Jess and Andrew recap the last 49 episodes of this show to discuss their overall thoughts before this week's big 50th anniversary show! Get hype people!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Jess and Andrew recap the last 49 episodes of this show to discuss their overall thoughts before this week's big 50th anniversary show! Get hype people!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Jess Mack: Hello, I'm Jess Mack and Alley.
[0:06] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:08] Jess Mack: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.
[0:14] Andrew DeWolf: And this is not a usual episode now, is it, Andrew?
[0:16] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, this is the episode where you get to find out how good of a job you did for the last 49 episodes.
[0:23] Jess Mack: Yes! Um, we're building up to our very special 50th episode next week, where we're reviewing a musical that is very close to I think almost every one of my fans' hearts. Um, so we're kind of building up to that by seeing how Andrew reacted to everything we've done previous to this.
[0:39] Jess Mack: What this is gonna be is um well, we might be a little late to the party on this, but there was the tier list meme that was going around, and what's that?
[0:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um stop breathing right into your mic so we get all these plosives with the mic next to your mouth. Jesus Christ.
[0:54] Jess Mack: Oh, sorry.
[0:56] Andrew DeWolf: Oops.
[0:58] Jess Mack: Okay. Well, we might be a little late to the party on this, but there was this um tier list meme where you would just rank things. Uh is in just just how good you think they are, and there really wasn't anything else to it besides just ranking them.
[1:15] Andrew DeWolf: Um exactly. And that's what we're gonna try to do with every single goddamn thing we've talked about on this stupid show.
[1:27] Jess Mack: Uh um, the rankings are as such, uh, for anyone who doesn't know. Uh there is at the very top S rank, which is the best it can possibly be, and then you have A through F. And it gets A is good, B is okay, C is eh, D is not good, and F is terrible.
[1:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so kind of like school grade system, except for at the top you have S.
[1:52] Jess Mack: Wow. How, how great. I'm in school again.
[1:55] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. Welcome to school, everyone. And we're also gonna be doing uh just a brief discussion of every single thing we've talked about. So this is like a clip show.
[2:04] Jess Mack: It's a clip show of the last 49 episodes.
[2:08] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. Alright, you ready to get started, Jess?
[2:11] Jess Mack: I am, and also this will be building up to a trivia contest where I test Andrew's knowledge to see what he really learned from all of this. So this is gonna be a fun-filled, like a little loosey-goosey episode.
[2:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this this don't expect any structure from this one.
[2:28] Jess Mack: Uh no.
[2:29] Andrew DeWolf: Nope, we're just gonna be fudging around.
[2:32] Jess Mack: We're fucking around.
[2:35] Andrew DeWolf: Don't worry, it'll all be worth the next week when you get your 50th anniversary episode. I think this is gonna be the best episode.
[2:41] Jess Mack: I think that 50th anniversary episode, garbage.
[2:44] Andrew DeWolf: Haven't even recorded it. Alright, Andrew. Let's go chronologically through every episode we did and start doing the rating.
[2:51] Jess Mack: And you guys could do this at home too if you want to listen to our episode and compare. So you can just start from the beginning.
[2:55] Andrew DeWolf: Start from the beginning and make your own.
[3:01] Jess Mack: Oh my goodness, it's fun for the whole family. Bring the kids. Bring your friends, bring your friends.
[3:12] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Andrew. I'll let you take the lead here.
[3:16] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, so our very first episode, which some people probably have never even known existed, because this was before our one-year ridiculously unplanned hiatus that we did.
[3:30] Jess Mack: That Andrew caused, because he just stopped responding to messages.
[3:34] Andrew DeWolf: Of course. Um, and that is Sweeney Todd, which I think this was back when these were videos, and we still had edited videos.
[3:42] Jess Mack: We had very nice edited videos back when we did this first like three or three episodes.
[3:48] Andrew DeWolf: Man, we stopped trying, didn't we?
[3:50] Jess Mack: We just cut that shit right away.
[3:52] Andrew DeWolf: Quantity over quality right away.
[3:55] Jess Mack: Quantity over quality. Uh so Sweeney Todd, which I mean I Do you remember how you felt about that originally when you first watched it? Because as far as anyone's concerned, this is the first musical you ever saw.
[4:06] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it kinda was. Besides like, you know, stupid stuff.
[4:10] Jess Mack: Yeah. Um, to be honest, I don't remember how I felt about it when I first watched it, but as of now, I think it's still one of my favorite ones that we've ever done. I I mean, is that bad to say?
[4:22] Andrew DeWolf: Did we blow your load too early with Sweeney Todd?
[4:25] Jess Mack: Potentially. I think we should have built up to that one. I uh it was fucking good.
[4:31] Andrew DeWolf: But it's the the reason why I picked it first is because it is everyone's gateway musical that we use to get our friends into it. Like, look at how great this can be. It's it's the first like really good batch of cocaine that gets you addicted, and then they just give you the garbage for the rest, hoping to give you that same high again.
[4:49] Jess Mack: Yeah. Well, great job. You did it.
[4:53] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't think it's a great gateway musical though, to be totally honest with everyone. I think—
[4:56] Jess Mack: Oh really?
[4:58] Andrew DeWolf: If you if you want to get your friends into musicals, show them something like Little Shop of Horrors or uh or Rocky Horror. You know, it's just Sweeney Todd has very it's not everyone's taste, I don't think, the music style and and not everyone's into horror either.
[5:13] Jess Mack: So I mean most non-musical fans usually have a taste for the dark, the macabre or the horror, as opposed to like um kick dancing homosexuals.
[5:24] Andrew DeWolf: I disagree. I think Rocky Horror has a bigger cult following in mainstream media than than uh Sweeney Todd does.
[5:31] Jess Mack: Well, cult following is yeah, cult. Yeah, it's still pretty popular.
[5:35] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. Sweeney Todd's very popular. Um look at the scene kids that all dress up like him every year.
[5:41] Jess Mack: Yeah. No, that's just that's from the fucking movie.
[5:45] Andrew DeWolf: Uh whatever. Has your opinion on the movie changed since you first watched it? Do you think you'd be more negative about it now?
[5:49] Jess Mack: No. I think it's it's still like it's okay, but it's just an inferior version of the show. That's really all there is to it.
[5:57] Andrew DeWolf: Uh as far as my tier ranking, uh, S rank. Just immediately.
[6:01] Jess Mack: It's an S rank.
[6:03] Andrew DeWolf: It's it's at the top, uh, Sweeney Todd.
[6:07] Jess Mack: Um same for me. Sweeney Todd is one of my favorite musicals of all time, so it's hard to not claim it.
[6:13] Andrew DeWolf: Don't blame you. I and I bet you most people listening have the same feeling. It's one of the greatest musicals ever.
[6:21] Jess Mack: Yeah, and then we followed it up immediately with Rent, because you hate me.
[6:25] Andrew DeWolf: And you hate yourself. Remember, we didn't pick this one. We put it to a vote.
[6:30] Jess Mack: Yeah, we put it to a vote. Uh we've never done that again.
[6:34] Andrew DeWolf: Do we have to talk about Rent?
[6:36] Jess Mack: I mean, I feel like we've talked it to death, kind of.
[6:39] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I'm not sure if I should give this a D or an F, but uh deep down inside I know I want to give it an F. I hate Rent so much.
[6:45] Jess Mack: Now why do you think you hate it so much?
[6:49] Andrew DeWolf: The characters are painful to listen to in every capacity, and I don't know, it's just it's just rock music too. It's like it you didn't even do anything too interesting music-wise, and the story makes me wanna off myself.
[7:05] Jess Mack: Now, for that episode, you also watched La Bohème, the original opera. Um has your opinions of that changed at all?
[7:11] Andrew DeWolf: I honestly I don't have very much recollection of it.
[7:14] Jess Mack: Gotcha.
[7:15] Andrew DeWolf: Um I haven't gone back and listened to it or anything like that. And opera is kind of something that you gotta go back and listen to to really get it.
[7:22] Jess Mack: Well, Rent, I've actually softened a little bit to Rent.
[7:25] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I'm putting an F.
[7:27] Jess Mack: I I hate Rent, but I'm gonna give it a D.
[7:32] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not gonna lie, the live production that they put on Fox softened me a lot to it. They had really good actors performing anyways.
[7:41] Jess Mack: Like they that was the best version of Rent I've ever seen, just because they had actors that had charm.
[7:47] Andrew DeWolf: I did not watch that, so that might be partially why I didn't soften to it.
[7:52] Jess Mack: There might be a commentary on that one day, folks.
[7:55] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Number three, uh we went back to Sondheim immediately. Thank you.
[7:59] Jess Mack: We had to rush back to where we were comfortable. We did Assassins.
[8:05] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I I think it's pretty middle of the road. It's not great.
[8:10] Jess Mack: As far as Sondheim goes?
[8:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean it's it's it's watchable. There's some songs that I liked and went back to, but you know, it's kind of muddled in it the talking uh scenes, like the everything that's like comedic when they're not singing is bad.
[8:27] Jess Mack: I don't think it's bad. I think it's just not as interesting as the scenes when they are singing. And I think that the things when the like the song scenes are just so good that anything else just seems significantly worse, even though they're pretty serviceable.
[8:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[8:41] Jess Mack: Assassins, I'll probably give a B.
[8:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Like it's not bad. It's pretty good.
[8:45] Jess Mack: Um, I'd actually still give it an A.
[8:48] Andrew DeWolf: Like it's S A, right?
[8:49] Jess Mack: Yeah, S and then A.
[8:51] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not sure if you're actually writing yours down, but I am wrestling.
[8:53] Jess Mack: I am down. I am. I am, I tells you, I am.
[8:58] Andrew DeWolf: I ams.
[8:59] Jess Mack: I am what I am. We do have a lot to cover here.
[9:02] Andrew DeWolf: So yeah, we gotta keep moving. Then we did the Rocky Horror Picture Show with um Laverne Cox and Reeve Carney and all that.
[9:11] Jess Mack: And that wasn't very that wasn't very good.
[9:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I don't want to even talk F. I hated that.
[9:15] Jess Mack: It's a funny video. Watch it on our watch on our YouTube page.
[9:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Uh Rocky Horror. This is the the remake of it.
[9:26] Jess Mack: Yeah, that Fox did. It's an F. It's bad.
[9:28] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Twisted. This was the last thing that we recorded intending to be a video.
[9:30] Jess Mack: Yes.
[9:34] Andrew DeWolf: And I just sat on it for over a year. And then we released it when we came back.
[9:40] Jess Mack: Yes. It was our first video back, but we recorded it like the same day we recorded our Assassin's video.
[9:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and it also may be the worst episode we've done, but yes, it 100% is one of the worst episodes we've ever done.
[9:52] Jess Mack: So I wouldn't go listen to it, but as far as the musical, I would definitely go listen to it.
[9:57] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm gonna give it at least an A. I'm considering S though.
[10:01] Jess Mack: I'm giving an S. I can't change a single thing about that musical.
[10:04] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[10:05] Jess Mack: Uh yeah, you know what? No, S, you're right. Twisted is fantastic. And I've gone back and watched that twice now.
[10:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's so good. Um let's move on to something else so good. Little Shop of Horrors, which was the first episode we recorded specifically to be a podcast.
[10:20] Jess Mack: And our debut episode back officially.
[10:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. And our audio quality still sucked balls.
[10:26] Jess Mack: Uh but it was a few minutes.
[10:29] Andrew DeWolf: Mine was pretty good.
[10:30] Jess Mack: Yours was terrible. But the episode was pretty good. We had a lot of good reception from that premiere episode.
[10:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Uh and as far as the musical itself, um, another S tier, I think.
[10:40] Jess Mack: I don't think I could sh I didn't this is a complicated one.
[10:44] Andrew DeWolf: Well, we did we do the movie or the show?
[10:46] Jess Mack: We did the movie, right?
[10:48] Andrew DeWolf: We did both.
[10:48] Jess Mack: Oh, we did both, yeah. And I stated in it that uh the musical is just the worst version of the movie, which is very, very rare.
[10:56] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's because the movie has all the cool effects and everything, which are all very impressive. And that's why it's complicated for me.
[11:03] Jess Mack: Like the musical itself is an A, the movie is an S.
[11:06] Andrew DeWolf: That's kind of how I feel.
[11:07] Jess Mack: Yeah. I'm gonna rank it as if we were doing the movie and put it in S.
[11:11] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna put S dash A.
[11:13] Jess Mack: Slash A. Alright. Um Alright, is this fun entertainment for you guys?
[11:17] Andrew DeWolf: I think this will actually I think people actually will like this surprisingly. You loving this so far?
[11:21] Jess Mack: All right. Um let's see. 21 Chump Street, which our episode might be longer than the show.
[11:29] Andrew DeWolf: This might be the only case where that is.
[11:34] Jess Mack: A hundred percent it's longer than the show.
[11:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um 21 Chump Street, I was okay with. Um I listened to this uh the show on my ride home from work on the way to record the episode.
[11:49] Jess Mack: That was how unprepared we were in the olden days.
[11:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um well, it's also was a 15 minute show. There was a video available that Andrew just didn't watch.
[11:59] Jess Mack: I did not watch the video. Sorry.
[12:01] Andrew DeWolf: We went into some deep conversation about Ronald Reagan, if I remember that right.
[12:05] Jess Mack: Yeah.
[12:06] Andrew DeWolf: In like our own high school life. So we got real real deep.
[12:08] Jess Mack: I don't think we ever got that deep ever again.
[12:11] Andrew DeWolf: I don't well, no, we did. With our with our one guest. You went pretty deep.
[12:14] Jess Mack: We'll come to that, I guess. Um, but 21 Chump Street. How would you where would you rate that?
[12:20] Andrew DeWolf: I'd give it an S because it's perfect as it is. Like it's a good for what it is.
[12:25] Jess Mack: I'd give it an A. I don't think I can compare it with Sweeney Todd or Twisted or I I definitely wouldn't go back to it that much, but I didn't have any problems with it really.
[12:34] Andrew DeWolf: Ah that's fair. Okay. I'm trying to get a gradient here so I'm not trying to give like only A's and D's.
[12:41] Jess Mack: Oh no of course but uh you know you have to do a lot of them to get a gradient.
[12:46] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah um and I feel like we started out with a lot of like we only did either almost perfect or absolute terrible was our our like initial couple that we did.
[12:57] Jess Mack: And then Carrie the Musical I think is a really midling show that I think was the first like okay we're really doing this.
[13:04] Andrew DeWolf: That was the moment we realized we're really doing this shit.
[13:07] Jess Mack: I like Carrie the Musical uh I didn't I'd probably put it with a I'd put it with Assassins in like B.
[13:13] Andrew DeWolf: I give it a B too. Um, I think it's gotten better with age, and I think its history is so interesting. I want someone to make a documentary about this musical. Really, I like a lot of the songs though, and I think it is pretty cool. It's just, there's something about it that's just not great though, and I'm not really sure what it is.
[13:30] Jess Mack: Well, was it the togas? It may have been the togas. Gosh, listen to that episode and listen to Andrew just get so baffled by some of the stories about this troubled production. I think that's the best part of that episode.
[13:44] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, um, Falsettos. We also did a bonus episode about Carrie the Musical. That was our first guest, so that was alright. You're right, you're right, you're right. Still, Falsettos. Um, Falsettos, everyone thinks I hate it, I guess. I don't know why. Jess seems to think I absolutely despise it. Um, I don't think it's that bad. I would probably put it in B.
[14:11] Jess Mack: You suck! Falsettos is amazing. I like the first act a lot. The second act was eh, and I don't really get that emotional at the dying thing. I don't know. Andrew's never died, so I'm going to die. I just don't want to fucking do it yet, you know.
[14:29] Andrew DeWolf: You gotta die sometime.
[14:36] Jess Mack: I'm giving it an S. I love Falsettos.
[14:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, great. Good for you. I'm putting it in B.
[14:42] Jess Mack: Oh my God. Everyone's favorite episode.
[14:46] Andrew DeWolf: What are you talking about? Alright, so you don't have to watch this episode, but I'm gonna tell you to listen to the fucking album. Tiara is excellent.
[14:55] Jess Mack: Fuck you. It's not a musical though, so I'm not sure it should be on this list. This is the only concept album we've ever done.
[15:02] Andrew DeWolf: Tiara is a good album. Listen to it if you want. I really like the acoustic version they just released. That sounds really good.
[15:07] Jess Mack: Yeah, they did just release that. It is very nice. Um, we now have more followers on our Twitter than they have on theirs.
[15:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, we've reviewed something where we're more popular than—well, actually, we've done that multiple times. Forget it. Um, Tiara is not a musical, so I don't know if I'm gonna put it on the tier list. Uh, I'm gonna give it a C.
[15:29] Jess Mack: C, Tiara. Good for you. If it was a musical, I'd probably give it an S because I love the music, but it's not, so I'm not gonna put it on there. Um, alright. What's next, Andrew?
[15:41] Andrew DeWolf: Is it your favorite musical ever? La La Land?
[15:44] Jess Mack: Um, I think it's a fun movie. I'm gonna give it a C. And also, this marks our first, like, official official guest with Brent Black, aka Brental Floss, who is currently our most recurring guest.
[15:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, he's also the one with the longest episode we've ever done, I think.
[16:02] Jess Mack: Yes. Yes, he is. Um, he gave us the longest episode we've ever done.
[16:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, I'm getting a big thing. I mean, if you want an opinion on La La Land, if you want our fucking opinion on La La Land, listen to us talk about it for an hour and a half with Brent.
[16:22] Jess Mack: Yeah. That's a fun episode where tensions were high.
[16:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'm gonna give it a C.
[16:28] Jess Mack: You said a D.
[16:29] Andrew DeWolf: That's fair. I'm a D.
[16:30] Jess Mack: Fiddler on the Roof.
[16:31] Andrew DeWolf: I don't like the music too much.
[16:32] Jess Mack: Fiddler on the Roof is another S. It's really, really good if you haven't already fucking seen it. We did the movie, um, but the movie, as far as I can tell, is pretty much the show.
[16:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[16:43] Jess Mack: It's one of the best movie adaptations of a stage show ever. Truly perfect. Uh, Fiddler on the Roof, S tier. I don't even think we need to go into it.
[16:50] Andrew DeWolf: Nope.
[16:51] Jess Mack: If I were a Muppet movie.
[16:55] Andrew DeWolf: The Muppet movie is great.
[16:57] Jess Mack: Yeah, is it a musical?
[16:59] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it kinda is, right? It's got songs.
[17:01] Jess Mack: It's got songs, and the songs sometimes relate to the plot.
[17:05] Andrew DeWolf: Not always.
[17:06] Jess Mack: Yeah. Sometimes they do though. I'm giving it a B.
[17:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think as a movie, I would give it an S. As a musical, I'd give it a B.
[17:16] Jess Mack: Alright. Um, Spongebob the Musical.
[17:21] Andrew DeWolf: Um, a lot of cool sets. Some decent songs. Uh, not like really weird story though. Like the strangest Spongebob story you could have possibly picked. Um, I'd probably give it a C.
[17:33] Jess Mack: Uh, yeah, I'll give it a C too. Not that it's bad. I do recommend you listen to it because it is a big thing.
[17:38] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, I don't think it's bad. I just don't think it's great. You know?
[17:44] Jess Mack: I don't know. I would like to see it. Uh, it's coming to my area at some point. I might come in. I'm coming to Detroit in December, so I think I'm gonna go see it. It is a non-union show though, which a lot of people are really upset about.
[17:57] Andrew DeWolf: Hiring non-union actors. People are really mad. Um, we did our back-to-back Mary Poppins.
[18:02] Jess Mack: Yeah, let's just do that. Mary Poppins, the original gets an S. The new one gets an F.
[18:08] Andrew DeWolf: Really?
[18:09] Jess Mack: Yeah.
[18:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I would give the new one a D. I just rewatched Mary Poppins Returns, and I was just seething angry the whole time. So honestly, probably my opinion soured on it.
[18:21] Jess Mack: Okay. Um, yeah, I mean, I wasn't super harsh on it, and I saw it in theaters. I haven't rewatched it. It was—I don't think it was terrible, but it definitely was not good, and I wouldn't really recommend it. So I'm gonna give it a D. I definitely do recommend Mary Poppins though. What about Wicked?
[18:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Wicked's great. Got good music. Uh, I think it's a little bit fanfiction for my taste. Uh, so I'm gonna give it an A.
[18:46] Jess Mack: I'm gonna give it an S. I don't think I could change it to make it better.
[18:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark.
[18:54] Jess Mack: With special guest Alison Pragler of Movie Nights. Wonderful, wonderful girl. We want to have her back soon.
[19:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, she was an excellent guest. Um, she had seen it live, which was interesting. Um, Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark, I thought it's baffling, which should be funny, but I didn't really laugh, is the thing.
[19:19] Jess Mack: So it's like if it weren't funny.
[19:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so I'm gonna give it an F.
[19:25] Jess Mack: Um, it also hurt people, literally.
[19:28] Andrew DeWolf: So F. I'm giving it a D because a lot of those actors are doing their best every night, especially Patrick Page as the Green Goblin.
[19:39] Jess Mack: I'm thinking now I'm thinking about the Green Goblin scene on the roof, and I'm comparing that to the Rocky Horror remake.
[19:44] Andrew DeWolf: You're right, D. You're right. You changed my mind.
[19:47] Jess Mack: You changed my mind. I did it! I won this episode. Spider-Man gets a D because of the Green Goblin.
[19:55] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. Phantom of the Opera.
[19:58] Jess Mack: Um, Phantom of the Opera has one really good song, and I like some of the set and stuff, and the Phantom looks cool. I give it an A.
[20:09] Andrew DeWolf: You give it an A?
[20:11] Jess Mack: Yeah.
[20:11] Andrew DeWolf: What would you give it?
[20:12] Jess Mack: I'm giving it a C, dude.
[20:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's about C.
[20:15] Jess Mack: Yeah. I am not. What's your reasoning? What's your reasoning?
[20:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I just think it's the worst of Andrew Lloyd Webber's like tropes. I don't find the story particularly interesting because we've watched fucking Cats now, okay?
[20:28] Jess Mack: Like as fair as that is, I—well, this isn't Andrew Lloyd Webber's worst work. I think it's indicative of everything that I don't like about him.
[20:41] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, you know what? Yeah, you're right. I'm putting it in B. Uh, now I'm looking at my list now, and I have Assassins and Carrie in B, and I'm like, I'm gonna put Phantom above that.
[20:50] Jess Mack: No.
[20:51] Andrew DeWolf: Phantom is in B.
[20:53] Jess Mack: It's in C for me. If you guys want to know my in-depth opinion, watch my 90-minute video on why I don't like Phantom of the Opera. Still on our YouTube page.
[21:01] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Love Never Dies.
[21:02] Jess Mack: Um, F.
[21:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I agree. I hate it. I don't even like any of the songs.
[21:09] Jess Mack: I like some of the songs, and I like some of the character movements. I think it's interesting. It's a very, very interesting thing.
[21:14] Andrew DeWolf: F.
[21:18] Jess Mack: But still an F. Next to Normal.
[21:21] Andrew DeWolf: Wow. We're on a roller coaster here.
[21:26] Jess Mack: Next to Normal, um, I would give it a C. I didn't love it.
[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: I'm giving it an S.
[21:33] Jess Mack: Good for you. I think I was in the episode I was very disagreeable with you on it.
[21:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I remember us getting really like kind of tense in that episode.
[21:42] Jess Mack: Yeah. Um, I would compare it. I liked it about as much as I liked Spongebob, where it's like I think some of it's good, but I just can't really get onto it.
[21:51] Andrew DeWolf: Can't get it. You had a lot of problems with the specific way that the mental health was portrayed.
[21:58] Jess Mack: You kind of want things that take away your blues, and that didn't—it doesn't at all.
[22:06] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like we missed one.
[22:08] Jess Mack: We may have. Or She Loves Me.
[22:09] Andrew DeWolf: You're right. Um, you must have forgot to put it on the list.
[22:12] Jess Mack: Okay, well, we're gonna do She Loves Me. Um, She Loves Me, we had a very good guest on for—we had Christy Estherly. Um, she has returned since. She is incredible, very sweet, very kind, um, very supportive of our show. She is a lot of the reason why we picked up so quickly because she was very willing to share stuff, so um, incredible. She Loves Me is a—I say with Wicked, I would put it with Wicked. I liked it a lot.
[22:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think it's great. Um, very, very, very, very sweet. It's a candy of a show, so to say.
[22:45] Jess Mack: Yeah, but I think it's—I mean, you need some of that sometimes. I don't know. I thought it was great. It's like a Christmas show too, so it's like it works. Makes you feel good.
[22:54] Andrew DeWolf: Um, alright. Now The Woodsman.
[22:58] Jess Mack: We didn't really do an episode on The Woodsman, did we?
[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: No, we didn't really do an episode.
[23:03] Jess Mack: We did an interview, but I know we both watched it.
[23:05] Andrew DeWolf: We did both watch it. I mean, I'm gonna give it a C, maybe lower, maybe a D.
[23:10] Jess Mack: I really liked it, so I'm giving it an A.
[23:13] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I like what it's doing, but it's not—a lot of the stuff it does is very avant-garde.
[23:19] Jess Mack: I don't know. I'm gonna give it a C.
[23:20] Andrew DeWolf: Was it better than Muppet Wizard of Oz?
[23:23] Jess Mack: Well, I even said in the Muppet Wizard of Oz episode that The Woodsman was better than the Muppet Wizard of Oz.
[23:29] Andrew DeWolf: But yes, it definitely is better than Muppet Wizard of Oz, but I mean, yeah, we'll talk about that one in a bit.
[23:36] Jess Mack: Alright, next we got Frozen Hyperion and Beauty and the Beast at the Royal Theater, Tangled at the Royal Theater, and Mickey in the Magical Map, which we all did in a three-episode collaboration with Tony Goldwyn.
[23:48] Andrew DeWolf: Are these being ranked separately? Because I think they all belong in different spots.
[23:52] Jess Mack: Just rank them how you want to rank them, but we're doing them all at the same time.
[23:55] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I'm ranking them separately. Um, Frozen Hyperion gets a C. Um, Beauty and the Beast at the Royal Theater and Tangled at the Royal Theater both get Fs.
[24:07] Jess Mack: Um, I'm just gonna put Royal Theater in F because it was—I hated those two fucking assholes running the fucking Royal Theater.
[24:16] Andrew DeWolf: Who were those guys?
[24:17] Jess Mack: I hated them. Smythe and Jones.
[24:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, fuck them.
[24:21] Jess Mack: Fuck Smythe and Jones, honestly. And Mickey in the Magical Map, um, also gets an F.
[24:29] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry. Well, where would you put them?
[24:31] Jess Mack: Yeah, I agree. No disagreements there. Um, let's talk about Matilda.
[24:38] Andrew DeWolf: The grand return of Brendan Black. Matilda gets an A from me.
[24:42] Jess Mack: I really like Matilda.
[24:43] Andrew DeWolf: S from me.
[24:44] Jess Mack: I like Matilda a lot.
[24:45] Andrew DeWolf: Really? You like it that much?
[24:47] Jess Mack: I do. I love Matilda. I think that is one of the best child-centric shows ever made. Like, and it makes me realize how not that great Annie is if things like this can be made.
[24:58] Andrew DeWolf: I'm comparing it to like Mary Poppins though, and I feel like Mary Poppins is a lot better.
[25:02] Jess Mack: Well, not a lot better, but a bit better.
[25:04] Andrew DeWolf: I can't say that.
[25:06] Jess Mack: Okay. I—we can disagree.
[25:09] Andrew DeWolf: We're not allowed to disagree.
[25:11] Jess Mack: We have to say it have the same opinions, Andrew. Don't you know that we're Crass and Caddy?
[25:16] Andrew DeWolf: That's—don't put that in the show.
[25:21] Jess Mack: Uh, fun fact, someone called us that recently, and I'm never gonna let it die.
[25:25] Andrew DeWolf: Which one of us is Crass and which one of us is Caddy?
[25:28] Jess Mack: Well, we all know which one's Caddy.
[25:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, fuck you.
[25:33] Jess Mack: Um, next we're talking about Hello Again.
[25:36] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Hello Again. Some of the songs are okay. D.
[25:40] Jess Mack: I'm giving it a C, but I get what you're feeling. But the songs I like in it, I really, really like in it. Like, I'm really positive about it. It has very high highs, but the lows are kind of middling, but they're still lows.
[25:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[25:54] Jess Mack: Yeah, but for me still, I really—I didn't like it that much.
[25:58] Andrew DeWolf: Merrily.
[25:59] Jess Mack: And I get that. Merrily, we roll along, roll along, roll along.
[26:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think this is one of our best episodes we've ever done.
[26:06] Jess Mack: Yeah, I actually really like the show. I'm not sure how what I said in the show, like our show, but watching it, I actually did really like it.
[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: You said you didn't like the fact that it was told backwards.
[26:18] Jess Mack: I did not like that. Um, but I think another one that we did later on made me feel a little bit better about it.
[26:28] Andrew DeWolf: So I honestly I feel like I might like it more now than I did before. Um I'm gonna put it uh thinking like B? A? One of the two. I'm giving an S. But the thing is, I recently when I did that podcast, I had seen it live for the first time ever, and I was like really emotional when I saw it. So it really hit me hard. Oh, specific time. So anything that like hits me that specific way, like it's it's doing something right in the material itself, so I can't give it anything but an S.
[27:00] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Something Rotten was something I was super positive on when we when we first talked about it. I gotta say, after several rewatches though, it kinda dies down a bit. So I'm gonna put it in B. I'm gonna put it in B. I'm giving I'm giving a C. I like the show. It's nothing amazing though. I think it's really funny if you haven't seen it. If you haven't seen it, you should definitely watch it. It's a one-watch though. I feel like if you see it once, you've got it and you never need to watch it again.
[27:25] Jess Mack: Exactly. But if you watch it that first time, you will really like it, I think. And I think it is a good show. I don't think it's bad at all.
[27:32] Andrew DeWolf: Institute Institute. I wish we were a visual medium so you can see Andrew's face. I um where the fuck do I put this? This is a really hard one to rate because for what it's trying to do, it is very successful. It is absolutely in what it's doing. But if you're watching it as a musical, it's like, uh I enjoy listening to it and I enjoyed watching the video. I'm gonna put it in D because I think it's unfair to put it in F because I think it is succeeding at what it's trying to do. I just don't want to see what it's trying to do.
[28:17] Andrew DeWolf: I'm putting it in B because I've gone back to it more often than I haven't. But honestly, I can't fault it. It's pretty it's good experimental theater, and that's rare.
[28:28] Jess Mack: Yeah, I mean, no, you're not wrong. It's just I I don't think I'm looking for experimental theater personally. But I'm not gonna put it I'm not gonna put it in F because I don't think it's a complete failure of a show. I just don't I don't like what it's doing, is all.
[28:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um Gypsy. Um Gypsy, I don't even remember how positive I was when we initially did it.
[28:48] Jess Mack: You're very positive.
[28:50] Andrew DeWolf: But I really like this show, and I'm gonna put it in S.
[28:52] Jess Mack: Me too. I think this this has been described by many people as the perfect book musical, and I don't disagree one bit. There is not a fault in the storytelling, there is not a fault in the music. It is perfection personified in musical theater.
[29:06] Jess Mack: Yes. Alright, you're in town. Uh, you're in town's gonna get a C from me.
[29:10] Andrew DeWolf: It's getting a D from me. It's kinda funny. There's nothing to go back to, though. The structure baffles me and not in a good way. It's got one or two songs I really, really love, but it's it's a hard sit. I honestly it reminds me a lot of Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark. It gives me an uncomfortable feeling when I watch it, and I don't know how to describe it.
[29:31] Jess Mack: Is it like a feeling like 9-11 just happened kind of feeling?
[29:39] Andrew DeWolf: Never forget, Andrew. Never forget town attacked. Let's talk about carousel.
[29:45] Jess Mack: Uh carousel. Carousel's a hard one to rate. One of our best episodes, though.
[29:51] Andrew DeWolf: One of our best episodes we've ever done.
[29:53] Jess Mack: Sure. I think I'm pretty funny in that.
[29:55] Andrew DeWolf: I'll be honest. I think you're I think we're both really on point in that episode. Like on point. But not to talk about ourselves. The show, Carousel, is a hard one to rate because what am I rating it on? I think no matter how I rate it, I'm gonna put it. I'm gonna put it in B.
[30:07] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna put it in A, but solely on the music alone. The music is probably one of the best scores we've ever covered.
[30:19] Jess Mack: Just on music and music.
[30:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, but the story drags it a lot.
[30:24] Jess Mack: Oh yeah, it does. That's why I could never give it an S.
[30:27] Andrew DeWolf: I would never be an S. You know what? I'm putting it at a B. You've convinced me. I feel like the story drags it too much. It it needs if it got like an Oklahoma style update, maybe it could work.
[30:37] Jess Mack: Yeah, and even the update they did, they didn't change it enough, if you want my opinion.
[30:41] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, they didn't. Uh okay, um, Muppet Wizard of Oz. Um This is maybe the worst thing I've ever like, not no joke. And I know people say this all the time. Muppet Wizard of Oz might be the worst thing I've ever watched in my entire life. Not just a musical, not just a movie, not anything. It's really fucking bad.
[31:06] Jess Mack: Yeah, it is. He's not wrong.
[31:09] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Muppet Wizard of Oz is not just the worst Muppet property, not just the worst musical property, not just the worst Wizard of Oz property. It's just the worst thing ever. Hashtag no regirts. Very, very hard F. If there was a rank below F, I would put it there. Giving it a negative F.
[31:34] Jess Mack: I'm giving it an F minus. Like, I feel bad having that in the same rank as like rent. That's how bad it is. Like, I feel bad putting it in the same level, even though I hate that show. But it's like I can't Oh. Okay. Uh Hades Town.
[31:52] Andrew DeWolf: Uh S.
[31:53] Jess Mack: A.
[31:53] Andrew DeWolf: I'll put it in S. I really like this show.
[31:56] Jess Mack: I liked it too. It's up to you, man. If you if you didn't love it that much, but I really liked it. I go back to the soundtrack all the time.
[32:03] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't cast recording. Pardon me.
[32:05] Jess Mack: Yeah, get it right, fucker.
[32:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, whatever. Fucking who cares. We taught him something. It's cast recording.
[32:12] Jess Mack: Yeah, okay. And when I went to fucking music school, they taught me not to clap during music performances. Fuck off.
[32:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah, it's an S. Guys, if it doesn't have singing, it's not a song.
[32:25] Jess Mack: Uh it's a piece.
[32:26] Andrew DeWolf: I learned something new today.
[32:28] Jess Mack: Yeah, well, whatever. Now you can be one of the jackasses that says, oh, the overture's not a song, it's a piece.
[32:38] Andrew DeWolf: The last five years.
[32:40] Jess Mack: Last five years, I'm gonna give uh I'm gonna give it a C.
[32:43] Andrew DeWolf: I'm giving it an A.
[32:45] Jess Mack: Really? I didn't I did not love this show at all. I got really confused by it, and I don't like the music that much, except for like one or two songs.
[32:53] Andrew DeWolf: I think the songs are all consistently solid with a lot of high peaks.
[32:56] Jess Mack: I mean fair. I find it actually selling. I'll put it I'll put it in B. I'll put it in B. Um now I'm thinking about it. There is I did go back to a few of the songs a few times, and I'm looking at my list here, and it's definitely better than uh some of the stuff I put in C, I think so. It's not perfect, um, but it is an easy watch and Jason Robert Brown's like most personal piece. I think it's great. Not perfect. No.
[33:18] Andrew DeWolf: Finding Nemo. Uh C D around there.
[33:22] Jess Mack: I'm putting it in D. It's good enough to not be an F, but it's definitely not good enough to do it. It's quality. Like quality for uh like theme park attraction.
[33:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, if I was at a theme park and I saw it, I would leave and I'd be like, that was not that bad. But if I was on Broadway and I went to see it, I'd be like, oh, I paid money for that.
[33:43] Jess Mack: There. Um Sunday in the Park with George.
[33:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um A.
[33:47] Jess Mack: S.
[33:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Of course you I mean, you have the fucking books and everything, whatever. It's one of Sundan's best pieces. Finishing the hat makes me weep.
[33:57] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck you. Great. Music Man, uh S.
[34:01] Jess Mack: S.
[34:02] Andrew DeWolf: No debate for me. Music Man is one of the most fun shows you can watch.
[34:06] Jess Mack: What about the Matthew Broderick version? What do you give that?
[34:09] Andrew DeWolf: F they basically just ruin it. They it it's thoroughly trashed.
[34:15] Jess Mack: I'm giving that a D specifically because of Kristen Channel.
[34:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you're right. There I mean, I I'm just harsh on Matthew Broderick, but every song that he's in is ruined, but there are songs without him, so I guess it's okay in those parts.
[34:29] Jess Mack: Alright, now parade.
[34:31] Andrew DeWolf: Uh parade, I would give an A.
[34:33] Jess Mack: Really? Why not an F or S. Why not an S?
[34:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. What brings it down? Because it is my favorite musical of all time, basically. It's a little dark for me.
[34:44] Jess Mack: Mm-hmm.
[34:44] Andrew DeWolf: And and I mean dark in like I I know I put like other like horror content on in S. But horror I feel is a different type of dark, like than like the real type of shit that's in this. And I I'm just not hugely into that, but it does it so well that I do like it still.
[35:00] Jess Mack: Mm-hmm. Alright. Um Jesus Christ Superstar.
[35:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I like a lot of the music in this. The movie feels a bit dated.
[35:08] Jess Mack: More than a bit dated.
[35:09] Andrew DeWolf: Very dated. But they released a new version of it like every ten years.
[35:14] Jess Mack: Yeah.
[35:15] Andrew DeWolf: It's good. I would I I think this would get an S from me.
[35:18] Jess Mack: Yeah, me too. Like I feel like we did a bunch of S's right in a row for me.
[35:24] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean you pick the episodes, don't you?
[35:26] Jess Mack: I mean, I usually it's because of guests. If that you want the honest answer.
[35:30] Andrew DeWolf: Uh okay. Uh next is Oh shit. Uh Deer of Enhanson.
[35:35] Jess Mack: Oh yeah. Where does that rank in this?
[35:37] Andrew DeWolf: F.
[35:38] Jess Mack: F.
[35:41] Andrew DeWolf: Uh that if you want our opinion on that, just watch the fucking episode. It's uh it's a rage. That is our most controversial episode though. Like people have yelled at us about that episode. People like people love the show, I guess. I don't I I hated it. That show makes me angry.
[35:57] Jess Mack: Yep. Uh B More Chill is up next, which is the better version of Deer of Enhancement, and I would put that in B.
[36:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'll give that a B too. For B more chill.
[36:08] Jess Mack: Haha! You have to put them in B. Get it.
[36:12] Andrew DeWolf: Uh No One Called Ahead. Um I'm giving that an A. I like that a lot.
[36:14] Jess Mack: Really?
[36:16] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I'll give it a C. I'm okay with it.
[36:18] Jess Mack: I didn't love it.
[36:19] Andrew DeWolf: I really liked it. And it's growing on me more, probably since the episode it came out.
[36:23] Jess Mack: I can't say the same for myself, sadly. Um Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of Atrein 12.
[36:28] Andrew DeWolf: We're getting very recent here.
[36:29] Jess Mack: S S.
[36:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, absolutely S. I completely agree. One of the best musicals ever written. Very good. Very, very good. Uh a lot of the music's really, really well done.
[36:39] Jess Mack: Um Oklahoma.
[36:44] Andrew DeWolf: B.
[36:44] Jess Mack: C.
[36:45] Andrew DeWolf: C. Yeah I I I'm thinking about the revival music, and I kinda like some of that.
[36:50] Jess Mack: Yeah, yeah, with the reviv the revival is an A for me, and the original is a C. So that's my official rating, but like the show itself is a C.
[37:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um Miss Saigon. I gotta say I really like the music in this. I'm giving that a B.
[37:03] Jess Mack: I wanna put it in A.
[37:05] Andrew DeWolf: I put that on par with like Carrie. Alright. Um Alright, that's all of us up to date. Andrew that's up to date. What why don't you give us what your rating would be for next week's episode without telling us what next week is?
[37:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um next week's episode without saying what it is. Yes. Okay. Um I would like we put that in A.
[37:26] Jess Mack: Alright. Um. Well, that gets you excited. It's an S for me, as everyone would probably guess.
[37:33] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sure. I would put it in A. Um, yeah. I'm not gonna give reasons because that would spoil everything, so um, okay, yeah. Um what do we do now?
[37:44] Jess Mack: Uh you have the trivia thing, and we haven't done a mid-show, so I guess we'll do like a late mid-show here.
[37:49] Andrew DeWolf: Nah, let's not even do a mid-show this time.
[37:51] Jess Mack: Oh, sure. Um, why don't we say what's in our top tier and what's in our bottom tier for first? Like organizing.
[38:00] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, what's oh, okay. So what what do you want to do? I mean, we just went through every single episode. I just want to see what's rate like if we were to put this all together if we're happy with our groupings.
[38:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm pretty happy with my grouping, I think. Um there's some stuff in the middle I feel like I might switch around a little bit, but I w so I'm actually thinking I may if I were to really do this again, I'd probably want an E tier between D and F to put some of the stuff. Uh I I like some of the bottom half of it is like like the C and D tier, some of it I feel like should be lower than others. Like I think Spider-Man is worse than Hello Again or Mary Poppins Returns, but I don't think it's bad enough to be an F, if you know what I'm saying.
[38:40] Jess Mack: Right. Well, that's fun. Alright, Andrew, are you ready for your trivia challenge? Because now the shoe is on the other foot.
[38:48] Andrew DeWolf: I've been ready as of right now.
[38:50] Jess Mack: Alright, so these are just trivia questions about our show altogether, just to see what Andrew's learned over the last few years m no, few weeks. Like we've only been doing this for like fifty weeks. We haven't missed a week yet, I'll say that.
[39:02] Andrew DeWolf: Don't jinx this, Jess.
[39:04] Jess Mack: Yeah. I don't think it's even been a full year yet.
[39:06] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm. Alright, so the first question, Andrew, are you ready?
[39:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, who was the composer of Wicked?
[39:10] Jess Mack: Of Wicked?
[39:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Oh man. That's one I probably don't know. Um, hmm. Well, um, I don't know very many composers. I know it's not I know it's not Sondheim, I don't think, at all. Um, it's not Weber, which is another one I know. It's not those two guys that have done nothing except for the Pirate Queen. Um Those are the big ones.
[39:40] Andrew DeWolf: Uh hmm.
[39:41] Jess Mack: I concede.
[39:42] Andrew DeWolf: I don't I do not know this one.
[39:43] Jess Mack: Steven Schwartz.
[39:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that name sounds familiar.
[39:46] Jess Mack: What has he done?
[39:46] Andrew DeWolf: Besides what?
[39:47] Jess Mack: Um he did Godspell, um Hunchback of Notre Dame, Prince of Egypt.
[39:47] Andrew DeWolf: Oh okay.
[39:47] Jess Mack: Hunchback of Notre Dame is where I would know from.
[39:55] Andrew DeWolf: Well, sorry about that. Didn't know that one.
[39:57] Jess Mack: Alright, Jess, go easy on me here.
[39:59] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, are you ready for the next one?
[40:01] Jess Mack: Alright. Um The composers of Fiddler on the Roof also did another musical we covered.
[40:01] Andrew DeWolf: What was it?
[40:01] Jess Mack: Fiddler on the Roof did another musical we covered.
[40:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um, well shit, I have the whole list of things we have done, so why don't I look and see what might sound similar.
[40:16] Jess Mack: Does it have a similar does it have a similar sound to Fiddler?
[40:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[40:20] Jess Mack: In a way.
[40:20] Andrew DeWolf: In a way.
[40:21] Jess Mack: Hmm.
[40:22] Andrew DeWolf: It feels very of the same time, musical theater-wise.
[40:25] Jess Mack: And it's of similar quality.
[40:27] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[40:27] Jess Mack: Well, now you've given me a ton of hints, and I'm probably still not gonna get it.
[40:37] Andrew DeWolf: Uh let's see.
[40:39] Jess Mack: Um was it hmm?
[40:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness. Everyone here is everyone is screaming at me right now.
[40:46] Jess Mack: I can feel it.
[40:47] Andrew DeWolf: We even brought it up in the episode.
[40:49] Jess Mack: Did I bring it up in the episode?
[40:50] Andrew DeWolf: No, I brought it up in the episode.
[40:52] Jess Mack: Oh you brought it up in the episode?
[40:54] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness. That shows how much I paid attention.
[40:56] Jess Mack: Actually we did Fiddler so long ago that never mind.
[40:59] Andrew DeWolf: That was a very long time ago.
[41:01] Jess Mack: We didn't do these two episodes very far apart.
[41:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh we didn't?
[41:04] Jess Mack: No.
[41:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[41:05] Jess Mack: Um okay I I I give in I'm gonna take a guess.
[41:10] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just gonna I'm just gonna fucking wing it.
[41:12] Jess Mack: Alright go for it.
[41:13] Andrew DeWolf: Is it uh is it falsettos?
[41:16] Jess Mack: No it was she loves me you don't actually that was my real guess.
[41:22] Andrew DeWolf: I'm actually not joking. I was I was gonna say she loves me but I was like there's no way it's that they don't sound that similar because you said it was like oh they sound the same ish yeah ish.
[41:33] Jess Mack: I think falsetto sounds more like fiddler in terms of like that Jewish sound.
[41:37] Andrew DeWolf: That's why I said ish it had more of a Hungarian sound in she loves me.
[41:42] Jess Mack: But alright are you ready for the next question?
[41:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um obviously no but here we go name one song title from hello again that isn't the title song um uh fucked um oh my goodness I I think I actually know one of these.
[42:02] Jess Mack: Oh my god.
[42:04] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Um Don't they just name it after the characters?
[42:08] Jess Mack: I feel like they just named it after the characters.
[42:11] Andrew DeWolf: Wasn't like one of them just called like the soldier in the whore or something like that?
[42:16] Jess Mack: Um I'll give that credit, but it's really like there are actual song names like the Mistress to the Senator and um Tom and all that.
[42:25] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[42:25] Jess Mack: Well, what was the title of the first song then?
[42:27] Andrew DeWolf: When the one I was trying to reference.
[42:29] Jess Mack: Hello again.
[42:30] Andrew DeWolf: But that one out.
[42:31] Jess Mack: Yeah.
[42:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh okay. What's the name of the song that I said I liked?
[42:34] Jess Mack: The one with the soldier and the nurse.
[42:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's a good one.
[42:41] Jess Mack: I was trying to remember the name of it, but I couldn't.
[42:44] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, are you ready for the next question, Andrew?
[42:46] Jess Mack: You're zero for zero.
[42:47] Andrew DeWolf: Zero for zero. Let's see if I can get one.
[42:49] Jess Mack: Okay. Who's like us, damn few is a quote from which musical we covered.
[42:56] Andrew DeWolf: Here's to us, who's like us, damn few.
[42:58] Jess Mack: Um oh my goodness. Wow.
[43:02] Andrew DeWolf: There's so many, and I'm like I'm like uh nervous because it's like this is the probably a really famous quote and I'm gonna get it wrong.
[43:08] Jess Mack: And everyone's gonna be like, How'd you get that wrong? Did you even watch the show?
[43:13] Andrew DeWolf: Did you even watch the show?
[43:17] Jess Mack: Yeah, I I did watch the show, but I don't remember all this stuff.
[43:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um is that from is that from Marilee?
[43:28] Jess Mack: Yes.
[43:28] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was. I got one.
[43:31] Jess Mack: You got one out of four, five, one, two, three, four.
[43:36] Andrew DeWolf: That's four.
[43:36] Jess Mack: Yeah, four. Alright. You're ready for the next question.
[43:38] Andrew DeWolf: I'm ready for the next question.
[43:41] Jess Mack: What was Jess's favorite song from the music man?
[43:41] Andrew DeWolf: From the music man? Oh, Jess's favorite song was some weird one. It was uh the barbershop song called Oh my goodness.
[43:53] Jess Mack: Uh was it the barb i I think it was the it was like the mix song, wasn't it? They like it was a barber shop and then it went into something else.
[43:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Do you remember its name?
[44:01] Jess Mack: Is it Oh jeez, I'm probably gonna say the one that you thought was annoying. Because I remember one of the barbershop songs you thought was annoying and the other one was your favorite song.
[44:09] Andrew DeWolf: Was it Light of Rose?
[44:10] Jess Mack: Yes.
[44:11] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Alright, you ready for the next one?
[44:15] Jess Mack: Yes. What was the name of the composer of Rent?
[44:19] Andrew DeWolf: Of Oh my goodness. I watched a fucking documentary on this guy, and I there's no way I'm gonna remember his name at all. I know he died, and it was so sad. Because he never got to finish Rent and I had to watch the unfinished version, so it was really sad.
[44:38] Jess Mack: Um can I guess his first name?
[44:40] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[44:41] Jess Mack: Was it Paul?
[44:42] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[44:43] Jess Mack: Okay, I have no idea.
[44:44] Andrew DeWolf: Jonathan Larson.
[44:45] Jess Mack: Jonathan Larson. See the thing is we've only done Rent by him, and I I just don't remember anything.
[44:51] Andrew DeWolf: He's done other people.
[44:53] Jess Mack: Yeah. We did one other one.
[44:55] Andrew DeWolf: We should talk about that.
[44:56] Jess Mack: We should talk about it.
[44:57] Andrew DeWolf: When it comes out on Netflix, we will.
[44:59] Jess Mack: Excellent. Um, alright, so here's the one that might make Andrew look like a dick.
[45:03] Andrew DeWolf: I got two of these, so.
[45:05] Jess Mack: Oh good. Make me look like a dick.
[45:07] Andrew DeWolf: Because it's about our guests, you fucking asshole. What was the name of our guest for something rotten?
[45:12] Jess Mack: For something rotten. Oh, we had like a really nice guest, and I think they were from weren't they from uh that Broadway network or something?
[45:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. What was her name?
[45:24] Jess Mack: What was her name? That's like a really tough ask. Um, I can't say I remember. Was it like Angela?
[45:30] Andrew DeWolf: Her name was Katie Lynch of Brook Backstage Bite.
[45:34] Jess Mack: I I remember the backstage bite thing. I remember they were they talked about food or something like that. They mentioned food. She's about to have a baby soon. Congratulations, Katie. We love ya.
[45:42] Andrew DeWolf: I do I do remember you, I just don't remember your name. I'm not good with names.
[45:46] Jess Mack: As if this isn't already obvious.
[45:51] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. You ready for the next question?
[45:53] Jess Mack: Yeah, sure. Name two of the numerous composers for the SpongeBob musical.
[46:00] Andrew DeWolf: The numerous composers. Um let's see, because they it's all pop musicians.
[46:05] Jess Mack: Um my goodness. Did they get Bono for this one as well?
[46:09] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[46:10] Jess Mack: No.
[46:12] Andrew DeWolf: I remember Bono did uh I remember Bono did Spider-Man.
[46:15] Jess Mack: I don't know how I remember that.
[46:19] Andrew DeWolf: Of all things I remember, I remember that, and I can't remember who did SpongeBob.
[46:23] Jess Mack: Um holy shit. Okay. Um well I know for a fact that um Tom Kenny is one of the composers.
[46:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[46:33] Jess Mack: For certain. Because he did he did Best Day Ever. So he definitely is one of them.
[46:38] Andrew DeWolf: Uh and then oh my goodness, did they get they got a rapper? Was it was it Kendrick Lamar that they got?
[46:44] Jess Mack: No.
[46:45] Andrew DeWolf: I have no idea.
[46:48] Jess Mack: You fail, Andrew. T I was the rapper they got.
[46:51] Andrew DeWolf: T I was the rapper. Umrew's a failure, and I can see the dejected look in his eyes.
[46:56] Jess Mack: Absolutely. Alright, are you ready for another one?
[46:59] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, well, who who is c who is their composers?
[47:01] Jess Mack: Oh, there was tons of them, dude. Like Cindy Lopper, Seller Sarah Barelis, Maroon 5, um Maroon 5, god damn. I was trying to remember who was the rock band that did that was in there. It was Maroon 5.
[47:16] Andrew DeWolf: Like so many composers, dude.
[47:18] Jess Mack: Steven Tyler, um, Panic of the Disco, Lady Annabellum, Jonathan Colton.
[47:24] Andrew DeWolf: See, here's the thing. I don't listen to any of those bands, so it's hard for me to do it.
[47:29] Jess Mack: I do like they might be giants. I should have known that one.
[47:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you moron.
[47:35] Jess Mack: Well, see, I didn't want to just guess a bunch of bands because then I would have just gotten it wrong immediately.
[47:40] Andrew DeWolf: If I just guess a bunch of stuff, I would get it wrong immediately, right?
[47:43] Jess Mack: Whatever you say.
[47:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, whatever.
[47:46] Jess Mack: Alright, you're ready for the next one.
[47:47] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. What do you think Jess's favorite and least favorite musicals we covered are?
[47:51] Jess Mack: Um well, your favorite musical of all time, as you've said earlier in this episode, is Parade.
[47:57] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, that's one. Um, and you wanted the least favorite?
[48:01] Jess Mack: Yes, and we're not counting Mappa Wizard of Oz, that's not amazing.
[48:04] Andrew DeWolf: No, I I know. Um I would guess your least favorite music of all time would probably be Love Never Dies.
[48:10] Jess Mack: Uh at least down there?
[48:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's down there, but it isn't the worst.
[48:16] Jess Mack: Is Dear Evan Hansen lower?
[48:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[48:18] Jess Mack: Really? I didn't think Dear Revan Hansen was lower.
[48:20] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Yeah, Love Never Dies actually has some redeeming value to me.
[48:24] Jess Mack: Okay. Um, are they both is is uh Dear Evan Hansen worse than the Rocky Horror remake?
[48:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[48:31] Jess Mack: Wow, Dear Evan Hansen is lower on your list than mine, I think then. Um Mary Poppins Returns is probably one of the worst things I've ever had to watch.
[48:39] Andrew DeWolf: So that's that was gonna be the answer.
[48:41] Jess Mack: That was the correct answer. That's lower than Deer of Enhanson.
[48:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. See, but you were like positive in the episode we did.
[48:47] Jess Mack: Yep.
[48:47] Andrew DeWolf: At least mildly.
[48:49] Jess Mack: Mildly. You have drastically changed your we have to talk about that for a sec. What what caused you to change your opinion so drastically?
[48:56] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I watched it again and I was just angry, so angry at every choice that that movie made. I I will say it should have been great. That's kind of it. I think it had so much potential, and that bothers me more.
[49:08] Jess Mack: Okay. Do you have any more questions?
[49:10] Andrew DeWolf: Did I did I get that wrong or right?
[49:12] Jess Mack: I have I think that's a no contest to answer.
[49:16] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, so here's the last one. You ready?
[49:18] Jess Mack: Yeah, sure. Name three songs from musicals we've covered that were also covered by Frank Sinatra.
[49:25] Andrew DeWolf: Really?
[49:26] Jess Mack: Yeah.
[49:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I mean, I like Frank Sinatra. I can't say I'm like a Frank Sinatra fanatic, though.
[49:36] Jess Mack: Um, well, let's see what's going on.
[49:38] Andrew DeWolf: Think about the time he the musicals came out. Think about the time of Sinatra. Think about all that.
[49:42] Jess Mack: I I mean, I would assume he's probably done something from like Carousel. Has he done anything from Carousel?
[49:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm gonna need you to tell me the songs if he did.
[49:53] Jess Mack: Okay. Am I allowed to look at a song list for Carousel to see what one I think would fit his voice the most?
[49:58] Andrew DeWolf: I I will give you that.
[50:01] Jess Mack: Yeah, sorry. I I I'm not a huge Frank Sinatra. Let's see. What would he do? I feel like he would have covered If I Loved You.
[50:08] Andrew DeWolf: That's one.
[50:09] Jess Mack: He would do a duet with somebody. He might have even done multiple songs from this, but I'm actually.
[50:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, he has.
[50:15] Jess Mack: Oh my goodness. Um let's see. June is busting out all over. I don't think he would do.
[50:19] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[50:20] Jess Mack: Um, what's the use in wondering?
[50:22] Andrew DeWolf: No, that's about justifying why a man beats her.
[50:25] Jess Mack: No, I no, I know. I'm saying he wouldn't.
[50:28] Andrew DeWolf: Um what would he cover from this? I'm looking at this, I don't I don't feel like he'd cover anything else.
[50:33] Jess Mack: Um, there has to be one solo male song in that show.
[50:37] Andrew DeWolf: There is.
[50:39] Jess Mack: Uh sorry, I'm trying to remember which which song it fucking was. Is it soliloquy? Is that the name of the song?
[50:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yes, yes, that's the name of the song.
[50:47] Jess Mack: Oh, that's like a song name that sucks. I was looking for like something that would fit the song that it was.
[50:55] Andrew DeWolf: Nothing.
[50:55] Jess Mack: Alright, and there is one more song. Um he also did Sir the Fringe on Top from Oklahoma.
[51:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um people say we're in love from Oklahoma.
[51:04] Jess Mack: And he did good thing going from Merrill Rollong.
[51:07] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, ch you didn't even let me guess.
[51:10] Jess Mack: You're good.
[51:10] Andrew DeWolf: You could have figured it out.
[51:11] Jess Mack: What's that?
[51:12] Andrew DeWolf: You weren't gonna figure it out.
[51:13] Jess Mack: I was gonna say that Oklahoma was the other one he would have done.
[51:17] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, guys, thank you for listening. Um thank you to our incredible patrons over at Patreon who made the show possible. Stephanie L, Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Lair, Chris O'Kelly, Lily Accles, Daniel Rhett, Danielle Rennicks, Mackenzie Horner, John Donna, Terran the Duck, who is an actual duck, Melissa Goldman, Jess Lightning, Ewan Cassidy, Haley McDonald, and Teskeer.
[51:42] Jess Mack: Thank you all for your donations and making this possible. I know this was a bit of a loosey-goosey episode, but don't worry, next week's is gonna be worth it. It's gonna be a lot of fun. Andrew, do you have anything else do you want to say?
[51:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm not very good at trivia, which is why I don't usually do the trivia on the show.
[51:57] Jess Mack: Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, iHeartRadio, and all that other nonsense at musicals with cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. Give us some Patreon love at musicals with cheese. Our Instagram is Musicals with Cheese. Our YouTube page is also Musicals with Cheese. Email us at musical theaterlives at gmail.com. Check out our brand new spank and website, musicals with cheese.com. I put a lot of work into that, so someone check it out. Our title card was created by Jolene Casco. Follow her on Instagram at Jolene Casco. Tell her we said hi. Send her our best. We love you.
[52:30] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Is there anything else you want to say before we wrap up?
[52:32] Jess Mack: Uh I think the next episode's gonna be very good. So check it out.
[52:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I know the wait will be agony.
[52:40] Jess Mack: Now you you spoiled it in the last fucking second.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
