Skip to main content
BPN Logo
On Bette Midler with Kevin Winkler and Charles Kirsch

In this episode, Kevin Winkler discusses On Bette Midler: An Opinionated Guide. The book traces the rise of the Divine Miss M from the Continental Baths to mainstream stardom, exploring her impact on gay, Jewish, and feminist culture, as well as her influence across stage, film, music, and activism... Read More

From the show: The Drama Book Show!

58 mins
12/21/25

Guests

Featured Shows

About

In this episode, Kevin Winkler discusses On Bette Midler: An Opinionated Guide. The book traces the rise of the Divine Miss M from the Continental Baths to mainstream stardom, exploring her impact on gay, Jewish, and feminist culture, as well as her influence across stage, film, music, and activism.

Moderator Charles Kirsch, the young host of Backstage Babble, guides the conversation, offering insider insights into Midler’s enduring legacy and the evolution of her bold, iconic persona.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:18] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Hello and welcome to The Drama Book Show.

[0:20] David Rigano: My name is David Rigano.

[0:22] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And tonight's episode is on Bette Midler with Kevin Winkler, moderated by Charles Kirsch.

[0:30] David Rigano: This was the second time that Charles came in to moderate.

[0:34] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yes, because he moderated Nora's event, the Diva event.

[0:38] David Rigano: Yeah, and so, uh, and this was at his suggestion too.

[0:41] Mark-Eugene Garcia: He reached out about it.

[0:42] David Rigano: Yeah, and it was a really cool event talking about someone we love.

[0:47] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[0:48] David Rigano: It's really interesting because, um, as a gay of a certain age, uh, Bette Midler was a part of my life, but also wasn't a defining point in like my gayness, I guess.

[1:00] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Sure.

[1:01] David Rigano: Um, but still is for so many people. Like there was a joke I remember from Tales of the City, which was one of my favorite jokes, where they talked about a breakup between a gay couple and someone asked why they broke up, and he said because of S&M.

[1:15] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And they said, like, S&M, what does that have to do with anything?

[1:18] David Rigano: He goes, Well, he was in the Strice and I was in the Midler.

[1:26] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I almost couldn't even get through it.

[1:27] David Rigano: Um, but it just shows like the, the don't make me choose.

[1:31] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[1:31] David Rigano: Because there were also two Jewish icons. Don't make me choose.

[1:33] Mark-Eugene Garcia: But it's just, but it also shows that like the legend behind it.

[1:39] David Rigano: Yeah.

[1:39] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Um, but then it takes me back to, so when I was in elementary school, um, we sang "From a Distance" in my choir, my fifth grade choir.

[1:50] David Rigano: And it was a beautiful song.

[1:52] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yes.

[1:52] David Rigano: And I didn't really have a lot of knowledge of outside music other than like oldies, because my dad listened to them, to like Motown and, um, Disney because that's what I listened to, and I was a very sheltered life.

[2:04] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So here's this song that is really pretty that I knew. And so my mom had taken me and my brothers to, uh, Target, like we were all shopping or something, and she said that we each can pick one CD to buy.

[2:17] David Rigano: And I remembered that song, and so here I was at fifth grade buying a Bette Midler album.

[2:24] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Did you like go to the clerk and be like, "No, I, what album is this song?"

[2:28] David Rigano: I went and looked at all her albums and then found the—

[2:28] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So you knew it was a Bette Midler song.

[2:32] David Rigano: I knew who it was, yeah, I knew that much. Um, and I went and bought it, and then so I was like a little gay boy way back then too. And I remember like going home and just listening to it over and over again.

[2:44] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I remember, and I didn't get this at the time. I didn't know the stereotype at the time, and I've talked to my brother about this. That I, like one of the ways I was like bullied in like middle school was kids being like, "David listens to Bette Midler, David listens to Barbara Streisand," and I just remember being like, "Well, they're phenomenal vocalists, why wouldn't I look at it?"

[3:10] David Rigano: Like I didn't, I didn't, I didn't know that like, I didn't know that the joke that they were making was saying that I was gay.

[3:17] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[3:18] David Rigano: I was like, I don't, I don't know why that's a bad thing to do when they're both so incredible. It never dawned on me. It was just music that I liked and it made me feel good and made me happy.

[3:30] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And so, yeah, it's just interesting how that legend has become part of that. And then I started to learn about her as an actress, and I learned about like Ruthless People. I remember watching that over and over at my family's house, and then one of my favorites in the world was Outrageous Fortune.

[3:47] David Rigano: Yes.

[3:47] Mark-Eugene Garcia: One of the key moments for me, this might have been my real introduction to her, was that, um, Gypsy is of course one of my father's favorite musicals. So when that was on TV, when like the night that that TV production was broadcast, I don't remember where we were, but my father set the VCR.

[4:10] David Rigano: Yes.

[4:11] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And we got home from whatever thing we were out at. It's late, it's past our bedtimes. And my dad's like, "I just want to make sure that it records."

[4:19] David Rigano: Yes.

[4:20] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And he presses play, and I heard the Gypsy overture for the first time.

[4:23] David Rigano: Oh my god.

[4:23] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And I was just like, "Wait, can we watch this?" And he was like, "No, uh, you have to go to bed."

[4:28] David Rigano: Yeah.

[4:28] Mark-Eugene Garcia: How do you send someone to bed when they've just heard the first strains of the Gypsy overture for the first time? But he's like, "We can watch it tomorrow."

[4:36] David Rigano: Mm-hmm.

[4:36] Mark-Eugene Garcia: "But you have to go to bed now." But I was just like, "But, but, but I need to." So I think that was my first introduction to Bette Midler was the TV movie of Gypsy.

[4:45] David Rigano: That makes sense, yeah.

[4:46] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah, it just, it's just, I, there's so many moments in my life that have involved this person. And it's neat to see that, like, and my godfather, who I mentioned in the previous episode, used to be the, um, chairman of the board of GMHC, um, is also a fabulous Puerto Rican gay man. And so he would, uh, would do all of the Sophie Tucker jokes that Bette Midler did in her act.

[5:18] David Rigano: The dirtiest, filthiest jokes you've ever heard.

[5:21] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Of course, yeah. And, uh, so many of them I heard from him doing his impression of Bette Midler's impression of Sophie Tucker.

[5:30] David Rigano: Yeah, and it's just, again, it's someone who's influenced my life or influenced our lives without ever knowing it, but did. And I'm sure they know it. But I mean, just not for us personally, but she knows she's affected—

[5:45] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Oh, of course, of course.

[5:45] David Rigano: She's affected generations.

[5:47] Mark-Eugene Garcia: But, uh, so that, that flashes forward to, um, yesterday.

[5:53] David Rigano: Yeah.

[5:53] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Um, not from the podcast episode, but yesterday from the recording, where, uh, I happened to look up and see her in the store for the second time.

[6:04] David Rigano: Yeah.

[6:05] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Um, you texted me and I was like, "Sorry."

[6:09] David Rigano: I was just like, "Please just, please just don't say that this was in the store. Please just say that you met her somewhere else."

[6:14] Mark-Eugene Garcia: No, no.

[6:15] David Rigano: Um, and I was already having a great day because I had just talked to, uh, Marcia Mason on the phone.

[6:19] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So I was on a high.

[6:21] David Rigano: I had talked to the Goodbye Girl. I had already texted my dad that I watched that movie on the regular.

[6:27] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Um, the musical version was the first show I ever saw on Broadway starring Bernadette Peters.

[6:32] David Rigano: Yep.

[6:33] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Wow. Um, I had told Marcia Mason she made my day, and then she said I made hers because I told her I was fainting when I talked to her on the phone.

[6:39] David Rigano: So it was already high. I was already there.

[6:41] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah. Um, then Bette Midler walks in, and, uh, we talk a little bit at the place she was looking at, and then we talk again because I was bringing her up.

[6:48] David Rigano: And so, of course, I had to say, "Listen, I know it's probably weird, but Outrageous Fortune is one of my happy movies. It is one of my favorite movies."

[6:56] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And just to—and it's one of the things that you and I share.

[6:59] David Rigano: Yes.

[7:00] Mark-Eugene Garcia: The love of that movie. And just to have that moment was, uh, so powerful.

[7:05] David Rigano: Yeah.

[7:06] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And, and so wonderful to connect on that. Because it's like, I wanna, I want to tell the person that made the art thank you for making this.

[7:16] David Rigano: Of course, I think that's what it is. It's less about like, especially a comedy that is so silly like that, but is so smart in how silly it is.

[7:25] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And that, yeah, that movie is just very meaningful for both of us.

[7:29] David Rigano: Totally.

[7:30] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And it's just, it's that, it's, it's, uh, I always wanted to tell the artist, "Yeah, thank you."

[7:36] David Rigano: Yeah, there's a lot of that where I think so many times people are like, "Oh my god, I hate to meet this person because I love them." But it's like, but why? And I'm like, "No, I always want, like, I will search out a writer of a movie or a writer of a play to tell them yes and thank you."

[7:50] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I got to get—I Shining in Misery happened because I met Andy because I searched out an author of the movie Waiting in the Wings, who, uh, wrote this really cool, cute gay musical movie. Uh, reached out to him and said, "Hey, I just saw your movie on Amazon, I absolutely loved it."

[8:06] David Rigano: And he's like, "Well, I'm turning it into a musical, you want in?" And I was like, "Yes." And he's like, "Well, I'm pairing you with my friend Andy," and Andy and I loved writing a song together and ended up writing Shining in Misery together, all because I reached out to this one person who wrote a show.

[8:21] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I've done that here at the store. I was reading The Book of Will by Lauren Gunderson, and I got to a part that was going to make me, uh, openly cry at work. So I needed to put the book down because I couldn't do that.

[8:30] David Rigano: Right.

[8:38] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Um, and so while I was pulling myself together, I decided to just, um, message her on Instagram and say, "Hi, I work at the Drama Book Shop, we've met once, and I'm reading your play right now, and I had to put it down because it was gonna make me cry."

[8:53] David Rigano: So while I'm pulling my stuff together, I thought I'd just send you this message and say thank you for this play.

[8:58] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And she was like, "Oh my god, thank you so much. I hope that I get to see you next time I'm in the Drama Book."

[9:03] David Rigano: You know, all of that pleasantries.

[9:04] Mark-Eugene Garcia: But yeah, absolutely. And we have gotten to, you know, to meet some of our heroes, and to meet authors who maybe we wouldn't know their work, except that they come in and we meet them and then we read their work because they're cool people.

[9:22] David Rigano: I like, uh, Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa messaged me this morning about Shining in Misery.

[9:26] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Uh-huh.

[9:27] David Rigano: And I was just like, "Oh my god."

[9:28] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Amazing.

[9:29] David Rigano: Um, it's wonderful to have that experience.

[9:34] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah, is that for a while there was like three weeks, I feel like in a row on Wednesdays always.

[9:43] David Rigano: Oh, were you where someone like Conan O'Brien?

[9:48] Mark-Eugene Garcia: You missed Conan, Cranston, and so it was like three weeks in a row where I would come in on a Wednesday afternoon to find that someone huge had been in that morning, and like Conan took a picture with everybody.

[10:03] David Rigano: Yes.

[10:04] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I'm not in that picture, I wasn't at work yet. Or Brian Cranston. I walk in one day, and one of our co-workers standing behind the register sees me and just starts laughing.

[10:17] David Rigano: And I went, "Don't tell me. Don't tell me. I don't want to know. I don't want to know. Let me at least go upstairs and put my stuff down before I find out."

[10:25] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And then through her laughter, she goes, "Bette Midler."

[10:28] David Rigano: And I went—

[10:32] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And I was so—then when you texted me and you were like, "I just told Bette Midler that Outrageous Fortune is one of my favorite movies," I was like, "No, the store you didn't back."

[10:47] David Rigano: Second time that I missed her at the store.

[10:50] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So Bette, come on back, please.

[10:53] David Rigano: Yes, please.

[10:53] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Third time's a charm.

[10:54] David Rigano: Yeah, I'm happy to see you again. Um, other movies if you guys I liked. But also one of the albums that I grew up with at home, uh, was the compilation, like the best of album.

[11:04] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Right.

[11:04] David Rigano: Uh, Bette Midler Experience the Divine.

[11:07] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yes.

[11:08] David Rigano: And I used to work, I still occasionally pick up shifts and occasionally see playwright friends like, uh, like James Imes and Liz Duffy Adams at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine.

[11:19] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And, uh, and, and, and I, I will say Bette, uh, used to do her Hula Win fundraiser at the cathedral.

[11:28] David Rigano: Oh wow.

[11:29] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So I have gotten to, like, I not meet her, but like kind of up close and personal, watch her, uh, do her thing and, uh, rehearse.

[11:38] David Rigano: Yeah.

[11:38] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I got to watch her and David Hyde Pierce rehearse a fun little parody song that they were doing together. So it was, uh, that's, that's the closest that I've gotten.

[11:47] David Rigano: But also for pride every year, the cathedral lights up the columns. These are, this is the largest cathedral in the world, so these massive columns going down the stretch of the nave, and they light up the columns in rainbow.

[12:03] Mark-Eugene Garcia: If you Google it, you can find images out there.

[12:07] David Rigano: And it's Cathedral of St. John the Divine.

[12:11] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So, uh, one year I took a picture of the rainbow columns and I photoshopped Bette Midler from the cover of that compilation album into my picture, and I labeled it the Cathedral of St. John Experience the Divine.

[12:28] David Rigano: I love it, and I figured that was pretty much the gayest thing that you could get.

[12:34] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Truly. Well, we have had some really good stories about Bette Midler. But the book, we have some other really good stories about Bette Midler.

[12:44] David Rigano: Um, while Kevin Winkler and Charles Kirsch talk about On Bette Midler.

[12:49] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So let's delve in.

[12:50] David Rigano: Here we go.

[12:53] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And thank you, Kevin, for being here with me tonight. And this is such a really wonderful book for all of you who haven't read it yet. It, you get to know her really not just as an icon but as a person, and it's a really great biography, as all of Kevin's are.

[13:05] David Rigano: So I'd love to start at the beginning asking you how you first came up with the idea to write about Bette Midler.

[13:12] Kevin Winkler: I've been a fan of Bette Midler's. I followed her career for over 50 years. I even did my graduate thesis on her. I won't tell you how long ago that was. But today she seems to be well known for her revival of Hello Dolly, for Hocus Pocus, and the sequel to Hocus Pocus that was just on Disney Plus.

[13:34] Kevin Winkler: And I come to feel that her important contributions, her successes early on in her career, were in danger of being forgotten or neglected anyway. And Oxford has a series called Opinionated Guide, and I was reading one of them. They're deep dives into the creative output of important figures in entertainment.

[13:57] Kevin Winkler: And as I was reading one, the idea got in my head is that somebody needs to write a book like this about Bette Midler. And then I think it took me, I don't know, 15 seconds to say, "I'll do it. Why not leave?" So that was the start of it.

[14:14] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah. And how did you find that your process with this book differed from those of the Tommy Tune and Bob Fosse biographies?

[14:22] Kevin Winkler: I'd say that the other two books, the Fosse and the Tune biography, were unopinionated. Based on, or they were grounded in archival research and first-person interviews. And in the case of the Tune book, I had his cooperation, and I interviewed Tommy numerous times for the book.

[14:41] Kevin Winkler: This was different because it really is, it's not only opinionated, it's highly opinionated. And I didn't speak to Bette Midler, I didn't speak to anyone who has ever worked with her. I don't quote performance reviews. It's really, as I say, a deep dive into her creative accomplishments as a multi-platform artist, someone who has excelled in theater, films, television, recordings. So my goal was to dig in and examine her accomplishments in all those areas.

[15:15] Charles Kirsch: And how did you decide how best to structure the book and split it up into those categories?

[15:21] Kevin Winkler: I'll enter that in two parts. By putting together chapters on the individual mediums in which she excelled, it really gave me the space to really dig in and examine her evolution as an artist, as a stage artist, by looking at her shows, her big touring shows over the years, to look at how she evolved as a recording artist, and then looking at how she has changed or how she hasn't changed as a personality who pops up with some regularity on TV, and then her trajectory as a film actor. But when I first started working on the book, I needed, I felt like I needed a hook for it. I needed something to give it a kind of narrative arc. And I wasn't exactly sure how to proceed. So I was talking to my mother one day on the phone, and she asked me what I was working on, and I told her.

And the first words out of her mouth were, oh, I just love her. And I said, Mom, what is it that you love about her? And she said, oh, she's so funny, and I like the way she sings, and I like her movies. And I said, Mom, you're engaging in a little revisionist history. Because I clearly remember the first time I saw her, first time you saw her, I was a teenager, I was still living at home. We were sitting on the couch watching the Johnny Carson show, the Tonight Show, and I fell in love with her the minute I saw her, that you were not having it. You thought she was vulgar and trashy, and you were particularly upset because she didn't appear to be wearing a bra. So there was silence on the other end of the line, and finally she said, that was a long time ago.

And I thought, exactly, how did we go from vulgar and trashy to oh I just love her over the course of a 50-plus year career? And I thought if I could use that as the hook, and I start the book with her origin story, as it were, her entry into mainstream theater and show business, and use that to show how not only how she's changed, but how the culture has changed and how we have evolved in terms of her reception.

[17:37] Charles Kirsch: Since we are at the Drama Bookshop, I'd like to start a little bit by talking about her early kind of theater influences. Charles Ludlam is one that you mentioned, Tom Ayen is another. And I wonder if you could tell us a little bit about how theater influenced Bette Midler.

[17:52] Kevin Winkler: Actually, that's a great jumping-off point. Can I read a little bit?

[17:55] Charles Kirsch: Yes, absolutely.

[17:56] Kevin Winkler: Let me read a little something from the book about just that point. You probably know that Midler grew up in Hawaii, in a small town in the outskirts of Honolulu. And she spent a year and a half at the University of Hawaii as a theater major, doing plays and musicals, and in the summer she'd work in a pineapple factory. And when she was 19 years old, the production company behind the movie version of John James Michener's novel Hawaii came to Hawaii to do location shooting. And she was chosen as a non-speaking extra, a bit player in the movie. And she worked on that for quite a while. You can actually find this. There's a great clip on YouTube where you can actually see her, a glimpse of her as a C-Sick missionary's wife, kind of heaving over the side of the boat in Hawaii.

But anyway, the money that she made doing that film financed her move to New York City. This was in the fall of 1965. Midler was just 19 years old with only a small nest egg, no connections, and no real training or experience. But just like countless gay boys who make their way to the city, I just bloomed when I came here, she later said. I never felt I was home until I came here. I became all the things I wanted to be. It was like I was finally free. Midler's arrival in New York coincided with a burgeoning off-Broadway scene, much of which was marked by gay camp humor, satire, and parody. The free-for-all atmosphere of these shows was more welcoming to her unorthodox looks and wild sense of humor than the traditional Broadway plays and musicals she auditioned for.

Years before his big Broadway hit with the book and lyrics for Dreamgirls, Tom Ayen was a fixture of downtown experimental theater. His cheerfully anarchic plays were laced with sex and movie references. In the fall of 1965, he was preparing his latest, a Cleopatra musical spoof, when Midler arrived at his door to audition, looking like, as he said, an ingenue version of Lotte Lenya. She was cast immediately, and on her 20th birthday, Midler made her New York stage debut as Naomi in Assorted Virgins in a musical called Miss Nefertini Regrets at La Mama Experimental Theater Club. The musical was revived twice in the early months of 1966, with Midler elevated to the title role. She immersed herself in the work of other downtown artists who would influence her later performance aesthetic.

There were a lot of people who were doing exciting things back then, she later said. As a matter of fact, I got a great deal of my early inspiration from Charles Ludlam. Ludlam was at the vanguard of this new theater movement that produced works of epic scale, combining high culture with low, and featuring uninhibited nudity and simulating sex. Charles Ludlam and Tom Ayen gave Midler a glimpse of an expanded theatrical world unbounded by the strictures of commercial theater, which relied on types and prescribed gender and ethnic norms. So that's enough of that. So anyway, that's what she was. That's where she was, those were all the influences that she was soaking up when she first moved to the city.

[21:20] Charles Kirsch: And further to the theme of Bette Midler and theater, you discuss in the book her performances as Dolly in Hello, Dolly! and as Rose in the TV film of Gypsy, and neither of them quite pass muster with you as per the book. And I wonder if you could talk a little bit about your opinions on those two stage great musical roles of hers.

[21:42] Kevin Winkler: You had to ask that question. I adore her. I wouldn't have spent a couple of years working on this book if I didn't. But as an artist, not everything she's done is the equal of her best work. I felt the Gypsy TV movie was not particularly well directed, and I don't think she got the help she needed from the director. The director was very ill, and Emile Ardolino was very ill during the filming, and he died actually just before the film's broadcast. So I think with a stronger director, he would have helped her bring more nuance and subtlety to the performance. With Hello, Dolly!, Hello, Dolly! was fabulous. It was really, it was fabulous. It was as close as I think anyone's gonna get today to seeing a replica of a golden age musical put on the stage.

No expense was spared, it was a big cast, a big orchestra. It was thrilling, and she gave the star performance at the center that it deserved. I think I say in the book that I wish she had done the show 10 or 15 years earlier, when she was somewhat vocally fresher. She certainly didn't seem old, and she has a great vitality about her, but there was a carefulness to the performance. The older I get, the more I understand that. The show was a thrill. I loved it. But I wish she had done it 10 or 15 years earlier. But she didn't. So we enjoyed it for what it was.

[23:06] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. It was delightful. And so the other reason that Bette Midler has been in the news recently, other than this book, is a lot of this discussion over whether she should play Mame, which she said in an interview that she wants to do on Broadway. And what's your opinion on do you think that would be a good next project for her, or do you think she's too old now? Or what do you think?

[23:26] Kevin Winkler: Again, the older I get, the more hesitant I am to say someone's too old for something. But sure, why not? I saw that interview too. I took it as more of her musing or thinking out loud about projects she would like to do in a perfect world, songs she would like to sing. So sure, why not? Even if she did it as a concert event or a one-night thing, that would be wonderful. Whatever she does, if she does it, I'll be there.

[23:57] Charles Kirsch: And you talk in the book about some of the projects of hers that never came to fruition, especially in the movie and television section of the book. And I wonder if you have a favorite one that in a different world you would have liked to have seen happen.

[24:11] Kevin Winkler: Oh, yeah. There were a couple of projects that she worked on that didn't turn out. But at the be when she first emerged on the scene in the early 70s, she was touted for movies immediately. She was really sought for films almost from the get-go. And her agent, her manager, Aaron Russo, really kept really pushed her back and said, I want the first movie you do to be a movie that no one else can do, a role that no one else can do, and it needs to be something special, an event. And so they turned down a few things. She turned down playing Adrian in Rocky. She turned down the movie Foul Play, Goldie Hawn did that role. But the one that I'm really sorry she didn't do was Robert Altman's Nashville.

She was offered the role of Albuquerque, this kind of country woman who sneaks off from her husband and tries to be noticed by national talent scouts. And at the end of the movie, there's an assassination, and she ends up galvanizing the audience with a gospel number and leading the cast in this number. And Barbara Harris ended up playing the role. She was terrific. She's wonderful. But I really wish that Midler had done that role. And it would have given her that song, It Don't Worry Me. That could have been an early hit for her. But the other movies that she had in development at various times during her film career, this was the 80s and the 90s, there were two that stand out that I'm really sorry she wasn't able to get off the ground.

One was a biographical film about Lotte Lenya and her marriage to Kurt Weill and her work with Bertolt Brecht. And Midler has a real, I think has always had a real affinity for Brecht. And when she went to audition for Tom Ayen, she pulled out a 12-page arrangement of The Threepenny Opera. So not only did she look like an ingenue Lotte Lenya, she sang like one too. So I'm really sorry that never got off the band. That would have been terrific. And the other one was a project that she was going to do with Martin Scorsese, a biographical film of Texas Guinan, the saloon keeper from the 20s. And I don't know whatever happened with that. It never got made. And I think she would have been ideal casting in that. And working with a terrific director like Martin Scorsese would have been wonderful, and I'm sorry it never happened.

[26:46] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And if I could share my own, I gasped a little bit reading the book when Little Me was mentioned at something that almost happened, the movie of Little Me starring her, which would have been such a great thing, I think.

[26:56] Kevin Winkler: So they wanted to do the movie. She and Aaron Russo wanted to do the movie Little Me. And this is the Broadway musical, the lead. I guess she would have played both parts. I don't know, she would have played both parts, young Belle and old Belle. Belle Poitrine is the lead character in Little Me. Belle Poitrine is French for divine bosoms or something, beautiful bosoms or something. And they had an interview, a meeting with Ross Hunter, the producer Ross Hunter, and Russo questioned Ross Hunter's taste because they had just been to see his movie Lost Horizon, the musical that was musical Lost Horizon with Peter Finch and Liv Ullmann. And anyway, Hunter got very indignant that Russo would question him. So when he found out that they were trying to get Little Me as a vehicle for her, he bought it for Goldie Hawn. So they wouldn't get it. But they never did it. It is too bad.

[27:54] Charles Kirsch: Yeah, it's too bad. And so a lot of people, of course, know how Dolly, Gypsy, a lot of people in the wind Beneath My Wings and a lot of her other things, but are there underappreciated Bette Midler recordings or films or TV shows that you think people should be sure to see?

[28:09] Kevin Winkler: Sure. Oh, there are a lot of them. Certainly in terms of recordings, if I was exiled to a desert island, the one Bette Midler album I would take with me is her live album from 1977 called Live at Last. It was one of her mid-70s tours that was not only videotaped for HBO, but was also the basis for a live two LP live album. And it's really the complete Midler experience in I don't know, an hour and 15 minutes. It's got comedy, it's got heartbreaking ballads, it's got the boogie woogie, it's got all the characters, Vicky Edie, Ernie, all of them. And it really shows the full range of her talents as both a singer and an actor. Let's say what, oh, you're talking about other medium? Certainly, staying on movies. Her first movie was her best movie. That was The Rose, 1979. It's a film that seems to have fallen out of consciousness.

[29:11] Kevin Winkler: I don't think it's on any streaming platforms that I know of. It was a big hit at the time. She was nominated for an Oscar. She won a Grammy Award for her recording of the title song. But it's a film that seems to have been forgotten. And she gives really it's a scalding, a brutal performance that has these gorgeous touches of lyrical touches and grace notes to it. It's just it's a brilliant performance, and she really has never had another film like that since then. And she had many hits, certainly, she had lots of comedy hits in the 80s. There's another film that I would recommend to people. She made about 15 or 16 years ago called Then She Found Me. It starred and was directed by Helen Hunt.

And it's about a 40-year-old woman played by Helen Hunt who goes looking for her birth mother, a woman who gave her up for adoption when she was a baby. And her birth mother is Bette Midler. She plays a kind of Ultra Winfrey-like TV personality. And the dynamic between the two of them, the mother and the daughter, the reunion of them, is very sensitively handled. Helen Hunt was a terrific, is a terrific director of actors. And it's a subtle and nuanced performance, and they work great together. I would recommend seeking it out, if you can.

[30:31] Charles Kirsch: Yeah, absolutely. And since you mentioned The Rose, I was going to ask you anyway. You talk in the book about how, while it may have started as the biopic of Janis Joplin or something similar to that, it ended up having quite a lot of parallels to Midler's own life. And what were some of those that especially stood out to you in that film?

[30:49] Kevin Winkler: Yeah, when Janis Joplin, the poor woman, was barely in her grave before they started promoting movie ideas, biopic ideas. There was one, the one that was the strangest that I came across was an exploitation movie that was going to be produced by a porn producer starring Patty Duke as Janis Joplin. That never got made. And she had really great respect for Janis Joplin. And she had made an impact on Midler, who Midler saw her in concert. And she didn't want to just do an impersonation. They rewrote the script, they went through numerous rewrites, and as it became less Janis Joplin and a little more Bette Midler. There are references to her appearances at the Continental Baths. There's a scene in the bathhouse.

There's a scene with drag queens. Midler had a rather rocky relationship with her father in terms of her performing career. He never came to see her perform. He was very straight-laced and uptight. And there's a subplot where her parents won't come to see her. Her manager, played by Howland Bates, has some kind of controlling element that Erin Russo had. So there are moments like that in the film that resonate with her biography.

[32:10] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And Aaron Russo has come up a few times now as her manager to whom she said, "Make me a legend. Make me a legend." A simple request. And I wonder what you think in your sort of opinionated way about whether he was good for her career, whether he was too controlling if he prevented her from certain opportunities or she said that he was very good for her career.

[32:33] Kevin Winkler: He came into contact with her around 1972. She was just starting to emerge. She had done the Continental Baths off and on for a couple of years. She was doing small clubs, touring, like college venues and so forth. And he was a huge fan of hers, and he made a big pitch to manage her. And when she said, "Make me a legend," what she meant was she had a management at that time that was trying to steer her sort of in the girl singer mode, playing Las Vegas and that sort of thing. And she said, "I don't want to just be another girl singer working the circuit. I want to make me a legend," only half joking. And what he did was instrumental in breaking her to a larger audience. He really pushed her and booked her into rock venues, places like The Troubadour in LA, the name the place here in New York in Lower Manhattan, I'm completely blanking on now.

It's in the book. Places were at San Francisco, Philadelphia, rock venues. And it turned out the rock people loved her. They loved the boogie bourgeoisie, they loved the dirty jokes, they loved her brashness. And so he really helped, he was instrumental in broadening her audience. And certainly in terms of he produced The Rose and showcasing her in that film, he certainly did right by her. But I think by the end of the decade, she had grown tired. It was a volatile relationship. And I think she had grown tired of the sense of control that he had over her. And so they parted as the 80s got underway.

[34:08] Charles Kirsch: And you talk in the book about how part of what made her concerts and recordings so special was this combination of very different styles that she would use. But I have to ask, is there one that you value more than the others, or wish she'd done more of rock and roll or standards or blues or I don't know?

[34:26] Kevin Winkler: She's tackled such a wide range of material throughout her career. I can't say that she neglected any particular genre. I will put in a pitch for one of my favorite albums. It's what is referred to as her disco album, Thighs and Whispers, which was released at the peak of the disco era. It's mostly disco; it's not all disco. There are a couple of really terrific ballads, very haunting ballads. But it's a lot of disco, and it's amazing how much variety she got out of that genre. All of the songs, the disco songs are all very different in style and tone. So if you're looking for something that you haven't heard before, I would recommend listening to that.

[35:10] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And so, as anyone who's read just this book or all three of your books knows, you really do a lot of extensive research on the person you're writing about. And what did you find to be some of the most helpful sources for this particular book?

[35:24] Kevin Winkler: I somebody asked me how recently how did you do research for this book? And I said, or how long did it take you to research this book? And I said, I've been researching it for I guess about 50 years. And I'm also a former librarian, so I'm one of these people who rips out articles in the newspaper and prints things out and sticks them in clipping piles. So I had a clipping file about Bette Midler. Part of it was revisiting interviews she'd done, particularly at the beginning of her career, and then really revisiting all of the work that I had experienced over the last 50-some years. I watched every movie she ever made. I saw all of them. I listened to all of her recordings, all of her live shows, all of her big concert tours, virtually all of them are available on YouTube.

So you can dip into YouTube and see her full concert trajectory and TV appearances as well. I went over to the Paley Center, the used to be the Museum of Broadcasting, and looked at a few things that I couldn't find on YouTube. But that was mainly how I did the research.

[36:36] Charles Kirsch: And how many times, if you've kept count, have you seen Bette Midler live?

[36:41] Kevin Winkler: Probably not all that many. I refer to myself as a fan, not a fanatic. I wouldn't like if she's playing three nights in the city, I'm not gonna go all three nights. I couldn't afford it. I'm not someone who camps out on her doorstep and finds up for autographs or things like that. But I don't know, I've seen all the live shows since the mid-70s, eight, ten, twelve times, something like that.

[37:07] Charles Kirsch: And so, even with all of that background, was there something that was especially surprising to you in doing research for this book?

[37:19] Kevin Winkler: No. It was interesting. It was a lot of fun kind of digging through publicly available material to see what she had done in college, roles that she had played in college. I found the scans of programs from the University of Hawaii of her playing a maid in The Cherry Orchard, and things like that. Those were unusual. That was a surprise to me.

[37:46] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And so one of the things that's so interesting about your book, one of my favorite parts, is that you really get into sort of whether some particular project was a good decision in the arc of her career, or kind of a not as good decision in the arc of her career. And I can I ask, is there something that you would identify as the best and worst career decisions that she made?

[38:08] Kevin Winkler: Oh god, oh god, let's say the best and worst career decisions. She would say the worst decision was doing disco. She has trashed her disco album up one side and down the other. I certainly don't agree with that. The best, certainly, she after she did The Rose, she really didn't get any offers to do anything else. She's special, she's unique, and she doesn't fit every role that comes along. And she had a hard time getting a follow-up vehicle after The Rose. So I guess probably the worst thing she did, and she would agree in this, is she did a film called Jinxed in 1982. And she had a lot of trouble with the director and her leading man, and they really trashed her. They were just reading through these interviews in the LA Times and Variety, where they just trashed her.

Ken Wall was her leading man. And he said, "I had to think of my dog, and I did love scenes with her." What the hell? And they just tried, they were terrible to her. And I think it impacted her very greatly. I think it had a huge impact on her. And then a couple of years later, though, she was approached by Paul Mazursky, the writer-director, to do a film that he had set up at Walt Disney Studios called Down and Out in Beverly Hills. And as she said, she got three leads who were on their uppers at that time: her, Nick Nolte, and Richard Dreyfuss. And the name of the film, it was a big hit, and it started a whole new movie career for her at, of all places, the Walt Disney Studios. And she became a top 10 box office star for the next several years. So that was probably one of the best decisions she made in terms of her career trajectory.

[39:56] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And you talk in the book about how The Rose was the only movie that was really able to capture the entire essence of Bette Midler. And I wonder if you could go a little bit into why you think some of her later projects weren't quite as for her, didn't quite meet her.

[40:12] Kevin Winkler: I think she did a very ambitious music movie musical in the early 90s called For the Boys. And she reunited with Mark Rydell, who had directed The Rose. He directed this film. And it had everything in place for it to be a terrific film that kind of scanned decades. It starts in the 40s and it goes up to I guess the late 80s or 90, around the time the movie was made. And she's terrific in it. She gets to age over a long period of time. She tackles a lot of really interesting 40s music. There's some terrific performances on the soundtrack album. But the film didn't really hang together as a dramatic film. It was disappointing. So that I think was somewhat of a setback for her. I think movies have been difficult for her because she's such a unique performer.

I think directors and producers maybe have not thought of her beyond being a crazy funny woman as she was in all of her Disney comedies. And I think Hollywood, there's a brutal calculus in Hollywood for women as they get older; there just aren't the opportunities as much. So she's had that problem, so lots of other actresses.

[41:27] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And another kind of thread that runs through the book, and how could it not with Bette Midler as the subject, is sort of her relationship with gay men and the gay community. And you talk about how, of course, they launched her career, and then a little bit later in the book, you get into how she started to joke about it a little too much on like her TV appearances and things like that. I wonder if you could trace that arc a little bit for us.

[41:49] Kevin Winkler: She had a kind of outsider's perspective that because she again she grew up in Hawaii, surrounded by Chinese, Filipinos, Samoans. She has said there were very few whites and no Jews, and I was both, and made to feel that I didn't belong. So I think she understood that outsider's perspective, and I think that was part of the reason for her performances at the Continental Baths in the early 70s were, I don't know, there was an emotion to them. You can tell that just looking, there's some footage of her in performance at the baths, and you can just feel the emotion. So I think she related to those men who were dealing with their own issues. They went to the baths not just for sex but also for a sense of community and safety.

And she was, as I said in the book, she's like every mouthy girl who ever stood up for her friends who were getting bullied on the playground. She was that person. And I think that ran real deep with me, and I think it runs real deep with a lot of gay men.

[42:53] Charles Kirsch: And then how did that sort of change later on to her maybe being a little bit too flippant about it?

[42:59] Kevin Winkler: That was the passage you're referring to. And let's how would I put this? Somewhere in the 90s, I say, she decayed Bette Midler, all in caps, became a diva, and she would joke in a mocking way about her gay fans. Those were just one-offs. I wouldn't hold it against her, but I think they were just one-offs. She was being flip, yeah, and sometimes a flip remark can be hurtful.

[43:32] Charles Kirsch: Yeah. And you mentioned, of course, her sort of underdog thing and how that may have connected with gay men, and that's something that people also say about a lot of other gay icons, like Cher, Judy Garland, Liza Minnelli, Barbra Streisand, and how do you think she fits in that pantheon and claims her own place and is different and yet similar?

[43:53] Kevin Winkler: And she she's certainly in that pantheon. She's she has a place of honor in that pantheon. I mentioned something in the book about Barbara Streisand from the very very beginning. This as soon as she as soon as she burst on the scene, she was compared to Barbara Streisand. And a lot of those comparisons I thought were very reductive and were insulting to both of them. But one of the one of the ways that they were different is that Barbara Streisand had a lot of help early on in her career from gay men who helped her come up with her style, her makeup, her clothes, and so forth. And Bette Midler had lots of early gay mentors as well, friends who turned her on to new music and to movies and things that she'd never had no idea about.

And she always remembered them, and she was very quick to credit them with helping her. She said, I think there's a quote in the book, she said, I've had gay friends, gay mentors. For as long as I've as long as I've known, certainly since I've been in show business, they gave me my voice, they gave me my vision, and I could never repay them. And so she's she's very open-hearted about giving credit to people who were there with her and who helped her in a way that Barbara Streisand really isn't. She promotes the idea that she emerged fully formed without the help of others.

[45:17] Kevin Winkler: And another kind of thread in the book is the public perception of Bette Midler, and she often says, This is not what my public wants to see, or something like that, when discussing projects she wants to do. And I wonder if you could talk a little bit about what you think that is now and what her public wants from her in this current moment. Golly, that let's see. I'm not sure. I'm I'm not sure. I guess I could answer it from my position as part of her public. I'd like to see her, I'd like to see her do some choice supporting roles in films or television. Because first and foremost, she's an actor. And I think films and TV work are certainly easier than putting on a big show and doing MAME, a full production of MAME or touring in water for I suspect she probably won't ever go out with one of her big touring shows again.

But she's uh she's a frightfully good actor, and I wish she had more opportunities to show that. There was a show on HBO that was broadcast during the pandemic. It was uh an anthology show. It was written by Paul Rudnick called Coastal Elites, and it's five different monologues, and each of them is a Zoom call. It's all takes place, it's all filmed during on Zoom during the pandemic. And she played a woman named Miriam Miriam Nessler, a retired New York City school teacher, a as she called a politically liberal Jewish woman, an NPR totebag toting New Yorker who gets into a tussle with a Trump supporter at a Starbucks, and she rips his MAGA hat off him, and she runs and seeks sanctuary in the hallowed space of the public theater.

And he still presses charges anyway. So she the her monologue takes place at the police station where she's pleading her case to the police chief. She's wonderful. She's just terrific. It's about 23 minutes, 23, 24 minutes. She's just terrific. And I I would say, Bette, do more of that, because she really is a wonderful actor.

[47:23] Kevin Winkler: And uh I'd love to see do more of those kind of projects. She really is. I remember seeing that when it was on during the pandemic, and it is a great monologue. And something else you talk about in the book in terms of more recent steps for her is her becoming a political activist figure on Twitter a little bit. And what do you think? How do you think that sort of fits in with her history of activism? She's always been outspoken, and she's always been an activist. She's always stood up for a gay friend. She did a lot of fundraising and under the radar financial help to people who were close to her during the AIDS, the worst of the AIDS crisis. She's campaigned. I saw her campaign for Obama. She has taken to Twitter with a vengeance, like a lot of people, and she makes very pithy, smart ass comment.

She can't stand Donald Trump. And they've they've butted heads over Twitter or X now over the years. He called her a washed-up psycho at one point. And she uh she recorded when he left office in 2021, she recorded a farewell to him called goodbye, Donnie, to the tune of hello dolly. That's pretty scathing. Let's pray. That sticks, right? That sticks. So she she's engaged, she's politically engaged, she's aware of what's going on. She's also a really intelligent person. She's she's uh she's an informed person, she's well read, she cares about the environment. We haven't even talked about her New York restoration project, which has done so much to make New York more livable over the last almost 30 years. So she's a citizen of the world, and you, as you would, and outspoken, so you'd expect that she'd let off some steam on social media.

[49:11] Kevin Winkler: Yeah. And so a final sort of fun question before we turn it over to your reading and then to the audience. If you had to make your dream biopic of Bette Midler, who do you think would play her or some of the people close to her? Oh my God. You were asking some tough questions. Let's say, who would play Bette Midler? I don't, I guess my first thought would be she hasn't been born yet, the woman who could play Bette Midler. I'm sure there are some fabulous young actresses that I'm not thinking of off the top of my head right now. Oh man, and Theo Russo and Barry Manlow. We didn't even talk about Barry Manilow, one of her first musical directors, or Mark Shaman. Remember, Mark Shaman could play himself. I don't know. You've completely stumped on this show. I'm gonna have to think about that and get back to you.

[50:02] Charles Kirsch: Yes, you'll let us know. Well, so I know you have another reading prepared for us, and then we will move on to audience questions. How are we doing on time?

[50:11] Kevin Winkler: Five minutes? Okay, I'll just I'll read something very short. Let's say. Oh, well, I'll read a little something about the origins of her of the commodity bands. Ever since she arrived in New York in 1965, Midler had been auditioning for Fiddler on the Roof, the Broadway musical Smash. Midler spent three years in the show, first as an ensemble member and later as Seidel, Tevy's oldest daughter. Midler had hoped to use her Broadway perch as a platform for other jobs, but was unable to land another show. Instead, she began singing in showcase cabaret rooms where performers would get up and try out songs. As Midler was establishing herself as a singer, another New Yorker was realizing his dream.

In 1968, Steve Ostrow, a married, openly bisexual entrepreneur, opened the Continental Baths and Health Club, a bathhouse for gay men in the basement of the Ansonia Hotel, a landmark residential building located on Broadway between 73rd and 74th Streets. The previous tenant had been a health club featuring a 45-foot swimming pool with a gym, steam room, and showers.

[51:18] ⚠ About 5 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.

[56:10] Kevin Winkler: Ooh.

[56:11] Charles Kirsch: They were.

[56:12] Kevin Winkler: Indeed.

[56:12] Charles Kirsch: They were.

[56:13] Kevin Winkler: You're the wind beneath my wings.

[56:14] Charles Kirsch: Yeah.

[56:16] Kevin Winkler: Beaches is coming to Broadway.

[56:18] Charles Kirsch: That it is.

[56:19] Kevin Winkler: Yes.

[56:20] Charles Kirsch: Very exciting.

[56:21] Kevin Winkler: Very, very exciting.

[56:22] Charles Kirsch: It's Jessica Voss.

[56:23] Kevin Winkler: Uh-huh.

[56:23] Charles Kirsch: Yes.

[56:24] Kevin Winkler: Oh.

[56:25] Charles Kirsch: Just that some some Yeah.

[56:27] Kevin Winkler: A little more, a little more uh bet adjacent.

[56:30] Charles Kirsch: Again, again, influencing the world still.

[56:34] Kevin Winkler: Yeah.

[56:34] Charles Kirsch: Yeah.

[56:34] Kevin Winkler: And hopefully she'll come in again and influence us some more.

[56:37] Charles Kirsch: Yeah.

[56:38] Kevin Winkler: Uh, but coming up, uh, we're gonna have our uh regular guest co-host back, Dylan Glick.

[56:45] Charles Kirsch: Yeah, is gonna be with us to uh talk with us about the novel version of Prima Facie.

[56:53] Kevin Winkler: Not just Dylan Glick, but also Nora Bridget Monaghan writes interviews Susie Miller on the novel The author and playwright of Prima Facie.

[57:05] Charles Kirsch: Yes.

[57:05] Kevin Winkler: So there are a lot of levels to the next episode.

[57:09] Charles Kirsch: I'm excited to have you experience them.

[57:11] Kevin Winkler: So remember to follow us on Instagram at Drama Book Show Podcast.

[57:15] Charles Kirsch: Please subscribe to the drama bookshop on Eventbrite so that you can be alerted when we add in-person events to our calendar.

[57:22] Kevin Winkler: And give us some likes and some uh comments and comments and stars and great stuff on Apple Podcasts and on Instagram.

[57:31] Charles Kirsch: Tell your friends.

[57:32] Kevin Winkler: Yeah.

[57:33] Charles Kirsch: I I was I recently thought that there were like tens of people listening, and then I got to see some of the analytics, and I'm like, actually, there's a good amount of people.

[57:40] Kevin Winkler: And I hey out there makes me so happy to know that people like to I did get recognized at the at the register once.

[57:46] Charles Kirsch: Me too.

[57:47] Kevin Winkler: Come say hi to us.

[57:48] Charles Kirsch: Yeah, come say hi to us.

[57:49] Kevin Winkler: Tell us, you know, tell us you like the podcast.

[57:51] Charles Kirsch: Yeah.

[57:52] Kevin Winkler: Because yeah.

[57:53] Charles Kirsch: Because all the books we talk about can be found here at the drama bookshop.

[57:58] Kevin Winkler: And so can we.

[57:59] Charles Kirsch: And we will see you at the bookshop.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred