The Dear Friends are back with you and ready to count down the musicals we think are overrated! Be prepared to get angry because we've got some hot takes here!.. Read More
From the show: The Dear Friends Podcast
Featured Shows
About
The Dear Friends are back with you and ready to count down the musicals we think are overrated! Be prepared to get angry because we've got some hot takes here!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Christi Esterle: Without further ado, the Dear Friends podcast.
[0:05] Emily Clark: Dear friends, spill your woes to your musical family.
[0:10] Jess McAnally: Dear friends.
[0:11] Christi Esterle: They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom.
[0:18] Emily Clark: And an awful icy world.
[0:23] Jess McAnally: Dear friends.
[0:26] Emily Clark: Hi, I'm dear friend Emily.
[0:28] Christi Esterle: I'm dearer friend Christy.
[0:29] Jess McAnally: And I'm dearest friend Jess.
[0:31] Christi Esterle: And welcome to Dear Friends, a write-in advice podcast for the musical minded. How are you guys doing today?
[0:34] Jess McAnally: Doing fine.
[0:39] Christi Esterle: I'm feeling controversial.
[0:41] Emily Clark: I'm hydrated.
[0:42] Jess McAnally: I'm medicated.
[0:43] Christi Esterle: I'm good.
[0:43] Emily Clark: That's good.
[0:44] Christi Esterle: We got a write-in letter today.
[0:47] Jess McAnally: Um, you know, from a good old friend Jason Robert Crown.
[0:51] Christi Esterle: I don't think there's any relation to the other one, but they're asking, hiya guys. What musicals do you think are vastly overrated and or overhyped?
[1:02] Jess McAnally: Well, I don't really like the words. Those are pretty loaded terms.
[1:05] Christi Esterle: I mean, there is, yeah.
[1:09] Jess McAnally: There's a lot of shows that you know a lot of people love, and I'm like, yeah, not getting it, or it's yeah. There's a lot of reasons why people don't like shows. They don't resonate with you. Um, you know, it's you know, it rubs you the wrong way based on your personal experience, or you know, maybe you did it in high school and you had to listen to that one song 50 million times and you never want to hear it again.
[1:34] Christi Esterle: Yeah, my list consists of musicals I am kind of like I don't get it about, and musicals that I actively hate. So it should be a little controversial, but again, folks, this is subjective.
[1:46] Jess McAnally: Subjective.
[1:47] Christi Esterle: You can love these shows and we still love you.
[1:49] Jess McAnally: A lot does a lot of you love shows. You're fine, we love you.
[1:53] Christi Esterle: But your opinion is.
[1:54] Jess McAnally: We all have our opinions.
[1:55] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[1:56] Jess McAnally: I do want to say for my list specifically, I didn't want to recover information I've already said. I've kind of famously had opinions on Rent and Dear Evan Hansen and stuff.
[2:05] Christi Esterle: So I really didn't want to be like, well, let's pull out the old trunk ideas. So I'm trying to do things that I think are spicier to my individuals here.
[2:16] Jess McAnally: Don't worry.
[2:17] Christi Esterle: Don't worry.
[2:17] Jess McAnally: I think we'll cover some of those, you know, on our heads.
[2:21] Christi Esterle: Okay. I just wanted to say that up front while while people have known me to say shit about Rent and Dear Evan Hansen. I wanted to say, yeah, that's still true. These are different, different vibes, you know.
[2:32] Jess McAnally: Yeah, yeah.
[2:33] Christi Esterle: And hey, we got we got five different top fives we're doing here. Um Christy, do you want to start us?
[2:39] Christi Esterle: I guess I'll start um because mine's gonna be um, you know, a little bit of a controversial take with my number five, and that is The Sound of Music.
[2:48] Jess McAnally: Oh my goodness.
[2:49] Christi Esterle: Yeah, I'm sorry. It's again, this is Yeah, I know, yeah.
[2:54] Jess McAnally: I love yeah, I was expecting that, but and it's you know, it's not a bad show. It's you know, it's Rogers and Hammerstein, you can't go wrong with it, but it's I did it my sophomore year in high school, and you know, got tired of it. It's you know, kind of, you know, kind of got a little cloying on me with the cutesy kids and you know, everything.
[3:15] Christi Esterle: You're just like Christopher Plummer.
[3:17] Jess McAnally: Yeah, it's you know, and it's well, you know, the critics thought that at the time when it came out. They were like, what these guys are the guys who wrote Oklahoma and Carousel groundbreaking.
[3:27] Christi Esterle: It's I know, I know. It's so funny to think about. They were at the time they were like, this is too treacly. It's really the safest of the um Rogers and Hammerstein shows because how can you go wrong with cute kids who are trying to run away from the Nazis? Who cannot who you know who cannot um go along with that?
[3:42] Jess McAnally: And Hammerstein was, you know, died right after.
[3:45] Christi Esterle: Yeah, he was dying. It was his last show. So but yeah, and it's it does have some great stuff. Um yeah.
[3:50] Jess McAnally: Yeah, climb every mountain, Edelweiss, um, you know, it's got good songs. Um, you know, you you know, got some good liturgical stuff for the nuns, but it's like, yeah, it's I don't need to see, you know, I don't need to see it. It's very overexposed at this point.
[4:08] Jess McAnally: You see, I have a similar opinion where I think it's a not that great musical, but I think it's a great movie. I think the movie is significantly better than its incarnation on stage.
[4:14] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[4:18] Jess McAnally: Maybe I'm crazy. Alright, Emily, what is your first choice?
[4:22] Emily Clark: I don't think these are in any particular order. This isn't like a top five, these are just five.
[4:26] Christi Esterle: Oh yeah, okay.
[4:26] Emily Clark: Yeah, this um so this is low-hanging fruit, of course, but I'm I'm gonna go with it anyway. Uh Dear Evan Hansen.
[4:33] Jess McAnally: Um fighting deer.
[4:35] Emily Clark: I I know I know nowadays everyone kind of sees it, but like when did it come out? Twenty sixteen.
[4:41] Christi Esterle: Twenty six yeah twenty sixteen.
[4:42] Emily Clark: Okay, so I remember teaching um you know, I teach middle schoolers performing arts, and I remember um a lot of my students were just so into it.
[4:52] Christi Esterle: And um every cabaret I would perform in, there would be people doing songs from it.
[4:56] Emily Clark: And I remember being like, I don't get all these songs sound the same. I don't get it. What am I missing?
[5:01] Christi Esterle: And not like not in that every composer has a voice sounds the same. It's like these literally just sound like the same song to me.
[5:09] Emily Clark: Um, and uh once I saw the movie and you know, learn more about it, I I I don't get it.
[5:16] Christi Esterle: Yeah, I don't get it.
[5:18] Emily Clark: I don't get it.
[5:18] Christi Esterle: Yeah, it's um I think it's a I think, well, among many other things, I think it's a really bad match of material and composers because Pasek and Paul, they are all about, you know, the inspirational, you know, power ballads, you know, and you know, putting that voice into, you know, an uh, you know, a c uh uh an introverted, um, you know, socially awkward, you know, teenager who has difficulty communicating and you know, makes a mess of everything.
[5:52] Jess McAnally: Yet it just doesn't fit.
[5:54] Emily Clark: Yeah, I risk I don't like it. I don't I don't get it. I don't I don't think it's particularly um groundbreaking or interesting and um you know I I I know uh the waving through a window song is again is a good song, I guess, but um yeah, I don't I don't like it.
[6:13] Christi Esterle: I don't get why people like it.
[6:14] Emily Clark: I respect what the Pasek and Paul were trying to do originally, which was like an Evita style thing where the big school bully, like high school what is it, t quarterback dies of like an heart attack or like drug overdose, and then he swoops in and just takes over by claiming he's his best friend.
[6:33] Christi Esterle: Um that was at least an interesting, like mean idea that at least could have been something instead of what it became, which is manipulative and kind of mean.
[6:42] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[6:43] Emily Clark: Yeah, I don't like it.
[6:44] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[6:44] Emily Clark: Um, is it my turn now?
[6:46] Christi Esterle: Yes, it is.
[6:47] Emily Clark: Here's mine. Alright, ready for anger from you two. I really don't like 1776.
[6:56] Jess McAnally: Well, I think that, you know, that's valid, especially as as we're talking more about, you know, American history as it's taught versus what it actually is, and you know, the whole founding father's mythology, you know, that's yeah, that comes a lot harder to accept um as we deal with um, you know, all the stuff that we haven't been dealing with for the past 400 years.
[7:20] Christi Esterle: Yeah, that's some people still don't want to deal with.
[7:23] Jess McAnally: They've got a song about triangle trade.
[7:25] Christi Esterle: I guess they do.
[7:27] Jess McAnally: Weren't we just talking about how like it doesn't have to be historically accurate?
[7:31] Christi Esterle: Well, there is that, yes.
[7:33] Jess McAnally: And it does have it does have it does have the molasses to rem to slaves, which is, you know.
[7:39] Christi Esterle: But it is kind of I I it the way it was written, it was very much more of a um a musical play almost.
[7:46] Jess McAnally: Um it has it has the record for the longest period without music in a musical.
[7:53] Christi Esterle: And you know what? We can phrase that, but in all honesty, it makes it boring.
[7:57] Jess McAnally: It makes it really boring.
[7:58] Christi Esterle: I'm not praising it, I'm just saying it, yeah.
[8:01] Jess McAnally: These things are just so dull to watch.
[8:04] Christi Esterle: John Adams as a lead character is probably the only thing with energy, and Ben Franklin, and aside from those two, it's just uh so dull.
[8:12] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[8:12] Christi Esterle: And the movie adaptation is garbage.
[8:14] Jess McAnally: Like the that like I don't know if it's a lot of people.
[8:16] Christi Esterle: And there's like you know, there's nothing there's nothing for women in it.
[8:20] Jess McAnally: I mean, you know, he plays the violin.
[8:23] Christi Esterle: They recently did an all-female.
[8:25] Jess McAnally: And and and um, I know.
[8:27] Christi Esterle: I would love to do that. I would love to play one of the founding fathers in the world.
[8:31] Jess McAnally: All female production of 1776, I'd be up for that, yeah.
[8:34] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[8:34] Jess McAnally: And then um Yeah, I did a reading of oh god.
[8:38] Christi Esterle: Oh wow, I just forgot about this.
[8:40] Jess McAnally: My um my theater company back in 2016, the night of the election.
[8:45] Christi Esterle: We were like, we were like, let's read 1776. It'll be great, it'll be really fun.
[8:49] Jess McAnally: And then when we get out, Hillary Clinton will be clicking the movie.
[8:51] Christi Esterle: Oh, jeez!
[8:52] Jess McAnally: Oh my god.
[8:54] Christi Esterle: Halfway through the reading.
[8:56] Jess McAnally: I guess it was 2015.
[8:57] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[8:57] Jess McAnally: Uh halfway through the reading, we got very, very, very depressed.
[9:00] Christi Esterle: But anyway, I played um uh Abigail, I remember, and that was fun.
[9:05] Jess McAnally: But um that's so yeah.
[9:07] Christi Esterle: I mean, it is it is it is a stuffy history show.
[9:11] Jess McAnally: It's a boring, stuffy history show, and the film adaptation's really bad, and the extended version is even worse.
[9:17] Christi Esterle: Um please don't request that on my Patreon. I really don't want to talk about it anytime soon.
[9:23] Jess McAnally: Alright, Christy, what's your next one?
[9:26] Christi Esterle: Okay, so this next one, I don't know if I would say it's overrated so much as overdone, and that would be Annie.
[9:33] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[9:33] Christi Esterle: I mean it's you know, and I kind of I'm kind of conflicted about it because it really does have some great songs.
[9:38] Jess McAnally: I mean, Easy Street is one of my all-time favorite villain songs, NYC is fantastic.
[9:43] Christi Esterle: Even Tomorrow, you know, it's like that kind of you know, sweet, you know, little kid optimistic thing.
[9:50] Jess McAnally: But for getting one of the best songs ever written.
[9:53] Christi Esterle: Thank you, Mr. Hoover.
[9:54] Jess McAnally: Yeah, my god, how many times has this been done on Broadway and on film and on television?
[10:02] Christi Esterle: I be please, can we find something else?
[10:04] Jess McAnally: As a performing arts teacher of children.
[10:07] Christi Esterle: Can we find something else every with like our kid our kids?
[10:11] Jess McAnally: Matilda is right there.
[10:13] Christi Esterle: Matilda's flipping hard though, dude.
[10:16] Jess McAnally: Yeah, I mean I'm teaching revolting children in my middle schoolers right now, and it's good, it's working out, but that like seven eight meter into like four-four thing, it's crazy.
[10:28] Christi Esterle: There's a reason why I do you're never fully dressed without a smile with like kindergartners.
[10:32] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[10:33] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[10:33] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[10:34] Christi Esterle: So yeah, it's that.
[10:35] Jess McAnally: You're right.
[10:35] Christi Esterle: You're right. We need to mix it up.
[10:37] Jess McAnally: It's not bad.
[10:37] Christi Esterle: It's uh, you know, it's one of those shows a lot of people probably came into music theater with either because they were taken to it, because it's a kid, you know, kid-friendly show, or they were in the YouTube film.
[10:47] Jess McAnally: So it's a great gateway show on that angle.
[10:50] Christi Esterle: It's just it's everybody has done it, and please let's do something else.
[10:55] Jess McAnally: Fair enough.
[10:56] Christi Esterle: Emily, what's your next one?
[10:59] Emily Clark: Um, I feel like I feel like this is gonna be controversial, um, at least for listeners. Um Legally Blonde.
[11:06] Christi Esterle: I I don't I've taught it.
[11:09] Emily Clark: Um now I I'm gonna go, I'm gonna preface this by saying Legally Blonde, the film came out when I was in college, and I love that movie and like I I've watched it to death.
[11:20] Jess McAnally: So the musical was just never gonna live up in my mind because it's that same thing we talked about a few episodes ago. I just end up playing the movie in my head while I'm watching the musical. But having taught and directed Legally Blonde and seen a high school production of it, um, not like maybe two or three songs out of that score stick out to me. I just don't think it's a very good score. And I know a lot of people love it, but um I just don't care for it. And um, I remember like the search for Elle Woods thing. I remember when they did like the pro shot on MTV with the live audience, and I could only last about like 10 minutes because the mugging from Laura Bell Bundy was driving me crazy.
Um so I just think this, um, it again, it's a good high school show. It's a great show for kids because obviously there's a lot of parts and there's a lot of girl parts, which is great. Yeah, um, and a lot of range of voices, but I would never unless I actively knew someone in the show and they were like, "Will you please come see me?" Yeah, I think it's, I don't care for it. Yeah. As far as, you know, um film adaptations of musicals that mostly exist just because people love the film, it's, you know, it could have been worse, but it's okay. Yeah, like I don't think it's actively bad. Like there's some on this list that I think are actively bad. Um for me, it just doesn't resonate and it like never sticks in my brain.
Um and then there's that TikTok trend of everyone doing that Muni audition. And I had completely forgotten that song until I heard it and I went, "Oh yeah, I've taught this, haven't I? How did I forget this? How did I forget this?" So, but you're right, yeah, apart from, I think apart from, oh my god, you guys, I couldn't remember much of the score, so yeah, it, uh, there's it, it either I think is actively bad sounding. I remember I didn't like the, um, oh god, that stupid Ireland song is the stupid song. Oh my god, yeah, I agree. Ever. It's so stupid. Um and then like the workout song, or I don't like it. I just don't think they're very good. So anyway, Legally Blonde.
[13:25] Jess McAnally: Alright, um, my next one. This is gonna be, I don't like this show. I don't like this show. I don't like Newsies, guys. Boys dancing for 58 minutes. I don't know. I mean, like the nostalgia factor was what you're doing. Yeah, it's, yeah, and they fixed so many, har, thank you, Harvey Fierstein. He fixed problems, right, with the film, the book. Again, you know, I get it. I get it. Again, you know, it's, uh, you know, a cult, the film is a cult classic, but I think a lot of people forget when it first came out, it was a flop, and you know, you can see why it was a flop. It was, uh, you know, Disney trying to bring back the golden age musical and it just didn't work. Yeah, it was a barren wasteland for movie musicals at the time that weren't animated.
And the only reason I saw it is they used to play it on the Disney Channel. Right. And then it was like, ooh, cute boys dancing, and you watch the first thirty minutes and then you don't have to watch anymore. Yeah. But, uh, yeah, Newsies. Open the gates and seize the day. Yeah.
[14:31] Christi Esterle: Alright. Um, what about you, Christi? What's your next one?
[14:34] Christi Esterle: Oh jeez. I got Book of Mormon.
[14:39] Jess McAnally: Okay.
[14:40] Christi Esterle: I do not like, you know, I have issues with Trey Parker and Matt Stone. Chief among them are that they do not know the difference between being vulgar because it contributes to the humor and being vulgar just because you think it's funny. Cause there's, there's like moments where they're actually, you know, trying, they're doing stuff that's actually pretty good. Like, um, you know, the "I believe," you know, where he says, "I believe in 1970, whatever God changed his mind about black people." That is a pretty good satirical lyric. But then you have, you know, people saying, "Fuck you, God in the ass mouth and cunt" over and over again just because you think it's funny to say those words. Yeah.
And I mean, yeah, it's, it's a mess. You know, my tolerance for gross-out humor is very low, which is another issue I have with them. Um, you know, obviously, you know, the black representation, you know, you look at it now and it's kind of, yeah. And you know, you're, it's, I, you know, you're talking about things like, you know, the AIDS epidemic and female genital mutilation, which are, you know, serious issues in Africa. Um, but you know, you're just saying that because you're just talking about it just because you think it's funny to say everybody has AIDS in that way and to say the word clitoris over and over again. So it's, yeah, I think, you know, I think it's, I like the idea and I like some of the satirical stuff that they have in there but it's, you know, a lot of frat boy humor and not my thing.
[16:10] Jess McAnally: Hasn't aged well though, I'd say.
[16:12] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and it definitely has not aged well. Um, alright, Emily, what about your next one?
[16:10] Emily Clark: Spring Awakening.
[16:22] Jess McAnally: Ooh.
[16:20] Emily Clark: I remember getting the recording for Spring Awakening and having seen it at the Tony Awards and I was like, oh, I'm so ready for some angst and literally like two songs on the soundtrack are like that. Everything else was like, and I just was like, I just, it never, I thought it was going to be something that it wasn't and then I've just never, it's another one where I don't really like the score. I think there's like a few good songs. I think I'm a little, I'm a little past my prime to be kind of connecting with this like teenage angst. Um, it's fine if it connects with you and you like it. I don't think it's a bad show unlike my take on Legally Blonde, but I just have never been able to get into it. Just, yeah, I've tried, I've tried so many times, you guys, and I just can't do it.
[17:18] Jess McAnally: I get that, that's fair.
[17:20] Emily Clark: And honestly, I think, you know, there's, you know, it doesn't quite delve as much into a lot of the complexities of the story as it could. I mean, it never really deals with the fact that when you get down to it, Melchior rapes Wendla.
[17:33] Jess McAnally: Yep.
[17:34] Emily Clark: And is dubious, yeah, I mean, and I'm not, yeah, it's, it's just an, I think it's not even that. I just get bored. I like, I'm just bored watching it. I'm bored listening to it. And I would, I should be taken away by more of that drama. Right. Because there is a lot of drama in it. And for whatever reason, I just sit there and go, hmm.
[17:53] Jess McAnally: Yeah, and it's, it's not, you know, it's not that it's, it's complex, actually, because I honestly don't think Melchior understands what he's doing, um, because in that way he is still a teenage boy who doesn't know what he doesn't know and has been failed by adults in that regard, but we never get into it because we're presenting him, you know, as, you know, this angsty, you know, rebellious teenager who wants to be, wants to fight the system.
[18:21] Emily Clark: Yeah, and I think like a lot of the younger audiences for it just see it all as hot. Like they're like grounding.
[18:27] Jess McAnally: Well, yeah, and it's not, and yeah.
[18:31] Emily Clark: Because, you know, it's, it's a little like Rent in that aspect because you're at that age where you are like, you know, you just wanna, you just wanna fight against stuff. You want to figure out who you are and you don't know who you are, and you've got all these hormones and feelings. I get why it's popular. Yeah, and I get why it's a good idea. So yeah, and gravity. Yeah, and I also, but going back on you, I also get why, you know, if you've passed that, um, in your life.
[19:00] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[19:01] Emily Clark: You're past that in your life, and it's like, okay, yeah.
[19:04] Jess McAnally: Alright. So I think I'm next. Um, you're next.
[19:09] Jess McAnally: Oh, this might, I should I go with the one I know people won't care if I'm upset about? No, fuck, I'm gonna go with the confrontational one. I don't like Avenue Q. Not my thing. Very much not my thing. Um, I think there's a lot of people who don't really like Avenue Q nowadays. I am very baffled that it won the Best Tony um up against like Wicked and Caroline or Change.
[19:28] Christi Esterle: Well, that's because they did a huge promotional thing and then afterwards they had to change the rules so you couldn't do that anymore. And I remember at the time it was, it was a big deal at the time because Thoroughly Modern Millie and Urinetown were up against each other the year before, I think. And Thoroughly Modern Millie won when everyone thought Urinetown won. And so everyone thought the same thing was gonna happen with Avenue Q and Wicked. And yeah, I remember I went to New York for the first time around then, and I remember those posters, yeah, were everywhere.
[19:59] Jess McAnally: Yeah. Um, I know a lot of people don't really like Avenue. For me, I know there's of course stuff that hasn't aged well, but I, I don't know. It's like I connect it with my college days.
[20:09] Christi Esterle: I agree so much.
[20:10] Jess McAnally: I just really resonate too, but I would totally get why you wouldn't like it.
[20:13] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[20:14] Jess McAnally: I agree. You know, I think there's, you know, some really great stuff in there. I mean, uh, especially when it does get serious, like with stuff like "For Now" and "There's a Fine, Fine Line." Um, those are some really great pieces, but on the other hand, again, you have stuff like "Everyone's a Little Bit Racist," where it's just like lol PC culture, and it's like, okay, you know, you started off at a good point, but then you lost it. I also, there's like one character that becomes actively homeless, and it's hilarious that they're homeless throughout most of the second year.
[20:44] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[20:45] Jess McAnally: Yeah. Uh, uh. Don't sit well with me anymore, and I did not enjoy watching it. Maybe I'm just too old to laugh at the internet being for porn.
[20:53] Christi Esterle: Um, yeah.
[20:55] Jess McAnally: Maybe.
[20:56] Christi Esterle: Um, Christy, what's your next one?
[20:57] Christi Esterle: Oh, geez, Dear Evan Hansen. For pretty much the reasons everybody said. Um, you know, it's, you know, the score is a lot of it's the same. It really doesn't treat, you know, the whole mental health thing as well as it could. It doesn't really address, you know, the issue, you know, Evan's, I, you know, not Evan. Yeah, Evan's Hansen's issues or whatever. And yeah, it's like they just didn't stick the landing. It's like, it's like the, yeah, it's the message they're portraying is very different than the characters. Absolutely. You know, yeah, it's like talking about you will be found and you know, in a, in a space where you know that's a whole lie, and it's, you know, yeah, but they're still, but they're playing it straight with the, you know, the PASIC and Paul inspirational ballads, so it's like, okay, uh, do you understand that this is an issue, or do you feel that this is, you know, actually a big inspirational moment?
[22:05] Emily Clark: So, um, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat. I hate this show. I hate this show, and every time I tell someone that they go, "It's for kids." And I go, "So what? Kids' musicals, Annie is good, uh, Matilda is good. Joseph is so, I find it insipid and stupid, and I hate it. And I'm, I'm sorry, you're never gonna convince me otherwise. I'm the, the one blessing is that it's short.
[22:32] Christi Esterle: Yeah, it yeah, and then they threw in all these stupid pastiche numbers.
[22:37] Jess McAnally: Oh my god, oh I have to hear one more angel in heaven, I will be a die a happy woman.
[22:42] Christi Esterle: God red and yellow and it's like the worst of Angeloid Weber.
[22:49] Jess McAnally: And I know it's like one of his first projects.
[22:51] Christi Esterle: Um yeah, it's an early show that should have stayed like that juvenilia that you look back and it's like, yeah, I really didn't know what I was doing. You know, he should have just kind of left that in the But sh but yeah, uh children's theaters do it, and community theaters do it all the time because again, bunch of parts, bunch of kid roles.
[23:09] Jess McAnally: Oh yeah, it was like it was like a huge um holiday thing at the Arvada Center uh like about 10 15 years ago.
[23:16] Christi Esterle: But I actively avoid productions of it.
[23:19] Jess McAnally: I just do not care for that show very much.
[23:22] Christi Esterle: It's okay if you do, it's fine.
[23:25] Jess McAnally: I just it's like inane to me.
[23:28] Christi Esterle: It's just like stupidity on stage.
[23:32] Jess McAnally: That's how mean I'm gonna be about this.
[23:35] Christi Esterle: I love how angry Emily is because she's always very much like, you know what, everyone everyone loves their own show, and you know And just seeing her this vitriolically angry about a musical brings me such joy.
[23:47] Emily Clark: Yeah, well, that's not um not even my number one yet.
[23:49] Jess McAnally: I know.
[23:50] Christi Esterle: Um next one.
[23:51] Jess McAnally: Um Mean Girls.
[23:53] Christi Esterle: Don't like it.
[23:54] Jess McAnally: Don't like it.
[23:55] Christi Esterle: That's yeah.
[23:56] Jess McAnally: Legally blonde part two.
[23:58] Christi Esterle: Yeah, right?
[23:59] Jess McAnally: Yeah, except the legally blonde guy eventually did Heathers, which is a show that I kind of respect and enjoy.
[24:03] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[24:04] Jess McAnally: And uh can appreciate.
[24:05] Christi Esterle: Mean Girls has nothing to offer.
[24:07] Jess McAnally: Absolutely nothing to offer.
[24:13] Christi Esterle: Like it's just the same shit.
[24:14] Jess McAnally: Like legally blonde took a little bit of liberties in some places to expand upon the story and bring something new.
[24:21] Christi Esterle: It wasn't just quoting, and it gave some moments where more characters can be more fleshed out.
[24:26] Jess McAnally: Nothing.
[24:26] Christi Esterle: This this show gives you nothing.
[24:28] Jess McAnally: Yeah, nothing.
[24:29] Christi Esterle: Alright, that's it.
[24:30] Jess McAnally: Like Mean Girls, I I don't like it.
[24:32] Christi Esterle: I don't think I can expand upon it.
[24:34] Jess McAnally: And I'm also just not a big fan of high school musicals.
[24:37] Christi Esterle: Not not the high school musical series.
[24:39] Jess McAnally: I mean, that's fine.
[24:40] Christi Esterle: Well, I'm not a big fan of that either, but that's for kids in a way where I'm like, alright, if kids want to do that, like I I would not, I don't think it would be the worst thing in the world to watch.
[24:47] Jess McAnally: Um, this I don't want high school productions.
[24:50] Christi Esterle: I think it's a gross movie that flippantly used the N-word a couple times that a lot of people forget about.
[24:56] Jess McAnally: Like that.
[24:58] Christi Esterle: That show is so weird, and it feels so 2001 Trump anger, let's be vulgar vibe.
[25:06] Jess McAnally: In the same way that Hamilton feels like Obama administration confidence of the new world.
[25:12] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[25:14] Jess McAnally: Um, yeah.
[25:14] Christi Esterle: So, Christy, what's your next one?
[25:17] Christi Esterle: Okay, probably a little controversial, but it's always rubbed me the wrong way.
[25:23] Jess McAnally: I will never like Greece.
[25:26] Christi Esterle: Yes!
[25:26] Jess McAnally: Yes!
[25:28] Christi Esterle: You just took my number one, baby, because my number one is also.
[25:34] Jess McAnally: Oh my god.
[25:35] Christi Esterle: Alright, we are.
[25:39] Jess McAnally: Alright, I am sorry.
[25:41] Christi Esterle: Everybody does it, and it is, you know, it's just like a bunch of stupid teenagers being stupid teenagers for two hours.
[25:49] Jess McAnally: It's it's not even just like like fun, like nothing.
[25:53] Christi Esterle: It's like actively harmful.
[25:57] Jess McAnally: It's like uh gross toxic masculinity, it's got girls bullying girls, changing who you are in the end of the Yeah, girls being pressured to have sex and being, you know, shamed when they're not having sex and being shamed when they are having sex, and people forget how fucking dirty that show is.
[26:17] Christi Esterle: And I'm not against her.
[26:19] Jess McAnally: Because they still do it in high schools.
[26:21] Christi Esterle: That's the thing, is that they do it in high schools all the time, and I saw a local high school production, I don't know, maybe a decade ago, because I knew some students in it, and it was one of those things where I was like, okay, I'm going to see high school production of Greece.
[26:31] Jess McAnally: And I'm sitting there and I'm going, Oh God.
[26:33] Christi Esterle: Oh God, I feel uncomfortable.
[26:34] Jess McAnally: Oh God, I feel uncomfortable.
[26:36] Christi Esterle: Like the whole time.
[26:36] Jess McAnally: As it was going, I'm like, ugh, these children should not be doing this.
[26:40] Christi Esterle: And then the other thing is like we all watched the movie when we were way too young, correct?
[26:46] Jess McAnally: Because I watched it when like from birth.
[26:48] Christi Esterle: Okay.
[26:49] Jess McAnally: So a lot of kids are still like that.
[26:51] Christi Esterle: A lot of students of mine will be like, let's do Greece.
[26:54] Jess McAnally: Like 13-year-olds.
[26:55] Christi Esterle: And I always say to them, we can do maybe a song.
[26:59] Jess McAnally: We can do like summer nights or something, or we go together for like a show or something.
[27:03] Christi Esterle: But mark my words, you are 13.
[27:05] Jess McAnally: Even summer we are never doing.
[27:07] Christi Esterle: Even summer nights, he's talking about how he's getting it on with this girl.
[27:10] Jess McAnally: Come on.
[27:11] Christi Esterle: Huh?
[27:11] Jess McAnally: Yep.
[27:12] Christi Esterle: Yep.
[27:12] Jess McAnally: I mean, yeah, it's it's it has some good songs.
[27:16] Christi Esterle: I mean, summer nights has some decent he said she said going on.
[27:19] Jess McAnally: There are worse things that I could do.
[27:21] Christi Esterle: Um, I mean, Rizzo's, you know, pregnancy scares up a lot is probably the best part of it.
[27:27] Jess McAnally: But it's completely it jump yeah, and it just goes away.
[27:30] Christi Esterle: There's no resolution.
[27:31] Jess McAnally: It's just she's pregnant.
[27:34] Christi Esterle: I know there's been like this movement to try to rehabilitate the ending, saying that Sandy is, you know, liberating herself from her from yeah, the from the uh social conditioning that says she has to be a good girl, but honestly, I think she's just giving one form of pressure for another because the entire show, everybody's being like, What?
[27:52] Jess McAnally: You don't smoke, you don't drink?
[27:54] Christi Esterle: Ew, what are you? Some kind of virgin and look at me like Chandra D.
[27:58] Jess McAnally: And it's yeah, I don't think, you know, I feel like she just caved into that, and it doesn't, it it does not sit well with me, and it never ever will.
[28:07] Christi Esterle: Um, and this is the other thing.
[28:09] Jess McAnally: So my husband was in Greece um national tours, he did it in Vegas, he did it for a while.
[28:16] Christi Esterle: Um, and he met the guy who wrote it, and he said he is a piece of shit who wrote this show about actual people in his life, and like like there was a Rizzo, like a girl got knocked up and like actively did it to like be a mean asshole and like shit on like people in the show.
[28:34] Jess McAnally: And like they all like make fun of the nerds and the goody two shoes in the show, and it's not fun, and there's no lesson learned.
[28:41] Christi Esterle: It's just like it's people I'm not against watching shitty people on stage, but there needs to be a reason for it.
[28:47] Jess McAnally: It's the stupid stuff you did in high school, but it's presenting it like, hey, wasn't this great?
[28:53] Christi Esterle: No, it was not great.
[28:54] Jess McAnally: I hated it.
[28:55] Christi Esterle: Don't remind me of it.
[28:57] Jess McAnally: Can I talk for a moment about Greece 2?
[29:00] Christi Esterle: Which takes a lot of I think it's better than the first one, because at least he he doesn't change who he is.
[29:06] Jess McAnally: He has a part of the personality that suits what she's interested in.
[29:10] Christi Esterle: Like well, Greece 2 is like the the room.
[29:13] Jess McAnally: There's like a guy who like tries to trick a girl into sex by saying there's a bomb space.
[29:17] Christi Esterle: There's an entire song about whatever reproduction.
[29:20] Jess McAnally: I I yeah, I love Greece because it's just bad bad, but like bad, like how Love Never Dies or the Room.
[29:26] Christi Esterle: It's like Greece, the original is just oh god, wait, they're making some pink ladies show now.
[29:33] Jess McAnally: Oh, yes, like there's a pre- The Rise of the Pink ladies.
[29:35] Christi Esterle: We do not need a prequel about the freaking pink ladies.
[29:38] Jess McAnally: Come on.
[29:39] Christi Esterle: And the problem is is that it was during the 70s when we were getting that 50s nostalgia really, really hard.
[29:45] Jess McAnally: And so that there are a lot of very, very catchy songs in Greece.
[29:51] Christi Esterle: Oh, but there is, yes.
[29:52] Jess McAnally: It's why it keeps being done.
[29:54] Christi Esterle: Because yeah, we go together, it's fun.
[29:56] Jess McAnally: All those like four-chord change songs.
[29:59] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[30:00] Jess McAnally: Uh C C C C whatever that.
[30:02] Christi Esterle: Yeah, Greece Lightning, even though it's basically a song about compensating for the city.
[30:05] Jess McAnally: Beauty School Job out.
[30:06] Christi Esterle: They're all catchy.
[30:08] Jess McAnally: The problem is they're they're catchy songs that are portrayed by horrible, horrible people that I hate.
[30:16] Christi Esterle: And I didn't realize till I was older that they were horrible.
[30:19] Jess McAnally: And then when I realized that, I was like, God, why did my mother let me watch this so much?
[30:24] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[30:25] Jess McAnally: I'm I'm still just in over ecstatic joy that at the end of the day we all came together.
[30:31] Christi Esterle: All came together to fight the true enemy.
[30:34] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[30:34] Christi Esterle: Which is Greece, which needs to die.
[30:37] Jess McAnally: It's one of those musicals that people who don't know anything about musicals, people who like just casual musical likers, you know, they'll just be like, oh, Greece is my favorite.
[30:48] Christi Esterle: And I'm like, Yeah, fine.
[30:51] Jess McAnally: You don't know anything.
[30:52] Christi Esterle: It's bad.
[30:53] Jess McAnally: Yeah, that's the one way we're very elitist.
[30:55] Christi Esterle: It's I'll be a snob about this forever.
[30:58] Jess McAnally: It's it's a piece of shit.
[30:59] Christi Esterle: And yet sometimes I'll just like it'll come on TV and I'll just kind of keep keep watching it for a little bit because I want to see John Travolta dance or something.
[31:06] Jess McAnally: It's so stupid.
[31:07] Christi Esterle: God, that musical.
[31:09] Jess McAnally: Wow.
[31:11] Christi Esterle: Well, why don't we promote our wonderful content for the world to find us other places where we can talk shit about Greece?
[31:18] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[31:19] Christi Esterle: I talk shit about Greece too.
[31:22] Jess McAnally: Yeah, yeah.
[31:23] Christi Esterle: Reproduction.
[31:24] Jess McAnally: Reproduction.
[31:25] Christi Esterle: Didn't Andrew Garfield just say that that's one of his favorite movie musicals.
[31:30] Jess McAnally: Jeff said that.
[31:32] Christi Esterle: No, no, Andrew Garfield.
[31:33] Jess McAnally: Oh.
[31:34] Christi Esterle: Oh, Jesus.
[31:35] Jess McAnally: Yeah, I remember that.
[31:36] Christi Esterle: It's like, oh geez.
[31:37] Jess McAnally: No, baby, come here.
[31:39] Christi Esterle: Let me introduce you.
[31:40] Jess McAnally: He appreciates that.
[31:41] Christi Esterle: He also recently just said multiple times in an interview.
[31:45] Jess McAnally: Brian Stokes Mitchell was famously the fam of the opera.
[31:48] Christi Esterle: That's Norm Lewis.
[31:48] Jess McAnally: He did a race.
[31:49] Christi Esterle: No, he won't.
[31:50] Jess McAnally: Yeah, he wasn't.
[31:50] Christi Esterle: I would mind.
[31:51] Jess McAnally: I wouldn't mind seeing Brian Stokes Mitchell as Phantom.
[31:53] Christi Esterle: But it was Norm Lois.
[31:54] Jess McAnally: Yeah, it was Norm Lewis, yeah.
[31:57] Christi Esterle: Okay, so um uh my my stuff.
[32:00] Emily Clark: Um, yeah, I'm Emily Clark.
[32:02] Christi Esterle: You can what it what where's my brain?
[32:04] Emily Clark: Okay, my show is Stealing Focus.
[32:07] Christi Esterle: You can find me at Stealing Focus on YouTube and on Patreon.
[32:11] Emily Clark: And um my uh handle is Emily A. B. Clark uh on all the socials you could possibly find.
[32:19] Christi Esterle: Alright.
[32:21] Jess McAnally: Alright, I am at Musical Hell on YouTube, Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook, um, you know, a lot of other stuff.
[32:29] Christi Esterle: I've got Patreon, I've got merch.
[32:31] Jess McAnally: I talk a lot about overrated shows and um enjoy, you know, getting mad at them, so um, I'm Jesse D. McMally on Twitter.
[32:41] Christi Esterle: I have a show called Musicals of Cheese.
[32:45] Jess McAnally: Um check them out, I guess, if you're bored.
[32:51] Christi Esterle: If you're bored, just watch all our stuff, please.
[32:54] Jess McAnally: Yeah, if you're bored for an evening and you want to just like listen to me and my friend talk about musicals in a catty and crass way as described by Paul Gordon's um manager, let go for it.
[33:05] Christi Esterle: Um we'll see.
[33:06] Jess McAnally: The late Meat Loaf's enemy.
[33:08] Christi Esterle: Oh, yeah, yeah.
[33:09] Jess McAnally: Andrew's arch enemy was Neat Meatloaf, and Andrew won.
[33:14] Christi Esterle: Oh.
[33:16] Jess McAnally: But anyway, we'll see you next time on the Dear Friends Podcast.
[33:20] Christi Esterle: Bye-bye!
[33:22] Jess McAnally: Grease sucks.
[33:23] Christi Esterle: Grease sucks.
[33:25] Jess McAnally: Dear friends, spill your voice to your musical family, dear friends.
[33:32] Christi Esterle: They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom.
[33:39] Jess McAnally: And anecdotes in an awfully cynical world, dear friends.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
