Playwright Harvey Fierstein and actor Michael Urie discuss "Torch Song," their newly revised version of Fierstein's breakout work "Torch Song Trilogy." Along the way they talk auditions, bus and truck tours, the legacy of gay history plays, and Estelle Getty... Read More
From the show: Stagecraft with Gordon Cox
Guests
About
Playwright Harvey Fierstein and actor Michael Urie discuss "Torch Song," their newly revised version of Fierstein's breakout work "Torch Song Trilogy." Along the way they talk auditions, bus and truck tours, the legacy of gay history plays, and Estelle Getty.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Gordon Cox: I'm your host, Varieties Theater Editor Gordon Cox. In 1983, Harvey Fierstein won a Tony Award for Best Play and another for Best Actor for the play he wrote and starred in, Torch Song Trilogy, a 1988 movie adaptation, which also starred a young Matthew Broderick, cemented the play's status as an unflinching, warm and funny landmark in gay theater. Now Fierstein has rewritten and condensed the play, and the new version, now called simply Torch Song, is debuting off Broadway at Second Stage Theater in a production that stars Michael Urie, who spent four seasons on Ugly Betty, and has appeared on stage in New York in shows including Buyer and Seller and most recently The Government Inspector. On this episode of Stagecraft, Harvey and Michael are in the studio with me to talk about Torch Song and more. Harvey and Michael, thanks for joining me.
[0:59] Harvey Fierstein: Thank you.
[1:00] Gordon Cox: Um Harvey, let's start by talking about the impetus behind this new version of Torch Song. What prompted you to go back and work on it?
[1:06] Harvey Fierstein: Who told you I was impotent?
[1:10] Gordon Cox: It was a non-disclosure.
[1:12] Harvey Fierstein: They signed a non-disclosure.
[1:14] Gordon Cox: Those don't matter anymore.
[1:16] Harvey Fierstein: They don't matter anymore.
[1:18] Gordon Cox: What happened?
[1:19] Harvey Fierstein: Okay, so for years people have wanted to revive Torch Song. I haven't let it be done because frankly, I wanted to stay far enough away from AIDS where, you know, my feeling has always been that obviously AIDS is a disease, and I hate that the gay community has been labeled with it as if a disease defines who we are. And though obviously, I think it's a very important cause, and I'm obviously in the middle of the fight and have been, I didn't want Torch Song colored that way. There were people when the movie came out that said, "Why didn't you put AIDS in it?" Because AIDS isn't everything. Anyway, so I sort of, and then over the years, a lot of companies have asked for permission to do act one and act three or act two and act three, or even do act one, and I'd say, "Why?
We don't have the wherewithal to do four hours." And I always thought, you know, I gotta come up with a way because the plays are written to be done anywhere. I mean, you need a couple of chairs. I mean, you really can do the play with a couple of chairs, but the length seemed to be holding people back. So all of this has always been going on in my mind. Like, how do I get it down so that everybody can do it? So that was always in the back of my mind. And I did finally come up with an edit that I liked, and then we sort of looked around for a theater, and then there were a bunch of theaters. We said, "Okay," and then you gotta find your Arnold. And we did a couple of readings, no names that's in the non-disclosure, and just didn't work.
And you can tell right away. I mean, it's like one of those funny things. It's either that connection happens or it doesn't. And then Richie said that Michael wanted to do a reading, but it came through some—who did it come from? Well, Richie came to me. This is Richie Jackson. Richie Jackson came to me, who is personally—who is he still your manager or how what's his title now?
[3:11] Michael Urie: It's his, yeah, as they say, it's a long-time friend of the court, Richie Jackson.
[3:18] Harvey Fierstein: He was my assistant when he was 18 years old.
[3:20] Michael Urie: Oh wow, and I was doing the movie of Torch Song.
[3:22] Harvey Fierstein: He's now my manager, I think. But he's also the producer of Torch Song at Second Stage. So he—and you knew him because I knew him from around, just from socially from around.
[3:30] Michael Urie: From socially.
[3:36] Harvey Fierstein: And not disclosure. And he reached out to me and said, "What do you think about Torch Song?"
[3:41] Gordon Cox: Well, so it wasn't your idea.
[3:43] Harvey Fierstein: No, but when he did that, I said, "You won't believe this. But someone else reached out to me about Torch Song, Morris S. Kaufman." They reached out to me independently. Totally because I had never a million million years thought that I could play this part. I knew the play very well and loved it. I read it when I was in high school and I thought it was amazing. And I just never thought that anybody would want me to play the role. And here these two guys came along separately. And so I put them together.
[4:12] Gordon Cox: Right.
[4:13] Harvey Fierstein: And then so we did a reading. We put together a cast and we did a reading. And it was abundantly clear two or three minutes into it that, you know, I had already signed up. I could have gone to Coney Island and ridden a couple of rides. And then it was a matter of, you know, putting everything else together because his schedule is, you know, he's a very big star.
[4:33] Michael Urie: I know.
[4:34] Harvey Fierstein: I know.
[4:34] Michael Urie: I know.
[4:34] Harvey Fierstein: He's like, he does television.
[4:36] Michael Urie: Yeah.
[4:37] Harvey Fierstein: And benefits.
[4:38] Michael Urie: Yeah.
[4:38] Harvey Fierstein: All those things.
[4:39] Michael Urie: And cabaret work is world-known.
[4:45] Gordon Cox: Well, and so Michael, I imagine you must get this question from everyone, which is how do you step into a role that is so closely associated with the actor who originated it and with now the well-known personality who originated?
[4:57] Michael Urie: Right, right. Well I thought I've thought a lot about that because it it bec—and I think part of the reason it was I was able to is because of the way that it came to me. Because I didn't seek it out. I didn't think of it until somebody said, "What about you?" And so I think it gave me a freedom to trust that whatever I was gonna try was what they had in mind, or what they saw in me that made them think that I could do it. And I had the luxury of just reading the whole play for Harvey instead of having to do an audition, which is—I mean, auditions are the worst thing in the world for any actor to have to go through ever at all. And the idea that like I would be given a few scenes to perfect and then bring in and present was like that I wouldn't have gotten it if I'd had to audition in a proper way.
But because my audition was to read the whole play and fail and succeed throughout, you know, like when you do a reading of a whole play, you mess up here, you get it right here, you mess up there, you get it right there, but you get to do the whole arc, and by the end of it, you're like—and I think that because of that, I was able to forgive myself every time I didn't get something, you know, exactly right. Whereas in an audition, as soon as you make a mistake, you're like, "Well, that's it, it's over." And it kind of is. I mean, it's like that's kind of what happens in an audition. You have to be perfect. It's so bizarre. Even though, especially with a play, you're not auditioning for opening night, you're auditioning for the first day of rehearsal.
But with this play, I think it's not a matter of even being a good actor. I've seen a lot of really good actors fail in Torch Song. I mean, remember how many actors I've seen do this role? I've seen a lot. I mean, I had—you know, we ran five years on Broadway and there were understudies, and there was—we had those were the days when you could actually tour a show. I mean, we had a first national and a bus and truck, a bus and truck of a play.
[6:50] Harvey Fierstein: That's insane.
[6:50] Michael Urie: A bus and truck of Torch Song Trilogy out for two years, a four-hour gay play.
[7:02] Harvey Fierstein: Wow.
[7:03] Michael Urie: The back rooms I created around America. So I saw a lot of actors do it wonderfully and badly, but it's an inhabiting of the role and it's what the role does for the actor and what it does for the role and you'll have to ask Michael about that. But there's a marriage that has to be made there and there's something that comes up in your soul because something very strange—and I was trying to explain it to Michael last night. Because last night I sat in the middle instead of sitting in the back and there's a very strange thing that happens when Torch Song works and it's the audience has an ownership of it and an ownership of those characters and it's almost creepy how much they care. How much they care of how these people treat each other, what happens to them, what's said between them, and I mean it's a very beautiful thing but that only happens if you are able to give enough of yourself that—well you talk about what it's like to play it.
Michael, how much do you keep or did you as you were crafting the character, how much did you keep in mind knowing Harvey and who he was and you know everything you know about Harvey and with also creating your own take on it? Like what was that balance for you?
[8:18] Michael Urie: Well, you know, he's always there—not physically literally there in the room but like he's there and he's in your head and in your ear in a good way, not in an oppressive way. And in that spirit, his spirit is the play. I mean, it is a play—I mean you could see sitting here with him, he's like, if love—love, he's love and the play is love and family and you know, I mean he's the kind of person who makes a stranger feel like they've known him for 20 years.
[8:50] Harvey Fierstein: And well, they don't take off the clothes either.
[8:55] Michael Urie: Aging Mr. Fierstein.
[8:59] Harvey Fierstein: But that's—and that's what I think he's talking about with the way the audience feels about the characters too. The characters feel like family to them. I mean, it's really a play about love and family. And that the—I think the characters become family to the audience and that's why they—I mean the way that they react to how we treat each other, not just when they laugh but when they groan or when they gasp or when they sigh, you can hear them, "Oh!" You know, and "Oh!" You hear all of that stuff and none of that was planned. We didn't intend to get any of that out of them. We were just trying to figure out how to do it, how to tell the truth and listen to each other. And I think so I—in terms of, you know, shaking the Harvey, I never tried to do that.
I knew that there was no way I could do the Harvey. I knew that it would have to be—I knew that I would have to attack Arnold from within me and use myself as a vessel and not try to be something else, not try to, you know, that—and audiences would—they wouldn't want me to be that anyway. I mean, and so many people who come to see it saw him, of course, right, and remember it vividly and it changed their lives or it, you know, or they saw it six times, seven times, they saw it with several different people and I can feel that they don't want me to do, you know, an imitation or, you know, they don't want me to invoke what he did. They want me to tell this story again. And I was absolutely given license from the very beginning to just go from within. And I was lucky enough to have the Bible around, you know, the encyclopedia of the author himself.
[10:48] Harvey Fierstein: The author himself, yeah.
[10:49] Michael Urie: Sorry, I'm gesturing too. It's great on the radio.
[10:53] Harvey Fierstein: The good gestures, they really read beautifully.
[10:57] Michael Urie: It's somebody who not only like came up with it, but who played it so—and who is an actor and knows how to talk to actors. So like, you know, I had a question.
[11:06] Gordon Cox: What did he tell you that was really helpful?
[11:10] Michael Urie: The thing that I go back to always is the first thing he said.
[11:12] Harvey Fierstein: Look at his face.
[11:13] Michael Urie: Yeah, I first said, I wish you guys see it. You know, make that relationship between Moises and you.
[11:20] Harvey Fierstein: Yes, which is a different real—I mean, which is like, yeah, I mean, he—it's like, you know, Moises is Moises, by the way, we should just say for people who don't know, he's the director, he directed The Laramie Project and many, many other things.
[11:30] Michael Urie: Yeah.
[11:31] Harvey Fierstein: I Am My Own Wife.
[11:32] Michael Urie: I Am My Own Wife, yes, of course.
[11:33] Harvey Fierstein: And vastly different things.
[11:35] Michael Urie: Yes.
[11:35] Harvey Fierstein: But you know, what he and I do is, you know, make the play and he gets me where he needs me to tell the story. He's like, he's a master storyteller, and so for him it's really about the story and how I fit within the story, and that's how he helps me. And then when I would need to help with the kinds of things that I would need help from Harvey are, you know, like I think the biggest question I ever said was, "Why do I love this guy?" And his answer, I mean, I sort of don't want to say it because it's very personal, but his answer made total sense. And it was playable. That's the other thing, it's like that an actor can tell another actor something that is playable. And it wasn't, "This is how I did it," which is not helpful because like I couldn't do it.
You know, I can't get into it the same way that he would get into it. I wouldn't know where to begin. Like it just instinctually you can't do that. But like, but the first thing he said that was so impactful at the first rehearsal to everybody, to the entire room, you know, designers, interns, ticket takers, the entire, you know, the meet and greet, he said, "If this play doesn't embarrass you, you're not doing it right."
[12:57] Michael Urie: Which embarrassed me.
[12:58] Harvey Fierstein: Uh, everyone looked at me.
[13:03] Michael Urie: It's a very—it's a very baring thing.
[13:05] Harvey Fierstein: Yeah.
[13:06] Michael Urie: If you're not embarrassed to say some of the stuff that you say.
[13:10] Harvey Fierstein: Yeah.
[13:10] Michael Urie: Because it's a young play.
[13:12] Harvey Fierstein: I mean, it's—uh, that's interesting. Like when you're really—when you're really so raw. But the thing that he had to fight, what all of them in the play have to fight that nobody would really think of is the difference of 35 years ago in attitudes to take yourself back to a time when—I mean, I thought the play would—I thought the play would feel a lot more dated than it does. And it doesn't feel—I mean, it's like, boy, does it not feel—did you do anything other than make cuts to the show? Did you—okay? So you just streamlined.
[13:43] Harvey Fierstein: Wow. Just edits. You guys touched on something that I actually wanted to ask about because it seems like Torch Song is at the start of a season that has Angels in America coming in and there's a new production of Band's Visit coming in and Boys in the Band.
[13:56] Harvey Fierstein: I'm sorry. Excuse me. There's a new production of Band's Visit, which is a different thing entirely. What I mean is Boys in the Band and uh And Butterfly. And Butterfly, that's true. And I feel like there has been an impetus to kind of look at these shows that have become kind of landmarks of gay uh thinking about gay identity and gay history. And I just wonder what it sort of chimes with both Richie and Moisess bringing you the play at the same time. What is it right now that do you feel like drives people to look at these again and kind of re-examine them?
[14:26] Michael Urie: I don't know. I you know, I've always pushed for doing our plays because without your history, where are you? And so much of our history is buried because we're not blood relatives, because we come out of every different family, so it's not like you can say these are those people. Um, and especially, I mean, this is not even ghettos anymore. You know, gay ghettos hardly exist. Uh I remember uh uh being on tour in Dublin. I said they said, What do you want to join the night off? I said, Oh, let's go to a gay bar. They said, We don't have gay bars here. It's legal to be gay here. You don't have to live in in ghettos anymore, which was such a shock to me. That was 20-something years ago. So I feel the same way.
I you know, I I produced three productions of the haunted host, which was a play that was done five years before Boys in the Band. Um I I acted in a play called The Madness of Lady Bright that Lever Wilson wrote. You know, that was very early gay play. You know, um, I I designed Staircase once, which was Charles Dyer's gay play. Um Richie Burton and Rex Harrison did the movie. Wow. Oh my god, is that terrible? Um I I think I think our history is a really important thing. So when and I'm very friendly with Joe Mantello, so when he told me, I, you know, obviously we talked about he was gonna do boys in the band, I was gonna do Torch Song, and I said, I said, what would be wonderful is if we all banded together, like, look at us.
I said it instead, they're gonna come and say, Well, I like this one better, and they're gonna judge us and scare put us on a scale, which is really horrible, rather than say, look at us. We're we're it's like this festival uh of remembering our history. But it's a good time to do that because we did come through this really dark piece of history, and these kids need to understand. Um Carol Rothman, the producer of the artistic director of section. She told me, because I asked her, you know, because a lot of our audience at this moment is donors and stuff like that, patrons, and I said, I want to know what young people are saying. And she said, What I hear from them is a lot of them that didn't know anything about the play at all, think it's a new play about that period.
They don't, you know, they they don't see anything aged in it or which is really one. And the first play was written, what, 78? Was it? It was late 70s. I think it's last week last week. Now yeah, it was written. No, the the back room scene was written in 75.
[16:48] Harvey Fierstein: Oh, wow. Is that the first scene you wrote? Yeah, I did it as a one, I did it on as at its uh uh at myself. Yeah, the up Crystal Field Theater of the New City called me and said, Uh, I want to do a woman at play festival for the bicentennial. Do you want to do one? And I said, Okay, I'll write something, and I wrote the back room scene, performed it, it was a big hit. How shocking was that back then? Was it that this is too to explain to listeners? It is a scene that takes place in the back room every day bar where show them how it's done. It doesn't work already. There's a lot of physical comedy. Very mime is yeah, a lot there's a lot of miming. It's just one actor on stage. It shouldn't be.
Um last week in the back of the house, there were twenty five girls from a Catholic school in New Zealand. Wow. And like, is that like the beginning of a joke? Yeah. And so the teacher comes up to me at intermission because they see it, we're all huddled in the back, so they must have figured she must have figured out. So the teacher slash nun and says to me, Is there any sex in the next act? I said, excuse me. I'm here with all these girls, and uh nobody warned us there was gonna be something exp there was gonna be explicit sex in this. And I said, explicit sex. I said, um, do they have television sex in New Zealand? I said, because I think they see a lot more on TV. I said, you didn't notice that he was fully dressed, yes.
And he's alone. How explicit can you have a sexy when you're fully dressed and alone and never touched any part of his body at all? But it's amazing what the isn't the imagination much better. Yeah, fill it all in. Fill it all in. We were playing off Broadway, and there were all these people that wanted to move it to Broadway, and we had a lot of producers that wanted to move to Broadway, and um they just wouldn't do it with the back room scene. And I was thrilled because I said, Am I not going anywhere? And I didn't say yes until they finally said we'll move it with the back room scene. But yeah, they were always scared of nuts. And this was actually actually, we should say, for the listeners who don't know this, these plays originated as three separate one acts. They were all one acts, is that right? Uh and at least two of them premiered at La Mama, right?
[19:05] Harvey Fierstein: No, oh no, all of them. Okay, right. I did, well, first I was the back room scene, then I made it a whole play. Then I was done at La Mama, it moved off Broadway. Then I wrote Act Two, we did it at La Mama, it moved off Broadway. You played at La Mama by itself? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, they each played at La Mama, and then and then I wrote Act Three, it was bought for Broadway, never happened. Okay. Oh. Anyway, that never happened. And then it took me two years to find the lines, John Glines, to produce the three together. Right. Yeah. First off Broadway. And then off off. Off off. It's a place called the Richard Allen Center, which is across from Lincoln Center. The building's not even there anymore.
Sixth floor walk-up. Somebody somebody stopped me at a at a show the other day and said I was in the audience the night that it was raining so hard that during the third act, while you were fighting with your mother, you were moving potted plants under the drips from the ceiling. Yeah. It was one of those productions. We changed the sets ourselves. Oh wow. You know, Matthew Broderick and Estelle Gettelman at that time. Oh wow. This is the woman who would become Estelle Getty. And Joel Crothers, who is a big soap opera star. I was so in love with him. And Paul Joint. And um, but but my bet my favorite was I mean, this place was such a dump. My favorite was one night she opened the can of cookies, and there was a giant water bug on top of the cookies going, she threw them up in the air.
That was like 10 minutes of the of the show doing that while cleaning cookies off the floor. Yeah. You know, usually you mentioned the role of your mother of Arnold's mother, and we should probably mention that uh the role is played by Mercedes Rule in this production.
[20:44] Michael Urie: Yeah, it's a woman named Mercedes Rule, she's quite good. Um she has a future, yeah. She's she's um she's uh uh an aunt, yeah, exactly. An Oscar and a Tony winner. Yeah, right. She's halfway there. Um what'd she like to work with, Michael?
[20:57] Michael Urie: She is she is uh uh like a lightning bolt. She is the the greatest listener I've ever worked with on stage. She will only respond to what you give her, and she will give you whatever is happening for her right then and there. Um she's smart, she's exciting, she's she's cares about it so much, she takes it so seriously.
[21:26] Harvey Fierstein: Is she one question that occurred to me watching it is Harvey? How much is she at all like your mother?
[21:31] Harvey Fierstein: Oh, that's an interesting story. So for all the years, and you know, we're talking 40 years now of that play existing. I would say it's not really my mother, it's based on my mother and my grandmother fighting because they always fought, and you know, and blah blah blah. So then I always said that, and it's you look at any interview, and the interviews articles will all say it's really Harvey's mother and grandmother fighting. And uh dress rehearsal, my brother came. And uh this production of this production, my brother came. Yeah, I don't think you know this story. Oh no, you'll tell Mercedes with me from the story because I'd sort of love it. So anyway, so he uh for the third, I was watching from all the way in the back, and he watched the first two two plays down front, and then he came back and sat with me for the third, and um and I saw him starting to cry, um, even in the funny parts at the beginning, and um, he just kept crying and crying and crying, and um, and at the end we were supposed to go over to Billy Porter, and Shark Sand had gone back into um Saturday party with a book written by Harvey Fierstein.
Yes, but based on a book unless somebody actually said, No, he didn't write the musical. He wrote the book based on the book by Harvey. But anyway, so he was supposed to we were supposed to go to a party, he said, No, I just want to go home, and he left, and I thought, you know, maybe it didn't feel right. Anyway, he calls me the next morning, and this is all I hear. That was mom, wasn't it? Wow. I'd say, uh, yeah. He said, why did you always say that it wasn't? And I said, Well, the woman was alive. I didn't want to insult her. I didn't want people thinking she was as mean as she sort of was. And I said, She did come around and all that. And he said, I just sat there going, my mother said that.
Wait, my mother said that. My mother said that. And it's something he didn't notice before. For 40 years. He's heterosexual. That's a lot. You know how this thing. But isn't that in that isn't that unbelievable? He finally figured it out. Wow. And he just went to the wheel. And what did your mom say when she saw the play?
[23:36] Harvey Fierstein: Oh, she loved the play. Oh my gosh. She and Estelle were friends. They became friends. And uh yeah, they became close. Yeah, Estelle was the housewife in Queens, you know, who used she was a big fan of mine who used to come to all my shows, you know, way before Torch Song, the three plays of Torch Song. She kept saying, Put it up, put a mother in your show, put a mother in your show, I'll play it. Put a mother. And I said, she came up to my to my belly button. And I thought, okay, I'll put a mother in it. It'll be very funny to have this little tiny thing come on stage. And I mean, you know, Estelle wore her own clothes. That was her own wig. That was her own Miami purse. It was her own bed.
You know, the or he just came in, you know. She didn't know it was buddy. She actually was that woman. I mean, Mercedes is a brilliant, brilliant actress. She is not that woman. Estelle was that woman. Which was but it but for my brother, it was uh it was a really emotional thing that he went through.
[24:34] Michael Urie: Do you, Michael, have you perfected your Harvey Fierstein impression? And can you do it right now?
[24:39] Michael Urie: I've never heard him do it. Should I put my fingers in my ear?
[24:47] Harvey Fierstein: Mary, you can put your fingers in your ear. There was a point where I thought maybe the the I the they would I when I first was like really planning on doing it I was like is there any place where I could do Harvey in the play? Like that like maybe the drag queen maybe the drag personas spoke you know but it it's only there's only one line in the play that you could do it.
[25:13] Michael Urie: Which is it which is answer the phone at the end of you know when you're waking up in the morning happy hope with the bewildered yeah that's the only that's the only place that I would that I could think that that you could do with that. No I could do I could the that's the reason I mean teasing about it I mean I I don't know if you notice but he does dead on impression of three of the people in that play. He does he does Mercedes and he does um and he does uh Michael Rose with the and you do and you do Ward also Ward a little bit too where do you do Ward I forget uh the original wide plank oak floor so he so he lampoons the people on stage with him.
[26:04] Harvey Fierstein: Yeah.
[26:05] Michael Urie: And Harvey do you have a Michael Urie impression?
[26:08] Harvey Fierstein: No I do. Do you yes but I'm doing it he has to go on stage every nickel I mean it's like you know you know when you when when the last thing you ever want to tell an actor who's doing something funny is oh and when you did this it was so because they will never be able to do it again. You don't want you don't you don't ever. A mirror is the worst thing you can give an actor. That's why do you read reviews?
[26:32] Michael Urie: I don't read reviews for that reason. And it's like that was good? Oh, that was good. Okay.
[26:43] Harvey Fierstein: They're bad, your friends will read them theater.
[26:45] Michael Urie: That's exactly right. You find out in a matter of yeah, but no, but you have to see what he's d I can't believe he said. Do you know what he said about you with them?
[26:53] Harvey Fierstein: Yeah.
[26:53] Michael Urie: Yeah, friends will call you.
[26:55] Harvey Fierstein: Well, I could talk to the both of you for at least two more hours, but uh we are out of time, so thank you for both for being here. I really appreciate it. Nice to talk to you.
[27:01] Gordon Cox: One question on the test about geology. That was Harvey Fierstein and Michael Urie on their revised version of Torch Song, now playing it off Broadway's second stage theater. On the next episode of Stagecraft, I'll be talking to Jonathan Groff, the Broadway favorite from Hamilton and Spring Awakening, who's now headlining David Fincher's buzzy new Netflix series, Mind Hunter. Until then, see you at the theater.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
