Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Joe Iconis

How to make your musical go viral, according to the fan-fave composer... Read More

From the show: Stagecraft with Gordon Cox

28 mins
8/21/18

Guests

Featured Shows

About

How to make your musical go viral, according to the fan-fave composer.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Gordon Cox: You're listening to Stagecraft, Variety's Theater Podcast, taking you backstage and behind the scenes at the biggest hits on Broadway, off Broadway, and beyond.

[0:13] Gordon Cox: I'm your host, Gordon Cox.

[0:16] Gordon Cox: On this episode of Stagecraft, I talked to Joe Iconis, the cult favorite composer behind the musical Be More Chill, now playing off Broadway.

[0:24] Gordon Cox: The show came and went quietly in 2015 at Two River Theater in New Jersey.

[0:28] Gordon Cox: But three years later, the original score has racked up a whopping 100 million streams, driven by a national and international fan base that has bought advanced tickets to this new production of Be More Chill to the tune of 1.2 million dollars, which is an astonishing number for a little off Broadway show that purportedly no one's ever heard of.

[0:46] Gordon Cox: Iconis is here with me in the studio to talk about his work, his fans, the performance he calls his family, and what's next.

[0:52] Gordon Cox: Hi Joe, thanks for being here.

[0:54] Joe Iconis: Hi, thanks for having me.

[0:55] Gordon Cox: So to get the kind of big question out of the way for all the aspiring musical theater creators out there, how do you create a grassroots hit musical?

[1:05] Gordon Cox: How do you do that?

[1:06] Joe Iconis: Um there are a few steps to doing that. The first one is to write a musical.

[1:11] Joe Iconis: Right. And then the next step is to have it become a viral sensation.

[1:17] Gordon Cox: Right. Well, yeah, how does that happen?

[1:19] Joe Iconis: Uh I do not know. The hilarious thing is that I, as the writer of one, could not tell you how one goes about doing it, and I certainly did not try.

[1:31] Gordon Cox: Right.

[1:31] Joe Iconis: I didn't set out to write a viral, you know, grassroots musical. It just kind of happened.

[1:37] Joe Iconis: It might not even be possible, right?

[1:39] Gordon Cox: I don't know how that—I don't think so.

[1:40] Joe Iconis: I mean, it's probably possible. Like now that it's happened, I feel like we'll see a lot of people really try to like engineer the very organic and authentic thing that happened with Be More Chill.

[1:50] Gordon Cox: Yeah.

[1:51] Joe Iconis: And so then once people start doing that, maybe then I'll be able to like, you know, figure out how it's actually done.

[1:56] Gordon Cox: So you don't have a theory about like, oh, it was referred on YouTube something, you know, whatever, whatever.

[2:01] Joe Iconis: You know, I think it was a few things. I think it was sort of like a perfect storm of shows that were sort of popular around the same time that had some crossover with my work and Be More Chill in particular, you know.

[2:14] Joe Iconis: Like, um, The Lightning Thief is a musical that has a fan base that definitely intersects with the Be More Chill fan base.

[2:23] Joe Iconis: And the book writer is the same guy.

[2:25] Gordon Cox: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[2:26] Joe Iconis: So Joe Tracz, the book writer of Be More Chill, collaborated on The Lightning Thief with a whole bunch of other people who I often work with.

[2:37] Joe Iconis: And so here the score of The Lightning Thief was written by this guy Rob Rokicki, who's a good buddy of mine, who's in my band, and George Salazar was in The Lightning Thief, and it was directed by Steven Brackett, who directed Be More Chill.

[2:47] Joe Iconis: So it was all this sort of crossover.

[2:48] Gordon Cox: Yeah, George Salazar, we should say, is um, he's not technically the star of the show, but he is the actor that definitely everybody cheered at when he came out.

[2:59] Joe Iconis: He is the kind of breakout star, let's say right now.

[3:01] Gordon Cox: For sure, for sure.

[3:02] Joe Iconis: You know, and George kind of was like the eye of the storm as far as what happened with Be More Chill a year ago.

[3:08] Joe Iconis: Um, and I think that was because George's song in Be More Chill is the song called "Michael in the Bathroom." And that was the thing that initially turned people on to the show.

[3:18] Joe Iconis: You know, so everyone's entry point initially was through that song.

[3:24] Gordon Cox: And what was your experience of it? Take us through the experience of it. First of all, it was a commission, right?

[3:30] Joe Iconis: It was, yeah.

[3:31] Gordon Cox: And how did they bring the novel to you? Had you read the novel?

[3:35] Joe Iconis: What was—so the novel was—the novel happened before the commission happened, right?

[3:41] Joe Iconis: The novel—uh, was your discovery of the novel.

[3:44] Joe Iconis: My discovery of the novel. Yes, yes, yes.

[3:46] Joe Iconis: The novel was given to me by my agent just in a very sort of like he had read it and he said, I think there's something here. I think you might be into this. I could see you getting excited about this material.

[4:01] Joe Iconis: Um, and he never really does that. And he hasn't really done it since.

[4:07] Joe Iconis: You know, it was sort of this—it's such a random thing. And I read the book and it was a very like no-brainer. You know, I read it and I felt like, oh yeah, this is something I can turn into a musical.

[4:16] Gordon Cox: Can you identify kind of what exactly about it you thought, oh yeah?

[4:20] Joe Iconis: Mm-hmm.

[4:20] Joe Iconis: For sure, for sure, for sure. A few things. I think we should say actually for—we haven't—we should talk about the plot a little while, actually. Explain the plot while you explain to me what you responded to in it.

[4:30] Joe Iconis: Absolutely. So Be More Chill is about a teenager named Jeremy here, and he is like the least special teenager who ever lived. There's nothing remarkable about him.

[4:40] Joe Iconis: And he finds out that there is this thing called a squip, and a squip is this Japanese supercomputer inside a pill, and teenagers everywhere swallow the squip and then the supercomputer implants in their brain and a voice tells them how to behave.

[4:58] Joe Iconis: And so Jeremy finds out that all these kids who have it together in high school have it together because there's this Japanese supercomputer that's telling them how to go about their lives.

[5:08] Joe Iconis: And so that's essentially the plot of Be More Chill. And the novel, written by the late Ned Vizzini, really excited me because of the characters first and foremost.

[5:22] Joe Iconis: You know, I loved that they were these teenage characters that felt—they felt like, you know, they were in some ways they were archetypes but they were really sort of like falling in between the lines like they're all kind of messy and they were characters that felt real even though they were living in this heightened world and I just immediately responded to that.

[5:44] Joe Iconis: You know, it's a story that's solely populated by kids who feel like misfits, kids who feel like they don't quite fit in anywhere, and I just—I’ve in my career I've naturally returned to characters like that, be they high school kids or adults or animals, whatever. It's like I continually write about people who feel like they don't belong, and so that was like an immediate like, oh yeah, I love these—I love these people that I'm reading about.

[5:44] Joe Iconis: And then the idea of these really relatable specific characters kind of bumming around in this sci-fi story was really exciting to me. And you know, I've written shows about young people before. I love writing young characters, but the thing that was like, oh man, this is a show I could spend some years working on was the opportunity to talk about these huge issues and these issues that young people experience in a very real, heightened way, but that adults experience as well, to explore these issues through this lens of like a sci-fi comedy, you know, which was really different than other stuff I've done.

[7:01] Gordon Cox: Yeah.

[7:02] Joe Iconis: And so you got a commission from Two River in New Jersey. And then the show happened. And then what happened?

[7:10] Joe Iconis: So the show happened in the spring of 2015. And a lot of the people who were in that production are now in the off-Broadway production.

[7:17] Gordon Cox: Yeah, yeah, we're like half and half.

[7:18] Joe Iconis: Half and half?

[7:18] Gordon Cox: Yeah.

[7:19] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, including George.

[7:20] Gordon Cox: Uh yeah, yeah, including Salazar, for real.

[7:23] Joe Iconis: We, you know, leading up to the opening of the show at Two River, everyone was really excited. It felt like there was a huge amount of momentum. I've been in this position a few times in my career where like I'm working on a new musical, and everyone's like, oh man, this one is gonna blow up. Like this is gonna be the one that goes into New York and is at a fancy nonprofit and goes to Broadway and does that whole thing.

[7:49] Joe Iconis: And that was definitely there with Be More Chill. The audiences in Jersey were loving it. They were all like, we've never seen anything like this. It felt like there was a real connection.

[7:57] Joe Iconis: Um, and then we opened, and you know, we got a review in the Times that was sort of like meh, and that just made everything disappear, which is what happens when you have a new musical that doesn't have any famous people and doesn't have a commercial producer attached and isn't based on a bankable property. It just kind of goes away.

[8:21] Joe Iconis: And it was so disappointing. Everyone working on it was like the most sure that we were gonna get to continue on with the show, and it didn't happen, and so it was this really like—it was just a big disappointment for a while, you know.

[8:36] Joe Iconis: And the magic thing that happened is that Two River Theater said, even though the show is clearly not going on, we're really proud of it, and we want to preserve it. We want to make a cast album of the show. Ghost Light Records, Kurt Deutsch, who's been a big supporter of mine my whole career, he came to see the show, and he felt similarly, he felt like the score deserved to be preserved on record, and so we made this album a couple months after we closed.

[8:47] Joe Iconis: Whoever produced it made it happen, and it was released the Halloween after we closed, so a few months after we closed the album was out, and this would have been Halloween 2015.

[8:47] Joe Iconis: Yeah, and so the album, people liked it, but it was the kind of thing where the amount of people who liked the Be More Chill cast album are the amount of people who you would think would like the cast album of a musical that no one had ever heard about that played for five weeks in New Jersey.

[9:35] Gordon Cox: Right.

[9:35] Joe Iconis: You know, it's like not—it was everyone was like perfectly thrilled, but like that everyone could fit in a club, right? Probably like literally called 54 Below, like that's everyone who cared about the Be More Chill album.

[9:47] Joe Iconis: And so it was just kind of there, you know, and I tried so hard to get the show back on a stage anywhere in the subsequent years, and no one was interested, which I understand.

[10:02] Joe Iconis: And then in the spring of 2017, which is just like a little over a year ago, I just started noticing truly out of the blue social media attention for Be More Chill.

[10:17] Joe Iconis: And it was the kind of thing where I would get tagged in an Instagram post about a character in the show where people would be tweeting like lyrics. And it—you know, I have a fairly healthy sort of culty fan base, you know, and I've had that for a while.

[10:34] Joe Iconis: And um, so I've been lucky enough to, you know, have people tell me they like my stuff and get excited about my work online. But this was like nothing like I had ever experienced before.

[10:45] Joe Iconis: And so it got to a point where everything was about "Michael in the Bathroom." And it got to a point where I texted George Salazar, who, you know, I'm very good friends with and who I work with all the time, and I was like, did you do something with Be More Chill? Like is something happening that I don't know about?

[11:01] Joe Iconis: And he said, I was gonna ask you the same thing. I'm getting all of this Be More Chill attention. The same thing happened with Joe Tracz. And so the three of us were kind of like, what, you know, what's going on? Everyone thought someone else had been doing something, but no one had.

[11:18] Joe Iconis: And so it sort of, you know, started growing and growing and growing. And when it first started, you know, it was the kind of thing where I called like Sh-K-Boom, Ghost Light who put out the album and said, you know, there’s something happening with this album. Like people are actually listening to it, and it feels like it's for some reason in the culture in a way that it has not been in the last two years.

[11:42] Joe Iconis: Um and you know, Ghostlight, they're amazing, but their initial response was sort of like, oh yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, that's cute. I'm glad that, you know, some kid in Idaho tweeted at you, and now you think that you're gonna be on top of the world or something.

[11:56] Joe Iconis: Um, but then of course, you know, within a matter of weeks, like numbers started coming in, and then Ghost Light was like, wait a minute, like people are actually buying this. Why are they buying it?

[12:06] Joe Iconis: And so then, you know, Kurt Deutsch then called me and he's like, are you doing something with Be More Chill? What's going on? It's like, man, I don't know. It's just happening.

[12:12] Joe Iconis: And we should say that the fans do an extraordinary amount of fan art. There are these things called animatics, which are essentially animated storyboards, right? And there's, you know, one for "Michael in the Bathroom," and I guess the rest of the score are made by the same—oh, all of it.

[12:31] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah. And um, I'm told there were action figures at a recent performance of homemade action figures, obviously, of characters in the—

[12:32] Gordon Cox: Oh my gosh.

[12:39] Joe Iconis: Yeah, I have seen the most extraordinary art created by kids and adults based on Be More Chill. I can't even begin to tell you. It's just extraordinary.

[12:52] Joe Iconis: And also like fan fiction is also a huge thing, which is a world that I knew nothing about. Also, I should point out that I have never seen security and crowds at the Signature Center waiting to stage door actors coming out.

[13:07] Joe Iconis: I mean, this was—it's the fan reaction is extremely vocal in the room and then extremely sort of rabid but not in a scary way. Or at least it didn't seem in a scary way. It just seemed very avid and very excited.

[13:22] Gordon Cox: Yeah, you know, and I think that the first few previews especially had a particularly, you know, excitable. And people have come from all around the country.

[13:31] Joe Iconis: Oh yeah.

[13:32] Gordon Cox: Also it sounds like around the world. If they haven't yet, they will be.

[13:35] Joe Iconis: I know their tickets have been bought from around the world. Yesterday I met someone from Australia who came specifically to see the show.

[13:41] Gordon Cox: Wow.

[13:42] Joe Iconis: At the matinee, at the evening, I met multiple people from Thailand who did not know each other, who were there.

[13:48] Gordon Cox: Wow.

[13:48] Joe Iconis: Uh, Sweden—I mean literally Brazil, like all over.

[13:52] Gordon Cox: And we've only—we've played seven performances.

[13:55] Joe Iconis: Yes.

[13:55] Gordon Cox: Yeah, we're early in the run right now.

[13:56] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[13:57] Gordon Cox: Yeah.

[13:57] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[13:57] Joe Iconis: Um, but I think that part of the passion at these early shows too is that these are people who have truly loved this piece of theater for a year and they've just never seen it.

[14:10] Joe Iconis: Like it's what's so crazy about it is that it's the, you know, some at every performance multiple people have said to me, like, "Oh my god, I feel like I'm in Hamilton," you know, like as far as the audience reaction, and it's that is not a—I was sitting in the middle of it the other night.

[14:26] Joe Iconis: Like that's right.

[14:27] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[14:28] Joe Iconis: And um, and it's just we have the reaction of like a mega hit show without having actually like had the hit show first.

[14:37] Joe Iconis: You know, it's like what happens to a show when it becomes that kind of hit.

[14:41] Joe Iconis: Yeah, we just—there was never a show in the first place.

[14:43] Joe Iconis: And so we have this bizarre situation where like we're in early previews and we have this audience that's like going nuts for it.

[14:50] Joe Iconis: Right.

[14:50] Joe Iconis: Um, which is, you know, both like good and bad in some ways.

[14:54] Gordon Cox: Let's talk a little bit about your process and how you work. Um, which comes first for you, music or lyrics?

[14:59] Joe Iconis: Uh, they both kind of come at the same time, you know.

[15:03] Joe Iconis: It's, uh, it's where I'm a really messy writer, and so I don't mean it—it means like literal mess or just in terms of snippets here and there.

[15:12] Joe Iconis: Um, all those things you just said, yeah.

[15:14] Joe Iconis: Uh, it means that I, uh, for starters, I don't have like a set time of day that I write.

[15:20] Joe Iconis: You know, I know writers who are super rigid and like, "Yeah, I wake up and then I have six hours of writing and that's when I write."

[15:26] Joe Iconis: Um, and I just can't do that, you know.

[15:28] Joe Iconis: And, uh, and so for me, when I do write, I'll usually like obsess over an idea for a long time.

[15:35] Joe Iconis: And then when I actually put pen to paper, um, I feel like I've already like sort of written the song in my head before I actually start, you know, writing it.

[15:43] Joe Iconis: And usually I'll start with a hook or some major idea.

[15:47] Joe Iconis: Um, and that will usually—that will always be actually lyric driven, it'll be the words, and then in those words, there's usually some sort of implied music in my head.

[15:56] Joe Iconis: Uh, and then I just kind of go back and forth, you know, and I write—um, I bounce around a lot when I write, so I'll start, you know, at a coffee shop and then I'll go to a piano and then I'll, you know, go to a bar and then I'll pace around my apartment and I like to sort of, you know, bop around as I'm making stuff.

[16:16] Gordon Cox: How long does it take to write a song? If you've done this pre-thinking, how long does then a song usually take you?

[16:18] Joe Iconis: It's truly different for every song, you know, it's like the ultimate depending on the needs of the patient, it's gonna take as long or as short.

[16:33] Joe Iconis: You know, there are songs in Be More Chill that feel like they've taken, you know, four years to write because I, you know, worked on them in New Jersey, you know, leading up to the show and couldn't get it right and I'm still working on it here and, you know, still not getting it right and then so it's like, oh that song's a year in the making.

[16:33] Joe Iconis: And then there's other songs like there's a song in the show called "A Guy That I'd Kind of Be Into" that I had to write in a pinch when we were in rehearsals for the first production, um, and it was just one of those things where like we had this time to stage this number, I knew I needed a number there and I just—it's like if I'm not—if I don't write this now, this thing's never gonna end up in the show.

[17:07] Joe Iconis: And so I, you know, ran away and in 40 minutes I had the whole song.

[17:10] Gordon Cox: Right.

[17:10] Joe Iconis: So like it's just, you know, it—and it's always a surprise to me.

[17:14] Joe Iconis: I never know how quickly something will come or how, you know, torturous the process will be.

[17:21] Gordon Cox: And what makes a good musical theater song in your view?

[17:25] Joe Iconis: Um, I think that a good musical theater song is, uh, is one that takes, uh, takes the audience on a journey of some kind.

[17:36] Joe Iconis: Uh, it feels kind of, kind of like cheesy to even say that.

[17:40] Joe Iconis: Um, but, uh, it's the truth.

[17:42] Joe Iconis: You know, I think a good musical theater song, you start in one place and you finish in another, and that's kind of like the simplest thing, you know, you should be moving somewhere somehow, you know.

[17:52] Joe Iconis: And I think that the sort of common, uh, notion about musical theater writing and musical theater songs is that, you know, if the song doesn't move the plot forward, you have to cut it.

[18:02] Joe Iconis: Um, but I don't always think that.

[18:03] Joe Iconis: I think if the song is moving a character forward or, you know, um, or whatever, that's totally valid, you know.

[18:10] Joe Iconis: Um, but it's that—it's movement, I think.

[18:13] Gordon Cox: Right.

[18:13] Joe Iconis: And rhyme.

[18:14] Joe Iconis: I'm like the biggest stickler for rhyme.

[18:16] Gordon Cox: Oh, really?

[18:17] Joe Iconis: Oh my god, yeah.

[18:19] Joe Iconis: I get made fun of so badly.

[18:21] Gordon Cox: By who? Who are the people who are making fun of your rhymes?

[18:24] Joe Iconis: Like other musical theater writers.

[18:25] Gordon Cox: Right.

[18:25] Joe Iconis: I like literally feel picked.

[18:27] Joe Iconis: I feel like I'm like Poindexter over here trying to, you know, make rhymes.

[18:31] Joe Iconis: Perfect rhymes, yeah.

[18:32] Joe Iconis: What I—I oh my god, I've had so many, uh, truly like fights about it because I'm, I'm like kind of a bitch about it.

[18:40] Joe Iconis: Um, but I'm proud of that.

[18:42] Joe Iconis: I like, I, you know, I've said so many times, like there's no such thing as a perfect rhyme because it either rhymes or it doesn't.

[18:47] Gordon Cox: Like wow, all right.

[18:49] Joe Iconis: Those are fighting words.

[18:51] Joe Iconis: I mean, but it's like, you know, it just, it, it, it's language, it's syllables, it's, it's, uh, a word rhymes or it does not.

[18:58] Gordon Cox: Aside from perfect rhyme, what in musical theater would you like to see more of?

[19:04] Joe Iconis: I would like to see, uh, more of musicals that are populated by characters and people, uh, who don't look like robots, uh, who don't look like sort of sparkly musical theater robots.

[19:21] Joe Iconis: I like seeing interesting, um, strange human beings on a stage, and I like when those interesting and strange human beings have material, uh, written for them that is worthy of their, uh, strangeness.

[19:35] Joe Iconis: Um, so that's something I would love to see.

[19:36] Joe Iconis: I would love to see more, uh, just personality-driven work.

[19:41] Joe Iconis: You know, I feel like a lot of musicals that I see, especially in a, in a, on a, uh, uh, in the commercial sphere, uh, they feel a little bit like musicals made by committee, you know, it's like I, I feel like sometimes you see a show and I just, it's like I can hear the conversations, you know, behind the scenes about which number is gonna offend the least amount of people and, uh, and it, uh, it just gives everything the sameness that, that kind of bugs me.

[19:41] Joe Iconis: And I think what's so funny about it is that it, it, oh, it seems it without fail the shows of every season that are like the hit shows are the ones that don't do that.

[20:18] Joe Iconis: Like they're always the shows that are strange and that didn't follow the rules and that feel like, you know, the shows that people like love to call like edgy in quotation marks and downtown in quotation marks, those are always the ones that are like the successful ones.

[20:18] Joe Iconis: But it seems, you know, from, for me at least, it feels like as someone who, who definitely, you know, lives in that world, um, it's so hard to get people to get behind that kind of writing, you know, so I just want to see more shows that will make it easier for me to get my shows produced.

[20:49] Joe Iconis: I'm just totally selfish.

[20:51] Joe Iconis: I feel like being a creator of musical theater is one of the hardest, uh, I don't know, kind of, uh, aspects of the business to break into, right? I mean, just in part because first of all, you have to find collaborators you like, right, and click with, and then just in order to get people to hear or see your work, you have to like get some actor or like hire the actors and rent a studio and hire some musicians and record a demo, and it just feels like the barrier to entry is, uh, even higher than it is for a lot of, uh, other, um, do you—what's your advice for aspiring musical theater creators who, um, break into it?

[20:51] Joe Iconis: Yeah, my, uh, my advice is to, uh, to immerse yourself in the community, uh, whatever that means to you or whatever that, you know, be that like the, the theater community in New York or wherever you're from.

[20:51] Joe Iconis: You know, it's, it's hard because as you said, there's no, there's no rule book, you know, there's no like, there's, there's no how to become a musical theater writer.

[20:51] Joe Iconis: It's so nebulous and it's so scary, and for me the thing that saved me and the thing that allowed me to enter into the world was literally just finding people who were doing the same thing and connecting with them and learning from them and, um, being open.

[22:18] Joe Iconis: You know, if I didn't, if I didn't go to the NYU graduate musical theater writing program, um, I never would have been able to enter the musical theater world.

[22:26] Joe Iconis: Also because my, my personality, especially at the time when I was sort of, you know, finishing undergrad and going into grad school, I was like super reserved.

[22:35] Joe Iconis: I, um, never thought that I was the sort of person who would be able to like sing in front of people or, you know, which we should say you do regularly, you perform as Iconis and Family.

[22:44] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, all the time.

[22:45] Joe Iconis: And um, and that felt so beyond anything I would ever imagine doing.

[22:51] Joe Iconis: The thought of like going up to someone and introducing myself and being like, "Hi, I'm Joe, I wrote a musical, you should do it," like truly just beyond terrifying to me, like Panic Attack City.

[23:02] Joe Iconis: Um, and so for me, going to that program and just being around all these other people who are writing musicals and are for the most part just as confused, um, made me feel like, okay, this is something that human beings do, and they start somewhere and this is that place, and then, you know, you just learn how to like swim in the pond, or you learn like this isn't it for me, and you get out of there, you know.

[23:26] Gordon Cox: And the, uh, and Family of Iconis and Family that you perform with, is that sort of an outgrowth of that community that you found?

[23:34] Joe Iconis: Um, is that how you found a lot of those people?

[23:36] Joe Iconis: Yeah, for sure.

[23:37] Joe Iconis: You know, I, um, when I first graduated school, I, uh, had a musical that was in development, uh, with a nonprofit theater, and I sort of felt like, oh cool, my musical, um, is in development with this theater, it's gonna open off Broadway, it'll transfer to Broadway, I'm gonna be set for life.

[23:57] Joe Iconis: Awesome.

[23:57] Joe Iconis: And like clearly that didn't happen, and it's like not the way it works.

[23:59] Joe Iconis: And I didn't know about like musical theater development timelines when I graduated.

[24:03] Joe Iconis: Uh, and so after, you know, like a year, I felt like, wait a minute, I'm writing all of these songs and I have all of this stuff, and no one's hearing it, and that doesn't seem correct.

[24:14] Joe Iconis: And so I—it was like I want to just put on a show, and it came from like the most, um, you know, just, uh, the cheesy, like, you know, let's put on a show in the backyard kind of thing.

[24:24] Joe Iconis: I didn't know how to do that at all, and so I found a theater company, um, that was, you know, run by someone I knew and was like, "Hey, can like I want to do a show with my songs. How do we do that?"

[24:35] Joe Iconis: And they helped me out.

[24:36] Joe Iconis: Um, and so then that's how this sort of like Iconis and Family thing was born, and or just as far as like me doing shows was born.

[24:42] Joe Iconis: Yeah, and um, the more and more I started doing those shows, the more and more I started meeting, you know, actors and people and, and kind of formed this group, you know, and it was just literally just actors or musicians who I would see and I was a fan of and I would just say, "Hey, you know, I saw you perform at this gig or I saw you in this play and I think you're great.

[25:06] Joe Iconis: And, uh, if you want to come sing with me, let's do it."

[25:09] Joe Iconis: You know, and at the time when that, when we first started doing the shows, like 2000, you know, seven, 2008, um, there wasn't quite as much of a musical theater concert scene as there was, as there is now, yeah, and so it sort of felt like this like kind of new thing, you know, and even in the context of the musical theater concert scene, most of the shows that I would go see as far as new musical theater shows felt like recitals to me.

[25:31] Joe Iconis: Like they always felt like, you know, like a night of songs by such and such composer with like music stands, um, which is totally valid, but I always felt like, oh, I don't want to do that.

[25:39] Joe Iconis: I want to do something that feels like a cross between a, like sort of classic cabaret like, you know, Don't Tell Mama in 1989 cabaret and like a full-blown rock concert.

[25:49] Joe Iconis: Um, and so I just sort of approached it in a different way from the get-go and, um, yeah.

[25:53] Gordon Cox: What's next for Be More Chill after its run off Broadway?

[25:56] Joe Iconis: Uh, I don't know.

[25:58] Joe Iconis: You know, we're really hoping that it, uh, it moves on to another life post off Broadway.

[26:04] Joe Iconis: Um, of course that's like not totally in the control of, of certainly not in the control of myself.

[26:04] Joe Iconis: Um, a lot of things need to, you know, happen, a lot of things need to line up, but I mean we're, you know, we're knock wood, we're doing super well off Broadway as far as things like ticket sales and, you know, and audience reaction and all that.

[26:23] Joe Iconis: Yeah, really unusually well for a show that, uh, as you said, you know, played the five weeks in New Jersey, the end.

[26:31] Gordon Cox: Yeah.

[26:31] Joe Iconis: And there's no famous people in it.

[26:33] Joe Iconis: And there's no, I mean, you know, like sort of theater, like Will Roland is theater famous.

[26:36] Gordon Cox: Right.

[26:36] Joe Iconis: Will Roland is the, uh, plays the, um, the—I was about to say title character, but his name is, uh, Jeremy, thank you.

[26:42] Joe Iconis: And um, leading man.

[26:44] Gordon Cox: Yeah, leading man.

[26:45] Joe Iconis: And he was, uh, in the original, or at least in the Broadway cast of Dear Evan Hansen.

[26:49] Joe Iconis: Um, yeah, and even that with—and what's hilarious though is that people have talked about Will Roland as sort of being like star casting, which I mean is hilarious to me for so many reasons.

[27:00] Joe Iconis: Uh, you know, because it's like, it's, uh, that's also like such a theater thing, or like these people that we build up and be like, "Oh well, you know, you have to put like this, you know, quote unquote star in the show."

[27:08] Joe Iconis: And it's like nobody knows who these people are.

[27:09] Joe Iconis: Yeah, and nobody knows who Will Roland, no one knows who I am.

[27:11] Joe Iconis: Uh, and but whatever.

[27:13] Joe Iconis: But, uh, but Will is someone who I've—Will's been in like the Iconis and Family stuff for 10 years.

[27:18] Joe Iconis: You know, I've known Will for literally 10 years and, um, and have worked with him on so many shows.

[27:24] Joe Iconis: And the fact that now he's like the leading man in my musical, and people talk about him like it's star casting, is just the coolest, most hilarious thing.

[27:34] Gordon Cox: Right.

[27:34] Joe Iconis: I love it.

[27:35] Gordon Cox: I can't wait to see what happens with the show.

[27:37] Joe Iconis: Me too.

[27:38] Gordon Cox: Yeah.

[27:38] Gordon Cox: Thanks for joining me.

[27:39] Joe Iconis: Thank you for having me.

[27:40] Gordon Cox: Yeah, nice to talk to you.

[27:48] Joe Iconis: That was Joe Iconis on his popular new musical, Be More Chill.

[27:52] Gordon Cox: Now playing it off Broadway's Signature Center.

[27:54] Gordon Cox: If you like what you've heard on this and other episodes of Stagecraft, don't forget to rate and review us on iTunes and subscribe wherever finer podcasts are dispensed.

[28:01] Gordon Cox: On the next episode of Stagecraft in two weeks, I talk to Andy Carl, the Broadway favorite, now starring in the new musical adaptation of Pretty Woman.

[28:08] Gordon Cox: Until then, see you at the theater.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred