"Rebecca, wherever you are your heart is restless like the wild and open sea..." Grab your burning staircase and litigation papers because this week we're joined by Blake Ross the creator of Burnt on BPN to talk about "Rebecca das Musical" it's a great episode and you may learn a thing or two!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
About
"Rebecca, wherever you are your heart is restless like the wild and open sea..." Grab your burning staircase and litigation papers because this week we're joined by Blake Ross the creator of Burnt on BPN to talk about "Rebecca das Musical" it's a great episode and you may learn a thing or two!
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:06] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.
[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:10] Jesse McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.
[0:13] Andrew DeWolf: And Andrew, we have an extra super special guest.
[0:16] Jesse McInally: Ooh, a super special guest.
[0:18] Andrew DeWolf: That's even more special than they usually are, I think.
[0:20] Jesse McInally: Extra super special.
[0:21] Andrew DeWolf: They add legitimacy to us.
[0:23] Jesse McInally: Um legitimacy, we need that.
[0:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, we're the most legitimate podcast in the world.
[0:28] Jesse McInally: Andrew, please join me in welcoming the co-founder of Broadway at Work, former longtime editor-in-chief of Playbill.com, and the host and reporter of the Burnt the show on Broadway Podcast Network.
[0:40] Andrew DeWolf: That is about the show that set Broadway ablaze.
[0:43] Jesse McInally: It is.
[0:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[0:53] Jesse McInally: You did it.
[0:55] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, we're having some mic issues now.
[0:57] Jesse McInally: Oh my goodness, Blake.
[0:58] Blake Ross: It's a ghost of Rebecca haunting my microphone.
[1:03] Jesse McInally: She tied it in.
[1:04] Blake Ross: She tied it in.
[1:05] Jesse McInally: Keep it in, Bree.
[1:06] Blake Ross: You gotta add some ooky spooky noises underneath it, too.
[1:11] Jesse McInally: Raback!
[1:14] Blake Ross: You know what? That's a great cue.
[1:16] Jesse McInally: This week we are talking about Rebecca Das Musical!
[1:20] Andrew DeWolf: Cue of the music, Bree.
[1:30] ♪ Musical number: "Life Seems Your Soul Has a Law" — performed by the cast of Rebecca Das Musical ♪
[2:02] Jesse McInally: Rebecca Das Musical is a musical with music by Sylvester Levet and lyrics by Michael Coons and a book by Michael Kunze. It is based on Rebecca by Daphne de Maurier, um, which you might also know as the one that wrote the Book of the Birds, um, another Hitchcock favorite. Uh, premiered on September 28th, 2006 at the Raymond Theater in Vienna, Austria, where it ran for three years. Subsequent productions have been mounted in Finland, Korea, Japan, and elsewhere, but notably not on Broadway. We'll get into that a little bit later. Um, the plot, which adheres closely to the original novel, revolves around a wealthy Maxim DeWinter, his naive new wife named I, and Mrs. Danvers, the manipulative housekeeper of DeWinter's Cornish estate, Manderley. Miss Danvers resents the new wife's intrusion and persuades the new wife that she is unworthy to be the replacement of Rebecca, the former wife that tragically died. A lot of shit goes down, and it's a mess.
[3:04] Andrew DeWolf: It is a wild one.
[3:06] Jesse McInally: So, we're having you on, Blake, because right now you have a very long in-depth podcast story called Burnt about the entire history of Rebecca, including its tumultuous attempt to get on Broadway, which failed horribly.
[3:21] Blake Ross: Yes.
[3:21] Jesse McInally: Well.
[3:23] Blake Ross: Yeah, well no, I was gonna say the best part about it is that really the musical, which is so over the top and dramatic and the airs on the ridiculous, but we'll get into it, is the very least of the entire story.
[3:35] Jesse McInally: Mm-hmm.
[3:36] Blake Ross: Um, we don't really want to get into that because we don't want to be replacement value for Burnt. Burnt is its own thing. But if you could give me the like less than one-minute description of the legal issues for Andrew and the audience, like as short as you can.
[3:51] Blake Ross: Let's do it. So it very basically it centers around this man named Ben Spreck. He is this sort of big wave in the 80s and 90s off-Broadway scene, and he becomes a man obsessed with a musical, Rebecca, and he just takes any measures that he possibly could to get it to Broadway, including falling into business with this absolute crook, mini Madoff style guy. There's a fake death, there's sabotage by one of his own employees. There's multiple perp walks involved, there's jail time, there's my own finding people in jail and getting the jail, you know, you have a call from, which was very exciting for me because I love true crime. Um, and it all ends up where everybody gets burnt. Nobody gets unscathed in this entire story of trying, and it's what makes it so great is it's the fact that it's all about bringing a musical to Broadway, which is like silly and ridiculous and like you know, fun and camp. It's broadly musical, but somehow it became like this true crime, ridiculous roundabout story.
[5:11] Jesse McInally: That is a great ad for Burnt. And Andrew, it's a kind of frame for you, like after that musical ended, that a bunch of Americans try to take it and then messed it up so bad that no one will ever bring this to America.
[5:23] Andrew DeWolf: They messed it up so bad that there's people in jail from it.
[5:26] Blake Ross: I mean, how do you even do that?
[5:29] Andrew DeWolf: Multiple people in jail for it, Andrew.
[5:31] Blake Ross: Multiple people in jail because of this show.
[5:34] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[5:36] Jesse McInally: I'm impressed.
[5:37] Andrew DeWolf: That yeah.
[5:38] Blake Ross: It happens. People think the life of the Broadway person is so Pollyanna, that's all singing your feelings. But sometimes it's about going to jail.
[5:45] Jesse McInally: And that's the part I love.
[5:50] Blake Ross: Every good Broadway story ends in a court case.
[5:53] Jesse McInally: We all know this.
[5:54] Blake Ross: Yes, of course. He has said that in many, many episodes, and that has made me believe that Rebecca, that story, not Rebecca the musical, needs to be a Broadway musical.
[6:03] Blake Ross: Well, I'm gonna be the one who writes it because damn if I didn't spend a lot of time enmeshed in these characters. It's it's a lot of twists and turns and a lot of really weird characters that you couldn't make up.
[6:10] Blake Ross: You couldn't make up. But I hope people will listen to it. It is a good ride. Whether or not you're a musical person, or if you're like an Andrew who's just dipping their toe in the Broadway pond. If you like, you know, creeps, you might like Burnt.
[6:33] Andrew DeWolf: I will say I listened to all episodes. It was a wild ride. I loved it. Your narration throughout it was incredible. I really highly recommend it.
[6:41] Jesse McInally: But you know what, Blake? You spent all this time dedicated to Rebecca. You must really love this show a lot, I'm sure.
[6:48] Blake Ross: Um, it's a show that I've watched. Um, I should say that we watched that all three of us watched a bootlegged version from the German musical version, Rebecca, das musical. Um, and so it's it is always hard, but you know, this is your jobs, it's not my job. But it is always hard to sort of uh judge a musical watching a bootleg, but it's an interesting, it's an interesting musical.
[7:17] Andrew DeWolf: I will I I understand that, but also we're strangely I I can't imagine an anti-bootleg thing, especially when you're across the world and this was 10 years ago.
[7:26] Blake Ross: I I don't know how we could ever watch this show.
[7:29] Andrew DeWolf: There would have been no I agree.
[7:31] Blake Ross: There would have been no other way, and frankly, I don't know if I would have wanted to watch it another way. Like it just so campy and ridiculous that I don't know that I would want to have watched it another way than sitting in my house with a sleeve of Oreos, my head in my hand, and just saying, what the fuck is this shit?
[7:51] Andrew DeWolf: I I did not expect to walk into this podcast on the the Rebecca defense train.
[7:57] Blake Ross: Um but I kind of liked it.
[7:59] Andrew DeWolf: How strongly can you defend it though?
[8:01] Blake Ross: It's not I mean it does Andrew Lloyd Webber better than Andrew Lloyd Webber has for the last 10 years.
[8:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah, yeah, yeah.
[8:09] Blake Ross: Y'all is podcast cannot spicy take right there.
[8:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, yeah, that compared to School of Rock, yeah.
[8:16] Blake Ross: This is why I said before we started recording why I often agree with Andrew.
[8:23] Jesse McInally: I don't blame anyone who often agrees with Andrew. The reason why I have him on this show is because I love his opinion so much.
[8:29] Blake Ross: I'm interested now, Andrew. Will you do me the honor of describing me the plot of Rebecca?
[8:35] Andrew DeWolf: Please.
[8:36] Blake Ross: Oh Lord. It it's kind of pretty simple, but it's all like wrapped up in itself and in like weird twists and and mysteries. But when you get down to it, not that much actually happens.
[8:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's that's the biggest issue with this show, is it kind of meanders.
[8:51] Blake Ross: Yeah, so there is um the main character who uh I'm not forgetting their name.
[8:56] Andrew DeWolf: They don't have a name.
[8:57] Blake Ross: Their name is I.
[8:58] Andrew DeWolf: Their name is I.
[9:00] Blake Ross: Or uh you didn't do bring that over because that would just make Ben Brantley's time much easier.
[9:11] Andrew DeWolf: Beautiful wife, and and Ick is um an employee for this mean woman who doesn't stick around very long, and and they're staying at a hotel in France, I believe it's France.
[9:26] Blake Ross: Um Monte Carlo.
[9:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and um there's this rich gentleman who has recently uh lost his wife, who is Rebecca, um, and he is also at the hotel, and for really no real reason other than I guess he thinks she's pretty, he invites her to the mountains.
[9:45] Blake Ross: Yeah, it's it's true love.
[9:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um love at first sight, and then immediately asks her to marry him, and of course she says yes because um she loves him, I guess a lot, you know, after like one hour.
[9:59] Blake Ross: Um then they move back to his house, where um she is just constantly treated horribly by him, by the one of the lead servants there who like worships Rebecca.
[10:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[10:17] Blake Ross: Mrs. Danvers, who like literally is she's like the voice of Rebecca in the show, in a way. She is just overly creepy and weird and treats uh the lead like garbage the entire show.
[10:31] Andrew DeWolf: And then as the best part of the show.
[10:34] Blake Ross: She is also the best part of the show, sadly. Um and then after you know, assaulting uh her several times, eventually um her her husband um finally admits that he he murdered Rebecca um because she smiled at him too meanly.
[10:54] Andrew DeWolf: Bravo.
[10:56] Blake Ross: I mean, Rebecca admittedly, Rebecca was like cheating on him and a bunch of stuff. Although I don't know if you can really say murder was justified there uh at all.
[11:05] Andrew DeWolf: You need you forgot to say who she was cheating on.
[11:07] Blake Ross: Oh, I mean, yeah, of course.
[11:09] Andrew DeWolf: It's it's her cousin.
[11:11] Blake Ross: No, this is a man that knows how to marry his cousin.
[11:15] Andrew DeWolf: She likes to fuck her cousin.
[11:17] Blake Ross: Uh she loves it. Just like Rudy Giuliani. We can't blame her.
[11:21] Andrew DeWolf: And then she also when she died, the cousin keeps coming to the house to steal money, uh, because he is just a uh fine gentleman, uh who and she obviously had very good taste.
[11:31] Blake Ross: Um so then she gets murdered um by uh the husband, Maxim Maxim, who I I think I haven't said his name yet. Maxim, who is the husband, uh, and the entire second half is about Maxim getting away with murder and the lead helping him do so. Uh and then the house burns down and everyone everyone lives happily ever after.
[11:51] Andrew DeWolf: The the house burning down is really fucking cool, but it does look very like the visuals in the show are better than the show.
[11:59] Blake Ross: Anything I've seen on Broadway. Like literally, that's I brought this up before in a lot of our um other European shows. They do it visuals better than we ever have.
[12:09] Andrew DeWolf: I was gonna say, isn't this we've seen another German show which was uh hunchback?
[12:15] Blake Ross: Yeah, the hunchback. Which also looks really good.
[12:18] Andrew DeWolf: Looks better than anything.
[12:19] Blake Ross: Yeah. Well, you guys, okay. I know I'm talking to a bunch of dudes here, you know. You know, they set the stage on fire.
[12:25] Andrew DeWolf: So, so like, whoops, it's fire, fine.
[12:30] Blake Ross: Which is very sweet and great. However, I should say it was a $14 million musical, which in those days was kind of like a, you know, this was 10 years ago, which was kind of, you know, a lot of money, which nowadays kind of standard, but it was a lot of money. But that show in Germany was so cheap looking, except for the fact that they set the stage on fire at the end.
[12:55] Andrew DeWolf: That was the cool part.
[12:55] Blake Ross: They set the stage on fire. It wasn't everything.
[12:59] Andrew DeWolf: But then after they spent all their money.
[13:02] Blake Ross: There was like one prop, and like everything else was a script, but it was like one prop, the entire musical.
[13:08] Andrew DeWolf: Sorry, I just wasn't, yeah.
[13:09] Blake Ross: How much everything on fire, I guess.
[13:11] Andrew DeWolf: They would have had to spend to give the lead a name.
[13:15] Blake Ross: How much does the name go for nowadays?
[13:18] Andrew DeWolf: Our main character.
[13:19] Blake Ross: Uh oh. Don't have the budget for that one.
[13:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um jokes aside, um, I know you've got a deep, deep history with this Blake. I know you you're gonna have a lot of thoughts here.
[13:31] Blake Ross: I know you don't like this show. You you don't like what it says. You don't like a lot of it, I imagine.
[13:38] Blake Ross: No, well, else let me say this. Michael Kunze and Sylvester Levet, who wrote the musical, are are the Andrew Lloyd Webbers of their town in Europe. They wrote very successful musicals. Rebecca is one of them. I mean, it's one of the most um toured show in Asia. It played forever in Germany. I mean, it was a hit. Michael Kunze also brought Dance of the Vampires here, which was a humongous mess.
[14:08] Blake Ross: And I couldn't imagine sitting in that theater as Ben Sprecher, the lead producer, did, and watched it and become so enamored with it.
[14:18] Blake Ross: It's basically a rip-off of a rip-off of Phantom.
[14:22] Blake Ross: I mean, everything about it, they have a Mrs.
[14:24] Blake Ross: Van Hopper, who's basically Carlotta, right? She's the funny sort of overweight, fancy rich woman. She's there, right? So she's the Carlotta. Then they have the brother and the sister who are sort of funny. That's like the two opera owners. They have a masquerade ball.
[14:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was gonna say that.
[14:47] Blake Ross: That's phantom. They have the little trinket that was Rebecca's. Remember, like the she has a little trinket at her desk that was Rebecca's trinket. That's the music box. I mean, so it's it is so I can't imagine watching it and thinking other than this is a poor man's phantom of the opera. And again, the music is I agree with you, Andrew. The music is quite beautiful, it's great, but just the production itself, I couldn't imagine saying to myself at that moment in time, after having a production of Phantom of the Opera running for 20 years, uh making billions of dollars, and thinking, you know what? I think I think this show, which uh has it speaks so poorly of women that she doesn't even have a name. She's called like a little fool. She's uh it's so like caught in its time. I think that should be the show that I obsess about so much that I lose everything over.
[15:44] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna counter you with respect. I agree with everything you're saying with Jekyll and Hyde.
[15:50] Blake Ross: Yeah, I was gonna say this is a wild board. That is the poor man's phantom done in America, and it made a lot of money.
[15:57] Andrew DeWolf: Agree.
[15:57] Blake Ross: Well, that's a fine, but that also had David Hasselhoff. It had like, remember they brought in the guy plays Hasselhoff. You can't hassle off. But once again, it didn't start with the Javelhoff, it just had Robert Cuccioli and all that at first. But that yes, I think it wasn't good until Hasselhoff touched it. That music, that musical did a great job of making a shit ton of money.
[16:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, which is why I can understand. All right, that was fan Diet Phantom. If we do our own version of Diet Phantom with a little more sure, you're Euro Poppy, you're a poppy, and the story can be interesting if you like you know gothic tales of ghosts and stuff like that.
[16:45] Blake Ross: So I'm not and the I mean I am a fan of the Hitchcock film, yeah. Um, because how could you not be? It's Hitchcock. But to me, it just was a little cheesy as we're talking to musical species. It to me, it had a bit of a yellow on it. And that's I agree with that, but also this has about 20 more songs than Phantom does. So I mean, Phantom's got five songs and then they repeat like 20 times, plus 20 more songs that all sound the same. Does it really that Miss Man uh Miss Mandalay, Miss Stanver sings this song Rebecca, which is an earworm of a song? Oh, yes. I'm into it, but man, did that do they have like 12 reprises of that song? She sings no other song except that's a oh bro, rub and it gets into your soul, it gets into your old one you can remember at the end of it, too.
[17:37] Andrew DeWolf: You're right. You're you are the name of your musical because I didn't realize that that was the name of like the tourist that's like, come into it. It was rubber. Come into Broadway. Come, like, I'm gonna go see this. And they're like, oh, do you remember any of the songs? I was one that was like Rabaka. Like a Midwest mom that's like, I remember that. I remember it.
[18:05] Blake Ross: Well, I but I do have to say that version. So so what happens, what was supposed to happen was Christopher Hampton, who wrote um the less dangerous what's the leason danger. Yes. And he um recently wrote The Father, one an Oscar for it. Like he he's humongous. He was supposed to come and doctor the whole thing with Michael Kunza. So they were it was it was to transition from this very European Euro poppy type musical into um something that was perhaps more palatable for the Broadway stage. Um so again, we were watching the German Das musical version, which is different. It is different. And I even just the casting choices, like Sierra Bogus is a great comic actress. I hope they would have leaned more into that.
Given her more of a look to the audience, like, can you imagine that? Can you believe this situation I'm in? Because it is a wacky situation. And if you made I or Ick a little more aware of what a crazy situation she's in, it would kind of add to her character rather than. She's like so naive through the entire thing. It's like painful. And she has a beautiful, beautiful voice. The singers in this are amazing. So if anybody has the the wherewithal or the want to go and get the actual album, I would um suggest that because it is or you could find some of the songs on YouTube because they belt the hell out of the score. Um beautiful voices, and I would have loved to have heard Sierra Bogas on some of these songs.
[19:48] Andrew DeWolf: Agree. But yes, she does come in as a little church mouse, ech, whatever her name is. She comes in as a church mouse and is in a church mouse the entire time. She's literally a quote paid companion. That is her job to an old lady, which I guess in the 40s was like a thing where you paid young ladies to make it 90 pounds a year or something.
[20:10] Blake Ross: Exactly. To make my titles a year and beer and accompany you places. So there was lots of dated material here. But yes, that was her that was her job. And then she comes in and like Andrew said, she falls in love immediately for no reason at all with the star Max. Their first date is like he they go to a mountain and he has like an anxiety attack, and then they go home.
[20:38] Andrew DeWolf: Man, I've had I've had worse first dates, you know.
[20:41] Blake Ross: I was gonna say, I I didn't get married until I was 37, kids. So I had a lot of bad first dates with bad anxiety attacks in them, but that's a whole other podcast. What do you think? Did you get married the next day on those dates though?
[20:56] Andrew DeWolf: I did not get married the next day. I did not. I waited a whole week, Andrew. I waited a modern lady. My husband remembered my husband actually gave me a name. And it wasn't just his last name.
[21:12] Blake Ross: Exactly. This is Mrs. Mrs.
[21:15] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it was I it was highly entertaining way to watch musical, I do have to say. So thank you for giving me the opportunity. Because honestly, when I was researching this, I didn't watch the whole musical. I kind of I had seen parts of it. I saw commercials for it, I had seen clips of it on YouTube. But I didn't have banner in Times Square. I I know the whole story around it, but I hadn't watched the entire musical because I didn't really want to. I didn't really want to have any feelings about it either way, um, in investigating it. I kind of just wanted to tell the story, and it really wasn't about the musical so much, much as about the crazy shit that happened bringing the musical to Broadway or trying to at least. Um, so this gave me a chance to watch it, and gosh, oh, it was a lot of musical. It was a lot.
[22:01] Blake Ross: It is a lot of musical with a lot of weird dated gender politics. Why is this one of the most performed shows in Europe and across the world? What what drives people to see it that aren't Americans?
[22:12] Andrew DeWolf: It's the Jekyll and Hyde effect, I think. Didn't that get really popular too?
[22:16] Blake Ross: Yeah. It's the Frank Wildhorn effect. He's big in Korea. Just like you just give him a bunch of ballads, and then people are like, all right, this is what musicals are. Lots of scene, a lot of ballads. I honestly, that's what I mean. It just goes back to what I was saying. I can't imagine sitting in that theater and thinking this would be palatable for for New York audiences or for Broadway audiences. It just um, I think also the fact that it was so phantom adjacent to me was like, oof. And I also I probably again, which is the reason why I didn't watch it earlier. I had so Ben Sprecker, this was supposed to be his phantom of the Opera. The entire this that was his goal. Andrew Lloyd Webber came to the readings because he and Sierra Bogas had been working together.
So this was all about. I mean, Andrew Lloyd Webber was mentioned in this man's picture deck more than the woman that was starring I more than her. Andrew Lloyd Webb was in his pitch deck documents to investors. So he was so obsessed with Andrew Lloyd Weber and Phantom and having that be his big ticket. Um that but I just I can't imagine watching it and thinking this is better than the Phantom of the Opera.
[23:26] Andrew DeWolf: I'll bring this. I don't think he wanted better. He just wanted money. He's like, this is close. People will see this also, maybe. The masquerade was just there was the masquerade and her coming down the stairs, which is literally like one of the most iconic musical moments. When she came down the stairs, I was like, my goodness, this is too much.
[23:47] Blake Ross: Okay. Top five Broadway are musical theater staircases. Number one Rebecca, Rebecca, the best musical staircase.
[23:57] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'd say number two, um, Dolly, when she comes down the stairs.
[24:03] Blake Ross: That's a good one. Yes.
[24:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um, three masquerade. Um, four, I'm pretty sure Quasimoto had to walk down a stairway in the playhouse version. I like when they have like the rolling staircases and they push them around on. And yeah, that was gonna be my fifth one. You're in town, where they're pushing around the staircases in your town.
[24:18] Blake Ross: That's your top five computer staircases. Hamilton has good staircases in it that they passed that they yeah, you're right. But you know what? that's it. We I don't think Hamilton needs more awards.
[24:33] Andrew DeWolf: No, it doesn't mean forget about Hamilton. But I will, but I did think, like, wow, this the grandeur of this palatial mansion was like I mean, like Beauty and the Beast. If you remember some of the sets, and I again, we're not watching the Broadway version. I would have actually loved to have seen what they did on Broadway and how they brought it here. Because Benjamin the Opera was made for $8 million in 1988. That would have been like 20 million dollars. It's one of the most opulent musicals ever to have graced the Broadway stage. I mean, like you can't, everywhere you go was the flickering lights and the smoke and just drapery and gold and it's gothic. This was like again, it had a staircase. Sure. It was a really cool staircase. I mean, there was another staircase with the boathouse. That was pretty cool too.
[25:24] Blake Ross: Yeah, there's a lot of staircase staircase. There was the lattice stairs. Really fancy. You think of a notion there. Is this what we're doing musicals to now? Like their transportation. Remember one floor to another? Give it a Tony.
[25:49] Andrew DeWolf: It's a lot. This is a weird thing to appreciate. I usually hate projections, but I like the way they use projections in this musical. Um, it wasn't just like here's the background, like they did in the Lay Miz revival, and it's just like that. That's our background. It's like in between cutting off or a continuation of the set. I thought that was a cool use of projections. But I agree with you. And again, this was 10 years ago, right? So this was a long time ago. It probably, if it would have been in today's iteration, probably would have been a little bit cooler with all the with the spectacle of that. So I agree with you on that.
[26:21] Blake Ross: Oh, I did write one other thing where I was like, Are they serious? There's literally a song that she sings about being the woman in white. Oh, just an Andrew Lloyd Webber musical. You're right. There's just a lot of yeah. I will say I prefer Miss Danvers to Madame Giri. I I really wanted there to be a ghost the whole first half, and then they never did.
[26:46] Andrew DeWolf: That's too that's too close to family opera. Can't can't make it be a real ghost.
[26:50] Blake Ross: Like he's we could have had a real he's a fake ghost, though. I want a real ghost. I will I wanted Rebecca to come back and like ask her to come back and be like haha and still to be the reveal that like like like uh miss Miss Danvers or whatever was actually communicating with the dead. Rebecca was still in the house, literally. Your pitch is better than the musical, and then and then the actual reveal is just like the guy's a dick and gets away with murder. A man murders his wife and gets away with it.
[27:22] Andrew DeWolf: The musical we just watched Annette, which is what we're covering next week, and it has the same plot. There's a lot of misogyny here. She kills him. I would like that actually. Uh just no, that would probably still be misogynistic because they just do it. But that would have been a good end. I mean me telling Daphne de Morier what to do, but like if she if he actually was this like horrible, you know, remember that Jennifer Lopez movie where like the husband ends up being like a total creeper and he's like goes after her and then she kills him at the end. Just saying if anybody wants to produce that musical, yeah, exactly. If anyone's actually gone girl, the musical, call me. I'd be into it. What if what if she just goes and she kills him? She kills the cousin. She kills Miss Danvers. She just murders everybody in Act Two. Like everyone dies. A ghost does murders.
[28:00] Blake Ross: I'd be into it. No, no, no, no. The main character does.
[28:14] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Ick. Yeah. We also, we would maybe you give her a name. Maybe. We're not even sure about that in our revision. It'd be like Kill Bill, right? This kill Bill, she doesn't have a name in Kill Bill, right? It's the bride. But what were we saying, Blake?
[28:28] Blake Ross: No, I was gonna say the sh this the ship sinking song. You know, like when they're in the ocean and the ship is sinking and they're like, the ship is sinking. I like that song. I liked that scene. I like we'll go into the songs a little bit. Just saying things I like because I hate to be a hater. I didn't want to come on. That's what we do here. I want my time on musicals with cheese to be drinking the haters.
[28:55] Blake Ross: Um say this like this is your only time coming here.
[28:58] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't, I didn't want that for myself. But listen, life takes you places, man. This is gonna be a bunch of angry Europeans.
[29:05] Blake Ross: Exactly.
[29:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, now they're really gonna be mad. We cut our European audience just in half right there.
[29:21] Blake Ross: Well, I mean, speaking of what audiences think. I mean, I guess we have to. It's time to compare our opinions to those of the theater critics when this came out. It's time for breews without Brie.
[29:29] Andrew DeWolf: We miss you, Brie. Please come back. We're we're a mess without you sometimes.
[29:35] Blake Ross: It's time for it. It's time for previews.
[29:42] Andrew DeWolf: So, Variety took a look at the original 2006 Vienna production, and they wrote a glowing review, like an absolutely glowing review, which is interesting, mostly because like I don't quite know how Variety is in other places that aren't America, but I just don't imagine them loving this as much as they did.
[30:01] Blake Ross: Like one of the it rang wrong to my ears. I'm not a journalist or anything, but it feels like Variety really. Do you know who wrote it?
[30:09] Andrew DeWolf: It just was it was credited to the Variety staff.
[30:14] Blake Ross: I have no idea because I tried to look. Um and it just is basically like um Kunza's deft lyrics take us on a deep into the psyches of the never named heroine, simply called I, Moody McCurial, Maxim DeWinter, obsessive Miss Danvers, and even the late Rebecca herself. LeVay knows how to write tunes that jam in your head. He delivers the goods with Miss Danvers haunting Rebecca and the anthem, The Power of a Woman in Love.
[30:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, that's that's basically the tone of the rest of it. But let me see if I can get into the performances a bit. Ewa Kroger has uh built a substantial career on his pretty boy look. His singing while in passion is merely adequate, but he rises to the challenge as confessing his hatred for Rebecca, and no smile was ever as cold. Mrs. Danvers gets the best music, and in Susan, Rigvava Dumas has found a perfect interpreter with a rich mezzo-soprano as her weapon. She embodies evil born of passion and jealousy in a multi-layered turn.
[31:15] Blake Ross: They were into the show. They really were, which I don't know why it surprised me so much. Um, but it was like wow, glowing except for Ila Kroger. Or Ela. But listen, Mike Kunza and Sylvester Levet are A-O-K. Yes, so who gives a crap if they come to Broadway?
[31:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um I did not enjoy Dance of Vampires, I'll tell you that.
[31:39] Blake Ross: Yeah. When do I get started? Who cares? You're famous and for it's it's a we it all comes back to David Hasselov. You're gonna be Dave Hasselov and be Euro star and make all your money in Euros.
[31:50] Andrew DeWolf: Why not? Euros are almost real money.
[31:53] Blake Ross: It's pretty close. I'd rather make euros than making the US dollar at this point.
[31:59] Andrew DeWolf: Huh. You make great points, both of you. Um you guys just made horrendous statements.
[32:09] Blake Ross: I'm like, great points, everybody. Really good points all around. Um, but I don't you you've worked for Playbill. You've probably had to write a lot of critiques of things. Like, how what do you go into when you see a show and you have to report on it?
[32:24] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Playbill famously does not do because Playbill is the Switzerland of the Broadway.
[32:33] Blake Ross: So you're no Ben Brantley.
[32:35] Andrew DeWolf: I'm no Ben, I'm certainly no Ben Brantley. But I do have the thing I love so much about the theater is going to the theater, either loving it. Sometimes when you hate watch it's even better than when you when you love watch it. There's a I mean, I do remember watching that revival of um Jacqueline Hyde with Constantine and Deborah, what's her name?
[32:57] Blake Ross: Deborah Cox.
[32:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. And that was a hate watch for the days. I mean, she sang the shit out of that show. She is a voice like no other, but that was a great funny hate watch.
[33:07] Blake Ross: That'll be our next musical with cheese, because that was a lot of show.
[33:10] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. I saw that when it did its pre Broadway tour. And my God, Constantine Marulis. He was not ready for that tour. And apparently he's a he's a real bad guy in real life.
[33:20] Blake Ross: So, like all my didn't know that, but he was super dramatique. My goodness. He like threw his pregnant wife down a set of stairs.
[33:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my wait, what?
[33:32] Blake Ross: Yeah.
[33:33] Andrew DeWolf: On purpose.
[33:34] Blake Ross: No one does it on accident. Um, but yeah, that was a unless you're Max DeWinter.
[33:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, Max DeWinters. Um proven. That was something that there is still like litigation over.
[33:46] Blake Ross: Um that might be an allegedly, but maybe you're I don't know. What I'm saying. I remember it was something that came out after all that. That was one of my favorite nights in the theater, just watching that. Watching Deborah Cox sing her ass off, but watching that production, which was full of cheats. And it was about a half hour too long, too. Like every version of Jackal and Call of Hyde.
[34:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I will say, anytime I see rent, I don't even watch the show anymore. I watch the audience and see how long they make it.
[34:13] Blake Ross: I I know are you gonna go on an anti-rent tiger?
[34:22] Andrew DeWolf: This is your doctor. I gotta be on his side this this time. Rent is uh No.
[34:28] Blake Ross: Guys, the last three times I've seen Rent Live, um, everyone in my area has left before or at intermission.
[34:36] Andrew DeWolf: See, that's where I think the generational thing that I was talking about before we came on, may play into it because I am the gener I believe I'm the generation before you guys, and rent was our, you know, rent was everything to us.
[34:51] Blake Ross: So even like rent on Fox, which was like ridiculous.
[34:55] Andrew DeWolf: That live rent.
[34:56] Blake Ross: Oh, but even that, I mean, it's rent. I think that was an improvement.
[35:00] Andrew DeWolf: I can't believe you hate rent.
[35:02] Blake Ross: Really?
[35:02] Andrew DeWolf: Rent?
[35:03] Blake Ross: Rent is unfinished work. It could have been great. That's how I see it. I'm excited for TikTok boom. I'm I gotta, I'm hopeful that that will be a great movie. They did that City Center version was wonderful. And if my money's on any anything, it's Lynn Meno Morant.
[35:18] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think that's a safe bet at this time.
[35:20] Blake Ross: I was gonna say, you know.
[35:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we're kind of famous for our hate of rent.
[35:26] Blake Ross: Um, we were a little too harsh on it because it was like our second episode. Um, we've since come back and had an actual critique of it.
[35:32] Andrew DeWolf: So wait, did you guys get so much hate?
[35:35] Blake Ross: We didn't get as much as you would think, but we did get a good amount. We got a lot of people like, yeah, I agree with you, and then the millennials would come in like you had to be there at the time, you you idiot. You just don't get it. You don't get us, okay?
[35:53] Andrew DeWolf: Doesn't it doesn't feel edgy enough to me? Like, I feel like we've gotten so much further than this culturally that it just feels like a stale critique of an old culture.
[36:02] Blake Ross: On that note, how about we sell out uh you know the the capitalism and we go into a mid show announcement? Enjoy these ads, you guys.
[36:19] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shh sh at you.
[36:24] Blake Ross: Now we can speak.
[36:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Andrew, tell us about Patreon. What do we got there?
[36:32] Blake Ross: Oh boy, Patreon. We got all sorts of stuff. We got extra content, we got uh full full length like commentary tracks that go over like certain movies and and we have episodes about TV shows that are coming out.
[36:46] Andrew DeWolf: Uh we got all sorts of stuff over there. You can also have the uh video uh of us right now if you if you have a you can see Blake's beautiful face right now.
[36:55] Blake Ross: Oh my gosh, she's doing cartwheels.
[36:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, she's on the ceiling! How to get to the phone you can't prove that she's not get your clothes back on.
[37:07] Blake Ross: Um she maybe for your only fans call it only cheese here though.
[37:16] Andrew DeWolf: Only cheese, you guys have a big uh old mom crowd. That's my kind of my kind of only fans. Sign me up for that.
[37:24] Blake Ross: I can see just on the tip of your lips, though, Blake. I can see you just want to say join join their Patreon. You want to tell people this that you need to join our Patreon.
[37:28] Andrew DeWolf: I can see you want to say it.
[37:28] Blake Ross: Join their Patreon, you guys. I gotta say it! I gotta do it. How could you look at these two fellas? The gorgeousness. How could you not want to be able to do that? The non patrons.
[37:46] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. How could you not want to be seeing us on video for yourself? In fact, all three of us are naked now.
[37:52] Blake Ross: It has become only fans. Join our only fans.
[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: Join our only Jess who are who are our current fans.
[38:01] Blake Ross: Our current OnlyFans participants are Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, that's your mother, John Donna, Danielle Renics, Jessica Stampede, Ewan Cassidy Taskier, Fire September, Monica Thorobe Mina Miniri Blend, Brent Black, Hailey Murray, Lathaniel Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans, Green Carrier Hearn, Mary Lou Shoquet, John Finals.
[38:20] Andrew DeWolf: Heck you, I go by Elijah now. Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Tubboyam, Kyle Summers, Jen A C. Scoot and the Technicolor Dreamcoat, Police A, Liz Lynn, Alison Steller.
[38:29] Blake Ross: Nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes. John Vanaz, Tesbian, Ren Cullen, Wheat Lewin's, Jacob's Droop, Rafael, Martinez Salaz, Robert Benjamin, Rachel T, Jessica T, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keys, Tit Jeffrey Machado, Jacuse, Toon Vanessen, R.
[38:47] Andrew DeWolf: Elliot, Chris Marcote, Katie Cherberg, Mimu, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Leila, RJ Norija, Sebastian Canino, Cinema Geddon Reviews, Avan Regan, Super Antelope, Super Antelope, Lizzie Keynes, and Charlie B.
[39:03] Blake Ross: We had some new ones. I had to look around, baby. Um they give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get all those fun perks that Andrew listed, and some more, come join us over there.
[39:17] Andrew DeWolf: How are we ready to get back to the show?
[39:19] Blake Ross: Mm-hmm.
[39:20] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm.
[39:38] Blake Ross: With a whistle set.
[39:44] Andrew DeWolf: I still hear see.
[40:23] Blake Ross: Let's talk about I Dreamt of Manderley, the opening number, which is also the very famous opening lines of the book.
[40:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[40:30] Blake Ross: Um effective. It's effective in the same way that the opening to Phantom is effective. It made me think there was gonna be a ghost.
[40:37] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna be honest with you.
[40:39] Blake Ross: Again with the ghost. This is it. I mean, there's like the shadowy figures in the background, and then one of them walks up to her. I thought it was through I thought there was gonna be a ghost.
[40:49] Andrew DeWolf: It's I think it's good though. I mean, the song is pretty effective in it's one of the like better dramatic songs early on in the show because then we cut into these like goofy songs with Mrs. Van Hopper and all that, but it yes.
[41:03] Blake Ross: I liked it. I like that opening. So it was a nice opening of musical.
[41:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, and it's iconic in the same way that it represents the uh iconography of the book and the movies, and it takes the one thing that basically everyone knows about Rebecca, which is those opening lines. It's like the call me Ishmael of um from Moby Dick. Like, takes all those and makes them work.
[41:23] Blake Ross: Um there it's really hard to translate prose into lyrics, um, which is why you gotta appreciate the lyrics, lyricists that are really able to do it, like the Dave Malloy's and the Paul Gordon of the world.
[41:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so I appreciate it on that level. It is, it feels like it's writing me a check it doesn't pay, you know.
[41:41] Blake Ross: In what way?
[41:42] Andrew DeWolf: Like, yeah, it makes it seem like the story is much more epic than it really is when really it's more of a gossipy kind of story.
[41:51] Blake Ross: Well, uh again, I don't know if this is a generational thing or what, but Rebecca was not like the, you know, was certainly not like our Moby Dick. It wasn't I I think perhaps Ben Sparker maybe over um emphasized how much of a classic Rebecca was.
[42:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, sure, you know, like it was, but uh that everybody would always know Rebecca.
[42:14] Blake Ross: And oh, last night I dreamt I was at Mandalay again, and everybody knows. I mean it was Alfred Hitchcock's first movie, sure, but I think maybe there was perhaps a little bit of wishful thinking on how much this piece of literature meant to the American heart and soul. Am I wrong?
[42:32] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I didn't read Rebecca when I was in school. I don't I don't think my parents did. And they and they were probably the ticket, the ticket audience that they were going for, you know, like older women, and that's like primarily the people who buy tickets on Broadway.
[42:46] Blake Ross: But like I don't think that they were like, that's such a beloved novel. Am I wrong?
[42:51] Andrew DeWolf: Uh-huh.
[42:52] Blake Ross: No, but neither was Phantom. Phantom was a pulp detective story that was. I'm not saying your your source material necessarily needs to be like a thing, but this was like, you know, everybody knows Rebecca, the tale of Rebecca, and everyone's seen that movie and everybody's watched that, read that book. And I don't know that that's necessarily true.
[43:12] Jesse McInally: I mean, at in Phantom, they don't do an opening number that is the opening number.
[43:16] Blake Ross: Right.
[43:17] Jesse McInally: In fact, they basically throw the book away with Phantom.
[43:20] Blake Ross: They light it on fire and throw it in the garbage and then make their own thing.
[43:23] Jesse McInally: No, they throw it onto the staircase that's already on fire.
[43:26] Blake Ross: Oh, right, right, right.
[43:28] Jesse McInally: Um it's not even I agree with you completely. It's not even like Hitchcock's most famous adaptation of a DeMore book.
[43:35] Blake Ross: Right.
[43:35] Jesse McInally: Yes, exactly.
[43:36] Blake Ross: Exactly.
[43:36] Jesse McInally: Do the birds the musical or bird demic the musical. One of those two.
[43:39] Blake Ross: We definitely need to get more birds on Broadway.
[43:42] Jesse McInally: We can't do Bird Demic right now. It's too too political.
[43:48] Blake Ross: Um let's go on to the another song.
[43:51] Jesse McInally: Oh gosh, there's so many songs in the for the first act, and it's like they kind of wash over you like in a sea of ballads. Um, are you happy? I do kind of want to talk about it because it's both are you happy, are you angry? Because that's another section that I know for a fact is translated right from the book.
[44:07] Blake Ross: Bist du glücklich, can't er tragen.
[44:13] Jesse McInally: Ich bin schwierig, es lebt sich nicht sehr leicht mitweien. Das ist uns still my augen sage. Ich liebe dich maxim. Ich möchte niemals wart von dir. Bist du glücklich? Ich habe noch so viel zu lernen. Manchmal denke ich, dass ich dich dauern. Du bist jung. Wahrscheinlich fehlt dir vieles he.
[44:53] Blake Ross: I remember I or Ick was just like, Are you happy? And he's like, I don't think uh what's happy. Who cares? Like, that's not what you want to hear from your husband.
[45:04] Jesse McInally: And I wanna talk about how, at least in the Vienna production, they really softened up Max. I know that Andrew's like, he's basically abusive.
[45:13] Blake Ross: He was so much worse than the books.
[45:15] Jesse McInally: He was so much worse in most movie adaptations.
[45:19] Blake Ross: Even the movie, yeah.
[45:20] Jesse McInally: How bad can he get? Like he's like he like physically like puts his hands on her and like shakes her and like pushes her down, like whenever she questions him on anything.
[45:29] Blake Ross: It's a lot of gaslighting and distance emotionally. I mean, he is a murderer, so I mean, I guess uh to be expected.
[45:36] Jesse McInally: May maybe also the caricatures. I think even like the Danver's character, while the woman who played her here has again a beautiful voice, and the fact that they give her this song just saying over and over and over again got a little tiring, but she does have a gorgeous voice.
[45:51] Blake Ross: But like Danvers in that movie, Judith Anderson is like the creepiest of creepers. Like really crazy creepy.
[45:59] Jesse McInally: And she was, you know, she was. I just wish they would have gone like if they're gonna go overly over the top, which what this musical was, I wish they would have just gone there and made her like so creepy.
[46:11] Blake Ross: They needed to take a lesson out of Steven Sondheim's book and embrace the Fosca of it all. Like, don't worry if she's likable or if you love having her on stage.
[46:21] Jesse McInally: You gotta that's a great, great comparison. Like Fosca, I mean, like you can't get over the creep and the mole and the clapiness of her. And Danvers, you know, like again, she had a great ballad, but like I wish that she was like more Judith Anderson, where she was like in that movie.
[46:38] Blake Ross: She's again for all your wonderful Patreon watchers, like when she's like physical comedy. Great. Ah, I could watch that for days.
[46:51] Jesse McInally: Didn't they just they kind of like make her hair black in like with a white stripe or something like that?
[46:56] Blake Ross: Yeah, but Andrew, she lets it out when she gets a little unhinged a little bit.
[47:00] Jesse McInally: Oh yeah. She could have been way creepier.
[47:03] Blake Ross: Yes.
[47:03] Jesse McInally: Um, and also uh in in that Hitchcock film, they really kind of leaned into her maybe having a romantic feeling for Rebecca, and it feels like they were trying very hard not to imply that as much here.
[47:17] Blake Ross: They wanted to make sure you knew that Rebecca just loved her cousin.
[47:21] Jesse McInally: Yes, exactly. It wasn't they wanted to make really good.
[47:26] Blake Ross: It wasn't gay.
[47:28] Jesse McInally: Just wanted to be a good one. Sleeping with a cousin. That was the lean heart, the choice. It was an artistic choice.
[47:37] Blake Ross: No. This is a man that knows how to marry his cousin.
[47:42] Jesse McInally: I mean, it's not that uncommon. Rudy Giuliani's married to his cousin and all that.
[47:48] Blake Ross: Is that a good example?
[47:49] Jesse McInally: I'm not saying good old.
[47:54] Blake Ross: It's not, but once again, like Merv and Rudy. Rebecca really is the Rudy Giuliani of this story.
[48:01] Jesse McInally: You know, just make everyone's life work. Please do.
[48:05] Blake Ross: Like Rudy Giuliani. If Rudy Giuliani smiled at you real real nice, you would want to push him down the stairs.
[48:11] Jesse McInally: Oh yes.
[48:11] Blake Ross: Oh god. Okay, I finally can I I understand Maxon's ability. If I'm just imagining Rebecca as Rudy Giuliani and you're just smiling at me.
[48:21] Jesse McInally: Yeah, yeah, you're dead.
[48:23] Blake Ross: Wait, there's another song. Can I can we talk about one other song?
[48:28] Jesse McInally: But I wish it would have gone a little further. It was like the Van Hopper American Woman song, which was obviously funny for German people, watching this, like you know, ha ha ha silly American rich goofy woman.
[48:41] Blake Ross: Then Z.
[48:44] Jesse McInally: I'm an American woman. Ich bin nicht discretisch möchte das man mich.
[48:57] Blake Ross: Also didn't finish right.
[49:32] Jesse McInally: I kind of I appreciated that song. They could have gone so far. It could have been like, remember in Aida when she's the closets open and she's my strongest suit and she's dancing with the dresses. Like I feel like it could have been that kind of moment, like how crazy American one lady. Ha ha ha.
[49:36] Blake Ross: It could have been like the scene from Pacific Overtures where they do like the Uncle Sam cakewalk kind of style.
[49:58] Jesse McInally: Totally. Um I love that song. I also have discovered a new like thing that I love to hear it. It's Germans speaking German with an American accent. It just is something that's like my brain cannot compute what I am hearing.
[50:12] Blake Ross: I mean, you have to think about it. We we have all the like other accents that in our movies, like Russian accents and stuff like that. You know, I'm sure that they have the same thing for us.
[50:23] Jesse McInally: It's great.
[50:25] Blake Ross: Yeah, like Russians have like American characters who are speaking Russian, but in an American accent.
[50:35] Jesse McInally: Um, doing our version of it. Um, that scene is w uh a a lot time when you need it.
[50:44] Blake Ross: Yes, that was a nice little moment. And again, if we're gonna play, you have to that the masquerade ball to me, really. I was the masquerade ball, the Antroloid Rebber fake masquerade ball. Um did me. I will say they they didn't have the audacity of putting it at the start of act two. But I will give them that much credit.
[51:03] Jesse McInally: They didn't close. It was close.
[51:06] Blake Ross: It it is a weird okay. I talk about musical theater structure a lot in this show, um, because I find it fascinating in how it's very different from film structure, which a lot of people have done analysis on. But usually the one that the song that opens act two should really have nothing to do with the plot.
[51:22] Jesse McInally: Whereas like the what did I miss, or it was a real nice clam bake. Um, all those types where it's kind of like everyone sit back down, relax, we're not gonna start for a minute.
[51:32] Blake Ross: Yeah, you get in your seat, get your get your soda cop pop open. No one cares about this song. Here it's like plots back, all right. We're back into it, guys. No, no, there's no breathing time. Sit your ass down, Rebecca's at it. Maybe I'll see her back after all.
[51:44] Jesse McInally: It was very diligent.
[51:46] Blake Ross: Yeah, they they they respect theater, you know. They're like, we're back in our seat, like 10 minutes before. They took their two poops before the musical started.
[51:54] Jesse McInally: That's true. Um, I guess we really have to talk about the most important song in the show, so important that it's sung 27 times.
[52:04] Blake Ross: Rebecca.
[52:12] Jesse McInally: I brushed it every night. She was settled in velvet, she looked like a queen. A smile was boyish when I saw her for the last time. She won't smile at me anymore, but she's here on the set in the wind, and is calling her name.
[52:38] Blake Ross: Where are you?
[52:43] Jesse McInally: Life seems your song as long as society everywhere. Come back from your shadow. Rebecca. Rebecca. Rebecca. Rebecca. Rebecca. Rebecca.
[53:20] Blake Ross: Wait, there was other songs in this show?
[53:20] Jesse McInally: Yeah. I love this song. I bet you, I bet you tonight, when you lay your heads down. I I can't. I have to do it. On your pillow, you will hear Rob. I'm um heim. Oh, she won't surrender.
[53:43] Blake Ross: And and they've updated the lyrics more recently, um, so that they are a little bit more direct. And strangely, Miss Danvers is the only one with a goal in the story. She's the only one with agency and a goal that she's trying to achieve here.
[53:58] Jesse McInally: So the cousin. Fuck you.
[54:00] Blake Ross: Um cousin does have a lot of agency.
[54:06] Jesse McInally: Yeah, too much, if you ask me.
[54:10] Blake Ross: So Karen Mason was supposed to play her on Broadway. Before that, in the readings, Carolie Carmelo played her in the readings.
[54:18] Jesse McInally: Oh.
[54:19] Blake Ross: Women with like some voice says. So to wrap your head around who you could play those women taking on that belt would have been like astounding. And also the character work that I'm sure they would have done. Um, but yeah, it's a good song, I think.
[54:36] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's a new musical. It's very catchy and they know it. I mean, that's why it's everywhere.
[54:41] Blake Ross: It was their memory.
[54:43] Jesse McInally: Sure. It's a marketable song. You could hear it once and it's in the head your head for the rest of the week.
[54:49] Blake Ross: I am never gonna be able to get that song out of my head now. Whether it's because they play it 27 times or because it's a good song, you tell me, but does is there a difference? Is the real question.
[55:01] Jesse McInally: Maybe that's the only reason why we all know music of the night is because they play it 500 times in family opera.
[55:07] Blake Ross: Maybe it's a good song. When she sings it with um with I when she like, I mean, those two in her belting, it's fabulous.
[55:15] Jesse McInally: So that was definitely a good calling card.
[55:17] Blake Ross: Yeah, I I love this song. Like, I have no critiques about this song. Like, maybe if I heard it with English lyrics, I'd be like, oh, that's a little crazy.
[55:25] Jesse McInally: Well, I will say there's a version on YouTube that people should find of all of the Mrs. Danvers singing it in like Korean and German and all the different, not English, of course, but all the different versions. And it's really cool to hear like how it's all in different languages.
[55:42] Blake Ross: Cause again, like I I'm I'm I don't sit home and watch foreign musicals often. Can't say it's something I do. So it's it's very interesting to see the different because it the the the music is beautiful.
[55:56] Jesse McInally: This musical it is today and a thousand for schm.
[57:07] Blake Ross: Wow, that was great. Talking about the music in this, sometimes it's easier to digest like melodies and things like that when it's not in English because you don't have to listen for the lyrics at all. Um, and we like we had like subtitles and we were trying to read along and everything, but the music itself, like you there's no moment where you're like groaning at a lyric or anything like that because you can't understand anything.
[57:37] Blake Ross: They're they don't necessarily translate the entire show.
[57:41] Andrew DeWolf: Isn't that the way it is with movies too?
[57:44] Blake Ross: Yeah. Well, I think English is such a common language, especially in Europe, that it's not profitable for them to really do all the translations.
[57:54] Andrew DeWolf: Right. So we kind of were doing the reverse, I guess, like appreciating what it's like to listen to a musical not in your native tongue, but listening to it and having it translated and a janky translation.
[58:10] Blake Ross: Um, which is why it's so important, I guess, those producers really should spend money on people who know good translations for your musicals, man. Worth the money.
[58:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, that's an entire audience you're missing out on.
[58:22] Blake Ross: Um, let's talk about the one song where, you know, a man isn't telling a woman to smile. Um, let's talk about "Never Was a Smile That Cold."
[58:31] Blake Ross: Dashtansi auf den Kopf zurück.
[58:40] Blake Ross: Was mast du then kind bekommen? Man will denken auf jeden Fall, und einmal wird man perfekte Gutinmax.
[59:22] Blake Ross: Ich dachte ich hilf ja. Save our toad.
[59:31] Blake Ross: Um, where a man really does not want a woman to smile and don't smile, they tell you to smile, you do smile, they kill you.
[59:40] Andrew DeWolf: And she dies and she still has a smile on her face. Like, whoa.
[59:45] Blake Ross: So I had to lock her in a boat and sink the boat. What a way to go?
[59:51] Andrew DeWolf: And then, okay, okay. In every version of Rebecca, after hearing that, she's like, so you do love me? That's the only reaction she has.
[1:00:01] Blake Ross: You murdered her, but you love me. You still love me. That means you love Rebecca and you love me. Oh my God.
[1:00:07] Andrew DeWolf: Well, again, you know, Alfred Hitchcock was not the paragon of like women's empowerment.
[1:00:13] Blake Ross: So yeah, he's like, well, you know, that means she's gone, and you're the new Mrs. DeWinter. Enough that you don't even really need a name, girl.
[1:00:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's her winter. I mean, she gets the song, just I am Mrs. DeWinter.
[1:00:25] Blake Ross: So wait, in the movie, because it's been a while since I've seen the Hitchcock movie, does she also doesn't have a name or is she?
[1:00:33] Andrew DeWolf: I um unnamed character, but also in that movie, he does not murder Rebecca. She ends up dying through hijinks.
[1:00:43] Blake Ross: And then he doesn't tell her.
[1:00:45] Andrew DeWolf: Those silly women. That's also another thing. A lot in the movie. It's like silly, silly lady, silly girl. Don't you know? Silly, silly, silly little girl.
[1:00:55] Blake Ross: Yeah, they did just did a new version of Rebecca with Lily James um about a couple months ago. And in that one, it is everybody surrounding this.
[1:01:06] Blake Ross: It is a cursed property. Everyone surrounding this um this property is like creepy. It's one of the contests about it. Rebecca, she's everywhere. She won't surrender.
[1:01:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, she won't. Um, she is invincible. Um, yeah.
[1:01:24] Blake Ross: She's a ghost. Um, I hate this song, but I also hate that I kind of like it. That's my biggest concern with like my thought is that the song is fine.
[1:01:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. It's like another ballad in the sea of ballads.
[1:01:37] Blake Ross: Oh, the smile one. Smile that cold. And especially when I can't even understand the lyrics.
[1:01:43] Andrew DeWolf: Like, if I just heard the song, I'd probably be like, yeah, that's fine. But like when you know what's being said, it's like, wow. So he's just confessing that he killed her.
[1:01:52] Blake Ross: I can imagine like Ramin Karimloo going to like sing this out of 54 Below and being like, enough, smile like gold. And I'm like, wow, how beautiful. And then in context, like, oh no, oh my god.
[1:02:04] Blake Ross: Ramin Karimloo would have done the shit out of this musical. But that was the one point where I was like, all right, Max. Okay, cool. Because you know, like he is sort of like, you know, he's really hot, which is a plus for me.
[1:02:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but he didn't, you know, he's got moments, but he again he wasn't as like crazy as Lawrence Olivier.
[1:02:24] Blake Ross: No, right? So I mean, but then that one song, I was like, he brought it. Okay, we get it. You don't want your wife to smile at you, you better not.
[1:02:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um after she fucked her cousin. You know what? My wife fucked her cousin and she's smiling at me too much. Gotta sink in a boat. Sorry. Them's the rules.
[1:02:44] Blake Ross: I don't have many rules, but that's my one. Do you think he lied? Do you think he just drowned her? Like, think about what it would take to die that way.
[1:02:54] Andrew DeWolf: Because they were like, I'm saying, like, the hatch was open. So, but there were holes in it, and they were the hatch was open. So, does that mean like how do you sink a boat that like remember the Titanic took forever to sink?
[1:03:04] Blake Ross: Like, how long does it take a boat to sink? Enough for the woman to get. I mean, there's a lot. They said it was they said the hatch was locked from like the inside, and then there was holes drilled in from from the inside as well.
[1:03:15] Andrew DeWolf: I thought that I thought it meant like the took on water, like he opened the things that took the that makes more sense.
[1:03:22] Blake Ross: He drilled holes and then he took her, put her down there and then locked it. Oh, why did he lock it if she was dead?
[1:03:31] Andrew DeWolf: Rob I think I think his side of the story here might be a little bit like, oh, I just pushed her, and I don't know. She both reached for the gun.
[1:03:44] Blake Ross: Yeah, we both reached for the gun. Yeah, it's like maybe you put her in the boat and then you sank the boat and she drowned.
[1:03:52] Andrew DeWolf: If this musical has taught you anything, as long as you have the love of a man, that is what really matters. And as if you're a man, as long as you have a ton of money, you won't go to prison. That also matters.
[1:04:04] Blake Ross: And if you're white, those are the two things. A lot of money, white, white, rich, and a man. That's all that matters. Never have to do anything. Army Hammer still out free.
[1:04:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no. And I'm pretty sure he's eaten someone on that.
[1:04:17] Blake Ross: Yeah, I was gonna say the one of the stars of Rebecca was James Barber. So oh god, oh that motherfucker. You can get away with a lot of shit.
[1:04:29] Andrew DeWolf: What did this person do? I'm not up on the flashback.
[1:04:31] Blake Ross: You're gonna listen to my podcast and you're gonna take five, you'll find out. Episode five of the what is it, burnt?
[1:04:40] Andrew DeWolf: Burnt.
[1:04:40] Blake Ross: Yeah. Um, I've told you about him before. Um kids look it up. He's the reason why we haven't covered Jane Eyre yet. I want to. I love that musical.
[1:04:51] Andrew DeWolf: I like Jane Eyre. I wish he wasn't in it. Give me a new cast recording so I don't have to listen to his fucking voice.
[1:04:58] Blake Ross: I could say with almost certainty, you probably won't get another cast recording when you get it. I was talking to Paul Gordon. He is apparently planning a streaming version of it along with like he did with Pride and Prejudice.
[1:05:10] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I'm hoping. Just give me something without James Barber.
[1:05:14] Blake Ross: I was gonna say, hopefully James won't be reprising his role there. Coming back to the role, it's James Barber, the one who originated it. And I'm like, no! Why would you do this?
[1:05:25] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, what is our overall thoughts on Rebecca and our cheese rating?
[1:05:30] Blake Ross: Ooh. Andrew, are you aware of our cheese ratings?
[1:05:33] Andrew DeWolf: No, tell me more.
[1:05:35] Blake Ross: I'll just make Andrew go first, and I think that'll be enough of an example.
[1:05:38] Andrew DeWolf: Great. All right. Um, so overall thoughts. Uh, you know, it's a German language musical, so I don't know if I can do anything commenting on like lyrical quality or anything.
[1:05:52] Andrew DeWolf: The I mean, if you're looking for a feminist piece, you're you're not gonna find it here. Um, and if you like ballads, you're probably gonna really like this one. Fans of uh Frank Wildhorn uh embrace this show.
[1:06:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um personally I found it a little bit boring. The first half I was like, eh, this is okay, and then it kind of just keeps going and the songs don't really change.
[1:06:13] Andrew DeWolf: Um and they play the same song over and over, even if it's good. I mean, it gets to be a little bit much. Um, but it does look very cool when they burn the place down at the end.
[1:06:23] Andrew DeWolf: So extra points for that. Um I'm gonna give it a uh, you know, I looked up German cheeses and I'm realizing I can't pronounce any of these. Uh here's one.
[1:06:31] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Romadur. Romadur cheese from uh Bavaria, Germany. Okay, well, we'll go with that. Because it's a German thing.
[1:06:35] Blake Ross: Okay. Well, we'll go with that. All right, Blake. You want to head up? Are you ready?
[1:06:42] Andrew DeWolf: It could be literally any cheese you can justify.
[1:06:45] Blake Ross: Yes. Um, I'm gonna I again this if I if I was Michael Clins and Sylvester Levet sitting pretty on my hunk of cash from lots of musical success over in Europe and Asia.
[1:07:00] Blake Ross: Um, I would give it like like a like a parmesan or a mozzarella, like a like a very big staple cheese. But for an American, I'm gonna give it like like like a Costco version of Belvita, like not even like the real slices, like a knockoff cheese.
[1:07:23] Blake Ross: It wasn't for me. That's a that's a that's a good one, but I uh I kind of like this show, but mostly didn't like it.
[1:07:31] Blake Ross: Like there's a part of me that's like I really like the song Rebecca, that staircase though, the projections though, like maybe it's just because I felt fancy because I was watching something in a different language and I was like falling under its spell a little bit.
[1:07:44] Andrew DeWolf: Cultural distancing right there.
[1:07:46] Blake Ross: It feels more powerful because it's not in English. Maybe um uh I just I didn't mind watching it, but I understand every critique you guys have said and agree a hundred percent with every critique brought up here.
[1:07:59] Blake Ross: It is completely accurate. So what I'm gonna give this is a very fine, very nice uh cheese plate. However, that cheese plate was made in 2006 and has been sitting underneath the bed, and then you pull it out, and you know what?
[1:08:14] Blake Ross: It was a cheese plate given to you at a specific hotel. This is called Magical Mandalay, and they give out cheese plates with your room.
[1:08:22] Andrew DeWolf: So it's a cheese plate from 2006 at Magical Mandalay. Good luck writing that one, Juliet.
[1:08:29] Blake Ross: Yes, I did. This guy. Rude.
[1:08:31] Andrew DeWolf: It's hard to do that. A lot of cheese.
[1:08:34] Blake Ross: Yes. That's a lot of cheese, man. It was once really nice, but it's gone beyond that now.
[1:08:40] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. You don't see that.
[1:08:42] Blake Ross: Cheese gets better when it ages.
[1:08:43] Andrew DeWolf: What? Not if it's left under your bed, which will be a good one.
[1:08:46] Blake Ross: Yes, under my bed. She's like, I gotta go get some cheese. Hang on.
[1:08:49] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know what you're doing at night, but Blake, you were a wonderful guest. This was so much fun.
[1:08:56] Blake Ross: Thank you for coming on. You've got a lot to promote, so promote it out for the world.
[1:09:02] Blake Ross: Yes, please listen to again if you like creeps and you like twisty turny turny tales and you like musicals, come over and listen to Burnt on the Broadway Podcast Network.
[1:09:13] Andrew DeWolf: If they're here, they already like creeps. I mean, why else are they listening to us?
[1:09:20] Blake Ross: It is great. I listened to all of it a long, well, not long time ago, a couple weeks ago. Um, because Alan sent me actual sneak peek, so I got to see it before everyone else.
[1:09:30] Blake Ross: It is a very in-depth analysis, very, very thorough and well executed. I was surprised at a lot of the interviews you got and uh a lot of the tensions being held.
[1:09:41] Blake Ross: Um it well, it was tense, but it wasn't it if you didn't live through that time. Um it was such it's just such a batshit crazy story. So listen to it. Cannot recommend it more.
[1:09:52] Andrew DeWolf: Rebecca is so wacky, and you know what? I don't think it would have done well on Broadway. I really don't.
[1:10:01] Blake Ross: Maybe it's so sad. Like after all this, this guy was so obsessed with this musical. And after all this, I was like, I don't know that this would have played a day, but who's to say?
[1:10:11] Andrew DeWolf: Who's to say you never know?
[1:10:14] Blake Ross: You know who's definitely not to say though? Our wonderful patrons.
[1:10:18] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you guys for listening. We're on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. We're on Patreon at Musicals with Cheese.
[1:10:22] Andrew DeWolf: We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. We're on Instagram, Musicals with Cheese, YouTube Page Musicals with Cheese. Patreon only podcasts is Patreon with Cheese.
[1:10:27] Andrew DeWolf: Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our title card is created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go send her some love at Jolene Casco.
[1:10:37] Andrew DeWolf: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. This show is produced by the Incredible, The Wonderful. I miss you so much. Please come back to the show, Brianna Jones.
[1:10:44] Andrew DeWolf: And in case you haven't noticed, we've had some brand new theme songs playing throughout. Um they were all created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Go send her some love there.
[1:10:51] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for talking so much shit about Rent.
[1:11:00] Blake Ross: Um, do you have socials you want to promote?
[1:11:03] Blake Ross: Sure. Follow Burnt Broadway on Instagram, and you can find me. And if you like uh cute little kids, because that's mostly what I uh Instagram, my kid, my daughter.
[1:11:14] Blake Ross: Um, follow me at Blake Ross NY.
[1:11:17] Andrew DeWolf: Wonderful. Blake, thank you so much for joining us. Andrew, Blake, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap this on up?
[1:11:22] Blake Ross: Um thank you for having me, you guys. This was a dream come true. And even though you hate Rent, I'm still here for you.
[1:11:30] Andrew DeWolf: You are welcome on the show anytime, Blake. If there's a musical, you're like, oh, I gotta really, I got an itching to talk about this. Just shoot us an email for an email away.
[1:11:38] Blake Ross: You got it, guys. All right, you guys. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
