On this week’s episode, Rob, Jennifer, and Jamie talk to Broadway casting director, Tara Rubin. For over thirty years, Tara has been casting Broadway shows like The Phantom of the Opera, Cats, Jersey Boys, Dear Evan Hansen, and this season’s hit Ain’t To Proud: The Life and Times of the Temptations... Read More
From the show: The Fabulous Invalid
Guests
Featured Shows
About
On this week’s episode, Rob, Jennifer, and Jamie talk to Broadway casting director, Tara Rubin. For over thirty years, Tara has been casting Broadway shows like The Phantom of the Opera, Cats, Jersey Boys, Dear Evan Hansen, and this season’s hit Ain’t To Proud: The Life and Times of the Temptations. We talk to Tara about how she got her start, what it’s like working on The Phantom of the Opera for so many years, and what makes a good audition. A little bit later, Rob gives us a closer look into the Casting Society of America (the “C.S.A.” you often see after a casting director’s name). This week’s music: “Putting It Together" from Sunday in the Park with George, “Opening, I Hope I Get It” from A Chorus Line, “Think of Me” from The Phantom of the Opera, “The Theme from Another World” by Crystal Gayle and Garry Morris and “A Beat Behind” from The Goodbye Girl.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jamie DuMont: I'm Jamie DuMont.
[0:01] Jennifer Samard: I'm Jennifer Samard.
[0:02] Rob Russo: I'm Rob Russo, and this is The Fabulous Invalid.
[0:19] Jamie DuMont: Hi Rob.
[0:20] Jennifer Samard: Hi Jennifer.
[0:21] Rob Russo: Hi.
[0:21] Jamie DuMont: Hi.
[0:22] Rob Russo: Love the snacks today, the cucumber sandwiches.
[0:25] Jennifer Samard: It's tea time.
[0:26] Rob Russo: It's tea time.
[0:26] Jamie DuMont: And scones, or as we know, they're called Fat Bastards the way I'm...
[0:30] Rob Russo: I still can't believe that's what they're really called.
[0:31] Jennifer Samard: Google it.
[0:32] Rob Russo: Fat Bastard.
[0:33] Jamie DuMont: I don't believe you.
[0:34] Rob Russo: It's like a it's like a or they're called rock cakes.
[0:34] Jennifer Samard: Rock cakes.
[0:38] Rob Russo: And what's the quiche?
[0:39] Jamie DuMont: What is the uh oh it's just a bunch of shit in the quiche.
[0:44] Rob Russo: It's shit quiche.
[0:45] Jamie DuMont: It's a shit quiche.
[0:46] Jamie DuMont: It's literally all the vegetables from dinner last night thrown into asparagus and potatoes.
[0:55] Rob Russo: Well, that's sort of why I made it.
[0:57] Jamie DuMont: Because we were chatting, and you said you love a quiche.
[1:00] Rob Russo: And you know, I always struggle with vegetarian requirements, Rob Russo.
[1:06] Jamie DuMont: You shouldn't.
[1:06] Rob Russo: And no, I know. You're actually, I have to say, of all my vegetarian friends, and this is a dig at someone specific who's listening. You are so easy.
[1:15] Jamie DuMont: Because you will, you there's no like pre-approved, you'll go any restaurant. You're willing to eat. You and you also like you don't mind the little bone broth in your soup.
[1:24] Rob Russo: It doesn't kill you, right? Like you don't seek it out.
[1:27] Jamie DuMont: But yeah. So you're you're you're very easy as a vegetarian.
[1:31] Jamie DuMont: And Jennifer, you're just a delight.
[1:33] Jennifer Samard: Oh.
[1:33] Jamie DuMont: But you're not a vegetarian.
[1:35] Jennifer Samard: No.
[1:36] Rob Russo: No.
[1:36] Jennifer Samard: No, I'm not.
[1:37] Jamie DuMont: I feel like we've eaten meat together.
[1:38] Rob Russo: All that that doesn't come out quite right.
[1:41] Jamie DuMont: I mean, our husband's listening.
[1:44] Jennifer Samard: Oh, I'm sorry, Brad.
[1:47] Rob Russo: Sorry, right.
[1:47] Jamie DuMont: Oh, can I say his name? Is that all right?
[1:49] Jennifer Samard: Yeah.
[1:49] Jamie DuMont: All right. It's fine. Your husband's very sweet.
[1:52] Jennifer Samard: Thank you very much.
[1:52] Jamie DuMont: He is.
[1:53] Jennifer Samard: Yeah, it was so nice to meet him at Oklahoma.
[1:55] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:56] Rob Russo: That was fun. We did that a week ago.
[1:58] Jamie DuMont: And he came to the case. Well, I don't know. By the time this comes out, I guess several weeks, two weeks.
[2:02] Jamie DuMont: He gave us a really great nugget. I don't know if if you guys recall this conversation, but um Jackie Hoffman tweeted the other day. Do you think they throw away the corn that they rip up in Oklahoma?
[2:13] Rob Russo: And I had the answer because your husband told us that they the cast, you know, the casting crew take it home and they've been swapping recipes on what to do with all the corn.
[2:21] Jennifer Samard: Right.
[2:21] Rob Russo: Well, we couldn't get an answer out of Mary Testa. She didn't quite know.
[2:23] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[2:24] Rob Russo: She assumed they threw away everything.
[2:27] Jamie DuMont: We didn't talk about the corn with the big thing.
[2:28] Rob Russo: No, we talked about the cornbread.
[2:29] Jamie DuMont: We talked about the like the mix and all that stuff.
[2:32] Rob Russo: She did say they reused the jiffy boxes.
[2:34] Jamie DuMont: Oh, okay. I think I always hate waste, you know. So it's nice to know that it's people are being thoughtful about these things.
[2:41] Jamie DuMont: I did pay particular attention to how she cracked her eggs.
[2:44] Rob Russo: Based off our conversation.
[2:45] Jamie DuMont: Right, Aaron.
[2:46] Rob Russo: I did too.
[2:47] Jamie DuMont: Me three. I actually look at now how I crack an egg.
[2:51] Rob Russo: I tried the Mary Testa way, which is two cracks, but it doesn't work for me.
[2:54] Jamie DuMont: I so rarely crack an egg.
[2:56] Rob Russo: Well, I mean, there's time.
[2:58] Jamie DuMont: You're young, Rob.
[2:59] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[3:00] Jamie DuMont: We can get you a kraken.
[3:02] Rob Russo: Oh, did there that?
[3:04] Jamie DuMont: All right. So what's going on? What do we want to talk about?
[3:05] Rob Russo: Well, I um was so delighted this past weekend. Well, I guess by the time this airs, it won't be this past weekend, but um, to receive uh New York Times magazine, the style magazine, uh, this week was titled America 2024.
[3:21] Jamie DuMont: And what they did is they commissioned 15 playwrights to each write a 10-minute play about what was set in the world in 2024, so five years from now.
[3:31] Rob Russo: Um, and it's a really I I brought it here, if you want to page through it. It's a really, really cool um magazine, because it contains the text of these plays, but also they have a digital component where they got a lot of really wonderful actors, you know, people like David Hyde Pierce.
[3:35] Jamie DuMont: Like David Hyde Pierce and Nathan Lane and John Lithgoe to do videos, uh basically readings of the plays that you can find on the New York Times website.
[3:58] Rob Russo: And it just, I don't know. I I I've been I've been so struck by the very prompt of it. Um because you know, we we have historically and do in the present look to the theater to imagine the future.
[4:12] Jamie DuMont: Um and that's really what what the prompt was. And if you read some of the plays, I mean they're mostly dark, I think, which is a reflection of the case.
[4:20] Rob Russo: Well, we live in a dark time.
[4:22] Jamie DuMont: Right. And that's you know, that's part of the the civic function that the theater has always served. Uh tip of the hat to the New York Times for assembling 15 amazing American playwrights and giving them this platform to think about the future, which is something that we as a society don't do enough of.
[4:38] Rob Russo: No, not at all. Can you imagine if we thought about the future, we wouldn't maybe be in this situation where we're we wouldn't be in the present, would we?
[4:43] Jamie DuMont: Well, I'm glad you brought this in and brought this up, and I'm sure someone had to cast these people in the show.
[4:49] Rob Russo: And luckily we're gonna talk to someone who can help us out about that topic.
[4:56] Jamie DuMont: Shall we talk to Tara Rubin?
[4:57] Rob Russo: Let's do it.
[4:57] Jamie DuMont: Please.
[4:58] Rob Russo: Great. Finish your cookie here.
[5:00] Jamie DuMont: What cookie?
[5:01] Rob Russo: Oh, yeah. I mean, sorry.
[5:02] Jamie DuMont: There are cookies.
[5:06] Rob Russo: No, I'm never making cookies again after the last time I gave them all away.
[5:10] Jamie DuMont: Well, that's the wrong answer to that problem.
[5:12] Rob Russo: Yeah, that's it. I gave a cute boy the cook all the cookies, and I got yelled at by these two.
[5:16] Jamie DuMont: I gave it literally all the cookies.
[5:19] Rob Russo: Well, I thought I okay, in my defense, I thought everyone had had cookies already. I didn't realize that nobody had had a cookie.
[5:26] Jamie DuMont: Jamie DuMont giving away his cookies.
[5:28] Rob Russo: Giving giving my cookies to a cute boy. It's the story of my life.
[5:38] Jamie DuMont: Today we are thrilled to welcome casting director Tara Rubin.
[5:42] Tara Rubin: Thank you for having me.
[5:42] Jamie DuMont: She began her career with the legendary casting office, Johnson Liff Associates, working on such shows as Phantom of the Opera, Cats, and Sunset Boulevard.
[5:49] Tara Rubin: For over 18 years, her own company, Tara Rubin Casting, has become a powerhouse on Broadway, casting over 50 shows like Jersey Boys, Aladdin, School of Rock, Dear Evan Hansen, and this season's Smash Hit Ain't Too Proud.
[6:02] Jamie DuMont: Welcome, Tara. Thank you for coming today.
[6:05] Tara Rubin: Thanks for having me.
[6:05] Jamie DuMont: Welcome. I hope we got all the shows right. There were so many. What are your favorites?
[6:13] Tara Rubin: Oh gosh. Um, well, my current I my current favorite is Ain't Too Proud, of course, because it just opened and it's enjoying some success. And um, I love that company. Those actors are all very dear to me and dear to all of us at our office.
[6:29] Tara Rubin: So and Dez, of course, has been a wonderful loyal collaborator all these years. So I've been really lucky to work with him. And um then to have, you know, a book by Dominique Moriso, and you know, and and you're doing a musical, it's sort of like we hit the jackpot. It doesn't get any better than that.
[6:47] Jamie DuMont: And it sounds so good.
[6:49] Tara Rubin: It really does.
[6:49] Rob Russo: We were we had John Miller in here a little while ago, and uh it's just it it might be the best sounding show on Broadway.
[6:58] Tara Rubin: It's really extraordinary. I'm so happy for Derek Baskin.
[7:01] Jamie DuMont: Oh I know him from Spelling Bee. Such a dream.
[7:03] Tara Rubin: What a voice. What a human being. Really, truly. And all of those men are just, they're they're kind of, you know, ready to take over as leaders of our of our industry and of our of their profession. You know, they're they're all really uh they have that great combination of being really modern and forward thinking, and then like have a great respect for everything that came before them, you know, in a way when you when you read their interviews and stuff.
[7:32] Tara Rubin: So I I have really enjoyed seeing their success.
[7:35] Jamie DuMont: Well, and I apologize for asking you to choose your favorite child because I have a fair question.
[7:40] Tara Rubin: Yes, as a mother of two, I I um I wouldn't really normally even answer that question. But and then, you know, last season we had the band's visit, and that was also a great, great, you know, experience to be a part of that, uh, you know, from its early days at Atlantic Theater Company to the you know surprise response it had. I mean, not that I was surprised, but you know, it was such a special piece.
[8:05] Tara Rubin: So I I'm very happy that these last two years that we were able to be involved in two shows that have been that were so unique and and special.
[8:16] Jamie DuMont: Very, very special shows. Um so I thought we'd start. I wanted to read, I I spoke to sort of a cross section of people that work in the theater about what they think a casting director's role is.
[8:28] Rob Russo: So I thought I'd read a couple of them to you and see if they track or what what you think of that.
[8:33] Tara Rubin: So I spoke to a publicist, not my husband, um, and he said, I think of a casting director kind of like a real estate agent. You tell them what you're looking for, and then they find the very best available offerings that meet your criteria.
[8:48] Tara Rubin: Does that sound it's part of what we do?
[8:51] Jamie DuMont: Part of what you do.
[8:52] Tara Rubin: Okay, let me let me read it. And that's for that part of what we do, that's a very, very good description, especially the part about the best available offerings. Um, so yes, that is definitely an aspect of our profession.
[9:08] Jamie DuMont: Okay, well, we're gonna get into what you actually do a little bit in just a second. But then I spoke to somebody else, uh, a producer, and they said a casting director is an entertainment professional who scouts screens and curates talent for specific roles to present to producers and creatives.
[9:23] Tara Rubin: And then I spoke to one other person, and I think they just they they wrote something very long, and I'll tell you who it is later because they love you dearly. But what they did say is that I thought was really interesting is that a good casting director finds ways to keep the room fresh so actors seen late in the day are not disadvantaged by the wandering creative teams.
[9:45] Tara Rubin: That's very good. I thought that yes, that's a very um uh specific kind kind of point of view about what we do, and and um it seems like that's come from someone who has been in an audition room and and understands how energies can flag or the the general temper in the room can begin to change.
[10:08] Jamie DuMont: And so that person seems like definitely a person who has been or understands what the casting room is like, I think.
[10:17] Tara Rubin: Absolutely. They also said that one of your great talents was that you're actually an incredible actor, and so that you elevate an actor when you read with them.
[10:26] Tara Rubin: Oh gosh. I always refer to myself as being like the least successful actor I've ever met. So that's very I'm chuffed by that as they say.
[10:35] Jamie DuMont: But well, it was Rick Ellis.
[10:39] Tara Rubin: That's actually the perfect transition because um, you know, my my first question is: how did you come to be a casting director? It's not something that I think a lot of kids, you know, dream of as kids, or that there was necessarily, you know, a lot of programs out there to train a casting director.
[10:39] Tara Rubin: How did you come to this profession?
[10:57] Tara Rubin: That's really true. And that's something I think that uh our professional organization is trying to address, the casting society of America. We've been trying to uh promote what we do to young people and speak to panels and try to help young people understand that this is a full-fledged profession, and that you can, you know, something that if you love the theater, this is a job that might be right for you.
[11:23] Tara Rubin: I think a lot of people, and and I was one of those people when I was trying to be an actress, and I kind of can't help but put it in quotes when I say that, because when I see like how talented Jennifer Samard is and everybody else I've met in my career, the idea that I ever thought I could call myself an actor is a little bit absurd.
[11:42] Tara Rubin: But anyway, um, you know, I think a lot of people are attracted to the theater, and so they think, oh, well, I need to write plays or I need to direct plays or I need to design them or I need to act in them.
[11:54] Tara Rubin: And of course, the that the function within all of those that that people know the most about or think they know the most about is acting. So you think, oh, I love the theater, so I want to be an actor, so I will become an actor.
[12:07] Tara Rubin: And then for me, the minute I had the the least bit of an opportunity to be in the theater doing something else, it was like a great weight had been lifted. You know, suddenly I was in the place where I should be, and that happened to be a producer's office, and they were we were producing the play execution of Justice, which was being cast by Johnson Liff.
[12:34] Tara Rubin: So after the play opened, and it was a critical success, but a financial failure, or not a commercial success, I guess is a better way to put it, a more positive way to put it.
[12:45] Tara Rubin: Um, I went to work for them and I stayed there for 15 years. So I I very quickly saw that I had and found that I was in in my place.
[13:00] Tara Rubin: I mean, I did casting while I was an assistant, but back then it was ever the roles were less defined, you know. I would go off and cast something, and then I'd come back and do the expenses and file photos and be like, don't have to cast today. This is you know, this is a break, and then I'd go do some more casting or associate on something.
[13:20] Tara Rubin: So it was a it was a little less defined in those days. But I you know that's when I first met you with the late great Vinny.
[13:27] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[13:28] Tara Rubin: So over the years you have seen thousands of people audition at this point, right? I mean, um, what what do you think makes a good audition?
[13:38] Tara Rubin: Um, well, preparation, I always say, I mean, you know, the more prepared you are, the the more able you are to deal with the flagging energy, energy in the room, the fact that you're maybe not feeling your 100% best that day, whatever Jennifer could probably give us a better list of like the things that might happen that and you could maybe you agree or don't agree, but the more prepared you are.
[14:05] Jennifer Samard: 100%.
[14:06] Tara Rubin: That's number one.
[14:07] Jennifer Samard: Yeah, I do agree with you. That the more, which is hard when you do get an inevitable last four hour or 48-hour notice audition. But the more you can be off the page while still holding the page, if the better.
[14:22] Tara Rubin: So and also, and yet not be married to it for when you get feedback from the director so that you can adjust. But you uh I'm I digress a little bit. You're also one of the most kind casting directors.
[14:35] Tara Rubin: Thank you so one it's true, and I've told you that, or when I've had to cancel because of illness, or you never felt made me feel punished. But um it's preparedness, I guess I agree with you. And um, and truly as an actor, you can't underestimate what it's like when you have a warm room, which is why I bring up your kindness.
[14:52] Tara Rubin: Well, it just fosters creativity as opposed to an authoritarian environment, which quelches it.
[14:59] Tara Rubin: It's quite a word. Did I think it's um I thank you for saying that, but you know, I I I did kind of learn that from Vinny and from Jeff, and so I always say it's like saying, you know, my husband's great, he doesn't beat me, you know. It's like to do less than that would not be it just wouldn't be right, and you can only uh try to make like you think about what an actor does every day to for as part of his life, part of his profession, her profession. And you think the least we can do is be open and receptive and kind or warm, whatever you want to call it, while that person is in the room. It just seems like anything less well, maybe I don't know, but anyway, that's that's that's the the it's it's um it's like a circuit of energy, isn't it?
Because we're getting that from you, and you're getting, I hope, getting that from us too. So that you know, that's the most creative environment you'd want to be in, right? Sorry, Angela. Um, as far as the lull in the room, I've always found it's the right the appointment right after lunch is a little tough. Everyone is a little sleepy sloopy Ken. I think that's true of everything, right? I mean, remember back to school, you always had science or math right after lunch, and it was a struggle. So yeah. Um well, do you agree with the old saw that uh 90% of directing is casting? Oh, that was um, I think Mike Nichols, wasn't it? Yeah. Um to a certain extent, I would love to think that that is true, obviously.
Um elevates, you know, what I do to a certain extent. And and yes, there are times when someone is just so perfectly cast that you do begin to think, like, I wonder what they're gonna do for four weeks in that rehearsal room. Like, you know, how can it possibly the the audition just seems so deep and complete and detailed, and you think, wonder what they're gonna do together? But um I know there's always something. Um but there's also you know, so much of casting isn't just the kind of casting that Mike Nichols did. So much of it is finding that person who can dance and do triple pirouettes and sing a high C and cover a principal part. Who am I anyway? Am I my resume? That is a picture of a person I don't know.
What does he want from me? What should I try to be? So then we faces all around. And here we go. I need this job. Oh God, I need this show. Yes, that is 90% of it. But then the other aspects, replacement casting and ensemble casting, I think there's a little bit more to it, you know. That's where a director comes in to say, that's where a director has to take that leap of faith and say, okay, I think I think he can understudy this part or she can understudy this part. And I think that by observing and being in the show, and you know, by working with us, well, you know, that's where a director, I think, really um is challenged. When you're putting together an ensemble or or a group of people, how much of it do you think about individual personalities in terms of shaping that cast?
Does that come into it at all? Or is it all talent-driven? Do you mean like someone that will work well with others? Correct, right, right. So outside of the star casting and the principles, and you know, this person is particularly right for this role, when you're looking at the ensemble or the whole group, does do you look at individual personalities and work ethics, or does that is that not part of the decision-making process when you bring people in? It's a really good question, and um it's something that I think people would be surprised to um to know about, would you know, the the way in which uh your work ethic and your reputation can follow you. And the interesting thing about it from my point of view is that directors are usually pretty forgiving because they have that four or five weeks in the in the rehearsal room and then they have the previews and everything and they're gone.
But dance captains and stage managers who are you know in the thick of it with the company day in and day out, they are less forgiving about the person who didn't know his part or the chronic lateness or you know, chronic, you know, just not having a good work ethic. So I always encourage people to, you know, just it's like you know, you it's what you've worked for your whole life, so why would you squander the opportunity on you know not making it the most important? That's your job, so why why would you not make it the most important thing in your world during the time that you're in that company, you know, no matter what your your role is. Um but yes, that work ethic and and reputation is important.
And I do think that there are personalities, you know, some directors love well, I don't know if they love, but they enjoy challenging actors, and some prefer someone who will uh pretty much go along with what their plans are for the role. Um, you know, if something is original, some actors are better at that than others, and um someone who's gonna get pages, all of that during the process. So we I do keep that in mind. And I guess even more important is just like a general tone of a of a personality, you know, and a tone of matching those things together, the the more ineffable part, which I think when you were reading those those descriptions of what people in our business think that casting directors do, that's the thing that I don't think everybody really understands is that whole sort of the like me becoming the actor for a moment and figuring out you know that kind of uh the process of trying to understand whether or not a person is going to make this language come alive, is going to be you know make this be a denizen of the world of this play.
And the the more um the things that have more to do with emotional intelligence than than what you can write down on a piece of paper. I feel like that's what people don't get that we do. And not me, every anyone who's a good casting director is constantly sort of like in another person's head. So you're literally putting yourself in someone else's shoes for a moment and seeing it through their lens. I think so, yes. And sometimes that person's the actor, and sometimes that's Edin Mar Moses or you know, Dominic, you know, it's another, it's a writer, and sometimes it's a director. It's just um it, yeah, you're kind of constantly putting yourself aside and putting yourself into another consciousness, another set of circumstances.
That's really interesting. It's fascinating to think that you're you're putting yourself in the minds of all the other, or not all the other, but many of the other creatives. And they do they do that? It doesn't seem like it's necessarily reciprocal, right? The director does the directing, the you know, so on and so forth, but you have to put your shoes in you have to put your you have to put yourself in many other shoes in order to do what you do so beautifully. Well I think we yes and I think what we're doing is actually kind of trying to I always say you know we're there to assist their to be part of their imagination. My imagination is secondary to that imagination that that they're sort of collaborating you know they're making Edmar and David Kromer and and David Yazbeck are all making a world together and so that collaboration is going on and I have to kind of like try to get in there.
Bit by bit putting it together only with to make a work of art every moment makes a contribution every little detail plays a part having just the visions no solution everything depends on execution putting it together. Audiences and theater makers are are increasingly being more mindful about diversity in casting and not just um you know in terms of uh race or gender but you know size ability um you know there's been some really incredible you know milestones made in the last short few years of people breaking barriers in terms of diverse casting how do you incorporate that sort of mission that idea into the work that your firm does you know it's um the very first casting society of America meeting I ever went to, which I think was in like 1987, there was a presentation by about the non-traditional casting project, which was like an early movement to bring non-Caucasian, non-traditionally cast people into the casting process.
And a special room was set up at equity so that casting directors could drop in and go through files. And so I I referenced that mainly to make the point that it's something that it's an issue that casting has been really trying to be at the forefront. We have tried very hard to push diversity and inclusion. And I think because of that, you know, we've we are finally at a place where it is the center of almost every conversation that we have about casting. So I I think that you know, the world we live in and the culture that we serve is now sort of requiring us to make sure that it's always a part of our conversations. And so it's kind of for the cat from a casting director's point of view, it's kind of like okay.
It's like you know, it's let somebody else be the leader on that, you know. Like we've been pushing this for a long time and doing everything we could, doing as much as we could, I guess, probably not everything. So it I I am really relieved that you know the the pressure is on all of us to make sure that's part of everything we think about, and that in terms of stories that we're telling, in terms of the kinds of actors who are telling them, and and across the board because it is a collaboration, right? It's not, I mean, the casting director's not making the decisions. Right. It's it's the creative team, right? So you could be there with that mission and you could be presenting the people, but ultimately it is the decision of the director or the producer or the you know, the choreographer, whoever is involved.
And it's a it's a really um, you know, it's a great question because we find ourselves at the crossroads between sort of like an intellectual freedom and uh uh a mission to use your word to correct something that's been wrong for a really long time. So I have to constantly be thinking you know, I'm I I've always kind of defined my job as as serving another person's imagination, but now I actually am taking this role where I'm saying, well, I don't really care what you're imagining, or you know, it I I mean I I do care what you're imagining, of course, but like um can we think about what you're imagining and try to uh see how we can you know involve our mission in it. So and part of that's just bringing more people into the room, more device like it the the end result or the end uh decision is the director and the creative team, but the more people you bring in that might be out of the box or not traditionally cast or whatever you want to say, that can only help everybody, correct?
Yes. And you know, I think it also comes in programming. Um, when the Westport Country Playhouse decides to do in the heights and uh a lynn notage play, and get you know, as part of their season, then that gives us an opportunity to be telling stories that you know we don't traditionally think of as Westport. So, yay, Mark Lemos on that, you know, for it comes from people, all of us have to all be thinking about it all the time. Arn isn't easy, every minor detail is a major decision. Have to keep things in scale, have to hone to your vision. You work with Westport, as you mentioned. You work with Yale Rep, is that correct? And you work with a few other regional theaters. And is there a huge difference in casting for those institutions than casting on Broadway, or is it relatively a similar experience from your perspective?
Um from my perspective, I would say that casting in regional theaters is a little bit more difficult because the creative standard is the same. The desires of the creative team are the same, and yet we're asking people to leave town, leave home, especially at an age where great high quality television is you know is being made in New York right now. And so, you know, I realize that it's not a small um decision for an actor to make. I'll go away for 12 weeks and you know be away from my family or be away from my partner, or have to sublet, or you know, uh, you know, the financial considerations. So it's um it's not easy. It's really fun. You know, that's where we encounter a lot of the the new and early career voices.
Yale rep has you know, working there for over a decade has introduced us to all kinds of people that we wouldn't have met in the commercial world, and so you know, I love that part of it, but it's it's difficult.
[29:49] Tara Rubin: It's difficult to find the people you know who they want to and tell, you know, but they're telling more and more exciting stories, so hopefully we'll continue to be able to attract top people.
[29:49] Jennifer Samard: Can I like to go that well to you as a callback to what you said earlier? I did have a lot of experience before I moved to New York in more dramatic plays and Shakespearean plays, and that's actually my jam. I love that, but in New York, people know me as a comedian and the musical theater gal, so it would interest me because that's something I love to do, but most people don't know.
[30:21] Tara Rubin: But there's a Law and Order clip to your point.
[30:36] Rob Russo: So you're ready for head of gobbler somewhere?
[30:34] Tara Rubin: Hell yes! What advice would you give though to a young person or an aging actress who is interested in doing what you do for a living? Well, I would encourage them to, um, it's hard for more senior people because usually casting is something that you learn from the ground up, and so you start at an entry-level job or an internship. I'm not saying that if you're a mid-career or midlife person that you couldn't come into our world, but it's just, it's not a high-paying profession for any of us. And so, you know, especially in the theater, we lose a lot of our great casting talent to film and television where there's a union for benefits and the pay structure is higher. So I would encourage that. I would also encourage them to go to the theater as much as they can, see people, you know, see everybody they can see, and just begin to think about how all of that is put together.
[30:34] Tara Rubin: Small moments adding up to make a whole. First of all, you need a good foundation; otherwise, it's risky from the start. It takes a little cocktail conversation, but without the problem, the vision is no solution. Everything depends on execution. We are making all just putting it together.
[30:34] Rob Russo: You may have just answered part of this question a moment ago, but now that there's so much television and so much content and so many different services, Netflix, Hulu, all creating original programming, how has that world changed your world?
[30:34] Tara Rubin: It's had a big effect. Television has had a big effect on the writing; we're like in a new golden age. I think the content is so high quality. The people who we used to cast at Yale Rep are all on the HBO series now, and so it's sort of had a trickle-down effect in the sense that people who used to go to Yale Rep now can be, you know, people who used to be on Broadway now do the series regular roles. People who used to go to Yale Rep are in those series because there's so much of it, you know, we're doing major roles in all of those things.
[33:22] Tara Rubin: So it has left us being very, we have to be really, um, what can I say, like we have to include everybody in our mix, and it's exciting because we are kind of giving opportunities to people, not just saying, "Oh, can Jen Samard do it? Great, we'll have Jen do it." We have to go into casting; we have to go into the process and find really, we have to though, you could just give me if she wasn't on Broadway. It has really had an effect on my work, especially because I work pretty much exclusively in the theater.
[33:22] Rob Russo: So although you did cast Another World, correct?
[33:22] Tara Rubin: Yes, yes. Um, what is it about New York soap operas that was so attractive to cast Broadway actors? Was it just the availability? Just that they were just available and New York is just full of great actors?
[33:22] Tara Rubin: Yes, and you know, New York theater actors were accustomed to, they could learn scripts really fast, they could take pages and make them work. They were trained, they had great voices, and they had the discipline because you were basically shooting an hour-long series every day. You know, if you Wikipedia any soap opera and look at the cast list, it feels like it's 80% Broadway actors. It's really incredible here in New York.
[33:22] Rob Russo: Yeah, that was super, super fun too, to put the people from all the musicals, you know, putting them in and giving them that first television job, many of them.
[35:05] Tara Rubin: It was really fun.
[35:06] Rob Russo: I bet it was great.
[35:07] Tara Rubin: Yeah.
[35:08] Rob Russo: You take me away to the well. I have to ask about another sort of institution, The Phantom of the Opera, which I believe you've been casting for, I don't know how long, but the show's been running for 31 years now.
[35:27] Tara Rubin: 30, yeah, 31 years now.
[35:29] Rob Russo: What challenges does a long-running show like Phantom present to you as a casting director in terms of keeping it fresh or, you know, infusing the show with new talent?
[35:41] Tara Rubin: Well, with Phantom, I would say we were blessed with Hal and Jillian. Um, because they never sought to preserve it as a museum piece. They always wanted it to be a living, breathing piece of theater. And so, you know, although we haven't changed things, I have started to use the phrase that I hardly ever say is like kept up with the times. You know, I can't believe I started to say that, but that's kind of it, in the sense that, you know, the way the company sounds now is in keeping with the contemporary, you know, the way contemporary musical theater sounds.
[36:29] Tara Rubin: It doesn't sound like Rent, but it doesn't sound like John Raitt. And so I, and the fact that they understood that that would be part of the maintenance of that show on some level, um, I think has kept it fresh.
[36:51] Tara Rubin: Think of me.
[36:54] ♪ Musical number: "Think of Me" from The Phantom of the Opera — performed by Tara Rubin ♪
[37:03] Tara Rubin: Please promise me.
[37:08] Rob Russo: And I think that diversity and inclusion has been a big part of that, you know, having lots of different kinds of people playing those parts.
[37:18] Tara Rubin: And that goes back to Hal too, doesn't it, with Robert Guillaume in the 80s and the Los Angeles companies. So, you know, I, when I went to see the revival of Oklahoma at St. Anne's, um, Hal and Stephen Sondheim were there in the audience, and they were sitting together.
[37:38] Rob Russo: So I think they had come together.
[37:40] Tara Rubin: And I just thought, of course, their lovingness. That's their brilliance. Is that they're, you know, that they don't make museum pieces out of their work, that they're constantly being, you know, that their creativity is being informed by the time and place that they're living in. It's pretty, pretty cool.
[37:59] Rob Russo: I don't think there's a better example of that than Stephen Sondheim, who lets almost any production of one of his shows take a chance and do something different, which is for better or for worse, his work is always evolving, and it's fascinating.
[38:14] Tara Rubin: It doesn't always work; sometimes it's brilliant. But it's really interesting how that happens.
[38:19] Tara Rubin: That was sort of the inauguration of my company was doing that Sondheim celebration at the Kennedy Center. And you know, that he entrusted all of those pieces to young directors who were Chris Ashley, Mark Brokaw, Eric Schaeffer, Sean Matthias, you know, people who had didn't have a big background in musicals, some of them, and just, you know, unique new voices to be, you know, mouthpieces for his work.
[38:50] Rob Russo: And to your point earlier about that kid in the audition room who nails it, and the person says, "Yeah, but they don't have a lot of credits." You know, you need to take a chance on people, and you know, and look, all those directors you mentioned, look what's happened to their careers and how great they are.
