Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#3 - All Dolled Up, with Michael Urie

Ugly Betty and Torch Song star Michael Urie loves Hello, Dolly! and Barbra Streisand. Movie Musical Madness host Mark Peikert loves exactly half of those things. Can they agree on the 1969 film adaptation of the beloved Jerry Herman classic?.. Read More

From the show: Movie Musical Madness

33 mins
5/27/20

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Ugly Betty and Torch Song star Michael Urie loves Hello, Dolly! and Barbra Streisand. Movie Musical Madness host Mark Peikert loves exactly half of those things. Can they agree on the 1969 film adaptation of the beloved Jerry Herman classic? Just how out of touch was this movie in a year that also saw the release of Easy Rider? Was Carol Channing OK being passed over to recreate her role? Why did star Walter Matthau use the expression "butterfly fart"? And is Hello, Dolly! even a good story? From terrible impressions (is that Mark doing Sarah Paulson doing Kathleen Turner?) to second-hand stories from firsthand sources, this episode demands you put on your Sunday clothes and listen.

Produced by Dori Berinstein and Alan Seales for the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Mark Peikert: Call it the butterfly fart effect. That's what Walter Matthau told Barbra Streisand. She had less talent then. And surprise, their mutual dislike did no favors for their on-screen May December romance in Hello, Dolly! Then again, neither did Director Gene Kelly's weird staging. Or the terrible lip syncing. Or Streisand's casting. Yeah, we're going there. Still, a big glossy movie musical starring Streisand near the peak of her powers with that Jerry Herman score. Maybe Hello, Dolly! deserves another look. I'm Mark Peikert. I'm a little lumpy, but I ring. And this is Movie Musical Madness, all dolled up with nowhere to go.

[0:51] Mark Peikert: Joining me today is a special guest. One I traveled all the way to a Malibu basement mall to recruit, Michael Urie.

[0:57] Michael Urie: Hello.

[0:58] Mark Peikert: Oh, Michael Urie. Oh, we will have words about this version of Hello, Dolly! that you so detest because I think it is terrific.

[1:09] Michael Urie: Do you?

[1:10] Mark Peikert: Yes. It is a wonderful film. It is grandeur, it is spectacle, it is overblown, it is perhaps too much, but definitely worthy and wonderful.

[1:28] Michael Urie: Wonderful woman.

[1:30] Mark Peikert: So you're never bored during the 148-minute running time.

[1:36] Michael Urie: I, you know, it was, when "Put on Your Sunday Clothes" enters its tenth verse, I just buckle up and listen closer. You know, I've always wanted to meet the people who did all those Jerry Herman 20-verse songs.

[1:53] Michael Urie: Oh man. The end of a number because my God, you think about like, you think about the title song of Mame. They're hitting some insane at the end of Mame. They just keep changing the key.

[2:04] Mark Peikert: And they just, they all died every night.

[2:07] Michael Urie: They had a new cast every night.

[2:09] Mark Peikert: That's equity.

[2:10] Michael Urie: Four equity guys.

[2:11] Mark Peikert: I know. Well, that's, you know, we can't get away with that now.

[2:13] Michael Urie: No.

[2:14] Mark Peikert: God no. That's why Mame's never been revived on Broadway.

[2:17] Michael Urie: But I think there's only one key change in Six.

[2:20] Mark Peikert: I haven't seen Six, I don't know.

[2:21] Michael Urie: Six is amazing.

[2:23] Mark Peikert: I can't keep key change.

[2:23] Michael Urie: Yeah, I loved it.

[2:24] Mark Peikert: Oh, I can't wait. I haven't seen it.

[2:26] Michael Urie: Not since Grand Horizons have I loved a show as much this season.

[2:31] Mark Peikert: Oh, someone says always happens when you're in a limited run. Someone says, when do you close? You have to say, Sunday, we already did. It's gone. You missed it.

[2:43] Mark Peikert: But who knows when this podcast will air? It could be revived. But maybe by the time this podcast airs, I'll be playing Jamie Cromwell's role.

[2:51] Michael Urie: Oh.

[2:52] Mark Peikert: Now that's James Cromwell for people who aren't friends with him.

[2:55] Michael Urie: Sorry, did I drop that name?

[2:56] Mark Peikert: It's okay. We throw a big bucket for it here.

[3:00] Mark Peikert: All right. Michael Urie, let me set it. Let me set a scene for it.

[3:03] Michael Urie: Yes, please.

[3:03] Mark Peikert: It's 1964. Hello, Dolly! opens on Broadway, the St. James Theater. Carol Channing already had one iconic role with a Laura Liley, the gentleman for blondes. She got a second one, Dolly Gallagher Levi.

[3:18] Mark Peikert: Down the street at the Winter Garden, a young upstart named Barbra Streisand starring on Broadway in Funny Girl, Fanny Brice.

[3:26] Michael Urie: Ooh, they vie for the Tony.

[3:28] Mark Peikert: Who gets the Tony?

[3:29] Michael Urie: Who gets the Tony?

[3:29] Mark Peikert: It's Carol Channing.

[3:30] Michael Urie: Carol Channing gets it.

[3:32] Mark Peikert: That's right. But who got Dolly in the film version?

[3:36] Michael Urie: Barbra.

[3:37] Mark Peikert: Yes. Barbra got it. Good job. How many, uh, uh, but six or seven years later?

[3:42] Michael Urie: 1970.

[3:43] Mark Peikert: No, they filmed in '68.

[3:45] Michael Urie: Filmed in '68.

[3:47] Mark Peikert: And then they had to sit on it until because of the Vietnam War.

[3:50] Michael Urie: No. Wait. They had to sit on the movie until 1969 because David Merrick, that old rascal, had a clause in the movie sale contract that said you can't release this movie if the Broadway show is still running.

[4:03] Michael Urie: Oh my God.

[4:04] Mark Peikert: And the Pearl Bailey production was running in 1990 when they were ready to release the film. And so Fox had to spend another one to two million dollars for a buyout.

[4:13] Michael Urie: So they could rush this into theaters.

[4:16] Mark Peikert: Oh really? Wait, they had to buy David Merrick out?

[4:19] Michael Urie: They had to pay like a penalty to release the movie when they, before 1971.

[4:23] Mark Peikert: Wow.

[4:23] Michael Urie: So it was, uh, you cannot release it before 1971 if the show is still running.

[4:28] Mark Peikert: Oh wow. Yeah.

[4:29] Michael Urie: That's nuts.

[4:31] Mark Peikert: And Merrick. God, they did, because the world deserved to see this motion picture.

[4:36] Michael Urie: That movie belonged in the '60s. It's 1969. Other movies released that year include Easy Rider.

[4:44] Mark Peikert: Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid.

[4:47] Michael Urie: Okay.

[4:48] Mark Peikert: And Sweet Charity.

[4:50] Michael Urie: Oh.

[4:50] Mark Peikert: Bob Fosse.

[4:51] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[4:52] Mark Peikert: Yes. Oh, good job. Bob Fosse direct that he directed that.

[4:55] Michael Urie: He did. That was his first, right?

[4:57] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[4:58] Michael Urie: Well, he directed it, but Gwen Verdon choreographed it, as we know from Fosse.

[5:03] Mark Peikert: I saw that, of course.

[5:05] Michael Urie: Wow, that's so interesting. Because Hello, Dolly! feels so much like a 1950s musical movie.

[5:11] Mark Peikert: When you think about like, you know, what it, like it feels like a great big musical from the 1950s, not a musical from like the hazy Vietnam War '60s, mid-'60s.

[5:26] Michael Urie: I mean, that does not, those two things when you imagine. I mean, Easy Rider is the smallest movie in history, and it's opened the same year as the biggest movie.

[5:37] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[5:38] Michael Urie: So this apparently made cost as much money as Cleopatra to make.

[5:42] Mark Peikert: Oh my gosh. Really?

[5:44] Michael Urie: And it didn't make as much money at the box office.

[5:47] Mark Peikert: Wow.

[5:47] Michael Urie: It was a flop, right?

[5:49] Mark Peikert: It was, it made money at first and then it stopped making money. And the critics were like, ooh, this doesn't work because, well, I'm, you know what? I'm gonna say it. I'm not a fan of Hello, Dolly!

[6:01] Michael Urie: Oh.

[6:02] Mark Peikert: The show.

[6:03] Michael Urie: Oh.

[6:03] Mark Peikert: Yeah. From the get.

[6:05] Michael Urie: Well, you know what? I'm not a homosexual, so I feel free to say that. I'm sorry for misleading anyone who thought I was a homosexual.

[6:12] Michael Urie: No, no, I didn't think that. I didn't think that at all. I'm just a simple heterosexual from Texas who runs Playbill.

[6:19] Mark Peikert: Runs Playbill and loves the Lord.

[6:21] Michael Urie: But you're in Texas?

[6:22] Mark Peikert: Yeah. I'm from Texas. We've talked about it.

[6:24] Michael Urie: Oh, sorry.

[6:25] Mark Peikert: Oh cool.

[6:27] Michael Urie: Awkward.

[6:28] Mark Peikert: We've met.

[6:31] Michael Urie: Not in person.

[6:32] Mark Peikert: Well, I don't know. Just chat roulette camp.

[6:36] Michael Urie: Um, okay. So fast. I have, I have, there's some, wow.

[6:41] Michael Urie: I, uh, there, I have many threads that I want to offshoot. Is it okay to like jump in on some of those things?

[6:48] Mark Peikert: Well, I would like to just, I would like to defend my statement about disliking Hello, Dolly!

[6:52] Michael Urie: Okay, we'll just let that lie there.

[6:53] Mark Peikert: Okay, yeah. Like Walter Matthau's performance.

[6:57] Michael Urie: Oh, rim shot. Special effect.

[7:01] Mark Peikert: Uh, I do not love Hello, Dolly! because I do not buy her wanting to marry Horace Vandergelder.

[7:10] Michael Urie: Uh-huh.

[7:11] Mark Peikert: And I think that it does a disservice to the character because she is such an entity unto herself that to imagine her tethered to this like sad sack, like, you know, don't no time off for you.

[7:25] Michael Urie: Right, right.

[7:25] Mark Peikert: This Scrooge without redemption. It's just like, oh no, I don't want to see you squandering your light and your talent out in Yonkers.

[7:34] Michael Urie: I've lived in Yonkers. It's not fun.

[7:36] Mark Peikert: Right. You needed the bright lights of 14th Street, Dolly.

[7:39] Michael Urie: Yeah. Don't. But don't you think she deserves a half a million dollars?

[7:44] Mark Peikert: No, because she seems like she's doing okay.

[7:46] Michael Urie: Did you see those gowns?

[7:48] Mark Peikert: Well, yes, I saw the gowns, but they seemed old.

[7:51] Michael Urie: Oh.

[7:52] Mark Peikert: And older than Streisand.

[7:54] Michael Urie: Well, her gowns don't, her gowns don't seem old. But when I think of, I mean, I don't think, because also I don't really think the movie is so different than the show simply because it's Streisand and not Carol Channing or Bette Midler or Bernadette, you know, or Ethel Merman, or you know, like Streisand was like 20.

[8:13] Michael Urie: She was 27. She was the same age as the young couples.

[8:18] Mark Peikert: She was the same age as Michael Crawford.

[8:20] Michael Urie: So it's like you can't, like whenever I watch Hello, Dolly!, I imagine, and she's on screen, I don't imagine 27-year-old Barbra Streisand. I imagine, frankly, me as Barbra Streisand and Byron Seller. That's what I always hear and see.

[8:38] Michael Urie: Even as a child.

[8:39] Mark Peikert: Even as a child.

[8:40] Michael Urie: Wow.

[8:41] Michael Urie: She was old to me because, like, not old, but like she was middle-aged to me because, you know, she was middle-aged when I was a child. So even when I saw her as a young woman, and my mom loves Barbra Streisand, so I grew up with a lot of Streisand.

[8:53] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[8:53] Michael Urie: Um. So, like, even watching her as a young woman, I see the middle-aged woman from her concert in Las Vegas when she came back in '94 or whatever that was. Like it's always been that Barbra to me.

[9:05] Mark Peikert: Because that was my first impression of Barbra, was that concert.

[9:08] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[9:09] Mark Peikert: And she was, you know, middle-aged then.

[9:13] Michael Urie: And so she's always been sort of middle-aged to me.

[9:16] Mark Peikert: So she's, so to me, she's always been the right. But I can recognize that the Dolly she plays is completely different than any other Dolly because she's so youthful.

[9:29] Michael Urie: She, but what's interesting is you, it's her second movie.

[9:33] Mark Peikert: After Funny Girl.

[9:34] Michael Urie: After Funny Girl.

[9:35] Mark Peikert: Uh, she shows up. She and Walter co-won the Oscar for us.

[9:39] Michael Urie: Yes, with Catherine Hepburn, uh Oscar.

[9:43] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[9:43] Michael Urie: Uh, that's my Catherine Hepburn.

[9:43] Mark Peikert: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[9:46] Michael Urie: Always showed.

[9:47] Mark Peikert: No, it's, it's really good when you explain who it is.

[9:50] Michael Urie: Well, that's the market. But because of it's because of the nature of podcasts, you couldn't see the shaky head.

[9:56] Mark Peikert: But it was uncanny. What's that Joan Rivers quote? I'm on the Catherine Hepburn diet. I only eat as much food as stays on my forehead by the time it gets to my mouth.

[10:04] Michael Urie: Oh, we can cut that.

[10:06] Mark Peikert: Jane.

[10:07] Michael Urie: I love, I love a comeback reference.

[10:09] Mark Peikert: Jane, cut this whole thing.

[10:11] Michael Urie: No, but what's interesting is you see Barbra Streisand in this movie in this role that she is not really right for.

[10:17] Mark Peikert: No, which she's admitted, she's said that she kind of regrets taking it because she was too young to play a glamorous middle-aged widow.

[10:23] Michael Urie: Yeah, shocking.

[10:25] Mark Peikert: But she's already there. Her persona, her stage presence, her charisma is already there, is already set. She is giving a really great comedy performance.

[10:38] Michael Urie: Oh, yeah.

[10:39] Mark Peikert: In a really badly directed movie where no one is on the same page as she is.

[10:46] Michael Urie: Right.

[10:46] Mark Peikert: And she is absolutely right. She has speed. She has daffiness, she has everything that that role needs, and everyone else is acting as if they're in some operetta.

[10:57] Michael Urie: But is it possible that everyone else is in the same movie and she's in a different movie?

[11:02] Michael Urie: Yes, but I would rather watch her movie. And that's what led her to direct Yentl. I don't know if that's true or not. You know, well, she tried to take a code, you know, when she did Star is Born, she tried to take a director credit from that director whose name I can't think of, but exactly. She spent so much time, you know, she felt like she was so she she she uh uh uh put so much of the work as a director into that movie that she deserved a credit and asked for one. And if she were a man, she would have gotten it.

[11:33] Mark Peikert: Maybe maybe I don't know. Giving the star a director credit after the movie's been shot, even a man.

[11:39] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[11:40] Mark Peikert: Has that ever happened?

[11:42] Michael Urie: I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. We're not here to talk about men. That's why it's a movie musical podcast.

[11:48] Mark Peikert: My good. I mean, I mean, uh, you know, obviously, like she would have if she was a man, she would have had a lot of a very different career, though. And that is she would have made many more movies.

[11:58] Michael Urie: Oh, yeah. She she would have, and she would have done different kinds of different kinds of movies. She would have been able to like make uh action movies and and I mean she would have done all that stuff. But I also think what's so interesting is at this point in her career, she had a reputation as being a kook.

[12:14] Mark Peikert: Oh, she's so kooky.

[12:15] Michael Urie: She's running around in uh vintage clothes and feather boas, and she's a freak. Uh Walter Matthau called her a freak of nature, like a boa constrictor. Oh, he was like, she doesn't, she got famous too fast. She doesn't have the talent to back it up. She is a freak of nature that people pay money to come and watch. But what I find so fascinating about this movie and this performance is there's a real push-pull between this very old-fashioned musical and her very 1970s energy.

[12:44] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[12:44] Michael Urie: Like there's a real 60s, 70s energy to Barbra Streisand that we think of when we think of The Way We Were or the comedies that she did.

[12:52] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[12:52] Michael Urie: Uh uh. Alan Pussycat and Alan Pussycat and up the sandbox. And that is there in this, but underneath Irene Sharaff's Oscar-winning gowns.

[13:03] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[13:04] Michael Urie: And the giant wig.

[13:05] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[13:06] Michael Urie: The largest wig I've ever seen is something that Charles Bush would deem too much. And so you have this force, this force of nature uh kind of going up against Walter Matthau, who hated her.

[13:22] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[13:22] Michael Urie: And everyone hated everyone on this movie. Yeah. It was an unpleasant. My understanding is that it was a it was a tough set. But it's also uh, you know, like you imagine you're doing it's it's a tough time in the world. We're at a very, very controv, we're in a very controversial war, and there are people being assassinated all the time.

[13:45] Mark Peikert: They were filming during RFK's assassination.

[13:47] Michael Urie: Literally, okay, literally, they shot the day that RFK was assassinated. And and I I heard this story from Tammy Toon.

[13:56] Mark Peikert: Oh, who played played uh uh Ambrose Kemper in that film.

[14:01] Michael Urie: He did, he's he's Ambrose, yeah. Yeah. Um he said that the day that RFK was shot, they were shooting, and they had to scrap the whole day because Walter couldn't shoot because he was so upset. And so they ended up shooting a different scene. You know the scene where Ambrose and Ermingard and Dolly climb up a ladder into the second floor window.

[14:25] Mark Peikert: Oh yeah.

[14:26] Michael Urie: They sneak into the house, Horace's house, and they climb up a ladder into the second story window. So that was done, you know, practically on a real with a real ladder, uh, really going up to the second story. And before they they shot it, Gene Kelly pulled Tommy Toon aside. And this is all, and they hadn't planned it because it was they had to they had to shuffle the schedule because Walter was too upset to shoot. And so Gene Kelly pulled Tommy Toon aside and said, Um, you listen to me, damn it. You're gonna get up that ladder first, and you're gonna climb in there, and then you're gonna turn around and you're gonna pull her in. Because if we lose her, we're all fucked. That's the movie. If we lose her, that's the movie.

And so Tommy was like, okay, I'll do it. Yes, I'll get up there fast. And he was like so nervous, like he doesn't want to lose Barbara. So he climbs up the ladder really, really quickly. He climbs in the window and he turns around and he grabs her by the fingers to pull her in. And she was wearing gloves, and he only got the very tips of her fingers. And she goes, Oh, wow, oh, oh, ow, ow. And so he was like, Oh, I'm losing her, I'm losing her. I gotta hold on tighter. So he hold held on even tighter. Oh, oh, oh, stop. We have to stop, stop. And they cut and they stop, and she stops. And he had only grabbed fingernail. He couldn't tell. I think it's okay that I'm telling this story, but he had only grabbed fingernail because he couldn't tell where her fingers ended because he she was wearing these little dainty gloves.

And of course, her nails are famously real. I mean, they're who knows if they're still real. And really long. And super long. So long enough to be mistaken for fingers. And so they stopped. She went away. Now they can't shoot anything. She went to her trailer. And uh Gene Kelly was like, Don't worry, kid, you did the right thing. I hate those galies. They're not Dolly at all. Something like that. And it's like good Gene Kelly. And uh finally later she came back and he felt terrible. And Tommy was like, I'm so so sorry. Um, I'm sorry, Barbara, I had no idea. Are your nails okay? And Barbara said, they're damaged. That was her response. They're damaged. Not don't worry about it, but they're don't worry about it.

It's not your fault. But well, they're damaged. They were damaged. And what did Tommy Toon do? I think he just tucked his tail between his legs and kept tapping, you know. I mean, I I I don't uh uh I think that was that. But uh now he also played the ladder that scene, correct?

[17:01] Mark Peikert: Yeah, so she was fine. Let's face it. She was getting up that ladder because he was playing both parts.

[17:05] Michael Urie: Yeah, but it did that. I didn't get all I didn't get any other stories out of him, but that one was good, and and and it sort of made me think, oh, that was a tough set. I mean, Michael Crawford and Matthau stopped speaking because they went to the racetrack, and there's a horse called Hello Dolly. And Michael Crawford's like, oh, you know, I think that we should bet on this. He's British. Yeah. And Walter Matthau said, I'm not gonna bet on that horse because it reminds me of Streisand. And so Michael Crawford's like, I'm going to. And he bet on the horse. The horse won. And Walter Matthau refused to speak to him for the rest of filming.

[17:41] Mark Peikert: Wow.

[17:42] Michael Urie: Because he won on the Hello Dolly horse. Matthau seems like he was a bit of a difficult person.

[17:51] Mark Peikert: He apparently complained to Fox producer Darryl Zanuck, uh, who I'm sure everyone remembers from Smash on NBC.

[17:59] Michael Urie: Yeah. Sure.

[18:00] Mark Peikert: He had a he had a whole song in Smash. I think uh Mark Kudisch maybe played him.

[18:05] Michael Urie: In in the musical within Smash.

[18:08] Mark Peikert: In Bombshell.

[18:08] Michael Urie: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Uh Walter Matthau was like, uh, you know, uh Barbra Streisand is getting all the attention. I don't like it. I don't like it. I just won an Oscar two years ago. Yeah, I don't know. This sounds like Gene Kelly. They were famously mistaken for each other vocally a lot. It made directing the movie extremely complicated. Action, what, Walter? No, that wasn't me. And so Darryl Zanuck looks at him and he goes, What do you want me to say, Walter? It's not called Hello Walter.

[18:35] Michael Urie: Oh.

[18:36] Mark Peikert: Well, I and see, I heard that Barbara said of Hello Dolly that Walter thought it should have been called Hello Walter. Um, I heard another great Walter Matthau story from Drew Jogi, who you've had on this podcast.

[18:47] Michael Urie: That's true.

[18:47] Mark Peikert: Uh friend of the podcast.

[18:48] Michael Urie: Friend of the FOP, fellow FOP.

[18:51] Mark Peikert: Um in so many ways. Um, Drew Jogi said that uh Walter Matthau was visiting Auschwitz. And I know it's so funny, right? Um Walter Matthau was visiting Auschwitz, you know, a sombre occasion, and he was touring, you know, as you do. And this person came up and says, Oh my god, you're Walter Matthau. He's like, Yes, yes, I am. And he's like, Oh, a huge fan. He's like, Thank you, thank you so much. And he's like, Wow, it's so cool. It's so cool to meet you. And he's like, I appreciate that. I always always nice to meet a fan. And he's like, Hey, could I get a photo with you? And Matthau's like, you know, I don't think it's really appropriate today here. So I'm sorry, I'm gonna I'm gonna say no. And the guy's like, okay, whatever. And like goes off. And then, you know, they keep touring, keep touring. And later the guy comes back up to Matthau and he's like, hey, Matthau, I just want you to know you ruined Auschwitz for me.

[19:52] Michael Urie: Oh, I love that.

[19:52] Mark Peikert: I don't know where Drew heard that, but oh, I love that story. Wow. So Walter Matthau just ruined everything.

[19:59] Michael Urie: So I want to talk about what? One.

[20:01] Mark Peikert: One, the number of musical numbers in this movie that are filmed as if they're in a rodeo stadium.

[20:09] Michael Urie: Yes. Where it's just a ring of seats and then a giant empty center ring. Where for the Writers Ballet, like Harmonia Gardens, what is all this? It's insane.

[20:18] Mark Peikert: Busy burned to me.

[20:21] Michael Urie: It's like it's shot like a Busby Berkeley movie. But with nothing from above.

[20:24] Mark Peikert: Right, except nothing from above.

[20:26] Michael Urie: But you know, like those big on those big stage movie musicals. But like, yeah, they and it happens, it happens before the parade passes by. It happens in put on your Sunday clothes. It happens, of course, in Hello Dolly. I mean, before the parade passes by is basically Gene Kelly, Gene Kelly looking at Rain on My Parade from Funny Girl, like, I'm gonna do that, but on land.

[20:48] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[20:48] Michael Urie: It's just a her trailing her feather boa. And that impossible note she holds at the end.

[20:53] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[20:54] Michael Urie: Actually, impossible, right?

[20:56] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[20:57] Michael Urie: Well, yes, because we haven't talked about the lip syncing in this. They film so much on location and so much outdoors that entire dialogue scenes. Or ADR.

[21:06] Mark Peikert: Or ADR.

[21:07] Michael Urie: Yeah, it's true. So obviously, where it feels like you're watching through a scrim, or like you've had some daiquiri or something, and you're a little bit off.

[21:16] Mark Peikert: You're just watching them talking about it.

[21:18] Michael Urie: Or you need to reboot your Apple TV.

[21:19] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[21:20] Michael Urie: What's going on? Let me hit pause. Well, that should I blow on the cassette? No?

[21:24] Mark Peikert: Yeah, big, big ol' big old numbers. You would think though that I mean that Gene Kelly wouldn't want to be compared. Because it's such a similar number.

[21:32] Michael Urie: It's such a similar final. But then again, she did it in Yentl too. I mean, she's still maybe it's her. Maybe it's her. Maybe uh Vincent Canby in the Times called it her Streisand Sousa moment.

[21:46] Mark Peikert: Oh.

[21:46] Michael Urie: Like John Phillips Sousa.

[21:48] Mark Peikert: Philip Sousa.

[21:48] Michael Urie: Like a marching band.

[21:49] Mark Peikert: Like a marching band, yeah.

[21:50] Michael Urie: In all three, or in just in Hello Dolly.

[21:52] Mark Peikert: No, he was saying it's uh one of her signatures in Hello Dolly. Like she has the big Streisand Sousa moment.

[21:56] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[21:59] Mark Peikert: Interesting. But what's so funny is like that number, the parade number in the movie is so enormous that when I saw the Broadway show for the first time, I was like, I was like, that's it.

[22:11] Michael Urie: She's just standing there. What is a throw over time? Cool. Where's the craneshot? Like I don't where's so boa? Why isn't she marching more? And I guess that's what that is. It's not a big, it's actually more of an introspective number on stage, which is wonderful and lovely. But like I was really surprised. I was ready for some big number. The big number, I mean, Sunday clothes in the Broadway show is so breathtaking. So here's one thing that I did like about this motion picture. I loved the new opening number, Leave Everything to Me.

[22:44] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[22:44] Michael Urie: In place of I put my hand in there.

[22:47] Mark Peikert: Yeah, that's right.

[22:48] Michael Urie: Gosh, I forgot about that. It is a good number. Now, it does sound a little bit like uh come to the supermarket in old Beijing, which Barbra Streisand sang in one of her TV specials.

[23:00] Mark Peikert: Oh, look at you.

[23:01] Michael Urie: Which Patti LuPone famously covered on her live album.

[23:04] Mark Peikert: For a straight guy, you really know about Barbra Streisand.

[23:09] Michael Urie: I'm like a sponge for information. I don't do anything with it, but I just love it. Oh yeah. I'm a real collector of information.

[23:18] Mark Peikert: I know that about you.

[23:20] Michael Urie: Wow. So do you think that she wrote that song?

[23:22] Mark Peikert: No.

[23:22] Michael Urie: Jerry wrote that song.

[23:23] Mark Peikert: No, Jerry wrote that song. And the other new song in the show is Love is Love.

[23:27] Michael Urie: Yes.

[23:27] Mark Peikert: Pre Lin-Manuel Miranda.

[23:30] Michael Urie: That's why they stopped it true. Love is love. They didn't know. Is Ribbon's Dow My Back in the movie?

[23:35] Mark Peikert: Yes, it is.

[23:37] Michael Urie: Oh, she doesn't sing it?

[23:39] Mark Peikert: She does not sing it. Everyone else sings. Except Irene Malloy.

[23:43] Michael Urie: And that's not her voice.

[23:44] Mark Peikert: No.

[23:44] Michael Urie: Who is it?

[23:45] Mark Peikert: Yeah, some lady. It's not Lisa Kirk, and it's not Marnie Nixon.

[23:50] Michael Urie: So now, what do you know about Jerry Herman's relationship with Carol when she didn't get the movie?

[23:59] Mark Peikert: That I don't know. I know that. Seems like that must have been really hard. I know that Carol did an interview uh after the movie came out that said, I felt terrible, and then I saw the movie.

[24:03] Michael Urie: Oh.

[24:03] Mark Peikert: And then I saw the movie.

[24:13] Michael Urie: Did she say terrible or did she say terrible?

[24:15] Mark Peikert: Well, she said terrible. Then she saw the movie and she was like, Yeah, gave it a rage weary. And in her book, she talks about how uh she won the Tony over Barbra and that the movie was a flop.

[24:30] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[24:31] Mark Peikert: Well, and she gloats. She, I mean, she said she saw the movie and they wanted something completely different. They wanted something that she was not going to give them.

[24:38] Michael Urie: Right.

[24:39] Mark Peikert: They wanted youth.

[24:41] Michael Urie: Youth.

[24:41] Mark Peikert: Youth. And that wasn't Carol Channing.

[24:46] Michael Urie: Yeah. Like Elaine Stritch, she was born old.

[24:48] Mark Peikert: Yeah. How much I uh how much older was Walter Matthau?

[24:53] Michael Urie: He was in his 40s, late 40s.

[24:57] Mark Peikert: Right. I think it was a uh it was like a 23-year age difference.

[25:00] Michael Urie: And it's so it's not just the age, it's really the temperament. Because he seems 60 in that movie.

[25:08] Mark Peikert: Yes.

[25:08] Michael Urie: And also just think about the technique. Like she is kind of self-taught and intuitive.

[25:16] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[25:16] Michael Urie: And he seems like a real stickler.

[25:19] Mark Peikert: Right. Well, that's sort of like, you know, when I think about that's sort of what why I asked if they're all in the same movie and she's in a different movie, because he definitely, you know, I saw David Hyde Pierce and Victor Garber and Louis Stadlin all play that role. I mean, there's no one, we don't have anyone more Walter Matthau than Louis Jane Stadlin. And so I really could see him in, I mean, like Matthau's right for it. Yeah. He's just in the wrong version.

[25:48] Michael Urie: He doesn't seem comfortable. Like if Matthau had been opposite Carol Channing, maybe it would have been a totally different movie.

[25:56] Mark Peikert: I mean, obviously it would have been a totally different movie, but maybe you would have loved him, is my point.

[25:59] Michael Urie: It's true. Maybe you would have uh, you know, maybe that would have been the harsh hour that you needed. I mean, it's just it's such a weird movie because you look at all the parts and nothing meshes. Although you know what I did enjoy.

[26:17] Mark Peikert: Tight tight pants on Michael Crawford.

[26:19] Michael Urie: Yeah. Oh, he's dreamboaty in that movie.

[26:22] Mark Peikert: So dreamboating.

[26:23] Michael Urie: So cute. High kicks. Michael Crawford could dance.

[26:26] Mark Peikert: Oh, yeah.

[26:27] Michael Urie: But you know, Gene Kelly taught him how to dance. He didn't know how to dance.

[26:29] Mark Peikert: Oh, that's right.

[26:30] Michael Urie: That's what I heard when I listened to the Michael Crawford live album. He talked, he does a whole Hello, Dolly thing. And he talks all about how Gene Kelly didn't really want him, but his wife thought he was cute. So he was like, my wife thinks he's like, he's like, what I need is an attractive idiot. And my wife thinks you're attractive, and I think you're an idiot. And he said, I can't dance. And he's like, can you count to three? One, two, three, then you can dance.

[26:56] Mark Peikert: Which I don't think is. I mean, I think that's true.

[26:59] Michael Urie: You think that's true?

[27:00] Mark Peikert: I do. If you can count, you can dance.

[27:01] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[27:02] Mark Peikert: Really?

[27:02] Michael Urie: Why not?

[27:03] Mark Peikert: With Gene Kelly standing in front of you.

[27:05] Michael Urie: Maybe. I mean, maybe if it's Gene Kelly teaching you how to dance. Gene Kelly stood in front of me. I'd do more than dance.

[27:11] Mark Peikert: I heard a Gene Kelly, I think it was Gene Kelly. Gene Kelly, Fred Astaire, when they met, they were both like so shy and nervous.

[27:17] Michael Urie: Oh.

[27:17] Mark Peikert: And I think it was Gene Kelly was like practicing putting. And that's a golf term for anyone for who's out of heterosexual.

[27:25] Michael Urie: Yeah, yeah.

[27:27] Mark Peikert: Thank you for no, I know that.

[27:28] Michael Urie: You know that.

[27:29] Mark Peikert: No, I'll translate.

[27:30] Michael Urie: As a hater.

[27:31] Mark Peikert: As a hitter, she can't. I think Gene Kelly was practicing his putt, and Fred Astaire was on the lot or whatever, and they were, and somebody was like, we should get these two to meet, you know. They're two of the greatest dancers ever. And uh while they were standing, they were shy. They were both sort of like shy to meet each other, and they were just sort of looking down, and Gene Kelly like just very gently kicked one of the golf balls, and it went flying.

[27:55] Michael Urie: And the power of his ankle.

[27:58] Mark Peikert: And then later, it's it's apparently it is said that you could you could see Fred Astaire somewhere else in the lot practicing kicking golf balls.

[28:08] Michael Urie: Oh.

[28:08] Mark Peikert: Isn't that great? Isn't that great? Now, my favorite Gene Kelly story is on the set of On the Town, Frank Sinatra took one look at Gene Kelly in his sailors outfit and turned to the wardrobe mistress and said, I'm gonna need a patted ass.

[28:23] Michael Urie: Oh my God.

[28:25] Mark Peikert: Because uh Frank Sinatra had a very flat ass. Gene Kelly had a bubble buttons. There's a Tumblr dedicated to it that is worth checking out on a slow day at work.

[28:38] Michael Urie: On your phone.

[28:38] Mark Peikert: I'm not saying you should work computer.

[28:42] Michael Urie: Well, I'd attack that.

[28:43] Mark Peikert: I don't have. I mean, Oh, you don't have a job.

[28:45] Michael Urie: That's right. I don't have a job. I don't have a job.

[28:48] Mark Peikert: Oh.

[28:48] Michael Urie: Nor would I ever get a computer at this job.

[28:52] Mark Peikert: Just like Cassie in a chorus line.

[28:54] Michael Urie: Yeah. Unemployed. I haven't worked in a year.

[29:01] Mark Peikert: No, I haven't worked since Sunday.

[29:05] Michael Urie: Thank you. Thank you. Today's Tuesday for those of you who didn't get that joke.

[29:09] Mark Peikert: It's a Tuesday. I mean who knows what Tuesday you're listening to this on out there in podcast land. Here's my question for you.

[29:18] Michael Urie: Yeah.

[29:20] Mark Peikert: Do you think that Hello, Dolly! the movie works as its own entity?

[29:26] Michael Urie: As a as a movie.

[29:27] Mark Peikert: You mean and without any previous knowledge of what Hello, Dolly! the Hello, Dolly! lore is?

[29:32] Michael Urie: Yes. Great question. Um I would say probably not. I would say it I would say if you don't have a love of the music and lore of and I don't I don't just mean um the musical, but I mean knowing that like that the characters are based on a Thornton Wilder. I mean, it's you know, it's it's too bad that that revival closed because I feel like there could it would have been cool if the if the show could have run without giant stars.

[30:01] Mark Peikert: Yeah.

[30:02] Michael Urie: And you know, we could have gotten so many amazing people in and out of there. I would have seen Gene Smart's dolly.

[30:09] Mark Peikert: Oh, yeah.

[30:07] Michael Urie: I would have seen Audra McDonald's darling.

[30:09] Mark Peikert: Oh yeah.

[30:10] Michael Urie: I would have seen Andrea Martin. Kathleen Turner's dolly?

[30:18] Mark Peikert: Sure.

[30:19] Michael Urie: Um I'm I'm going with real ones.

[30:22] Mark Peikert: And you're you seem to be uh Gene Smart can sing.

[30:25] Michael Urie: Okay, okay, fair enough. Fair enough. Um I like to see the gravitas that Kathleen Turner could bring to that role. Or would about say in you know, I mean, hearing hearing Kathleen Turner sing that score. Did you just launch into a Kathleen Turner impression and then think better of it?

[30:43] Mark Peikert: No, I'm working my way into a Harvey Fierstein joke.

[30:45] Michael Urie: Cool. I uh I see. Because you were very close to a Kathleen Turner impression.

[30:50] Mark Peikert: I do have a Kathleen Turner.

[30:52] Michael Urie: Ooh, she came to see. She came, she came to speak to us at uh Juilliard when I was a student there, and and she was like, never talk about people badly.

[31:01] Mark Peikert: Wait, is that it?

[31:02] Michael Urie: Hold on. And then she was telling, and then somebody was like, Is there any movie you hate you you that you didn't like? And she was like, Yes. Switching channels, fucking Burt Reynolds. And then somebody was like, somebody's like, I thought you didn't say anything bad about actors you'd worked with, and she was like, he's the exception. Something like that. It doesn't quite work, but there was not a lot of mouth movement.

[31:25] Mark Peikert: I know that.

[31:25] Michael Urie: Like, yeah, but I can only do Sarah Paulson doing Kathleen Turner.

[31:30] Mark Peikert: Oh, from Studio 60?

[31:32] Michael Urie: No, no, from um, she was on Jimmy Fallon on Wheel of Impressions, and she landed on Kathleen Turner doing slip and slides.

[31:38] Mark Peikert: Uh-huh.

[31:39] Michael Urie: Talk about slip and slides. Great. Oh, I know all about that long, lonely crocodile mile, Jimmy. You run, you hit a bumble, you take a dive.

[31:50] Mark Peikert: That's so good.

[31:52] Michael Urie: Oh, anyway, she would have been a great dolly. I would have watched it.

[31:55] Mark Peikert: And that's all the time that we have. Thank you so much for going all around the town with me in this conversation.

[32:00] Michael Urie: That was fantastic.

[32:00] Mark Peikert: All around the town like a Mary Higgins Clark novel I would have read as a child. She had multiple personalities.

[32:12] Michael Urie: Oh uh-uh-huh.

[32:13] Mark Peikert: That was the first in the series, and then the second book was Back Around the Town and then and then Cars Drive Around the Town.

[32:20] Michael Urie: It's one of those series.

[32:21] Mark Peikert: Driver around the town.

[32:22] Michael Urie: Driver. Comma around the town. Exclamation point.

[32:28] Mark Peikert: Well, this is Mark Peikert. You've been listening to Movie Musical Madness. Actually, I don't know what you've been listening to, but it was a super fun episode of Movie Musical Madness. Tune in again whenever we release a new episode.

[32:42] Mark Peikert: This episode of Movie Musical Madness was edited by Kyle Moore with Theme Music by Sunshine Music. And thank you for listening to Movie Musical Madness, part of the Broadway Podcast Network. You can find out more about the podcast and me at BPN.fm slash movie musical madness.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred