Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Summer Break Audio Blog: A Secret to Success in the College Audition Process: Process over Product

Read the blog HERE. If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at... Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

14 mins
7/23/25

Guests

About

Read the blog HERE.

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at

mtca.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier, Kelly Prendergast and Socials by Jordan Rice. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds with Additional Vocals from Elizabeth Stanley

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, dear listener. I am back. Hope you're having a wonderful July. It should now be late July by the time you're hearing this, but I'm still in June recording these blogs where I'm realizing, my gosh, the clickbaity titles that I've used on all these blogs. I think I'm kind of doing a joke with myself for those, but this one is called A Secret to Success in the College Audition Process: Process over Product. If you've come to this blog post, you're likely looking for tips on how to succeed in the college audition process for theater and musical theater. Maybe you've heard about MTCA's 20-year history of success and are hoping to get a bit of the secret sauce that has made our students successful.

Maybe you're already an MTCA student and you just can't get enough of our great content. Either way, you've come to the right place. Here's one huge part of what we preach that differentiates our students from those working with other organizations, using their high school theater teachers, or going it alone. That secret is process over product.

[1:06] Charlie Murphy: This idea is something I talk about every year in this process, but it only gets more and more relevant as the schools demand more quote unquote product from you all. Maybe that's why I talked about it in the intro to my latest podcast episode with Tony Winner Lauren Patton, or as the closing thought in our last MTCA webinar, where we were talking pre-screen preparation. But for those of you who haven't already consumed every morsel of MTCA content you get your hands on and aren't sure what I mean by this odd statement, I'll explain it in detail in this blog post. The TLDR of what I'm advising you to do, and I urge you, please do continue to read, is to focus more on the process you are using to achieve a result rather than focusing on the outcome itself.

This concept is broad and wide-ranging as a life skill, but it's also particularly apt in the college audition world, both because it applies to your mental health and dealing with the ups and downs of this roller coaster ride, and because it is essential acting advice for you as you continue to improve as a performer.

[2:02] Charlie Murphy: In the sports world, this concept is already all too familiar. In basketball, an open shot attempt that bounces off the rim might be better than an off-balance three-pointer that happens to bank into the net off the backboard. In baseball, a hard line drive hit into the opponent's glove is generally preferable to a pop-up that happens to land on a lucky spot for a hit. And the same analogies would hold true in the business world and many other walks of life. If I were to offer you two to one odds on the outcome of the flip of a coin, you're making a good decision to take the bet, assuming I wasn't cheating, even if you happen to lose that bet five times in a row. However, we need to go in even a step deeper, especially as it relates to the acting process.

Even the concept of a quote unquote line drive is a result, right? It's helpful to think of that positive result as more important than the outcome of out when the ball is caught, but both are really results of the approach a batter makes to the plate, including the endless batting practice taken over years of their life, experiences with these particular pitchers, etc.

[3:02] Charlie Murphy: And let's just fly past that idea. There is great value in focusing on the more relevant result that we have some control over versus the more arbitrary outcome over which we have precious little. Consider in this analogy, the first result being quote unquote an excellent audition, over which we have some modicum of control, as the line drive that we hit, and the outcome of quote unquote not accepted to my dream university, over which we have almost no say, as the ball hitting the fielder's glove. For the sake of your mental health in this process, it is essential to focus on how we can continually do our job and create the conditions for auditions that allow us to bring all of ourselves fully into the room.

This involves auditions that are prepared well as a starting point, for example, for monologues, this would mean at a minimum you have A, read the play, B, explored your given circumstances, C, memorize your lines to a level that you can recite them while dodging wrenches if needed, and D, have explored the range and depth of vocal, physical, and emotional choices that your pieces might contain. But also that you're giving yourself adequate space to discover in the room to be joyful, present, alive, messy, and vulnerable.

[4:06] Charlie Murphy: You can control a large part of that process, although you won't have complete control over it necessarily feeling like a quote unquote good audition. But it is much better to focus on the line drive of a good audition than in what they say behind the table afterward or what that portal says weeks later. This same idea of doing the work and releasing it will be so helpful to you in your professional career as well. Some young actors early in their career like to focus on getting callbacks rather than getting jobs as a sign that the casting director is at least interested and might call them in again. I agree that is a far more preferable focus than whether you ultimately land the job. But I would urge those actors to go even one step further in focusing on the process that they use to prepare the audition and how the audition went for them before any feedback from casting in the form of a callback or not.

[4:56] Charlie Murphy: Uh, in here we have some bracketed notes here. A no here on feedback. Of course, it is worth noting that at some point checking in with the results is essential. As if what you think you're doing to prepare yourself is continually leading to auditions that are turning out poor, you might need to adjust what your process is. But focusing on those end results of cast or not is so subjective that in trying to learn too much from that, you will likely do more harm than good given how separate those concepts are from your control. For high school students in the college process, it is very helpful to have expert guidance from coaches who know this process who can deliver that holistic feedback about your process more incisively than those subjective yeses or no's that may come early on. End of little bracketed quote.

[5:40] Charlie Murphy: And this all leads me back to the pre-screen preparation process that many of you are currently in the midst of as I type this in August and as I read this in June. Because I know those finished pre-screens are calling to you all, and they themselves are quite literally a product. They are a video product containing all of the hard work that many of you have spent many months preparing. Product is a tricky mistress. It is our default setting as artists and humans to focus on what the end product will be. The exact sound of that note or the timing of that comedic delivery, the sharpness of that gesture, or the aching drama of that line reading. I urge you as much as humanly possible to resist this calling for perfection of the product.

There are two main reasons for this. One, the quality of work in the pre-screens themselves, very importantly, and two, for the sake of this many months-long process that will necessitate you continuing to play and discover within these pieces into late winter.

[6:42] Charlie Murphy: On that latter point, it is worth remembering that what the colleges are accepting are not the best performances they see, but the performers who they most want to train for the next four years. And their focus is always going to skew toward the living potential in an artist versus the more quote unquote perfect rendition of a particular piece. But it's the former part I want to focus more on. The quality of the work in the pre-screens themselves, as I think this concept is not intuitive to those who have not studied this particular art form. What I'm saying is in continually working to polish, perfect, or solidify your material, you are almost certainly diminishing the potential of that work.

Now, read that sentence again, or I'm gonna have to read it again because you're not reading. Listen to that sentence again if it doesn't make intuitive sense to you. In continually working to polish, perfect, or solidify your material, you are almost certainly diminishing the potential of that work.

[7:42] Charlie Murphy: Now, some of you may be asking, but wouldn't drilling and perfecting my material necessarily make it better? And yes, I am saying that it will often, in fact, make it worse. To return to our sports analogy, there's an old Vince Lombardi saying, practice doesn't make perfect, only perfect practice does. The way in which you rehearse and work on your material is incredibly important to whether it continues to deepen and expand or whether it begins to calcify and polish into something shiny but less alive. That doesn't mean you can't make choices that you know are repeatable, or that work can't move solidly in a direction toward a range of outcomes that are expected and becoming more similar. It is essential there is always a range and not an absolute certainty. It is important that there is some level of freedom in the performance itself, or we risk something that feels overly perfected and therefore not truly lived in.

[8:35] Charlie Murphy: Often the work of a coach as we near the date of pre-screen filming is actually to crack a piece open a bit, to allow some life and verisimilitude back in where we've overly closed up any potential imperfections. To modify our Lombardi quote above, for artistic purposes, maybe we'd say, rehearsal doesn't always make improvements, only expert rehearsal does. Anyone who's ever done high school theater has likely encountered a version of this concept of playing for a result or a product. It's often called quote unquote second show let down in the theater world. An opening night full of adrenaline and energy of uncertainty and possibility, we're striving to make all those moments work with a frenetic energy of under-rehearsed glory. And often, with the listening ears of a new audience and our own strong instincts as storytellers, it goes way better than we could have dreamed of or how we could have feared.

[9:26] Charlie Murphy: Then on the next night, flush with our success from opening, we try to recreate the result that worked last night, the same line readings, the same emotional moments, the same comedic timing, and it ends up falling flat on its face. This is because we cannot recreate or replicate these kinds of indefinable emotional results successfully as actors. In doing so, we immediately start doing an impression of our previous selves and the moments ring hollow. What we would ideally do, and it's a lot easier said than done, even for professional actors, is try to recreate the circumstances and recreate the preparation for ourselves that led to those great results, and then trust that the new result, though slightly different, will be interesting and authentic in its own way.

[10:09] Charlie Murphy: I often feel young actors disbelieve me when I say this, as if I'm trying to rob them of this easy shortcut that's available to them. I mean, aren't adults always telling us to do things the harder, the more correct way? When in actuality, it would be so easy if I just copied my brother's paper, which got an A. Aside from the fact that it would be cheating, I know for sure the paper is good. So wouldn't it be obvious to watch a YouTube video of a girl who got into my dream university and copy and paste exactly what she did? That wouldn't be cheating, right? And yes, I'm telling you, there is nothing morally wrong with doing that, but it just won't work. Recreating results from the outside in with another person's piece, as opposed to starting with yourself and working from the inside out with your own justified intentions will lead to a night and day difference in the performance.

[10:56] Charlie Murphy: It's not that it will necessarily be terrible, what you would do with your impression of someone else's material, but it would not be alive with your own artistry, and it is your alive artistry that's gonna get you into these schools. A side note on material, aside from the replication difficulty in the above example, it's also essential that you do pick material that you are connected with personally and that tells the story of you and not what you think they're looking for based on previously accepted students. But that is another blog post. And as crazy as it sounds with recreation and the replication process, when we talk about your monologues and songs for college auditions, there's a significant risk of being trapped in replicating yourself. Many of you will likely perform these pieces literally many hundreds of times over the course of this process, between coachings, solo rehearsals, masterclasses, and auditions.

[11:43] Charlie Murphy: When something works in a piece, it is ever so tempting to try to glom onto that thing that worked and tuck it away to build on it. To copy yourself and your choices in order to paste them later, as opposed to noting and learning from the process you use to achieve that great result. I harp on this now because so many of our students just successfully completed their summer faculty masterclass week with MTCA, where they got new exercises from great college faculty from all over the country. Many students had major breakthroughs and they want to carry that momentum forward into their pre-screens. This is all to the good. But if you've been reading this blog so far, you'll know that my advice will be to focus less on the specific line reading or even the specific exercise, though certainly great to tuck all those exercises away for later use, but see if you can focus on the conditions you are in, on the way you approach the material that day that allowed you to make that discovery so that you can continue to make those kinds of process-based discoveries into your pre-screens and beyond into your live auditions.

[12:44] Charlie Murphy: Now, I often say this at our mock auditions when we're debriefing the day, that we as performing artists are not like sculptors. We do not walk into an audition room and say, hey, here's this great statue I built painstakingly over the past five months. What do you think of this statue I built? Instead, we walk into a room, we unveil a blank piece of granite and we chisel away. The preparation we've spent months on is what enables us to smoothly and constantly work toward the piece of art that we are planning to make. Still, it is always made fresh and new each time and always ever so slightly different in the way we create it, even if our approach is identical. And it's for this reason the fact that we cannot successfully replicate the quote unquote product of our pieces, nor can we guarantee ourselves an outcome in any individual audition that we must focus on our process.

[13:36] Charlie Murphy: We focus on how we can continue to improve our approach to our material and our auditions themselves. Now, if you're not sure exactly what that means, please talk to your MTCA coaches who can help guide you in areas of improvements. But I promise you that this focus on process over product will set you up for success in this college audition process and well beyond into your career. All right, there is another blog from 2023. I'll be back next week with our last vlog before our summer break is over. We'll catch you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred