Skip to main content
BPN Logo
DEAR FRIENDS PREVIEW: "The Music Man & Golden Age Revivals"

This is an episode of the new and improved Dear Friends Podcast featuring Emily Clark, Christi Esterle, and Jesse McAnally. We're trying new things in 2022, we're going to be switching up our format. Today we're talking about The Music Man and Golden Age Musical Revivals!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

29 mins
1/17/22

Guests

Featured Shows

About

This is an episode of the new and improved Dear Friends Podcast featuring Emily Clark, Christi Esterle, and Jesse McAnally. We're trying new things in 2022, we're going to be switching up our format. Today we're talking about The Music Man and Golden Age Musical Revivals!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Emily Clark: Dear friends.

[0:02] Christi Esterle: Hi, I'm dear friend Emily.

[0:05] Jesse McAnally: I'm dearer friend Christy.

[0:07] Emily Clark: And I'm dearest friend Jeff. And welcome to Dear Friends, a writing advice podcast for the musical minded.

[0:12] Christi Esterle: How are you guys doing today?

[0:13] Jesse McAnally: Happy New Year, everyone.

[0:15] Emily Clark: Yes, happy 2022.

[0:18] Christi Esterle: It's a whole week into it and we haven't completely fucked it up yet.

[0:21] Jesse McAnally: So yeah, yeah.

[0:24] Christi Esterle: It's exactly right. Like last year at this time we had an insurrection.

[0:29] Emily Clark: So as long as we don't have like full on the street, now we just have now we just have a plague.

[0:35] Christi Esterle: So just plague last week.

[0:39] Jesse McAnally: But when it's only the plague to deal with, it's just like a little bit more manageable.

[0:44] Emily Clark: Well, as they say on the internet, it's a new year, new me, and that goes for the Dear Friends podcast too. And we're changing things up because you know what? We're allowed to do that. We're allowed to be different. And from now on, we're basically gonna have one writing question per episode. So it doesn't make it any less special, but it makes it more special.

[1:03] Christi Esterle: Um so this week we have from Alexandrian Walla Walla, Washington, who writes in asking, dear friends, with the new production of The Music Man hitting Broadway and people having a lot to say about it. Is there a place for golden age musical revivals on Broadway nowadays? And where do they fit in our modern discourse?

[1:23] Jesse McAnally: Of course there is. The good shows, the good courses are always gonna be good. We're not too far removed from Oklahoma that fucks, so yeah. If we can still do like feasibly like plays by the ancient Greeks, then of course we can find a place for Shakespeare and I said and of course, the good stuff stays good.

[1:45] Christi Esterle: And um, yeah, the Oklahoma revival was a really um, I think it's going to be kind of like a, I don't know, like a catalyst or a linchpin for people to stop treating these golden age shows as so precious. I mean, they are precious, but like taking what's good about them and then trying something new with them.

[2:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Again, like we do with Shakespeare all the time.

[2:06] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and I think, you know, part of that is, you know, we have to recognize that this uh the golden age musicals, especially were the popular entertainment at the time. So it was designed to fit to pop to the popular tastes and you know, perspectives of the time.

[2:23] Jesse McAnally: And yeah, a lot of those perspectives have changed quite a lot. So yeah, and there's some golden age musicals that I think lend themselves to being played with and adapted. And then there's some shows like I would argue like The Music Man, which is like almost kind of perfect as is. I don't really know you could do subtle stuff, but to me, like completely changing stuff about it, like they're kind of doing with this for seemingly no rhyme or reason, except we've got celebrities and we're gonna cater to the celebrities, right? That's not a good enough reason.

[2:59] Christi Esterle: There's a lot I want to talk about um with this. And I think because they framed it in the comparison of the Music Man revival, how about we start there? Um, what is going on with his new Music Man revival? It's been nothing but a myriad of controversies and issues from day one.

[3:15] Jesse McAnally: And the more you hear about it, the less interested most of us feel in it.

[3:19] Christi Esterle: Well, let's start with Scott Rudin.

[3:21] Jesse McAnally: Yep. I mean, you know, that's a big problem is that he's, you know, one of the the one of the driving produ uh producing forces behind this. And he has yeah, he has issues. If you are in uh if you've been following theater at all in the past couple of years, you know very well that this is this is a pretty toxic guy.

[3:42] Christi Esterle: And so there is that baggage, and you know, the added baggage that I think you know, um Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster, you know, had the chance to you know kind of speak out or say something on this, and they didn't, because you know they've got this revival that they're doing, so there's that going on, and yeah.

[4:03] Jesse McAnally: I I feel like there are two camps because and and they're not pleasing anybody, like there's the people who don't like The Music Man, and there are just people who don't like The Music Man, and there are people who think it represents like a old style of musical theater, and that's you know, that's neither here nor there.

[4:18] Christi Esterle: But there are people who already like I don't I don't want to see the show, and then there's people like me who like love The Music Man, and every choice they make that I've seen, I haven't obviously I haven't seen the show yet, right? But every choice they keep putting out there, like look at this, and they're promoting on their socials, like, can you believe this? Every time I see it, I go, why? What why why? Why were these choices made?

[4:45] Jesse McAnally: Right. I I just did like a huge rant on TikTok about this, but the thing that kind of drives me the most crazy is that apparently they're lowering all the keys for Sutton and throwing in tap numbers for her. And to me, it's like there are soprano celebrities. Why don't we have Audra McDonald? Why don't we have Audra McDonald as Mary and Laura Benanti or Lara Bonon? Or Kelly O'Hara, or there's so many Jesse Mueller, she just did it with Norm Lewis a few years ago.

[5:14] Christi Esterle: Thank you. I I'm like, why can't we just have a soprano do it? And why in God's name is button up Mousie Marion the librarian tap dancing and like marching with the band at the end? Like she's part of the band. I'm like, this why are we just completely changing the character? Oh, because Sutton.

[5:35] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and well, that's part of her arc is that she kind of comes out of her show. Like, you know, when she we when she dances with Hill in Shippy, that's kind of like a That's a big moment.

[5:44] Christi Esterle: Yeah, that is a big moment. But yeah, that's not that's not her character. She's not a song and dance character. She's very much that. She needs to go on an arc in the show. She has to be a foil to Harold Hill. Harold is zippy fast power. He needs that element that she provides, just like he does the same. That's why their big song, "76 Trombones" and "Goodnight, My Someone" are the same song in different time signatures. Like they're meant to be like two sides of the same coin. Like they need each other.

[6:13] Jesse McAnally: And then it's like, why am I just watching, couldn't Sutton just play Harold Hill? Because that sounds more right to me. That seems more right to me.

[6:20] Christi Esterle: Yeah. Speaking of things that they've changed for no reason. Um Hugh Jackman, once again, they slowed down "Trouble," as our good friend uh Tommy from Musical MASH had pointed out. Um, from 120 beats per minute to around 110 beats per minute. What the hell is that being?

[6:36] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I don't know. And it's like, I, you know, I would have thought that I would have thought Hugh Jackman could do it all tempo. I don't know what the heck they're doing there.

[6:45] Christi Esterle: I he the greatest showman was his Music Man audition. I remember seeing that movie and going, he's auditioning for Harold Hill right now. He wants to play Harold Hill so effing bad. And at the time, I remember being like, not a bad choice. Not a bad choice.

[7:01] Jesse McAnally: Um I could see it. He obviously has the Broadway creds, so he's one of those movie stars when he does a musical, you're kind of like, well, I'll allow it. You started your career doing this. It makes sense.

[7:11] Christi Esterle: Um but like you got "Trouble." It's I I do it faster. I've done it faster with high schoolers and middle schoolers. Why is it, and why are they doing little choreography?

[7:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah, why is yeah, and it's not even fun choreography. It's the choreography that everybody does with the gospel hands. It's like, okay, I think that's what bothers me is that you know, you're doing this, you're reviving this classic show, and it's like, okay, you know, I've seen this before.

[7:40] Christi Esterle: And you know what? Here's another thing now that I think about it. In The Music Man, the first people who start like dance dancing, it's like footloose, right? It's the teens. The teens are the ones who are the first ones who start doing it. The kids start marching with Harold Hill, then they're in the auditorium, and they they start kind of dancing and getting excited. He's the one who leads them into dancing.

[8:00] Jesse McAnally: And then you have Marion the Librarian, where all the teens are, you know, it grows gradually through the show.

[8:05] Christi Esterle: Right. The first time you meet the Iowans or the River Citiesians, they are like standing stock still singing, "Oh, There's Nothing Halfway."

[8:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Why would they all of a sudden be doing choreography in like the third number in the show when we've established these people don't like dancing? Um, and and and Harold Hill uses dog whistle code words like ragtime to freak them out. Why would they be dancing? It's just a it's just a directorial choice that I don't, I don't like. I don't like it.

[8:32] Christi Esterle: Yeah. And I think, you know, that's another angle that they're, you know, they're not examining as much, is that how you know, this kind of hidebound, um, you know, provincial, you know, group of people are gradually broken out of that mindset. Because um, you know, you in the first act, you have like the old biddies who are like, oh, Marion, she was in this relationship with old man with Miser Madison, and she reads dirty books. And then, like in the second half, they're like, We read all the books and they're fantastic. There's like an arc.

[9:07] Jesse McAnally: And it's reflected in the music and in the choreography. And like, I to me, it's everything I hate about people who just kind of go, that's an old musical, just do whatever you want. It's like Meredith Wilson did not write the book, music, and score, and go in-depth and mo make everything completely motivated for you to just throw this shit in because there's old people in the audience who are like, oh wee, I remember the ship poopy. Like there's a context for everything, like in these shows, and it drives me crazy.

[9:39] Christi Esterle: And I just don't like it any of the choices they've thrown out there yet. Harry Hugh Jackman should be able to handle a faster "You Got Trouble."

[9:49] Jesse McAnally: Exactly. I mean, what the heck is going on?

[9:52] Christi Esterle: I don't know. What do you think, Jess?

[9:55] Emily Clark: Another sip of wine. I want to transition into things that I'm sure you guys don't know about, but I want your opinion on.

[10:02] Christi Esterle: Okay.

[10:03] Jesse McAnally: Listening.

[10:04] Emily Clark: Are we aware of the changes made to the book and lyrics in this new revival?

[10:09] Christi Esterle: I've heard something along the lines, but please refresh my memory.

[10:12] Emily Clark: What did they do?

[10:14] Okay. First of all, um, they altered the lyrics to "Shipoopy." Basically rewrote the entire story.

[10:20] Christi Esterle: Okay, yeah, I heard this. That was that's stupid. That's dumb.

[10:25] Emily Clark: Do you guys want to hear what some of the lyrics sound like?

[10:28] Christi Esterle: Oh, just for the sake of the audience, please.

[10:31] Emily Clark: Alright. So the original lyrics were woman who kissed on a very state is usually a hussy, and the woman who's gonna be a big thing. And a woman who'll kiss on the second time around is anything but fussy.

[10:41] Christi Esterle: Yeah, the woman will kiss on the third time around, head in the clouds. Head in the clouds, feet out on the ground.

[10:46] Emily Clark: Yeah. I mean, it's I I it's it's dumb, but like, yeah, it's about a girl, it's about a girl playing hard to get and not see out on the first date.

[10:54] Christi Esterle: Okay, so give me your new ones.

[10:55] Emily Clark: Are we ready?

[10:56] Christi Esterle: Yeah.

[10:56] Emily Clark: Alright. Here's here's the new intro. Well, a fellow who goes on his very first date is usually shy and fretful, and a fellow who tries for more than a kiss would end up something dreadful.

[11:06] Christi Esterle: And then it keeps going on for the next one.

[11:09] Emily Clark: For that. Are you ready for the chorus?

[11:11] Christi Esterle: Yeah.

[11:11] Emily Clark: Um shipoopy, shapoopy, shapoopy. The boy who tries his best. She poopy, shapoopy shapoopy. The past the lady's test. Um the boy who's seen the light, to treat a woman right, the girl you can't forget, but you can win her yet.

[11:24] Christi Esterle: Those are the new Wait, so a Shapoopy is a boy now?

[11:28] Emily Clark: Yep. A Sha Poopy is like a fine gentleman caller.

[11:32] Christi Esterle: Yep. Apparently, we needed to take this fun song about flirting and courtship and just silly. The silly irreverent opening act number and make it relevant.

[11:44] Jesse McAnally: Like, do we not realize that Meredith Wilson was writing this show in the 50s about a time that was nostalgic in the 50s?

[11:55] Christi Esterle: It's like it's supposed to be stup.

[11:59] Jesse McAnally: It sounds like some it sounds like a silly song that they would sing in the 1910s. Also, why bother? Like, why bother? It's not described, it's why even bother.

[12:08] Christi Esterle: It's the shipy.

[12:09] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yes, exactly. Oh, I hate it.

[12:11] Christi Esterle: It has exactly I said this when I was reviewing um the Matthew Broderick um uh remake, which you know has been around.

[12:18] Jesse McAnally: And they changed lyrics.

[12:19] Christi Esterle: They didn't change the lyrics, but um, you know, it has exactly one job, and it's to be, you know, a fun song and dance number.

[12:28] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[12:28] Christi Esterle: Yeah. Okay, we got more guys. Don't think that's it.

[12:32] Emily Clark: So they changed um the Satterball Weiser Girls lyrics to my dog.

[12:40] Christi Esterle: That's and they made it a full dance number.

[12:43] Emily Clark: So they changed the lyrics so they can make it a proper dance number between um uh Marcellus and Harold Hill.

[12:50] Christi Esterle: Okay, Satterball Weiser Girl actually has a great message.

[12:54] Jesse McAnally: I mean, it's wrapped up in like this language, but he's saying I don't care if he's like, I want a girl with experience.

[13:00] Christi Esterle: Yeah.

[13:01] Jesse McAnally: And it's a great song.

[13:03] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and the whole point is that, you know, Harold Hill is at this point where you know, he thinks this is what he wants, but then he realizes what he wants is Marion.

[13:13] Jesse McAnally: So it's not like it's not like Meredith Wilson was saying was writing this and saying, Yep, relationship goals. He knew what he was doing.

[13:21] Christi Esterle: Harold Hill has an arc. They have an arc.

[13:24] Jesse McAnally: He's he goes from singing that to singing "Till There Was You."

[13:28] Christi Esterle: Uh uh so okay, wait, so what is what is he saying in Satter but Wiser?

[13:32] Jesse McAnally: So, like, what are they?

[13:33] Christi Esterle: I do not have any ex I I think they might have had a little bit of the lyrics from have you guys ever heard the Seth McFarland cover?

[13:40] Jesse McAnally: No.

[13:41] Christi Esterle: No.

[13:42] Emily Clark: They add another verse into it. It's alright. It's an addition rather than a change, if that makes sense.

[13:48] Christi Esterle: And I think that might just be what they do, just to give more dancing breaks into it.

[13:53] Jesse McAnally: Um and to kind of recontextualize it.

[13:55] Christi Esterle: I don't, I don't mind I think they kind of do wait.

[13:58] Emily Clark: I'm th I'm trying to think of the movie. They don't do a dance break, they do that little shuffle off the street.

[14:02] Christi Esterle: There's like a little bit where Marcellus didn't.

[14:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah. Marcellus kind of like does, you know, this silly, you know, 40 girl walk.

[14:09] Christi Esterle: It's there's like a little 16 bar, you know, not even 16 bars, it's like eight bars or something where they do something.

[14:15] Jesse McAnally: They shuffle off to Buffalo again or something.

[14:18] Christi Esterle: But um I I don't even really mind an extended dance break in it. It's more the idea of changing the lyrics because those are really good lyrics, man.

[14:28] Jesse McAnally: They're so clever and yeah.

[14:30] Christi Esterle: God damn.

[14:32] Jesse McAnally: That bums me out.

[14:34] Christi Esterle: For no Diana, do I play Fawn.

[14:37] Jesse McAnally: I love that line.

[14:38] Christi Esterle: For Hester to win just one more A.

[14:39] Jesse McAnally: Come on.

[14:40] Christi Esterle: Exactly.

[14:41] Jesse McAnally: Thank you.

[14:42] Christi Esterle: Um so Sutton sings the altered version of my white my white night, um, kind of similar to the one that Barbara Cook sang at Carnegie Hall, which was a little faster.

[14:50] Christi Esterle: Mm-hmm.

[14:51] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[14:52] Emily Clark: Which isn't bad. I guess it is on the minute.

[14:54] Christi Esterle: Yeah.

[14:54] Jesse McAnally: I'm a little bit. Are we ready to talk about the Wontany girls?

[14:57] Emily Clark: Oh, no, this is interesting.

[14:59] Christi Esterle: That's right.

[15:00] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, this is interesting because again, this is one of those things where obviously it was something they would do in the 1910s, but it's really hard to portray it now without people going yikes.

[15:12] Emily Clark: Plus you I think it's it's like two references. You can cut it and be fine.

[15:15] Christi Esterle: Right, yeah.

[15:16] Jesse McAnally: I think something similar happened um in the recent revival of Edwin Drude when they had um Jesse Mueller and uh someone else playing the Indi the um Indian British Indian characters. I'm like, well, yeah, in you know, 19th in like an early 20th century music hall, they would have white people in brown face, but you know, without that context and without explaining, yeah, we shouldn't be doing this. People are just going to go yikes.

[15:40] Emily Clark: You have to walk that line. Anyway, so what what they do, Justin.

[15:45] Jesse McAnally: Anyway. I actually kind of like this. Um, instead, they are now dressed as revolutionary war soldiers. Um and the the they think that the explosion is initially like a false gunshot.

[15:57] Christi Esterle: It's that makes sense.

[15:58] Jesse McAnally: That makes sense.

[15:59] Emily Clark: But that makes sense, and that's the Fourth of July.

[15:59] Christi Esterle: The Fourth of July, everybody's like patriotic and crap.

[16:05] Jesse McAnally: So yeah. And better than civil war soldiers or something. It's and it's that whole Americana thing um with the idolization of the revolution and the founding fathers. That really fits in with um the whole mood of the show.

[16:18] Emily Clark: Yeah. And the final thing, and this is the just the me thing, they cut the overture except for like a minute of 76 trombones. No whistle at the beginning, just they play 76 trombones and Rock Island.

[16:31] Christi Esterle: We need I'm sorry. But that's a per that's that's a perfect musical to have an overture. It has a great overture.

[16:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I mean, there's it's a show about a marching band. Why not show off yip yep?

[16:44] Emily Clark: Yeah. But this drives the question that we're asking here. Golden Age musicals, it's either you don't change enough and then it doesn't work to modern audiences, or you change too much where the originalists like us are like, what no? Come on.

[16:59] Christi Esterle: That's great.

[17:01] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I think it depends on the show. I think, like, for example, a show like Gypsy keeps getting revived every like 10 years or so, and you really don't need to change there's been nothing really different about any of those Broadway remote.

[17:18] Emily Clark: I think they just that's something that that the I I call it Mama Rose, who cares?

[17:23] Christi Esterle: I know, I think it's I think it's probably a situation where like what everyone who wrote it is dead, so uh probably estates are gonna have to have a little conversation.

[17:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and part of it. Yeah, yeah, and part of it is yes, um Rose, you know, Louise used that word in her stage name. So um it's a slur, even in the context of the music. We're going to have to, we're going to have to address that.

[17:45] Emily Clark: But you know, yeah, it's it makes it really awkward. It's like, you know, and it it's not exactly something we can drop from the canon. It is literally one of the greatest musicals of all time, with you know, one of the best mature female roles ever.

[17:58] Christi Esterle: So yeah, playing playing, um, and then yeah, like the fact that it was written by um, you know, Gypsy Rosalie, like it it it's tough. It's very tough.

[18:08] Jesse McAnally: It's it's I'm not saying there's an easy answer, and I think it's good that we're at this place right now where we can start having that conversation about that because even a couple of years ago, like this wasn't even a thing.

[18:20] Emily Clark: But right, that aside, you know, that's that's uh that's a word change that you can change. Yeah, other than that, the book, the show itself, you could just keep doing it the same and people kind of keep doing it the same, and we love it if you have a good idea.

[18:33] Christi Esterle: There's a timelessness, there's a timelessness to it.

[18:37] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um yeah, on the other hand, we'd have to think about it. I guess the sound of music is one you could sound of music could probably do forever.

[18:47] Emily Clark: You don't need to I mean it's kids running away from Nazis. How can you not cheer from that?

[18:51] Christi Esterle: Yeah, yeah. The problem with the Sound of Music show is that the movie is significantly better structurally. Like, I that's that's the feeling I feel anytime I show anyone the Sound of Music stage show as opposed to them who are used to the movie, they're like, the movie just kind of works better.

[19:05] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I mean West Side Story, the film of West Side's story, the 61 adaptation, and obviously the new one, um, are arguably better in my opinion than the better structured than the stage version. But with the sound of music, again, you could still see it on stage and pretty much as is, and it's except other than like a few song movements and you know the beefing up of the Baroness and Max and no way to stop it, it. It's pretty much the same.

[19:30] Christi Esterle: Um, you know, some new added songs. Actually, I think sometimes sometimes don't they add the movie songs into the stage version?

[19:38] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yeah.

[19:39] Christi Esterle: But the lonely goadard being in the place of uh favorite things and favorite things being with the mother out of I don't like those. Those are big ones I really just don't like.

[19:51] Jesse McAnally: Um I'm sure there's more if I could yeah. I mean, okay, here's a question to be posed. What golden age musical do you think could hit with a Broadway audience? And we're talking about that just because that's the network we're on. I know that they fit much better in community theaters. But which one do you think we could bring to Broadway and it be a success? And what changes would need to be done to those shows?

[20:14] Christi Esterle: It's a good question. I think I would like to see an Oklahoma style subversion of carousel.

[20:22] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, because carousel is what it's I there are major, there are some major problems that could be easily fixed with some cuts, and uh maybe taking a maybe Oklahoma style minimalist version uh style, or just really thinking out of the box with the production because that score is my favorite Rogers and Hammerstein's. It's fantastic, but you know, eventually you get to the point in the book where the heroine says, you know, if a someone who hits you, if someone who loves you hits you, it doesn't hurt. And it's like, okay, we have to deal with this.

[20:57] Emily Clark: Yeah, and so that how do you deal with it? Because even the latest revival kind of just like they just cut that line, and that was their only change.

[21:04] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and the thing is, like, Billy Bigelow isn't supposed to be a good guy. So, so like, how much darker can we go with it? Like I uh the 90s revival, I remember seeing, and I remember that. I was like in high school, I think, and it blew my mind the Audrey Mc No, I was younger than high school because it was like 93 or something. Um, but that one I remember being like blown away by how dark it was, but I think that was because it was the first time I had really seen it on stage. Because even the old movie version, uh, where are they? I've got as dark, and that's just Hollywood at the time.

[21:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, that's true. And I've got I gotta say right now, the ending of Carousel has never completely sat right with me. I mean, Billy, you know, goes back to Earth, he sees his daughter, he keeps screwing up the way he screwed up all during his life, and you know, then he like whispers a few nice ears, it it a few nice words in her ear at graduation, and suddenly everything's cool. I'm like, okay, I don't feel like that's an earned ending.

[21:57] Christi Esterle: I've got a pitch. I've got a pitch for you guys.

[22:00] Jesse McAnally: Alright.

[22:00] Christi Esterle: So here's my pitch for re-revising the ending of carousel. There's a lot to do in the beginning to fix, but here's my pitch. Um, so he does the same thing, he messes up with his daughter again, and the star maker's like, well, I guess it's time to go to hell. He runs away to his daughter, and then I'll just a chance to just try to make amends with her. He says the thing, and then he goes to hell, but he gets to see his daughter go off to a bigger and better world, and that's okay enough with him.

[22:25] Jesse McAnally: I think just the fact that he goes to heaven is really what bothers most people. So if we make it very clear he's going to hell, but he's if I even if you know the idea is you know, he hasn't earned heaven yet, but he's made a start. I think I could live with that.

[22:40] Christi Esterle: Yeah, I I'd like to see, yeah, you I I like to see that stuff cut. Um as I want them to do what they did with Oklahoma, which is lean into the ambiguity of it all a little bit so that every audience member can interpret it the same way. I would actually, I actually don't want a definition of what this afterlife is. I think it would be cool to make everyone in the afterlife a little more ethereal and ambiguous.

[23:07] Emily Clark: And what happens to it's not so much about him going to heaven at the end as it is maybe about her having ha I don't know, feeling a little bit better. Um have enclosure or something. Um, as someone, you know, my dad wasn't Billy Bigelow levels of shitty, but you know, I had a very I have very complicated relationship with my dad, and he's dead. And there are times where I wish I there are times I wish I could have told him off, and then there's times in my life where I'm like, oh, I wish he was here.

[23:37] Christi Esterle: I think I I think um when it comes to relationships like that, being like, you're the bad guy. It's like how everyone's doing this with Abuela and Encanto right now, and it drives me freaking crazy.

[23:46] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yeah, no, like this is like we're humans. I think what makes it more fascinating is the human ambiguity. It's not like her being like, I miss my shitty dad, I wish he was here. It becomes more about her for whether she doesn't know he's there talking in her ear. It's her being at her graduation and maybe feeling a little bit better. And the powerful moment for me comes from when like she like, I don't know, like she grabs a classmate's hand. Like that stuff is the stuff that sticks with me rather than Billy walking up in the clouds.

[24:14] Christi Esterle: So I think that would be interesting to push that much out. And pushing into like, why is this girl like there's reasons why this girl is so messed up right now. That's like the interesting stuff to me. And I don't think we need to change the fact that Billy's a shitty person or that Julie was kind of in in an abusive relationship. I think that's a good thing. She was in an abusive relationship.

[24:37] Jesse McAnally: And I think that those would be really interesting to explore if just the uh the tone is different. You know, like in the Oklahoma revival, they didn't change a single word of that like courtroom in the living room scene. All they did was change the direction, and it completely changed the tone of the moment. It went from like, come on, you guys, it was an accident. Come on, we gotta do this. They just got married, to them all being like, you saw it. He fell on his own knife. I mean, it happened. Like, come on, we gotta do it It became this thing where the whole town is conspiring about it. Didn't change a word. And I think that's where you could go with it. Because it's such a good book. A lot of those lines you can take a different way by the way.

[25:14] Christi Esterle: I think yeah, I think you know, you could for example, you could play What's the Use of Wonder in Very Dark.

[25:19] Jesse McAnally: Yup.

[25:20] Christi Esterle: Because you know, that's a song that says, you know, this guy sucks, but you're stuck with him. It's sad. It's very simple. It becomes about a domestic abuse cycle, and all you have to do is just go in the direction and maybe do something in how you orchestrate it. I think that would be really fascinating. Um I don't know if every change would work, just like with the Oklahoma revival, but I would like to see someone make the attempt.

[25:43] Jesse McAnally: Cut the clambake song. Alright, you guys.

[25:46] Christi Esterle: The Vittlesley.

[25:48] Jesse McAnally: But don't cut June's busting it all over.

[25:50] Christi Esterle: Oh, June.

[25:52] Jesse McAnally: We gotta have the we gotta have the animals having sex.

[25:56] Christi Esterle: I love June.

[25:57] Jesse McAnally: June June Joan. I think this is a wonderful discussion where we talked about a lot of things. And I don't ever want to lose the DNA of what dear friends is. So I want us all to recommend one of our favorite golden age musical songs to wrap this all up.

[26:11] Christi Esterle: Ooh, good question.

[26:13] Jesse McAnally: Alright, I can go first because this has always been my favorite, and it's the one I come back to. Um, I'm gonna actually recommend two because I I see them as a hand in hand. Um, the carousel waltz is like the best overturn of all time. Oh my goodness. And literally, I could turn that on and listen to the whole thing, and it just makes my day better.

[26:32] Emily Clark: Yeah.

[26:32] Jesse McAnally: Um, anytime if I love you is performed. Not like the trunk kid, like, oh, just the melody. I need the whole 10-minute scene. The whole scene.

[26:40] Christi Esterle: Yeah.

[26:41] Jesse McAnally: Well, if we're not doing the full 10-minute scene, what's the point of putting on this show?

[26:45] Christi Esterle: So good.

[26:46] Jesse McAnally: So those are my two. Uh if I loved you, the full scene and the carousel waltz, because carousel is simultaneously the best and worst golden age musical.

[26:56] Christi Esterle: Yeah.

[26:57] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Christy, what about it?

[26:59] Christi Esterle: Okay, I am gonna go with uh Lonely Room from Oklahoma. It is one of the greatest villain songs of all time, and I think it taps into that ambiguity and complexity that we've been talking about. Because yeah, Judd is not a nice person. He stalks and sexually assaults Lori. At the same time, you know, he's getting a lot of sh a lot of shit receiving a lot on the receiving end of a lot of shit, and that's messed him up. And I think this really taps into you know what motivates him, and it really fleshes the character out.

[27:31] Jesse McAnally: Alright. That's a great I love Lonely Room, it's so good.

[27:33] Christi Esterle: So good.

[27:34] Emily Clark: Uh let's see. Well, I'm gonna go with, since we start with the music man, um, I'm gonna go with a little you got trouble. But um, I'm gonna recommend you listen to Robert Preston and Robert Preston only, maybe Mandy Patinkin. Because I saw Mandy Patinkin do this, and of course it was amazing. I can see him rocking that crazy person, you know.

[27:57] Christi Esterle: Yes, but caveat to mine: do not listen to Mandy Patinkin and Patty Lapone's if I loved you, which is bad.

[28:03] Jesse McAnally: No.

[28:03] Christi Esterle: No.

[28:04] Emily Clark: My friend used to call that show they did together. Remember when they were doing concerts together? He used to call it, he used to call it the battle for Downstage center.

[28:15] Jesse McAnally: I can't think of the two of them together without calling it the battle for Downstage Center.

[28:21] Christi Esterle: Oh I love that.

[28:23] Jesse McAnally: You know what? On that note, anything else we have left to say? Um, you guys want to promote your wonderful work? Christy, Emily?

[28:30] Christi Esterle: I'm at Musical Hell on YouTube, Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook. I've got a Patreon and a red bubble with merch, so check me out.

[28:39] Emily Clark: Uh, yeah, you can find me at Stealing Focus on YouTube, um, musical theater history stuff. And uh, I'm uh Emily A. B. Clark. It looks like Emily Clark on all the socials you can find. And I I host a show called Musicals with Cheese on top of this. It's also on this network. You can find it.

[28:58] Jesse McAnally: Alright. Um, we'll see you guys next time on Dear Friends. Bye!

[29:03] Christi Esterle: Bye bye, dear friends.

[29:06] Emily Clark: Spill your woes to your musical family, dear friends.

[29:11] Christi Esterle: They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom.

[29:18] Jesse McAnally: And an awful icynical world, dear friends.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred