Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#183 - Mrs. Doubtfire the Musical

"The goodness will surely follow you As long as there is love..." Grab your dentures and poorly aged jokes because this week we're talking about the Broadway musical "Mrs. Doubtfire." We talk about what works, what doesn't, and the state of Broadway as a whole... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

58 mins
3/10/22

Featured Shows

About

"The goodness will surely follow you As long as there is love..." Grab your dentures and poorly aged jokes because this week we're talking about the Broadway musical "Mrs. Doubtfire." We talk about what works, what doesn't, and the state of Broadway as a whole. Don't miss out!

Donate to Black Lives Matter here

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jess on Twitter

Jess on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew on Instagram

Andrew on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna on Twitter

Brianna on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:08] Brianna Jones: Oh my god, and I'm Brianna Jones.

[0:10] Jesse McInally: Hello. And welcome to Musicals With Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Bree to like musical theater.

[0:15] Andrew DeWolf: I'm scared.

[0:19] Jesse McInally: Keep that in.

[0:20] Andrew DeWolf: That's staying in.

[0:20] Brianna Jones: That's funny.

[0:21] Jesse McInally: Yeah, Bree, do not re-record that.

[0:24] Andrew DeWolf: He's staring off in his face.

[0:27] Brianna Jones: Put a cricket noise.

[0:31] Jesse McInally: Um, Bree's dog, uh ate my headphones.

[0:35] Andrew DeWolf: $900 headphones.

[0:38] Jesse McInally: And they won't replace them.

[0:40] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, we told you it worked around, but we'll get to that.

[0:44] Jesse McInally: Um do you know why the dog ate her headphones?

[0:48] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[0:48] Jesse McInally: Because there wasn't a nanny watching them.

[0:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because there wasn't a nanny watching them.

[0:52] Jesse McInally: I'm starting my own nanny service where I wear a fat suit and pretend to be an old Scottish woman.

[0:58] Andrew DeWolf: It's a great idea, right?

[0:59] Jesse McInally: Totally not gonna offend like 500 different people by doing this, right?

[1:03] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[1:03] Jesse McInally: Why who would be offended by you doing that?

[1:06] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, that would be I don't know. I just feel like I'm not close enough with my kids, so I'm just gonna gaslight my ex-wife into thinking I'm this big old Scottish nanny.

[1:16] Jesse McInally: Yeah, this seems like a really good idea.

[1:19] Andrew DeWolf: I w it's all for my kids, Andrew!

[1:21] Jesse McInally: How dare you shame me?

[1:23] Andrew DeWolf: I want to be a good father, so I need to dress as an old Scottish woman!

[1:26] Brianna Jones: Have you tried just like not doing that?

[1:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like the judge took away my kids!

[1:34] Jesse McInally: What do you want me to do?

[1:36] Brianna Jones: The Mennonist has arrived.

[1:39] Jesse McInally: On that note, this week we are talking about Mrs. Doubtfire, the musical.

[1:42] Andrew DeWolf: Cue the music, Bree.

[1:48] Brianna Jones: Hello, dearies.

[2:10] Jesse McInally: So long open. So Mrs. Doubtfire, the musical, is a musical with a book by Carrie Kirkpatrick and John Farrell, and music and lyrics by Wayne Kirkpatrick and Carrie Kirkpatrick. Um, you might recognize those names from Something Rotten the musical. Um, it premiered on Broadway in previews on March 9th, 2020 at the Stephen Sondheim Theater, with a scheduled opening night of April 5th.

[2:36] Andrew DeWolf: Are we all following where this is going next?

[2:39] Jesse McInally: Due to the governor Andrew Cuomo's response to the coronavirus pandemic, all Broadway productions were suspended on March 12th, 2020, and were ultimately set to resume the week of September 14th, 2021. Mrs. Doubtfire resumed previews on October 21st, 2021. The official opening night was on December 5th, 2021. However, the production began a nine-week hiatus from January 10th to March 14th, 2022. However, that hiatus was extended another month to April 14th, 2022.

[3:12] Andrew DeWolf: Mrs. Doubtfire. We're like real critics on this one. We're see we're we're reviewing this before you can even watch the bang thing.

[3:20] Jesse McInally: A little bit.

[3:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but it had its opening night, and then they closed because they got we'll get into it. I want to talk about that. That's a big thing I want to talk about.

[3:30] Jesse McInally: Part of the reason why I'm talking about it today. So, Mrs. Doubtfire is about Daniel Hillard, a struggling out-of-work actor who will do anything for his kids. After losing custody in a messy divorce, he creates the kindly alter ego of a Scottish nanny, Eufgenia Doubtfire, in a desperate attempt to stay in their lives. As his new character takes on a life of its own, Mrs. Doubtfire teaches Daniel more than he bargained for about how to be a father. A hilarious and heartfelt story about holding on to your loved ones against all odds.

[4:00] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. Mrs. Doubtfire is the musical comedy we need right now. One that proves we're better together. Alright, Andrew, what do you think of Mrs. Doubtfire?

[4:10] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy, there is uh there's definitely some stuff to say.

[4:16] Jesse McInally: Alright, what's your history with the film version then?

[4:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I honestly have only seen the movie maybe like twice, and I didn't really like it either time, and I honestly can barely remember anything about it. So there's gonna be times in this where I'm probably gonna ask if it was in the movie, and hopefully Jess knows.

[4:35] Jesse McInally: I do. I have seen the movie a couple times. I wouldn't say it's a favorite of mine, it never really was. Mara Wilson's really cute in it. I like that it's an honest-ish divorce story where things don't end well. I think Sally Field's performance in it is very, very good.

[4:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[4:53] Jesse McInally: Aside from that, eh.

[4:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's just kind of not the funniest premise, honestly. We should there is the red flag of transphobia in the room.

[5:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, it's a little bit like, dang. This was really uh this was really funny, wasn't it? Back in 1990, whatever.

[5:14] Jesse McInally: Two years before we were born, right?

[5:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[5:18] Jesse McInally: Uh so I mean, you know.

[5:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, this goes along with a trend that we talk about so much on the show about famous movies becoming stage musicals. Sometimes it works in a way that we think is effective. Like we were both fairly positive about Beetlejuice and Shrek the musical. Then you have other ones like American Psycho or oh, there's gotta be another terrible one, right?

[5:41] Jesse McInally: Uh Tootsie?

[5:43] Andrew DeWolf: Tootsie, yeah. Those two are bad. Like see is uh bad in a similar vein to this as well, so I think it's a say that this musical would not exist without the success of Tootsie.

[5:55] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Um I think what's recurring about what the ones we like is a lot of times they will expand on the movie and make it more than it was in a certain way to make it fit the musical format.

[6:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[6:09] Jesse McInally: Especially Beetlejuice. Um I feel like Beetlejuice honestly has kind of surpassed the movie for me. Uh the musical version. It's just they added so much more to it. This really just feels like the movie with songs in it, though.

[6:25] Andrew DeWolf: It is, it is. And we've recently talked about another musical where it was just the movie with songs in it.

[6:30] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I forget which one it was.

[6:32] Andrew DeWolf: What what m what I don't even know what show we do anymore?

[6:35] Jesse McInally: Well, the thing about these mediocre shows is they're very forgettable.

[6:39] Andrew DeWolf: They do tend to blur together. Like this one I would say is like I don't I I don't want to talk bad about a show that's currently like on the stage and like really trying its best, but my god. You can tell that there's a lot of effort put into certain aspects of this.

[6:53] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[6:54] Andrew DeWolf: And I just I feel like you can also tell that there isn't very much effort put into other aspects of this.

[7:00] Jesse McInally: Why don't you break down what let's talk positives? What works in this musical?

[7:03] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, number one positive. Uh, uh the biggest positive, the most impressive thing you'll see, the costume changes always being visible and yes, they never try to hide it. Um, and frequent and the costume being relatively elaborate is kind of impressive. I do think that that was fun for them to do. Um, and you can definitely tell that that was supposed to be something that was impressive and supposed to kind of wow the audience a little bit. And I feel like it it does work. Um I don't think it's very funny. The thing is they expect you to have a laugh ride out of it, and I don't think it's funny. I think it's impressive, but I don't think it's funny.

[7:41] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and the thing is that's just laughing at a man in a dress, which isn't funny.

[7:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um continue.

[7:46] Andrew DeWolf: No. I'm just saying that I think the costume work that they did is actually impressive, but if anything, that's not in that's not a credit for like the writing team or anything. That's a credit for the uh costume department uh and staging and everything like that.

[7:58] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[7:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think that the sets look expensive. Uh that is the most back-ended statement I've ever heard.

[8:07] Jesse McInally: I mean, they look good.

[8:08] Andrew DeWolf: Uh it looks like that's where a lot of the money was going.

[8:12] Jesse McInally: Um I'm just being honest here.

[8:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh other positives. I mean, the the uh the lead is definitely trying very hard.

[8:19] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I was about to say this is a D minus show with a lead giving A plus effort.

[8:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think and I mean I think he he helps sell some of the costume change stuff. I mean, he's obviously doing a lot of the work there. Um, and yeah, I mean he does a very good job. I don't even think really nobody else is doing like a bad job. Most of the actors are doing very well.

[8:40] Jesse McInally: Um I just oh good lord, it's all in service of nothing.

[8:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's kind of the point of it. The movie worked because of Robin Williams' performance in a way. And for better or for worse, he is a very empathetic actor in a way that you kind of follow him down a lot of dark tales. And Rob McClure, very, very good funny actor, doesn't quite he can't step in those shoes as much as I give him all the credit in the world. Those are just too big of shoes to step into.

[9:08] Jesse McInally: I don't even know if it's that though, because I feel like he does a great job. I just think this story was never really that good. And I feel like the the jokes that they're giving him, because I don't think he's ad living up on stage there.

[9:20] Andrew DeWolf: No, of course not.

[9:21] Jesse McInally: Um so I think the jokes that they're giving him just aren't particularly funny.

[9:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um but you weren't a big fan of Robin Williams' improv to begin with. You're not a Robin Williams fan.

[9:32] Andrew DeWolf: I hate Bill Murray, you hate Robin Williams.

[9:34] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I wouldn't say hate. I mean, I think I think some of his more serious stuff is actually really good. It's more that his comedy, I I never really just enjoyed his just like I'm gonna do this accent and then I'm gonna do this reference and like that kind of stuff.

[9:46] Andrew DeWolf: Right.

[9:47] Jesse McInally: I know that in that's not all of his comedy stuff, but that is definitely Mrs. Doubtfire, and that's like the genie, and like that's you know that's what he was mostly known for in like our generation.

[9:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, um I yeah, and that's part of the reason I never really enjoyed Mrs. Doubtfire all that much.

[10:02] Jesse McInally: Um, yeah.

[10:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um, if I'm gonna say anything positive about it narratively, I like the fact that the kids are shown as the victim throughout, um, due to the parents' immaturity and the inability to congregate together, because they really are the only victims here. The mom isn't a victim, the dad isn't a victim, the kids are, and they do very good job of showing that.

[10:25] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I would say you could maybe argue the dad is like sort of a victim at the very beginning.

[10:31] Andrew DeWolf: I you see, let's talk about that. Um Bree, you are a female who might uh uh has the ability to have children in the future. I don't think you will, but yeah, um the off chance you do.

[10:44] Brianna Jones: Okay.

[10:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um let's say you have a child and you're a stay-at-home mother and your wife and or husband decides they're gonna be the breadwinner and you're gonna take care of the house. Then you get divorced. Because you were never allowed to have a job because that was the agreement you have, you are now unable to support your children on your own, so you only are allowed to see them on the weekends. Should that be allowed?

[11:06] Brianna Jones: I feel find that a really kind of messed up rule.

[11:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um it's I don't know. I've been through a lot of divorces uh growing up uh so there's typically alimony paid uh for someone who was the stay-at-home parent um from the breadwinner so uh a little unrealistic unless they signed like a prenup that said like with yours like that there will be no alimony given this musical at least this is how they frame it.

[11:32] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[11:32] Andrew DeWolf: The father was the stay-at-home dad the mom was the big breadwinner yeah um they get divorced and they're like oh yeah you're going with the mother and he's like come on my kids I was there every day and then they're like we'll see about that but you until then you only get them weekends.

[11:46] Brianna Jones: Weird it was wasn't it more than that it wasn't even just weekends. He got 'em for like an hour like one day.

[11:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah yeah an hour for the weekends. I mean that doesn't seem fair.

[11:55] Jesse McInally: Yeah so it's kind of that's kind of the messed up thing and so he has to kind of pretend he's a nanny which I don't know I think his solution to the problem is absolutely terrible.

[12:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[12:05] Jesse McInally: I just think that um I you could maybe argue that he he got kind of screwed a little bit. But that's the kind of thing that because in most court trials people say yeah, the kids go with the mother.

[12:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[12:16] Jesse McInally: Um watch a marriage story. We all know how that goes. Um but here he was a stay-at-home dad. You can't really blame him for not having a job because of that. Context matters, is what I'm saying.

[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, if you're a stay-at-home parent, that is your job.

[12:30] Jesse McInally: Right.

[12:30] Andrew DeWolf: And it's not any more or less of a job than someone that's going out and doing stuff.

[12:34] Jesse McInally: I would be more concerned with this if they actually cared about this aspect of the of the It's just a thing that you have to overcome to get him into a dress.

[12:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[12:43] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Like they never really like it's not like he's like a becomes some sort of father's rights activist or some nonsense.

[12:51] Andrew DeWolf: That would actually be an interesting musical if they did that.

[12:53] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and then he has to like do something to with the courts, but he it kind of just bypasses the courts. In fact, even at the end, the courts still disagree with him. It's just that the mother sort of forgives him.

[13:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[13:04] Jesse McInally: Um, so if really you can talk about that and how that's like a real issue or whatever if you want, or how you think it's not a real issue. Either way, this musical doesn't care.

[13:14] Andrew DeWolf: No, neither does the film very much.

[13:16] Jesse McInally: Um the only reason why they care is Robin Williams delivers some very good monologues very well. I don't think any emotional beat in Mrs. Doubtfire's musical lands in any way.

[13:26] Andrew DeWolf: Um maybe like the very, very end, where like they're all a big family and like okay, the happy beat, that kind of works.

[13:34] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I don't think there's really anything where it's like can I just talk about the jokes and how bad they are? Like really quick.

[13:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, let's go.

[13:42] Jesse McInally: Talk about the humor.

[13:44] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, like so I was kind of like middling on this show, like for the first half. I was like, man, this is like kind of like eh. Like there's some funny stuff, but it's like whatever. And then like halfway through, they do this TikTok song, um, where it's like a it's a clock sound, and he's doing it on a looping machine. I think it's kinda cool.

[14:02] Jesse McInally: It's kind of cool, but it's like aggressively not funny.

[14:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, like maybe that's just my sense of humor, but it's it is a like a grown man playing with puppets and doing a song about clocks. Um, and it just it just comes off as very not funny.

[14:17] Jesse McInally: Um, and then followed up by with that, like very soon after, or it might have been before. I think I can't quite remember the order.

[14:33] Andrew DeWolf: In a bikini. In like a bikini, and she raps like he raps because it's just the guy. He's not like he doesn't really identify as Mrs. Doubtfire in a real way. Um, so he raps about having a big tushy or something like that. I don't even remember. Yeah, it's about being a big woman, and because haha, fat woman in bikini, no hot, no make boner. Why do that? Yeah, so it's Mrs. Doubtfire rapping about this, and it's also aggressively not funny, like in an in-your-face kind of way. Um, and it's hard to talk about bad comedy because I don't know how to explain it, like why it's not funny. All I can say is that it really isn't funny. It like is painfully not funny.

[15:17] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[15:20] Andrew DeWolf: The thing is, every musical I have to go into it with the idea of who is this made for? If this was made for fans of Mrs. Doubtfire, this is just a worse version of Mrs. Doubtfire. At least with Beetlejuice, it's like Beetlejuice, but much, much different. So you're getting what you liked in a different way.

[15:37] Jesse McInally: Yes.

[15:37] Andrew DeWolf: This, it's way too similar and worse. Like it's the same movie but done worse. Yeah, because like everything now, everything is like dragged out, so like all the jokes have to be three minutes long because they all have to be a song number. And it's like Mrs. Doubtfire is like what? Probably like a 90-minute movie. It's still too long a movie. I think it's nearly two hours. I think Mrs. Doubtfire is too long as a movie. Either way, um, it's two hours and six minutes. Why the fuck is Mrs. Doubtfire that long?

[16:02] Jesse McInally: Well, if anything, maybe they trimmed some stuff and yeah, now that I think about it, maybe they did.

[16:09] Andrew DeWolf: Which, I mean, good on them, because that's way too long. Why is Mrs. Doubtfire over two hours long?

[16:14] Jesse McInally: I don't know. Robin Williams had too much improv.

[16:17] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that probably is it. It literally was like, we can't cut that. That's hilarious. It's so funny. He did an impression of a hot dog. I don't know. I'm being very negative, and I don't actually feel that negatively about this show. I just, how does this stand up next to Tootsie the Musical, the other big transphobic musical?

[16:38] Jesse McInally: This is better than Tootsie, but not by a lot.

[16:41] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. What makes this better than Tootsie?

[16:43] Jesse McInally: Tootsie was more aggressive in the deception and mean.

[16:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it was like almost just purely mean-spirited, where it was like, I need to get a job, and it's so much easier for women, so I'm gonna be a woman and do it. And it's like, oh my god. Whereas this was like, at least this was like a genuine like, I'm a father and I really want to see my kids, and this is the only way I can do it. You know, it's like, okay, that's like sort of a reason.

[17:13] Jesse McInally: Well, we've talked enough negative about this show. Why don't we compare our opinions to those of the New York theater critics when this first came out? It's time for our favorite section of the show. It's time for previews.

[17:25] Andrew DeWolf: It's Tom Falls!

[17:30] Jesse McInally: It's Tom Fall Previews. Alright, Andrew, what have we got first?

[17:34] Andrew DeWolf: Why don't you read the first one from Maya Phillips?

[17:37] Jesse McInally: Maya Phillips, in their 2022 review for the New York Times, wrote that in 1993, a film about an irresponsible father dressing up as a woman to manipulate his way back into his family's life was a barrel of laughs. A man in a dress, classic. He does impressions even better. He tries to sabotage his wife's new relationship. Comedy gold. Truly, it was a different time.

[18:02] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, that first sentence could have just been written by you, Andrew.

[18:06] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I think I've actually, before even reading this, I had said exactly this stuff to you in a Facebook chat.

[18:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, actually, we didn't even talk about the, I thought the, um, he tries to like sabotage his wife's new relationship like five times, and every single time it's played as if like it's like the funniest thing ever to happen.

[18:26] Jesse McInally: So funny. Your ex is trying to ruin your new relationship, so great. Wow. This is really good. I cried at the end, Andrew.

[18:36] Jesse McInally: Okay, Rob McClure steps into mint Mrs. Doubtfire's sensible shoes in this production. He's vivacious on the stage. I can't pronounce these words sometimes. And his impressions, including a hilarious tongue-wagging Gollum, are precious.

[18:52] Andrew DeWolf: Is that, was that really that funny? Is that sarcasm? I feel like it's not funny. I saw the clip. It wasn't funny. But the director, Jerry Zaks' ambivalent production, tries to have it both ways. The story of a playful male man-child with whom we empathize, but whose good intentions can't excuse his machinations. The film pulled it off at the time, primarily thanks to Williams' charms. McClure's Daniel, though, is more irritating than entertaining with his antics, which include hacking into his wife's email account to sabotage her nanny search.

[19:25] Jesse McInally: Let's pause there. I agree with that wholeheartedly. Because that is a much more vicious attack. In the movie, he just changes one number on the sheet she's about to submit.

[19:36] Andrew DeWolf: And yeah, that's, that's, it's an invasion of privacy in a lot of ways in the musical.

[19:42] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's more updated, but it's gross.

[19:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's gross. Yeah, they try to play it as like, oh, well, he just knows her passwords. Like, she hasn't changed, like, okay, but that you still have to be. That's a breach of trust and emotional contact.

[19:56] Jesse McInally: Yeah, you shouldn't be doing that. Um, but would Williams have fared much better in 2021 when the toxicity of this male character's actions would raise alarms? That strain is everywhere in this production, whose 18-month pandemic hiatus coincided with renewed conversations about race, gender, and equity.

[20:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I just don't think the story works now, and I think that that's what they're saying here. Like, and it kind of just doesn't. Like, I don't know. We'll keep going. Maybe we'll talk about it at the end of this. Lines from the movie about Mrs. Doubtfire having a penis have been excised.

[20:31] Jesse McInally: Thank God.

[20:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because that would have been hilarious. The height of comedy. And in a surface-level attempt to make Daniel's long-suffering wife, Miranda, a more feminist and sympathetic figure, the show's creators have made her the owner of a body-positive activewear line called M-Body. The pseudo-feminist song that she sings during a fashion show, "Shape of Things to Come," is a painfully punny inspirational poster masquerading as a piece of music.

[21:00] Jesse McInally: That is the song I was talking about.

[21:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Um, where Mrs. Doubtfire comes on, and honestly, even if the message was working, having a man in a fat suit and a bikini come on and sing in rap is probably not gonna help your message.

[21:19] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and just, I don't know. I find that offensive in like 90 different ways. Um, we are gonna hear from a trans reviewer after this just to get like a trans opinion on Mrs. Doubtfire.

[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: I would like to hear that because I am interested in what their thought of. I would, uh, trans reading on this is much more interesting than this. Uh, but continue with the New York Times.

[21:38] Jesse McInally: Uh, while the Mrs. Doubtfire movie may now be understandably considered transphobic, it is funny and likable, and most importantly, confident in what it is. Its musical counterpart feels unsure of what notes to hit, what jokes to rewrite, and what updates to add to be relevant. The production wants the audience to both like and be skeptical of its straight male protagonist, and it includes gay characters but doesn't fully embrace them.

[22:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, I do remember that as well.

[22:05] Jesse McInally: That was in the movie as well.

[22:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, a man in drag, come on, it's 2021. That's just another night in the city. Um, having the gay characters sing a song that includes lyrics about Margaret Thatcher, like over and over and over again. About how ugly Margaret Thatcher is and like a bunch of other older women.

[22:25] Jesse McInally: Yeah, a little weird.

[22:26] Andrew DeWolf: It is one of the more interesting song numbers, I will say. Visually, at least they brought something. It's not like the chef number where Mrs. Doubtfire is trying to learn Chef from Siri, and then suddenly a bunch of chefs come out and make dinner with her.

[22:39] Jesse McInally: Yeah, um, aggressively unfunny, as I was saying.

[22:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Also, haha, man cannot cook. Man incompetent. No known to cook. Mr. Mom 30 years ago, 40 years ago.

[22:52] Jesse McInally: Okay. Maybe we should just stop making, you know what, 90s movies don't need to be musicals.

[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: Also, comedies just don't age well, just like in general. Just because the things that we joke about get updated every year.

[23:07] Jesse McInally: What genre do you think ages the best? Because I have one answer in my head. I want to see what your thoughts are.

[23:12] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, that's a tough question. Um, I don't really know. I think horror ages the best. I think horror films genuinely stand up the test in time compared to most other types of films.

[23:24] Jesse McInally: Like dramas, they age like milk, same with comedies. But horror films, we're still talking about Halloween, Nightmare on Elm Street. All the same films from the same times. Scream is still more relevant today than ever.

[23:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's almost because like the themes are interchangeable in a way. Like you can just, whatever was supposed to be scary about Halloween, we can just put a modern viewing onto it whenever we want. Like it's very easy to do so. Cause like, I don't know, even like very old stuff, like stuff that you would think would be really problematic. You can just be like, well, no, it doesn't mean that to me. I don't know. Whereas comedies, uh, comedies are explicit.

[24:07] Jesse McInally: Alright, let's think about this. Let's take a movie that's considered transphobic, like Tootsie, which is rightfully considered transphobic, and a horror film that's considered transphobic, like Psycho.

[24:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[24:16] Jesse McInally: Which is aged better.

[24:17] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, Psycho still aged better.

[24:20] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Why is that?

[24:21] Andrew DeWolf: Be, I am still wondering that myself, to be honest. Um, I don't even know. I mean, it's probably just because the tone of it is so different. With Tootsie, where you're supposed to be laughing.

[24:32] Jesse McInally: It's a who.

[24:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. It's a little different. When you're not asked to laugh at it, you're asked to like think about it. It's a little different.

[24:40] Jesse McInally: Mm-hmm.

[24:40] Andrew DeWolf: And you can come to your own conclusions in horror as well. Like, sure, maybe Psycho is trying to tell you, like, this is really scary that he's like this or whatever. But like, maybe you don't have to think that way. I don't know. Or even something like Buffalo Bill and Silence of the Lambs. I think that still ages better because it isn't pointing a finger the way that Tootsie or Mrs. Doubtfire is. Now I would still argue that these are bad and we shouldn't be doing them again.

[25:09] Jesse McInally: But no, but I still think that Jonathan Demme has more empathy for someone like Buffalo Bill than Chris Columbus does for actual trans people, despite directing the Rent movie and Mrs. Doubtfire. Like, literally he directs Mrs. Doubtfire, then twelve years later directs Rent. I don't know why that's so brainwashingly stupid to me, but it is.

[25:29] Andrew DeWolf: Well, let's read this.

[25:29] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I'll read the second one. Next one. So this is from Christian Lewis, and they are a trans writer. They said this of Mrs. Doubtfire in December of 2021. While both Jagged Little Pill and Company struggle in their own ways to explore both gender and sexuality in nuanced ways, the bigger problem of the season is Mrs. Doubtfire, another nostalgic adaptation of a man in a dress film comedy. In theory, Mrs. Doubtfire had the time and chance to learn from Tootsie's mistakes. The writers even had the entire pandemic to rethink, adjust, do some research, and perhaps begin to actually listen to the trans people critiquing it. They did not. For supposedly family-friendly show about love, it spread some dangerously transphobic messages.

I found the experience of watching Mrs. Doubtfire difficult and upsetting. Not least because the audience around me seemed to love it. Uncritically cheering and clapping as the musical replicated each famous moment from the film: The Pie in the Face, The Vacuuming Dance, The Scorched Fake Breast. Perhaps most painful was the fact that the audience was enthusiastically laughing at each and every man in a dress joke. While critics seem to forgive me. While critics seem to have learned a bit since Tootsie, several mentioned transphobia and or gender issues in the reviews of Mrs. Doubtfire. It appears that the writers, Casey Kirkpatrick and Wayne Kirkpatrick, and John O'Farrell are happily to pander to the same transphobic attitudes as Tootsie did.

Sitting in the audience, it felt as if nothing had changed. It might as well have been called Tootsie 2. Transphobia Reloaded. While watching Mrs. Doubtfire, I had a simple idea. If it is possible to be about a father who is an actor and wears a disguise to be with his kids, why does it have to be Mrs. Doubtfire? Why can't he be an elderly male Scottish nanny? It would not change the plot at all. It would just remove the transphobic man in a dress joke at the center of the whole enterprise. Ironically, a lot of the marketing for the show simply uses the title Doubtfire, as if the PR team is trying to stay away from the gendered part of the title that goes with it.

[27:27] Andrew DeWolf: So, well, they couldn't have it be a Mr. Doubtfire, as they're suggesting here, because, um, you would lose a lot of the jokes.

[27:37] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and that's kind of the problem.

[27:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, that is the, yeah, exactly. What, where if you don't have the man in a dress jokes and you still have no emotional connection to the story, why do it at all?

[27:49] Jesse McInally: I agree with Christian. They're right.

[27:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.

[27:51] Jesse McInally: But who cares what these professional critics think? It's time to look at the insane people on Letterboxd. Bree, you've curated a list of letterbox reviews for us to talk about from the Mrs. Doubtfire movie, and it's me and Andrew in Letterboxd Reviewed.

[28:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it is time to hear what the real critics think.

[28:11] Jesse McInally: Okay, okay. Alright, who's going first today?

[28:14] Andrew DeWolf: You choose. You run this shit.

[28:16] Jesse McInally: Um, Andrew, you lost, so I guess you can go first.

[28:20] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.

[28:21] Jesse McInally: You lost the last one, right?

[28:23] Andrew DeWolf: No, you guys tied.

[28:24] Jesse McInally: It was a tie, but we'll say I was.

[28:27] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um, material girl.

[28:33] Jesse McInally: The insecurity in that shit.

[28:36] Andrew DeWolf: Gore. Goyle. Material goyle.

[28:40] Jesse McInally: Um, material goyle.

[28:43] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. That's the entire review.

[28:47] Jesse McInally: Yep.

[28:48] Andrew DeWolf: That's five stars.

[28:51] Jesse McInally: Five stars.

[28:52] Andrew DeWolf: That is a five star. I nailed it. I knew it. I just, I had a feeling from it, you know.

[28:57] Jesse McInally: Yeah, no, I totally.

[28:59] Andrew DeWolf: Is it my turn?

[29:00] Jesse McInally: It's your turn.

[29:02] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Material goy. Goyle.

[29:05] Andrew DeWolf: Material goyle.

[29:07] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[29:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um.

[29:08] Jesse McInally: So she's the man is the yessified version of this.

[29:15] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh.

[29:16] Jesse McInally: I'm gonna give it five stars.

[29:19] Andrew DeWolf: That's a five.

[29:20] Jesse McInally: Now, Jess, are they are they right or wrong though?

[29:23] Andrew DeWolf: I have not seen she's the man, except for knowing that Amanda Bynes flashes her top at a football game or something, like flashes her tits at a football game to prove that she's a woman.

[29:33] Jesse McInally: And that movie probably is not aged well.

[29:35] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[29:36] Jesse McInally: That sounds like it aged really well, Jess.

[29:37] Andrew DeWolf: But it's based on another film of the like a different name.

[29:41] Jesse McInally: Like some boys in the club or some shit.

[29:43] Andrew DeWolf: Either way, what I I'm winning.

[29:45] Jesse McInally: No, you both have one.

[29:48] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[29:49] Jesse McInally: Winning is my heart.

[29:50] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, Andrew.

[29:52] Jesse McInally: Miss Doubtfire.

[29:53] Andrew DeWolf: Colin.

[29:54] Jesse McInally: Blank.

[29:55] Andrew DeWolf: Me.

[29:55] Jesse McInally: Mommy?

[29:56] Andrew DeWolf: Sorry.

[29:56] Jesse McInally: Mommy?

[29:57] Andrew DeWolf: Sorry.

[29:58] Jesse McInally: Mommy?

[29:59] Andrew DeWolf: M mommy?

[30:00] Jesse McInally: Sorry.

[30:00] Andrew DeWolf: Is that is that Billy Eilish there?

[30:03] Jesse McInally: Wait, was that all was that all part of it?

[30:05] Andrew DeWolf: I'm a little confused.

[30:06] Jesse McInally: Yeah, so you not know the meme, Andrew.

[30:09] Andrew DeWolf: So Miss Doubtfire did nothing.

[30:11] Jesse McInally: Oh, okay.

[30:12] Andrew DeWolf: So it's the it's this format.

[30:13] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[30:13] Andrew DeWolf: Missed out fire.

[30:15] Jesse McInally: Nothing.

[30:15] Andrew DeWolf: Me.

[30:15] Jesse McInally: Mommy, sorry.

[30:16] Andrew DeWolf: Mommy, sorry.

[30:17] Jesse McInally: Mommy, sorry.

[30:21] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.

[30:22] Jesse McInally: Absolutely.

[30:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[30:26] Jesse McInally: Ooh, alright.

[30:27] Andrew DeWolf: What do we got next?

[30:28] Jesse McInally: As if.

[30:30] Andrew DeWolf: Deep.

[30:31] Jesse McInally: Makes you think.

[30:32] Andrew DeWolf: Makes you wonder.

[30:34] Jesse McInally: I'm gonna give it a one star.

[30:36] Andrew DeWolf: That's a five star.

[30:37] Jesse McInally: Shit!

[30:39] Andrew DeWolf: As if, Jeff.

[30:41] Jesse McInally: As if.

[30:42] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? Now I'm on the other side.

[30:44] Jesse McInally: This kind of sucks.

[30:48] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[30:49] Jesse McInally: Andrew, what did marriage story give us that this movie didn't?

[30:54] Andrew DeWolf: Adam Driver punching a wall.

[30:57] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[30:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um five stars.

[31:01] Jesse McInally: That's correct.

[31:02] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, Andrew's beating me.

[31:05] Jesse McInally: He's on fire.

[31:06] Andrew DeWolf: Boom!

[31:07] Jesse McInally: He's had more training than me.

[31:09] Andrew DeWolf: So really this isn't fair.

[31:10] Jesse McInally: You might be right about that.

[31:12] Andrew DeWolf: It's like beating up a child.

[31:16] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[31:18] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[31:21] Jesse McInally: I'ma let that go.

[31:23] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[31:23] Jesse McInally: Parents show this to their kid after getting a divorce.

[31:27] Andrew DeWolf: It's me.

[31:27] Jesse McInally: I'm that kid.

[31:30] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, is that a good thing or a bad thing?

[31:32] Jesse McInally: Do you think?

[31:33] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna give it a five star.

[31:34] Jesse McInally: That's five.

[31:35] Andrew DeWolf: Hey!

[31:36] Jesse McInally: I'm back on the board.

[31:39] Andrew DeWolf: See, the problem with you guys who do these letterboxes, you think too much.

[31:45] Jesse McInally: Alright.

[31:46] Andrew DeWolf: No brain.

[31:47] Jesse McInally: Andrew gave me terrible second hand embarrassment.

[31:51] Andrew DeWolf: One star.

[31:52] Jesse McInally: So that was a five-star.

[31:54] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know why, though.

[31:55] Jesse McInally: They like to cringe.

[31:56] Andrew DeWolf: It's cringe culture.

[31:57] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[31:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um I feel like I can say the same thing about the that it gave you second hand embarrassment.

[32:06] Jesse McInally: Um, starting the year off strong.

[32:09] Andrew DeWolf: I could be sarcasm.

[32:12] Jesse McInally: Uh I'm gonna give it one.

[32:14] Andrew DeWolf: That was a one.

[32:15] Jesse McInally: Now you guys are trying.

[32:17] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[32:18] Jesse McInally: I'm gonna pour myself another glass of wine for that one.

[32:22] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[32:23] Jesse McInally: Andrew, if my ex knocked on the door in a wig doing voices, I would probably call 911.

[32:31] Andrew DeWolf: And you should.

[32:33] Jesse McInally: Here I go, making myself laugh again.

[32:35] Andrew DeWolf: No, but you see, Daniel, his voices are just so good.

[32:40] Jesse McInally: You know?

[32:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um jeez.

[32:46] Jesse McInally: One star.

[32:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[32:48] Jesse McInally: That was right.

[32:50] Andrew DeWolf: Just the white version of Big Mama's house.

[32:57] Jesse McInally: Bruh.

[32:58] Andrew DeWolf: That's a five-star.

[32:59] Jesse McInally: That is a five-star.

[33:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's pretty funny.

[33:02] Jesse McInally: Why is that why is that so true, though?

[33:05] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Big Mama's house, at least he was pretending to be a person that existed.

[33:10] Jesse McInally: Like Big Mama was an actual character that existed in the world.

[33:16] Andrew DeWolf: And then Martin Lawrence is pretending to be Big Mama.

[33:19] Jesse McInally: Mrs. Doubtfire doesn't really exist.

[33:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so it's more like Jack and Jill, where like Jill is like a real person.

[33:24] Jesse McInally: It's not just Adam Sandler.

[33:25] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no, no.

[33:26] Jesse McInally: So, Big Mama is a character in Big Mama's house.

[33:30] Andrew DeWolf: Then she leaves.

[33:31] Jesse McInally: Then Martin Lawrence, the character played by Martin Lawrence, dresses up as the character Big Mama to pretend to be her.

[33:39] Andrew DeWolf: So it it is still the character Martin Lawrence is playing in drag.

[33:43] Jesse McInally: Okay, so it's still Mrs. Doubtfire.

[33:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[33:45] Jesse McInally: It's just that Mrs. Doubtfire is actually real.

[33:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[33:48] Jesse McInally: It would be like if Mrs. Doubtfire was a real nanny, then Daniel just beat the shit out of her and then dressed up as her.

[33:55] Andrew DeWolf: Which honestly.

[33:56] Jesse McInally: If you went that route, I think I'd I that would be like a laugh a minute.

[33:59] Andrew DeWolf: That would honestly have a little bit of a funnier twinge to it.

[34:03] Jesse McInally: It's like he just finds this nanny and like kills her and like presses off as her.

[34:10] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.

[34:11] Jesse McInally: Oh no.

[34:12] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[34:12] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[34:13] Andrew DeWolf: Um, let's see.

[34:15] Jesse McInally: Who's up?

[34:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's Andrew's.

[34:17] Jesse McInally: I was the Big Mama's house person.

[34:19] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, yeah.

[34:21] Jesse McInally: Um.

[34:24] Andrew DeWolf: The dude, in fact, does look like a lady.

[34:28] Jesse McInally: Intentionally so.

[34:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um, five stars?

[34:31] Jesse McInally: That's a one star.

[34:32] Andrew DeWolf: Not an aerospace.

[34:33] Jesse McInally: Are we tied now?

[34:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think so.

[34:36] Jesse McInally: Alright.

[34:38] Andrew DeWolf: She makes dinner.

[34:39] Jesse McInally: She does windows, she reads bedtime stories.

[34:42] Andrew DeWolf: She's a freaky man.

[34:46] Jesse McInally: Ew.

[34:47] Andrew DeWolf: Is that like a tagline for the movie?

[34:49] Jesse McInally: I have no idea.

[34:51] Andrew DeWolf: That's that's a one star.

[34:53] Jesse McInally: It has to be.

[34:54] Andrew DeWolf: That is a one star.

[34:55] Jesse McInally: And now you're leading.

[34:57] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, fuck you, Andrew!

[34:59] Jesse McInally: God dang.

[35:00] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[35:01] Jesse McInally: Let's see.

[35:03] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[35:04] Jesse McInally: Oh boy, I can't wait to get home from school and watch the Dick Van Dyke show.

[35:08] Andrew DeWolf: Normal Teenagers in 1993.

[35:11] Jesse McInally: Said normal teenagers in 1993.

[35:13] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.

[35:14] Jesse McInally: That's a one star.

[35:16] Andrew DeWolf: What you know what show they're watching on the TV in the movie?

[35:21] Jesse McInally: And you still give it a freaking one star?

[35:24] Andrew DeWolf: I will say, I do remember this part of the movie, and it does stick out to me.

[35:28] Jesse McInally: Because like all three of the kids are sitting at home watching Dick Van Dyke.

[35:31] Andrew DeWolf: Mrs. Delphire comes in and is like, oh, turn that off.

[35:34] No more TV.

[35:35] Jesse McInally: Like, we always watch Dick Van Dyke whenever we get home.

[35:38] Andrew DeWolf: Like they make a thing out of it.

[35:40] Jesse McInally: I remember that specifically enough to be like, yeah, that was a little weird.

[35:44] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, do they they also do all start watching that like public access TV show that Mrs. Delfire starts making?

[35:48] Jesse McInally: Even if my best friend, like someone I love dearly, started a public access TV show where they were the lead, I 100% would never watch it.

[36:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yo, it's public access.

[36:02] Jesse McInally: I'm not watching this shit.

[36:05] Andrew DeWolf: Like even if it was the best show ever, like it was certified Fresh and Rotten Tomatoes, I would still like put it off.

[36:10] Jesse McInally: Like, yeah, fuck that guy.

[36:11] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, are you ready, Jess?

[36:13] Jesse McInally: The lying in this movie stressed me out as a child, and it stands true today.

[36:18] Andrew DeWolf: Oof.

[36:19] Jesse McInally: So Andrew had a set similar one with the secondhand embarrassment, and that was a one star.

[36:24] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna give this one a five star.

[36:25] Jesse McInally: That's a five star.

[36:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I just gotta throw it out there.

[36:30] Jesse McInally: This is not fair at all.

[36:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh all right.

[36:35] Jesse McInally: There's only a couple more here.

[36:37] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[36:38] Jesse McInally: Uh Andrew.

[36:40] Andrew DeWolf: This movie is about a liar.

[36:45] Jesse McInally: It's upsetting.

[36:46] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I yeah, I don't like that either.

[36:49] Jesse McInally: Um star?

[36:50] Andrew DeWolf: That's a one star.

[36:51] Jesse McInally: Don't like liars.

[36:57] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Bree, what we got next?

[36:59] Brianna Jones: Um, Mara Wilson really was everywhere in the 90s, huh?

[37:03] Jesse McInally: She was.

[37:04] Brianna Jones: Fun fact, I've invited Mara Wilson onto our podcast and got two different rejection letters.

[37:09] Jesse McInally: Oof.

[37:11] Brianna Jones: Two rejection letters for one email?

[37:13] Jesse McInally: No, I like wrote it once, then waited a year, then wrote again two different rejections.

[37:19] Brianna Jones: Same with Rachel Bloom. I should probably like write another one for Rachel Bloom, see if she says no again.

[37:24] Jesse McInally: Um, but I'm gonna give that one a one star.

[37:27] Brianna Jones: Because people didn't tend to like her.

[37:28] Jesse McInally: That was a five star.

[37:30] Brianna Jones: Oh shit.

[37:31] Jesse McInally: I thought I was better than the nostalgia critic for a second.

[37:36] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[37:37] Jesse McInally: Ready, Andrew?

[37:40] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.

[37:40] Jesse McInally: Andrew looks so done with today.

[37:42] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[37:44] Jesse McInally: They really just let him go.

[37:49] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, yeah, it's over two hours long.

[37:51] Jesse McInally: Like they could they didn't cut anything.

[37:53] Andrew DeWolf: Like, my god.

[37:54] Jesse McInally: Fun fact there's a four-hour R-rated cut of Mrs. Doubtfire and people are on Twitter like, at least the R-rated version.

[38:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I heard there was a big cut scene, too.

[38:05] Jesse McInally: Yeah, there's a big scene.

[38:06] Andrew DeWolf: Actually, I think they should have kept it in.

[38:08] Jesse McInally: It was the like an emotional scene where the kids are like, I hate you. I hate my parents. You guys are just fighting and ruining our lives, which, yeah, fair.

[38:15] Andrew DeWolf: But Andrew.

[38:17] Jesse McInally: Andrew, was that a They didn't cut anything.

[38:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean wait, wait, wait.

[38:21] Jesse McInally: Read the review again, Brie.

[38:23] Andrew DeWolf: They really just let him go.

[38:25] Jesse McInally: I know, they really just let him go.

[38:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like, they didn't cut anything.

[38:27] Jesse McInally: I would give it a one, but well, let's say five stars.

[38:30] Andrew DeWolf: We're gonna say five stars.

[38:30] Jesse McInally: No, no, no, Andrew.

[38:31] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, I don't want you to do this.

[38:32] Jesse McInally: Don't do it, don't do this.

[38:34] Andrew DeWolf: I think you're interpreting what he's saying wrong.

[38:36] Jesse McInally: I think they're saying they led him off the hook.

[38:39] Andrew DeWolf: Literally dressing as Mrs. Doubtfire.

[38:41] Jesse McInally: Because that's how I'm interpreting it.

[38:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.

[38:45] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[38:45] Andrew DeWolf: I want to make sure you were interpreting it the way I'm hearing it.

[38:48] Jesse McInally: Oh, I was interpreting it like they just let him do whatever he wanted, like on the set, like ad lib, everything.

[38:55] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[38:55] Jesse McInally: If it's they let him off the hook for doing bad stuff.

[38:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I guess that's one star.

[38:59] Jesse McInally: That's how my brain is.

[39:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that was a one star.

[39:02] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[39:03] Andrew DeWolf: Let's see.

[39:03] Jesse McInally: One, two, three, four, four.

[39:04] Andrew DeWolf: Give him that point.

[39:06] Jesse McInally: I don't think he heard it right.

[39:07] Andrew DeWolf: Well, then we also started talking about how they cut things, and yeah.

[39:10] Jesse McInally: Yeah, yeah, that wasn't his call.

[39:11] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[39:12] Jesse McInally: He's a he's a gentle babe.

[39:14] Andrew DeWolf: We have to we have to adjust the rules for little boy, baby boy.

[39:20] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[39:21] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know what I expected.

[39:22] Jesse McInally: This is for you, Jeff.

[39:23] Andrew DeWolf: That sounds like a one star.

[39:25] Jesse McInally: That is a one star.

[39:26] Andrew DeWolf: You win the game.

[39:27] Jesse McInally: Woohoo!

[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: Eat my ass, Andrew.

[39:30] Jesse McInally: Okay, Andrew.

[39:31] Andrew DeWolf: You can tie up the game right now.

[39:33] Jesse McInally: We'll give you one more chance.

[39:34] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[39:35] Jesse McInally: This is the last one.

[39:36] Andrew DeWolf: Get it, Granny.

[39:37] Jesse McInally: Five stars.

[39:38] Andrew DeWolf: That's a tie game.

[39:41] Jesse McInally: Andrew, we tied.

[39:42] Andrew DeWolf: We are equals in everything forever.

[39:51] Brianna Jones: Hey guys. Sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shisha shell at you.

[39:55] Jesse McInally: Bree, tell us a little bit about Patreon and what's on Patreon.

[39:58] Brianna Jones: Alright, guys. Patreon is where you can go and get exclusive content from Andrew and Jess.

[40:05] Brianna Jones: And they got a bunch of commentaries on there.

[40:08] Brianna Jones: They got like basically another podcast over there.

[40:10] Brianna Jones: Like they're doing cool stuff over there, so you should check it out.

[40:14] Brianna Jones: And sometimes, sometimes I'll pop in.

[40:17] Jesse McInally: Nice.

[40:17] Brianna Jones: They call her Mary Pop.

[40:18] Jesse McInally: It's because she is always popping in.

[40:22] Brianna Jones: Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, John Donna, Danielle Renics, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Tess Gear, Monica Thoreau, Mina Miniri, Brent Black, Lathaniel Stacey Toon, Joseph Evans Green, uh Carrie Ahern, Mary Lou Choquette, John Van Alves, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janay C, Scootin' the Technic or Dreamcoat, uh Liz Lim, Alison Staller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxis, Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Raphael Martinez Salaz, Robert Benjamin, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai T Cup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keyes, Crick Chris Marquette, uh, Mimu, Akiji, Maria Anastasio, Leela, RJ Noriga, Sebastian Canino, Charlie B, Patrick Deering, Joe, Avery Brinson, Merlin, Marilyn Brown, Mel Cormac, Lafemme Fictionale, Bjorn Herman's Mac the Knife, Erica S.

[41:10] Brianna Jones: Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most, Lopez, Pleana Morton, Angela, uh, Kaylee Blazer, Birdman69, and Daniel Smith.

[41:21] Brianna Jones: These folks give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, musicals of the cheese.

[41:25] Jesse McInally: If you would like to join them in supporting us in tons of fun perks such as Patreon only commentaries, our episodes are a few days early.

[41:31] Brianna Jones: Now they're posting on Monday with the video episodes.

[41:33] Jesse McInally: Come trunk us all out over at Patreon.

[41:36] Brianna Jones: How about we get back to the show?

[41:45] Jesse McInally: So legally, we can only talk about two songs from this musical.

[41:52] Brianna Jones: Because they have yet to release an official Broadway cast album.

[41:56] Jesse McInally: But that has never stopped us before.

[41:59] Brianna Jones: So let's talk about the children's song, What the Hell?

[42:03] Jesse McInally: Can't you see what's happening here?

[42:06] Brianna Jones: Mom has made a head to sell here, and that's all that she thinks can replace you.

[42:17] Jesse McInally: I can't even know we're gonna share that house with creepy old lady in a hitting slice.

[42:29] Brianna Jones: Do you even remember this number, Andrew?

[42:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh um no.

[42:38] Brianna Jones: I actually don't.

[42:40] Andrew DeWolf: I just straight up don't remember this one.

[42:41] Brianna Jones: How's it how does it go?

[42:43] Andrew DeWolf: You don't remember the song at all.

[42:45] Brianna Jones: No, I really don't.

[42:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so god dang.

[42:52] Brianna Jones: I remember I'm looking at the song list and that we have, and I remember the songs before it, and I remember the songs after it, and this song I literally don't remember.

[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: So this is the song about the kids and how th they are allowed to swear because the k the adults are acting like children.

[43:09] Brianna Jones: So they're like, alright, we're all gonna say what the hell about this situation.

[43:14] Andrew DeWolf: Now, I've got a small issue with this song.

[43:17] Brianna Jones: I've listened to this song about six or seven times today.

[43:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I know, but I wanted to be like, alright, what do I have to say about the songs I can talk about?

[43:27] Brianna Jones: I don't like some of the rhymes.

[43:29] Andrew DeWolf: I I guess we probably should have talked more about like something rotten, which we covered a thousand years ago.

[43:34] Brianna Jones: Do you remember anything about that show?

[43:36] Andrew DeWolf: I just remember that it was actually somewhat funny.

[43:39] Andrew DeWolf: There was some pretty good jokes in it.

[43:40] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it wasn't from the book writers.

[43:42] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, the same book writer did not come to this.

[43:45] Jesse McInally: It is the songwriters.

[43:47] Andrew DeWolf: I remember the songs were pretty generic, like very very much like just kinda okay.

[43:52] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and I think the same's here too.

[43:54] Andrew DeWolf: But let me read you some songs and maybe you can understand why I don't like the rhymes.

[43:58] Jesse McInally: So, well, this was not supposed to happen.

[44:01] Andrew DeWolf: And this is just a bunch of crap, and no one asked if I would go along.

[44:05] Jesse McInally: And all at once the adults have spoken.

[44:07] Andrew DeWolf: Now I'm a kid in a home that's broken, because they can't fix all that they did wrong.

[44:11] Jesse McInally: So this is my life. Isn't this gr just great? Isn't this just well? What the hell?

[44:17] Andrew DeWolf: So let's talk about let this happen and crap and crap and and happened.

[44:24] Jesse McInally: I mean, it's like a like a near rhyme. You could justify it being an internal rhyme, but they make the poor child actors who I s I wanna say, all the child actors in this show are doing a great job. Ten out of ten, no faults in them. You are doing the best you can with this material.

[44:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[44:43] Jesse McInally: Uh the wife character, on the other hand, not so great. You're you you turned a pretty nuanced character into a shrew, and I think you did a particularly bad job in this role. Sorry.

[44:56] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I think she's very bad in this role.

[44:59] Jesse McInally: Okay. It's hard to step into Sally Field's shoes just as hard as it is to step into Robin Williams's.

[45:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but they make her say crappin', so it sounds like she's talking about taking a dump.

[45:10] Jesse McInally: Yes. Just to make their rhyme work, and it just rings to my ear awkward.

[45:15] Andrew DeWolf: Brie play clip of it right now.

[45:18] Jesse McInally: Well, we're sponsored supposed to happen's just a bunch of crappin' no one asking by go along.

[45:31] Andrew DeWolf: Boy, isn't that sound weird? Maybe they were just talking about taking a dump.

[45:35] Jesse McInally: I wish they were. At least that might get a laugh out of me in this musical.

[45:39] Andrew DeWolf: Well, what other songs are we allowed to talk about? Is there what why would they pick this song to be one of the two they released?

[45:45] Jesse McInally: Because they have cute kids that you can send to like Broadway Con to perform it.

[45:50] Andrew DeWolf: Not into that.

[45:51] Jesse McInally: Alright. However, at Good Morning America, Rob McClure did perform your favorite song about the clocks.

[45:57] Andrew DeWolf: Did they just pick the worst songs to put out?

[45:59] Jesse McInally: That is slightly impressive. I I know you don't like this song, but I think it's pretty cool.

[46:04] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it's just the looping machine. I've seen people do that at local music shows. I saw uh Cyril Amey, who performs like very intense Sondheim songs, and she did an entire a cappella Sondheim song with a loop machine as her backing track.

[46:21] Jesse McInally: It was the most impressive shit that I've ever seen anyone do live. So it is pretty impressive to watch someone come up with a looping machine and make it sound like anything worthwhile.

[46:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, it's it's fine. I I think what I have a problem with is the um The the puppets.

[46:37] Jesse McInally: The voice. The puppets and the voices, like it's all particularly not funny.

[46:41] Andrew DeWolf: So uh what was the name of this song?

[46:44] Jesse McInally: About time.

[46:45] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, so I was right. This is this is this is before the uh the uh fashion show.

[46:51] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's well before it.

[46:53] Andrew DeWolf: You said it was after.

[46:54] Jesse McInally: Did I? Okay. Sorry, my bad.

[46:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[46:57] Jesse McInally: Um, yeah, no, so this is uh yeah, it's fine. I I think it's an interesting thing. I I mean the looping machine is kind of cool. The way they introduced the looping machine makes it very obvious that they're about to do a thing with it, but you know, whatever.

[47:11] Andrew DeWolf: I like it. I I think Rob McClure's a very good actor. I just wish I don't know. It's less cringe than what raw our Robin Williams did in the movie, which is just rapping about dinosaurs.

[47:22] Jesse McInally: Yeah, well, I I've not said that I was a fan of the movie either.

[47:25] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no. I'm not saying you did. Just as far as if a musical's making a change that I think is better, I do want to point it out.

[47:33] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[47:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Then the only the only song that they've officially released as like a proper recorded one, where the other ones were just kind of live performances officially released, though, is the final number as long as there's love, which is probably the most effective song in the show.

[47:48] Jesse McInally: Wherever you go, whatever you do, not goodness will shine follow you as long as they love.

[48:04] Andrew DeWolf: Whatever you dream, whatever you choose, whatever the end of us, as long as there is love.

[48:17] Jesse McInally: Yes. I like that. Even if it is just kind of a generic, like, man, isn't it good to love everybody? Sweet.

[48:24] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it is at the same time, everyone. I I like I like seeing it. Is it's nice that he like is getting along with his ex and and even her new boyfriend in a way.

[48:36] Jesse McInally: Like do you get along with any of your exes, Andrew?

[48:39] Andrew DeWolf: Not at all.

[48:39] Brianna Jones: Really?

[48:40] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[48:40] Brianna Jones: Brigie, what about you?

[48:43] Brianna Jones: No.

[48:44] Jesse McInally: That's a no. What about you, Jess?

[48:46] Jesse McInally: I get along with most of my exes. Like two of them worked on my last film. We're good buddies. I just feel like it's not that hard to keep in good contact with your ex, but this seems like a fucking uns insurmountable mountain.

[48:58] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I haven't been in a breakup for about 11 years, though, so maybe I'm just out of touch.

[49:04] Jesse McInally: What do you think, Andrew?

[49:05] Andrew DeWolf: I think that after a messy divorce like that, it's kind of a miracle that he's able to get along with her. I mean, you're both.

[49:11] Jesse McInally: I hate to say this, I don't and feel free to cut this out. You both kind of went through your own divorces, right?

[49:14] Andrew DeWolf: You didn't go through a divorce, Andrew.

[49:18] Andrew DeWolf: I've never been married.

[49:19] Jesse McInally: Not you, but like your parents.

[49:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I've been through several.

[49:24] Brianna Jones: Oh, yeah, my my parents got divorced. Like they live in different states now. I think a lot of the effectiveness of both the movie and the musical is how the kids kind of lame themselves for the divorce, whether or not it makes sense or not.

[49:37] Jesse McInally: No, that's like a totally valid thing. I was just talking to my therapist about this yesterday.

[49:42] Brianna Jones: I'm so sorry, I don't mean to bring up anything.

[49:43] Jesse McInally: Oh my god, no, it's no problem. No, but yes, children do have a tendency to take on like this idea that uh divorce is their fault, or that they have to like be like a peacekeeper or do something for their parents.

[49:59] Brianna Jones: So I think it is the mature thing for parents to try to work it out and make it an effective relationship between the two of them by dressing up as a Scottish nanny.

[50:08] Jesse McInally: Yes! That is the only way to make divorces work.

[50:12] Andrew DeWolf: Remember when your father did that, Andrew?

[50:16] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, fond memories.

[50:18] Andrew DeWolf: Fond memories. It was Irish actually, though.

[50:22] Jesse McInally: Oh, that always have to be lucky chums.

[50:26] Brianna Jones: Jeez, guess you don't have to bring the racism into it.

[50:30] Jesse McInally: I'm sorry. What is my last name again?

[50:33] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. It's certainly not Irish, though.

[50:36] Jesse McInally: McAnally?

[50:37] Andrew DeWolf: McEnaly's.

[50:38] Jesse McInally: MC Ainley. That's more like a DJ, isn't it? You've been making that joke for over a decade now.

[50:48] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, what is everyone's overall thoughts on Mrs. Doubtfire of the musical and a cheese reading? Andrew, why don't you start?

[50:55] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy. Um, I didn't like it. Um, really at all. I think that there was certain aspects of it that I was like, well, this is fine, and like they're trying. Um, but like, yeah, I mean, the the man in a dress jokes just don't land. They are just not funny. Um, and like I'll be real, like some of it was like cringe, like like aggressively unfunny, like secondhand embarrassment, you know, like giving me some serious secondhand embarrassment.

[51:24] Jesse McInally: Um that being said, um, I'll give it a cheese rating. Uh, here's here's a good one. we're gonna give it uh Butterway's cheese, which is a Scottish cheese.

[51:31] Andrew DeWolf: That's fair. We'll give it that. Um, and uh I think that's the last I want to talk about this ever.

[51:37] Jesse McInally: Really? Tell us more.

[51:41] Brianna Jones: Bree, what is your overall thoughts on our discussion and your cheese rating?

[51:45] Brianna Jones: Your discussion? Fantastic. Very fun to listen to. Um, but I will be in New York in a couple months and I will definitely not go see this.

[51:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um can I come with you?

[51:55] Brianna Jones: Yeah, it's a bachelorette party if you're

[51:55] Andrew DeWolf: Oh hell yeah. I get dressed in drunk as a Scottish nanny.

[52:01] Brianna Jones: I'm just here to clean the room.

[52:07] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[52:08] Brianna Jones: Uh so yeah, I definitely don't want to go see um Doubtfire.

[52:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um uh it is um it doesn't work. Doesn't work.

[52:18] Brianna Jones: I don't think it probably worked in the 90s, doesn't work now. So I'm gonna give it like an expired cheese, like maybe some expired Swiss.

[52:27] Andrew DeWolf: That's just a great cheese rating.

[52:29] Brianna Jones: 10 out of 10. Thank you. Got some black mold on it.

[52:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, my cheese rating is flaming Greek cheese, because you know, this shit's on fire. So much as you might even doubt it. It might be even a doubt fire.

[52:42] Brianna Jones: Ha ha, what did you think of the show though?

[52:45] Andrew DeWolf: The show's bad. I don't like it. The movie is better and it hasn't aged well to begin with. Um, Rob McClure, very good actor. We should give him a good role one of these days.

[52:55] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[52:55] Andrew DeWolf: I think this is Doubtfire. It's just a show that we uh it's just a story that we need to just forget. That Tootsie, there has to be one more. The rule of threes. There's one more like guy dresses in drag to fool someone musical.

[53:09] Jesse McInally: I I'm honestly sure there's a lot of them, and I think they just need to go away.

[53:13] Andrew DeWolf: So today on Twitter, I actually put a tweet out, and it's gaining some traction that I did not expect because it was just a question.

[53:20] Jesse McInally: Um yeah, I did not expect traction. Like throughout this, we've had like 30,000.

[53:26] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god, that's a lot of lot of replies. But I put this tweet out. Is Kinky Boots the only Broadway musical about a man dressing in drag within the last 15 years that isn't trying to deceive someone?

[53:36] Jesse McInally: And basically everyone is agreeing with me, like, oh shit, you're right.

[53:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[53:40] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and I don't know why that is. Why are men dressing in drag to try to fool people? Can't they just do it for fun?

[53:46] Andrew DeWolf: Because I I almost feel like it's because there's like a uh a humiliation aspect to it.

[53:51] Jesse McInally: Is there though?

[53:52] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's like this guy's in his lowest possible point, and then he's forced to dress in drag to get any sort of respect or whatever back. And then in Tootsie, it's like this guy's can't get any work, so he has to dress in drag to get work. And it's like, I don't know. I feel like part of the humor is maybe we're supposed to be laughing at these people.

[54:09] Jesse McInally: I don't know. It's nothing funny to me about a man in a dress.

[54:12] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, there shouldn't be. It's just I think that the people writing these jokes think that there is.

[54:18] Jesse McInally: Maybe we should just stop letting boomers write musicals.

[54:21] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe we should just stop letting boomers.

[54:24] Jesse McInally: Maybe we should stop letting musicals.

[54:28] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, guys. Musicals are done.

[54:31] Jesse McInally: Yeah, we're done.

[54:32] Brianna Jones: We'll be back next week with cheese.

[54:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, just cheese.

[54:40] Jesse McInally: Welcome to with cheese.

[54:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um, a podcast where I try to get Justin Andrew to like cheese.

[54:47] Brianna Jones: Doesn't Andrew.

[54:50] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. We're talking about Doubtfire the Musical. I don't know what's going on anymore, Brie.

[54:54] Brianna Jones: You don't even know who I am.

[54:57] Jesse McInally: I know you're wonderful.

[54:59] Brianna Jones: And you know who else is wonderful?

[55:02] Jesse McInally: Tell me.

[55:03] Brianna Jones: Our wonderful patrons. Thank you guys for listening. We're on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals with Cheese, Instagram musicals with cheese, YouTube page musicals with cheese. We have a patron only podcast called Patreon with Cheese. It's a lot of fun over there. We have a ton of commentaries over there on Patreon, a lot more coming, so that's gonna be a lot of fun.

[55:23] Jesse McInally: Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our title card is created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go send them up some love on Instagram at Jolene Casco. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Thank you for keeping me up with our cheese ratings, because God knows I wasn't gonna do it. This show is produced by the wonderful, the incredible, one of my favorite people in the entire world, Brianna Jones.

[55:46] Jesse McInally: I love you, Brie. Our theme songs were created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for knocking us off or make talking so much shit about Doubtfire the Musical, which no doubt will be the most incredible musical when it comes back in April.

[56:04] Andrew DeWolf: Because hold on, I didn't even get to talk about that. They took uh nine month week hiatus because they got bad reviews, and when they come back, they're hoping people will forget they got bad reviews.

[56:15] Jesse McInally: And I think that's the funniest shit on the planet. They took a hiatus. They're like, alright, we're done. We'll come back in March. And then they're like, we'll come back in April. Maybe someday they'll forget how bad the show is, and then they'll maybe we can figure out how to make the show work in that time, but probably not, you know.

[56:33] Andrew DeWolf: Well, we can't change anything, so maybe uh it will just be better.

[56:38] Jesse McInally: Maybe people will get so stop being so upset and laugh at the man in a dress.

[56:44] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

[56:53] Jesse McInally: I don't know any songs from Mrs. Doubtfire, so I'm just gonna sing dude looks like a lady.

[56:58] Andrew DeWolf: Nah!

[56:59] Jesse McInally: Nah! Dude looks like a lady!

[57:03] Andrew DeWolf: Dude looks like a lady!

[57:05] Jesse McInally: I think I think the only song I can actually remember like how it goes is the uh fulmenko song that they do.

[57:11] Andrew DeWolf: Well, how does that one go?

[57:13] Jesse McInally: Lie to me or something like that.

[57:15] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, that song was fun.

[57:16] Jesse McInally: Yeah, that was like maybe the best song in the whole thing, but it was like not even plot like relevant necessarily. It's just gonna like it was just kind of funny. It's like, oh ha, they're singing about lies, and like you lied. Haha.

[57:28] Andrew DeWolf: Free keep all the sin. Also, geez, did you see what's happening in Texas right now? Feels like a little bit relevant to this, what we're talking about here.

[57:38] Jesse McInally: He's like making it so any parent that has a uh trans child could get uh prosecuted for child abuse. Just a reminder that like maybe this is bad stuff that we shouldn't have in our culture, fellas. It's not just like uh, oh, we're uptight and don't like stuff. It's like uh, hey, maybe like maybe this is just bad.

[57:57] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe we just shouldn't have stuff like Tootsie and Mrs. Doubtfire just kinda chillin' out on Broadway.

[58:04] Jesse McInally: Especially when Broadway is supposed to be kind of a haven for like progressivism and things a lot of times, so

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred