Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#100 - Take A Bow LIVE!

JJ Niemann, Presley Ryan, Anthony Rosenthal, Max Von Essen, Charlie Alterman, and Eli Tokash go LIVE to celebrate 100 episodes of Take A Bow! The 100th Episode of Take A Bow is unlike any podcast episode you've ever heard before... Read More

From the show: Take A Bow

1 h 24 mins
4/21/22

Guests

Featured Shows

About

JJ Niemann, Presley Ryan, Anthony Rosenthal, Max Von Essen, Charlie Alterman, and Eli Tokash go LIVE to celebrate 100 episodes of Take A Bow! The 100th Episode of Take A Bow is unlike any podcast episode you've ever heard before. Enjoy chats, performances, audience engagement, and so much more in a thrillingly fun episode that is not to be missed.

Take A Bow LIVE! talking points include:

  • Mental Health of performing
  • Song Writing
  • Falsettos/Newsies
  • Beetlejuice/Fun Home
  • Tony Nominee/ An American in Paris/ Secret Garden
  • Book of Mormon/ For You, Paige/ Ratatouille the Musical
  • Swing life
  • Current stage of Broadway
  • Audience Questions including favorite fails
  • Music Directing
  • + a ton more

Connect with JJ Niemann, Presley Ryan, Max Von Essen, Anthony Rosenthal and Charlie Alterman on Instagram: @jjniemann, @prezryan, @maxizpad, @anthony_rosenthal, and @charliealterman

Connect with Take A Bow on Instagram: @takeabowpodcast

Connect with host, Eli Tokash on Instagram: @tokash_eli

Produced by the Broadway Podcast Network

Edited by Tessie Tokash (@tessietokash)

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Eli Tokash: Oh my word.

[0:03] Eli Tokash: Hello everyone and welcome to the 100th episode of Take A Bow.

[0:08] Eli Tokash: I'm your host, Eli Tokash, and this week's episode is literally unlike any other podcast you've ever heard ever before in your life. Not even just like an episode of Take A Bow. This week's episode is featuring some of your favorite Broadway performers that we've had on the podcast from the first 100 episodes, or I guess the first 99 episodes, because this is the 100th episode. They have come back and they are revisiting the whole podcasting Take A Bow family to share what they've been up to since they've been on the podcast.

[0:42] Eli Tokash: So these are actually some earlier guests that we have on talking about what they're up to, and then not only are they coming on to chat with us and take a bunch of audience questions that was received live. That's right, live. For those of you who don't know, this episode was recorded live at the Green Room 42 with a sold-out crowd, which was absolutely unexpected, but so happy that that it happened and that it all worked out, and we did it in a safe and just amazingly fun manner.

[1:16] Eli Tokash: Before we turn it over to the 100th episode, as always, let's talk about some Broadway news, shall we? So, first off, happy opening to the minute, How I Learned to Drive, and For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide / When the Rainbow Is Enough. Congratulations are in order all around, but we also have some more openings.

[1:36] Eli Tokash: Well, these openings are a happy preview wish. Happy previews to POTUS and A Strange Loop. And tonight, if you're listening to this Thursday, April 21st, when it comes out, the Hangman opens on Broadway. So happy preview and happy first performance to all of you. Very exciting. It's wonderful to see all these wonderful new pieces come to Broadway.

[2:00] Eli Tokash: I've heard such great things about POTUS and A Strange Loop. And of course, The Minutes and How I Learned to Drive and For Colored Girls, like all the things. I've heard great things about all these shows, so I'm so excited to see it. POTUS and A Strange Loop have been out for like about a week now. And then tonight is the Hangman. So I actually haven't heard much about that.

[2:17] Eli Tokash: But I have heard a lot about the other shows that I mentioned. I cannot wait to see them all. And with not much going on this week in the Broadway world other than a bunch of a million openings, there was only one casting announcement this week and not much other news to talk about.

[2:33] Eli Tokash: So I'm gonna keep this intro short, but I wanted to congratulate Christian Borle, Jay Harrison G, and Adriana Hicks to lead their new Broadway show, Some Like It Hot. So congratulations to you all. The cast that they've announced is amazing. They've only announced select casts at this time.

[2:50] Eli Tokash: But it looks amazing and it's opening in the fall. So keep your eye out for this one, because it looks like it's gonna be a good one, and it's based on the movie, so we'll see what happens. So with this week's episode, we are not going to be having a drama dictionary.

[3:04] Eli Tokash: However, I did want to use this time to say thank you to everyone who came out to be there live for the live show. I don't expect you to be reliving the show right now on this audio version of it. But I just wanted to put it out there in the universe that I'm so, so grateful to everyone who came out and supported, saw these wonderful performances and kind of participated in the live show, which you all will see how they were able to participate and really be a part of it.

[3:33] Eli Tokash: It was so wonderful, and huge, huge, huge shout out to the amazing guests that were willing to lend their days off, their Monday nights to take a bow and perform and chat with us. That includes JJ Niemann, Presley Ryan, Max Von Essen, Anthony Rosenthal, and Charlie Alterman.

[3:56] Eli Tokash: I also do want to shout out Sierra Renee who was willing to do it and totally was planning to be there, and then she was recovering from getting sick, and she just recently had a negative COVID test and everything, so she still felt like it was a little too close, and her voice wasn't up to where she wanted it to be. So we just alluded to playing it safe and she was able to watch from home, which was so lovely and so grateful.

[4:24] Eli Tokash: So shout out to all of them and their kindness that they were willing to come out and perform with us. That being said, I want to say that this was my first ever live show that I have ever put on. So that means like producing. It was my first time like actually hosting a show, I guess you could say, live with multiple people. Figuring all of that stuff out was crazy.

[4:50] Eli Tokash: And then of course, it was one of my first times, actually, like the first time performing ever since my voice changed. And this is a song that I had never worked on, and I had made a switch to sing this song like the week before this live performance. So, gonna admit it was a crazy night for me. My brain was going a thousand miles a minute. Like it was just constantly racing.

[5:18] Eli Tokash: Totally forgot my words. Totally forgot how to sing. It was craziness. Once I forgot my words, it was just like, oh no. So, what I will say is I'm keeping everything live that happened live because you all deserve to experience the liveness of it all. And I think it's hilarious, and I think it's great.

[5:35] Eli Tokash: So I want to put it out there. However, if you want to stick around afterwards, after the live show is done, and in the outro of this podcast, I am going to be doing a live version of the song that I sang live at the Green Room 42. Just this time in my room where I've only sung with this new voice, and I'm not going to be as nervous, and I'm not going to be having a million things on my plate and on my mind.

[6:00] Eli Tokash: So stay tuned for a version where I actually know all the words and sing it properly. So if you want, if you want. So stay tuned if you want to have another little go. So let's turn it over to the live show of Take A Bow, the first ever. There's going to be more. Let's turn it over to Take A Bow Live.

[7:01] Eli Tokash: Good evening and welcome to the Green Room 42. Thank you so much for being here.

[7:11] Eli Tokash: At this time, we ask you, please take a moment and silence your phones at the Green Room 42. The use of photography and recording is strictly encouraged.

[7:22] Eli Tokash: And please tag us in your pictures and your videos at the Green Room 42. If you need to use the restroom, please exit through the doors you came in through, and they're located down the hall on the other side of the elevators.

[7:31] Eli Tokash: And if you'd like to order something during the performance, our servers will be available throughout the duration of the show, or you can use the table number on your lamp to order online. With those few necessities out of the way, I want you to please put your hands together for the reason you're all here. Take a Bow Live.

[7:59] Eli Tokash: Hi everyone. Yay! I'm so excited. Thank you all for coming tonight. It means the world to have so many familiar faces all in the same room again. This is kind of what I've always pictured for Take A Bow.

[8:15] Eli Tokash: And it's turned into a strictly an audio podcast because of the pandemic. And this idea formed just a couple weeks before the pandemic actually hit. And yeah, so now two years later, we're two years next week. So very excited that we've been doing this whole Take A Bow thing. Very exciting, yes.

[8:37] Eli Tokash: So here we are, two years later, and we're finally doing the first live presentation of Take A Bow. So very exciting all around. It's good. So good. I'm so thankful to have all of these wonderful artists that are going to perform for us tonight. They're gonna be amazing. They're gonna blow you away. Honest to God.

[8:57] Eli Tokash: What are you doing? Hi, Anthony. Anthony's one of the artists, and he's sitting with the guests. Great. Um, so yeah, so here we are. So Take A Bow is this is the 100th episode of Take A Bow, and this will be the what you all hear on the 100th episode.

[9:17] Eli Tokash: Everything that happens here tonight. So that means you all are also part of it. So all of your little shout-outs and reactions and everything, you will be able to hear that on the 100th episode. So I'm very excited for that, and I'm so excited that you guys get to be a part of that as well.

[9:32] Eli Tokash: I'm gonna kick, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yes, and this is our wonderful music director, Charlie Alterman, who's gonna be playing with us tonight. You all know him. He was on an episode of Take A Bow. He also we met in Pippin.

[9:45] Eli Tokash: Um, and speaking of Pippin, Sierra Renee is one of the performers that was scheduled to be here tonight. Unfortunately, she came down with COVID this past week and is still recovering. So she will not be here tonight, but we still have some incredible performances, and it means more time for everyone else to come on stage and perform and have their moment.

[10:05] Eli Tokash: That being said, I'm gonna kick off the night. I'm gonna sing a song. Yes, very exciting. And um, it's actually going to tease an upcoming guest that we have on Take A Bow. It's probably gonna be episode 102 with Ryan McCartan.

[10:25] Eli Tokash: So here is "Freeze Your Brain."

[10:38] ♪ Musical number: "Freeze Your Brain" — performed by Eli Tokash ♪

[13:09] Eli Tokash: Oh my goodness. Yes. Okay, fun fact. That was my first time performing since the voice change. Um, yeah, it was very stressful.

[13:26] Eli Tokash: Um, happy that that's out of the way. Happy that it was here with all of everyone I know. Um goodness. Um, so yeah, that was "Freeze Your Brain." And yeah, check out episode 102 with Ryan McCartan is gonna come out. I'm very excited.

[13:43] Eli Tokash: Um, and he originated the role of JD in Heathers, for those of you who don't know. He's also in like a million other things. Anyways, we'll move on and we'll get the show on the road. Do you wanna head off?

[13:55] Eli Tokash: Because we're gonna invite the next guest, Anthony Rosenthal. Yes, come on up, Anthony.

[14:08] Eli Tokash: Thank you, come chat.

[14:10] Unknown speaker: Yeah, let's just talk.

[14:11] Unknown speaker: Let's just talk.

[14:12] Unknown speaker: Let's just talk.

[14:13] Eli Tokash: So that's the beauty of this little cabaret here tonight. It's gonna be a little pod beret. Um, and it's like a podcast cabaret, not a pot of beret. Um, I like it. I like it. I'm with the right crowd tonight. Um, so yeah, um, so we're gonna chat and we're gonna go into songs and it's gonna be great. So Anthony here, he is going to be performing a song that he actually wrote. Uh, and this was yes. And he's debuting it. It's the first time he's ever singing it. It's gonna be crazy. Yes. It's gonna be crazy, you're not ready. It's so crazy. So talk to me about the song that you're about to sing and what started and the whole pandemic process of it all. Talk to me about it.

[14:59] Anthony Rosenthal: Um, yeah, so there I was in um 2020. Um this is a very important story to me. Um so Celia, no, no. Sally and I were just talking about musical. Sister Celia, right there. Um we're we were just talking about uh musicals and um, you know, trends, the latest musical trends, and we were talking about how there have been a lot of like musical adaptations of movies lately. Um, you know, finding Everland, right? Uh we have like Mrs. Doubtfire on Broadway right now, uh Pretty Woman, Groundhog Day, um, whatever uh you know Disney theatrical joint is currently on. Um, you know, we were talking about like what what musical like I could place my stamp on, you know, because I you know I want to write musicals, right?

Um and one of my quarantine watches was um Forrest Gump. I never watched Forrest Gump before. And um a light bulb lit up, and that started uh basically my passion project of creating Forrest Gump the musical. Um so I got right to the piano and I wrote the song. Um unfortunately, it's the only song I ever uh completed for Forrest Gump the Musical. It kind of it never really got its feet off the ground. Um, you know, many it was a hard year, right? And um, you know, doubt. Yeah, you know, there's that there was also that like TikTok Ratatouille musical that I feel like come on, take it any man! Yeah, yeah. But like it kind of upstaged me a bit, like we already had a lot of those like trailblazers, like, you know, like creating the next big blockbuster.

So um yeah, uh this is my um I'm finally revisiting it now. Um this is like my Lin Manuel at the White House moment for like Hamilton. You know what I'm saying? This is a historical moment. This is are there any producers in the audience tonight that uh wanna maybe back his musical up? No, it's okay. Um no, I'm so excited. I'm so excited to to watch this. It's hilarious for those of you who don't know. So why don't we get on right to it? Why don't you debut it? Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's the moment you waited for. I might care. Okay, okay. It's okay, it's okay. Um the uh for first of all, forgive my uh my Forrest voice. Um I'm I'm doing my best here. Um this is like a you know the composer presentation, right? So the curtain opens opens up, and Forrest is sitting on it on his bench with his suitcase of things on his lap. And this elderly woman sits on the bench across from him. And Forrest sees her.

[18:06] ♪ Musical number ♪

[21:36] Thank you

[21:45] Eli Tokash: Yeah. See, there were some positives that came out of the pandemic. Thank God it happened so that we could have had this night to celebrate Anthony's debut of Forrest Gump. Yeah. I'm obsessed. Thank you so much. I'm so happy. He he brought that to me and was like, can I like sing this? Like, I don't really know what else to sing. And I was like, can you send me a video? He was literally said, This is a Forrest Gump parody. And I was like, What? Like, sure, you could sing it, but I don't know what it is. And then, like, he sent a video, and I was like, this is everything. You're doing it. Um, so thank you, Anthony, and thank you for doing that tonight. It was so much fun. Um, ridiculous. So funny.

Okay, we're gonna bring up our next guest. Our next guest is Presley Ryan. Welcome to the stage. Come on. Welcome back to the stage, Charlie Alterman. Oh, yeah, cocktail. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Take that mic. Okay, hi. So the lovely people can hear you. Um, for those of you who don't who don't know, uh Presley, I mean, you should know who Presley is. Um, she was a star in Beetlejuice in Fun Home. Yeah, seriously. And uh is a TikTok little queen. Um, so uh uh talk to me because right now you're currently in the college process. Yeah. And what is the college process like for a Broadway star?

[23:14] Presley Ryan: Um, I mean it was pretty much the same as anyone, I think. At least like I took the SATs, I wrote a bunch of essays, pretty much like took the whole year to like focus on that because that was like something that I knew that I wanted to do. Um and yeah, no, it was it was a lot of work, but I'm grateful that it's all over, and now it's kind of just choosing where I'm gonna go at this point. So yeah.

[23:36] Eli Tokash: Totally. Yeah. And do we wanna share with the people what it's between?

[23:42] Presley Ryan: We can share. It's between Brown and USC.

[23:48] Eli Tokash: Ridiculous. So we'll see. Go Brown, Charlie saying, use your mic.

[23:53] Charlie Alterman: Go to Brown, go to Brown, go to Brown, go to Brown.

[23:56] Eli Tokash: Use the mic, you have it.

[23:57] Charlie Alterman: I've heard it's wonderful. I I'm on the colour. Charlie went to Brown, everyone. If you're gonna be able to do it, the best school on the planet.

[24:05] Eli Tokash: Um that's insane. You went to visit her backstage. I was like, do you know the people who didn't get in that want to go there? You got in. Literally. Um I don't know how you feel. I know you're leaning towards USC, so sorry, Charlie.

[24:19] Charlie Alterman: I quit. I quit. Uh I quit. Uh over here with my crock. Sorry.

[24:25] Eli Tokash: Well, talk to me a little bit about what it's like. So Beetlejuice is back on Broadway. Okay. What are you going to see it? Have you already seen it? Um what is it?

[24:33] Presley Ryan: No, I haven't seen it yet, but I'm definitely planning on seeing everyone. Like I have so many friends and I definitely want to support them. Um, but no, right now I'm just like focusing on college, and that was like really big thing for me.

[24:44] Eli Tokash: Totally. Are you like now that it's back on Broadway? Is it like kind of weird that like my god, this was like my show for so long?

[24:52] Presley Ryan: Like not at all. I'm just like so supportive of everyone, and I'm just like super excited. I mean, Broadway's back, and that's like the most exciting thing.

[24:59] Eli Tokash: Yeah. Come on. Beautifully said. Um, you know, uh, Broadway being back, it took a lot to get here. It was really a climb. Um, do we wanna do we wanna start singing your song?

[25:14] Presley Ryan: Let's do it. Yeah.

[25:19] ♪ Musical number: "The Climb" — performed by Presley Ryan ♪

[28:02] Unknown speaker: Ain't about what I'm swinging on the other side.

[28:10] Unknown speaker: It's a clock.

[29:30] Eli Tokash: Oh my word. Presley, can you come back to the stage?

[29:34] Presley Ryan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sorry.

[29:35] Eli Tokash: Um, Anthony, I'm gonna invite you back too eventually. Um, but I forgot that during while you all were sitting out here and we were getting ready, um, I asked you all to do a little audience question fishbowl. Um, I don't know if everyone did one. Oh, you still got more. Okay. Uh, I'll come to you next song. But let's do a couple of these because we have some time. Oh, I think I know this handwriting, so I don't want to do it. I feel like it's my brother. Okay. Okay. This question says, if you had thing—wait, what does this say? If you had wings, where would you fly to?

[30:21] Presley Ryan: Oh. Ooh. USC. I mean, yeah, I probably would, but um, I don't know, maybe like Paris or Greece. I've never been to those places, and like I've always wanted to go, so that'd be cool.

[30:34] Eli Tokash: If you had—adding on to that—if you had a superpower, what would it be?

[30:39] Presley Ryan: I've always said this: teleporting. Like people underestimate teleporting. Like you could go anywhere, like at any time. I think that would be like so cool.

[30:47] Eli Tokash: Totally. Um, I actually am gonna ask this question because you're a TikTok star and you do this on TikTok. So we can talk about it here. What is your traditional morning slash daily routine?

[30:58] Presley Ryan: Ooh. Um, I think it depends on what I'm doing. Probably right now, like wake up at like 6:30, go to the gym, get like a green juice. I'm like that girl, but like I actually do love it. But like, um, go to school, um, typically have some like lessons or anything like that after school or whatever like work I'm doing, and yeah.

[31:20] Eli Tokash: That's your daily routine.

[31:22] Presley Ryan: Yeah, I love it.

[31:23] Eli Tokash: And what about like now that like there's no school? You just do a casual cabaret at 9:30.

[31:28] Presley Ryan: Exactly. Yeah.

[31:31] Eli Tokash: Would you say?

[31:32] Presley Ryan: I just laughed. Oh my god. Um, amazing.

[31:35] Eli Tokash: Like playing hooky.

[31:36] Presley Ryan: Oh, yeah, you're playing around. No. It's just this week. We're on break.

[31:40] Eli Tokash: Oh, dude.

[31:41] Presley Ryan: But normally we have school, yeah.

[31:42] Eli Tokash: Okay, okay.

[31:43] Presley Ryan: She's going to Brown. She already got into college.

[31:45] Eli Tokash: True school. Come on.

[31:48] Presley Ryan: I'm just kidding. USC it is. Anyways, thank you so much, Presley, for coming out back up here. You sounded amazing. Seriously.

[31:50] Presley Ryan: Thank you so much.

[31:58] Eli Tokash: Now, for our next guest, my dear friend, Max Von Essen. Come on to the stage. Let's go.

[32:09] Max Von Essen: Sorry, I shouldn't introduce you as Tony Nominee.

[32:13] Eli Tokash: No.

[32:13] Max Von Essen: Max Von Essen.

[32:18] Eli Tokash: You heard about it?

[32:19] Max Von Essen: You heard about it?

[32:21] Eli Tokash: News travels fast as only seven years ago.

[32:24] Max Von Essen: And it was for Dear Evan Hansen, right?

[32:27] Eli Tokash: Yes. It was the Hanson's Evan standby.

[32:30] Max Von Essen: Oh yeah. Amazing.

[32:32] Eli Tokash: Well, Max, you and I met doing Secret Garden.

[32:36] Max Von Essen: Uh-huh.

[32:37] Eli Tokash: For like two days.

[32:39] Max Von Essen: Yeah, but actually it was like full out.

[32:42] Eli Tokash: It was the 25th anniversary, like concert, like fundraiser type production, right? But we—I didn't know this, but they were like, oh no, you have to have it memorized. I was like, what?

[32:51] Max Von Essen: Yeah.

[32:52] Eli Tokash: For free? Like I'm doing this for free.

[32:54] Max Von Essen: And like learning it in days.

[32:58] Eli Tokash: Literally.

[32:59] Max Von Essen: When we did while doing shows.

[33:01] Eli Tokash: While in a show.

[33:03] Max Von Essen: I'm not sure you actually ever did memorize it.

[33:05] Eli Tokash: No, I did not.

[33:06] Max Von Essen: Oh I fully did not.

[33:08] Eli Tokash: Just like my song tonight. Um. No, I truly. It was like Max and I were backstage. I was in a wheelchair because I played Cullen.

[33:16] Max Von Essen: Yeah.

[33:17] Eli Tokash: Or Colin. I see Cullen. Same thing. That was an English accent. Cullen. And uh I fully was like sitting down in my wheelchair backstage with my script on my lap. And like Rebecca Luker, the like star she is, that she reprised the role and everything, was like, oh, do you need some help? If you forget, I know all the words. I can do it for you. And I was like, oh my god, this is so stressful now. Um if I could just say also one quick thing, because this was astounding. Like losing Rebecca Luker is one of like the greatest losses to the earth, let alone to musical theater. But this was 25 years after she debuted the role, and she was the only one in this production that she reprised her role. She played Lily again in this version that we did. And it sounded like it was right off the recording.

[34:12] Max Von Essen: Yeah.

[34:13] Eli Tokash: She was like phenomenal. Luminous, phenomenal, just like the the voice just whew flew around. She's like one of the greatest talents. What a loss, but I like feel her pressed, don't you feel her like constantly like go listen to Secret Garden tomorrow. We were blessed to not only be—how are we in this room.

[34:32] Max Von Essen: Literally.

[34:32] Eli Tokash: Yeah, literally. Just like her. She would walk in and like smile, and everyone would be like, I'm so happy to be here.

[34:39] Max Von Essen: Yes, I do this for free.

[34:42] Eli Tokash: But for real.

[34:43] Max Von Essen: Yeah, it was really special.

[34:44] Eli Tokash: I feel so honored that we got to do that. Seriously. So now here you are what seven years later?

[34:51] Max Von Essen: Reprising.

[34:52] Eli Tokash: Yeah, yeah.

[34:54] Max Von Essen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[34:55] Eli Tokash: Oh, Secret Garden?

[34:56] Max Von Essen: Yes, and you're revisiting the show, right?

[34:57] Eli Tokash: Oh, yeah.

[34:58] Max Von Essen: I'm gonna do it this summer.

[34:59] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[35:00] Max Von Essen: And I'm gonna play Archie, yeah, in a production.

[35:02] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[35:03] Max Von Essen: I played Neville, the brother when we did it.

[35:06] Eli Tokash: Right.

[35:06] Max Von Essen: Um, yeah, anyway.

[35:08] Eli Tokash: So and where? So that people can go see you.

[35:10] Max Von Essen: Well if they live. Don't they probably want to say it themselves.

[35:14] Eli Tokash: Okay, okay, fair enough.

[35:15] Max Von Essen: I haven't—the theater hasn't like announced their season in their cast, so let's leave it. Just you know, keep a little Google alert on Max Von Essen and see if you've got to be a good one. Um or just like follow him on Instagram.

[35:22] Eli Tokash: Or just like do a little research, like what theaters are doing this summer and then you'll figure it out. But I can't say it.

[35:28] Max Von Essen: No one does that show anymore.

[35:29] Eli Tokash: Okay, yeah.

[35:30] Max Von Essen: It's a hard one.

[35:31] Eli Tokash: Anyway, I'm excited.

[35:32] Max Von Essen: It's wonderful, but it's hard. Um that's what they also um no, so yeah, so you're doing that, and um and and you're doing a bunch of things this summer.

[35:44] Eli Tokash: Yes, finally.

[35:45] Max Von Essen: I can't say any of the other things, but um I'm so but like he's booked in business. But like I'm like when I do a Secret Garden at the end of the summer, it will have been almost three years since I've done a role on stage because of the pandemic. Because it was a few months, I finished a show, then a few months later the pandemic started, and now we're two plus years, and then this is a few months from now when I'm starting this, so it's almost like I can't even believe like I've missed it so much. I don't even know if I can do it anymore. Um, but isn't that crazy? Like, I mean I've done some concerts and stuff, and you know, this is great, but like I've never I haven't done a a role like in front of an audience in almost three years. Like that's the longest in my entire life, probably I've ever gone since I started performing.

[36:24] Eli Tokash: Insane.

[36:25] Max Von Essen: I know it's so exciting though to be like back on a stage telling a story.

[36:29] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[36:29] Max Von Essen: Yeah.

[36:29] Eli Tokash: I'm so excited for you. I it's so funny. I follow Max on Instagram, obviously. And like he he fully like pops in and out every night of a different cabaret space. Like he's constantly performing. So he's always keeping his craft in shape.

[36:45] Max Von Essen: Uh that's really true. Gotta do anything you get. You know, cool, because the the money's in cabaret. So you know, I I really, you know.

[36:53] Eli Tokash: What what's the fee tonight? What was it uh uh my metro a metro card?

[36:58] Max Von Essen: 275?

[36:58] Eli Tokash: I drink.

[36:59] Max Von Essen: A drink at the bar.

[37:01] Eli Tokash: Hurry up. Let me sing. Okay. All right. Take it away. Do we want to do an audience question or do you want to start singing?

[37:08] Max Von Essen: Um let's do an audience question, because then I'll sing and be done, right?

[37:12] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[37:12] Max Von Essen: Oh, like then you can leave.

[37:13] Eli Tokash: No, but you know what I mean. Like, we go home to pocket your cat, your hairless cat.

[37:17] Max Von Essen: At Pocket the Sphinx on Instagram.

[37:20] Eli Tokash: Plug in the Instagram. I can't. I can't with you. This is what he did in Secret Garden. We remember at the time it was like, you're like, oh my god, you're almost at 5k.

[37:28] Max Von Essen: Yeah.

[37:29] Eli Tokash: So he followed me to like get me to 5,000.

[37:31] Max Von Essen: You had what, like 38?

[37:34] Eli Tokash: No way. I feel like I had more followers than you and I did.

[37:38] Max Von Essen: You did actually. You were teaching me a lot because I was like the old guy. And you were like, hey, Eli, do you mind giving me a shout-out? And I was like, you want me to shout you out?

[37:46] Eli Tokash: You're right, actually. And we we kept tabs on like how many followers we got from each other's shout outs.

[37:50] Max Von Essen: We totally did. We were so obnoxious.

[37:52] Eli Tokash: Gotta befriend the kid actors. Gotta befriend the child actors. You know, you may not know his lines, but he will get you followers.

[38:01] Max Von Essen: It's my staple. I have to keep it going. It's okay. Anyways, I have a question for you.

[38:08] Eli Tokash: Oh wait. What?

[38:11] Max Von Essen: Oscar! What is this? I'm secretly confessing my undenying love for you, Oscar.

[38:21] Eli Tokash: Makes sense.

[38:22] Max Von Essen: It makes sense. Very good question. Very great answer, Max Von Essen. Um I love you.

[38:31] Eli Tokash: Typical. Okay. Here's a real question. Let's see. No offense, Oscar. You're doing great. Thanks for coming. What advice would you give to someone who is trying to get into the professional world?

[38:48] Max Von Essen: Oh, um, I mean, this is very general, but like, love it. Love it so much that it hurts if you don't do it. Like, it hurts me that I haven't been that I haven't done a role and done musical theater in almost three years. Like, I haven't felt like myself the entire pandemic because I haven't performed in a role and got in front of an audience and done musical theater. Like, that's how much I love it. And even though it's been so hard, it's totally reminded me the past couple years. It's been hard, and that there haven't been enough work, enough money. And I'm like, but but not doing anything else. Like, I'm pushing through because it is the greatest thing in the world to me. So like love it at that kind of level because it's so difficult and there is a lot of rejection.

Um, that you really have to have that like passion for it and to work your butt off and be prepared because then the payoff is like astronomical. So, like, because like when you are working, it's the greatest like thrill of your life, makes everything else worth it. But really, you gotta like you gotta love it.

[39:42] Eli Tokash: Yeah, if you love it, it's gonna keep you in it because yeah, I mean, that's beautiful advice because there's a lot of no's in this industry, you know. There's a lot of no's. You gotta keep just headstrong, you know, just keep plowing through. So hopefully loving it will allow you to do that. Anyways, you continue to trolley on and uh sing your next song.

[40:04] Max Von Essen: These are two can I just say quick because I'm like the old guy who doesn't sing anything from Heathers. Um because I don't know anything, any of any of this new stuff. No, I'm literally saying that like I feel like I it's my duty to like bring keep bringing songs like from another era and golden age and like America Standards, and these are two songs matched up together, made both made famous by Judy Garland. One's from Meet Me in St. Louis, and the other one is from A Star Is Born. We were talking about you're like, There's another Star is born. I was like, Yes.

[40:34] Eli Tokash: So you are routing me out.

[40:35] Max Von Essen: Oh no, no. Kind of interesting. Judy Garland did uh a version in like the 50s, and then Barbara Streisand did one in the late 70s, and then Gaga did it in 2018, and then there was even one before all of them. It was like a movie without music, I think, in like 1937. It's kind of fascinating. It's been like such an incredible story for these like iconic female performers to play. So these are two Judy Garland songs.

[40:58] Eli Tokash: Amazing. Take it away.

[41:00] Max Von Essen: Judy who?

[41:01] Eli Tokash: Wait.

[41:02] Max Von Essen: Judy who? Judy.

[41:06] Max Von Essen: I'm gonna vamp. I'm gonna vamp.

[41:10] ♪ Musical number ♪

[41:55] ♪ Musical number ♪

[42:03] ♪ Musical number: "I'm Alive" — performed by JJ Niemann ♪

[44:26] Unknown speaker: How dare you?

[44:28] Unknown speaker: How dare you?

[44:30] Unknown speaker: Come on.

[44:32] Unknown speaker: Woo!

[44:33] Unknown speaker: So good.

[44:34] Unknown speaker: How dare?

[44:35] Unknown speaker: So good.

[44:36] Unknown speaker: So unnecessary.

[44:37] Unknown speaker: Just rude.

[44:39] Unknown speaker: What?

[44:40] Unknown speaker: Rude to be that talent.

[44:41] Unknown speaker: I know.

[44:42] Unknown speaker: I'm that casual about it.

[44:43] Unknown speaker: Do you have an equity card?

[44:45] Unknown speaker: Just a question.

[44:46] Unknown speaker: Do you have an equity card?

[44:50] Unknown speaker: Oh, great, great.

[44:51] Unknown speaker: Yeah, I think you'll I think you can make it.

[44:53] Unknown speaker: I really do.

[44:54] Unknown speaker: I think there could be another Tony loss in his future, right?

[45:00] Unknown speaker: How dare you!

[45:01] Unknown speaker: Oh my god.

[45:02] Unknown speaker: Terrible.

[45:03] Unknown speaker: A win in the future.

[45:04] Unknown speaker: We're manifesting it.

[45:06] Unknown speaker: But nonetheless, congratulations on your recognition.

[45:10] Eli Tokash: Um, okay. Next up, we have our final performance of the night.

[45:16] Eli Tokash: I know craziness.

[45:18] Eli Tokash: I don't know.

[45:18] Eli Tokash: It was so wrong.

[45:20] Eli Tokash: I know, right?

[45:20] Eli Tokash: It really did.

[45:21] Eli Tokash: Um, an icon.

[45:23] Eli Tokash: An icon, uh, a Broadway star.

[45:26] Eli Tokash: Please welcome to the stage, JJ Niemann.

[45:29] Audience Questions: Woo!

[45:34] JJ Niemann: Hi, Eli.

[45:35] Eli Tokash: Hi, JJ.

[45:36] JJ Niemann: I'm glad I'm not the only one that needs the lyrics.

[45:39] Eli Tokash: Oh, hell.

[45:41] JJ Niemann: Um, no, this is fantastic.

[45:43] JJ Niemann: I'm so happy to have you here tonight.

[45:45] JJ Niemann: It's actually our first time meeting.

[45:46] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[45:47] JJ Niemann: Like in person.

[45:48] JJ Niemann: It's nice.

[45:48] JJ Niemann: Um, we met like a lot of people the past two years virtually.

[45:53] JJ Niemann: And we had a little virtual date on the podcast.

[45:55] Eli Tokash: No, it's great.

[45:56] JJ Niemann: Um, no, no, no.

[45:57] JJ Niemann: It's so much fun.

[45:58] JJ Niemann: And uh, I'm so excited to have you here and talk to you all about the incredible things that you're up to.

[46:03] JJ Niemann: Um, I am currently a swing over at Book of Mormon.

[46:08] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[46:09] JJ Niemann: And um, if anyone's been following along on Broadway.com or Broadway World or Instagram, anything, uh, Broadway's craziness right now with shutdowns and all of these little things going on, and uh, Book of Mormon is no less.

[46:25] JJ Niemann: So you're really shape saving the show over there.

[46:27] JJ Niemann: Yeah, it's been a little while.

[46:28] JJ Niemann: So like I left the show pre-pandemic, like a few months before as a full-time swing.

[46:33] JJ Niemann: I was there for two and a half years.

[46:34] JJ Niemann: And so coming back, you know, they've been knocking on my door a few days.

[46:38] JJ Niemann: Some days like the day before, sometimes the day of.

[46:41] JJ Niemann: And you know, if I can make it work, I make it work in my schedule.

[46:43] JJ Niemann: But it's been, I mean, the vacation swings and the swings and covers have truly like saved that show and kept it running.

[46:48] JJ Niemann: Because the show hasn't closed at all for any amount of time, which is great.

[46:52] JJ Niemann: So and a part of that was the other day, 17 covers were on in one show.

[47:00] Eli Tokash: So only you said only five people were in the...

[47:00] JJ Niemann: So yeah, the cast is like the cast on stage is only like twenty-one or twenty-two people.

[47:07] JJ Niemann: So there were, I think, five people in the tracks and roles they normally do, and then everyone else on stage was either like brought into the show or they were like ensemble members or standbys on for the roles they cover.

[47:18] JJ Niemann: So it was a wild way.

[47:20] Eli Tokash: Broadway's hard.

[47:21] JJ Niemann: Broadway's hard, y'all.

[47:22] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[47:23] JJ Niemann: Yeah.

[47:24] JJ Niemann: But it's amazing.

[47:25] Eli Tokash: Yeah, it is.

[47:26] Eli Tokash: Um, and uh that you're doing you're doing all of it.

[47:29] Eli Tokash: So that's so exciting.

[47:31] Eli Tokash: And then you just did the For You Page, which is the TikTok musical.

[47:36] Eli Tokash: Talk to me about that because I know we mentioned earlier that you were in Ratatouille.

[47:40] JJ Niemann: Uh-huh.

[47:40] Eli Tokash: Um, and that was like a whole virtual thing.

[47:42] Eli Tokash: But now this was like you kind of had a cast to work with on a stage.

[47:47] JJ Niemann: Yes.

[47:48] Eli Tokash: Um talk to me about it.

[47:49] Eli Tokash: How many people like watched it or tuned in on TikTok?

[47:51] JJ Niemann: Oh, okay.

[47:53] JJ Niemann: You know what? That's kind of fierce.

[47:54] JJ Niemann: Okay.

[47:55] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[47:55] JJ Niemann: Um, yeah, no, we're here for that.

[47:57] JJ Niemann: I mean, I the it was insanity.

[47:59] JJ Niemann: Like, when I was on his podcast, I talked about the Ratatouille musical and how that was just thrown together, baby, like in the best way, but um, so was this.

[48:07] JJ Niemann: I mean, they planned it, but we learned the whole show in like four days, and then we had two days of tech, and then we put it up.

[48:14] JJ Niemann: Like it was insane, and we did like a full like 50 55 minute musical of all original new music, and it was cool, like it was written over the past four or five months by a bunch of different writers.

[48:25] JJ Niemann: I think there were 10 writers that worked on it, so again, very collaborative.

[48:28] JJ Niemann: But TikTok literally produced it, and that was like insane and a step towards hopefully more accessibility.

[48:34] JJ Niemann: I don't know.

[48:35] JJ Niemann: I mean, it was it did well, so yeah, yeah, yeah.

[48:37] Eli Tokash: Yeah, and is there like I don't know, like is there a hope that it like comes to Broadway, or is it was it just like a fun TikTok?

[48:44] JJ Niemann: I don't know about that.

[48:45] JJ Niemann: I know that they're gonna rebroadcast it, so if you missed it, they're they are gonna do that and announce that.

[48:50] JJ Niemann: Um, and I think maybe cast album, which will be cute because the songs are cute, cute, like they're good.

[48:56] JJ Niemann: So yeah, I'd be interested in that.

[48:57] Eli Tokash: And the dancing, come on, yeah, come on, dance!

[49:00] JJ Niemann: Come on, dancer.

[49:01] Eli Tokash: You're I love watching you dance.

[49:03] JJ Niemann: I love it.

[49:03] JJ Niemann: Because you did it in both the Ratatouille musical and um For You Page.

[49:08] JJ Niemann: One thing I will say is is dancing slash staging for the vertical format is wild.

[49:14] JJ Niemann: Like, because you then have to be staged.

[49:16] JJ Niemann: Like you can't have all of this.

[49:18] JJ Niemann: You're literally like, okay, we're gonna do all of this to camera one, and then we're gonna move to camera three, and like you're in this little tiny, you know, nook and are so close to your fellow actors, but it feels weird, but on camera it looked cool.

[49:30] JJ Niemann: So that was a first for me, and I think maybe the first ever vertical streamed thing, maybe in that facet.

[49:36] Eli Tokash: Oh my god, I totally didn't think of that.

[49:38] Eli Tokash: That's fascinating.

[49:38] JJ Niemann: So they filmed it like on a phone.

[49:40] JJ Niemann: No, they had like professional cameras, but then they were like, wait, what?

[49:43] JJ Niemann: No, yeah.

[49:44] JJ Niemann: We had three cameras and there were two normal ones and then like one handheld that was on stage.

[49:49] Eli Tokash: Oh my god, amazing.

[49:50] JJ Niemann: Yeah, wild.

[49:51] JJ Niemann: Um, your life is amazing and so so fascinating to learn all about it.

[49:56] Eli Tokash: But um, that's what that's what you've been up to since the last time you've got it.

[50:00] JJ Niemann: Yeah, a little bit of this, a little bit of this.

[50:01] Eli Tokash: I know, and I love too, I love the fact that like even when you're not in Book of Mormon, like you're it in Book of Mormon because your poster is everywhere.

[50:10] JJ Niemann: Just like um if you see him on trash.

[50:12] JJ Niemann: She rocks under me.

[50:13] JJ Niemann: I'm sorry about it.

[50:14] Eli Tokash: You've totally thrown trash on him.

[50:17] JJ Niemann: Definitely.

[50:18] JJ Niemann: Uh no, it's great.

[50:19] JJ Niemann: I'm obsessed.

[50:19] JJ Niemann: So it's so cool to see all those little fun things.

[50:22] Eli Tokash: Do you want to do some audience questions?

[50:23] JJ Niemann: Oh my god, let's do it.

[50:24] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I kind of already picked one.

[50:25] JJ Niemann: Anyways.

[50:26] JJ Niemann: Um, the first one is what was your favorite kids' toy?

[50:32] JJ Niemann: Ooh, favorite kids toy.

[50:34] JJ Niemann: Oh, they are asking these questions.

[50:35] JJ Niemann: Yeah, very simple.

[50:37] JJ Niemann: I mean, I was obsessed with Winnie the Pooh, so like I had every single Winnie the Pooh thing.

[50:42] JJ Niemann: Yes, the bathtub accessories, the bed sheets, the plushies, the wallpapers.

[50:47] JJ Niemann: Like, like I was obsessed, and I used to cry to my mom that Pooh wasn't real.

[50:50] JJ Niemann: So that definitely was my favorite.

[50:52] Eli Tokash: Okay, but there was like Winnie the Pooh, like a problem.

[50:55] JJ Niemann: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[50:56] Eli Tokash: Oh my god.

[50:57] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[50:58] Eli Tokash: But it's gonna be back, I think, apparently.

[51:00] JJ Niemann: Anyway.

[51:00] Eli Tokash: You should be in it.

[51:01] JJ Niemann: I know.

[51:02] JJ Niemann: Come on, Winnie.

[51:02] Eli Tokash: I would love to.

[51:03] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[51:03] JJ Niemann: Come on, Pooh Bear.

[51:05] Eli Tokash: Um, next up.

[51:08] JJ Niemann: If you could have okay, sorry.

[51:10] JJ Niemann: If you could have your hair changed to a color permanently.

[51:15] Eli Tokash: Oh, which one would it be?

[51:17] JJ Niemann: Uh listen.

[51:18] JJ Niemann: I'm actually getting my hair, I'm getting uh highlights for the first time in May.

[51:22] JJ Niemann: No, but like cute, like cute little little caramel moment.

[51:25] JJ Niemann: You know what I mean?

[51:25] JJ Niemann: Like not crazy.

[51:26] JJ Niemann: Not the frosted tips.

[51:27] JJ Niemann: I'm still nervous.

[51:28] JJ Niemann: Not the frosted tips.

[51:29] JJ Niemann: Um if I could die, oh my god, well, there's a wig I wear in Mormon that's platinum blonde, and like it's insane, but like I I low key think I would love it, but um honestly, if I'm being realistic, if I had to dye like forever, I would just dye it like black or like lighter brown, something boring.

[51:44] Eli Tokash: It's kind of like what you're doing.

[51:45] JJ Niemann: Which is what I have amazing.

[51:48] Eli Tokash: I mean, you do you.

[51:49] JJ Niemann: Yeah, you know, so that it doesn't turn gray.

[51:52] JJ Niemann: You know, what about you over there?

[51:54] Eli Tokash: Yeah, would you like to dye your hair?

[51:59] JJ Niemann: This is long for me.

[52:00] JJ Niemann: I'm desperately looking for a haircut.

[52:02] Eli Tokash: I think it looks good, but thank you.

[52:04] JJ Niemann: Um, but uh I I would just say any color, like I would say like let's start with the length and then we could talk color.

[52:09] JJ Niemann: But um yeah, sure.

[52:11] JJ Niemann: Something that has staying power.

[52:14] Eli Tokash: Yeah, you know, yeah.

[52:15] JJ Niemann: I I love it.

[52:16] JJ Niemann: I think it would be so fun to see like green things coming out of your hair.

[52:20] Eli Tokash: You know, just for a minute.

[52:22] JJ Niemann: I don't know if for eternity.

[52:24] JJ Niemann: Like that's cute now, and then like I'm 85 and it's like wow.

[52:27] Eli Tokash: You know what I mean?

[52:28] JJ Niemann: That's a lot.

[52:29] JJ Niemann: That's a lot, yeah.

[52:30] Eli Tokash: No, it looks great.

[52:31] JJ Niemann: Um do you want to sing for us?

[52:33] Eli Tokash: Let's do it.

[52:33] Eli Tokash: Let's sing.

[52:34] Eli Tokash: Because y'all are about to be blown away.

[52:36] JJ Niemann: Oh don't make any promises.

[52:38] Eli Tokash: Listen, you're gonna be amazing.

[52:40] Eli Tokash: Here is JJ Niemann.

[52:43] Audience Questions: Woo!

[52:44] JJ Niemann: Quick.

[52:45] JJ Niemann: Oh, hello.

[52:46] JJ Niemann: First, real quick, I'm gonna tell a little story about the song.

[52:48] JJ Niemann: So I haven't sung this in like seven or eight years, I think.

[52:51] JJ Niemann: And it was my college audition song, and I I haven't sung it since then because it's triggering the trauma of not getting into certain colleges, or you just have bad vocal days.

[52:59] JJ Niemann: And I used to sing this song and lose my voice every day because my voice teacher, like when I was growing up, taught me to sing wrong.

[53:04] JJ Niemann: Curse you.

[53:05] JJ Niemann: I mean, hope you're doing well, but you know.

[53:07] JJ Niemann: Um so we're gonna do it now, hopefully with better technique.

[53:10] JJ Niemann: Okay, here we go.

[53:23] ♪ Musical number: "I'm Alive" — performed by Anthony Rosenthal ♪

[56:02] ♪ Musical number ♪

[56:48] Eli Tokash: Once again, give another round of applause for our artists tonight. Wonderful performers. And another one for Charlie. Come on. For those of you who don't know, Charlie and I met doing Pippin on Broadway together, and then he's been in a million other things, and he was in, uh, he did Next to Normal. So it was a little, it was a little like, uh, you know, reprise of, uh, both for both of them. Um, and now he's doing Zoe's Extraordinary Playlist. Um, good. Uh, Charlie's doing everything. Charlie, I want to do an audience question with you.

[57:20] Charlie Alterman: Oh my lord.

[57:22] Eli Tokash: Because why not? I hope it's a juicy one. If not, I'll make one up. Okay, just kidding. Um, okay. This says you had more followers. I think this was for me, Max. Um, let's see. How do you feel being back out with people again in like a room like this?

[57:45] Charlie Alterman: I mean, I feel mostly safe. I think. Uh, I don't know. I think it's, it actually, it's weird because I like, I even had a moment coming in where I was just like, oh my goodness, there's so many people here, and everyone's just like breathing in the air still, and it's like we're like, we've been trained. We have like Stockholm syndrome, I think, where we've been trained to be afraid of things. But I'm like, it also feels so good. I've missed human contact so much.

[58:07] Eli Tokash: Totally. It's so important.

[58:10] Charlie Alterman: It's so, I'm vaccinated and I ain't scared.

[58:14] Eli Tokash: Yeah. You know? It's so funny because I think the past two years made everyone turn into a germophobe.

[58:20] Charlie Alterman: Yes.

[58:20] Eli Tokash: So including myself. Some of us were germophobes before the pandemic.

[58:24] Charlie Alterman: So, you know.

[58:25] Eli Tokash: What are you saying yes to, mom? Right? I know I'm bad. I get it. Um, then I had like the reverse reaction. Like this, the comedy to me of all these people who were like, oh, we have to wash our hands now. And I'm like, now who was going in the bathroom and not washing your hands before?

[58:41] Charlie Alterman: Right.

[58:41] Eli Tokash: Like, what? Who's eating with, I had hand sanitizer in my bag before it was fashionable?

[58:47] Charlie Alterman: Okay, come on.

[58:48] Eli Tokash: I'm so pleased.

[58:50] Charlie Alterman: Yeah.

[58:50] Eli Tokash: Thank you. Not alone. Okay. I got one more for you. Who is your biggest, like, theatrical, you know, influence?

[59:00] Charlie Alterman: Oh my god. I don't know. I couldn't pick one. I couldn't pick one. I mean pick a couple, pick a couple.

[59:05] Eli Tokash: Pick your top five.

[59:07] Charlie Alterman: My top five, or I would have to say, like, this is gonna sound so obnoxious, but like I pinch myself daily because I've gotten to work with many of them. Yeah, like Steven Schwartz is a huge one for me. Like I grew up on his shows. Like, I was obsessed. I played out all of those albums. I remember like seeing Pippin when I was in junior high and being like, I've got to learn this whole score. I'm gonna go to get the sheet music, and they had just published the full score. I was like, I want to learn everything, I want to learn the underscoring and all blah blah blah. Um, so the fact that I got to do Godspell and Pippin on Broadway with him was like insane. Um, Mark Shaman is a huge hero of mine who I got to work with on my first Broadway show.

Also with Martin Short, who's also like a hero of mine. So I was a good one. Funniest man alive. So that was and Tom Kitt from Next to Normal. I mean, so it's like a little, I'm, I've like the old and then the other one would be Steven Sondheim, who I've like done some of his shows, and I got to work with like in a concert once for five minutes. But like won't get a chance to work with him now. So I should just quit the business. But um no, but I'd like, I gotta find some new heroes.

[1:00:14] Eli Tokash: But you're, it's cool because you can still, you still have the opportunity to do his shows.

[1:00:17] Charlie Alterman: 100 percent.

[1:00:22] Eli Tokash: And you like are, right? Like you're kind of doing Company, right?

[1:00:25] Charlie Alterman: I sub over a Company. I like worm my way in there. I like stalked people on that team just because it's my favorite show. And I was like, Do you need subs? Do you need subs? Do you need one in a sub or whatever? And like, and they were like, Charlie, you like a Broadway music director. You're not gonna, and I was just like, No, I will. I need to be in there, I need to be in there. I'm obsessed. I want to play that music, I wanna play that music. Get me in, get me in, get me in. I like literally stalked, yes.

[1:00:46] Eli Tokash: Yes, yes, 100 percent. I love it. Well, yeah, that's Charlie. They're like occasionally, but it's funny.

[1:00:52] Eli Tokash: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Come on, Anthony. I want to bring you back on the stage and do a couple audience questions with you. Um, everyone, welcome back to the stage, Anthony Rosenthal. Or Forrest Gump, whatever you want to refer to him as.

[1:01:06] Anthony Rosenthal: You can refer to him as Forrest.

[1:01:09] Eli Tokash: Yeah. I just want to say, um, uh Max and JJ. Um, I'm very interested in both of you for the role of Forrest. So um sometime come over. Um, um we'll sing the songs. Um, it can be a double parter, the both of you. I mean, one can do two shows a week, one can do six, you know. But I think a solid four and four would be good.

[1:01:31] Charlie Alterman: Okay, yeah.

[1:01:32] Eli Tokash: Come on. They're both so talented. Uh, it's funny. I actually double cast at least. I'll do matinees. I'm surprised you want to do the matinees.

[1:01:40] Anthony Rosenthal: Oh my, you already have it. It's already casted. They made life easy for you. Um, it's funny. I actually that I actually picked a question that's specifically for you. Um, does someone know what it is? Um, who do you like playing D&D with? And who is your favorite answer?

[1:02:03] Anthony Rosenthal: How'd you know that was for him?

[1:02:06] Eli Tokash: It says for Anthony.

[1:02:06] Anthony Rosenthal: Um, maybe everyone, you know. I don't know. It's I've played D&D with so many people, it's so hard to choose. But um, I, I, my friends, uh Olivia and Kara and Sophia, I really enjoy playing D&D with, and they're here right now.

[1:02:20] Eli Tokash: Oh my goodness.

[1:02:22] Anthony Rosenthal: Yeah, I had a few Zoom sessions. Uh, we were in a tavern, did a little tavern rom-com, and that's where it ended for now, but that will continue. So stay tuned for our podcast.

[1:02:32] Eli Tokash: Oh, come on. Plug it.

[1:02:35] Anthony Rosenthal: Oh my god. Plug it.

[1:02:38] Eli Tokash: You can plug it.

[1:02:42] Anthony Rosenthal: Oh my god, he's like directing now. He's writing, directing, oh yeah.

[1:02:45] Eli Tokash: No, not for, yeah, for real.

[1:02:47] Anthony Rosenthal: Yeah, but in the fictional world as well, like so many projects going on. Um, I have a juicy question. So let's bring the whole cast up here real quick. Um, because this is getting interesting. Uh, Charlie, I want to start with you, because this is kind of your thing. What's your least favorite show tune?

[1:03:06] Charlie Alterman: Oh god, why is that my thing?

[1:03:08] Eli Tokash: 'Cause it's like your music. You're a mean, you're the music guy.

[1:03:12] Charlie Alterman: Oh god, I don't, I pro, I, I mean, I like all things, but I also then block out the things I don't like so I don't carry negativity with me, so it's hard to answer. Um, no, I know. So wait, show tune, right? This is a tricky question. I'm gonna give a very specific answer because I actually love the song, but my least favorite thing is people singing If I Loved You incorrectly.

[1:03:37] Eli Tokash: Oh.

[1:03:37] Charlie Alterman: Because it is a flirtation, and uh, this is the most obnoxious. I sound like such a, like shut just stop talking, Charlie. But it's supposed to be anyone who's an aspiring actor out there. It's, it's a scene and it's a flirtation, and it's like if I did, and it's all what's actually going on in the scene is, I mean, of course I don't, but I maybe I do. Like there's such an interesting dynamic in it that it's like actually delicious to explore as an actor. And so often people are like, oh, you want something legit, I'll do, uh, and just sing it like it's like this big bombastic, like I love you so much song, and I'm like read the lyrics, work with the text. So that's my pet peeve. Like if I'm in an audition room and people come in with that, I'm like, stop, stop, stop, stop. That's like my do not fly list.

[1:04:21] Eli Tokash: So yeah.

[1:04:22] Charlie Alterman: Yeah.

[1:04:23] Eli Tokash: It's a good choice.

[1:04:24] Charlie Alterman: Thank you.

[1:04:24] Eli Tokash: Thank you. But if you sing it right, sing it all too.

[1:04:27] Charlie Alterman: One of the best.

[1:04:28] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[1:04:28] Charlie Alterman: Yeah, truly. Do you guys want to answer that or do we want to do one?

[1:04:33] Anthony Rosenthal: That's an obnoxious question to answer, because it's like be mean.

[1:04:36] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[1:04:37] Anthony Rosenthal: Talk about things you don't like, you know.

[1:04:40] Eli Tokash: Everyone's like, uh say that. Um, okay. Oh, this is a good one for everyone. This is one that's like cute and everyone can do anyway. Um, we lost a battery.

[1:04:51] Charlie Alterman: We lost a battery.

[1:04:55] Eli Tokash: Oh, I'm real. Great. Thank you. Um, so what is your most embarrassing theater experience? And we will go whoever wants to stop.

[1:05:08] Anthony Rosenthal: I have one.

[1:05:08] Charlie Alterman: Okay.

[1:05:09] Anthony Rosenthal: Okay. So I was doing this show called Beaches, and it was in Chicago at the time. It was like an original, um, it was like it was like an out-of-town try, and I played the role of young Cece, and so I was like in the first like 15 minutes of the show, and then like the rest of the show, like I was not in it. And so like I would like take off my wig, I would like take off everything and like chill my robe and like watch some Netflix. And um, I guess like one day, like I just like fully zoned out and like didn't realize what time it was, and like I would have to like get re-get into costume for the bows, and I just like the bows had started, and I was like still in my dressing room, like not in costume, not in my wig.

So I like put my costume on super fast. I like grabbed my wig like this, and basically like the way that the dressing rooms worked is that like so we had our dressing room upstairs, and you would like go through the bathroom and through this other dressing room down the stairs and then onto the stage. It was super complicated. And so I had my wig in my hand like this, and I'm running through the bathroom, and my wig fell into the toilet.

[1:06:08] Charlie Alterman: No.

[1:06:10] Anthony Rosenthal: And no, it did. And so like I like I grabbed my toilet wig, like threw it on my head. Oh then I like went on stage.

[1:06:14] Eli Tokash: Hashtag toilet wig, you deserve a raise.

[1:06:22] Anthony Rosenthal: Yeah. No, literally, I should like make that a hashtag. And then like I went on stage, like did my bows, came off, and like I had to like write like a 10-page long apology note to like the hair department. I was like, I'm so sorry, I dropped my wig in the toilet. It won't happen again. Like, where does I don't know how that happened, but like, yeah, that's my, that's everything.

[1:06:44] Eli Tokash: Come on. Toilet wig.

[1:06:48] Charlie Alterman: Who's up next?

[1:06:50] Max Von Essen: Um, I fainted on the stage of Newsies once, kind of.

[1:06:53] Eli Tokash: How do you kind of fade?

[1:06:56] Max Von Essen: Well, it was like I blacked out for like a second. And then I stood, so we were, I was at like the end of the stage um during World War World World No, and this is when me and like three of the principals are like, so the world says no, and the kids do too. And I just had this moment where everything was like shadowy, and then next thing I know, I'm like on my knees, and I like bang my head on the light. Um, and then I close my eyes for like one second. Um, and the guy who played Davy is like, uh, Jacob Kemp. He's like, Oh god, and he immediately gets me to my feet, and I'm like, I keep singing, stop over you. Um and I stumble, and then we're at the end of the song, and I get on the table, no, and I just sit down, and um I did the rest of the show.

[1:07:39] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[1:07:40] Max Von Essen: They gave me orange juice back.

[1:07:43] Anthony Rosenthal: And my mom told me to drink more electrolytes from than I.

[1:07:46] Eli Tokash: So that's mine. Max, do you have what do you want to get?

[1:07:49] Max Von Essen: I mean, I, I'm old, so I've had so many. I have fallen like in every show I've done. You know what I mean? Like one time in An American in Paris, it's like every, we've all, we're all in love with this girl, like wonderful, it's marvelous, and the whole cast is dancing, and I'm like, I'm downstage center. It's my time. We have these things where like your leg crosses and you twist, and like, and I slid like my Laducas. No slid on the wooden floor, and I flipped, like turned in the air, flipped, and hit the stage, like so loud, but I'm also like carrying this like journal that I write in. And it was, you know, like a book smack, like so loud against the ground. It sounded like my face had hit the ground.

Now, now my body like splat on the ground and it really hurt. I literally was like jumped, I got up immediately. I was like, small us. But like the, the it was so loud that the entire audience just goes, oh no. Like 1600 people like go back in their seats, like and the whole cast, and it goes into like a slow motion section after everyone's like.

[1:08:51] Eli Tokash: But like every show I had, you know, another a fall. Like if you're in a show for a year, like at some point you wipe out or like go up on a lyric. So I could be here all night on my fall stories. But I think um toilet wig is a new TikTok challenge.

[1:09:05] Charlie Alterman: Come on!

[1:09:07] Eli Tokash: Who's got the video of that? We're gonna get started.

[1:09:10] JJ Niemann: Um, yeah, I don't have anything as crazy as though like that's amazing. Um, I feel like luckily, like the nice thing about sometimes, like I've been in the ensemble in a lot of shows, and the nice thing about being in the ensemble is a lot of times, like your flubs like don't get as noticed because like you're not like in tapped mics or whatever. And so um, so I, but like one time in Book of Mormon, like when I was in, we're like underdressed in our hell dream costumes. We're wearing like these devil costumes, but we have like our Mormon outfits under. Anyway, there was a whole costume malfunction, so I was already flustered, but um, like I was just like doing the whole number, like with my next scene costume out for everyone to see, and that's how that how that happened.

But then I also ended up like in one part, I like have to climb up onto one of these rolling platforms, and I, my costume got caught on the platform, and I yanked the platform off of its track, and it's like an automated platform.

[1:10:01] JJ Niemann: And so we're literally in a freeze on stage, and I start literally sliding off the stage, and then I like shimmied it back with my body. Anyway, that's like the funniest thing I feel like that's happened to me.

[1:10:12] Max Von Essen: Yeah.

[1:10:13] JJ Niemann: Oh, I'm screaming. I'm screaming. That's brilliant. It ranks up there, I promise. It was pretty strong. That was pretty strong. Come on. That was amazing.

[1:10:21] Charlie Alterman: All right.

[1:10:22] JJ Niemann: Whoa. Yes. Whoa. Mimi. You're not getting that easy.

[1:10:29] Presley Ryan: Yeah, it was yours. Spotlight. I thought I was.

[1:10:33] Anthony Rosenthal: Oh.

[1:10:35] JJ Niemann: Oh. Who invited him? Why is he here? I'm just kidding.

[1:10:42] Presley Ryan: I don't know. Like, I feel like something crazy was just like fully performing. Like, I don't dance in the first place. Like, everyone who's seen me in a show is like, oh yeah, like you don't. Um, so in Fighting Neverland, we had a dinner party. Um, and uh we all know that there's like a dance break. Pat knows. Um, Pat was there every night. Um, and uh, you know, sometimes when you're dancing, especially with someone that's not flexible, that like tries new things every night because why not test? Um not push the limits, um, your pants end up splitting. And so on top of like, yeah, JJ knows. Um, especially especially like right along the seam. Like, so like it's it's not helpful. It's a great and easy fix, so the wardrobe's not too mad, but for me, the fact that I'm already like having an anxiety attack that I have to dance, um, but then I have to be like this, and my underwear is fully like out.

Um, it's not a good look. Um, and everyone's definitely seeing that, and then I climb onto a table. So, so like, sorry, front row, um, because they're definitely seeing that. Um, so yeah, that's probably like one of the most embarrassing ones for me, but I feel like that's a pretty basic one that uh everyone's definitely had that experience for sure.

[1:12:03] Anthony Rosenthal: Um I had an experience like that with that song almost because fun fact, I auditioned for Funny Neverland at one point. I went to a dance call and we were learning a combo for that song. Yeah, and I I there was like a supposed to be a slide, and I think I bloody my knee all the time. All the time. Yesterday, like the assistant had to give you like a knee pad.

[1:12:19] JJ Niemann: So my god. You're not alone, buddy.

[1:12:21] Anthony Rosenthal: Yeah. I love it. I'm obsessed. Well after the injury, not before. Don't take a knee pad preventatively. Just like now that you're hurt, now you can have a knee pad.

[1:12:31] JJ Niemann: Yeah.

[1:12:32] Anthony Rosenthal: So that's the most embarrassing uh Broadway story is that uh all of you had asked about toilet wig toilet wig for the win. I think that's a pretty come on. I think that's absolutely amazing, but so disgusting. Um sorry, Presley. It's just utterly, I would never put that thing on. I would go out in a bald cap. Um rig cap, yeah, same thing. Um, so yeah, that's what we have for you tonight. Um, this is the 100th episode of Take A Bow.

[1:13:02] Eli Tokash: Yes, come on. I am so so happy that all of you are here. As you could tell, um, you being here tonight totally changed the outcome of tonight's event with these wonderful questions and all of these things. So I'm glad that you were able to be a part of it and kind of come out and celebrate with us. Uh, and thank you once again. Let's give another round of applause for the performers. Come on. So so good. And uh huge shout out to my family who made this possible tonight. Uh especially Zach and Tessie. They helped me with all of the all of the podcasts, my sister editing and Zach always helping out with social media and and guiding us in every direction. So thank you both. And uh shout out to my parents and everyone supporting.

And shout out to all you on the live stream. Thank you for streaming this. Um and and being here with us tonight, even though you couldn't be here physically in New York. Um, and uh huge shout out to my patrons, Pat Mack, Lou Grummet. Um, I don't know if there's any others here tonight, but uh they're they're the reason that this podcast is still happening. Um they allow me to to support my lovely sister and her countless hours editing and uh all these wonderful things to continue to keep this going for so many people listening. So uh I'm very excited to continue to grow this, and uh we'll see you here uh at the Green Room 42 for episode 200.

[1:14:42] Eli Tokash: Take about everyone involved in the live performance. That was so much fun. I'm literally so upset at myself that one, I didn't bring previous guests that were there that night uh up to the stage, such as Abby Day Phillips, Oscar Williams, Nikki Torsha, Alexa Shaynezak, Sky Alyssa Friedman. There were so many incredible people there that came and supported that were on the podcast episode. I wanted to bring them up, but again, there were a million things on my mind, and it totally slipped. Um so thank you all for coming. Wanted to give you guys an extra shout out. And then I cannot believe this entire like two years of Take A Bow. I've wanted nothing more than to like actually like say take a bow the guest and like actually have them take a bow.

And I had the prime opportunity to do it live at the Green Room 42 for our 100th episode. And it totally slipped my mind too. I literally, it just goes to show that there were so many things on my mind. And um it was just it was an amazing night, and all of it was a blur. But I just can't believe that, like looking back, I'm like, oh I can't believe this. Um, anyways, so worth it. Uh I'm doing it now, and I've learned for next time, but needless to say, I still think that that night turned out better than I could have ever imagined. Um we had no idea what that this was going to be, how it was going to be ran. Uh totally like put it together. Um, you know, with everyone's busy schedule kind of like the day of so craziness all around, but uh I'm so so thrilled with how fun it was, and and that's all that really matters to me. So um I hope you all enjoyed it as much as I did. And without further ado, I'm gonna give my song that I sang Freeze Your Brain another go. So here is Freeze Your Brain.

[1:16:36] ♪ Musical number: "Freeze Your Brain" — performed by Eli Tokash ♪

[1:19:31] Eli Tokash: It's still like a work in progress for me. And I've learned that I've I've learned to accept that with my voice because it's been a whole learning process. So for everyone out there, especially the the teenagers, the my age group for sure, uh, both male, female, whatever you identify as. Listen, it it's tricky, and even for someone who has been on Broadway, um, the vocal change is no joke, and it takes time to find it. And as you can tell, it may still not be perfect, but that's okay, because you know, we're putting in the time, we're putting in the effort, we're putting in the work, and uh we're dedicating our craft to to continue to get better and to continue to do what we love, which is telling stories and making others happy.

Um, so there you have it. I just wanted to come on here to actually do a proper uh version of the song with me remembering all the lyrics because I I just feel like it's the right thing to do. Um once again, it's still not perfect, but that's okay, and um, that's what I'm here to do. Um, I've talked about what I've dealt with at through my vocal change, it's been a lot, it's been a learning process, both physically and mentally, all the things, and uh, I wanted to come on here, do it again, show it what it was like with with the with the actual words, and uh show that like listen, it's a learning process still, and I'm here with all of you, and we're all in the same boat, and let's just continue to support each other along the way.

So there you have it. That's my singing. That's the first time I'm debuting it on the podcast. It's the first time I've debuted it since the voice change. Um, and yeah, once again, this is the 100th episode of Take A Bow Live. You got two performances from me. You got one performance from uh JJ Niemann, you got Presley Ryan, you got Anthony Rosenthal, you got Max Von Essen. Uh, we had a wonderful pianist, Charlie Alterman, who was also on the podcast. That's what I loved about last night. Even the uh pianist was was a part of the podcast, Take A Bow family. Um, so just thrilled all around for everyone, all the friends, all the family, um, everyone who live streamed, everything. Just it could not have been, it could not have been more perfect.

And I just appreciate everyone and all of you, um, especially those who who didn't make it but continue to listen every week, uh, that are currently listening. Seriously, means the world. It's the only reason why we've made it to a hundred episodes. As long as there's literally only one person listening, we're still coming at you because if we can make one person happy, that's the goal here. So many more to come. Hopefully, we'll see you all at the next live show. And uh, thank you again to everyone coming out, and thank you to everyone who has supported me uh in this wonderful journey to a hundred episodes of Take A Bow. That's all for this week. Stay tuned for next week's episode 101 Craziness, um, because we have another incredible guest. So I can't wait to see you all next week. And I hope that you have a wonderful week in the meantime. Bye everyone. Have a great week. Thanks for listening to 100 episodes. Yeah!

[1:22:44] Eli Tokash: For this episode's current call, I would like to recognize a few people who also deserve to take a bow. This podcast would not be possible without the help from Dory Berenstein, Brittany Bigelow, Katie Rosen, Alan Seales, and the team at the Broadway Podcast Network. Next in line to Take the Bow is Tessie Tokash, who edits the audio and all the visuals for this podcast. A special thanks to patrons Brian Thompson, Pat McNamara, the listeners at PCC, as well as all of the other patrons for their continued support. If you're interested in becoming a patron, go to Patreon.com slash T A B. And if you enjoyed this week's episode, don't forget to subscribe on the platform that you're currently listening to this on. Also, feel free to give us a follow on Instagram at Take A Bow Podcast. Take a Bow's logo is designed by Giselle Bustos, and the music is by Nikki Torsha and Cormac Collinon. Bye everyone. Hope to see you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred