Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#22:  "Spider-Man Turn off the Dark" (Feat. Allison Pregler)

Sponsored by Audible. Get your FREE AUDIOBOOK at: www.audibletrial.com/MusicalswithCheese. Spider-man, Spider-man, this week we're talkin' 'bout Spider-man! We are joined by the incredible Allison Pregler of Movie Nights to talk about Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 1 min
2/1/19

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Sponsored by Audible. Get your FREE AUDIOBOOK at: www.audibletrial.com/MusicalswithCheese

Spider-man, Spider-man, this week we're talkin' 'bout Spider-man! We are joined by the incredible Allison Pregler of Movie Nights to talk about Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark. We chat about the trials and tribulations behind the scenes, the final product, and the experience of seeing the show live compares to a recording.

Special Thanks to Patrons:

Terri Needleman

Stephanie L

Links:

Listen to "Spider-Man Turn off the Dark" Now!

Donate to our Patreon

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals w/ Cheese on Instagram

Jess on Twitter

Jess on Instagram

Andrew on Twitter

Andrew on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jess McInally: Hi guys, welcome to the show.

[0:01] Jess McInally: Just so you know, today's show is brought to you by Audible.

[0:03] Jess McInally: Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership.

[0:08] Jess McInally: Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs.

[0:14] Jess McInally: Download a title free and start listening.

[0:16] Jess McInally: It's that easy.

[0:17] Jess McInally: Go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese.

[0:20] Jess McInally: Alright, let's get you on to the real show.

[0:25] Jess McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[0:27] Andrew Dwarf: And I'm Andrew Dwarf.

[0:29] Jess McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I tried to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:33] Jess McInally: And today we've got a very special guest.

[0:36] Jess McInally: Um her name is Allison Pregler, and she is known for Movie Nights, Bay Watching, and a ton of other incredible things.

[0:43] Jess McInally: So, hooray, Allison is here.

[0:45] Allison Pregler: Hi guys. Thanks for having me on.

[0:48] Jess McInally: Oh, thank you for coming. Welcome to the show, yeah.

[0:50] Jess McInally: So tell us, tell the audience just a little bit about what you do in your section of the internet, because it's wonderful.

[0:56] Allison Pregler: Oh, thank you. Um, I talk about movies, TV, all sorts of different things.

[1:02] Allison Pregler: Uh usually so bad it's good kind of things.

[1:05] Allison Pregler: Just having fun with the uh the corniest kind of um hilariously bad stuff.

[1:10] Allison Pregler: Uh things like Birdemic or The Room or Baywatch, like you pointed out.

[1:14] Allison Pregler: So that's what I do.

[1:15] Jess McInally: I mean, we're covering something pretty so bad it's good today, kind of.

[1:19] Jess McInally: This is sort of the ultimate so bad it's good of this genre, don't you think?

[1:24] Allison Pregler: Is it good though?

[1:27] Jess McInally: You know, it has moments.

[1:28] Allison Pregler: It has moments.

[1:29] Jess McInally: So what are we covering today, Allison?

[1:32] Allison Pregler: Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark.

[1:33] Jess McInally: Yay, that didn't feel rehearsed.

[1:45] Jess McInally: So Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark is a musical with music and lyrics by Bono and the Edge for some reason, and a book by Julie Tamor and Glenn Berger, with revisions by Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa.

[1:56] Jess McInally: The musical is based on the Spider-Man comics created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko, published by Marvel Comics, as well as the 2002 film and the Greek myth of Arachne that tells Spider-Man's origin story, his romance with Mary Jane, and his battles with the Green Goblin.

[2:11] Jess McInally: It shows the show includes highly technical stunts such as aerial combat scenes and actors swinging from webs.

[2:18] Jess McInally: And Allison, you are actually blessed and a part of history because you got to see this live.

[2:24] Allison Pregler: I did.

[2:25] Allison Pregler: You know what? This is the only Broadway show I've ever seen.

[2:28] Jess McInally: Oh my god.

[2:29] Allison Pregler: And I'm glad if I'm going to see one, it's gonna be Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark.

[2:35] Allison Pregler: I bought the t-shirt.

[2:37] Allison Pregler: I was all for this thing.

[2:39] Allison Pregler: Like, um, I was visiting some friends in New York, um, with uh Lindsay Ellis and everyone over there, and uh, and we just wanted to go see a show, and we're like, Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark is on.

[2:51] Allison Pregler: We know that this is a thing.

[2:52] Allison Pregler: We've been hearing about it forever.

[2:54] Allison Pregler: Like, this is historic, so we gotta go see it.

[2:57] Allison Pregler: And we did, and it was everything I could have hoped and more.

[3:03] Allison Pregler: It was truly an experience.

[3:05] Jess McInally: Oh my god.

[3:07] Jess McInally: I just wanna know what that was like.

[3:09] Jess McInally: Like, uh, because I've only seen clips and like bootlegs.

[3:13] Jess McInally: Like, are the stunts as incredible as they seem, or are they just a little bit lackluster?

[3:19] Allison Pregler: I know it's a little early, but I'm just too curious.

[3:21] Allison Pregler: I can't ask.

[3:22] Allison Pregler: I can't help but ask.

[3:24] Allison Pregler: Well, it was the show is such an enigma, right?

[3:28] Allison Pregler: Because it's so mired in controversy over this troubled production that they had.

[3:34] Allison Pregler: But honestly and truly, the wireworks and the stunts and the sets um were all really, really amazing in person.

[3:44] Allison Pregler: Like when Spider-Man's like flying over everyone, and when you see like the um, there's parts of the set that's like a building, and then it moves up to show they're like scaling the building, and um all of it is so grandiose, and that part genuinely is very impressive.

[4:01] Allison Pregler: I can tell you one thing though.

[4:03] Allison Pregler: Um it's a show that's like both expensive and cheap because uh as you guys could tell from from the copy that we all watched, um, it is the most expensive Broadway production of all time, and you can see it in the in all of the uh the the sets and the stunts and all of that, but also you get wacky inflatable arm man lizard and uh and a blow-up doll wrestler and a prominent display of prominent display of stage hands.

[4:36] Allison Pregler: It's it's bizarre the shortcuts that are there for something that was so extraordinarily expensive.

[4:43] Allison Pregler: It's like they blew all their money on like some of the stunts, and then the rest of it, they're like, we've got five dollars, what do we do?

[4:50] Allison Pregler: I didn't know.

[4:51] Allison Pregler: You know, I was glad to watch the copy um that that we all watched because I haven't rewatched it since it came out, obviously, because it didn't they don't put it on anymore.

[5:00] Allison Pregler: But seeing it again, um I got to see details I either didn't remember or didn't notice from from being in in the audience versus right up there by the stage.

[5:10] Allison Pregler: And uh I didn't remember like a part where there's like a there's like a flyer flying toward him, and it's just a it's just the stage hand with it on a stick, and then the stick floats over to him.

[5:24] Allison Pregler: I'm like, is this a high school production?

[5:26] Allison Pregler: What is happening here?

[5:28] Allison Pregler: No, this is the most expensive Broadway show of all time.

[5:31] Allison Pregler: The most expensive of all time and paper on a stick that happened.

[5:35] Allison Pregler: The small steps that it took to be like from that like most expensive show of all time and deserving that title to um basically paper mache art on stage is it's a small They have silly string webs.

[5:35] Allison Pregler: Silly string.

[5:51] Allison Pregler: It's a slippery slope from like an actual idea to like complete insanity.

[5:57] Allison Pregler: And now I'm just curious to you guys, both of you.

[6:00] Allison Pregler: Um given the same amount of resources and ideas I'm sure we all generally know about Spider-Man, how would you guys make a Spider-Man musical?

[6:09] Andrew Dwarf: Uh I mean I would do probably literally anything except this.

[6:13] Andrew Dwarf: Uh this is just a remake of the movie to put on stage in like the worst way possible with music by Bono.

[6:20] Andrew Dwarf: I I don't e I think they just did almost everything wrong, and it's amazing.

[6:25] Jess McInally: What about you, Allison?

[6:27] Allison Pregler: How would you adapt Spider-Man to stage if you had a gun to your head and had to choose to?

[6:32] Allison Pregler: I would take the original Julie Tamor version with the song about shoes and not change a damn thing.

[6:42] Allison Pregler: That's what I would do.

[6:43] Allison Pregler: Uh that's the saddest part to me, is not being able to see that version because as goofy as the one was that we ended up with, it sounded even more insane before they had workshopped it.

[6:56] Jess McInally: Was it was this something that that you'd heard about, Andrew?

[6:59] Andrew Dwarf: I know Jess probably looked into it.

[7:01] Andrew Dwarf: I mean, I if there's like a more insane version of this, if you're just trying to preserve the like this is the room on stage kind of thing, then maybe I would say that's a good idea.

[7:12] Andrew Dwarf: If you want to make something that's actually good, I I think this whole thing needs to be scrapped, but I mean, if you're trying to do like a a genuine good Spider-Man musical, I think the um like I mentioned, the wire work and all of that is great.

[7:27] Andrew Dwarf: And if you're gonna base it on the movies, which it's heavily the Sam Raimi movies, um, that's fine too.

[7:33] Andrew Dwarf: But I I don't know if Bono was really the best genre music choice for musical theater.

[7:40] Andrew Dwarf: That was really weird.

[7:42] Andrew Dwarf: All of the stuff with Arachne just seems very out of place.

[7:45] Jess McInally: So I I would have like leaned into the Arachne elements and made it very much its own thing.

[7:53] Jess McInally: Like I would have like because that's actually one of the more interesting parts of this show, like the Julie Tamor aesthetics of actually knowing how to tell a story theatrically instead of just like I just gotta check all the boxes.

[8:07] Jess McInally: I liked the stuff with the the weavers at the beginning when they're they're telling the story of Arachne, and they have them coming in like weaving the uh the things that they're hanging off of together, and and she comes out.

[8:20] Andrew Dwarf: Though I mean some of the lyrics, like she starts singing about like being a spider.

[8:25] Andrew Dwarf: She goes, forever a spider is what she sings.

[8:28] Andrew Dwarf: And I'm like, how do you know what a spider is?

[8:30] Andrew Dwarf: You're the first spider, aren't you?

[8:32] Allison Pregler: Yeah, this doesn't make any sort of sense to spiders are you.

[8:37] Allison Pregler: She fell into that right away.

[8:39] Allison Pregler: And um, she has these mitten hands, like her hands are these these mittens.

[8:44] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah, that was weird to me too.

[8:45] Andrew Dwarf: It's it's ridiculous.

[8:47] Allison Pregler: Maybe drop the Spider-Man, maybe drop Spider-Man and just make an Arachne musical.

[8:51] Jess McInally: I think I recommended that a few weeks ago.

[8:53] Andrew Dwarf: He did, it's fast.

[8:54] Allison Pregler: Her songs are really pretty, like, and her voice is really pretty.

[8:57] Allison Pregler: It just doesn't nothing's terribly cohesive.

[9:00] Jess McInally: Well, Arachne has other than the spider part, has nothing to do with Spider-Man at all.

[9:05] Jess McInally: So it has to do with Julie Tamor loving like mythology and all that and trying to put a stamp onto this um Spider-Man show that she was greenlit into doing.

[9:14] Andrew Dwarf: Well, if you don't know about the original version where Arachne was the villain and and it was more the uh part of the story there, it's a little confusing because like why is Arachne part of this story if she isn't the villain?

[9:28] Andrew Dwarf: Like, I I don't know about the the story parallels there, even though the visuals are really pretty.

[9:35] Allison Pregler: Um exactly that.

[9:36] Allison Pregler: They already paid for the lady spider costume and all the stuff, so we gotta get her in there somewhere.

[9:42] Allison Pregler: It was the same with the Swiss Miss character, too.

[9:45] Allison Pregler: She was a holdover from the other one, and with the uh the backstory that they put into this new version, it doesn't make a lot of sense her being there.

[9:54] Andrew Dwarf: Uh and it it's a shame with the copy that we watched because they cut out part of the middle which explains some things.

[10:00] Andrew Dwarf: Um, but all of these villains are created by different organic elements that uh that uh the goblin has put into his machine.

[10:09] Andrew Dwarf: So you have like Carnage is made from a guy in some blood or something, and then Kraven is part animal and and all these weird things, and then you have like electricity, and Swiss Miss is like a Swiss army knife.

[10:26] Allison Pregler: What?

[10:26] Andrew Dwarf: But why that's not organic.

[10:28] Andrew Dwarf: How does that work?

[10:30] Allison Pregler: So so the Green Goblin in in in this key creates all the Spider-Man villains, basically.

[10:35] Andrew Dwarf: He does.

[10:36] Andrew Dwarf: Um basically what they did in this one was give him kind of Doc Ock's story from the second Raimi movie.

[10:44] Andrew Dwarf: Like he gets in his machine and then his wife dies and he like creates himself.

[10:49] Andrew Dwarf: And uh a section of this copy that we watched was just cut out, and I know what happens because I saw it.

[10:56] Andrew Dwarf: I don't know how confused you guys were.

[10:59] Allison Pregler: I got a little bit confused, yes.

[11:00] Andrew Dwarf: Yes, I did too.

[11:01] Allison Pregler: Um they cut out the best damn song in it though.

[11:04] Allison Pregler: The best song in this musical is Freak Like Me Needs Company that the Green Goblin sings with all of the villains.

[11:12] Andrew Dwarf: I think it was a soundtrack though.

[11:13] Andrew Dwarf: I could have sworn the soundtrack somewhere.

[11:15] Allison Pregler: So if like they used it for all the promotions because it's easily the best song.

[11:20] Allison Pregler: And uh if you guys have Spotify, like check out the soundtrack on there, it's all there.

[11:25] Allison Pregler: Um it highlights also that the Green Goblin is the saving grace of this whole thing.

[11:32] Allison Pregler: He is easily like the most entertaining part to me.

[11:35] Allison Pregler: Portrayed by the amazing Patrick Page.

[11:37] Jess McInally: Is he well known in the theater circuit?

[11:39] Allison Pregler: Um, he's becoming well known.

[11:41] Allison Pregler: He was very well known for playing Scar for many years, and then the Green Goblin made him more prominent, and he's been in the more recent productions of The Hunchback of Notre Dame as Frollo, where he's incredible and he's about to premiere on in Hadestown this um this upcoming Broadway season, which he's gonna be fantastic in.

[11:59] Jess McInally: So he's getting up there.

[12:01] Andrew Dwarf: That's great.

[12:01] Andrew Dwarf: Like it's he sold it.

[12:03] Allison Pregler: It's never too late to start.

[12:05] Andrew Dwarf: How old is he?

[12:06] Allison Pregler: He's on the older side.

[12:07] Allison Pregler: He's gotta be like late fifties, early sixties.

[12:09] Andrew Dwarf: Well, good for him.

[12:10] Allison Pregler: Good for him, because he he committed to it.

[12:13] Allison Pregler: And um one of the things I remember too about when I saw it and uh from stories that I heard too was that when they were having these uh huge production issues, like for instance, uh during their opening night for press, things were going wrong, like the wire work was going wrong, and they had to like halt everything, and he would be like vamping for the audience, like buying time for them.

[12:34] Allison Pregler: So he'd be like playing the piano on the top of the stage, like he does in the actual show, but he would just keep going and try and just make it a good time. And I remember the reviews saying, like, if more if the show had more of the self-awareness, it would be an altogether more pleasant experience.

[12:50] Jess McInally: Uh-huh.

[12:51] Allison Pregler: And when I saw it, um we had the intermission, and when we came back, I distinctly remember the lights come up, and he's standing on the stage in his full Green Goblin outfit, just basking in it, and no response at all. Like everyone's sitting there silent. You could hear like a cough, like as we're watching, and clearly he's waiting for an applause or something that doesn't happen. And he goes, Oh, I bet you say that to all the boys.

[13:22] Jess McInally: As if he did get the applause.

[13:27] Allison Pregler: Should have done like a jazz hands or something, like tada. And I don't think that's even his fault. It's the fault of the staging and the way that it's like because it is awkward. It really is.

[13:39] Jess McInally: Oh, it totally is.

[13:40] Allison Pregler: But like he's not, it's not anything to do with his performance, and really I I don't think it's anything to do with anyone else's performance either. Just the the show as a whole is very awkward at parts. There's no saving it as a problem. I mean, every one of these actors saw this show slowly divulge into artistic trash into a universal stage show. The guy who played um Peter Parker in the copy we watched was the understudy, and the version I saw, I believe was with the original one.

[14:11] Jess McInally: Reeves do you remember?

[14:13] Allison Pregler: Reeves Carney would have been the original if you saw him, I believe.

[14:15] Jess McInally: Yeah, Reeve Carney.

[14:16] Allison Pregler: I believe it was him. Um because this guy, I don't he just kind of seemed like more of a nerd, but not in a way that I I bought. Kind of contradictory.

[14:27] Jess McInally: Well that's the thing about Reeve Carney's performance. He always seemed too cool to be a nerd. A lot like how the Andrew Garfield version of Spider-Man it's a hard line there like when you're trying to be Spider-Man because Spider-Man is cool but Spider-Man's also a nerd and so you gotta kinda be both.

[14:45] Allison Pregler: It's it's a difficult role for any action play like in stage or in live action as we've seen. So I feel like the whole like the the the bullies that were that were bullying him they had that like bullying by numbers song that went on just short of forever. And they all kind of talked like this bullying by numbers and um it was not good.

[15:10] Jess McInally: What's that bully from uh from that cartoon Doug?

[15:12] Allison Pregler: It's like all of them were that were that kid.

[15:15] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[15:15] Allison Pregler: All of them were greasers for some reason. Like either greasers or Burger King kids.

[15:20] Jess McInally: Yeah well the the time period confused me too with this because like it it's all over the place. They seem like they're straight from the 90s but then you got these 40s Dick Tracy villains going on and then you got these 60s secretaries at the paper and like all of these things mishmash together that don't like stylistically I'm not sure why they did that.

[15:43] Allison Pregler: And then on top of that they have jokes about Applebee's.

[15:46] Jess McInally: Yeah, what in all reality it takes place in ancient Greece.

[15:50] Allison Pregler: So that was something that was in the um the original uh Julie Tamor version that I was sad that they took out was the geek chorus.

[16:00] Jess McInally: Yes.

[16:01] Allison Pregler: Terrible pun, like so cringe, but I think that's a good one. I thought that was a typo.

[16:07] Jess McInally: I thought it was a typo.

[16:08] Allison Pregler: Nope. There was like a couple of geeks on the side of the stage just guiding you through the story.

[16:13] Jess McInally: Oh my god.

[16:14] Allison Pregler: And the girl that played Arachne in the final version started as one of the geek choruses, and then slowly, as the other arachnines got injured and like fell out, became arachne.

[16:26] Jess McInally: Oh man, what a trajectory.

[16:29] Allison Pregler: What is it with uh Ancient Greece and ruining Broadway shows?

[16:34] Jess McInally: What was that? Like uh the Carrie thing where they all were dressed in togas or something?

[16:38] Allison Pregler: Yeah, the original version of Carrie, there was a miscommunication that they wanted to be like Greece, and the director misinterpreted it from like the Greece musical to Ancient Greece.

[16:48] Jess McInally: Oh my god, is that true?

[16:50] Allison Pregler: Yes.

[16:51] Jess McInally: Oh my god.

[16:53] Allison Pregler: One of many reasons why Carrie flopped.

[16:55] Jess McInally: I need to see Carrie the musical.

[16:58] Allison Pregler: That just sounds fantastic. I saw the Riverdale episode that centered around it.

[17:06] Jess McInally: Did you guys notice in uh in Turn Off the Dark that uh all of the well not all of it, some of the costumes and the cloth and stuff they painted on lines as if it was a comic book?

[17:18] Allison Pregler: Yes, that sounds like a very a very tamor-esque decision.

[17:22] Jess McInally: Yeah, they did. I noticed that. It was awkward. I don't think it looked good. I wish it was consistent. Like, cause it you almost don't notice it, so it's like uh go into it more, like if you're if that's what you're gonna do.

[17:36] Allison Pregler: The inconsistency is beyond just that, though, because they have like different styles for every single scene in the show, and like you got the uh the giant inflatable guy, and then the uh criminals with like a big big heads, like you can't they can't keep an art style, like they can't pick anything.

[17:56] Jess McInally: I feel like the most consistent thing about the show is the disgusting neon look of everything.

[18:02] Allison Pregler: My favorite part to revisit, because this was just surreal when I saw it and seeing it again, like brought back such great memories. Um when they have the montage of when he first becomes Spider-Man and he's saving the city, and that's when you get like all the bobblehead gangsters and all that stuff going on, and he's like flying through. You have the different stunt Spider-Man and and all of these like uh audio clips, and a lot of it's very artistic representation of things. Um, and they have like these cutouts that will like come through, and while he's like stopping some robbers, you just hear my baby, and then giant Spider-Man floats in, his hand comes in, and a a baby floats into his hand, which has to be so tiny that it that the baby fits just in a hand.

[18:57] Jess McInally: Ridiculous.

[18:58] Allison Pregler: It's either Spider-Man has just grown so much that a baby is that size, or that's a very tiny baby.

[19:04] Jess McInally: Weird proportions.

[19:07] Allison Pregler: Well, there was a uh a storied history with this, and um uh there's a book about it called Song of Spider-Man, Song of Spider-Man, I should say. Uh Song of Spider-Man, uh by the the other creator, Glenn something or Glennberger.

[19:22] Jess McInally: Glenn Berger.

[19:24] Allison Pregler: And uh I read it a while ago, so I I couldn't remember all of the details of it. But basically it goes from beginning to end, how did this happen? And it's really, really interesting because when you read it, you really can't blame any one particular person for everything. A lot of it went on to Julie Tamor, and that's why she ended up fired, but she came into it just with a lot of ambition, and maybe she was tackling it from just a a different angle because of Lion King and just wasn't seeing that this wasn't the right direction or or whatever, but all these ki things came together, and and I don't think it was as expensive as it eventually became just because of all of the injuries and all of the reworkings and all the delays and and everything that went into it.

[20:08] Jess McInally: Because just piled up. It had like the longest like preview period in Broadway history at 182, like preview performances, and that is insane.

[20:17] Allison Pregler: Man, that the I don't envy anyone that was part of the production because that's it's so thankless. But you know, they all worked really hard on it, and uh like I said, genuinely um the wire work that went into it is super impressive and I could see the work that went into making this. Um and there's a part two when he first uh gains his powers when he's singing that bouncing off the walls song, and then like the set starts like going around him like a rotating set. That was really cool.

[20:51] Jess McInally: Yeah, some of the stuff in the show is very cool to look at. Um, even if it is like stylistically like weird in and not fitting all the time, but they can tell it's it's Frankenstein from several things.

[21:03] Allison Pregler: Yeah.

[21:04] Jess McInally: But some of it they did manage to make it look somewhat cool, and I can imagine in person it probably would be pretty impressive to see some of these stunts where they go out almost over the audience, it looks like so.

[21:14] Allison Pregler: Yeah, they were going right over us. It was really fun.

[21:44] Jess McInally: Andrew, I'm gonna pick you because you've been surprisingly quiet. Describe for me the plot of Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark in as concise a way as you possibly can.

[21:48] Andrew Dwarf: Spider-Man turn off the dark. So the plot is um, well, have you seen the 2002 Spider-Man movie by Sam Raimi? That's the plot.

[22:07] Jess McInally: Uh yeah, I mean it's it's just the origin story of Spider-Man, which I don't think I need to explain. Um, and then he fights the Green Goblin.

[22:15] Allison Pregler: But it has sprinkles of Doc Ock from the 2004 movie.

[22:18] Andrew Dwarf: Yes, and there's a little bit from the the second movie in there. But it it's it's surprising how close to the like the movie it really is, though. Like it they just took it's like they didn't even bother to research the comics or anything. They're just like, watch the movie. Alright, that's we'll just do that.

[22:35] Jess McInally: Yeah, I'm not a huge Spider-Man buff, so like I I couldn't tell you a lot of stuff from the comics, but even then, like yeah, it was surprisingly very much the Sam Raimi movies, to the point where like things that they couldn't fit in, they just did anyway. Like when they're doing the final curtain call, they do the like Spider-Man come from the ceiling upside down kiss.

[22:58] Allison Pregler: Yeah, yeah, they and um one thing that was like a a dead giveaway to me and I'm not a Spider-Man buff either, so don't think I'm reading the comics or anything. I I really don't, but uh he says that he has organic webs, which I know is basically only from Sam Raimi. They didn't do that. That's not in any of the comics or anything like that. And even the newer movies don't do that.

[23:16] Jess McInally: It's organic silly string.

[23:18] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah like organic silly string. He's just growing it right in his right in his wrist. Um I mean if you could you would yeah so basically they just took the Sam Raimi movie and just did that and that's it. Uh it bothers me with so many insanely creative people that they couldn't be more creative about the story.

[23:37] Allison Pregler: It did start out with the Arachne plot though, so I think a lot of that was them just thinking what is the most marketable thing because this is a disaster right now.

[23:48] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah they're like let's just do the movie. Everyone knows the movie. But I mean they've had um productions that are based off of specific versions of things like movies and all that that follow them closely but become their own thing. Like Shrek the musical for instance follows the exact plot of the movie, but they somehow manage to do their own thing because um they have really well well written songs and add just little things to the characters to make it its own thing.

[24:17] Allison Pregler: And in I'm not sure they really did that here.

[24:20] Andrew Dwarf: I feel like with Shrek really you only have the movies to go off of Spider-Man a book technically.

[24:27] Jess McInally: Technically but nobody nobody d knows the book.

[24:30] Andrew Dwarf: Nobody read the book. Nobody read the book. The movie's better.

[24:34] Andrew Dwarf: Sorry, did you like Shrek before it was cool?

[24:36] Allison Pregler: Get out of here.

[24:38] Andrew Dwarf: I like Shrek after it was cool, okay? Check yourself before you Shrek yourself.

[24:42] Allison Pregler: I didn't like Shrek till it became a meme.

[24:45] Andrew Dwarf: You're partially right on that. Uh yeah, but with Spider-Man, there's like a huge backlog of comics that you could have picked so many stories that have never been done. Like I'm just thinking of like the recent Spider-Man movie because I had just seen that and like how off the wall that is. And you can't tell me there wasn't any story that could have worked better as a musical in Spider-Man's catalog, you know? I mean, use Mysterio. He is a theater actor. You could do the clone saga, you could do uh when Doc Ock married Aunt May, there's just a plethora of stories. I mean, we've got we're in a weird like blessing of Spider-Man within the last like 15 months where we've had like four solid Spider-Man stories thrown at us, including a video game. So maybe there's a lot of Spider-Man right now.

[25:35] Allison Pregler: We have the hindsight.

[25:36] Andrew Dwarf: There's a lot of Spider-Man even.

[25:38] Allison Pregler: Yeah.

[25:39] Andrew Dwarf: And women, yeah.

[25:40] Allison Pregler: And women.

[25:42] Andrew Dwarf: So maybe we just have too much of that hindsight that we're not able to judge this story.

[25:47] Allison Pregler: Well, not exactly because Allison, you saw this at the time before Spider-Man was blessed upon us all from all angles. I think they were sort of stuck in that they were they did do their own story with the Arachne thing, and then they had to rework it. And this was what they thought I guess was the most appealing to a mass audience. But also, if you're talking about the comic stories, I mean there's such a long history of very complicated stories that like I think you just gotta start from the beginning when you're trying to appeal to a mass audience. Um, and now we have like series of movies that you can build on, and more people know about it, so you're not just gonna do the origin again. But if you're doing a musical and you're starting in the middle of it, uh I don't know how appealing that would be to the people creating it as far as getting a return investment. Maybe that was their fear that they didn't want to have another it's a bird, it's a plane, it's Superman.

[26:39] Andrew Dwarf: That's a deep musical theater cut for everyone. How many times has the Spider-Man origin story been told in the past 20 years, counting this here?

[26:49] Allison Pregler: Uh like at least three or four times, right?

[26:52] Andrew Dwarf: Three, I'd say.

[26:53] Allison Pregler: It feels like it, really.

[26:54] Andrew Dwarf: Four.

[26:55] Allison Pregler: Four because of Into the Spider-Verse.

[26:56] Andrew Dwarf: Forgot about that one.

[26:58] Allison Pregler: Yep. Which they did it multiple times in that, so can I just say that this show is trashed because it has no Stanley cameo?

[27:06] Andrew Dwarf: Ooh.

[27:08] Allison Pregler: Aww.

[27:14] Andrew Dwarf: Hey guys, tell me about this Audible thing. Today's show is brought to you by Audible. Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day trial membership. Just go to AudibleTrial.com slash musicals with cheese, that's the name of our show, and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs. Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy. Go to audible.com slash musicals with cheese and get started today.

[27:38] Allison Pregler: Why Audible? Audible content includes an unmatched selection of audiobooks, original audio shows, news, comedy, and more from the leading audiobook publishers, broadcasters, and entertainers. So, a book that I'd recommend that's currently on Audible is Stanley, the man behind Marvel, narrated by Kevin T. Collins. It tells you all about Stanley and how he created a universe. So to download your free audiobook today, go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese. Again, that's AudibleTrial.com slash musicals with cheese for your free audiobook. Alright, let's get you back to the show, guys. You're gonna be saying wow every time you use it.

[28:13] Andrew Dwarf: Wow.

[28:19] Jess McInally: Alright, do you guys want to talk about the songs?

[28:21] Allison Pregler: Alright.

[28:22] Jess McInally: Oh boy, howdy, do I want to talk about the songs? Alright, so really the first song really worth talking about because it is so terrible is entitled Bully by Numbers.

[28:31] Allison Pregler: That I think was the worst one, wasn't it?

[28:34] Jess McInally: Uh it's up to the DIY world, actually, might be a little worse.

[28:38] Allison Pregler: That's what I said. I actually have a soft spot for DIY world.

[28:42] Jess McInally: That's quite the double whammy, those two one after the other.

[28:46] Allison Pregler: Back to back. It's like I want to not watch this anymore, please.

[28:50] Jess McInally: Thank you. There's only two songs out of this whole thing that I thought were worth anything, really. Well, three of them. Um, the rest of it, we just it blended together so much. And there's never any question what the name of any of these songs are, because they repeat the name of the song constantly, like ten times. It was written by rock musicians, so I can see why they would do that.

[29:16] Andrew Dwarf: And specificity isn't really what they go for in rock music. They just say general ideas.

[29:20] Jess McInally: Yeah. But Bully by Numbers, it also doesn't tell any story. Like it shows that he's a nerd, but it's so long. Like that sequence is so long and so draining on your patience. They made a conscious choice with these bullies to make them like the most stereotypical eighties-90s movie bullies in like costumes that look cheap because they're just like normal outfits. Um, one of the guys has a flat top haircut. It just feels dated even for that time.

[30:00] Allison Pregler: Were they doing the bullies from the Sam Raimi?

[30:03] Jess McInally: I haven't seen the Sam Raimi movie in a while, but I remember there was like bullies in that. Were they they were they copying anything from that?

[30:09] Andrew Dwarf: They were crappy white kids in the original movie. That was it.

[30:12] Jess McInally: Yeah I don't remember them being that distinct in the movie.

[30:15] Andrew Dwarf: Well they weren't in it very long. Like in this one they had probably more uh time on stage.

[30:20] Allison Pregler: They had more time to do nothing though. It really was in the service of nothing and didn't move the story forward very much. It didn't tell you much about them outside of the obvious. They like to bully people they do they like to bully by numbers.

[30:34] Jess McInally: What does bullying by numbers mean?

[30:36] Andrew Dwarf: Um ask Bono is it just mean like paint by numbers like they're the most stereotypical cliché because that would fit name one bully in your entire life that say I'm gonna bully you now by numbers.

[30:51] Allison Pregler: It's time to bully you get over here it's bullying time bullying bullying if that's how bullies actually were then maybe it wouldn't be that bad I mean it's like alright come over we're it's time to bully we're we're doing it well alright yes so no we need to do it's gonna be telling some bully on the do you guys want to talk about DIY world now, because I'm actually a defender of this song.

[31:34] Jess McInally: Oh no.

[31:35] Allison Pregler: Please tell me what the worth of DIY world was.

[31:39] Jess McInally: Um I really like the like repetitive B, what you wanna do, what you wanna in the DIY world. Like and Patrick Page like just kind of humming over it. I'm like, oh, I like that, but everything else in that song is god awful. I like his uh lab coat that's like got circuitry on it.

[31:56] Allison Pregler: Very back to the future, too.

[31:58] Jess McInally: It's maybe the cheapest looking set, I think.

[32:01] Allison Pregler: I it looks garbage in my opinion.

[32:04] Jess McInally: I don't remember there being much of a set, right? Just some beakers and stuff.

[32:08] Allison Pregler: That's part of the issue. It was like a production of Our Town all of a sudden.

[32:13] Jess McInally: Yeah, it's like the he had a lab coat, so it's like, oh, he's in a lab, and then there was like one machine in the middle, and it's like okay.

[32:20] Allison Pregler: Yeah, it was not very impressive. I know we're talking about songs, but that reminds me of the thing I found weird about this too, is fall as far as the structure and and things that they changed. Um, a very important part of the mythos of Spider-Man is the fact, at least in the movies, this is how it went. Um, he when he gets his powers, he's told uh well he he remembers uh what he was told by his uncle Ben with great power comes great responsibility, but he doesn't really get it until his uncle dies.

[33:00] Andrew Dwarf: Uh he lets that that uh robber go past or whatever, that carjacker who ends up killing Uncle Ben, and it's this powerful lesson about um taking responsibility uh if you have the ability to help people and and what what you have at your disposal. And uh they take that out of this. He goes to the wrestling match with the blow-up guy, and then he comes back home, and then a carjacker killed him randomly, and he's like, Oh no! With great power comes great responsibility. Like, well, you could have been doing anything at that moment, and a carjacker came and killed him. It just doesn't connect to a very important part of the story.

[33:38] Allison Pregler: I think you're misremembering he actually said rise above was the real quote.

[33:43] Jess McInally: They do use the like the great power thing, don't they?

[33:47] Allison Pregler: No, they just say you rise above it so they can turn it into a song.

[33:51] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[33:52] Allison Pregler: Okay. I I'm sorry for misremembering.

[33:54] Jess McInally: No, no, that's a very important thing. Spider-Man thing is he sp he says rise above. That's Spider-Man's thing.

[34:00] Allison Pregler: Okay.

[34:01] Jess McInally: I hope you're feeling the sarcasm. There was um actually uh there was a I had a a weird experience um like a year or two ago. I was in a grocery store, and then I heard that song playing on the radio.

[34:20] Allison Pregler: What they were trying to do like a radio version of that song, not related to Spider-Man, like as a marketable thing.

[34:28] Jess McInally: Yeah, it just very briefly they were trying to like a resurgence, because it was weird that long after Spider-Man turned off the dark who was off the stage. I heard that, and I'm like, what?

[34:41] Andrew Dwarf: Are you sure?

[34:42] Jess McInally: They gotta recoup that two hundred million dollars they slumped into this somehow.

[34:46] Allison Pregler: Well, because the guy uh I completely keep forgetting his name, the played Spider-Man.

[34:52] Andrew Dwarf: Reeve Carney.

[34:53] Allison Pregler: He's he's uh lead singer in a band, right?

[34:56] Andrew Dwarf: Um yeah, he was also in Penny Dreadful. He's like an actual actor now.

[34:59] Allison Pregler: Okay. Well, um, I think maybe he was like there was just that musician connection, you know, trying to make that more of a a thing just as a separate thing.

[35:09] Jess McInally: Really liked that song. I also heard too that like Imagine Dragons, they had that album uh a little bit ago, and it was originally stuff written for Spider-Man turn off the dark.

[35:22] Allison Pregler: Yes, I remember that, like the album with radioactive, like that was a specifically a Spider-Man song just to that people put out there to see if there could be a rock and roll Spider-Man show.

[35:32] Andrew Dwarf: That would have been so much better than this, though.

[35:36] Jess McInally: Much better choice than Bono and the Edge, I'll say that.

[35:41] Allison Pregler: Imagine Dragons, like I remember their songs.

[35:44] Andrew Dwarf: I truly did not remember anything but like a few of these um while re-watching this. I think Rise Above is the only one I can still kind of like remember, other than other than the ones that are so bad that I like got annoyed by them.

[35:57] Allison Pregler: Like uh Bully by Numbers, I remember that part, but you see, I feel like everyone is so hard on Bully by Numbers DIY world that they don't know that pull the trigger is really the worst song in the show.

[36:12] Jess McInally: Spider-Man, Spider-Man, genetics, Spider-Man, Superhuman Kinetics, Spider-Man, muscle augmentation, and look at that.

[36:21] Allison Pregler: Web bio generation.

[36:23] Jess McInally: This looks like my world.

[36:24] Allison Pregler: I don't remember that.

[36:25] Jess McInally: How did I block that one out?

[36:27] Allison Pregler: That's when all the like Duke Nuka military people come out.

[36:31] Jess McInally: Yes.

[36:32] Allison Pregler: That song what bothers me so much. Especially because it starts with just Patrick Page going, Spider-Man, Spider-Man, and Hans Genetic Spider-Man.

[36:45] Jess McInally: And then Oh my god.

[36:47] Allison Pregler: Evil Miral Terry comes in, and his wife's like, Whoa, what's going on?

[36:50] Andrew Dwarf: He's like, These are my investors. Like, what am I watching right now? I didn't I didn't get the transition at all there. I'm like, what? All of a sudden there's I guess something happened. That song, like, I had Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark on my iPhone for years, and every time that song would come on, I would just hear, bump, bump, Spider-Man, Spider-Man. I like that uh that Norman Osborne, he kinda he kind of came off like an evangelical preacher about technology, or like a southern lawyer. Like, I'm just a southern lawyer. It felt like he had the southern accent sometimes, and then like maybe he had it the whole time, but he he like overdid it in certain scenes. It felt like it faded when he became the Green Goblin, but before, like, he's just like, and then the technology will deliver us.

[37:47] Allison Pregler: Well, Norman's from the South. The Green Goblin was born in New York, so fair, fair, fair. Can't can't argue with that.

[37:58] Andrew Dwarf: Oh no, please. Oh my phone now. Oh the windows in the night.

[38:14] Allison Pregler: Well, I guess it's time for us to talk about the most fabulous song in the entire show.

[38:19] Andrew Dwarf: A freak like me needs company.

[38:21] Allison Pregler: Yes.

[38:23] Andrew Dwarf: I don't think like just videos can do this scene justice. I feel like it's something you have to see live. Fabulous. I knew about the song before going into it, because that was what they were promoting it with a lot, and for good reason. Like, this is a uh campy fun time. And there's a a clip you can find uh on YouTube of them doing this on uh David Letterman's show. This is like David Letterman like uh Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark, and then Green Goblin comes in and is like, this place was so easy to break into. They start singing the song, and then like wacky inflatable arm lizard comes out in the audience, and you can see people ducking, like, ah, don't hit me with your lizard. And then when they're all like on stage in the end, and like Green Goblin has this line where he's like, Craven loves the animals just a little too much, if you ask me.

[39:18] Andrew Dwarf: What? What are you implying? Is he is he fucking the animals? What is happening? He kills them first, okay? So it's fine if it's necrophilia as well.

[39:30] Allison Pregler: For animals.

[39:31] Andrew Dwarf: For animals. How about we don't approve of necrophilia or like bestiality or necrophilic bestiality on this show at all?

[39:40] Allison Pregler: I th I disapproved of it, but you know, you can deny that. I think they colored his tongue, the Green Goblin, at least for that production, because he's like sticking his tongue out and it's all like blue or green or whatever. He's like, like all of a sudden he's a member of Kiss or something, and he's like, They're just throwing stuff at a wall to see what sticks.

[40:00] Andrew Dwarf: And fun fact, in that scene, David Letterman decided I'm gonna retire. I'm just gonna like the stage was packed with a bunch of of campy villains, and then David Letterman lost in a sea of neon colors trying to find his way to the front to like go to commercial.

[40:21] Allison Pregler: Oh god. Uh truly uh an amazing clip.

[40:28] Andrew Dwarf: For all the wrong reasons.

[40:33] Allison Pregler: And every doorway is high something.

[40:43] Andrew Dwarf: And Futura.

[40:48] Allison Pregler: Let me talk about If the World Should End, which is a song that makes no sense in this specific version of the show. Between Mary Jane and Peter, it's what they sang at the Tony's. And it's like this dark, melancholy number um out the end of the world, and really nothing's happening. Like it's obvious it was supposed to be like while stuff is happening, but nope.

[41:09] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah, I don't know if they showed a very good progression with their relationship to get to that point. Uh just the fact that it's Mary Jane at all and somehow they treat her worse than the Sam Raimi movies treating Kirsten Dunn's interpretation of it. I just don't know if they did a lot with her until she gets kidnapped. They do some stuff about showing like her abusive family. Uh, but it uh it got kind of lost in the shuffle, I think.

[41:36] Allison Pregler: Yeah, and Jennifer Diamano, who played her, and she was also a very well-known Broadway actress, um, does what she can, but it's really sad to see someone just kind of have to like wince her way through these cringeworthy lines, and her and Reeve Carney just absolutely no chemistry whatsoever.

[41:54] Andrew Dwarf: She called me Tiger.

[41:55] Allison Pregler: Well, she could have called me Dolphin!

[41:59] Andrew Dwarf: Why? This is really more of a like Green Goblin Spider-Man movie than than uh or pr uh play than a um than anything about uh Peter and Mary Jane, and she doesn't even have any songs of her own. Like there's not really a lot to build her character. She's more of a plot device than anything.

[42:21] Allison Pregler: Which is a remnant from the original version of the show where in Act Two it's basically all Peter and Mary Jane, and Arachne kidnaps Mary Jane and like tells Peter, you must either love me or kill me, or else I'm gonna murder Mary Jane.

[42:34] Andrew Dwarf: Oh, okay.

[42:35] Allison Pregler: So I uh it's a remnant from when she was a more important active person or fridged care. It would have been a better show with more of her. There's just no there's no real connection, it's just uh it's basically just bare bones superhero fighting, uh, and that's it with no real emotion to it, as it is now.

[42:53] Andrew Dwarf: And the fighting's not very good either, to be honest. They have the the the Green Goblin in uh Spider-Man fight, their first uh fight together after he's like taken his mask off, and the hits and the punches like completely miss contact. It was really bad.

[43:11] Allison Pregler: They don't try very hard.

[43:13] Andrew Dwarf: No, no. Maybe that's why a couple people almost died.

[43:17] Allison Pregler: Oh no.

[43:18] Andrew Dwarf: Well, they tried for the stunts, they didn't try for the fighting.

[43:21] Allison Pregler: Yeah, like the stunts, when they're like the hang glider stunt, when they're like going over the audience fighting each other, that was good. Like the hand-to-hand stuff was bad, I think, because they were both kind of encumbered with things that made it not uh very conducive to like hand-to-hand fighting. But the uh yeah, when they're like you're going over the audience like together in the air fighting, that was pretty good.

[43:43] Andrew Dwarf: Do you think it would have been handled better if they just threw up like the POW cards from the 1960s Batman animated series just so they block the lack of connection?

[43:52] Allison Pregler: Yeah, maybe. Throw out some like smoke clouds or something, or just flash a light.

[43:57] Andrew Dwarf: Like that's like blind the audience for a second so they don't see the misconnection.

[44:02] Allison Pregler: Strobe lights?

[44:03] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah, I don't think strobe lights is the answer.

[44:06] Allison Pregler: Yeah, in musical theater, strobe lights are literally always the answer. They just have to put the warning out front, like, hey, there'll be strobes.

[44:14] Andrew Dwarf: Don't come in if you're epileptic.

[44:15] Allison Pregler: Hey guys, you want to get a headache from this show? Well, boy, boy, do we have the thing for you? Are are you epileptic? Do you like living dangerously?

[44:27] Andrew Dwarf: Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark. It would be, I think, the only production to injure so many people in the production, and also the audience at that point.

[44:36] Allison Pregler: I mean, I am shocked that no audience members like ever got hurt, like, with them like flying over the flying over the audience the way they do. I mean, I I'm really glad that no one died. Like, I'm really glad that uh that it wasn't worse than it was, because I I really feel for the actors and the stunt people that that were in these dangerous situations.

[44:58] Andrew Dwarf: Agreed. If someone died, I feel like it wouldn't be funny to talk about, and this would just be a depressing show altogether.

[45:05] Allison Pregler: I mean, I still look at this show and find it a depressing show. Like, even the people that got hurt really got hurt. Like the original Arachne, like got a concussion and had to perform two shows through it because she smashed her head on the top of the ceiling. There was other times where she was held upside down indefinitely for like an entire hold with the audience, like right there just staring at her.

[45:26] Andrew Dwarf: Oh my god.

[45:27] Allison Pregler: And let's not forget the kid that jumped like smashed on the ground 30 feet because he didn't attach the wire correctly. So literally 30 feet straight down onto concrete.

[45:37] Andrew Dwarf: So yeah.

[45:38] Allison Pregler: Yeah, and he was a stunt performer, like, and he was permanently damaged from that. Like, that's his entire so I'm still like really disgusted at this show and a lot of the precautions that weren't there with it.

[45:51] Andrew Dwarf: Sure. Well and that didn't have to do with any of the story stuff. That just had to do with the ambition and and not properly checking safety uh things that they should have.

[46:01] Allison Pregler: I'm surprised they were able to go over the audience like they were allowed to do that honestly.

[46:06] Andrew Dwarf: I mean in Cirque de Soleil they do that all the time so it's not that insane for me to imagine.

[46:12] Allison Pregler: Cirque de Soleil, but I trust them I don't trust Spider-Man.

[46:16] Andrew Dwarf: Like Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark does not have a trustworthy name for me.

[46:20] Allison Pregler: Maybe after a hundred and eighty two runs they finally figured out how to do it not so dangerously.

[46:27] Andrew Dwarf: Did someone get injured on the last on the last show just to prove that wrong um I do not believe that I do not believe that they did I don't believe they had any more injuries past the uh all of the the false starts there.

[46:40] Allison Pregler: Um the the last injury was on a August 15th 2013 actor Daniel Curry was hurt by apparently being pinned under a piece of equipment and suffered extreme leg trauma.

[46:50] Andrew Dwarf: So that was like well after the show had opened like oh gosh that sucks.

[46:54] Allison Pregler: Mm-hmm. And like almost every actor aside from like Reeve Carney like hurt themselves really bad. Especially the poor Arachne's the arachne is one of the most depressing parts of this show because they were once a huge part of it then they get reduced and then they're still in extreme danger every night.

[47:13] Andrew Dwarf: Uh just because of the the wire work.

[47:16] Allison Pregler: The wire work and the way you flip and the way you have to do that, like you're gonna like pull a muscle if you're moved the wrong way at the wrong time because it is kind of like all on uh uh set like timer.

[47:27] Andrew Dwarf: Mm-hmm.

[47:27] Allison Pregler: So well, and and they're also stuck in the big like spider butt cocoon that that gets put in the bottom half.

[47:34] Andrew Dwarf: Oh yeah.

[47:35] Allison Pregler: Well, you know what? These people worked hard.

[47:36] Andrew Dwarf: They did.

[47:37] Allison Pregler: These people worked hard. And like they deserve the injuries for sure.

[47:41] Andrew Dwarf: And now most and now fun fact, now that I'm thinking about it, most of the cast of this is in Hades Town coming out this Broadway.

[47:48] Allison Pregler: You got r or this year on Broadway, you got Reeve Carney, you've got Patrick Page, you got TV Carpio, who is the original um Arachne. So just g go see him in that. They don't have to do flips or nothing or anything.

[48:00] Andrew Dwarf: Hey.

[48:05] Allison Pregler: Literally when uh when they said break a leg, you know what I'm saying?

[48:08] Andrew Dwarf: But uh were you guys confused by how they get rid of the Green Goblin at the end?

[48:16] Allison Pregler: I think I missed this, like there's just like a line of dialogue to explain it very quickly, and I remember watching it live, not knowing what happened just all of a sudden, like he's like, nah, he falls.

[48:31] Andrew Dwarf: He got hit with the piano, right?

[48:33] Allison Pregler: Well, he was he was webbed to the piano, and then uh he pushes it down to like fall on a crowd, and Spider-Man's like, Hey, I webbed you to that piano, so you wouldn't do that.

[48:43] Andrew Dwarf: What?

[48:43] Allison Pregler: No He flies back and then like splat Nickelodeon sign shows up.

[48:50] Andrew Dwarf: The end.

[48:51] Allison Pregler: What was that?

[48:52] Andrew Dwarf: I don't understand how you go to that. Like, even if you're trying to be tongue in cheek, like it's such a pathetic way to end it and confusing. They don't even show it happened, they just it's just like I webbed at the piano.

[49:06] Andrew Dwarf: Oh, he pushed it.

[49:07] Allison Pregler: Oh no, I don't do that.

[49:10] Andrew Dwarf: Wait, no.

[49:11] Allison Pregler: What?

[49:12] Andrew Dwarf: Want one.

[49:13] Jess McInally: You know, that's a fine goofy way to end act one of a two-act musical.

[49:18] Andrew Dwarf: But to end act two of it, it's just like, ah, oh, okay.

[49:23] Jess McInally: It's over now.

[49:24] Andrew Dwarf: That's the end.

[49:25] Jess McInally: That's all, folks.

[49:30] Andrew Dwarf: Rise above.

[49:31] Jess McInally: Play me off, Johnny.

[49:36] Jess McInally: So, who do you guys think was wronged artistically the most in this situation? Would it be Sam Raimi?

[49:41] Allison Pregler: There.

[49:44] Andrew Dwarf: Not the poor acrobats that almost died or the actors that were stuck on this project for years. Sam Raimi, who had nothing to do with it.

[49:53] Allison Pregler: He wrote the entire thing, apparently, so.

[49:53] Jess McInally: What about you, Allison?

[49:57] Allison Pregler: I don't I don't know if anyone in particular was the most wronged. Like, genuinely, I just think like a lot of things didn't turn out the way that people wanted, and maybe they had different visions, but I think just a lot of elements didn't come together for them.

[50:13] Jess McInally: So I don't know if I can say one person in particular was was the one that got the worst end of it. Maybe the audience?

[50:21] Andrew Dwarf: Uh excuse me, I had a great time. I do not think I was wronged at all. I I still cherish that t-shirt.

[50:28] Allison Pregler: Uh I will have it all. Spider-Man fans, like actual Spider-Man fans, maybe they they wouldn't see the Broadway music.

[50:35] Jess McInally: Then why make one?

[50:39] Allison Pregler: Exactly. It's they will complain about the fact that Ben uh Uncle Ben doesn't have the right hair or that Mary Jane doesn't have red hair.

[50:46] Andrew Dwarf: Do you think they're really gonna like accept the fact that the green goblin is splatted by a piano?

[50:53] Allison Pregler: I think if if you can make it past the inflatable wrestler that he is just carrying like that scene in Ed Wood with the octopus. I think if you can get past that, like you you gotta be on board with the rest of it.

[51:09] Jess McInally: I feel like we didn't talk about that enough. That that inflatable wrestler thing was maybe the worst thing in the whole show.

[51:16] Allison Pregler: And is so funny.

[51:19] Jess McInally: It's not funny in the way that they intended either. It's like embarrassing that they thought this was acceptable.

[51:25] Allison Pregler: I was I was watching it and and just but I didn't see it coming at all. I didn't expect that whatsoever.

[51:32] Jess McInally: And it just comes on and I'm like, is this is this real? And then you got that tongue in cheek, like the announcer is like, it looks like he's using them like an inflatable dummy.

[51:42] Andrew Dwarf: And then you follow it right up with Uncle Ben's murder.

[51:46] Jess McInally: Yeah, total whiplash.

[51:51] Andrew Dwarf: This show's not good, but it's one Randy Savage, that's for sure.

[51:57] Jess McInally: Takes the best character from the original Spider-Man.

[52:05] Andrew Dwarf: And you can run.

[52:44] Jess McInally: Okay. So Andrew, what is your cheese rating and overall thoughts about Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark?

[52:50] Andrew Dwarf: I didn't give any thought into a cheese rating this this week or any week. Um so I'm gonna give it provolone. I don't know why. I just don't really like provolone that much. It's like it's it's okay, and I'll have it in like a sandwich. Um, but it's generally not my favorite. Uh but the show, this show I I think I like some of the songs, and I think it's really goofy, and I probably would watch it again, but it's enjoyable in only an ironic sense, uh, and not it's it's just not actually good by by any stretch of the imagination.

[53:22] Jess McInally: Alright, now Allison, what is your overall thoughts and your cheese rating?

[53:27] Allison Pregler: Uh I love Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark. Um, it has great memories attached for me, but also it is that perfect kind of fascinatingly bad. Um the story is so interesting about how this was made, and it's it's a fun cheesy musical. Um, despite the fact that most of the songs are actually not very good. So uh I'd rate it blue cheese. It's very strong and not for everyone. And sometimes it could be a bit unpleasant, but in the right combination, like it could be very, very good.

[54:02] Jess McInally: That's a good one. I like how she picked up on the cheese rating thing, went with it, and she like totally got it.

[54:07] Andrew Dwarf: Nailed it.

[54:08] Jess McInally: You had some time to think it over.

[54:10] Andrew Dwarf: I didn't get any time, so I I had to go right for it.

[54:13] Jess McInally: Whoa, whoa, whoa, Jess, what did you think of this?

[54:15] Jess McInally: An interesting mess. I think that's the way to describe it. Um, really, it's hard to describe. It's uh a bunch of different people's work trying to form together something coherent, but it's just barely so. I would have been much more interested in the artistic mess that would have been Julie Tamore's um two-act monstrosity, um, as opposed to this one, which is understandable but boring, and it will never play again.

[54:42] Andrew Dwarf: Like the show will never play again.

[54:44] Jess McInally: Like, it's no, it's like cats, it'll be forever.

[54:47] Andrew Dwarf: Well, they keep promoting like we're gonna do like an arena tour soon. So get ready, but they've been promoting that for like five years.

[54:55] Allison Pregler: Oh man, do it, guys.

[54:57] Jess McInally: Do it. The world needs more Spider-Man turns.

[55:00] Andrew Dwarf: I would see it too. Like, I'd be first to buy my tickets. I'm like, I'm ready for this.

[55:04] Jess McInally: Well, just you'll see anything.

[55:05] Andrew Dwarf: You're right. I did just go see Rent in at a live theater recently, so that like just goes to show.

[55:13] Jess McInally: I'm I'm just curious, uh, Andrew.

[55:16] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah, um, you because you're not very into musical theater. Um, and this is a new kind of endeavor for you. How would you say that this movie compares or this I keep saying movie? Uh how would you say that this play compares to other musicals you've seen?

[55:33] Andrew Dwarf: Honestly, this is it's a disaster, but it's actually not my least favorite, not even close.

[55:41] Jess McInally: What's your least favorite?

[55:44] Andrew Dwarf: Uh, I think we've gone over this several times, is uh I I really dislike Rent a lot. Uh it's just I I really there's something about that one that I just hate.

[55:56] Andrew Dwarf: Um, but that one I really hated. Um my probably my favorite though is the first one we ever did was uh a Sweeney Todd, and I still really like that one.

[56:06] Jess McInally: That one's good.

[56:07] Andrew Dwarf: Yeah, and this I would say is kind of right in the middle. In terms of ha like production and everything, it's it's much worse than rent, but I just it's just so it's this one is so bland and and terrible that it's hard to really hate it. And it has no negative messages the way that Rent does.

[56:24] Jess McInally: Rent has like some messaging that really is bad.

[56:27] Andrew Dwarf: Well, it seems like this see, I haven't seen a wide spectrum of musicals, though I have seen some, but it just seems like it's such a category of its own that like I I was just curious like how it compared to you since you guys had watched a bunch of them.

[56:42] Jess McInally: Yeah, it's hard to say that this is like in a lot of musicals are like this because the music styles and how they put on the show varies so drastically that's hard to like compare them directly. Um but yeah, I mean it this one's terrible, but it's in a in such a goofy way that you can't hate it. Like you really can't be like, oh uh I disliked watching that. It's just maybe you're bored at the very worst.

[57:07] Andrew Dwarf: It's like any other medium. It's like animation. Like food fight is probably an equivalent to Spider-Man turn off the dark, but it's very fun to watch.

[57:17] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[57:17] Andrew Dwarf: Like I'd rather watch that than um than like I don't know, the emoji movie or something like that, where it's like it's just it's just straight bad and and everyone hates it and there's just something about it that's disgusting.

[57:32] Jess McInally: Well, and this is also something that tried to be something and just transformed into something else. Like you can't say that they didn't have a vision in mind, um, versus something that was a little more cynical, perhaps.

[57:47] Andrew Dwarf: So I I'd put this right in the middle of the road if I had to rate it.

[57:50] Jess McInally: Would you put it above or below falsettos? 'Cause I know you say that's like in the middle of the road too.

[57:55] Andrew Dwarf: Uh this is below falsettos for sure. Uh falsettos is actually good. This I just didn't love it. Whereas this is bad, but I didn't hate it.

[58:04] Jess McInally: May su make sense to me.

[58:06] Jess McInally: Alright. Hey guys, today's show is brought to you by Audible. Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership. Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs. Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy. Go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese.

[58:26] Jess McInally: Alison, why don't you promote some of your amazing work? Send us your way. Send my audience that might not know you, which I highly doubt, but just in case, tell us all about you.

[58:35] Allison Pregler: Oh uh well, if you um want to watch me talk about so bad it's good movies or episodes of Baywatch or Night Rider or any sort of things like that. Um you can find me at YouTube.com slash movie nights of the series. Or uh if you look me up on uh Twitter, I'm uh um I'm obscurous underscore lupa, or you could just look for Allison Pregler.

[58:59] Jess McInally: Alison, I do have a question for you. Um since you're on here and you're usually used to talking about Baywatch or so bad it's good movies. How would you adapt Baywatch into a musical?

[59:10] Allison Pregler: Oh man. Well, it'd have to star David Hasselhoff. It would have to. No substitutions. And David Hasselhoff probably has pitched this before. I know they um there was a musical tour that was called David Hasselhoff and his Baywatch Friends. But it was mostly just David Hasselhoff songs and women in bathing suits, as far as I can tell.

[59:36] Jess McInally: Would you expect less?

[59:37] Allison Pregler: Which might be what the musical would be. It would probably be like a jukebox musical if it's Baywatch, because they did so many different popular songs over the montages. You'd have to do that. So I I guess it would be a story centered around popular songs. Um, and probably just about a a rescue or something. Maybe uh maybe Mitch finds some romance. Maybe something like that. Not a terribly complicated plot.

[1:00:05] Jess McInally: Alright, let's go through our nonsense. Um, thank you guys for listening. We're so glad that you're sticking with us. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, all of the podcast podcast promos at Musicals with Cheese. Please keep leaving us reviews. That helps us get noticed, and we're still doing a giveaway. Not um next week. We'll be doing a giveaway of $25 Amazon gift cards, so please leave a review. You could be a winner. Follow us on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Instagram, Musicals with Cheese. Our YouTube page is Musical Theater Lives. Our email is musicaltheaterlives@gmail.com. Send us an email. We'll love to read it. Our title card was created by Jolene Casco. Our Instagram and her Instagram is Jolene Casco.

[1:00:47] Jess McInally: Um do any of you have any final remarks to say before we wrap this on up?

[1:00:51] Allison Pregler: At least Spider-Man turn off the dark. Do a DVD, do a documentary.

[1:00:55] Jess McInally: That's what they do. Preserve this history.

[1:01:00] Allison Pregler: I agree.

[1:01:01] Jess McInally: The title doesn't make sense.

[1:01:03] Allison Pregler: Turn off the dark, turn on the light.

[1:01:06] Jess McInally: Oh my god!

[1:01:07] Allison Pregler: You're right.

[1:01:08] Jess McInally: The whole thing is garbage.

[1:01:10] Allison Pregler: Just gotta throw it out from there.

[1:01:12] Jess McInally: Alright, let's end it with that.

[1:01:13] Jess McInally: Alright, thanks for listening. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred