Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#1 - Back of the Line, with Jay Armstrong Johnson

Join host Mark Peikert and Broadway fave Jay Armstrong Johnson as they step up and turn out to discuss the 1985 A Chorus Line film. Does it matter that Cassie shows up late? (Yes!) Do the new songs hold up next to the originals?.. Read More

From the show: Movie Musical Madness

38 mins
5/6/20

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Join host Mark Peikert and Broadway fave Jay Armstrong Johnson as they step up and turn out to discuss the 1985 A Chorus Line film. Does it matter that Cassie shows up late? (Yes!) Do the new songs hold up next to the originals? (No!) And just where is the sex studio Cassie and Zach reminisce about? In a world where jazz hands indicate “sexy,” no performance is off limits!

Produced by Dori Berinstein and Alan Seales for the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Mark Peikert: Well, now we know what Dance Three looks like. Then again, based on what could have been, we should just be thankful that A Chorus Line wasn't worse. At one point, we could have had a version starring John Travolta and Mikhail Baryshnikov as a gay Cassie and Zach. Instead, we got a movie about dancers cast with singers, a very sulky Cassie, and so much reworking of the song list you have to wonder why they wanted to film this in the first place. But maybe, just maybe, A Chorus Line does film works as its own entity. I'm Mark Peikert. I don't give a fuck about the red shoes. And this is Movie Musical Madness. Back of the line.

[0:48] Mark Peikert: Joining me today is a man as smooth as a lemon pie. Surprise. Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[0:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That intro, though.

[0:58] Mark Peikert: Hi, Mark.

[0:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hi, Jay. What's going on?

[1:06] Mark Peikert: I'm delighted to have tricked you into being on this podcast.

[1:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well and to have tricked you into watching A Chorus Line the movie.

[1:09] Mark Peikert: The trickery's all mine, actually. I had a blast rewatching it.

[1:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So when was the last time that you actually watched this movie?

[1:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god, you're gonna freak out. So when my freshman year of college was here at NYU, and I couldn't afford to fly home for the first holiday for Thanksgiving. So I was pretty much the only one in my freshman dorm that just stayed behind. So I went down the street, I got a double quarter pounder meal, brought it back to my freshman dorm, and watched the A Chorus Line movie for the very first time in my bunk bed dorm room.

[1:42] Mark Peikert: I love that journey for you.

[1:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was lovely. I was very thankful. I spent one Thanksgiving alone in my dorm eating a sweet potato pie and watching The Little Foxes.

[1:50] Mark Peikert: There you go. Very on brand for both of us, I feel. Alright, so let's just get into it. This is a terrible movie.

[1:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yeah.

[2:00] Mark Peikert: This is a—okay. Let's not go so far as to say it's a terrible movie. Let's say it's a terrible adaptation of A Chorus Line.

[2:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[2:07] Mark Peikert: That gets so much wrong about what A Chorus Line is about that I don't even—they might as well have just made a completely separate movie about auditioning for something.

[2:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it's kind of true. Which I think in doing my research, that's what Michael Bennett wanted to do. He wanted to do a movie of casting the movie, essentially.

[2:28] Mark Peikert: Yes, which sounds way more interesting to me, and they ended up kind of doing that with Every Little Step.

[2:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right. Remember that documentary back when they were casting the revival in 2008, nine? But yeah, that I think that would have been way more interesting than this very, I don't know, washy 80s version of—I don't know really what it was.

[2:49] Mark Peikert: Well, this version one is about young dancers just looking for the big break.

[2:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, young dancers looking like 45 years old, though. They keep saying, like, I'm 23, and I'm like, bitch, no, you're not 23.

[3:00] Mark Peikert: People aged very differently back then.

[3:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I guess they did. They didn't have keels.

[3:04] Mark Peikert: We did. And we didn't have cryogenics.

[3:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, right, Restylane injections.

[3:09] Mark Peikert: Oh, the Restylane bills alone.

[3:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, truly. Well, I mean, you know, what's her face? Val, I mean, had so much plastic surgery, but did she? Like, those boobs were like really kind of like small. I mean, when she was like, "You're all looking at my tits now, aren't you?" I was like, where are they? Mostly your nipples because it's cold in there, clearly, but I don't know.

[3:30] Mark Peikert: It's called inside the Mark Hellinger Theater.

[3:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right. Where they filmed.

[3:34] Mark Peikert: That is true. Do you have any fun fact points about the Mark Hellinger Theater?

[3:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like to pull that show off. Well, when I was watching the opening scenes, I was like, oh my god, they're standing outside of the stage door of the Jacobs Golden Majestic Theater. It's the stage door I walked into for a year and a half while doing Phantom of the Opera. So I was like, well, that's kind of fun. That only took six minutes to get to.

[3:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So they keep going in and out of my stage door. But then I was like, but that's definitely not the inside of the Majestic. I know that's not the inside of the Majestic, and Cassie literally goes into the stage door of the Majestic in the movie.

[4:06] Mark Peikert: And then the magic of the movies.

[4:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right. Exterior shots are always different than interior shots.

[4:11] Mark Peikert: But it is what you said.

[4:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You learned that on Quantico.

[4:14] Mark Peikert: That is very correct. It is inside of the Mark Hellinger Theater, which is now renamed the Times Square Church.

[4:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And no longer a theater.

[4:22] Mark Peikert: It's no longer a theater.

[4:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It is a sanctuary.

[4:25] Mark Peikert: Beautiful inside.

[4:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I've never been inside, actually.

[4:28] Mark Peikert: Oh go for service.

[4:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, sure, sure, sure.

[4:30] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[4:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Maybe I will.

[4:31] Mark Peikert: I got a tour because I'm important.

[4:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, really?

[4:33] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[4:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Who gave you that tour?

[4:35] Mark Peikert: Jesus himself.

[4:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes, actually. He appeared one day. He led me. He had some wine that had been water. And we had a great time.

[4:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Great.

[4:44] Mark Peikert: At least he got drunk. So you've already brought up Val. So let's just maybe the whole defining narrative of this podcast is we just shout out things that we really hated about the movie and then dissect them. So Val, first of all, that's what Audrey Landers, who is like an 80s sex symbol. And she'd been on Dallas at the time. And the director, Richard Attenborough, wanted unknowns to be in the movie. And she was like, oh my god. Oh my god, I think I'm too famous. I don't know if I should audition. Also, you're the worst dancer in the movie, sorry girl. They literally cut away from her anytime that they can.

[5:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it's true. It's like, well, she made the line, but clearly she shouldn't have made the line. So Zach just wants a piece, really. Also, it's insane what she does with "Dance Ten, Looks Three," where it's like a comedy patter song. I don't get it. The whole—the way they made the movie is really kind of ridiculous. Certain things are dream sequences where they're cutting away with theatrical light, and some is not. There's working in work lights, and it really—it is truly a mess of a movie.

[5:50] Mark Peikert: So let's take a moment about that and discuss Richie.

[5:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yeah. Swinging on a rope?

[5:59] Mark Peikert: During "I Can Do That"?

[6:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was Mike, actually. Mike swung on the rope.

[6:03] Mark Peikert: Yeah, randomly. I mean, the unions would have gone fucking ballistic, first of all. So that doesn't make any sense whatsoever. How did he—I mean, here, let's just follow this through. So he's out there telling his story, right? And tapping, kind of. And all of a sudden, a rope descends from the flies.

[6:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I think they cut away to some other thing, like a—I don't know, some scene with Zach and Cassie or something, and then they come back and he's on the rope.

[6:30] Mark Peikert: He's swinging across the stage.

[6:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right. So there's no even introduction of the rope. He's just randomly on one.

[6:37] Mark Peikert: Probably.

[6:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes. Probably making some fly like fall to its death. Who knows? And then how did he get off and why? It was a tap—no, I mean, Michael Bennett had nothing to do with it. So I mean, and look, this is a movie that they bought the rights immediately. It languished. No one could figure out a way to make it work. At one point, they said, oh, you know, you know who's a big movie star and who can dance? John Travolta. Let's talk to John Travolta about starring.

[7:05] Mark Peikert: And John Travolta said, oh, uh, uh, hey, you know, uh—

[7:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's why John Travolta.

[7:09] Mark Peikert: Oh, that's really good.

[7:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, thanks. Um, oh hey, you know what I think would be really cool? Um, what if I starred as Tony Manero in A Chorus Line? What if I played Tony Manero auditioning to be in a show? And they're like, that's the dumbest fucking idea we've ever heard, John Travolta. And he—so he took it for Staying Alive, the sequel to Saturday Night Fever.

[7:34] Mark Peikert: Oh, good for him.

[7:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But instead they said, well, hey, you know, John, we don't like that. But what if you start as Cassie? And John Travolta said, oh. Oh, there's a movie I'd watch.

[7:46] Mark Peikert: Okay.

[7:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And they're like, yeah, and you could—uh, gay Cassie, a gay Cassie, and we'll get Baryshnikov to be Zach.

[7:54] Mark Peikert: Michael himself.

[7:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And John Travolta's like, yes. Why didn't this movie get made though, Mark?

[8:00] Mark Peikert: Uh, I don't know, but you can read—so there will be a companion website with this episode of the podcast where you can read my fanfiction about the making of that movie.

[8:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Alright, I'm just gonna do that.

[8:11] Mark Peikert: Just all the behind the scenes. I'm literally stroking my chest as I'm saying that.

[8:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You really are. I mean, you're living here in fantasy over here.

[8:18] Mark Peikert: Um, I do, but it's fine. Back to the mic thing, because like there's this whole dramatic sequence where like Cassie falls and it's raining and she's trying to catch a cab, and then some like bitchy New Yorker comes by and steals her cab and she's wet and it's raining and she's hurt her elbow, and then all of a sudden we cut to this vaudevillian number. Like the transitions are so absurd, they make zero sense.

[8:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But also, so Cassie. You shouted out something that I hated. This Cassie, Allison Reed, bless her heart. She did the cabaret revival with Joel Gray in the 80s.

[8:52] Mark Peikert: Oh, I didn't know that.

[8:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh, she was the teacher on High School Musical.

[8:56] Mark Peikert: Right. Yes.

[8:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[8:58] Mark Peikert: I forgot about that.

[9:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So she is there with her asymmetrical perm.

[9:03] Mark Peikert: Oh my God.

[9:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And she shows up to audition and Zach's like, "You're too big of a star. You can't audition for this. It's too small." And she's like, okay. And then she hurts herself in the rain, and then they're just like, come backstage and hang out.

[9:14] Mark Peikert: Yeah, come back and hang out. And then ultimately they go on a break, and she comes out and she's like in a purple leotard. I mean, this is one of the most egregious things about this movie to me is cutting the music in the mirror.

[9:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know.

[9:28] Mark Peikert: And replacing it with "Let Me Dance For You."

[9:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Let me dance for you.

[9:31] Mark Peikert: And replacing, "God, I'm a Dancer. A dancer dances" with "God, I'm a dancer. It's who I am. It's what I do." Like that's also could be said—a dancer dances.

[9:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, the only thing they kept which was genius was like the mirror motif.

[9:48] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[9:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was only like a three-second shot. And I was like, oh, they—oh, now it's gone. Also, what was their weird sex dance studio?

[9:56] Mark Peikert: Couldn't tell you.

[9:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Those like flashback cutaways with an even worse wig.

[10:00] Mark Peikert: Oh, I mean, was that that? That was the worst.

[10:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was terrible though, poor girl. I mean, I like Michael Douglas as Zach in his robe with his hair slicked back just fresh from the shower.

[10:11] Mark Peikert: Yeah, why did he just shower? Does he own the studio? Does he live in that specific dance studio?

[10:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Maybe it's a reference to like how Michael Bennett took his A Chorus Line earnings and bought 890 Broadway.

[10:22] Mark Peikert: I might have made up that address. He bought a building and made it into like a big rehearsal studio space.

[10:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[10:26] Mark Peikert: Okay. So maybe they're just like paying homage.

[10:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's French for homage.

[10:31] Mark Peikert: Oh, really? I thought it was pronounced homage.

[10:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, no, it might be in Texas.

[10:37] Mark Peikert: It actually definitely is.

[10:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Just like Jerry Jones started in The Harris on Broadway.

[10:45] Mark Peikert: So Zach apparently has a sex studio where Cassie dances for him late at night.

[10:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, absolutely. Annie's bipolar. I mean, she doesn't even do the audition. She does a Broadway show. Cassie's there from downbeat to curtain call.

[11:01] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[11:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And this Cassie is lounging backstage, smoking cigarettes, looking like she's in a bad production of Godspell in whatever outfit she's wearing. I mean, like just trying to make a phone call on that payphone.

[11:13] Mark Peikert: A collect call or whatever.

[11:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She doesn't know where she's gonna go. She's gonna have to stay with Terrence Mann.

[11:19] Mark Peikert: Terrence Mann who I thought was Tim Curry at first.

[11:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you, Terry.

[11:29] Mark Peikert: My goodness. So what I mean, they cut the music in the mirror. They cut "Hello Love."

[11:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[11:35] Mark Peikert: They started out with "Hello 12," and then went to that really weird—

[11:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[11:41] Mark Peikert: Surprise. This is all your choreography is on point.

[11:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is exactly what he does.

[11:48] Mark Peikert: Yeah, because sex means jazz hands, I guess. So I'm sorry. First of all, this song "Surprise" is a huge sexy dance number.

[11:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That feels like a ripoff of the "Come Fly With Us" from All That Jazz.

[12:00] Mark Peikert: Okay, I feel that.

[12:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So it's a super sexy number.

[12:04] Mark Peikert: Is it?

[12:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sorry. It is filmed as if it's a super sexy number, and people are staring meaningfully at each other. You don't see their feet because you shouldn't.

[12:13] Mark Peikert: Right.

[12:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And the lyric nominated for an Oscar, the lyrics are sailing through the sky, smooth as a lemon pie.

[12:21] Mark Peikert: Surprise.

[12:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was nominated for an Oscar.

[12:23] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[12:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Different time.

[12:25] Mark Peikert: Different time. No.

[12:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure, sure. And that is the weirdest thing about the song. Oh my God. What I found kind of remarkable though is how much of the original text actually did make it into the movie. Like, I'd be like, oh shit, they're okay. This is the script. This oh now they're diverting. You know, so it was very weird. It's like, why not just write a completely new script? If you're gonna fuck with it that much, you know, if you're gonna—the whole movie's a bait and switch. It really is. Oh, okay. Here's Hello 12, Hello 13, Hello. Oh no, now we have—who was making those executive decisions? I don't think many people. So basically, the rights were about to expire to make the movie. So they had to make a movie.

Okay. And this is that thing in the 80s where a lot of people who had never directed a movie musical before were like, I mean, how hard can it be? No, it's the hardest, actually. Have you seen these movie musicals they're making these days? Yikes. I haven't really liked one since Chicago. Like actually. Truly. And that was what? 20 years ago? It's too long. I don't like that. I don't like that math. No. It was like John Houston directing Annie. And then all of a sudden they're racing up a fire ladder. No. No. No. Into the Maltese Falcon. No, thank you. Oh man. What you know what? You wrote down notes. Tell me about some of your scribblings. I noticed the Twin Towers in the first few shots, which was just like, oh, right.

That New York in the 80s. I noticed the tree in the middle of Times Square, which I was like, there was foliage in Times Square. What a twist. I didn't actually know. Now, if there's a tree in Times Square, Scarlett Johansson playing a tree character trying to take a photo of tourists. Very good. Um, the smoking indoors was very nostalgic for me. My whole family smoked growing up, so I was like, oh, I'm back home. Oh, that's nice. Um, like weird militaristic. I mean, like they did pay homage to like the 80s dance military kind of boot campy style that like those kinds of auditions had back in the day. Also, they're in a Broadway theater on a Broadway stage, which is how Broadway auditions have were done back then.

They would never be done these days because it's just way too much money to pay a crew to be there to have to watch an audition. I actually did have one audition on stage though, and it was for the National Tour of Spring Awakening. Weirdly. Did you get it? Sure didn't. Um, stage was it? But it was in the same time I was in callbacks for A Chorus Line, the national tour, and so I got A Chorus Line. Oh. I know. And you were the best Sheila I've ever seen. Uh, also quick reminder that this Sheila is allegedly 29. Oh, bitch. No, she's not. Also, I feel like they cut because Michael Douglas is chain smoking up a storm. Also, fun fact about Michael Douglas, he refused star billing for this. He said, I don't want my name above the title.

It's an ensemble thing. My name should be, it should just be alphabetical. Sure. Where did you valiant? Yeah. Anyway, he's chain smoking up a storm. So they had to cut Sheila's one of my favorite lines. Can the adults please smoke? Right. Well, they also gave turned Val's—I don't know the red shoes. I never saw the red shoes. I don't give a fuck about the red shoes. And you, I don't give a shit about the red shoes. And that's not funny. No, it's not funny. And they cut, I mean, that's one of the best monologues in the show, and they cut it literally in half, which was upsetting to me. Also, Judy Turner's name is now Judy Monroe, and there's a Marilyn Monroe joke as opposed to Lana Turner, which, you know, is a thing, I guess.

Lana Turner was still alive. She was doing Falcon Crest at the time. Jane Wyman had a few there with the papers all the time. I don't even know what all of that meant. Well, don't worry about it. Also, I literally so I'm looking at my notes, and I this is what I wrote about Judy. Jesus, Judy. Fake Jessica Lang. That's so real. Oh. And poor Judy does not make the line at the end. She does in the stage production, but she does not in the movie because BB Benson gets it in the movie. Yeah. Because that gorge dancer who does the—so remember when Zach's like, come forward, come forward, and she's wearing that like teal number, and she like hits those, she's like doing all those body rolls and she's hitting those accents.

Yeah, so BB got the line because she should have. I mean, but also I mean, yeah. There is something very strange about seeing Zach's reactions to their stories. Yeah. Because it's as if they're telling you how you should be reacting to the stories. Right. Which is completely opposite of what they do in the stage production because Zach is merely a voice of God, and so you're having your own reactions as opposed to watching reactions. Yeah. And this I would see Michael Douglas like, oh, oh, I'm Riley amused by this story. And I was like, oh, am I Riley amused? Should I be? Why am I not? Because it's not emotionally captivating. It's—it wasn't well directed or written or acted. I mean, like Paul's monologue should be fucking heartbreaking.

And it is in the stage production when it's done right. And this one was just—it was a fleeting moment that meant jack shit. And when he broke his leg, I said, I don't care. Oh. Oh, did he break his leg? I mean he's just brained his ankle or you know, re-injured his knee or whatever the fuck it is. But you know who knows what to do? Cassie. Cassie showed up from sulking backstage, and she was like, Oh, here, get elevate it. And Sheila has her value. I've taken two already. Before lunch or after lunch or something, which was an added line, which it was not needed. It was like I was on a hat. That was just—that was improv. Probably so, actually. She didn't know that she was being filmed. She was just sharing a personal anecdote from her life.

Oh man. But there, I mean, the movie is filled with these moments that should be affecting, and ultimately are not. Paul's monologue does not register. Not even a little bit. It gets a little teary at the end. I was like, okay, well, he got there and it's close up, but where was the ramp up? But even in the first number, uh, you know, God, I hope I get it, when Paul has this little solo, he's staring at himself in a mirror. Right. But his reflection isn't singing. I didn't even notice that. He's singing, but his reflection isn't. I don't get it. What are you trying? I don't know. Is that the only time they're gonna use that device? And how many times would they be singing out loud versus they would—you just—they would just be singing in their heads?

Right. And why are you going back and forth between the two? And why choose at the ballet to be like the one moment where they're using the device where like the world goes away and it's just someone singing in a black abyss? It's like okay, so this is a dream sequence, but they're not gonna go into a beautiful ballet montage like they do when the big huge, rousing beautiful music comes in. I was con—I'm just—I'm truly confused by the whole thing. I'm confused by a lot, but also the black void thing comes up frequently in movie musicals. Diana Ross also sings home at the end of The Wiz in a black void. You're right. While photos of people that we've previously seen float past, not like moments from the movie, just still photos.

Just—they had production photos they just threw up there. Just a PowerPoint presentation. Oh, and then why is Sheila singing like Barbara Streisand, like Fanny Bryce? I don't know. Like she was doing a whole thing, oh. Well, that's Mae West, but you know what I'm saying. I hear you. Also, the girl that plays Christine, when I see her headshot, I say, Oh my god, I've seen that headshot. How the hell do I know that headshot? I know that headshot, I know that headshot. And then I realized that that's Nicole Fosse, Bob Fosse and Gwen Verdon's daughter, who was in the original cast of Phantom of the Opera, and I walked by her headshot every single day of my life for a year and a half, and that's how I realized that that was Nicole Fosse.

Also, there was—I was talking about—I was talking to Christopher Catelli. Do you want to pick up that name that I just dropped? Hey Chris, how are you, babe? And we were talking about the movie, and he was like, I mean, it's so embarrassing to watch them dance next to Nicole Fosse because she has nothing to do, but everything is so small and precise, and everyone else is like strapping shoes onto like horses, and they're just galloping around. I love all of the tap sounds too in Mike's number when they're just in—they're clearly in jazz flats and there's zero taps on them, but the tap sounds are so clean. They're so clean, the cleanest. That's how you get clean. You don't actually tap. You just do them later.

Oh, definitely in post. Oh man. Also, I mean, should we talk about one and how one is like a horror film? Oh, it's the messiest, most not together. Like it's supposed to be a chorus line of people doing the same exact movement in complete precision, and it is a junky, messy fuck show. I mean, truly, there is the moment where it's going to the big finale. They've all gotten cast. Blah blah blah. We're supposed to care. Right. We're Zach tells us with his face that we should care. We're trying to find it in our heart to care. And then all of a sudden it cuts to individual people like popping out from behind hats. With solos, with solos. Or rising up from out of camera range. And you're like, this isn't like a scary jack in the box.

Michael Bennett directed it so that everyone is in the same exact costume, everyone looks the same exact way, and everyone does the same exact movement in unison vocally and physically. Because that's what a chorus is. That's what a chorus is, and that's what the dire conceit of the fucking show is. And so for them to like break it up into solos and like bad choreography that is hard to even clean, uh, is truly messy. And if you look close enough in the end shot where they're like zooming out of the like really crazy kick line where they're all kicking a little too high, there's a woman in the second row, third to the right, that falls. She just fully bites it, and then just comes back up and starts kicking more.

And they kept it. I definitely took a video of it. Just so if you'd like to see it, it's all my—do you want to play the video for everyone to watch on the podcast, Jay? Would you enjoy doing that? Yeah, it's definitely a visual medium, right? Yeah, no, I like that. That's why we're dressed up today. I mean, and then there's just—oh man. I mean, just to go back to Cassie and Zach, because the whole thing is so shoehorned in. And in the stage version, it doesn't feel—it feels natural. Right. It feels like, oh, hey, it's a small industry, we've worked together before, and like we heard a thing. Right. Like, if I had a penny for every chorus member that I've had a thing with. Well, and that's the thing, is you want to root for Cassie in the stage production because you've seen her on stage with the rest of these people killing it the whole time.

So when her time comes to tell her story, then you've at least watched her in the show from that point up. So that you have some kind of inkling as to what you should feel about her. Yes. Or that you should feel something at all. And this one, she's just been lounging backstage as though she owns the place. Yes. And then comes out and it's owed a role. Right. Because she's been unemployed for a year. And she keeps popping her fucking head and rolling her fucking shoulders. Don't pop the head, Cassie. Oh, you know what? But Michael Douglas goes after her in the chorus line auditions. Like when they're all dancing together. Like in a way that I've never heard a Zach go after a Cassie before. I mean, it's the gig.

I mean, you're supposed to, but Michael Douglas, like we said, is fully bipolar. I mean, he's dealing with semantic depression. Oh, and it's delicious to watch. Yeah, I mean, those cigarettes are doing something. But also, correct me if I'm wrong, because you did tour the country in this musical, did you not? I didn't want to. I also did a small stint here in New York at the City Center last year. Oh, well, you would go into the City Center stage door, but you would actually be on the stage of the Majestic. Ironically. LOL. Uh, in the musical, do—oh no, we have to look this up. Uh, in the musical, do Connie and Morales both know Mr. Carp? No, no, no, no, no. I wrote that down on my notes as well.

I was like, what is this scene between Connie and Morales? These two women of color who were at the same performing arts high school? Yeah, that was definitely a conceit made up for the movie. And they were like, remember Mr. Carp? Do I hit it? That failed the Bechtel test. Two women talking about a dude. Oh man. Just again, Morales' song. Nothing. I felt literally nothing because she was standing at the edge of a stage in work light. There was no dream sequence. There was no cutaway. There was no like cinematographic language that shows that she went back into like her mind and her past. And you know, it was just all at the lip of the stage, and she was telling her story in zero theatrical light. Yeah. And in which case, why not just film the stage production? Correct. If you're going to do so little in terms of making it into a movie, then just film the stage.

[25:17] Mark Peikert: Right. Get an amazing cast and do that. But there's also... I have this question for you because you're a dancer.

[25:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Go on.

[25:26] Mark Peikert: One of the greatest dancers of our generation.

[25:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You must be joking.

[25:30] Mark Peikert: You move well.

[25:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure. I'm a strong mover.

[25:33] Mark Peikert: You mean well.

[25:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Is it feasible that those dancers could dance in those clothes? And I'm thinking specifically of the men whose shirts are unbuttoned completely.

[25:45] Mark Peikert: Oh, sure. Flapping about their abs.

[25:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's the 80s. No one really had abs. I wasn't around in the 80s, but like all the photos that I've seen of my dance teacher and her dancers back in the 80s, it all looked like that. I mean, kind of that was what they wore back then. I mean, it was all spandex at least, so you could move in it, but you're right. The open shirts and the flappability of it all.

[26:11] Mark Peikert: Oh, so flappable.

[26:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. They didn't know. They didn't have Lululemon yet.

[26:15] Mark Peikert: They sure didn't. What did we do before that?

[26:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Am I right? I don't really know.

[26:20] Mark Peikert: What did we do?

[26:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Capagio.

[26:22] Mark Peikert: Oh.

[26:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just still around.

[26:24] Mark Peikert: Still around.

[26:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Still kicking.

[26:26] Mark Peikert: Still kicking. We're desperately going for some sponsorships on this episode. Um, and whenever I watch A Chorus Line, I make sure to drink LaCroix.

[26:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god, I love LaCroix.

[26:37] Mark Peikert: Uh, Peach Pear, Pompa Mousse, two of my faves.

[26:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, I love a pompa mousse. I also love just a simple lemon.

[26:42] Mark Peikert: Oh, okay. I'll take your lemon.

[26:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You have that on hand, and then you can just add gin to it.

[26:45] Mark Peikert: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And all of a sudden you've got a sphere, you've got a spicy cocktail, you've got a bubbly cocktail too.

[26:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay, also, okay. What's the line that Al has? He's like, um, I'm straight, I'm not too bright, but I'm not too dumb, I'm not too talented. Like that. That's how he's selling himself to Zach trying to get a job on the show.

[27:07] Mark Peikert: Also, notice the dumb straight guy is like, here, this is who I am. And everyone else has to go into their childhood trauma.

[27:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Exactly. Like everyone else to get a job has to be like, oh my god. And then I was doing drag, and my father walked past me and it was humiliating.

[27:14] Mark Peikert: Oh my god.

[27:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And he's just like, I mean, I'm gonna do it the same way eight times a week.

[27:24] Mark Peikert: When has anyone ever walked into an audition and been like, cast me? I'm not too talented, but cast me. I won't ever go off book and I'll just do everything you want.

[27:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, no.

[27:36] Mark Peikert: Does that not work for you?

[27:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, it does not.

[27:39] Mark Peikert: Is that not how you got Hands on a Hard Body?

[27:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, it is. It's definitely not.

[27:43] Mark Peikert: No.

[27:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I stole that role from a friend.

[27:46] Mark Peikert: Sorry.

[27:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, was it one of those classic stories where you just went to the audition with him for moral support?

[27:51] Mark Peikert: And the casting director said, You.

[27:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Actually, he got a movie, and so he couldn't do one of the workshops. And so I was like a temporary replacement for him. Um, but then I came in being actually from Texas and had this level of authenticity as a Texan that they ended up liking, so then I took over the job.

[28:08] Mark Peikert: And that friend was Ben Platt.

[28:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I wish. I wish he was probably in middle school at that point. Let's be real.

[28:13] Mark Peikert: Oh, that's true. I forget that time passes.

[28:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my, you know where time doesn't pass? When you're watching the A Chorus Line movie.

[28:20] Mark Peikert: Oh, wow.

[28:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: John really drags on.

[28:23] Mark Peikert: Yeah, I would like to choose to go to the restroom and I'll be like, ah, I'm not pausing it.

[28:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh no.

[28:27] Mark Peikert: I'm just gonna let it keep playing. I got up to do dishes. I came back and was like, oh, this is still happening.

[28:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right. How wonderful. I did really enjoy Don's physique, though.

[28:38] Mark Peikert: That ass in them pants.

[28:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh. It was just really, it was a lovely visual. I mean, the bodies be banging.

[28:45] Mark Peikert: Yeah. I mean, 80s dancewear was like ugly, but at least it showed shit.

[28:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It sure did. You know? They're not covering everything up.

[28:52] Mark Peikert: They're not covering up their bulges with little shorts.

[28:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They are not.

[28:57] Mark Peikert: No. Have it out. Loud and proud.

[29:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh man. I mean, it's just so misguided that you watch it and you just think, how many people got involved with this not enjoying the original musical?

[29:13] Mark Peikert: Right. I mean, they just missed the point.

[29:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. It's really, I mean, Cassie singing "What I Did for Love." We haven't even talked about that.

[29:20] Mark Peikert: I mean, and she's just like walking the catwalk while singing it while all of the dancers are down on stage doing the work.

[29:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Doing the work, doing the thing that she did for love, and yet she's just singing this like sweeping solo about Zach.

[29:35] Mark Peikert: Yeah. So it's like, what you did him for love? Like what are you trying to do? What are you trying to tell?

[29:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it just misses the point almost every single time it tries to do it.

[29:46] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[29:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or to try to do something different to make it more like having her walk up the catwalk singing a song should be a beautiful cinematic moment.

[29:54] Mark Peikert: Sure.

[29:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's not because all you're thinking is, why are you singing about this lame guy? And also, why have we taken one a solo from the woman of color?

[30:03] Mark Peikert: Correct.

[30:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And given it to the star who has a big star entrance, sulks backstage, has a huge breakdown falling into traffic, like she's Celeste Talbot throwing herself in front of a bus. Girl, get it together.

[30:15] Mark Peikert: Also shows up late.

[30:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh yeah, way late. Stuck in traffic. I mean, we've all been in a cab and been late, but like girls straight from LaGuardia.

[30:24] Mark Peikert: She sure did. Maybe it's still called Ottawild then. I'm not sure.

[30:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Was it? I don't know. I'm not that old.

[30:30] Mark Peikert: Oh, I am.

[30:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am though.

[30:32] Mark Peikert: Are you?

[30:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am.

[30:33] Mark Peikert: That's okay. Uh yeah, I just don't want Cassie to get the part.

[30:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, uh, I don't really either. And what's crazy is in the original production, when they were in previews, Cassie did not get the part on Broadway. And they had such pushback from the ticket buyers, like, how the f couldn't you have let Cassie get the... I mean? And so they actually changed the script to make it so that Cassie got the line every single night because there was such egregious pushback from the audience, guys.

[31:05] Mark Peikert: And early, early on, I'm gonna go back further than you.

[31:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Please.

[31:09] Mark Peikert: Uh, they had Cassie show up late.

[31:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh.

[31:12] Mark Peikert: And it doesn't work.

[31:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It doesn't work.

[31:14] Mark Peikert: So she's gotta be there. Some of the cast members when they interviewed for the book On the Line were sharing stories about the movie and their reactions. And they said, in most of the instances where you don't like what the movie has done, it's something that they had tried in rehearsals or in previews and had rejected as not working.

[31:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh, well, I agree.

[31:35] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[31:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I feel like I read that, but it was also 15 years ago when I was a good idea. And also, I mean, like Richard Eyre said, Oh, you know, I didn't want to cast any of the original cast members because they're so old now. And this is really a musical about young people making it. And Kelly Bishop said, No wonder the movie's a piece of shit.

[31:52] Mark Peikert: Kelly Bishop, what a legend.

[31:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She's an icon.

[31:57] Mark Peikert: God, I mean Kelly Bishop as Sheila. I mean one of the great legendary.

[32:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: One of the great performances.

[32:06] Mark Peikert: Yeah. And you know what? Donna McKechnie as two casts spring to mind.

[32:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Donna McKechnie, of course.

[32:12] Mark Peikert: Of course. And Miss Jessica Simpson played Cassie in high school.

[32:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, and there is video footage.

[32:20] Mark Peikert: I refuse to watch that.

[32:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Singing the hell out of "Music in the Mirror."

[32:23] Mark Peikert: Okay.

[32:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And then she dan... she moves well. And then she pas de bourrée a couple of times.

[32:30] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[32:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, worth watching.

[32:34] Mark Peikert: Maybe.

[32:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I might check it out.

[32:36] Mark Peikert: I probably won't, but you know, I might.

[32:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Put some gin in your pompa mousse. And, you know, fire up the old YouTube.

[32:43] Mark Peikert: What they did not change was the tap combination. It is the same from the stage production as it is in the movie. I will tell you that much.

[32:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was surprised by that. Some of the only choreography that like kept its true form.

[32:56] Mark Peikert: Now, most of your stuff got cut from the film, didn't it?

[33:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, when I played Mark, yeah. Uh, his whole like gone. I mean, a little bit of the gonorrhea monologue made it, but it was like one of the only times where like because they cut so much of the original text. They cut so much of the gay text.

[33:15] Mark Peikert: Well, that's real.

[33:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Although Mark's not technically gay, because he has a crush on Val, but I did play Bobby at City Center, and they kept, I would say, 50% of his monologue. And Michael Douglas hated him.

[33:28] Mark Peikert: Oh, yeah.

[33:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Don't you come onto my stage and make jokes. I want authenticity and pain. And then you watch what he wants it for. Just put on a goddamn gold top hat.

[33:37] Mark Peikert: That's true.

[33:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And kick your legs.

[33:38] Mark Peikert: But here's a flaw with the musical in general, stage or film. Sorry, I'm going to...

[33:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It sure did.

[33:45] Mark Peikert: So Zach is saying, don't perform, I just want you to talk. And then every time we watch someone tell their life story, they were giving a full-blown, sometimes vaudevillian incredible performance.

[33:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's just like, okay, well, that's not what he asked for, but okay, I guess we're just gonna smooth over that one.

[34:06] Mark Peikert: Well, that's because you have to know you have to hear what he asked for, but know what he meant. So Bobby's not allowed to perform, even though Bobby's doing a monologue, but like Mike's allowed to do a full vaudeville tap number.

[34:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And swing from a rope if it comes.

[34:20] Mark Peikert: Like Tarzan.

[34:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I don't understand why you're not using this at Ripley Greer. You just need to come in with a rope.

[34:29] Mark Peikert: Oh man. That's actually how you got Phantom.

[34:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yeah, truly.

[34:33] Mark Peikert: The rope.

[34:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You swung into the lair.

[34:35] Mark Peikert: And Hal Prince said you.

[34:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The lasso.

[34:41] Mark Peikert: Some job lasso.

[34:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I guess my question now, Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[34:49] Mark Peikert: Go on.

[34:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Is separate from the A Chorus Line stage production? Do you think that A Chorus Line, the movie, is a good piece of art?

[35:03] Mark Peikert: Not comparing it to the stage.

[35:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I would say it is a representation of what it might have been like for a dancer in the 80s. I wouldn't say that it's a well-curated piece of art that has a beautiful arc and meaning, but it at least is a timestamp of a specific way of life in the 80s.

[35:32] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[35:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. I think that if there's a... like looking at it just as a movie, sure. Separate from anything else. I think that if there is a major flaw, it is one, a lack of cohesiveness about fantasy versus reality.

[35:45] Mark Peikert: Truly.

[35:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And two, they are assuming reactions to characters that are baseless. So they assume that we're going to root for Cassie.

[35:54] Mark Peikert: Right.

[35:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But really, if... and we do because we have the back history with the character in the show.

[35:58] Mark Peikert: Sure.

[35:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so we know, like, oh, okay. Like she's... oh, she's fell on tough times. She got cut from that movie where she did a commercial. She had to do a commercial.

[36:06] Mark Peikert: But in reality, I'm just staring at the mole on her face.

[36:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I wrote that in my notes, I was like, this mole. Oh my god. I mean, I just... I honestly cannot get over the I've been unemployed for a year. I'm ready to go back to the ensemble.

[36:19] Mark Peikert: For a year. Who does a voiceover work? Teach a class.

[36:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Could it be three years, maybe? I mean, like honestly.

[36:27] Mark Peikert: Everyone's been unemployed for a year. That's the dream. You just get some beer and some... you fire up the Wii and you play Mario Kart until you get cast.

[36:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's true. It's true.

[36:38] Mark Peikert: I mean.

[36:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I used to play eight to nine hours of Mario Kart a day.

[36:43] Mark Peikert: And look at you now.

[36:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And look at me now. I have my own podcast.

[36:49] Mark Peikert: All right. I think that that is all the time that we have for A Chorus Line.

[36:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh.

[36:55] Mark Peikert: What a delight.

[36:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Truly a delight. A Chorus Line is really one of my biggest loves, so thanks for making me hate it for a day.

[37:04] Mark Peikert: You know what? I get that a lot from men. I've never found something that you love that I can't make you hate for a spell.

[37:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: All right, Jay Armstrong Johnson. This is it.

[37:13] Mark Peikert: Thanks for having me, Mark. This was a delight.

[37:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This was better than the movie.

[37:18] Mark Peikert: Actually, it was.

[37:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And please tune in next time for another episode of Movie Musical Madness.

[37:28] Mark Peikert: This episode of Movie Musical Madness was edited by Kyle Moore with Theme Music by Sunshine Music. And thank you for listening to Movie Musical Madness, part of the Broadway Podcast Network. You can find out more about the podcast and me at bpn.fm/movie musical madness.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred