Joe Iconis is huggable. Joe Iconis is intimidating. Joe Iconis has amazing talent. Joe Iconis also has amazing hair. He is a darling of musical theatre, and someone I always catch myself rooting for... Read More
From the show: NOW WE'RE TALKING with Drew Gasparini
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Joe Iconis is huggable. Joe Iconis is intimidating. Joe Iconis has amazing talent. Joe Iconis also has amazing hair. He is a darling of musical theatre, and someone I always catch myself rooting for. We ALL know that Joe Iconis is a staple in NYC with his infamous concerts featuring the “Joe Iconis Family” but did you know that Joe Iconis has a deep love for all things The Muppets? We all know Joe for his Tony nominated work for his musical adaptation of BE MORE CHILL, but did you know this show almost didn’t have a fighting chance to blow up into the phenomenon it did? The man is a legend and ALSO, a myth and it was a joy having him on the show to not only discuss life during COVID-19, hear about his amazing career and play some silly games, but he also gives some truly terrific advice to all future generations of theatre workers. So TUNE IN, and turn it the hell up! Joe Iconis is in the house, and he is spitting truth all up in this pod! For more on Joe make sure to follow him on his socials @MrJoeIconis!
For more info on this podcast visit bpn.fm/NWT
Follow Drew Gasparini:
- Twitter @DrewGasparini
- Instagram @DrewGasparini
- TikTok @theDrewGasparini
For more info on this podcast, visit bpn.fm/NWT
A Proud Member of Broadway Podcast Network.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:02] Drew Gasparini: Hello, you silly little monkeys. It's everyone's favorite Blink182 music video, Drew Gasparini here with a brand new episode of Now We're Talking, the only podcast with a Michelin star. And today we have a fantastic guest. I've looked up to this man's work since before I came on to the scene as a writer in New York City. He's been the darling of the musical theater concert movement for as long as I can remember. You might know him for his musicals, The Black Suits, Blood Song of Love, Things to Ruin, or the songs he contributed to season two of the NBC series Smash. He's a Tony nominated composer lyricist whose musical BE MORE CHILL became an internet phenomenon and led him all the way to a production on Broadway and beyond. He's one hell of a guy and someone I'm thrilled to share the space with. Ladies and gentlemen, now we're talking with Joe Iconis.
[0:47] Joe Iconis: How are you, dude?
[0:50] Drew Gasparini: I'm doing alright. You know, it's just uh it's a crazy time.
[0:54] Joe Iconis: It is a crazy time.
[0:56] Drew Gasparini: You seem a little more lax about it than I don't know. Say me, for example.
[1:01] Joe Iconis: No, I don't think I'm I don't know. I I feel like internally I'm really uh really falling apart, but I'm trying trying to keep it together.
[1:10] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, a lot of loud screaming in your mind late at night, things like that.
[1:15] Joe Iconis: No, I mean during the day, yeah. No, I mean like literally, I've uh I've been having like nightmares. The that are like like like stress, anxiety induced nightmares. Um I've and just from like the sort of general uh madness in the world and the the exhaustion of all of that.
[1:35] Drew Gasparini: Absolutely, absolutely, and it is fucking exhausting. I'm telling you again, from my parents' garage I relate to you here.
[1:45] Joe Iconis: Uh it has been exhausting to say the least. And the nightmares are real. They're fucking real. And I can't, I kinda want to know what your nightmares look like just based on what you're writing is.
[1:55] Drew Gasparini: Uh Joe, you are, in my mind, one of the most approachable humans in the industry. And right at the exact same time, one of the most intimidating individuals in this industry. Do you understand what I mean when I say that?
[2:13] Joe Iconis: I do. I do understand that. I think that I've I've heard I've heard from people that have had that experience or that perception of me.
[2:21] Drew Gasparini: Why do you think that is?
[2:23] Joe Iconis: I cultivate it. I try really hard approachable and uh really distant and and scary. No, I don't I don't know. You know, it's like I um it's just it's just me, you know. I I think that I think that I have a lot of I have a lot of like warring sort of things inside of me and sort of worn aspects of my personality. You know, I think that I am someone who's like who's super uh, you know, I'm I I think I'm a very nice person. I I would describe myself as very nice. Uh and uh I think of myself as like a very warm person, uh, but I'm also like really really opinionated about things and and I'm very passionate and I take things very seriously. So I I don't know. I think I definitely have like uh I give off kind of both both uh both things.
[3:12] Drew Gasparini: I think, but those are those are such good reasons to be intimidating, is being impassioned and being opinionated, especially in this industry. I'm one of those yucks that like I go to maybe here's the difference between you and I if I were to assess this. If we go to a comedy show, I want to go to I want to, I'm already laughing, even if I don't like the guy who's doing the stand-up. I'm like, I want him to know that there's laughter in the room, so I'm gonna start laughing very loudly so he understands this is an exciting time for him. I'm very excited to be laughing. I feel like you would look around and be like, what's so funny about this guy? Do you know what I mean?
[3:48] Joe Iconis: I don't go to comedy shows for that very reason. That sounds like a lime, but it's not I I hate hate comedy shows. I won't, I just won't go. I hate sketch, I hate improv all of this because of that thing. Because of that thing of like, oh, you have to laugh. And if you're not laughing, everyone in the room knows that the person on stage is is has failed. It's like it's so comedy is so terrifying to me in that way.
[4:13] Drew Gasparini: Joe Iconis hasn't laughed himself in about 35 years. Is that correct?
[4:17] Joe Iconis: It's something like that.
[4:18] Drew Gasparini: No, I laugh. I laugh all the time. I'd love to be, I'd love to be delighted. No, it's like when I love something, I'm you know, I'm like screaming and shouting and crying, and you know, I I yeah, when I love something, I love it, I love it deeply. But I've gotten a lot better about about hiding my uh my dislike of things. I was when I was sort of younger, when I was uh, you know, first starting out in in musical theater, I felt like it was like a like a like a badge of honor or something. Not a badge of honor, but I just I felt like, oh yeah, if I don't, I'm gonna go to something, and if I don't love it, I'm just gonna like I'm not gonna I'm not gonna stand up, or I'm not gonna like say that I like it. And now it's like, you know, now I I I fake it.
[4:31] Drew Gasparini: I've gotten a lot better at being at lying and being.
[5:02] Joe Iconis: I love that. So everybody who's listening to this, if you see Joe Iconis giving a standing ovation, just know that he's been working on faking it. That is from his own mouth. Well, here's a question for you, actually. When because you do these, I'm in awe of you. I'm gonna get into like my my little obsession with you, but like I am in awe of you live when I see you do like the Joe Iconis and family concerts and what you bring to the stage. Is there an element of like do you fear the Joe iconics in the audience? Like, is there a part of you that's like, God, I really hope everybody likes this, or are you just kind of like, yeah, they like it or they don't like it? You know, you know what I mean? Like, do you fear that there is someone out in the audience who is like not gonna stand because they they want everyone to know that that wasn't their thing necessarily?
[5:49] Joe Iconis: Um I don't, I definitely don't fear it. But um it's yeah, I mean, you know, I I uh like like like listen, I I don't I want, you know, I if we're talking specifically about you know audiences, I want an audience to like me. I want an audience to like what I'm doing. Uh, you know, and and specifically at like icona family shows where I'm performing, like, yeah, I want a rock concert vibe and I want people to be like, you know, uh over the top in their their approval and their excitement and their enjoyment of things. Um, but I would never it it's not I feel like I feel like I'm not afraid of people not having that reaction, or I don't I don't alter things so that people will have that reaction, if that makes any sense.
Like it's not of course the fear of that doesn't change the way that I do things, and the and in so far as like the way that I write or produce things, I definitely have the thing of like this is what I this is what I believe in, and I think it's pretty good, and you either like it or you don't, but this is what it is, and I'm not gonna like, you know, change this thing because maybe someone won't like it.
[6:53] Drew Gasparini: A hundred percent. But and I will say though, that um, and also I just want to clarify, like I'm not like I'm not like sitting arms folded with like a I don't do that. Like it's just you know, in in a previous time of my life, I think it was, you know, it was more just like whatever. I don't even know what it was. But I wasn't like, I'm I'm not like sitting stony-faced uh in in the way that that some people do, but I definitely hate hate people uh when I'm on stage who are actively showing me that they're not having a good time.
[7:21] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, that's that's a little rough. And yes, I I just painted the picture of you that you like begrudgingly, you're just sitting there grumpy. That's what I just painted. That's not at all what you do, I'm sure. Um Joe Iconis, fucking A, from the black suits to uh uh all the way to BE MORE CHILL, making it too Broadway, the the resurgence of your songs during the year of Smash with Broadway Here I Come and the Goodbye song, these songs that have lived in the ether, and then they get this big fat resurgence. Uh you've had such an insane career. I want to ask you what I feel like everybody wants to know. What were you like in middle school?
[8:02] Joe Iconis: I was uh I was uh really really large. I was a very uh very large child, uh and young man and and and adult. Uh uh, and I was pretty uh pretty shy. I was pretty quiet. Um, and I love musicals. I was just like a I was a piano playing musical theater uh geek. That's what that's what I was.
[8:26] Drew Gasparini: Do people ask me this all the time? I mean, like in terms of of when you hear your shows, when you hear your songs and your song cycles, they don't like exude musical theater necessarily. There's a great kid, there's characters, there's storytelling, but like it doesn't sound like what I imagine. I like I don't know what musical theater you might have been obsessed with in middle school or back then, but like the way that translated into your music is amazing to me because you're you're not quite you don't fit under the umbrella of musical theater in the best way, in this way that I'm like always bewildered by, but you so live in the world of musical theater almost as this like in the same way that like Walter White was such a great superhero, but he was so not a superhero. Do you know what I mean? It was like you you're the Walter White of musical theater. Like I root for you, I root for you for almost the reasons I don't root for any other musical theater.
[9:23] Joe Iconis: Thanks. That's very kind. Thank you. How did that happen? What was that evolution? And like, I don't know. Like I can't, I hear I just can't imagine you like bopping out to hello dolly.
[9:33] Joe Iconis: Um, I mean, I I was. That's the that's the truth of it. And that also is like that's a funny, you know, it's a funny thing that I kind of it took me a while to to realize sort of people's perception of of me and who I was. I feel like so many people used to think, or and certainly still do think, like oh, like, you know, I came from like the rock world, or I came from the, you know, like I played in bands and then I found my way to musical theater, which is just so not the case. Like, I I loved, you know, classic musical theater when I was uh when I was a kid, you know, I saw Little Shop of Hars when I was six years old. Uh and then that sort of kicked off this love of musicals. And you know, I I loved like, you know, newer stuff as it came out, like Rent and Hedwig and stuff with like a you know decidedly more contemporary sound.
But I mean, truly, you know, like Sondheim is, you know, is my my my god and Candor and Ebb and all the Rogers and Hammerstein stuff and Frank Lesser, like all of that stuff is what I listened to exclusively until I got to college.
[10:30] Drew Gasparini: And so I think that I had this really strong uh understanding of musical theater songwriting and this real love and appreciation of musical theater songwriting form. And also it was just because I loved musicals so much. The way that the way that's you know, sort of classic musical theater songs were written, to me, that was songwriting. Like to me, like, oh yeah, that's how you saw you write a song, this is how you say you do it. And so it was kind of in my bones. So then when I got to undergrad uh at NYU, I kind of felt like, oh, I should probably try to listen to things that aren't um only original cast albums. You know, it's like I've heard there's I've heard there's other music out there, and so maybe I should give it a shot.
[11:13] Joe Iconis: What is this? What is this the Beatles everyone keeps talking about?
[11:17] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[11:17] Joe Iconis: Oh man, yeah. No, truly, truly. I remember I remember like I, you know, in in high school, you know, people would say, like, who's your favorite band? And I would literally say Hedwig and the Angry Inch because it was just like an off-Broadway show at that time, so like nobody knew what that was, and so I would act like it was like uh like a band, like I would hysterical, yeah. And I would say hysterical, even like even as a even you know, younger, like even in middle school, I would sometimes when kids would talk about music, I would I would say the names of shows and pretend that they were like band names, like I would say, like I love Blood Brothers because no one knew what the fuck that was.
[11:53] Drew Gasparini: You got to jamming out to fucking, you know, but you then you slip up and you say, Yeah, Lion King. They're like yeah, this is his new band.
[12:02] Joe Iconis: Lion King, yeah. But but yeah, so I you know, so I think that I had this real strong base of of musical theater, and then when I got to college, started listening to all this, you know, other stuff and and found some real like, you know, uh loves and really like developed a love of of a lot of other types of music, and so then I think that my my voice as a writer kind of started taking shape at the very end of my undergrad time, um, and that sort of coincided with me.
[12:31] Joe Iconis: Also, like I really had like a big I had a big sort of physical transformation. I just kind of came into my own as a man as I was also, you know, sort of shaping my voice as a writer, and I was like loving all this music. So all those things I think kind of congealed and sort of started me on this path, you know. It's so funny. Like we're talking about you as a writer, but to me it's so much bigger than you as a writer. Your writing does like live in its own universe and speaks for itself, and those songs can be sung by anybody, and they're those are your songs. But you have this presence of an artist, and that's why I think it's so uh not confusing, it's surprising that the uh uh Rogers and Hammerstein and all that kind of stuff was part of your listenability in middle school.
That's what you were jamming out to because it doesn't translate to what you're I'm gonna put this in big air quotes for you, but your persona, whatever your persona is on stage is like, oh yeah, I follow the flaming lips, and oh yeah, I'm I'm a big fan of like giant bombastic live acts like arcade fire and shit like that. I I almost said rusted root, but I wouldn't do that to you.
[13:35] Drew Gasparini: Not rusted root.
[13:38] Joe Iconis: Rusted root. Rusted fruit. We did we need more white people with dreadlocks. That's what we look at. Um no, but you bring this this energy and it like bleeds out. I used to I was so envious. Envious is also the wrong word, but when I first moved to New York, the two first concerts I saw, and they were vastly different, but I was wildly inspired by both was uh a concert of yours in like 2008 at the Laurie Beachman and a concert of Ryan Scott Oliver's at Joe's Pub. And I was just like, God damn it, what the fuck am I doing with my life? And I'm a little backwards here because you started listening to musical theater. I started, I was a singer-songwriter. The theater was like an accidental byproduct to all the songwriting I'd been doing.
So I kind of was like trying to find this way to be a singer songwriter and write musical theater. And when I saw your concerts I was like he fucking did it. He he did he just did it. He's a rock star on stage but these are all his theater songs that he's playing right now. It like blew it actually blew my mind. Were you did you feel like the first to kind of like make this con because everybody's fucking doing concerts these days. Well you were before before the volcano diarrhea thing that happened in 2020 but but like everybody everybody's trying to put their stamp on what their live performance is not just their writing and I think you are a huge you're like kind of this godfather of that contemporary live concert thing that everyone's trying so badly to not replicate but have their own version of it.
[15:07] Drew Gasparini: And the Joe Iconis uh jamboree and the family thing it all of it is just so addictive and alluring everybody wants to be a part of it. It feels so fucking rock star. How come you never went the route of singer songwriter at any point because you clearly have the chops um thanks thanks for thanks for all of that. I feel like you really just complimenting me so much. I was not not expecting this is like I like you Joe. You might not believe it I like you thank you thank you.
[15:34] Joe Iconis: Uh yeah so no I mean I you know uh the as far as the uh the the concert stuff started uh really because I was kind of out in the world of of musical theater and uh it became obvious to me uh after sort of being in development with with the new musical for a while like oh this dream that I had of like graduating from grad school and having this musical about a garage band uh that had young people in it having it open off Broadway and being this massive uh critical success and then moving to Broadway and the rest of my life being set that was like not gonna happen in the timeline that I was kind of dreaming about. And so I was like I wanna I I was writing songs and I was like I want to I want to have these songs on a stage. You know I want to I want to I don't want to be some writer who's just like writing stuff for no one to hear you know I want to I want to put it on a stage.
[16:28] Joe Iconis: And for me you know I like I loved going to see live performance. You know I love I love going to see like cabaret like sort of classic you know show tune like don't tell mama 88's Rose's turn to get a cabaret and I loved um you know going to see like like rock bands and I loved you know like going to Mercury Lounge and like going to like sort of small rock venues in the city uh and so I just felt like oh there's a there's a way to sort of combine this idea of like you know a sort of you know classic show tune cabaret and a and a rock concert and I so I started doing you know doing doing that and when I started it it's the concept the me there wasn't really a musical theater concert scene you know as you alluded to like all the musical theater concert stuff that I had seen which I you know which I loved uh always felt like a recital to me you know it always felt like 100% it was like oh people in music stands and and it also always felt like oh these people these writers are are doing this as an audition like these writers are doing this probably because they've invited someone from you know from Disney or someone from whatever to come and see you know whoever happened to be famous at the time stand behind a music stand and sing their song and uh which is totally fine and like I loved it I went to all of them but I just felt like oh I want to do something like that feels like a show you know in the way that like you go to see you know you when you when you go to see uh you know whatever like like the White Stripes I wasn't going to you know I I didn't feel like oh the white stripes are doing the show so they can get like a a song place and a commercial like they're just doing the show to do it that that's what I wanted to do with the what kind of musical a musical theater thing.
[18:06] Joe Iconis: Yeah and you know I I was not a performer before I started doing stuff. Like I really I performing freaked me out and I was not good at it but I always like I loved the idea of it. You know I loved like I always feel like I wish I could be like one of those guys who could just like sit at a piano and and and perform or I wish I'd be one of those guys who like read a lead a leader rock band.
[18:27] Drew Gasparini: Did you feel like did you feel like safer behind the piano? Did you feel like you kind of had this fortress protecting you I you know what I mean like it's man is is intimidating as hell to me. I don't know how people just like I think of Brendan Ure from Panic at the disco and he's just got a mic and he's just like why he's just owning a stage and like I could never do that. I need a guitar I need a shield I need something to block my actual insecurities here.
[18:52] Joe Iconis: Oh same same same same and I mean from you know for me like a still still it is so weird for me to like be on a stage with just a microphone I've had to do it I've had to do it like quite a bit now in the last couple years of my life and so I've gotten better but still it's like the piano that just feels like that feels very comfortable that feels like home it's literally in you know in front of you.
[19:13] Drew Gasparini: So yeah the the piano definitely helped transition me from I got a question about your piano playing.
[19:20] Joe Iconis: Yeah.
[19:20] Drew Gasparini: Because you rip it up. I mean, like, I've seen you like I I don't know if it's part of of just the energy of the show, but like you really, your whole body is playing that piano at some points. You know what I mean? What was your training? I mean, you said you were listening to classical theater. Were you uh how how good of a reader are you? Are you like really like you can whip it out on the keys with a classical piece or no?
[19:41] Joe Iconis: No, I mean my my chops are not what they were, so I probably couldn't now. But I mean, I'm a good, uh yeah, I'm a good read, you know, I'm a good, I'm a good musician. Like I can look at it, you know, have a piece of sheet music in front of me and play it. And um, you know, uh however when I was a kid, I so I come from a family that's not in the arts at all, at all, at all, at all. No one in my family is like in entertainment, no one had any idea what to do with me as a kid. And so, you know, my my background uh with piano lessons was like I I worked with a uh a neighborhood piano teacher, uh Mrs. Jablonski, and I I the more I loved theater, the more I started playing by ear. And so I would have, you know, my sort of piano assignments, but then I would like, you know, whatever go to see uh, you know, the Who's Tommy, because you have a Tommy poster behind you, which is why I said that.
Um the Who's Tommy, and then I would go home and I would pick out, you know, the the songs that I heard on the piano, um, which and just sort of you know started improvising, which then led into me like writing stuff myself.
[20:42] Joe Iconis: Uh but it was um, you know, it was sort of like it felt like something separate from the kind of traditional classical uh piano playing that I was being taught. And then I went to like that sort of exceeded the neighborhood, you know, teacher's abilities. And so she was like, Oh, there's this piano, you know, this fancy piano school called Strecker and Harwitz, uh where it's like they teach like the real kids on the island who know how to play piano. So I went to this this piano school, like you know, just like a you know, once-a-week piano lesson kind of deal. And it was just straight up classical. Uh and so I did that, but I just I hated it so much. And I was I was good at it, but like what's so weird, and I'm still on like this.
[21:17] Joe Iconis: Like, I I'm so good at faking things in that way that you know, I would look at at these these classical pieces, and I could just I just kind of could tell like where my fingers should fall, you know, and like the piano teacher would be like that that's not the note, that's not the note, and I'd be like, Well, it's in the chord, so it's the same thing, you know. And I had no sense of like why that was wrong, why that was so bad.
[21:38] Drew Gasparini: Wow. So your head must be cluttered with just chord progressions. Do you just like memorize chord progressions like you're some kind of rain man?
[21:44] Joe Iconis: No, they're just like in there. It's just so it's so weird. You know, it's music is very it's very intuitive for me, and so it just kind of it's hard for me to even talk about. I just kind of feel it, you know.
[21:55] Drew Gasparini: It's just sort of like it's in the world.
[21:56] Joe Iconis: I I agree with that 100%.
[21:58] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, yeah. That's that's my my strictly that's my only approach to to music is like I need to be able to feel it before it comes out in some sort of way.
[22:06] Joe Iconis: Yeah. I I never approach a song, uh, I never approach writing a song with this character seems like they'd be singing in a major. I never like that's not the way I start. It's like it just kind of all happens at once, you know what I mean? I hate I hate the question, and I'll never ask you this question because I I'm telling you out loud how much I hate this question.
[22:24] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[22:30] Joe Iconis: Stop asking that stupid question. There's no way, and there's no way that every song is like, well, first music and then the lyrics. There's no possible way. If you're as prolific as a writer as you or I or anybody who's trying to do this is, there's no way it's gonna be the same method every single time. And if it is, you're boring. You're fucking boring. And that's yeah, no, I I agree. I agree. To me, that's the ultimate like, who cares? Question. Like, truly, it's like, what is the like and how does it affect you? If you like the song, what does it fucking matter? You know what I hear?
[22:58] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[22:58] Joe Iconis: Uh Joe, I this is just a quick thought. I have it written down. I literally have it forbidden written down. Joe, I think you would be a really good cigarette smoker. Your thoughts.
[23:08] Joe Iconis: Oh man, I wish I smoked cigarettes so bad. It's like it's an awful, it's a very bad habit. Uh really, really uh really shitty, you know. Don't don't do it, don't smoke, blah, blah, blah. But I I wish I did. I just don't.
[23:23] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[23:24] Joe Iconis: There's something, but like, there's something about your essence that like, and here's what it is. Since we've been talking, you put your hand through your hair like a thousand times, and it looks glorious. You've got a great head of hair.
[23:33] Drew Gasparini: Why do you think I wear hats all the time, by the way? Thanks.
[23:37] Joe Iconis: So I uh so you with the cigar it's like this, it's the James Dean. It's the you know what I mean? You got the cigarette in one hand, the other hand's going through your fucking slick locks. You look, you you got the look down.
[23:49] Drew Gasparini: Thank you.
[23:50] Joe Iconis: Yeah, no, I I agree. I think it I think it looks so cool. Uh, but I just never did. You know, my grandparents were smokers growing up, and what's and I think the reason that I never did was because there were all these smokers that were in my life growing up, it never felt like a cool thing when I was a kid or like a rebellious thing. And I was like the least rebellious kid of all time. But um, but you know, I I have all these pictures. My my my grandma, um, my my dad's mom uh was this sort of like sort of wild uh southern lady uh whose name was Mama Wee, and uh she thought it was hilarious to put cigarettes in my mouth, like as an infant.
[24:27] Joe Iconis: So I have all of these pictures of me like as an infant where she would put the cigarette in my mouth, and then when I got to be like three or four, she would like light the cigarette as I had it in my mouth. And she'd be like, now that his lungs are three or four years old, we can light this bad boy up.
[24:43] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, yeah.
[24:43] Joe Iconis: So it was really in my life. It would have been really natural for me too, but I just never did. You just look like you got the aesthetic for it. You've got a good fatal strike. You got deep dark features too. You got the dark eyebrows and the dark hair. You look like you could work in one of those offices from the Mad Men era. I just see it working for you. And I love that you have these pictures of you as a baby with a cigarette. We're gonna get a petition started. Start the hashtag Joe Iconis needs to be a solo artist because you have the album cover right there. If you as a baby with a cigarette, how great is that? That's a perfect album cover.
[25:16] Drew Gasparini: It's a pretty yeah, I mean, like Grammy nomination for best album packaging, here I come.
[25:21] Joe Iconis: Yeah, that's a thing. That's a thing, right? That should absolutely be, it is now. It is today. Let's talk about a little bit about career stuff just for a minute. First of all, I want to say, I'm sure this never happens to you in the other way than I'm about to explain it. But what happens to me almost on a weekly basis is Drew Gasparini, I love your song Broadway Here I Come. I hear that all the time. Do you ever get a song of mine tossed your way thinking that like, oh wow, I love this song? You're like, I actually didn't write that. Or not even me. Other writers, do you get things like I really enjoyed Leave Luan?
[26:00] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. All the time. People a lot of times think that I wrote Kind of a Funny Story. Well, because of Ned Vizzini.
[26:10] Drew Gasparini: Because of the Ned Vizzini affiliation, probably, because of BE MORE CHILL, which is a perfect segue. You and I are both writing, or I am writing, you wrote, to some success, I hear, a musical based on a Ned Vizzini novel. I'm writing It's Kind of a Funny Story for Universal with Alex Brightman, and you to some great acclaim wrote BE MORE CHILL. I want to talk about that not in a way that I'm sure that you've probably talked about it before. I probably will ask some questions that you've answered a thousand times, but like what an incredible journey. I remember getting the soundtrack after you had done it in Two River, is that what it was?
[26:47] Joe Iconis: Yeah, Two River, Red Bank, in Jersey. And I was listening to it, and I was like, this is, first of all, hearing it, you hear Charlie right away. You hear Charlie's influence on it right away. Charlie Rosen, what a genius. But you hear your stamp on it as well, and I love the Joe Iconis stamp because it's one of those things that you can hop genre to genre, you can hop style to style and make it fit whatever show, but it just like Sondheim does, it just has that thing that you do, and this really encompasses the Joe Iconis sound so well. I really love the soundtrack for BE MORE CHILL. Then you guys go off-Broadway because that soundtrack started getting some love.
[27:32] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Did you ever anticipate your road to Broadway being paved by the internet?
[27:32] Joe Iconis: No, definitely never anticipated it. And honestly, I am so, or I at least I used to be so old school about the business and the process of songwriting. And still, like I'm someone who I don't do nice sound demos of things. I make voice recordings of me and a piano on my phone. I'm super old school. And so, you know, I always sort of imagine slash fantasize that if I was gonna get to Broadway, it would be the sort of traditional route for stuff like I write. Like, so I thought that it would be, you know, a little musical that would probably be at an off-off-Broadway theater or a regional theater that would then be well received, and because it was well received, it would come to like a fancy nonprofit off-Broadway, and then I'd get a great New York Times review and I'd go to Broadway, which is like how that's how it works for shows like, you know, the type of shows that I write. And so that's, you know, that was sort of my dream of how I would kind of get there.
[28:47] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[28:47] Joe Iconis: And with BE MORE CHILL, you know, it just so had a life that was so not that, you know, and so it was definitely the most unexpected thing. And honestly, it's so weird, but like the journey of it gave me faith. Like it gave me hope that I didn't realize that I had lost, which is weird because I, you know, because I wrote it, like it's my show. But the way that it got where it got, it was because of reasons that had nothing to do with me. You know, it's because of the internet. And of course, like, you know, I made it happen in a certain way, and then many other people made it happen. But the fact that it, you know, the cast album that we made of this show that everyone thought was dead because we got a shitty New York Times review, which has happened to me multiple times in my career, and that just, it kills the show for the type of shows that I write.
We got the bad New York Times review, the show was dead. The guy who was the head of the board of the theater, Bob Recknitz, he loved the musical and wanted to make a record of it because he really felt like it deserved to have a record. And so that's why we made that cast album. And for us, it really felt like, oh, this is this cast album on this thing that's never gonna be heard from again.
[30:01] Joe Iconis: Because it was your guys' yearbook. You were signing the back page of this cast album, like have a good summer, everybody, not thinking it would turn into the next step in your education, quote unquote. You know?
[30:12] Drew Gasparini: It was, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[30:13] Joe Iconis: No, I mean, it was a gravestone. It wasn't even a yearbook. It was a, the day, you know, the day that BE MORE CHILL came out, it came out, so we closed in June. We made the album, recorded it very soon after that, and then it came out right before Halloween in 2015. And I listened to it. I bought it on iTunes because that was still like a thing in 2015. So I bought it and I listened to it, and I was walking to Party City on 34th Street because I was gonna do my Halloween show that night, or the next night or whatever, at the Beachman. And I was listening to it, and as I was listening to More Than Survive, it got to the end where everyone does like the nah nah nah nah nah nah nah na na. And I like truly just started crying, like hysterically crying on 34th Street, because I was like, I just truly believe that I'm doing good work here, and no one is gonna hear this ever again. No one is gonna care that I released this album and it's not, this will never be on a stage again, and it makes me so sad because I really believe in it.
[31:19] Drew Gasparini: Hey, it's everyone's favorite part of the interview, the part where I interrupt and screw up the momentum of what we're talking about. I like to interrupt to remind you listeners that the way we support our guests here is by following them on their socials and keeping up with what they have going on. Joe Iconis is a prolific writer who has done more than I might ever do in my lifetime, and he's got a lot more coming up down the pipe. So make sure to follow Joe Iconis on Twitter and Instagram and beyond at Mr. Joe Iconis. Hey, and while you're following things, make sure to subscribe to this podcast. Back to Joe.
[31:54] Joe Iconis: This is, by the way, that kind of speaks to the appeal of doing, for me at least, like doing the 54 Below shows. I do those because I'm like, well, I have a mountain of songs that have been cut from shows or will never ever get to the light of day ever. I'm gonna have to force them onto a stage so that they have a blip of a life, and then maybe YouTube will do the rest. You know what I mean? I feel that very hard about crime because you're like, I put so much of myself into this. The product is good. I don't care what people said in the New York Times. This is a good show. When you started to see the effects of what the internet had to say, were you like, did you feel super validated and like, I told you, goddammit?
Was it like an about time kind of thing? Because I will say this, Joe. There is, you are cemented in theater lore, at least for writers of my generation, your generation, the Ryan Scott Olivers. We all heard the stories and watched the this close moment, the like inches away from Broadway with black suits and all that kind of stuff. There's a back and forth. So for you to be the announcement of Broadway was like, Joe Iconis is finally going to Broadway. There was like a collective celebration from all of your composer brethren in the community because we'd been watching you pump out work, and what you just said is so amazing because you're like, I know I'm doing good work. And that's what your shows prove.
It's like, I know what this is is fun. I'm gonna do it because I know it's good. I'm gonna write BE MORE CHILL and put it and get that album out because I believe in this. And then to have the thought of no one's gonna get to see this. That stings. Joe, when your announcement came out for Broadway, the whole theater industry was like, it finally happened. It happened.
[33:40] Joe Iconis: It happened. Uh, so tell me about it when all the announcements started going down off-Broadway to Broadway and then London. And oh my god.
[33:49] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, if it weren't for COVID, this thing would still be playing its life longer and longer and longer.
[33:54] Joe Iconis: I know, I know, I know. Yeah, no, it's, you know, it was nuts. And the sort of outpouring of love and support, it felt really genuine and it felt really earned, which was really nice, you know? And that all happened. Well, the crazy thing is that it wasn't like a switch, you know, to BE MORE CHILL stuff. It wasn't like, oh, BE MORE CHILL went viral, and now it's going to Broadway. Like it truly was like, it sort of gradually happened, and honestly, it was such hard work to get it to New York City because for the longest time I found myself in the position of beating this drum of people are into this show. This show is huge. People want to see this, there'd be an audience for this. I know there would, and no one cared.
No one cared. Because the things I was using to prove that was like, you know, it's the number two show on Tumblr. And it's been, you know, it's been streamed millions of times. And like, and theater people, you know, bless them, but they are old school and they're very suspicious of anything new, and they're really suspicious of anything that they're not in control of. And so everyone was just kind of like, oh, that's cute, that's sweet. You have, I'm glad you have a lot of retweets, whatever you call it. Like it was true. You're still up, and so like there was like this time when it felt like where I felt like, you know, right before I hooked up with Jerry Gorian, who's the producer of BE MORE CHILL that made it happen.
You know, right before that, this was like in the winter of 2017 and 2018. And I just felt like this is, if this doesn't, if nothing happens with this show, I'm gonna like lose my mind and go like live on a farm somewhere. Which is not to say that like living on a farm is bad. Just I'm just meant, you know, I'm gonna like it.
[35:42] Drew Gasparini: It's not necessarily what your plan was.
[35:44] Joe Iconis: Yeah. I just immediately had a vision of a farmer like listening to this podcast and then being like, fuck you.
[35:51] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, I hear a lot of the followers of this podcast, we have a big farmer audience, so I'm glad you clarified.
[35:57] Joe Iconis: Amish love Drew Gasparini. Uh, but yeah, but so I, you know, so it was so bad because no one, I felt like I have all of this, this miracle has happened where this thing has reached this level of awareness that all of these shows try to get that have corporations behind them and that are based on, you know, whatever movies or theme parks or whatever. And this just happened from the show that played for in New Jersey for a few weeks, and no one cares. But the Jerry Gorian cared and Jen Tepper cared, and because of that we were able to like, you know, do it off-Broadway.
[36:37] Joe Iconis: And truly, when like tickets went on sale for off Broadway, we just didn't know if anyone was gonna buy them. Like it was like we hoped. But then holy shit, you know, because goddamn. Yeah, yeah. And so then because like off Broadway was such like a crazy bonanza of tickets, you know, we were able to go to Broadway. But even what was so wild is that when we when we started, you know, when it was like, okay, we're gonna do memor uh off Broadway this summer. I was so thrilled because you know, I had I hadn't had a show play in New York City since Blood Song of Love, which was 2010. Like it felt like I didn't know. Arsnova, right? At Arsenova, yeah, at the gorgeous Arsenova. Um, but so I just wanted to have a show, I want to have a show in the city, you know.
I was like, I want to have like please let me have like like a work where I I can like sleep in my own bed, you know, because I just far away for a long time. And so I was like, that's that's amazing. It was like 10 weeks, it's like this is all I want. I just want to be able to do this show off Broadway. I don't want to think about what happens next. I just want to like be in this place and enjoy it and like not worry about property. But as soon as it started selling, of course, like when we were in rehearsals, then everyone was like, Oh my god, oh my god, there's interest in this thing. This thing could happen. If this thing, if this thing gets a New York Times review this time, plus these ticket sales, it's gonna this could happen.
This could happen. I was like, oh god, no, no, no, no, no, please. I do not want to be like like going towards opening night of this fucking show, being like, okay, it all rests on the New York Times review, which is what it has always been for me. And it has always been bad. And so go, you know, be more chill opening night, we uh we got it another terrible New York Times review, which was like so so thrilling to me that there's like two separate ones now for this like little show that could um we got a bad one, and that night, the night of the party, so truly dude, like everyone, everyone would come up to me, um, and people that we mutually know, um, titans of the business would be like, I'm so sorry.
Like, like literally, like it was a funeral, because that's how it's so black and white that it's like for a show like mine, like you need that in order to get to this next step. You know, people are, I'm so sorry, I'm so sorry, but it's gonna, it's gonna have a good life, and this is amazing, and kids really love it. And and then um the person who did not do that that night was Jen Tepper, who was just like, no, we're not doing this. We're not like playing this the way that we're supposed to play it. And we like, we got this, like, absolutely not. We're not like playing this game. The rules changed for you guys without you changing the rules. The internet did that for you. And this young audience, I'll tell you, I went and saw it off Broadway.
I went with my manager, Erica Rotstein, who I you may or may not know. She's married to Ian. Uh uh, we went and saw the show, and like every song, the the row of nine girls with different colored hair sitting next to me, are screaming the lyrics like they're at a Taylor Swift concert. Like I but I do you understand what that does to my insides? It makes me feel like I am part of something bigger. It the whole audience felt that it's like, wow, people are clung to this. These people knew the words verbatim, and like there were there, like some a character who is certainly not the lead would come out and then get entrance applause. And I I was I was bewildered by it. You guys really created like a whole new way to do this and a whole new brand of theater, I feel like.
Uh, I want to ask real quick, just because I am having an experience, you know, adapting a show uh and writing an original show. You've written many original shows, one of them you just mentioned, which is like one of my favorite things of yours that I've ever seen. Perhaps my favorite was Blood Song. I love that so much. So so my friend. Uh, but the I'm working on the karate kid, so taking a big fat franchise and like having to deal with what that means to others and not just myself. Taking taking it's kind of a funny story, which is lives in the Ned Vizzini world, which his fans, you know, not just be more chill, not just funny story fans, Ned Vizzini fans are a breed of their own who really cling to the material.
Did you feel uh while adapting this or watching the evolution of it make its way to Broadway, did you feel like you did Ned's work justice? And uh was that ever a part of your creative process, or were you like, we have the rights, let's make it ours and let's put it up there? What was your approach to all that?
[40:49] Joe Iconis: Yeah, you know, I it was it's weird because I I feel like when we started working on BE MORE CHILL, Ned was not um Ned was like a little bit more of a cult y figure, you know. It was not the the awareness of his stuff was not quite as widespread as it is now. And so, you know, luckily we didn't have that. Like we didn't have the thing of like, oh man, what are the fans gonna think about changing this and changing this? We truly were just like, oh, this book is really cool. We love Ned, we love his writing. Uh, let's, you know, let's do our best version of the musical version of this. And, you know, I I knew when we started working to be more chill, um, you know, Ned was was was alive, and so we had conversations with him, and we talked about the show and we talked about what we wanted to do.
And he was very cool in a way that a lot of uh authors or you know, people who are the the creator of the original source are not cool, where he was just like, I don't know a musical. So he's like, I don't know anything about this, you guys do, and so just like do your thing. And his his main thing, he was he was really concerned about the the characters themselves feeling like true to the characters that that he created, which they do, even though we've changed them a bunch. It was more about the you know, the the intention. I think that you wanted to make sure that it wasn't that we weren't trying to like turn it into something, some sort of like, you know, like glossy, uh fake, you know, sort of like cartoon version of what he did.
And so, uh, and so yeah, so that's all we had to kind of go on, and we really believed like he would really have liked what we did. Um, and sadly, like he killed himself before he ever he ever even heard us. It was so crazy. We had a our first ever reading was scheduled for Jan the January after he killed himself in in December, and and it was like it it always it just like blows my mind that like oh man, this guy never got to hear anything in the show because also everyone was like, don't send him any songs because if he doesn't like it, he could like you know stop something. And I was just thinking, man, I wish I could have like sent him some stuff. Um, but luckily he, you know, um uh uh uh uh Sabra, uh, who's his uh who's his his uh his widow, yeah.
His widow, his wife, uh she uh she's been really involved and really awesome and and has said that you know she really thinks he would have dug the the show when we did. So that's that's kind of the thing most important to us.
[43:05] Joe Iconis: Um yeah, yeah. The weirdest thing with with you know, that kind of thing with BE MORE CHILL was like we because you know, because the first time we did it in New York, people had our we were able to do it because people knew it. Like that that was weird where it felt like the fans that we were worried about in the writing process was like the fans of the show, which I've never had the experience, and I would love to never have that experience again. Where you're like, it's not even like oh, they're gonna get so pissed if we change this about the source material. It's like, no, it's like they're gonna get pissed if we change this about the show. So the show that they that they fell in love with wasn't quite done. You know, we were like sort of in the process of developing it. So that was a weird thing.
[43:46] Joe Iconis: How many times did you get uh questions about like your love for Little Shop of Horrors? Because it's like a there's like the sci-fi comedy aspect of beam or there's a lot of parallels, I guess, just in terms of those two shows uh as a musical and just like genres. Was was a part of you like, this is my this is my little shop moment. I'm having my little shop of horrors moment right now.
[44:09] Joe Iconis: Um I mean, ish, you know, what's so funny is that both like Trace and I we love Little Shop, and it's like Little Shop is very you know informative uh musical for me, but we never consciously set out to be like, oh, this is gonna be like our little shop. And when we were writing it, the the musical theater references that I would always say were sort of very much more old school. Like I kept talking about Dan Yankees, I kept talking about sort of old-fashioned musical comedies. You know, and that's where I was like, I'm I'm doing that. I'm just we know we're using technology and we're you know, and I'm drawing from different influences, like 50s, you know, sci-fi movies and 80s horror movies.
Um but it wasn't until we did the first reading where we were like, oh right, we just kind of like wrote Little Shop. Cool. You know, I mean, but you but you didn't. I mean, like it's it's clear that it's like that's just like the happenstance of how the show kind of ended up. I just love the parallel of I've heard in interviews and I've read in interviews with you that like Little Shop was a big thing for you. So to see this like live the life it had, it's like oh my god, this is his sci-fi comedy. It's it's like what Little Shop must have felt like for Makin and the such.
[45:14] Joe Iconis: Um a couple random questions for you, Joe, if you don't mind just hopping off topic for a little bit.
[45:19] Joe Iconis: Yeah, I love it. Just this is kind of a general thing, but and I I want to know this as uh as a great admirer of yours, but I think listeners would also like to know because you're so prolific. If you just list the the musicals you've written, not songs. I mean, because songs can go live and die in 54 below, they really can. But you but you have had a number of musicals. You're very, very prolific. And you also have a very based on what you've said, you have this old school mindset of here's what I would like here's how I want it to go down this is my hope this is what I want Joe's trajectory to be what is something that holds you back what holds you back in this industry what holds me back in this industry or in life not even in this industry I would just say like what is something that holds you back I guess the the deeper way to question it is what is the insecurity that you continue to carry with you that's a good question um or is it that you started getting Broadway money and now all those insecurities are out the window yeah the Broadway money really yeah it pays I I paid pay someone to extract my insecurities from it I think I just fell asleep no I don't know I'm thinking I want to that's a it's a great question I want to I want it I want it to have a great answer um I don't I don't know you know I think I think I think maybe I think that I it's not that I want I it's not that I want everything to be perfect it's no you know what I think maybe it is I don't know I don't know if this holds me back, but I think it's something that keeps me from from feeling content.
It's this it's this sense of like things could be better always. Like it's the sense of like no no success is no success is is quite good enough. You know, it's the sense of like, oh, if I get I, you know, I'm I I think I'm trying to get to I think I'm trying to get to you know to to point A, but uh, it was actually point B and I just missed point B, but I'll, you know, I'll try for B next time. And it's like this sense of like never being fulfilled with with anything. Um and so I think that it's I don't know if that's like drive or you know, it's like my you know, my ambition will get the the best of me if I'm just like playing out there will be blood in the the American musical theater. Uh but like it's it's I I think that is something that that that trips me up.
And then I think because of that, I I have a tendency to get really um, you know, furious or depressed or whatever. I think my my highs and lows are are really extreme because I because I'm always like unsatisfied. I can never just be settled, you know. I I say this to anybody, uh, and you know, you're married to the lovely Lauren Marcus, but I I always say anybody who dates a writer is in for the biggest up and down roller coaster of their entire life because it's either like we have the most sunshine or we are casting the biggest shadow. It's there's like hardly a medium in between those two states. That's at least my experience, and most writers I know are like that. I do think it comes from that drive of like even when you get there, and I'm sure there are moments, even when BE MORE CHILL made its way to Broadway, as amazing as that felt, and for all the reasons that it got to Broadway being extra amazing.
[49:03] Drew Gasparini: There were probably moments of just looking around, because I put myself in your shoes in this situation, where I would have gone, like, yeah, but it's not what I wanted. It's not how I it's not how I wanted it. Like, I'm here and I'm still finding things that are missing from this experience that I wanted specifically.
[49:21] Joe Iconis: Oh yeah.
[49:21] Drew Gasparini: Oh yeah. I mean a hundred percent, which is it's a very it's a challenging thing to talk about because it's hard, you know, it's hard to be like, my show got to Broadway, and I'm so sad about it.
[49:32] Joe Iconis: Oh, sure, but that's exactly what I wanted.
[49:34] Drew Gasparini: But that's just that that's part of that that frustrated, uh endlessly uh happy but frustrated, never satisfied writer mindset. That's that's where I'm coming from. Is I would have yes, a show could go to Broadway. Uh the the minute I booked karate kid, I called my mom and she goes, Holy shit, Drew, you you did it. Like it's all you finally got the thing, and I'm like, I got the thing. And then I get off the phone, I'm like, how the fuck am I gonna write? I don't this isn't what I wanted to do. Like, I I I didn't even think it was a good idea. Like karate kids seemed like a bad idea. Like I really had this like meltdown of what am I thinking? What are they thinking? And any other writer would have been like, fuck you, I want that job, or fuck you, I want that experience. And I'll find a way to complain about it. Maybe that's what it is. Maybe cut writers have uh perfected the art of complaining a little bit.
[50:22] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, or just having complicated feelings about things, but that's you know, but that's why we're we're writers, you know. And I think that it's if you if you didn't feel that way, if you didn't, you know, if you weren't like the examining things and second guessing things, then you'd you'd probably be a shitty writer, you know.
[50:38] Drew Gasparini: I think you're right. I think you are right. Uh Joe, a couple couple more silly questions before we wrap up here, if that's cool with you.
[50:45] Joe Iconis: I thought that I thought the what holds you back question was gonna be a silly question.
[50:49] Drew Gasparini: No, sorry, you're right. It was just it was just an off topic question. But here are the silly ones now. Sorry, that that was a that was a misdirect on my uh here.
[50:58] Joe Iconis: I liked it.
[50:59] Drew Gasparini: It was very exciting. If you had to make out with uh any of the following composers, would it be Ryan Scott Oliver, Adam Guan, or Drew Gasparini?
[51:13] Joe Iconis: Out of those three, who would you want to make out with? There is truly only one right answer, but uh I defer to you. Go for it.
[51:18] Joe Iconis: Adam Guan, the prettiest.
[51:20] Drew Gasparini: You are no, that was the right answer. Absolutely correct.
[51:24] Joe Iconis: He's just so cute. He's just he's just an adorable little pocket sized man, and I want to make out with him right now as we're talking. Um last last silly question, and then uh uh one last real question before we part.
[51:37] Drew Gasparini: Yeah. We're having a dueling pianos royale, okay? And I think you're a you're a prime uh person to ask this question to, just based on your extensive study of piano and how you bring it to the stage in this in this rock and roll format a lot of the time. Uh let's let's start with an easy one. Elton John versus Billy Joel, who's taking who?
[51:58] Joe Iconis: Who's conquering that battle royale?
[52:00] Joe Iconis: Elton John.
[52:01] Drew Gasparini: What makes you say that?
[52:03] Joe Iconis: I love that you said that, because I feel like you would have said Billy Joel strictly for the Long Island thing. But what is what is uh the Elton John reason?
[52:10] Joe Iconis: I mean, I think in the and you know, if we're talking about literally what would happen, I just think that Elton John uh has a sense of of showmanship uh that that sets him apart from Billy Joel. And I think that he um uh he's a he's a more he's a more aggressive uh d character, I would say. And I and I think that Elton John, I feel like he would uh he would fight uh he would fight dirty, and I feel like he wants to win. And so I think that he would he would just take take Billy Joel. But for you know, for my personal piano battle, I just always like loved Elton John so much. I think too because he was also kind of goofy, you know, like not goofy, but has a sense of like he both has the thing of like I'm the coolest fucking rock star in the whole world and nobody can touch me. And like, you know, I'm gonna like dress up like Donald Duck and so like just silly and like and like challenge you to think that he was cool, in addition to just making you know being so badass.
[53:10] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, yeah, perfectly put. Uh yeah, yeah.
[53:13] Joe Iconis: Elton was always my guy. People flip flip out when I say that, they're like, what? Over Billy Joel? I go, yes, over Billy Joel. I'm sorry. I like Billy Joel too, don't get me wrong, I do, but yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[53:22] Drew Gasparini: No, no, Sam. It's hard. It's hard for me too, because Billy Joel, like when you're from Long Island, Billy Joel is like the you know, he's the god. He's like even like, you know, even like the the shitty, like, you know, Republican, you know, relatives or people you had eyes doing.
[53:36] Joe Iconis: Yeah, exactly.
[53:36] Drew Gasparini: Like even they like Billy Joel. It's like the shittiest in Jersey who like who like Bruce Springsteen. It's like even Nay, like it's like he's a like a uh this unifying figure. And I think because of that, I was always like Billy Joel's okay, but I prefer Elton John.
[53:49] Joe Iconis: Right, right, right. I prefer this flamboyant Englishman. Uh Billy Joel really did lock down the shitty Republican relative demographic. That was really his thing.
[53:56] Drew Gasparini: I know.
[53:57] Joe Iconis: Um all right, now in a more uh in a more theater uh arena, who would win in this battle royale of dueling pianos? And I think there's kind of a clear yes here, but I've seen footage and they both rip it up. Tom Kitt and Jason Robert Brown.
[54:17] Joe Iconis: I think um I think that I think that Jason Robert Brown is the winner.
[54:29] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[54:29] Joe Iconis: Just in terms of chops. No, it's it all it all it comes down to like it comes down to internal stuff for me. So I think that Tom Kid has this like niceness. Like Tom Kidd has this kind of like midwestern vibe to me. And uh I think Jason Robert Brown has like a more sort of like angular, sharp uh sort of personality, and uh and I think if I was Jason Robert Brown, I would be so pissed that Tom Kid won a pulitzer, and I didn't, and so I'd be like, oh, I have to fucking kill him. And so that's why I think I could just put my I could put myself there. I like them both very much, and they're both great piano players. I could have just asked you these questions, and I feel like we would have gotten so much about you just with these questions, how you're answering them.
[55:12] Drew Gasparini: Uh the final one, this really lives in in the in the from the Joe Iconis playbook. Dr. Teeth versus Rolf the dog.
[55:22] Joe Iconis: Uh Rolf.
[55:24] Drew Gasparini: Rolf.
[55:25] Joe Iconis: I I mean love them both, but Rolf.
[55:26] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, Rolf was legit.
[55:28] Joe Iconis: He he he's a talk about a tender heart though. Like uh he really had this like tenderness because he was like the bar piano player of like, tell me your woes, my friend, and like would like tickle the keys in like this gentle underscore kind of way.
[55:42] Drew Gasparini: Yeah, yeah, no, I know.
[55:43] Joe Iconis: And he has that the thing that I love of like the you know, he likes super super cool, like like Rolf could be super, you know, very rock and roll, um really badass and going crazy, you know, his ears flapping, um, but then be like super tender and be, you know, like be your best friend. Both feel both intimidating and uh very warm and fuzzy. But there is no dispute here that Dr. Teeth would have better drugs. That's there's no dispute that Dr. Teeth would would have the goods.
[56:09] Drew Gasparini: That's what I'm thinking.
[56:10] Joe Iconis: No, for sure. All right, Joe, that is gonna be the last of the silly questions. The last thing I want to ask you before I say goodbye to you, first of all, thanks for taking an hour of your time to chat with me. I I haven't seen you since I think we bumped into each other at the Jagged Little Pill uh intermission for a brief second. That's probably the last time I saw you, so it's really good to see you.
[56:29] Joe Iconis: Yeah.
[56:30] Drew Gasparini: Uh I want to ask you one last thing. Right before the end of things. It was right before the end of the world for a minute. And how excited are you for things to come back? Are you just fucking like endlessly excited? Or do you have different thoughts now?
[56:41] Joe Iconis: No, I am so excited. I want I want it to come back. I fucking hate this. I think it's so shitty. I don't want to I don't want to zoom anymore. This zoom is great, but like I don't want to zoom. I don't want to be writing in a room. I don't I don't want to make theater for computers. I don't I don't want to do it. I want to be back in a fucking room making stuff. I want to be in a restaurant. I am so I am so ready for us to be back on the stage.
[57:05] Drew Gasparini: I'm with you there. Uh my last question for you, my friend, is what is something you want to see? And as someone who idolized you before I moved to New York and ended up getting to watch you do your thing, watch you make it to Broadway. We're all saying the big congrats and and knowing full well now that I've I'm starting to make my way in this little industry of ours as well. There are such a large young audience for musical theater, and they look to guys like you and me and this generation of writers. What is something that you want to say to the future generation of theater makers?
[57:41] Joe Iconis: I want to I would like I would like to say uh don't be don't be assholes.
[57:47] Drew Gasparini: Yeah.
[57:47] Joe Iconis: That's a good, you know, that's like a no brainer, but yeah. You can, you know, be like you'd be nice to people and and that's that that'll be really helpful to your lives. But I don't I don't know. I honestly actually the the I I definitely get asked a lot, like, what advice do you have for you know young people or people like sort of just starting out? And um and I always you know, I always say that that um that it's uh that it's a hard life, but it's a it's a really great life, you know. And I think that if you have an inkling to do it, you just like absolutely should. You know, I think that I I'd when I when I speak to like speak to young people and speak to people who think are you know thinking about maybe doing this.
Um I just feel like when I was young, I was just hit with so much negativity surrounding you know being in the arts or being you know being an artist in any way. And I just felt like I was constantly told by you know, like older white guys, the thing of like if you can do anything else, then you should do that and don't do this. And I just hate that. Like I love the idea of choosing to do this. And I love the idea of like, yeah, you can do a million things, but you choose to be in this life, and it's and it's a and it's a great life, and it actually, you know, it it helps a a great many people. Um yeah, and so I think that uh I would like to say like don't lose your your passion and your and your your your optimism and uh and don't be an eye roller, you know.
That's the only those are the only people I I unequivocally hate, the the eye rollers, the people who are over it. I just think like maybe you want to, you know, you'd want to be like crazy, you know, maybe you're you're furious and you're like Arabian lunatic in this business, but like that's okay, but don't be over it, you know. They I like these people who'd who and I see a lot of them, this sense of like everything is like oh, I can't believe that I have to do this concert, or I can't believe I have to do this. It's just like get get out, you know, like if you're in it, like ha hang on to that passion and that and that that love.
[59:40] Drew Gasparini: That's it, man. I couldn't have said it better myself. Stop being an eye roller, kids. That was beautiful from Joe Iconis. Joe, uh, thank you very much for your time and for having this little chat. I really, really enjoyed this talk with you. And I I look forward to the times that New York is up and running, and and we can kick it over a martini or something like that in the future, my friend.
[1:00:02] Joe Iconis: Let's do it for real.
[1:00:04] Drew Gasparini: Until next time, thanks, Joe Iconis.
[1:00:07] Drew Gasparini: Hey, you made it to the end of the episode. Cookies for everybody. Cookies and money and sex for everybody.
[1:00:14] Drew Gasparini: Anyway, isn't Joe great? God, didn't it make you miss theater? Just talking to the guy made me miss being in a theater.
[1:00:21] Drew Gasparini: Oi, soon, soon, soon. Hey, thanks so much for listening, everybody. Now we're talking as a proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network.
[1:00:29] Drew Gasparini: And you can find out more about me, this podcast, and the network if you go to BPN.fm slash now we're talking. You can find me on Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok.
[1:00:38] Drew Gasparini: Just look for Drew Gasparini. You'll see the goods. Special thanks to our guest, Mr. Joe Iconis.
[1:00:42] Drew Gasparini: I love you, dude. And thank you to all you listeners for tuning in. Make sure to subscribe and rate this podcast wherever you stream your podcast and keep tuning in for more amazing guests.
[1:00:54] Drew Gasparini: Next week we're gonna have somebody cool.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
