Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Carey Renee Sharpe: From Pediatric ICU Nurse to Finding Her 'Blood' Off-Broadway

What happens when the career you've dedicated your life to no longer feels sustainable? Carey Renee Sharpe details how she went from burnout to Broadway on The Art of Kindness podcast... Read More

From the show: The Art of Kindness: Pop Culture & Positivity with Robert Peterpaul

41 mins
Jun 29

About

What happens when the career you've dedicated your life to no longer feels sustainable?

Carey Renee Sharpe details how she went from burnout to Broadway on The Art of Kindness podcast. The creator and star of the Off-Broadway musical Blood Love: A Vampire Opera joins Robert Peterpaul for a moving conversation on how reinvention can help you find your way back to yourself.

Before writing musicals, Carey spent years as a pediatric ICU nurse and nurse practitioner caring for critically ill children. When the emotional weight of the work became too much to carry, she made the difficult decision to leave the profession that had defined her for years. What followed was unexpected: restoring a historic theater, writing music during the pandemic, and ultimately creating Blood Love, an original Off-Broadway musical rooted in love, friendship, and the search for light.

In this podcast podcast episode, you'll hear:

  • Why Carey left a successful career in pediatric critical care
  • How she pivoted from the ICU to Off-Broadway, creating Blood Love from deeply personal experiences
  • Building a rehearsal room centered on love instead of competition
  • Balancing motherhood, leadership, and creative ambition
  • Why "art is the best form of rebellion" in difficult times, plus more.

Together, Robert and Carey discuss the courage to change directions, leading creative teams with vulnerability, motherhood, sustainable theater culture, and why making art can be one of the most powerful acts of hope in a complicated world. Because sometimes kindness means caring for others. And sometimes it means finally caring for yourself.

CAREY RENEE SHARPE made her Off-Broadway debut as Valerie in her own original production BLOOD/LOVE, a lifelong dream realized. Carey spent her childhood steeped in music, with formal violin training beginning at age three, but chose to pursue a career as a critical care pediatric nurse practitioner inspired by her personal history of congenital heart disease. In 2018 she stepped away from healthcare and restored a historic theater in her hometown, reigniting her love of music. She has spent the past 6 years writing, developing & performing in BLOOD/LOVE.

Follow Carey:

⁠⁠@careyreneemusic

Follow us:

⁠⁠@artofkindnesspod⁠⁠ / ⁠⁠@robpeterpaul⁠⁠

Support the show!

(⁠⁠https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theaok⁠⁠)

Music:

"Awake" by Ricky Alvarez & "Sunshine" by Lemon Music Studio.

We are supported by the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Carey Renee Sharpe: I'm Carey Renee Sharpe, and you're listening to The Art of Kindness.

[0:09] Robert Peterpaul: Hello, beautiful people. Welcome to The Art of Kindness, where we have compassionate conversations with artists from all areas of the entertainment industry who are using their voice to spread joy and make this big spinning planet in the universe a better place to be. I'm Robert Peterpaul, and I'm so glad you're here.

[0:37] Robert Peterpaul: Hello, friends. Today we have a conversation with someone who truly defines the art of kindness. A pediatric ICU nurse who experienced burnout, left the career she thought defined her, and finds healing through art. I'm talking about the kind, Carey Renee Sharpe.

[0:59] Robert Peterpaul: Carey Renee Sharpe made her Off-Broadway debut as Valerie in her own original production, Blood Love: A Vampire Opera, a lifelong dream realized. Carey spent her childhood steeped in music, with formal violin training beginning at the age of three, but chose instead to pursue a career helping people as a critical care pediatric nurse practitioner, inspired by her personal history of congenital heart disease.

[1:25] Robert Peterpaul: As mentioned, Carey eventually stepped away from healthcare and restored a historic theater in her hometown, reigniting her love of the arts. She went on to spend six years writing, developing, and performing in her show, Blood Love, which rocked New York City this past spring and will continue to live on. Carey and I talk about creating art from deeply personal experiences, balancing parenthood with ambition, which is so hard, art as an act of rebellion, and so much more.

[2:01] Robert Peterpaul: I hope we'll find you on Instagram at Art of Kindness Pod and at Robert Peterpaul. You can also watch full video episodes on YouTube. Please share it with a friend and help expand our kindness community. Oh, audio hug. Now, without further ado, please welcome the kind, Carey Renee Sharpe.

[2:21] Carey Renee Sharpe: Kindness is sharp.

[2:32] Robert Peterpaul: I'm so excited to meet you. Congratulations on Blood Love and thanks for being here today.

[2:37] Carey Renee Sharpe: Thank you for having me.

[2:39] Robert Peterpaul: Well, in looking at your career, you have such a multifaceted journey that's just so cool and kind of sits at the intersection of what I love to talk about on The Art of Kindness, from healthcare to restoring a historic theater to motherhood and now Blood' Off-Broadway. When I zoom out, I feel like I see someone who really just does acts of service in general, from healthcare to music. Is that a through line you feel?

[3:04] Carey Renee Sharpe: Absolutely. Yeah, certainly. And I think I've always kind of worn that label, you know, for myself. It was definitely something that I really define myself with. I've always really cared about other people and wanting to help people has just been really central to my life, really. And so I did that, obviously, for very many years in one of the most literal senses as being a nurse and a nurse practitioner. You know, there really is no more caregiving thing than being a nurse. But I got burned out. You know, caring for others in that way is very mentally, emotionally, physically exhausting, really. And I worked in the pediatric ICU, so I mean, obviously, as you can imagine, taking care of sick and often dying children is really sad.

And it kind of turned away on me after a while. But I've found that, you know, shifting gears now and working in musical theater, I get to care for people in a different way. And also I get to care for myself in a different way than I had when I was working in healthcare. So it's been a project for myself, of course. I know, you know, obviously I wrote the show and I'm in it, which people have all kinds of feelings about that. And I understand, I understand that I do. But at the same time, you know, I wanted to be in my own art. I wanted to be part of it myself, you know. So I'm doing that. So I get to take care of myself too now.

[4:20] Robert Peterpaul: No, it's so cool. And I think it's something that's necessary in today's industry is that you have to kind of write your own projects. I mean, look at Lin-Manuel Miranda, Hamilton. I think it's so cool to see the writer actually in it. And we'll get into that a bit more, but I do wonder, just having so many nurses in my family, and my brother Thomas went through a cancer journey when he was little and he ultimately passed away, unfortunately. But the nurses and the people that were there for us are just ingrained in our brains. You all touch so many families that it'd be impossible for you to even realize that. But it makes me wonder now, do you have former families coming to see you on stage or have you had that experience?

[4:54] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, I worked in Wisconsin and in Chicago, and now we're in New York. So I don't, yeah. And it's been quite a few years since I left. It's been eight years. And I will say I really did maintain professional boundaries with my patients. Although, you know, I'd have patients for long term sometimes that I didn't ever like cross that boundary of like being friends with them outside of work. Some people do that, and I think that's okay too. I just, that was a boundary for me. I didn't, I don't because it was already hard enough to like work in that, you know, and have that close relationship even just in the professional context. So I just didn't want it to spill into my life outside of work. I really like tried to leave my work at work when I was still working in the field.

[5:40] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, that makes sense. I think there's a parallel too with performers too because even though you might have had that, people probably hold you in their brain as just such a special part of their life. It's the same with, I guess, seeing someone in a show and it's all wrapped up in kindness, what we're going to talk about. And I do wonder, Carey, what is your definition of kindness and how do you think it's evolved over this wild journey that we just touched on?

[6:03] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, I mean, I certainly just genuine care for other people and like, like you said, like acts of service and extending the love that you have and the light that you have to offer to the world, like extending that to other people. I would say that's what kindness is to me.

[6:19] Robert Peterpaul: Well, do you think there's an act of kindness that changed your trajectory? I usually say into the arts, but I know you started in the arts, I think at age three. You've always been entrenched in the music world and then you had this side journey and came back. But I wonder if any act of kindness comes to mind as sort of getting you where you are here today.

[6:38] Carey Renee Sharpe: Sure. Yes, I guess I would frame it in the way that I was a patient myself as a child. I have congenital heart disease. So I had open heart surgery when I was a baby, but then my whole childhood was followed up with cardiology and just, you know, I was always in contact with healthcare professionals and particularly my cardiologist that was my cardiologist my entire childhood until I was about twenty-two, was really wonderful. And so it inspired me to go into the field as well. So that would be like a person in a situation, just like having that experience of being a patient. And frankly, I had a good experience. It wasn't particularly traumatic or anything. I just, you know, I felt so supported and had a good healthcare team. So that kind of inspired me in that way too.

[7:24] Robert Peterpaul: I love that. You know, we've already touched on it a bunch, but as we make our way to Blood Love, I'm so fascinated by the act of kindness that you gave yourself, which was to leave this stable career in healthcare as we talked about as you were burning out. And I think it's such a twisted tough decision because you know you are helping people and I know it's probably very complicated. You left to restore an old theater, which just sounds very dreamy to me. But what did that decision look like internally for you? You know, was there clarity, fear, all of it?

[7:53] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh gosh, there's still fear, you know, and so yes, all of that. And I don't know if there's ever clarity in anything in life. You know, I don't know if I've certainly felt like I'm on the right path. So I guess in that sense I feel like it's clear, but you're learning as you're going in whatever you're doing in life. But certainly obviously doing such a major 180 from, and I've been in the field for a long time between my training and my career. So really doing such a 180 into theater and starting over and being the new one, you know, that has been very humbling. So yeah, I don't know if there's much clarity necessarily, but I do feel like I'm on the right path and I do feel like I'm making the right decisions and I'm certainly working with the right people and we're putting together some really beautiful art. So I feel very proud of that.

[8:44] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah. Well, I'm happy for you. I wonder if there's even clarity in the sense of knowing something's no longer serving you and that you have to leave. Because I think a lot of people stay in things sometimes their whole life because they're either scared of whatever it is. So what are your thoughts on that? And maybe what's your advice on taking that leap?

[9:03] Carey Renee Sharpe: It was so hard. And I'll try not to cry. But until a few years ago, I would cry anytime I would talk about this, but I think I'm okay. But I loved my career so much and I defined myself so much by it. And I felt so, I don't like, I felt like I owed it to my team and my patients to stay, you know, like I felt like I was letting them down by leaving. And so when I left, it really took a long time for me to understand like that it was okay for me to leave because I really, I felt very guilty about it. I felt very, and it took me a long time to work through that. It's been eight years now. So I can talk about this without crying. It took literally years for me to be able to do that. But I had an interesting moment.

Maybe this is a clarity moment for me. I had been out for about 18 months because I left after my son was born. And I just, I had two kids, and so he was my second, and I was like, it was just too much. Something had to give. And but then I was kind of missing it again. And I applied for an entirely new job in a different state. I was gonna just do something just a different hospital, still in pediatric ICU. And I got offered the job on like March, I'm gonna just make up this date, but it was like March 4th of 2020. When it was a Friday, and I said no, I said, let me just talk about it over the weekend with my husband, because of course we have to figure out childcare and working as a nurse practitioner, I had to work a lot of nights and weekends, you gotta make that schedule work. So I was like, you know, let me just talk about it over the weekend with my husband and I'll get back to you on Monday. And over that weekend, the world shut down.

[10:28] Carey Renee Sharpe: Wow. And I was already kind of on the fence. I was nervous about going back because I'd been out for 18 months, and I was like, gosh, can I do this anymore? Because you have to keep your skills really sharp. And I actually had a friend from my old hospital that was working at this hospital, and she's like, You'll be great, you know, don't worry about it, we'll help you. And I was like, I think this is the universe telling me that I need, I just, I made the right decision by leaving, and I do not, I should not go back. So obviously that was such a global event. And yeah, but for me, in this weird way, it was like kind of telling me like, you're done. You just, you left this reason and you, and so I had to find another path.

I didn't have, I kind of was lost at this point. So and then through the pandemic, that's when I started writing music with my co-writer Drew, and there was a couple of us at the time, but now it's mainly Drew and I. So it just, I weirdly would have never expected it. I found myself in art because I just needed the therapy of it. I needed something to feed my own soul. And now six years later, here we are.

[11:21] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah. Did not start out thinking we're gonna do an Off-Broadway show. That was really not what we started, you know, off with the intention of, but it's just evolved that.

[11:28] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, same with this podcast started during the pandemic, and I didn't know I'd still be here almost two hundred episodes in, which is crazy. So it is, it's nice when it comes from feeding yourself, like you're saying, or nourishing yourself.

[11:35] Carey Renee Sharpe: Feeding yourself.

[11:44] Robert Peterpaul: Although I know it can be hard for you to feed one of your kids from the research I've heard. He's a bit of a picky eater, which I formerly was that too, and now I'm not. So it does, I used to make my parents wipe the sauce off of pasta before I ate it, apparently.

[11:58] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, I have, yes, my kids will do that. They'll be like, What is, you know, what is this?

[12:02] Robert Peterpaul: You've done all kinds of crazy things if you're a parent.

[12:04] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh my gosh.

[12:05] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, I'm sure. Well, I'll find out soon. We just found out we're expecting our first baby in the fall.

[12:11] Carey Renee Sharpe: That's so wonderful. Well, I'm a secret, but congratulations.

[12:15] Robert Peterpaul: It's such a wonderful time.

[12:17] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh yeah.

[12:18] Robert Peterpaul: I appreciate that. Well, I'm glad you decided to make a change because imagine being on the fence and hanging in and then being a nurse during COVID. I mean, or anybody working during COVID.

[12:30] Carey Renee Sharpe: I mean, but that did also add to my guilt. I felt very, and I did, you know, even though I turned down that job, I contemplated going back to my old job and just, I actually did try, that's funny that you say that. I did try to go back, not to the PICU though. I didn't want to go back to the PICU because that was where I'd really burned out. I wanted to go back to the NICU because when I was a bedside nurse, that's what I'd started in. The NICU is the babies, you know, the really little ones. And I just wanted to be a nurse. I didn't want to, I'm not a nurse practitioner, so I couldn't work as a nurse practitioner in that specialty area. And they would not, I couldn't, they wouldn't hire me because like they won't let you work below your license. And I was, I did, I wanted to, I tried a couple times to just be a bedside nurse, and they won't let me.

[13:09] Carey Renee Sharpe: Okay. I wish I could just still do that because I did love that too.

[13:14] Robert Peterpaul: I love another thing about the universe kind of pointing you in the right direction.

[13:19] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, it pointed you toward something before Blood Love. You put a lot of blood and love into restoring a theater. And I just need to ask you about this because again, it does sound very dreamy to me. I know it was a ton of work. Can you just share a bit about that time? Restoring a theater in your community.

[13:34] Carey Renee Sharpe: Do not recommend. That's all that I'll say. No, it was a labor of love for sure. So we really did it as like a philanthropic project for our community. We just, it's in my hometown. We love our hometown, and there was this beautiful old building that was just really dilapidated.

[13:49] Carey Renee Sharpe: We picked it up for a song and then frankly put, you know, poured some money into it to really revive it. We wanted to save this beautiful old building. We didn't really have any personal tie to it, just it was beloved in the community. And um, so we did that and we went through, we did it well, obviously worked with a contractor. Actually, the contractor is a family friend, but his grandfather built the original building, which was so cool. So he had the original photos and renderings, and like it was really, really a special project for him too. And during that process, we got it listed on the national and uh state historic register, which is a whole process.

[14:23] Robert Peterpaul: Wow.

[14:23] Carey Renee Sharpe: You're like, if we're gonna do this, we want it to be saved. So when you do that, it basically forces anybody that ever owns the building in the future to like preserve it. They can't like tear it down, they have to like maintain some standards of like historic whatever relevance of the building. So um, so we did that too. So all it was, we learned a lot. I've never, I I've actually now done several historic renovations, but that was my first. And it's really, you learn a lot. And it's, they're always hard. And there's always so many things that you do not expect to pop up that you have to fix and you know, whatever. The buildings are sure. I love old buildings, but whoa, they're a lot of work.

[14:56] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, no, a lot of a lot of parallels with the theater, right? Because things popping up left and right during that process and then unveiling the buildings kind of like the opening night, I guess. And it's sort of storytelling too, as you said, learning about the building, the story, how to preserve that. And there's a lot of that in New York. And now you're in New York, like we said, you've been developing Blood Love for six years, I believe. And first of all, it can just be so hard in this business, especially to hold on to a dream. And I wonder what sort of allowed you to be committed to this project and this story for so long. What what's kept you from giving up, I guess, in the hard times?

[15:31] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, I mean, partially it is because the show is really, it is deeply personal to me. And um part of the reason why I didn't pursue it, I didn't really have any desire to like perform as Carrie or to like audition for other people's shows. You know, I've get asked all the time, like, what's your dream role? I'm like, honestly, I love a lot of musical theater, but I don't ever dream of playing any of those parts. If I had to pick one, honestly, it'd be Jesus in Jesus Christ Superstar, but they're not casting females in that very often. So, anyways, you know, I just I don't I don't think that way, and it's just not not what it was called to do. But so doing the show has allowed me to create this character, Valerie, and she really is kind of my alter ego in a lot of ways.

And I get to step into her and perform these songs that are like written about things in my personal life, a lot of them, and it like she's kind of like my Lady Gaga. I get to like personify her and be vulnerable in that way. Whereas I just don't really do that as myself and I don't really want to. I feel that it's like the Hannah Montana situation.

[16:30] Robert Peterpaul: Totally.

[16:28] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah. You get the best of both worlds. Well, now you're in the Mecca. I mean, the most iconic theater world, you know. I mean, obviously, we love the West End, but there's nothing like Broadway in New York for theater. How does it feel to I know you had to sort of tweak it a bit and change it a bit to be serving the theater because it's gone through a lot of iterations, but yeah, and it's not done yet. It's still not, you know, it's really great. It is spectacular, but it's not done yet, it's not perfect. We know things already after doing it for several weeks that we want to change, and it's just a living, breathing, growing thing still. But um, yeah, it's always evolving.

[17:03] Robert Peterpaul: What do you look for in those changes? Is it sort of a mix of audience feedback? What you're realizing as the show comes to fruition?

[17:10] Carey Renee Sharpe: So I am still relatively new to this. I acknowledge that. I spent a lot of years in my youth studying music. I was a musician, you know, I formally trained for 15 years, I just did a long break. So I took, you know, almost a 20-year break. Uh, then I got back to it. And I've been studying, you know, with a teacher and stuff now again for the last couple years, but I, you know, I I'm still relatively new to this world, and so I know I have a lot of growing to do, and so there's a risk in coming to New York, um, because you're opening yourself up to the eyes of the biggest theater town in the world, right? I mean, this is but at the same time, I knew that this was how we were gonna grow the show and how I was gonna push myself to grow along with it.

And that has been an extraordinarily humbling experience. It's been hard in a lot of ways. Um yeah, I've worked, I've worked really hard and I had I did not have an easy career. I do not shy away from difficult things, and this has been a challenge big time for sure. It's very rewarding in a lot of ways, but it's you know, it is it's been very hard at times.

[18:11] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah. And I mean, you're saying that as someone that was a nurse, and I know two very separate things, but at the same time, it's like Laurie Hernandez is on Broadway now, you know, an Olympian, and she's like, This is harder than the Olympics. Broadway performers are Olympians. And I only do six shows a week, and I never, you know, I don't know what the future holds for the show or for myself in the show, but I knew even going into this that I didn't want to do eight shows a week. I didn't want to commit to that, and I just I knew six was and I now after doing it, I don't think I'd ever want to do more than six shows a week. That's plenty.

[18:41] Carey Renee Sharpe: I know, and the joke is that there are so many wonderful, talented, magical humans out there who want to do this, and yet I don't know, we haven't figured out a way to maybe make it more sustainable where there's a bigger cast that swaps in and out. I don't know, but I think you know some shows do do this where the principal cast will have, or certainly like the leads will have like a uh c alternate scheduled performances.

[19:01] Robert Peterpaul: Yes, like once a week.

[19:02] Carey Renee Sharpe: I think Nicole Scherzinger was doing that in Oh, yeah. I think she was only doing it. You have to be like a celebrity or something, and it's like, why can't we make this a bit more sustainable for families? I certainly believe in that model, and I think, you know, we've had a really supportive culture for all of our sta all of our casts that if they need to swing out for any reason, we're like, yeah, like call out. You know, it's like take care of yourself. And also we've got such an amazing so swing and understudy casts. It's like they're happy to go on and they're all amazing. And so we've really fostered like this more healthy, it's not competitive. It's just like everybody's cheering on everybody. And it's, you know, we so we've really embraced that. But I I don't know why more shows don't do that.

[19:39] Robert Peterpaul: They should.

[19:40] Carey Renee Sharpe: They really should. We love our swings and our understudies. They're incredible. And they frankly deserve to get a chance to perform these parts because they're working really hard too. And sometimes that with them stepping in is harder because they they haven't gotten the reps in that we have. So it's like scary to do a part they've only done a couple times. So anyways, we like to like encourage that in a healthy way.

[20:00] Robert Peterpaul: No, well said. I mean, swinging, the hardest thing I've ever done in the in the theater, I'll say. And then you gotta the first time you do it, you're doing it on the stage. It's it's wild. And I just think we should let them do it, you know, let them kind of have their moment. Well, this leads really well into my next question, which was creating something from scratch, especially that's very personal, is so vulnerable. And I wonder what does kindness look like for you in sort of the rehearsal process, uh, especially as the leader. Like we've just touched on a beautiful tangible thing that you all have done to treat people with kindness. But is that something you thought about throughout the process? Tell me everything.

[20:38] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, you know, I sort of I I recognize that I am certainly one of the leaders of this production, you know, there's a couple of us that are kind of at the helm, but I certainly want to those. And I think for me, leading with kindness means leading with vulnerability and authenticity and also doing my best. It's impossible, but doing your best to put your ego away and like just not leading with that fear that comes along with your ego, you know. And so to me, I think it's just, yeah, it's like just showing up authentically. Sometimes I'm not my best self. There is, I remember there's a day during tech that I walked in and I was like, you guys, I am so crabby. I'm sorry. I'm tired. I'm crabby.

I and I almost like make a joke out of it. I'm like, I know I'm just not my best today. And I'm telling you now, I'm sorry. And you know, people just laugh and it's it's fine because we've already created, especially in our cast and crew now, it's like we've created such a culture of love and respect that of course you're allowed to have a bad day and like be tired and crabby and just like not be 100% because we're all humans, of course. So I think that's kind of how I try to lead in general, is just like by being a real person first.

[21:40] Robert Peterpaul: I love that.

[21:41] Carey Renee Sharpe: And the people that say that and acknowledge that and are aware of that usually are still a joy to be around and are just kind of like maybe crabby, but in their own head a little. And I'm sure no one even noticed. It's usually the people that say that that it's still fun to be around them. So I think that's fun.

[21:55] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah. I mean, I I'm have a good sense of humor, so I'm kind of funny about it. But you know, I'm just like, I just know I'm not my best today. I'm so sorry.

[22:01] Carey Renee Sharpe: I know. It's it's tough because it is, it's a business, but it's also so personal and it's such a mix all the time, even though we pretend sometimes it's not.

[22:08] Robert Peterpaul: Yes. And especially as a songwriter, since I have you on here, do you have advice for other performers who break down songs for auditions and projects as a writer yourself? I just wonder your thoughts on how someone can approach a song and and tell the story.

[22:23] Carey Renee Sharpe: I mean, of course I've written these songs, but they're not all like about me. I mean, some of them are like there's one that's about like a fashion show. So it's it doesn't have anything to do with me. But um certainly as a writer, and you hear this all the time, like I just write from what I know. But what I what it really is means for me is I I just try to pull from real emotions. And like I'm just how I write songs is certainly in that realm, is like just trying to like actually put my emotions on the page. And so I think when you're selecting songs for anything, and even like just you have to find something that like emotionally resonates with you more than anything else because that's how you can tell a story and that's how you can connect with it.

We don't connect with letters on a page, we connect with our feelings and our heart. So you've got to find like a way to do that with music. And of course, there's millions of songs out there that I connect with emotionally that I didn't write. So you just I think you gotta find and they can be fun, they can evoke all kinds of emotions, but I tend to be like liking the more angsty songs. I that's just my personality and my character. But um, yeah, I think that's like the best way to find music, just like something that really resonates with your heart.

[23:25] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, I love that. I mean, certainly with your show. And then of course, so incredible the timing. We have another vampire show on Broadway right now, The Lost Boys, which is very different than ours. We saw it, it's so fun, but it's just so different.

[23:34] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, it's totally different than ours.

[23:38] Robert Peterpaul: So yeah, it's so good. You know, it it's what you said is so true. It's like if you're not grounding all of that in something honest and real and feeling it, it's just gonna maybe be cheesy. You know what I mean? It's not, it's not gonna land. And so I do want to acknowledge, I mean, you have a lot to ground this in as we talked about your story a bit. We we've mentioned that you're raising two kiddos at the same time.

[24:03] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah.

[24:04] Robert Peterpaul: And I just wonder, even if someone out there listening doesn't have kids, it's so hard to strike the personal and professional balance. And I know no one has the answer, but what have you found during this process as you're now in a in a big groove and kind of reaching the end?

[24:19] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, well, in full transparency, my kids are not here. And the the reason that I'm able to do a lot of this is that my husband is amazing and he has just like taken on he's all I don't want to say allowed me, but he has not like he gave me permission, but he's um allowing me to do this by taking on the all the parenting basically for the last five months. So I can be free to do this and have really dedicate all my time and energy. Now the kids come out and visit, and I they but they're not with me full time right now, which yeah, yeah, is tough. You know, it's it's been hard. But I my daughter is my older one and she's 10. So she's old enough now that she will fly by her like an accom unaccompanied minor, like she can fly by yourself basically.

And so I had to drop her off at the airport a couple weeks ago to send her back. And I just cried so hard. I was like, my baby, she was fine. I was just like So and that's the other thing are fine. They're fine. The night before I was leaving to come out here, and I was, you know, I'm gone basically for five months, and I was just, you know, snuggling with my daughter at bedtime and saying, like, you know, are you sad that I'm leaving tomorrow? And she's like, Yeah, I'm really gonna miss you. But she's like, But you have to do this, and I'm really proud of you.

[25:28] Robert Peterpaul: Oh I know you raised them right.

[25:31] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, I know that she's proud of me. And I know that I'm I'm showing them the example of like chasing your passion and working really hard to achieve something. And I'm I I'm you know, you I'm modeling that and I I feel good about that at least.

[25:43] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, no, I was that's what I was actually gonna say. I think it's so important, especially in our industry where it's like, I mean, there's a lot of history wrapped up in it, especially with female identifying people. It's like at a certain age you play certain roles or whatever it is, and I just think if we can all find ways to be more forgiving and you don't have to be a kid to be a dreamer. I think your your dreams don't have to stop at a certain age, and you're such a great example of that because you made this huge pivot and you've had such success. And even if you're seeing this as a tryout to rework the show, I mean it's New York City on Broadway and people are loving it. And so it's just such an incredible thing for your kids to see. And yeah, I'm grateful that that we have you to look up to in that regard.

[26:23] Carey Renee Sharpe: There's not a ton, I mean, obviously there's some, but there's not like a ton of moms in theater at this. So, you know, I'm 42, so I'm also a little bit older.

[26:31] Robert Peterpaul: And okay, vampired, never aging.

[26:34] Carey Renee Sharpe: It's really hard to balance, you know, because it's hard to do that. So I know it's kind of there's a couple moms on our production, which it's been nice to have this is the first time I've ever worked with any other moms in this world. And actually, my standby Elizabeth Davis, who's wonderful and she's really been a mentor to me in a lot of ways, she also has two kids. So it's been really nice to like connect with somebody that's also playing my part. And like under like, how do you do this? And I think the answer is just like barely. Sometimes you're just hanging out by a thread, and that's okay too. You know, it's just like it's okay.

[27:02] Robert Peterpaul: You know what? That's true.

[27:03] Carey Renee Sharpe: But also nurses, moms, you know, and dads too, will say, you're all used to doing so much at once while also raising kids that I just think that while this is a crazy process to enter, you can juggle a lot a lot more. Like my wife was a teacher, and then she taught during the pandemic, and then she got a I call it a muggle job. But she's like, you know, I'll just work until five, and I I feel like I'm not doing enough. And I'm like, that's because you're used to having 90 kids screaming at you at once while you did 80 other things. You know what I mean?

[27:31] Carey Renee Sharpe: So I think there's something to be said for, I don't know, moms getting the job done, is what I gotta say. I mean, even on TV, a lot of these powerful female producers and directors, I forget who it was. They're like, we're gonna wrap by six because I want to eat dinner with my family. And it's like, why can't that be the norm? I don't know. It's that's kindness to me. It's handy, but you know, I think there's a lot to be said about women as leaders in general, but I think even particularly as moms, like just I think there's something that mothers bring to leadership that is just unique.

[28:05] Robert Peterpaul: Hmm. I agree. Retweet. Well, the theater schedule's no joke, as we've touched on. Yeah, I do wonder, because we've talked about it a bit, we sort of circled around it, and this tends to be a hard question for people. It's a pretty simple one. But how are you kind to yourself, Carey? What does that look like during this time?

[28:23] Carey Renee Sharpe: I've got a great support system. I will say. I sometimes I pull from some of the love around me that is in my team. I just, you know, it's so hard to be forgiving of yourself because of course everybody's their own worst critic, and I'm particularly bad at that. Yeah, I just try to know tell myself I'm working really hard and I'm giving it my all. And I just remind myself of that when things aren't going perfect or I have a less than a hundred percent performance, because again, we're all human. And then I also get a weekly massage.

[28:56] Robert Peterpaul: So that's it.

[28:57] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, there you go. That's tangible. I like that.

[28:58] Robert Peterpaul: Yes.

[28:59] Carey Renee Sharpe: I'm just not like I'm like, I told my husband like, I'm sorry, I'm getting one. Like, you get a weekly massage. Like, because you know, usually that's a splurgy thing, but I'm just like to do this. Like my body is not gonna last if I don't get a massage every week. So no, I mean, especially I also love Pilates. It's a really like, you know, it's such a good workout for I don't know, women my age. I think it's just yeah, I love it.

[29:20] Robert Peterpaul: That's beautiful. I have a funny story about my mom made me go to Pilates with her in high school. That was wild. I started cracking, I always cry laughing because the instructor like was talking to us and being like, How's your day? But her legs were over her head and was she was like an orangutan, and I had to physically remove myself because I'm just a giggler.

[29:36] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, it's weird if you haven't done it before to get used to the reformer and yeah, I'm sure we look ridiculous, but it's a good one.

[29:41] Robert Peterpaul: No, but like you're killing it, and it's so good for your body. And I mean, the show itself, I think that's the tough part is like you gotta take care of your body, but then your show is also such a workout. And I do we always joke, I am not a dancer and I don't, so I don't dance. Oh my gosh. I don't even like really move all that one. It's just not my character. But I will say I was noticing the other day, I was like changing and I was like, I have abs. I've never had abs. I am like in the best shape of my life between you know, just doing Pilates a couple times a week and just doing the show and walking around this city. I'm like, dang, this has like been really apparently it's even more of a workout than I'm realizing because I'm like really fit right now.

[30:17] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, yeah. Sometimes the backstage is I mean, it's a whole other show running around the costume changes and all that. And then don't you find you're also just you're never more hydrated than when you're in a show because you're aware of drinking water right now.

[30:29] Robert Peterpaul: Two I always have two beverages with me at all times.

[30:32] Carey Renee Sharpe: What was the second one? Was that a seltzer? Was that a diet wild cherry Pepsi?

[30:35] Robert Peterpaul: I have a addiction to diet wild cherry Pepsi. It's in my dressing room at all times.

[30:40] Carey Renee Sharpe: That's okay. Apparently, Pepsi's better than Coke. And I tend to have well, a lot of us, you know, have terrible postures. So my friend, who's a dear friend, is always like coming up to me. Well, now I think I'm better, but he would just in rehearsal just come up to me and just like poke me and be like, Get your show.

[30:55] Robert Peterpaul: That's helpful.

[30:56] Carey Renee Sharpe: But for my body, I guess it's just you know, tired.

[30:59] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah. Well, looking at the choreographer, all these folks. I mean, what's been special about the way you've been able to collaborate on this? Because I know you've had a lot more people come on board for the off-Broadway production. So, how has it been adding the new flavors? And yeah, what's come to mind there?

[31:15] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah. Well, Drew and I have been working on this since day one together, obviously. And then Jonathan and Aksana, our choreographers, came on, they worked on the first production with us. So in that, you know, within the first year, they were already involved. So the four of us are really good friends. And so that's really nice to just like have my core creators, and we're all in the show. Drew's in the band, Jonathan Oksana are dancing in the ensemble, and then you know, I'm playing the lead. So we're all like literally have each other's back on stage. So that's just always fun. I love that. And I don't think I don't really want to do the show without them. I just I you know, I like that. But so then, of course, yeah, you gotta bring all these new people into the mix.

And I think frankly, since we already had like such a good, like core group, and there's a couple other people that have been working on the project for a couple years that are really strong. It was like easier to bring people into that because we already like have a really solid core group of us. My executive producer's been on it for a while, a creative producer that's been on it since LA. So it's like we then brought people in and it's like pretty seamless, actually. I mean, you know, it's stressful and there's little blips and things that annoy you about people, it's not like it's perfect, but like pretty great, honestly, considering you're just like putting all these people together and like hoping it works, kind of, you know.

[32:23] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, I love that so much. Well, in looking at the shows on stage because the show is good. Oh yeah. And you I've heard this from people that have no relation to the show, just have come to see it and then talk to me after the show. And they're just like, you can really tell that people that everybody's having fun out there and that they really love each other. And I'm just like, it's true, but like I think it resonates in the audience that like because we've put this group together and it's just like some sort of magic is happening.

[32:45] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, I love that. Yeah, well, the tricky thing about that, because I've it's so rare when you get that on shows, is that you can also be prone, like I've mentioned, to maybe the giggles or a little mishap. And I wonder if you could regale us with any sort of fun mishap stories on the off-Broadway. If they've happened, maybe it hasn't.

[33:02] Carey Renee Sharpe: I don't think it's ever been anything that has oh no, I did break one night pretty bad. Cause I that's my favorite. There's a number that humans are boring is a great number, but um Brooke and who are her understudies, they sing on or they dance on the table. And so the first time they there's three of them that have done it, and the first time each of one of them has done it, I'm just like, oh my god, please don't fall off the table. You know, it's just like they gotta do it at least once for me to be like, all right, they're probably not gonna fall off the table. It just it just it's slightly terrifying. I'm sitting there, and I have to like be still, just like watching her. And um, so Naya went on a couple nights and so I for the first time, and so I had to have that experience, and I was so worried she's gonna fall off the table that after she got done, I was so relieved I forgot my line. So I just and I just totally was like, Oh my, I just totally broke. It was whatever. It was so funny.

[33:56] Robert Peterpaul: Well, that's very kind that you're my whole brain was focused on like hoping she didn't fall off the table. Well, she didn't, she's fine. But yeah, you had a mishap because you were thinking of someone else.

[34:03] Carey Renee Sharpe: I mean, it was just like worried about her. So, anyway.

[34:06] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, I would love if we could quickly play a surprise game. It's called the compliment game.

[34:09] Carey Renee Sharpe: Okay.

[34:11] Robert Peterpaul: And basically, I reached out to someone in your life, Carey, for a loving statement, something they admire about you. I'm gonna read it to you, and then you have to try and guess who's.

[34:18] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh my god, this will make me cry.

[34:23] Robert Peterpaul: Okay. It's just sweet, it's a really sweet one. You can ask me yes or no questions. I don't know much, but this one's pretty specific, so I think you'll get it.

[34:31] Carey Renee Sharpe: Okay.

[34:32] Robert Peterpaul: Everyone's beautiful in their own way. It's the compliment game on the compliment.

[34:37] Carey Renee Sharpe: Compliment, yay.

[34:43] Robert Peterpaul: Okay, here we go. A wise woman once said to us, art is a form of rebellion. We will always hold this dear to our hearts. This same woman has also shown how powerful someone can be with such kindness, creativity, and loyalty, and what you can achieve by pushing the boundaries. Carrie is a rare gem who not only brings a team together, but creates a family. Hence blood love.

[35:13] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, yeah.

[35:14] Robert Peterpaul: Dot dot dot. Oh, this part's a hint. So I'm gonna leave this out.

[35:17] Carey Renee Sharpe: Okay.

[35:18] Robert Peterpaul: Oh my gosh.

[35:20] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh really sweet.

[35:22] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, I needed that today.

[35:25] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, I'm glad. Well, I I don't know.

[35:26] Robert Peterpaul: Oh.

[35:26] Carey Renee Sharpe: I don't know.

[35:31] Robert Peterpaul: Is it like our director or something?

[35:33] Carey Renee Sharpe: I mean, I have such a beautiful relationship with so many people that no, well, I'm glad.

[35:37] Robert Peterpaul: I can tell.

[35:38] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, okay, I'll I'll read you the hint.

[35:40] Robert Peterpaul: Okay.

[35:40] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh yeah, dot dot dot. And we love our dressing room tea time. Hashtag twinning.

[35:44] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, oh, is it oh, is it Jonathan?

[35:50] Carey Renee Sharpe: I guess it well, I didn't even realize there were two here.

[35:54] Robert Peterpaul: It is Jonathan.

[35:55] Carey Renee Sharpe: Okay.

[35:55] Robert Peterpaul: And Jonathan and Oksana.

[35:57] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah.

[35:58] Robert Peterpaul: Well, they're, yeah, they're a couple, yes.

[36:00] Carey Renee Sharpe: There you go.

[36:01] Robert Peterpaul: So you got it. Ding ding ding.

[36:04] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah. Sounds so lovely. And they're really dear friends. So yeah.

[36:08] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, I'm glad that we could share that today. And that came in literally just in time, not to quote a different show. But I'm curious, can you expand a bit on how art is a rebellion to you?

[36:20] Carey Renee Sharpe: I agree with you, but I'm curious about your sentiments there. You know, right now the world is a heavy place. It is filled with so much darkness and so much pain that is real. So showing up and making beauty and spreading love in itself is a rebellion. And I refuse to sit home and be angry and scared. I just won't do it. And so, you know, and sometimes you kind of get criticized for that, right? Like we're supposed to all just be angry and like just be so hyper-focused on all the evil in the world. And I can't do that. I don't want to do that. I don't want to live my life like that. And I'm not clueless to the world around me, of course. None of us are. But I just I refuse to let it take all of our light away, you know, and take the love away that is real.

And I think if you start with that and you start with the people in your life and like in your community and just like in the small circle that we all affect. And if you can just fill that with all the love and light that you have to bring, if we all did that, like the world would be such a different place. Sitting home being angry is not helping anybody. So showing up and doing this show that is kind of silly and whimsical and it makes no political statement. It's really just supposed to be about love and friendship and you know, finding yourself. That in itself just like I think that is a rebellion because it's not it's just taking a stance to just be an artist and and not have to focus on the evil all the time.

[37:51] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, well said. I appreciate that. As someone who hosts the kindness podcast, you know, I'm like, you can rebel in a positive way too.

[38:03] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yes, or at least have the positive agreement. Even I do think kindness is very complicated. So it doesn't mean you're showing up with puppies and kittens and rainbows, but it does mean that you're on that like same positive wavelength, and there is science behind it being contagious. So, like you said, it literally does spread from person to person. And if we all did that, you know, the world would be a much better place.

[38:24] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, spreading the light, which is ironic for a vampire show because they don't love the light, you know. That's what Valerie was always seeking in the show. She's seeking the light, and that means a lot of different things, but you know, she's seeking light.

[38:35] Robert Peterpaul: It's love and just you know, all the good in the world. And have you noticed too with vampires specifically and this type of story that the fan base and audiences are just it it's more community creating in a weird way. I don't know if that's because vampire stories are typically about being othered and and that sort of subliminal messaging and finding your family and choosing them. But have you found that with this show?

[38:57] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah, I mean, certainly our team really does feel like a family. We're all super close. I mean, we we only have two weeks left and we're we just keep joking, we're like, oh my god, whoever comes to that closing night show is just we're just gonna all be crying the whole time. It's gonna be messy.

[39:14] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.

[39:15] Carey Renee Sharpe: So yeah, I mean, I don't I don't know if it's like specific to like the subject matter, but we certainly have felt that in our group for sure.

[39:24] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, I love that. Well, I have loved getting to talk with you, and I would just appreciate if you could share as we close out our time together, a tangible kindness tip. So you've certainly shared a lot of them, but something specific you think everybody can do on their own corner to try and create the change we were talking about.

[39:42] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, I'm from Wisconsin, so we're very Midwest nice, right? Yeah. So I just this is it's a little thing, but I just like go out of my way to just compliment people on things all the time because it costs me nothing, you know, and it really can make a big big deal to somebody's. I just I really try to like hype people up, you know, like just and and specifically, not you know, just like whatever specific thing about them I think is wonderful and lovely that day. I just try to make sure that they they I actually share it with them. And ever we can all do that. It costs us nothing to like just actually tell people what why we think they're wonderful.

[40:17] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, I love that so much. Well, as you know, I love compliments, and I think it's something you can do. Just look up from your phone, even at the grocery store checkout and I've telling random strangers that I like their shoes. I mean, I just all have to know. It's very vulnerable, right? I think as artists and musicians, maybe it's a little bit easier, but for people that aren't in these, I guess, circles or communities, it can be so hard, even just to say hi to somebody walking by, you know? So it's an important reminder to strive at least for that. And I'm so grateful that we have had you off Broadway. I can't wait to see what comes next. Congratulations. And thank you again just for being such a shining example of so many wonderful things that we need in this world.

[40:57] Carey Renee Sharpe: Yeah. It's been really nice talking with you. This has been a really nice um.

[41:02] Robert Peterpaul: I'm glad. Until next time, remember, everything is gonna be okay.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred