Please join me as we revisit my guest spots on Hello Puzzler, a delightful podcast hosted by AJ Jacobs and his Chief puzzle Officer, Greg Pliska. Each week, they have a celebrity guest who appears across three episodes, and they then toss puzzles at them like peanuts to an elephant... Read More
From the show: Matching Minds with Sondheim: The Podcast
Featured Shows
About
Please join me as we revisit my guest spots on Hello Puzzler, a delightful podcast hosted by AJ Jacobs and his Chief puzzle Officer, Greg Pliska. Each week, they have a celebrity guest who appears across three episodes, and they then toss puzzles at them like peanuts to an elephant. However, to me it was more like knives to a juggler who can't juggle. I tried. Really, I tried. So today you can listen to my second and third appearance. In the first one, Greg challenged me with an inventive and hilarious Sondheim theme puzzle. I'll let him explain how it works. But all you who know the names of Sondheim songs will especially enjoy playing from home. Then in my final appearance, I get to relax and turn the tables on them. I found a number of Sondheim's own puzzles from crosswords and treasure hunts, and challenged both AJ and Greg to try and solve them. Give it a shot at home and see if you do a better job than they did at… matching minds with Sondheim.
Make sure to get the book everywhere books are found, or click here.
00:00 Introduction to the Puzzle Concept
05:07 Introducing Steven Sandheim
05:26 The Twist: One Letter Changes Everything
05:40 Example: West Side Stork
06:06 Explaining the Puzzle Format
06:13 First Puzzle Challenge
Special Links:
Thanks to everyone who contributed behind the scenes to this episode, specifically the musical stingers composed by Mateo Chavez Lewis, and the theme song to our podcast with lyrics and music by Colm Molloy, and sung by the one and only Ann Morrison, who created the role of Mary in Merrily We Roll Along.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Barry Joseph: Welcome to another re-podcast of Matching Minds with Sondheim. This week, please join me as we revisit my guest spots on The Puzzler, a delightful podcast hosted by AJ Jacobs and his chief puzzle officer, Greg Pliska.
[0:17] Barry Joseph: Greg invited me just last weekend to present at the 44th annual Wonderful World of Words weekend at the majestic Mohunk Mountain House. If you're not familiar with it, it is in New Paltz, just north of New York City. I got to hang out with so many amazing people in such a beautiful place with such a special community. At an event where Sondheim himself presented around 35 or so years ago.
[0:43] Barry Joseph: On Friday night, the audience joined me in opening the weekend with Sondheim's words from his first board game, Stars, Stars Shine Tonight. And then I gave a presentation about Stephen Sondheim, which included many of the members in the room, including Will Schwartz. Then on Saturday, in the afternoon, I sold books and I sold out, and I had a blast chatting with people about Sondheim. And then the second night, I ran my How to Host a Sondheim Style Games Night workshop. We played the listening game, running charades, and more. In fact, one participant took over for a spell to demonstrate a charade variant, feat only. Check out my Instagram feed or Facebook to see his photo, which somehow my wife guessed correctly as War and Peace.
[1:28] Barry Joseph: I also had a wonderful time at a hilarious live recording of The Puzzler podcast. Wait, as of yesterday, it was renamed Hello Puzzler. Whichever it's called, check them out. Each week they have a celebrity guest who appears across three episodes. And they then toss puzzles at them, like peanuts to an elephant. However, to me, it was more like knives to a juggler who can't juggle. I tried, really, I tried. So today you can listen to my second and third appearance. In the first one, Greg challenged me with an inventive and hilarious Sondheim theme puzzle. I'll let him explain how it works. But all you who know the names of Sondheim songs will especially enjoy playing from home. Then, in my final appearance, I get to relax and turn the tables on them.
I found a number of Sondheim's own puzzles from crosswords and treasure hunts and challenged both AJ and Greg to try and solve them. Give it a shot at home and see if you do a better job than they did at Matching Minds with Sondheim.
[2:26] Barry Joseph: Matching Minds with Sondheim is streaming in your ears. It's your new favorite podcast about a theater god casting off your fiends from polygames to treasure hunts. You need a feeler dance because Barry is here to hold your hand.
[3:49] Barry Joseph: Matching Minds with Sondheim. And it is this. What do these phrases have in common? The woods, the wild, the spider verse.
[3:49] AJ Jacobs: Alright, that has three phrases that have something in common: the woods, the wild, and the spider verse. I am your host, AJ Jacobs, and that of course was Chief Puzzle Officer Greg Pliska.
[3:49] AJ Jacobs: So Greg, before the break, I gave a little mini puzzle. What do these phrases have in common? The woods, the wild, and the spider verse. Any thoughts?
[3:49] Greg Pliska: You have gone like right into my wheelhouse with those.
[3:49] Greg Pliska: Oh, yeah. Because I'm a big fan of Sondheim's Into the Woods. I read Into the Wild, and I've seen Into the Spider-Verse.
[3:49] AJ Jacobs: There you go. I'm really into all those things. Alright, well, it's a great wheelhouse to be in. Glad to be here.
[3:49] AJ Jacobs: And I thought Into the Woods in particular was appropriate because our guest today is none other than Barry Joseph, author of a great book and host of the podcast of the same name, Matching Minds with Sondheim, The Puzzles and Games of the Broadway Legend. Welcome back, Barry.
[4:07] Barry Joseph: AJ, Greg, thank you so much for having me back.
[4:11] AJ Jacobs: Ah, we are delighted. And Barry, I believe you came to us via Chief Puzzle Officer Greg Pliska.
[4:18] Greg Pliska: He knows you from other contacts.
[4:20] Greg Pliska: I just cold called Barry because I knew about the book. I knew the book was coming, and I was like, I gotta, we gotta, I gotta meet this guy, I gotta read the book. And then, you know, Barry wrote back and we chatted and I will say, if we're plugging things, Wonderful World of Words weekend this year at Mohunk Mountain House.
[4:41] Greg Pliska: We will be there, of course, The Puzzler, and Barry will be one of the presenters talking about Sondheim and his games and his puzzles. That's specifically his murder game.
[4:51] AJ Jacobs: You know what? I'm just gonna turn it over to Chief Puzzle Officer Greg Pliska because he came up with today's puzzle for you.
[4:58] Greg Pliska: Alright. Well, thank you, thank you. I mean, there's so much to talk about with Sondheim in puzzles and games, and we'll get into that here and on the weekend. But I decided I would create a puzzle, not about Stephen Sondheim, but about Stephen Sondheim, who's a famous composer and lyricist whose last name happens to be just one letter different from Stephen Sondheim.
[5:21] AJ Jacobs: Weird.
[5:22] Greg Pliska: Very weird, right? Unexpected tangential direction.
[5:25] AJ Jacobs: Yeah, exactly. You didn't think that was coming.
[5:27] Greg Pliska: Well, and what's even more amazing is all of Sondheim's works are the same as the names of Sondheim works with just one letter changed.
[5:36] AJ Jacobs: Oh, I see where we're going now.
[5:37] Greg Pliska: You see how this is gonna work. So, for example, this is a musical about two rival gangs of long-legged birds in New York City.
[5:49] AJ Jacobs: It's West Side.
[5:52] Greg Pliska: So it's not West. So you change one letter story to make it a bird to make it a long-legged bird that delivers babies.
[5:59] AJ Jacobs: Ah, which is the bigger one.
[6:00] Greg Pliska: It becomes West Side Stork.
[6:02] AJ Jacobs: Exactly.
[6:03] Greg Pliska: West Side Stork. I’d watch that in a second.
[6:06] Greg Pliska: So basically, these are all Sondheim musicals that have had one letter change to become these alternative world musicals. So here's your first one. This musical is subtitled The Demon Reptile of Fleet Pond.
[6:23] AJ Jacobs: Clearly, we're talking here about Sweeney Todd.
[6:25] Greg Pliska: Yeah.
[6:26] Greg Pliska: But in this alternate universe, it's Sweeney Toad.
[6:30] AJ Jacobs: Exactly.
[6:31] Greg Pliska: Sweeney Toad, I imagine, just like Sweeney Todd, has a song where there's a very witty wordplay battle going on between two of the characters.
[6:39] AJ Jacobs: Oh my god, yes.
[6:40] Greg Pliska: I know which song in Sweeney Todd.
[6:43] AJ Jacobs: A Little Priest.
[6:44] Greg Pliska: And in A Little Priest, that is the moment when things get quite dark. That's the one where the characters decide that they're gonna not only start murdering their customers, but serving them up on the menu. And in their playful song, they are joking about which type of people and in which type of careers will taste best. And what we're doing in the audience is watching them match wits with each other. And as they're each upping the ante with each other, we suddenly realize it's also Sondheim playing with us as an audience as we're cheering him on.
[7:13] AJ Jacobs: How far can he go?
[7:15] Greg Pliska: Do you have an example of wordplay of the profession that gets turned into a meat pie?
[7:22] AJ Jacobs: Yep, I do. Here's one for example. Now you see the trouble with poet is how do you know it's deceased?
[7:29] Greg Pliska: Try the priest.
[7:31] AJ Jacobs: Lawyer's rather nice, if it's for a price.
[7:36] Greg Pliska: So the poet is so boring that you don't even know if he's already dead. That's the jokes about both the careers and also can you get that rhyme in?
[7:44] AJ Jacobs: Right.
[7:45] Greg Pliska: Let me give you another one of these. This musical, this Sondheim musical, is an exploration of fairy tale tropes as told by a group of auto mechanics.
[7:46] AJ Jacobs: Auto mechanics.
[7:57] Greg Pliska: Love it. So the fairy tales take us to his 1987 production of Into the Woods. But of course, Sondheim is not doing Into the Woods, but he's doing am I gonna play with the word into or woods?
[8:12] AJ Jacobs: The latter.
[8:13] Greg Pliska: Auto mechanics. Where do they work?
[8:17] AJ Jacobs: Auto mechanic.
[8:18] Greg Pliska: One letter in the word woods. I'm sure your listeners are screaming it out.
[8:22] AJ Jacobs: First letter.
[8:23] Greg Pliska: First letter.
[8:24] AJ Jacobs: First letter.
[8:25] Greg Pliska: Into the auto mechanic.
[8:30] AJ Jacobs: Go through the alphabet, not boots, not...
[8:37] Greg Pliska: Into the hoods.
[8:38] AJ Jacobs: Exactly.
[8:39] Greg Pliska: We got it. Exactly. Of course, Into the Woods is about fairy tales. Those games that he played allude to some of the point and click games, like the Infocom games that some of us know.
[8:50] AJ Jacobs: I don't think he actually played those type of games, but he did play puzzle-based games in the late 80s.
[8:55] Greg Pliska: So in 1989, for example, he not only played Cliff Johnson's Three and Three, he's actually thanked in the credits because he was a playtester.
[9:03] AJ Jacobs: So he loved video.
[9:04] Greg Pliska: I mean, video games, yeah. This was the thing I was so excited about in the book that I didn't know anything about. Sondheim playing video games.
[9:11] Greg Pliska: And in fact, in the early 90s for a time, he toyed with turning Into the Woods into an educational CD-ROM game that would teach music.
[9:11] AJ Jacobs: CD-ROM.
[9:19] Greg Pliska: That's a word you don't hear a lot.
[9:21] Greg Pliska: And by the way, Into the Woods, two quick things on it. First, my son Lucas played the Baker in a wonderful production. And second, it is also very puzzle-like because it's a scavenger hunt. They're looking for four things to remove the curse from the witch. And they're not only looking for four things, but it is that very structure that made Sondheim think this might be a good game.
[9:45] AJ Jacobs: I love it.
[9:46] Greg Pliska: Alright, alright. Here's another one for you, another Sondheim musical. After a disappointing initial run, this show had a Tony-winning revival in 2023 with Daniel Radcliffe, Jonathan Groff, and Lindsay Mendez as three friends working on the New Jersey Turnpike.
[9:49] AJ Jacobs: Working on the New Jersey Turnpike.
[10:05] Greg Pliska: So immediately I know which show is being referenced.
[10:07] AJ Jacobs: That's Merrily We Roll Along.
[10:09] Greg Pliska: Yep. Now we're gonna change Merrily We Roll Along and do something about the New Jersey Turnpike, which rolling along the New Jersey Turnpike sounds wrong already because it's usually so much traffic. But that's not, I think what you're looking for.
[10:21] Greg Pliska: No, you also have to stop on the New Jersey Turnpike and any Turnpike to...
[10:31] Barry Joseph: Those were the toll booths, as in Merrily We Toll Along.
[10:31] Greg Pliska: Exactly.
[10:31] Barry Joseph: Merrily we toll along.
[10:36] Greg Pliska: Now Merrily We Roll Along, of course.
[10:38] Barry Joseph: For those who don't know, Merrily We Roll Along is a show structured so that chronologically each scene happens in the opposite order in time.
[10:46] Greg Pliska: So the beginning of our show is actually the end in time, and we go back to the first moment in time.
[10:53] Barry Joseph: So the show is not only physically structured backwards, but the songs and the music are structured backwards as well.
[10:59] Greg Pliska: So normally in a show, you might be introduced to a tune, then you get a song, and then you get a reprieve.
[11:04] Barry Joseph: In Merrily We Roll Along, we experience the reprieve first before we actually get the full song.
[11:08] Greg Pliska: Right, right.
[11:09] Barry Joseph: So the entire show is a type of jigsaw puzzle where you and the audience are trying to piece together the cause and effect where the effect happens before the cause.
[11:17] Greg Pliska: It's just again, it's Sondheim setting himself a challenge.
[11:21] Barry Joseph: It's not just to delight us. He's like, this will be really fun to try to construct this thing.
[11:26] Greg Pliska: Yeah, it's like Memento.
[11:28] Barry Joseph: It's uh backwards.
[11:29] Greg Pliska: And it's also I love it, it's like a pun, you get the punchline, and then you have to figure out the setup.
[11:35] Barry Joseph: This one is a brilliant exploration of art, romance, and the Parisian practice of shutting off all electric lighting on the weekends.
[11:46] Greg Pliska: I really like this, Mr. Sondheim.
[11:48] Barry Joseph: Right? Really great musicals.
[11:50] Greg Pliska: So I think we're in the realm of Sunday in the Park with George.
[11:54] Barry Joseph: And can you remind me about what's happening?
[11:55] Greg Pliska: It's about electricity.
[11:57] Barry Joseph: Shutting off all the electric lighting on the weekends.
[12:00] Greg Pliska: You turn off all the lights on the weekends.
[12:02] Barry Joseph: So I'm thinking about Shabbat, but that's what I thought too, and I didn't see a Shabbat or Shabbat in the Park with George.
[12:09] Greg Pliska: You guys are too smart.
[12:10] Barry Joseph: It's just when you turn off all the light, you are therefore in Mr. Sondheim's world, the show has become Sunday in the Dark with George.
[12:22] Greg Pliska: Exactly.
[12:22] Barry Joseph: I was trying to figure out a way to work in the idea of recreating the painting as they do at the end of Act One, but within the dark, so you can't see how brilliant it is that it's been reconstructed.
[12:32] Greg Pliska: So again, Barry, what you're referencing, for those who don't know, at the end of the first act, all of these characters and actors and props on the stage all rearranged for the first time to become the painting that George has been creating, which is the actual painting in the real world.
[12:47] Barry Joseph: And we know in the audience to expect it, but when that moment comes together, like a jigsaw puzzle, finding its image, it's a moment that's just devastating.
[12:55] Greg Pliska: And that the painting is who does that. That's the island of a famous 19th century painting of these fancy Parisians and like top hats and not just fancy park.
[13:07] Barry Joseph: Everyday people too.
[13:13] Greg Pliska: Interesting.
[13:13] Barry Joseph: On this Sunday.
[13:14] Greg Pliska: On this Sunday.
[13:15] Barry Joseph: There you go.
[13:17] Greg Pliska: On the blue, purple, yellow, red water.
[13:20] Barry Joseph: Um, I love it.
[13:21] Greg Pliska: Well, I can't keep going or I'll start crying.
[13:23] Barry Joseph: Yeah, I oh God.
[13:24] Greg Pliska: Um yeah, might be my most emotionally, you know, engaging Sondheim musical.
[13:30] Barry Joseph: I get so into it.
[13:31] Greg Pliska: It was a time.
[13:33] Barry Joseph: I thought it was my life.
[13:34] Greg Pliska: I write a complicated composer and his girlfriend.
[13:38] Barry Joseph: That was me back in the day.
[13:40] Greg Pliska: All right, I'll give you another one. This is an ancient Roman in this musical, ancient Roman comedy meets James Brown and Sly in the Family Stone.
[13:50] Barry Joseph: Well, this one's quite funny.
[13:51] Greg Pliska: Thank you, Barry. Clearly referencing A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.
[13:55] Barry Joseph: Yep.
[13:55] Greg Pliska: But this one's referencing you said Sly Stone.
[13:57] Barry Joseph: Yeah, Sly in the Family Stone and James Brown.
[13:57] Greg Pliska: And James Brown.
[14:01] Barry Joseph: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.
[14:06] Greg Pliska: Becomes pretty hip, I have to say.
[14:09] Barry Joseph: Yeah, yeah.
[14:09] Greg Pliska: What kind of music?
[14:11] Barry Joseph: Well, particularly it's a particular style that is in the second, it's the second word of the title.
[14:17] Greg Pliska: It's not A Funny Thing That Happened on the Way to the Forum.
[14:20] Barry Joseph: What about Welcome to Blank Town?
[14:24] Greg Pliska: Won't you?
[14:25] Barry Joseph: No, won't you take me to...
[14:25] Greg Pliska: There you go.
[14:29] Barry Joseph: Now I got it. You turned A Funny Thing That Happened into A Funky Thing That Happened.
[14:33] Greg Pliska: Exactly.
[14:34] Barry Joseph: Exactly. That's where I was getting that nice feel.
[14:37] Greg Pliska: I want to see that production.
[14:38] Barry Joseph: Right? They did the funk version of A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.
[14:42] Greg Pliska: I think it's time for a revival.
[14:43] Barry Joseph: Yeah. I'll do one more of these. This is based on an Ingmar Bergman film, and it's a musical that follows the lives of several couples, all of whom are constantly bickering, accompanied by the theme from Rocky.
[14:45] Greg Pliska: Huh.
[14:45] Barry Joseph: The theme from Rocky.
[15:00] Greg Pliska: Mr. Sondheim.
[15:02] Barry Joseph: Yeah. Listen to you.
[15:03] Greg Pliska: Okay. I think we're talking about the movie here, A Little Night Music.
[15:07] Barry Joseph: The musical A Little Night Music, yep.
[15:08] Greg Pliska: Yep.
[15:09] Barry Joseph: Right. And yet you say the theme song to Rocky?
[15:12] Greg Pliska: Theme from Rocky, because they're constantly bickering.
[15:15] Barry Joseph: Because they're bickering.
[15:16] Greg Pliska: It's not A Little Night Music.
[15:18] Barry Joseph: What is sing the theme from Rocky?
[15:20] Greg Pliska: That'll get us.
[15:21] Barry Joseph: But a bump but a bump but a bump but a bump but a bump.
[15:24] Greg Pliska: That's rising up.
[15:25] Barry Joseph: Straight to the top.
[15:27] Greg Pliska: Got the guts.
[15:28] Barry Joseph: Got the glory.
[15:30] Greg Pliska: Wow.
[15:31] Barry Joseph: That's look at that.
[15:34] Greg Pliska: There we go.
[15:35] Barry Joseph: Die of the tiger. That's the Rocky II theme, actually.
[15:38] Greg Pliska: Uh oh.
[15:38] Barry Joseph: That's all right.
[15:39] Greg Pliska: That's okay.
[15:40] Barry Joseph: But it still works, right? Doesn't that still work?
[15:41] Greg Pliska: It works.
[15:44] Barry Joseph: They're bickering.
[15:45] Greg Pliska: They're bickering because what they're doing is they are going head to head against each other because they are fighting in a little fight music.
[15:45] Barry Joseph: A little fight music.
[15:53] Greg Pliska: Exactly.
[15:55] Barry Joseph: Fantastic. Well done.
[15:57] Greg Pliska: Thank you.
[15:58] Barry Joseph: Excellent job, Greg. That's the great thing about this book. If you're a Sondheim fan, this book is a chance to discover a whole other section of his creative life.
[16:08] Greg Pliska: And if you're a puzzle and games fan, it's a chance to discover a whole world of puzzles and games that, you know, it's changed some of what we know about puzzles and games.
[16:17] Barry Joseph: Just delightful, delightful stuff.
[16:18] Greg Pliska: Exactly.
[16:19] Barry Joseph: Thank you, Greg. And I wrote it so that people from both worlds won't feel like they're outsiders.
[16:23] Greg Pliska: I want everyone to feel comfortable coming into this space, whether you're learning about Sondheim for the first time, learning about puzzles, learning about games, or how they're all connected together.
[16:31] Barry Joseph: Fantastic.
[16:32] Greg Pliska: Well, thank you.
[16:33] Barry Joseph: And actually, tomorrow we're gonna do some of Sondheim's own puzzles that he wrote.
[16:39] Greg Pliska: So come back for you.
[16:40] Barry Joseph: And you guys will be up.
[16:41] Greg Pliska: Oh yeah, we're on the hot seat.
[16:43] Barry Joseph: Greg, do you have an extra credit?
[16:47] Greg Pliska: This is a musical in which a crumbling theater hosts a reunion of musicians who once performed there. Pete Seeger, Arlo Guthrie, Odetta, and the Weavers.
[17:01] Barry Joseph: I am drawing a huge blank, but I'm counting on find out tomorrow.
[17:06] Greg Pliska: All right, I can't wait.
[17:08] Barry Joseph: In the meantime, thanks, Barry.
[17:10] Greg Pliska: Thanks, Greg.
[17:11] Barry Joseph: Thanks, listeners, and of course, we'll see you here tomorrow for more puzzling puzzles that will puzzle you puzzlingly.
[17:20] Greg Pliska: Now we've got a theater expert with us.
[17:23] AJ Jacobs: Back again. We've got Barry Joseph, author of the book and host of the podcast, Matching Minds with Sondheim, The Puzzles and Games of the Broadway Legend.
[17:35] Barry Joseph: Welcome back, Barry.
[17:37] AJ Jacobs: I am so thrilled to appear on this episode because now I get to thank you both. Because in the past two episodes, you were asking me questions. Now I get to turn the tables and ask you questions, but not ones I created, ones that I have learned through my own research that were developed by Stephen Sondheim.
[17:52] Barry Joseph: Love it.
[17:52] AJ Jacobs: Well, that's it. Exactly. The theme of this episode we decided was turn the tables. And Barry is going to try to puzzle us with, as we had mentioned in earlier episodes, Sondheim himself wrote puzzles. He loved puzzles, but he wrote them. He wrote crosswords and cryptics and all and treasure hunts. So Barry's going to try to muse and amuse us with some of Sondheim's puzzles.
[18:20] Barry Joseph: So we're going to start in 1995. This was a fundraiser for the Edna St. Vincent Millay colony. And in this treasure hunt, all of the answers were numbers.
[18:33] AJ Jacobs: Oh, interesting.
[18:35] Barry Joseph: Okay. The question is this: What is the number when you dial it on the telephone?
[18:35] AJ Jacobs: What is the number?
[18:43] Barry Joseph: Are we allowed when you dial it on the telephone?
[18:46] AJ Jacobs: When do you dial it?
[18:48] Barry Joseph: So I'm guessing it's IT.
[18:50] AJ Jacobs: Yeah.
[18:50] Barry Joseph: So it's like whatever I is and whatever T is when they have.
[18:56] AJ Jacobs: You are allowed.
[18:57] Barry Joseph: Uh and I was the 1990s.
[18:59] AJ Jacobs: Right.
[19:00] Barry Joseph: No one had a cell phone.
[19:01] AJ Jacobs: 48.
[19:02] Barry Joseph: 48, right?
[19:02] AJ Jacobs: Yeah, IT.
[19:03] Barry Joseph: Exactly correct.
[19:04] AJ Jacobs: Oh, yeah.
[19:05] Barry Joseph: So moving to the second question, we're now going to jump to my favorite of all of his cryptic crossword clues. In fact, it's one of the most often referenced. It comes from his June 17th, 1968 puzzle that was called Chop Logic.
[19:20] AJ Jacobs: Okay.
[19:22] Barry Joseph: The clue is broken harmonicas found floating in Manhattan.
[19:28] AJ Jacobs: Broken harmonics found floating in Manhattan.
[19:31] Barry Joseph: And it's a cryptic clue. And the cryptics, by the way, I think regular listeners might remember, they are super tricky clues that are almost like a little language of their own. But all of the clues lead to something, some sort of word play, puns or anagrams.
[19:49] AJ Jacobs: So break this one down.
[19:51] Barry Joseph: I was too busy yammering on. So Greg, what do you got?
[19:54] Greg Pliska: I got it.
[19:55] Barry Joseph: So say the clue again, Barry.
[19:56] Greg Pliska: It's broken harmonicas found floating in Manhattan.
[19:59] Barry Joseph: You got it, Greg.
[20:00] Greg Pliska: Right?
[20:01] Barry Joseph: So what's brilliant about it, first of all, is the surface, you know, kind of paints a picture of you've got these harmonicas that are broken and they're floating somewhere around the island of Manhattan.
[20:14] Greg Pliska: But cryptic solvers, we've done we've played with cryptics on the show a bunch, and so people might recognize broken as a clue to anagram the thing that comes next to break it up.
[20:25] Barry Joseph: So if you take harmonicas and you mix the letters around, you get maraschino.
[20:32] Greg Pliska: That's correct.
[20:33] Barry Joseph: The kind of cherry that would be floating not around the island of Manhattan, but in drink the Manhattan.
[20:40] Greg Pliska: Oh, yeah. Well done, Greg. Well done. There are so many levels that it's like, uh, yeah, it's crazy.
[20:46] Greg Pliska: Yeah, and we see again, as I mentioned with the first puzzle, this misdirection. When you ask me to picture something floating in Manhattan, I immediately jump past the illogic of it. Manhattan is an island. You float around Manhattan. And so I start thinking about the Hudson River and objects in a river. But that's not what it says. It says floating in Manhattan.
[21:05] Greg Pliska: Yeah. And also it's not a pretty picture. Having grown up in New York, when it was even dirtier, it was uh you don't want to picture things floating in the East River. For our third one, we're gonna stay in the world of crypto crosswords, but this is one that Sondheim never published.
[21:19] Barry Joseph: Okay.
[21:20] Greg Pliska: So let me explain for a moment. You described, AJ, that the listener was the publication in England that was one of the most famous for creating these really difficult crossword puzzles. The person who constructed them was named Jimenez, or at least that was the pen name. Jimenez would always leave one clue undefined. And it was up for the readers to decide what they were and submit them. He would then rate them, and then everyone who did would get back what were called his slips, which he would then judge. And so what I'm gonna read you now is one of the ones that Sondheim got really well rated by Jimenez.
[21:52] Barry Joseph: Okay?
[21:53] Greg Pliska: So same logic of all cryptic puzzles. So I'm not gonna tell you what the answer is that Jimenez came up with. You're gonna figure it out. Love it.
[22:01] Greg Pliska: Pop art panel derived from data.
[22:06] Greg Pliska: Pop, as in POP, pop art panel derived from data. That's D-A-D-A with a capital D. And that's interesting because that is like a legitimate sentence. If you saw that, that's not like stuff floating and I mean that makes sense. But of course, he's using it in a very weird and punny and anagrammy way.
[22:27] AJ Jacobs: Um, a way that I have no idea what I'm doing. Are we is it a two-letter answer?
[22:32] Greg Pliska: It's uh one-word answer. And I should say one word you would probably have this as well, is eight letters.
[22:34] AJ Jacobs: Eight letters.
[22:38] Greg Pliska: Eight letters.
[22:39] AJ Jacobs: Wait, say one more thing.
[22:41] Greg Pliska: Pop art panel derived from data.
[22:44] AJ Jacobs: All right, well, Greg, walking.
[22:46] Greg Pliska: Data D-A-T-A or D-A-D-A?
[22:48] AJ Jacobs: D-A-D-A.
[22:49] Greg Pliska: D-A-D-A. Like the first two letters of the same.
[22:51] AJ Jacobs: You're right, right. Exactly. So even that's the capital D to suggest it's that.
[22:54] Greg Pliska: That's correct. What are you working on, Greg? Walk us through some of your theories.
[22:59] Greg Pliska: My theory was derived from data, meant take whatever the answer is out of the word data. And you know, but there's it's a short word, so I was like, well, ad is hidden in there. And then I thought we saw pop art has, you know, is kind of ad-based.
[23:16] AJ Jacobs: Yeah.
[23:16] Greg Pliska: Pop art, right?
[23:17] AJ Jacobs: Right.
[23:18] Greg Pliska: Could be, you know, based upon images from ads. But anything there, Barry?
[23:23] Barry Joseph: Or is that uh so if it's helpful, um, with as you know with cryptics, one side can be a straight definition.
[23:30] AJ Jacobs: Yeah.
[23:30] Barry Joseph: Do you want me to let you know where the line is?
[23:33] Greg Pliska: Then I thought maybe.
[23:35] AJ Jacobs: Oh, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute.
[23:37] AJ Jacobs: What about the fact that pop is a name for father and data is a name for father.
[23:42] Greg Pliska: Oh, I like that. Uh-huh.
[23:44] AJ Jacobs: Pop art panel derived from data.
[23:49] Greg Pliska: Art panel.
[23:50] AJ Jacobs: So that so one of those is the straight definition.
[23:55] Greg Pliska: Pop or data.
[23:56] AJ Jacobs: Or diptych.
[23:57] Greg Pliska: Eight letters.
[23:58] AJ Jacobs: Triptych as well.
[24:02] Greg Pliska: Um what about diptych?
[24:04] AJ Jacobs: No, I don't think I don't think panel is the definition. We're looking for an answer that means derived from data, meaning from the father.
[24:12] Greg Pliska: Paternal.
[24:13] AJ Jacobs: You got it.
[24:14] Greg Pliska: Yes, pop.
[24:16] AJ Jacobs: Oh, pop is the crypta is the anagram indicator. We're gonna take art anagram it to get a word meaning derived from father.
[24:25] Greg Pliska: Paternity. Beautifully done, Greg. Beautifully done.
[24:27] AJ Jacobs: That's why he's sweating.
[24:30] Greg Pliska: People, he's got like uh, yeah.
[24:32] AJ Jacobs: There's a dripping from his forehead.
[24:35] Greg Pliska: You got any more?
[24:36] AJ Jacobs: Oh, yeah. We're gonna now move over to a treasure hunt.
[24:39] Greg Pliska: We're actually gonna go back to a party, a small private party that was held in the Dakota, which for those who don't know is a building, apartment building right next to Central Park in 2009 that was organized by one of your former guests to this very show, Jonathan Mark Sherman.
[24:54] Barry Joseph: Oh, yes.
[24:55] Greg Pliska: No way.
[24:56] Barry Joseph: Yeah, that's so fun.
[24:57] Greg Pliska: There's a there's a photo in your in your book of him with Sondheim, and you interviewed him for the book.
[25:01] Barry Joseph: He's in there in the book, yeah.
[25:02] Greg Pliska: Get out of town.
[25:04] Greg Pliska: So he's the one who shared with me both these clues and these answers, because he was able to answer them. So let's see if you can not only match minds with Sondheim, can you match minds with Sherman?
[25:13] AJ Jacobs: All right.
[25:14] Greg Pliska: Sherman's cackling right now. He's like, oh yeah, you guys stumped me. Now I'm turning the tables from the past.
[25:21] Greg Pliska: So in the last treasure hunt, you had to imagine yourself being in a theater. Now you have to imagine yourself being in someone's apartment.
[25:28] AJ Jacobs: Okay.
[25:28] Greg Pliska: And these clues were gonna take you to objects in the apartment.
[25:33] AJ Jacobs: Okay.
[25:34] Greg Pliska: Otherwise, there was no other instructions. They were just sentences you had to solve somehow. So here's the first one I have for you.
[25:42] Greg Pliska: This could be so New York, comma, shortly, period.
[25:47] AJ Jacobs: This could be so New York, comma, shortly.
[25:50] Greg Pliska: So like N Y or N Y C that's New York shortly.
[25:55] AJ Jacobs: Right, or S N S N Y is so New York shortly, right?
[25:59] Greg Pliska: Oh, that's good.
[26:01] AJ Jacobs: S N Y.
[26:02] Greg Pliska: Okay.
[26:02] AJ Jacobs: That's a TV station that didn't exist when this puzzle was done.
[26:06] Greg Pliska: Which is also S N Y Sny.
[26:10] AJ Jacobs: Sny Sun.
[26:12] Greg Pliska: S N Y. Could be something you watch things on.
[26:15] AJ Jacobs: A T uh not Oh, Sony!
[26:19] Greg Pliska: So New York short.
[26:20] AJ Jacobs: Sony.
[26:21] Greg Pliska: Yes, yes, yes. We're on the card.
[26:23] AJ Jacobs: Shorted sh I shortened too many things.
[26:25] Greg Pliska: That's great. Right behind the Sony television is something to take you to the next step.
[26:28] AJ Jacobs: That's right.
[26:29] Greg Pliska: All right. You guys did a beautiful job. Well, and and Barry, you did a great job. Particularly one of the things that you have in the book is Sondheim's principles of play, which one of them you mentioned was generosity, right? Wanting everybody to feel like they were being uh included and and it was you know, you want he wanted everybody to feel good and receive that generosity.
[26:50] Barry Joseph: Playfulness, of course, and and mentorship, you said, which uh the idea that he wanted to try to bring people along, right?
[26:59] Greg Pliska: That's right. That's right. My my book is called Matching Minds with Sondheim, because it's not only about challenging yourself by getting into his headspace through the designs of his puzzles, but also having him bring you along, having him mentor you through his puzzles.
[27:12] AJ Jacobs: Oh, this is great.
[27:13] Greg Pliska: Well, I want to thank Mr. Sondheim and thank Mr. Barry Joseph for joining us.
[27:20] AJ Jacobs: AJ, Greg, this was such a pleasure. And I just want to remind all your listeners someone is on your side when matching minds with Sondheim.
[27:30] Greg Pliska: That's the jingle for No one is alone.
[27:32] AJ Jacobs: No one is alone.
[27:33] Greg Pliska: And what is what's that from?
[27:35] AJ Jacobs: That's a quote of no uh the song No One is Alone from um uh Into the Woods.
[27:40] Greg Pliska: Okay. Well, there you go.
[27:42] AJ Jacobs: Yeah, and I know.
[27:44] AJ Jacobs: I have a little extra credit for our listeners.
[27:49] AJ Jacobs: This is a crossword clue uh that has appeared in uh crossword puzzles, and I'm just gonna give you the clue, and then you have to uh the answer is seven letters long, and uh the clue is hedonism for Sondheim.
[27:49] Greg Pliska: Hedonism for Sondheim.
[28:08] AJ Jacobs: Yeah. Excellent. Barry is loving it, he's gonna be able to do it. He knows this one.
[28:11] Greg Pliska: It's a classic.
[28:12] AJ Jacobs: It's a classic.
[28:13] AJ Jacobs: All right. Well, that was uh that was your extra credit.
[28:16] AJ Jacobs: And if you want to know the answer, come back tomorrow where we have more puzzling puzzles for you to puzzle.
[28:24] Greg Pliska: Whoa.
[28:24] AJ Jacobs: Okay.
[28:29] AJ Jacobs: Where we what is that?
[28:31] AJ Jacobs: Puzzle.
[28:31] Greg Pliska: More puzzling puzzles that will puzzle you puzzle.
[28:34] AJ Jacobs: That one?
[28:34] Greg Pliska: That's the one that I've said 500 times, literally.
[28:38] AJ Jacobs: But thank you.
[28:39] AJ Jacobs: We'll see you there.
[28:45] Greg Pliska: Hey, puzzlers. It's Greg Pliska from the puzzle lab with the extra credit answer from our previous episode.
[28:51] Greg Pliska: We did a quiz uh about Stephen Sondheim, whose shows are all one letter different from the more famous shows by Stephen Sondheim. Your extra credit clue was this.
[29:02] Greg Pliska: A crumbling theater hosts a reunion of musicians who once performed there.
[29:07] Greg Pliska: Pete Seeger, Arlo Guthrie, Odeta, and The Weavers.
[29:11] Greg Pliska: And that, of course, is the great Folkies, F-O-L-K-I-E-S, one letter different from Stephen Sondheim's famous musical Follies.
[29:21] Greg Pliska: Thanks for playing. Go check out that anti-match quiz and donate to the Trevor Project. And we'll catch you here next time.
[29:29] AJ Jacobs: We were there.
[29:30] Greg Pliska: Oh, it's so much fun.
[29:32] AJ Jacobs: There's no better way to represent his brilliance than through puzzles.
[29:36] Greg Pliska: I feel like he was probably more obsessed with puzzles than musicals.
[29:40] AJ Jacobs: Maybe that's heresy.
[29:41] Greg Pliska: He was a brilliant puzzle solver and a great mind. It was quite amazing when you walked into his apartment because it was full of games and puzzles.
[29:49] AJ Jacobs: And Sondheim started to build the crypto crosswords for New York magazine. His treasure hunts were legendary. Everybody was just running around screaming and laughing and it's almost ridiculous to be like, yeah, I went on a scavenger hunt created by Stephen Sondheim.
[30:03] Greg Pliska: You know, in some ways you could almost consider him like the sort of inventor of the very form of escape rooms or puzzles because Stephen Sondheim blurred out when the final exit door opened.
[30:11] AJ Jacobs: But I want to stay.
[30:12] Greg Pliska: How cool that we're sitting here trying to figure this game out again.
[30:16] AJ Jacobs: I have to say, I'm so grateful to be invited to participate in this.
[30:21] Greg Pliska: I can't tell you. It's just such a gift. You know, and it's he's here, you know.
[30:24] AJ Jacobs: He's here.
[30:29] Greg Pliska: Matching minds with Sondheim, telefriend and quiz him.
[30:34] AJ Jacobs: Test him on his anagram, his pure hedonism.
[30:39] Greg Pliska: His songs and his shows.
[30:41] AJ Jacobs: Mary Flynn, Mama Rose, everybody already knows their superbly designed.
[30:49] Greg Pliska: But where would we be without a puzzle to bring us D?
[30:53] AJ Jacobs: Even someone in a tree would believe we need Steve and his pain.
[31:03] Greg Pliska: Just delightful, delightful stuff.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
