Another Day of Podcasting with Musicals with Cheese! This week Jess & Andrew are joined by a special guest: Brent Black aka Brentalfloss to cover Damien Chazelle's Modern Musical Movie "La La Land" The Trio discuss the tonal inconsistencies of the film, the lack of chemistry between the leads, the shortfalls of the musical storytelling, and the altogether successes and failures present in the film... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
About
Another Day of Podcasting with Musicals with Cheese! This week Jess & Andrew are joined by a special guest: Brent Black aka Brentalfloss to cover Damien Chazelle's Modern Musical Movie "La La Land"
The Trio discuss the tonal inconsistencies of the film, the lack of chemistry between the leads, the shortfalls of the musical storytelling, and the altogether successes and failures present in the film.
Links:
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Buy Brent's game "USE YOUR WORDS"
Brent's Star Trek Musical Page
Musicals Theatre Lives on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jess: Hi guys, it's Jess and Andrew, and we're just giving you a little warning before the show starts. I'm gonna be swearing quite a bit. Uh, if you got kids or anything like that, maybe don't let them listen to me. I'm a bad influence.
[0:12] Andrew: Yeah, if you're driving around the car or something, just maybe throw on some headphones or maybe save this episode for another time. Thank you. Enjoy the show, fellas. Let's get to it.
[0:25] Jess: Hello, I'm Jess.
[0:28] Andrew: And I'm Andrew.
[0:29] Jess: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater. And today we've got a special guest.
[0:34] Andrew: His name is Brent Black, aka Brental Floss. Say hi, Brent.
[0:40] Brent Black: Hi, hello.
[0:42] Jess: How you doing?
[0:43] Brent Black: Great.
[0:43] Jess: We're so honored that you're schlepping down to our level and joining us today.
[0:48] Brent Black: Schlepping, I've never heard that phrase, schlepping down to your level.
[0:52] Brent Black: I liked your show. I as uh well, I wasn't sure if we were gonna talk about this, but I literally invited myself on because I like complaining about musical theater, so thank you for having me.
[1:04] Andrew: That's right. We didn't actually beg him for this one.
[1:06] Jess: No, no. It is an honor. It is an honor to have you on.
[1:09] Brent Black: It really is.
[1:10] Jess: Well, thanks. And speaking of complaining about musical theater, Brent, do you want to tell us what we're complaining about today?
[1:18] Brent Black: Oh man, yes, I do. We are complaining, or maybe not, about the 2016 musical, air quote, musical film La La Land.
[1:32] Brent Black: I don't care if I know to swear I will go. Cause all that I need's the crazy feeling. Are you shining just for me? La La Land is a 2016 film written and directed by human computer program Damien Chazelle with music by Justin Hurwitz and lyrics by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, known for Dear Evan Hansen, The Greatest Showman, and their only good thing, Dogfight.
[2:14] Brent Black: The film received many accolades, including stealing best original song from Lin-Manuel Miranda, Best Director, and briefly Best Picture.
[2:21] Jess: Keyword unbriefly. So what is our all-together relationships with La La Land? It has been out for about a little over almost two years now, so we all are allowed to have like an opinion on it.
[2:37] Andrew: I just watched it today.
[2:40] Jess: For the first time.
[2:42] Andrew: So that's my relationship with it. Brent, you had a very specific interaction with it very early on.
[2:49] Brent Black: Yes, I was coming back. I don't know if you guys ever do conventions like nerd conventions, but you know, at the end of it, you can be very cranky, and I think I saw it when I was coming back from Norway. So, like there was a jet lag thing, I was exhausted, I was cranky, and I decided to watch it on a plane, and immediately started taking copious notes of why I hated it, and I couldn't make it past the 45-minute mark.
[3:17] Brent Black: In the time since I have watched it twice, and like my opinion has improved only as much as the fact that I got a little bit of sleep and wasn't quite as cranky, but I still do not like it.
[3:29] Jess: Whereas I saw it the day it came out, just cause I'm a musical theater guy, and any time musical theater content is released ever, I just go and force myself to see it, good or bad, no matter what. It's just the world I'm in.
[3:42] Andrew: And I was meh on it then and have only gotten negative since, but still pretty meh. Andrew, what is your overall opinion, just straight up so we can keep on going from this.
[3:53] Andrew: Oh, what's my opinion on it?
[3:55] Jess: Yeah.
[3:55] Andrew: Um well, having just watched it today, I actually have a pretty positive opinion. I thought it was pretty good. And this is why it's interesting we all have the full gamut of thoughts on this. Brent with an extreme negative, Andrew with an extreme positive, and me dead center.
[4:12] Jess: I don't know if I'd go extreme positive, but you're leaning positive.
[4:18] Andrew: Yes.
[4:18] Jess: And I'm just not even sure that Brent is extreme negative, but he definitely leans negative.
[4:24] Brent Black: Well, uh the thing is there are things that I and I'll enumerate them later, that I really appreciate about this movie. But as a musical theater writer and a musical theater lover, it has serious unforgivable flaws. That's where I'm standing.
[4:38] Andrew: It kind of is the same way for me, except the flaws don't completely diminish the whole. Because um, I think Brent and I are very reversed on it, where he went to school for musical theater, um basically uh Tisch, right?
[4:53] Brent Black: Yeah, actually, specifically musical theater writing, which is very weird. It's basically Hogwarts.
[5:00] Jess: Um, but uh yeah, so I'm coming at it very much from like a structural how to write a musical perspective.
[5:08] Brent Black: And I'm coming in it as filmmaking, and a lot of my issues are strictly in the film content, because that's where I went to school and that's where I got my degrees and where I spent most of my years studying.
[5:18] Jess: So Brent and I are probably gonna have mixed smash opinions just based on that.
[5:24] Andrew: Great. I don't have experience in anything. I'm just watching it because Jess told me to.
[5:29] Jess: I mean. Alright, the basic plot of La La Land surrounds Mia, an actress trying to make it in LA, and Sebastian, a jazz performer, and both of them idealize a bygone age, much like the film itself. They follow the average Hollywood romantic comedy structure. They meet each other, don't like each other, love each other, break up at the end of the second act, but then this does something different where they don't get back together.
[5:52] Brent Black: Wow, such amazement. Jason Robert Brown called, and he's filing a class action lawsuit. Alright, so do you guys want to go right into the songs and just talk about them one by one, track by track?
[6:04] Jess: Because in doing so, we're kind of covering the story.
[6:07] Andrew: Sure.
[6:23] Brent Black: I lived in Madame Greyhouse Station west of Santa Fe. We were 17 buckings, sweet and it was true. Still I knew what I had to do. So the first song, Another Day of Sun, Brent. What is your thoughts on that?
[6:39] Brent Black: It is an opening number as well as an introduction to this film. So the first thing is you see this old-timey cinemascope logo. As if to say this movie is going to be like or remind you of classic films. Nobody made them put that. Nobody forced them, but it's there.
[7:03] Brent Black: And okay, so immediately, you know, nice shot of cars, whatever. But it's unclear why anyone begins dancing. I can understand why the first woman that sings, like she's kind of daydreaming or flashback and she's remembering a thing. Okay, the emotional content of that might make her sing, but I don't understand why if she and everybody else are bored and impatient and annoyed in traffic, completely stopped on the highway. Where is the emotion or intention coming from to dance?
[7:37] Brent Black: First woman, why? Second guy, double why. He like looks at her from his car like, what the hell is she doing? And then he's suddenly like, oh, wait, no, I'm in this credit card commercial too. It makes no sense. Um it's a it's emotion for the city. It's emotion for like it's a juxtaposition, is how I kind of interpret it as like, yeah, this is the worst part of LA at its worst, me hitting LA at its best, kind of.
[8:03] Brent Black: I can I can I can imagine a movie that would set that idea up a little more clearly. And so, like, I'm coming at this from an angle of how things have been written before. And that can be very limiting because that is more like history than where things are going. But to me, songs grow out of either intention or emotion. There's no emotion going on in this moment that makes them want to be joyful, and there's no intention unless they're telling us a thing. By the way, they are people that we'll never meet again if we see for this music video, and then they're gone.
[8:41] Brent Black: Um, but also in terms of like how you make a musical, the opening number kind of sets up the rules of your universe. And if I'm not mistaken, this is the only song in the show where people go against their current emotional state um entirely. And sing a song that's not metaphorical, it seems to be like what they're literally feeling, but it is joy when they're in a non-joyable situation and they're honking and they're annoyed. It just strikes me as made by someone who doesn't know quite what to do with an opener.
[9:17] Andrew: I find that hard to disagree with. But then again, it's trying to ape off of things like tradition and location setups like that from Fiddler on the Roof and so on, and do it in a way that represents LA, which is both the negative mixed with the starry-eyed like glimmer of it all. And just it felt like it had that general idea, and then they're like, but we want the honking to be a percussive element to it.
[9:46] Brent Black: Well, LA has a lot of traffic.
[9:49] Andrew: Absolutely. And the thing is, to me, what they could have done is either make a song about LA traffic as a metaphor for the hustle of an actor, or done a song like basically taking the song they had and made it, you know, like a merry villagers kind of opener about actors at an audition or actors all over town getting to their auditions, failing in auditions. Like I just feel like the way you talk you guys talked about juxtaposition, which is the perfect word, but to me it's catch up in marshmallows. It's like, why is this lyric juxtaposed with this visual?
[10:23] Brent Black: But um, just to move on to a couple more bullet points I have. I love the fact that you're thinking of this as a musical theater from a musical theater mindset where I'm thinking of it as a film mindset where I know a hundred percent the idea of closing down the freeway and getting it in like a fake one or was the only thing going through the director's head, as opposed to like that storytelling setting up.
[10:42] Jess: Right. And the thing is that, like, I think it's beautifully shot, and it's so impressive. They got these long, long, unbroken shots um while being on either a fake or shutdown freeway. But they miss the boat on what I think, you know, the most important thing is, and of course I do. But just real quick, I gotta say, I hate everything about this goddamn freight truck full of happy musicians.
[11:10] Brent Black: It's it's like the most appalling thing about the whole song. The guy who opens the truck seems to know they're in there somehow, and consider whether to open the door, and then he does it. Uh, and the band is made of a stand-up bass, a marching bass drum, a flautist, and a man playing a pair of timpani.
[11:32] Brent Black: Um and also, it's another day of sun. These people should be dead in a hot metal truck. I just it bugs me because I don't know why they're there, and I don't know, like the rules aren't consistent about what's metaphorical and what's literal. Were they literally in there, or were they metaphorically in there? In which case, why is any of this happening without a visual indication that it's metaphorical?
[11:58] Andrew: I mean, clearly, this is where my very analytical brain comes in ruins this film. It's the diagesis. It doesn't set up the diagesis like immediately, but it seems like it follows these rules later on, especially when they're like flying or the cameras floating around people and giving this high fantasy life when also it's trying to mix with the real drama of relationship stuff, which is where I start to have issues.
[12:23] Brent Black: Um, but I feel like that's not. I mean, it feels like Moulin Rouge in guise of something a lot more grounded by guys of Children of Men.
[12:36] Andrew: You know, I never thought that I would like favorably compare the writing and structure of Moulin Rouge to anything. Like I love it, but I also think it's bad. But like, yeah, Moulin Rouge is so much better in that way than this.
[12:50] Brent Black: As someone who absolutely loves cheese and goofy shit happening, the band was awesome, and I laughed, and I thought it was hilarious.
[12:59] Andrew: Uh and I really liked it. I mean, I know that I noticed that the instruments were wrong, but I mean that's not really a big deal because it happens in movies literally all the time.
[13:09] Brent Black: Uh but I thought it was hilarious. I thought it was a funny moment. It's an unexpected moment, um, go to, but it's like so unexpected that your brain is like, what, what, why, why? Like before you're even able to laugh at it, you're asking questions.
[13:26] Andrew: Yeah, I think that's like that's a running theme for my reaction to this movie is that like I go, this thing right here would be fun to me if it were undergirded differently.
[13:39] Brent Black: Um, and you know, the thing is it is hilarious. Like the woman doing flamenco dancing. What the fuck was she doing there? Was she driving and then just went like, I'm gonna grab my fan and I'm gonna dance. This is what I was born to do.
[13:52] Andrew: Yeah, she was. I mean, that's what that's literally what happened.
[13:58] Brent Black: I mean, uh, I get really caught up in in really good music, and I thought the song was great, and that almost excuses every illogical thing happening, and it actually makes it work for me.
[14:12] Andrew: The problems that Brent have are like the opposite of my problems. My biggest problem is that our two leads aren't involved in this in any way. Because this could serve as basically an I want song because the only one that really has one is Mia, very briefly. Very, very briefly at the end of another song. But this could really set up their own view of LA, but in the way that Tevye sets up um to Anatevka and tradition, but it doesn't.
[14:37] Brent Black: I totally, totally agree. And like to me, the best opening number of all time is "Belle" from Beauty and the Beast. Not that this had to be that, but to your point, it could have easily set Mia and Sebastian up. They were both on that fucking highway. Where were they in this musical number?
[14:56] Jess: I can chime in with some director's commentary information.
[15:01] Andrew: Oh man. I should get drunk and watch that. It'll make me even angrier.
[15:06] Jess: Um Damien Chazelle is crazy talented, but he also might be a robot. And um basically they originally did one where they had a five-minute overture and then this scene, and then they got rid of the overture because the people were sick of it. Um but they originally started with panning across him and her um in their respective cars panning out and then going into song number. So they set up them being in this traffic jam and then going into the big song number.
[15:34] Brent Black: I think cutting the overture was a good idea, but like the things that match that, like the typeface of the logo of the movie at the end of the opening number is so like, it's a classic movie musical. But it's like, yeah, but you're it's like you know what that looks like, but you don't know what the mechanics of it are underneath it all. And like there's a bunch of shitty, fluffy old movie musicals, but I'm talking about like the good ones.
[16:06] Andrew: I don't know. Even the good ones, I think, are too fluffy for me. I know Andrew personally loves the fluffy, fun singing in the rains, Gene Kelly musicals of the world.
[16:16] Jess: I'm a fan. I like cheese. That's that's where the name came from. Jess is the musical, I'm the cheese.
[16:24] Brent Black: That totally makes sense. And the thing is like Gene Kelly singing the "I'm singing when he's like, I'm singing in the rain." There's a reason he's doing that that comes out of emotion, and we get into it because he's happy and we know why he's happy. And even though it's silly, we like it. Later on in the movie, there's a point at which Ryan Gosling twirls around a lamppost, and it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, what? You were just being a total dick and you were grumpy. Where is this coming from?
[16:53] Jess: Let's let's hold that for a second. But then again, we also have a scene where Gene Kelly um just says it gotta dance out of nowhere, and then we waste 10 minutes.
[17:03] Brent Black: That is fair.
[17:05] Jess: Oh yeah. Um basically, this film is nostalgic for the worst time in musical filmmaking as a storytelling art form. And it replicates the worst elements of it very well.
[17:18] Brent Black: Sure, that's a great point.
[17:20] Jess: Yeah, it it yeah, that was well said. And that's the reason why I feel this film doesn't work. But another day of sun is a symptom of that, but I don't think it is the root cause, more or less. Every every number except for one that we're about to talk about, I think is a different symptom of a horrible syndrome. None of them quite are fully representative of the problem.
[17:45] Andrew: Back to the after after the music ends, everyone's back in their car and and uh the traffic starts moving, but uh but the lady doesn't move. What is her name?
[17:54] Jess: Mia.
[17:55] Andrew: Yeah. Mia doesn't move because she's practicing her uh script or something like that, so uh Ryan Gosling just like goes around her and she flips him off. That's the first thing he does in this movie.
[18:08] Brent Black: Yeah. I mean, he's kind of a dick, though.
[18:10] Jess: Yes.
[18:11] Brent Black: You think that's intentional.
[18:13] Jess: Uh at least it seems it to me.
[18:16] Brent Black: I don't know. I really don't know because Damien Chazelle acts the same way as this guy.
[18:22] Jess: Well, he maybe he's a dick too.
[18:26] Andrew: You know, some people are just really This is like uh this could have been a sequel to Whiplash, and this is just what Miles Teller is doing now.
[18:35] Brent Black: Yeah, I mean he acts the same well, all the jazz guys act like that. Come on.
[18:40] Jess: I know plenty of jazz guys. You know who you are.
[18:43] Andrew: Oh, those jazz guys with their jazz cigarettes and their jazz attitudes.
[18:48] Brent Black: Jazz heroine, you mean the best guy.
[18:53] ♪ Musical number ♪
[19:10] ♪ Musical number ♪
[19:19] Jess: The next musical starts when uh when Mia gets out of the shower. I I find it weird because she turns off the water and she already has the towel around her. Like she was there are so many weird things about this scene in that way.
[19:37] Brent Black: If I if I remember right, it was a bigger shower, so I think that there was like extra room in there where she could stand where the water was.
[19:43] Andrew: Dude, just grab the towel after you turn the shower off. Don't I'm with Jess on this one.
[19:50] Jess: It's it's just a lapse in logic from a filmmaking perspective. Can we talk about the line where the roommate, by the way, one of four unnamed colorful like diamond? I mean like the interchangeable roommates. But anyway, his roommate just barges in and says, Holy shit, you want to open a window? Which is like, what?
[20:12] Brent Black: That's some people actually do that. I could have been dumping in here.
[20:19] Jess: That's the thing. It's a there's so many things. This is like a tiny nugget of the room, because holy shit, you want to open a window. Like, I think people are allowed to have a little steam going in the bathroom when they take a shower. But also, Mia says, I was trying to give you an entrance, which is like, is this how this household functions? Like nudity and pooping and all kinds of bathroom things are just cool to bust in on. Like, it just feels like they didn't see it.
[20:48] Andrew: Is it bad that she has more intimacy with her roommates than she does with Ryan Gosling for the entire movie?
[20:55] Brent Black: Yes.
[20:56] Andrew: Look, me and my boys, we just barg in the bathrooms. Uh I don't know what you guys are doing. My my dude was in with the sh in the shower with me earlier today, so.
[21:06] Jess: Well, Godspeed. Uh and then someone in the crowd starts up and it's it's an alright song.
[21:16] Brent Black: Yes. Yes. To me, like this is the song that tells me that they have no excuse because they actually know how to do it. They just don't do it in the other songs. Like it's pretty simple. The roommates have an objective, which is get Mia to come to the party. The song breaks out of their desire to convince her. And then the logic they use to convince her drives the action. We know why they're singing and what they're singing leads logically to the next thing they're singing. Uh Mia gets a nice little moment in the bathroom where she has her bell singing like I want adventure in the great white somewhere, and then it ramps up for like a big production number finish. I don't know why the fireworks were there at the end, but like for five minutes, it's a decently charming movie musical.
[22:01] Jess: Can I chime in with uh hypothesis for why this song works and probably the other ones don't? Just a quick like conspiracy theory. Alright, so Justin Hurwitz, he does all the music for Damien Chazelle's movies and all that. They probably had these songs sketched out a long time ago, just with general this will be a song, this will be a song. And then when they bring Hasick and Paul in, um, let's go through the songs real quick. Another day of sun, uh, make it about LA and just general LA stuff, lovely night. Uh they're nice. Do the um if I loved you, like um apprehensive love song. Um City of Stars. Yep. Um, you know, LA happiness, love general. Um, this is the only one with specificity. This is the only one where there is characters to work with and an actual goal with it, where all the rest of them are very much like archetypes.
And let's go back to the Sontime quote that I'm like pasted in here and wanted to refer back to because I knew I was gonna say it. Um, where basically he said, if you asked me to write a love song, I would have a lot of trouble. But if you tell me to write a song about a girl with a red dress who goes into a bar in her Fifth Martini and is falling out of her chair, that's a lot easier because you have the specificity. Even songs like If I Loved You or Um People Will Say We Were in Love, you have the reference it is to the blossoms falling out of the tree, and that's so specific, as well as baking my favorite pie, like very specific things that differentiate these c differentiate these characters from our usual normal practic protagonists.
[23:38] Brent Black: I totally agree, and I'm gonna like weirdly name drop, like so. As we mentioned, I went to NYU Tisch for musical theater writing uh as a grad student. I recently stopped paying my student loans, but I'm bringing it up to say we got to do a QA with Sondheim, and he told us something we didn't know or I didn't know, which is he almost never writes a song to fill a hole in the script. He never writes a song where they say a song goes here. There's usually a playwright who writes a dialogue version of the scene, and then he takes that and adapts it. And it's a whole different process than just going, uh, song goes here. And to your point, Jess, I do feel like, yeah, it feels like a lot of these songs are shoehorned in a way that um if you're really paying attention to the setup and to the lyrics compared to the dialogue, though they don't quite fit.
[24:33] Jess: And I think that's the biggest issue with this song this film as like a musical is the lack of specificity. Yeah. The fact that they every song feels like it was written by someone completely different from everyone else, and they aren't character songs, they are group songs that happen to be sung by one character.
[25:08] Andrew: Uh I mean, I like the uh I like the roommate's uh singing. It's fun. She lives in a really rich apartment, it looks like.
[25:17] Brent Black: That is weird how like everyone here is just independently wealthy, even though most of the time you either see them getting fired or working at a coffee shop.
[25:26] Jess: To be fair, four or five women living together means you can afford it, even though you're probably sharing a bedroom, you know.
[25:34] Andrew: Maybe you're sharing a bathroom.
[25:36] Jess: Yeah. Maybe a bathroom is their bedroom, and she's like, What are you steaming of my bedroom for? Open a window. This is where I study. This is where I sleep. I sleep.
[25:53] Brent Black: Uh oh. And then so they go on their individual story. Ryan Gosling meets J.K. Simmons, and you remember what life feels like for a minute.
[26:02] Jess: Sebastian's Day.
[26:04] Andrew: Yeah, he came in contact with Mia a second time. Um, but the scene where he goes home and his sister is there, again. I don't know if your listeners are fans of the room, but there are just a few moments in this movie that feels straight out of the room. Like he shows up, his sister's there for no reason, he doesn't want her to be there. It's very like, anyway, how is your sex life? Like it's weird. Um, and this sister character never comes back again. She is only there to set up Sebastian and nothing else. And I guess I just feel like, you know, if this were a stage musical, certainly, but even a better written movie, you'd have her be someone recurring. Maybe one of Mia's roommates is the sister or something, but it's just so random and so transparently there for exposition about Sebastian.
[26:57] Jess: Let me chime in here with a small correction. Um, she does appear twice later.
[27:02] Andrew: Yeah, sworn she could disappear later.
[27:05] Jess: No, yeah, because in that she introduces her um fiance, and then later Brian Gosling plays at her engagement ceremony.
[27:14] Brent Black: Oh, that is a really good catch. You know, twice I've when I've watched the movie, that part of the movie is the hardest to pay attention to. So I bet I wouldn't be surprised if I was like looking at my phone for 30 seconds during that part. So, okay, that's fine. However, it does feel like she's not really a fleshed out character as much as a device. Um, she is a device for exposition, um, but it's a necessary device. And I'm not saying it's well done, but it does it all in one shot, so it's hoping that that really impressive one shot with dialogue moving between the walls will distract you from that.
[27:54] Jess: Yet again, like I loved the movie Birdman, which had like the illusion of being all in one shot. But it's like, you know what else is all in one shot? The aquarium at the dentist office. Like, I just think the content needs to be good.
[28:10] Andrew: I really like his character, though.
[28:12] Jess: Really? Okay, you do?
[28:14] Andrew: He likes.
[28:15] Jess: Yes, I do. Because he's.
[28:17] Andrew: I've met so many people like this that are just so terrible and obsessive with one thing, and that's all they it reminds me of uh of Whiplash.
[28:26] Jess: Oh, I thought you were gonna say me. I was like, oh.
[28:29] Andrew: It does remind me of Jess as well, but I was gonna say Whiplash. The character from Whiplash is exactly like this. Um, fun fact, Miles Teller was cast as this guy originally.
[28:40] Jess: It would have been good if he was.
[28:41] Brent Black: Really? So my question, Andrew, is you say you like it, but is it ironic, or is it like you enjoy the unusual dickishness of a romantic lead? Like what what specifically?
[28:53] Andrew: I think I like that it's um it feels realistic to me because I know people like this. Uh and I'm sure I think probably most people know people like this. And it just it feels like a realistic character, where it's just like the the perfect guy from the romantic comedy is not a real person.
[29:12] Brent Black: Yes, but this movie almost wants us to feel like this is a hero. Like in the end, he's seen as this great guy that saves the day and tells her to get off her ass and all that. I think that it's the whole movie thinks he's a dick.
[29:27] Jess: Really?
[29:27] Brent Black: Yes. I mean, well, a lot of it. Not the whole thing. There's some parts where they're like, oh, he's got these redeeming qualities, but in the end, the reason he doesn't get the girl is because he's a dick. That's what the whole ending is about.
[29:41] Andrew: Ooh, that's an interesting interpretation. For my money, and I don't know if Jess, you have an opinion about this, but I just would have liked a quick save the cat, which is a reference to a book written by a screenwriter about the scene that lets you know a character sort of has a heart of gold, regardless of whatever problems they might have. Um, because this the fact that it's not a comedy makes it hard to like him.
[30:07] Brent Black: Groundhog Day is a comedy where Bill Murray's a total dickhole, but it's sort of like a big thing.
[30:14] Jess: Oh, is Bill Murray a uh third rail topic?
[30:17] Andrew: Jess does not like Bill Murray.
[30:19] Brent Black: Oh my.
[30:20] Andrew: Well, in any case, the point is in Groundhog Day, he can be a dick because it's a comedy, and the whole story is about redeeming that. But here it's like, I wish I could have seen one thing that wasn't Ryan Gosling angrily playing the piano to make me feel like, oh, this is essentially a good guy, even if he's gruff.
[30:40] Brent Black: I also want like I think Ryan Gosling's performance, like, I think on the page this character could work. Like if you had that um that obsessiveness with jazz played more like goofy obsessiveness, like I think Santino Fontana would be really great at that goofy, like obsessiveness, like, no, you don't understand. But when Ryan Gosling, I don't think has been sincere about anything in his life, like sincerely in love with anything, like as goofy as jazz, and his like obsessive goofiness comes off as creepy. Like he looks dead behind the eyes every time he's like excitedly talking about anything.
[31:17] Jess: Brent, he is a real human being, okay? And you need to just leave him alone.
[31:24] Brent Black: Uh that's just my opinion on his performance here. I loved Blade Runner 2049, where looking dead behind the eyes was perfect for him.
[31:33] Andrew: I'm gonna agree with you. He doesn't have very much enthusiasm.
[31:36] Brent Black: Well, no, he does have enthusiasm.
[31:39] Andrew: It's strange how he uses it. Like when he's do you know how like iPhones have like low power mode? Like fucking Ryan Gosling is on low power mode this whole movie.
[31:51] Brent Black: I saw it as um as a sense of like self-seriousness, though. Where he shook himself so seriously that he couldn't show emotion. Like he was like, I'm a jazz guy. I'm important.
[32:05] Andrew: I think that's a totally logical interpretation. Also, I hate people like that.
[32:10] Brent Black: Uh I also don't like people like that, but I think it's cool to see a movie about someone like that.
[32:15] Andrew: That's fair enough. I think it's just weird because we're next to such a near faultless character like Mia.
[32:24] Brent Black: Yeah. I think if they had like an equally like I don't think she's quite flawed on the same level he is, I think is more than Mia is a miserable failure who can't get a job.
[32:35] Andrew: Whoa! Shit.
[32:36] Brent Black: Shadow serious.
[32:39] Andrew: She beat Kylo Ren with a lifesaber.
[32:44] Brent Black: I mean, you know, I think that Mia, it's weird, right? Like, she's supposed to be a the wor In these auditions that make her out to be a bad actress, but she's clearly good. And also, on the other hand, she super doesn't have her shit together. Who is surprised by a reminder that you set yourself for an audition that you're supposed to leave at the time you already told your manager? Why does she go, oh shit, and have to leave when she set the reminder? And also, you live in LA, you've been there for six years, as you say later in the thing. How do you not know what a toe zone is and how it works? Anyway.
[33:23] Brent Black: Um, storytelling, contrivance. Uh, let's talk about a lovely night, guys.
[33:29] Andrew: There's nothing here.
[33:30] Brent Black: Well, let's make something clear. I think I'll be the one to make that call. And though you look so cute in your polyester suit, you're right. I'd never fall for you at all. And maybe this appeals to someone not in heels, or to any girl who feels. There's some chance. The romance. But I'm frankly feeling not. Alright. A lovely night, the conditional song. Brent, what do you think?
[34:04] Brent Black: The sunset's beautiful, but the whole setup is weird. You said a little while ago that like somebody else could have made I think you were saying that somebody else could have acted Ryan Gosling's part better with the same script. If he had let on that he liked Mia a little bit, a little grin, a little, like even if it's a shot where he's like where she doesn't see him, where we go, oh, he likes her, but he's been nothing but a dick to her. The film doesn't actually make it clear that he walked her to her car. It makes it seem like they're just both walking to their cars, and you don't know that he did that till after the song. But my point is it's a horrible setup.
[34:47] Andrew: I think you see where he parked before the party.
[34:51] Brent Black: So I think you could know that.
[34:53] Andrew: Through my rage, I probably missed that. Um but yeah, so like he hasn't cracked a smile. They see a sunset. There's no shot of them looking at the sunset or hanging chimes to show that it's magical or anything. They just face away from the camera, and then for seemingly no reason, he twirls around a lamppost and they're doing a conditional love song. The way they aim the cannon is just ass.
[35:22] Brent Black: I have very little to disagree with, aside from the fact that the fact that up to this point, aside from another day of sun and someone in the crowd, it has been a very grounded story, and then these fantastical elements of the song numbers, and this is really our first like dance dance number, like where dance is the focus of it. It just clashes so hard tonally with me, and the camera is not doing anything um really intense enough to justify it. Like we don't I need that tr tonal transition. And I feel like Damien Chazelle is much more interested in getting one shots than like telling a compelling dance number.
[36:03] Andrew: Well, and to me, if you're gonna do a one shot of a dance number, then you gotta get Fred Astaire.
[36:10] Brent Black: Yes. Because, like, the opposite of this is when uh is it Richard Gere who was in Chicago, um, they totally faked his tap dancing and cut to somebody else's feet. Like, that's the opposite of this. Here, they really did the dancing, they did it in a one shot. But it's ex i you know, when Fred Astaire's at Easter parade and he's dancing in like, you know, on all these toys and the drum, and you're like, how the hell did he do this in one shot? That's impressive. Here, it's just like lazy camera work, and like they're okay dancers. It's great that they learned to dance for this movie, but when you metaphorically zoom out, it's like, yeah, they're pretty good.
[36:49] Andrew: They're alright. Imagine if they had casted actual Broadway dancers, like imagine Cynthia Erivo and Leslie Odom Jr. up there dancing the life away.
[36:58] Brent Black: Totally different movie.
[36:59] Andrew: This movie could have been.
[36:59] Brent Black: Yeah, the dancing was lame.
[37:03] Andrew: The dancing was lame.
[37:05] Brent Black: Sorry, Andrew, I'm gonna let you talk in a second. I just want to get this thought out. I'm gonna I'm gonna let you finish. I'm gonna let you finish, but Beyonce had the best video of all time. So this film needed Baz Luhrmann for the segment. Like you need the intense edits if you're gonna have non-dancers dancing. Like, at least it makes it feel more intense, high fantasy powerful. That is the diegetic language you want.
[37:32] Andrew: Um, here's what I think about dancing in any musical, including a movie musical. Dancing together, two people dancing specifically, means we're having fun, we're falling in love, or we're banging, but we can't show banging, so this is standing in for that.
[37:49] Brent Black: Um Bollywood style.
[37:52] Andrew: This is Bollywood porn. Um, but like the thing is, like, they don't it doesn't logically follow. Like, this song is actually not bad as like uh you're a jerk, actually I like you. You're a jerk, actually, I like you. Like, that's a fun thing, and it's very, very traditional, and I guess what I'm saying is it's tried, but it is true.
[38:20] Brent Black: Um, but the dancing here, I don't know why Ryan Gosling starts dancing, why he starts doing the feet thing on the bench. It's like he's being silly, but we haven't seen him do this yet. We don't know why he started doing it. Was it the sunset? I it's just not clear. And then after this song where they do dance together, which is supposed to mean a lot between two characters, like they don't even exchange information. He doesn't even like add her on Facebook.
[38:50] Andrew: Facebook didn't exist in the 1940s.
[38:56] Brent Black: Yes, she's got that good 1940s iPhone.
[38:59] Andrew: They're really rare.
[39:00] Brent Black: And she's driving that 1940s Prius.
[39:03] Andrew: Maybe it would have been better as a period piece.
[39:05] Brent Black: Oh, it probably would have. Very possible.
[39:07] Andrew: Very possible.
[39:09] Brent Black: Or go back even further. Make it take place in the 1800s. I want like a big 1940 style like hello dolly musical again.
[39:16] Andrew: No.
[39:17] Brent Black: Let's just go full on Jane Austen.
[39:20] Andrew: He's Mr. Darcy.
[39:22] Brent Black: Just really jump in.
[39:23] Andrew: I'd be down for that, like, but still keep like the um contemporary musical theater sh sh sh shtick going on.
[39:32] Brent Black: Oh yeah. And I want them to also be driving horses and buggies on the LA Highway.
[39:38] Andrew: This is gonna be a very specific cool movie we're making.
[39:41] Brent Black: This is awesome. Another day of dysentery.
[39:46] Andrew: Um, so after this song's over, randomly and briefly, we hear about Mia's boyfriend. For I might be wrong, but it seems like the first time in a way that you know who's being talked about. And to me, it's like I don't know, as I'll say later again, probably, I don't know why she has a boyfriend in the context of the way they tell the story, and it's weird that it took this long for us to concretely find out.
[40:17] Brent Black: I'm not gonna lie, I was excited that Finn Whitrock was in this movie, and then I saw how long he was gonna be into it for, and I was like, oh no.
[40:26] Andrew: Yeah, like he had some kind of deal with the director to be in the next movie, and the director was like, uh, I'll write you in as an unnecessary obstacle who's gone in seven and a half minutes.
[40:39] Brent Black: It was pretty pointless. She probably should have just not had one.
[40:42] Andrew: But an editing trick could have just saved this, like, and saved us that plot cul-de-sac. It didn't really have a point.
[40:51] Brent Black: To be honest, it could have. Like, he could have been like actually kind of like a really great guy and added some conflict to this really predictable, really overstretched, like romance. They basically have this weird false start meet cute like five times. So if she had a boyfriend that like she had to deal with an ethical dilemma, I'm I l I'm with this one dude who's not always in town, but I'm falling in love with another, that's drama. The way they do it, he just shows up and it's like both of you said, it's just it's porn.
[41:30] Andrew: But it's accented and made even worse when every time we see Mia at one of these parties, her friends are pairing her up with a guy as if they're trying to hook her up. She's the virginal one that don't don't find men very easily. And that makes it even more blurred. Like, if she's always like with these guys that her friends are trying to pair her up with, she must be single. Like just that.
[41:49] Brent Black: That's LA baby.
[41:51] Andrew: Yeah, and and someone in the crowd, in my mind, implied either like somebody that's gonna give you your big break, or someone you might want to be with. So, like, yeah, yet another thing where they they just all seem to not know she has a boyfriend.
[42:08] Brent Black: Yeah, I I actually didn't catch that she had a boyfriend at all.
[42:14] Andrew: You mean like you didn't know that's who that was?
[42:16] Brent Black: Yeah, I didn't know I like I think there's a scene where she skips a date with him or something. I actually thought it was her dad.
[42:26] Andrew: I didn't get a dude the first time I watched it because it was so random. I just assumed I had missed the setup.
[42:30] Brent Black: Maybe he's like a brother. Like, I just I must have I don't know. Maybe I told the flight attendant I wanted like a drink or something and missed that, but it really was fast.
[42:42] Andrew: Do you want me to ruin the reason why that's in the movie for you?
[42:45] Brent Black: Thanks to directly.
[42:47] Andrew: No. Is there a whole plot they cut out?
[42:49] Brent Black: No, they just wanted one scene where they did a cool audio trick and they didn't know how to do it aside from this.
[42:56] Andrew: Where she's there and you hear like the Sebastian Mia theme over the like Museak PA and Oh, yeah, like is that again diagesis? Like, did I say it right?
[43:09] Brent Black: Yeah. Perfect.
[43:11] Andrew: Shut up, Andrew. Cool. So the point is that word I mispronounced. Like, is it coming out of the speaker, or is she hallucinating? Is does she have a brain tumor? I hate that this movie never establishes or follows through on its rules.
[43:26] Brent Black: I think she was just thinking it.
[43:28] Andrew: Then why did they sh then why did they zoom in on the speaker?
[43:32] Brent Black: Yes. They wanted to do a magic trick without giving us the setup or the prestige.
[43:37] Andrew: Right. It's like, hey, there's a rabbit. It came out of a hat.
[43:41] Brent Black: Trust me. Um, and also I know I've got this theme of like the room, right? But when her boyfriend shows up, uh, he actually physically shows up 50 minutes into the movie. We don't know who he is. He's this hulking black-haired dude in a suit, and his first line is, hey babe. Like, it just I don't know. It feels uncanny to me. And also we never see him after like five minutes. If you're gonna compare it to the room, you have to do the where's my money, Denny. Where's my jazz club, Mia? Where's my fucking jazz club? Oh shoot. I do love the room, and the room should get a musical adaptation. I'm surprised it has it in all honesty. But honestly, I don't think this is it. I really didn't get the room vibes.
I'm not, I don't know. I think it's just shot too well. I think it's shot too well, and Finn Whitrock is just such a strange choice. You get random nobody to play that role. I know this guy. If you don't get these weird like character actors to play bit roles because it just takes you out of it. Right. I feel the same way about Mia's well, spoilers, but you know, I feel the same way about Mia's husband later on in the thing. It's like that's a featured extra. Why are you gonna use an actor who we've seen in movies, you know, for this like 30-second role? I thought it was the same person as her boyfriend at first.
[45:08] Andrew: You thought it was Ryan Gosling?
[45:09] Brent Black: Or it's the guy from that thing you do, whose name I can never remember, who is not James Marsden. They should have gotten Tommy Wiseau to do it. That would have been cool.
[45:18] Jess: Oh my god. Yes.
[45:19] Brent Black: That would have been meaningful. We can he can be the boyfriend and then Greg Sostero is the husband at the end.
[45:27] Andrew: Oh. If only.
[45:29] Brent Black: I want to hear Tommy Wiseau sing City of Stars. The real quick, the only reason to bring up the room is because of really lazy, convenient characters that are only there as devices and there's no economy to them. It's like we have this character that shows up for a tiny amount of time. It makes all these characters like this weird picaresque parade of characters when it could have had some dual roles and had a smaller, more interesting cast. Anyway, City of Stars.
[46:22] Jess: Are you shining just for me?
[46:28] Brent Black: City of stars. There's so much that I can't see.
[46:48] Andrew: Or that I cannot.
[46:54] Brent Black: This song shows that Ryan Gosling, as a musical theater performer, is a coward. Like he's acted well in movies. He's a gorgeous, like perfect slab of man, but it's a boring song, and he sings it as if he's trying to sing it while not waking up a baby. It's like so low effort, low energy, and the opening lyric is so dumb. It's City of Stars, are you shining just for me? To answer your question, Sebastian, no. No, they are not. Um, and the way he asks it so like in such a dull way, it's like, do you even care? I don't know. His lack of effort here is borderline disturbing to me. Because it's like, why is there even a song here if you're gonna be so too cool for school?
[47:53] Jess: I think that's his character, though.
[47:57] Brent Black: I guess I just feel like the thing to me is like volume, sheer volume equals passion at a point when it comes to singing. And his lack of volume and effort make me feel like he's not actually all that into Mia. The structurally, this song is like a song for us to see into his heart and go, wow, he really likes this girl. And if it was a good musical, it'd be wow, he really likes her, and he's not sure about X because there's some stakes involved. But instead, it's like I just got high, I'm gonna dance with a stranger anyway. Bye. Like, that's it. If you want to hear this song sung very well and very passionately, look at the Oscars performance by John Legend, who like can bring soul to the dumbest lines.
[48:50] Jess: Are you shining just for me?
[48:57] Brent Black: City of stars so much that I can't see.
[49:07] Andrew: Oh no.
[49:10] Brent Black: Is this the start of something wonderful? Under I didn't see it, but I believe that. Because he's a real singer.
[49:19] Jess: Mm-hmm.
[49:20] Brent Black: And he's a passionate singer. He's not a great actor, as we see in this, but he is a fantastic singer. Alright. Then she comes and chases after him, and they're at a movie theater and they're seeing Rebel Without a Cause because, you know, nostalgia, old films. Um another tie-in to uh to Tommy Wiseau, by the way.
[49:42] Andrew: Yeah, that is this.
[49:43] Brent Black: Oh, that's a great point. I'm starting to think this film is taking me apart. Um, and then they hold hands and the film doesn't work out, and then they go to a planetarium and fly around.
[50:01] Andrew: Uh I want to know what Andrew thought.
[50:06] Andrew: Um, honestly, I think this was my least favorite part of the whole thing. Uh them flying around was a little silly and they didn't dance very well, so it wasn't really that spectacular. It bothers me just because like, is it that easy to break into the conservatory at night?
[50:23] Brent Black: It's a great point.
[50:24] Andrew: I don't care about that. I mean, if someone wants to break into a conservatory, I don't think anyone's gonna stop them. And do they leave this like Frankenstein lab Tesla coil ball on all night? That's quite a drain on the power bill, one would think.
[50:40] Brent Black: Arnold doesn't care.
[50:44] Andrew: I to me this sequence is where the the movie, like what air it has, all just completely goes out of it. Um and it's beautiful, it's gorgeous to look at, but it's boring as shit. It is the Star Trek the motion picture of dance sequences, and like it all seems to think that every advance in their physical contact is like a twist, like, oh, they're holding hands.
[51:15] Brent Black: Yeah, they've they've been predictably the love interest for like half an hour now.
[51:21] Andrew: Wow, they held hands.
[51:22] Brent Black: And then like at the end of the whole boring ass, like I'm gonna go buy some milk duds, see a kind of dance sequence. They kiss, and like it's this huge thing. Like they have a whole vignette circle that comes down on it, the music swells. It's like, what a twist? It's not a twist. This was a this should happen 20 minutes before. Um it's playing with the chasteness of 1940s musical without realizing that it can't do that anymore. Societal expectations have changed, and no longer are we gonna be surprised that the two leads that are obviously gonna get together are gonna get together.
[52:04] Andrew: It's still playing by 1940s rules.
[52:08] Brent Black: Eating her ass in that planetarium, not just holding her hand and I thought that's what dancing stood for.
[52:15] Andrew: But see, okay, that's a good point.
[52:18] Brent Black: But look, we have everything in this in this film so far has followed the rules of physics, to my knowledge. And so, like, they're already inconsistent with the logic, the diagesis, um, which is like regular Jesus, but like two of them. Um But like, for real though, the fact that they can suddenly fly just pisses me off. Because it's like you I don't know. We've already seen them dance, and now I get that it's in their heads, but there's a literalism to the way it's shot sometimes that doesn't, you know, like for instance, Reefer Madness, the Showtime movie of the musical, has a great way of like switching over to a different world when they sing songs, so you kind of see the world through their eyes for a second. And when the song's over, it switches back. This movie doesn't do that. This movie's like, now they're literally flying, and it's it bugs me.
[53:23] Andrew: Um, I think I said this to my girlfriend when I walked out of the theater when she was like, this is actually her favorite sequence. I was like, it felt like someone put in their really expensive short film with movie stars in the middle of a longer film. Like, I got this idea, and we're gonna put it right in here, and then it's not gonna really connect to much else, but you know.
[53:44] Brent Black: And then after that scene, it's pretty much the beginning of the end for this couple.
[53:49] Andrew: This okay. The the Rebel Without a Cause scene. What once she once Mia is with her boyfriend, there's this long, long chasm with no momentum and no stakes. Because right after this, there's the summer montage, um, which is just like they're in love. And I don't know, like, I'm not a screenwriter, but we got it. You just danced in the fucking clouds. We don't need to watch you like soft shoe in a subway station. You're in love. Is anything else gonna happen in this movie? And it just keeps on not happening right before your eyes. They're like really happy, and it's all these shots of them happily going around and hanging out with friends or being silly with each other.
[54:34] Brent Black: Uh, I think that's where the jazz club scene where Emma Stone's dancing and Ryan Gosling's like playing on stage. Just an example.
[54:41] Andrew: Yeah, sequence of them being in love.
[54:44] Brent Black: I I mean, I thought that part was fine, and I think that this whole section here is less about their relationship and more about their goals in general, which is why you get the parts where he's trying to uh figure out if he wants to join this band or if he wants to follow his actual dream and shit like that. And there's a I think there's a montage of her doing auditions as well. This would be this goes where the postcoital conversation would be, basically, in any other love story.
[55:11] Andrew: Um, this would be where if I were making this, it would be the opening up for intimacy scene would be if a human being actually wrote this instead of the computer program that is Damien Chazelle.
[55:22] Brent Black: Um basically they thought, you know what, they could dance, have fun, and this could be them enjoying their relationship, and he doesn't seem to understand that relationships aren't just about smiling and looking happy, it's expressing the deepest, darkest secrets.
[55:38] Andrew: Like I think the best interpretation of this was um eternal sunshine, where she has the am I ugly conversation where she's like, I had this doll and I didn't want to be ugly, and it's just opening up that intimacy and wanting that.
[55:53] Brent Black: And I think we could have had that and still had that work if she just told him a little bit about her aunt's story and that connection and how that drives her, like, or at least, like, why do you want to be an actress? Like, we don't even know why she wants to be an actress, it's just something that she wants to do.
[56:09] Andrew: Who doesn't want to be an actress?
[56:10] Brent Black: Well, that's the assumption as you go in, but a lot of people, like, I wouldn't want to be an actor, I don't want to be a performer. Like, I do a podcast, but that's a little different.
[56:18] Andrew: Literally a performer right now.
[56:19] Brent Black: Well, the thing is, if she's dealing with all these rejections and all that, what is that drive that makes her feel it's worth it? And I feel like we're missing that.
[56:30] Andrew: I feel like that's it's not necessary.
[56:32] Brent Black: I I don't know. I guess I feel like that's one thing I can actually get on board with. I I happen to have majored in acting in college, so I'm not unbiased, but I think that where everyone has a keyhole into that is that I think almost everyone, at least in America, values fame.
[56:50] Andrew: So even if you don't get into like the craft and the art of it and it being your happy place, I think people watching the movie can be like, yeah, she wants to be famous. Who doesn't?
[57:00] Brent Black: Yes, but then the ones that dream the audition song seems to be paying off like her like emotional goal, the drive that we never got set up.
[57:11] Andrew: Well, and not to spoil it and skip ahead, but uh, here's to the ones who dream. Unlike you who went home and only came back because of your boyfriend.
[57:21] Brent Black: Anyway.
[57:23] Andrew: Yeah, okay.
[57:24] Brent Black: Well, I think that it's so far into it at a certain point that you kind of just uh come jaded, I guess, and I think she's kind of at that point.
[57:35] Andrew: Right.
[57:35] Brent Black: After six years, she says, and that makes sense.
[57:40] Andrew: So Alright, so then Ryan Gosling at the peak of his happiness, meets with his good friend John Legend.
[57:49] Brent Black: Does he have a character name that isn't John Legend?
[57:51] Andrew: Keith.
[57:52] Brent Black: Keith.
[57:53] Andrew: Keith.
[57:53] Brent Black: Keith Messenger. Um, so he's like, hey, you wanna join this fake jazz band with me to make money? And he's like, no, art. I wanna wanna be my art. And then he overhears Mia on the phone with her father saying, like, oh yeah, he doesn't really make money. And then he's like, I gotta sell out. And then he joins the John Legend band.
[58:17] Jess: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the podcast, but we're here to shill at you.
[58:22] Andrew: Yay.
[58:23] Jess: That's my favorite thing to do.
[58:25] Brent Black: That's my game.
[58:27] Jess: Alright. Please subscribe to us on iTunes and leave us a review. It's our way of getting viewed and getting up there on the new and noteworthy list. We really want that.
[58:35] Andrew: Also, find us on Spotify, Stitcher, and all the other podcast websites.
[58:39] Jess: Uh, check us out on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. On Instagram at Musical Theater Lives. YouTube, Musical Theatre Lives.
[58:49] Andrew: And please, if you have any questions, recommendations, thoughts, or just anything that you want to say at us, email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. We always read them and we will respond.
[58:57] Jess: We'll probably respond to them on the show. Also, a reminder that we are currently having a raffle for anyone that is gonna leave us a review on iTunes.
[59:09] Andrew: If you leave a review, you'll be automatically put into a raffle for a $20 Amazon gift card. So if you leave a review, you have a chance to win. Just letting you know.
[59:21] Jess: Exactly. So thank you for listening, and let's get you back to it.
[59:28] Brent Black: I don't know what your name is, but I like it. I've been thinking about some things I wanna try. I don't know what it came to do it, but I wanna do it with you.
[59:42] Andrew: And I don't know, I'm feel so good tonight. Like they had this whole conversation about John Legend wants to evolve jazz. Ryan Gosling wants to preserve jazz. But after all that, the song that they take three or four minutes of our lives will never get back to show us that they do at the live show is not jazz.
[1:00:06] Jess: I'm not trying to be all purist, I don't care. It's 70s funk with an 80s pop synth. It's not jazz.
[1:00:15] Andrew: Yeah, but it's performed by someone who can sing. Some people lump funk into jazz fusion, some people do.
[1:00:22] Brent Black: I mean, that's okay, that's your right. I'm just saying, to me, Ryan, I mean, you could actually look at this and go, this is Ryan Gosling selling out because it's not a jazz band at all. But to me, it's like you could have had Keith as a character be like, nobody likes jazz, dummy. Come play in my EDM band, come play in my top 40 band. That would have been interesting.
[1:00:49] Andrew: He had already been doing that, though. He was in the 80s cover band. Uh, so that it wouldn't have been any different. This was him trying to follow his dream in a realistic way. But, as Mia points out later, it's not really his dream because it isn't actually jazz, and that's I think that's kind of the point of it.
[1:01:09] Jess: Well, that's fair. I guess I just feel like if they were trying, it seems like they're just trying to showcase John Legend. Like he said, if I'm gonna act in this movie, I get a whole song to myself. But it feels like from a dramatic standpoint, from a storytelling standpoint, it's not different enough from jazz to be like, oh, that must really suck for Ryan Gosling, but it's not that close to jazz per se, in a way that makes me, I don't know.
[1:01:40] Brent Black: It's like, and when Mia says, do you like the music you're playing? I'm skipping ahead, but when she says that, like, I don't know. It all feels like they could have given it a once over and made it all feel a little bit more of a piece from a storytelling perspective.
[1:01:55] Jess: Agreed. I kind of got it, honestly. I thought it was pretty well done. Because it isn't really jazz and what he's been playing throughout the—because we've kind of skipped a lot of jazz pieces that he plays throughout the entire movie. None of it is similar to anything he plays with John Legend, so that's true.
[1:02:16] Brent Black: I mean, to me, I think that why I don't like this. I don't know if you guys have seen a movie called Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, which is literally a movie with the Bee Gees and Peter Frampton doing a musical where every song is a Beatles song. It's you need drugs or drink to enjoy it. But the point I'm getting at is Earth, Wind and Fire randomly show up for a number, and they do it for three minutes, and it has nothing to do with the plot. You just sort of sit through it, and this kind of feels like that.
[1:02:50] Andrew: Like, I guess I understand that now Ryan Gosling is like in this band he doesn't want to be in, but we could know that in terms of pacing and momentum, we could know that without having to watch John Legend be like, hey, this is the song they promised me in my contract.
[1:03:08] Jess: I'm gonna make the argument that the importance is not in fact Ryan Gosling in that scene, it is Emma Stone. Her facial reaction, the fact that she sees all these women racing up there toward the guy that she's so in allegedly in love with, and seeing like how insignificant she is in the sea of people, and that just the face journey of that is more the importance of that scene.
[1:03:32] Brent Black: I agree with Jess actually. Because Ryan Gosling doesn't really do much in this song, he just plays the piano.
[1:03:39] Andrew: Yeah, this is I think another example of me like wanting to shoehorn this movie into the model of good movie musical, and to both of your points, there is storytelling going on here that's germane to the movie they're trying to make. I just go, you told me there was going to be a musical, and now you're doing a second-rate John Legend music video with some incidental shots of the main characters emoting.
[1:04:06] Jess: I don't know. What'd you think of the song?
[1:04:10] Brent Black: It was fine. But the thing is, it was fine in a way that had nothing to do with anything else. And like, this could have been honest to God. You know what it was like? It was like in movies where they just show a little bit of a strip tease or a little bit of, sorry, an exotic dance show to establish that we're in a CD strip club. Imagine if they stopped to do like all three and a half minutes of the strip tease or the exotic dance thing instead of just being like, this is the establishing shot.
[1:04:46] Andrew: This whole thing in the movie that was tightly paced that got around to itself, that got to the point, could have been a ten second shot. They're playing on stage, John's John Legend singing, Ryan Gosling's having a feeling about it, Emma Stone's having a feeling about it, and we're done. Making it a whole song in this movie felt weird. Even though it's a great song, John Legend's great, it's shot perfectly well. It just feels—I feel like this is in the middle of this long chasm where nothing really happens, and what does happen doesn't happen quickly enough.
[1:05:21] Jess: I agree with that. They probably could have done a trimmed-down version of the song, but I think you did need to actually hear the song because the genre of the song matters.
[1:05:34] Brent Black: Well, but again, if they'd had a slightly more extreme version of the song that was way not jazz, it could have been a 10 or 15 second shot. Imagine if they were playing dubstep or something.
[1:05:49] Andrew: Well, then why would he have joined that band? I mean.
[1:06:01] Jess: Yeah. I mean, I guess I just feel like they could have—it could again. I'm bugged by the fact that in a musical, and maybe this doesn't count as a movie musical because structurally it's so lopsided, but we could know a lot more about Ryan Gosling's feelings about all this if he broke into song about it. But we don't really deeply know what he thinks about it because it's all implied in weirdly subtle film storytelling in the middle of a musical. It just—it's odd.
[1:06:39] Brent Black: I agree. I agree a hundred percent with that. You could try to argue that maybe this isn't a musical, it's just a movie with music in it.
[1:06:47] Jess: Which I almost find worse.
[1:06:49] Andrew: Would you find that worse? Because I think it works more as that.
[1:06:53] Brent Black: Well, here's my counterpoint to that. If you judge by the number of songs, like the number of numbers, it's similar to Little Mermaid, Aladdin, much, much, much better movie musicals. So in my mind, it's if you think of it as a movie with music, well, people do kind of break into song.
[1:07:15] Jess: Um, so I feel like in that way it's a musical, it's just structurally very, very lopsided.
[1:07:22] Andrew: So Mia's writing a one-woman show for some reason to show off her acting chops. Um, which is strange.
[1:07:28] Brent Black: Brian Gosling recommended her.
[1:07:31] Jess: She did it.
[1:07:32] Brent Black: Yeah, yeah, yeah. He literally just came up to her and he said, "You should do that thing Tommy Wiseau did, just you know, write your own thing." Um, and I've just—and it goes terribly, mostly because I feel like a lot of actors don't quite understand how hard writing a show is, let alone a one-person show when you literally have nothing to act off of but yourself and the audience.
[1:08:01] Andrew: Did the fight over the dinner that like the surprise dinner, did that happen before?
[1:08:06] Jess: That happened right before it.
[1:08:08] Andrew: That happens before the show.
[1:08:10] Jess: So, like, just to really quick touch on that, I really every time I watch this fight scene, I feel differently about it. I'm a self-employed artist type. Um, and I feel like there's something so mundane and like forced about like that they needed structurally to have a fight here, but it's like they go through the motions of boy loses girl, but I don't know, like there's lots of lapses in logic, and then they'll be really reasonable and they'll switch off who's being reasonable.
[1:08:44] Brent Black: Um, how did she not know when he first went on this tour that he would continue to be on tour?
[1:08:50] Jess: But okay, uh, maybe she didn't.
[1:08:52] Andrew: Well, he's making money from his art. That's hard to do. That's what she wants to do. How can she judge that? How is she just now realizing the implications of his tour? And also, you know, I don't know if her one-woman show has a bunch of magic tricks and ridiculous tech requirements, but she probably could, as he suggested, rehearse it on the road with him.
[1:09:17] Brent Black: I can explain this a little bit. Have you noticed that up to this point they have never had a conversation with each other that wasn't about their own respective artistic goals? Not a single one.
[1:09:29] Jess: Wow.
[1:09:31] Brent Black: No, I hadn't. That's a good catch.
[1:09:33] Andrew: The fact is, up to this point, they have nothing else that they could fight over that would have any weight up to now. Aside from you can't do my art thing, but your art thing's getting in the way of my art thing, and then if I do your art thing with you, then it is the way that a psychopath would write romance and think that humans fight about.
[1:09:53] Jess: Thank you. You can't help me make my film, you can't help me do this because you want to be an actress.
[1:09:58] Brent Black: Well, maybe the point is that they don't really care about each other. Like they're not right for each other, which goes back to Ryan Gosling is a dick the entire show. He was never actually a point where he's not.
[1:10:10] Andrew: Uh, they just haven't had to fight about it yet, because neither of them have been successful. Or the fact that they haven't seen each other.
[1:10:20] Jess: If that was the intention, that's meta as fuck. But at the same time, maybe it was.
[1:10:25] Brent Black: Like, and on that level, I guess it succeeds. Because I don't like him.
[1:10:31] Andrew: Well, I mean, he says some mean stuff there. He doesn't end up getting the girl. I think the movie knows he's not really that great a person.
[1:10:42] Jess: Ma, maybe maybe I'm just naturally mean, but like I have a hard time—I think if nothing else, they did a good job showing that they both contributed to the fight and yet were both reasonable at points. Cause like when she says you're just doing it to be liked, and he's like, you're an actress. What the hell are you talking about? That's a good point.
[1:11:01] Brent Black: He's not being entirely respectful in that moment, but that's what fights are. I think he's totally right, and she looks at him like, ow, I'm wounded. And it's like, hello, come on. You are trying to be an actor. And at a certain point, wanting attention and wanting to be liked. You can pretend it's all about the craft, but I've never met an actor that was like, oh no, I leave before I hear any clapping.
[1:11:28] Jess: Um, but this is the life of two people that literally have no life outside of their artistic endeavors, and that is a scary world to imagine.
[1:11:43] Jess: And Sebastian misses it because he's too busy. Um, doing a photo shoot with literally the best character in the film.
[1:11:53] Andrew: Oh my god, I would follow that photographer to the ends of the earth.
[1:11:57] Brent Black: Same. So much more interesting than anything else. Like, he's my hero.
[1:12:03] Jess: Well, because he said he played good, like three times.
[1:12:06] Andrew: Oh, now you pry, don't you? Bite your lip, bite your lip.
[1:12:09] Brent Black: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Look, look like you're focusing on your music.
[1:12:13] Jess: Like, there's nobody else in this movie I'd like to get a drink with. Aside from the roommates, but that's only for reasons of wanting to have sex with them. This character seems interesting. He seems lived in, and he seems like he's got some good stories to tell.
[1:12:29] Andrew: What about J.K. Simmons?
[1:12:31] Brent Black: I love J.K. Simmons, but in this movie, he just seems like a dick. Like, I think that the song Ryan Gosling played that got him in trouble, almost the entirety of it was actually really nice. And even though it's Christmas, it's a nice song.
[1:12:53] Jess: Not quite my set list.
[1:12:55] Brent Black: Wonderful, but say again.
[1:12:56] Jess: Not quite my set list.
[1:13:01] Brent Black: Uh and so after he doesn't show up, Mia just is like, I'm going back to Nevada. Quitting acting after six years, I'm going back to school.
[1:13:13] Andrew: Wasted more money.
[1:13:14] Brent Black: Well. And again, she overhears people saying her play sucked, but every time she auditions, she's amazing. This movie can't decide if she sucks at actual acting or if she's good. Because they hired a really good actor, but she's, I guess, not good at acting badly. It's confusing.
[1:13:36] Jess: I love Cate Blanchett, but if she wrote herself a one-woman show and performed it herself, I don't think I'd give a shit.
[1:13:45] Andrew: I was gonna say that there is a few audition segments where clearly she's bad. Like where she's pretending to be a police officer. Uh that one was like really bad. There's a few of them in one of the sequences where they are bad.
[1:14:01] Brent Black: That's true. And I mean I felt like that whole sequence, it feels like they kept it to show the woman reading, like, you know, I've been an actor, and sometimes the person reading opposite of you in an audition is totally wrong for it and not even trying. But at the same time, that whole like I forget what the joke was, but it was like, what up with that, or some kind of shit. And it was like, okay, this is a 1997 joke about black people. Like, can we please try? I see what you're saying, Andrew. I just feel like she's so good when she's good that I refuse to believe. I mean, look, maybe her writing was shitty. I just feel like the movie can't decide when she's good and when she's bad and why.
[1:14:48] Jess: So she leaves Sebastian and then he gets a call about her getting a callback for this big film in France. So he drives the four hours to Nevada and wakes up an entire city street to get her attention.
[1:15:02] Andrew: I thought that was pretty funny. And the guy like throws like a book at it.
[1:15:08] Brent Black: Yeah, that's the one time it feels like a romantic comedy in this film. Well, he does that every time he shows. I mean, that reaction of the guy throwing a like newspaper at him. That feels like something out of a 90s romance comedy. Like Ten Things I Hate About You.
[1:15:29] Jess: Um, and they basically get together, she's like, uh, I'm a failure. And he's like, You're gonna go, and I'm gonna make sure you go. And he takes her to the audition, and then they ask her to tell a story. And she rambles on a story about how her aunt once went to Paris.
[1:16:22] ♪ Musical number: "Audition (The Fools Who Dream)" — performed by Emma Stone ♪
[1:16:48] Brent Black: Yeah, kind of. Yeah, and the thing is, like, this is not the worst song, and boy, Emma Stone acts the fuck out of it, but it's schmaltzy and lyrically unfocused. And like. Once again, it's even abstractly, it's introducing a character we we'll never hear about again. If they had really organically thought of what the right thing for her to do in this movie would be, I think this would be the time for her to tell a story about herself and Sebastian. They could have cut 20 minutes of we're in love by her here telling a story about a boy she loved. We know she's gonna nail the audition and get the part either way. So why not have some economy? Why not use every part of the buffalo instead of wastefully doing this song about a character we don't even give a shit about?
Um and structurally, I feel like here's to the ones who dream should have been the conclusive hook rather than here's to the mess we make. That's just my opinion from like a nitpicky point of view. It's show offy like camera movement, like going around the world disappearing, like all practically. It feels like look at me, I'm gonna do something cool, suck at lame is one shot my ass, we're gonna move all around and do all this crazy stuff.
[1:18:18] Jess: I just like it to me, it's like look, do Goodfellas or do Easter Parade. But like, I just feel like to your point earlier, Jess, like so often the the place where the director and the cinematographers' heads were was the technical elements of filmmaking and not whether the song really made sense. So they decide since she's gonna get this part, she needs to go to France for a good period, and they basically end the relationship for Rizzle.
[1:18:51] Andrew: Yeah, I don't know. I think this scene suddenly they're mature, they're making good choices, it's bittersweet. But you know, sometimes with a musical or with a movie, a scene doesn't work not because it's bad, but because like of what precedes it. And like for me, I wish that it it had happened 30 minutes before. But all the air was taken out of the pacing with all the stuff that happened in the 30 minutes prior.
[1:19:19] Jess: Alright. Let's talk about the ending. We've basically spoiled it at this point. They don't end up together. She marries some dude. She has a daughter that doesn't know not to look at the director during a scene. Um Yeah, it's really sad, and then they make eye contact at the bar that he has when she just happenstances her way in there. And then they have this big epilogue um musical montage that magically relives their entire relationship, but in a musical like Singing in the Rain way.
[1:20:00] Brent Black: It relives it and then it shows what it could have been. Almost. Yeah, and it's it's like the good kind of confusing where you're like, wait, is this what really happened? Like, that's what I thought at first. Um and like my thoughts are it's beautiful, it's emotionally compelling, but all of its power is undercut by the ruined pacing of the preceding 40 minutes. Like my arms were folded half an hour ago, and at this point, my fucking skeleton is turned to pudding. I don't care. I just want it to be over. Um, and I think this ending would work as the ending of like a one-hour Black Mirror episode, but I just don't know if they quite earned it. Like, I think the idea of the one that got away is very universal and speaks to me very deeply, but I just wanted the movie to be over.
And also, that trumpet solo. Like, we're we're in the denouement of this film. Who what trumpet that trumpet guy's agent was really good because the it stops dead to indulge this guy's trumpet solo for way too long.
[1:21:07] Andrew: That's jazz, my man.
[1:21:09] Brent Black: I guess. Um, but like if the whole movie had been stylized like that ending sequence, that would have been a hell of a thing. But at this point, despite being beautiful to me, it's I don't disagree. Um, Andrew, what do you think about that?
[1:21:29] Andrew: It was really good. I'm not sure what to say. I'm not sure what how to say it. I mean, I thought it was great. I mean, I wasn't bored of the movie at this point, so I I just thought it was really good. Uh I think everyone agrees it was really good, so I just agree even more.
[1:21:47] Brent Black: Now, to Andrew's point, this movie got nominated for six Oscars, and nobody was shocked when they thought it won Best Picture. People like this movie, particularly people that live in LA and want to be reassured that it's worth it. Um, but like I think I am an outlier for reasons we've talked about, and the fact that I'm just snobby about musical theater structure. But yeah, like, much like your girlfriend, Jess, like there comes a point for me in this movie where I just I want to be invested, but it just drops the ball. And from a perspective of momentum, once it's dropped, it it's so hard to pick back up. I think you could cut this movie in a way that would give so much more power and weight to this epilogue. And if you just start watching the movie at the point of this epilogue, it's like, oh, what a beautiful movie must have preceded this. But structurally, I just feel like I'm bored and I just want it to be over.
[1:22:49] Jess: I 100% agree, but I also I feel like this montage in and of itself is a larger symptom of the film itself. It's great in moments, but it really needs to be cut down. We don't need to see recreations of the scenes that we just saw, like of her with her fake child, uh, but it's Ryan Gosling's this time, and them going to the spar. I'm like, okay, cut that, cut that, and I I get what they're doing, but no.
[1:23:15] Brent Black: Well, I mean, it's the the music was probably already made and they wanted to make it long enough to have the whole song. Well, that's a lot like the filmmaking decisions that they made before they wrote the songs, or like they had the idea for the shots before they thought of how the song would affect the story. That's not how you do a good storytelling with musicals. I feel like you can fix a lot of things in post. If they wanted it to be shorter, they could have changed the the musical arrangement, but it it's hard because it's hard for me because like it's so beautiful, and the the s the the scene on the sound stage where it actually is quite abstract. You know that it's not representative of anything that could be real, but it's stylized in an old movie musical kind of way. It's like, oh, that's so great! Why the fuck did you put it here and not do it any other time?
[1:24:03] Jess: Yeah, and then the movie ends. They give their last look to each other, the music sounds pretty for a minute, and we go into the credits. And that last title, again, is like trying to tell you, hey, no, we're we're totally White Christmas. And it's like, you're not White Christmas. I knew White Christmas. I worked with White Christmas, and you, sir, are no White Christmas. Like it's just, I wish this the way that it dresses itself up in this nostalgic kind of accoutrement is like just because three kids are in a trench coat doesn't mean I think they're a detective. I just wish it was more nostalgic for better musicals. Like, I wish it was nostalgic for The Sound of Music and My Fair Lady, like things that actually use story, musical theater story structure to its advantage, as opposed to um the Gene Kelly musicals.
[1:24:53] Brent Black: Right, and well, and that's why I think that the idea that it's meta or it's trying to do a take on musical theater in a way that is deconstructive is either misguided or unsuccessful or not the case because up to the end it's still doing that. It's still doing these visual cues that tell you what it's trying to emulate, or or be a love letter to, or whatever all the critics did. But if you want to introduce more people to music theater, then you have to have Hollywood movies that are musicals.
[1:25:28] Andrew: Yeah, I mean, I guess like the show Glee, right, did a lot to introduce people to musical theater, even though it wasn't really musical theater. But like, you're right, there's like baby food that you gotta get into before you can, you know, chew up a steak. I just I I just like clearly I have some issues with this movie. I think if you watch it as a movie and not as a musical, it makes more sense.
[1:25:53] Jess: Sure, but even without thinking of it as a structurally like a stage musical, even in thinking of it structurally as a movie. I think honestly, a lot of the sins that I count against it could be fixed by just pacing and momentum. Lead, you know, make one scene lead to the next. It's kind of like um Matt Parker, sorry, Matt Stone and Trey Parker have this theory of storytelling where it's like every next scene that happens, you either should start it with a a butt or a sew. This thing happened, so that thing happened, but this thing happened, so that like and this movie just goes, and this thing happened, and that thing happened, and you're like, okay, great. Is there a particular thing I should give a huge shit about? I don't know.
[1:27:02] Jess: Alright. Well, let's go backwards through this. This time we're starting with Andrew. Andrew, what is your overall thoughts about La La Land and your cheese rating?
[1:27:11] Andrew: Oh good, I get to give the cheese reading.
[1:27:13] Jess: Yeah, you always do.
[1:27:15] Andrew: I always do. Um, I thought it was a lot of fun. Uh I I find the the actual story itself very relatable.
[1:27:24] Brent Black: Um, and I like the message that it gives. And I am a huge sucker for bittersweet endings as well, so uh, that's great as well. And I also like jazz. If you like jazz, you should watch it. Uh and as far as a cheese rating, it gets a straight cheddar. It is cheesy as hell. I'm not gonna lie, I'm a little bit angry that you got more emotional at this than you did at Falsettos.
[1:27:49] Andrew: Yeah, I listened to that episode. Uh and I watched the 2016 Falsettos with my girlfriend, and we sobbed like we babes. And the fact that that I mean, I'm with you on that, Jess. The fact that, like, you've had an emotion here, but I mean, actually, it sounded like you did have an emotion toward the end of the second act of Falsettos, but still, quite an interesting dichotomy.
[1:28:13] Jess: Well, I mean, Falsettos is not at all relatable to me in any way.
[1:28:18] Brent Black: Uh that's fair. It is quite I mean, I mean, many people I think can't quite relate to the situations in that. I can definitely relate to having a passion for something and wanting to achieve those goals and having somebody help you do that, but you're just not right for each other.
[1:28:38] Andrew: I mean, you don't relate to wanting to beat your boyfriend at chess.
[1:28:42] Brent Black: Yeah, I just I just don't relate to getting AIDS and dying. I mean, I just it's never happened to me.
[1:28:50] Jess: Alright, so I'm gonna give my opinion so I can cut that out later. Um performances outside of our leads, I think are incredible. Like all of the ensemble work, including the musicians and featured dancers, are doing their bestest, and they are incredible, like especially in that opening number. This film is nostalgic for musical films at their worst. It's the big Gene Kelly song and dance numbers that ruled the mid 20th century that died way too late at with the existence of Hello Dolly. Um none of the songs are completely terrible, and neither is La La Land, but none of them are completely compelling. It's hard to create an air of verisimilitude in a world that has large dance numbers and as commonplace commas as commonplace as conversation.
Really, I'm just not a huge fan of this, but I also don't hate it. I have a lot of other notes, but not much I can really say. Aside from the fact that why don't we cast Broadway actors in these very big dance roles that we're supposed to be impressed by.
[1:30:13] Brent Black: If they had shot it just a little bit later, they would have realized that they should have gotten an actor that had just come off the first cast of Hamilton. If they got David in there, if they got Odom, if they I mean they wouldn't have gotten Lynn Manuel, but like, yeah, like Hamilton was so hot, that could have been a whole different deal. But also, they could have moved and like your average moviegoer is actually not cool with vibrato. Um, which is great because Ryan Gosling barely has it, aside from that, like barely trying Regina Spektor jazz vibrato thing. Um but anyway.
[1:30:51] Jess: Yeah, I think that it could have been cast in a way that would have been it would have just real dancers, real singers. Could have been a whole different thing.
[1:30:58] Brent Black: Yeah, but Anna Kendrick is the new hotness, as far as everyone's concerned, and her vibrato is probably one of the most noticeable things about her voice.
[1:31:09] Jess: Uh well, yes, but I mean, and I'm judging from the last five years movie, it's still, it's not like, oh, who am I thinking of? You know, when somebody comes up on stage and they just do this Ethel Merman, like and it's like, we don't put that in movies.
[1:31:25] Brent Black: You mean like Audra McDonald or Laura Benanti or someone like that?
[1:31:28] Jess: Sure, sure. Well, Laura Benanti's got a very, very tight vibrato, and I think actually Anna Kendrick has a similar thing where it's it's like closer to that Regina Spektor hip, like um, you know, it almost calls back to a Billy Holiday like older jazz thing. And when Anna Kendrick does the full-on musical theater sound, yes, there is vibrato, but when has she been in the movie that didn't call for it?
[1:31:55] Brent Black: I would argue that Into the Woods and Last Five Years both called for a little bit more of a Broadway sound.
[1:32:03] Jess: Pitch Perfect. Like all those films.
[1:32:06] Brent Black: I haven't seen those, turns out.
[1:32:09] Jess: So you're saying that she really lays it on in those movies?
[1:32:12] Brent Black: She lays it on as thick as she does in any of the other films she's in. Interesting.
[1:32:17] Jess: Um I actually wrote a cheese rating. I didn't know if I was supposed to check it out.
[1:32:22] Brent Black: Yes, please.
[1:32:23] Jess: My cheese rating is La La Limburger, because I don't like Limburger. Um, I'm gonna just say a couple of good things about this, because I've been such a prick about it, but okay. The cinematography and production design for my money is immaculate. The uh use of color is amazing. There's gorgeous shots throughout, a lot of impressive shots where they went 20 seconds or more without cutting. Like you said, it's cool that Gosling actually plays the piano because there's so many movies that fake it. Um it's also cool that Gosling and Emma Stone actually performed the dances and got it in one take. Um I liked the line about LA, they worship everything and value nothing. It's brilliant. Unfortunately, they also don't value how musicals work, but it's still a great line.
[1:33:12] Brent Black: Um, but we've talked about how Sebastian's a dick. I compiled a list that I'd like to rattle off of evidence that he's a dick, and most of it's in the first half hour when we're getting to know him. He makes a point to shame Mia on the highway in two different ways. He keeps a stool in his living room that no one's allowed to sit on. Uh he will not clean and organize his home until he opens his own jazz club. He insists that any woman he dates must already like jazz. He's snippy with a server after she just says, Welcome back. Uh, he bumps hard into Mia's shoulder, doesn't apologize. Um, he's mad, Mia requested Iran right after playing Take on Me. Uh, calls himself a serious musician in that context.
Later, the whole, you know, picking her up by honking instead of knocking on the door when it's her apartment in LA, that's douchey. And then after driving all the way to Nevada and convincing her to go back, like when he comes to pick her up the next morning, he waits like three seconds after checking his watch before he's ready to drive off. He's a dick. He's such a dick.
[1:34:21] Andrew: And I know, Andrew, you feel like there's uh I guess some meta element to that that's either more realistic or whatever, but it just makes me not really give a shit if he's falling in love with someone because I'm like yelling at Emma Stone, like, look, there's a better guy for you. There's a better guy for you out there. Stop it.
[1:34:47] Andrew: That's a great point. Also, have you seen Falsettos?
[1:34:48] Brent Black: I think the one thing that lends credence to Andrew's point is uh Mia ends up with someone that loves her in the end and he doesn't.
[1:34:52] Brent Black: Okay, Marvin is a total asshole.
[1:34:56] Andrew: I I think that I'm I I have to put a little crowbar separation in between a movie. Anyway, look, they're uh but yeah, Marvin's a total asshole.
[1:35:06] Brent Black: No, no, the other guy.
[1:35:08] Andrew: Mendel.
[1:35:09] Brent Black: No, no, the other guy, Mendel.
[1:35:11] Andrew: Mendel?
[1:35:12] Brent Black: Yes. I don't think Mendel's as creepy as you think, but I also think that's because Bill Finn, who super name drop, was my teacher was a little bit more.
[1:35:21] Andrew: Oh shit.
[1:35:22] Brent Black: So um Mendel was a character written at a time when his creepiness was played more for laughs. I think in 2016 it absolutely is creepier, but I don't know. Falsettos is a show that I got into in my early 20s, so I grandfathered in my understanding of it. But anyway, yeah, Mendel, it's it's weird. He asks anyway. That's the that's another episode. Um I think it could be portrayed like acted better. I think it's always been miscasted. That's my opinion.
[1:35:54] Andrew: Mendel's hard.
[1:35:55] Brent Black: Yeah, Mendel's a real hard role uh to get right, but I think that La La Land leaned too heavily on Ryan Gosling being attractive. Like, if you had Michael Cera in the role, but he was really charming and you really liked him, and you really or or even if you didn't like him but you knew why he was doing what he was doing, it would have been a better movie.
[1:36:18] Jess: Um, this is like a universe where telephone technology sometimes exists and the characters are sometimes aware of it, but sometimes not. Like, Mia can't text Sebastian about why she isn't at the movie with him. Sebastian can't text that he's outside when he picks her up. Uh, he can't text that he's gonna miss her show, and then a casting agent has absolutely no way of getting in touch with her, even though every casting agent in town probably has a resume, which would have her contact info. Um in the end, like I think the ideal way to watch this movie is on a plane, but not on your seatback TV. On the person across the aisle's seatback TV, where you can't hear it, you just see it. And just to see it with no sound, it seems beautiful and meaningful, and you never have to hear all the ways in which it's not.
[1:37:15] Brent Black: Um I think that's the best possible way.
[1:37:19] Andrew: You're gonna miss all the really good jazz in it, though.
[1:37:23] Brent Black: Ah, yeah, that good authentic jazz explained to us by a privileged white guy. Tell us more about the black people who made this music you love.
[1:37:33] Andrew: Maybe John Legend should have played Ryan Gosling.
[1:37:38] Brent Black: Would have probably been a more charming character.
[1:37:42] Andrew: I disagree. I've seen him in Jesus Christ Superstar.
[1:37:45] Brent Black: I just I don't think he was supposed to be charming. I I think that that's just a misunderstanding that he's not supposed to be charming at all.
[1:37:53] Jess: Well, again, you know, it's the thing is that I think Andrew, you came to this movie to your credit with a more open mind that anything could happen in this movie. And when I saw CinemaScope, and I saw the logo they put at the beginning of the movie, and I saw what they were going for in the opener. I went, oh, okay. I'm immediately applying structural expectations to this. And so, yeah, like the movie may well have been like, yeah, no, we're gonna make him a jerk, and that's kind of the point.
[1:38:22] Brent Black: Well, that's fine. The first thing he does in the movie is is honk at somebody in the highway. Like, that's this that's our introduction to the character. You really think they don't understand what that does, like for expectations? Like, oh, this guy's a dick.
[1:38:36] Andrew: I mean, you've got a good point there, but at the same time, it there feels like there's like a Zack Snyder obliviousness with the filmmaking here. Like, the way that the Watchmen film is very true to a lot of the visual elements of the graphic novel, but simultaneously misses the point a lot of the time. Like, I don't trust the filmmaking team here to always know what they're doing. But again, if you're if you're like looking at it through the lens of he's supposed to be a dick, then it's spot on. And seeing him grow a little bit and be nice to Mia later feels like, oh, he's growing. But for me, I guess I just like my romantic love interest to be likable. Hell, Sweeney Todd has more redeemable, interesting qualities than this guy.
[1:39:26] Brent Black: He kills everyone he meets.
[1:39:29] Andrew: Yeah. That's his most redeeming quality.
[1:39:33] Jess: Jess loves murder, but uh no.
[1:39:36] Andrew: Alright, alright, alright. It's more likable. Let's wrap this up. It's uh push in two hours now, kids. Thank you guys. It was really great. Brent, I'm so glad you're here. Like, it was very great debates we've had tonight.
[1:39:51] Brent Black: It's been so much fun. I had fun too, and again, sorry for talking too much, but gosh, it was fun, and uh it's it's great to talk about this stuff with you guys as well.
[1:40:02] Jess: Yeah. Anytime you want to come back, let us know. But now we gotta chill and do the usual thing. So thank you guys for listening to our show. Please download our show on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, all that nonsense that we're on. Follow us on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Instagram at Musical Theater Lives. Our YouTube page is also Musical Theater Lives. If you want to send us a question, email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Um also we're having a raffle for our iTunes reviews. Um whoever puts an iTunes review on, you'll be entered into a raffle for an Amazon gift card. So if you enter in, there's a chance you could win. So go on ahead. Brent, I know you've got a lot of stuff you want to promote, so let's get to promoting.
[1:40:43] Brent Black: Oh my goodness. Okay, so uh on YouTube for the last 10 years, I've combined musical theater with video game music in a series called the with lyrics series. You can check that out at YouTube.com slash Brentalfloss. Uh for you musical theater fans, I'm also working slowly on a Star Trek parody musical, and I've actually got a Facebook page where you can follow the progress of that. That's Facebook.com slash Trek Parody Musical. Uh, I'm on a news and politics podcast called Trends Like These on the Maximum Fun Network. And I'm also the co-creator of a really, really fun party game called Use Your Words. It's available on all the uh current gen consoles as well as Steam and the Wii U. More information about that at UseYourWords.lol.
[1:41:29] Jess: I can endorse that. I played it with my family tonight. It's crazy fun.
[1:41:33] Brent Black: Hey, thanks.
[1:41:35] Jess: And yeah, thank you guys for listening. Um, I'm Jess.
[1:41:39] Andrew: And I'm Andrew.
[1:41:42] Brent Black: And I'm Brent.
[1:41:43] Jess: And we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
