Skip to main content
BPN Logo
BONUS: Ten Best Episodes of 2023! (feat. Juliet Antonio)

Today we're joined by the one and only keeper of the cheese Juliet Antonio to talk about their ranking of the top ten best episodes of Musicals with Cheese of 2023. Will your favorites make the list? There's only one way to find out!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

35 mins
1/8/24

Featured Shows

About

Today we're joined by the one and only keeper of the cheese Juliet Antonio to talk about their ranking of the top ten best episodes of Musicals with Cheese of 2023. Will your favorites make the list? There's only one way to find out!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:43] Jess: Hello and welcome to this extra special bonus episode of Musicals with Cheese. Today, as we do every year, usually a little earlier, but I'm glad we're doing it now. Um, we have a countdown of the previous year's best episodes. But it would be really, really dumb if me and Andrew or Liz kind of did that. We'd be objective. We just remember the process of recording it. Thankfully, the wonderful and incredible Juliet Antonio, our own keeper of the cheese, has been keeping track, listening to episodes, and is the best authority on what the best episodes of 2023 were. And with all the wonder in the world, Juliet, I am passing the ball to you. This is your show now. Um what what do we have in store?

[1:28] Juliet Antonio: All right. Hi, everybody. For those who don't know me, if somehow this is your first episode, then interesting choice, but let me give you a lowdown. I'm Juliet, I'm the keeper of the cheese. One day Jess said it would be hilarious if somebody created a spreadsheet of the cheese ratings. So I made one, and I've been doing this since episode one. And how this works is I go through every single year, picked the top ten episodes for that year, and then I assign the top ten cheese ratings of that year for Jess and Andrew for the guests, and I'm also doing one for Liz. Liz's is gonna be a bit different because I'm gonna give you a cumulative cheese rating since the first time I reviewed the top ten episodes, I gave Jess and Andrew cumulative ratings as well.

So I feel like that would only be fair. Okay. Yep. So everything that we are covering for 2023 is basically everything from A Star is Born up until just before Tar. I think the last one was Grandma Got Run Over by All of the Other Reindeer.

[2:27] Jess: Yeah.

[2:28] Juliet Antonio: So, as I always do, I'm gonna start around with everybody and say, what episodes do you think are going to be on the top of the list? Who wants to go first? Um, Andrew, why don't you go first? Because I'm curious if you remember any episodes from last year.

[2:53] Andrew: Oh fuck. I I have uh notoriously bad memory, so I I really don't.

[3:02] Jess: In a certain way, every musical is your first.

[3:05] Andrew: Yeah, in a way. Yeah. Let me let me let me see if I could just pull up our list of episodes and see if there's something that sticks out to me. I can send you the wonderful cheese rating spreadsheet that Juliet has put together mistakenly for the last like three years now, you've been doing this.

[3:23] Juliet Antonio: It's only the reason why I'm here.

[3:25] Andrew: Yeah, that that sounds about right. Yeah. This was this was the year we did all the uh phantom stuff, right?

[3:32] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, we did all the phantom stuff. We also did the Matilda musical, I think, and Dream Girls.

[3:39] Andrew: Yes, yes. And Dream Girls was Breeze last episode. Um when you started taking over editing.

[3:47] Jess: Okay. Best episodes, uh, The Frogs. Um Phantom Month. Uh and I don't know what else. Those those are my predictions.

[4:00] Juliet Antonio: Okay. All right. My big prediction. I'll I'll go next. My big prediction is Brigadoon's gotta be on there. In the moment I knew magic was being made while recording that episode, and it's still probably one of my favorite tangents, and some of my favorite pieces of Andrew's editing ever. So I yeah, I I my that is the big one where I'm like, that has to be on there, right?

[4:21] Jess: I made a Brigadoon joke with my friends. None of them got the reference, but everyone in your server did, so I was so grateful.

[4:28] Juliet Antonio: The Patreon server, join it.

[4:30] Jess: Join it.

[4:31] Juliet Antonio: Yes, peace for the Patreon server. It is really, really fun. I can I can I can attest to that. Uh Liz, what is your prediction? Do you think?

[4:38] Liz: Uh I I came in late, so I had to like dig through the episodes a bit. Um I I'm gonna agree with Jess. Definitely Brigadoon. I felt the magic happening when we kept talking about Colomo, and I wasn't annoyed. Um I remember listening to that episode and being like, man, Liz is great. Everything is great in this episode. And I guess I'm also gonna this is reasony bias. I'm gonna eight crazy nights just because we all kind of went insane collectively. Uh that episode I'm gonna guess those two.

[5:12] Juliet Antonio: Okay. Great choices. All right, what's what let's get into it. I want to know. Number 10.

[5:17] Jess: Oh, I want to know. I wanna know. Can you show me?

[5:22] Juliet Antonio: Alright, uh, sorry, Ethan. Alright, so something's going on with my mouse. Hold on one second. Okay, so I've got it. Alright, can everybody still hear me?

[5:31] Andrew: Yes.

[5:31] Liz: Yep.

[5:34] Juliet Antonio: Can you hear us? Alright, so for number 10, we have episode 252, The Fantasticks.

[5:43] Jess: So Monica!

[5:44] Juliet Antonio: I will admit my bias. This was one I where I wanted you guys to be serious and not to shit on or even uh use too much humor. I think I'm just protective of the show and how the music makes me feel. But I think there was one inclusion that made this episode work, and that was patron Monica Thoreau. She has the optometrist precision with her thoughts on this show. And Andrew and Jessica kind of made you guys be on your best behavior. Although the most hilarious part was Andrew creating the visual of El Gaio with flaming hot Cheetos. I was laughing my ass off in the car. That was humor and good taste. Wonderful.

[6:21] Andrew: I don't do it often, but sometimes I have good taste.

[6:26] Juliet Antonio: I I love that episode because it is one of the more requested ones. I didn't have that deep familiarity and love for it that I know a lot of folks do. So I I I was very grateful for Monica there. And she's just a peach of a human being, and getting to know them was a good good time. And I got to learn about the proper ways to get my eyes checked during their time as our. Um yeah, uh Monica's great. Um go listen to that episode. I I forgot we did that one. Um what's next, Juliet?

[6:58] Juliet Antonio: Okay. So, number nine, we have episode two hundred and fifty, Newsies.

[7:05] Jess: Oh yeah.

[7:06] Juliet Antonio: Yeah. The one the one we all knew was inevitably coming.

[7:13] Andrew: Yeah.

[7:13] Juliet Antonio: So there are three shows that everybody was waiting for you to cover. Uh wait, not n um, not three. Pardon me. Uh oh no, no, no, it was three. Sorry, I misread that sentence. So there were three shows everybody was waiting for you to cover. Newsies, another one that's going to be featured on this list, and Six. And Jess, I'm going to make an observation too, in fact.

[7:38] Jess: Okay.

[7:39] Juliet Antonio: You said you put off Newsies because you didn't know how to talk about it. I think you underestimate yourself. Because you weren't a fan, you realize, okay, I still have to make this a good episode after so many people had been waiting for it. So you dug deep down to the bottom of your soul, like Diana did in the chorus line, and made an effort to explain why this wasn't exactly for you. And Andrew was your perfect foil. However, this episode also gives you my second observation as to the infamous Jess Hades dancing theory.

[8:12] Jess: Jess does hate dancing.

[8:13] Andrew: I don't hate dancing.

[8:15] Juliet Antonio: Well, here's the thing. As the person who has listened to every single episode, here is the truth to this statement. Here is the axiom. Jess hates dancing unless it is Bob Fossey choreography shot for film. Because you like the dancing in Sweet Charity, you like Chicago, and All That Jazz is one of your favorite movies. So you don't totally hate it, you just need it fossied up with all the appropriate angles.

[8:45] Jess: Oh, um, I hope I don't contradict that in our Damn Yankees episode we just did.

[8:50] Andrew: You don't you don't. You literally say the dancing is good.

[8:53] Juliet Antonio: Perfect.

[8:54] Jess: It's the Bob Fossey choreography.

[8:55] Juliet Antonio: You said Bob Fossey likes to show dancing, you like it.

[8:58] Jess: Yep.

[8:59] Andrew: Alright, I am anything if not consistent. Now it's out there. Now everybody knows it. Everybody can stop talking about it.

[9:06] Jess: You're saying it'll never stop talking about it.

[9:09] Juliet Antonio: You're just confirming what we all said.

[9:11] Andrew: He hates dancing.

[9:12] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, Andrew and I will continue to bring it up.

[9:15] Andrew: He hates dancing asterisk.

[9:17] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, except Bob Fossey when it's shot on film.

[9:19] Jess: That's a tiny asterisk.

[9:21] Juliet Antonio: That's a very small asterisk.

[9:23] Jess: Stop talking about my asterisk.

[9:25] Andrew: It's so fucking small. You can't even see it.

[9:28] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, so I was worried about that episode, but I'm glad like you're a fan of Newsies that you really enjoyed it.

[9:35] Jess: I'm not a fan of Newsies, actually.

[9:37] Andrew: What?

[9:38] Jess: Yeah, I think it's I think it's fine. You know, it's not my favorite musical of all time, but it's like, you know, if somebody had it on the streaming, or when I went to go see it and I got a free ticket, I was like, well, it was worth a free ticket. You know.

[9:51] Andrew: Fair enough.

[9:52] Juliet Antonio: Now for number eight, episode 270, A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.

[10:00] Jess: Oh, that's a s that's a shock.

[10:03] Juliet Antonio: I feel like Forum can get forgotten in the Sondheim Pantheon, just because it's the one that seems least like him, even though you listen to the word play and you can identify it's him almost instantly. And there was a great explanation about hummable songs. Uh plus the conspiracy theory about how this is connected to The Frogs like six degrees and was a revelation. And I have been looking forward to you guys covering this because as a musical farce, I figured it'd be right up your alley. And you were able to list the pros and cons of the movie in a fair and balanced way. The most hilarious part was when you you guys added this to your Sondheim ranking tier list, and Jess, you say to Andrew, you pick what you want. I don't care. And then fast forward five seconds later to Andrew, you're putting that above this. What?

[10:50] Andrew: I I okay. Put it where you want, I don't care. But also, what the fuck, man?

[10:58] Juliet Antonio: He just had good taste. We're gonna get into that a little a little bit later, but to wrap up Forum, it was fun to hear you guys talk about this and what came out of an intense back and forth between Sondheim and George Abbott and Jerome Robbins that led to Forum being the way it is.

[11:15] Jess: Maybe that's the real reason Sondheim related to Syrod.

[11:19] Juliet Antonio: Fantastic.

[11:21] Jess: Fantastic.

[11:22] Juliet Antonio: Oh my gosh. I love I love these so much. I'm just I'm on the edge of my seat wondering what the next one is.

[11:29] Jess: Um never know. I'm excited.

[11:30] Juliet Antonio: I'm I was on I was on that episode.

[11:32] Liz: Now I'm it now I'm here.

[11:33] Andrew: Yeah.

[11:35] Liz: How'd you feel? I remember you thought that that show was super sexist.

[11:38] Andrew: I don't remember if it was. Um I've reflected on it. It's stupid. I was I was mad only because when I hear sexism initially, I'm like, I hate this. And then I think about the context of the sexes I'm like, nah. He's not he's not a sexist, he's just being doing a parody musical, like just chill. Like I also had fun with it.

[11:58] Liz: Oh, yeah. I also feel like everyone forgets Buster Keaton is in that movie.

[12:01] Andrew: Yeah, yeah.

[12:03] Liz: Oh yeah. One of his last roles. He he's barely a presence, and it feels kind of sad seeing him.

[12:08] Andrew: Yeah, exactly.

[12:11] Liz: Okay. Next one.

[12:13] Andrew: Okay, episode 271, the book thief featuring Lady Knight the Brave.

[12:18] Juliet Antonio: Really?

[12:19] Andrew: Yes.

[12:20] Juliet Antonio: What?

[12:21] Andrew: My reaction was when I first heard when I saw the title on my phone, I was like, they made this a musical. Um, only the West End.

[12:30] Juliet Antonio: So Lydia Nate the Brave was the perfect guest to have. Uh going into detail about the visual medium of theater versus film versus the original novel and what can get lost in translation between each one. Especially in the Gentile Savior narrative when visual elements just don't work, such as the Boxing Puppets.

[12:48] Andrew: And you guys both listened. It was one of the more constructive conversations about West End theater you guys have had on the show, which is why it's on here.

[12:55] Juliet Antonio: But West End Theater's pretty dumb sometimes.

[12:58] Andrew: Oh no, West End Theater is very dumb. It's like there's European theater with France and with Germany, and then there's West End Theater.

[13:05] Liz: With David Hasselhoff.

[13:07] Andrew: Yeah. Go see a play.

[13:09] Liz: Go see a play.

[13:10] Andrew: Go see a play.

[13:11] Liz: Yeah. Um, this is a shock. Um just because that night I just felt so tired and we all were kind of burnt out. It was getting close to like like the November October time, so we're just all so fucking exhausted.

[13:24] Juliet Antonio: So I'm glad that turned into constructive conversation.

[13:28] Andrew: Good. I I couldn't tell that you guys are burnt out, honestly. You guys, you guys troop through it really, really well.

[13:33] Liz: We were professional.

[13:39] Juliet Antonio: Like, it's mid, and then just laugh his ass off.

[13:49] Andrew: Ah, there's the wheez.

[13:50] Liz: Yeah, it's that happened. It's been a while.

[13:53] Juliet Antonio: Um alright, Julia, what's next? What number are we on?

[13:57] Andrew: Alright, let me count. Is this nine, eight, seven, six.

[14:03] Juliet Antonio: Alright, six. So, for number six, we have episode two hundred and thirty-seven, you're a good man, Charlie Brown, featuring Big Beak Entertainment.

[14:11] Andrew: Oh my heart. I love this episode.

[14:14] Juliet Antonio: This one got went to some weird places, I think.

[14:17] Andrew: Oh yeah. Every now and then, a guest comes on the show who fits in perfectly with the musicals with cheese humor and world, and Big Beak is one of them. The humor that the three of you had together with your rapport worked really well. And you guys dove into what make peanuts unique. What works about this musical and what doesn't, and the really interesting casting.

[14:37] Juliet Antonio: We all knew Kristen Chenoweth, but Anthony Rapp, wow. It's another odd mark in Peanuts history and in musical theater history, but I feel like what also really helped with this one, Jess, was the interview you had done with Andrew Lippa years and years ago because it gave some context for this episode. And it was also another one where Andrew's editing skills really shine as Big Beak pretended to be Doug Walker and the channel awesome theme played in the background.

[15:03] Andrew: And Big Beak just rolled with it. It was perfect. I feel like in that episode, didn't I, every single time someone mentioned his name, I think I played it again.

[15:11] Juliet Antonio: Yes, it was fucking hilarious. Um I I love it. And yes, I I'm so glad this made the list. And Big Beak was someone I had wanted. Literally, I was like just salivating at the idea of having him on for like months and months, but too nervous to send out the email. And then when I did, like I I knew, like, oh yeah, you'd fit in perfect here. What was I thinking?

[15:31] Andrew: Absolutely. Um, and then School of Rock was also just as chaotic for different reasons. Um but let's move on.

[15:41] Juliet Antonio: Okay. So alright. Number five, episode two hundred and thirty four. Andrew, you were correct, the frogs.

[15:50] Andrew: Yay!

[15:51] Juliet Antonio: Yay. It finally happened. Andrew was foaming at the mouth and chomping at the bit to cover the frogs. Jess's words were, and I quote, You're selling me on a show I know is bad. Stop it. And lo and behold, Jess was wrong. Listen, is the frogs perfect? No. But this episode showed don't necessarily believe the rumors or the hype. The best way to find out is to see the show for yourself or to listen to the cast album yourself.

[16:20] Andrew: It's another Sondheim work that gets swept under the rug, but in a different way from Forum. Andrew had his finger on the pulse quicker than most hardcore theater fans ever had or ever will have. Yes, I said it, come at me, I don't care. And Andrew, I admire you for sticking to your guns by saying how much you preferred the frogs as a whole over forum with some of the elements of that show. And this shows Jess's point that even if Jess gets bought out, Andrew never can. And your insistence on covering this show made for a perfect episode.

[16:52] Andrew: You know, the only reason I wanted to cover it was because it was called The Frogs, and then when Jess was like, no, it's bad. It's about it's about Dionysus. I was like, wait, I want to cover it more now.

[17:04] Juliet Antonio: Swimming pool.

[17:07] Andrew: Chaos. The swimming pool recordings were hard to find and horrendous.

[17:12] Juliet Antonio: Oh yeah.

[17:14] Andrew: But Meryl Streep is one of the ensemble members in that swimming pool production.

[17:19] Juliet Antonio: Amazing. Amazing. Um, yeah, the frogs. I that is secretly one of my favorite Sondheim now. So Yes, I was wrong.

[17:27] Andrew: Hey, there you go. I wonder if Meryl is that on her resume, that would be interesting to know.

[17:31] Juliet Antonio: I think she brought that up. Like she brings it up quite a bit. Because that's where she met Sondheim and how they had a relationship um when Into the Woods came about.

[17:39] Andrew: Oh, well now you know.

[17:41] Juliet Antonio: Okay. So number four.

[17:45] Juliet Antonio: Number four is episode 254 Trouble in Tahiti.

[17:49] Andrew: I forgot we did that.

[17:52] Juliet Antonio: You're noticing a pattern here where some of your best episodes are one where you discuss composers' lesser known works. And I think the only Bernstein musical you've covered so far is West Side's story along with his reference a reference to his Peter Pan and your Peter Pan episode. And it was fascinating to hear the context of the story especially when the Fablements had come out around the same time.

[18:13] Andrew: There's also another pattern I've noticed where the opera episodes of musicals with cheese are some of the best and you guys aren't snoots about it. It's clear opera isn't your you know your normal cup of tea every day but you don't go shitting on it just because it's like you know highbrow classical music. Interesting that I'm saying that after you guys just talked about tar today.

[18:32] Juliet Antonio: Um but also plus Jess's story about seeing this show was the cherry on top remind me of what it was I don't remember I know it was funny.

[18:43] Andrew: I remember the episode it's a teaser.

[18:46] Juliet Antonio: Yeah listen if I don't episode yeah yeah listen to the episode you'll never find out here we're not going to give it away oh yes we have very good memories here.

[18:56] Andrew: Yes um I'm so grateful for you Juliet I I I'm I'm glad you love that episode because that was very personal show to me I listened to it a lot um and I picked out every every playing of Trouble in Tahiti in Maestro and they play it a good amount.

[19:10] Juliet Antonio: Oh wow really when they cut to just him existing on life it's just like Zoobidoo Wap Wap, whatever that song is.

[19:19] Andrew: Okay, that's good.

[19:20] Juliet Antonio: Yeah. Um, Andrew, anything?

[19:23] Andrew: Uh I remember liking this show and thinking it was a weird thing to cover, but I think we need to do more opera.

[19:30] Juliet Antonio: Yeah. I try to squeeze it in every now and then. Um, Julia, what's next?

[19:36] Juliet Antonio: Alright, number three, episode two hundred and thirty-two, the music man revival.

[19:41] Andrew: Oh boy.

[19:45] Juliet Antonio: Let me take you back to when this was announced on theater Twitter. The rage.

[19:49] Andrew: The rage.

[19:50] Juliet Antonio: Ametso taking a classic soprano role in a world where sopranos are an endangered species and will soon be locked in a room screaming glitter and be gay. A man who snuggles up with fascists for a lead and an abusive producer who killed Beetlejuice. The lackluster reviews were delicious.

[20:07] Andrew: You could have easily just done a nostalgia critic-esque rant about everything that was appallingly wrong about this production, and we would have been cheering, to be honest. But instead, you took the more critical road, and we have a better episode for it. You went into detail about why this was a slap in the face to the original. I'm not even a fan of the original, and I was offended on Meredith Wilson's behalf.

[20:29] Juliet Antonio: You also had some iconic musicals with cheese moments, such as Andrew editing in Band Geeks from SpongeBob to show why Robert Preston could do donuts around Hugh any day. And also sparking the brilliant idea of a gender-bent revival, which led to incredible fan art by I believe Captain Rodastic, an incredible episode. I love this episode so much.

[20:49] Andrew: That was one of my best edits, I think.

[20:51] Juliet Antonio: I agree. I I think I sent that to Jess and said I'll never talk to you.

[20:56] Andrew: You literally did.

[20:58] Juliet Antonio: I think I was like one of like your first like five edits. Like it was very early on in your rhyme.

[21:01] Andrew: I still don't think I've topped it though. That's that's one of my best edits.

[21:06] Juliet Antonio: I don't know. The Brigadoo uh Dune Columbo edit.

[21:09] Andrew: Um okay that was that one's pretty good too. Sometimes you just have material that just lends itself to something and then other times I'm just like I got nothing here.

[21:17] Juliet Antonio: I think Jess told me a while ago that he for a video he wanted me to make a video out of the music man episode and I never got working on that.

[21:26] Andrew: So if you're interested in that Yeah hit Liz Eston up on that it's number three in the top ten.

[21:34] Juliet Antonio: Yeah. We might.

[21:35] Andrew: Um yeah but we got two more to go and I I could shit on Hugh Jackman all night truly um I can pretend to laugh too um but let's just move on.

[21:47] Juliet Antonio: Number two, episode 259, the Pee-wee Herman Show Okay, let's go the timing of this one was everything given how soon it came out after Paul Rubin's passing.

[22:01] Andrew: If you had covered it at any other time in the show's history, then it wouldn't have done as well because of the emotional impact it would have been lost.

[22:09] Juliet Antonio: And we have the juxtaposition of the two of you perfectly Jess is the childhood fan with nostalgia and Andrew is rediscovering Pee Wee Herman and learning about the franchise and the man. This is also a good episode because we get to see Jess embrace your inner child and be genuinely happy even when screaming after the secret word of the day.

[22:27] Andrew: This is also because it was cheese and it was like oh god I know when they say keeper the cheese he's gonna scream and it's like oh I would rather you do ASMR for my name every single day.

[22:37] Juliet Antonio: Anyway this is also another episode where we get a pretty good and thorough timeline as we track Paul Rubens's career and it also cleared up a lot of the scandal surrounding Paul Rubens for me as well.

[22:48] Andrew: I'm grateful.

[22:49] Juliet Antonio: I love that episode. And I I knew I that was like one of the ones where it's like, I know it's not a musical, but I I my soul needs this more than like actually I think this belongs on the show.

[23:00] Andrew: So I'm I'm glad you liked it.

[23:02] Juliet Antonio: I really am.

[23:04] Juliet Antonio: I thought that was a very good episode when we recorded it. So I'm glad it's on here. I think we paired it with Ride, which is a much less good episode because I committed to the bit in a different way. Um, I think that episode is interesting just because you are actually riding a bike the entire time. That was a risk. I don't think that one paid off.

[23:25] Andrew: How'd your body feel the next day?

[23:27] Juliet Antonio: Oh, it felt fine. I do that. Uh, how about top one worst episodes? Was it that?

[23:34] Andrew: I would be interested in what the worst episode of the year is.

[23:37] Juliet Antonio: Um, yeah, there's like a tie for 50. Um, I will say, I forgot to say this in the opening. When Jess said, hey, can you put together a list for 2023? I said, yeah. And I texted him, this is the quickest I've ever done a list, and he's like, why were all the episodes that bad this year? And I forgot to tell him, no, it was because I was actually marking it in the spreadsheet as I went along this year, so that's why it took a quick time to put together, not because of quality.

[24:07] Andrew: Garbage emoji.

[24:08] Juliet Antonio: Smart.

[24:09] Andrew: Garbage.

[24:11] Juliet Antonio: It's respect on that name. Alright, Juliet. We built it up. What is our number one episode of 2023?

[24:18] Juliet Antonio: Okay, let me first of all say, I don't think you'll ever do an episode like this again.

[24:23] Andrew: Oh.

[24:24] Juliet Antonio: Um, but we'll get into it when I reveal it. Number one of 2023 is episode 230. A Star is Born.

[24:32] Andrew: All of them.

[24:34] Juliet Antonio: Okay. The moment I first heard this episode, I knew it would be number one of the year because what a behemoth. The two of you watched all four films and were able to weave together a chronological narrative about the history of the Star is Born franchise. And that included tiny details such as how the name of the male lead evolved over the years. I was thoroughly impressed. The research paid off, and I think given this film's place in film history and the pop culture zeitgeist, you had to do it justice. And as I said, I don't think you'll ever come close to doing an episode that's about more than one version of the same musical. I mean, the only one I can think of is Rogers and Hammerstein's Cinderella, but that's about it.

[25:21] Andrew: And because this was a truly once in a blue moon episode that you pulled off so well, I gave this the number one for the year.

[25:30] Juliet Antonio: Understandable. I love this episode too. Um, I knew it was a behemoth at the time. I think because I paired it with Anastasia, which Andrew and I saw months ago, so I just knew that we had the time and I was gonna take advantage of that. Um, yeah, I love that episode. I remember all the cramming, all the research. That one was another one my soul needed. I'm pretty sure I had to, and I didn't have to, I guess, but there's a part near the end where we talk about each version, and I edit in like them saying kind of the same line from each version. That took me so long to find the line in each version and then edit it into every single section.

[26:10] Andrew: Um, so yeah, the editing on that one was, uh, that took me probably six hours.

[26:16] Juliet Antonio: Yeah. And I do want to say, Andrew, that is the third episode of Musicals with Cheese you ever edited.

[26:21] Andrew: Yeah.

[26:22] Juliet Antonio: So you've, you gave me a tough one right away.

[26:25] Andrew: And you set up your own style.

[26:26] Juliet Antonio: I like you kind of did your own thing for Blue's Clues and Little Mermaid.

[26:30] Andrew: But Star is Born is really where your Andrew DeWolf style came to be, I think.

[26:35] Juliet Antonio: And the show got a lot more memey and quippy.

[26:39] Andrew: Which I personally love.

[26:40] Juliet Antonio: It depends on the other.

[26:41] Andrew: I was about to say.

[26:42] Juliet Antonio: I have two different styles. I feel like if our episodes are more informative or we have a guest, I kind of let it rock. Um, but then there's other episodes where we go off the rails, and so I bring the editing off the rails for those too.

[26:57] Juliet Antonio: Um, alright. Were there any big honorable mentions on there for you?

[27:03] Andrew: Not at that point. I mean, I think any honorable mentions that I had, I ended up taking off the list just so I could focus on the top ten. So if there are, and if I've forgotten them, I'm sorry, but I will say, um, and I always say this every year. If you're a guest and your episode was not featured this year, this is nothing against the guests. All the guests in 2023 were wonderful, and I loved all the people that you had on this year.

[27:25] Juliet Antonio: You know what? I think they're terrible. Never invited on again.

[27:26] Andrew: Didn't make the top ten, you're gone.

[27:30] Juliet Antonio: Big beacon loan, you're the only one that's coming back.

[27:35] Andrew: Oh, not over the last episode.

[27:37] Juliet Antonio: Well, the five timers club was good while it lasted.

[27:40] Andrew: Yep.

[27:41] Juliet Antonio: Uh, fuck you, sideways, you're gone!

[27:44] Andrew: Big B.

[27:45] Juliet Antonio: Okay, what was wrong with School of Rock?

[27:47] Andrew: I thought that was a great episode.

[27:49] Juliet Antonio: It's the mostly the hour that no one else heard.

[27:52] Andrew: Oh, yes.

[27:53] Juliet Antonio: That was the best hour of the episode.

[27:54] Andrew: I know, right?

[27:55] Juliet Antonio: It was the best. And you had to cut it out.

[27:57] Andrew: You had to cut it out.

[27:58] Juliet Antonio: There was literally no other option. We couldn't release that.

[28:01] Andrew: We could not release that, but my god, was it some of the funniest things on this podcast?

[28:08] Juliet Antonio: The School of Rock episode is why you should become a patron.

[28:10] Andrew: That is, that's the one.

[28:11] Juliet Antonio: It literally is.

[28:12] Andrew: Yeah.

[28:12] Juliet Antonio: Join the Patreon and you will get to hear all of that in its unfiltered glory. I think it's a difference between like an hour and five minute podcast and a two-hour podcast. Like it is.

[28:21] Andrew: I cut so much out of that, and I felt bad about it because I was like, this is the funniest part of the whole episode.

[28:29] Juliet Antonio: But like it couldn't stay.

[28:34] Andrew: Juliet, that is a wonderful list. I understand every one of them, and I'm so grateful that you listened to every one of our episodes. When we started this, we didn't dream that like three people would listen to this. And if they did, they only listened to one episode. And you've listened to everyone, and that's so wonderful.

[28:50] Juliet Antonio: And I'm not sure. Since you were in video format.

[28:53] Andrew: Oh god.

[28:54] Juliet Antonio: Since episode zero.

[28:56] Andrew: I no, no, Jess, you know how far back this goes? I was listening to you when I was in middle school and you were XX World XX.

[29:06] Andrew: I have been there for years.

[29:10] Juliet Antonio: That's cringe.

[29:11] Andrew: I'm sorry you experienced cringe.

[29:14] Juliet Antonio: Until Jess the first time I like I met him, and he was like, that's this exact response.

[29:18] Andrew: Yeah, I was in those videos.

[29:20] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, he was.

[29:21] Andrew: No one remembers that, but you were.

[29:23] Juliet Antonio: I was in them.

[29:25] Andrew: Huh, that's interesting.

[29:26] Juliet Antonio: Okay.

[29:27] Andrew: No one will ever see.

[29:28] Juliet Antonio: They're all gone.

[29:28] Andrew: They're worth it.

[29:29] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, they're all gone. No, no, nobody go looking for them.

[29:32] Andrew: But I was Jeff, the stormtrooper.

[29:37] Juliet Antonio: Oh, okay. Um, don't go looking for them.

[29:40] Andrew: Um, we ready for cheese?

[29:42] Juliet Antonio: I'm ready for cheese.

[29:43] Andrew: Get us off this topic.

[29:45] Juliet Antonio: Alright. So, we're gonna do Jess, Andrew, Guests, and Liz.

[29:49] Andrew: Okay.

[29:50] Juliet Antonio: Jess, your best cheese rating of the year was from The Book Thief, where you gave the show The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Tales, because it was cheese, and you had actually stolen the book.

[30:00] Jess: Yep.

[30:00] Juliet Antonio: That tracks. Um, out of context, that would be a really offensive thing, but I'm glad you could put that back in its context.

[30:08] Jess: Exactly, of course.

[30:10] Juliet Antonio: Andrew.

[30:11] Andrew: Oh boy.

[30:12] Juliet Antonio: Your top cheese rating for the year was, I already referenced it, Cheeto's Fantastics Flaming Lot from The Music Man.

[30:20] Andrew: It was perfect.

[30:21] Juliet Antonio: That's from The Fantastics, wasn't it?

[30:23] Andrew: Yep, exactly.

[30:25] Juliet Antonio: And for the guests, the best cheese rating for the guests overall, making this the second time they've been featured on this list in this capacity, is Brent Black for Con the Musical with the green cheese the moon is made of.

[30:41] Andrew: Brilliant.

[30:42] Juliet Antonio: Iconic.

[30:43] Andrew: Oh, Brent. We gotta have him on again, but we don't have nine hours.

[30:47] Juliet Antonio: Um, get him and big in a room and watch everything explode.

[30:55] Andrew: Um, that was lovely.

[30:57] Juliet Antonio: And Liz.

[30:59] Liz: Oh and Liz.

[31:00] Juliet Antonio: Hey, I'm here. For your cumulative cheese rating, I went all the way back. This technically isn't from 2023, but it made me laugh so hard. Your top cheese rating is from The Devil's Carnival and Alleluia, where you had a cheese platter, but it's communion wafers instead of crackers.

[31:17] Liz: Wow.

[31:21] Juliet Antonio: That is absolutely wonderful.

[31:24] Liz: And Juliet.

[31:24] Juliet Antonio: I was raised Catholic. Those traumatized me.

[31:28] Liz: They're always stale and taste like cardboard for...

[31:31] Juliet Antonio: So everybody has been saying, oh wow, I forgot about that one. I forgot about that one. So basically I remember it, so you don't have to.

[31:41] Andrew: God damn.

[31:42] Juliet Antonio: I'm so sorry. God forgive me for what I just said.

[31:45] Andrew: Brown.

[31:46] Juliet Antonio: Brown.

[31:52] Andrew: Meet your nostalgia chick.

[31:55] Juliet Antonio: Oh no.

[31:56] Andrew: Oh no.

[31:57] Juliet Antonio: Oh no.

[31:59] Andrew: Um, we've gotten to that point of the evening where we're just saying words. Juliet, you're one of the best people I've ever met, truly, through this entire experience. You have been nothing but a joy to know as a human being. I am so grateful I get to say your name every week as the person that keeps track of this. You are amazing and you are so talented and promote your stuff for the world to find you.

[32:18] Juliet Antonio: Okay, on Twitter, I am Juliet Thespiet. On Instagram, I am Aurora99. I have a show on YouTube called My Dad Listens to This, where Dad and I review albums in his music collection. We just wrapped up season five with Those Straight Jackets, and we are starting season six with the irresistible Kathy Dennis. And if you've been listening for a while and wonder why Jess whispers my name at the end of every episode, it's because I write ASMR roleplay and romance and erotica for voice actors such as Dade Audio, Darien Audio, Eastgate Audio, and Mr. Foxhound. I have been taking a break from writing those scripts because I'm currently doing The Prom at East End Theater in Rhode Island. But I have some scripts from Mr. Fox that are going to be coming in their way down the pipeline, so you can definitely expect some romantic and spicy content in 2024. And that's all I got.

[33:08] Andrew: Who did the best ASMR of the year?

[33:13] Juliet Antonio: I figured.

[33:16] Andrew: And there was one, there was one more person who also did it really, really well.

[33:20] Juliet Antonio: I can't, I can't remember it, but if I think of it, I'll let you know.

[33:23] Andrew: But yeah.

[33:24] Juliet Antonio: Was it Laura Crohn that you mentioned?

[33:25] Andrew: Oh, Laura Crown does this.

[33:27] Juliet Antonio: Is the best ASMR in the Discord.

[33:28] Andrew: Grace and Laura.

[33:30] Juliet Antonio: Yes, they're the top two. Like when I say, when I legitimately say they could have a career being ASMR voice actors, I'm not just saying that to flatter them. They literally sound like some of the actors I've had to work with before. So hey, if they were on next year, paycheck, the internet's open.

[33:44] Andrew: Heck yeah.

[33:45] Juliet Antonio: The internet's open for all of us and all of our voices.

[33:48] Andrew: Yes.

[33:49] Juliet Antonio: Thank you so much again, Juliet. You are amazing. And thank you for listening. And hopefully, we'll have some more fun things coming up this year that'll make another top ten list. Um, and sometime we gotta do all out of all 300 episodes a proper top ten.

[34:04] Andrew: Um boy.

[34:08] Juliet Antonio: We'll see you next time, guys.

[34:11] Andrew: Bye-bye.

[34:12] All: Bye everybody.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred