Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Musicals with Cheese | Post Mortem & Ranking

Andrew and Jess are back at it to say goodbye to the old show, and rank their best and worst moments. Also, our keeper of the cheese provides their rankings too!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 16 mins
8/8/24

Featured Shows

About

Andrew and Jess are back at it to say goodbye to the old show, and rank their best and worst moments. Also, our keeper of the cheese provides their rankings too!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Jesse McInally: And welcome to our Musicals with Cheese post-mortem.

[0:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this is our real goodbye. Our here we are episode is a kind of like a finale, and this is kind of, you know, the talking dead of Musicals with Cheese.

[0:23] Jesse McInally: We made it.

[0:24] Andrew DeWolf: We did it.

[0:25] Jesse McInally: We did it.

[0:26] Andrew DeWolf: Um, 300 episodes.

[0:28] Jesse McInally: Yeah, we cheated a little bit, but we need 10.

[0:31] Andrew DeWolf: Or maybe more, honestly. I mean, if you count like all the bonus episodes and all these other things and Patreon episodes, we've done so many hundreds of hours of content.

[0:42] Jesse McInally: Like, truly, truly.

[0:44] Andrew DeWolf: So much content. And I guess at the end of it, Andrew, did you expect this would become what it is when we started five years ago in 2018?

[0:54] Andrew DeWolf: No, I thought you were gonna post a video on your YouTube and it would get like a couple hundred views, and then we just call it a day.

[1:01] Jesse McInally: Because I guess I don't think we've ever gone through our proper origin story in detail of how we don't have to here either. I mean, but we we'd work together, but not really in any public forum. Like we always had the idea of maybe we'll do something together and maybe we'll do this, and this has kind of been the one that stuck, sadly.

[1:23] Andrew DeWolf: And we always kind of knew we had good chemistry working off of each other, which is, you know, all these years later, very interesting.

[1:31] Jesse McInally: It doesn't really make any sense.

[1:34] Andrew DeWolf: It really doesn't. That these people that met through Doug Walker now have their own kind of, you know, sustaining brand and group of people that really, really enjoy what they do.

[1:46] Jesse McInally: Um, but we can't frame this like, you know, we're going to war and like this is anything serious. Like we're not going to war. We're just two chuckleheads here.

[1:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what has been the highest point and the lowest point of doing Musicals with Cheese?

[2:01] Jesse McInally: Um, you know that's that's a great question. The highest point, I don't know if there's been one highest point, you know? There's been a couple times where it's like, dang, we did a pretty cool thing there. And then I feel like the lowest point has just been sometimes when it's just it felt like work, you know.

[2:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and it does feel like work. Like we we do try to have fun here, but often if something's not going right, or you know, if time and we all have real lives to manage on top of this, which sounds ridiculous because all we're doing is talking to a microphone and being goofy about musical theater.

[2:39] Jesse McInally: Uh, but it is kind of a social drain. And sometimes we we don't always love being around each other either.

[2:48] Andrew DeWolf: I know you don't.

[2:49] Jesse McInally: You know, you say that, but honestly, I don't think I've ever even one time thought, oh man, I have to talk to Jess.

[2:56] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, that's positive. That's nice. Um, there was a couple times where you just didn't show up to records.

[3:05] Jesse McInally: I think that only happened once.

[3:07] Andrew DeWolf: Twice.

[3:07] Jesse McInally: It happened twice.

[3:08] Andrew DeWolf: But both one time it was like a good excuse, and the other time it was just like, you know, mental exhaustion. And that happens.

[3:15] Jesse McInally: Um, between all of our iterations, because I think we have three distinct periods of Musicals with Cheese. Strangely almost coinciding with each chunk of hundred episodes.

[3:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um, our first hundred was us figuring out how the fuck to do this, which is really sad to say. But a lot of things that would become staples weren't even there in our first hundred episodes.

[3:43] Jesse McInally: Our first hundred, um, I don't think I like any of those.

[3:48] Andrew DeWolf: Really?

[3:49] Jesse McInally: I think there's moments from them that I like, but I'm not sure I would even recommend starting in the first hundred episodes if you're gonna listen through our show.

[3:57] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think you should start there, no. If you want to like go back and see where we started or came from, prepare to be disappointed, I guess, but I suppose you can do that.

[4:07] Jesse McInally: I mean, that's kind of my advice to anyone that's gonna start listening to us. Prepare to be disappointed, I guess.

[4:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, there's some gold in there. Like, uh, the real the eras of Musicals with Cheese are really just the editors.

[4:25] Jesse McInally: I mean, I don't think I was a particularly good editor of Musicals with Cheese either. I don't have a tendency to know how to edit comedy. I know how to edit for tone or if I'm trying to make a point, like I'm able to pull all those things, and I was very good about that, but I would let a lot of silences linger a lot a way too long, and that was a big issue with the early episodes, as well as the evenness of the audio.

[4:50] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I didn't know how to do any of that, and I think I don't think I figured out how to properly do that until like the 90s. And then I was like, oh, this shit's hard.

[5:01] Jesse McInally: And then Brie came on, which kind of re-reconfigured our entire show and gave us something that made sure that we were always kind of uh on our tippity top, which is an audience at all times.

[5:15] Andrew DeWolf: Like you when you and I are together, we can't always gauge what we're doing because we're kind of a two-headed monster at this point, where we're both kind of like, oh yeah, I'm thinking what you're thinking, you're thinking what I'm thinking.

[5:26] Jesse McInally: But if you had of another person in the room that is making faces and is a good gauge of whether this is funny or boring, it really does help center yourself for an audience.

[5:37] Andrew DeWolf: And I I think that's a lesson we learned and stuck with. And I think moving into into our new iteration, we're even adding on to that in a way.

[5:50] Jesse McInally: Yes. Um, there's exciting things there. Um, but I guess the highest point for me, um, and it's gonna ruin one of my episode picks.

[6:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think it was really incredible to be able to perform live in front of an audience and meet a lot of our fans at BroadwayCon 2022. That was a really neat experience.

[6:12] Jesse McInally: That was definitely one of the high points. Um, and uh we should get into our episode picks, I think.

[6:20] Andrew DeWolf: I do want to say one quick thing about the bittersweetness of because I listened back to a lot of episodes today.

[6:26] Jesse McInally: Um and I I can I get real a second for just a millisecond. I promise this won't be long.

[6:33] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.

[6:33] Jesse McInally: It is kind of depressing to me. Um how much my cognitive decline is kicking in since those days.

[6:41] Andrew DeWolf: How much are you you were just sharper back in the...

[6:41] Jesse McInally: I was!

[6:46] Andrew DeWolf: I really was.

[6:46] Jesse McInally: Like, no, you are actually more sharp and more on it now, because back then you're like, hmm, alright, that's weird.

[6:55] Andrew DeWolf: Like that was your what you'd bring down.

[6:57] Jesse McInally: That was a major criticism of our early episodes is that I was just why was I even there, right?

[7:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[7:02] Jesse McInally: No, it wasn't everybody, but it was definitely we got that a couple times. I think unless you had something funny to say, you often didn't talk.

[7:09] Andrew DeWolf: I don't I think you got a lot better at analysis, media analysis, but uh in 2022, when we went to BroadwayCon, I got a really, really bad st bad thing of COVID that didn't affect my body as much as it fucked up my brain and made it very hard for me to talk and read.

[7:28] Jesse McInally: And I'm still kind of dealing with that, and I hear it in the episodes. Like, we kind of make it a joke, but it really is difficult for me to read like the intro things where I'm reading like the dates that things opened, and just hearing those early episodes where it was not a struggle for me was weirdly like, oh god, what have I become?

[7:49] Andrew DeWolf: Well, welcome to the rest of our lives.

[7:52] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's only getting worse.

[7:53] Andrew DeWolf: So the I will never be this on it ever again.

[7:58] Jesse McInally: Um, but yes, um, we had Juliet Antonio rank all of our best episodes previously, but we've never given our personal best picks um before.

[8:09] Andrew DeWolf: So me and Andrew, on our own, have written our own list of the top 10 Musicals with Cheese episodes.

[8:16] Jesse McInally: So really you're getting 20 episodes here that you should cultivate and give a listen because we think that's us at our best.

[8:24] Andrew DeWolf: I'm curious as to how you picked your list. Did you listen back through and pick based on that?

[8:29] Jesse McInally: There's some I didn't have to listen back through because they I'd been around them a lot and people bring them up to me. You know what I mean?

[8:36] Andrew DeWolf: See, I I picked it based on my experience making the episode, more so than anything in the episode.

[8:44] Jesse McInally: So some of the episodes I picked may not even be very good. It's just I have positive memories of making them.

[8:50] Andrew DeWolf: I have weirdly positive memories of all of them, but I do want to let's get out our honorable mentions before we get into our list.

[8:55] Jesse McInally: You have two, I have like five.

[8:58] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[8:59] Jesse McInally: Why don't you start since you have more?

[9:01] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Here are ones that won't appear on my list, but I think are really good listens, anyways. First one is Ride the Cyclone. That episode was really fun to do and goes on a beautiful tangent about rolly coasters.

[9:14] Jesse McInally: Um, just a good time. Mrs. Doubtfire is one I look back on very positively too. Like that was such a fun episode to do, and we pissed a lot of people off with it.

[9:25] Andrew DeWolf: But I stand by every word. Actually, I can't even miss Doubtfire. I can't even say that, because I've seen Mrs. Doubtfire live. It's fine.

[9:32] Jesse McInally: It's honestly fine.

[9:35] Andrew DeWolf: I haven't seen it live, so I stand by every word. It's kind of cute. Um, God bless you, Mr. Rosewater. Our first episode was Sideways, and I feel that episode is less even about like the content, but like our friendship with Sideways coming together, and that is like one of our dearest collaborations.

[9:55] Jesse McInally: Um, that one almost made my list. Same with La La Land with Brent, like the developing of a friendship there, those two episodes are very like, oh, that that's we got to hear a friendship start live on a podcast.

[10:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Legally Blonde, I think we also just were kind of hitting a stride there, had a lot of good opinions. And here's a wild one, but I look back on it so fondly. Dario Argento's Phantom of the Opera. One of my favorite recording sessions ever. One of the weirdest things we've ever covered on the podcast.

[10:25] Jesse McInally: 10 out of 10. Great episode, but didn't make my list.

[10:28] Andrew DeWolf: What are yours?

[10:30] Jesse McInally: Um, well, my two are my my two weird things that I got us to cover. Um, so obviously episode 10 Tiara, which is the only time I managed to get Jess to cover a heavy metal album.

[10:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it may be the only time ever. I don't know. We'll see what happens on the new show.

[10:46] Jesse McInally: Yeah, so episode's not very good, I don't think, but I liked making it.

[10:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um and you should listen to that album. I'm always gonna do that.

[10:55] Jesse McInally: And uh the uh I don't even know if it's a real episode, but the Rock of Fire Explosion episode.

[11:01] Andrew DeWolf: That was the bonus episode.

[11:02] Jesse McInally: Those are the episodes.

[11:02] Andrew DeWolf: Which is a bonus episode.

[11:04] Jesse McInally: So that one doesn't count, but it's in my honorable mentions, so it's not even a real one.

[11:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, that was a fun one. Like, I I think we did a lot of wonderful commentaries, like our Camp Rock 2 commentary on Patreon is an all-timer.

[11:18] Jesse McInally: It's definitely a banger. I'm not gonna lie.

[11:20] Andrew DeWolf: The Catrock. I can't promise much content.

[11:24] Jesse McInally: Like, but we did just kind of start doing an improv bit of it.

[11:27] Andrew DeWolf: There's content.

[11:28] Jesse McInally: There's just not content about Camp Rock 2.

[11:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[11:33] Jesse McInally: But let's get on to the list.

[11:35] Andrew DeWolf: And to be fair to us, we're gonna list these in a top 10 format.

[11:40] Jesse McInally: We're kind of making up our top 10 as we go. I kind of know what my number 10 is, and I know what my number one is.

[11:45] Andrew DeWolf: Everything in between is kind of interchangeable.

[11:47] Jesse McInally: Um, Andrew, do you feel the same way?

[11:49] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't rank shit. There's some of these where I might later on be like, oh, that definitely should have been above that one, but honestly, like whatever.

[11:56] Jesse McInally: Oh, and if we're talking about bonus episodes, I really love both our Ratatouille bonus episodes.

[12:00] Andrew DeWolf: I think those are great.

[12:02] Jesse McInally: Those are good, yes.

[12:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Andrew, you go first. What's your number 10?

[12:06] Andrew DeWolf: My number 10 is Blues Clue's Big City Adventure, which is the first show that I ever edited.

[12:16] Jesse McInally: That is such a special one. I put in a lot of work into that edit, and it's probably the show that I took the longest to edit out of every edit that I've ever done.

[12:25] Andrew DeWolf: I'm talking about television, especially, not not movies necessarily. I don't know. I think when you get to like mid-teenage, like I really like The Owl House. I like in the train.

[12:33] Jesse McInally: I mean children, like small children.

[12:46] Andrew DeWolf: And looks nice. Like I see even people our age or older doing video essays on them, and parents watch it without their kids, and that's like preschool shows. But I don't know. It all has that digital shine to it. Like nothing looks like PP and J Otter, which is a show that no one remembers, but I remember it being at least feeling like a show. Feeling like animation. And it just feels like each heroes of one. Alright, next Wild Pack.

[13:15] Jesse McInally: Oh no. Just because you were learning the ropes. Um but because of that, it just kind of stuck with me, so I have to put it here. It's the lowest spot, but honestly, like I don't know. I I have to throw it on here.

[13:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um I think this is the I think that's a great choice. Um I think that we had a lot of fun that episode. Um, and I look back very fondly on it. Felt like a new show began. It kind of felt like we were piloting again. It was like it was the first one we did without Brie as well. So it was like we didn't know it was up. And it was it was definitely interesting, and I feel like there's a decent energy in that one.

[13:56] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Um I I really enjoyed recording that one and listening to that one. I actually really had a good time listening to that and being like, okay, yes, this'll work.

[14:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um, my number 10, and I think this is the only one from our first hundred episodes, and it's falsettos.

[14:12] Jesse McInally: Oh Jesus.

[14:13] Andrew DeWolf: I know why this is here, though.

[14:17] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and that goes the way that you'd expect. Um, Jason doesn't want his bar mitzvah because his um father's boyfriend's dying, and he doesn't want to lose a good friend. So they decide to have the Jason's bar mitzvah in Wizard's hospital room, and at the end of that, Wizard basically walks off stage and dies. Marvin and him have a last duet where we see Wizard dressed exactly how he was at the beginning, and he dies leaving Marvin alone again.

[14:49] Andrew DeWolf: Rest in peace, wizard. Um do you think he'll come back as Gandalf the White?

[15:03] Jesse McInally: It's so fucking funny.

[15:07] Andrew DeWolf: Why did I say that? Because I'm being so impassioned about how much I like this show, and I can hear it in my voice, like genuine love for it. And I'm like, and it's so sad that Wizard died. And you're like, it's okay, he'll come back as Wizard the White. And it's just like the epitome of everything that this show eventually should be.

[15:32] Jesse McInally: It yeah. I have to. Let me be sincere for a second. I have a bit of an irreverence to me, and I don't I don't know. It was it was fun. I think I've lost some of that over the years, but I I disagree.

[15:47] Andrew DeWolf: You got you still got like a wily coyote look.

[15:50] Jesse McInally: Um Brent brings it up like you can tell there's like a spark in Andrew's eyes when he knows he's gonna say something to piss you off.

[15:58] Andrew DeWolf: It's true though.

[16:03] Jesse McInally: I mean, it it is true. Um what do you agree with that? Like, do you get why that's there or no?

[16:10] Andrew DeWolf: I get why that's there. That was an iconic it's an iconic moment. I don't know if the entire episode is good, but I know that the Wizard of the White thing is maybe the funniest thing I've ever said.

[16:20] Jesse McInally: And it's also the first episode where Broadway responded in a way.

[16:25] Andrew DeWolf: Really?

[16:25] Jesse McInally: Yeah, because one of our first reviews is from um the little boy in that show, uh Jason. Um I forget the actor's name. Um, Anthony Rosenthal, his mother reviewed our show and was like, oh, I really love the falsetto's episode. I'm I'm hit Anthony's mom, and I really appreciate how you had both points of view, and then also Betsy Wolf and Tracy Toms retweeted it when we posted like it was the first time where Broadway people kind of gave us a little legitimacy, and you know, we got some praise for the work we did.

[16:56] Andrew DeWolf: And then and then we lost a lot of it later on.

[16:59] Jesse McInally: It took some time, but we eventually destroyed every ounce of goodwill we ever had.

[17:04] Andrew DeWolf: It's fine. We're here now. What's your number nine?

[17:10] Jesse McInally: Let's see. What's a good pick for number nine? Um.

[17:15] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna go with School of Rock as my.

[17:19] Jesse McInally: Okay, that's not fair because the best parts of that are cut out.

[17:23] Andrew DeWolf: I agree. But that's why putting it at number nine.

[17:27] Jesse McInally: I'm gonna we talked about this previously, how you're gonna put clips from each one in in this. You should uh put the cut part of this in this right here.

[17:37] Andrew DeWolf: Does everyone wanna know?

[17:38] Jesse McInally: Everyone wants to know.

[17:40] Andrew DeWolf: We should just discuss it right here because we're gonna play it.

[17:43] Jesse McInally: Just play it.

[17:44] Andrew DeWolf: Well, just play it.

[17:45] Jesse McInally: No discussion.

[17:45] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck it.

[17:46] Jesse McInally: No discussion.

[17:47] Andrew DeWolf: Right. Exactly. At least you didn't like come out and play the ukulele or something.

[17:51] Jesse McInally: I'm not a groomer, just a loser.

[17:53] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, listen. I want to say this. As a as somebody who does play the ukulele, like that was like 9-11 for our community.

[18:00] Jesse McInally: That was like was that posted on like every ukulele, like everything?

[18:06] Andrew DeWolf: I was like, oh fuck. I I want merch now that says Colleen Ballinger started ukulele 9-11. Like I want the.

[18:17] Jesse McInally: And I want to wear it.

[18:18] Andrew DeWolf: Child Ballister fucking instrument now. You see the toxic gossip train coming towards the two ukulele towers.

[18:24] Jesse McInally: The fucking tabs are on uks.

[18:30] Andrew DeWolf: Can learn the song.

[18:32] Jesse McInally: Sir, a second gossip train has hit the tower.

[18:37] Andrew DeWolf: They hit the Pentagon!

[18:39] Jesse McInally: The gossip train hit the Pentagon!

[18:42] Andrew DeWolf: I think it was I'm trying to remember is Andrew's thing that I think we're done.

[18:48] Jesse McInally: I don't think we can continue.

[18:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you know what, Andrew? You won.

[18:51] Jesse McInally: That's fine.

[18:56] Andrew DeWolf: Not a grooming.

[18:58] Jesse McInally: I can just loser.

[19:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. Colleen Ballinger is taking credit for all the actions.

[19:07] Jesse McInally: Have we grounded all the ukuleles?

[19:09] Andrew DeWolf: Ground all the ukulele's.

[19:11] Jesse McInally: Dick Cheney says, shoot it down.

[19:15] Andrew DeWolf: This is because it was a second ukulele has struck you too.

[19:24] Jesse McInally: The sad part is we can't keep any of this in.

[19:27] Andrew DeWolf: A second toxic gossip trains coming down the trucks.

[19:36] Jesse McInally: And people make mistakes.

[19:39] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god.

[19:40] Jesse McInally: Okay, alright. This is all gonna get cut, hopefully.

[19:45] Andrew DeWolf: I hope the Patreon really I hope the Patreon recognizes like the value of the content they're paying for.

[19:50] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it is one of the best bits, but we knew we couldn't post it.

[19:54] Andrew DeWolf: Like, and we this is the play, so exclusive.

[19:57] Jesse McInally: Tag, you know what? If you listen to us, tag big the bigger beak at the bigger beak, let him know it's here.

[20:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[20:04] Jesse McInally: But is that the only reason why it's here?

[20:06] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's it's here because the recording session was just so fun.

[20:11] Jesse McInally: And part of it is because of that. But honestly, the entire thing I remember, we were like riffing on like how cold it was at Broadway or whatever. Like there was some random shit that we were just talking about, and I don't know. It was just so much fun to record that one. I had to put it on.

[20:28] Andrew DeWolf: I agree.

[20:28] Jesse McInally: And Big Peak's been another consistently great guest, always bringing a lot of good value stuff.

[20:35] Andrew DeWolf: I I once again, the same thing with your good man Charlie Brown. You can kinda hear us all becoming friends in that episode, which is I I kind of romanticize it.

[20:43] Jesse McInally: Not in my top ten, though.

[20:44] Andrew DeWolf: That's a great pick, though.

[20:45] Jesse McInally: Not that is also not in my top ten.

[20:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so my number nine is it's here because it's honestly the one where me and Andrew got as real as possible we can without being presentational.

[21:03] Jesse McInally: Like, people brought up like, oh, the mood in this episode's a little weird.

[21:10] Andrew DeWolf: And that's our Diana episode.

[21:13] Jesse McInally: Oh, yeah.

[21:19] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McNally.

[21:21] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[21:23] Jesse McInally: And I'm Brianna Jones.

[21:24] Andrew DeWolf: And welcome to Musicals of Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Brie to like musical theater. How are you two doing today?

[21:32] Jesse McInally: Oh, well, you know.

[21:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I was just busy running my empire.

[21:39] Jesse McInally: You know, worldwide global domination doesn't run itself, sweetie.

[21:43] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, so I'm girl bossing it up over here, uh, you know, exploiting everyone in the whole planet.

[21:52] Jesse McInally: Diana, the musical.

[21:54] Andrew DeWolf: Hear the music, Brie.

[21:58] Jesse McInally: Who gives a fuck?

[22:01] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck this. That's the episode. Goodbye, everyone.

[22:06] Jesse McInally: Dude, I hated that.

[22:08] Andrew DeWolf: It's bad.

[22:09] Jesse McInally: But in the first like 15 minutes of the episode, you and I get into a basically a real life fight.

[22:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[22:17] Jesse McInally: Which is still entertaining. Like, we still are being entertaining, and I think it's a good discussion, but you can just hear the anger in both of our voices.

[22:27] Andrew DeWolf: I can see why you would put this on there.

[22:29] Jesse McInally: I I would say because it's uncomfortable, it's probably not for everybody, but for it might be entertaining.

[22:29] Andrew DeWolf: It might be.

[22:37] Jesse McInally: I think it's very entertaining. It's one of our most downloaded episodes.

[22:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's unique as well.

[22:42] Jesse McInally: Uh-huh. We don't usually do that.

[22:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we tend to be able to like present well for for you know, for for the audience for our kids in the room.

[22:51] Jesse McInally: But there do you remember what the fight was about?

[22:54] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.

[22:55] Jesse McInally: Probably something to do with I I thought Diana didn't.

[22:58] Andrew DeWolf: I don't give a shit that she died or some shit.

[23:00] Jesse McInally: No, it was like someone can be miserable and also rich, and you're like, yeah, but if they're rich, they have no reason to be miserable.

[23:07] Andrew DeWolf: I'm like, they you could be two things at once was the argument.

[23:11] Jesse McInally: Like, being rich does not evaluate invalidate like a disease you have, and you're like, uh nope, they should die.

[23:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, I still agree with that actually.

[23:20] Jesse McInally: No, you should. Because the thing is, if you're if you're miserable and rich, you can stop being rich at any time by giving your money away, and then I'll care about you because you're just miserable.

[23:33] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[23:34] Jesse McInally: We have opinions.

[23:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what's your number eight?

[23:43] Jesse McInally: Um, my number eight is going to be uh weekly.

[23:45] Andrew DeWolf: I'm so excited because you have to p oh really.

[23:48] Jesse McInally: Which is the worst garbage we've got.

[23:49] Andrew DeWolf: Are you fucking kidding me?

[23:52] Jesse McInally: What?

[23:53] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god.

[23:54] Jesse McInally: I'm putting it on here because it's the worst show we've ever covered.

[23:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[23:59] Jesse McInally: And because of that, I remember it distinctly.

[24:03] Andrew DeWolf: So I have to put the episode on the list, but I don't want to put it too high because I fucking hate this show.

[24:19] Jesse McInally: I couldn't actually find any clips of our episodes, so I'm just gonna put this here.

[24:35] Andrew DeWolf: Truly, I cannot even listen to that episode again because of how much We Will Rock you upsets me. It is one of our most downloaded episodes, but that episode like that content for We Will Rock You is so so disgusting to my soul that I can't even revisit us talking about how bad it is.

[24:53] Jesse McInally: I don't want to. This is why it's on the list.

[24:56] Andrew DeWolf: This is why it's on the list. We will rock you is the worst thing we will ever cover.

[25:01] Jesse McInally: I am convinced we will not find something that makes us more depressed than that fucking show.

[25:09] Andrew DeWolf: That was a Patreon request from Joseph Evans Green, and I will never forgive him.

[25:13] Jesse McInally: He broke us, dude.

[25:14] Andrew DeWolf: He fucking did it.

[25:16] Jesse McInally: Dude, it was the most soul-numbing experience.

[25:21] Andrew DeWolf: Like you'll never experience something like that.

[25:24] Jesse McInally: And I know what's really sad is a ton of people love We Will Rock You and were mad at us for it, too.

[25:30] Andrew DeWolf: It's three fucking hours long, too.

[25:33] Jesse McInally: So fucking bad.

[25:35] Andrew DeWolf: See, right now I'm just staring into the middle distance, remembering that and feeling dread in my soul.

[25:42] Jesse McInally: But are you really telling me that it can't get on the list?

[25:45] Andrew DeWolf: Like you can't see why it would be here.

[25:47] Jesse McInally: I feel like I have too much PTSD to even remember what was said in that episode.

[25:52] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember what I said. All I know is that we were both pissed.

[25:56] Jesse McInally: I'm feeling sick right now thinking about that show.

[26:00] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm not being hyperbolic. Like, truly, the more I think about it, the more ill I feel.

[26:04] Jesse McInally: I feel bad for you having to drop clips of us talking about We Will Rock You here.

[26:10] Andrew DeWolf: It's gonna be fun to dig through that one.

[26:12] Jesse McInally: I'll have to find what I think is the funniest part.

[26:15] Andrew DeWolf: It might just be the first part that I listened to that I put in, honestly.

[26:18] Jesse McInally: I don't want to listen to the whole fucking thing.

[26:22] Andrew DeWolf: Damn, I overestimated how much effort I put in.

[26:24] Jesse McInally: Um, yeah, We Will Rock You is very bad.

[26:27] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe we were funny in it.

[26:28] Jesse McInally: Uh, I doubt it.

[26:30] Andrew DeWolf: I doubt that.

[26:31] Jesse McInally: I bet you we were funny.

[26:33] Andrew DeWolf: I doubt we were in any mood to be funny during that.

[26:35] Jesse McInally: I think what it's gonna be is this is one of those episodes where it's like a classic reviewer episode where the point is that you want to see the person making the video suffer, and you're gonna listen to us suffer.

[26:49] Andrew DeWolf: Like Doug Walker's not actually suffering in the Batman and Robin review.

[26:53] Jesse McInally: We are truly suffering.

[26:56] Andrew DeWolf: This is the real experience.

[27:00] Jesse McInally: Oh, okay. Can we move on?

[27:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we can move on.

[27:03] Jesse McInally: My number eight is a recent one.

[27:06] Andrew DeWolf: I'll give it, but probably one of my favorite crowning achievement kind of episodes.

[27:12] Jesse McInally: And that's our Annie 2 episode.

[27:16] Andrew DeWolf: With uh, with Robbie?

[27:18] Jesse McInally: With Robbie Rosell.

[27:19] Andrew DeWolf: I think this is like an all-time great one to me.

[27:23] Jesse McInally: Um, Robbie, I'm curious. Which one do you have a deeper love for?

[27:27] Andrew DeWolf: Annie 2 or Annie Warbucks?

[27:28] Jesse McInally: Annie Warbucks.

[27:30] Andrew DeWolf: That's not a score.

[27:32] Jesse McInally: Okay, okay.

[27:33] Andrew DeWolf: I'm so fascinated by that.

[27:35] Jesse McInally: Because Andrew, you have a fucking hot take here that no human being has ever had in their entire life.

[27:41] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[27:42] Jesse McInally: I thought Miss Hannigan's Revenge was better.

[27:46] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, wow.

[27:47] Jesse McInally: I think fake Annie is my favorite character ever to appear in any Annie property.

[27:53] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I like that Miss Hannigan came back because I love Miss Hannigan.

[27:58] Jesse McInally: Sure.

[27:58] Andrew DeWolf: More than any other character.

[28:00] Jesse McInally: Dorothy Louden even came back to play the role.

[28:03] Andrew DeWolf: She sure did.

[28:04] Jesse McInally: She did that.

[28:04] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like it did.

[28:05] Jesse McInally: She uh, she wandered through that set.

[28:08] Andrew DeWolf: We had some funny moments in this one, and I'm glad that I came out and defended Annie 2 over Annie Warbucks.

[28:17] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[28:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I feel like I defended Annie pretty well there.

[28:23] Jesse McInally: I mean, and both Annie 2s are better than the original Annie.

[28:26] Andrew DeWolf: What's really great about the end of Musicals with Cheese for me is that I'll never have to talk about Annie ever again in my life.

[28:32] Jesse McInally: You think so?

[28:34] Andrew DeWolf: I do think so.

[28:35] Jesse McInally: There's no Annie content left.

[28:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, there probably isn't.

[28:39] Jesse McInally: Unless they do another Annie.

[28:41] Andrew DeWolf: We're not covering the fucking comic, I'm sorry.

[28:44] Jesse McInally: Well, if I put it on the wheel, we have to.

[28:47] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck you.

[28:49] Jesse McInally: Um, I love all of our Annie episodes.

[28:52] Andrew DeWolf: I actually think our first Annie episode is one of the few pre-100 episodes that is very, very good, consistently good throughout.

[28:59] Jesse McInally: Um, but Annie 2 is just a magical recording session.

[29:04] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, you're number seven.

[29:07] Jesse McInally: Okay, for my number seven.

[29:10] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna put on The Frogs.

[29:13] Jesse McInally: Um, for the experience of uncovering a hidden gem.

[29:18] Andrew DeWolf: Musicals with Cheese presents The Frogs.

[29:22] Jesse McInally: The Musicals with Cheese theater presents The Frogs, sorry, Andrew Randles and Josh Gad.

[29:27] Andrew DeWolf: Will go bankrupt faster than Rebecca.

[29:30] Jesse McInally: Ben Brantley will come out of retirement just to write the fucking video.

[29:33] Andrew DeWolf: I will invite him.

[29:34] Jesse McInally: I will sit next to him.

[29:36] Andrew DeWolf: I will give him the hand job while he's writing his review.

[29:40] Jesse McInally: He will have a good night.

[29:45] Andrew DeWolf: He ignored the balls more, but somehow he happened to know that I didn't like much Fall Work.

[29:50] Jesse McInally: Oh my god.

[29:51] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[29:55] Jesse McInally: Mid Show Time.

[29:55] Andrew DeWolf: Mid Show Time.

[29:57] Jesse McInally: Alright.

[29:58] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[29:58] Jesse McInally: And I think it was kind of us me coming to terms and you convincing me how great this is.

[30:05] Andrew DeWolf: Like that is a rare episode where you're convincing me how good a musical is.

[30:11] Jesse McInally: I think maybe the episode isn't the greatest thing ever, but I feel like we come back to it a lot.

[30:19] Andrew DeWolf: It's almost a must listen because every episode past The Frogs, like it must be at least every other episode, we bring up The Frogs again.

[30:27] Jesse McInally: Like, but remember in our first hundred episodes, you brought up The Frogs a lot as being like, that's gonna be my favorite musical of all time.

[30:33] Andrew DeWolf: And then you weren't wrong.

[30:35] Jesse McInally: What's crazy about The Frogs is it is kind of a climax of our show almost.

[30:41] Andrew DeWolf: It's like we tease it at the beginning, we actually cover it, and then past that, we change as a show and keep bringing it up.

[30:50] Jesse McInally: That's the Chekhov's gun of Musicals with Cheese is The Frogs.

[30:54] Andrew DeWolf: The Frogs is a necessary episode to listen to if you want the Musicals with Cheese experience.

[31:03] Jesse McInally: It has to be on my list.

[31:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I guess.

[31:05] Jesse McInally: But then again, I don't think this is gonna be maybe it's on your list.

[31:08] Andrew DeWolf: Our Cats episode, I think, is very necessary, but I also don't have it on my list.

[31:14] Jesse McInally: That is fair.

[31:19] Andrew DeWolf: But Cats is Cats and Frogs are Frogs.

[31:24] Jesse McInally: A cat is not a frog.

[31:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, that episode is really important, and I love The Frogs.

[31:31] Jesse McInally: The Frogs is something I'm so glad I have an appreciation for now.

[31:35] Andrew DeWolf: We talk about art in a way in that Frogs episode that I appreciate as well.

[31:41] Jesse McInally: Where we just, it's us uncovering something, I feel.

[31:44] Andrew DeWolf: It's like we're finding a hidden masterpiece.

[31:50] Jesse McInally: I kind of feel that way about Here We Are, that episode and that.

[31:52] Andrew DeWolf: They have very similar tinges, both the shows and our episodes on the respective shows.

[31:58] Jesse McInally: Um, you're right.

[31:59] Andrew DeWolf: Except for they're kind of flipped where I'm convincing you on one and you're trying to convince me on the other.

[32:04] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I think those are actually a pretty good companion piece to each other, if we're being honest.

[32:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what number are we on?

[32:12] Jesse McInally: Seven?

[32:12] Andrew DeWolf: Six?

[32:14] Jesse McInally: Seven.

[32:14] Andrew DeWolf: Seven.

[32:15] Jesse McInally: My number seven is, okay, this is actually one that I think is your crowning achievement as an editor.

[32:24] Andrew DeWolf: And this is the A Star is Born episode where we covered all of the A Star is Born movies.

[32:31] Jesse McInally: I think that one is so good.

[32:33] Andrew DeWolf: 1937.

[32:35] Jesse McInally: Yep.

[32:36] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, I think I'm gonna give this a B rank.

[32:38] Jesse McInally: I don't think this was that bad.

[32:39] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know if you fully disagree with that, but I think that one's probably my third favorite.

[32:46] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[32:47] Andrew DeWolf: I think this one, it's either my second or third favorite.

[32:50] Jesse McInally: It's kind of like close.

[32:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this one, it's fine.

[32:54] Jesse McInally: Obviously, the lack of songs holds it back a little bit, but I think it tells the story in a more concise way than any of the other ones do.

[33:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I kind of like it.

[33:05] Jesse McInally: It's okay.

[33:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it's a 1930s movie, so you know it's got that kind of old Hollywood charm to it as well.

[33:13] Jesse McInally: Um, cheese rating.

[33:15] Andrew DeWolf: Let's give it like a, we'll do it like a cheese platter rating.

[33:18] Jesse McInally: Like we're gonna, I'm gonna look up cheeses to put on a cheese platter.

[33:21] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[33:22] Jesse McInally: And we'll give it different stuff.

[33:24] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[33:24] Jesse McInally: I'm gonna give this Brie.

[33:26] Andrew DeWolf: For brief views.

[33:28] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[33:29] Andrew DeWolf: You mind if I take just one more look?

[33:33] Jesse McInally: Next up, I think 1954 is also a B tier.

[33:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[33:39] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I can't disagree with that.

[33:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think I just changed which order, but they're both B tier for me too.

[33:45] Jesse McInally: It's too long, and that's really my biggest issue with it, and it's weird that they have cut footage and that kind of sucks.

[33:55] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and then there's also weird racist shit, so I can't recommend it because of that, but I guess if you can push past it, there's good stuff in there.

[34:05] Jesse McInally: Like Judy Garland sings well, obviously.

[34:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, actually now that you think about it, it's not a complete film, so I think, yeah, the 31 has to go above it because at least that is the full story.

[34:15] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I mean it's close though.

[34:17] Andrew DeWolf: They're both close for me.

[34:18] Jesse McInally: We're gonna give it horseradish cheese.

[34:20] Andrew DeWolf: Because it's a little spicy.

[34:22] Jesse McInally: I'm gonna give it blue cheese because they blew it up.

[34:24] Andrew DeWolf: That's true.

[34:25] Jesse McInally: They did, they did. You could give it like Swiss because they cut holes in it.

[34:28] Andrew DeWolf: I like that one.

[34:29] Jesse McInally: I'm changing it to Swiss because there's gotta be holes in it, literally.

[34:33] Andrew DeWolf: Hey.

[34:35] Jesse McInally: I just want to take another look at you.

[34:36] Andrew DeWolf: I put so much work into that edit.

[34:39] Jesse McInally: I don't think I ever put more work into an edit than that episode.

[34:43] Andrew DeWolf: And it's so good, and that's one I've listened to quite a bit, and you've only been editing for like a year.

[34:50] Jesse McInally: And so I've listened to that episode at least two or three times because I really think you did a great job with it.

[34:55] Andrew DeWolf: I wish I had the amount of time that I had when I was editing that show still because I would love to put more work into some of our edits than I'm able to, sadly.

[35:06] Jesse McInally: Yeah, yep.

[35:07] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? Give us more money on Patreon so Andrew can quit having a day job.

[35:13] Jesse McInally: We can dream.

[35:15] Andrew DeWolf: It would be nice.

[35:16] Jesse McInally: Imagine two episodes a week.

[35:19] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you kind of forced my hand here because A Star is Born is also on my list.

[35:25] Jesse McInally: Well, that's a good point.

[35:26] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, um, that's my number seven is your number six, then.

[35:29] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[35:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and I, it's on the list because it is the episode I put the most work into.

[35:34] Jesse McInally: The ending section where I find the shared quote in each version of A Star is Born.

[35:41] Andrew DeWolf: That took so much effort and time, you have no idea.

[35:46] Jesse McInally: What I believe we run through each version of it and I play what is the quote that they say.

[35:51] Andrew DeWolf: I wanna get one last look at you.

[35:53] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I play that quote from each version of it.

[35:57] Andrew DeWolf: That took a lot of fucking effort.

[36:00] Jesse McInally: I'm sorry.

[36:00] Andrew DeWolf: It feels like I feel every ounce of love and care in the stitching of that episode.

[36:06] Jesse McInally: I think that's like an all-time great one for me.

[36:09] Andrew DeWolf: I love it.

[36:10] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's definitely up there.

[36:13] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I guess it comes back to me again.

[36:16] Jesse McInally: Sorry.

[36:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[36:17] Jesse McInally: Um, my number six, um, and I think this is probably the most we've laughed in an episode, and that is our Brigadoon episode.

[36:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like Jeff just can't catch a fucking break.

[36:30] Jesse McInally: And there's like women that he's not interested in hitting on him all the time.

[36:33] Andrew DeWolf: What if he's actually just in love with Tommy, and that's the reason why he wanted him out?

[36:37] Jesse McInally: Honestly, that would have been a good one.

[36:39] Andrew DeWolf: That would have been really good if they did that.

[36:41] Jesse McInally: Brigadoon from Jeff's perspective.

[36:44] Andrew DeWolf: That alternate universe fanfic.

[36:48] Jesse McInally: Then like, no, in the end of Act One is Tommy goes back to Brigadoon and then we get a whole Act Two where Jeff is just alone and miserable.

[37:01] Andrew DeWolf: I find no joy in anything anymore.

[37:04] Jesse McInally: Life.

[37:04] Andrew DeWolf: What is life even?

[37:06] Jesse McInally: Brigadoon took it all from me.

[37:08] Andrew DeWolf: I might have left, but I never really did.

[37:12] Jesse McInally: No one really, no one ever leaves Brigadoon.

[37:16] Andrew DeWolf: And then Peter Falk, Jeff comes in and it's a crossover episode.

[37:21] Jesse McInally: Into the Jeff verse.

[37:23] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I gotcha, kid, I'm also Jeff.

[37:26] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: Columbo shows up and he solves the murder.

[37:31] Jesse McInally: I gotta question.

[37:33] Andrew DeWolf: Act Two is a Columbo episode where it's like Jeff.

[37:40] Jesse McInally: Yeah, where Jeff gets away with a murder by having the place where he did it no longer exists.

[37:46] Andrew DeWolf: And then Tommy calls Columbo to solve the murder.

[37:49] Jesse McInally: Columbo's like, he solves it somehow.

[37:52] Andrew DeWolf: He's like, why did you go back there?

[37:54] Andrew DeWolf: You know, tell me this. Where's your friend? Oh, listen, there's one other thing I wanted to ask you about. Did he know something? There's nothing I love more than justice. So when I went to the to the to the the the the the Lee of uh Scotland. It the Brigadoon opened up. They felt my love of justice and invited me in. No, no, Colombo would have to say something really vague. Like he would be like, he'd be like, you know, have you been feeling really sleepy? I've met some people. They were uh they were pretty tired, but they woke up for me, you know? And and like, yeah, you don't he doesn't say it out loud though, and Jeff has to be like, he knows what's going on, but he's like, uh, uh, no, I'm not tired, you know?

It's I'm actually I've been drinking a lot of coffee. Um, you know, most people would have would have gotten rid of the murder weapon, but you left yours, didn't you? Your foot. Alright, alright. This is this is the this is what we need from Brigadoon. I I was definitely considering this one for the list. Um, but the only thing I remember about it is that we talked about Columbo a lot. And I was like, should I put that do I put the Colombo episode on the list? And I don't know. It's not just that we talk about Columbo, but we kinda set it up and we keep setting it up, and then it has a nice payoff in the third half like the last third episode. The editing, I do do a great job with the editing on this one as well.

[39:28] Jesse McInally: I agree. I I find the Colombo like music loop, and we it plays for like three minutes, I swear to God. And it starts so low you don't even know you're hearing it until you're like, wait a second, this is a Columbo episode. What the fuck I also just think Brigadoon's such a weird concept for a musical, and we have enough like fodder to have fun with that. And I think us actually talking about the musical is just as good as our Columbo bits, but the Columbo bits are kind of what pushes us over the edge. It's a good, it's a high energy episode. It's definitely really good, and I could see why you put it on here. Um yeah, that one's such fun. I remember listening to it the first time and getting like chills because I was just laughing too hard. Um what's your number four?

[40:12] Andrew DeWolf: Four.

[40:13] Jesse McInally: Five.

[40:15] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm gonna put um, and this is sort of cheating, maybe. I'm putting home on the range with the conversation that we have with the director. Collectively as well. Collectively, as one episode. Um, because I think it is one of the coolest things we've ever done.

[40:36] Jesse McInally: Um, why don't you talk about your favorite song, Randy Quaid singing Yodel Edel Edel Idol O.

[40:43] Andrew DeWolf: You see. This song is just uh a blast. Um it's one of the most fun villain songs in any Disney movie. Um it's the only song in this movie that's actually sung by a character. Um, and it's completely meaningless, which means that they're able to do a pink elephant's uh music video for it. Um to quote Doug Yancey Walker, is it a big-lipped alligator moment? U I forget what that means. Something happens and it's never mentioned again, and it's really weird.

[41:16] Jesse McInally: They definitely mention it again.

[41:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[41:18] Jesse McInally: It is kind of plot.

[41:19] Andrew DeWolf: So it's not. It is plot-centric.

[41:21] Jesse McInally: Oh, it's plot relevant for sure.

[41:22] Andrew DeWolf: It's just style. The lyrics of the song are just like, I just Yodel and But it's great. And I I honestly I kind of love Yodeling. It sounds really good. It sounds really goofy and fun. Uh to quote the uh the one character, Yodeling is uh the goofiest, corniest, uh cheesiest.

[41:43] Jesse McInally: The yodeling is the cheesiest thing someone can do.

[41:47] Andrew DeWolf: I agree. The scene, the animation in that scene is fucking incredible.

[41:51] Jesse McInally: Oh yeah. And they allow a Disney villain to like look happy, like jolly, you know, like most most Disney villains that have songs, they look like uh they look like death, you know.

[42:02] Andrew DeWolf: The only one I can think of that isn't that way is Radigan's song from the great mouse detective. Because he's a big smiler.

[42:08] Jesse McInally: I think like Gaston, I guest star just looks sort of, but he's he still looks like evil.

[42:14] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I we got to talk to the fucking director of the movie. I just think that's really cool.

[42:20] Jesse McInally: I don't know. I I agree. I a hundred percent agree.

[42:24] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I think we strangely came on the defense of Home on the Range. Like we were kind of going against the grain there.

[42:32] Jesse McInally: Honestly, like it's not a great movie, but it isn't a terrible movie, like a lot of people would have you believe, I think.

[42:41] Andrew DeWolf: Like it's kind of fine.

[42:45] Jesse McInally: I I don't know. I Home on the Range. I like I liked talking about it, and I loved that we got to speak to the director and get like behind the scenes information about the making of it and why it was the way it was. Uh I just think that that's one of the cooler things we've ever done on the show.

[43:02] Andrew DeWolf: I agree, I guess.

[43:03] Jesse McInally: I I mean I I love that episode too, but it's not on my list.

[43:09] Andrew DeWolf: I we don't have the same list, you know, that's fine.

[43:12] Jesse McInally: Yeah, um what number am I on?

[43:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh you're on five.

[43:17] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[43:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, okay. My number five is our episode on Popeye at Broadway con.

[43:27] Jesse McInally: That was such an incredible experience to be able to have an audience. Like, under i I I never know if we're funny, but having some people laugh and at the right moments and be engaged and be able to do the previews to an audience was such a fucking rewarding thing and give out prizes.

[43:45] Andrew DeWolf: That was so cool.

[43:46] Jesse McInally: You have forced by hand again. Popeye was also on my list for the same reasons.

[43:54] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[43:56] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[43:57] Jesse McInally: And I'm Liz Eston.

[43:58] Andrew DeWolf: And welcome to Musicals of Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Liz to like musical's.

[44:03] Jesse McInally: How are we?

[44:04] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, we finished it!

[44:06] Jesse McInally: He did it! Give him my hand.

[44:09] Andrew DeWolf: He said the thing! Um how are you doing today, Andrew?

[44:12] Jesse McInally: I am doing phenomenal because we're at BroadwayCon today.

[44:15] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, we are?

[44:16] Jesse McInally: Yeah, we're talking to some about something very, very relevant for Broadway.

[44:19] Andrew DeWolf: Very extremely relevant. Um, just for a show of hands, how many in this audience have seen the Robert Altman film Popeye?

[44:28] Jesse McInally: We got we got it!

[44:30] Andrew DeWolf: Hey! I was so expecting absolutely no one to see this. This is fantastic.

[44:37] Jesse McInally: I I also think it's excellent that we went to BroadwayCon, and the only thing we did was we covered a fucking movie.

[44:46] Andrew DeWolf: Do you want me to be honest? Do you know why we did that?

[44:49] Jesse McInally: Yeah, sure.

[44:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Grace Aki, when we told her, hey, we're going to BroadwayCon, she's like, don't do anything. Even like the easy targets, they will take personally. So even like a jab at James Corden, they will so don't do anything that would hurt any Broadway show that is running. And so I was like, okay. And I was like, what do I think would be a fairly easy target? And do you remember what the alternative was if we didn't do Popeye?

[45:18] Jesse McInally: No, I don't, honestly.

[45:19] Andrew DeWolf: It was gonna be Cartoon All-Stars to the Rescue was gonna be the other one we'd do.

[45:24] Jesse McInally: Right.

[45:25] Andrew DeWolf: I'm glad we did Popeye because not only was it a great experience, we actually had a good conversation about Popeye, is the weird thing.

[45:34] Jesse McInally: It is strange.

[45:35] Andrew DeWolf: And also we had like an audience member that's like, oh yeah, I went to the Popeye Multi-Ion. That's like it was like perfect.

[45:42] Jesse McInally: It was like, how did this even happen? We went to Broadway con and we talked about Popeye and it went amazingly.

[45:49] Andrew DeWolf: I'm pretty sure we were the only ones to fill that room in that entire weekend.

[45:55] Jesse McInally: We were not the only ones. There was a couple other podcasts that did, but we definitely we were one of the few that did fill that room.

[46:02] Andrew DeWolf: It was neat.

[46:03] Jesse McInally: It was really neat. And a lot of the people that came in didn't know about our show and were like, we just saw that people were talking about Popeye and we're like, well, we're gonna go check that out.

[46:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I like I don't know if they thought we were like announcing a Popeye musical or something, but people had their butts in the seat and they listened to us riff on Popeye.

[46:25] Jesse McInally: And and honestly, we did it so well, like it felt really fucking natural.

[46:29] Andrew DeWolf: Like I was I I don't know. I guess I maybe it's me. I don't get like that performance anxiety, I guess. Like I went out there and it just felt like recording it in my in my room here.

[46:41] Jesse McInally: I agree. I didn't have performance anxiety as much as I had no one's gonna fucking show up anxiety.

[46:46] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, but by the time we started, we already knew that that wasn't gonna happen.

[46:50] Jesse McInally: Yeah, we had a full room. So I was cool as a cucumber beforehand because I was like, alright, we're not playing into an empty room.

[46:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um we had video recording of it. Um it it is truly one of the the the highlights of doing musicals with cheese.

[47:03] Jesse McInally: Yeah, no, it was a it was a great experience. Um a lot of fun, and I I hope we can someday do some more stuff like that again.

[47:11] Andrew DeWolf: I hope so too. Invite us to cons.

[47:13] Jesse McInally: We'll we'll go cheaper than most people.

[47:15] Andrew DeWolf: We're fucking podcasts, you know.

[47:18] Jesse McInally: Yeah, invite us to a con, please.

[47:21] Andrew DeWolf: Um, if you run a con, we'd love to go.

[47:23] Jesse McInally: Um, alright, number four.

[47:25] Andrew DeWolf: My number four is the Wizard of Oz with Maggie Mayfish.

[47:33] Jesse McInally: God damn it, you keep you keep doing it. That's on my list too.

[47:37] Andrew DeWolf: Really?

[47:37] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[47:38] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that's just I I likely would have put it lower, but because you forced my hand on two of the other ones that I was gonna put higher, so but uh it was it is also on my list.

[47:48] Jesse McInally: I kind of get the feeling that the people who made the movie really liked the lion more than any other character.

[47:53] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Bertlar was like the biggest actor among them. Once he's added in, he gets more screen time than anybody else.

[47:59] Jesse McInally: And then Oh, it can't be about the girl.

[48:02] Andrew DeWolf: What are you?

[48:05] Jesse McInally: It's gotta be about the lion.

[48:06] Andrew DeWolf: He's the big man, he's the big guy.

[48:10] Jesse McInally: Because it's like he wants to be king and like he could be, but like, you know.

[48:14] Andrew DeWolf: He's that's he on a podcast.

[48:17] Jesse McInally: Zach Snyder's Wizard of Oz.

[48:20] Andrew DeWolf: I can't.

[48:21] Jesse McInally: Oh god.

[48:22] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, it's in color, and then they get to Oz and it goes to black and white.

[48:26] Jesse McInally: Four by three.

[48:27] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, the movie's already in four by three shit!

[48:29] Jesse McInally: Of course the lion is Jesus.

[48:31] Andrew DeWolf: He gave up everything.

[48:34] Jesse McInally: And the tin man is Jesus.

[48:37] Andrew DeWolf: And the Wizard of Oz is Jesus.

[48:39] Jesse McInally: The lion sees the tin man and asks, do you bleed?

[48:43] Andrew DeWolf: Or you will.

[48:45] Jesse McInally: Well, well, what may I'm surprised it's on your list, because you don't usually pick the guest episodes.

[48:50] Andrew DeWolf: I picked this one because the the Zack Snyder com uh conversation was too iconic.

[48:57] Jesse McInally: Um and I know I'm almost a hypocrite because I said I said I didn't want to pick something for the Columbo conversation, but I don't know. I just I really liked this one, and it felt more along like it felt like it stuck around longer.

[49:12] Andrew DeWolf: And honestly, I just I just fucking hate Zach Snyder.

[49:15] Jesse McInally: And also the Wizard of Oz is fun to talk about.

[49:17] Andrew DeWolf: And we We had a lot of good conversation in that episode. Like it's a proper educational episode.

[49:23] Jesse McInally: I did a lot of research for it.

[49:25] Andrew DeWolf: My number three is cabaret.

[49:27] Jesse McInally: I think that's a fucking monster of an episode. Bree did an incredible job editing, and Liz did another incredible job in the video version of that episode, which I think is very, very strong.

[49:36] Andrew DeWolf: And our most viewed video on our YouTube channel, after everything that is like cr it it flopped on first airing, and then it's crept up to like 40,000 views at this point.

[49:48] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[49:50] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[49:52] Jesse McInally: And I'm Brianna Jones.

[49:53] Andrew DeWolf: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I tried to get Andrew and Bree to like musical theater.

[49:58] Jesse McInally: And guys, it's our 150th episode.

[50:01] Andrew DeWolf: We did it.

[50:02] Jesse McInally: We did it.

[50:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, we're already there.

[50:05] Jesse McInally: This marks so much.

[50:06] Andrew DeWolf: Not even just 150th.

[50:08] Jesse McInally: It is our 50th episode since Brie has joined on.

[50:11] Andrew DeWolf: It is so many landmarks.

[50:13] Jesse McInally: Like a year ago, this show was so different than what it is right now.

[50:17] Andrew DeWolf: And a year from now it'll be so different than what it is right here.

[50:20] Jesse McInally: And I'm just so happy.

[50:21] Andrew DeWolf: And I want to thank you guys for going on this journey with us.

[50:24] Jesse McInally: It's been a fucking blast so far.

[50:27] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I was just thinking about our show and how much it has changed, and I feel like we have to cover a show that's about how things can change very rapidly.

[50:37] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember a ton about this episode, honestly. I remember covering it, and I remember like I don't think we did a bad job or anything. Is there what do you think is so special about this one?

[50:47] Jesse McInally: Well, it's another mammoth episode like A Star Is Born where we covered all of the cabarets. We covered the nineteen sixties, the film, the nineteen ninety. Like we covered the trilogy of them and the changes and how they were received, and also got us the iconic Ben Brantley review of um, you know, where he just was like, I was uh he was reviewing the people around him more than the show.

[51:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's fucking true. God, uh you know what actually I have another honorable mention, the fucking Peter Pan episode, if you don't have it on your list.

[51:19] Jesse McInally: That is on my list.

[51:20] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um let me give my number two, because I don't have um I'm going to pick uh and honestly, I think I wanna pick uh the Dario Argento Phantom episode here, but it's kind of as a stand-in for I enjoyed this entire Phantom but not Phantom month. The Phantom May or whatever we did. I thought it was such a well-executed thing by us, the entire thing. But I think this one was the weirdest one, and the one that we the episode itself is the best. And then she just comes across the rat man in his Ratmobile. Like it chases her. Like it is I love the ratmobile so much.

[52:11] Jesse McInally: Describe the ratmobile for people, please.

[52:14] Andrew DeWolf: The rat catcher is such a joy, by the way. He's just he's just having a fucking blast in this scene. He's it's like um, it's just a big like go-kart with like a vacuum. Did you call it like tubby custard or tubby noon or something?

[52:31] Jesse McInally: It's it's like the Teletubbies vacuum. You remember the and it has a little thing. Away go the bubbles.

[53:03] Andrew DeWolf: But I really enjoy like Phantom of the Paradise, Phantom of the Mall, like the Freddie Krueger Phantom, like the fact that we covered all of this. There's only one speed bump of that month. There's like one bad episode in there, and that's the Ken Hill episode. If it wasn't for that one, it'd be a perfect track record.

[53:19] Jesse McInally: Exactly. Yeah, and even even that one's it's kind of more of a mediocre episode than a fully bad episode. But like every other episode in that month was great, but Dario Argento, like that one is just fucking weird. It's so fucking weird. It was fun to talk about. It was uh truly one of the most insane experiences ever. And I feel like you having the context of Phantom of the Opera and learning so much made you appreciate how strange that movie is.

[53:50] Andrew DeWolf: It was great. I really liked I liked that a lot, and uh I hope we can do more theme months like that in the future as well. That was a fun thing.

[53:59] Jesse McInally: That is part of the plan for the wheel. Um there's a lot we there's a lot of fun ideas there. Um I I that was kind of our test run of the cheese wheel. If you like that, that's kind of what this new show's gonna be like. If you notice that whole month, we don't really cover any musicals.

[54:19] Andrew DeWolf: We do, but we don't. Like, Phantom of the Paradise has original songs, is a musical for all intents and purposes. Yeah, but like Phantom of the Mall, not really. There's one song. We also had a wonderful guest for that one. Like, Timmy was such a good guest.

[54:34] Jesse McInally: Um, all right. My number two is Peter Pan. New York Times critic Peter Mark says of the 1998 revival. It was during the Ugga Wag Indian number that the little girl in the rainbow colored cardigan turned and flashed me an AOK sign, so I knew she was a white supremacist. I might have been quick to suspect her as an audience planned by the Peter Pan public relations people. Except she was my own daughter. My pleasure was observing their pleasure. For a parent, there are few experiences more exhilarating. And of course, it took me back a hundred years or so to the first time I saw Peter Pan. It was the grainy television version starring Mary Martin and how wowed I was not by a boy who could fly, but by one who had to have his shadow sewn on.

[55:23] Andrew DeWolf: This is the worst review we've ever had. Does he know does he know he's trying he's supposed to be reviewing the show that he's watching? It's like he had nothing to say. So he just word vomited onto the paper and turned it in.

[55:39] Jesse McInally: It I yeah. I mean, we have so much fun in the in the preview section there, it's kind of ridiculous. And yeah, it yeah. I can see why you'd put it on here. And also, like, I remember the energy of that episode. We were recording it the day before Thanksgiving. Like, we were all just excited to not have to work. Like, there was that like first first day going back to first day off of work for a minute, and we all just had like that goofy excitement of like, yeah, we get it. I don't have to worry about the rest of the weekend. It was such an energy that goes with that episode, as well.

[56:14] Andrew DeWolf: As well, I think we make really good points. Our entire conversation about, you know, native representation, I think, was actually really interesting. And I think Liz also made an incredible video that coincides with the thigh really, really like. We're just we're just pimping a YouTube channel at this point.

[56:31] Jesse McInally: Um I uh actually I'm gonna cheat and make this a tide for number two, if that's okay.

[56:36] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, you have a second, you have another video you want to pim.

[56:40] Jesse McInally: I wish. This is one I want to make a video one day, um, but haven't yet. And my my what Peter Pan is tied with our Music Man revival conversation, where I think we got the most lively, interesting debates about like modern theater, and I really think we had a lot to say about like censorship and how modern relationships to older media that has not aged perfectly and the wrong ways to handle that. I think that's a really well-done episode where he got into really good debates.

[57:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. And I think that leads nicely into my my my number one pick, I guess, which is our Dear Evan Hansen revisit with the movie. I think both our Dear Evan Hansen episodes are great, so they're both that's my number one too.

[57:27] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[57:29] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[57:31] Jesse McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater. How are you doing today, Andrew?

[57:37] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I just watched Dear Evan Hansen, so I'm I'm sure you can guess how I'm feeling.

[57:41] Jesse McInally: Oh, I bet you're feeling great.

[57:43] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like someone just broke my arm.

[57:45] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I I this I I can't put the original on be in good faith because I haven't re-listened to it and I don't really know what I say in there. I would assume that we're probably mostly fine, but the revisit where we go back to it after the movie had come out and after basically everyone had changed their minds and started agreeing with us. It was weird.

[58:07] Andrew DeWolf: It's one, it was like vindicating to come back, make the same sort of points, and be like, wow, everyone agrees with us now. Isn't that nice? But also, I had more time to think it through, and I feel like the points we made in that revisit were better as well. And I think we were playing a little fairer. You know what I mean? We were mean early on. Like we liked especially me. Like, I just we liked being mean. And we we got fair because we realized that people are actually watching us, and maybe we shouldn't just say irresponsible things all the time.

[58:44] Jesse McInally: Um so we got a lot more fair, but honestly, I think fair is better. Like fair is, you know, it's a little it's it may be less exciting to be fair, but I think we make better points and we we have more interesting things to say. And also I did a lot of research to make sure that I knew what I was going into and understood the context, you know, uh the context for which I we all exist within um and all that jazz. Um I I really think that that's uh an effective uh like I think it's a great episode. And I think our Dear Evan Hansen episode made us, and I think our second Dear Evan Hansen episode re-made us.

[59:25] Andrew DeWolf: That's I think that is fair. That is a fair assessment. Like, I don't know how the actual popularity happened, but I know the Dear Evan Hansen episode definitely got us attention.

[59:37] Jesse McInally: Not always good.

[59:38] Andrew DeWolf: Well, let's be clear, not always great. We didn't get good attention necessarily. There was some people who were like, oh my god, someone's finally saying it. But there was definitely other people. A few members of the Great Comic Cast specifically. Um I I it's hard to top when we did something that was that uh impressive and telling our own stories of seeing that movie. And also the movie is just fucking weird. I feel like we don't. That movie is so strange.

[1:00:06] Jesse McInally: I feel like if we had kept the same energy as our older show, we would probably just bring that up in every episode and make fun of it in every episode, but we kind of just stopped. Like we just I I don't know. I don't think about the Dear Evan Hansen movie anymore, even though it is just dog shit. Like the build-up to it was real. The build-up to that movie was insane because the trailers were crazy and it's we're coming out of COVID and we don't really know what movie theaters are like anymore. And this is what you're offering us? It was like made during COVID, and you can tell.

[1:00:43] Andrew DeWolf: You can really tell when you watch it now, and you're like, man, those halls look pretty empty. It's i i it's it is just a bad movie. Especially bad because it's based on a show that wasn't good in the first place. So It's weird. It's weird to think I can't even say they ruined it. I I think I I hope that if we had any impact on on the wider theater space at all, it is making people not like Dear Evan Hansen. I think that is our mettle. And you know what? Dear Evan Hansen closed shortly after the movie. I think the movie killed it.

[1:01:20] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Like I don't know. What do you think?

[1:01:25] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I guess we we gotta end this soon, but Yeah, we gotta wrap this up. What what do you think our our impact on the theater space will be now that we're leaving it?

[1:01:36] Jesse McInally: I really don't know. I feel like I made a lot of friends in the theater world that I plan to keep. It's not like they're going away, and I'm very grateful to have them and I love them very much. And it's not like, oh, now that we're moving on to not talk about Broadway every week, we're not gonna talk have Broadway people on. We love Broadway people.

[1:01:52] Andrew DeWolf: Well, they're our friends.

[1:01:55] Jesse McInally: Yeah, honestly, I think I guess leaving the space isn't necessarily accurate because I mean we s we're gonna keep all the same friends and all the same yeah interests and everything. We're still on the Broadway Podcast Network. That ain't changing at the moment. But we're not gonna be talking about musicals every single week. We're gonna try to fit in some new things. Um and it's also gonna have a little bit more gamified um that it'll be interesting.

[1:02:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um are you gonna miss learning about musicals?

[1:02:27] Jesse McInally: At this point, I I think I'm I think I'm good. I've learned I've learned so much that at this point I'm effectively an expert.

[1:02:35] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like you know more about musicals than some people writing musicals right now.

[1:02:40] Jesse McInally: Yeah, which isn't a good thing for our show. And I feel like you you could feel it in our show at a certain point where it's like we've lost the premise.

[1:02:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:02:48] Jesse McInally: The premise of the show is. It's it's gone, and now it's not that interesting to hear this guy. Like, remember I and I I was almost thinking about a adding these as honorable mentions, but do you remember really early on we did those two episodes where I guess what happens in musicals?

[1:03:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[1:03:05] Jesse McInally: Like we can've got to be. Have you ever thought about revisiting those?

[1:03:08] Andrew DeWolf: No, I I haven't. Like, I would just read off a title and Andrew would have to pitch what he thought the musical was about.

[1:03:14] Jesse McInally: And some gold.

[1:03:16] Andrew DeWolf: You're right, brothers musical. That's still a fucking great idea. I'm sorry. I hope that that gets made someday, maybe by us. I would love to. Um, but it's sh and make me a musical is still something I love doing. I wish Andrew had more time to do it, but I still think it's a great premise and a fun thing to do. And if it's not dead, just kind of hiding.

[1:03:38] Jesse McInally: Well, do you feel about uh how do you feel about if we go out and we capture like a small nation state? Like, how do you feel about that?

[1:03:46] Andrew DeWolf: That sounds pretty kick-ass.

[1:03:48] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Um, what last question, literally last question before we wrap this up. What do you think is the best thing we've ever covered? Like the best piece of content we ever covered. And we know what the worst one is. Like, we will rock you. So basically, what would be your S tier and what is your lowest tier?

[1:04:07] Andrew DeWolf: Well, we will rock you, I've already said. That's on the list because I think it's the worst thing we've ever covered. Um, I think the best is way too subjective. I think there's quite a few things that could easily be there. But honestly, the thing that's still my favorite thing we've covered is still our first episode.

[1:04:25] Jesse McInally: Sweetie Todd.

[1:04:26] Andrew DeWolf: I wear it.

[1:04:27] Jesse McInally: I did too well too early. It's the only horror musical to ever really do it. Like, it's the only one that really like nails the tone and the sound of like a horror film. And I hope that someone else does it eventually.

[1:04:43] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, Repo tried.

[1:04:46] Jesse McInally: It tried.

[1:04:47] Andrew DeWolf: It failed, though.

[1:04:49] Jesse McInally: I don't think it failed. I think it just didn't fail.

[1:04:52] Andrew DeWolf: It's quite do it. It's not quite what I'm looking for. Um, but there's I mean, if that's not your like, there's plenty of other stuff we've covered that I'd be like, yeah, that was really freaking good. Um, I think see, the problem is a lot of the things I'm so emotionally attached to.

[1:05:08] Jesse McInally: I don't know. Here's the thing. It's bummed me out that I can't really enjoy musicals because it feels like work. I'm very excited to be able to enjoy musicals again now that this is all kind of behind me, and we can do other things, and hopefully that means I can have the passion to bring something to the table and be like, fuck, look at this, everybody. I want that again.

[1:05:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:05:26] Jesse McInally: So um another episode I thought we did really good on was our um unabridged uh Bridgerton musical. That that's just a fun episode.

[1:05:39] Andrew DeWolf: I wanted to throw that one in there.

[1:05:41] Juliet: Hello and welcome to Lace's still and my dad listens to this. I'm Juliet, pronoun she they, and I am the keeper of the cheese. After listening to all 300 episodes, to which Jess and Andrew, I salute you both. I have come up with the final top ten episodes from musicals with cheese in its entire history.

[1:06:12] Juliet: So we're gonna do some top ten episodes and we're gonna do some cheese ratings. So, let's dive into it, shall we?

[1:06:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yes, let's.

[1:06:21] Juliet: Number ten.

[1:06:22] Juliet: Home on the range. So this list is going to be a balance of joking around and some good theater criticism. But in terms of the joking around episodes, this one is the most iconic because of the Alameda's slim in his nephew's comparison. Alameda for Andrew, the nephew's for Jess. And I think that if you wanted to start with a non-musical theater episode, this was the one to do it.

[1:06:43] Juliet: Number nine on the list, which I believe was also number nine for when we first did a top ten, the Yestin and Copit Phantom. One of the Phantom episodes had to be on here, for me personally, as a Phantom fan. And if you listen to any of them at all, do this one. Because we learn about its place in the Phantom Legacy and also get the best recap, or the most hilarious recap, of the most heart-wrenching version ever.

[1:07:09] Juliet: Which you think you wouldn't be able to make it funny, but Jess, Andrew, and a great guest to discuss it with, Angelina Meehan, did. Next episode, number eight.

[1:07:19] Juliet: Damn Yankees. Another one that was on here primarily for the lulls, but it was an episode that poked good naturedly at a Bob Fossey musical from Theatre's Golden Age. And yes, if you're going to know your musicals with cheese lore, then you're going to have to know about their feelings on Angels in the Outfield. This episode gave birth to that.

[1:07:40] Juliet: Number seven, The Frogs. Putting this one on the list because this is an episode where Andrew stuck to his guns and showed why the dynamic between Jess and Andrew worked perfectly. In terms of Andrew sticking to his guns episodes, it was a toss-up between Pippin and this, but this one won out in the end.

[1:07:58] Juliet: And it showed why the dynamic between Jess and Andrew worked, because if Jess got bought out, Andrew never could. And I feel like if musicals with cheese disrupted the Broadway gene pool for good, this is the episode that did it for taking a Sondheim show swept under the rug and showing why it didn't deserve it. Hence why it's on the list.

[1:08:17] Juliet: Next episode, Death Note. So if you listened to a Frank Wildhorn episode in the musicals with Cheese Cannon, I think you should pick this one. Because Wildhorn had finally arrived in the musical theater scene in Japan, and we got to hear what it was like getting to put on the show from one of the actresses involved, the beloved Musicals with Cheese regular Rachel Chan.

[1:08:41] Juliet: If this was the last Wildhorn show you ever covered, I mean, what a perfect note to go out on. And again, I feel like it's also a good gateway episode for people who might not be as into musicals but are into anime and kind of going down the rabbit hole things they're passionate about. You find this episode, and then you're a fan for life now.

[1:09:01] Juliet: Alrighty, we are moving in to the top five. So, number five, the number one episode from our second ever year interview, Sweet Charity, featuring the band Thanks. And Andrew became the teacher in this one for his friends Andrew and Grell.

[1:09:15] Juliet: And I also think this episode is good evidence as to why the new podcast, The Cheese Wheel, is going to work. Because you guys get along great talking with anybody on something they're passionate about, even in this case, if it happened to be a Fossy musical, because someone had to play drums in the pit when a senior in a musical production got a case of senioritis.

[1:09:37] Juliet: And it's an episode that also had to go back to musicals with cheese's roots of explaining musical theater and what the show's place was in history and the musical theater cultural zeitgeist.

[1:09:49] Juliet: Number four, the music man revival. An emotional catharsis for all the theater fans outside the New York theater scene. It's an episode that could have become a nostalgic critic rant, and we wouldn't have blamed you if you did, but you didn't let it go that direction, and we had a better episode for it.

[1:10:05] Juliet: And if this was the episode that pissed off the Broadway community, good. And it was also the episode I most remember Andrew's editing skills getting to shine as he incorporated the memes from SpongeBob's episode of Band Geeks into this episode. I mean, that's a perfect combination.

[1:10:20] Juliet: And frankly, I'm a bit boggled that nobody had ever thought of that combination before because it works perfectly. Alright, number three.

[1:10:29] Juliet: God bless you, Mr. Rosewater. This one is a great comfort episode for me. Ethan from Sideways fit in with the show perfectly, and I remember even while just listening to the opening while you guys were joking about, oh Tim Allen's here, and you brought Puzzle here, and you didn't tell me the chemistry was just blossoming, and we could tell that you guys were gonna be friends and collaborators for life.

[1:10:51] Juliet: And this one goes on here for bringing awareness to an Ashman Mencken project that gets forgotten due to their Disney career, but it's a show I'll always be glad that you covered as a Howard Asherman fan. And it's a perfect balance of humor and respecting an obscure musical theater piece.

[1:11:08] Juliet: Alright, number two, a strange loop. I will be grateful to this episode for filling in the blanks that listeners had who only read the book and had the cast recording to try to piece together what the plot of the show was.

[1:11:21] Juliet: He treated this seriously and made time to listen to Cam Blackwell's critiques of the show, his comments on Inner White Girl being a key moment in the episode, so he wasn't tokenized like he easily could have been. And it was recorded at just the right time as the show came out. It's a perfect capsule of musical theater history.

[1:11:40] Juliet: Okay. Final episode. The number one musicals with cheese episode of all time is A Star is Born. This is number one because I meant what I said the first time when I made it number one for last year's year interview. We were never gonna see a musicals with cheese episode like this again.

[1:12:01] Juliet: Your research paid off as you dove into all four films, explaining their context in movie history and movie musical history. You weave together a chronological narrative that made sense for the listeners and they didn't feel lost. We felt like we went on this journey with you, and for that reason it's number one.

[1:12:19] Juliet: So that's the musicals part. What about the cheese part? Well, as the keeper of the cheese, I've got you covered. Here are the top cheese ratings of all time.

[1:12:28] Juliet: So, first is Jess. Jess's best cheese rating of all time is the one he gave to the wild party, both versions. For the Lippa version, he gave it a party cheese platter, but cheaply made full of cheeses I like, and all of them are good but badly made. And for Laquisa, a fancy cheese assortment, but of cheeses I don't like that are produced way better.

[1:12:50] Juliet: I feel like that rating perfectly captured the differences between the Lipper version and the Laquisa version. And if you listen to the episode in more detail, you'll look at why that rating makes sense. Now, the best cheese rating for Andrew.

[1:13:05] Juliet: Cheetah's Fantastics flaming hot from the Fantastics episode, because it conjured up the image of Al Gaio just watching all this stuff that's going on, and just, you know, calmly standing there eating some Cheetos Fantastics flaming hot while singing the musical theater standard try to remember. So for that visual alone, it's on here.

[1:13:25] Juliet: And we're going to go with uh three more. And we're gonna pay tribute to our first ever editor of musicals with cheese, the first professional editor we had, Brie. The best cheese rating for Brie is Swiss cheese from the Little Drummer Boy because of the plot holes that were not in the Bible. Perfect.

[1:13:43] Juliet: And for Liz, Liz's best cheese rating is from Rock of Ages with the cheese pour some gouda on me. What a perfect pun. Thank you, Trader Joes.

[1:13:55] Juliet: And finally, the best cheese rating of all time, Jess's mom, Mama McInally, with blue cheese for the Grinch Live on NBC, because they blew it. Yes, it's technically a bonus episode, but no cheese rating will ever top that one. Hence why it's on the list.

[1:14:10] Juliet: Alrighty, everybody, so that's it. That is the final top 10 recap of musicals with cheese. I'm sorry I couldn't be there with you, Andrew and Jess in person, but the schedules didn't line up. However, I wanted to take the time to record this.

[1:14:24] Juliet: Who would have thought when you jokingly said, oh, we should have a spreadsheet of someone keeping track of our ratings, that one person who you had never met before would listen to it, hear that comment, go back and listen to 100 plus episodes, and create a spreadsheet for you. I still can't believe that I know you guys.

[1:14:42] Juliet: It boggles my mind, but I am so proud that I could play a small part in the show, and I'm so glad that you guys are going on this new chapter, and I cannot wait to record the new cheese ratings for the cheese wheel. And every time I'll see my name under your names on Spotify, to quote 1776, a show that you'll never do.

[1:15:05] Juliet: Oh, my puny little chest will swell with pride. Alright, well, everybody, thanks for listening to Musicals with Cheese for all these 300 episodes. And everybody, I'll see you next time.

[1:15:18] Andrew DeWolf: Any last words, Andrew, for us as Musicals with Cheese before officially next week we are the Cheese.

[1:15:25] Andrew DeWolf: No. We're done.

[1:15:26] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. I've said everything I need to say. Thank you all for listening.

[1:15:31] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you so much. And stick with us. It's gonna be fun.

[1:15:34] Jesse McInally: It is.

[1:15:34] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna go. Let's take over to the k Molassia.

[1:15:38] Jesse McInally: Let's go!

[1:15:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah! See us next week, motherfuckers!

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred