The Dear Friends are back with you and ready to talk our TOP FIVE FAVORITE STEPHEN SCHWARTZ MUSICALS! What will take the top spot, Wicked? Children of Eden!? You'll have to listen to find out!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Featured Shows
About
The Dear Friends are back with you and ready to talk our TOP FIVE FAVORITE STEPHEN SCHWARTZ MUSICALS! What will take the top spot, Wicked? Children of Eden!? You'll have to listen to find out!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jess: Without further adieu, the Dear Friends Podcast.
[0:04] Jess: Dear friends, spill your woes to your musical family.
[0:09] Jess: Dear friends.
[0:11] Jess: They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom.
[0:18] Jess: And an awful ice cynical world.
[0:22] Jess: Dear friends.
[0:26] Emily: Hi, I'm dear friend Emily.
[0:28] Christy: I'm dear friend Christy.
[0:31] Jess: And I'm dearest friend Jess, and welcome to Dear Friends, the Ride-In Advice Podcast for the Musical Minded.
[0:37] Jess: Hello, my dears, my dear dear friends.
[0:39] Christy: Oh my goodness.
[0:40] Jess: I love you both very, very much.
[0:42] Christy: I love you too.
[0:44] Jess: I don't know why, but I'm in a very, very cozy vibe today.
[0:48] Jess: It might have something to do with the question that we got written in by someone with a doctorate.
[0:52] Jess: Um this is one Dr. Dillamond who writes in asking, um, what are your favorite Stephen Schwartz musicals?
[1:00] Christy: Oh, should we are we gonna rate them?
[1:02] Jess: Like, do we have a rating system?
[1:04] Jess: This will be our top five Stephen Schwartz musicals.
[1:07] Emily: Well that's gonna be interesting, because I'm gonna have I may have some controversial rankings here.
[1:12] Emily: I'm Geppetto number one.
[1:15] Emily: Um is the Geppetto or My Son Pinocchio the stage version?
[1:20] Jess: I guess it depends, you know, it's Geppetto in the movie, but um Oh, Drew Carey all the way.
[1:25] Christy: Come on.
[1:25] Emily: Oh, yeah.
[1:26] Christy: Yeah, we gotta have the Wayne Brady and all that.
[1:30] Emily: Oh, come on, got Usher doing like a second rate magic to do.
[1:33] Emily: It's fantastic.
[1:34] Christy: I kind of like it though.
[1:36] Christy: I'm not gonna lie, I kind of like the Usher in that movie.
[1:39] Emily: Yeah.
[1:39] Christy: He's one of the better parts of that movie.
[1:40] Jess: I think do all three of us have videos or episodes about Geppetto?
[1:44] Emily: I think we do.
[1:46] Emily: I know I know Emily and Christy, you do.
[1:48] Jess: I've been saving that one.
[1:49] Jess: That's that's that's what I'm building up.
[1:52] Jess: Yeah.
[1:52] Emily: Um, all right, Emily, why don't you start with your number five?
[1:56] Emily: What's your number five, Stephen Schwartz musical?
[1:59] Emily: Okay. Um number five Stephen Schwartz musical is Godspell.
[2:06] Emily: And um, I you know, I never really knew Godspell growing up.
[2:11] Emily: I wasn't like a church kid.
[2:12] Emily: Um, I know it's big for like community church theater.
[2:15] Emily: Um, I only knew like day by day, really.
[2:17] Emily: Um, and then I had to music direct um a high school production, maybe I don't know, maybe seven or eight years ago.
[2:25] Emily: And I really got to know the score because they were doing the revival version, which is incredibly difficult.
[2:31] Emily: And I had I had to do a lot of work paring it down for high schoolers.
[2:35] Emily: Um, but I remember being like, this is good.
[2:38] Emily: This is good music.
[2:39] Emily: Like I really like these songs.
[2:41] Emily: I really like the flexibility of the show that you can kind of make it your own um and shape it to the cast that you have and the performers that you have and their skill set.
[2:52] Emily: I can't think of very many big musicals that do that.
[2:55] Emily: And um, I love that you can do it anywhere.
[2:58] Emily: You could do it in a black box, you could do it outside, you could do it in a Broadway house.
[3:02] Emily: Um, and I just think I think it's just kind of good.
[3:04] Emily: Has that nice, like kind of 70s vibe, um, 70s pop music vibe.
[3:09] Emily: Uh and yeah, I I just really like it a lot.
[3:12] Emily: It took me a while to get into it, and now that I know it and I know a lot of these songs, I'm like, this is a really good show.
[3:17] Emily: Um, yeah.
[3:18] Emily: My husband apparently did it back in the day too.
[3:20] Jess: Oh, I would kill to see footage of that.
[3:22] Emily: Yeah.
[3:23] Emily: There's pictures of him.
[3:24] Emily: I'm pretty sure he was Jesus.
[3:26] Jess: Oh, that's perfect.
[3:27] Emily: Yeah, yeah.
[3:28] Emily: Yeah, I can see him doing that.
[3:29] Jess: Totally, totally.
[3:30] Emily: Uh, but yeah, Godspell, number five for me.
[3:32] Jess: Heck yeah.
[3:33] Christy, what about you?
[3:34] Christy: What's your number five?
[3:35] Christy: Okay, I am probably going to get uh crap for ranking it this low, but Wicked.
[3:40] Jess: That's fine.
[3:41] Christy: I would never give you crap for that.
[3:42] Christy: Other people might because you know it's it's a really good gateway show.
[3:46] Christy: I mean, obviously that was, you know, the millennial early Gen Z.
[3:50] Christy: That was what they saw in the theaters and said, Yes, this is awesome.
[3:54] Christy: I want more of this.
[3:55] Christy: And obviously, it's fantastic for that.
[3:57] Christy: And it's got some really catchy stuff.
[3:59] Christy: I think you know, Defying Gravity is, you know, one of those, you know, great uh Act One closers.
[4:05] Christy: Um it would work in a film version that would be nice and long.
[4:11] Jess: Yes, in the actual full film, yeah, in an actual full form version, it would be a good closer for a it would be a good, you know, high point for about the middle of the film.
[4:20] Christy: I'm not sure you could end a film with it and then continue the story in a sequel.
[4:25] Jess: I know I know.
[4:26] Christy: Watch this movie like make it break so many records though.
[4:29] Christy: But like I think the first one will do obscenely well, and then the second one will just lose a lot of good faith.
[4:35] Jess: Yeah, yeah.
[4:37] Christy: It's you know, um, but yeah, it's uh down this low.
[4:41] Christy: Um, mostly because, you know, the if the lyrical work on it is interesting in places.
[4:48] Christy: No, I definitely have some weird rhymes and some weirdly around of words how people normally speak in order to make a rhyme work.
[4:59] Emily: Yeah.
[4:59] Christy: Yeah, it's you know, I kind of get that they're kind of doing this kind of weird Oz vocabulary slang, and that's fine.
[5:05] Christy: And some of it works, but then there's some of it like disgusted defied, and I'm like, okay, you know, I'm I I'm not sure what that would actually mean.
[5:13] Christy: Like definition, I like that because it's like, yeah, certainly, almost maybe.
[5:18] Christy: I I kind of like that, but there's some of it like swankified and swankified.
[5:24] Jess: Yeah, that's well, maybe.
[5:26] Christy: Yeah, it's that kind of pseudo the pseudo buffy speak that you know sometimes works, sometimes doesn't, and then it's there's sometimes it's like you know, like, okay, it's obvious you just did said terrible green blizzard because you were running it, you didn't have too many things to win.
[5:41] Emily: I thought it was Green Lizard for the longest time because I was like, lizards are green.
[5:46] Christy: Yeah, so this makes sense, but it's like I don't know, it's odds maybe lizards fly there.
[5:52] Christy: I will say there is one line that a lot of people crap on, and I don't think that deserves it.
[5:57] Christy: And it's there are bridges you don't know you've crossed, there are bridges you've crossed you don't know you've crossed until you've crossed.
[6:02] Christy: I think you know that it's Diana, the the people who will change the world are not the ones you think you'll change the world.
[6:08] Christy: Well, it's it's one of those things, it's like, yeah, it sounds kind of weird, but at the same time, I can see you know, Glinda, who is not used to having you know complex thoughts and feelings about things.
[6:19] Christy: I can see her trying to, you know, phrase it in that way.
[6:22] Jess: So yeah, that works for me.
[6:24] Christy: So yeah, that is an argument for character, but then you've got uh Nessa, uh Nessa, I have something.
[6:29] Christy: I have something to confess, yeah.
[6:32] Christy: That was yeah, I have no way it's too confess uh some things on a reason why but yeah, like confess uh yeah, it that's it it is very tricky to you know do those rhymes over a phrase or you know, even over a word, which he does a couple of times.
[6:48] Christy: Um like your ascent allows me to feel so parental, things like that.
[6:53] Christy: And you know, again, sometimes sometimes it's just like what did you do there?
[6:57] Jess: What are you doing?
[6:59] Christy: What are you doing?
[6:59] Christy: So yeah, it's a it's a great gateway show.
[7:02] Christy: I love that it sparked so many people's love for music theater.
[7:05] Christy: I'm not entirely sure if they're gonna pull off this two movie thing, but there you have it.
[7:11] Emily: Um I agree because my number five is also Wicked.
[7:13] Emily: Um, okay.
[7:15] Emily: Wicked is once again, everything that you said, uh, but there are moments that we're like when it's live and you're watching it live, it's great.
[7:23] Emily: But I know that we talk a lot about community theater.
[7:26] Emily: I think that one of the reasons why this hasn't been given a theater license is because almost all of the magic will be gone from this as soon as like anyone else plays it outside of that, I think.
[7:36] Emily: When it has to stand on just the book and the lyrics on its own, it's gonna be really interesting.
[7:41] Christy: Well, book lyrics, and you do need to have two, you know, top-tier uh female leads, which is another good thing because there's not many, there's you know, not a whole lot of musicals that require that.
[7:52] Emily: Yeah, I I agree, but I just am imagining like I know Emily talks about this on her TikTok a lot, but those TikTok compilations of cringe brought are like student performances, and it it's I I can see those coming out where it's just like a mashup of like the Courtney Take Your Break from Legally Blonde of the Bad.
[8:12] Christy: I mean, frankly, I would love to have a Wicked Junior because every year I have students say, Let's do Wicked, and I go, We can't.
[8:20] Jess: Right, right.
[8:21] Christy: After you know, that show came out on Broadway in 03.
[8:24] Emily: Yeah, something like that.
[8:25] Christy: It's yeah, it's it's kind of like the now, yeah.
[8:28] Christy: Can we let kids do this show already?
[8:30] Emily: I mean, I'm ready.
[8:31] Christy: I'm ready to see little kids with little alphabet.
[8:35] Emily: You know, they'll love it, you know.
[8:36] Christy: Have high school kids, you know, going around getting quiet.
[8:39] Emily: Yeah.
[8:40] Christy: I I'm all for it.
[8:42] Christy: I thought what are those things where I see the producers are aware of the show shortcomings and realizing how much they would lose as soon as anyone tried to put the show on just on the backs of the book and score.
[8:52] Emily: I mean, I think it's just because Wicked is always just a cash cow, you know, it's like phantom.
[8:56] Christy: Like it's as long as they can make money.
[8:58] Emily: Yeah, but even phantoms have has a high school production at this point.
[9:01] Christy: So yeah, yeah.
[9:03] Christy: That took a minute too.
[9:04] Christy: Because they were definitely not doing Phantom.
[9:06] Emily: Well in 30 well into 30 years before that happened.
[9:09] Christy: So 25.
[9:11] Christy: Yeah, that's fair.
[9:11] Jess: But Wicked, not my favorite Schwartz musical.
[9:14] Christy: All right, Christy, you're next.
[9:15] Jess: I mean, sorry, Emily, you're next.
[9:16] Emily: Go ahead.
[9:17] Emily: Okay.
[9:17] Emily: So my next one is The Hunchback of Notre Dame.
[9:23] Emily: Um, I have not seen the stage version.
[9:26] Emily: Um, but I remember um viscerally, and I'm sure Christy is with me here, um, seeing that movie in the theaters when I was, you know, in the 90s, and it blew my mind.
[9:38] Christy: Yes.
[9:38] Emily: Yes, that whole entire score um is it's frankly like um remarkable.
[9:45] Emily: I I don't know how they got away with a lot of it.
[9:48] Emily: I guess they had to throw in that that gargoyle song, but um yeah, the uh the opening is one of Disney's best, uh one of the best villain songs.
[9:56] Christy: Absolutely.
[9:57] Emily: I I the underscore, I mean that's obviously Alan's wheelhouse, but the underscore is unbelievably amazing.
[10:05] Emily: Yes.
[10:06] Emily: I I you know I never I never, you know, I'm not a church going person, however, I sang in choirs my whole life, and a lot of what you sing in choirs uh in educational theater is like stuff in Latin and stuff, you know, DSE ray stuff like that.
[10:19] Emily: Um and so I already had all that in my head, so being able to see that it in a Disney movie was like, whoa, this is like the kind of heavy stuff.
[10:28] Emily: I'm singing four part harmonies in choir, and um it it just blew my mind.
[10:33] Emily: And um, I really I think out there is a very good I want song.
[10:37] Emily: Um, when when Jeff was on the cruise ship, he did the show called the Golden Mickeys, and he was an understudy for the guy playing Quasimoto, and one time he was like, I have to go run through this track.
[10:48] Emily: Do you want to come watch me do it?
[10:50] Emily: So I got to watch him unofficially uh play Quasimoto and sing it, and it was great.
[10:55] Emily: But um, but yeah, I love that.
[10:56] Emily: Someday I'm sure I'll see the stage version.
[10:59] Emily: Um I feel like the stage I know the stage version is a lot heavier and a lot more.
[11:06] Christy: I have a feeling you got too.
[11:07] Emily: I might yeah.
[11:08] Christy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[11:09] Emily: But um the the Disney movie version I think it it's really good, and I think uh good lyricism from Schwartz.
[11:15] Jess: So all right, Christy, what about your number four?
[11:18] Christy: Um my number four is Godspell, actually.
[11:21] Christy: Um a lot of what Emily said, it's a very, you know, good music.
[11:26] Christy: It's a very versatile show, which I think, you know, allows you to, you know, kind of say what you want with it.
[11:33] Christy: So, you know, and it's you know, as far as you know, biblical um musicals go, it's pretty straightforward.
[11:39] Christy: I mean, most of it is lifted, you know, directly from the gospel text.
[11:43] Christy: I mean, I think the only thing really controversial you can say they do with it is that they double cast uh John the Baptist and Judas Iscariot, which I think is very interesting thing.
[11:53] Christy: But yeah, it's it's a m it's got a lot of neat stuff day by day, obviously.
[11:57] Christy: All for the best is just like uh real yeah, a really fun the world is fucked, but let's, you know, let's try to be happy and yeah, really it's got that fun little counterpoint there.
[12:10] Christy: And some really be yeah, just some really beautiful um pieces.
[12:13] Christy: Yeah.
[12:14] Christy: And the movie is, you know, the movie's really interesting too.
[12:17] Christy: Um, it's uh, you know, they obviously do it all around New York.
[12:21] Christy: Um, I think you know, my favorite part is when Jesus is arguing with the Pharisees and they've kind of got like this weird, you know, found object sculpture puppet, um, you know, representing the irreligious authorities.
[12:32] Christy: I thought that was pretty cool.
[12:33] Jess: So um, can I tell a story about Godspell specifically?
[12:37] Emily: Oh, sure.
[12:38] Jess: Um, I might cut this out, but I did bring this up in our episode on Godspell on Musicals with Cheese. But when I first started looking at Godspell's very early YouTube days, um, All for the Best ends with them on the World Trade Center.
[12:51] Christy: They are in the World Trade Center, yeah, which was like just built back then.
[12:54] Jess: So yeah, it was in the process of being built, but I guess some edgy musical theater fan was like just posted All for the Best and then added 9-11 footage at the end of it. I remember that very vividly being my first experience watching the song All for the Best and cutting direct into a plane hitting it.
[13:18] Emily: I shouldn't laugh at that.
[13:19] Jess: I shouldn't laugh at that.
[13:21] Emily: I mean, we're laughing up the absurdity of what happened.
[13:25] Jess: That's like, you know, I'm not sure if that's wrong or funny or both. Maybe a little bit of a, uh, none of us created it, but yeah, yeah. That is my first experience of seeing All for the Best. Sorry.
[13:37] Christy: Didn't mean to derail this.
[13:39] Jess: No, that's okay. I love it. All right, um, my number four is where's my list here? Um, it is Children of Eden.
[13:47] Emily: Have either of you looked into that show?
[13:49] Christy: I have.
[13:50] Jess: Yeah, I know I learned a lot. It's also on my list, so um, I just really, really love like I this was actually given to me by a Patreon request um from Layton Accles um a few years ago from Musicals with Cheese and I've kind of stuck around with the show. I just think it's very interesting. It's not like it is one to one-to-one Bible stories from like the Adam and Eve days all the way to Noah and like how they constantly make the same mistakes, and how the only character with an arc is God, who is like this angry boyfriend figure.
[14:24] Christy: More like angry dad, but it's, it just feels like he broke up with the world and he's just a little bitter about it. I think it's just really clever, and it's got some banger songs. Let there be is an incredible number, especially when Ken Cage sings it.
[14:45] Emily: Numbers.
[14:45] Jess: And Lloyd Weber and Steven Schwartz are our only guys who write biblical musicals. Um, yeah.
[14:52] Christy: What the hell?
[14:56] Jess: Like Steven Schwartz stuck with it too. Like he's like, no, I think this will be my bread and butter for a while.
[15:03] Emily: Yeah, he does it well.
[15:04] Jess: He does it better than Weber.
[15:06] Christy: Um, I love Superstar, but ever Joseph, are you kidding me?
[15:10] Jess: Yeah, well, I mean, Jesus Christ Superstar is so um bleak in a lot of ways, whereas you Godspell, which is the comparable one, is yeah, you know, there's sad parts of it, but there's sad parts of it, but it's a lot more optimistic and fun.
[15:23] Emily: Yes, which I think Children of Eden, check it out if you haven't already.
[15:26] Jess: All right, Emily, you're in a hurt.
[15:28] Emily: Okay, so my number three is Wicked. Um, I uh gosh, okay. So I saw Wicked before it went to Broadway. The only time I've ever seen it on stage was at its pre-Broadway tryout at the Orpheum in San Francisco, and I was uh at UC Santa Cruz at the time, and I remember um going up to see it, and this is before they had Joel Gray in it. This is when they had some different songs. Like, like like instead of dancing through life, it was like raise the roof or something like that.
[15:55] Jess: Um, raise the Oz Roof.
[15:58] Emily: It was something lame like that. And I remember at the time it blew my mind. Now every musical is kind of living in Wicked's shadow. You wouldn't have a lot of modern Broadway or the way a lot of modern girls are supposed to sing on Broadway without Wicked.
[16:19] Jess: But it holds a big nostalgia factor for me.
[16:25] Emily: Including its flaws. It is a great gateway musical. It's just, God, when it, when you're like 21 and you're just that obsessed musical theater kid, a show like that just works so well. And then by the time it got to Broadway and became this big commercial venture where you could buy all this like merch and whatnot from it, I was kind of over it. But I do think there's a reason why it sticks around. Um, why a lot of the songs are classics. Um, I would love to see a nice tight movie version, but um Universal needs a franchise very, very, very bad.
[17:00] Christy: So apparently, yes.
[17:02] Emily: Yeah, they really do.
[17:03] Jess: What, the Minions movie aren't giving them all the money they need?
[17:08] Emily: Yeah, they're all over Universal too.
[17:10] Jess: Um, yeah, but I like Wicked, I think it's great. I like that it's a family musical. I like that you can go with your mom on Mother's Day or something and have a nice philosophy club to the movies.
[17:22] Christy: Yeah.
[17:23] Emily: Oh, the other thing was is I got really into the book before I read the book before I saw the show. Because I was really into uh reading Gregory McGuire's books at the time. And I remember reading that book going, How are they gonna do this? And then I saw it, I was like, oh, they literally just changed the ending. They literally just changed the entire ending.
[17:41] Jess: All right.
[17:42] Emily: Like, nope, she actually, nope, it's all just a sneaky thing. In the books, it's like, no, yeah, water does kill her.
[17:47] Jess: Water does kill her, yeah.
[17:48] Emily: Yeah, yeah.
[17:49] Jess: And in the show.
[17:50] Emily: Well, I guess maybe in the sequels, she does come back. I haven't read any of them, but or maybe it's ambivalent.
[17:58] Jess: It's kind of ambiguous, yeah.
[17:59] Emily: But uh, yeah, I think overall it's a big mainstream money making, big budget musical, but I think compared to a lot of them out there, it's one of the better ones.
[18:11] Christy: That's fair.
[18:11] Jess: I like it.
[18:11] Emily: Yeah.
[18:12] Christy: I like this and I like Wicked to quote us from the blue.
[18:15] Jess: Um, Christy, you're up.
[18:18] Christy: Okay, so uh my number three is actually Children of Eden. And you know, I was actually like just because, you know, I was thought I would be the only one who has this on there, but it's a fantastic show. I saw it at the Arvada Center, I guess probably about 10 or 15 years ago, and it was just incredible. I was kind of debating what I was kind of debating placement with this and Godspell, but I think this is, you know, kind of the more nuanced biblically based musical. Because yes, it is, you know, the creation, here's Cain and Abel, here's the flight. But the way they tell it and the way they interpret the actions of these figures is very interesting. And you know, this whole thought idea of you know, God, you know, who they refer to as father is explicitly because you know, this is kind of this dysfunctional family relationship where you know, God wants everything, wants this perfect, you know, family, you know, perfect creation here, but the kids aren't always doing what he wants them to, and that's very a very real parenting thing that a lot of you know, obviously, a lot of parents still struggle with.
So I really enjoy that. Um, you know, str I love Stranger to the Rain. I love um What's the Snake song um in Pursuit of Excellence? I really like how they did the snake with just like the multiple casts. So yeah, it's good things in Children of Eden, not many people.
[19:35] Jess: Yeah, it's an amazing, it's an amazing show. Check it out. If there is a local production by all means, go see it.
[19:42] Emily: Yes.
[19:43] Christy: I never hear of productions of it, but I feel like college productions, maybe.
[19:47] Jess: Yeah, I feel like it should be done more often.
[19:49] Christy: So yeah.
[19:50] Jess: Yeah.
[19:51] Christy: I think there was gonna be like a revival recently, and then COVID hit. I remember Norm Lewis was attached. Um, I think he was God.
[19:59] Jess: Norm Lewis's father, I would, you know, I would be York's daddy say that.
[20:04] Christy: Daddy, sorry, daddy.
[20:05] Jess: Sorry, Daddy Norm.
[20:07] Christy: Yeah, or Broadway Daddy, yeah. Um, okay, so and it was announced in December of 2019 that it would play in the Arcada Theater in August of 2020. And that's that obviously didn't happen.
[20:20] Jess: If anybody wants yeah, anybody wants to pick that up, please do so. Or just like do, I don't know, if you've got like kind of like a if you're directing a high school musical and you've got maybe a small smaller group and they're like a little more advanced, that might be a funny project for them. Or a college production. It is pretty, it is pretty um, you know, there's probably I think maybe about uh sixth grade main characters, and it is double cast, like you know, you have Adam plays Noah, and then Eve plays his wife, and so on and so forth. A lot of roles for women in that show, if I remember correctly. Like there's a couple good ones.
[20:52] Jess: Um, did I ever tell you guys that I saw Norm Lewis live a couple weeks ago?
[20:58] Emily: Did you post about it?
[20:59] Christy: I feel like I think you might come out.
[21:01] Jess: Either way, it was just an interesting thing, and I don't know if either of you remember Josh Young from the Jesus Christ Superstar Revival a few years back. Apparently he lives in Michigan now, and he pulled him on to do the confrontation. I was like, wow, for a cabaret, he's just fucking doing the confrontation. No one ever does it.
[21:18] Christy: I love it.
[21:21] Jess: With a piano and no one else. It was great. Either way. What is my number three?
[21:28] Christy: Oh, Godspell.
[21:29] Jess: Yeah, Godspell's good. Um can't top anyone else's comments on Godspell. Um, I told my fun Godspell story, and we'll move on.
[21:39] Emily: All right, Emily, your turn.
[21:41] Emily: Number two.
[21:42] Emily: My number two is The Prince of Egypt.
[21:45] Jess: Ah, cannot impart to you guys how obsessed I was with The Prince of Egypt.
[21:51] Emily: Again, there's a stage version that's happening or that happened, but I don't really know that.
[21:54] Christy: It's bad.
[21:55] Emily: Yeah, I don't really know it, but um, I love the movie so much. Um, I think I just I showed it to my husband, I think just this year because he had never really seen it, and he was kind of like, How have I never seen this? I was like, I know. Um it's just a great, it's just a great animated musical film. It just uses it has all the beats that an animated musical film should have. It's heavy. Um, it takes things seriously.
[22:21] Jess: And the score, like the very first notes, like I just thinking about it, or like the do you live or us? Like, I get goosebumps when I think about it.
[22:29] Emily: Um, I just think it's so good. And we all I've taught when you believe to kids a million times. One of the great uplifting anthems of the Hebrew section, I know it too because I've had to teach it so many times. Um yeah, it's so good. Um, yeah, I just think it's a masterpiece of an animated film musical. Um, from the way it looks and um excuse me, from the acting and the characters, but like the score and the songs really what make it. And um, I can see it translated to the stage. Um a few years after that, I went and saw uh The Ten Commandments, the musical at the Center starring Val Kilmer.
[23:14] Christy: Ah yes, I am familiar with it.
[23:17] Emily: It was it was I remember being like this were playing Moses. He was he was Moses in the movie. This is gonna be great. And it was, it was bad. But I choices were made with that musical. Let's just predict that. But The Prince of Egypt, the film, um one of the best things Schwartz has ever done.
[23:35] Jess: Um hard to disagree with that.
[23:36] Emily: I do want to say that I am bummed that that movie flopped, and then they basically said that since Shrek was our only hit, we're gonna make a thousand Shreks for the next 30 years.
[23:46] Jess: Oh yeah, but I am loving trying to figure out who they were.
[23:49] Emily: Yeah, I am loving that we are seeing this, you know, vindication from you know the millennial generation. So because you're right, it is a fantastic. I haven't watched it in years, but every, you know, she's right, it's fantastic.
[24:02] Jess: Yeah, it's great to, I mean, obviously it's good to put on on like Passover, um around that time of year in the spring.
[24:07] Emily: So yeah. Or, you know, Easter, if you don't want to watch, you know, Charlton Heston, you know, storming around in the Ten Commandments.
[24:13] Christy: Yeah, or watching John Legend doing Jesus Christ Superstar.
[24:16] Emily: Yeah.
[24:17] Jess: Yeah, a lot of things we could not be watching.
[24:19] Christy: All right, Christy, what's yours?
[24:21] Christy: Uh my number two is Pippin. Uh fantastic show, amazing metafictional um stuff going on in there. Um, you know, I love, you know, it's got a lot of fun, you know, vaudeville type stuff. It's got, you know, one of those, it's got probably one of the best, you know. This character comes on, they do a great song, and then they leave for the rest of the performance.
[24:42] Jess: Yeah.
[24:43] Christy: Um, you know, in no time at all. It's you know, one of those really great character numbers. Um, and yeah, it's just a lot of fun and a lot of very interesting with the philosophy. This is another one that I first saw at the Arvada Center, and you know, it's like, oh yeah, this is really cool. And then it starts getting into the ending, and I'm like, oh wow. And then, you know, at the end where they break everything down, and then Theo comes back on and the players just start kind of creeping around him doing the magic to do motif.
[25:08] Jess: And I was like, mind blown. I mean, that's just it was an incredible experience and still, you know, one of my favorite experiences in life theater to this day. So and the revival was amazing. Um, you know, they really leaned into the circus uh motif. Um casting the leading player as a woman, I think was a very good choice. Um, you know, I'd like to see more of that in the future. Honestly, Patina Miller, fantastic. Um, and yeah, great ensemble show. I just love that Charlotte Dambois and Terrence Mann, who are married in real life, played the King of T in that revival. Yeah. Great roles for them. Yeah, great ensemble piece. Um, you know, a lot of interesting things about life and ambition, and you know, maybe you know, you don't have to be famous or exceptional or wonderful just to, you know, have something wonderful and fulfilling.
Hell yeah. Um, I struggle with Pippin a lot. Um people can go check out our my episode on Musicals of Cheese of It. But honestly, outside the ending and no time at all, I really struggle with that show. Like the ending, like I'm like, that ending is brilliant. I don't know if I love the journey to get to that ending.
[26:17] Emily: Well, that's fair. Um, oh yeah, is it my turn? Oh yeah, I'm cheating again. I'm doing I'm being a dirty, dirty cheat. So my number two is a tie between the Prince of Egypt and Der Glockner von Notre Dame, specifically the 99 Berlin version of the Hunchback of Notre Dame on stage. So Prince of Egypt, everything that Jess said, wholeheartedly agree with it. This is specifically the film. The film's perfect ages, like fine wine gets better every year. Now, Der Glockner von Notre Dame. Do any of you know about the difference between that and the American action?
[26:48] Christy: I have only seen I've only seen the American version. So you'll have to enlighten.
[26:53] Emily: So I found this version a long time ago, well before the American version even existed. It starred Strusarich and was directed by James Lepine. Um he also wrote the book for this new adaptation. Um it was done in Berlin. Um, and the sets were incredible. They had like these big giant pillars and background projections, but it's like of stained glass. Everything was done like in shadows, and they kept the ending dark, but they didn't remove the gargoyles the way that the American one version does. So it feels a little bit more tonally varied. Um everything in that production is gorgeous, and I think that they put a lot of money into both the orchestrations and the set design in a way that the American production was like, we'll just hire a bunch of uh vocalists and that'll be it.
And it just kind of looks cheap. Um you guys should look up what that set looked like in Berlin because my god. And they changed the vocals to be lower in the American version, where they were just kind of showing off how high the vocalists were in the Berlin. It's just better in Berlin. So that is the best. If you are looking for everything you loved in the Disney movie, but a little bit more mature and on stage, that is the one you'll want. Because it is very, very effective. Um, yeah, that's it.
[28:13] Emily: All right. Number one, Emily.
[28:16] Emily: My number one is Pippin. Um I love Pippin. Uh I love the original cast recording. Um, I remember seeing a community theater production of it when I was young, and I it blew my mind. Um, I think the older I get, the more it resonates. Um I think the stylization of it, the fossil of it all, the um the dance being intertwined so much in the storytelling and everything, having that yeah, heightened vaudevillian feel. Um, I really love. Um when I saw the revival, uh, it was the tour uh because my friend Ryan Cantwell was conducting. Um and so we got to kind of go on the stage and kind of walk around and see it. Like, I can't even believe um uh uh um what's her name? Uh oh God, who played her in the revival?
Um Patina Miller. No, um Rachel Bay Jones. No, oh God, who played uh fuck you guys, I'm sorry. Uh who played Andrea Martin. Andrea Martin, I think. Thank you. I was gonna say I've got over time to tease this. It's gonna be Andrea McCartney. Five different Andrea's in my head and then I think too many Andreas and seeing Andrea Martin doing like aerial silks was that was mind blowing. Um was uh uh Lucille Ball and Desi Arnez's daughter, Lucy Arnez.
[29:37] Christy: Lucy Arnez, yeah, yeah. I've seen her in some community theater too. She did that on she did that role on the tour and it was great. Yeah, but like um I think the score is so good. I think it's got that Fosse that Fosse stank on it that kind of rubs kind of the rosy edges off of Schwartz's music. Yeah. It kind of makes that it a little more subversive and dark exactly. Um I remember when I was a kid, before it was even a twinkle in Broadway's eye going, I want to play the leading player. I don't care that that's a boy part, I want to play the little player. But sing the leading players part, I would imitate Ben Vereen every time. Um I just remember seeing that show. I I guess I had to have been like 12 or 13. And I was like, I didn't know Broadway musicals or musicals in general could end like that. That could kind of the ensemble the whole time, you're like, Yeah, yeah, I'm into them. And then by the end, you're like, scary. Yeah, yeah.
[30:32] Jess: So um, you know, it's worth noting the pro shot is fantastic. The only fault the only problem I have major problem I have with it is that it kind of cuts out that, you know, dark final twist at the ending. It's just like, you know, they say, not a bad way to end a musical, ta-da, wow. But yeah, otherwise it's a pretty decent um the the infancy of pro shots. Yeah. You got Ben Vereen. Yeah, um, Ben Vereen. Oh yeah. So it for me, Pippin is um it's my number one favorite, not just for the nostalgia that it holds kind of on my heart, but I just think it's a genuinely really good show. Um I like it a lot.
[31:07] Christy: Okay. All right, Christy, what's yours?
[31:09] Christy: Well, since I always do these by, you know, just what I enjoy the most rather than actual quality. My number one is Hunchback in Notre Dame. And I am actually going to shout out to the um American stage version because it's you know, I just love that they took this score, which was great on the film, and just expanded it in a brilliant way. I mean, so often when you do that, you know, they add a lot of extras, they add a lot of things that's like, yeah, I'm not sure if this fits with the score. I'm not sure if I like this. And yeah, there are some pieces like where, like, yeah, you probably don't really need that, but otherwise, it's enhanced beautifully. Um, I love that they brought more of the original novel into it, uh, specifically restoring Quasimoto's deafness.
Um, and also uh what else kind of kind of kind of bringing Jahan back away um and doing a lot of other things like that. Um, so yeah, I think it's uh really, you know, it's something that was great on film. They made it better, and um I just love it. I you know, I'm kinda sad that they're not doing it on Broadway, probably because that they have that big choir that they don't want to pay equity bunny to. But, you know, there's like regional productions that have like good local choruses that can do this for a couple of weekends. I think you could see that, you know. I like that, you know, some productions have actually um, you know, given Quasimodo to hard of hearing actors and then have the singer work behind him.
I think that's a great way of interpreting it. I like that we all have a different iteration of Hunchback on our list. Yeah, like we each have a different one. Yeah, it's it um, you know, it's one of those that they've done, you know, they've done it as several different ways, and there's good things and bad things about both. Um, but generally it's a really good score. And you know, again, I've got to shout out the fact since Schwartz was the lyricist, I love the way they use the Latin in this. Um especially, you know, if you are familiar with church music and the meanings. When you hear um, you know, Frollo singing fit hellfire and they're doing the Confiteor Deo, he's singing It's not my fault, and they're singing Mea Culpa, I have seen true my fault. It's you know, it's a fantastic juxtaposition. Love it.
[33:15] Jess: I agree entirely. Um Wow, I didn't think my choice is gonna be this controversial, but my my number one didn't end up on either of your lists.
[33:24] Christy: Okay, that I know what it is.
[33:26] Jess: My number one is the Baker's wife.
[33:28] Christy: Yeah, Baker's wife.
[33:31] Jess: I know. I’m I’m sorry. Meadowlark. You know, it's one of those. I'm surprised it's not Rags. Yeah. Um I haven't seen Rags. I will say that one. It's one of those, you know, little shows that you know you pretty much it's one of those things that nobody knows about unless you know music theater. Yeah. I mean, Patty LuPone was in the original cast. Like I I think this is actually my first Steven Schwartz that I really found. Um I don't know how I found this, but I found this album early, so it's like real big nostalgia for me. Um I enjoy listening to it. Alan Armstrong in the original cast is wonderful. Um of course Meadowlark is one of the best musical theater songs ever written. It's a good nine-minute theater song.
Okay. It's a fun you know, it's Meadowlark. Yeah, it's a fun journey song. I mean, you know, it's one of those songs like Me and the Sky where it takes you through like, you know, half a dozen different emotions, and it's a great actor showcase, and it also sounds fantastic. Plus, it's really fun to have Patty be like, Meadowlark. Like, yeah, sing for me. Yeah, I can't do Patty LuPone, but you know how she sounds. And the Meadowlark. Sang my Meadowlark. Okay, that's fair. That's good. That's good. That's Patty. Um, I can't do her doing any other song but that. But no, I just think she's that she has that very rich dark tone. Um that unfortunately we don't hear a lot of in music theater right now because it's all about you know the belting, the bright masky amber.
Yeah, yeah, the bright um I D's and E's and F's and everything. I remember when uh in Patty's book, she was talking about her experience on the Baker's wife and how struggled with it. But she also said, like, I wish more people would associate me with a song about a girl making a decision like Meadowlark than a girl singing about tears in Argentina. Which I'm like, oh and I uh I just love this musical, honestly. Sincerely, if you haven't looked at it, it might not be your favorite musical of all time, but there won't be another musical that you'll watch it like, oh, it's just like that. Like this is incomparable in its own way. I think it's a ton of fun and a good emotional listen to. But what is your favorite Steven Schwartz musicals, everyone? Why don't you leave us comments?
[35:46] Jess: Yes, let us know. Are we gonna do that? Who do you think the stupidest one? Like, is it Jess with the thing number one? Yeah, come and attack our choices. Yeah, yeah. Jess out there with like passion. What the fuck, Jess? I love that you pick like these little obscure shows that you know peop you know, most people don't even think of, but you just love to death. Deep cuts, deep cut Jess. Oh yeah, deep cut, deep cut Jess. We love him. I worry that people are like, oh, you're just trying to be a contrary one. I'm really, really not. I just have bad taste, is what I'm saying.
[36:22] Jess: Um, my wonderful dear friends, why don't you promote yourself for the world to see? Christy, why don't you start this time?
[36:29] Christy: Okay, I am on Musical Hell on YouTube and Facebook and Tumblr and Twitter. I have a Patreon, I have merch. Um, I spend a lot of time talking about musicals good and bad, and you know, making snarky comments about the state of everything. So come check me out.
[36:44] Jess: All right, it's great stuff. We gotta check it out. And Emily.
[36:47] Emily: Yes, I have um excuse me, I'm clearing my throat. Uh, I have a show called Stealing Focus on YouTube, and you can find me at Emily A.B. Clark on Twitter, TikTok, Insta, and we also have a Stealing Focus Patreon. So uh check them out. I am on both of those Patreons.
[37:05] Jess: All right. I I have Musical Cheese. I it exists. Um, all right. We'll see you next time on the Dear Friends podcast. Bye.
[37:16] Jess: D dear friends. Spill your woes to your musical family, dear friends. They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom. And anecdotes in an awful icynical world, dear friends.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
