Skip to main content
BPN Logo
S1/Ep1: Jesse Tyler Ferguson

This week, Eva talks to the lovely and hilarious Jesse Tyler Ferguson on MY FIRST SHOW’s very first episode. In addition to being an actor of stage and screen, who makes us laugh and feel, Jesse is an activist who fought for same-sex marriage and LGBTQ rights... Read More

From the show: My First Show

46 mins
6/16/20

Guests

Featured Shows

About

This week, Eva talks to the lovely and hilarious Jesse Tyler Ferguson on MY FIRST SHOW’s very first episode. In addition to being an actor of stage and screen, who makes us laugh and feel, Jesse is an activist who fought for same-sex marriage and LGBTQ rights. Tune in to hear Jesse’s stories, ranging from community theater in Albuquerque to his Broadway debut.

Part of the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Eva Price: Hi, I'm Eva Price, and welcome to my first show.

[0:04] Eva Price: I love theater, like really truly love it. When I was a kid, I spent more time listening to original cast albums than almost anything else. While most kids played video games or had hobbies, I dreamed up musicals to put on in my living room instead. And now I'm living my dream. I'm a Broadway producer. On March 6th, I had shows running in Chicago, Los Angeles, and on Broadway. And on March 13th, I had zero shows running anywhere. I was heartbroken. The theater is not only a second home, but it literally makes me feel more alive. So I adapted to the new world and to the new me, and I realized I'm not alone with this heartbreak. So I came up with this idea for this podcast. See, my first shows made me who I am today, so why not hear about the first shows that inspired and transformed other people too?

More interesting, better known, more successful other people. Everyone could use a little joy right now. And what better way than being reminded of the happy memories that made us? And though it's important to find joy and levity right now, it's also paramount that we recognize the pain and anguish our industry and country are also going through. COVID may be the framework for this terrible time, but the epidemic of racism, both in America and in the American theater, cannot be ignored. Today I'm celebrating the resilience of the theater industry, but I'm also celebrating its capacity for change. So many talented and brave people have stood up and are speaking out. And I stand with all those black artists, and I say black lives matter, and I will work harder, I will work longer, and I will work with you to change the future of theater and Broadway for the better.

And since it's June and it's pride, I'm also celebrating my dear friend Jesse Tyler Ferguson. In addition to making us laugh and feel both on stage and on TV, Jesse has fought for gay rights so people like myself could legally wed. Thank you, Jesse. You and I both know there are so many more fights ahead of us. And thank you for tuning in. I hope you enjoy the pilot episode of My First Show recorded on May 4th.

[2:46] Eva Price: Well, hello, Jesse Tyler Ferguson. You are my first guest on my first show for our first podcast during our first pandemic. How about that?

[2:56] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Hopefully our last pandemic.

[3:04] Eva Price: Thank you for being here. You're an activist, you're an artist, you are a dad to be. Can we talk about that this hour as well? It is a show of firsts in many, many ways. And Jesse, I don't know if you know this, but um, I saw you uh when I had just begun m dipping my toe into the theatrical space here in New York. You know, I came from the politics and television news business.

[3:43] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Right.

[3:48] Eva Price: You were doing a Joe's pub concert or cabaret. I believe I remember seeing you at that Joe's Pub Cabaret and thinking, who is this guy?

[4:02] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Oh my gosh. I don't even remember what I sang at that.

[4:05] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I I I remember the company I kept, but I don't remember what I did in it.

[4:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Um was it was I good?

[4:12] Eva Price: You were great. You were great. I because I think this was even pre-spelling bee. This was like it must have been. Leah Delary was probably part of that because I did a lot of stuff with her at that point in my career. But yeah, that was that was pre-spelling bee.

[4:25] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, yeah.

[4:26] Eva Price: So I've been watching you. I've been watching you. Jesse Tyler Ferguson, you were making your thrilling return to Broadway this season in the revival of Take Me Out. If you don't mind, uh we're so sorry, you know, to every member of the Broadway community who was in rehearsal or about to open or in tech or in previews or in performances. There it's an unprecedented time and there's nothing we can compare this feeling to. But will you take us back maybe just for a minute? Where where in your process were you and what did you guys think was actually going to be happening as the ground started to slip underneath you?

[5:07] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Uh well, you know, uh when we first started rehearsal, uh we saw rehearsal on on March 3rd. Um, and the pandemic was starting to sort of feel like this real thing that was sort of creeping in. But you know, we continued on with rehearsals, not really knowing uh what was gonna happen. Um, you know, there was weird things happening, like we weren't able to get the hand sanitizer and its stores, and like they were it was like on Amazon for $80. And like weird things like that were sort of making themselves known, and it felt like, oh, something strange is happening. Um, and it did make the early days of rehearsal um something I was very grateful for because it was it was you know something to focus on.

But at the same time, it it was hard to sort of sit into the process because there was sort of this growing panic in the city. And um, you know, creating something, it's very personal and it's very um it's very emotional and it's uh the the rehearsal process is a really delicate time for a company. And you know, it's it's a time to try new things and to to be vulnerable and to to be in that process, but at the same time feel such vulnerability outside the rehearsal room was was really hard to be quite honest. Um, you know, I think it was hard to create in that in that environment. Um, but at the same time, like I said, it was just such a great thing to be able to focus on something. Um so uh we were two weeks into the rehearsal process when um when we decided to pause our rehearsals and and uh return home, uh, which was very hard.

I mean, I came back to LA and like Jesse Williams and Patrick Adams, who were two of my other cast members who live in Los Angeles, came back uh on the same flight with me and it felt very defeatist to come back, but at the same time felt like it was the right thing to do. Um but it it's uh it was heartbreaking because you know, we were we had gotten to the point where we got to go visit the stage and we did some voice work with Kate Wilson who's a fantastic dialect coach um and voice coach on on the stage of the Helen Hayes and um you know I I'm just I'm so I'm so deeply emotionally connected to live theater um and the excitement that I've been having around doing this play has been building for almost a year now because I've I've I was offered uh a while ago so it's been something that has really kept me kept me going and um you know it's it's it's it's really devastating to have to sort of step away from it.

But there's also this comfort knowing that the entire theater community is in the same boat and we're there we're gonna pull each other through it and um you know we will we will get out of it. You know what that timeline is who who knows but um there there's no one more resilient than than the Broadway community.

[8:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Absolutely and all the community and all that the in all the actors and community in New York who produce theater and make art.

[8:18] Eva Price: Yeah no absolutely it's you know it's a moment of resilience that that we're all um responding to and that we were made for it feels like we were we were called upon to deal with m moments of resilience in our in our life. And it's really interesting as an activist who cares deeply and spends his time and and energy to promoting LGBTQ issues. Um what a remarkable, what a remarkable return to the theater to be in take Me Out of all the plays, too. That must have been so meaningful.

[8:54] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It it was um it's a play that I got to see for the first time at the public theater in 2003. Um ironically, I was rehearsing a show at second stage uh called Littlefish. It was a new Michael John McCuzzle musical. And I I had a night off and I went to go see Take Me Out of the Public and fell in love with it and fell in love with Dennis O'Hare's performance is is Mason Marzak. And you know, it never occurred to me in my wildest dreams that I would ever get to play that exact part um in you know years later uh for second stage. So that does a full circle moment right there. I believe that because it does mean so much to me that that the the universe is is bringing it to me for that for a very specific reason, and um it's it's rewarding me for um I don't know, something and I I I feel like because I have such a uh a meaningful relationship with this play and the history of it. I I've uh it makes me believe that the play will happen just for that reason alone.

[10:01] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It will.

[10:02] Eva Price: It will.

[10:02] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It will be back.

[10:04] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It is always the right time for Take Me Out on Broadway.

[10:08] Eva Price: That I don't think any of us have to worry about.

[10:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It is the right time, and it will always be the right time for that play.

[10:14] Eva Price: So one of the things, four of the things we talk about, not just one, is our firsts. Our first as it relates to theater and how it shaped us, who we are today. So um, I have four basic questions for you, and I'm gonna launch right into it and see where the conversation takes us. Um what was the first show you ever saw?

[10:36] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: You know, I was uh I'm thinking about this, and it's it's one of those things I it's sort of foggy. I I it was definitely a production done by um a community theater uh in Albuquerque, New Mexico. It was either the Albuquerque Civic Light Opera, which did all you know the standard musicals, or it was um part of the Albuquerque Children's Theater, um, which you know I ended up being a part of later. But I think my very first that I actually saw was a production of Oliver at the Alpha Peace Civic Light Opera. Um and I I think um no, no, sorry, not not Oliver. I did Oliver later. Peter Pan. And I remember that because Neil Patrick Harris was um was John Darling in it. And I I remember he was like the celebrity from Albuquerque.

And um I was just like, I was just in the audience watching Peter Pan with my mom and my dad, and um thinking like this is an amazing thing. I would rather be on the other side of the footlights than sitting in the chairs. I remember thinking that very specifically.

[11:37] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: And do you remember, first of all, this was post-Dougie Hauser?

[11:41] Eva Price: That's what you're telling me.

[11:42] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I think it was pre-Dready Hauser.

[11:44] Eva Price: Oh my gosh.

[11:45] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It was like post-Clara's heart, pre-Dugie Hower.

[11:48] Eva Price: I love Clara's heart.

[11:51] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Right?

[11:54] Eva Price: Of course.

[11:55] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Of course. I tell you, I have an eye. I saw Clara's heart back then, and I thought this kid is gonna be somebody.

[12:01] Eva Price: Yeah, yeah. Um and so what was it sitting in that audience? Like what specific either emotion or scene or idea popped into your head or that you observed that made you think I need to be on the other side of the footlights?

[12:19] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: You know, I was a very shy kid growing up. Um, you know, I don't think I knew that I was I was gay at that point, but it I knew there was something different about me, and uh, I didn't feel like I fit in with a lot of the kids that I went to school with. And I remember sitting in the audience and watching all of these people come together and create art together. And it was something clicked inside of me. I was like these these people are all so connected and it seems like they're a family up there. And you know, I I love the relationships that they were um creating in front of me. And I I of course I love the music and the dancing and I was just like how did they learn all of that? Like that must have taken time to to figure out and like I want to be a part of that process to figure out how to do that thing.

And um you know I also I mean Peter Pan's such a great show to see is um you know as your first show because like literally actors are flying around the stage. I mean, you know it's like flying by foy back back then. So it was sort of like they sort of just like dangled across the stage. They sort of like swung back and forth. There wasn't a lot of technology behind it. But I remember just being so enamored with all of the stagecraft and I told my mom afterwards like I want to I want to be a part of that. I I want to I want to do this. And uh she uh she knew of the Albuquerque Children's theater which was a a company of children that performed children's theater basically for other kids. Um and you know, it was like a uh low pressure um type of you know theater group and you know they it's a lot of theater games and then you know it it was mostly uh small little productions and then once a year they would do a a bigger show and the bigger show happened to be at the same theater that I saw Peter Pan at.

So I was like, if I get to perform someday on that big stage, I mean that would be a huge thrill for me. And my mom was very confused because I was such a shy kid and such an introvert. So I think she was just excited that this was something that I felt so passionate about.

[14:17] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Um I also was in a production of Peter Pan where Flying by Foy did the flying. So they they have a lock on the Peter Pan production. Especially in in you know that the 80s. Uh the 70s, 80s, and early 90s. It was like if you're flying, you're flying by foy.

[14:39] Eva Price: That's so true.

[14:40] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: That's so true. That is really funny.

[14:43] Eva Price: And you know, Peter Pan, that's so interesting that that was your entree into this world because that is literally the story of people who dream, people who don't grow up, people who use their imagination to answer life's big questions. And here it was compelling to you to reach for a life in the theater, right?

[15:11] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I've never I never thought about it that way, but that's that's that's so true. I mean, all the themes of Peter Pan are are, you know, about imagination and yeah, not wanting to be tied down to or yeah, I mean it it it's a lot of themes about being an actor really are are tied very closely into what Peter Pan's about. Um ironically, a few uh after I had been performing a little bit in Albuquerque, they they did Peter Pan again. You know, I mean with those commun community theaters and regional theaters and those smaller towns, um Albuquerque where this one was, you know, they sort of recycle the same like 10 shows. Like every every five years, you're gonna see a South Pacific. Um, and Peter Pan was one of the ones.

So, like, you know, during Christmas time, you know, every every five or six years there's gonna be a Peter Pan, and I got to actually be part of the next production Peter Pan that they did as one of the wonderful lost boys. So that was really exciting.

[16:06] Eva Price: That's amazing.

[16:07] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: That's amazing. Yes. I I learned a lot of hard knocks in my production of Peter Pan, um, when I was cast as second Indian to the left and not SME, which which was my dream role because I was, you know, a slightly sexually ambiguous pirates assistant anyway in life.

[16:29] Eva Price: I love that.

[16:32] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Um, but uh but I think it was great. I think actually the fact that I didn't get the role I wanted, and I learned the competitive nature of the theater business in my production of Peter Pan helped set me on for um a very cutthroat business of being a theater.

[16:49] Eva Price: Oh, 100%. I mean, I actually never was given a speaking role until my very first, you know, professional show. Like I was always put into the chorus. Um, and I I I guess I I there was a point where I was like, do I start second guessing my talent at this point? Like I I think I'm pretty good, but it was, you know, a little bit of an um an incestuous business, and there was a lot of inside politics, even in at the Albuquerque Children's Theater and and the uh Alpha Creature Civic Light Opera, you know, that the same like four people would always get cast, you know. The woman who's playing Anna Leon, and she's definitely gonna be Nelly Forbush. Like it was, you know, she was like the Kelly O'Hara of of the Albert Greek Civic Light Opera, except for like not nearly as talented.

Um, but it was like, you know, the same six people just on constantly getting cast, and I was always in the chorus, and I desperately, desperately wanted a speaking role. But at the same time, like what really resonated with me about being in these shows was like I I said before when I was sitting in the audience, that sense of like family and creating something together and camaraderie. And even to this day, like my favorite type of shows to do are our ensemble pieces where you know we're all like building something together.

[18:00] Eva Price: That's beautiful. So that actually leads us really well to our second question of the podcast, which is what was the first show you were in.

[18:08] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: So yeah, then I I got to be a part of the Albuquerque Children's Theater, which is what I begged my mom to let let me do. And um my very first uh production I actually got to be in was a production of Alice in Wonderland, and I was the white rabbit. Um I I I probably just because I was so alabaster skinned and like I was I'm still to this day very, very white. Um but it was uh you know, I felt I felt very um I felt very important. It was a very it was a it was a big role. It was, you know, the white rabbit and Alice of Wonderland. And I guess I take back what I said about never having a speaking part, because I did that was like my right out of the gate, I got a pretty good part.

[18:48] Eva Price: So White Rabbit is like a big deal, right?

[18:53] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yes. Yeah. I mean, he's he's one that we're down the whole down the rabbit hole. I mean, you know, to the that's how she gets the Wonderland. I mean, it's you know, and she's chasing the white rabbit. It did that throughout the whole show. So yeah um I not only did I have lines, but I had a lot to do.

[19:10] Eva Price: Yeah.

[19:11] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Um and you know, it was maybe typecasting because of your translucent, young red headed ginger type.

[19:20] Eva Price: Maybe maybe.

[19:23] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I I um uh but I d but what I really I don't I really I don't really remember what my duties were in the show. I don't remember like what my costume looked like. I just remember again like that sense of being so excited to rehearse. I remember you know when we got to technical rehearsals and you know we were kids so we they didn't like do 10 out of 12 so we were like working till midnight um and it wasn't a very complicated show to tech I'm sure. But just you know at the end of those rehearsals when I had to go home and like go back to school the next day and not be around those those people it was just devastating. I just could not wait to get back into rehearsal so much so that when I wasn't um rehearsing a play uh I knew enough about the the Pope Joy Hall was was where we performed.

I knew enough about the ins and outs in the theater and this is obviously pre-911 I knew how to break into the theater and I would watch um other shows tech their their shows I I knew how to like get into the flies and I would I would stand up and in the flies and and actually watch other shows in tech rehearsal.

[20:24] Eva Price: Wow um which is probably not safe but no not a not even a little bit for you or the other children.

[20:33] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: There's a there's a great line I think it's in gypsy baby which is the one thing I hate more than kids is kids on stage. And I always think about that because every theater professional was a kid on stage. So absolutely there's one thing about like being a kid on stage with other adults and there's other things going on. There's an it's it's quite a different situation when it's just children running the show.

[20:59] Eva Price: Right.

[21:00] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Because it's like the the, you know, the inmates are running the asylum at that point. Like they've got full control of the stage. And I mean, I'm sure that, you know, w we had been directed within an inch of our life, but there is that thing that I was like, I look back on that time, I was like, did my parents enjoy going to those? Probably not. I mean, they were happy for me to like do what I wanted to do and probably lit up a little bit when I was on stage. But were the shows really that good? I don't know if they were.

[21:24] Eva Price: Right, right, right, right.

[21:26] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: That's so funny. Now Alice in Wonderland is another, granted, I've never seen a production of it. I've just read it ages upon ages ago. Um, it's another sort of deep layered messaged script and book and text of of things also you know, also going on on a whole other deeper level, which I you know, I think all great children's stories do that. They they have a yeah, a deeper hidden message that they're saying something else about the world and our our our minds and our hearts. Um that's uh was there anything you were afraid of during that production? Like you were excited about rehearsals, which is sort of funny because no one's excited about rehearsals, but were you scared about it at night or scared about free anger lines?

[22:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I mean, I feel like opening night was really more like an opening afternoon. Um I like ran for maybe three performances over the course of a weekend. I don't remember having a lot of fear. I do remember like in the studio when we would rehearse the the shows and like there was improv and like we'd we play theater games and it was a little bit more social. I feel like I shied away a little bit. Like I liked hiding behind a character. I do know that. And I I think that's still true to this day. Um it was, you know, when I had to just sort of be myself and and and play theater games and like come up with ideas off the top of my head and and uh teamwork with people just you know s in in these like trust exercises.

I think that's what I s I got a little scared. I really relished in like learning a song or learning a dance or learning my lines and putting on a costume and hiding behind um you know makeup. That was that was my that was my my thing. That was my jam. Yeah. I think when it was about like me sort of being me um I was probably a little more timid and scared.

[23:20] Eva Price: That's interesting, right? Because you became, if I'm not incorrect, you became an extrovert. You became someone who knows himself and knows the presence that he holds in a room and is truly his individual self. And it's interesting, right, that your shyness was such a level that even your mother was like, are you really gonna be doing a play? I'm so surprised. Do you have a sense of like why and how your introverted personality was what it was at that age and what flipped it?

[24:04] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I again, I think it sort of falls back to like I was always just a very shy kid. I was an indoor kid, you know? I didn't like playing outside. I didn't like getting dirty. I liked to hang out in my room by myself, and I liked, you know, imagination. I liked creating things in my own little bubble. I don't know what flipped because for the longest time, you know, when I'm looking back, I'm thinking how shy I was during, like, these, for example, trust exercises or, you know, games we'd play in the theater rehearsals. I think that like I didn't truly become an extrovert until it sounds so terrible to say, but I think I'm kind of realizing this as I'm saying it, until people sort of told me that I was talented.

And like, I needed that validation from other people, whether it be an audience or a critic or a director, or just an opportunity, truly. And that didn't happen until I was, you know, in my twenties. So it took a while, but I think, you know, like I said before, having put myself out there so many times and constantly being told like, you know, you're not good enough for a speaking role or you can't have one of the leads and sort of always brushed aside to the ensemble. I guess, you know, it sort of I enjoyed doing what I was doing, but I don't think I had the confidence there yet. I knew, but the thing is my drive was always still there and I still put myself in those situations and I still tried out for the big parts, even though like the heartbreak behind it when I didn't get it was always so intense.

I remember crying so much when I didn't get these speaking roles. But I kept putting myself out there. And that's one of like, you know, when people always say, you know, don't go into this business unless you really know you want this. I think back to those times I was like, oh, I must have really wanted this because I kept putting myself in that situation when it wasn't even like a career, it was just like a hobby. Right. You know, it's like I've always known that this is something I desperately and deeply wanted to do, and I believed in myself, even when other people didn't believe in me. But I think as far as like opening up and becoming more of an extrovert, it took a lot more validation from people and the public and external places.

[26:35] Eva Price: But so how interesting though that you had that internal dialogue that said I really want to do this when it was in some ways the antithesis to who you were as your everyday self. So something really palpable was going on within you that you knew you were shy and knew you were a loner to a degree, right?

[26:59] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, sure.

[27:00] Eva Price: And yet you were compelled to say, but this is a thing I want. This is where I'm most comfortable. This makes me feel more alive.

[27:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, and it was also just nice having something that I believed in so deeply and it almost felt precious to me because I went to a school where, you know, the arts program was not really appreciated and, you know, my schooling looked bad that I there wasn't a lot of support for the arts and it felt like this secret thing for myself, which I think in a lot of ways sort of made me more connected to it because I felt like it was like this relationship almost that I had with acting and being on stage and it was so meaningful to me and, you know, other people just didn't get it and that almost made it even more vivid and more intense for me.

[28:01] Eva Price: Hmm. Yeah.

[28:02] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah. I think that's what happens when we have dreams and we go after them.

[28:09] Eva Price: Um, let's talk about your first professional show. What was it? When was it?

[28:13] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Um, so my first professional show is kind of a big deal. It was a big one. I was 21 years old, about eight months out of school. I went to the American Musical and Dramatic Academy in New York City. I was non-equity. I had an agent who, his name was William Schill, and I don't think he's around anymore. But he basically told, he saw me in my showcase at school and told me that he wanted to work with me mostly because he didn't have any other redheaded clients. At least that's my end. Um, but he submitted me for the non-equity audition. He submitted me for On the Town at the Public Theater in Central Park, at the Illic Theater that George C. Wolfe was directing. The big revival of On the Town.

They'd been doing the entire Shakespeare Canon and they were finishing the Shakespeare Canon that summer and they were following it with a big love letter to New York, and it was gonna be On the Town. It was the first revival that had been done in the city for I don't know, 25 years or so, and he submitted me for the role of Chip, which is the part that Frank Sinatra played in the movie, and I just knew it as a big dancing show. So I thought, well, I'm never gonna get this because I'm not a dancer. But they never had a dance call. They just said George Wolfe wanted three actors to make it. He had a different vision. I mean, I eventually was gonna have to learn how to dance, but that wasn't what he led with.

And I got to audition for On the Town. I went in for Jordan and Heidi at the Public Theater, and they called me back and I met with George Wolfe, who is someone I already was very much aware of because I was obsessed with Jelly's Last Jam and Topdog/Underdog and the West Side Story musical, Bringing the Noise, Bringing the Funk. And so I met with him, he was great, and I got to go back again, and I got to meet and sing for Betty Comden and Adolph Green, which was insane. Adolph Green at that point of his life was not hearing so well, and so he thought he was whispering to Betty when I was done singing, but he was actually screaming it into the room. He goes, "He's very good." So I immediately had validation from Adolph Green.

They cast me, and it was a huge, huge opportunity. It was a really big deal. And it was the ensemble and cast was full of people I've been watching on Broadway for years. It's how I met Mary Testa, who to this day is such a dear friend of mine and of yours. And I just remember just could not believe I was being able to be in this room. It was bigger than anything I'd ever imagined. You know, when I say like, you know, having grown up and never been given a speaking role and just sort of being like, oh, maybe I'll just be in the ensemble of a Broadway show, and that valve was enough for me. It truly would have been. And here I was like my first big job out of school, you know, I was getting my equity card and I was being given a huge, huge speaking role. I was one of the three major sailors of On the Town, and it was just, it was beyond. It was so exciting.

[31:37] Eva Price: That is crazy.

[31:39] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: So that, and when we say professional here on My First Show, it could be, you know, it could even be a local community theater, but it's a professional show. Or it could be someone being an usher, but it's a professional show. Or that stage crew. Your very first gig, your paid gig in the theater was, and this was the public run revival of On the Town.

[32:03] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Oh my god. Yeah.

[32:04] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Oh my God. Yeah, it was insane. It really was insane. And I met so many people who have stayed in my life through that experience. You know, William Finn was a dear friend of Mary Testa's and came to see the show, and that's how I first met him. And George C. Wolfe, that Thanksgiving after the run of On the Town had, you know, all the orphans basically in New York who didn't have anywhere to go for Thanksgiving invited us all to his place for dinner, and I sat across the table from Tony Kushner, and that's how I met him. So like, you know, it really opened up my entire world. The people that are very dear to me to this day are people I met during that time.

[32:47] Eva Price: Was Lea DeLaria in that too?

[32:50] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: She was. Yeah. Lea DeLaria played Hilde and I played Chip and we were each other's love interests.

[32:54] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah. And we had great chemistry. The gayest revival in town.

[33:00] Eva Price: And no one knew.

[33:02] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: No one knew.

[33:04] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: You knew.

[33:05] Eva Price: The general public didn't know.

[33:07] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, exactly. It was, I mean, and she's one of my closest friends to say as well.

[33:13] Eva Price: Wow.

[33:15] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, it was pretty special.

[33:17] Eva Price: That's amazing.

[33:18] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: That's amazing.

[33:19] Eva Price: Oh my god. I need to, I'm sure Lincoln Center captured that, right? Because I need to go back and see that.

[33:24] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah. Well then we do, we so we transferred from the Delacorte, we transferred to Broadway about, I don't know, eight or nine months later. And you know, it was such a huge hit in the park and, you know, I mean, it's free theater in the park, so like it's very popular regardless. But it was a production that people were really excited about and it had some mixed reviews, but you know, I think on the most part people really enjoyed it. And then it transferred to the Gershwin and it had a very tumultuous run and closed after three months. So something that was such a big important thing in my life also became something that was a huge, huge heartbreak and it felt like my one big opportunity had come and gone. But fortunately they did record the production at the Gershwin and it's at Lincoln Center and the archives.

[34:11] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, yeah. I mean, it is crazy, right? How when a show, especially early in your career, when a show closes early and disappointingly and surprisingly, that it feels a devastation like no other, that it actually feels like—

[34:15] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah. It felt like a death. I mean, 'cause also when you're at the Delacorte Theater, there's never an empty seat. It's always full because it's for the people of New York and the tickets are free and they line up and people fill those seats because it's a gift to them and they are able to experience theater for free.

[34:53] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: And then at the Gershwin, when it was struggling, you know, the Gershwin's such a huge house, it's we're wicked to playing now. And, you know, we would have, you know, I think it's like two thousand seats in that theater, and we would have maybe two hundred people in the audience and they'd all be sort of near the front of the stage and it'd just be this vast darkness behind them. So to go from something that was such like a sparkling jewel of the season to this thing that was like just not working was just so heartbreaking. Um because we had experienced a show when it was just clicking and working and it just sort of fell apart and um you know I don't know why really because it's I think it's still to this day one of my favorite shows.

[35:35] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah it is it's a special one. It's such a love letter to New York too which is why I love it. And it's also was it was great because you know Betty Condon and Adolf Green were still alive and would come to the show every night at the Delacour Theater. You know they lived on Central Park West and they would wander into the theater and watch the show every single night and around you know five minutes before the show would start we'd be down in the dressing rooms and we'd hear a huge elevation and we knew that Betty and Adolf were walking into the theater and it just felt so special to be doing this piece for them. And you know here we were doing it for them in this beautiful theater in the middle of Central Park it was just very special.

[36:17] Eva Price: Yeah that's really romantic.

[36:19] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: And that's living the dream my friend that.

[36:22] Eva Price: No I know I know wow wow.

[36:26] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Okay our fourth question of the hour is if you could be in any show anywhere at any time what would it be?

[36:38] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Gosh I mean this is such a hard question to answer because it's like how big in the dream.

[36:45] Eva Price: The biggest.

[36:46] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I know, I know. I mean part of me is like I want to be at the Delacour theater again, but like with Meryl Streep doing Taming of the Shrew. Like, would that be what it is? Or would it be, you know, in the original production of like Merrily We Roll Along or some sort of iconic on time show. Um but I think I think the way I want to answer this is by I guess like thinking of my dream roles. Um I would have loved to as brilliant as Brett Carver was, and I adore him, but I'm so jealous that he got to originate the role of Molina in Kiss of the Spider Woman. I love that part so much. It's it's a dream role of mine. Like it's I hope maybe someday I get the opportunity to try and do it. But that production was so special and um you know, Chita Rivera was so brilliant in it and uh it was like at the height of my Kander and Ebb obsession. Um yeah, that might be it might be that show.

[37:47] Eva Price: Wow, that feels very doable, Jesse.

[37:52] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I mean I appreciate that it's a dream, but I actually think that's not a match we can make that happen. Just to guess.

[38:00] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I'm sure there's a line of people who would like to play that part, but I would like to be standing that line. But also just to be, you know, I love doing like on doing On the Town was great and I love doing a revival, but also I've gotten to create a few new musicals and um the idea of creating that show from the ground up, I'm sure was thrilling and heartbreaking and and devastating and and and just I mean creating new work is so hard. Um and it's it's a miracle that sometimes we figure out the formula of these shows because the amount of work and the amount of stuff that gets cut out of out of songs and out of scripts and ends up on the floor, like it's devastating. Um and the fact that you know we continue to hold our heads up high and and continue to work through the piece and that that writers continue to work on on the material is is kind of astonishing and it's like what I love most about artists.

I mean, I think that that really painful time of creating a new new show is um sometimes when you're in you're in the trenches with it, it seems so so difficult. But looking back upon it, uh you know it's it's so worth it too.

[39:12] Eva Price: Wow. Um that's beautiful, Jesse. As we near the end of our show, and this is a surprise, we did not tell you about this ahead of time, we do a lightning round where I list off a bunch of classic Broadway musicals and you list off the theme, the first theme that comes to your mind when I say the name of the show. And one word thing.

[39:34] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Okay.

[39:36] Eva Price: Because this conversation has been about the things that made us feel emotional and connected to the theater. And we know that when people see shows, they glom onto the things that make them feel emotional and connected to the show. And I wanna see if what you believe is an emotionally connected theme is the same as what I believe is the musical's emotionally connected theme.

[40:01] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Okay, yeah.

[40:01] Eva Price: Here we go. All right. It's a lightning round, so we're gonna go fast.

[40:05] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Okay.

[40:06] Eva Price: A Chorus Line.

[40:08] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Uh resilience.

[40:11] Eva Price: Cabaret.

[40:14] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Uh bodiness.

[40:18] Eva Price: Company.

[40:20] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Uh relationships.

[40:23] Eva Price: Evita.

[40:26] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Power.

[40:27] Eva Price: Gypsy.

[40:29] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Uh drive.

[40:27] Eva Price: Into the Woods.

[40:27] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Imagination.

[40:27] Eva Price: La Cage aux Folles.

[40:27] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: What's the word I'm looking for? Being seen.

[40:49] Eva Price: Two words.

[40:52] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: My Fair Lady.

[40:55] Eva Price: Uh love.

[40:59] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Oliver.

[41:03] Eva Price: Ah beautiful.

[41:07] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: You did great.

[41:08] Eva Price: I did okay.

[41:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: We're we're no, you did great. We're pretty matched up.

[41:13] Eva Price: We're pretty matched up, you and I.

[41:15] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: We're a little off in some places, but we're we're pretty alarmed.

[41:21] Eva Price: It's not about imagination.

[41:23] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: But so many more things. Um it it's a you know, when people ask me that, it's this isn't there's not a one-word answer for me. It's the answer to all of life's questions are in those lyrics.

[41:35] Eva Price: Yeah.

[41:36] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah. It's funny. I feel like all the so many Sondheim songs have such a specific different meaning right now in this weird wacky time we're in.

[41:46] Eva Price: They really do.

[41:47] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: They really do. Um, you are entering a very exciting period of your life in a few months, and I'm thrilled that amongst this darkness and these series of unknowns and unexpects and and lack of answers, you you have um a baby arriving.

[42:10] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: That's yeah.

[42:12] Eva Price: Yeah, pretty.

[42:12] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: How are you feeling about all that?

[42:15] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Really, really excited and scared to borrow from a Sondheim lyric. Um it's you know, it it is uh in these times right now that are so uncertain and and so wacky and weird, and we have no control over so many things. Uh it's just nice knowing that something definitely I have some control over. There's a baby definitely coming in July. Um and that's that's definitely not getting postponed.

[42:44] Eva Price: No, no, no, there are no refunds or exchanges until there's something nice about that certainty.

[42:52] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, yeah. How to change the diaper, how to make uh the baby sleep and eat. Those those are full of uncertainties, but exactly.

[43:01] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Yeah, but the fact that it's coming is pretty certain.

[43:04] Eva Price: That's so wonderful. Well, I am so thrilled for you and your husband, and I kind of can't think of two better parents on the planet um who are so joyful and full of love and inspiration.

[43:17] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Thank you.

[43:21] Eva Price: And um you play your cards right, um, then a miniature track suit might arrive.

[43:27] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Uh oh, oh that's my thing. I love I love infant track suits, they're really oh Jesse Tyler Ferguson, thank you so much for spending this time with us and opening up about where you began, where you found your voice, um, where you found your inspiration, and how you became the beautiful, extroverted, not shy human that we love from television and from theater.

[44:01] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Thank you. It's been really nice talking to you about this.

[44:04] Eva Price: I'm glad.

[44:05] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: It's it's it's nice. It made me think about a lot of things I haven't thought about in a while.

[44:07] Eva Price: I'm glad. You know, the idea sort of came um and you know, once this crisis had started, it sort of came to me um out of nowhere just thinking about how sad I was about um not being able to experience joy and levity with the theater people of my life. Um, and I just started thinking about the one medium that's not affected by all this, and that was podcasts, which I've always felt were really similar to theater, sort of the way I consume them. There's a story, there's an emotional connection. You have to be you have to concentrate and pay attention to get the full experience. And um it just it seemed like it might be a nice way to connect with theater people and their and their dreams.

[44:54] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: So I think it is, and I'm really happy you're doing it.

[44:57] Eva Price: Thank you. Well, and I'm very honored to be your first guest.

[45:00] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I am delighted that you're my first guest.

[45:03] Eva Price: First and best done. Um Jesse, have a wonderful night, have a wonderful week. Thank you for everything. Um and uh we'll be back after this.

[45:16] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: No fire.

[45:21] Eva Price: My First Show is produced by Josh Alban, MEP, Dory Berenstein, and Alan Seals, and is part of the Broadway Podcast Network. This episode was edited by Derek Gunk. Special thanks to Leslie Papa and Whitney Holden Gore at Vivacity Media Group. For more info about the podcast, visit bpn.fm backslash my first show. Follow me on Instagram at Eva R. Price.

[45:52] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: And be banished if I don't.

[45:53] Eva Price: And be banished if I don't cause never will always be the whole youth and joy and live for me.

[46:09] ♪ Musical number ♪

[46:09] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: I'll never grow up, never grow up, never grow up.

[46:13] Jesse Tyler Ferguson: Not me. Not me. Not me. Not me, no sir.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred