was about. And then it also became about demystifying the actual casting process, who everybody is behind the table, how to make decisions about your choices based on what you know about the room that you're walking into, just things that nobody ever told me that I think if I had known would have given me more confidence.
[57:28] Charlie Murphy: I love it. Um, well, Mary, thank you so much for the time today. This was such a joy for me.
[57:33] Merri Sugarman: I'm so glad. Thank you for having me.
[57:35] Charlie Murphy: That was really fun.
[57:41] Charlie Murphy: Heidi Heidi Heidi Ho. That was a great interview with Mary Sugarman, if I do say so myself. Uh, she was such a blast to talk to, and she was really funny from almost jump. Like genuine in her groundedness, but also so smart and quick with that dry humor. She kept making me and Megan laugh in all of the breaks with some really great self-effacing humor that unfortunately for various reasons we could not include in the show. Speaking of including in the show, we take our games very seriously and would never want to deceive any of you here. So shrewd listeners may notice that it's a bit odd that I compliment Mary on going four for four. I think at one point she even goes six for six. She was doing unbelievably well.
But she does eventually miss two people. We decided to include Carrie in here since she's a friend and is now out of the business, so I know she wouldn't mind being missed in this case, but we thought we would spare the other person the very slight embarrassment it might cause. They're still active in the business and they're a heck of a lot more famous than me, but still don't need to be publicly aired during what I realized partially through the game was a very dangerous game of my creation. Um and I do also think most importantly, Mary's performance was incredible in terms of who she remembered and how quickly, especially given some of these questions were from like 20 years ago. But if you're marking on it sounding a bit odd that this was the only miss, quote unquote, at the end, and I didn't speak to that near-perfect game she would have had, that was sadly not the case. And I wouldn't want to try slipping something by you, our listeners. I know you're all much too clever for that.
[59:14] In terms of a takeaway from today, uh, I thought I would chat a bit more about a small part of our discussion when we chatted uh about Mary going to LA and exploring the TV film as part of this business. We were talking about exploring the TV film world at some point, and I mentioned it's worth reckoning with that part of yourself that will eventually want to explore that, even if right now you're a gung-ho on musical theater and nothing but musical theater. Um, I I would expand that answer a bit more to encompass more than just TV and film, and maybe just say it is simply that at some point most actors are gonna want to make sustainable money from their acting. And this may seem like the most obvious statement in the world, but you would be surprised how many actors, especially those who love their craft deeply, love theater, love the rehearsal process, which is very common, are pretty happy in their 20s working away for pretty small amounts of money in chasing their dream and then just supplementing financially with those supporting jobs.
But inevitably, at some point, maybe it's their late 20s, early 30s, often I feel like it's early 30s, sometimes it's mid-30s, even into your early 40s, they're gonna want to figure out how to make that sustainable money and to do it from their craft. You know, you'll all often hear someone say something like, you know, I really want to try to get into getting into TV now. And while of course that can happen at 35 or at 40 or at 45, I think it is helpful to have laid as many of those breadcrumbs early in your career as possible, so that you aren't necessarily starting from square one in your 30s or your forties when you come around to that. But I also do want to expand that beyond just TV and film because there are absolutely other ways to make sustainable income in this business.
It is rare that it's gonna be consistently solely with theater, again, unless you're working constantly on Broadway. But theater and some of that theater success can absolutely become parlayed into stuff like concert gigs, which can be very lucrative, and certainly the world of commercials as a whole world where people can sustain themselves, voiceovers, industrials. Even now there's stuff like video games that can be great gigs to get into uh as well that pay well for quote unquote performance. And this is quite aside from the question of side jobs and survival jobs, which are also worth considering. And it's not to say that I think there's any more value personally in a dollar earned from a commercial versus a dollar earned in a restaurant or a temp job.
I certainly don't see any distinction between those dollars. I'll just say there is a specific and noticeable phenomenon that I often see in mid-career actors who are successful, where they now say, Hey, I think I'd like to make real money doing this thing that I'm already successful at doing. Where you're already, you know, doing this impossible thing of getting cast and getting roles in the theater world, which is very difficult. But now you sort of say yourself, like, hey, I'm I'm too good to be paid so little. I I deserve to be paid more for this thing that I studied and that is my craft. Or often, you know, it's about I love the work I'm doing so much. Maybe it's doing off-Broadway plays, for instance.
I want to do a lot of off-Broadway plays, that I need a way a way to make this work, which doesn't necessarily mean waiting tables four nights a week or doing something that's taking so much time away from what I'm doing. So maybe it is then about getting into a a couple guest spots or it is about a commercial world or what can you be doing voiceover-wise. That makes it so you don't have to necessarily be working at night when you want to be, you know, performing if you want to do off-Broadway shows. That doesn't really come wrapped in too much advice, except maybe that if you're the kind of actor who thinks I won't be like that, um, I think you probably will, though I guess I don't know, prove me wrong.
Check back in 10 years, maybe you'll be the person who goes, No, I'd love theater and I'm gonna do nothing but theater all the time, and I don't care if I ever make money doing it. Um, but if you're making decisions based off that narrow focus, I just think it might be worth trying to expand your concept of your career and what it could be. Uh I'm saying that maybe partially because myself at 17, all I thought I wanted to do were plays and new plays and play development. And I basically had no interest in anything that smelled commercial. The idea of it being more commercial or or sort of even worrying about the finances felt gross to me where all I wanted to do was the art and the the making of the plays and and all that kind of stuff.
But now I know realistically that if I were to take a new play off Broadway or many regional theaters, not all, but many regional theaters, my babysitter would likely make more in that week than I would make for doing that theater. Doesn't mean it still can't happen for the love of the art and that people do that. And people I've seen people make those decisions, but the reality of life does creep in there as well. And the business part of show business comes around and bites us all eventually. That's it. We've done a show. I hope you thought it was good. And if you did, maybe hit us with a rating and review. Five stars if you please. Uh you can also follow us on all the socials media and check us out at mtycollege editions.com, all of which is found in your show notes. Two my young artists out there mapping their journeys. Make some darn choices. We'll see you next week.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
