In this week's episode Tori and Eliza are once again joined by Gareth Isaac for part 2 of their Phantom of the Opera and Love Never Dies Deep Dive! We hope you are ready for a wild ride as they discuss in depth the plot of the shows, the unexpected innuendo, Christine's motives, the "character murder" in Love Never Dies, the beautiful sets and more!.. Read More
From the show: Stage Door Podcast
Guests
Featured Shows
About
In this week's episode Tori and Eliza are once again joined by Gareth Isaac for part 2 of their Phantom of the Opera and Love Never Dies Deep Dive! We hope you are ready for a wild ride as they discuss in depth the plot of the shows, the unexpected innuendo, Christine's motives, the "character murder" in Love Never Dies, the beautiful sets and more!
Resources and suggestions from the episode:
- "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" at QPAC
- "Alice's Adventures: The Musical" Postponed season on sale now!
- ALW "Cinderella" Original Cast Recording
- Mental Health Organizations Beyond Blue, Headspace and Lifeline
Leave us a rate and review, and let us know what you’d love to hear in our next episode on our Instagram @ps.stagedoorpod or via our email at ps.stagedoor.podcast@gmail.com
Created, Edited and Produced by Victoria Bullard & Elizabeth Gunther
Music by Catherine Gunther
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Tori Bullard: Hello everyone and welcome back to Stage Door Podcast.
[0:08] Eliza Gunther: Today we are bringing you part two of our Phantom of the Opera Deep Dive.
[0:13] Tori Bullard: But before we get into that, we would like to acknowledge the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation, the traditional custodians of this land in which we work, live, and record, and recognize their continuing connection to land, water, and community.
[0:28] Eliza Gunther: We pay respect to Elders past, present, and emerging.
[0:31] Tori Bullard: Alright, Tori, take it away with the bulletin.
[0:35] Eliza Gunther: This past week, the full cast of the Brisbane premiere of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was announced.
[0:42] Tori Bullard: Leading the cast are Steven Anderson, Robert Grubb, Lucy Morda, just to name a few.
[0:48] Eliza Gunther: The show will be running at QPAC from the 2nd to the 26th of September 2021.
[0:53] Tori Bullard: For ticket details, head to the website at www.qac.com.au.
[1:01] Eliza Gunther: The sold-out season of Alice's Adventures: The Musical has officially been rescheduled for the 7th and 8th of August this year.
[1:09] Tori Bullard: Tickets are on sale now and selling fast with opening night already sold out.
[1:14] Eliza Gunther: So if you missed out the first time, don't make the same mistake.
[1:18] Tori Bullard: Hop over to Alice's Adventures underscore the musical on Instagram for all the ticket details.
[1:24] Eliza Gunther: In this latest deep dive, we briefly spoke on Andrew Lloyd Webber's Cinderella and how keen we are to give the cast album a listen when it finally comes out.
[1:33] Tori Bullard: And well, as of tomorrow, the wait is over.
[1:36] Eliza Gunther: The full cast album will officially be released Friday, the 9th of July.
[1:41] Tori Bullard: If you can't wait, there are already a few songs available to listen to, which we are absolutely loving.
[1:46] Eliza Gunther: Let us know what you think.
[1:47] Tori Bullard: In the final piece of news for this week, Sydney has almost completed its second week of lockdown and is heading into its third.
[1:54] Eliza Gunther: We know many people are not coping well and feeling hopeless in these times.
[1:58] Tori Bullard: These feelings are valid and are hard to fight.
[2:00] Eliza Gunther: But please remember that you are not alone.
[2:03] Tori Bullard: We're here for you, and so is the entire community.
[2:07] Eliza Gunther: If you ever need to talk, not only are we here, but there are also amazing organizations like Beyond Blue, Lifeline, and Headspace who are available to assist you in whatever way necessary.
[2:18] Tori Bullard: Everyone, please stay healthy and safe.
[2:20] Eliza Gunther: Keep doing your part.
[2:21] Tori Bullard: We love and support you.
[2:23] Eliza Gunther: Back over to you, Eliza.
[2:25] Tori Bullard: Today we will be talking about all things Phantom of the Opera again with the lovely Gareth Isaac.
[2:35] Eliza Gunther: My God.
[2:36] Tori Bullard: Gareth, I'm really having a day.
[2:39] Eliza Gunther: My name is in the title of the thing.
[2:42] Tori Bullard: We've known each other for years.
[2:44] Eliza Gunther: This is hurtful!
[2:45] Tori Bullard: Gareth!
[2:46] Eliza Gunther: Gareth Isaac!
[2:49] Tori Bullard: Hi Gareth.
[2:50] Gareth Isaac: I apologize so much.
[2:52] Eliza Gunther: I'm having a day today.
[2:54] Gareth Isaac: You know what? Keep it in. Keep it in. This is the introduction.
[2:56] Eliza Gunther: Alright, let's go.
[2:57] Gareth Isaac: Hi, I'm Gareth Isaac. I'm gonna talk about the Opera of the Phantom.
[3:01] Gareth Isaac: It's a musical about a building. And the guy just happens to show up.
[3:05] Gareth Isaac: And he's quite ugly.
[3:06] Eliza Gunther: Oh, he's pretty rough.
[3:07] Gareth Isaac: Oh, that's controversial.
[3:09] Gareth Isaac: Anyway, take it away with the introduction to the show.
[3:13] Eliza Gunther: Thank you so much. Welcome to this delightful deep dive.
[3:17] Eliza Gunther: The first two-parter deep dive to have ever occurred on Stage Door Podcast.
[3:22] Tori Bullard: Before we get started, a brief recap for those who don't know the Phantom of the Opera storyline or who didn't listen to the last episode.
[3:31] Eliza Gunther: Go back and listen to it, it'll help you skip a bit.
[3:33] Tori Bullard: The Phantom of the Opera, with music by Andrew Lloyd Webber, lyrics by Charles Hart, Libretto by Lloyd Webber and Richard Stilgo, is based on the 1910 horror novel by Gaston Leroux.
[3:43] Tori Bullard: The Phantom of the Opera is a romantic, thrilling story of the legendary Phantom, a musical genius who dwells deep beneath the opera populaire in Paris.
[3:52] Tori Bullard: The Phantom is shunned by society for his horrific facial deformity.
[3:57] Tori Bullard: He takes a promising young soprano, Christine Daaé, under his wing and grooms her for operatic fame, all while falling deeply, madly, obsessively in love with her.
[4:08] Tori Bullard: As Christine grows ever more successful and a handsome young man from her past begins to successfully court her, the Phantom descends into a jealous rage and terrorizes the opera company with increasingly dangerous threats.
[4:22] Eliza Gunther: Now we did last time take a look into some of the plot, but not all of it, and we didn't quite get that far when we had a little chat last time.
[4:32] Eliza Gunther: And we also did have a little look at Love Never Dies, which is the sequel to Phantom of the Opera, which we will be looking at today.
[4:42] Tori Bullard: But first of all, we're gonna actually take a look into the plot of Phantom and have a bit more of an in-depth discussion about that said plot.
[4:51] Eliza Gunther: Yes, yes, yes. Now I think we can start it off today with the beginning of the show, which definitely starts out quite spectacularly, where we get the auction.
[5:03] Eliza Gunther: Um, of the Phantom Auction, and then we see the chandelier, and who doesn't love the chandelier?
[5:10] Tori Bullard: Yes, it's delightful.
[5:12] Eliza Gunther: Is it bad to say that's my favorite part of the show?
[5:16] Tori Bullard: The inanimate object.
[5:19] Eliza Gunther: It's like it is, it's like the thing though, you know.
[5:22] Eliza Gunther: It's like what I remember. I think Phantom was the first proper show that I saw in a theatre, and I just remember like it coming up and it falling down.
[5:32] Tori Bullard: Like that was like the key memory I have.
[5:34] Eliza Gunther: Um, it's such an iconic moment.
[5:36] Gareth Isaac: Oh, definitely. Like I remember seeing it on Broadway, and I had tears in my eyes when the bloody chandelier was going up because I'm a big sook.
[5:44] Eliza Gunther: Who doesn't love a set piece?
[5:46] Gareth Isaac: I cry in every overture of a show I cry at.
[5:52] Eliza Gunther: Every, like no matter what it is, because the overture is always like, in my opinion, like it swells so much more because obviously, depending on the show, you tend to have like a mix of the songs throughout the show, or for Phantom of the Opera, it is Phantom of the Opera that plays.
[6:07] Gareth Isaac: Um, kind of it's, it cycles through quite a few of the different songs.
[6:12] Gareth Isaac: But like it's always like such a swollen.
[6:17] Eliza Gunther: No. It swells.
[6:18] Gareth Isaac: Massive, spectacular.
[6:20] Eliza Gunther: But it is. It is always like this like over-the-top extravagant version of the songs that you hear throughout the show.
[6:28] Gareth Isaac: Because it's um, it's like it's louder. It feels like obviously it's the same amount of people in the orchestra, but it feels like ten more people have come in and are playing along as well.
[6:41] Eliza Gunther: So I feel like I cry at every opening.
[6:45] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, well, the opening of the prologue of the Phantom is now iconic because it is set so far after the fact.
[6:55] Eliza Gunther: You see Raoul, Christine's love interest, stuck in a wheelchair, and you see once that overture starts, the chandelier raising, the opera itself transforms.
[7:05] Gareth Isaac: Again, credit to Bjornson and her set design. The rags and sheets are falling off all the set pieces as they themselves rise back to what they once were.
[7:16] Eliza Gunther: So the story is being set before your eyes.
[7:19] Gareth Isaac: Uh, fun little fact about the music in this section. Uh, that little synth patch, I may have mentioned this last time.
[7:26] Gareth Isaac: The synth keyboard, the d-da da da da da da, uh, is all pre-recorded because that patch no longer exists on conventional synthesizers.
[7:36] Eliza Gunther: So fun little note.
[7:37] Gareth Isaac: I just love the opulence that it brings.
[7:41] Eliza Gunther: And I'm not gonna talk about this much because I think I ranted on about it last time.
[7:46] Gareth Isaac: Did you? I hadn't noticed.
[7:48] Eliza Gunther: Of course. No, because again, somebody said that same person that I was talking about last time brought it up again of, and specifically said Phantom of the Opera.
[7:56] Gareth Isaac: What would happen if they did it like really dark and dingy?
[7:59] Eliza Gunther: I was like, it would look like the prologue the whole show, and I couldn't give two shits if it looked like that.
[8:05] Gareth Isaac: Correct.
[8:06] Eliza Gunther: Like it's not just about the set, but like, you know, when all of those when all of the set pieces and the lights start to rise, and you see this opera house in Paris, and you're just completely taken back, and you're completely in the moment.
[8:23] Gareth Isaac: Um, it's like one of the most, I wouldn't say the most, but one of the most beautiful openings, I think, in theatre.
[8:31] Eliza Gunther: And following this little opening, we're rapidly introduced to all the major players in the piece.
[8:37] Tori Bullard: We see the two new managers, Andre and Firmin, we see Madame Giry and her daughter, Madame Giry, the opera's rehearsal mistress for the Corps de Ballet.
[8:46] Eliza Gunther: We see Monsieur Reyer, the repetiteur, we see Carlotta, the opera's leading soprano for three seasons.
[8:53] Tori Bullard: Carlotta.
[8:54] Eliza Gunther: And then Sin.
[8:55] Tori Bullard: Oh, I think you have thoughts on Carlotta.
[8:57] Eliza Gunther: Oh, I mean, I just think that she's a bitch, but I love her.
[9:02] Tori Bullard: She's a bitch, but she's an amazing character.
[9:04] Eliza Gunther: Like you couldn't have that show without her.
[9:07] Tori Bullard: Uh, yeah, she's a diva.
[9:08] Eliza Gunther: She is the prima donna.
[9:10] Tori Bullard: She is the first lady of the stage.
[9:11] Eliza Gunther: She's entitled to this.
[9:12] Tori Bullard: Yeah.
[9:13] Eliza Gunther: You have to have a diva character.
[9:15] Eliza Gunther: And I mean, as diva characters go, my favourite bit, obviously, like at the start of the show, they're doing the aria and she's performing the aria.
[9:23] Tori Bullard: And then all of a sudden something drops on stage.
[9:25] Eliza Gunther: And then they're all like, ah, she goes into her diva moment.
[9:29] Eliza Gunther: I'm not going to perform. Goodbye. See you later. And off she trots.
[9:32] Tori Bullard: And then Christine's like, oh my god, I can possibly sing.
[9:36] Eliza Gunther: Oh no.
[9:37] Tori Bullard: It's not even Christine that does it.
[9:39] Eliza Gunther: They're in leading to one of my main gripes with the Christine character.
[9:42] Eliza Gunther: It's her best friend who just steps forward and says, hey, this one can sing, she can do the role.
[9:47] Tori Bullard: Like Meg Giry steps forward like the little shit stirrer that she is and says, my best friend can sing.
[9:52] Eliza Gunther: Would we say that in Love Never Dies, Meg is the diva?
[9:57] Tori Bullard: Uh, yes.
[9:59] Eliza Gunther: I believe so.
[10:00] Tori Bullard: Not to the same extent.
[10:02] Eliza Gunther: Not to the same level as Carlotta.
[10:05] Tori Bullard: Carlotta is like makes something out of nothing, you know.
[10:09] Eliza Gunther: Whereas Meg has like this mix of like, and we'll kind of get to it when we get to it.
[10:13] Eliza Gunther: But like I also feel like she's got something.
[10:16] Tori Bullard: There is something quite wrong about her in a lot of the things.
[10:19] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, like she's the second choice.
[10:22] Tori Bullard: Always has been, and I believe that that plays over.
[10:26] Eliza Gunther: But uh, we will get to that.
[10:28] Tori Bullard: We will get to that.
[10:29] Eliza Gunther: She wouldn't have been if she hadn't, if she, why didn't Meg volunteer herself?
[10:33] Tori Bullard: Leads to a very good question.
[10:34] Eliza Gunther: Very good question.
[10:35] Tori Bullard: It might not have ended very well, and Carlotta might have continued on performing.
[10:43] Eliza Gunther: But Meg volunteered Christine because one of the questions that um, I'm not sure who put it in the document, but about is Christine a strong female character.
[10:54] Tori Bullard: I don't, I wouldn't necessarily say that she's not, but she has spent her entire life being told what to do by other people.
[11:02] Eliza Gunther: Her choices and her agency ultimately don't matter, and that goes on and on throughout the show.
[11:10] Tori Bullard: Like she's just, and she doesn't really, but she doesn't really try to like take back control of that.
[11:15] Eliza Gunther: The only time that she really makes a choice is with the Phantom.
[11:18] Tori Bullard: Exactly.
[11:19] Eliza Gunther: The choice to kiss him.
[11:21] Tori Bullard: You know, spoilers for 1986.
[11:23] Eliza Gunther: Spoiler alert for a show that's been out for like, is the longest running show on Broadway.
[11:29] Tori Bullard: Because it was Cats prior.
[11:31] Eliza Gunther: Yeah. Well, this is the interesting thing as well, because like she doesn't really like make any strong choices, and then the ending, it's kind of like, is this the right choice for her?
[11:41] Tori Bullard: She might be making a choice, but is it the right choice?
[11:44] Eliza Gunther: Is it really the strong choice that you would want for her?
[11:47] Tori Bullard: I think the question.
[11:48] Eliza Gunther: I think the strong choice would have been to just flip the bird to both of them and be like, absolutely not.
[11:55] Tori Bullard: I'm done with this shit show.
[11:57] Eliza Gunther: Let me just go and do my dancing, let me be.
[12:02] Tori Bullard: It's like because I don't think she loves either of them, honestly.
[12:05] Eliza Gunther: I think with the Phantom, again, thinks it's the angel of music, her father come back in spirit, and Raoul, it's just I guess it's kind of almost like he forces it.
[12:15] Tori Bullard: Raoul's an old childhood friend that is giving her some merit of protection against this otherworldly threat that is killing things around her, but still teaching her all this stuff.
[12:25] Eliza Gunther: Yeah.
[12:25] Tori Bullard: So I don't think either of the relationships are terribly healthy.
[12:31] Eliza Gunther: Even from the first scene where we're introduced to the love triangle.
[12:34] Tori Bullard: Raoul comes in and says, hey, remember me? You're coming to supper.
[12:36] Eliza Gunther: Phantom appears in the mirror.
[12:38] Tori Bullard: Nut you're coming to my cave, love.
[12:40] Eliza Gunther: And obviously, there's an interesting dynamic here.
[12:44] Tori Bullard: That's where she should have.
[12:46] Eliza Gunther: That's where she should have turned around and gone, guys, I'm actually very, very gay.
[12:51] Tori Bullard: Um, sorry, I have a boys, sorry, I've spoken to you.
[12:57] Eliza Gunther: Sorry. We can go to dinner, but like, just so you know, nothing's gonna happen.
[13:03] Tori Bullard: But it's also like a cave.
[13:05] Eliza Gunther: A cave or dinner.
[13:06] Tori Bullard: A cave or dinner? I'm not sure.
[13:07] Eliza Gunther: The platonic of the opera.
[13:09] Tori Bullard: It's like the possibility of love versus, oh, I get to see my father's spirit reincarnated as the angel of music.
[13:19] Eliza Gunther: It's not even, I don't think, whilst obviously the Phantom very clearly is like infatuated and in love with Christine, I don't know if there's any love element for her other than initially this thing of this could be my father come back as this angel of music.
[13:36] Gareth Isaac: And then obviously the love I say in air quotes, therefore that she has to portray to protect not only Raoul, but everybody else in the opera, because it's kind of like it's not her fault in any way.
[13:51] Eliza Gunther: But if she doesn't show that affection back, the Phantom's just gonna keep it.
[13:58] Gareth Isaac: Exactly. And herein brings us to the next scene in the show, the next big scene after the Phantom of the Opera, etc.
[14:07] Tori Bullard: Music of the night. It is the song in the show.
[14:13] Gareth Isaac: The song for damn near every tenor who's ever come out of a musical theatre degree. And here's where I'm gonna ruin it for you.
[14:21] Gareth Isaac: It's about sex.
[14:23] Eliza Gunther: Oh well, yeah, yeah.
[14:25] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, but music of the night is about the sex, and it's like this is coming to me from a friend of mine who did some cruise ship work with the Music of the Night show with the Really Useful Group at the head, which is Lloyd Webber's production company. They get one of the MDs from the Phantom Production in. They sit my friend down and say, "Alright, you're doing music of the night. You see this? Da. That's the in and out of intercourse. That is literally what it is."
[14:42] Eliza Gunther: Oh no!
[14:58] Gareth Isaac: No! I cannot.
[15:02] Eliza Gunther: How do you think I feel?
[15:03] Gareth Isaac: Oh no! That's stuck in my head now.
[15:08] Eliza Gunther: That's that oh my god.
[15:09] Gareth Isaac: Yep. Aside from the lyrical content as well, to make the music of the night. What happens at night? What do you hear at night?
[15:17] Eliza Gunther: Oh no!
[15:20] Gareth Isaac: I'm really sorry to have done that.
[15:23] Eliza Gunther: Oh my god. At first I was like, oh okay. Like, you know, there are songs about like love making. And like there are songs about love making stuff that exists in the world that are really like lovely, and it's like, you know, it's tenderness. That's just a good thing.
[15:39] Gareth Isaac: Which is an important point of the Phantom's character. It's not love. It's not affection. It's obsession, it's lust, and it's I want this thing.
[15:52] Eliza Gunther: Yeah. I do think, and like on that note of love, I do think it's very much so like an obsession and infatuation. I do think towards the end of the show there is a love for Christine that the Phantom feels enough to let her go.
[16:06] Gareth Isaac: Which is still very much a power move. It's like I'm letting you go. It's a learning thing. Just you wait till the terrible sequel, and I'll be right back at you.
[16:16] Eliza Gunther: Um but it definitely feels like there's like a some kind of a true affection forming to kind of go, I have to let you go.
[16:26] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, I think it's a learning experience, but unfortunately it took the better part of a year in the story and two and a half hours of our time for him to learn it.
[16:34] Eliza Gunther: I feel like this kind of feeds into another point that we have, which is Christine too too young for the Phantom, but also too young for the story, because there does seem to be some misconception about Christine's.
[16:47] Gareth Isaac: Yes, this was a point I myself didn't know until I did a bit of reading. Originally I thought that Christine was roughly fourteen years old, and this is a common thing throughout the story that she's like fourteen or fifteen. Um, but it was mistranslated. The original French novel has a passage that states her heart is as pure as that of a fifteen-year-old, which ultimately someone misread and said, "Oh god, she's fifteen, she's a teenager." Uh she's actually twenty, as of the novel and musical.
[17:20] Eliza Gunther: But unfortunately that naivete does come back into play, and she's just sort of treated as a warm prop for a lot of the show. Things happen around her as the show progresses, people getting killed around her, she's getting put into more positions of power throughout the opera populaires season, overtaking Carlotta in one show.
[17:40] Gareth Isaac: It's it's a lot.
[17:42] Eliza Gunther: It is a lot. There's a lot of plot, actually, to this show.
[17:42] Gareth Isaac: There's a lot of insight.
[17:46] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, there's an awful lot of plot, but on the bright side, there's enough mirroring in act two that you can just say, cool, remember that thing in act one, it happens again.
[17:54] Gareth Isaac: Dangerous.
[17:58] Eliza Gunther: Just to kind of occur to me, and I would like me. Oh my god. Get empty, come on. Who allowed that?
[18:05] Gareth Isaac: Um, do you think that and this like this is not necessarily attributed anywhere? It was just a thought I just had about you saying that, you know, because she's got this growing power throughout the show, in a sense. Like if she wanted to, she could twist this all around and be like, yes, I want you to knock out everyone that could possibly get in my way.
[18:18] Eliza Gunther: Like if she wanted to, she could. Do you think that Christine kind of wanted this to happen? Like she almost um what is it? You know, when like uh like not reverse psychology, but that kind of idea a subconscious watch.
[18:45] Gareth Isaac: But also kind of did that to the Phantom to get him infatuated with her to then do her bidding in a way that doesn't require her asking for I mean I think it's a fun fan theory, but I think it doesn't hold a lot of weight.
[19:01] Eliza Gunther: But I do like I kinda like the fun fan theory because like I I like the idea though.
[19:06] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, because at the start of the show, when obviously that first happens with Carlotta and stuff, could it have been like pre-show that she chatted to the Phantom about wanting the opportunity. But this is going too far. Uh hey, hey, basement daddy, do you want to just mess with the leading lady for a bit so I get a chance?
[19:25] Eliza Gunther: And Meg, oh, just going go into her best friend and saying, "Oh, I could sing Carlotta's bit, surely." And then just Yeah, she like puts it all in place.
[19:33] Gareth Isaac: That's the new title for Phantom of the Opera. Basement.
[19:35] Eliza Gunther: Basement.
[19:39] Gareth Isaac: Um I will get that on a sticker. Thank you.
[19:42] Eliza Gunther: Um But I feel like but I feel like she could so easily have taken advantage of that because like she could have so much power, but still, you know, blame it all on the Phantom. This person that nobody has actually necessarily really seen.
[19:59] Gareth Isaac: And she's just the innocent doe-eyed 20-year-old opera singer who has this magically fantastic voice.
[20:08] Eliza Gunther: Right, so it's like it's like a reverse wicked then.
[20:11] Gareth Isaac: Kind of, yeah.
[20:12] Eliza Gunther: Alright, I'm okay with this.
[20:14] Gareth Isaac: I mean, you never know.
[20:16] Eliza Gunther: You never know. Probably on the bowels of the internet in the Phantom fandom, someone has written a fanfiction based on this.
[20:23] Gareth Isaac: Oh yeah, oh no, I don't want to know not I wanna know nothing about basement daddy fanfiction. Thank you.
[20:30] Eliza Gunther: Um I there's the episode quote. I basement daddy. That's the episode title. Basement daddy.
[20:38] Gareth Isaac: Oh my god. I would like to formally apologize to every listener of Stage Door Podcast for the amount of disgusting energy I'm bringing to this deep dive.
[20:47] Eliza Gunther: Well, it is the show itself.
[20:49] Gareth Isaac: Uh look, there's just now too many, too many aspects that have grossed me out to not make everybody else enjoy them.
[20:58] Eliza Gunther: In that case, let's continue on with Shall we basically, you know what, you know what happens from this part. The Phantom is bumping people off to give his protege more power and more roles in the opera, thinking, oh, this I'll just gift her all this stuff.
[21:15] Gareth Isaac: Raoul, on the other hand, the Vicomte de Chagny, is like, oh my god, there is no Phantom of the Opera, Christine. Calm down. I will protect you. No more talk of darkness. All I ask of you, etc. They get engaged in secret.
[21:28] Eliza Gunther: The Phantom swears revenge, and no one hears from him for six months after dropping the chandelier on a show.
[21:33] Gareth Isaac: And that's how Act One shows back finishing. Because he literally that's the end of Act One. He literally went Mic drop.
[21:40] Eliza Gunther: Mic drop.
[21:41] Gareth Isaac: Chandelier drop.
[21:42] Eliza Gunther: Chandelier drop.
[21:43] Gareth Isaac: And pat it with y'all bullshit.
[21:46] Eliza Gunther: Chandelier.
[21:48] Gareth Isaac: Hey, nice chandelier, you got there. Boom! No more. Would be a shame if someone was to uh tamper with it.
[21:56] Gareth Isaac: There is a very fun fact. An ex-girlfriend of mine told me this. She used to work uh front of house at Phantom West End.
[22:05] Eliza Gunther: And it became a rite of passage for once the chandelier dropped, for people to come up and start nicking the crystals off it when they went out for intervals.
[22:14] Gareth Isaac: No way.
[22:15] Eliza Gunther: It got so bad that at some point they just stopped dropping the chandelier.
[22:19] Gareth Isaac: Oh my gosh!
[22:21] Eliza Gunther: That's so fun. Imagine that. You're just like, I'm just gonna sneak onto the stage and steal one of these giant crystals from this beautiful chandelier.
[22:28] Gareth Isaac: Oh, that's just it. You didn't even have to sneak onto the stage because of the positioning of the chandelier. It just sat at the front of it.
[22:35] Eliza Gunther: So like very edge. It was just hanging over.
[22:37] Gareth Isaac: Of course. So anyone in like the triple A, triple B, triple C would just walk forward and go, yoink, mine now.
[22:44] Eliza Gunther: That's naughty.
[22:46] Gareth Isaac: Kind of love though.
[22:48] Eliza Gunther: But I'm not gonna lie, I would do that.
[22:51] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, I was like, I would do that. I would only do it the once, though. I would just do it the once, and then I would probably feel like insanely like sickly guilty for doing it.
[23:00] Eliza Gunther: Oh god, yeah. I would become like a musical theatre golem and just sit in my room touching this crystal going, my precious.
[23:08] Gareth Isaac: The Phantoms of Sopra's precious.
[23:12] Eliza Gunther: Well, we should probably get on to the Act Two.
[23:15] Gareth Isaac: Let's whiz through Act Two so we can get to some.
[23:18] Eliza Gunther: Whiz through act two.
[23:19] Gareth Isaac: Okay, it opens. We see Masquerade, we see the costumes, we hear the splendor, masquerade, seven part harmonies. Phantom shows back up in a cool moving skull costume, saying, "Hey guys, here's an opera, put it on, or you're all dead."
[23:31] Eliza Gunther: And Christine, I know you're engaged now, but you're still mine. You're gonna sing in this opera.
[23:35] Gareth Isaac: The opera's terrible. Like, it's really fucking bad. Christine tries to exert a modicum of self-control and say, "I don't want to do this opera. I want no part in this. I cannot, I will not." And literally in the very next scene after running away, she's in rehearsal for the opera.
[23:53] Eliza Gunther: She's like, I don't want to be in it, but alright, if you want me in it, I'm gonna be in it.
[23:57] Gareth Isaac: Well, because let's not forget that Raoul literally uses her as bait because he is so determined to catch the Phantom. Even though he doesn't believe the Phantom exists. He is so determined that he must use her as bait.
[24:12] Eliza Gunther: I'm like, mate, you're saying that you love this woman, right? Yet you're willing to have her die so that you can catch something that you don't even believe actually exists. Like, get your priority straight, sir.
[24:28] Gareth Isaac: Yep, it's a lot. Raoul hatches a plan to catch the Phantom using Christine as bait. Christine goes off to a graveyard to pray to her father's grave. Wishing meant somehow here again plays. We love, we stand, Sierra Boggus, gorgeous.
[24:41] Eliza Gunther: Or the lady. Phantom shows back up and is apparently a warlock now, starts blowing up the graveyard with Christine and Raoul in it.
[24:47] Gareth Isaac: Can we talk about that for a second?
[24:49] Eliza Gunther: Wait, I actually completely forget that that happens.
[24:52] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, he just pulls out a staff with fire on it and starts blowing the place up.
[24:56] Eliza Gunther: So either.
[24:57] Gareth Isaac: All I can imagine is, you know, those little pop rocks that you used to be able to like throw at the ground and they would pop. I just imagine he's got like a handful of those, just like ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha.
[25:07] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, this shall shall ya?
[25:09] Gareth Isaac: Why is he skeletor? Who knows?
[25:12] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, either he's gone to the trouble of carefully placing pyrotechnics in this graveyard, or he's a warlock.
[25:18] Gareth Isaac: I like to imagine.
[25:20] Eliza Gunther: Made the deal, done the warlock.
[25:21] Gareth Isaac: I agree. Maybe he's done a deal with the devil kind of thing. Wouldn't put a passed him.
[25:26] Eliza Gunther: Wait, why? Okay, but like, actually, there has to be a reason behind that, right?
[25:31] Gareth Isaac: I don't think there is. I think it's more the spectacle of it.
[25:37] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, I love Phantom to death, but it makes no sense.
[25:41] Gareth Isaac: Yeah. It has, like, I'm just imagining, oh god, Christine's gonna be here soon. Better lay down this dynamite. And maybe the boyfriend's there too. Who knows? What happens if they didn't turn up, Eric?
[25:52] Eliza Gunther: I kind of thought that it was like gunshots or something, but now that you've said that, I'm like, no, it is just like him being like, haha, fireball.
[26:00] Gareth Isaac: Ha ha, fireball. It's a lot of third-level slots.
[26:03] Eliza Gunther: I know. And I guess after that kind of debacle. So Raoul, Raoul kind of asks, uh, tries to treat the Phantom, obviously. The Phantom's opera happens.
[26:15] Gareth Isaac: They try to catch the Phantom. He comes out with a friggin' bag on his head, pretending to be the opera's tenor. It's like, oh, wonder who that idiot is. He's like, it's me!
[26:24] Eliza Gunther: And Christine is just casually there, like, guys, guys, guys, I'm just gonna go.
[26:27] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, Christine just rolls with it for half the song before realizing what's going on.
[26:31] Gareth Isaac: No, I feel like, right, in the most recent, in like the um the show must go on, Sierra Boggess' anniversary show, from like it's like to me, it has about like, you know, maybe like 30 to 40 seconds of her being like, ah yes, my moment, the point of no return.
[26:51] Gareth Isaac: And then she realizes, and she spends the whole the whole rest of the song being like, Raoul, Raoul, please.
[26:59] Gareth Isaac: Ral, he's right there. Ral, this is not the tenor. She somehow managed to see through that paper thin pantomime premise the Phantom put together. But it's also like his voice. You'd be able like you would if you had been practicing with someone and then you heard somebody else sing. Like, I find that I'm really like attuned to that. It's like, oh no, that was like I remember once seeing Wicked many, many moons ago, like on its first tour here, and I went to see a show, and um Glinda started uh, you know, very open, let us be glad, you know, all of that. And I it started singing and I went, That's not Lucy Dirac. Don't know who it is, but it's not her. Come on, Christine, get it together. She would know. And I feel like he was way like he was way more handsy than the original tenor would have been.
[27:51] Eliza Gunther: Oh yes.
[27:52] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, uh after that, then Phantom everyone's like, Oh god, he's got a bad face. Uh Phantom's dragging Christine off to the lair. Then we have the big mashup of a bit of music of the night, a bit of past the point of no return, a little bit of all I ask of you. It's a it's very fun, it's it's just called the lair scene in most of the libretto. Everyone is eventually Raoul is about to be killed by the Phantom.
[28:19] Tori Bullard: Yes.
[28:20] Gareth Isaac: Casual hanging. Choose him, he dies. Choose me, he lives. So deal with that. Christine's like, I'm gonna s I'm gonna smooch you now to shock you. Just do a little uh 180. My favorite thing though is throughout that whole scene, right? It's quite a long scene, and it's quite a long song as well. Raoul's just casually hanging.
[28:39] Eliza Gunther: Ral's in a goddamn noose.
[28:41] Gareth Isaac: He's like, Christine, whatever you choose, just be quick. Like, I'm just like I'm straggling. Yeah, it's fine, and yet still somehow getting a really good sound. Projection's great.
[28:50] Eliza Gunther: Yeah.
[28:51] Gareth Isaac: Oh, I was just gonna say the counter melodies in this section are honestly some of my favourites in the show. Because Phantom is doing uh past the point of no return, the final threshold, while Raoul underneath is doing say you love him, and my life is over. It's really, really nice composition, so fucking credit to Lloyd Webber.
[29:16] Eliza Gunther: Yeah.
[29:16] Gareth Isaac: Credit to Rao for singing whilst being hung by his neck.
[29:20] Eliza Gunther: Very true. I mean, herein lies another point that I wrote in our little Google Doc. The Phantom is Lloyd Webber. There is no getting around that, I don't think. The way he's written the role as the tragically misunderstood composer, at this point in his life, he's got his Christine. So he's writing his experience, I think.
[29:42] Tori Bullard: That's so interesting.
[29:44] Gareth Isaac: As a composer myself, that awful self-doubt is always influencing what I write. So one can only imagine how he's been doing this whole time, coming off. Joseph and every other big scale musical. How's his imposter syndrome doing? What's his mask?
[30:00] Eliza Gunther: True.
[30:01] Gareth Isaac: And then Phantom did him so well anyway, so he's skyrocketed since then. And I mean they've he's literally just got the new Cinderella out, which is very exciting.
[30:10] Tori Bullard: I'm very excited to see that one day.
[30:12] Gareth Isaac: He does, he does. I haven't heard anything from that yet. Have we heard anything?
[30:15] Eliza Gunther: Um, you can listen to, I think I believe Bad Cinderella and I Have a Heart are currently out on iTunes. Um they've just started previews. When this comes out, previews would have started about a week ago. And it looks to be going well. It looks interesting.
[30:35] Tori Bullard: Alright, cool. I'll I'll have to give it a wee listen.
[30:39] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, but I would like to see it definitely feels like the kind of show. I mean, obviously, with only having two songs out, it's got always kinda hard to tell. It feels a little bit currently like I would want to see it to understand, because it is a different take on the Cinderella story.
[30:54] Gareth Isaac: I do know it's quite different.
[30:55] Eliza Gunther: Yeah. Because they wanted to make something. Andrew Lloyd Webber had always wanted to write a Cinderella, but it had been done so much, he didn't know how to make it different. Um, so it is quite different. So I feel like I'd want to understand the story. Speaking of story, the final few notes of the Phantom of the Opera.
[31:12] Tori Bullard: Yes.
[31:13] Gareth Isaac: All that really happens is everyone in the opera finally is like, okay, this is fucked. There's a dude living under our house that is killing our friends. We're gonna hunt him down. Uh Raoul, Christine, Phantom hear this. Phantom's like, Oh, you two get out of here. You clearly love him enough to like be with me to save him. Okay, get out of here, forget everything you've seen. The Phantom sits in his chair, puts a cape over him. Uh Meg Giri of all people runs in, dressed in like Epineen best.
[31:44] Eliza Gunther: Yeah.
[31:45] Gareth Isaac: Throws the sheet off the chair, and all that's left is the Phantom's mask, which she takes, she kneels, points it so perfectly angled into the light that it's written into the script. Show ends. I wonder why Meg runs in. It's not because she's obsessed or anything.
[32:01] Tori Bullard: I mean, it makes no sense given that at that point Love Never Dies didn't exist.
[32:06] Gareth Isaac: That's true. There was literally no context for her to be there dressed like she'd just come off singing on my own.
[32:12] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, it just doesn't make sense.
[32:14] Gareth Isaac: It would have been it would have made sense if it was like I don't even know if it would make sense if it was Christine or anyone, really.
[32:20] Eliza Gunther: I kinda get it. I don't think it needed to be done. It could've it could have been fucking Joe Blow, the guy who sweeps the stage. It would have had the same effect.
[32:29] Gareth Isaac: I feel like the only person to me that makes sense is Madame Madame Giri, because she has known him since she was a child.
[32:39] Eliza Gunther: But I reckon Meg also was very close with him.
[32:44] Gareth Isaac: Which is how he was introduced to Christine, I think.
[32:47] Tori Bullard: Alright, I'm interested in this theory. Because don't forget, like Madame Giri kind of raised Eric, not raised him, but like supported him.
[32:57] Gareth Isaac: She was she was his patron.
[32:58] Eliza Gunther: And protected him.
[33:00] Gareth Isaac: She protected him as well.
[33:02] Eliza Gunther: Very true. She knew what he was doing to Christine and still she protected him. Um I feel like Meg would have s like, you know, followed her mother around, as you do when you're a child, found this strange, probably teenage boy, and she was like a ha-ha teenage boy, and probably became attached to.
[33:07] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, teenage boy with half a face.
[33:22] Eliza Gunther: Yes, but she probably came at became attached to him because he was this musical genius.
[33:30] Gareth Isaac: I mean, that is fair. That is fair. Well, I guess on that note, that wraps up our Phantom of the Opera deep dive for now.
[33:37] Tori Bullard: Amazing.
[33:38] Gareth Isaac: But we're going to actually do a bit of a game. I think Troy's got a game for us. And then we'll do a little bit of a chat of Love Never Dies and call it a day.
[33:46] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, I I think we can dedicate a little less time to Love Never Dies, because honestly, like Nobody hate me, but it's so bad.
[33:55] Tori Bullard: We'll just talk a little bit about it and then.
[33:55] Gareth Isaac: Oh, I thought you meant Love Never Dies.
[34:01] Eliza Gunther: Like we know that.
[34:01] Tori Bullard: Yeah, yeah.
[34:01] Gareth Isaac: The game. Let's find out.
[34:03] Eliza Gunther: Oh yeah.
[34:03] Gareth Isaac: Both. They both suck.
[34:05] Eliza Gunther: Um we're gonna be playing the same terrible game as last time.
[34:09] Gareth Isaac: Uh that I like to call guess the song in Ten Seconds.
[34:14] Eliza Gunther: Um such an inventive title.
[34:16] Gareth Isaac: I know. And this time we're doing it for Love Never Dies, which we have all discovered. None of us know particularly well.
[34:24] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, like I I have listened to it enough to do a basic critical review. I've watched it a couple of times, but I don't have the same obsessive knowledge of it.
[34:36] Gareth Isaac: Yeah that I do for Fantasy. I think I've listened to it fully once, and I've seen it, I think, once, which was the Melbourne um recording for uh the show must go on.
[34:47] Eliza Gunther: That is also my knowledge of Love Never Dies.
[34:50] Gareth Isaac: It's also, I believe, the only full recording to exist.
[34:53] Eliza Gunther: Exactly. So this will be interesting to say the least.
[34:59] Tori Bullard: Eliza. You will be first.
[35:02] Gareth Isaac: And I'll be giving you 10 seconds. Please do not buzz in until the 10 seconds has completed. Um we'll be doing two rounds each and then a buzzer round, as per usual. So here we go.
[35:17] Tori Bullard: Mother, did you see? Was it all alright? Mother, was he watching? Was he keeping out our side? I was frightened after death. And I had to catch my breath.
[35:28] Eliza Gunther: I remember the song. Do I remember the title? This one is easy in terms of the title.
[35:38] Gareth Isaac: Mother.
[35:41] Eliza Gunther: Oh, is it really? Keep going.
[35:44] Gareth Isaac: It's definitely not Mother Knows Best because that's definitely a Disney song.
[35:50] Tori Bullard: We'll give we'll give Eliza another second. It does have the word mother in it.
[35:54] Eliza Gunther: Oh, well, that's good. Go me. I'm just gonna. Mother, did you see?
[36:01] Gareth Isaac: Oh, Mother Did you see? This is awesome. I'm gonna give you one, Eliza, because I feel like you deserve it. You just finished, you just finished your first semester at the con, and I'm very proud of you. So you that's your gift from me.
[36:21] Eliza Gunther: Yes. Correct. I'm pretty sure I clipped my mic with how angry I got with that. It's called Mother Did You See.
[36:29] Tori Bullard: Alright. That is one point.
[36:32] Gareth Isaac: Alright. Alright, time to embarrass myself. I'm not afraid of him.
[36:42] Eliza Gunther: Oh, I actually know this one. This is Devil Take the Hind Mode.
[36:45] Gareth Isaac: Did I not tell you to wait until after the clip was done to answer the question, Gareth? Did I not tell you that I know four songs and that was one of them? And I was very excited. That is Devil Take the Hindmost.
[36:57] Eliza Gunther: What is that title?
[36:58] Gareth Isaac: Devil Take the Hindmost. Uh that is basically the Phantom and Raoul making a wager over Christine again, treating her like a warm prop and saying, hey, whoever loses is fucked, and the devil can. Also, who calls a song Devil Take the Hindmost?
[37:15] Eliza Gunther: Uh, the fact that it's the most repeated phrase in the song.
[37:19] Gareth Isaac: Then change the phrase. It's a stupid phrase.
[37:20] Eliza Gunther: You're a stupid phrase.
[37:23] Gareth Isaac: I am, I know. I'm defending Love Never Dies. I need to stop. Hey, if I just got one, I'm happy. I'm a happy chap. This is one all.
[37:32] Eliza Gunther: Okay. Um, oh, this is hard because I don't I don't know which one to do for the tiebreaker. I want it the tiebreaker one, I want it to be the one that you're both most likely to know. So let's go with ne I'll please and the clear marty.
[37:52] Gareth Isaac: Rice Alright. Think of where the sh Love Never Dies takes place.
[38:01] Eliza Gunther: Is this Coney Island?
[38:03] Gareth Isaac: Well, it's in Manhattan.
[38:04] Eliza Gunther: Oh, it's you take it takes a little bit.
[38:05] Gareth Isaac: No, no, no, no. Like no, no, no, no. You were right. You were right.
[38:08] Eliza Gunther: I was right.
[38:10] Gareth Isaac: But it's there's more to it.
[38:11] Eliza Gunther: There's more to it. Coney Island.
[38:15] Gareth Isaac: Coney Island.
[38:17] Eliza Gunther: Coney Island. Um What's that dance move that you told me is really hard to get right?
[38:26] Gareth Isaac: Coney Island waltz!
[38:30] Eliza Gunther: I'm not gonna give it to you because I gave you the full answer. But it is Cody Island.
[38:35] Gareth Isaac: Oh my god, I love that!
[38:36] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, no, don't give it to me. That is totally fair. But I I'm I'm happy with that. Thanks for all the hints, Troy.
[38:43] Gareth Isaac: I just wanted to see if I could urge you towards the right. It's like charades. This is like what do you call articulate? I love it.
[38:51] Eliza Gunther: I'm gonna go with one that's like starred on Apple Music, which I'm gonna assume means that it's like a popular.
[38:58] Gareth Isaac: Okay. I mean, more than likely.
[39:04] Eliza Gunther: Start the day ends. Time calls.
[39:13] Gareth Isaac: That is Till I Hear You Sing.
[39:16] Eliza Gunther: Correct! Round of applause. It's the first song in the show, and it's all downhill from there.
[39:24] Gareth Isaac: Alright. Now, this is a tiebreaker.
[39:27] Eliza Gunther: Oh, because we're totally on a tie.
[39:29] Gareth Isaac: So you're gonna buzz in with your name. Now this is the one that I think you're both most likely uh to get. Um we only do we have to wait till after it plays to buzz in?
[39:40] Eliza Gunther: Yes, okay. Wait until I finish and I will give you a countdown so that it's fair.
[39:45] Gareth Isaac: Okay.
[39:47] Eliza Gunther: And Liza!
[39:58] Gareth Isaac: Three, two, one, go!
[39:59] Eliza Gunther: Oh, Eliza!
[40:00] Gareth Isaac: Gareth.
[40:02] Eliza Gunther: Gareth, I think you got in first.
[40:04] Gareth Isaac: What is it?
[40:05] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, before the countdown. I didn't realize it was a countdown. I'm sorry, guys.
[40:12] Gareth Isaac: No, no, no, no, no. You've you've you've made your bed now, Eliza. Let's see if you can sleep in it with this song title.
[40:17] Eliza Gunther: Okay, is it Love Never Dies?
[40:19] Gareth Isaac: It is!
[40:20] Eliza Gunther: But I still didn't win. I only got two points.
[40:25] Gareth Isaac: You're now tied.
[40:26] Eliza Gunther: We're tied.
[40:27] Gareth Isaac: So we're gonna do another tiebreaker.
[40:30] Tori Bullard: Okay.
[40:31] Gareth Isaac: So it wasn't.
[40:32] Tori Bullard: So it wasn't really a tiebreaker then.
[40:33] Gareth Isaac: Well no, I honestly I didn't I really didn't know who was gonna get this first.
[40:38] Tori Bullard: So, alright.
[40:49] Gareth Isaac: Three, two, one.
[40:52] Gareth Isaac: Gareth.
[40:54] Tori Bullard: Gareth.
[40:55] Gareth Isaac: I could be entirely wrong. Is that Bathing Beauties on the Beach?
[40:57] Tori Bullard: Oh, my heart, it breaks.
[41:00] Gareth Isaac: It's not.
[41:01] Tori Bullard: Is it not?
[41:02] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, I thought so.
[41:03] Tori Bullard: No, it's not.
[41:04] Gareth Isaac: But it might be part of it because it is the enthract.
[41:09] Eliza Gunther: You!
[41:10] Gareth Isaac: You did it again!
[41:11] Tori Bullard: Which again is misleading because next to the on track it does say love never dies.
[41:16] Gareth Isaac: So I thought it was gonna be Love Never Dies Again.
[41:20] Tori Bullard: So I was trying to like stuff you up.
[41:23] Gareth Isaac: And I stuffed you up anyway because it clearly must go into Love Never Dies.
[41:28] Tori Bullard: Hey Gareth, at least we tied, you know, and and You tied.
[41:32] Gareth Isaac: And I really I tried to give you another chance.
[41:34] Tori Bullard: I'm happy to s I'm happy to say I'm not intimately familiar with the score of the show.
[41:40] Gareth Isaac: Me too.
[41:41] Tori Bullard: I'm this is not either of our strong suits, but hey, look, we got some right.
[41:47] Gareth Isaac: I might have had too much help to help me.
[41:50] Tori Bullard: It's fine. We're here. The game happened.
[41:54] Tori Bullard: Alright, so now we're gonna actually move into Love Never Dies.
[41:58] Gareth Isaac: Now before we move on to it, this is the sequel to Phantom of the Opera, of course.
[42:03] Tori Bullard: And let's do another storyline recap for those listening.
[42:06] Gareth Isaac: This is just a little one so that we don't have to go through the whole story. Um, the musical takes place ten years after the first musical where the Phantom invites Christine to New York to sing at the opera.
[42:17] Tori Bullard: But ultimately lost her, her husband Rao, and her child Gustav, to his amusement park, Wonderland, Coney Island to try and win Christine's love again.
[42:27] Gareth Isaac: The show itself did not receive great reviews when it opened, and it went through substantial rewrites before it launched nine months later.
[42:36] Tori Bullard: This version, the new version, had got a lot better reviews, but it didn't really perform at the box office.
[42:44] Gareth Isaac: That's why it's not as big as obviously the Phantom of the Opera.
[42:47] Tori Bullard: What does come as a surprise is that the Melbourne production in Australia had a much better run with a positive reception of the piece.
[42:55] Gareth Isaac: So that's a little bit about Love Never Dies. And as we know, most of us have seen it pretty much The Melbourne production.
[43:03] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, the Melbourne production from the stage with The Show Must Go On.
[43:03] Gareth Isaac: The show must go on, yeah.
[43:09] Tori Bullard: That has been universally decided as the version of Love Never Dies.
[43:14] Gareth Isaac: Everyone likes to pretend the West End didn't exist.
[43:18] Tori Bullard: Like the first director, I believe, was taken off the project after three previews, and then the entire show was reworked with a new director after that.
[43:27] Gareth Isaac: It was then incredibly poorly reviewed, like no one enjoyed it.
[43:32] Eliza Gunther: Yeah.
[43:32] Gareth Isaac: I think half of that comes from the fact that the story that is being told is not one of uh Gaston LaRue's creation.
[43:43] Tori Bullard: Those aren't the same characters essentially.
[43:46] Gareth Isaac: These are characters from a nineteen ninety-seven novel based on the nineteen eighty-six music.
[43:53] Tori Bullard: Okay, so I was gonna say that this would make that Love Never Dies would actually make it kind of a decent book if it was not connected to Phantom.
[44:03] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, well, therein lies the issue, because the novel is called The Phantom of Manhattan. It was written in 1997 and is essentially published fanfiction of the characters from the Phantom of the Opera.
[44:19] Tori Bullard: That makes a lot of sense because I actually was looking up a news article before, and Andrew Lloyd Webber said, I don't regard this as a sequel, it's a standalone play piece.
[44:29] Gareth Isaac: And then he later goes, Clearly it is a sequel, but I really do not believe that you have to see have to have seen Phantom of the Opera to understand Love Never Dies.
[44:38] Tori Bullard: But I don't know if I'd say I disagree.
[44:41] Gareth Isaac: Yeah.
[44:41] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, I vehemently disagree.
[44:43] Gareth Isaac: It is it is a sequel.
[44:45] Tori Bullard: Like you could have made it its own standalone piece, and I think it could have been great as a standalone piece, but it feels like all of the characters have just gone backwards and have started like a g completely again.
[44:58] Gareth Isaac: Except some of them have been so horribly mutilated for one reason or another.
[45:04] Tori Bullard: I think potentially all I think potentially author bias is the problem.
[45:09] Gareth Isaac: Like, for example, the Phantom has not changed, he has learned nothing, he's still all powerful, all controlling, still views Christine as a prize to be won.
[45:17] Tori Bullard: As does Rao.
[45:18] Gareth Isaac: Ral has been horribly character assassinated, can I say?
[45:22] Tori Bullard: I mentioned this a little bit in the first deep dive. He's now been reduced to this alcoholic gambling addict who is using Christine's talent to pay off his debts.
[45:33] Gareth Isaac: Which is awful.
[45:35] Tori Bullard: And I see the issues of control again coming in and Christine being uh pulled this way or the other.
[45:42] Gareth Isaac: Because it is then revealed in all of the marvelous plot spinning glory that Gustav, the child of Christine.
[45:53] Tori Bullard: Spoiler.
[45:54] Gareth Isaac: Is act yep.
[45:55] Tori Bullard: Spoiler.
[45:56] Gareth Isaac: Spoiler, I guess.
[45:58] Tori Bullard: Is actually the Phantom's son?
[46:01] Gareth Isaac: That makes me so mad.
[46:02] Tori Bullard: Like she wouldn't.
[46:04] Gareth Isaac: It makes no sense.
[46:05] Tori Bullard: She would not have gone back.
[46:07] Gareth Isaac: This is a man who traumatized you, kidnapped you, murdered a lot of friends and colleagues of yours, and you still think, you know what, I'm gonna spend one night of passion with him, like roughly before I'm married, and then go and marry someone else.
[46:22] Tori Bullard: Ugh, it makes no sense.
[46:24] Gareth Isaac: I love the drama of it.
[46:25] Eliza Gunther: Oh, yeah, we love the drama.
[46:26] Gareth Isaac: You kidding when it's revealed and you're like, no way.
[46:30] Tori Bullard: And of course, of course Ral doesn't get along with his child the whole time.
[46:35] Gareth Isaac: Of course, it's it's the Phantom's child.
[46:38] Tori Bullard: Okay, as soon as that child walked on stage in that production, I went, oh yeah, Phantom's kid.
[46:43] Gareth Isaac: Obviously.
[46:44] Tori Bullard: I was like, don't know when it happened, but it's the Phantom's kid.
[46:47] Gareth Isaac: Because what other explanation for there is like I would have much preferred if Christine had ended up with Meg.
[46:53] Tori Bullard: And there's another interesting character in this.
[46:56] Gareth Isaac: Meg Jeary, has uh joined up with the Phantom essentially, as he's known in this production, Mr. Y, the mysterious benefactor of Phantasma in Coney Island, which is essentially a freak show where he was born and raised.
[47:09] Tori Bullard: So good work continuing that cycle of abuse, Eric.
[47:12] Gareth Isaac: But Meg is now like the centerpiece. She is the star, she is the singer.
[47:16] Tori Bullard: Until Christine comes back.
[47:18] Gareth Isaac: Until Christine shows up again, and then we have this marvellous little parallel situation.
[47:24] Eliza Gunther: I think watching this show, really, I found this is controversial, but I actually really enjoyed watching it the Melbourne production.
[47:34] Gareth Isaac: Because I thought it was quite spectacular.
[47:37] Eliza Gunther: Like I really enjoy it, especially that scene where the Phantom takes Gustave um into like mirrors.
[47:45] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, the mirror scene.
[47:46] Eliza Gunther: I find that is quite spectacular.
[47:49] Gareth Isaac: There are really amazing moments, but then you're like confused at the same time.
[47:53] Eliza Gunther: You're like, do I really love this? Or like, do I?
[47:56] Gareth Isaac: Like I I agree.
[47:59] Eliza Gunther: Visually, it was beautiful.
[48:02] Tori Bullard: And like the costuming, the set.
[48:04] Gareth Isaac: I think if you could look if you could look at the story based around the set and what you can see rather than the actual story itself and the music, I would have loved it so much more.
[48:17] Eliza Gunther: But then you're sitting there going, wait, when did Rao turn into this person?
[48:21] Gareth Isaac: He was kind of decent in Phantom.
[48:24] Eliza Gunther: And didn't Phantom let them go because he knew she didn't love like what?
[48:29] Gareth Isaac: Like, I was like, I feel like everyone's like taken like ten steps back, and their characters have taken a massive U-turn.
[48:39] Tori Bullard: I was like, Christine would not have gone back and had a one-night stand with Phantom.
[48:43] Gareth Isaac: Like, she would not have done that.
[48:45] Eliza Gunther: Exactly.
[48:46] Gareth Isaac: And, you know, spoilers again, this is just further proof that no one is writing Christine Dae as Christine Dae.
[48:54] Tori Bullard: She is being written as a prop to further the interests and emotional growth of these two men.
[49:01] Gareth Isaac: And again, spoilers for the end of the show, she is ultimately shot dead during a confrontation between the Phantom and Rao.
[49:09] Tori Bullard: And then she lies there singing Love Never Dies.
[49:12] Gareth Isaac: Saying, I love you, Phantom, and then she dies.
[49:16] Tori Bullard: That's it.
[49:17] Gareth Isaac: It's such a and then the kid goes with Phantom, and that's that's Yes.
[49:21] Tori Bullard: Yeah, it's such a terrible ending.
[49:23] Gareth Isaac: But like, doesn't like Rao give Gustave to the Phantom as like kind of like a you'd be a better father.
[49:28] Tori Bullard: And I'm like, well, I don't know if that'd be true.
[49:30] Gareth Isaac: I honestly think this child would be better off with Madame Jiri, because you're both pretty bad people at this point.
[49:36] Tori Bullard: I think the child would be better off just going off to a boarding school or something.
[49:39] Gareth Isaac: Give him the Hogwarts treatment at this point.
[49:46] Tori Bullard: Hey, he might have magical powers, because uh the the Phantom has mass magical powers.
[49:52] Gareth Isaac: So um yeah, he's the product of the Warlock Pact.
[49:56] Tori Bullard: Maybe actually he goes to Hogwarts later in life.
[50:00] Gareth Isaac: And that boy grew up to be Alba's Dumbledore.
[50:04] Eliza Gunther: Oh, speaking of time period, like that's another thing that irks me about the show.
[50:09] Gareth Isaac: Phantom of the Opera, 1887.
[50:12] Eliza Gunther: Love never dies. 1901.
[50:14] Gareth Isaac: Andrew Led Weber has stated that it sets it's set ten years after Phantom.
[50:21] Eliza Gunther: Yes.
[50:22] Gareth Isaac: It's clearly not.
[50:23] Eliza Gunther: That is roughly 26 years or something.
[50:26] Gareth Isaac: Well, Phantom I'm not Phantom. Christine looks good for her age.
[50:30] Eliza Gunther: Damn.
[50:31] Gareth Isaac: It's a temporally impossible time period.
[50:34] Eliza Gunther: They're like, it's fine, we're just gonna change the time period completely so that we can have the circus that came in with the 19th century.
[50:41] Gareth Isaac: Um, and then we're just we're just gonna change it up here.
[50:46] Eliza Gunther: That's crazy.
[50:48] Gareth Isaac: And it's so interesting the setting of Coney Island.
[50:52] Eliza Gunther: Like, why a why a circus?
[50:55] Gareth Isaac: Why Coney Island?
[50:57] Eliza Gunther: Like Phantom, I understand that he had this backstory.
[51:00] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, that's probably the entire reason.
[51:02] Eliza Gunther: Just the Phantom's backstory of being in a traveling circus when he was young and being part of a freak show.
[51:08] Gareth Isaac: Well, he's just he's just a very rich um businessman who's made some obviously great decisions with his locations.
[51:16] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, the fan the Phantom invested in Regency GameStop.
[51:19] Gareth Isaac: It's fine.
[51:20] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, exactly.
[51:21] Gareth Isaac: And I think that actually having it set in a completely different location was kind of good.
[51:28] Eliza Gunther: And I liked the circus element.
[51:29] Gareth Isaac: I think I really like because obviously the first bit, it's like opera.
[51:33] Eliza Gunther: You don't want to copy the exact location, the exact everything, because it's not as interesting.
[51:38] Gareth Isaac: So bringing in this new element of like circus and um theme park and amusement.
[51:44] Eliza Gunther: It's kind of it kind of adds like a really nice life to the piece, and I think that that it acts as another character.
[51:50] Gareth Isaac: Like the like the chandelier does in the first one.
[51:53] Eliza Gunther: It acts as a character.
[51:55] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, I think therein lies what Love Never Dies was trying to do with its set was create its own identity, set itself so far apart from Phantom that it could not be compared and would be based solely on its own merits.
[52:10] Tori Bullard: Like Lloyd Webber said, he wanted people to be able to see Love Never Dies without having seen Phantom.
[52:15] Gareth Isaac: But therein lies the problem. You're so intrinsically tied to it.
[52:19] Tori Bullard: So this the set was beautiful. The design was beautiful.
[52:21] Gareth Isaac: Melbourne's direction, Simon Phillips is brilliant. I will be saying that till the day I die. The man's a genius.
[52:28] Tori Bullard: Amazing.
[52:29] Gareth Isaac: But like you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear, unfortunately.
[52:33] Tori Bullard: If the libretto looked as good as the set, they would have been fine.
[52:36] Gareth Isaac: Well, that was really interesting having a chat today about Phantom and Love Never Dies.
[52:41] Eliza Gunther: I hope you guys have enjoyed this episode and enjoyed everything we got to chat about today.
[52:46] Gareth Isaac: I would just like to say thank you for bringing me on.
[52:49] Tori Bullard: Thank you for being here.
[52:51] Gareth Isaac: And I'm so thrilled that I'm gonna be joining you on more of these deep dives.
[52:54] Eliza Gunther: It's a lovely little flex of the old musical theatre brain.
[52:58] Gareth Isaac: And it's nice to be doing it with such wonderful people.
[53:00] Tori Bullard: It's great to have a good argument over characters.
[53:03] Eliza Gunther: Thank you, Gareth, for joining us once again.
[53:05] Tori Bullard: I know you've just thanked us, but we'll thank you right back.
[53:08] Eliza Gunther: But yes, thank you so so much for listening.
[53:10] Tori Bullard: As per usual, if you could please leave us a rate and review on Apple Podcasts, that helps us out the most.
[53:17] Eliza Gunther: We will also be doing a poll over on our Instagram stories for our next deep dive.
[53:22] Tori Bullard: So you guys are gonna be helping us pick what we talk about next.
[53:25] Eliza Gunther: So if you head over there right now, the poll is already up on our stories.
[53:29] Tori Bullard: We'll have about six options for you to choose from, and then we'll have a little bit of like a final showdown.
[53:35] Eliza Gunther: But anyway, you guys, until next time, stay happy, healthy, and safe, and we will see you then.
[53:41] Tori Bullard: Bye!
[53:42] Eliza Gunther: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
