Bonnie Milligan, powerhouse performer and literal beam of light, sits down for a candid conversation about grief and faith, friendship, working with your heroes, and what she's learned in the past three years. Plus, how bonnie launched my entire career... Read More
From the show: The Come Up
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Bonnie Milligan, powerhouse performer and literal beam of light, sits down for a candid conversation about grief and faith, friendship, working with your heroes, and what she's learned in the past three years. Plus, how bonnie launched my entire career.
At the time of release, Bonnie is starring in the new broadway musical Kimberly Akimbo.
Bonnie was nominated by both the Drama League and the Outer Critics Circle for her Broadway debut in Head Over Heels, for which she also won the Theatre World Award. First National Tour: original Pat in Kinky Boots. Off-Broadway: Promenade and God Bless You Mr. Rosewater (Encores!); Gigantic (Vineyard Theatre); Jasper in Deadland (Prospect Theater). Television: recurring as Katherine Witherbottom on “Search Party” (HBO Max) and Bitsy on “Escape at Dannemora” (Showtime), “Chicago Fire” (NBC), and “Happy” (SyFy).
IG: @beltingbons
On The Come Up, host Matt Rodin sits with creative people to find out where they’re at, today, in the journey of becoming who they are. What unfolds are often inspiring, transcendental, and candid conversations about the reality of being a growing artist.
Matt believes that love is who we are. He taps into people’s light so that we can form deeper connections with ourselves and one another. He’s a queer maker of music, media, characters, and campfires. As an actor, Matt recently starred in Hedwig and the Angry Inch at Milwaukee Rep, and the upcoming musical film BEAU. In 2020, he released his first live solo album, Matt Rodin: Live at Home. Matt has also worked as a content producer and consultant for The Tony Awards, The Smithsonian Institute, SoulCycle, Hamilton, Cynthia Erivo, Ingrid Michaelson, Playbill, Broadway.com, Dear Evan Hansen, Write Out Loud, and more.
The Come Up is presented by Broadway Podcast Network
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Matt Rodin: Hey, thanks for hitting play. Welcome to The Come Up. My name is Matt, and on this episode, a conversation with Bonnie Milligan, who, interestingly, plays a pivotal role in my own New York City origin story, which you'll hear all about shortly. This was recorded in early November 2022 while Bonnie was in the middle of preview performances for the musical Kimberly Akimbo on Broadway. We talk about grief and faith and friendship and Victoria Clark and what the past three years have taught Bonnie. I'm grateful that the podcast gave us an excuse to catch up and dive deep. And now, here is Bonnie Milligan.
[0:46] Bonnie Milligan: Okay, before we like dive into everything, I have a story to tell you that I don't know. I'm not telling you the story. It's not a quiz. I'm not asking you to remember, but I have to tell you a story. Okay. So in 2014, I just moved to the city, and I was like, I need to do something. I can't just um I can't just sit around waiting for auditions. I need to like be somewhat busy and I want to be involved in the quote unquote industry. So I got an internship at 54 Below working for Jen Tepper as their programming intern. That summer, Bonnie Milligan, you did a concert at 54 Below. Michael Joya was um a participant in that concert. He helped hand out Girl Scout cookies, if I if I remember correctly.
[1:33] Bonnie Milligan: And helped bake them.
[1:34] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[1:35] Bonnie Milligan: Oh, you baked the cookie. Oh, they were like Girl Scout cookies. They were made cookies. Okay, great. Yeah. So that night I met Michael Joya, and six months later, Michael, Michael had seen something, a video that I had made on my own. He brought it to Blake Ross, who used to be the editor-in-chief of Playboy. Blake then was like, you should come work for Playbill. And then that was like the beginning of everything for me. So the truth is you are the reason.
[2:07] Bonnie Milligan: I'm the reason.
[2:08] Matt Rodin: For all of it.
[2:10] Bonnie Milligan: The good, the bad, and the ugly. But but but so it's so I was thinking about that last night. It was like, wow, I have to tell her that like it all started with Michael Joya handing out Girl Scout cookies at your concert.
[2:23] Bonnie Milligan: It's so amazing.
[2:24] Matt Rodin: And I just recently spoke with Michael Joya for People Magazine. And we were like, look how far we've come, babe.
[2:32] Bonnie Milligan: Wow.
[2:33] Matt Rodin: That's amazing.
[2:34] Bonnie Milligan: That's amazing. That I didn't know that was your first 54 Below show.
[2:39] Matt Rodin: That was my first solo show anywhere in the city. It was the year I had done so many different concerts at 54 Below. Um, guested and all these different things.
[2:50] Bonnie Milligan: Right.
[2:51] Matt Rodin: That uh Jen Tepper and Dylan Bustamonte were like, you have to do your own show before I was about to leave for the Kinky Boots tour. And they asked me literally like a month before.
[3:03] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah.
[3:03] Matt Rodin: And I said, okay, which was really scary to throw together a show in a month. Now I've since done it in like a week. So but like for your first one ever.
[3:12] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah.
[3:13] Matt Rodin: You're like, I don't know what to do. So um that's always gonna be like the most special show ever. But how how long had you been in the city at that point? Like, because you had but you like you said, you were doing con you were singing in people's concerts.
[3:27] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah, I mean, I had been around for a few years. Like I when I first got here, I definitely um kind of I've talked about kind of losing myself a little bit, and I wasn't really, I feel like in the industry or pounding the pavement the way I kind of uh had originally imagined when I moved here and then I got into some therapy and helped sort of rediscover uh confidence in myself. So I feel like I really started hitting the scene in 2012 when I did my first production at the Flea Theater um down in Tribeca.
[4:05] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah and that's when I started making connections that's actually where I met Adam Guan who the very first 54 Below concert I was ever a part of was his first solo show there in 2013.
[4:19] Matt Rodin: Oh my god and then it just built up from there and sort of meeting people and um getting a part of the concert scene um and then started doing workshops and readings and finally getting in on some auditions that I used to get typed out of.
[4:33] Bonnie Milligan: Right.
[4:33] Matt Rodin: You know did you did you feel like even as you were um I don't want to say like getting momentum but like doing the concerts and then you're doing your solo show I'm I'm curious like what the feeling was in terms of um like feeling accomplished and feeling like I'm doing the thing but also like you hadn't booked the Kinky tour yet and you obviously hadn't done a Broadway show yet. So like did you still feel like you were on the outside um I did feel on the outside I guess of like the Broadway industry um what I started what I felt like the first community I felt kind of accept me and become a part of were writers within um new musical theater writers who saw me in little things here and there and started asking me to sing their work.
[5:27] Bonnie Milligan: And I did a lot of those like compilation concerts where you know Jen Tepper produced a lot of those where it would be an evening of or they pick a theme and it would be many composers.
[5:38] Matt Rodin: And maybe I'd sing in one of those so the rest of the composers there that night heard me and then would get my contact info and then I'd start working with them that way. So that's truly kind of like how the networking of me meeting new writers was and new work is a big passion of mine. I went to the Ohio State University and they have a big the uh pro the you have to add the yeah always um that uh a big focus on their program is new work.
[6:08] Bonnie Milligan: Oh so um I write as well I developed as a writer and um I it it's a passionate thing for me to be in the room and to watch the process and to be a part of the process. And so that's kind of how I started making connections within the industry.
[6:25] Bonnie Milligan: And then I started feeling uh a part of the community in that way.
[6:29] Matt Rodin: So that was satisfying, I imagine that to like be a part of all that new stuff.
[6:32] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah.
[6:33] Bonnie Milligan: And I mean a lot of that, you know, those concerts for up and coming writers they don't have a lot of money. And I did it for free and I did it for the love of it. And um it was amazing because I made so many connections and you know my heart grew.
[6:49] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah to do something I really love doing. And you don't know you know I mean that's sort of the gamble with new work. It's like you don't know who will see this thing or what that could lead to or what project this person's working on. I, you know, that was one of the things that I feel like I I learned early on about auditioning was like, even if you don't get that job, like you're getting in the room for somebody, and you don't know what else they're working on now or in five years from now, when they're like, Oh, yeah, remember that person that we saw? You just don't know.
[7:20] Bonnie Milligan: You have no idea. Like, even I it's so funny. I was recently um, you know, purging things. I save everything. And I was like, okay, you need to, you know, clean out some things. I save I'm a big person on words mean a lot to me. So I save cards and I save letters and I save all these things. And I found uh I did Gigantic off Broadway back in 2015.
[7:43] Bonnie Milligan: And back when it was originally called Fat Camp, they were first going to be bringing it around. And I auditioned, and I didn't realize um I'd actually emailed my dad about it. I had auditioned five different times to come in as like in the ensemble and to cover, and I didn't get it. And I I just saw this email to him being like, I don't know. I felt they were so encouraging. It, you know, it's upsetting, but I understand.
[8:11] Bonnie Milligan: And it was just this interest interesting thing that like days before I had just found my opening night cards from the writing team talking to me about how they were so glad it finally worked out and how much fun it was. And it was like that is such a it was within days of each other I found these that email and these cards about something I had gone in for.
[8:42] Matt Rodin: You know what I mean? It was the same project that five times it wasn't right, and then years later, they're like, now it is.
[8:48] Bonnie Milligan: Now it is. Um, let alone those concerts where somebody's there. Like, I, you know, I was doing that show at the Flea Theater, and that's how I got my agent.
[8:59] Bonnie Milligan: Um, a casting director was there. Andrew from Manella, they have their own um agency now, but they were working at Telsey at the time. And they said, You're non-equity and you don't have an agent. I I think I want to help you. And they brought me in to Telsey like on a Sunday on a day off, and their boyfriend at the time played for me, and I sang a few songs.
[9:24] Bonnie Milligan: They put it on tape and submitted me to agencies. That's how I got my agent, was because a casting director was at the show that knew I was not getting paid and I was non-equity and had no agent. And um, it was because of the connection I made doing something that again, you're not getting paid for, but you get to do your work.
[9:46] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[9:46] Bonnie Milligan: And um I I found so much of like my career in this business has been about the connections I've made with people, as opposed to like going into a room as a stranger and auditioning.
[9:58] Matt Rodin: I think that's important too.
[10:00] Bonnie Milligan: And I also want to say that's also a reflection of you.
[10:04] Matt Rodin: Like that's a reflection of your kindness and your generosity.
[10:07] Bonnie Milligan: You know what I mean? Because like that, if you were if you were a nasty person, those those like people would not feel like that's what I'm saying. So so like, you know, like that is a reflection of like what you put out, you know, you're and that's not to say that like there's any guarantees, but right when you show up with kindness and you show up with love, you know, and excitement and joy.
[10:29] Matt Rodin: Um it's this sort of like, you know, sky's the limit.
[10:34] Bonnie Milligan: You you just don't know. I feel like Oprah has some kind of a she has some, you know, quote about that.
[10:39] Matt Rodin: Sure she does when preparedness meets opportunity.
[10:42] Bonnie Milligan: Like you need to show up, you need to have done your work, um, and be ready for anything. But also, I think adding into that a big thing that my parents always instilled in me growing up was kindness to others and um maintaining a humble quality, knowing that the work can always deepen, you can always learn from others, and you're not above anything.
[11:09] Bonnie Milligan: So just be pleasant to be around, and people will want to be around you.
[11:14] Matt Rodin: So let me ask you a question then like, how do you balance, and I really mean you like how do you balance that humility with like confidence? Because I feel like both of those are necessary in like knowing your worth, right? Being like, no, this is what I can do, this is who I am, this is what I bring to the room, but also being like, but I'm a student and I'm like willing to, I'm open, right?
[11:36] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah.
[11:37] Bonnie Milligan: I think honestly, it comes from my deep, deep love of musical theater.
[11:44] Matt Rodin: That this you're a theater, you're like a theater nerd, you're like a musical.
[11:48] Bonnie Milligan: I'm a theater nerd.
[11:49] Bonnie Milligan: And growing up in a trailer in the Midwest, you know, with family that we didn't have much money, and going and getting cast albums at Barnes and Noble.
[11:59] Bonnie Milligan: That's what we had to used to do, and learning about the show within the liner notes, you know, oh, that's the plot. Um and loving musical theater so much that I I truly still have that sense of wonder within me that anytime I got to be in a room with heroes of mine, and I've been so lucky to have really worked with many heroes of mine.
[12:24] Bonnie Milligan: Um, and some of these icons that I have looked up to for years and years, I now call friends, um, will never not humble me.
[12:34] Bonnie Milligan: I think it's so beautiful. I think so many times in many industries, but it's hard to break through when you don't have money and resources behind you to give you a step up in life, or parents or people in the industry, again, any industry that be like, you know, here's a million dollars, go start a business, or here meet my friend who's directing a thing. You want to be in it because you're my kid, stuff like that. To not have that is a harder start. But then to now be able to be in the rooms and get to be a part of this really loving, beautiful community who have embraced me so wholly, really. Um, it does humble me because I will never, I think, be able to forget that kid who didn't have much, who just dreamed of so much.
Yeah. Um, and to work really hard to say, I deserve to be here. I think there were some years that I didn't know and fully believe that there felt like the imposter syndrome of it all, you know, because I didn't have the other stuff that others do, that you're like, no, I've worked really hard, I've trained really hard, and um, I continue to work really hard that you deserve your spot here, and it's okay to feel good about that, but to not um get over, get in over your head about it. I don't know. That's something of like a young kid, I think was always instilled in me with my parents to be nice and humble and hardworking. So that's just still in there. And I hope I never let go of that because um I like realizing what I have and being very grateful.
[14:28] Matt Rodin: Yeah, like maintaining that sense of awe, I think it's like that you said is so it's so well said and so important, and honoring that little girl that's inside you that like still is like, oh my god, like this, this is I get to do this, I get to this need to do that. So so then I guess the question is, you know, when you're in the run, you've gotten to do a lot of things. Um, but in a sort of more extended run, um, or when you saw the reality, right? Because I think this is always so interesting when I talk to people who because I'm like this, people who were like fans of musical theater and dreamed of quote unquote Broadway as a kid. Yeah, I'm always curious to know like what was the experience like when that like you finally broke that barrier, you know, like when Head Over Heels finally happened, right? And the reality of doing eight shows a week, uh-huh. And all of that, like all of that real stuff starts to happen. Yes. How how did that land for you? You know, like what was that like?
[15:36] Bonnie Milligan: I mean, it's um it's a very intense um Head Over Heels. I guess we can talk about that specifically. At first was, you know, the first sort of breaking of the bubble of like the fantasy of it all and what it actually is to be inside of it. Yeah, that realizing we're not robots, we're human beings, and we can do what we can do. Um, and eight shows a week is really hard. And especially when you're in um tech and in previews and you're at the theater, you know, like Tuesday, I left my house at 12:45 to get to the theater and I got home at 11:30 p.m. Yeah. And it's just a long day to be out and to be gone and to be thinking about, you know, clearly you have dinner breaks and stuff in there. But it's just um it's a lot.
And to uh also not take it for granted because you're like, this is all I've ever wanted. Right. When you're walking through Times Square and you're like, uh, Times Square. I remember I used to have to really walk, you know, because I take get off the one train to walk um Head Over Heels was at the Hudson. So it's on the east side of you know, Times Square. I would really have to walk through it. And sometimes I would say out loud to myself as I was walking, this is all you've ever dreamed of. This is all you've ever dreamed of. This is all you've ever dreamed of. Because I would get such like walking like road rage for walkers because I'm like, oh God, get me through. Um, but it's it's it's a rude awakening to realize how exhausted your body gets, how your mind gets this now is a whole whole other level of COVID.
Um, the constant sort of mental, and it I honestly feel when we first did this, Kimberly at Kimbo at the Atlantic, it was really during the Omicron surge. And we had just come off like two years of like you know, not really two years, but like a year and a half of like everything shut down and everything's gone away. And so many of us are like, this may never come back. And you finally are like, oh, we're coming back. And then people are getting it again. And you're like, oh my gosh. So the mental anguish daily of taking those tests and being like, please don't be positive. Please let me go to work today. Oh God was another taxing um scary thing because we just come back. Now, of course, if we still test, I feel a little less like I say, watch, I get COVID tomorrow.
But you know what I mean? It's but it's scary. It's it's a level of taking care of yourself. I never do when I'm not in a show. It's funny now that I'm in Head Over Heels and now I take so many vitamins. I'm like doing the thing. Like I do not drink, I go to sleep while I try to sleep, I try to drink as much water as possible. And it um I have less of a social life. Um, because I choose to, and I choose to try to be at my top to perform. Um, because usually the roles I'm performing are a little difficult. Yeah, somewhat demanding. I have to like keep a certain vocal health and physical, emotional health about it all. Um, so it's a lot different than like the glitz and glam you kind of dream of.
But then there's there's also beauty in getting to live the dream and during Head Over Heels back when stage doors were, you know, really available and um they're hard. We're not really supposed to do them now because of COVID, and you should really keep your distance. But getting to meet fans and getting to see people that like represent really what I was as a kid when I'm right to me is a beautiful full circle feeling and so it's both it's like the hardest thing you've ever done and the most beautiful um it's really all the feelings in one um but it's completely different than what you than what you expect yeah yeah than what you imagine um it's just so much harder and um no matter where I'm coming at in life maybe something personal has happened or emotionally you're going through something or maybe your knee is kind of hurt or your back or whatever but showing up and giving everything you've got I think is also a beautiful testament to people who love this art form.
[20:23] Matt Rodin: And um and I see that happen with every single member of my cast members and can really come back. They're giving it everybody is giving all they've got and loving it. And you say they're giving a hundred percent or 75% I'm just curious. I'm oh I'm I just for my own curiosity would you say they're giving a hundred or something more like full out and go from there. Go from there.
[20:48] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah I just had a very interesting conversation with um Lena Hall about about about this and um and and about showing up as you are day to day and a hundred percent uh at least for me, meaning like I'm showing up fully today where I am. Yes. And I'm gonna and I'm gonna and I'm gonna do I'm gonna be present in whatever this is today. Yes. Um and it varies because we're human beings. Of course. Um I'm gonna say to watch Victoria Clark, who, you know, uh it's pub it's publicized. We can say it. She's 63 years old, donning this outfit and she disappears. I look at her as my niece. I really think of her as a teenager niece that I love. And she barely leaves the stage. She is she has worked so hard on how she approaches her vocals so she can kind of sound younger.
And even though she wants to unleash full piazza, uh you know what I mean. That like and we do we're like, please. Oh God, give me it all day long. And she gives you some touches of it. But like to watch this woman really uh it's she's one of the most generous scene partners I've ever had, and I truly all of my scenes are with her. That she's always with me. Those eyes are alive, she is there. The perf it's so in every single one of my co-stars, truly, it's one of the most incredible casts I've ever been a part of in so many Broadway debuts, but everyone is just responding. It just feels alive.
[22:29] Matt Rodin: And I know we're like early on, like talk to me in real life three years, we're still there. But you know what? But I but I think that but that's important though, Bonnie, because I think I I I think it's important to highlight that like where the conversation we're having right now is happening in this moment, right? Yes. You haven't opened yet. You've just locked your show. You don't have rehearsal today. Like that, that is the reality of this moment. And so I think acknowledging that and like finding the awe and the joy and the beauty in in what this is right now, I think is like a ma it just yeah, makes me. I feel my heart is very full hearing that. Because this is a fun moment to be in.
[23:07] Bonnie Milligan: It's so beautiful. It's so fun. It's so amazing to be a part of all these debuts. Um, I the first preview I came upstairs and Vicky and I were both burst into sobbing tears, literally just because we were so proud of, I mean, they're, you know, young adults, but we call them our kids, because they are so amazing and I'm so proud of them. And we are both crying and hugging everybody as they came up the stairs, just because we got to be a part of their history forever. And that is the literal like feeling of the theater, which is what's so beautiful. I think that like I'm more excited about everybody else around me, and that I get to be a part of it than anything that's like, oh, just me, Mimi. It's not that at all. And that's everybody on that stage. And I think that's why people are walking away, feeling this like beautiful desire of connection and doing something with your life and this uplifting tone is because we just lift each other up the whole time.
[24:14] Matt Rodin: In the company.
[24:15] Bonnie Milligan: In the company. And is that the is that currently right? Because we're talking about this moment. Is that like the vibe backstage too? Like, is it it has it been that like across the board?
[24:25] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah. That's like we ever since the Atlantic, then there's only nine of us in the show. We gather together and we kind of do little mini warm-up. We we say, let's do eyes, and we all look at each other in the eye, and we kind of just gather before every show. And um, we still do it now. They everybody comes down around my dressing room and we sit and make eyes, and we just say, Okay, we're about to do this thing, we get to do this thing today. Yeah, and um it's so beautiful.
[24:56] Bonnie Milligan: It's so beautiful. Did you anticipate that it would come that you guys would come in? Did you like honestly? No. Um, honestly, because there, you know, uh it was no, I'm not gonna lie to you. It was not on my radar. So much had happened, you know, the pandemic, my dad had just died when they asked for my audition tape, and then I was finally able to make one after a while. I got the show, and they're like, it's gonna be this summer, and I'm like, I don't know. And then it kept getting pushed back. That was 2020. And so when we finally got the note that we're actually gonna start rehearsals this September last year, I thought, oh, I do have a job. Okay, okay, sure. And you just show up and you think, oh my gosh, I get to be in a room again and collaborate.
That's what I love so much about theater, is it's so collaborative. Yeah, and we had just spent over a year on Zoom. Well, here we are on Zoom, but on like I did a couple of Zoom readings, yeah. And um it's so that the loneliest part would be like, okay, let's all take a five. And I would turn my camera off, mute it, and go get the kitchen. And I'm like, this is usually when you start talking to people. This is when you meet people. When you know, I do a ton of readings, and that's when you like make new friends. There's some people that I feel like are set. I'm like, have you worked with them? Oh, I've done like three readings with her, but never an actual show. But it's felt like we got to know each other.
I know her, right? Those break times. Yeah. And so when you're just on a camera on Zoom, we don't get that. And so I was just so thrilled to be in a room again and truly to be sharing a stage with all those people. But honestly, Victoria Clark, I've just loved for so long. And her voice is one I know well from either an album or a YouTube clip. And um to then become friends and um colleagues. And she's just such a generous scene partner that it feels fresh and new every time we do these scenes that we've now done so many times. Um, because she's a she's so alive, she's so in it. Um that it has been like the thrill of a lifetime. And people are like, how did you not know you were going to Broadway?
I was like, I was just happy to be doing what I was doing. Like the people in that room and at the Atlantic Theater was a lit a theater I've always wanted to work for. I've seen so many shows there, that I just was feeling grateful in the moment. And I think that's something that's kind of a message of our show. Like, nobody gets a second time around. And it's like, do what you can now and be in this moment and appreciate what you have when you have it. And that's honestly what I was doing. So by the time we got the announcement that Broadway was gonna happen, which was we were told um by David Stone around early January, but you know, the secret, it was a secret for a while. Um, by the time that happened, there were murmurings like, Do you think we're gonna transfer? People really like I think we might transfer. So by the time he told us, it was like, Oh my gosh, it is happening, yay. Um, but it wasn't something I was originally thinking, no.
[28:37] Matt Rodin: I'm curious to know what the experience of finding out you're going to Broadway, um, doing the show. How was it feeling without your dad?
[28:48] Bonnie Milligan: Um it's crazy to be doing a piece, you know. Our show isn't about dying, our show is really funny. You know, I've said everything else, it's really about, but at the center of it is someone who has a certain life expectancy on this uh fictional disease that she has. And I just spent so much time in a hospital with someone um in his final days, and having the hard conversations and um uh the the final moments of it all, you know. I grew up um singing because of my dad, and I will get emotional now. Um he was uh, I think he always wanted to be a singer, and then he became a pastor and he started doing southern gospel groups. He was always a part of quartets and stuff like that. Um, so he sang my whole life, and when I started singing, it was as soon as I could talk, and I was singing in front of church.
And I think, and he was always so funny. And um I am doing both of those things on a Broadway stage. I'm getting to be super funny, and um sing my heart out. And every time I sang, people would say, You sing like your dad. And so I remember it was like mid-rehearsal of the Atlantic when I kind of realized what we were doing and some of the scenes, and I thought, oh my gosh, somehow a part of me had blocked out that realization. And I had to leave the room and go cry in a bathroom stall for about five minutes. And the team was really supportive. They all knew where I was coming from. And I came back in, and uh, you know, it's just honoring the parts of him that are me that I take into every show.
Um, that um, I mean, his the things I'm saying and doing are not exactly pastor's message, but um the making people laugh and hopefully fall in love with you a little bit and um singing with everything. Uh he had a gift, and um I hope I honor that. And I have you know, pictures of him in my dressing room and um memories of that. When a one of the last nights um that I had in the hospital, my brother was with me, and we did about 30 minutes of singing together, and we just sang through a bunch of hymns and did like we used to do when we were kids. And um, I have a picture of us from that night in my dressing room. Um, just to kind of remember that joy that can be around um something that can feel really hard and letting people go and still finding the joy while they're here.
Um and I also have pictures of I have an amazing stepdad and mom and brother who have been so supportive and have come out and um you know seen and everything I'm in and done everything that uh they're very much a part of that. And so um I feel like I bring my family with me everywhere, but I have been thinking a lot about him. And November is uh pancreatic cancer awareness month, and that's what he had. So it's kind of a weird time that we're opening this Broadway show during the not so not so weird, not so you know, not a coincidence.
[32:46] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[32:46] Bonnie Milligan: So um it's something that's uh very on my heart and um thoughts, yeah, for sure.
[32:54] Matt Rodin: Um, are you still religious or spiritual at all?
[32:58] Bonnie Milligan: Um, I'm definitely um I feel like more um spiritual. I don't necessarily go to church every Sunday.
[33:05] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[33:06] Bonnie Milligan: Um, I um still believe in God and have those feelings and faith. Um, and I really like if we go back to actually that guy Jesus, what he did was super loving and caring.
[33:21] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[33:21] Bonnie Milligan: And um, I think that's where my deep seated feeling for kindness and for reaching out to people who need it and to looking out for others. And, you know, the sort of original idea of it all that some super religious organizations are the opposite of.
[33:40] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[33:40] Bonnie Milligan: Um is how I feel. And I I watched my parents be that way, be so kind and loving and do all they could for others, even though they had little. And so I feel like I had a great example of what real Christianity was. So that is how I feel my belief system is for sure. Um other like super religious things um don't sit as well with my soul because I don't think they're the same.
[34:09] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[34:09] Bonnie Milligan: But that's how I feel.
[34:10] Matt Rodin: Yeah, I and I also I'm never, I guess I'm never shocked to hear people who come from um a religious background, because theater feels very religious to me in the sense that we are gathering in a space together and we are sharing a moment in time and we're all just like present in this thing.
[34:32] Bonnie Milligan: Um, and we go on this journey, and sometimes it involves music, sometimes it doesn't, but it feels I I grew up Jewish, but I never connected to the faith.
[34:45] Matt Rodin: Right.
[34:45] Bonnie Milligan: Like I'm connected to the traditions and the culture and my heritage. But when for me, like that the theater was church for me, you know, it was it was a place to like gather and meet people. Um and that's like how I I or I should say one of the ways that I experience what you know, whatever the word you want to use, the universe God, like when I'm in that space and I hear Vicky Clark singing Piazza, like that's when I experience God, right?
[35:18] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[35:18] Bonnie Milligan: I I'm like, oh, the the wholeness of what life has. All of all of the like that goosebump feeling. You know what I'm talking? You know what I'm saying?
[35:29] Matt Rodin: I do.
[35:30] Bonnie Milligan: And I'm somebody that um, you know, since I was so little and singing in front of church, and people used to say to me, You're anointed, and this is, you know, God has a calling on your life, and this is what you're meant to be doing.
[35:44] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[35:44] Bonnie Milligan: And um, and maybe some would have hoped it would have been like in Christian music or something. Um, I still feel like uh like I said, I do have faith. I feel like I do have a calling on my life, and um, but there are so many kinds, and that being in theater is a way like you just said, how you experience it is um that and how I hope people experience me as a person.
[36:13] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[36:13] Bonnie Milligan: Um that kindness and empathy um is how I try to operate my life. I'm clearly no saint and I make a lot of mistakes.
[36:24] Matt Rodin: Well, we're human beings, right?
[36:25] Bonnie Milligan: I have my own feelings about certain things. You know what I mean?
[36:28] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[36:28] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah, but I try to, I try to um be a person that um does good in the world. And I do think our our sh our little show and uh does do a lot of good for people's hearts and souls right now.
[36:45] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[36:45] Bonnie Milligan: Um, after going through this pandemic that we've gone through, and we're continuing to go through, um, bringing a little light and a little perspective is um is a beautiful thing.
[36:58] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[36:58] Bonnie Milligan: And um, I still pray, I still pray that um what we do can help people in some way, and um yeah.
[37:08] Matt Rodin: Yeah, I've I I will say like I I've only found prayer in the last few years, and it and it's been super transformative for me. Taking an opportunity to like hand over control, at least for a moment, um in the form of prayer is has been uh revelatory in in this um process of the reality of being an artist because so much of what we do um is out of our control, or I should say often so many of the opportunities are out of our control, right?
[37:48] Bonnie Milligan: There's so many things that we don't have control over, right? Like obviously we don't know what jobs we're gonna get, we certainly don't know how it's gonna be received, we don't know what other people in the room are gonna feel, we don't know about the company that we're gonna be with. Um and to be able to accept the things, you know, that I cannot control that I cannot change, yeah, and have the courage to change the things that I can um has been profound in my artistic journey. Um that faith piece that I just never had before. Um so I'm curious if that's something that's been like helpful for you or um it absolutely has. I think, oh gosh, it's you lose, you feel like you lose so many things, you know, you hear so many no's. I um just saw Lee Silverman the other night, um, actually at the stage directors and choreographers foundation, um, a fundraising event.
And her and I were working up at Mass Mocha Sun Dance in I think November of 2019. And I had turned down a couple of things in order for to say yes to a project I was told they needed me for and it was going to be great and I was going to Broadway. And um and then I had to drop out of something else to do that. And it was advised by everybody and then I felt bad about that. But it was like this is the right choice is the right choice. And then um I was feeling so bad about that. And then I thought should by the way later I did that uh workshop and went great and then they ended up later replacing me. Don't you love all that again things we can't control. It's like ah so I was at a point where I was like should I have taken those other contracts because they were there but something in my heart was like I that's not for me.
And I thought I was holding out for the right stuff and then nothing worked out and now I have no prospects and I think I'm doing everything wrong. And I sat there we were on a lunch break and she came over to the table I think just to be sweet and was like how are you? And I just started crying and I said I think I'm doing everything wrong. And she was like what like you know it's like the last thing she thought was going to happen. And I kind of filled her in on stuff, and I was like, maybe I should just take these other projects, but I just don't think, and this and that, and now I just I've it was the end of 2019, and Head Over Heels had been so joyful, but then you know, our audiences weren't that big, and I thought it was gonna do some certain things for me that it did in many ways and didn't, and others, and I was left sort of part of me feeling back to square one, and the other part realizing that's a lie, but you know, you have that little devil on your shoulder saying, No, you're back to one, nobody cares.
And I was so just like, I've done everything wrong, and she just was like, There is no right way to do this, and you don't do that to yourself, and you're amazing, and what will happen will happen. And I remember having that, and we I talked to her about that recently because then you know, by February, that project I had dropped things out of to do, let go of me, and then um all the other projects I had said no to or got kicked out of, started rehearsals, and then the shutdown happened, and while all those things were in rehearsal is when my dad was dying, and I was able to go back to the Midwest, otherwise I would have been rehearsal and been like, I don't know if when I can make it, and we got to say the things that had to be said, and um be with each other, commune, like just have this really hard, hard time and love, and you know, long talks and acts of forgiveness and lots of things that um were really beautiful and transformative, and then next thing I know, I get a call to self-tape for something called Kimberly Akimbo, and it was like the because none of that other stuff happened, I was with my dad, and I'm now in this show that is like such a channel for grief and forgiveness, and um sorry. No, I'm I'm I'm I'm losing it over here.
[42:41] Matt Rodin: So we're in it together.
[42:42] Bonnie Milligan: And um, and other ways, and I remember saying to my agent, because they asked for my tape a couple days after my dad died, and I said, I can't. Um, you know, my dad. And they asked for it again a couple weeks after that, and I tried and I just couldn't memorize because my brain was so cloudy with grief. And I remember saying, 'Can you call me? I don't think I can make a tape because they gave me two extra weeks, and if I'm gonna give them a bad tape.' And if I give them a bad tape with two extra weeks, they're gonna think I've lost it or I'm bad. I was like, I think it will be more detrimental to me if I make something right now than if I don't make anything at all. And if this is meant to be, it will come back to me.
And that was the scariest thing because I wanted so desperately to work with those people. And I loved the play, and I just thought, oh, I hope this works out, but right now in my life, I can't do this. And then I got it, and then here I am, and it's like, and let me see. One, two, three, four of these other projects I'm talking about are happening within the next year. And um, and I'm where I'm meant to be.
[44:05] Bonnie Milligan: And you feel that I feel so uh that feels like God to me. That feels like trusting that what's meant to be won't be. And in this business, sometimes that's so hard because it's so unsure. And um, a lot of times things don't work out, and you have to hold on to believing you have something worth saying, and there is a reason for me being on a stage, and the way I look and the way I sound and the way I act means something to different people. And I would hope that it can be changing for others and moving for others in some way, um, in the way that you talked about. I mean, what a story that is, you know, and and again, I think it's important to reiterate the point you said that like in it, right?
In the thick of it, it's hard and heavy and confusing, and only in retrospect, right? Like now, two and a half years later, looking back at this whole experience, you're like, oh my god, that was God. Like I there's no other way to explain this series of events that now feels like, oh, this was exactly what was supposed to happen.
[45:25] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[45:27] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah, I wouldn't have been available for this. And the way that this show has been such a gift to me in so many ways, um, is immeasurable on my life and my heart and my own grief and my soul and all these things. So I'm just so thankful. It's it's it's be I mean, yeah, it's it's beautiful and and such a good I think such a good reminder that it's you just don't know. We we just don't know. We just don't know how things are gonna play out. And yeah, every time, and I imagine I I'm guessing, I don't know if this is true for you, but you come up against that sort of like wall of nothingness. There's there's there's it's just darkness. There's nothing, there's no pro like you said, no prospects. I have no projects coming up, you know, maybe a reading or a concert or something, but pretty much it's just kind of emptiness.
[46:20] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah. Like settling into faith in that space is really is really, really challenging.
[46:28] Matt Rodin: Yes.
[46:30] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah.
[46:30] Matt Rodin: But what but what but you know, it's like what else what else what else can you do other than you know what I mean? Other than just like surrender to to the to the waves of the thing. Um because the resistance, the resistance is like I I have found the resistance is like poison for me. Like if I start to spiral and start to have those sort of like devil on the shoulder thoughts, which are going to come, right? I can't control my thoughts.
[46:59] Bonnie Milligan: No.
[46:59] Matt Rodin: But how I respond and how I react, that's on me. Um, and I can certainly make myself physically ill.
[47:08] Bonnie Milligan: Yeah, right.
[47:09] Matt Rodin: With all of the fear and the and the questions and the confusion. But I also have the power to like pray, for example, or or or fill up my life um with things that that that make me feel whole, that make me feel God, that make me feel joy, maybe feel love. Um and that's one of the things I've I've I when I say when people are like coming out of school or I I always just say like make yourself a life that you love, you know, like find a community in New York, find a or wherever you're going, build yourself a life because that's gonna be the foundation that all the other things can happen on top of.
[47:50] Bonnie Milligan: But without that foundation, when you're just like hanging on to job to job to job to job, and then there's nothing, yeah, it's abyss. That's also part of the grounding of it all, you know, when you talked about confidence and staying humble, keeping people around you who aren't there just because you can sing high or just because you're funny. Um, people, I am still such close friends with college friends of mine. Um, and my dearest friends, some are in the business, but not all, and they just know me. And um that keeps me grounded and my family and when it feels, you know, I have some certain actor friends I can spiral out to on that because they understand the attacks and be like, oh dear God, Matt Doyle, number one. He and I can talk to each other like I'm freaking out. Can you talk me down? You guys have been through it.
[48:48] Bonnie Milligan: We've been through it first since 2014 when we met. Like it's we've really seen a lot of highs and lows for each other. So it's like I know I can turn to him and be like, either can you just hear me and not say anything, or can you give me perspective, you know? You know, and he does the same with me. Um, but just having people who know you, who know your heart, who know things years ago, and now I truly try to stay away from reviews, and also if I'm tagged in videos online, I have made the mistake of reading a comment, and then you go down a spiral of reading comments, and there's always going to be haters, and then I feel the worst, and I cry and cry and cry. And it's just like, what am I doing?
That means nothing. You don't know these people, and it's okay. People have to do that. And these people don't know you. They don't know me, and we all have different opinions. I could hate something you love, and vice versa. Doesn't make anybody wrong. It like being a bully online does, but um, trying not to take that in and stay grounded as a human being and not making my worth my performance or my career, like my worth is who I am as a human, how I treat people, and um that has to be like the core of who I am, and to remember that, and that's what keeps humble and kindness there is surrounding yourself with people who aren't there to just fluff your ego.
[50:16] Bonnie Milligan: I don't need that, I don't need you to tell me any of that. That's nice here and there. And so like I'd rather um hear I'm a good friend than um that than that. So that's a that's a big part of it. So watching Matt go through what he went through this past year, yeah. What was that like as a friend? Like, because you've seen you literally have seen each other, like, you know, started from the bottom, now we hear, like, yeah, yeah. I mean the most pride I can think of. I of course had COVID and was stuck in Mexico when they announced Tony, not always. Oh my god. Though I have a video, you can see it on my Instagram when I did the post of when he got nominated. And the last video is me. The sound is of a Jurassic Park creature.
I don't even know the squeal that came forth for me with my COVID riddled throat. But I um, you know, set an alarm so I could watch it live on my computer from Mexico. And he was already texting me and I was like, babe, I've got my setup waiting. I'm ready to watch. And he's like, I'm so worried, I'm so nervous, you know. And I was like, it's gonna happen. It's gonna happen. This is got a speech. And then we immediately FaceTimed and I was sobbing and I'm gonna cry again. Um because he's worked so so hard. And I've seen him do everything, um, from readings to um, you know, show at New World Stages, um, the Clockwork Orange play he did, uh Carnegie Hall, um, to everything that I know how hard he has worked and how um for a couple of years it was rough and to have like the feeling of trying to feel um validated and seen again in the business at a time when he kind of felt um like will this happen for me again and I just miss it, and um really choosing projects that would grow make him grow as a performer as an actor that and not and turning certain things down, and that was really amazing to watch him make brave choices and be scared for a while and then get this thing that was so right and he was so brilliant in it, and then to have that happen to him and watch it was just unreal.
[52:44] Bonnie Milligan: He worked so hard. And I watched he was so tired, and all of the work he did during that entire um season was um unbelievable. And so to see one of my closest, dearest friends, I just my heart couldn't grow any bigger when that happened. Um and he's already been just he's so beautiful and supportive, and the way he's like will text and check on me. He's like, I know this week must have been a heavy week. How are you doing? Like, God, you're you know, and he was there at first preview, and he's just um wow one of one of the best. I love him dearly. It's um hearing you say all that, and I think you probably have experience with this too. What I'm hearing is like, you know, it's like building up something I work on therapy, building up the internal validation.
[53:41] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[53:42] Bonnie Milligan: Right. Because the external is so out of our control. Oh my god, yes. And changes constantly, literally nonstop. That's the only constant is the change. Um building up the internal validation, right? And that takes years, right? Especially in in this world. Um, not for everybody, but for a lot of people, it takes a long time to build up that internal validation that you can walk in and say, No, I know what I'm what I'm worth, and whether I get this job or not, like I'm still gonna be okay and like I'm still a good person. And then to have the external meet that internal validation is it in my head, it's like fireworks because yeah, what's happening is we've taken the value off of the X the external doesn't um it doesn't define our worth it doesn't define our value it's it's not as um we're not like hanging on to it we're not gripping but it when it comes and it meets that internal it the the that kind of chemistry that happens is like it's magic and yes right like and I'm and I'm sure you've had that experience in in some way or another obviously not winning a Tony but but right but having that sort of like being met with where you are internally.
[54:13] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
[54:13] Bonnie Milligan: Oh no absolutely it's so powerful to see it happen for a friend and then the things like even you know last year with Kimberly Akimbo the way we were received off Broadway it I think because it was such a specific post pandemic we just get to be in a room oh my gosh I love all these people I was so in the moment of what we were actually doing that it's almost like for the first time I didn't care what the critics were gonna say it was just what we were doing and building and people around us felt so assured of what we were doing that sometimes that external stress of the validation of others can really creep into the room early for the creatives for the cat like for everybody and somehow and I think it was just because we were all so grateful to be working again.
[56:01] Bonnie Milligan: And so it was this amazing revelation that the world said we love you. And I was like, what? Oh my gosh, I love us too. Wait, you do. Because you know, I loved Head Over Heels so much. And I worked on that for so many years. And there were so many people that loved it, and a lot of reviews that loved it, and then some reviews that didn't. And you saw those. And it was heartbreaking to have put so much into something. And then to come out to a house, you know, that first pose was you watch the audience and it would be like 40% full. And you know you're gonna close soon. And we had producers that kept us open a lot longer than probably financially they should have, but they believed in us. So we got to run a good with previews six and a half months.
Yeah, which is amazing. Wow. But it felt like an uphill battle because it was just like we we were getting external validation, but then also the other kind that's like you're not good, right? And it was so hard to battle constantly, something I believed in and love so dearly to have that, and then this feels like so it's such a different feeling because A, I went into it with no, like I had so much expectation, and it was my debut, so I was really like you're talking about head over heels. You went in. Yeah, right. Yes, breaking that glass bubble of what your dreams are and what it's going to be, and feeling reality. And this was just like feeling the dream of getting to work again, and then all of a sudden, everybody loves it. And again, I don't read all the comments, I don't search boards, I don't search tweets. I stay away from it.
[57:49] Matt Rodin: Are you a masochist?
[57:50] Bonnie Milligan: Like, oh my god, no. I know some people that do, and I don't want to do that. So you're asking for trouble. You're asking for trouble because people just want to do that. And um to feel such overwhelming love immediately for something I really love has been nothing but joy. And so I am doing my best to hold on to that as we go into this opening next week and reviews that will come out. To just say, let's stay grateful for getting to tell this story, not only in a pandemic world, but after everything that happened has happened in my life and the loss of my dad, like all these different things that I get to be on this stage. And like you said, like uh the gifts that I have that I bring are gifts I got from him. And so it's like he does live on when I do this. And that's a beautiful thing. And um, just trying to feel grateful for that.
[58:49] Matt Rodin: Yeah, it's almost like when we're present, when we're like really present and we forget about everything else, like that's when the stuff comes in. There's no guarantees, but it's like that only really happens when we're so present.
[59:03] Bonnie Milligan: Yes.
[59:04] Matt Rodin: Um, and in a weird way, when we're not present and those things come, it like kind of perpetuates it doesn't help. It like it's it's not, it's actually not healthy. It like, yeah, you know what I mean? It gives us like a false expectation. Um, but to hear you say, you know, just being so present in putting the piece together and being like, yeah, this wow, I'm I'm really enjoying this process of just being in the room and then having people see it and be like, we love this. And you're like, oh my God, we love it too. Like well, because we joke, you know, like, I don't know if I drank the Kool-Aid, but is it good? Because you're like, you know, when you're a part of anything, hopefully you fall in love with it and hopefully you believe in what you're doing.
I mean, sometimes we know when we do stuff that you're like, uh, but you know, I'm gonna have fun. Yeah. But I'm gonna enjoy myself. I'm just gonna have fun and I I'm still gonna give it my all. Um, but I understand the story doesn't make sense. Um, but this is opposite. This is like, wait, you do love it? Oh my god, me too. Oh, look at us. We're all here together. Look at us loving this thing together.
[1:00:08] Matt Rodin: Exactly.
[1:00:09] Bonnie Milligan: It's so exciting. And and and I think again, like I I I wanna like be clear that like I think this is such a cool moment to be talking to you because it's before we we know like what what we're what like you have right now, like it's all just like ahead of you, you know? Like who who knows? Who knows what what the like what the rest of this could be, what the story of this will be, but at least right now to hear you be where you're at and not worrying about any of that, and just truly like in this moment is so it's so refreshing and it's so beautiful, and I and it's so yeah, I'm just I'm so excited and I'm so happy.
[1:00:50] Bonnie Milligan: I'm so happy. I feel the same, just like excited and happy. And I was telling somebody, I'm like, again, like I told you with Vicky and I at the end of first preview, just breaking down into sobs because we're so proud of all these Broadway debuts that there, I think there's something really special. It's only my second one, but like to be a part of their journey forever feels unbelievable. I think there's also something in there that it's like that's like the history of theater I get to be a part of. You know, they have the legacy robe, but it's like again, it's only my second go-around, but I now feel like a different part of the community, if that makes sense. Like it like even further, deeper seeps in.
And um, keeping my focus on that joy and gratitude is my plan. And um that's a good plan. I mean, text me in a few months, but like right now, no, I'm joking. Right now, that's really the plan because I feel nothing but um gratitude and joy, truly. I mean, exhaustion, but um mostly gratitude.
[1:02:05] Matt Rodin: Yeah.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
