Skip to main content
BPN Logo
To The Opera!

In this weeks episode Tori and Eliza are joined by Gareth Isaac to talk all things Phantom Of The Opera!.. Read More

From the show: Stage Door Podcast

56 mins
5/12/21

Guests

Featured Shows

About

In this weeks episode Tori and Eliza are joined by Gareth Isaac to talk all things Phantom Of The Opera! Together in the much awaited return of Deep Dives, the three discuss the current state of the show on the West End following the announcement by Cameron Mackintosh some "changes" are to be made to a number of aspects of the show, the opulence of the design, character choices, the importance of a live orchestra and more!

Resources and suggestions from the episode:
- Tickets for The Removalists at The New Theatre


Leave us a rate and review, and let us know what you’d love to hear in our next episode on our Instagram @ps.stagedoorpod or via our email at ps.stagedoor.podcast@gmail.com

Created, Edited and Produced by Victoria Bullard & Elizabeth Gunther

Music by Catherine Gunther

https://www.psstagedoorpodcast.com/

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Eliza Gunther: Hello everyone and welcome back to Stage Door Podcast.

[0:08] Gareth Isaac: Today we are bringing back deep dives, but before we get into that, Tori take it away with the bulletin.

[0:16] Tori Bullard: Hi guys, Gareth here.

[0:18] Gareth Isaac: Unfortunately, due to technical difficulties, Tori can't join me for this one. But not a worry, we're still ready, willing, and able to give you our full review of the New Theatre's production of David Williamson's The Removalists.

[0:30] Gareth Isaac: Now, this is a classic piece of Australian theatre that many of us may recognise from our days of HSC drama, but for those who don't know, the story follows two police officers in Melbourne, one fresh-faced new recruit and one grizzled sergeant, assisting a woman and her sister safely move out of a violent home and the violent relationship therein.

[0:49] Gareth Isaac: What follows is an examination of the microcosm of 1970s Australia, systems of power, the bystander effect, and the most frightening aspects of what we would now call toxic masculinity.

[1:01] Gareth Isaac: Thematically, the piece is still as relevant today as when it was written. The concept of power imbalance in relationships, the continued cycle of abuse that women face from systems designed and maintained by men, and the ease in which these systems are maintained, all of this remain constant, even 50 years after the play's writing and first performance.

[1:20] Gareth Isaac: One wonders whether we should applaud David Williamson's foresight or be terrified at the implications this has for our society.

[1:28] Gareth Isaac: In terms of casting, Lloyd Allison Young as the impressionable Constable Ross is a prime example of a new police recruit, quickly drawn into a system that brings out the worst in both police and men.

[1:39] Gareth Isaac: Lawrence Coy as Sergeant Simmons cuts an imposing figure of a man who knows exactly what control feels like and how to maintain it in any situation.

[1:47] Gareth Isaac: But unfortunately, the effect wears thin after a hundred minutes of what can be described as shouty vocal usage.

[1:53] Gareth Isaac: Eliza Nichols and Shannon Ryan play their parts as Fiona and Kate to a T, and Xavier Coy's detached removalist is a stark, frank reflection of the bystander mentality in both his reactions and his work ethic.

[2:06] Gareth Isaac: In terms of standout actors, the casting choice of Alfie Gledill as Kenny Carter not only allows his natural talent for detailed craftsmanship to come through, but it also raised a remarkable theme that Williamson did not address in his breakthrough piece: the casual approach of violence towards people of colour by the police force.

[2:24] Gareth Isaac: In a stark 30 seconds to a minute of police brutality, the audience is shocked into total silence as an act of sheer unadulterated violence and extreme force is committed against Carter, starkly reminiscent of the 2020 murder of George Floyd.

[2:40] Gareth Isaac: The audience's silence mimicking that of the titular removalist, whose only care is the truck he runs, raising the question of how should we react when faced with such a blatant crime, the question being especially prevalent when the victim has been shown to be nothing but an aggressive domestic abuser for the last ninety minutes.

[2:56] Gareth Isaac: The questions raised by the piece are still unanswered. The New Theatre's production of The Removalists is running from now until the 22nd of May.

[3:04] Gareth Isaac: For tickets, head to New Theatre.org.au slash the removalists. We would also like to add it may be wise to research trigger warnings before attending the production.

[3:13] Eliza Gunther: And now, back over to Eliza for the rest of the show.

[3:16] Eliza Gunther: Before we start today's episode, we would like to acknowledge the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation, the traditional custodians of this land on which we work, live, and record, and recognise their continuing connection to land, water, and community.

[3:30] Eliza Gunther: We pay respects to elders past, present, and emerging.

[3:34] Eliza Gunther: There is no better way to start off 2021 than with a deep dive chatting all things Phantom of the Opera.

[3:42] Eliza Gunther: We are very excited to announce Gareth Isaac will be coming on board as a regular co-host for our deep dives, alongside being our resident Sydney reviewer alongside Tori while I'm in Brisbane.

[3:55] Eliza Gunther: Let's bring to the mic Gareth.

[3:57] Gareth Isaac: Tell the audience I really shouldn't do this when there's not food in my mouth.

[4:00] Eliza Gunther: Hang on.

[4:02] Gareth Isaac: Keep it in, keep it in. Bear in mind, it's eight o'clock in the morning here, so we're all gonna do it in our crumpets.

[4:10] Eliza Gunther: Speak for yourself.

[4:11] Gareth Isaac: I'm fine. We're doing this early because I have to get my COVID vaccine, so get that jab of science juice into you.

[4:18] Gareth Isaac: Um yes, hello, Tori and Lydia, thank you guys so much for having me back on the podcast.

[4:25] Gareth Isaac: If you want to know more about me, listen to season one episode 15 of Stage Door Pod, and I do my whole life with this.

[4:32] Eliza Gunther: You know which episode it is.

[4:34] Gareth Isaac: Of course I do. What do you think I came in unprepared? That's nonsense.

[4:39] Gareth Isaac: Um, but yes, hello to everyone listening to Stage Door Pod. I'm Gareth Isaac. I am a musical theatre performer, actor, singer, writer, dancer if the money's good, as I leave on my bio.

[4:51] Gareth Isaac: I performed in a play called Puffs. I toured the East Coast of Australia with that and took out a best actor award. Thank you, Tori. That's I obnoxiously loud on these headphones.

[5:02] Gareth Isaac: Um, long story short, I am an avid lover of all things musicals. It's my career, it's my heart, it's my joy, and I'm so thrilled to be doing this deep dive with you and to be coming on board as your one of your resident Sydney reviewers.

[5:20] Eliza Gunther: We are absolutely thrilled to have you, because honestly, uh, we've had some great chats about theatre, and we've um actually Gareth recently has been doing his master's in voice and had the opportunity at NIDA, but had the opportunity to come to the Queensland Con and shadow one of the voice teachers up there, which actually happened to be my voice teacher.

[5:42] Eliza Gunther: So Gareth and I were at the con in the same classes, which was awesome.

[5:47] Gareth Isaac: Well, you were in the class. I sat in the corner and took notes on everyone's voice usage and what the teacher was doing.

[5:54] Gareth Isaac: So, you know, kind of a different experience.

[5:57] Eliza Gunther: And I was here in Sydney by myself.

[6:00] Gareth Isaac: Oh, Gorye. Way to make us feel bad.

[6:02] Eliza Gunther: Hold on, break out the violins, thank you.

[6:06] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, I need a tiny violin thing.

[6:10] Eliza Gunther: Alright. So now that we've all established that we're running on fumes, shall we shall we kick off?

[6:17] Gareth Isaac: Yeah.

[6:17] Eliza Gunther: Well, before we get started today, we thought we'd give a short recap of the storyline and some information on Phantom.

[6:25] Gareth Isaac: Just because, you know, if you don't know it, well, you should. Uh, but in case you don't.

[6:30] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, spoilers for 1986 coming up, guys.

[6:33] Gareth Isaac: Yep. The Phantom of the Opera with music by Andrew Lloyd Webber, lyrics by Charles Hart and Libretto by Lloyd Webber and Richard Stilgoe, is based on the 1910 horror novel by Gaston LaRue.

[6:47] Gareth Isaac: The Phantom of the Opera is a romantic and thrilling story of the legendary Phantom, a musical genius who dwells deep beneath a majestic opera house in Paris.

[6:56] Gareth Isaac: The Phantom is shunned by society for his horrifying facial deformity. He takes a promising young soprano, Christine, under his wing and grooms her for operatic fame, all the while falling deeply in love with her.

[7:09] Gareth Isaac: As Christine grows ever more successful, and a handsome young man from her past begins to successfully court her, the Phantom descends into a jealous rage and terrorizes the opera company with increasingly dangerous threats.

[7:24] Gareth Isaac: Andrew Lloyd Webber's score soars with such famous tunes as Think of Me and All I Ask Of You, The Music of the Night, and the title song The Phantom of the Opera.

[7:35] Gareth Isaac: And Phantom has gone on to become one of the most successful musicals of all time.

[7:40] Gareth Isaac: When originally creating Phantom, Macintosh and Lloyd Webber looked at films based on the 1910 French horror serial novel, but found no real inspiration for a musical on the subject until finding an actual copy of the out-of-print novel in a bookshop.

[7:56] Gareth Isaac: There was already a musical based on this novel by Ken Hill in 1976, who Lloyd Webber actually collaborated with on Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat.

[8:06] Gareth Isaac: This version of the musical utilized actual classical operatic songs written by Offenbach, Verdi, and Dvorak with original English lyrics to tell the story of the novel.

[8:16] Gareth Isaac: Hill was ultimately approached by Macintosh and Lloyd Webber to work on their version of Phantom, but the project ultimately went ahead without him.

[8:24] Eliza Gunther: Ooh.

[8:25] Gareth Isaac: Well, just like stop you, we're going out with this, sorry.

[8:29] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, I think that was ultimately it. Maybe Hill just didn't want to be involved in saying, Oh, I don't want to rewrite my piece with Andrew.

[8:38] Gareth Isaac: That's not my vision.

[8:40] Gareth Isaac: Although a very little fun fact, Sarah Brightman, the original Christine and Andrew Lloyd Webber's now ex-wife, was actually approached for the role of Christine in Hill's 76 Phantom.

[8:53] Eliza Gunther: I thought it was so funny because um, you know, she's a bit of the muse behind it.

[8:59] Gareth Isaac: Is she the muse behind uh the other one?

[9:01] Eliza Gunther: No, I I don't think so.

[9:04] Gareth Isaac: I think Miss Brightman has a certain amount of honour behind her.

[9:09] Eliza Gunther: She was like, for you, no, but for you.

[9:13] Gareth Isaac: For this tiny weasel man, yes.

[9:15] Eliza Gunther: What who said that?

[9:16] Gareth Isaac: Oh, it's I got some hot takes on Phantom. You've picked the right person for this deep dive.

[9:22] Eliza Gunther: I know, I was gonna say, so when we approached Gareth, and I was like, okay, so what musical pops out to you as being like the one that you would love to do first? And he was like, Phantom of the Opera.

[9:31] Gareth Isaac: We didn't just approach Gareth just about doing Phantom of the Opera.

[9:37] Eliza Gunther: And I'm sure it's already been made clear, but we actually approached Gareth as coming on to do deep dives is having that third voice. It's also nice having um a male perspective as well.

[9:47] Gareth Isaac: Not that we always necessarily think differently, but it's just nice.

[9:51] Eliza Gunther: Libby and Gareth spoke, yeah, while they were in Queensland. Eliza came back to me and said, Um, oh Gareth really loves Phantom of the Opera. And it was like, well then that's the that that's a you know, that's where we're going. That's what we've got to do.

[10:04] Gareth Isaac: What we're doing.

[10:06] Gareth Isaac: And I do just enjoy that the the fact the only point I think I've made in this document so far is that Raoul deserved better.

[10:13] Eliza Gunther: That is Yes, indeed.

[10:16] Gareth Isaac: The rest is all just me um splurging my knowledge of this musical. It is top three for me. I utterly adore it. It's only pipped by the Pirates of Penzance, which maybe we'll deep dive later, who knows.

[10:30] Gareth Isaac: Um, but I feel Phantom does have a remarkable amount of uh current prevalence and relevance to the theatrical uh world, and especially in Australia at the minute, because it's gonna be one of Opera Australia's first big shows coming back.

[10:46] Eliza Gunther: So it's nice to talk about it and see where it's come from, where it's going, and ultimately why people enjoy it so much and why it's coming back in the first place.

[10:54] Gareth Isaac: Yeah. Um Yeah, I'm really interested about that production because um, like you said, they're they're revamping a few things in the West End version, and possibly in Australia.

[11:08] Eliza Gunther: Oh yes, we shall get to that. Don't you worry, my dear. That is go that is that is going to be approached.

[11:16] Gareth Isaac: We're kind of gonna let uh Gareth take a lead for these episodes. Obviously, we all have strong opinions, so I will um rebuttal whenever I feel like it, but we are gonna.

[11:27] Gareth Isaac: Oh no, no, please jump jump in when you need to, because I will not stop.

[11:34] Eliza Gunther: We're like, we've got an hour, guys. I've got four.

[11:36] Gareth Isaac: Let's jump on in, starting with one of my favourite parts of this musical, the composition.

[11:46] Gareth Isaac: It's not without its controversy, but let's start with the positives. Uh Lloyd Webber emulated the styles of a bunch of different operatic composers, such as Milbea, Mozart, uh even Gilbert and Sullivan operettas in the creation of Phantom.

[11:59] Gareth Isaac: Lloyd Webber, not being a lyricist himself, originally approached the now late great Jim Steinman to write lyrics for the show. So this was the man behind Meatloaf's Bat Out of Hell and a lot of fantastic classic rock albums.

[12:13] Gareth Isaac: But unfortunately, Jim turned down the offer as he was working on a Bonnie Tyler album at the time. And then Lloyd Webber, okay, let's shift left, approached Alan J. Lerner as in Lerner and Low, as in My Fair Lady.

[12:28] Gareth Isaac: This gentleman contributed to the show as well, most notably the entirety of the song Masquerade, but withdrew from the production due to illness and went entirely uncredited for his efforts.

[12:39] Gareth Isaac: I find that ridiculous because come on. Like Masquerade is one of the best bits of Phantom.

[12:47] Gareth Isaac: Like, I love Masquerade. Like most notable. It's one of the strongest Act 2 openers in the industry.

[12:56] Gareth Isaac: I have to give it that label. If only because the minute that curtain rises and you see the sheer opulence of the design of the costuming of all the masks, the audience can't do anything but gasp and clap.

[13:11] Gareth Isaac: How many other shows that you know can do that?

[13:14] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, no, I think that that's all I can think of is, and of course, it being like 8:30 in the morning, my brain can't think of what it is.

[13:22] Eliza Gunther: The only thing that I can think that kind of is as exciting, but it's also a much slower excitement is, uh, is it 42nd Street with the curtain slowly rising?

[13:31] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, and you can see all the tap shoes underneath the, but even then that's more of like a slow burn, it's like a, you know, it's like a slow excitement.

[13:40] Eliza Gunther: Whereas for Phantom, the curtain opens and you're just confronted by the beautiful costumes, the amazing staging and set design, and just those voices pretty much start straight away.

[13:53] Eliza Gunther: 42nd Street I can compare to the slow cabaret fans where you're slowly revealing the girl.

[13:59] Gareth Isaac: Phantom is just like boom, the robes off, here we are.

[14:02] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, you you can do nothing but appreciate, I suppose.

[14:04] Gareth Isaac: I do love that they uh that he that Andrew Lloyd Webber reached out to Jim Steinman because that's just I didn't know that previous to now, but that makes so much sense when thinking of especially like Phantom of the Opera.

[14:18] Eliza Gunther: Um thinking of the like the the style and like the rock kind of essence that it has, but I would also would love to hear what it would have been like if he had have come on board.

[14:28] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, I feel like Steinman's input would have really changed the end product, given his dark gothic nature, his love of rock and roll, he would have had something to say about all the instrumentation of the piece.

[14:39] Eliza Gunther: It would have been insane.

[14:40] Gareth Isaac: But you know, respect to Steinman for sticking with Bonnie Tyler, because apparently that album was amazing, and respect to Mr. Lerner for doing Masquerade.

[14:49] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, these two weren't the only guys that we uh Lloyd Webber approached.

[14:54] Gareth Isaac: Uh we mentioned Richard Stilgoe in the introduction, who wrote most of the original songs for the show, but all of these were then reworked by Charles Hart, who was a favoured lyricist of Lloyd Webber and Mackintosh, who later went on to write all the lyrics for Aspects of Love.

[15:08] Eliza Gunther: A lot of Stilgoe's contributions lie in the spoken libretto sections, which are ultimately few and far between in a very sung-through show like this.

[15:17] Gareth Isaac: Yeah.

[15:17] Eliza Gunther: Well, exactly.

[15:18] Gareth Isaac: There's not a lot of dialogue within the show at all.

[15:21] Eliza Gunther: It's mostly music.

[15:23] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, which I think was the style at the time, because of course this was the same era as Les Misérables, the Evitas, the Starlight Expresses.

[15:33] Eliza Gunther: It was everything was sung through at this point.

[15:36] Gareth Isaac: I think we just got tired of words and needed emotion.

[15:39] Eliza Gunther: Oh, too right.

[15:40] Gareth Isaac: Too right.

[15:41] Eliza Gunther: And this is definitely I I would say that that um sung-through style of show is kind of on the way.

[15:50] Gareth Isaac: You know, obviously we have a lot more of c much more contemporary shows now, which are quite dialogue intensive.

[15:57] Eliza Gunther: Um intensive, intense, I don't know, English is hard.

[16:00] Gareth Isaac: Um, but I feel like that sung-through style of show is starting to come back purely just from my personal experience in what I'm currently working on.

[16:08] Eliza Gunther: That and I see I really quite enjoy sung-through shows because sometimes with a show, there's just a bit too much dialogue.

[16:15] Gareth Isaac: And I'm just like, you know, a musical is kind of that whole thing of the emotion is too intense for words.

[16:23] Eliza Gunther: That's the entire point of musicals, is that there is literally no other way for a person to communicate their ideas and their thoughts and their emotions.

[16:30] Gareth Isaac: I think dialogue in musicals is necessary.

[16:33] Eliza Gunther: I mean, it's the entire reason the industry exists.

[16:36] Gareth Isaac: I mean, Oklahoma first book musical spawned a revolution from the Gilbert and Sullivan operetta era.

[16:42] Eliza Gunther: But yeah, I think things are falling backwards now, and we're losing a lot of dialogue, and even from the eighties to now, there's a lot of musicals that are just straight sung through, and they're very fucking cool.

[16:53] Gareth Isaac: We all agree.

[16:55] Eliza Gunther: We all agree this is a not this is not an argumentative podcast at all.

[17:00] Gareth Isaac: Um no, no, no.

[17:02] Eliza Gunther: We're not turning into we're not going full Joe Rogan experience yet.

[17:05] Gareth Isaac: So we uh we talked about the composition.

[17:08] Eliza Gunther: Other than that, this show seemed to bring together a powerhouse of production team members.

[17:14] Gareth Isaac: Direction was by the legendary Hal Prince, now past.

[17:17] Eliza Gunther: Choreography by Gillian Lynn, aka the genius behind every movement in Cats, also now deceased.

[17:24] Gareth Isaac: And the design and the costuming that we mentioned earlier was by the late Maria Bjornson.

[17:28] Eliza Gunther: Please note this that three of these production members responsible for so many iconic moments of this production have now passed.

[17:39] Gareth Isaac: It's a damn shame.

[17:41] Eliza Gunther: But that just shows you how long this show has been going on for.

[17:44] Gareth Isaac: Oh, I was just gonna say it was really interesting because when I was doing a little bit of research for um for this episode, we I looked into more of the costume set things because I thought, like for me, Phantom is just so spectacular in and it stands out because of that reason.

[18:04] Eliza Gunther: Like people go to see this show purely for like the opulence of how beautiful the set and costume are because they are like incredible.

[18:13] Gareth Isaac: And Sam Fleming, who was like the current uh in he a head of like costume and everything at Phantom, she said that Beyond Beyoncé was interested in developing the show, and over time that they had done five different new sculptures for the Phantom Market mask itself because she kept wanting it to be more interesting.

[18:33] Eliza Gunther: And she also said that I'm sure if Maria was alive today, she'd still be improving the show because she was that kind of person.

[18:40] Gareth Isaac: And I think that's exactly what Phantom is.

[18:42] Eliza Gunther: Oh goodness, yes.

[18:42] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, you know what I mean?

[18:43] Eliza Gunther: Like Phantom is ever, ever evolving, and the costume and set, I feel like it almost evolves over time, especially the mask.

[18:53] Gareth Isaac: Like there's so many versions of that mask.

[18:55] Eliza Gunther: Um, every Phantom mask has to be moulded to the face of the current Phantom or the swings.

[19:01] Gareth Isaac: If anyone else were to wear it, it would actually ruin the moulding, and that would cost hundreds and hundreds of dollars to get it fixed.

[19:08] Eliza Gunther: One mask.

[19:09] Gareth Isaac: While we're on the mask, actually, you've seen the classic two-sided mask on the uh all the promotional material for Phantom, but the Phantom only wears half a mask in the production.

[19:20] Eliza Gunther: This is purely because during the original workshops, Colin Wilkinson, aka Jean Valjean, uh, was workshopping Phantom with Lloyd Webber, and because he was wearing the traditional two-sided mask that covered most of his face, no one could hear a damn word he was saying.

[19:37] Gareth Isaac: Oh that's lit literally it.

[19:40] Eliza Gunther: But I also think it is far more interesting, and I'm gonna have a point in a second about the set design.

[19:45] Gareth Isaac: Um I think it's far more interesting having half because I feel like it's almost easier just to go with a full face mask, like it would make like life for everyone so much easier in terms of like that's that, you know, it's it's covering the full face.

[20:02] Eliza Gunther: Whereas having that half-face, also the way that throughout the show, he almost becomes it's not necessarily it becomes more deformed, but the the bits that are hiding the deformity become less and less and less.

[20:17] Gareth Isaac: But I feel like if you had a full face mask, there's less opportunity for, you know, ripping it away from his face would be have a completely different meaning.

[20:27] Eliza Gunther: Also wouldn't get to see any of that emotion having a full face mask.

[20:31] Gareth Isaac: I think it would such I'm so glad that it doesn't work, having a full face mask.

[20:36] Eliza Gunther: Well, considering that uh stage phantom's deformity was rewritten from the original novel's deformity, like um, it's distinctly less deformed than it was in the novel.

[20:49] Gareth Isaac: In the novel Eric, which is the Phantom's name, and that pertains in some of the material of the show, but never mind, that's beside the point.

[21:00] Eliza Gunther: Um he is missing he is missing his entire nose.

[21:05] Gareth Isaac: He basically has no eyelids, nothing from the forehead.

[21:08] Eliza Gunther: Voldemort?

[21:09] Gareth Isaac: Oh, yeah, pretty much.

[21:10] Eliza Gunther: He is he's basically Voldemort with musical ability.

[21:13] Gareth Isaac: Oh my god.

[21:14] Eliza Gunther: Oh no, now that's all I can picture.

[21:17] Gareth Isaac: A love story about Voldemort.

[21:19] Eliza Gunther: We love that.

[21:21] Gareth Isaac: I'm pretty sure that exists in some fanfiction website deep within the bowels of the internet.

[21:27] Eliza Gunther: Um but yeah, they just reduced the size of the mask and reduced su the deformity to such an extent that the actor could actually be heard, and I assume hairline microphones wouldn't have been a thing because all the wigging and prosthesis involved.

[21:41] Gareth Isaac: It it's it's a lot.

[21:42] Eliza Gunther: It's a big process.

[21:43] Gareth Isaac: Um I can only imagine if the deform if they had kept kind of like full face deformity, how much extra time for special effects makeup and all that kind of stuff.

[21:54] Eliza Gunther: But I do want to I want to take a step back to what um Eliza said previously about how people not only do they go to see Phantom because it is, you know, one of the most iconic musicals of all time, um, but also because of the spectacle of the show.

[22:11] Gareth Isaac: Now we've been having a conversation recently in a class that I'm taking, and I there's someone in particular I don't quite agree with when they say that theatre has become too much about the spectacle.

[22:22] Eliza Gunther: Now don't get me wrong, there are some shows that I do occasionally see where I'm like, uh, you know, the the the set design can occasionally take away from the acting and such, but I don't often personally think so.

[22:37] Gareth Isaac: It's there to contribute to what is happening on stage.

[22:43] Eliza Gunther: And I have heard, like, a Phantom of the Opera was specifically an example that this person that I was having this discussion with used.

[22:51] Gareth Isaac: Don't forget, it's set in Paris in a beautiful opera house.

[22:56] Eliza Gunther: Of course it's gonna be opulent and a little bit over the top, and even then, I think the set is still quite minimal for what they could do if they really wanted to.

[23:06] Gareth Isaac: Having all of those pieces tells a part of the story, and I feel like if you were to take that away, like, yes, of course, the the scoring and the actors and everything are still amazing, and so are the songs, but that plays a part in the story.

[23:22] Eliza Gunther: Like, for example, like for something like Frozen, the set still plays a part in the story, and I think that that should never be like taken for granted.

[23:31] Gareth Isaac: Because if you were to take that all away, yes, the show would still be good, but there would be something missing.

[23:35] Eliza Gunther: Oh, it's and so I think that like, yes, it is definitely like a spectacle to have you know, the chandelier especially was spoken about as being unnecessary, and I was like, well, please don't buy but like that's part of the reason that I see the show to begin with, because that is such an important part of the story.

[23:57] Gareth Isaac: It's so important.

[23:59] Eliza Gunther: Like, I remember sitting in the Majestic Theatre on Broadway watching that chandelier go up.

[24:03] Gareth Isaac: I was like, Oh yes, this is what I'm here for.

[24:06] Eliza Gunther: This is delightful.

[24:08] Gareth Isaac: And it was aided and made necessary by the scoring that was playing as it rose into the air.

[24:15] Eliza Gunther: Yep, and that's that's what you get with a Lloyd Webber show.

[24:18] Gareth Isaac: And I think it's also about like for centuries now, ever since you look at how how theatre originated and you look at how it's gone, theatre is also supposed to be for entertainment, and part of that is sets and costumes.

[24:18] Eliza Gunther: Part of that is the spectacle.

[24:37] Gareth Isaac: Like people want to go to the theatre and see something that is not a part of their everyday life.

[24:42] Eliza Gunther: They want to be transported into a world that is that is so different from their own.

[24:48] Gareth Isaac: That is in Paris at the opera, and they want to see what that's like, and they want to they want to transport themselves without having to go all the way to Paris or be in an opera house at that period of time.

[24:58] Eliza Gunther: They want to bring it to them and live it on stage, you know?

[25:03] Gareth Isaac: Exactly.

[25:04] Eliza Gunther: And I think that right now as well, there is such this thing, and I think there's nothing wrong with having a message in your show.

[25:10] Gareth Isaac: Like you look at things like Jagged Little Pill has a lot of um imagery and a lot of messages throughout that show, but they don't, it's not in a way where you leave like, oh wow, that's that's heavy.

[25:22] Eliza Gunther: Like you definitely still leave with that thing, and like even Phantom still has a really strong message about it.

[25:28] Gareth Isaac: But I find that some of these people that are saying that uh theatre has become too like opulent or anything, like yes, you can strip back shows, like look at things like I've seen a production of Bright Star where it was pretty much just the one set piece, and it was still fantabulous, fantastic.

[25:45] Eliza Gunther: You're all you're allowed to make up words, it's your point.

[25:47] Gareth Isaac: Fantabulous.

[25:49] Eliza Gunther: Fan dabby does it.

[25:51] Gareth Isaac: But that particular show allows for that.

[25:54] Eliza Gunther: Whereas things like Phantom, Frozen, 42nd Street, like that's part of the experience of theatre, and people do need to keep remembering that theatre is there for entertainment.

[26:05] Gareth Isaac: We're there to entertain, we are there to, like you said, Eliza, be taken into this world.

[26:12] Eliza Gunther: And when there's no set there, or very minimal set, it feels so much more just like you're just like watching a bunch of people up on stage sing, which is obviously what you're doing.

[26:22] Gareth Isaac: But you want to be a part of that world that they themselves are in.

[26:27] Eliza Gunther: So I think that it's you know important to to keep that in mind because having that whole conversation, I was like, yes, but theatre is not just purely about having a message.

[26:36] Gareth Isaac: Like I know that that is a big thing, I don't want to say trend, but at the moment, so many people when writing things are like, so what's like the hard-hitting thing that I'm trying to say?

[26:46] Eliza Gunther: And I'm like, well, you don't you don't always necessarily have to have that.

[26:49] Gareth Isaac: If you want to write a piece where people just sit there and enjoy their time, that's okay too.

[26:53] Eliza Gunther: That's what theater is.

[26:55] Gareth Isaac: And the romance and the design of Phantom is clearly one audiences over for years and years.

[27:01] Eliza Gunther: I mean, look at everything it's done.

[27:03] Gareth Isaac: Like the original West End versions got two Olivier Awards, the Broadway run won seven of the ten Tonies it was nominated for.

[27:11] Eliza Gunther: That's not a bad bloody ratio.

[27:13] Gareth Isaac: And the West End production before the year that was 2020 was the third longest-running show on the West End after The Mousetrap, and the second longest-running musical after Les Misérables.

[27:23] Eliza Gunther: Like it's clearly doing it's doing something right on Broadway.

[27:27] Gareth Isaac: It's the longest-running musical.

[27:29] Eliza Gunther: It's hit 10,000 performances.

[27:32] Gareth Isaac: It's insane.

[27:34] Eliza Gunther: And I think I don't I don't think I've done anything in my life 10,000 times.

[27:37] Gareth Isaac: Oh no, now I'm questioning everything.

[27:39] Eliza Gunther: Let's not get into that.

[27:40] Gareth Isaac: Oh god.

[27:41] Eliza Gunther: Um, I think, yeah, and I think rightly so that it is still on Broadway. There are certainly shows that I wish were still playing, like that I wish never had to leave Broadway, but at the same time, they kind of have their time.

[27:54] Gareth Isaac: Whereas Phantom, the way that they keep casting and and they keep, you know, you know, costumes will never completely change, but they'll change slightly.

[28:02] Gareth Isaac: There'll be little things that kind of change along the way because they are, and the way that I feel Maria has kind of designed like the physical side of the show, allows for it to grow with time and have those changes. It's never going to be made, you know, minimalistic or anything like that. But it is allowing it to grow and change with time and as the cast change and as the orchestra changes and things like that. And as the story does take on new meaning over time, just naturally, as with any show, like you know, stuff happens like 2020, like COVID. There are gonna be those little aspects that you kind of when you're watching the show, you kind of go, Oh, that's kind of like what's happening right now. Um I'm gonna stop talking now because I talked on a major um uh detour just then about yeah, we we went very philosophical there about the nature of theatre in and of itself.

[28:57] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, well, I mean, I mean Tori Tory bringing up the current state of like Phantom changing. That does bring up, I suppose the spiciest topic I've got here, which is the current the current state of the show, and it's gonna inspire a lot of opinion, I think. So there's only one only one production of Phantom running in the world at the moment, and that's GWB Entertainment's Asian tour, which at the time of recording is currently in Taiwan. There's at least two versions of the show currently being worked on. That's the Australian and the West End version. It should be stated.

[29:31] Gareth Isaac: Yes, because West End is going to be back opening back up again soon.

[29:34] Eliza Gunther: Yeah, July, I'm fairly certain.

[29:36] Gareth Isaac: Exactly. Yeah, it should be with uh the first person of colour to be playing the full track of Christine rather than just an understudy, which we are so here for and thrilled about. It's phenomenal seeing that, and I also got very confused in seeing that because I'm also aware that currently, I believe Broadway, they're doing an open casting for Christine as well. Like they are openly casting it. Anyone who I believe is over the age of 18, maybe it's is it 21 in America? I'm not sure. But over a certain age, anyone, yeah, anyone can submit for the role of Christine, which I think is phenomenal. But yes, the fact that we have the first person of colour who is, yeah, like you said, not an understudy, not a swing, is playing the role of Christine is so exciting because it is, and it's like because it is a role. Seriously, within theatre, uh this ha this is everywhere, but like it seriously is a role that can be played by anyone.

[30:31] Eliza Gunther: Exactly. Like obviously, you've got to have the voice, keeping in mind, you've got to have the voice. But if you have that voice, it can be played by anyone.

[30:39] Gareth Isaac: Hmm. And that's what where I'm going with this now, because it should be stated that both the Australian and West End versions of The Phantom of the Opera are being reworked. The West End to some degree of controversy. I don't have the details on the Australian audition uh Australian edition, other than it is being publicised as a quote unquote new version by most publications, but the West End is making some pretty dramatic changes. Now, the design on the show, like all of Bejonson's classic stuff, has been different since the UK tour in 2019. It was intended to make the show lighter, easier to travel, and Bjornsen's iconic angel centerpiece from the Proscenium Arch was removed from the show entirely.

Which does ch does change a little bit of how Prince's direction because of course, uh, closing of Act One, the Phantom is sitting on that angel doing the I gave you my music rendition of uh All I Ask of You, which is really cool and haunting. But following the closure of the West End production after 33 years due to COVID, Cameron Mackintosh announced several changes would be made to the show, which has inspired a bit of discussion in the theatrical world.

[31:55] Eliza Gunther: The design, direction, and choreography of the West End version would be quote, reworked by a new team, and the orchestra size would be reduced from 27 parts to 14.

[32:08] Gareth Isaac: Oh.

[32:09] Eliza Gunther: With the rest, I believe, being digitized. Cameron Mackintosh was quoted as saying, I don't know why musicians would want to be playing the same pieces again and again.

[32:21] Gareth Isaac: Full quote.

[32:28] Eliza Gunther: Yeah. So this this is this is spicy. This is spicy. I'm like, so okay, so time comes for some change and stuff, like costuming and stuff. You know, there are I'm interested to see how big of a change. Because you know how sometimes a show will say, we've reworked stuff, and then you'll go see and you're like, wait, what was different? I don't get it. But that cutting down the orchestra by almost half and digitizing it. No, people live for this shit. I don't want to go to a show and be like, oh, cool, that's like the backing track version.

[33:00] Gareth Isaac: Well, to an extent, Summer Phantom was already digitized. The classic organ opening as the chandelier rises until the full orchestra kicks in, is all digitized and pre-recorded, purely because I believe that synthesizer patch no longer is sold on commercial models. Plus, also you can't, it's probably pretty hard to just like casually have an organ just sitting in the um orchestra pit.

[33:24] Eliza Gunther: Well, it depends how many pants they're wearing. That was nothing. That was bullshit. Edit that out.

[33:28] Gareth Isaac: I will say reducing the orchestra is a little frustrating. As um, I mean, even in Sydney, there's been controversy over a chorus line using when a chorus line was going on about using backing tracks, and it takes a lot of like, for example, Broadway is pretty much the main stage that any musician, any performer wants to be is on Broadway. And if Broadway can't make enough have a full orchestra, then we have a bit of a problem. And and then it's taking that magic away. Broadway at this point hasn't said they're doing anything with the orchestra, so we haven't heard anything from Majestic yet. This is all from the West End. But like, I I I agree exactly what you're saying though, Eliza. Like, but Broadway and the West End are kind of the big players.

And to be you're also like, you gotta keep in mind, we're coming out of a pandemic, and almost straight away you're going, cool, let's take away some more jobs. I get that also when it comes to like saving money and stuff like that, because to be fair, COVID did hit pretty hard, and you know what, theatre in on the West End opened for all of because I'm a big follower and and lover of Carrie Hope Fletcher who was in Lame's. I'm not I don't believe that she'll now be going back, because I believe her run is now over. Um, but yeah, they were open for all of I think maybe ten days. They closed, were open for like 10 days, and it was like this m big thing with Cameron Mackintosh again, like having this big like reopening of theatre and it being so exciting, and within 10 days they were shut down again. So they have lost so much money.

[35:10] Eliza Gunther: So I kind of get it from that point of view, but also from the point of view of making changes to the show. Is that a necessary change? Because you lose some of that live theatre magic by going, yeah, let's have exactly like what you were saying, Eliza about a chorus line. You lose a part of the magic of the show by taking away such huge and it's not like they're going, cool, we're gonna take it from 27 down to or like 25, we're gonna you know, a couple of those instruments that you know are harder to find people for I don't know if that that is a thing or not, but like you know, it's hard to find someone who can play this instrument. Let's digitize those, you know, we can reduce that a little bit by taking it down by almost half, you lose you're gonna lose such an authenticity, I feel, to the sound as well.

[35:57] Gareth Isaac: Hmm. I mean, the major changes to the show are the direction, the choreography, and the design. As I noted earlier, all three of the minds behind those sections have now passed. Maria Beyonson in 2002, Gillian Lynn in 2018, Hal Prince in 2019. So major changes to changes to the design started happening in 2019, off the top of my head, after Beyons had passed, but then as soon as Lynn and Prince have sadly left us, it seems like the changes are then being made again. So I'm just intrigued at the timing behind it. I guess also taking the show off the stage during a pandemic is going to give you the time and energy necessary to make such huge changes. But again, it's just inspired a lot of uh conversation and a slight controversy in the Phantom Fandom, I suppose you can call it.

A lot of people are saying, hey, I don't want to see this version of the show. I don't want anything else. But which I can see the the purism behind it. I can understand that, having seen that version myself, but I'm also like, hey, it's still gonna sound amazing and it'll probably still look amazing.

[37:17] Eliza Gunther: Yeah. I don't I can't imagine them making incredibly huge changes. Like, look, that might be wishful thinking, I don't know. But I feel like also, you know when you have that moment where you are like coming from writers, so we I believe all dabble. I I know Gareth, you less so dabble and more so you do write. But when you you know when sometimes you just sit with something a little bit too long. Like you've put something aside and you're like, cool, cool, cool, like I I don't have to think about that right now, and you sit there going, wait, but oh, maybe I maybe I should like I don't know. Does this does this need to be changing? And you could be ruining a perfectly great thing by making those changes, but I want to think, I really want to think that they're not gonna make any huge drastic changes, but I could be like completely wrong.

[38:05] Gareth Isaac: No, like I I'm not expecting I'm not expecting the Phantom to come out on stage in a mariachi outfit. I'm not expecting Raoul to be dressed as a giant teddy bear, like we're not gonna be super drastic with it. We still have an aesthetic to fit, and I think it could be refreshing for the show to change up a few things. Art is entirely subjective, it's an ever-evolving thing. I mean, we can look at the entire nature of the musical theatre industry to prove that. I'm I'm still annoyed about the orchestra reduction, because you know, musicians, it's kind of the lifeblood of the thing, but I guess we'll see what happens.

[38:36] Eliza Gunther: I guess the thing that is also probably a bit s jarring for the community is the fact that these amazing creatives have passed on, and and it's not like they have really had an input into um who is going to be taking over and and also main maintaining their own legacy within it. I think that hopefully there is still there is still some aspects of it that stay true to the original creatives, um, because they aren't there to oversee to make sure that like what they their original product is, you know, comes out in a new way, but is but is not taking away from the story. But then it it lends itself to being like, okay, well, you're gonna have new directions of every show. You'll go to you, you know, you go to some shows in Sydney and it'll be a total revamp and a total change, and that's exciting at the same time.

So it's like, is there a place it'll depend on what these changes are, but there's probably a place for the original work, and there's probably a place for some of the newer stuff that they're bringing out in terms of set direction, choreography, and there might be something new and exciting in there that no one has explored because they haven't changed that much.

[39:53] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, exactly. And people will always have that classic version of Phantom. DVDs and videos have existed for decades, for instance, the 25th anniversary, like people will go to that recording and say, This is the definitive, this is it. And yeah, which to an extent it is, Romane Caramloo is delightful in Sierra Bogus, just makes me weep every time. But yeah, so I I'm I'm interested to see what can be done with it.

[40:22] Eliza Gunther: Yeah. Agreed, agreed. I feel like this is probably also partially my fault. I took us on a really weird tangent of the set design stuff. Um and we are yet to even talk about the plot of the show. So I think what we might do.

[40:36] Gareth Isaac: Yes.

[40:37] Eliza Gunther: Is we might play our game.

[40:39] Gareth Isaac: I have created a little listening challenge.

[40:42] Eliza Gunther: But I think we might play a little bit of a game and then we're gonna jump into the actual plot things because I have a lot to say. We also do have some points about the sequel. Are we even gonna get to that? Because again, I have so much to say.

[40:54] Gareth Isaac: We might have to do uh love.

[40:57] Eliza Gunther: We might we might have to do a love never dies deep dive. We'll have to we'll have to wait and see, but for now we are gonna jump into the game.

[41:06] Eliza Gunther: Now I'm doing a little bit of a different game. We're doing a bit of a listening challenge where I'm gonna give you each about five seconds at the beginning of the song. Some of them are less, because let me tell you, there's not a lot of intro at the beginning of phantom songs, which makes it hard because I don't know whether to keep, you know, you know, when someone goes, you know, love never dies. Like that obviously you know what that is. Um anyway, I'm rambling.

[41:35] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, carousel.

[41:37] Eliza Gunther: But it this yeah, these are all phantom songs. These are all phantom songs. Um but you're gonna get five seconds, the first five or less of the song to guess what it is. Now we're gonna start.

[41:51] Eliza Gunther: We're gonna start with Eliza and Eliza.

[41:53] Eliza Gunther: Oh, I feel like I've started with an easy one. So if you don't get this, I'm gonna be mad.

[41:58] Tori Bullard: Alright, let's test my knowledge.

[42:00] Eliza Gunther: Are you prepared?

[42:01] Tori Bullard: Let's hope, let's hope this works.

[42:09] Eliza Gunther: Do you know what that is called?

[42:11] Tori Bullard: Like The Phantom of the Opera?

[42:15] Eliza Gunther: Yay!

[42:16] Tori Bullard: You got it right.

[42:18] Eliza Gunther: I feel like this is rigged.

[42:22] Tori Bullard: It's not. Don't worry. Um, are you ready?

[42:26] Eliza Gunther: Three, two, one.

[42:34] Tori Bullard: That's just an introduction to a certain part of the show, and I can't for the life of me remember what it is because I'm so damn tired.

[42:40] Eliza Gunther: Oh no.

[42:41] Tori Bullard: Oh no, my credentials.

[42:42] Eliza Gunther: Oh no, my credentials.

[42:44] Tori Bullard: I mean, that's because that is obviously where in the world have you been hiding? That piece shows up so many times in the show.

[42:51] Eliza Gunther: And it's confusing because that's the sound of a certain other song.

[42:54] Tori Bullard: It is.

[42:55] Eliza Gunther: That's where in the world have you been hiding. It also plays again when Christine kisses the Phantom at the end of the show.

[43:00] Tori Bullard: And that's definitely not that orchestration.

[43:03] Eliza Gunther: That orchestration is oh god.

[43:06] Tori Bullard: You know what? I'm just gonna take the L on that one.

[43:08] Eliza Gunther: It's the N tract.

[43:10] Tori Bullard: Oh tract.

[43:14] Eliza Gunther: I said it quietly for a reason.

[43:16] Tori Bullard: I'm just trying, I'm just trying to save face here because I ruined the.

[43:19] Eliza Gunther: Horrible.

[43:20] Tori Bullard: So fine, I just got the opera. So you know what, Gareth? You did well.

[43:23] Gareth Isaac: Alright.

[43:24] Tori Bullard: You know what? I quit. I'm done.

[43:25] Eliza Gunther: I'm done.

[43:26] Tori Bullard: I'm done.

[43:27] Eliza Gunther: I've gotta be quick to cut this one off.

[43:35] Tori Bullard: Think of me.

[43:36] Eliza Gunther: Damn it!

[43:38] Tori Bullard: See how hard that is?

[43:40] Eliza Gunther: That's probably two seconds.

[43:41] Tori Bullard: I mean, if you want to get technical, if you want to get technical, that's Carlotta's version of Think of Me.

[43:47] Eliza Gunther: Oh, because that's when she gets told to just get up and sing.

[43:50] Tori Bullard: So you are both on, oh no, Gareth has no point.

[43:54] Gareth Isaac: I was not expecting to be the winner here.

[43:57] Tori Bullard: So far.

[43:58] Gareth Isaac: Well, so far.

[43:59] Tori Bullard: Hey, hey, look, I'm already turning in my equity card.

[44:03] Gareth Isaac: I'm done as an actor.

[44:05] Tori Bullard: Gareth, this one you will get. I just know.

[44:06] Eliza Gunther: Alright.

[44:07] Tori Bullard: This one I also have to be really quick on.

[44:09] Eliza Gunther: So it's masquerade.

[44:15] Gareth Isaac: I think you're just playing me the entire act two now.

[44:18] Tori Bullard: No, no, no.

[44:19] Eliza Gunther: No, no, no.

[44:20] Tori Bullard: That is indeed masquerade.

[44:23] Eliza Gunther: Uh let me.

[44:25] Tori Bullard: I've changed.

[44:26] Eliza Gunther: I have changed indeed.

[44:27] Tori Bullard: Oh no.

[44:28] Eliza Gunther: And this one will probably be harder.

[44:29] Tori Bullard: Or it could be easier. I don't know.

[44:31] Eliza Gunther: It's always hard to tell with you, Eliza.

[44:34] Tori Bullard: Alright.

[44:35] Eliza Gunther: Let's find out.

[44:36] Tori Bullard: I will give you five seconds because I still don't know if you'll be able to figure it out.

[44:47] Gareth Isaac: Something with music.

[44:48] Eliza Gunther: Am I right?

[44:49] Gareth Isaac: Is there music in the title?

[44:51] Eliza Gunther: Something with music, but that's not the name of the song.

[44:54] Tori Bullard: Oh god.

[44:55] Eliza Gunther: It has music in the title, but that's not the full title, girl.

[44:59] Gareth Isaac: Uh something of music.

[45:00] Eliza Gunther: It's something of music.

[45:01] Tori Bullard: That's not, that's it's something.

[45:03] Eliza Gunther: He didn't give me the full title.

[45:05] Tori Bullard: It's Angel of Music.

[45:08] Eliza Gunther: Oh.

[45:09] Gareth Isaac: Which is pretty much who the Phantom is to Christine.

[45:12] Tori Bullard: The angel of music.

[45:14] Eliza Gunther: I'm putting my resignation in.

[45:16] Tori Bullard: The final one.

[45:17] Eliza Gunther: Will this be?

[45:18] Tori Bullard: Oh no.

[45:19] Eliza Gunther: We're gonna have to do another one because otherwise you're gonna be tied if you get this right, Gareth.

[45:23] Gareth Isaac: That's okay.

[45:27] Tori Bullard: I don't know the names of the track, but that's the opening of the show.

[45:30] Gareth Isaac: That's the overture, I suppose you call it.

[45:33] Tori Bullard: The entire piece is called the Overture.

[45:34] Eliza Gunther: The next one is called The Overture.

[45:36] Tori Bullard: This is called The Prologue.

[45:39] Eliza Gunther: You're a prologue.

[45:41] Tori Bullard: Oh you get the first one.

[45:42] Eliza Gunther: Opening and prologue mean exactly the same thing.

[45:46] Tori Bullard: Okay, okay, I'm gonna give you both.

[45:47] Eliza Gunther: You both got those, so those are you've both on two.

[45:51] Tori Bullard: Also, not a song.

[45:53] Eliza Gunther: Like, I cannot stress that enough.

[45:55] Tori Bullard: That is decidedly.

[45:56] Eliza Gunther: Just because I didn't plan this game very well, doesn't mean you can attack me for it.

[46:02] Tori Bullard: This is your final moment.

[46:04] Eliza Gunther: This is your final moment.

[46:05] Tori Bullard: This is a tiebreaker.

[46:07] Eliza Gunther: Alright.

[46:07] Tori Bullard: So I will play the five seconds.

[46:09] Eliza Gunther: I will then say go.

[46:12] Tori Bullard: Whichever of you screams at me first, gets to tell me what it is.

[46:18] Eliza Gunther: And if you don't get this, I'll be very upset.

[46:21] Tori Bullard: Okay.

[46:29] Eliza Gunther: Okay.

[46:30] Tori Bullard: Three, two, one.

[46:33] Gareth Isaac: Overmature!

[46:35] Eliza Gunther: It's a tie.

[46:37] Tori Bullard: I can't.

[46:38] Eliza Gunther: It's a tie.

[46:39] Tori Bullard: Yeah!

[46:39] Gareth Isaac: You both started screaming at me overture whilst I was playing it.

[46:43] Tori Bullard: It's a tie.

[46:45] Eliza Gunther: Yeah.

[46:46] Tori Bullard: If you want to get pedantic, it was plagiarized from Pink Floyd's Twelve Tones.

[46:50] Gareth Isaac: Controversy.

[46:52] Eliza Gunther: That is true.

[46:53] Tori Bullard: I do though, but I need to make a point.

[46:55] Eliza Gunther: I need to make a point.

[46:56] Tori Bullard: Oh god.

[46:57] Eliza Gunther: Brow did deserve better, you guys.

[47:00] Tori Bullard: He deserved better.

[47:02] Gareth Isaac: Prowl got exactly what he deserved.

[47:04] Tori Bullard: Oh, okay.

[47:06] Gareth Isaac: In Love Never Dies, yes.

[47:08] Tori Bullard: In Phantom of the Opera, no!

[47:10] Gareth Isaac: He gets what he deserves in Love Never Dies.

[47:12] Tori Bullard: He's written as an alcoholic gambling addict, and then his wife dies.

[47:16] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, he loses his love.

[47:18] Tori Bullard: He loses the one thing that he was trying to protect because he's an idiot.

[47:22] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, how does he deserve that?

[47:24] Tori Bullard: By being an overbearing bust, the technical term.

[47:32] Gareth Isaac: No, I don't.

[47:33] Tori Bullard: I'm just fuming with rage.

[47:35] Gareth Isaac: Rao deserved better.

[47:37] Tori Bullard: Rao was so kind.

[47:39] Gareth Isaac: Rao tried to protect Christine in Phantom and tried to do it in not an overbearing way.

[47:48] Tori Bullard: I think that Rao did make some poor choices.

[47:52] Gareth Isaac: But also I do feel in saying that Rao deserved better, Christine deserved better than both of them.

[47:59] Tori Bullard: I agree.

[47:59] Gareth Isaac: Well, that's my point.

[48:01] Tori Bullard: Christine is ultimately the object of two obsessive men who treat her as if they are in an abusive relationship.

[48:08] Gareth Isaac: One of the first things that Rao does is remind her of their childhood together, then says, Now you shall come to supper.

[48:15] Tori Bullard: But her and she says, No, I don't want to.

[48:18] Gareth Isaac: I have to stay here.

[48:19] Tori Bullard: Oh, I shan't keep you long, and doesn't take her choice into account.

[48:23] Gareth Isaac: The Phantom then turns up and terrifies the shit out of Christine, doesn't take her choices into account, and just says, Love me, sing for me, my angel.

[48:32] Tori Bullard: And that continues throughout the whole show.

[48:34] Gareth Isaac: Christine is a victim.

[48:35] Tori Bullard: As well as the fact that the Phantom lies as well by putting on this persona, whilst it may have never been intended to be this in her eyes, angel of music, once Eric isn't made aware of this angel of music, just kind of goes, Oh yeah, this is an easy way.

[48:35] Gareth Isaac: This is an easy in.

[48:55] Tori Bullard: I don't have to explain nothing.

[48:56] Gareth Isaac: I feel like also, dependent on how every production is acted by the actor and interpreted by the actor playing these two roles, can actually come across really differently.

[49:07] Tori Bullard: Because I feel like I've seen Phantom where I really don't like Rao at all, and I really don't vouch for him or care too much about him.

[49:14] Gareth Isaac: But there's been other productions where I'm like, oh no, I really see the love there, and I understand a bit more of his character.

[49:20] Tori Bullard: So I feel like there is definitely a place of interpretation and um more an actor's input into what they believe it is because it will always come across however that person portrays that character.

[49:34] Gareth Isaac: You can either be sympathetic to them or not.

[49:36] Tori Bullard: Oh yeah, like yeah, I agree, and I feel like I don't know, there's just something about Rao seems quite a bit nicer to me in the film version.

[49:45] Gareth Isaac: I actually also like it feels like a nicer person, like more caring to watch Christine and less possessive.

[49:51] Tori Bullard: Like there's still that possessive um vibe, but it feels a little bit more kinder, like a bit a little bit more kind, like, oh, we were childhood friends, let us be together in a slightly pushy way.

[50:02] Gareth Isaac: Whereas in the 25th anniversary, it is much more like I feel like Rao as a character deserved a different ending, and you could take better in many different ways.

[50:16] Tori Bullard: Better could be that they, you know, live happily ever after, or better could be that oh, well, he died.

[50:21] Gareth Isaac: Um but that you know that's just I feel I feel like that's better for you, Tori.

[50:27] Tori Bullard: Better for me, yes.

[50:29] Gareth Isaac: Better for Rao.

[50:30] Tori Bullard: Look, you know.

[50:34] Gareth Isaac: I think that the reason that people actually relate strongly to this show as well.

[50:39] Tori Bullard: I mean, I think Lloyd Webber has said something about this is that people see themselves in the Phantom, like people want to alter their appearance, they always want to alter their appearance to you know win something, or they want to relate, and that's I feel like that's part of the reason why people relate to the Phantom is that they he's an underdog, he's someone that you want to root for, you want him to win in the end.

[51:02] Gareth Isaac: Although he has some really horrible qualities, which is a little bit like should she should they end up together?

[51:09] Tori Bullard: Definitely not, but um there's still a rooting for quality about that and a relatability in terms of like there might be something about your own your own appearance that you don't like and you feel like um h holds you back, so there's definitely that relation there that people w want to see.

[51:27] Eliza Gunther: And I mean, talking about the film, because honestly, you watched the 25th anniversary edition, and then you watched the film, and I did that in like a span of a week because I just got really obsessed with Phantom.

[51:41] Tori Bullard: Oh, you made a horrible mistake.

[51:43] Gareth Isaac: We did this together.

[51:45] Eliza Gunther: We watched because I don't think I had seen the film.

[51:45] Tori Bullard: I had seen the film.

[51:50] Eliza Gunther: No, I had only seen the 25th anniversary.

[51:53] Tori Bullard: I've seen it live a few times, like you know, Sydney.

[51:57] Eliza Gunther: I think I honestly think Phantom was the first musical I ever saw live, which as probably like a seven-year-old child, might have been a little bit scarring.

[52:08] Tori Bullard: But oh my gosh, the film is so much worse.

[52:11] Gareth Isaac: Oh I've never seen Rao with so much hand.

[52:14] Tori Bullard: We can say what we like about the movie.

[52:16] Gareth Isaac: I think it's a bad representation of what Phantom can be, considering how much of it is spoken.

[52:21] Tori Bullard: But it's a great representation of every Joel Schumacher film that's ever been made.

[52:25] Gareth Isaac: Like if like if you if you look at the rest of his back catalogue, it's like, oh yeah, there's elements of that in all of the Batman films he ever did.

[52:32] Tori Bullard: It's delightful.

[52:34] Gareth Isaac: Like it's it's so very him and camp and ugh it aesthetically wonderful, but not a good representation.

[52:41] Tori Bullard: No, definitely not a good representation, but I gotta say, it was kind of a little entertaining to watch and be like, wow, this is uh I don't think the direction was particularly great on this one.

[52:53] Gareth Isaac: Yeah, and that I think that I think was Schumacher's interpretation of what Phantom was.

[52:59] Tori Bullard: So instead of being you still have you still had the opulence, you still had a whole bunch of really cool looking stuff.

[53:05] Gareth Isaac: Like, oh my god, masquerade.

[53:06] Tori Bullard: Yeah, but then you had Carlotta rocking up in pink fur all the time.

[53:09] Gareth Isaac: It's like, oh, this is the energy we're bringing to this.

[53:12] Tori Bullard: It's fun.

[53:13] Gareth Isaac: I feel like it's kind of the s a similar energy, especially in terms of like the set design and the costuming, the same as like Bridgerton, how the colouring is all extremely vivid.

[53:23] Tori Bullard: Where and then you go, what would it actually have been quite so vivid then, or is that just more like a uh film interpretation?

[53:31] Gareth Isaac: Technique and kind of the costuming for film just to make it pop that little bit more.

[53:35] Tori Bullard: Yeah, I always compare it to a knight's tale, if either of you have seen that one.

[53:40] Gareth Isaac: Uh early Heath Ledger film about jousting, medieval jousting.

[53:45] Tori Bullard: It opens with an entire crowd of medieval peasants doing We Will Rock You.

[53:49] Gareth Isaac: It's fucking camp.

[53:51] Tori Bullard: Yeah, I think we're not gonna have a lot more time to talk about stuff, unfortunately.

[53:56] Eliza Gunther: Because Miss Tor Ms Tory has to go and get some science juice.

[53:59] Tori Bullard: I do, I do have to go get my my science juice.

[54:01] Eliza Gunther: I need to go get my Let's Not Die in a Pandemic uh shot.

[54:06] Tori Bullard: Um I think that we can do a part two to this where we discuss not only Phantom but also the sequel that shall not be named.

[54:13] Eliza Gunther: Because I only recently uh had the opportunity to see Love Never Dies in the um, you know, the show must go on when they released that.

[54:22] Tori Bullard: Yes, they they would have released the Melbourne version.

[54:24] Eliza Gunther: Yes, and I must say I was watching that going, what the fuck happened between Phantom and this to create this like surely I kind of love it though I mean I have information about why it ended up the way it did but you know that can wait till part two ooh cliffhanger that can wait that can wait because I also have so much to say about a certain Meg um but anywho I think we are I think we are going to have to wrap this up for today but first and foremost welcome to our newest deep dive co-host Isaac round of applause for Gareth and applause clip here thank you guys so much for having me the checks in the mail right yeah it's on its way and also we will be putting up some polls on our Instagram for what deep dives you would like to see next obviously we will be doing a part two on Phantom and Love Never Dies.

[55:23] Eliza Gunther: But what other deep dives do you want to hear what do you want to hear us talk about if there are any particular shows like I believe that you know there is some you know mean girls things like that that people have requested but we shall put some polls up on our Instagram um but yeah visit our Instagram our Facebook our website it's all stage door podcast but anyway you guys until next time stay happy healthy and safe we will see you later bye

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred