"Turn the whole world upside-down And you’ll see, believe..." Grab your Pixie Dust and writing notebook because this week we're talking about one of the strangest musicals ever "Finding Neverland" the Musical! Our WEBSITE. Musicals with Cheese on Twitter... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Featured Shows
About
"Turn the whole world upside-down And you’ll see, believe..." Grab your Pixie Dust and writing notebook because this week we're talking about one of the strangest musicals ever "Finding Neverland" the Musical!
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:09] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.
[0:11] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[0:13] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.
[0:14] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Bree to like musical theater.
[0:20] Jesse McAnally: How are you doing today, Andrew?
[0:22] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I'm working on this new piece.
[0:24] Jesse McAnally: Okay, lay it on me.
[0:26] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. So I went down to the park, and this little kid was there, and he had this great idea for like a story, you know.
[0:37] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm thinking about just ripping it, just stealing the whole thing and then naming the main character after the kid.
[0:43] Jesse McAnally: Brilliant.
[0:44] Jesse McAnally: Um, what what's uh what's the idea though?
[0:46] Andrew DeWolf: Some nonsense about like pirates and stuff.
[0:48] Jesse McAnally: I don't know.
[0:49] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, brilliant, brilliant, brilliant. Actually, no, you fool, that'll never work.
[0:53] Andrew DeWolf: I I am everyone else in your life to be proven wrong when you get to your success.
[0:58] Jesse McAnally: Well, I guess I'll have to do it despite you.
[1:01] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we'll see how it works.
[1:02] Jesse McAnally: Oh no, it was a big success. Thanks for all the free money forever.
[1:06] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, no problem. Uh thanks to the case. And also your wife's cheating on you.
[1:09] Jesse McAnally: Dang, that stinks, but it's a good thing I'm cheating on her too, so it's all good.
[1:13] Jesse McAnally: In case you haven't picked up what we're throwing down, this week we're talking about Finding Neverland.
[1:18] Brianna Jones: You the music, Bree.
[1:19] Brianna Jones: We can sail tonight on a sea of pure moonlight.
[1:28] Brianna Jones: We can navigate the stars to bring us back home.
[1:36] Brianna Jones: In a place so far away.
[1:40] Brianna Jones: We'll be young. That's how we'll stay wish is a combo.
[1:48] Brianna Jones: We will find ourselves never.
[1:56] Jesse McAnally: Finding Neverland is a musical written by James Graham, but Alan Knee in the original production, with music and lyrics by Gary Barlow and Elliot Kennedy.
[2:05] Jesse McAnally: But some of the musical but the original music and lyrics in the original production was by Scott Frankel and Michael Corey.
[2:10] Jesse McAnally: And there was also National Tour revisions by Elliott Kennedy and James Graham.
[2:15] Jesse McAnally: It was based on the 1998 play, The Man Who Was Peter Pan by Alan Knee, and its 2004 film version, Finding Neverland.
[2:22] Jesse McAnally: Previews for Broadway began on March 15th, 2015, with the official opening April 15th at the Lunt-Fontanne Theater.
[2:30] Jesse McAnally: The Broadway production closed on August 21st, 2016, after 565 performances.
[2:36] Jesse McAnally: Despite being nominated for absolutely no Tony Awards, they did perform at the Tonys that year because their producer Harvey Weinstein paid the fee to do so.
[2:46] Jesse McAnally: He also strong-armed the Tonys to let them perform a song from the musical the year before it even opened, with Jennifer Hudson performing.
[2:54] Jesse McAnally: Um, guess money can really get you anything except out of prison.
[2:57] Andrew DeWolf: Um, the book hasn't done it yet.
[3:02] Jesse McAnally: Not for him.
[3:03] Andrew DeWolf: Not for him.
[3:04] Jesse McAnally: The plot of Finding Neverland is based on the Miramax motion picture by David McGee and the play The Man Who Was Peter Pan by Alan Knee.
[3:12] Jesse McAnally: Finding Neverland follows the relationship between playwright J.M. Barrie and the family that inspired Peter Pan, or The Boy Who Never Grew Up, one of the most beloved stories of all time.
[3:22] Jesse McAnally: What'd you think of Finding Neverland? And which version did you watch? Because there's like four distinctly different versions of this musical.
[3:30] Andrew DeWolf: I watched the Glee adaptation.
[3:33] Jesse McAnally: Uh no, but I watched the I mean it was the Broadway one, right?
[3:36] Andrew DeWolf: With the Glee guy.
[3:37] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, with Matthew Morrison and Kelsey Grammer.
[3:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, with the so the Grinch was the lead.
[3:41] Jesse McAnally: Um, Grinch was the lead and um what is Kelsey Grammer?
[3:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Sideshow Bob was the other guy.
[3:50] Jesse McAnally: Sure, true. Um, it's uh it was alright, I guess.
[3:55] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't like love it or anything, but it was like functional in a way.
[4:00] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I'm not a big fan of Peter Pan, and there was like a lot of fan service, like a lot.
[4:08] Andrew DeWolf: It was like every moment was um you were supposed to be like, oh, that's where he got the idea, and like, oh my goodness, that's where the pirates came from.
[4:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh wow, that's how we figured out Captain Hook would be the character. And it was like, okay.
[4:25] Andrew DeWolf: And the audience would lose their shit every time.
[4:29] Andrew DeWolf: Every time. Like literally every time.
[4:31] Andrew DeWolf: The one I remember the best is the Captain Hook one where the producer guy holds up his cane and there's literally like a music sting and the spotlight shines on it, and it's like, yeah.
[4:43] Andrew DeWolf: Captain Hook is the guy, the producer he didn't like. Got it.
[4:48] Andrew DeWolf: In that version, um, there's also other metatextual bullshit, like when they reference Cheers, the TV show that Kelsey Grammer was in, and then they stop the show, make a music cue, look at the audience, and they scream and lose their fucking heads and shit.
[5:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's just I don't wanna say it's like terrible, but it is not good.
[5:13] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna go on a limb and call it terrible.
[5:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, you're gonna call it terrible, okay I'm gonna be that guy.
[5:20] Jesse McAnally: Um, only because um I dove deep into this show.
[5:25] Jesse McAnally: Um, this show that I did not like. I was I had a Benoit Blanc fascination with it.
[5:31] Jesse McAnally: Um, it makes no damn sense, but it compels me. So I wanted to see where it came from, where did you go um to get to where it is?
[5:38] Jesse McAnally: So I had to go back to its original, original UK production at the Curve Theater, um, in Leicester.
[5:46] Jesse McAnally: And that's a different show altogether. A different book writer, a different composer, a different attitude towards the entire musical proceedings.
[5:55] Jesse McAnally: And in my opinion, a much better one. Obviously, rough around the edges, but it could have been something really special, in my opinion.
[6:03] Jesse McAnally: And I had only discovered this yesterday in relation to when we are recording this.
[6:09] Jesse McAnally: So I was well aware of the art production with Jeremy Jordan. I was well aware of the original Broadway production with uh Matthew Morrison, as well.
[6:17] Jesse McAnally: I watched the National Tour production where they did do significant changes to that.
[6:21] Jesse McAnally: And let me just say the National Tour Guide did the best um, Scottish accent, everyone else, um, variations of terrible to okay.
[6:29] Jesse McAnally: So if you guys will indulge me, and especially you, Andrew, would you mind you and I comparing the Broadway run starring Matthew Morrison to the Leicester run from 2012?
[6:42] Andrew DeWolf: So it's between 2015 and 2012, the difference that this show became.
[6:47] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I've only seen one of them, so I'll do my best.
[6:50] Jesse McAnally: No, no, you focus on Broadway, tell me what happens there, and then I'll tell you what happens in the 2012 original version.
[6:58] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[6:59] Jesse McAnally: Okay. So break down the plot of the Finding Neverland Broadway show and what happens.
[7:05] Andrew DeWolf: So it's just a I want to say a fictionalized account of the writing of Peter Pan, which I I guess I didn't know Peter Pan was originally a play, unless that is also fictional.
[7:19] Andrew DeWolf: And no, that is a good idea. I thought it was a book.
[7:20] Jesse McAnally: Okay, so it was originally a play.
[7:22] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[7:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. This guy, uh, you may have heard of his name's something something Barry.
[7:30] Jesse McAnally: J.M. Barrie, James Barrie.
[7:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. He he uh he like meets this like family, I think.
[7:38] Andrew DeWolf: So he meets this family. The kids are Peter and two other kids that probably don't matter at all.
[7:45] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I'm sure they have names.
[7:47] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, they have names, but I don't think they matter as much as Peter does.
[7:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, they're very imaginative and Barrie starts using their ideas.
[7:56] Andrew DeWolf: And he also falls in love with the mom.
[8:00] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[8:01] Andrew DeWolf: And yeah. I mean, that's kind of the whole plot.
[8:04] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, there's other stuff that goes on, but like what what could possibly be so different?
[8:11] Jesse McAnally: Okay, let's break down like the specifics, if you don't mind.
[8:15] Jesse McAnally: And I know you don't always love the specifics of it, but this is where it gets really important and why the Broadway production doesn't work.
[8:22] Jesse McAnally: So how does your show open? Like describe the exact opening. Like, do is there an opening number? Like what goes on, Andrew?
[8:31] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness. Because mine opens with J.M. Barrie having a nightmare about going to court against for crimes against his audience for mate writing such a shitty show.
[8:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um, which is interesting, and it's like against like all writers putting him on trial.
[8:46] Andrew DeWolf: Which shows it's not a song either, it's just a scene that opens it up, and then he's just at the bench.
[8:52] Andrew DeWolf: I'm pretty sure he just sings a pop song.
[8:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[8:55] Andrew DeWolf: I I can't even fully remember what it was supposed to be about. It was like some sort of like mushy like uh imagination or something.
[9:07] Jesse McAnally: Well, that's a good question because in every production of the show there's a different opening number.
[9:12] Jesse McAnally: Um, so in Cambridge in Massachusetts, it opens with Anywhere But Here, and Broadway it opens with a song called If the World Turned Upside Down, and the National Tour starts with a song called Welcome to London and My Imagination.
[9:26] Jesse McAnally: And in the Leicester version, which I'm focusing on, um, the original UK run, which is the first production with the original writers, no opening number really, just an opening scene, and then two-minute mark, James Barrie meets the boys.
[9:40] Andrew DeWolf: That's a good way to open it. Like, we know we don't have to see him going through the like the politics of the theater bullshit.
[9:47] Jesse McAnally: Two minutes into the show, no songs, no opening number. They introduce the boys bickering, and every one of the boys gets introduced significantly before Sylvia, which I think is very important because the Broadway show, he basically meets Sylvia and it seems like he's only hanging out with the boys to fuck her.
[10:02] Andrew DeWolf: Which is kind of true.
[10:03] Jesse McAnally: Yes, if you look at it. But my musical puts that idea on trial in a weird way.
[10:09] Jesse McAnally: Um, and it opens with and it's the sound is very different. So this is by Scott Frankel and Michael Corey. They wrote, um, and Michael Corey wrote Grey Gardens, War Paint, Doctor Zhivago, and directed by Rob Ashford, who did the London production of Parade.
[10:23] Jesse McAnally: Um, and it's a very classic musical, and with music in the style of Les Misérables more than um Dear Evan Hansen.
[10:32] Andrew DeWolf: That's um a positive comparison.
[10:35] Jesse McAnally: Yes. Um, it could never happen here, which is like the first kind of like really big number in the song.
[10:42] Jesse McAnally: Um, it feels like just a normal classic musical from the 90s or 80s.
[10:46] Jesse McAnally: Um, Julian Ovenden, who plays J.M. Barrie, doesn't even try a Scottish accent until like halfway through the first act, and then he just turns it on for some reason, which is very weird.
[10:56] Jesse McAnally: Um, and it's just a better introduction to everything, including the boys, and they go through painstaking efforts to show that he's not doing it to try to fuck their mom.
[11:06] Andrew DeWolf: But is he?
[11:07] Jesse McAnally: Not really. Um, they also go through the acts of not Peter Pan does not even get name-dropped as an idea in the first act.
[11:16] Jesse McAnally: He is not writing that play at all in the first act. The first act is just him ingratiating himself with his family and his wife.
[11:23] Andrew DeWolf: What does his wife do in the Broadway version? I'm curious.
[11:25] Jesse McAnally: Tell me.
[11:27] Andrew DeWolf: Is his wife even really in it?
[11:28] Jesse McAnally: Yes, she is.
[11:29] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like she's like barely there.
[11:31] Jesse McAnally: She's given a different personality trait in every version, but she is in it.
[11:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um, honestly, I don't remember what she does. I'll be fucking straight with you.
[11:40] Jesse McAnally: So she is just a shrew in the Broadway version.
[11:44] Jesse McAnally: She is just, "No, you can't do that. You're embarrassing me." And you're you're terrible.
[11:48] Jesse McAnally: And uh she is um what's her name? Um, the first one.
[11:54] Andrew DeWolf: And that's why you get this very uh strong feeling that he just wants to uh go be with the the mom of the boys.
[12:01] Jesse McAnally: Where in the original production, she was an actress that just wants to be cast in one of his plays and is supportive of him writing and doing good work because that opens her up to good work.
[12:12] Jesse McAnally: And he's just kind of like not present in her life, and they go out of it their way to show that Barrie is not a good husband.
[12:19] Jesse McAnally: Like he buys her flowers that she's allergic to, and she's not angry. She's like, "I can't get near that kind of stuff."
[12:25] Andrew DeWolf: I think the Broadway show, uh, they like to trim down a lot of Barrie's uh flaws, and by a lot I mean like all of them.
[12:35] Jesse McAnally: Like he is essentially a perfect, wholesome being of pure imagination and joy and childlike wonder.
[12:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and no one around him understands because how could anyone be so full of wonder and joy at all times?
[12:52] Jesse McAnally: Which this doesn't does that, but they also point poke a lot of holes in it, meaning that he's a bad person.
[12:59] Andrew DeWolf: Not in the way that a film tells or a story tells you they're a bad person because society says, but as a bad person because it looks like you're doing a bad person thing, and uh it it it reads that way.
[13:09] Jesse McAnally: So, how would you describe the relationship between Sylvia and Barrie in the Broadway production?
[13:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, they just feel like a uh traditional romance to me.
[13:18] Jesse McAnally: Okay.
[13:19] Andrew DeWolf: Like by the end, you're like expecting them to uh start making out, you know.
[13:25] Andrew DeWolf: And then she dies instead.
[13:26] Jesse McAnally: Spoilers.
[13:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yes, she does die instead, and everyone is very sad, but but Barrie's now the dad, so it's okay.
[13:33] Andrew DeWolf: And they call him dad.
[13:35] Andrew DeWolf: That is totally unearned. Um, because they make it a recurring thing in this one that they don't call him father and all that. Um, and I don't think that comes up in the Broadway one until the end scene.
[13:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and at the very end, they just drop it where um the kid's like dad, and there's like a pause so the audience can go, oh and they do because we're idiots.
[13:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um so Sylvia in the original production was a fangirl of Barry, like knew his work inside and out, and just had this deeply parasocial relationship that was a little unhealthy and one-sided. So much that both him and her mother calls her out for it, like you are going after a married man.
[14:20] Jesse McAnally: It looks bad for you. I I'm not saying this because I you shouldn't do what you want, but it really really is bad for you to cuck this man's wife.
[14:28] Andrew DeWolf: At least find yourself a rich husband.
[14:30] Jesse McAnally: Oh yes, mother, I'll take an advertisement and let all of London know how desperate I am.
[14:34] Andrew DeWolf: And all of London already knows how desperate you are. Like that's an actual pretty powerful line, where in the Broadway version, the mother character's just, I don't want you with this man because I'm the bad guy.
[14:46] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[14:48] Andrew DeWolf: And the producer character, not really a character in the original Leicester production.
[14:52] Jesse McAnally: Doesn't really exist.
[14:53] Andrew DeWolf: Because it's not about Peter Pan. It's about this family unit. Honestly, the producer character needs to exist in the Broadway show because without him, there's like no conflict, like at all.
[15:04] Jesse McAnally: Exactly. Like every like he's like the main villain, like to the point where they literally make him Captain Hook.
[15:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um here, like, yeah, Captain Hook appears for like a second, but it means more. Um, does Mary and Sylvia ever meet in your Broadway production?
[15:20] Jesse McAnally: Like they meet at a dinner party, right?
[15:23] Andrew DeWolf: Probably. I don't remember them interacting, though. There's a whole song about how much these two women are like, oh no, she seems wonderful, and that makes me insecure.
[15:33] Jesse McAnally: Like talking about how great this other woman is in both of their lives and how neither of them are good enough for Barry.
[15:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like, there's a proper like love triangle situation going on throughout the entire first act, and act one ends with no Peter Pan at all, for one.
[15:50] Jesse McAnally: Not even a reference of Peter Pan at the end of it. Act one ends with him finding out his wife's cheating on him.
[15:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Sylvia asking him to please stay away from her family, and uh basically just getting everyone turning against him, basically.
[16:05] Jesse McAnally: Act one in the Broadway show, I think ends with a big Captain Hook imaginary number.
[16:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.
[16:11] Jesse McAnally: Um, that doesn't even like happen in the real world. It's just like uh he's just with all the pirates from Captain Hook.
[16:19] Andrew DeWolf: You know Captain Hook, right? He's assembling the uh Peter Pan's cinematic universe.
[16:27] Jesse McAnally: Um Captain Hook does show up at the end of Act One of this version, but he sings a sea shanty about like how he shouldn't give up, as opposed to like the original where he sings like this epic power ballad because every song has to be memory from Cats in that version.
[16:41] Andrew DeWolf: Live by the hook, baby. Um, but the important thing is at the end of act one of the original version, Peter calls out Barry saying, You're just hanging out with me and my brothers because you want to fuck my mom, and that's not right.
[16:51] Jesse McAnally: And all of Act Two is putting that on trial, basically.
[16:55] Andrew DeWolf: Like I mean, that's kind of fucked up he did this. It's a much better conflict than just is he gonna write Peter Pan?
[17:02] Jesse McAnally: Right.
[17:03] Andrew DeWolf: And that is the only fucking conflict in the Broadway version.
[17:07] Jesse McAnally: And it's like, of course he's gonna write Peter Pan. Like, what?
[17:11] Andrew DeWolf: Like, why how would he how would he not like it? I I guess I'd be impressed if they if they ended it where he didn't write Peter Pan.
[17:19] Jesse McAnally: So Act Two becomes more about Peter Pan, but it's like like it's wallpaper for the actual family drama going on.
[17:26] Andrew DeWolf: It's much closer to the Broadway version, which I think act two is better in the Broadway version too. But I just wanted to paint that picture of how we had this like intense family drama that's not even like the original film this is based on.
[17:38] Jesse McAnally: Um instead, it's more of this dark tale with Peter Pan as like this small little thing, and there's no references to it.
[17:47] Andrew DeWolf: It's just an idea that he has, really. And he asked permission of each boy to name them after the characters before he starts writing.
[17:54] Jesse McAnally: There's important things that go on and makes it a much smarter and more enthusiastic piece of theater. And that's not even talking about how much better written the songs are.
[18:04] Andrew DeWolf: But can we also talk about how it compares to what happened in the real world?
[18:08] Jesse McAnally: That's what we're gonna transition to right here. Because neither the Broadway show, the Leicester version, or the movie, uh Finding Neverland, are anything compared to the original real life things that happened.
[18:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um so we frame this as Jam Barry walking into his life of a single mother and their kids, um, and then falling in love with all of them.
[18:27] Jesse McAnally: But in real life, the single mother had a husband that was alive, very much alive when JM Barry ran into them.
[18:33] Andrew DeWolf: In fact, he was very uncomfortable with their relationship. Oops.
[18:37] Jesse McAnally: Um, so he That would have been an interesting thing to include in you know something like this.
[18:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um according to some accounts, the former um like people viewed it at with very suspiciously.
[18:50] Jesse McAnally: Um, however, JM Barry even included Arthur, who was the husband, in the dedication to the start of Peter Pan in Kensington Gardens, to which it read to Sylvia and Arthur, Llewellyn Davis and their boys, in parentheses, my boys, which is a little bit of a turmoil push.
[19:05] Andrew DeWolf: My boys, if you ask me. But when Arthur died in 44 of cancer of the jaw, Barry basically stepped in and replaced him, but he also paid for all their medical bills and paid a lot of their like paid for all that.
[19:17] Jesse McAnally: Um so Barry was married at the time he met uh Sylvia Llewellyn Davis.
[19:23] Andrew DeWolf: His wife, um, he never fucked her, which was apparently well known information.
[19:28] Jesse McAnally: So everybody knew.
[19:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, like everyone knew that he didn't fuck her. Um, and so she went and cheated on him because she needed she had needs that he wasn't fulfilling, and he just divorced her on a whim.
[19:39] Jesse McAnally: And then Sylvia died.
[19:41] Andrew DeWolf: Did he have a very nice mustache though?
[19:42] Jesse McAnally: He did, and no production has ever included the mustache.
[19:46] Andrew DeWolf: Which is kind of sad, really. Imagine you have a very distinctive look like that, and there's adaptations of your life, and none of them include that.
[19:56] Jesse McAnally: I do also want to talk about um the Peter Pan curse that we talked about.
[19:56] Andrew DeWolf: The Peter Pan curse.
[20:03] Jesse McAnally: Um the end of the day. We're gonna have to explain this one.
[20:06] Andrew DeWolf: Is absurdly happy. It's almost like it's begging you to not Google what happened to the boys after the movie and musical ends.
[20:15] Jesse McAnally: Um But we did.
[20:17] Andrew DeWolf: Peter Llewellyn Davis, who Peter Pan was quote unquote based on, according to some sources.
[20:23] Jesse McAnally: Um, he would win the military crossover's efforts in World War One, and he became a publisher.
[20:28] Andrew DeWolf: Um but his lifelong notoriety with the character Peter Pan troubled him greatly.
[20:33] Jesse McAnally: He once referred to the play as that terrible masterpiece.
[20:36] Andrew DeWolf: Though no one is certain why his association with the character bothered him so much.
[20:40] Jesse McAnally: Um it is certain that Peter felt insulted when James Barry left his fortune to his secretary, Cynthia Asquith, and not to the Davies boys, who were the inspiration for Peter Pan.
[20:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um Peter's son Ruthvin, that's an awesome name, by the way, wrote My father had mixed feelings about the whole business of Peter Pan.
[20:57] Jesse McAnally: He accepted that Barry considered that he had the inspiration for Peter Pan.
[21:00] Andrew DeWolf: It was only reasonable that my father should inherit everything from Barry.
[21:03] Jesse McAnally: That was my father's expectation.
[21:05] Andrew DeWolf: It would have recompensed him for the notoriety he had experienced since being linked with Peter Pan, something he hated.
[21:12] Jesse McAnally: Um, so it was not a good life for young Peter there.
[21:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um on April 5th, 1960, almost seven months after the death of his brother John, 63 year old Pete Peter committed suicide by throwing himself under a train as it was pulling into the station at Sloane Square, London.
[21:26] Jesse McAnally: It is not known why Peter took his life.
[21:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but apparently he was while in the balance of his mind, the balance of his mind was disturbed.
[21:35] Jesse McAnally: Um so we we know a lot about Peter Pan's in the world, and I think the one Peter Pan is played by a woman or there is a connection to a woman, they they tend to be alright.
[21:47] Andrew DeWolf: The men who play Peter Pan tend to have pretty rough ends um so far.
[21:52] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, well, you didn't even mention um the other Peter Pans.
[21:55] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, who else has played Peter Pan?
[21:57] Jesse McAnally: Who do we got?
[21:57] Andrew DeWolf: We we got Bobby Driscoll.
[21:59] Jesse McAnally: Yep.
[21:59] Andrew DeWolf: And and why don't you explain what happened to him?
[22:02] Jesse McAnally: I think we've gone into it before, but um I think Bobby met a uh a similar fate to um Peter Llewellyn.
[22:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, um well Bobby couldn't get couldn't get cast in anything as an adult.
[22:15] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, was thrown out by Walt Disney himself, and he played it in the Disney film.
[22:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um got into drugs and overdosed in uh apartment, um, but he was unrecognizable, so he was buried in an unmarked grave until his mother went looking for him like 15 years after his death.
[22:32] Jesse McAnally: Um, so not the happiest end for them.
[22:35] Andrew DeWolf: And of course, Robin Williams played Peter Pan in the film Hook, and not the happiest end for him as either.
[22:43] Jesse McAnally: I'm sure we all know that one.
[22:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and of course, we have to um have Disney mocking uh Peter Pan's struggles in in the uh the Chippendale Rescue Rangers.
[22:45] Jesse McAnally: Rescue Rangers.
[22:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um so basically don't play Peter Pan.
[22:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: If someone offers you a role as Peter Pan, I'd I'd recommend against it.
[23:02] Jesse McAnally: There is a new Peter Pan movie coming out next year, um with a a new young boy playing Peter Pan, and let's take care of that kid, please.
[23:13] Andrew DeWolf: Be nice.
[23:15] Jesse McAnally: I don't tend to really have much faith in curses, but um I'm a little concerned about that.
[23:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's a little too much with the Peter Pan.
[23:22] Jesse McAnally: Let's go into our favorite section, brand new section called Wild Facts.
[23:27] Andrew DeWolf: So in nineteen twenty-nine, Barry gave the copyright to of Peter Pan to the Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children.
[23:33] Jesse McAnally: Even though the UK copyright expired in eight nineteen eighty-seven, fifty years after Barry's death, then Prime Minister Lord Callahan successfully proposed an amendment to the copyrights act, which gave Great Ormond Street the unique right to royalties from stage performances of Peter Pan and any adaptation of the play forever.
[23:49] Andrew DeWolf: What do you think about that?
[23:50] Jesse McAnally: Because I don't I I get that it's supposed to be like a charitable act of like we're always we're gonna give this hospital royalties forever on this Peter Pan thing, but like I don't know.
[24:02] Andrew DeWolf: Doesn't that make it harder to perform the play in like forever?
[24:06] Jesse McAnally: I I that is a good question, but I feel like folks like Disney, um, that's a drop in the bucket.
[24:11] Andrew DeWolf: Sure, sure.
[24:12] Jesse McAnally: Um Yeah, I I mean I get what they're trying to do. I I am iffy on extending copyright of any kind though, so I'm not sure how I feel on it.
[24:23] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like feel like you'd be concerned on both sides.
[24:27] Jesse McAnally: I get what they're trying to do, and I get that in this particular case, they're trying to be uh caring and nice, but anything that extends copyright forever is maybe a bad precedent.
[24:40] Andrew DeWolf: I'd say in the US, yes, and London, maybe not.
[24:43] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. I I'm of the opinion that copyright is a is a bad practice and probably shouldn't exist in its current state at all.
[24:52] Andrew DeWolf: So it's a it's a bad question for me to try to answer.
[24:55] Jesse McAnally: That's fair.
[24:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um another wild fact.
[24:58] Jesse McAnally: In 2017, as an offshoot of the investigation into the and reporting about Harvey Weinstein's many sexual abuse allegations.
[25:05] Andrew DeWolf: Several news sources also reported that a significant amount of money that Weinstein ostensibly raised for the AIDS charity Amphar was instead allegedly funneled into the American Repertory Theater and the production budget for Finding Neverland.
[25:19] Jesse McAnally: So this this show was produced with very dirty money.
[25:25] Andrew DeWolf: Wow. Did he even get in trouble for that?
[25:27] Jesse McAnally: I mean, I I he's definitely in prison.
[25:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, but did he get in trouble for this?
[25:32] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. I feel like there was a lot of other things pending on his plate at the time.
[25:37] Andrew DeWolf: You raised money for an AIDS charity and instead put it into a production of a musical that you're going to make money off of.
[25:47] Jesse McAnally: Not a good look.
[25:48] Andrew DeWolf: Harvey, this Harvey Weinstein guy, I don't know a ton about him, but he seems like a bad dude.
[25:53] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[25:53] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I don't know.
[25:55] Jesse McAnally: Have to do a little more research into this guy.
[25:59] Andrew DeWolf: The final and actually the sec the penultimate um fun wild fact.
[26:05] Jesse McAnally: Rarr.
[26:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it is rumored that Jam Barry may have been impotent.
[26:09] Jesse McAnally: However, it is just as likely that Barry and his wife, actress Mary Ansel, rarely fucked.
[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: Barry had little interest in sex and he found more pleasure in playing around with other people's children than having his own.
[26:20] Jesse McAnally: He uh he what now?
[26:21] Andrew DeWolf: His biographer stumbled upon several revealing entries from some of Barry's private notebooks, which seems to indicate his feelings about marriage.
[26:31] Jesse McAnally: It's it's kind of gross.
[26:33] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not reading that.
[26:34] Jesse McAnally: Um you can't feel like trapped.
[26:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um and the last wild fact, JM Barry suffered from psychological dwarfism.
[26:41] Jesse McAnally: As an adult, he stood at only 4'10.
[26:44] Andrew DeWolf: This is a whole foot shorter than his on-screen counterparts on stage and screen.
[26:48] Jesse McAnally: Um psychogenic dwarfism is a growth disorder that occurs between the ages of two and fifteen, brought on by extreme emotional deprivation or stress.
[26:56] Andrew DeWolf: The condition results in decreased growth hormone, gh secretion, inappropriate height and weight, and an immature skeletal age.
[27:04] Jesse McAnally: Um this is one of those wild facts that are contested because other places say that James Barry was five five three.
[27:13] Andrew DeWolf: Five three is still very short, but it's not like four. It's not four ten. But I would be interested to see Peter Dinklage play James Barrie. He could probably do an actual Scottish accent and make the... Isn't Peter Dinklage, I guess? I don't know how tall Peter Dinklage is.
[27:31] Jesse McAnally: Peter Dinklage is four five.
[27:32] Andrew DeWolf: I was gonna say he does seem too short for four ten, but I guess I don't know how tall four ten is.
[27:38] Jesse McAnally: It's pretty short. It's like an inch shorter than Kristen Chenoweth, which is tiny.
[27:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so those are the wild facts for this week. Um, pretty sad, honestly. These are some of the saddest wild facts. Maybe like a small kitten sound here. So like Peter Pan is such a wholesome story-ish, like at least it's portrayed that way.
[28:00] Jesse McAnally: If you ignore like everything around it.
[28:01] Andrew DeWolf: Everything around it is just horrible and depressing. And every time we talk about Peter Pan, it's like a downer mood.
[28:10] Jesse McAnally: Like, what do you mean? Like, what do you... we got Rainbow Card to get out of Peter Pan?
[28:15] Andrew DeWolf: The fuck you talking about?
[28:16] Jesse McAnally: The Rainbow Cardigan thing was not a good thing. It was just funny.
[28:22] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I think that's one of the best things that's ever happened on this show. Can we both agree that it was a very bad decision to make Peter Pan the bad guy in the Chip and Dale movie?
[28:32] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I can agree to that. Um, Peter Pan's use in media is strange. Um, because Peter Pan is not a good character.
[28:38] Andrew DeWolf: And that's part of the reason why Disney hated that film is because he thought Peter Pan was a shitty character.
[28:46] Jesse McAnally: He like literally said, I have more empathy for Captain Hook than I do for Peter Pan.
[28:50] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, Peter Pan is genuinely a selfish little boy. Like, who actually the actual motives are that of like a lich.
[29:01] Jesse McAnally: Like, I never want to age, you know?
[29:05] Andrew DeWolf: And what's the connection to James Barrie? Um, so I do dress rehearsals for this show where I tell my significant other all the things I want to say on the episode and all that, and they looked at me when I described the plot of Finding Neverland, and they were like, this tiny man is playing with little boys the same height as them, and then he just rips off their life to write a play that like soaks up all their life into it and expects them to just deal with that.
[29:37] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and it's kind of... I don't know, Finding Neverland, they take it and they make it into like a... he's connected with them in like a very deep personal way.
[29:48] Andrew DeWolf: But if you actually look at it, he just wrote a story based on stuff that they did, which is kind of weird.
[29:56] Jesse McAnally: Which is fine. You take from everywhere in your life as an artist, but do you take from everywhere, or do you take from a couple boys you met?
[30:04] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. And let's think about these boys, the wife, and all these characters. Like Sylvia Llewellyn Davis did not ask for this in her life.
[30:14] Jesse McAnally: She did not ask to be made iconic by Kate Winslet or Laura Michelle Kelly in these stories.
[30:21] Andrew DeWolf: She didn't ask for her name to be in the limelight where people just know that she died and that her kids were running around with a grown man.
[30:30] Jesse McAnally: That's just how we do it with some of these stories, though. I guess we take stuff that really happened and we just twist it into whatever narrative we need it to, for better or worse.
[30:43] Andrew DeWolf: Mostly worse.
[30:43] Jesse McAnally: So it does feel like mostly worse. Um, but look at this show where it... this is a product. This isn't a story.
[30:50] Andrew DeWolf: Like the Broadway final version.
[30:54] Jesse McAnally: I put a tweet out yesterday about it.
[30:57] Andrew DeWolf: And I literally just asked, hey, what are your opinions on Finding Neverland? This one I do this for a lot of shows where I'm trying to figure out how I feel and what the general consensus is.
[31:05] Jesse McAnally: This one was a little different.
[31:06] Andrew DeWolf: Because Broadway theater critics started replying and tweeting at it.
[31:10] Jesse McAnally: Really?
[31:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[31:11] Jesse McAnally: Were they diplomatic?
[31:13] Andrew DeWolf: Um, no. Jack Viertal, um, who follows me, which is a strange thing, he is an artistic director, a New York writer, replied, it's simply awful.
[31:24] Jesse McAnally: And then Adam Green, who is also a writer for the New Yorker and Vogue magazine, replied, I panicked in the middle of Act One because for professional reasons, I couldn't leave at intermission, and I had no idea how I was going to survive all the way through.
[31:37] Andrew DeWolf: My most hated... what?
[31:40] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god. And then Mr. David Gordon, who is a theater mania outer critic circle critic, um, replied, no worse than Dr. Zhivago.
[31:49] Andrew DeWolf: Dr. Wait, what was that?
[31:51] Jesse McAnally: That was another musical by the original composers, not the pop composer that came in.
[31:57] Andrew DeWolf: However, from the normal people, which is who I was really trying to get through, get connected to, um, range from long and boring, Jeremy Jordan should have moved to Broadway, who played it in Massachusetts and then was replaced by Matthew Morrison.
[32:12] Jesse McAnally: And in my opinion, they're negligible.
[32:13] Andrew DeWolf: They both do fine-ish work.
[32:16] Jesse McAnally: Honestly, I didn't actually have any problem with the Glee guy. I thought he was fine.
[32:21] Andrew DeWolf: Did he do the accent?
[32:22] Jesse McAnally: No, I mean, but like what? Nobody's gonna do the accent. Like, and I feel like the problems with the show is not who is playing the main character.
[32:32] Andrew DeWolf: There's a lot of deeper issues.
[32:35] Jesse McAnally: But there are a lot of people that are like absolutely loved it, absolutely. But you know the most recurring statement about it was sure the fucking sparkle tornado is really cool.
[32:45] Andrew DeWolf: That was the most consistent note about it.
[32:48] Jesse McAnally: And you know what? The sparkle tornado is really cool.
[32:52] Andrew DeWolf: I can't even fight that.
[32:53] Jesse McAnally: That moment in this show is magical and incomparable.
[32:57] Andrew DeWolf: Do you even remember the sparkle tornado?
[32:59] Jesse McAnally: I do remember the sparkle tornado.
[33:00] Andrew DeWolf: It was neat.
[33:01] Jesse McAnally: It's a good effect.
[33:02] Andrew DeWolf: It's a good effect, but the... and then the scarf flies up, someone said give that scarf a Tony.
[33:07] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[33:08] Andrew DeWolf: But if all that your show has to offer is a sparkle tornado at the last moment in the second act, is it really worth it?
[33:15] Jesse McAnally: Give King Kong the Tony.
[33:17] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah.
[33:18] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, they did though.
[33:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um, we... I do, before we move on to previews, I do want to talk about the pop song cover album they made of this.
[33:27] Jesse McAnally: So it isn't already a pop song cover album like the album just when it's on stage.
[33:31] Andrew DeWolf: It is, which is why it kind of makes no sense and is very bad.
[33:36] Jesse McAnally: But in 2015, a year after it closed, Harvey Weinstein brought together a bunch of pop stars to sing songs from this show.
[33:46] Andrew DeWolf: And I just want Brie to take a look at some of these stars, these people, and tell me like what her thoughts are about them.
[33:56] Jesse McAnally: So here's who we've got on this list. We've got Zendaya, very popular around that time.
[34:02] Andrew DeWolf: These are a lot of big names.
[34:03] Jesse McAnally: Nick Jonas, Elle Goulding, Bon Jovi, Jennifer Lopez, and Tri... Tri Songs.
[34:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.
[34:09] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[34:09] Andrew DeWolf: Pentatonix, Christina Perri, the Goo Goo Dolls.
[34:12] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like how much do you think this album costs to put together?
[34:12] Andrew DeWolf: A fuck ton for songs that are pretty bad for a musical that nobody really liked.
[34:21] Jesse McAnally: They got that Harvey Weinstein money, though.
[34:24] Andrew DeWolf: Why though?
[34:25] Jesse McAnally: Why do this?
[34:26] Andrew DeWolf: Because they saw a commercial product.
[34:29] Jesse McAnally: They're selling nostalgia.
[34:31] Andrew DeWolf: It's a classic formula.
[34:34] Jesse McAnally: In theory, Finding Neverland the musical should be a surefire hit if you care about the characters.
[34:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like it should be a wicked, because it's like, oh, a story I don't quite know that well, but it's the IP I recognize.
[34:45] Jesse McAnally: But yeah, there's so many fucking Peter Pan musicals already.
[34:49] Andrew DeWolf: You've got the original, you've got Peter and the Starcatcher, you've got the one done by... oh god, I forget the other one.
[34:56] Jesse McAnally: There's another one that isn't the one we covered.
[34:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um, done by a famous person I can't remember.
[35:01] Jesse McAnally: I'm... we're all sick of this story in a way that we're not quite sick of The Wizard of Oz yet.
[35:07] Andrew DeWolf: Soon.
[35:08] Jesse McAnally: Soon.
[35:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, Peter Pan, it's weird because Peter Pan, I don't... when I think of Peter Pan, I don't think of him as like a pop culture megastar, you know.
[35:20] Jesse McAnally: But at the same time, there is just a ton of adaptations of this character.
[35:24] Andrew DeWolf: I think one of the wildest moments on this podcast ever is when I showed you the Smells Like Teen Spirit scene from the movie Pan from 2014, 2015.
[35:34] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[35:35] Andrew DeWolf: Which for some reason I keep thinking that that's from Hook, but it's not.
[35:38] Jesse McAnally: No, it is not.
[35:39] Andrew DeWolf: Hook is a quality movie.
[35:41] Jesse McAnally: And would have probably made a better stage musical than Finding Neverland, honestly.
[35:46] Andrew DeWolf: I'm surprised that they haven't done that yet.
[35:48] Jesse McAnally: It was written to be a musical.
[35:50] Andrew DeWolf: That was supposed to be Spielberg's first musical.
[35:51] Jesse McAnally: Like all the songs were in there, and then they just like John Williams wrote songs for that movie with a lyricist, and then Spielberg got cowardly at the last minute and just turned it all into um like interstitial music.
[36:05] Andrew DeWolf: What a baby.
[36:06] Jesse McAnally: I know.
[36:07] Andrew DeWolf: That movie could have been great if that had songs.
[36:09] Jesse McAnally: But I do remember the Smells Like Teen Spirit thing.
[36:13] Andrew DeWolf: That was bad.
[36:14] Jesse McAnally: I mean, most Peter Pan adaptations are bad.
[36:17] Andrew DeWolf: Like, not gonna lie.
[36:18] Jesse McAnally: Hook is the only one.
[36:19] Andrew DeWolf: Peter Pan just a bad story.
[36:21] Jesse McAnally: I think it's like Pinocchio, where every director for some reason really wants to make fucking Pinocchio.
[36:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like that was Stanley Kubrick's White Whale that he really wanted, and then Spielberg directed instead.
[36:33] Jesse McAnally: Guaramo del Toro just directed one, Roberto Benigni's first thing after he won his Oscar, he wanted to make a Pinocchio movie.
[36:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Robert Zemeckis just made one for Disney.
[36:42] Jesse McAnally: Every director wants to fucking make Pinocchio for some reason.
[36:45] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what? Pinocchio is not that interesting a story.
[36:48] Jesse McAnally: I'm sorry, y'all.
[36:49] Andrew DeWolf: I don't even understand what the appeal is.
[36:51] Jesse McAnally: It's not like some artsy premise.
[36:54] Andrew DeWolf: Like, like there's not a ton you can do with it.
[36:56] Jesse McAnally: It's just a fairy gives a puppet powers or whatever and turns it real.
[37:00] Andrew DeWolf: No, Andrew, it's about an artist bringing something to life that can walk and breathe and really love.
[37:08] Jesse McAnally: You're right.
[37:09] Andrew DeWolf: Now it makes sense.
[37:10] Jesse McAnally: Now it makes sense.
[37:11] Andrew DeWolf: Because all the filmmakers, they're the artists and they want to bring something to life themselves.
[37:16] Jesse McAnally: Yes, yeah.
[37:17] Andrew DeWolf: When's your version of Pinocchio coming out?
[37:19] Jesse McAnally: I wouldn't make Pinocchio because I think it's a boring story.
[37:22] Andrew DeWolf: Like, unless you're doing something very different with it.
[37:24] Jesse McAnally: Like Astro Boy, at least that's something different.
[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: And AI, which was Kubrick and Spielberg's Pinocchio, that's something different enough where I'm like, okay, that's kinda interesting.
[37:34] Jesse McAnally: But if you're just gonna do a straight Pinocchio adaptation, why would you do that?
[37:38] Andrew DeWolf: If I were to make a Pinocchio adaptation, it would be a screwball comedy, and it would... they'd all have very silly Italian accents.
[37:46] Jesse McAnally: Um, that's basically Roberto Benigni's.
[37:49] Andrew DeWolf: They talk about eating the spaghetti in a goals in the Gabagool, Pinocchio would be in the mafia.
[37:57] Jesse McAnally: You know what? If I... Pinocchio in the mafia.
[38:02] Andrew DeWolf: Wow!
[38:03] Jesse McAnally: You can't rat on us.
[38:05] Andrew DeWolf: You gotta lie.
[38:07] Jesse McAnally: Gotta lie to the Pinocchio.
[38:09] Andrew DeWolf: You're talking about my son puppet like that?
[38:12] Jesse McAnally: Look what you did to my boy.
[38:15] Andrew DeWolf: Your father.
[38:16] Jesse McAnally: Is your father selling any drugs?
[38:18] Andrew DeWolf: Come on, tell me, Pinocchio.
[38:20] Jesse McAnally: No!
[38:25] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, we got him.
[38:27] Jesse McAnally: You don't have a very good poker face.
[38:30] Andrew DeWolf: They try to garrote him, but he just cuts into the wood.
[38:36] Jesse McAnally: Wait a second.
[38:37] Andrew DeWolf: This is a great idea.
[38:42] Jesse McAnally: They try to drown him, but he walks out a few days later.
[38:45] Andrew DeWolf: Pop on back.
[38:47] Jesse McAnally: Wait a second. Why is this like a brilliant idea?
[38:49] Andrew DeWolf: Why is this like actually great?
[38:52] Jesse McAnally: We found a Pinocchio pitch.
[38:54] Andrew DeWolf: We finally did it.
[38:56] Jesse McAnally: One that hasn't been done.
[38:59] Andrew DeWolf: Pinocchio in the mob.
[39:03] Jesse McAnally: On that note, how about we compare our opinions to those of the New York Times critic when this first came out?
[39:08] Andrew DeWolf: It's time for previews.
[39:11] Jesse McAnally: It's time for previews.
[39:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's time for previews.
[39:18] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Brie. What have we got?
[39:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so we have Ben Brantley here.
[39:22] Jesse McAnally: Hey, my boy!
[39:23] Andrew DeWolf: Hey!
[39:24] Jesse McAnally: Okay, and he said the first entrance applause occurs before even the overture begins.
[39:31] Andrew DeWolf: Riotous clapping is occasioned with a bright point of light travels over the ceiling and the curtains of the Lunt-Fontanne Theater in New York, where the push button, button pushing musical, Finding Neverland, opened on Wednesday night.
[39:45] Jesse McAnally: I got a Brantleyism.
[39:48] Andrew DeWolf: A push button, button pushing music.
[39:50] Jesse McAnally: What the... okay, whatever.
[39:52] Andrew DeWolf: If you say something twice, people will think it's smart.
[39:55] Jesse McAnally: Twice and backwards.
[39:57] Andrew DeWolf: This little light you see is pretty much guaranteed to elicit a Pavlovian response from anyone familiar with the story of Peter Pan in its various incarnations, which surely includes everyone who shelled out the big bucks for this show.
[40:13] Jesse McAnally: Said light equals Tinkerbell.
[40:17] Andrew DeWolf: Said light.
[40:18] Jesse McAnally: He gets the metaphor.
[40:19] Andrew DeWolf: He understands the complicated show.
[40:22] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[40:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[40:23] Andrew DeWolf: So said light equals Tinkerbell, the temperamental fairy who requires your applause to stay alive.
[40:30] Jesse McAnally: Clap if you believe in brand names.
[40:33] Andrew DeWolf: I clapped.
[40:34] Andrew DeWolf: I clapped because I knew what he was referencing.
[40:36] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah.
[40:37] Andrew DeWolf: Directed by uh Diane Polleth with the guidance of Harvey Weinstein, its chief producer.
[40:44] Andrew DeWolf: Ugh. Finding Neverland is filled with such triggers.
[40:48] Jesse McAnally: Triggered Snowflake.
[40:49] Andrew DeWolf: Did Tinkerbell trigger you to clap?
[40:51] Jesse McAnally: Yes. The most brazen, perhaps, comes when an English actor in a pub asks an American, do they say cheers when you where you come from, mate? The simple query sets the audience a roar.
[41:04] Andrew DeWolf: That's because the man playing the American happens to be Kelsey Grammer, who was a regular on the long-running sitcom Cheers.
[41:14] Jesse McAnally: Neither Mr. Grammer nor the show's leading man, Matthew Morrison of the television series Glee, appear wholly invested in their performance. But that's okay. Their mere presence do most of the work for them.
[41:28] Andrew DeWolf: As with a Broadway musical these days, Finding Neverland, which features a book by James Graham and sticky soft pop power ballads by Gary Barlow and Elliot Kennedy, is based on a popular film. That would be the 2004 biopic about the playwright JM Barrie and the creator of Peter Pan, which starred Johnny Depp. Uh, and for which Mr. Weinstein was an executive producer.
[41:56] Jesse McAnally: Wow. I mean, I can't say that anything he says here is incorrect.
[42:00] Andrew DeWolf: No, but the way he says it.
[42:02] Jesse McAnally: He has a way of making anything he says sound wrong, but it's not. He's completely correct. Uh, everything in this is absolutely just trying to be like, hey, you know this. You should like this, because you know this, like over and over, and yeah, the cheers thing is like the worst because they're not even referencing Peter Pan anymore. Now they're just talking about being Cheers.
[42:26] Andrew DeWolf: That was the moment where I was like, I'm done. I can't do this. I was so close to turning it off.
[42:34] Jesse McAnally: Wait a second. Are you Mr. Cheers from The Cheers? Or are you Mr. Frazier from The Frazier?
[42:42] Andrew DeWolf: Wow. I am neither. I am classically trained actor Kelsey Grammer. Vote for Trump.
[42:48] Jesse McAnally: Um, I do appreciate Jesse Green, who also reviewed it for Vulture. Um, he basically was like, it just feels so hollow, and I can tell that they just didn't have interest in talking about the less positive aspects of JM Barrie in this entire story because they just wanted people to shove this down their throat like a work of fantasy.
[43:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I kind of think complex characters can be interesting and fun to watch.
[43:19] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like even more so than characters without flaws.
[43:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and like Geppetto, he he's a part of the mob, and he made himself a boy, and the boy is to take over the family business. Pinocchio just wants to be made into a made man.
[43:37] Jesse McAnally: I want to be a real man, Papa. You gotta you gotta learn the blue fairy.
[43:42] Andrew DeWolf: Gotta stay away from that blue fairy kid.
[43:46] Jesse McAnally: The blue fairy's good though.
[43:48] Andrew DeWolf: What the fuck? That blue fairy it it means no good.
[43:52] Jesse McAnally: Come on. I'm sorry, like you can meme, but the mob story of Pinocchio would actually be really good.
[43:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I would watch the shit out of that. Like, and you could just turn every it could be like a true mobster movie, but it's like Pinocchio.
[44:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. You just take you like the whale thing, that's like a rival like mobster. Something like anything. He just he's trapped somewhere. Else. He's not in an actual whale. Like, there's there's a lot we could do with it.
[44:20] Andrew DeWolf: There's a lot you could do with it. The fact is they keep trying to kill Pinocchio, but he won't die. He's like the ultimate mob boss. Like, that's a main thing in the book, the Calodi book is people keep trying to kill Pinocchio. Like they hang him up by a tree, they try to burn, and he just won't die. And that I'm like, that's like we could bring it back, and it makes sense too, because it's like, well, yeah, he's in the mob. Everyone wants him dead.
[44:44] Jesse McAnally: Alright, guys. Um, we're gonna make this movie.
[44:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we we gotta make this movie now. That's gonna be my follow-up. Jess, you you already made you already made a bunch of money to make a movie. You can just change what the movie is.
[44:54] Jesse McAnally: You can't change what the movie is.
[44:57] Andrew DeWolf: You just easily change what the movie is.
[44:59] Jesse McAnally: I mean, you could also just maybe raise some money for an age charity and instead use it to produce the Pinocchio mob.
[45:08] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, um, let's go to our own uh uh money laundering age charity and talk about our Patreon!
[45:28] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Andrew, tell us a little bit about Patreon.
[45:39] Jesse McAnally: If you donate to our Patreon, the money definitely doesn't go to us and get you extra perks. We're actually donating it to a real charity.
[45:48] Andrew DeWolf: And this is a real thing and not a joke.
[45:50] Jesse McAnally: Um don't say the thing.
[45:53] Andrew DeWolf: I am actually joking, though. That is actually a joke. All of the money goes to us, but you get a few. It's in our description. We are verified because we paid $8. Um, you can see extra stuff like commentary tracks, and we have bonus uh episodes. You can request episodes from us at certain tiers.
[46:14] Jesse McAnally: You can also be a guest.
[46:15] Andrew DeWolf: And you can even appear as a guest on the show if you uh donate the right amount. Um also join this list of names that I will now read out. Um we will butcher your name horribly, and you will love it. You'll think it's hilarious.
[46:27] Jesse McAnally: Um our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Danielle Rennix, Jessica Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Lithanial Stacey Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanales, Wes Walker, Musical Hell, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Scoot and the Technicolor Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, Alison Stoller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Rafael Martinez Salaz, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, uh, Chris Marcote, Mimu, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Leela, RJ Noriga, Charlie B, Bjorn Hermans, Erica S.
[47:06] Andrew DeWolf: Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most Lopez, Leana Morton, Kayleigh Blazier, Birdman69, Cinemageddon Reviews, Villainous Miss, Sophina Ali, The Omega Geek, Paige Pearson, Matty Wargle, Eliza Erdmann, Anna Luscatova, Chesca Varay, Sarah Den Blaker, even Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Spencer Heller, and Gathering Party before venturing forth.
[47:32] Jesse McAnally: These folks give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, Musicals of Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get all those fun perks, such as Patreon Only Commentary's episode today earlier, even earlier, and a bunch of other shit, come join them over at Patreon.
[47:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it would mean the world to us. Um, and if we don't, um, I'm gonna kill this cat.
[47:50] Jesse McAnally: Alright, let's get back to the show.
[48:03] Andrew DeWolf: Uh this show is so.
[48:14] Jesse McAnally: Bree, play all the songs at once, overlapping each other.
[48:19] Andrew DeWolf: She's shaking her head like, why the fuck?
[48:22] Jesse McAnally: No.
[48:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but if you tried it, you'd realize that it they would all fit perfectly together because they're the same songs.
[48:26] Jesse McAnally: Honestly, it would be shocking how accurate that is. They every song thinks it's a memory from Cats.
[48:34] Andrew DeWolf: Every song wants to be the power ballad that is played on the radio. And so much so that every song was turned into a pop song sung by pop artists for no reason.
[48:44] Jesse McAnally: But which one was the most memory from Cats?
[48:48] Andrew DeWolf: Stronger, the act one closer.
[48:50] Jesse McAnally: I come from now.
[48:53] Andrew DeWolf: Much faster. Now defeat won't find my master for to conquer the demons.
[49:02] Jesse McAnally: I won't have to play them alone.
[49:07] Andrew DeWolf: I've got to be strong.
[49:16] Jesse McAnally: It's also the one that performed at the Tony Awards.
[49:19] Andrew DeWolf: Though I I feel like the one, and I can't even remember which one it is, but it's the one where I think it's uh Barry and and Sylvia are singing together.
[49:29] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, that one's gross.
[49:30] Andrew DeWolf: What you mean to me, which could be a song about anyone saying anything.
[49:34] Jesse McAnally: That's it. I won't lie. I'm a little bit frightened of my imagination.
[49:44] Andrew DeWolf: Swear I'll try, but I'm feeling enlightened in my inspiration.
[49:53] Jesse McAnally: We can fly if we want to promise your faith.
[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: We'll give you waves.
[50:02] Jesse McAnally: Just take the second start of a right, straight ahead to the borderline.
[50:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yes, but I think that one was the one that I felt like was the most memory from Cats. They really want it to be uh, yeah, I agree.
[50:19] Jesse McAnally: However, I do think, yeah, stronger, where he that's the one at the end of uh Act One, and he goes up on the like board with the sword in his hand or whatever.
[50:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. Um yeah, that one, that one is something.
[50:32] Jesse McAnally: I do want to say there is one song that was designed to be the memory from Cats, um, and the big song to promote this show, and was in the original Leicester production, and is the only song remaining from that production.
[50:46] Andrew DeWolf: To bring it back around to the top.
[50:48] Jesse McAnally: And that is the song Neverland. Whenever I was frightened, if I ever felt alone, I turned to the night sky.
[51:03] Andrew DeWolf: And a star I call my own.
[51:08] Jesse McAnally: Somewhere I could run to just across the Milky Way.
[51:16] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like I could take you.
[51:20] Jesse McAnally: It's just light here and day. Is between JM Barrie and Sylvia, where he's describing Neverland, which was this place that he made up when his brother died as like his idea of heaven.
[51:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and would eventually become like Michael Jackson's backyard.
[51:37] Jesse McAnally: Um, just as JM Barrie intended. Um, yeah, it's it's a fine song. And it was one that they had so much confidence in that they had Jennifer Hudson sing it a year before the show even premiered at the Tonies, just because.
[51:51] Andrew DeWolf: And it's the only one from that original show.
[51:53] Jesse McAnally: Like it and it worked better in that original show because it felt like an outlier and powerful because it was this big powerful song.
[52:01] Andrew DeWolf: And then it's just surrounded by songs that all sound the same.
[52:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and maybe, and it's the only one that's really powerful because at the end, because a the sparkle tornado that kills Sylvia.
[52:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[52:16] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it kind of works there.
[52:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um every other song is kinda garbage.
[52:21] Jesse McAnally: Um, I'm gonna pull up some of my notes about any of the songs here, um, just to see if I can give you a lie by play by play of what I was feeling.
[52:28] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[52:29] Jesse McAnally: Um, play maybe the show's biggest sin and the grossest song. Can you remember back when you were young? When all the simple things you did were so much fun.
[52:41] Andrew DeWolf: You got lost somewhere along the hallway.
[52:44] Jesse McAnally: You've forgotten how to play every single day. Am I right?
[52:52] Andrew DeWolf: I remember back when I was just a boy.
[52:55] Jesse McAnally: I got a gun and holster for a Christmas toy.
[52:59] Andrew DeWolf: Pretending to be a cowboy was the very best.
[53:03] Jesse McAnally: Cause I was always the fastest gun in all the West High play.
[53:07] Andrew DeWolf: Do you remember that song where they're all at the bar and they make the cheers joke and they sing a song that feels like it's from Come From Away, but it has all the souls sucked out of it?
[53:15] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, that it's like the whole cast, right?
[53:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[53:18] Jesse McAnally: Or something like and they're all in this bar singing.
[53:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[53:21] Jesse McAnally: And then you've got a song, something about that night, where they're all getting ready for the show and it's like in three different parts.
[53:29] Andrew DeWolf: And it sounds like it's from High School Musical.
[53:31] Jesse McAnally: Like, no exaggeration. It sounds like a High School Musical song.
[53:35] Andrew DeWolf: I saw I have never liked before.
[53:39] Jesse McAnally: Something about this nightman.
[53:41] Andrew DeWolf: I cannot express excitement so nervousness.
[53:46] Jesse McAnally: How we take my guess.
[53:50] Andrew DeWolf: But there is something about this nightman.
[53:53] Jesse McAnally: I just can't enjoy all the sweats and test boys.
[54:01] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like they started struggling to find songs like things to write about once he had already basically written the show, and now they're just trying to put it on.
[54:11] Jesse McAnally: Which is why. So they're like, well, what do they sing about now? The original production, you know, singing a s they put off Peter Pan's existence until Act 2.
[54:20] Andrew DeWolf: And then all the reviews of the original Nicester production is all like Act 2's better because it's all about Peter Pan. And then Harvey Weinstein's like, oh, make it all about Peter Pan. What are we doing here? And then he licked Princess Leia. Um, so can you try an experiment with me for this? I'm gonna send you one of the romance songs um about that Sylvia sings from the original production and put it up next to um All That Matters, which is just a nothing song in Act One. Like it's a in one of them it's called Um He Makes Me Smile, which is a very specific thing where she's justifying why she's wasting time on James Barry, the weird parasocial connection she has to him, and all that matters is a generic pop song that could be about literally anything. And just play them back to back for you for our audience right here, so you can really get how jarring the differences are.
[54:52] ♪ Musical number: "He Makes Me Smile" — performed by Sylvia ♪
[56:27] Andrew DeWolf: Ugh. I hate this show so much in its final form. And I didn't really hate it before I watched other versions of it. I feel like your hatred is coming from a place of knowing that it could have been much better.
[56:40] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[56:41] Andrew DeWolf: I kind of am struggling to like hate it because it just feels like a really bland, like nothing show.
[56:49] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[56:49] Andrew DeWolf: Which I don't like, and I wouldn't like actively want to watch this again, but I can't bring myself to hate it. I would have been in the same boat as you, and when I originally brought this in and got us all lined up to do this, I thought we were just gonna meme on it, make a few Harvey Weinstein jokes and make fun of Matthew Morrison, which we didn't really even do this episode. Um honestly, I don't think he deserved it here.
[57:11] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he wasn't the problem with this.
[57:11] Andrew DeWolf: I will say he comes off a little bit more predatory toward the boy boys than any of the other actors, like Jeremy Jordan and everyone else. Um and Julian Evenden. He also looks the part like the least out of everybody since he has like this curly hair.
[57:27] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[57:28] Andrew DeWolf: That just doesn't look anything like what the actual uh Barry looks like. He should have been an American Psycho. I think he would have actually done pretty well in that show.
[57:36] Jesse McAnally: If you say so.
[57:37] Andrew DeWolf: Like I don't know if that show would would have brought him anywhere though.
[57:41] Jesse McAnally: No, but he actually looks a bit like Patrick Bateman and plays like the hey I have no soul behind my eyes kind of look very well. He was on Glee, so um, yeah, I don't think I hated this that much before I listened to what it originally started as, and it obviously was something that someone cared about uh in its initial form, and then it became a product.
[58:04] Jesse McAnally: It can be difficult to hear a show instead of going through new versions and getting like mildly better as it goes, instead just like immediately falling off a cliff and just becoming the worst version of itself.
[58:17] Andrew DeWolf: The nose dive is incredible. Like and I didn't think it had I always thought this was just a product, like a goofy little product, and it's stupid, and this hurts more now, sincerely. Um, but what is our overall thoughts and our cheese ratings? Andrew, why don't you go first?
[58:31] Andrew DeWolf: Um so like it's bad. And I mean, I wouldn't recommend it, but like the music is boring songs, but they're all like listenable. Like none of them feel like oh, this song is like actively hard to listen to. There's a couple. Um, so there's maybe a couple, but mo like the majority of the songs in here are like vapid pop songs that you can kind of sit through. Uh the story is incredibly bland, and the characters are incredibly bland. Overall it's it's like a the musical equivalent of like a a wet blanket, I guess. It's just really fucking boring. Um so I wouldn't recommend it, but if you like it, I guess I understand. Like if you like Peter Pan, you'll probably like this because it's all fan service. The thing is, uh, if you like Peter Pan, you already know this, so you get nothing out of it.
[59:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, that's yeah, that's the other thing though. If you like Peter Pan, why are you watching this when you could be watching like the Peter Pan musical that's like better?
[59:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um as far as a cheese rating goes, I guess I like to fit with the type of rating I'm giving the show, I have to pick something like a boring cheese. And I know I've given shows American cheese before, which is what I think of as like the staple boring cheese, but I feel like this it kind of deserves it.
[1:00:02] Jesse McAnally: So that's fair.
[1:00:03] Brianna Jones: The show itself doesn't sound um great, but this show was great. I mean, hell, we got um Peter Pan Mafia version out of it.
[1:00:15] Andrew DeWolf: So Pinocchio.
[1:00:17] Brianna Jones: Although Peter Peter Pan Mafia would also work, and there's a Chip and Dale game would be called The Lost Boys.
[1:00:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the Chip and Dale already did it though.
[1:00:24] Brianna Jones: Okay, but Pinocchio Mafia version.
[1:00:27] Andrew DeWolf: Bree, can't come in. Can you Google to see that no one else made that joke first?
[1:00:31] Brianna Jones: Yes, let me see.
[1:00:33] Andrew DeWolf: It's not even a joke. I'm d I'm dead serious. I think this would be a great idea. I would watch the shit out of this movie.
[1:00:39] Brianna Jones: Let's see. Hey old Chapetto, where'd you get this boy from?
[1:00:42] Andrew DeWolf: I made it at home, Vinny.
[1:00:43] Brianna Jones: Okay, so I looked up Pinocchio Mafia.
[1:00:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:00:48] Brianna Jones: Um, all I got is stream rubber Nokio by Pinocchio Mafia on SoundCloud.
[1:00:54] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, what's that?
[1:00:56] Brianna Jones: Uh play some of that. I need to hear what that sounds like.
[1:00:59] Andrew DeWolf: I'm afraid.
[1:01:01] Brianna Jones: Hold on. Here, I sent I sent a private chat for you guys.
[1:01:05] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, you found it. Hold on. I'm gonna present.
[1:01:08] Brianna Jones: Bob, you're fired.
[1:01:09] Andrew DeWolf: I am slash am not racist. Is that a song? What the fuck is this?
[1:01:16] Brianna Jones: I honestly I don't know what this is. Did you read the bottom?
[1:01:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. I'm I'm sort of worried the people that made this are like 4chan Nazis, but it's still kind of funny.
[1:01:30] Brianna Jones: The album is dedicated to PepsiCo and Hillary Clinton. Our parents didn't like this album because they are Republicans and members of KKK. Thanks, Dada Schwizzel, little sister for the speech and let them know.
[1:01:42] Andrew DeWolf: I hate the internet.
[1:01:43] Brianna Jones: Is this different from rubber no seem like these guys seem like they're probably uh bad people, but that was funny.
[1:01:50] Andrew DeWolf: It's kinda funny that this album exists. Hold on. I want to know what rubber Nokio sounds like. We're gonna listen to that together.
[1:01:56] Brianna Jones: Get ready to it's just electric music, I think. But where was I going with my cheese writing? Um, I picked um True Du Cure, if I don't trude cra, I don't know how to pronounce it, but it's a stinky cheese and it's bandit Paris, and I feel like this is fitting.
[1:02:13] Jesse McAnally: That's fair.
[1:02:14] Brianna Jones: Um Brie, lovely cheese rating. Lovely digression, because I don't want to think about this show much anymore.
[1:02:21] Andrew DeWolf: I uh finding Neverland's bad. I don't like it. The worst part is I think I might have liked it had they let the original composers do what they were doing. Um however, that being said, I'm gonna give this a crumb of cheese left in the corner of the house for six years, where at one point it was probably edible and pretty good, but right now it's hard, it's gross. There's nothing of value in it. Um but you know what? Try to sell it anyways. Fuck it. Who cares? It's just like a paying public. It's not like they're real human beings. It's not like they're worth anything. It's fine for money. Just siphon out that AIDS donation money and just put it back to this cheese. Put it into this cheese and sell it. Sell it as a product. Get Zendaya to try to sell this cheese. Get Jennifer Lopez to try to sell this cheese. Just keep selling it. Just keep selling until you die and you're in prison because you're a horrible, horrible man.
[1:03:09] Jesse McAnally: Uh one star.
[1:03:12] Brianna Jones: Juliet, may be sure to write that verbatim. Um, all right, guys, that's the end of Finding Neverland. Um, welcome to December. This is how we're starting December, because I think we're gonna switch episodes.
[1:03:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um Different than I told Bree to do it.
[1:03:26] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:03:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.
[1:03:28] Jesse McAnally: So that was great. How'd you like that, Andrew?
[1:03:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I've got uh I've had a an advantageous song stuck in my head because of this show.
[1:03:36] Jesse McAnally: Which one?
[1:03:36] Andrew DeWolf: It's just called Neverland.
[1:03:37] Jesse McAnally: You know who definitely never lands? Peter Pan. Our wonderful patrons, thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher and Musicals with Cheese or on Twitter at Cheesy Meet Skulls, Patreon Musical Sweets, Instagram, Musicals Cheese, YouTube page musicals with cheese. We have Patreon only podcasts called Patreon with Cheese. Our email is musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com go there and tell us how wrong we are if you think we're wrong, because this is your favorite show, and we didn't do the nuances because we didn't jerk you off too much. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Here's some ASMR noises for you, Juliet. How are you doing?
[1:04:14] Brianna Jones: This show is produced by the She did the joke. This show is produced by the Wonderful, the Incredible, the very tired Brianna Jones.
[1:04:23] Jesse McAnally: I love you so much. Thanks for tolerating me. Our theme songs were created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform for not kicking us off for talking mean things about Harvey Weinstein. I don't know. On that note, is there anything else we have left to say before we wrap this on up?
[1:04:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, you guys are cool. Um, and I would definitely steal your childhood and write a story about it.
[1:04:48] Brianna Jones: Oh boy.
[1:04:49] Andrew DeWolf: Um, can we write Gangster Pinocchio first?
[1:04:52] Brianna Jones: Yes.
[1:04:53] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Geppetto, where'd you get that boy.
[1:04:56] Brianna Jones: I'm gonna steal that boy and put him in a show.
[1:05:00] Andrew DeWolf: In the end, in the end, he becomes a real boy, but he's still part of the mafia.
[1:05:04] Brianna Jones: No, he's not want the ending to be he leaves the mafia.
[1:05:07] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, he cannot leave the mafia. He runs the empire.
[1:05:10] Brianna Jones: Yes.
[1:05:10] Andrew DeWolf: The ending is not an ending where he becomes lawful or good. The ending is that he becomes really good at being in the mafia.
[1:05:20] Brianna Jones: Um he fucking blackmails the blue fairy as opposed to like actually learning a lesson.
[1:05:26] Andrew DeWolf: Breaks her lace. I'm gonna break your son's legs through a fairy unless you give me what I want, and what I want is a bak thunk on thunk in my chest.
[1:05:34] Brianna Jones: He he like talks, he is like a heart to heart with uh Geppetto, and Geppetto's like he's like, the blue fairy won't make me he won't make me real, or she won't make me real unless I become a good person. And Geppetto's like, my son, you know what you have to do, and he gives him a gun.
[1:05:51] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry you got caught up in this business, Pinocchio.
[1:05:54] Brianna Jones: I'm sorry that this is where you could.
[1:05:55] Andrew DeWolf: I was thinking you might one day be senator Pinocchio, President Pinocchio was never meant to be you.
[1:06:01] Brianna Jones: Dad, that's just not who I am.
[1:06:03] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't mean for this. You make me proud, but once this information gets out there, they will have you assassinated. And it's your job to see that you get them first, and the person will tell you will be the man that betrayed you. You cannot trust him.
[1:06:17] Brianna Jones: Uh-huh.
[1:06:17] Andrew DeWolf: This is the only version where Geppetto dies.
[1:06:20] Brianna Jones: Um Pinocchio kills Geppetto.
[1:06:22] Andrew DeWolf: Like he turns on him.
[1:06:23] Brianna Jones: Oh, damn, that's so badass.
[1:06:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like, he Pinocchio, like, carves his nose to be a shank, and he's like, tell me, tell me the truth, Pinocchio. Did did you did you rat on me?
[1:06:36] Brianna Jones: No, Papa Geppetto.
[1:06:37] Andrew DeWolf: Stabs right in the chest.
[1:06:40] Brianna Jones: I'm sorry, Pop.
[1:06:41] Andrew DeWolf: No, I want his lie. I want his lie to be that he loves him.
[1:06:44] Brianna Jones: Tell me you love me, son.
[1:06:46] Andrew DeWolf: He says, I love you, and it goes, I love you, Papa. Stabs him.
[1:06:49] Brianna Jones: I lied.
[1:06:52] Andrew DeWolf: This is the worst version of Pinocchio ever.
[1:06:54] Brianna Jones: No, no, already there's no way.
[1:06:56] Andrew DeWolf: There's been too many. We can't be worse than the poly shore one.
[1:07:00] Brianna Jones: Father.
[1:07:01] Andrew DeWolf: Can we be worse?
[1:07:03] Brianna Jones: We can we be worse than the Disney remake where he uh finds horse poop and plays it in.
[1:07:11] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh, it's stinky.
[1:07:17] Brianna Jones: Alright, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:07:17] ♪ Musical number ♪
[1:07:47] Andrew DeWolf: Wanna fucking I wanna f
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