[39:06] Tara Rubin: And you know, I just appreciate that.
[39:08] Rob Russo: I do too.
[39:09] Tara Rubin: I do too.
[39:10] Rob Russo: Um, we have one final question that we ask everyone, and that question is, was there a particular movie or show that gave you a love for theater?
[39:22] Tara Rubin: Well, you know, my the first musical I ever saw, or the first professional show I ever saw was The Pajama Game at the St. Louis Muni Opera. Um, a place where Jeffrey Johnson was once a stage manager, as a matter of fact.
[39:38] Tara Rubin: Um, and so, you know, I was that kid. I, it would probably have been something like seeing Bye Bye Birdie on television, because I'm from the Midwest and we didn't get to the theater a lot.
[39:51] Tara Rubin: So, um, but just, you know, we've all felt it, we've all seen it. It's like watching something, and like suddenly the line between who you are and that person on the screen gets really blurry all of a sudden, and you start to think like, "Okay, here I go, you know, down that path."
[40:12] Rob Russo: Tara, thank you so much for coming back to the house.
[40:14] Tara Rubin: Thank you for having me.
[40:15] Rob Russo: Thank you.
[40:15] Tara Rubin: You're the greatest.
[40:17] Rob Russo: I really need my understanding's God, I need my side.
[40:23] Tara Rubin: I got you.
[40:31] Rob Russo: Rob here, you may be wondering. Casting is an integral yet invisible part of live theater. It's done long before you sit down to see a show. And unless you've watched the documentary Every Little Step about the casting of the 2006 Broadway revival of A Chorus Line, it's also done out of sight.
[40:46] Rob Russo: So you may be wondering about this craft and how it has come to be an essential component of the art form. At a very basic level, every person you see on a professional stage was hired by someone as a result of some process known as casting.
[40:59] Rob Russo: Today, given the high cost of commercial production on Broadway, most stars you find above the title or on a marquee are selected at the very genesis of a production. For example, Hugh Jackman will lead the 2020 Revival of The Music Man, and the announcement of his casting was simultaneous with the announcement of the show itself.
[41:15] Rob Russo: And his casting was very likely the reason that the whole revival will exist. But The Music Man is not a one-man show. It's been announced that Sutton Foster will play Marion Peru, and I'm sure the producer and director will make other key choices.
[41:28] Rob Russo: But when it comes to filling out the balance of the cast, the production will hire a casting director, like Tara Rubin or Bernie Telsey, as examples to coordinate the presentation of actors for consideration in casting sessions or auditions.
[41:40] Rob Russo: During this pre-production phase, choosing who will be in the cast is essential business, alongside the coordination of a creative team. Casting directors don't make the decisions, but they do run the room and facilitate the process.
[41:51] Rob Russo: They also negotiate, on behalf of the production, the deals to hire the actors who are ultimately selected by a director, producer, and creative team. Like so many aspects of the entertainment industry writ large, casting has become increasingly professionalized over the years, like Tara alluded to.
[42:07] Rob Russo: While scanning the credits of a movie, have you ever wondered what CSA stands for when appended to the name of a casting director? Well, as Tara mentioned, CSA is the Casting Society of America, which was originally founded in February of 1982 as the American Society of Casting Directors.
[42:22] Rob Russo: The CSA was created to establish a recognized standard of professionalism in the casting field. Of course, Tara Rubin is a member and currently serves on the New York chapter's board of directors.
[42:33] Rob Russo: While it is not an industry union, in addition to promoting a standard of professionalism and excellence, the CSA also exists to provide its members with a support organization to further their goals and protect their common interests.
[42:44] Rob Russo: Founded in Los Angeles, today, the CSA's membership roster includes 1,000 casting professionals all around the world, working in theater, film, television, and new media. Membership is available to those who have two years of screen or stage credit as primary casting director and receive sponsorship letters from at least two current members of the CSA, though casting directors who are also personal managers are not eligible for membership.
[43:09] Rob Russo: The expertise and experience that a seasoned casting director like Tara Rubin brings to the process is invaluable in making sure that a production succeeds. In fact, when done right, it can have the impact of making you think that no one else could possibly play a given part other than the person who was selected.
[43:24] Rob Russo: That's what I mean by invisible work. Next time you see a show, take a look at who did the casting, and remember that every performance really began as an audition.
[43:39] Jennifer Samard: I am no stamina.
[43:54] Jennifer Samard: That's our show. Thanks for listening. The Fabulous Invalid is a production of OM, etcetera, and the Fabulous Invalid LLC.
[44:01] Jennifer Samard: Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Aaron Kaufman. Find us on iTunes and online at the FabulousInvalid.com and on social media at Fabulous Invalid.
[44:12] Jennifer Samard: And be sure to tune in next Wednesday.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
