Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Becoming... Legendary Broadway Producer Jeffrey Seller (Hamilton, RENT, In the Heights, Avenue Q)

Jeffrey Seller's shows have garnered twenty-two Tony Awards, including four for Best Musical, and his Broadway productions and tours have grossed more than $4.6 billion and reached more than 43 million attendees... Read More

From the show: Mentors on the Mic: Your guide to pursuing a career in the Entertainment industry

58 mins
6/30/25

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Jeffrey Seller's shows have garnered twenty-two Tony Awards, including four for Best Musical, and his Broadway productions and tours have grossed more than $4.6 billion and reached more than 43 million attendees. Jeffrey is the only producer to have mounted two Pulitzer Prize–winning musicals—Hamilton and Rent. He also revolutionized theater accessibility with the $20 ticket lottery for Rent, making theater affordable for many. This passion for accessibility underscores his belief in the power of the stage, which was his ticket out of his hometown.

In this episode, we talk about:

• First job out of University of Michigan was in publicity

• Learning all aspects of being a producer when he worked for the Barry and Fran Weissler

• Booker for Paul Blake and Kevin McCollum and they lessons he learned there

• Acting to writing to directing to producing and how/why he decided to stick with producing

• The power of writing letters as a form of communication, including a letter to his dad, a letter to Jonathan Larson and a letter to Lin-Manuel Miranda

• His complicated relationship with his father growing up

• The price of success and whether he had to sacrifice anything to get there

• Producing the audiobook with actors like Lin-Manuel Miranda, Danny Burstein, Annaleigh Ashford, and more

• His advice for establishing community as an up and coming artist

• Lightning round including a musical that always makes him musical, a project he wishes he produced, and projects he passed on

• His relationship with Jonathan Larson ahead of RENT

This episode is powered by welcometotimessquare.com, the billboard where you can be a star for a day. Thank you for the amazing studio!

Guest:

Wikipedia Instagram & Threads Playbill

Theater Kid audiobook

Buy Theater Kid

Host:

Instagram:⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠@MentorsontheMic⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠@MichelleSimoneMiller⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

Twitter:⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠@MentorsontheMic⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠@MichelleSimoneM⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

Facebook page:⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.facebook.com/mentorsonthemic⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

Website:⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ www.michellesimonemiller.com⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ www.mentorsonthemic.com⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

Youtube:⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/user/24mmichelle⁠

⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠If you like this episode, check out⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

Becoming... award-winning Casting Director Bernie Telsey ("The Color Purple," "The Idea of You," "Hamilton," "SMASH," "Wicked," "The Gilded Age"

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Michelle Simone Miller: Welcome to Mentors on the Mic, the podcast where we dive into the career paths of the most accomplished and respected professionals in the entertainment industry, how they got their start, how they moved up to where they are today, and how you can do.

[0:21] Michelle Simone Miller: This episode is powered by Welcome to Timesquare.com, the billboard where you can be a star for a day.

[0:26] Michelle Simone Miller: I'm your host, Michelle Simone Miller, and today I'm thrilled to welcome a true theater legend.

[0:31] Michelle Simone Miller: This is really special to me. Jeffrey Seller is the Tony Award-winning producer behind Rent, Avenue Q, In the Heights, and of course Hamilton.

[0:39] Michelle Simone Miller: His shows have earned 22 Tony Awards, which is insane, including four for Best Musical, and his productions and tours have grossed more than 4.6 billion dollars, which is a weird crazy thing to think about and process.

[0:52] Michelle Simone Miller: He's also the author of a beautiful and deeply personal new memoir entitled Theater Kid, which explores how a boy from suburban Detroit falls in love with Broadway and chases that dream all the way to the top.

[1:04] Michelle Simone Miller: Jeffrey Seller, welcome and thank you for being on Mentors on the Mic podcast.

[1:08] Jeffrey Seller: Michelle, I'm so happy to be here with you today and talk about my favorite subject, which is Broadway.

[1:16] Michelle Simone Miller: Oh, okay. I thought you were gonna be like me. I thought you're gonna be like me. I'm so nervous.

[1:19] Jeffrey Seller: No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I would never. Only Katharine Hepburn could have the audacity and probably the place to call her famous autobiography Me.

[1:30] Michelle Simone Miller: Me.

[1:31] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah.

[1:31] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, but no, this wasn't titled Theater Kid, which we're gonna talk about a lot because I absolutely love it. I have little post-it notes. I don't like writing in books if I can help it, so I haven't highlighted anything, but I pointed out with a pen where I want to discuss certain things.

[1:45] Michelle Simone Miller: But I always start off the podcast. What was your first role in the entertainment industry?

[1:50] Jeffrey Seller: I am going to interpret industry as meaning a professional industry where you actually get a job that pays you.

[1:58] Jeffrey Seller: So with that in mind, my first job when I got to New York was as a publicist. And I was able to get that job, even though I was a producer wannabe and a director wannabe, because when I was a student at the University of Michigan, I used to write articles and reviews for the Michigan Daily, the student newspaper, and the Ann Arbor News.

[2:23] Jeffrey Seller: In all of my years doing theater, I started writing press releases for my youth theater group when I was 14 years old for the Stagecrafters Ragamuffins in Clausen, Michigan.

[2:35] Jeffrey Seller: Yes. And I would write the press releases, I would design the program cover, and I would sell ads to support the marketing campaign, all for our youth theater group.

[2:52] Jeffrey Seller: So when I was graduating from Michigan, and I was asking that question that I know so many of your listeners are asking of themselves, what do I do with a BA in English?

[3:05] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, that's what I had that. I had that thought too.

[3:06] Michelle Simone Miller: Right.

[3:08] Jeffrey Seller: Or what do I do with a BFA in theater?

[3:11] Michelle Simone Miller: Right.

[3:11] Jeffrey Seller: Um, who's gonna hire us at age 22 to become a producer, a director, an actor, even a set designer? So we've got to get that first job.

[3:22] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, so I made that strategic decision: go get a job in publicity.

[3:27] Michelle Simone Miller: You actually have the goods to get it.

[3:30] Jeffrey Seller: And then you got paid. And you had health insurance, right?

[3:33] Michelle Simone Miller: For this one, I that was a big deal.

[3:35] Jeffrey Seller: It was a big deal because I never had health insurance during college. Our family couldn't afford it. We were poor.

[3:41] Jeffrey Seller: So though I put myself through college, I was flying there without a net. And it was the AIDS epidemic.

[3:49] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[3:49] Jeffrey Seller: And I'm gay, and I was scared.

[3:52] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[3:52] Jeffrey Seller: And I got that first job in publicity, and my take-home pay was $205 a week plus that health insurance.

[3:52] Jeffrey Seller: Plus that health insurance. And just so you see how my mind works, okay. So that's $820 a month minus the $400 for rent, meaning I have $410 a month, but I have to pay $120 for my guaranteed student loans, which means I have $300 a month and I would live on $75 a week.

[4:21] Jeffrey Seller: Which is a thing, it's a crazy thing to think about right now, right? Like now, the subway was only a buck.

[4:27] Michelle Simone Miller: Yes.

[4:27] Jeffrey Seller: And a lot of things were much more and you know, less expensive because you know inflation. But that's how I started.

[4:33] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah. So you had that job, and I remember you, you know, in reading this that you were like, at one point I have to leave. I have to be closer to Broadway. You felt far from Broadway.

[4:44] Jeffrey Seller: Well, when I first got to New York, I didn't know how to penetrate the insular community of Broadway. Like I knew that Broadway had publicists, but they were a special group, like this thing that I learned was the At Pam Publicist, which is a union publicist. And they were not part of the wide world of publicity agencies that were listed in books and stuff like that.

[5:08] Jeffrey Seller: And I knew that there were ad agencies, but I didn't know what they were. And I did not know how to get in. So I got into this first agency, and it turned out that the guy that I worked with there used to work in one of the Broadway agencies.

[5:21] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[5:22] Jeffrey Seller: So he started telling me about how it all works and how Judy Jacksina works and Fred Nathan works and all the big publicists of the time. He told me about the ad agency, Sereno Coin.

[5:34] Jeffrey Seller: And I stayed in that job for 10 months.

[5:37] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[5:38] Jeffrey Seller: And I did some publicity for Another World, the Soap Opera, and As the World Turns. And I had a couple of good experiences, but for the most part, I was not challenged enough. And I just was yearning to get closer to Broadway.

[5:55] Jeffrey Seller: And it was about nine or ten months into that job that I heard that the Weisslers, the great Barry and Fran Weissler, who were of the most active producers of that time, most as the producers of touring revivals with stars in them.

[6:13] Michelle Simone Miller: Right.

[6:13] Jeffrey Seller: So at the time that I interviewed with them, they were doing Joel Gray in Cabaret, they were executive producing Robert Goulet in South Pacific, and they were getting ready to do Topol in Fiddler on the Roof.

[6:26] Jeffrey Seller: So they had a lot of action going on, and I heard that they had an opening at the office, and I got an interview. And they were doing what you wanted to be doing, they were doing all of it, they were producing in-house, and then I learned what general management was, they were doing that in-house, and then I learned what booking was, right, which was booking those musicals all over America, from San Francisco to Denver to Columbus to Scranton to Providence.

[7:01] Michelle Simone Miller: Which I think people don't realize is a large chunk of how shows make their money.

[7:08] Jeffrey Seller: Right. A lot of times people just think of shows being, okay, it's lucrative on Broadway, great, they're making money. A lot of it comes down to the tour. Our Broadway system, our ecosystem, is completely dependent on both Broadway and the Road or touring.

[7:27] Jeffrey Seller: Because if you think about it, ultimately, more people have seen Hamilton all over America than have ever seen it on Broadway.

[7:36] Michelle Simone Miller: It's crazy.

[7:37] Jeffrey Seller: We actually gross more money out on the road with our shows when it's all said and done than we do on Broadway.

[7:45] Michelle Simone Miller: Because there's 80, 100 cities out there.

[7:49] Jeffrey Seller: That's crazy.

[7:50] Michelle Simone Miller: And it makes sense. Let's be taking a quick pause.

[7:59] Jeffrey Seller: Walking in beautiful.

[8:00] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, we don't want to do that.

[8:02] Jeffrey Seller: Um lovely. So I remember you wrote in your book that you left, and this, I mean, it's apropos, this podcast is called Mentors on the Mic, but you left Michigan without mentors. And I've had the same experience.

[8:13] Michelle Simone Miller: I left, I went to Brandeis in Massachusetts, and I felt like I left without mentors. I didn't realize the importance of that. I didn't know how to cultivate mentors at the time, which is one of the reasons why I created this podcast a few years ago.

[8:26] Michelle Simone Miller: I wanted to ask, firstly, was that a subconscious or conscious goal of yours when you graduated school, when you realized you didn't have any mentors to help, and were the Weisslers mentors for you?

[8:38] Jeffrey Seller: You know what's interesting? I had mentors in high school.

[8:40] Michelle Simone Miller: Okay.

[8:41] Jeffrey Seller: I even had mentors in middle school at the University of Michigan, which had a unremarkable, kind of dispersed theater department, in which I actually used theater as a minor, not a major.

[8:54] Jeffrey Seller: So there I never cultivated many.

[8:56] Michelle Simone Miller: So you're a political science guy?

[8:57] Jeffrey Seller: I did I got a poly sci degree and I was in many shows.

[9:01] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[9:01] Jeffrey Seller: And I directed many shows, but I never had one mentor. And it was not subconscious. It was just what was happening. And when I got to New York and started working at the Weisslers, I was basically getting a PhD in all of the forms of producing.

[9:25] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah. Watching Barry and Fran who were producing, watching Alicia Parker, who was general managing, watching, of course, Susan Weaving, who was my direct boss, who was the president of the booking division. And I worked in the booking division. So I was learning from all of them.

[9:41] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[9:42] Jeffrey Seller: But I did not consider any of them to be a mentor per se.

[9:48] Michelle Simone Miller: Like you were learning from them, but you didn't feel like it was a relationship in which they invested in you in a very personal way. What made them not feel like mentors out of curiosity?

[9:59] Jeffrey Seller: I was doing a really good job, and they were reaping the rewards of my work. But there was no special personal connection. There was just really good work.

[10:13] Michelle Simone Miller: Got it. And that honestly, I mean, that's a really great description for your next job, which we'll talk about, because I feel like for a long time you're the you're later became a partner, but Kevin, right?

[10:24] Jeffrey Seller: That's the Yeah, Kevin became like my brother.

[10:27] Michelle Simone Miller: Right. But before that, didn't you, you know, you wrote in the book that you really didn't feel like he valued a well, he he really valued your time, is what he said. He really valued you as a person, but when you wanted to leave, he made it very almost impossible really to leave. Did you feel like he also was that different?

[10:47] Jeffrey Seller: That's a very complicated story that we could unpack, but it will take a minute. I don't know if that story I think it may be too inside baseball for the for people who haven't read the book. They're not gonna understand how to unwrap that story.

[11:06] Jeffrey Seller: But you could certainly say that I had a more mentor relationship with Paul Blake because he was older. And when I know what to do here. I'm gonna give you a good example of a mentor that came a little bit later. After I left the Weissler office, I ultimately became a booker for the great producer of the Muni, Paul Blake, and his associate producer, Kevin McCollum.

[11:38] Michelle Simone Miller: Right.

[11:39] Jeffrey Seller: And Paul, being the age of my parents, was a great man of the theater. He produced shows at the Muni. He produced and directed shows on tour during the off season. And he had had a great career in the theater.

[11:58] Jeffrey Seller: And though our tastes were very different because he loved traditional musicals and I loved contemporary musicals, I felt I learned so much from him. And I give him credit because he said what I thought was maybe one of the most important phrases I ever heard up until that time.

[12:16] Jeffrey Seller: And he said, darling, when I sit at my desk every day, I invent myself every single day.

[12:23] Michelle Simone Miller: Hmm.

[12:25] Jeffrey Seller: Meaning I have to generate my own work. I can't wait for someone to call me and offer me something. I have to go make it happen for myself. I create myself every single day.

[12:43] Michelle Simone Miller: And that resonated deeply for me.

[12:47] Jeffrey Seller: And I realized it's true that I would have to generate my own work.

[12:54] Michelle Simone Miller: Which you did at various points in your story. There's one particular moment that I really wanted to talk to you about. It was you went on this survival three-week thing called Outward Bound.

[13:08] Jeffrey Seller: Which I found so interesting.

[13:14] Michelle Simone Miller: No, I love that chapter. And what stuck out to me, there was one particular line where you said at one point you're lost and you form a conclusion that you need to choose a direction and then keep walking forward. And for me, that was something I felt like kept coming up for me in the book.

[13:25] Jeffrey Seller: Wow.

[13:31] Michelle Simone Miller: Profound.

[13:32] Jeffrey Seller: No, just that that's how I saw that's how I saw the relationship with your family in a way, and with your father specifically, and what he was trying, but maybe not being able to do, and then what you go, okay, I'm gonna do this instead. And you kept doing that, where you had this goal in mind, I want to produce. And you might not know exactly how to get to that goal, but you tried different things, but it felt like you always had that goal.

[13:58] Michelle Simone Miller: And I wanted to ask you firstly, when did that change to producing? Because I wasn't sure exactly in the book, because you acted a lot, you were in choir a lot, you grew up acting.

[14:08] Jeffrey Seller: Yes.

[14:09] Michelle Simone Miller: When did it change for you where you were like, I now want to be a producer?

[14:14] Jeffrey Seller: First of all, I love that metaphor you just brought up about being lost.

[14:19] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah. And what was so interesting was that I was lost in a forest, but I knew I was on an island. That was nuts. So ultimately, the only way out was to just pick a direction and go, knowing if I keep going, I will reach the water.

[14:37] Jeffrey Seller: Yes. I will reach the beach. And um in my own um progression in the theater, um, I acted in a play. Then I wrote a play. Yep. And then Adventureland. And then with Adventureland, the play I wrote uh about my best friends and I, I got time in fifth grade in Mrs. Novetsky's class. Which by the way, I did you ever think it mirrors Jonathan Larson creating a show about his friends? Oh Tic Taco. I mean, I couldn't help but putting that connection together. That's very sweet of you. Maybe one of the reasons why, and we'll talk about it in a second, but like how how meaningful and impactful seeing what later became Tic Tick Boom for the first time is Rock Melbourne. You write about um our friends. We write our stories.

And what did Lynn do within the heights but write about his friends? Um, so yeah, I so then we do Adventureland, and then I'm in the community theater as an actor. And the Which by the way, you got yourself. That was very impressive that you called up the place and you were like I made a f I made a called call to 11. Were you? Oh, no, yes. Yes, exactly. I was 11. Yeah, that's crazy. And I picked up the right pages and I wrote, where is stagecrafters? And I was like, oh, Bauer Street and Clausen. I just picked up the phone and I called on a Saturday afternoon. It's incredible. And this woman said, Well, if you come Monday night at eight at seven o'clock, we're having auditions. We need two kids for this show, a nine-year-old boy and a seven-year-old girl.

You're like, okay, I can do it. And I showed up on Monday night with my dad. Anyway, but in eighth grade, I'm in the youth theater group play called Popcorn Pete. Yes. And I am the Jack in the Box, and I'm having fun being the Jack in the Box in this silly play. And I noticed three things. One, I thought it was a stupid title. Yeah. Two, it didn't have any conflict. Like I was like, what is the major dramatic question of this play? And by the way, I'm using a phrase that I did not know the meaning of when I was 13 in that play. But I I already had a sense of like there's no conflict here. Okay. There's no question. And then three is the audiences were meager. So I, after that play happened, said to the uh parent um advisor of the group, I said, Who picks the play?

Yeah. And she says the play reading committee, and I said, I want to be on the play reading committee. That's the first move toward becoming a producer. Got it. It's the first move towards saying instead of just being in the play, I want to pick the play. And um that's a seminal moment. Yeah. And I'm in eighth grade. Yeah. Uh by ninth grade, I'm writing the press releases and doing that other stuff I just talked about. So before I can drive, I am basically picking plays, um, doing the publicity for the plays, writing the press releases, raising money for the plays by selling ads in the program, and working on the flyers that we send out to try to fill the seats. I am fulfilling in ninth and tenth grade all of the jobs of a producer.

And and I'm still acting in plays. Yeah. All through high school. And um in college, I I'm still acting the first couple years, but it was somewhere around the first year of college that I wanted to direct the play. And I got a job directing camp plays. And I enjoyed that very much. And that was around the time I started to learn more and more about um the um career of Hal Prince being a producer director. And that's when I kind of took on the mantle of saying I want to be a producer director. And I actually um made money in college directing. I used to get my work study money by directing because I was very good with finagling the system. I wish I had a work study. I I worked at the ticket office of my school.

I wish it was a directing job that was also a work study job. So I was able to somehow get the work study office to give me my work study by directing anything goes at Ann Arbor Civic Theater. That's incredible. And I made 450 bucks. It's fantastic. I know. So I didn't have to go get a job in the cafeteria or anything. And you got to put it on your resume. Unbelievable. So great. I can't even believe it now, but it's true. Uh so I'm directing and producing, and of course, educating, right? Because I'm working with those campers. Which by the way, I loved hearing about the camp because I I was a theater kid, I went to theater camp, I went to Stage Door Manor, and you talked about different shows throughout the book.

And one show you talked about in particular was Pippin, which was my first theater camp show at Stage Door, directed by Larry Nye. Oh. I know. So you were I when I was reading the book, and I was like, You're talking about a choreographer named Larry Nye. I was like, that's the same Larry Nye that that directed me in Pippin. Who, by the way, the lead of that show was Shana Taub. Oh my God. What and was Shane uh the leading player? Yes, she was, and she was incredible. And what uh my favorite story about her is that the piano breaks down. It was an outdoor theater, the piano breaks down, and she entertained the crowd for 10 minutes silently, by the way. She just walks around the stage, she's looking at her fake watch, she's like tapping her shoes, she's entertaining the audience.

I left, and my dad goes, Who was that girl? Like that girl, like the whole thing was falling apart, and she's just this professional at age like 14. That's Shayna. Remarkable talent. Yeah, and you know who else was a great choreographer? Larry Nye. Yeah. And he and I did that production of Greece together at Michigan when we were both students. Which I thought was very awesome to hear. Did you ever work with him again? No. Fair. Uh that's fair. He was on his way as a director choreographer, and I wish I did. But life takes us. Life takes us. Yeah. No, I just thought it was just a little funny little moment, little thing. Um, um, but yes, so we were going into where were we? I know. I'm so I'm so thrown because the idea that you were at Stage Door being directed in Pippin by Larry Nye is with Shana as the lead player.

It's so moving to me. So cool. But I think one of the things we were talking about is how we loved shows like that. And what was amazing about Pippin was that it was a show about events that took place hundreds of years ago during the Middle Ages, right? The time of Charlemagne. Right. But it was written in the early 70s by Stephen Schwartz in a contemporary vernacular. So the sound the songs sounded more like uh Carly Simon or James Taylor than Rogers and Hammerstein. And of course, Bob Fossey directed it in a completely uh contemporary physical vernacular with magic and sexy bodies and sets that looked like ropes. And um it was both a contemporary show about an old event. Does that remind you of any other musicals like Hamilton?

Like, you know, it it had it the thought crossed my mind. Yes. That's beautiful. But anyway, so it was during that process. I'm directing, I'm producing. Yes. I get to New York, uh, I'm producing and directing shows at night with my friends. I'm working at the Weisslers by day, I'm directing community theater by night. Uh and uh, and then at one point I um get the wonderful uh reformed temple in the upper west side, Road of Shalom, who I've been directing community theater for to help us uh help Andrew Lippa and I, my college best friend, um, to do a new musical that he writes describe him as your college best friend. He was he was my college best friend, and of course, he was my first boyfriend.

Yeah, he was many things. Yeah, he was many things. Um, and uh, and we get them to put up the money so we can do this new musical called The Pound of Feathers, and I'm producing it and I'm directing it, and I'm trying to book all day, and um it was overwhelming. I actually overwhelmed myself, and it was through the process of doing that that I said, you might be one of the best producers around. But you're probably not going to be the best director around. And I started focusing purely on producing after doing that one show. And what's also interesting is we did that show in the fall of 89. And I meet Jonathan Larson uh really nine months later. Which is crazy. Uh in September, October of 1990.

And you meet him, and this was beautiful. So you see, you see his rock monologue, uh, which was not called Tic Tick Boom. You helped, I think, influenced to change that. It was called Boho Day. Yeah, which I get. I I get that as a name, but I do think Tic Tick Boom works really well for it instead. But you see this, you're profoundly moved by it. You see yourself in the show, you see your story in similar ways, and you write him a letter. And what was cool was that you write a lot of letters in this book and you include them. Did you include the actual letter, or is it like a paraphrase of what you think these letters are? Because you wrote a letter to your dad, you later wrote a letter to Lynn. This is something I wanted to ask you about in terms of how you chose to communicate to these people with letters.

[24:13] Jeffrey Seller: All the letters in this book are verbatim.

[24:17] Michelle Simone Miller: Wow.

[24:18] Jeffrey Seller: They are not paraphrases or rewrites.

[24:20] Michelle Simone Miller: Wow.

[24:21] Jeffrey Seller: They are the letter.

[24:28] Michelle Simone Miller: But that's it.

[24:29] Jeffrey Seller: Wow. Um writing letters is such a powerful form of communication because it does two things that cannot be replicated through text or through a conversation. One is a letter enables the writer to really think through exactly what he or she wants to say and to really spend time shaping that communication. It's very thoughtful. And then the receiver of the letter can take it in on their own time, can think about it on their own time, can process it on their own time, and then decide how they want to respond. It slows everything down to the benefit of both parties. And that's why I wrote letters.

[26:13] Michelle Simone Miller: And it's not a thriller.

[26:14] Jeffrey Seller: And it's not a thriller.

[26:17] Michelle Simone Miller: It's a real person.

[26:19] Jeffrey Seller: But there's one particular story that stuck out to me for my own reasons, but you know, your father became a clown.

[26:26] Michelle Simone Miller: He wanted to become a clown.

[26:27] Jeffrey Seller: Chip chip the clown. It's it's amazing. Because when you say about somebody they became a clown, you don't know, you're like, you mean they were silly or they became a clown. You're talking we're talking full makeup, and you describe it very well. The full makeup, the full outfit, and then it helps that throughout the book you have little cartoon, like a little character. So I I got to see the visual of what he looked like in the mirror. Um so you have him as this clown, and no one gets it in the family. Your mom specifically, understandably so, mind you, and you go see him perform, essentially.

[26:59] Michelle Simone Miller: Yes.

[26:59] Jeffrey Seller: You take you buy a ticket, and he's not working as a clown in the in the circus. He's almost like tangential. He's working with kids, he's giving them, he's making stuffed animals, uh, not stuffed animals, um, clown animals.

[27:11] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, yeah.

[27:12] Jeffrey Seller: Um, and you see him do this, and you go, I get it. I understand. What did you understand about your father in that moment?

[27:22] Jeffrey Seller: I understood how much he loves children. I understood his generosity of spirit. Um, I understood how kind he could be. How much it filled him with goodness to fashion a dog or a cat from a balloon for a little girl in a wheelchair, and how that smile he gave her meant the world. And I have to put that in perspective. Because that expression of his had a cost.

[28:02] Michelle Simone Miller: What was the cost?

[28:09] Jeffrey Seller: And the cost was that while he was at the circus doing that, almost all day every night for almost a month. Volunteering, mind you, not making money. No, this was the volunteer shriner clown unit at the Shrine Circle. While he's doing that, he is not going to work every day. He is not paying the mortgage, and he is not putting food on the table. In fact, it's he's making it even worse because at one point my mother just goes crazy when she finds out he has commissioned the cleaners to build for him a second clown suit.

[28:50] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[28:50] Jeffrey Seller: So that he can alternate. And that second clown suit, which costs over a hundred dollars, which is a lot of money in 1982. Um, makes her crazy. Understandably so.

[29:10] Jeffrey Seller: So this is why one of the reasons why that stuck out to me so much, because you see him do this, you understand him in a way that I think you didn't understand him before.

[29:19] Michelle Simone Miller: That's how I interpreted it anyway.

[29:21] Jeffrey Seller: So it's crazy because it's your life.

[29:23] Michelle Simone Miller: But and I think, you know, because when you read something, it's almost like a story, but you have to remind yourself this is someone's life.

[29:28] Jeffrey Seller: So you make a collage for him of all of these beautiful moments of him working with kids, which is so meaningful to him, and he loves seeing it, and it's just this beautiful moment, and you end the chapter with saying he didn't get the job as the clown at this point.

[29:45] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, he was a novice.

[29:46] Jeffrey Seller: He was like a candidate to become a clown with the Shriners.

[29:51] Michelle Simone Miller: And at the end, I end it by saying, but that would be his last Shrine Circus because they didn't ultimately vote him in as a full member of the clown unit.

[30:03] Michelle Simone Miller: So, what stayed with you more? Was it the joy of seeing him come alive in the role or the pain of that door closing on him?

[30:12] Jeffrey Seller: Uh I would fashion the question. What stayed with me more? The joy of watching him perform as a clown, or the pain of seeing him impoverish our family.

[30:24] Jeffrey Seller: The fact that they closed the door on him was sad, but it didn't stop him from being a clown at other places, that's fair.

[30:32] Jeffrey Seller: Um, so I lived with both.

[30:35] Jeffrey Seller: You know, I find it interesting in retrospect that um though I was very judgmental of him for being that clown, and I thought, why are you impoverishing our family? I still believed in him enough that I made him that collage.

[30:51] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, that's I mean, that really you know, my dad's been dead 11 years. Sadly, my mom died only one year ago.

[30:58] Jeffrey Seller: And when she died, I brought that I have I brought the collage back to New York and I have it in my house, and I haven't put it up yet, but I have the collage.

[31:10] Jeffrey Seller: It just that really uh really personally just stood out to me as like this important person in your life who you're supposed to look up to, who's supposed to be there for you and your family.

[31:24] Jeffrey Seller: And then this juxtaposition of seeing these beautiful moments in him, beautiful things in him and understanding him in a certain way, but also really still being angry and understandably angry and frustrated, and seeing the pain with your mom.

[31:37] Michelle Simone Miller: I mean you're very empathetic to your mom through the book, and then the pain that she had to deal with.

[31:42] Jeffrey Seller: Um, and they're just the juxtaposition of those feelings, it just felt really real and understandable to me.

[31:48] Jeffrey Seller: And um, anyway, thank you for answering my question about that.

[31:53] Michelle Simone Miller: Um good.

[31:57] Jeffrey Seller: Okay.

[31:58] Michelle Simone Miller: So let's go to okay.

[32:03] Michelle Simone Miller: Now I'm gonna be distracted.

[32:04] Michelle Simone Miller: So later you wrote um in the book you about Dreamgirls, which I found really exciting because it's one of my favorite musicals.

[32:10] Michelle Simone Miller: So you talk about Dreamgirls showing that success comes with a price.

[32:14] Michelle Simone Miller: This is actually relevant to what we're just saying.

[32:16] Michelle Simone Miller: That Dreamgirls that you said that shows that success comes with a price and asks us to question its cost.

[32:23] Michelle Simone Miller: Have you seen that manifest in your life in some way?

[32:28] Jeffrey Seller: Wow.

[32:38] Jeffrey Seller: Strikes me as being true.

[32:43] Jeffrey Seller: And um I am going to confess that for the most part um there has been to my eyes low cost to my work and my success.

[33:04] Michelle Simone Miller: That's good.

[33:05] Jeffrey Seller: But I want to also say um whether or not my two children age 22 and 21 listen to this, I don't know.

[33:14] Jeffrey Seller: My children are both born after Rent and around the time of Avenue Q.

[33:19] Jeffrey Seller: Um, they might answer that differently.

[33:23] Michelle Simone Miller: Fair.

[33:23] Jeffrey Seller: Well, kids always have a different relationship.

[33:26] Jeffrey Seller: My kids would say, you know, daddy never stops working, daddy's never, he's always on the phone.

[33:32] Jeffrey Seller: And they may say that was the cost.

[33:36] Jeffrey Seller: So I want to be open to the fact that there may have been costs for others in our family.

[33:36] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[33:36] Jeffrey Seller: There may have been a cost to my longtime partner, Josh.

[33:52] Jeffrey Seller: Um it's complicated.

[33:55] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah.

[33:56] Jeffrey Seller: And I hope my answer embraces all of that complication.

[34:01] Michelle Simone Miller: I think it does.

[34:02] Michelle Simone Miller: Um still very hopeful and reassuring to a lot of creatives.

[34:06] Jeffrey Seller: I do believe that.

[34:07] Jeffrey Seller: Um back actually, because I didn't ask you this question when we're talking about the Outward Bound survival thing, right?

[34:20] Michelle Simone Miller: Which really stuck out to me as an image of you just walking around this island.

[34:23] Jeffrey Seller: I just love your interest in that chapter.

[34:26] Michelle Simone Miller: I do, I yeah.

[34:27] Jeffrey Seller: So what I want to know is, you know, we talk a little bit about this idea that you need to choose a direction, you keep moving forward.

[34:33] Jeffrey Seller: Did you do you feel like you find that same mindset in producing, especially if like a show isn't working, or even when you're choosing projects to champion?

[34:44] Jeffrey Seller: Do you feel like that that is it something that that's part of your process in a way?

[34:51] Jeffrey Seller: Oh my gosh, yes.

[34:52] Jeffrey Seller: I think that all of us in life have to choose a direction and move forward.

[35:00] Jeffrey Seller: Because if we keep doubting ourselves, if we keep changing our minds and going backwards or going right or going left, then we're never gonna get forward.

[35:13] Jeffrey Seller: And we're never going to standing still.

[35:15] Jeffrey Seller: And we're never gonna find our way off this island.

[35:17] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[35:18] Jeffrey Seller: So um I think it's been an amazing guiding principle.

[35:22] Jeffrey Seller: I suppose that's why I put it in there.

[35:24] Michelle Simone Miller: I think so.

[35:25] Jeffrey Seller: And I want to also say one more thing about that chapter.

[35:29] Jeffrey Seller: I wrote it in 1990.

[35:32] Jeffrey Seller: No, yes, I wrote it when I did it.

[35:35] Jeffrey Seller: I did Outward Bound in 1990, right before I met Jonathan Larson.

[35:39] Michelle Simone Miller: Wow and Kevin McCollum and Paul Blake, you know, I say the three meetings that changed my life.

[35:45] Jeffrey Seller: And I uh did Outward Bound in the summer of 90.

[35:49] Jeffrey Seller: And I wrote that chapter.

[35:52] Jeffrey Seller: Um I actually wrote that story about Outward Bound after I got fired from the Weissler office and I had a lot of time on my hands because I didn't have a job.

[36:00] Michelle Simone Miller: So crazy.

[36:00] Jeffrey Seller: Did you know what it you were writing it for?

[36:02] Michelle Simone Miller: Was it no?

[36:03] Jeffrey Seller: I just knew I needed to write down what just happened to me because I think it was important.

[36:08] Michelle Simone Miller: Did you revisit a lot of essentially journals during this process of writing this?

[36:12] Jeffrey Seller: Oh, absolutely.

[36:12] Jeffrey Seller: I had journals from all through college at uh and some stories I'd written in my early years in New York.

[36:18] Jeffrey Seller: So sometimes when people have asked me, how do you remember all this?

[36:22] Jeffrey Seller: Some of it was that I had good documentation.

[36:24] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[36:25] Jeffrey Seller: Uh of my events and some of my feelings from my teens and my twenties.

[36:32] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, you can you can really tell that this uh, you know, is I was wondering about that because I remember when I saw you uh you were interviewed uh for I think it's the Little Known Facts Podcast in Bryant Park, you said that the book was actually longer and you needed your editor to be like, okay, tell me what you you're like, tell me what I need to take out.

[36:49] Michelle Simone Miller: But it means that you had a lot of subject matter that that felt, you know, I I'm not surprised that you had sp it wasn't just from your memory.

[36:58] Michelle Simone Miller: This felt very real.

[36:59] Jeffrey Seller: Um, there were a lot of visual moments that you were able to share with us.

[37:03] Michelle Simone Miller: Um, so that was really beautiful.

[37:06] Michelle Simone Miller: And I have to ask, if the book was adapted, I don't know if you've thought about this at all, but if it was adapted into a movie or a show, who would produce it?

[37:16] Michelle Simone Miller: And who would play you?

[37:18] Jeffrey Seller: And would it be a musical?

[37:21] Jeffrey Seller: Uh I doubt it would be a musical.

[37:24] Jeffrey Seller: And I feel like I did it.

[37:26] Jeffrey Seller: And that was by um persuading, cajoling, uh, and asking 15 of the greatest actors and actresses on Broadway to do my audiobook.

[37:40] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[37:40] Jeffrey Seller: So for me to have Danny Burstein and Lindsay Mendez play my mom and dad.

[37:47] Jeffrey Seller: Crazy.

[37:51] Jeffrey Seller: To have Annaleigh Ashford play Susan Weaving and my sixth grade teacher and mentor, Miss Shivley was so beautiful.

[37:59] Jeffrey Seller: And to have Renee Goldsberry and Lin-Manuel Miranda play Fran Weissler and Barry Weissler, come on.

[38:06] Jeffrey Seller: So I feel like when we were um getting ready to make the audiobook, that's when I said, okay, well, I'm gonna help produce this audiobook.

[38:15] Jeffrey Seller: I don't want to hear my voice for 10 hours.

[38:18] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah.

[38:18] Jeffrey Seller: Let's go get all these great Broadway people, and we'll do it like a staged reading.

[38:22] Jeffrey Seller: So for me, that was such a rewarding experience and a lucky experience.

[38:26] Jeffrey Seller: And I'll leave it, I'll let that let it rest and let anybody else figure out the rest.

[38:31] Michelle Simone Miller: I love that.

[38:32] Michelle Simone Miller: I love it.

[38:33] Jeffrey Seller: Um, you never, never done producing.

[38:35] Jeffrey Seller: Um, you close the book saying, I still want to produce another one.

[38:40] Michelle Simone Miller: So for those who are listening who are just starting out, any artist, if you will, any creative, they're trying to find their first good one.

[38:49] Michelle Simone Miller: What advice would you give?

[38:52] Jeffrey Seller: It's all about who you connect with and make friends with and nurture and make a show with.

[39:00] Jeffrey Seller: It's all about creating your artistic friend group.

[39:07] Jeffrey Seller: I knew when I was a booker working for Barry and Fran, I wasn't going to be producing Andrew Lloyd Webber's shows or Stephen Sondheim's shows or Stephen Schwartz's shows.

[39:19] Jeffrey Seller: I had to find my own group.

[39:21] Jeffrey Seller: So my group was Andrew Lippa and Jonathan Larson, and then ultimately Lynn.

[39:26] Jeffrey Seller: Um, and Bobby and Jeff.

[39:30] Jeffrey Seller: All these young folks today, the writers need to find their producers, the producers need to find their writers, the directors need to start their own theater companies.

[39:40] Jeffrey Seller: And when um you as a producer go out and find your group, go produce them and go make it happen.

[39:49] Jeffrey Seller: And you'll all rise together.

[39:53] Jeffrey Seller: I rose with Andrew Lippa and Jonathan Larson.

[39:57] Jeffrey Seller: Hal Prince and Stephen Sondheim rose together after they met at the opening of South Pacific on Broadway at the Majestic Theater.

[40:05] Jeffrey Seller: And Lynn Manuel Miranda and Tommy Kail rose together when Tommy started producing shows in the basement of the drama bookshop.

[40:16] Michelle Simone Miller: Can you give advice as to how to find those collaborators?

[40:19] Michelle Simone Miller: Because with Jonathan Larson, if I remember, someone, I think someone you knew saw him at Naked Angels and told you to go see.

[40:26] Jeffrey Seller: Yes, and then you wrote a letter.

[40:27] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, that's called open your eyes, open your ears, go to stuff.

[40:27] Jeffrey Seller: Go to stuff.

[40:34] Jeffrey Seller: And you'll find them because guess who's not going to that anymore?

[40:37] Jeffrey Seller: Me, because I'm old.

[40:39] Jeffrey Seller: I don't go anymore to that stuff.

[40:41] Jeffrey Seller: So go knock my block off and go find the next Jonathan Larson.

[40:45] Michelle Simone Miller: That's my advice to you.

[40:46] Jeffrey Seller: I love that.

[40:47] Michelle Simone Miller: I love that.

[40:49] Michelle Simone Miller: So I think that we've gotten through my questions.

[40:51] Michelle Simone Miller: I'm just gonna go through a quick lightning round of stuff, if you don't mind.

[40:54] Jeffrey Seller: You bet.

[40:55] Michelle Simone Miller: So one would be do you have a comfort TV show that you're watching at home?

[41:00] Jeffrey Seller: I have to be honest with you.

[41:02] Jeffrey Seller: I watch almost no TV.

[41:04] Michelle Simone Miller: Fair because I fall asleep.

[41:06] Jeffrey Seller: However, my comfort TV show that I have loved and that I just finished was Somebody Somewhere, Bridget Everett's beautiful show on HBO.

[41:16] Jeffrey Seller: I love her.

[41:17] Jeffrey Seller: I loved those people.

[41:19] Jeffrey Seller: And um it gave me, it made me feel good to watch it.

[41:23] Michelle Simone Miller: Excellent.

[41:24] Michelle Simone Miller: And I understand that actually.

[41:26] Michelle Simone Miller: Um let's go to favorite musical production you've seen that you haven't produced.

[41:33] Jeffrey Seller: Well, my the one show which does not qualify as a Broadway show that over all these years I was deeply jealous of was Glee.

[41:42] Jeffrey Seller: When Glee came out celebrating these kids who are all outsiders, who were forming their own Glee Club, I just said, Oh, I wished I produced that.

[41:53] Jeffrey Seller: That was the one I was deeply jealous of.

[41:55] Jeffrey Seller: And of course, this season, I really loved Maybe Happy Ending, its ingenuity, its humanity, and its beauty.

[42:02] Michelle Simone Miller: That was my question for you at the Bryant Park thing.

[42:05] Michelle Simone Miller: Uh we there was a QA and I asked a question.

[42:07] Michelle Simone Miller: I said, like, what show right now would you recommend people to see and why?

[42:10] Michelle Simone Miller: And you see that.

[42:11] Michelle Simone Miller: And everybody goes away loving it.

[42:12] Jeffrey Seller: Of course, everybody goes away loving John Proctor as the villain.

[42:16] Michelle Simone Miller: I still have to see it.

[42:17] Michelle Simone Miller: It's like my next show that I but I also really love Death Becomes Her.

[42:21] Jeffrey Seller: Those were Death Becomes Her and Maybe Happy Ending.

[42:23] Jeffrey Seller: That was a good group.

[42:26] Michelle Simone Miller: Are you reading anything now?

[42:29] Jeffrey Seller: Oh my God.

[42:30] Jeffrey Seller: I just started a new book.

[42:31] Jeffrey Seller: It's a biggie.

[42:34] Jeffrey Seller: It's The Magic Mountain by Thomas Mann, one of the greatest books ever written.

[42:38] Jeffrey Seller: I had never read it before, and it's my summer project.

[42:41] Michelle Simone Miller: Excellent.

[42:42] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah.

[42:42] Michelle Simone Miller: Lovely.

[42:43] Michelle Simone Miller: Who's a dream creative collaborator living or not living?

[42:52] Jeffrey Seller: Well, I would have loved to have uh done a show with Mike Nichols, who I became friends with in the last years of his life.

[42:58] Jeffrey Seller: Um he was so stimulating to be around.

[43:01] Michelle Simone Miller: Uh I would have loved to have been around uh him as he's directing a show.

[43:05] Jeffrey Seller: I'm so glad he brought that up because I actually didn't put this in my notes, and that would have been sad if I didn't bring him up.

[43:11] Jeffrey Seller: But I interviewed, hold on.

[43:15] Jeffrey Seller: I'm going Bernie Telsey was on my podcast.

[43:17] Jeffrey Seller: And I asked him, and the reason I thought of him because he worked for Mike Nichols for a period of time.

[43:22] Jeffrey Seller: I don't know if you know this, but I asked him, I told him I was interviewing you today, and I said, Is there any message you want me to pass forward?

[43:28] Jeffrey Seller: And he said, You can say his favorite casting director and friend says he loves collaborating with him.

[43:34] Michelle Simone Miller: Which I mean is really relevant to what we're talking about today and finding your collaborators.

[43:38] Jeffrey Seller: Beautiful.

[43:44] Jeffrey Seller: A chorus line.

[43:46] Michelle Simone Miller: You did talk about the ball.

[43:47] Jeffrey Seller: At the ballet.

[43:48] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[43:48] Jeffrey Seller: Holy moly.

[43:50] Michelle Simone Miller: Is there anything specific as to why, like any particular moment or parts?

[43:54] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, because at the ballet is about these young kids who have this yearning and these feel these inco it feelings about their parents. Um, you know, when this young girl talks about her father and wishing he could be there for him, or another girl talks about her father, um, and discovering that he's having an affair and betraying her mother, it pushes my buttons.

[44:19] Michelle Simone Miller: That's fair.

[44:20] Jeffrey Seller: I always find the thing, the moments that make me emotional in movies or in shows is when I see it's almost the up when I see fathers with their kids, like really like playing with them or spending time with them. Those are that just I mean, you don't even have it doesn't even have to be a seminal moment in the story. That just really impacts me.

[44:40] Michelle Simone Miller: So I get that. I totally get that. Um, one line or lyric you wish that you let's say you've written.

[44:48] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, one line or lyric of a song that stays with you that you wish you've written. Well, I mean, I'll cover you from Rent still just destroys me because of its sheer beauty, emotional resonance, and double entendre genius, because of course, in that action, Angel is physically buying a coat for Collins. And Angel is covering him with his love. And it is the beginning of their beautiful burgeoning romance. And that's why I'll cover you has always been my favorite song from Rent.

[45:28] Jeffrey Seller: And that's what it uh your questions today uh provoke. Which by the way, I've had, I mean, I love Rent, and I've I have favorite songs that I know all the words to. I've had one song Glory stuck in my head all day, and I'm not really sure why. Like in reading the book, I'm like I don't know why that's the song that keeps coming up for me but I did want to bring that up a show you passed on and you wish you hadn't you know I passed on several shows and I never you can't go back but I passed on Jersey Boys because it wasn't my music.

[46:01] Michelle Simone Miller: That's you know that's fair.

[46:03] Jeffrey Seller: You have a very specific that's my mom's music and I actually passed on um partnering with Paul Blake on um Beautiful because I just didn't uh it wasn't my music again so they were both big successes. Both beautiful and I loved going to see both of them but I didn't experience regret.

[46:22] Michelle Simone Miller: You know and I understand and I appreciate you saying that because I feel like in the same way you had a very specific direction as to what you as being a producer you also seem to have a very strong direction as to what you wanted to produce.

[46:36] Jeffrey Seller: Yes because the most important decision I will make as producer is what play to do and I have to want to adopt that child and raise it up like my own. And champion it oh well now we're gonna get into family. I'm not gonna do that again.

[46:57] Michelle Simone Miller: Um a player musical you think people need to see or read one that doesn't get enough attention that sticks out to you.

[47:11] Jeffrey Seller: You know what I'd love to see a production of falsettos right now just to see how uh on non-traditional family is sorting through a complicated, chaotic life and celebrating gay dads, straight moms, and everything in between.

[47:28] Michelle Simone Miller: It's great. I actually had a question that's similar that that reminds me of. When you saw Jonathan Larson's rock musical, and you you wrote him an impassioned letter, which I love. Getting what you want. You wrote in this letter, and in it you said it was great, because you started off with what you loved about his musical and his music. And then you pitched him a rock musical of your own, which was a similar storyline in some ways about a tumultuous family. Can you tell me why that that's you knew you wanted to work with him, but maybe didn't want to work with him on that particular work of his.

[48:03] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, it didn't occur to me that Boho Days, which became Tick-Tick Boom, would be a show that could run off Broadway and uh find an audience of a couple thousand people a week for many, many, many weeks because it was a play about a composer's creative process. And it was my original opinion, which evolved that it was that it was too inside baseball to do for a regular audience.

[48:27] Michelle Simone Miller: Got it.

[48:39] Jeffrey Seller: But the truth is, after I tried to produce it, I couldn't raise the money, and I didn't, but we moved on to rent and things turned out pretty well. And eventually my friends Robin Goodman and Victoria Leacock did produce Boho Days as Tick-Tick Boom with Raul La Sparza. And I was right because ultimately they couldn't find an audience to sustain it for all those years. Now, Tic-Tic Boom has become a great little part of the canon.

[49:05] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[49:06] Jeffrey Seller: Um, but that was the reason. I just I never thought that it would be able to sustain itself to a general audience. And so then later, there's there's a couple part chapters of the book specifically devoted to rent, but you talk about seeing his original iteration of rent, which was La Bohem, right? Was what was the name of the original title?

[49:28] Jeffrey Seller: It was based on the Bohap. But what was it called originally? Rent was always called Rent Fair.

[49:34] Michelle Simone Miller: So you went to see Rent and it it didn't work uh in it in its original form. Can you talk to me about that? Having that difficult conversation with Jonathan Larson, who was a friend of yours, a friend you you needed to work with. I mean, I I loved this idea of like that moment at the end where you were you were talking about how like you know, you said to him, You need to make this happen, or I'm gonna quit producing. Like this is this is important that's a good thing.

[49:56] Jeffrey Seller: Yeah, because I believe so fervently in Jonathan as the artist for our generation. But the very first time uh Jonathan did a staged reading of rent, which means actors singing and singing at music stands, uh, it didn't work. Yeah, it had a great opening number, Rent, and then it kind of got lost in themes and songs and characters all about the East Village, but without a plot and a spine. And uh one fellow I brought left an intermission, and the other one said at the end, Jonathan needs to do something else. So when Jonathan asked me to go out to dinner and tell him what I thought, I thought, oh, how am I gonna do this? So you take a deep breath, you give a compliment.

[50:46] Michelle Simone Miller: You did compliment sandwich it, yeah.

[50:48] Jeffrey Seller: You say start with a compliment. Wow. Opening number song, what an amazing scene. And then I had to say, but I don't understand what's going on. I can't follow the plot. I can't attach to the characters. And he was bruised. And I said, Do you just want to like write a collage of life in these villages? Or do you want to write a play? He said, I want to write a play. I was like, then go write the play. Because it's not there yet.

[51:17] Michelle Simone Miller: It's a very understandably so a very strong understanding of story. And I think a lot of it that comes from maybe obviously just naturally, but also just you've immersed yourself in theater being a theater kid. How did you approach writing a memoir while still keeping in the mind of I need to be a storyteller in this?

[51:37] Jeffrey Seller: Oh, thank you. Um I knew that number one, no one needs another memoir about Broadway. No one needs another memoir about uh a gay kid coming out. No one needs another memoir about the kid from the Midwest who moves to New York and becomes a success. What I thought we might need is a memoir that goes deeper and is willing to expose the pure core of our being and our vulnerability and our yearning and also our own ugliness, our own flaws. And I tried to do that, but I also knew that my job was to write a story with a conflict and a beginning, middle, and an end. Because it had to be a heck of a lot better than popcorn peat if it was going to work. And I was very conscious of creating that arc of a beginning, middle, and end. And I was very conscious that every chapter had to create that arc.

[52:46] Michelle Simone Miller: I felt that.

[52:47] Jeffrey Seller: And I think that's very hard to do as someone who hasn't written before. Um I wrote a lot of letters.

[52:53] Michelle Simone Miller: You wrote a lot of letters and a lot of journals.

[52:55] Jeffrey Seller: And they have a lot of beginnings, middles in it. But it's no, I think that's a very difficult thing to accomplish. And I think it's a lot of times why, and I say this with all the respect in the world, a lot of uh writers tend to not hit their stride after, like, you know, they need to write a couple books to kind of go, okay, this is what I'm doing well. This is how I can make story even stronger. But I really did feel that each chapter had its beginning, middle, and end, and I felt the whole book did, and I felt like the stories within were very visual and compelling. And there were moments I like would sit with a chapter for a second, just be like, okay, what did that bring out in me? What am I seeing? Uh, how do I form a question from this? Um, okay, but a couple more things, because we only have a couple minutes. Um, how do you relax?

[53:41] Jeffrey Seller: I go to yoga, uh beak room style, meaning the 26 poses that you do twice in a 106 degree room.

[53:50] Michelle Simone Miller: What a way to relax.

[53:51] Jeffrey Seller: I know. But you know what? What it yoga is about the relaxation one gains after the class, not during the which by the way, I tell people all the time about the benefits of meditation, is not what you like. People always think they're doing it wrong because they feel like in the meditation they're not hitting something or they're not it's really about the effects afterwards. So I love that you say that. Uh so I do yoga.

[54:16] Michelle Simone Miller: Is there another question?

[54:18] Jeffrey Seller: Well, I mean, if there's something else that makes you like a lot to read your own.

[54:21] Michelle Simone Miller: I don't relax.

[54:21] Jeffrey Seller: That's fair. You know what? You know what I do to relax? Take a nap.

[54:25] Michelle Simone Miller: Oh, I love naps.

[54:26] Jeffrey Seller: Not everyone can take naps.

[54:27] Michelle Simone Miller: I'm a big nap person too.

[54:28] Jeffrey Seller: I'm a big nap person.

[54:30] Michelle Simone Miller: Um, at what point of producing shows do you get your biggest high?

[54:36] Jeffrey Seller: I love the preview process because everything and anything is possible.

[54:43] Michelle Simone Miller: Fair. Is there a ritual or superstition you have on opening night?

[54:48] Jeffrey Seller: Oh, I hate opening night. Uh my ritual is to just try to keep my head down.

[54:54] Michelle Simone Miller: Okay.

[54:55] Jeffrey Seller: But um, it's not my favorite day in the life of a show, I'll tell you that.

[54:59] Michelle Simone Miller: It's not your high.

[54:59] Jeffrey Seller: That's not the high.

[55:01] Michelle Simone Miller: Okay. Do you have a go to karaoke song? Do you have a karaoke?

[55:03] Jeffrey Seller: No. And by the way, I want to go back. And the reason is not because I don't want to celebrate the company and all that we've achieved, is because the date we have to read the reviews at 10 04 is very, very um anxiety producing.

[55:21] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah.

[55:21] Jeffrey Seller: And it takes away a lot of the fun of opening a show.

[55:25] Michelle Simone Miller: It's interesting that the pre previews are some of the best moments for you, but then when those previews end and that opening night happens, it's almost like the end of that high, that particular high.

[55:37] Jeffrey Seller: That particular high. And if you get great reviews, you get new highs.

[55:39] Michelle Simone Miller: Yeah, yeah.

[55:40] Jeffrey Seller: And if you get crummy reviews, you uh have to deal with a whole nother thing.

[55:44] Michelle Simone Miller: That's true. Um is there a book you recommend?

[55:48] Jeffrey Seller: This is the last one, a book you recommend to every creative person. Um I I have certainly spent my career recommending Act One by Moss Hart, which was my inspiration. And I've also always recommended The Season by William Goldman, which he wrote as a nonfiction book about the business of Broadway uh around 1967.

[56:07] Michelle Simone Miller: Good to know.

[56:07] Jeffrey Seller: Well, I am going to recommend this book to my audience. I'm also gonna ask you to sign a couple more if you don't mind.

[56:13] Jeffrey Seller: With pleasure. Thank you so much for talking with me about this and for writing this book. And I appreciate your time.

[56:20] Jeffrey Seller: I loved our conversation with you.

[56:25] Michelle Simone Miller: I'm excited to share that we are doing a giveaway of the book Theater Kid, written by Jeffrey Seller, which I highly recommend. And I'm excited because three listeners will get a chance to win Theater Kid.

[56:40] Michelle Simone Miller: So what I would ask you to do is to follow us on Instagram at Michelle Simone Miller and at Mentors on the Mike to look at the very simple rules as to how to submit to this particular giveaway. And just because you were able to listen all the way through to the end of this episode, I'd like you to send me either a comment or a DM with the word Adventureland in the comments or in the DMs. Um, and you will get an extra entry to the giveaway.

[57:15] Michelle Simone Miller: So happy playing. Thank you so much for listening to Mentors on the Mic. If you enjoyed the episode, please share it with a friend in entertainment you know would love it. Let me know what you learned or what stayed with you on our Instagram at mentors on the mic. I love reading your messages. Uh, you can also find me at Michelle Simone Miller on Instagram. On both accounts, I'll be sharing even more information about our mentors. Talk to someone about what you learned today who would really appreciate it, and send them the episode. Also, if you love the show, please go ahead and leave us a rating and review on iTunes. It really makes a huge difference in growing this. It makes it easier for people to find our podcast, and I love reading your reviews. So thank you so much, and I'll see you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred