Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#55 - TAB's Pride Medley

TAB medley of LGBTQIA+ Broadway performers, who have had profound impacts on the community by using their talents and platforms. The episode features important stories and words of encouragement from Prom's Caitlin Kinnunen, HSMTMTS 's Joe Serafini, Prom's Josh Lamon, and Fun Home's Beth Malone... Read More

From the show: Take A Bow

41 mins
6/10/21

Guests

Featured Shows

About

TAB medley of LGBTQIA+ Broadway performers, who have had profound impacts on the community by using their talents and platforms. The episode features important stories and words of encouragement from Prom's Caitlin Kinnunen, HSMTMTS 's Joe Serafini, Prom's Josh Lamon, and Fun Home's Beth Malone.

Connect with these four on Instagram: @caitlin.kinnune, @joe_serafini_, @thebethmalone, and @josh.lamon.

Connect with Take A Bow on Instagram: @takeabowpodcast

Connect with host, Eli Tokash on Instagram: @tokash_eli

Produced by the Broadway Podcast Network

Edited by Tessie Tokash (@tessietokash)

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Eli Tokash: Hello everyone and welcome back to episode 55 of Take A Bow Podcast. I'm your host, Eli Tokash, and today we have a very different type of interview going on today. And it's not really like an interview, it's a bunch of our favorite interviews with some of the most iconic LGBTQ guests that we've had. So you will all be hearing from our Pride family here at Take A Bow, and all to celebrate Pride and to kick off our episodes and events that we're gonna be doing surrounding Pride Month. So I'm very excited for this episode. I'm very excited to see how this is gonna go down because it's gonna be very interesting and very fun all at the same time.

[0:46] Eli Tokash: I want to start off by saying happy June, happy Pride, happy Pride Month. It's going to be a very exciting. I have a lot of really, really cool episodes and guests coming up, and I cannot wait to share that all with you. And speaking of can't wait, oh my god, everyone, literally, Broadway is coming back in 16 days. That is right. 16 days. I don't understand this. I mean, like, I'm all for it, but like it seems like every week a show is trying to like outdo the other, and they're all just trying to open first.

[1:24] Eli Tokash: So that's right, 16 days. Bruce Springsteen is going to be coming back for a limited engagement starting on June 26th. I'm like mind-blown, first of all. I am so excited. I didn't get to see it when he was on Broadway before. But now that he's coming back and it's literally gonna be the only show open, I am so intrigued and going to see that. I cannot wait. I don't know if I'm gonna be able to wait any longer, but so I guess I'm gonna have to live the rest of my life saying that Bruce Springsteen was the first Broadway show that I saw after a pandemic, after it was shut down for quite some time. What a world we're living in, everyone.

[2:10] Eli Tokash: That's right. There's lots of things happening. There was some more very exciting news, one very dear to my heart. This one made me so happy when I saw this a couple days ago. It was announced that Trevor the Musical will be returning off Broadway on October 25th, and tickets are officially on sale for it. I don't know what's going on as far as like a cast and everything if they're bringing the cast back, are they gonna have to re-audition? What are they gonna do? It's gonna be very interesting to see, but I'm very excited just for the story to get told.

[2:45] Eli Tokash: I'm very excited for my friends who were in the cast to hopefully be returning to the show. And just all of these things. I literally cannot wait for this to be in a theater again and to be in a theater that is very, very close to me, which is great because it's gonna be in New York, it's gonna be at New World Stages. It's gonna be amazing. October 25th. Everyone literally just go, please just go. It's so good. I can't wait to see it. I will be in the audience for one of their first shows. I guarantee that. I'm just so excited. I'm so freaking excited.

[3:23] Eli Tokash: And there was some speculation that it what who knew what was gonna happen with it. So for it to finally be announced that it's coming back, it was a very good day for me the other day. I was very excited. Let's talk about some of these movies that are happening surrounding Broadway. I don't know how to feel about it. Okay. Annie Live is happening this year on NBC. And they already found their Miss Hannigan, and that's gonna be Taraji P. Henson, which is very exciting. I cannot wait to see that.

[3:57] Eli Tokash: And then like I'm excited for Annie Live, of course, because those are live events that happen every year. That was pretty much inevitable that something live is gonna happen this year with everything going back to normal. We needed we wanted some live TV. They did it with the Grinch when the pandemic was kind of at its peak, but like starting to slow down. So yeah, it was good to see that they're gonna be doing a live performance again. But now they've also announced that they're gonna be doing filmed events of both Matilda and Jersey Boys.

[4:34] Eli Tokash: So I don't know how to feel about this. I mean, the reason that these stories are becoming relevant again, such as a movie, such a world-renowned book and movie in Matilda is because of the musical that they did on Broadway. And so now they're gonna be doing a musical movie. I don't understand that. I just wish that like they would have filmed the Broadway version and that's what would be released because that's kind of what got everyone talking about Matilda again. I don't know how I feel about it, and then same with Jersey Boys.

[5:07] Eli Tokash: I mean, I am very excited because they did announce that Nick Jonas will be returning to his Broadway roots and starring as Frankie Valli in it, which, you know, I'm not shy to say that I am totally a Jonas Brother fan, a Joe Bro for life, you know. But no, Nick Jonas, I like him. I love that he's gonna be in this Jersey Boys event, but at the same time it's like, you know, they're gonna be doing it based off of the musical, so why wouldn't you just post the musical? I don't know. I am indifferent about it all.

[5:46] Eli Tokash: I'm just excited that we're gonna be getting more entertainment, more, you know, Broadway's gonna be in these bigger markets. Not Broadway itself, obviously, because they're not like taking that, but you know what I mean. Like the musical aspect of it all is going to be brought to a higher scale and gonna be reachable for more audiences that hopefully get more excited about Broadway who they as they may not be. So stuff is happening, everyone. There is a lot of announcements that came out this week.

[6:21] Eli Tokash: I've already named five of them. Yes, that's right, five. And so I only have one more thing to announce. So there was a very emotional for me, at least. I don't know. For others, it was quite entertaining and everything like that. But I was just like I was just brought many emotions while watching this on Tuesday night. I don't know if any of you were able to watch the Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, but Lin-Manuel Miranda was on it, and Anthony Ramos is gonna be on it very soon.

[6:56] Eli Tokash: All to talk about In the Heights, which is literally premiering tomorrow. Can't wait for that. HBO Max or in theaters. Go check it out because it's gonna be amazing. I cannot wait. You can watch the first eight minutes already. Just like search it up on the web and on the interweb, you'll find it. But anyways, they're promoting that, and they went on Jimmy Fallon, and it was one of Jimmy Fallon's first shows with a full live audience again.

[7:26] Eli Tokash: And so with Lin-Manuel Miranda there, they decided to salute the return of Broadway. And it was literally incredible. They included shows, like literally every show like Six, Phantom of the Opera, Chicago, Dear Evan Hansen, Lion King, Hadestown, Company, Come From Away, Book of Mormon, Moulin Rouge, Chorus Line, Aladdin, Wicked, Hamilton. So like they did all of these incredible things, and a lot of the shows that are on Broadway now, and some of the historic ones that kind of made Broadway, and all of these things, and everyone who was on the stage performing those numbers were all Broadway actors.

[8:04] Eli Tokash: So, like a few of my friends were in there, and it was just so amazing just to see their emotion. Like at the end, almost everybody on that stage was crying. It was just wonderful to see people perform again in front of a live audience. It was incredible to hear some of the stories again, hear some of the songs, the tributes and everything. Like it was all just brilliantly done. Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon, you guys are literally icons. You guys are literally musical geniuses, and I would love to see Jimmy Fallon on a Broadway stage.

[8:41] Eli Tokash: Honestly, I was thinking because okay, so at the end, I don't know if I'm gonna give it away, but like it it's good. Maybe it'll get you guys even more excited to watch. At the end, they do like a little remix, I guess, of "You'll Be Back." And honestly, I was kinda like, I would love to see Jimmy Fallon play the king. Like, I don't know, maybe that's just me. I was really excited about it. "You'll Be Back" was kind of really fun to hear from him. And I know he'll never do it because he has the Tonight Show and everything like that. So it's like too much going on, but like how cool would that be?

[9:03] Eli Tokash: I don't know. Maybe it's just me. Jimmy Fallon is amazing and really talented in a lot of ways. And I would love to see him on a Broadway stage, but that's besides the point. Anyways, back to the topic. They were literally showcasing a bunch of Broadway ensemble members, but also Broadway royalty, such as Felicia Rashad, Kristin Chenoweth, Laura Benanti, Christopher Jackson, and In the Heights star Olga Merediz and Jimmy Smith. It was literally everything that you wanted to be.

[9:53] Eli Tokash: Obviously, they've had to put some In the Heights stars in it, as that's what they were promoting. And of course, Christopher Jackson was in the original In the Heights on Broadway. And I think he's gonna be making an appearance in the movie as well. But literally it was incredible. It was great to see all of these amazing Broadway icons and royalty and legends. So that leads me into this week's drama dictionary word of the week.

[10:15] Eli Tokash: And if anyone watched this lovely salute that they had to Broadway reopening, they did this thing that is called a medley. And what a medley is, is it's a combination of a bunch of different musical numbers in a musical or just songs in general. They all just combine it and they make it flow in a way that like it works. So they didn't do exactly a medley, they did a medley as in they incorporated all kinds of Broadway shows and then did like a tribute.

[10:54] Eli Tokash: But a medley is very famous in Broadway because usually at the bows, they'll usually do like two songs combined. And so that would even be a medley. And then if you see like a Macy's Day performance, sometimes they'll do a medley, or sometimes they just do one number. And that would not be a medley. So it's just multiple numbers or songs put together to make one really, really cool and lovely song. If anyone is familiar with the, it was very popular when like they both came out.

[11:21] Eli Tokash: So Dear Evan Hansen and Hamilton did this like amazing medley. I mean, it was like Lin-Manuel Miranda, Ben Platt, and Pasek and Paul who wrote, they all collaborated on it and they like made this medley of "You Will Be Found" and "The Story of Tonight," and they called it "Found/Tonight." And so like they just combined the two songs and made like a lovely medley to celebrate both wonderful shows and both amazing songs and everything like that.

[12:02] Eli Tokash: I'm trying to think of another example, but I think you all get the gist of what I'm trying to say. A medley is very famous on Broadway. I know Pasek and Paul, who they love to kind of write medleys, and they did that in their first ever musical Dog Fight, and they took two songs that they had that they were like figuring out where to put in the show, and then they combined it and they made this "First Date/Last Night" song that was just incredible, and like two different people were singing two different songs.

[12:38] Eli Tokash: So it was just really cool. Just so now that you all know what it is, and now you're all aware of it. Look out for it. It's really, really cool what people come up with. It's also pretty famous on like the internet. A lot of people try to like incorporate all kinds of different songs. I don't know. That's my rant on medleys. It's very fun. And now let's get to this week's episode because it's an exciting one, and I'm just gonna explain it all to you because this is a medley of podcasts.

[13:04] Eli Tokash: Literally. Oh my god, this is so I didn't even plan that. This is a medley of podcasts that are from some of my favorite episodes with some of our Pride family surrounding Take A Bow. And you're also gonna be hearing from our beloved original co-host, Sidney Lucas, and all of these interviews. Today you're gonna be hearing from Josh Lamon, Caitlin Kinnunen, Beth Malone, and Joe Serafini. So we are going to be kind of sharing the short clips of you know their iconic moments and how they've changed Broadway and how they've saved lives, and how they've just been huge factors on the LGBTQIA+ community, and just their impacts that they've had that will last forever, literally, and how they've changed Broadway for the better in a lot of ways.

[14:05] Eli Tokash: So here is episode 55 of Take A Bow.

[14:29] Eli Tokash: I call Prom the gift that keeps giving because just when you think things have calmed down and it's fine, the show is closed, we're all moving on. No, it keeps going and it keeps giving, and just so many more incredible, amazing stories keep coming out of it. I get so many messages on Instagram, and I got so many letters at the stage door, and like meeting people at the stage door just saying that they felt seen and heard and represented and how much that meant to them. I think my favorite stage door story is that there was one, they must have been like 12 to 15 years old, and they came and saw the show, and I was stage dooring, and they put their hands on my shoulders and they said, "My mom is right behind me.

She doesn't know I'm gay, but I am. I don't know when I'm gonna tell her, but thank you for what you've done." And I just like that to me is why it's so important that it's like there's no time limit on when you can come out. There's no time limit on like, oh well, I have to decide my sexuality now. And it was so cool to be able to see all of these kids and young adults come and say, "Oh, I'm figuring this out and I'm working on it, and you're giving me confidence to like talk about it," and that's great. And so that one just hit me so hard that like their mom was right behind them, and they had the courage to say that to me and come out to me when they hadn't come out to their parent yet. Like, yeah, yeah.

And there's so so many stories like that that are just heart wrenching and touching and beautiful. I just got a message on Instagram two nights ago that was a very similar like, "I'm trying to figure out myself out, and you're giving me the confidence to do that." And I'm like, I don't know how I'm doing that. And a lot of this comes from just the Prom itself and what I learned playing Emma. I have confidence now. I have self-confidence and self-worth, and I know what I am worth, you know, and that is spiritually, emotionally, physically, monetarily, and I think that's the difference between being a child actor and adult actor is I can walk into a room now and say, "No, I belong here. I am meant to be here.

This is the right thing." Whereas when I was a quote unquote child actor, it was all like, "Well, I'm supposed to be here. Is this the right place? Is this the right thing for me to be doing? Can you guys tell me what you need me to do? Because I'm not sure. Do I need to go here? Do I need to go there?" It was all of these questions. And now I feel more comfortable in saying, like, "No, this is who I am. And if you want me, great. If not, I'm gonna go do something else because I'm awesome." Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So, and that truly was like, that is a lesson that I have worked on for the last like five years being a part of the Prom and figuring out what all of that means to me.

[17:20] Eli Tokash: Okay, Thanksgiving Day Parade. Yeah, yes, and at the end of the performance, the first same-sex kiss in the parade's entire century of existence took place. When that happened, by the way, I jumped off the couch with my entire family and we cheered. We are so happy. It was such a huge moment in history and such an impactful win for the LGBTQ+ community.

[17:52] Eli Tokash: Yeah. Were you nervous at all for that? Or nervous for like the backlash you might get for that? Because there's still way too many uneducated people.

[18:00] Caitlin Kinnunen: Are we like, yeah, this is happening? Love is love, and anyone who has a problem with it can go crawling a hole.

[18:05] Caitlin Kinnunen: Yeah. I mean, some of my own ignorance came into play because like I didn't know that that hadn't happened on the parade before. I was completely unaware because love is love, whatever. Both Izzy, the woman who played Alyssa, who's Emma's girlfriend in the show, we went into it and we were like, "Yeah, we're just doing this number, it's awesome, it's great." And it wasn't until we got to the rehearsal at Macy's the Monday before that our director, Casey Nicholaw, was like, "You know, this is the first time this has happened, right?" And we were both, "Oh my god," and that hit us, and we were like, "Oh, okay, this is huge." The true weight of what we were doing hit us because before it was just, "Oh my gosh, we get to be on the Thanksgiving Day Parade.

That's incredible. It's so exciting to like bring our show to that." And then it just added this other level of, "Oh no, this is important that we're doing this." And honestly, it was just like pushing through and getting to the end because we're so exhausted and it's so early and it's so cold. And it's TV, you have the audience who's there, but then you just have cameras in your face, so you don't even think about, "Oh my god, millions of people are watching this." That's not in your brain, or at least it wasn't in mine, and so then to like do it and then get back to the theater and then start to like slowly see all of the hate that came back at us, it was a lot. But what was so cool about it was that for all of the hate and backlash and unacceptance of us, we got ten times the amount of love and support and acceptance and joy and the people who were reaching out saying, "Oh my god, my family saw that and we all cheered.

This is what families look like. Thank you for showing that. We feel seen and represented," and it's so cool. And I just I applaud Macy's for doing that and saying, "No, you keep that kiss in." Our team was so afraid that they would come and see the finale and say, "Okay, you can do the finale, but you can't do the kiss." And Macy's zoomed in on it, you know.

[20:09] Caitlin Kinnunen: Yes. Way to go, Macy's. That's incredible. And so it really just became such a beacon of love and hope. And it was such an amazing experience and such a cool moment of history to be a part of. That's one of those moments where I just go like, "What is my life? I got to do that and like represent people, and that's awesome."

[20:32] Eli Tokash: Absolutely. You're not just making history in that way. You know, queer people have worked in the Broadway industry and the theater industry for so long, and yeah, it wasn't until very, very recently the shows started revolving around queer people. You've been in at least two of them. You've been in Prom, you've been in Fun Home.

[20:50] Caitlin Kinnunen: I'm quite literally making history in them.

[20:56] Caitlin Kinnunen: Yeah. And I think it's just the beginning. More people need to be telling these stories and they matter and they need to be heard. And I just I encourage anyone out there who is in a position where they can make that change happen, do it, you know. You know? Tell these stories. Make these voices heard. Keep going.

[21:15] Eli Tokash: For sure. For sure. And your role is so inspiring for everyone. Like what's it like being a role that, you know, has that inspiration for a lot of people?

[21:27] Caitlin Kinnunen: Um, it's a little scary, honestly. Um, just 'cause just 'cause I know I mean it's I'm so grateful and I I would never want to be like I'm so honored to be playing this role. Um, but the scary aspect that I'm talking about is just like, you know, people the situations and like the topics that I'm involved in are pretty sensitive topics to some people, just like, you know, LGBTQ+ issues are and it's not even that Seb was ever going through issues, but you know, I just never want to, when speaking about those issues, I never want to misspeak or um offend anyone if for any type of phrasing thing that I say wrong or you know it's just people are sensitive and and we have to really watch the way we use our platforms and I don't know, send those messages out.

[22:21] Eli Tokash: Absolutely. For sure. Okay, so we gotta we gotta talk about Fun Home.

[22:26] Caitlin Kinnunen: Okay.

[22:26] Eli Tokash: Um, well actually let's talk about before Fun Home. Let's talk let's talk about how before Fun Home you were you were doing a musical in Asbury Park, right?

[22:35] Caitlin Kinnunen: That is correct. I was doing another lesbian musical called The Breakup Notebook and Lisa Kron came to see it randomly because she was on vacation. She was like, "What am I gonna do tonight?" And they were like, "Oh, there's a lesbian musical. Let's go do that." And so they were there on my opening night and inexplicably. But I knew I knew at Lisa before that. Um, but that was how I got the audition for Fun Home. That's how, like, when I got home, my agent was like, "Hey, you put yourself on tape for this thing at the Public," and I I wanted to like me on stage. I want to represent gay lesbian LGBTQ people on stage, which like at that point you just never saw it. And of course, you never saw a musical about a lesbian, like you just never saw it.

So this was totally, totally different than Fun Home. It was like a it was a rom-com sort of thing about a girl who gets dumped. But like that happened, and then and then Lisa said, "I think I found the person who I think, you know, because it's a tough, that's a tough world of cast. Like Alison Bechdel's a tough person to cast, especially back then when they really wasn't they weren't sure what they were even writing at that point.

[23:47] Eli Tokash: Did you have any memorable fan experiences from Fun Home?

[23:51] Caitlin Kinnunen: Oh wow. I mean the kinds of stories that we heard and the kinds of stories that people would write to us, like we got a lot of letters. Um, and you know, it's a very dangerous world for gay people still. So to have this kind of representation, um and and this kind of honesty and dignity given to a story that wasn't just like the gay person's on the upright side of the stage being a punchline. This is a story with dignity and substance, where the gay person is down center. Um, it just it was so incredibly powerful to receive all of the stories, the stories, the stories, the stories.

[24:49] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[24:49] Caitlin Kinnunen: Um, people would bring their mother to Fun Home. I'm like, you're braver than I am, man. I would never bring my mother to Fun Home. Um, or my father. Um, you know, it was like a movement. It wasn't just a show. It ended up being like the second act ended up being that um that autograph line.

[25:10] Eli Tokash: Autograph line.

[25:11] Caitlin Kinnunen: Yeah. Right. It was intense. I'm sure that you have incredible stories too. I mean, I have I have a uh a manila envelope stuffed full of some of the more beautiful ones, more intense ones, like um people still write me, you know. It's really um an honor to receive those kind of stories from people and to have been the receptacle for um, you know, people's uh vehicle for for people to uh you know have courage and and tell their tell their truth. And it was um it was really powerful, it's really powerful, but it also made me intensely sad because uh of all the work that's still to be done, you know. You think, oh, we've come so far, and then these people are traveling from all kinds of places just to see you and tell you that they s you know you saved their life.

[26:09] Eli Tokash: Yeah.

[26:09] Caitlin Kinnunen: It's very, very intense, and it's real. And also because it was not just a musical.

[26:15] Eli Tokash: Yeah, no, it wasn't just a musical, and also because I mean, this was the I mean the show revolved around a lesbian woman. You played Broadway's first ever openly butch lesbian lead.

[26:27] Caitlin Kinnunen: Ever.

[26:28] Eli Tokash: Ever.

[26:29] Caitlin Kinnunen: Um, yeah.

[26:30] Eli Tokash: And maybe only for a really long time.

[26:33] Caitlin Kinnunen: I can't imagine another musical soon coming out and being like, "Nah, well, another butch woman sings." No, I don't think so. It's not gonna happen for a while. But yeah, it was amazing to be that to be that person has historically has been pretty heavy. Pretty heavy. Um, you know, but also like as an actor and casting wise, to not to sort of like go, and now I'm gonna set that down and I want to be in other things. You know, for people to see me as like a legit actor who can play things has been sort of a fight.

[27:02] Eli Tokash: To anyone out there who wants to give up on their passion, can you tell them anything? Just just like if you could tell them one thing, what would you tell them?

[27:15] Caitlin Kinnunen: Well, I would say like the five things, the five I got really good advice right before I quit. Peter was like, Peter Schneider, my friend who used to be the head of Disney, he told me, um, because he was the one who was directing Sister Act, and he got fired too. So he and I were out of jobs. And he said to me, "I get it, but before you quit the business, don't leave the house for less than a thousand dollars."

[27:42] Beth Malone: Don't leave the house unless it's a thousand dollars, or it's a show you've always wanted to do, or it's people you've always wanted to work with, or the thing has legs. Even if it's something you're not that nuts about, you know it's going in. And if there's anything left undone, do it artistically. If there's anything you haven't done that is within your power to do, for me, that was writing a solo show. So I wrote "Beth Malone So Far," and that was really scary to do. It was part of the thing where he was like, do something that scares you, do something that scares the crap out of you. Because obviously, you're in a place where you're willing to throw it all out. So if you're gonna throw it all out anyway, you might as well do this terrifying thing before you quit.

It was excellent advice because it did scare the crap out of me, and it made me feel so alive. Every time I'd step out there to do that solo show, I was like, why am I doing this to myself? This is awful, this is terrible. And afterwards, I would feel so exhilarated and such a huge weight off of myself because I was telling my own true story of my parents disowning me when I came out. I was telling this through pop songs and with a lot of humor, trying to get laid for the first time and failing miserably, and just all of these stories that were intensely personal, also really funny, and meant something to somebody else, which is the other part I didn't really see coming. I was like, oh, this actually is helping people.

This story I'm telling is actually changing people's lives. Janine Tesori always says, "You gotta see it to be it." So I was being a thing that people could see, and I was being really visible, and my visibility was empowering other people to feel better about themselves and their own lives. That is a reason to do it, that's reason enough to do anything on top of all the other benefits that I got from doing it, which was learning how to write a show. Now I know how to write a one-woman show. I know how to take pieces from songs that say what I need and throw the rest out, and then write dialogue in between and put another piece of a song that says exactly what I need it to say. I don't need to sing a whole song.

I'm not, no one's making me. I'm the boss of this. I learned that there's a place for you if you make it, if you write it. If you make your own, you know, so I became my own writer, and then people that were like-minded and people who were my people found me. I couldn't go out and find them. I became the beacon for them to see me in the dark and to go toward me. That's what writing that solo show did. Be the most you you can be is a good way to say it. Figure out who exactly you are and what the thing is that makes you you and give it voice.

[31:09] Eli Tokash: So you were in "The Prom" on Broadway, and I remember when you were out of town in that kind of stage of the production, you were so excited. You were posting about it all the time, you were texting, and it was great. I was so happy for you. When it finally came to Broadway, it was around the same time I was actually doing "Trevor," so we were both doing LGBTQ shows, which was super interesting that it was at that time. Talk to us about your experience there because you also understudied the lead, and when you actually went on a few times, and I'm so mad that I never actually got to see that. Just talk a little bit about that.

[31:49] Joe Serafini: I have to say, I saw you, you absolutely freaking killed it. Sydney, I remember when you came backstage after. Doing a queer-themed show is something that the three of us can relate to because I'm sure you both also had the experience of people coming up to you and sort of being a poster child, whether you wanted to be or not, and being in that light of being like, "Oh, part of my job is to hear your story as well and to validate that." I was actually about to ask you about that. While you were doing the show, did you feel the impact that the show had on so many people?

[32:34] Caitlin Kinnunen: Absolutely. I still feel it, especially after the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade kiss. I tweeted that it was the first same-sex kiss on the parade, and as soon as I tweeted that, the media took my tweet and it was everywhere. Then every hate group in the world came at me. Some of our cast members got death threats during the show. Somebody got a hold of Izzy Mikaela's number and started calling her with death threats. The precinct in Times Square, the best damn cops in the universe, swarmed in and blocked off the theater, and they made sure that all of us got home safe. It got very real, but it was also a reminder that we live in a very liberal bubble. We are not nearly as liberated from hatred as we think.

But also, I am a gay dude. I know what it's like. When I was in high school, there was an underground support group for gay students and gay teachers, but it was underground, it was in secret, and we were not allowed to talk about it. It was very hush-hush. That is no longer an issue for students in high schools, or at least most places here. For me, I take it very seriously when I meet people that were impacted by "The Prom" or that would come out to me or parents that would come to me and say that they know their child is queer but their child doesn't know that they know. What do they do? Or even parents that are struggling with how to deal with it. It's not that they don't like their child; it's just that this is not in their set of tools, which is also understandable. Not all of us were raised with a lot of gay friends that we knew about or in New York City or whatever.

[34:50] Joe Serafini: It's interesting because I remember during "Wicked," I would see a lot of the show fans and I'd be like, "Oh, a lot of these people feel like alphabet," and I get that. I'd be like, "I see you're alphabet, you're an outcast." That's why you're here, and that's why you identify, and I get that. But at the same time, I never really got emotionally attached to them because I was an alphabet. That's not my journey. That's not their journey with me. But with "The Prom," it was very much a collective journey for everybody in the show with the show's fan base. Getting to play Barry, I think I got to play it 27 times. Brooks is not only one of my closest friends, but he's my hero. You create a role, and what you do is you create a blueprint.

It's like a house. I hate to use the word perfect because there's no such thing, but it's a perfect blueprint. Your understudy or whoever, your replacement, has the perfect blueprint. You learn the blueprint, you master the blueprint, and once you master the blueprint, that's when you put your own shell on it and make it you. You have to learn the fine details. Sorry, everybody listening. I swear like a sailor, trust me. But once you master the blueprint, that's when you make it you, but you have to respect that blueprint. Brooks made the perfect blueprint, and when I got to learn it and make it my own, I got to be a big boy. During "The Prom," I was the heaviest I'd ever been, which also put another spin on being a poster boy for the fatties. I've never seen myself center stage before, and I get to be center stage for me, and sing a song. That doesn't happen.

[37:33] Eli Tokash: Take a bow, Josh Lamon, and honestly, take a bow to all four of you wonderful friends of mine. All four of these amazing people had such wonderful stories to share, amazing lessons, and so many wonderful memories and words of encouragement and pieces of advice that I will carry with me forever. I hope that you all can too, and I hope that it'll help you in any way, shape, or form that it has helped me. Literally from Caitlin's wonderful stories at the stage door, and just playing such a staple role that is changing Broadway forever. I can't say enough about her and her bravery, as well as Beth Malone, who is another huge component in that aspect, playing Alice Bechdel in "Fun Home," and of course Joe Serafini and Josh Lamon for everything that they've done in contributing.

They are huge supporters of the Trevor Project. They speak out about being yourself and encouraging others and sharing their stories. Joe Serafini, of course, was the first gay couple on Disney Plus. It was a monumental moment for Disney and Disney Plus in "High School Musical: The Musical: The Series." They're still together. It's incredible. Everyone loves the storyline there. Big Seblos stands, as the kids say. I thought all of these messages were very important to visit, especially in the month of Pride. I wanted to share these stories again. I know we've had a lot of new listeners since these stories have aired, and I thought it would be only right to share their stories once again and highlight these amazing words and advice that these four superstars had shared.

[39:15] Eli Tokash: So that's gonna wrap up this week's episode. I'm very excited for what's to come. We have some of my favorite people coming on, literally. We're gonna have a pair of Broadway husbands on the podcast. We're gonna have one of my dear friends who I did "Finding Neverland" with. I'm not gonna reveal the name yet because it's just too exciting, and I want to announce it live during the episode. We're gonna have an interesting dynamic in one of these pride episodes, as we're going to be having one of the most famous fans of Broadway. It's gonna be really cool, and I'm excited to hear all of the stories that are going to be shared in these next couple of episodes. I cannot wait for you all to listen to it.

Until then, thank you for listening to this week's episode. I've had a wonderful time celebrating Pride so far this month. Oh, "In the Heights," tomorrow. Check it out on HBO Max or in theaters. So excited. Okay, I'm done. Love you all. Be kind, and love is love. Bye everyone.

[40:29] Eli Tokash: For this episode's current call, I would like to recognize a few people who also deserve to take a bow. This podcast would not be possible without the help from Dory Berenstein, Brittany Bigelow, Katie Rosen, Alan Seales, and the team at the Broadway Podcast Network. Next in line to take the bow is Tessie Tokash, who edits the audio and all the visuals for this podcast. A special thanks to patrons Brian Thompson, Pat McNamara, the listeners at PCC, as well as all the other patrons for their continued support. If you're interested in becoming a patron, go to patreon.com slash TAB. If you enjoyed this week's episode, don't forget to subscribe on the platform that you're currently listening to this on. Also, feel free to give us a follow on Instagram at takeabowpodcast. Take A Bow's logo is designed by Giselle Bustos, and the music is by Nikki Torsha and Cormac Collinon. Bye everyone. Hope to see you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred