This week Jess & Andrew head WAY DOWN to CHEESEYTOWN with the incredible returning guest CHRISTI ESTERLE of MUSICAL HELL... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
Featured Shows
About
This week Jess & Andrew head WAY DOWN to CHEESEYTOWN with the incredible returning guest CHRISTI ESTERLE of MUSICAL HELL. They talk about the numerous Tony Awards the show is nominated for, the bombastic energetic music, the wonderful performance by Amber Gray, Patrick Page, and Eva Noblezada, and how the show has changed from its original 2016 New York Theatre Workshop performance.
Links:
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jess McEnally: Today's show is brought to you by Audible.
[0:02] Jess McEnally: Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership.
[0:06] Jess McEnally: Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs.
[0:12] Jess McEnally: Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy.
[0:15] Jess McEnally: Go to Audibletrial.com slash Muschools with Cheese.
[0:20] Jess McEnally: Alright. Also, we have a huge special thanks to our patrons on Patreon, who are John Donna, Stephanie L and Terry Needleman.
[0:29] Jess McEnally: They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese.
[0:34] Jess McEnally: If you would like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks such as patron-only commentaries, our episodes a day early, and tons more, just follow us on Patreon.
[0:43] Jess McEnally: Throw us a couple dollars. Andrew, do you want to talk about our affiliate link?
[0:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, sure. We also have an affiliate link.
[0:49] Andrew DeWolf: Uh so if you want to buy anything on Amazon, you click the link and you can buy whatever you want, and we'll get a cut of it.
[0:55] Andrew DeWolf: Very nice. Doesn't cost you any extra.
[0:58] Jess McEnally: Alright, let's get on to the real show.
[1:04] Jess McEnally: Hello, I'm Jess McEnally.
[1:06] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[1:08] Jess McEnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater more.
[1:12] Jess McEnally: And today we have a returning guest.
[1:15] Jess McEnally: The returning guest. A wonderful friend, a kind person, and one of the most talented musical theater creators out there. It is CHRISTI ESTERLE, aka Musical Hell.
[1:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Hello, hello.
[1:28] Jess McEnally: We're so glad to have you back.
[1:29] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Thank you. It's good to be back.
[1:31] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I like that if they're a returning guest, they don't get the very special guest intro. They get returning guests.
[1:35] Jess McEnally: I'm not special anymore.
[1:38] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Very nice of you, Jess.
[1:39] Jess McEnally: You're fantastic. I think you're special.
[1:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: That's fine.
[1:43] CHRISTI ESTERLE: How are we all doing today? Christy, how are you?
[1:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Doing very well, thank you.
[1:46] Jess McEnally: Right well. And Andrew, how are you?
[1:48] Andrew DeWolf: Is this where I try to come up with a joke referring to the show we watched?
[1:51] Jess McEnally: Exactly.
[1:53] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not sure I got one for this.
[1:54] Jess McEnally: What do you have, Jess?
[1:57] Jess McEnally: There we go. It was that easy. Alright, she's feeling like hell because today we are talking about Hades Town.
[2:22] Jess McEnally: Hades Town, The Myth, the Musical, is a 2016 stage musical adaptation of the 2010 folk opera concept album by the same name by Aeneas Mitchell. It premiered off Broadway at New York Theater Workshop on May 6, 2016, and ran through July 31st, following productions in Edmonton and London.
[2:41] Jess McEnally: Um the show premiered in previews on Broadway in March of 2019. The show of the show was developed for the stage and directed by Rachel Chavkin of Natasha Pierre, the Great Comet of 1812.
[2:53] Jess McEnally: Like the original concept album, Hades Town tells a version of the ancient Greek myth of Orpheus and Eurydice, where Orpheus journeys to the underworld to rescue his fiancée, Eurydice.
[3:03] Jess McEnally: It received generally critical, like positive reviews. Um, from the New York Times described the off-Broadway production as inventive and gorgeously sung. As well, the new Broadway production has gotten even better reviews.
[3:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So, Christy Andrew.
[3:17] Andrew DeWolf: And a metric crap ton of Tony Awards.
[3:20] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yes.
[3:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Tony Award nomination.
[3:22] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry. It hasn't won.
[3:24] CHRISTI ESTERLE: You better get a metric crap ton of awards because I'm still bitter about Great Comet.
[3:29] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Fuck yes. This better make up. Rachel Chavkin deserves her Tony.
[3:33] Andrew DeWolf: I think Dear Evan Hansen should just win again this year.
[3:37] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Bite your tongue.
[3:40] Jess McEnally: So I feel like it's very clear that we're all very positive about this show.
[3:44] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Definitely. I'm a huge fan of uh Greek mythology and, you know, obviously a huge fan of musicals. And I love folk music because it has a lot of the same storytelling elements that draw me to music theater. So this is like, you know, right in my sweet spot of, you know, things that just make me giddy and happy.
[4:03] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I love concept albums. Uh Jess knows that. Concept albums are good. And this is based on a concept album. And I also like the bluesy folk music style as well. Um, and mythology is awesome. So it's like everything is great.
[4:20] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And those who follow me for a long time will know that one of my earliest short films was actually an adaptation of Orpheus and Eurydice. So this story has like that very deep connection to me.
[4:30] Jess McEnally: Of course, it's got something to do with Jess.
[4:33] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Good God.
[4:36] Jess McEnally: Of course it does.
[4:38] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yes. Of course. And as well, like Rachel Chavkin, like watching her grow from Great Comet, like the thing she brought to that show that she also is bringing to this one. She is redesigning what exactly a director does on Broadway stage. She's very inventive.
[4:55] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, she does amazing things with, you know, sets and lighting, and you know, using the cast in various ways, and it's just wonderful to watch. It's an amazing experience.
[5:06] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And currently the show is nominated for 14 Tony's best musical, best performance of an actress, best performance of an actor, best performance of a supporting actress in a featured role. Um, best original score, best book of a musical, best direction of a musical, best choreography, best scenic design, best costume design, best lighting design, best sound design, and best orchestrations.
[5:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Pretty much the only thing it's not nominated for is Reeve Carney as uh best actor in a musical, and yeah, there are people who are pissed off about that.
[5:34] Andrew DeWolf: So how do you feel about that?
[5:37] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I think, you know, I can understand understand why they're unhappy about it because it's got all the awards, but he's getting left out. But at the same time, I kind of get it because I feel like you know, Orpheus is kind of, you know, not the big personality in this musical. I mean, Eurydice, I think, has this great journey, and then you have, you know, Hades and Persephone, who I think are if, you know, I think are the real stars of the show, if you want my honest opinion.
[6:03] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And then, of course, you have Hermes, who is like, you know, your narrator, MC, um, you know, guide character. So they kind of draw the attention a lot more, and those performances obviously will draw a lot more attention.
[6:15] Andrew DeWolf: I agree with you. In fact, I think the most brilliant thing about the adaptation to a different medium is the fact that they took the story away from Orpheus and Eurydice and kind of put the framing device through Persephone and Hades.
[6:28] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, it's kind of this parallel journey between these two couples and seeing them go through um, you know, go through their relationships and how they're similar is really one of the better parts of the show.
[6:41] Andrew DeWolf: Well, what do you think about like the character use in the show?
[6:44] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I don't know much about the Tony nominations, but it looks like everyone got nominated in the whole show. I'm just reading here 14 nominations.
[6:52] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't know. How am I supposed to feel about that, Jess?
[7:00] Jess McEnally: You should feel pretty goddamn good. Best choreography. They definitely did spin a lot.
[7:03] Andrew DeWolf: I liked it. I loved the spinning.
[7:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um Yeah, but they've also got some fantastic stuff. Um I just saw uh where they did Living It Up on Top on Good Morning America, and that had some amazing work in it.
[7:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um Wait for Me, um, which they've expanded from the original um Off Broadway live album. I guess not the original second album. Um they've added some amazing stuff that they're doing with the lighting, which you know looks really good.
[7:30] Andrew DeWolf: So there are definitely some really good um theatrical moments in there.
[7:34] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, they did a great job with it. It deserved probably all of these. I don't know what's competition, so I can't say.
[7:42] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I know Diva is not a fan of Be More Chill.
[7:46] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, definitely. Um the other four uh nominees are what, Tootsie, um, Ain't Too Proud, Beetlejuice, and The Prom.
[7:54] Andrew DeWolf: There is guys because there's one more. So it just gotta be good, right?
[8:00] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's getting uh mixed reviews.
[8:03] Andrew DeWolf: We'll leave it at that.
[8:05] Jess McEnally: I like this.
[8:06] Andrew DeWolf: Jess likes it.
[8:10] Jess McEnally: That's right, one of Jess's first films was Beetlejuice, actually.
[8:13] Andrew DeWolf: So all right, Christy. Give me like the full plot synopsis of this new version of Hades Town.
[8:23] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Just landed on her.
[8:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Okay, you know, this is my wheelhouse, okay. Um, and I'm doing at the source right now, which is also, you know, summarizing musicals pretty succinctly, or you know, source material from musicals. But anyway, basically, um, this is the story of Orpheus and Eurydice, which if you go back to the original myth, Orpheus is this um great musician.
[8:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, in most versions, he's the son of the god Apollo and our or Calliope, who is one of the muses, so he has crazy mad musical talent. Um, he falls in love with Eurydice, um, and Eurydice dies.
[8:58] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, so he goes to the underworld to get her back. And Hades, you know, agrees because he uh Orpheus is such an awesome musician that he, you know, gets everybody to fall in love with him and do what he wants.
[9:09] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So Hades says, okay, you can take her back, but you have to walk all the way back to the world of the living and not look back to see if she's following you.
[9:17] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And depending on um which version you go on, either he, you know, looks back about halfway through because he doesn't trust she's there, or he gets right to the e uh threshold of the gates of hell and then turns around, but she's still behind him, so it doesn't count.
[9:33] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So that's the myth. And um what Aeneas Mitchell has done is she's kind of reframed this in this kind of semi post-apocalyptic Great Depression.
[9:44] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's one of those things that's kind of then and now and every time all at once. And she's reframed the underworld as Hades Town, which is this industrial dystopia ruled over by Hades, who is a robber baron who works all his um people to death building this huge wall around his kingdom.
[10:03] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And Eurydice goes down there because up on Earth, she up on uh top, she's starving and cold, and she wants money and security, and so Orpheus has to go and get her back.
[10:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: That I mean, that's pretty much it. That's pretty much it. Um I should also explain that the reason why it is so cold and miserable up on the surface world is because Hades' wife Persephone, who brings the spring and summer and you know, helps the seasons turn, he's been kind of bringing her back home early because he's jealous and afraid he's gonna she's gonna leave him.
[10:37] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And so, you know, the spring and summer have been being shorter and shorter, and now there's this big famine.
[10:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. There's also trains now.
[10:46] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yes. Uh there's a train that goes between Hades Town and the Surface World, and it's a big motif in the show.
[10:53] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I love it.
[10:57] Andrew DeWolf: Didn't everybody go through that train phase when they were a kid?
[11:01] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, at least boys did.
[11:02] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I think most girls did. A whole Thomas the Tank engine set.
[11:06] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And I would make little short films about trains. Some of my first short films were actually about trains.
[11:12] Andrew DeWolf: My boys were all over Thomas the Tank Engine at preschool.
[11:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So this show really resonated with me.
[11:22] CHRISTI ESTERLE: You know what? Um, I'm sick of your shit, Andrew.
[11:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um we have this framing device of Hermes telling us this through his point of view. And he is so wonderfully played by Andre de Shields as well as in the 26 production by Chris Sullivan, who is also known as Taserface from Guardians of the Galaxy Volume 2.
[11:45] Andrew DeWolf: I did not know that.
[11:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, I learned that today too, and I was like She was Taserface.
[11:50] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Okay, that's pretty incredible. He's also on This Is Us, which is another, like, yeah, he's pretty big.
[11:58] Andrew DeWolf: Why did Taserface not get a music number?
[12:00] CHRISTI ESTERLE: But either way, we both have that framing device and the Fates, which are three ladies that occasionally interrupt in the story and give like the inner monologue and thoughts and reflection of things.
[12:12] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, if I'm gonna give any critique about this show, it would be that it is a little confused at the fates between Hades Hermes and the Fates. Like who is really the framing device of the show?
[12:22] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And I feel like that was much bigger problem in earlier productions, and it has been lessened as it's gone to Broadway.
[12:31] Andrew DeWolf: It's Hermes.
[12:32] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, it kind of makes sense, but you kind of have to have a little mythological background to understand it because Hermes is um, you know, what they call a psychopomp.
[12:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: He's the person who or he's the figure that guides people between the world of the living and the world of the dead. So yeah, he is kind of our messenger guide character between these two worlds.
[12:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And then the fates, you know, obviously were the people who or the figures who set everybody's destiny and could not be gainsayed by anybody, including the gods.
[13:03] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So yeah, they're the ones kind of in the background, you know, kind of whispering in people's ears and kind of pushing them in the direction that destiny leads them.
[13:11] Jess McEnally: That's what I was gonna say.
[13:12] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, you're gonna hear me you're gonna hear me myth geeking out a lot about this. I'm sorry.
[13:16] Jess McEnally: Well, what do you think of Hades?
[13:17] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh what do you think of Hades in this show? Is it accurate? Or is he too much of a villain?
[13:23] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Well, it like a lot of versions, I think Hades gets villainized um in this one quite a bit because again, you know, he is partially, you know, the god of the dead, but at the same time they've reframed him as, you know, this capitalist tycoon who is, you know, building this empire trying to protect, well, specifically, uh, you know, protect his relationship with his wife.
[13:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, and you know, kind of building that building this wall around him to keep him and her safe, and you know, uh driving her away in the long run. Um, so yeah, there he is kind of a bad guy, but he's also pretty well nuanced, I think, for a villain.
[14:02] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um pathetic.
[14:04] Jess McEnally: Yeah, he has a sympathy.
[14:05] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's definitely better than like the Disney version of Hades.
[14:08] Jess McEnally: He's not he's not like a he's not like a hard bad guy like um Disney the Hercules Hades and the Disney version.
[14:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, but he's not like, you know, um in Greek myth, he's probably the most sympathetic of you know the three main gods, which I would say Zeus, Poseidon, and Hades, uh, if for no other reason than the fact that he is not running around trying to stick his dick into anything that moves.
[14:31] Jess McEnally: That is true, which both the Zeus and Poseidon are doing.
[14:34] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Frequently.
[14:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[14:36] CHRISTI ESTERLE: See Percy Jackson.
[14:39] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, they wanted to have sex with Percy Jackson?
[14:42] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I gotta go see this.
[14:45] Andrew DeWolf: Nope.
[14:46] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Out of all the characters, who do we think we relate to the most? Between Hades, Hermes, Orpheus, you were to see Persephone and the Fates.
[14:53] Jess McEnally: Well, you know me, so definitely Hades.
[14:55] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Because you're a capitalist, you're a bit of an asshole, and you get jealous really easily.
[14:59] Andrew DeWolf: I gotcha.
[15:00] Jess McEnally: Yep, absolutely.
[15:01] CHRISTI ESTERLE: You got all you nailed every point.
[15:04] Jess McEnally: What about you, Jess?
[15:05] Jess McEnally: Um, Persephone, I want to be everyone's fun wine aunt.
[15:10] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I gotta go with Persephone too, because um, you know, I think she has I the best perspective of things, you know, understanding that, you know, everything, you know, lives and dies in this cycle, and you know, that things are dark, but things can also get better again.
[15:29] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And yes, because she is the fun wine aunt, and because Amber Gray is the best person in the world.
[15:34] Andrew DeWolf: So And her performance brings a lot to it, like the nuances and like the jazz brows that she adds to like some lines, like sh her physicality alone.
[15:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Like, if they're ever gonna make a biopic about like Eartha Kitt casting.
[15:49] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness, I'll see yes.
[15:51] CHRISTI ESTERLE: She brings an innate sexuality without being sexual, which is another thing about her performance that I really like.
[15:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, definitely.
[15:58] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Orpheus is boring in this.
[16:00] Jess McEnally: Yes, I agree.
[16:02] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And I feel like in other past productions, like the 2016 production, he was less boring.
[16:07] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I just don't think um Reeves Carney is that talented a stage performer.
[16:13] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I think also they've kind of moved him from what I understand from being, you know, kind of this driven artist to being somebody who's kind of a bit more out there mentally.
[16:24] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So he's kind of a bit of a space case, and yeah, it is kind of difficult to, you know, bring a lot of new bring a lot of nuance to that.
[16:33] Andrew DeWolf: He kind of like zones out too, like of the show.
[16:36] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Like he just leaves the show for a bit.
[16:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[16:40] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Like at the beginning.
[16:41] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[16:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I gotta write my song.
[16:43] Andrew DeWolf: He's pulling full Roger.
[16:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Well, he's so focused on this song, um, because he's convinced that this song is going to bring spring back.
[16:51] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And you know, depending on how you interpret the ending, that's more or less what happens. But at the same time, it's one of those things that's like, okay, that's nice, honey, but you know, I'm co cold and hungry right now, so what are you gonna do about it?
[17:03] Andrew DeWolf: You can't write a song and help your girlfriend at the same time.
[17:06] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Apparently he can't.
[17:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I like that though. Like the fact that Orpheus is kind of get dumbed down character-wise, gives a lot of nuance to Eurydice. Where in the original Greek myth, she's kind of a plot device.
[17:19] CHRISTI ESTERLE: She walks into a field, gets bitten by a snake, and is sent to the underworld.
[17:22] Andrew DeWolf: And dies, yes.
[17:23] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, there's also a kind of similarity between um the film Orphe by Jean Cocteau, who you may know did um the version of Beauty and the Beast in the 1950s.
[17:33] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Both films are very fantastic, but in that version, yes, Orpheus is also, you know, this hyper-focused poet who kind of ignores his wife and comes to regret that.
[17:44] Andrew DeWolf: So there's that element going on in there in this one as well.
[17:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Why does uh Eurydice die in this one?
[17:50] Andrew DeWolf: I I didn't quite get that.
[17:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Basically, Hades seduces her, is the long and short of it.
[17:55] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um, she's cold and he's hungry and she's hungry, and she's kind of fed up with Orpheus not, you know, helping her out with that. And then Hades comes by and he sings this magnificent villain song called Hey Little Songbird, which, if you listen to nothing else from this musical, listen to that because Patrick Page and his amazing vape bass voice will rock your world.
[18:18] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And he kind of, you know, offers her this way out, you know, saying that, you know, she would be beautiful, she would shine like a diamond down in the mine, and you know, he could you he could use a girl like her, and basically offers her this opportunity to be, you know, protected and secure, which is, you know, kind of very tempting to her at that point.
[18:39] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And it actually gives her an active role in her own damnation, which is something that would have been an issue for anyone else adapting this material like giving Eurydice an active participation in her own story.
[18:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And I like how, you know, they allow her to make that choice, but then they also have the fates come in and say, Yeah, you can blame her for doing this, but what would you do if you were hungry and starving and desperate?
[19:04] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I mean, you can sit there when you're in your comfortable seats with your full bellies and say, You shouldn't do that, but you what's gonna happen to you when the chips are down?
[19:13] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Both the chips are down is a metaphor, but I also love that it's a sonic device that the Hades uses to simulate the sound of a rattlesnake.
[19:22] Andrew DeWolf: Right.
[19:22] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Which again is a great mythological parallel because it's the rattles of the snake that you know kills Eurydice. And you know, it also has that um Judeo-Christian parallel of the serpent tempting Eve in the garden.
[19:35] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's all very good. It's all very symbolic. This um Anayas Mitchell has done a lot of interesting crossover with um, you know, Greek mythology and American religious motifs.
[19:48] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh you can hear it in uh the second uh version of way down Hades Town after Eurydice in the underworld, and she's kind of realizing this wasn't the best idea, and the fates are saying, yeah, but you're kind of stuck with it, and they kind of twist all these traditional um of African American spiritual imagery, like you know, crossing the river and laying down your burdens and laying his hands on you and things like that.
[20:14] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And it's I think it's a really neat way of you know expressing the divinity of these characters in uh you know, kind of an American folk setting.
[20:23] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I think the setting is one of the strongest parts of this whole show.
[20:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but I have a tr a hard time dealing with it within the connection to the story.
[20:32] Andrew DeWolf: Like I I'm hard finding the connection. I hope one of you can explain that to me, like between Great Depression and Greek mythology.
[20:40] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh, there isn't one.
[20:42] CHRISTI ESTERLE: That's why it's just it's just juxtaposed. Again, uh the time frame I think is very fluid because one of the first things Hermes says in Road to Heli says, don't ask where, don't ask when.
[20:54] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So it's kind of, you know, it's kind of part Great Depression, it's kind of post-apocalypse, so it's you know, in this kind of almost mythological setting.
[21:05] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's like a um, it's like a steampunk kind of idea, basically, where like it doesn't matter what the setting is, it's just it it it exists.
[21:15] Andrew DeWolf: But it doesn't have the pretension of street steampunk, which I appreciate.
[21:19] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Well, that's just because it's not like Victorian, so yeah.
[21:21] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not sure what you would call the 1930s version of steampunk. Would that be like gasoline punk or something?
[21:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I'm not sure.
[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: Cold punk.
[21:31] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Cold punk.
[21:39] Andrew DeWolf: Sorry to interrupt you, but today's show is brought to you by Audible.
[21:43] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership. Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs. Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy. Go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese to get started today.
[22:01] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So this week we are suggesting Orpheus of Greek mythology by James Gardner and narrated by Paul Sperra.
[22:09] Andrew DeWolf: No one knows why we're recommending that.
[22:11] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Completely unrelated. To download your free audiobook today, go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese. Again, that's Audible Trial.com slash musicals with cheese for your free audiobook.
[22:22] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Alright, folks, let's get you back to the show.
[22:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Now on the road to here, there was a railroad game. And there were three old women all dressed the same. And they was always singing in the back of your mind. Everybody meet the fates.
[22:44] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Can we talk about Road to Hell and how that's like such a great introduction into the stuff?
[22:48] Jess McEnally: Oh my goodness. I you know, I love a good opening number, but this uh there are very few where it's like I hear the first few notes and I'm like, oh yeah, I'm into this.
[22:57] CHRISTI ESTERLE: But this one, you got that, you know, amazing jazzy trombone riff that they start off with, and it's like, you know, you're instantly in like this smoky New Orleans club, and I'm like, oh my goodness, this is gonna be fantastic.
[23:09] Jess McEnally: Yes.
[23:11] CHRISTI ESTERLE: No, the trombone makes it. Uh it just immediately I was like, if this is the music for the whole show, this is gonna be amazing.
[23:18] Jess McEnally: So and it was.
[23:21] CHRISTI ESTERLE: You're kind of seeing a lot of parallels to Great Comet's prologue in this, where you have um somebody come up and say, Okay, this is what's happening, and these are all the characters. Everybody give them a hand.
[23:29] Jess McEnally: Which is the right thing to do, especially in like uh piece that is so like involved this. Like, this doesn't have nearly as many characters as Great Comet. Obviously. It is still confusing. You know, even if you do have a grounding in the myth, it kind of helps to kind of reorient you in this new setting that they've put it in.
[23:48] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And introduce you to like the rules like I'm Mr. Hermes, I'm gonna guide you through this, and like Orpheus, you're ready to see this is what they look like.
[23:57] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[23:57] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It is a brilliant way, like to open the show. It it is right up there with tradition and like other almost every other like great opening. It's like, yep, I'm ready for this. Lock me into the roller coaster, let's go.
[24:10] Jess McEnally: Yep.
[24:10] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And again, it's got that fantastic um, you know, folk music storytelling aspect, you know, it's like, you know, once upon a time there was a railroad line, and it just starts, you know, set painting this beautiful picture for you, I guess.
[24:23] Jess McEnally: Not so beautiful because everything is kind of gray and depressing and Great Depression, but you get the idea.
[24:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's jazzy.
[24:29] Jess McEnally: Is ja it is very jazzy.
[24:31] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's it's the good kind of jazz. It's before jazz got super pretentious, you know?
[24:35] Jess McEnally: It's it's that jazz.
[24:36] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It was before Damien Chazelle got his hands on jazz.
[24:39] Andrew DeWolf: You're not gonna go all um, you're not all gonna go all Sebastian and La La Land on me, are you?
[24:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, I mean, that's what I'm talking about. It's before that.
[24:50] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[24:53] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Before white people got involved.
[24:55] Andrew DeWolf: No way.
[24:59] CHRISTI ESTERLE: There's way too many of them.
[25:00] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's like he said, I'm an outdoor girl. Married to the king of the Andrew. Living it up on top. Trying to enjoy myself. Six months out of it.
[25:16] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Let's talk about living it up on top. This is where we're introduced to um Persephone as and in her role as basically the queen of the summertime, and she brings the wine and she brings the party, and you know, everybody's, you know, having fun, and even if they don't have an overabundance, they have just enough of everything, and that's enough.
[25:37] Andrew DeWolf: So they party and have fun.
[25:40] CHRISTI ESTERLE: That shows everyone's relationships with one another. Like I think this is where it's cemented, like in the world. Like how everyone feels about Persephone, how Orpheus feels about Eurydice, how Eurydice feels about everyone else. Like you get the feeling of everyone's relationships here.
[25:55] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And you also get a sense of Orpheus' idealism. Um, you know, how he talks about, you know, we if we share, we will always have enough and to the world we dream about, and you're just trying to imagine things as better than what they are.
[26:09] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So I think it's a great song. It's uh it's pretty catchy, too. And it has Amber Gray singing it, so how can you lose?
[26:15] Andrew DeWolf: Amber Gray can literally sing the phone book at me, and I would...
[26:15] Jess McEnally: Jess has weird fantasies.
[26:21] CHRISTI ESTERLE: She has this amazing rasp to her that doesn't sound like it hurts her to sing, though. Like, even when Eartha Kitt sings, like it sounds like it's hurting her.
[26:30] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Amber Gray sings and it feels like it's bringing elation to her. And she has an innate sexuality about this character. Unlike her character in Great Comet, which is just beaming with sexuality. Like at one point she's like making out with another woman. Like that one is a sexual character, whereas hers is more like naturally sexy in the same way that kind of like a mama rose is sexy.
[26:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, and at the same time, you know, she can feel that she's kind of weighed down and broken with how her relationship with Hades has fallen apart. So there's definitely a lot of nuance to that, which you know, obviously you didn't have with Helene in Great Comet because she was, you know, uh very objectively awful person.
[27:11] CHRISTI ESTERLE: All I've ever known is how to hold my own.
[27:18] CHRISTI ESTERLE: All I've ever known is how to hold my own. But now I wanna hold you. Now I wanna hold you. Hold you close. I don't want to ever have to let you go.
[27:22] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Now I wanna hold what do you think about Eurydice's I Want song that follows it up? And I find the structure of this show so strange.
[27:41] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's a concept album first, right? Did they change the order of anything?
[27:46] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um they added more than they switched around. They have added they have expanded and added and changed around some things, but the basic structure is the same. But yeah, all I've ever known, um, I think is just this, you know, very beautiful folk ballad. Um, and it's got some of I think some of my favorite uh lyrics at the very beginning, um, where and I'm gonna paraphrase this. She says, you know, I was cold so long I didn't even know I was cold. I've been alone so long I didn't even know I was lonely. And you just kind of feel that ache and hollowness in her and how much she wants to believe um that Orpheus could be, you know, uh could be her love and could be uh part of a better life for her.
[28:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: What do you think, Andrew?
[28:29] Andrew DeWolf: Well, in the original Greek myth, Eurydice is a prop. And the fact that they add so much nuance, so much idealism, so much like she is wide-eyed but not stupid. Like, I love what they did with this character, and I'm surprised that they were able to do it without betraying what the original Greek myth was trying to do.
[28:49] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Right.
[28:54] Andrew DeWolf: I think this is um I think this is a lot more about Eurydice's journey than it is about Orpheus', because you know, he he kind of gets takes a beating at the end, but she's the one who kind of, you know, goes through this, you know, transition of being, you know, this hard realist to, you know, being having, you know, being more idealistic but still practical to being disillusioned and then just kind of broken.
[29:19] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like adding a lot more character to her makes the ending a lot sadder. And uh it's not just because for Orpheus either, because now it's now she's she's the one that gets the real punishment.
[29:33] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Bring me home to Hades Town.
[29:35] Andrew DeWolf: We're down Hades Town, way down under the ground.
[29:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Let's move on to way down Hades Town, which is so fun, but also so sad. I love this song.
[29:47] Andrew DeWolf: This is a ton of fun. It's so dark because this is um officially our introduction to Hades. Like he leers over the entire show, but this is where he finally enters, and like the entrance where she's like, You're early, and he's like, I missed you.
[30:00] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Oh my god, just shows the relationship between these two with only one word with one statement each.
[30:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and it's you know, Patrick Page, you know, he's got three words, but he he invests them, you know, with so much um, you know, passion and at the same time kind of this creepy possessiveness, and you're like automatically, okay, that's the character right there.
[30:24] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Everybody looked and everybody saw it with the same man they've been singing about.
[30:30] Andrew DeWolf: You're early.
[30:32] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I missed you.
[30:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's perfect.
[30:36] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It is.
[30:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Patrick Page is a stand-up guy, uh seeming to be a wonderful human being and a fantastic performer.
[30:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And the first I heard of him was Spider-Man, and then like he wasn't really given the chance to like get his muscles like to stretch. Then you see him as Frollo, and it's like, oh, oh my gosh, like show me more, sir.
[30:58] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah. Fantastic.
[31:01] CHRISTI ESTERLE: He's come a long way from playing piano on a rooftop.
[31:06] Andrew DeWolf: That he has.
[31:07] CHRISTI ESTERLE: But yeah, if anyone out there has not listened to um the studio cast of Disney's Hunchback in Notre Dame, you've got to do that because um, you know, we all love Tony J as Frollo, but Patrick Page is just all that in a bag of chips.
[31:21] Andrew DeWolf: Patrick Page is probably the better Frollo because at least he could hit notes.
[31:26] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh may you rest in peace, Tony J.
[31:31] CHRISTI ESTERLE: But the other thing I really like about this that is added in the more recent productions is the connection between Hades and Eurydice to set up like the conflict that they will have later on in the story.
[31:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he c they kind of have this moment where they look at each other before um Hermes, you know, uh blows the whistle and yells all aboard, and you're kind of like, okay, this is gonna get this is not gonna lead anywhere good.
[31:55] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Whereas he's just kind of using her as a tool to make Persephone jealous, or at least kind of find a tool to like get her like down there as a replacement, maybe.
[32:06] Andrew DeWolf: Right. It's hard to quite know exactly why he's after Eurydice.
[32:10] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I think he, you know, I think he, you know, he's he's so desperate to find somebody impressed by this empire that he's built that he, you know, goes looking for somebody who, in his own words, can appreciate a gilded cage.
[32:23] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And then he finds somebody who is, you know, cold and desperate and you know, ready to make a deal with the devil in, you know, both a literal literal and figurative sense, and he's like, ah.
[32:35] CHRISTI ESTERLE: He even calls her a songbird, which we keep in cages.
[32:38] Andrew DeWolf: And he uh calls her a canary in the in a mine, which is a really creepy metaphor if you understand what canaries in mines were used for.
[32:46] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh when they die, you leave the mine.
[32:48] Andrew DeWolf: Essentially, yeah, they were there to they were there to um be the first warning if the gases got too bad.
[32:55] CHRISTI ESTERLE: What if my uh one of my first canaries died in a mine, so I have a real attachment to this show.
[33:00] Andrew DeWolf: Did you make did you make a short film about it?
[33:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Wait for me.
[33:11] Andrew DeWolf: I'm coming to um college.
[33:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Alright, let's talk about Wait for Me, which is basically the theme of the entire story.
[33:22] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I like this song a lot too.
[33:26] Andrew DeWolf: Is there a bad song in the entire show? Just out of curiosity.
[33:29] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I'm not a very huge fan of flowers, but um it's a very solid score all the way around.
[33:34] Andrew DeWolf: I think this is songs that are definitely like filler songs, I would say.
[33:38] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I don't know. When you have such a tight studio album, like that is an issue that might pop up.
[33:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[33:45] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah.
[33:46] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think there's anything that I would say is bad.
[33:48] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I've heard some people say that this has been stretched out too much, um, that it could easily be a one-act show, and I can kind of see that in some places, but I absolutely love the way they expanded um Wait for Me from the original um and gives, you know, Orpheus this additional um conclusion, you know, where he says, I'm not alone, I can hear the rocks singing to me, and that's where we get, you know, like the fantastic um choreography and lighting with the lamps swinging around, and it makes for a really good effect there.
[34:20] Andrew DeWolf: So yeah, you can argue about um the editions pretty much anywhere else, but that's a great one.
[34:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Why do we mail the wall?
[34:27] Andrew DeWolf: We bail the wall to keep us free.
[34:31] CHRISTI ESTERLE: We mail the wall.
[34:33] Andrew DeWolf: We mail the wall to keep us free.
[34:37] CHRISTI ESTERLE: How does the wall keep us free?
[34:40] Andrew DeWolf: My children.
[34:42] CHRISTI ESTERLE: My children, how does the wall keep us free?
[34:49] Andrew DeWolf: I guess we should probably talk about why we build the wall.
[34:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yes, I was gonna say we're gonna get to the Act One finale here, why we build the wall.
[34:56] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And um, this is one thing that I think we should restate, um, even though even though I think it's been said several times. This was written in 2001. So, you know, you can't you hear some you hear like this big tycoon talking about building a wall to keep out the enemy for freedom and you know keep away poverty, and that draws some obvious parallels in our current climate, but you know, it's kind of something that kind of happened after the fact.
[35:22] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like uh if it was written for that, it would probably somewhat lessen the impact, because then it's just a purely political statement, but it obviously is not, so it's not uh that is not the case.
[35:34] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, uh she kind of meant it in a more general sense of you know, the walls we built to you know keep keep other people out and you know, kind of protect our little kingdoms all around us.
[35:47] Andrew DeWolf: So it's kind of more of an emotional wall than a literal wall.
[35:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yes, especially in the case of Hades, I think, where he's building it to keep in the person he loves, basically, not really to keep things out, I don't think.
[36:01] Andrew DeWolf: So it it's not really a good parallel, but if you just listen to it on a very basic level, then yes, Donald Trump exists.
[36:09] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Donald Trump's trying to keep Melania from escaping, so he's gonna build the wall.
[36:13] Andrew DeWolf: You know, I would I wouldn't be surprised, but Hades am Hades is a much more sympathetic character than that.
[36:19] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So that is true.
[36:21] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Hades is in a buffoon.
[36:23] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Well, yeah.
[36:24] Andrew DeWolf: That's what I said initially.
[36:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah.
[36:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he's a lot smart, he's a lot smarter as well.
[36:29] CHRISTI ESTERLE: He's uh probably a better businessman as well.
[36:31] Andrew DeWolf: Pretty much.
[36:32] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Has Hades Town ever gone bankrupt?
[36:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh as far as we know, no.
[36:37] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Has it ever been sued when he tried Hades University?
[36:43] Andrew DeWolf: He doesn't need his a he doesn't need his stakes um well done with ketchup either.
[36:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Oh well done with ketchup.
[36:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.
[36:52] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I got sunshine up on the shelf.
[36:56] Andrew DeWolf: Allow me to introduce Master.
[36:59] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Brother, what's my name?
[37:02] Andrew DeWolf: My name is I Lady of Brother Latin.
[37:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So can we talk about Our Lady of the Underground and how it is like one of the best Act Two openings ever?
[37:13] Andrew DeWolf: We can.
[37:14] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Again, Amber Gray is all things beautiful. And um again, I love, you know, how she kind of opens this up with, I don't know about you. I can't do it, but you know, she has no bra.
[37:26] Andrew DeWolf: I I can I cannot do it.
[37:28] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I don't know about you boys!
[37:30] Andrew DeWolf: There you go, that's it.
[37:32] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And she just go comes in, already sounding like at least two sheets to the wind. Um, but in a very good way, and it's just a great way um introduction.
[37:42] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I don't know about you boys. And again, I like that they've kind of adapted the Catholic Our Lady for this um Greek mythical character.
[37:51] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And also, I talk about musical theater structure way too much on this goddamn podcast.
[37:56] Andrew DeWolf: Stop it.
[37:57] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um musical theater by nature, the first song in act two, basically shouldn't have anything to do with the plot, shouldn't push the story forward. Is a time when everyone should be sitting the hell down and fun, basically.
[38:12] Andrew DeWolf: Like Hamilton makes a joke out of this by turning into like, what did I miss? Which is what every audience member asks as soon as they sit down.
[38:20] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So this one is the perfect one where it is both fun, character building, and you don't really miss a ton if you like miss the song, but you're missing a lot of fun if you do.
[38:31] Andrew DeWolf: Not missing the plot, but you're missing the names of the side.
[38:34] CHRISTI ESTERLE: All the people that forgot to take poops are missing this song.
[38:37] Andrew DeWolf: You take them before the show, not in the middle.
[38:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Bio musical was with cheese uh theater going kit. It includes uh laxatives that you can use right before.
[38:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[38:49] CHRISTI ESTERLE: But yeah, I love how she has the speak as he only instead of you know, like a legal boost, she's kind of bringing in, you know, like the things from nature the sun and the rain and the sky and moon sh and literal moonshine as in the light of the moon.
[39:05] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I think that's a neat way of um reinterpreting that because that's what the people in the underworld want need and want the most.
[39:12] Andrew DeWolf: And there's also a reference to pay-per-view, which is a little weird, but also adds to like the don't don't matter what time it takes place in.
[39:19] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, there's also that little element of you know, kind of the s kind of almost like a little peep show that she's got going on, as you know, gross as that sounds.
[39:30] Andrew DeWolf: But yeah, she you know tells them about look look into the crack in the wall to you know, see the moon and the sky, and it you know, it's kind of almost got this racy element to it.
[39:43] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Moonshine is just rebranded sunshine, it's just a corporate scheme.
[39:50] Andrew DeWolf: It's r it's racy without being vulgar, which is very good to ride.
[39:56] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh exactly. See, this act two is where I feel a lot of like that inflation of the story come into p play. Like in act one, it's like, okay, we need to build up these characters. But here it really like the conflict Orpheus is feeling is really difficult to feel emotionally connected to.
[40:14] CHRISTI ESTERLE: How many reprises do we have in the second part here?
[40:17] Andrew DeWolf: A lot.
[40:18] CHRISTI ESTERLE: But there's some things like the chant reprise, which I really love. And also, um, you know, the ul final reprise of Epic, which brings things full circle because that is the song that Orpheus is working on. Um, and you know, he presents it in its um a more or less completed form to Hades. And um And Hades sues him for uh stealing his intellectual property.
[40:42] Andrew DeWolf: Not exactly.
[40:44] CHRISTI ESTERLE: He could have. Eurydice sues him for writing a story too close to reality. And he has to change the song if I I could be in love with someone like you to Shook's a goddess, and it's a mess. It's a big mess.
[41:01] Andrew DeWolf: Where did you get that melody?
[41:03] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I really like the relationship that Hades has with Orpheus in the very few scenes they have together. I love the parallel between the two characters because these are ultimately two guys who um have their um wit who have the women in their lives telling them, This is what I need from you, and they are, you know, off doing something else.
[41:23] Andrew DeWolf: Completely that's pushing them away.
[41:26] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I think that, like, let's say that Hades and Persephone weren't there in the show, and it was just an Orpheus and Eurydice straight story. It doesn't work. You have to have that reflecting couple. Like, it's so strange that in a story that tells the Orpheus and Eurydice story, they are the secondary couple. They are the eight-ole Annie. Essentially, um, but yeah, I think, you know, you have, you know, the younger, innocent couple, and then you kind of have the older, more cynical couple and how they um react to each other and you know, reflect each other's circumstances, I think is really where the heart of the story is.
[42:01] Andrew DeWolf: And it's also kind of like a mirror image of what they could be, like what Orpheus and Eurydice might become if they don't figure their shit out.
[42:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, it's and that's almost explicitly stated in um the bargain that Hades offers them because he, you know, you know, he expects um Orpheus to give in to doubt and mistrust and fear because those are Hades' own um weaknesses. That's what he has been fighting this whole time is the doubt and mistrust and the fear that Persephone is not going to be there when he turns around.
[42:34] Andrew DeWolf: Which Orpheus eventually proves true.
[42:36] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Why did he turn around?
[42:38] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. The bargain doesn't make a huge amount of sense. There's no upside to turning around.
[42:44] CHRISTI ESTERLE: You could just walk the whole way and then wait and then turn around and how long is that walk though?
[42:49] Andrew DeWolf: If it's three days, like it's a very long walk. That would just be difficult in a uh like how do I physically prevent myself from turning around kind of way.
[43:02] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, you're kind of getting you're kind of getting into what happens if she needs to stop or I need to stop. Do we kind of signal each other? Does she throw a rock at the back of my head?
[43:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what are we doing here? Like my first question is can I communicate with her? Can I be like, hey, Eurydice? Three feet, right? And she's like, Yes. Are you still there? Yes.
[43:25] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah. Communication is important in a relationship. Again, Orpheus is a bit of a space case, so I think I can see where he would not be asking the important question.
[43:37] Andrew DeWolf: Or can she like put his hand her hands on his shoulders?
[43:40] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, they they do the cha-cha-cha all the way up the Aga again. I don't think they're supposed to, but again, it is not specifically stated.
[43:49] Andrew DeWolf: And that's one of those things you have to keep in mind when you're making these kind of bargains. You have to be very literal about it. It's like, okay, I can't look at her, but you know, maybe I can have this rope that we can tug on each other, or we can say talk, or I allow to have a speaker with the channel.
[44:05] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, can she stomp her feet really loud? And like, does he accidentally turn around at the end in like see her before she got all the way up? Is that what happened? Or did he actually turn around because he was doubting it?
[44:17] Andrew DeWolf: I think, you know, at I think it kind of goes with the version where he gets to the thr the threshold of the living world, and then you know, he can't wait another second and turns around, but she's they're not all the way out yet.
[44:31] CHRISTI ESTERLE: So why would he do that?
[44:33] Andrew DeWolf: Because he Because he's jumping the gun on it. He's a dumb.
[44:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: That really counts?
[44:42] Andrew DeWolf: Like apparently. He made it all the way to the top. Like, what that doesn't count.
[44:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I'm not gonna lie. Another issue I have with this is the fact that since we spend so much time in Hades Town, and it is just kind of like weird, like not quite post-apocalyptic, like just town. It's hard to like be like, oh, I'm so sad to see her go back to that change where Persephone comes and we'll probably take care of her.
[45:07] Andrew DeWolf: Why doesn't Orpheus just go back to? I mean There's not. Is there a rule against that?
[45:12] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Um I think you know, he's he probably wouldn't last 30 seconds there, let's be honest. In the original Greek myth, you know, he kind of falls into this depression after you know he loses Eurydice for the second time, and he eventually gets torn apart by um some women who are followers of Dionysus who are you know drunk and crazy.
[45:32] Andrew DeWolf: Dionysus is pretty cool. Like if he Andrew took the Greek god test, like he would be Dionysus. I can see it right now.
[45:38] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I'm not sure if this translates well, but in the original Greek myth, he had to like play his loot all the way out of there as well. I think he might have had to do that. He also had to play his loot all the way down because that was pretty much the only way he was getting through, because um that was how um, you know, Cerberus um, you know, kind of lays down and lets him pass, and how um Caron, you know, lets him on the boat, and um, you know, all the you know, gateways and guards of the underworld just kind of let him pass. And that's hand-waved away in this musical.
[46:10] Andrew DeWolf: They just let me go. How come Chiron wasn't wasn't the uh or Karen or however it's pronounced? Why was he enough the conductor of the train?
[46:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It probably would have been an extra character that the musical didn't need, but I think that's my personal headcanon. Now he's the engineer.
[46:22] Andrew DeWolf: Now, how do we all think about the ending? Because it is bittersweet but also triumphant in a way.
[46:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It is. Um I like to think that um, you know, Orpheus did kind of, you know, do what he set out to do in bringing back the spring and kind of restored the natural order by kind of getting um Hades and Persephone to give their relationship another shot and you know, not keep dragging her down to the underworld at the first opportunity.
[46:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but at the same time, he doesn't get his happy ending. I like that they start singing the the opening song again. I also I know this is like uh calling back to like the beginning again, and that's probably not good for structure-wise. But another thing I really like is how they kind of play with your expectations with that opening number.
[47:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And it's like instead of saying it's a sad song, like it's a song about it, like there's a rhyme that sets it up for you to think that it's like gonna rhyme with dies, but instead they change it to tries.
[47:08] Andrew DeWolf: Right.
[47:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It's a song about s story about someone who tries, which sets up this ending very, very, very well.
[47:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[47:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And it also, you know, comes back full circle, um, where he says, you know, we tell the story as if it might come out this time, which I think, you know, is kind of the function of the story, is kind of like saying, okay, you know, this is a sad story, um, but we can learn from it, and we can try again, and we can hopefully not make the keep not make not keep making these same mistakes.
[47:51] Andrew DeWolf: Learn from the past as opposed to repeating.
[47:53] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Exactly. Now, who gets the worst tragedy? Orpheus or Eurydice at the end.
[47:57] Andrew DeWolf: Eurydice.
[47:58] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Really?
[47:59] Andrew DeWolf: It depends how bad Hades Town is.
[48:01] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Well, yeah, well, I guess that is true. And if it does get better um after um Orpheus leaves, which, you know, is a possibility, but she gets scre she gets screwed over because he cut he messed up so it's all right.
[48:15] Andrew DeWolf: Well, she messed up first.
[48:16] CHRISTI ESTERLE: She did mess up first, to be yeah, too.
[48:18] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that is true.
[48:19] CHRISTI ESTERLE: That is true.
[48:21] Andrew DeWolf: So yeah, it's probably kind of not to point fingers. It's probably kind of a wash between them, then.
[48:27] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah.
[48:27] Andrew DeWolf: But as they said, he's someone who tries.
[48:30] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I tried, you're in the sea.
[48:33] Andrew DeWolf: Should have tried harder.
[48:35] CHRISTI ESTERLE: One job, Orpheus.
[48:39] Andrew DeWolf: Blindfold, that's what I'm saying. Blinded yourself, Oedipist or style. Bird box your way out of there, bitch.
[49:00] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Guys, we're reaching the end of the show. What is your overall thoughts on Hades Town? Christy, you go first.
[49:05] CHRISTI ESTERLE: It is the best musical of the season, and I will riot if it does not win the Tony.
[49:10] Andrew DeWolf: People think that Tootsie's the front runner, though.
[49:12] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I've heard the pizza rule?
[49:15] Andrew DeWolf: No, as in like the 80s comedy with Dustin Hoffman where he dresses like a girl. I've heard people say Tootsie is the front runner. I've heard people say this is the front runner. I've heard people say the prom is the front runner. But honestly, I think this is the best musical of the year.
[49:27] Andrew DeWolf: So Andrew, what are your thoughts?
[49:29] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was very good. And I would really recommend it. I don't know the other shows of the season, so I can't say if it's the best one or not, but I liked it a lot.
[49:44] CHRISTI ESTERLE: How's it compared to the other things I've made you watch on this show?
[49:48] Andrew DeWolf: It's in the it's definitely in the top top five. And don't make me list five because I'm not gonna be able to. But it's definitely in the top five.
[49:56] CHRISTI ESTERLE: We're pushing 50 episodes now, so.
[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: I know. I can't believe I've watched so many musicals.
[50:03] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And there are so many more to watch.
[50:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, there is.
[50:06] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, there is.
[50:10] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, what is your cheese rating?
[50:13] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I'm gonna give it a feta cheese.
[50:16] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Why?
[50:17] Andrew DeWolf: Because it's a good Greek cheese.
[50:19] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Okay, what about you, Christy?
[50:21] CHRISTI ESTERLE: I swear to God, I was going to rate it feta cheese too, because obviously it's Greek. It's got this, you know, kind of good um homey feel to it. And you know, there are probably a few people who are probably not who are probably gonna find it, you know, too strong for their tastes, but I find it very excellent and uh good food.
[50:41] Andrew DeWolf: So well, mine is so main train because it has the word train in it.
[50:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Jesus Christ, Jess. You could have picked something for like New Orleans or something like that. To like counter the Greek cheese we did, but instead you just pick one that has train in the name.
[51:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, it's got a train in it.
[51:08] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Can you believe this guy? Like for real.
[51:11] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you know what I think about that, Andrew.
[51:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: You're about to shill.
[51:16] Andrew DeWolf: He's about to shill.
[51:17] Andrew DeWolf: Guys. Shill away.
[51:20] Andrew DeWolf: I think that today's show is brought to you by Audible. Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership. Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmeshed selection of audio programs. Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy. Go to Audible Trial.com slash musicals with cheese.
[51:41] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Christy, I'm so glad you came on. I'm sure you've got a lot of things you want to promote, so go ahead and promote them.
[51:47] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Uh, main thing is musicalhell.com where you can find all my videos. Uh, you can also look up musical hell on YouTube. I do my reviews of terrible musicals, and I also do uh know the score and at the source, which are some kind of slightly less deep dives on better musicals.
[52:03] Andrew DeWolf: I love that show. I highly recommend it. It's good watching.
[52:05] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Thank you for coming on again.
[52:07] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Yeah, it's okay. Thank you for having me. Love being here.
[52:10] Andrew DeWolf: What did we talk about the first time?
[52:11] CHRISTI ESTERLE: We we talked about uh Shazam musical, right?
[52:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[52:15] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Shazam the musical. I brought up chocolate cheese, and y'all both looked at me like I was a fucking idiot.
[52:23] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, right. And now you bring up the train cheese that no one's ever heard of, Jess.
[52:29] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Well, Andrew has tried chocolate cheese since then.
[52:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah. If you wanted a conclusion on that, it tastes like fudge. That's about it.
[52:39] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Okay. If you were waiting on the edge of your seat for that.
[52:43] Andrew DeWolf: Either way, thank you guys for listening. We are on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. Our Twitter is at Cheesy Musical. Support us on Patreon at Musicals with Cheese. Our Instagram is also Musicals with Cheese, as well as our YouTube page. Send us an email at musical theaterlibs at gmail.com. Tell us whether you love us, hate us, all the above. Our title card is created by Jolene Casco. Follow her on Instagram at Jolene Casco.
[53:09] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Anything else you guys want to say before we wrap this on up?
[53:12] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you and have a good evening.
[53:13] CHRISTI ESTERLE: Thank you and have a good morning.
[53:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, if you're listening to this in the morning instead of it. Whatever time of day you're listening to, and have a good one.
[53:20] CHRISTI ESTERLE: And have a great afternoon.
[53:21] Andrew DeWolf: And in case I don't see you.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
