How do you take the "ick" out of the ask? Kel shares her process leading outbound fundraising efforts for non-profit theatres. Thank you for taking the time to listen to our chat with Kel Haney! If you are listening to this on Apple Podcast, we'd love it if you could share your love in a review!.. Read More
From the show: Page To Stage
About
How do you take the "ick" out of the ask? Kel shares her process leading outbound fundraising efforts for non-profit theatres.
Thank you for taking the time to listen to our chat with Kel Haney!
If you are listening to this on Apple Podcast, we'd love it if you could share your love in a review!
About Kel Haney:
Kel Haney, Senior Consultant at Donorly, is a NYC & Maine-based fundraising expert with 17 years of experience in the field, specializing in Outbound Fundraising.
She’s consulted with such organizations as MCC Theatre, Signature Theatre, Ensemble Studio Theatre, Manhattan Theatre Club, The O’Neill Theater Center, New York Theatre Workshop, Page 73 Productions, Marin Theatre Company, BroadwayUnlocked, The Glimmerglass Festival, American Composers Forum, and RIP Medical Debt.
Kel’s work boils down to “Taking the Ick out of the Ask” and shifting fundraising conversations from transactional encounters to relationship-building opportunities. She spent twenty years as a theatre director and her fundraising methodology is based on how she led a rehearsal room: focusing on what makes each of us unique and engaging. Over her fundraising career, Kel has helped non-profit organizations raise over $11M, primarily in donations under $2K. www.kelhaney.com
When not working, Kel's seeking out all kinds of artistic experiences, taking nature walks with her rescue pup, practicing yoga, playing extremely intricate board games, and attempting to recreate the fabulous meals she & her husband (actor Michael Grew) have enjoyed on their various travels.
Resources from this episode:
Come say hi to us!
Facebook: @PageToStagePodcast @BroadwayPodcastNetwork
Instagram: @PageToStagePodcast @TheMaryDina @BrianSedita @BroadwayPodcastNetwork
Twitter: @TheMaryDina @BwayPodNetwork
Youtube: @PageToStagePodcast @BroadwayPodcastNetwork
#PageToStagePodcast
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Brian Sedita: Hey everyone, welcome to Page to Stage. A conversation with theater makers. We're your hosts. That's Brian. And that's Mary. Join us as we focus the spotlight back on the theater maker to uncover their process. We speak with folks in the industry that often aren't heard from, such as stage managers, producers, crew members, marketing professionals. And everything in between. We hope you enjoy this episode.
[0:26] Kel Haney: Hi, my name is Kel Haney. I'm an outbound fundraising expert. I'm also a senior fundraising consultant at Donorly. Welcome. When Brian had messaged me about this interview, I was really excited because I felt like this really like threw me back to a couple years ago, really. It wasn't even that long ago. So I worked in development for a nonprofit theater, like 90 miles outside of, not even 90 miles outside of New York. I haven't thought about it obviously since I've transitioned into marketing, which is ironic, because just before we started recording, we were talking about the connection between those two departments. But yeah, I mean it's fascinating. And now like on the producing side of things commercially, like my brain is just constantly going. So I'm super excited to just like dive in with you on these topics. It's great.
[1:14] Brian Sedita: And the way that we were introduced was um one of my best friends, friend of the pod, Juliana Carr, actually works in one of your fundraising call center rooms at MCC. And I've actually, you know, heard a lot about what you guys do in the room, and I'm like, that's just so interesting. And like, who's leading these efforts? And so Juliana graciously made the introduction. And so I'm really thrilled to be able to speak with you. She's spoken very highly about like your creative passion for this type of work, which I think is really exciting for both of us to be able to share with our listeners.
[1:49] Kel Haney: That's awesome, Brian. Thank you. I really appreciate your curiosity about what we're up to. So I'm excited to dive in.
[1:57] Brian Sedita: Yeah. So, you know, I was going through your website a ton, which all of our listeners should. I actually want to read your methodology just straight from the website, just to give our listeners a little context. So this is in the words of Kel. After spending 20 years as a theater director, I've developed a fundraising methodology that's based on how I led a rehearsal room, focusing on what makes each of us unique and engaging. I empower artists, administrators, board members with the knowledge that they already possess the most critical tools needed to be skilled fundraisers: empathy, candor, vulnerability, enthusiasm, and storytelling. So I'm so curious, how did you find yourself making the shift into fundraising for theaters?
[2:42] Kel Haney: Sure, that's a great question. And um thank you for sharing my methodology. I think that's the first time I've ever had anyone read it back to me. I will take it and run, Brian. So thank you. I just think it was so well written, of course, but it just tells so much about the care that you have, and that I think we'll be able to get through our conversation with you. So that's what I'm interested in really diving into, that human aspect, because fundraising could happen anywhere for anything, but I think there's something special, and I think for theater people, there's got to be something a little more special for fundraising for something you love so passionately.
[3:21] Brian Sedita: Yeah, yeah, it's a great question. So the way I got into it is actually in my early 20s I was, as you read, I was a theater director for 20 years and in my early 20s, I needed some kind of quote unquote, I would call at the time a survival job. So I happened to be interning at one of the major not-for-profits in New York City and loving it. I was supposed to be there for a three-month stint, and then I read all the plays happening in the next season. And I read this one play and I thought it should win the Pulitzer and it should move to Broadway. And I couldn't imagine going to New York, leaving New York while this play was going on. And this dates me, but it was Doubt. It was John Patrick Shanley's Doubt.
So it was hyper formative for me in terms of my career as a director. And what I didn't realize I started to do was to build this career as a fundraiser. So I needed some sort of survival job to support my directing career. So I started to fundraise over the phone for this not-for-profit, and I got really good really fast. And it really was a great supplemental income as I was developing my directing career.
[4:24] Kel Haney: So as I got to the point of being the associate on Broadway, I was able to, when I wasn't in rehearsal, to be fundraising over the phone. And it just was this marriage of some of my favorite things. I've always loved to connect with people. I've always loved to be on the phone. I've always loved to talk to people. And so I was just connecting with people over my favorite thing, which was new plays. And so I got to just talk about that. And that led to bringing in a lot of income. I think I probably raised seven million dollars, something like that over eight years myself, mostly in gifts of under 2500. And I was just really good and I really loved it. So I got burned out from doing that. So I started just really focusing on my directing career.
But I had all of these colleagues in the industry who knew how skilled I was at this. So people started to come out of the woodwork who were now at different other organizations. And um, I did a short stint at New York Theater Workshop, and that led to working at MCC Theater. I thought I was going to be there for two months, setting up their fundraising room, which is where I know Juliana from, Brian. And um that was over seven and a half years ago. So I thought before the pandemic, I had this accidental parallel career. So I thought I was going to be an artistic director and I was going to use all of these fundraising skills specifically towards being an artistic director. And I got really close.
I got really close actually to being the artistic director of Perseverance Theater in Alaska right before the pandemic started. So my husband and I had, who's an actor, Michael Grew. We had some really big conversations about what our life would be like if I went and we went together to Alaska for a few years. So this was all fall of 2019. Um and then the pandemic hit, and obviously everybody's lives changed and um was no longer in the rehearsal room. And I had the opportunity um with my colleague um at Donorly, Sandra Davis, to work with Sandra with some of their clients. She was really smart about the pivot really quickly and said, you know, we have a bunch of research clients, and I think what you do in terms of this, what I now call outbound fundraising, but this fundraising predominantly through phone calls and also through some personal emails and sometimes every once in a while a good old-fashioned letter, believe it or not.
She said, I feel like this is going to go on longer than anyone will expect. So I started to work for her and also keep working at MCC. So I found myself as a full-time fundraising consultant, just kind of during the pandemic as a band-aid, so to speak. But I ended up really loving it. And we could do a whole other podcast when I talk where I talk about what it was about an artist being an artist and being a theater director, that I started to feel like that wasn't feeling right to me anymore. And this was feeling really right. So I have started to build my own brand as this outbound fundraising consultant having conversations with people about how to ask. Like honestly, at the beginning and end of the day, that's really what it comes down to. And I'm in early stages of writing a book that I'm tentatively titling Taking the Ick out of the Ask. Uh so I love talking about all of this.
[7:32] Mary Dina: There's so many parallels in my brain that are just running as you're talking right now. So I really love that you one, you know, came as a director into this area, whether well, you know, stumbling or on purpose, and made that connection because when I came into the nonprofit fundraising, I came in as an intern, but I really didn't know what I wanted to do. I knew that I wanted to work in the admin office, but I didn't know like what was the next step. And so my grad school mentor basically was like, I really wish I worked in development because I think that is a really, that is a very specific skill set that you probably won't get anywhere else, and once you have it, it's invaluable, right?
Like it sounded by it is transferable in ways that you can't even imagine right now, but also like it's just going to be really good for you. So I just took the leap and kind of just snowballed from there. But what's fascinating is that I found it really hard to grasp the concept of like making the ask. And I didn't come from at one point I wanted to be a director, but I didn't really pursue that too much, and then I was not an actor, so I really truly came from like the admin management side of things. So I didn't have that creative mindset, I guess, that was kind of putting those pieces together of looking at these donors and prospective donors as just people. And what I find exciting, I don't know if you have made this connection either of as a director, you're pitching also like you, right?
You're putting together like what the vision looks like for the show and then you're sharing it with so many different groups of people. And I that's very similar to what people in development do. They're putting together this picture that they're painting for their prospective investors and um and donors. And so I don't know if you've made that connection or if you found that kind of like parallel between the two.
[9:26] Kel Haney: Yeah, I absolutely have, Mary. I think that, you know, for me when I was a theater director, you know, I always thought about it was my job to be the connective tissue between, you know, the text itself, between the aesthetic and then also between and with text I also say like text and the actors and also like the design components and then the third point of the triangle I always thought of as the audience and that I got to exist in this ephemeral space in between. And so yeah, as a director one is always thinking trying to watch it with a fresh eye and think about okay what is the audience getting and you're always managing and creating expectation. So something I really love about fundraising, it's similar to what you're saying.
I mean the way I train people to fundraise is actually helping them build an arc of their conversation, so similar to a story arc. And um there's room for tributaries like there's room for, oh who knew without, you know, I also Mary, we could do it right now and we could talk about Pennsylvania. I'm from Westchester, Pennsylvania like we could go down that rabbit hole if we wanted to. Um, but if we were at a fundraising conversation, I would know what was my next tent pole and where I was headed next in terms of our conversation. So, you know, I really do think that it's all about relationship building and I want to be really clear in terms of the kind of fundraising that I'm looking to create and the way I want to shift the world of philanthropy is to a place that's really about building community.
And I trust that if we're trying to one-on-one build community that um we go ahead and from there, um it, you know, the money follows. It doesn't have to be about the numerical amount. It doesn't have to be about a transaction, transactional moment. It can be about a building moment.
[11:12] Mary Dina: Actually, just to piggyback off of that, I think, yeah, even if there is no transaction that's being had, just getting the name out there is some sort of marketing and maybe building some sort of collective base for a theater regardless. Just from a process standpoint, how do you normally get your clients and how do people, I know you said a lot of word of mouth, but once you do, um, once you are hired by a theater company to come in and help with their fundraising efforts, what are the strategies that you're, you know, are you coming up with the strategies for raising the money with them? Are you in budget conversations about how much is needed to be fundraised? You know, can we can you give us the back end of those workings?
[11:53] Kel Haney: Um, yes, to everything that you just said, Brian. I mean, to me, yes, figuring out numbers. I love playing with numbers and knowing what numbers are. And as a fundraising consultant, I mean, that's what we need first and foremost is to know again, what's the expectation of our client? And so, you know, knowing as much as we can about the financials of the last few seasons are super helpful and also going ahead and working to project what this next season can look like and how we can be helpful and you know, really setting everybody up for success and in a way that's pragmatic as well. Um, and I really, um, in terms of my specific, more niche work in terms of working specifically with training fundraisers and setting up this outbound fundraising type circumstance.
Um, we do do it as you alluded to with Juliana. Um, do it over Zoom at this point. Um, it was something that we started early in shutdown and actually works really well. So I will sometimes have five or six different fundraising rooms happening within the day. Um, got somebody else managing it, either one of my amazing colleagues at Donorly or somebody who's internal, usually in the development department, sometimes in marketing or audience services, uh, with the particular not-for-profit. So I hop back and forth between all these rooms all day.
[13:10] Kel Haney: Um, but to your point, so just to paint that picture, because when Juliana first told me she was doing this, I didn't understand. I'm like, oh, you just get a list of names and numbers and you're calling them, right? And she's like, no, no, no, we're in it, we're in a room. I'm like, what do you mean a room on Zoom? Can you just paint that picture for everybody?
[13:44] Kel Haney: Um, got a little tricky in that usually it was like taking over somebody else's desk, um, which obviously in the pandemic is weird and like not sanitary, and I don't think we're going back to that in that same way. So it just came out of immediately. We did have the MCC fundraising room up and running, um, like as shutdown started. So we only took two weeks off, if you can believe it. We started making those phone calls very, very early. Um, those phone first phone calls were very vulnerable and kind of scary, just as we all didn't know what was happening, but we wanted to reach out to our community. We wanted to reach out in to start with our very close um circle of donors that were already associated with the organization.
So I've just like, how can we do that? And what can we do? That's the closest proximate, um, you know, closest in proximity to what we had been doing before the pandemic. So we just all hopped on Zoom. So there's a way to set it up so that like they're using their cell phones, they're using their cell phones with the number of the organization. There's different programs that do that work. Um, but we can all listen to each other and obviously push mute if it's getting too crazy to hear everybody at once, but they learn from each other. Like the fundraisers learn from each other. And I really do subscribe to the tide rising all ships. And so it's really great that they can all be there to support each other.
And when things go really great, we can all celebrate together. And if somebody has a really challenging phone call, there's people right there to be able to talk about it. So we actually do have a community. We have this online community, and particularly in the middle of shutdown, that was like the closest for some of these, you know, fundraisers I work with, like they might have lived at home. They might not have even seen anybody else. Um and so now it still works great. I've got people who are going on tour and they're still doing this for a couple of hours a day while they're on tour, or they're, you know, working in with the rest of their schedule and just the idea of asking people, we usually only do two to three hour shifts at a time, anything else, and it starts to get um pretty intensive in terms of like it's a lot in terms of your emotional capacity.
Um, you know, it's like performing a show, you know, like just kind of having to be on for that long. Um, that you can only sustain that for so long. So I love that for equitable reasons, people can do this work for a very short amount of time during the day and that it doesn't have to have travel time and that you know it can fit into everything else that's going on from them.
[16:15] Brian Sedita: Do you think that this method could work well for like sales? So like a sales um, a sales office or a sales team for selling tickets, perhaps like the the face to face. Do you think that that does the same thing if there's like an outbound call campaign? Or do you think it really works because it's like a more it's a high touch, well, a higher touch situation with with current donors?
[16:38] Kel Haney: Great question. I think that if there is a connective, if there's a connection between the person who's fundraising or who's selling with what they're, you know, what they're raising money for or what they're quote unquote selling, I think it could work. I could it definitely can work for tickets. I mean, it could work for anything. I mean, a lot of the larger not for profits with which I work, while the focus is on potentially bringing people in as donors, if they're not in a financial place or they're not interested in getting involved on that level, but then the next part of the conversation is at the end of the day, we just want you part of our community and we want you seeing the work and here's the work that's coming up.
I mean, that's part of the conversation starts from a place of talking about the work. It doesn't start from a place of hopping right into a fundraising conversation. It starts from a place of like what's our what's what's our connection to each other and what's the thing that we're both passionate about. And I like that it almost feels like a chance encounter. You know, it's like that feeling of sitting, you know, before a show starts or at intermission, and you start up a conversation with the person to your left or your right, or you're on the subway and somebody sees your playbill, or you see somebody else's playbill and you end up in this random conversation.
[17:50] Kel Haney: So I only hire um, I really only hire individuals who are artists or who are art administrators. You know, we want to start from a place that there's already an authentic passion about the work, and if there's also working knowledge about the organization, even better. If there's not, like a lot of the training involves um reading all of the scripts and you know, watching a lot of footage from things that have happened in the past and interviews with the creatives and you know, really trying to understand the work and finding your own in. So, for instance, for actors, as if they were auditioning for these, you know, for a part in one of these plays of like what's your particular in? What are you passionate about so you can lead with that as part of the conversation?
So we're not cold calling anybody. These are all people who already have a connection to the organization. They might not know that. Like we might have to start from a place of saying, you came to see the show six months ago, probably don't even remember it. But if you do, we love that you were here and here's what it was about. And sometimes it's like, what was it called? What what did I see again? And finding out like how to jog people's memories. Um, but that starts a really great conversation in that way.
[19:00] Brian Sedita: Do you mind? I just am really since we're on the topic of like the actual phone calls. I would love if we could try to break down what that like how you if it's a script and how that script is either outlined or then how is it like discussed among the like the people that you're hiring? Um so we could start there and maybe kind of deconstruct like how you go about building out. Is it a script? I guess we should start there. Is it a script that you're building out?
[19:27] Kel Haney: It's not actually a script. Um, I do have like some training deliverables now that I have official clients, that feels a little more formalized and necessary. But when I first started training people how to do this, it was just me sitting in a room with whomever I was training and kind of walking them through how I do this. So I have I have formalized this methodology as I have more formalized, you know, my role in all of this. Um, so it's not a script, but it is this idea of kind of crafting out the arc of the call. So I I have other podcasts where I've gone really deep into it. So I'll try to keep it like very on the surface, but I have four tent poles. The first is the opening event, and that's just the first 15 seconds of the call are the most crucial.
And I encourage like having being very clear right off the bat of who you are, where you're calling from, why you're calling, and what's the connection that this audience member already has to the organization, and then saying, I think you saw you know this show last spring, just wanted to see what you thought of it and what brought you in in the first place. And then that goes into the second tent pole, which is the main event, and that's sharing what's going on at the organization right now or upcoming. So this is a great moment right now to say, love that you came to see this musical we produced last year. This year we actually are gonna start our season with a new musical. We just started uh we just started yesterday rehearsals.
I'm thinking specifically of MCC Theater and Only Gold, which just started rehearsals yesterday, and there was lots of really great press that you know, just today um and yesterday we started to use on the phone. So talking about the upcoming season, and then through that, another thing that is going on right now is that we are on a fundraiser. And so there's a way to just talk about the fundraiser and talk about the need to raise money as just another item that's happening at this organization. So without having to, you know, do some kind of hard pivot into now. Here's the icky moment we talk about fundraising. It's like, no, yes, we need to raise money in the same way that we can talk about the fact that we've got Kate Nash and Andy Plankenbueller at the theater right now. Like we can talk about all those things in the same conversation.
[21:31] Kel Haney: So then the third tent pole is the actual ask. And so this is where, to your point, Brian, about understanding the budget, understanding numbers. Um, I'm really clear with these fundraising rooms. We have goals. We have goals for the year, which I break down to goals for particular months. August is traditionally a slower month. Um, but so we have slightly lower goals for August. Um, but here's our goal for the month. Here's our how far away we are from the week, and then kind of putting out our pitch. And so I always encourage, and again, we can talk, we could break this down further if you too want, we don't need to, but um, really specific about the action and this call to action is a specific numerical amount.
And we're gonna set that in a place that might feel I like to use the phrase shoot for the moon. It might feel a little high. If I'm always looking for, I do a lot of yoga in my own life, and so I'm looking for a good stretch versus a bad stretch, both for the person who's fundraising and also for the person that we're reaching out to. So, what feels like a good stretch to them versus a bad stretch? And you don't know unless you go ahead and shoot for the moon and make the ask and say, you know, is a $1,500 gift over the year, which includes tickets, is that within the realm of possibility? And then you hear what I just did as hold for the silence. That's like the biggest goal. That's the biggest gift, the biggest like tip I can offer you is hold for the silence.
Um, so that's that's the third tent pole. And then the fourth is is you know, the wrapping up. And so that is obviously if this person says yes to a gift, you're getting all of the pertinent information. But regardless, we're setting up the next contact point. So whether this person is donating $5,000 to the theater who says, no way, I don't want to talk to you. I can't believe you're calling me. Uh, we're gonna set up like what's the next point of contact because the whole idea is that I want this moment of um this phone call to be really about building out this relationship as opposed to just being about the moment. So it's not like great, you said you do this, thanks. Bye. It's like, I'm so glad you're doing this gift.
We're so excited to have you at the theater. Here's what the next steps are. And only gold, for instance, you know, starts October 2nd. So, you know, we'll we'll reach back out closer to that date and set up date tickets for you or however that works.
[23:46] Brian Sedita: I think what's so interesting is that in today's world, so many people have so many tools to raise money now. Like you have online fundraisers, there's you know, so many campaigns that people have to, you know, crowdfund, there's phone banking. What do you only employ the phone banking technique in your work?
[24:07] Kel Haney: Great question. And I'd love to talk about that a little bit more, like why I think it particularly works for theater. I can get into that too. Um, but to first answer your question, um, yes, it's predominantly over the phone. There's also emails. Um, if we don't have somebody's phone number, uh, we will reach out and write them a personalized email. And so this is like, yes, there's particular text and particular messaging, but the idea is that this should feel a little different than the mass emails that they're getting from the theater. Obviously, it's coming specifically from the outbound fundraising campaign. So it's a different email address, but also it's a more personalized message of, you know, reaching out to you because saw that you saw Space Dogs with us.
Um and we didn't have a phone number for you, but we're really excited about only gold, and we'd love for you to come in and see it. And um it's more specific than that. Um, but the reason this is gonna sound really wild. And if you'd asked me when I started doing this almost 20 years ago, if we would still be using the phone to fundraise 20 years from now, I would have said no way. I really did not predict we'd still be here. But here's where why it works. You ready? So it works, I really believe, because these calls are intimate, they're immediate, which is just like theater, and also just like theater, it's slightly inconvenient and maybe even seen as a little archaic. You know, that idea of sitting in a theater, turning off your cell phone, sitting around strangers, particularly in whatever stage we are of this pandemic right now.
Uh, so it's it's a really it's really fascinating that that it still works. Um, but people really do want to connect one-on-one. Um, and voicemails, believe it or not, people do listen to their voicemails. And if the voicemails have a very specific directive, people respond. They either call us back or they get on the internet and they take and they sign up and they donate on them on their own.
[26:07] Brian Sedita: My experience with like an annual fund campaign, let's say, right? So is you I mean, the theater that I worked at primarily relied on the letters and mailing out like a mailing campaign. And half, you know, we would we would segment segment it where we, you know, pars partial, you know, a percentage of whatever would be, you know, done through like a system where it's more automatic, and that maybe the lower level donors or people who have only donated once and it may have been like over a couple of years ago. Um, and then obviously the people who are more um heavily integrated with the community or the organization would get more of like a personalized letter, but it was still really grounded in letters.
And at the time it was because, oh, that's what this community is is used to. That's with the this like this actual like community of people who live around this theater. That's what that's what they do on a daily basis still. They're still like, you know, sending snail mail. So I'm wondering, is there an argument to be made for knowing the audience? And is there an audience that would still be that might not work for phones, or do you really believe that like you kind of have to like steer them in the direction a little bit to see like what really does work?
[27:22] Kel Haney: Such a good question. Um, I really, and it's funny, I was in the conversation with a colleague at Donorly earlier today, who's um younger than me, who's you know, in her mid-20s, who really is having some resistance to making these calls.
[27:37] Kel Haney: Um, in her case, it's about thank you calls, um, and saying, I don't think everybody wants to get these calls. And what I say is I don't think it's about whether somebody thinks they want this. It's about if they get a phone call from someone who is enthusiastic, who's charming, who's really knowledgeable, who's passionate. We all want to connect in that way, and we all want to connect in that way with people who have similar interests that we have. I can't tell you how many times over the phone we hear, I never take quote unquote calls like this. I never talk to anybody on the phone for this long. And it's like, well, that's because the people that I work with are really, really good at this and they're really, really good because they're very smart, artistic, entrepreneurial minded humans who genuinely want to connect.
And that is about all of those qualities, Brian, that you read earlier about candor and um curiosity and creativity and vulnerability and having the, you know, ability to storytell. Like that's all part of what makes this work work so well. So I really think Mary, if anybody who loves theater gets a call from someone who has been really well trained, who really genuinely loves what they do, the conversation is there. And I think that goes across demographics. I mean, obviously it's harder to get people who are, you know, millennials and younger to pick up the phone. I mean, the contact rate is lower, but it's really successful when we do get them on the phone. Um, and also to your point about the letter campaign, um, I find that this outbound, what I call outbound fundraising works best when it really works um in cadence with the rest of the communication at the organization.
So I'm not saying that this is in place of uh, you know, end of the letter appeal, uh, end of the year, pardon me, end of the year appeal. I don't, I'm not saying that this is taking the place of that, but this works in tandem with that. So if we know that first week in December, that letter campaign is going to hit, we could start those phone calls a week later and start from a place of I know you just got a letter in the mail about our year end campaign. We're actually 20,000 away from our goal. So we'd love to talk to you. But also first and foremost, how's the season going? I see that you had to switch your tickets for the last show. Did that work okay? Um, I love you get the gold star. You've seen all three shows we've done so far.
Which was your favorite? I really liked this particular show personally, you know, so it can all work together. I think a lot of our conversations that we have on the podcast can be translatable to so many people, regardless of industry, regardless of what you do in the theater or what your interest is in the theater. And so I want to ask the methodology that you use and the way that you approach these conversations. Do you have any piece of advice for just anybody in the theater industry or in any industry about making these big asks in their life for things that will help them advance their career or help them in any other way get what they need?
[30:41] Kel Haney: 100%. I love that question. Um, I always love thinking about networking. I love personal development. I think that's all a larger part of what I do and what I will continue to build as I continue to forge ahead with this new career path for myself. Um, so yeah, I think that it's really about leading with vulnerability. And that's really hard. And knowing that fine line about like this is not about asking someone else to take on our own vulnerability or to fix that, but to really lead from a place of I'm passionate about whatever that is. So whether that's somebody who's, you know, talking to a potential new agent, you know, it's like we all always want to do our homework. We want to be specific about what our ask is and really go into any conversation, knowing what that ask is.
The other homework I really suggest that we do is that other person, getting to know them as human beings. For me, my favorite networking book is Keith Farazzi's Never Eat Alone. Title's a little harsh. Don't have to go that far. Totally feel free to eat meals by yourself. But I really like that networking book because it's about um connecting with people as human beings first and foremost and also not looking for any kind of quid pro quo um of uh yeah I'm going to ask this of someone and then they're going to offer something back. Like how to always lead with generosity and to know that we all have something to give to everyone with whom we're speaking. So that idea of what can I offer to this individual and also how can I be specific about what I'm asking from them.
And they don't owe you anything. They net none of these people whether it's a phone call or whether that's talking to an agent or that's you know as when I was a director, you know, having very intimate, very vulnerable conversations with playwrights, with producers all the time with actors, with designers, you know, it's like just trying to truly be an active listener in every moment and really trying to get to know this person as a human being and being like I'm just building relationships in a larger sense. So if this particular opportunity works out amazing but hopefully life is long and hopefully careers are long and it's about so much more than what happens in this particular moment this particular fundraising call, this particular coffee date it's so much bigger than that.
[33:01] Kel Haney: I want to call back to before we were speaking I guess before we were recording, you mentioned that you're interested and fascinated at like the intersection of what you do and the marketing press aspect of theater. So if you wouldn't mind expanding on that, and if you've, you know, what what kind of juices have been flowing when it comes to those those thoughts.
[33:24] Kel Haney: So I actually think that this outbound, well, you know, just talking really specifically about not nonprofit theater for a moment. I think that this outbound fundraising works best when there is some real communication between the development department, the marketing department, and the audience services departments around these communications. Okay. And so part of that is because I like to offer, I like I think I already said this, but I like to offer um, you know, yes, what I do is focused on fundraising, but it's truly focused even larger on community building. So if we're making a fundraising ask, we're seeing if this single ticket buyer is interested in becoming a $1,500 patron, obviously that's not for everybody.
But since we start the conversation by starting up talking about the work and the work that's coming up, um, I get really excited about the idea of keeping these people at the theater. And ultimately, and at the end of the day, we just, I just want them here. I just want them part of the community. And again, that good stretch. I want them to stretch a little bit, but not too much that that like then feels uncomfortable to them or like sours the relationship at all. I want this to really be that not only are they donating, but they're there at the shows. And if they can't donate, no sweat, go ahead and come on board and come see the shows and really explaining why having um somebody, you know, committed to a subscription, again, something that feels a little antiquated in our 2022 lives, but that really is terms of the bottom line for the theater so crucial.
And I really do feel like when an audience member is with a theater for the season as a subscriber, it's like going to an art museum, right? It's like there's that one exhibit, you're you're that gets you in the door. There's, you know, an artist that you know you like and you think you'll like, and then you're surprised that you like something that you didn't even know existed. Maybe that exhibit you came in for was actually your least favorite thing and you had this other beautiful surprise. So I think if we really continue to encourage um audience members to sign up for a season, again, I get it. It's like antiquated to say these things. I feel a little funny saying it out loud. But I do feel that it sets them up to like truly have a deeper investment with the organization and also to see see theater and be inspired by theater that they may not have got gone to see or bought a single ticket to otherwise.
[35:48] Kel Haney: So that's the marketing section. Like that's the marketing, the getting into the marketing. We can continue there. Go for it, Mary.
[35:55] Mary Dina: You've said like the it feels a little strange to keep pushing like a subscription package, but I actually think okay, so pre-pandemic, yes, I would have thought we're coming out of this age of subscription tickets and packages for theaters. But I mean, we saw such a surge of people uh all different companies, not even just theater companies selling subscription packages where you would buy and you would get a box in the mail. Like I have one for my dogs that comes in every month, right? So I feel like the pandemic kind of like helped re reignite that idea of like subscriptions. And yeah, I maybe people don't necessarily make the connection of like a of a box of treats and toys for your dog to uh, you know, a season of tickets to see a show.
They I don't know if they'll put the pieces together, but I don't know. I'd be curious to see like how over the next couple of years, subscription packages with theaters in New York and even in regional theaters, how that works for people and if if it they're really continuing to see this like exit, if you will, of subscription tickets and an increase in single tickets. I don't know. I think that if there are individuals who are having individual conversations, it can really continue. Do you know what I mean? But it and I'll I'll be honest, like it's it's it's not the cheapest, it's not the cheapest option. It's definitely expensive. I mean, I only agree to do this work if these outbound fundraisers, these artists, these part-time um employees of an organization are being commissioned or bonused for their work.
I really believe in the equitability of the work and how challenging this work is, and that people should be compensated fairly for what for the work that they're doing. They're developing a very specialized skill that almost no one else can do, that almost no one else wants to do, that's also very valuable and important to the organization. So it's most frequent for the return on investment to be well over 200% in terms of the investment from the organization uh for doing this work. But it is much more expensive than uh letter mail. It's much more expensive, obviously, than social media, but it really I have seen that the return on investment is very, very strong.
[38:08] Kel Haney: So that being said, Mary, I love your analogy of of you know the subscriptions in the mail. And what I that I that I had never made that connection myself before. So you've totally blown my mind in an amazing way with that thought. I love it. And I do think they're connected because I think it's about um feel again, I feel a little weird saying this, but I think it's about brand loyalty, but like the developing a brand loyalty, and how can subscribe how can theaters to continue to develop brand loyalty. And that also goes with convening, convenience. Like there's something fun for you about getting that box and not knowing exactly what it is in the mail for your dogs every month, but you know it's coming, and like you've already made the financial commitment, you've already decided it's happening, and you don't know exactly what's gonna be in there, but you trust this company, so you're gonna see where it takes you.
You're gonna see what that journey is of you opening that box and going on that journey, similar to showing up at the theater and to be like, I don't know exactly what this is, but I really love this theater company. And yeah, sometimes the boxes are a little more not your cup of tea as like a theater, you know, a piece isn't necessarily totally up your alley, but it's like fun to see what happens, and it really is about brand loyalty, I think.
[39:24] Mary Dina: Yeah, and I think you go one step further from a marketing perspective. So now, like my marketing brain's sparking right now. So I think what is actually gives theater a leg up in compar, you know, comparing to like the dog box analogy is that your audience has to go to your place, right? So they're walking into your surrounding, and where they will be. I mean, I hate to use this word, but they they will be touched many different times, right? So you go to like the bar, you go to the merch stand, you go to customer service. If you have a question, you go to a coat rack. If there's a restaurant nearby or even attached to a theater, they're spending time in that place. So not only are they in your environment where they're more likely to get even like a deeper connection to the establishment, to the people, to the community.
They're also, you know, best case scenario is that there's the artistic director, the director of development, the um director of education, someone up there who is mingling, who is talking to these people who and not even director level, honestly, it could be anyone in the industry, anyone in the organization yeah just talking to them and that like really helps your case even more when you do get on the phone with them later down the line and because something that I wrote as you were talking about you were saying um uh outbound calls don't necessarily replace end of year mail campaigns um I think that it's so similar to a marketing strategy of of um of like the the multiple touch points so you want to hit them multiple different times in multiple different ways so it doesn't just take one email that sells them on something it won't take one phone call it's totally it's accompanied by like a bunch of different things being at the theater experiencing all of those senses is one of them as well so I just oh my yep I agree to speak yes you're speaking my language in all of the ways Mary and yeah it's just another one of those touch points and frequently sometimes these calls are the only other than you know going to the merch or going to the box office or you know this is this is the most in-depth conversation they have from anybody at the theater and so it's really important to me that all of those individuals are really knowledgeable and really passionate and really warm and really welcoming always like that's truly what we're always leading with.
[41:47] Kel Haney: I mean it's like the antithesis and I don't know if you two hopefully when you were in school they did not make you read Glenn Gary, Glenn Ross, the David Mamet play like the coffee is for closers. So glad you all don't know any of this anymore thank goodness. But you know, they made it into a movie with Alec Baldwin, and it's just like an you know, an angry white guy yelling at a bunch of even older white guys, like coffee is for closers, always be closing. So, what I do is the antithesis of that, and instead of ABC always be closing, I say always be candid. So it's like you're always leading from a place that's as honest and open and curious as possible. So that's that's super important. The other thing that's really great in terms of marketing with these phone calls is that we get to really beta test messaging and even beta test programming because it's just one on one interaction.
It's really like a grassroots circumstance. We can say, we're trying out this new program. I mean, who knows? What do you think? And so we can really be the testing ground without having to go really public of this is what's going to go on our social media, or this is what's on the website, or this is the mass email, or this is the letter campaign. We can play with that messaging over the phone in a different type of way. Um, we can also, which I really love, is I know we're all always, you know, so tied to the press release and what information can we share in what moment. And what I love about this is that usually the fundraisers know what that next season is going to be, even if it isn't announced yet.
So they can give some little hints that don't give anything away that they can say, you know, we've got a Tony award-winning um director connected with a Grammy nominated, you know, musician for this next piece, or we're gonna bring back someone who's worked with us in the past couple of years. Like we can hint at things without giving any information really away, but that makes the person feel like they know a little bit more so we can get ahead in terms of our um ticket sales, or you know, most mostly in my case, the development work, like in terms of how much money we're raising for the theater, we can get ahead of that even without having all of that press release information yet.
[43:58] Mary Dina: How sorry, real quick, how long are the phone calls usually lasting?
[44:03] Kel Haney: Oh my gosh, it could be anything. Because it feels like, I mean, just from what you were saying, I'm I'm sure it might not be like all at once, but it just feels like a lot of information you're like sharing and you're having this great conversation. And that's just one side of it, right? That's just like your team side of the conversation. Who knows what's being discussed from you know, on the other on the other end of the line. I mean, it varies. I have seen, I've seen, you know, major donations come in from a 60 second phone call of like, yes, I'd actually, I saw this in the program. I want to do this. How much is it? Or wait, you can get me in to see that show next week. Excellent. Like, happy to go ahead and make a $1,500 donation right now.
So I've seen it be as quick as a minute, honestly, or you know, it can be lengthier. It's it really depends on what that person wants, how that person wants to engage. And again, that's where the act of listening comes into play of like, how does this person want to engage with me? Um, there is, you are really right, what you're um what you're experiencing in terms of feeling like it's really kind of uh front, there's a lot of front footed um nature to what this is, and also like a lot of like information right at the get go. And I design it like that specifically, so that there's no kind of apprehension from the person that we're calling of like, who is this calling me? Like, because I mean, think about it.
We get all these robocalls for crying out loud. Do you know what I mean? It's like, oh wait, you're an actual person. Oh, wait, you actually know about this organization. You don't sound like a scammer. Like, this sounds like I'm actually talking to somebody who's associated with the theater. So we have to do work, and that's why that first 15 seconds of the call is so so important, is because we've got to like break through all of somebody's preconceived notions about being being caught on the phone immediately. So yeah, there's a lot of information. We don't expect that people will retain that as soon as we put that out there. It's like we'll circle back and share that information as that phone call unfolds a bit more.
So it could be anything. I mean I do encourage if there's somebody who really wants to talk and it's time to move on to say, you know, it's been so great to talk to you Cheryl, but I do want to you know make some more calls. I'm only making these calls for another half an hour. I really do have to go, but I am excited you're seeing the shows. So they you know do have some really graceful and empathetic ways to end calls if somebody is just really excited to talk to them. But it runs the gamut I don't time them. I have no idea Mary like I think probably most calls are about four or five minutes probably.
[46:32] Mary Dina: Is there one specific experience that you've had either working with colleagues, working directly with theater patrons in some way that you'd like to share that was super memorable that touched you in any way that kind of like leads back to that original like why you do this?
[46:49] Kel Haney: Yes I love that question. I do. So when I was working it was Manhattan Theater Club was that first organization where I was making these calls for um in my early 20s and David Lindsay-Abaire had written this play called Rabbit Hole and um he had written that um inspired by at Juilliard apparently Marsha Norman had said right about the thing that scares you the most so he wrote about like this idea that there'd been death of a child. And so it was Cynthia Nixon and John Slattery played the parents. The child had already passed away at the top of show. And Tyne Daly played a grant played hit the grandmother. And there was the scene where Tyne Daly, I'm going this, I promise this will tie back into an audience member's experience.
But Tyne Daly was folding the deceased young boy's clothes and talking about her own son who had died of an overdose as an adult and talking about grief and how grief doesn't ever go away. It just changes and morphs. So I happened to, you know, 25 year old call Mr. Smith who saw Rabbit Hole and said, you know, hi, Mr. Smith, my name's Kel. I'm calling you from Manhattan Theater Club. I know you just came to see Rabbit Hole. Um, and I wanted to see what you thought of the show and what brought you in in the first place. Turns out that Mr. Smith's wife had passed away, partner had passed away within the last six months, and they had always gone to the theater together. And this was the first time he had been back without her, and he had no idea what the play was about.
And so it's it started and it was really vulnerable and impactful on him. And then when Tyne Daly had that speech, he said, no one had this the first time he'd heard grief articulated in that way, and it felt like exactly what he was going through. So he waited at the stage door after the show, and he said, I know she didn't write it, but I just had to tell her how impactful that was on me. And um, so he got to actually share that with Tyne Daly that that had really done something for him and his own healing process. So that's one of my favorite stories, and it's one of my favorite stories to share because I just say, like, we don't ever know what impact we're making in our art as artists. And we also just don't know what conversation we can be and entering into as fundraisers.
And just because it's a vulnerable, challenging moment, like if we as humans have the bandwidth to sit with somebody in that, like there can really be something impactful that comes out of that. So I was just able to really be in that moment with Mr. Smith. And yeah, I don't even remember what he did, you guys. Like, sure, maybe he became a donor, maybe he became a subscriber. I don't remember what happened in that moment after that. But what I do know is like it's okay to have hard conversations, even with strangers, even over the phone, and that theater can bring us together in that way.
[49:44] Mary Dina: It's a really beautiful story. And it's it's really just brings us back to that whole why we theater, like that connection, the collaboration, the community, and getting to have those experiences is I'm sure so fulfilling for you over the years. Mary, what do you say? We move into our lightning round.
[50:01] Kel Haney: Let's do it.
[50:06] Mary Dina: Do you want to kick us off?
[50:07] Kel Haney: Sure.
[50:08] Mary Dina: Okay. What is one thing in the theater industry that confuses you?
[50:12] Kel Haney: Representation. Uh, specifically in terms of business repute representation.
[50:17] Mary Dina: What are three adjectives that would describe your ideal working environment?
[50:22] Kel Haney: Curious, vulnerable, and supportive.
[50:26] Mary Dina: Is there something in your process that you find unique to you?
[50:29] Kel Haney: Oh, just this work I'm doing, period. I mean, I have I am branding myself as this outbound fundraising expert. I don't know anyone else who does anything like this. I think the whole brand I'm building is something that feels new and exciting. And I look forward to, I love when I connect with people, but I've yet to find anybody who's doing anything remotely like this.
[50:50] Mary Dina: Do you have any books or resources that have been helpful to you in your process or podcasts?
[50:56] Kel Haney: Oh, yeah. Um, I love Cal Newport's Deep Work. I already mentioned Keith Ferrazzi's Never Eat Alone. I love Elizabeth Gilbert's Big Magic. I love uh Priya Parker's The Art of Gathering. Um, what else off the top of my head? Maybe we'll leave it, we'll leave it at that. Um yeah, I'll leave it at that.
[51:20] Mary Dina: What is one job in the theater industry that you would trade jobs with for one week?
[51:25] Kel Haney: I wanna, I would love to see what that means to be um like uh an animal wrangler. I want to see what that is like.
[51:34] Mary Dina: Never got that answer before.
[51:35] Kel Haney: I've never had that answer before. It's wrapped in the weirdest. I think because I've done enough of the other things, slash been close enough in proximity. And I never did work on it like a big show, you know. I'm thinking of like years ago they did the royal ten, uh oh, I don't remember. There was a show that had like big great Danes on stage, and I was like, that looks amazing. Yeah, uh Animal Wrangler. I'm very curious what that job would be like.
[52:01] Mary Dina: Uh what's a hobby that you have outside of theater outside of the work you do?
[52:07] Kel Haney: I'm gonna be really geeky for a second. Durain shut down my husband and I started to play game boards, like games, like very intricate game boards. So, like we play this game called Viticulture, and we are in a 16th century Tuscany building our own vineyards. We have one called Everdell, which is like we're building our own animal cities. I'm telling you, I'm gonna have to write a blog post at some point about how much I've learned in terms of like entrepreneurial impulses and how much I'm honing my entrepreneurial impulses by playing these games. And it just came out of us wanting to have something to do at night that wasn't staring at screens. And now we own like 20 of them, and anyone who comes to our house, we feed them great meals.
That is like another hobby I have. I really like to cook. My husband likes to cook. We'd like to try to recreate great meals we've had in all of our travels, but we'll feed you a really good meal and then we'll try to convince you to play a board game with us afterwards.
[53:01] Mary Dina: I love that.
[53:02] Kel Haney: Oh, I love that.
[53:03] Mary Dina: Um right. Last question. What's the last great piece of theater that you've seen?
[53:10] Kel Haney: Cambodian Rock Band, written by my dear friend Lauren Yi. Um, saw it right before shutdown started. And it was the first show that I saw that like actually started to potentially get some productoral juices flowing through me of like, I just want this show to be seen and um I just want to support it happening. So yeah, Lauren Yi's Cambodian Rock Band at Signature Theater.
[53:35] Mary Dina: Very nice. Well, it's been such a pleasure. How can our listeners find you in the work that you're doing?
[53:41] Kel Haney: Sure. Um, so you can find me. You can go right to my website, which is KelHaney.com. Um, my handle on all of the socials is just my name, Kel Haney. Um, if you work with a not-for-profit and you want to have a 30-minute consultation um through uh the consulting firm with whom I work, Donorly, that's Donorly.com. We could definitely set you up for a free consultation. If you're looking for any kind of um more individual coaching, um, I'm also happy through my website, you can contact me, and I'm happy to also do a free consultation that way as well.
[54:12] Mary Dina: Amazing.
[54:13] Kel Haney: Amazing.
[54:13] Mary Dina: Well, thank you. This was this was amazing.
[54:15] Kel Haney: I really like really everything I wanted it to be.
[54:18] Mary Dina: Yeah. I mean, there were so many other ways we could have webbed out with what we what we spoke about.
[54:23] Kel Haney: Um, but we'll have to get you back on another time.
[54:26] Mary Dina: Love it.
[54:26] Kel Haney: For some more for some more adventures.
[54:28] Mary Dina: We'll do it. Thank you so much.
[54:30] Kel Haney: Thank you guys.
[54:30] Mary Dina: Thanks everyone for listening to this episode of Page to Stage. To keep up with us, you can find us on Instagram and Facebook at Page2Stage Podcast. And if you're enjoying these conversations, we would really appreciate it if you could take a couple minutes to rate and review us wherever you're listening to this podcast. Until next time. That's Brian.
[54:47] Brian Sedita: That's Mary.
[54:49] Mary Dina: We'll see you later.
[54:50] Kel Haney: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
