Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 51: Theresa Rebeck: Let The Writing Teach You

On this week’s show, Jamie, Rob, and Jennifer chat with playwright Theresa Rebeck about her smashing new play, “Seared” at MCC Theater... Read More

From the show: The Fabulous Invalid

47 mins
11/13/19

Guests

About

On this week’s show, Jamie, Rob, and Jennifer chat with playwright Theresa Rebeck about her smashing new play, “Seared” at MCC Theater. Theresa was also the creator of the television show “Smash”, and is the award winning playwright of “Mauritius”, “Bernhardt / Hamlet”, “Seminar”, and “Dead Accounts” on Broadway, and “Omnium Gatherum”, “A View of the Dome” Off-Broadway. We discuss all things food, the challenges of cooking on stage, the secrets of mac & cheese and butter, and get some insight into her writing process. A bit later, Rob gives a look into other shows that feature cooking on stage.

This week’s music: “Overture” from “Company, 2018 London Cast Recording”, and “Food Glorious Food”, from “Oliver!, 1994 London Palladium Cast Recording”.

Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid

Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid

Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc

Email us at: info@fabulousinvalid.com

Jamie Du Mont

Twitter: @jamiedumont

Instagram: @troutinnyc

Rob Russo

Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC

Jennifer Simard

Twitter: @SimardJennifer

Instagram: @thejennifersimard

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Theresa Rebeck: I'm Theresa Rebeck, and this is the Fabulous Invalid.

[0:13] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, a Broadway-centric podcast where we take an in-depth look at the theater through interviews with actors, writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.

[0:22] Jamie DuMont: I'm Jamie DuMont, recovering Broadway marketer, personal chef, and event planner.

[0:26] Rob Russo: I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with staged left.nyc.

[0:30] Jennifer Simard: And I'm Jennifer Simard, currently appearing on Broadway in Mean Girls.

[0:34] Jamie DuMont: Hi, Jennifer.

[0:35] Rob Russo: Hi, Rob.

[0:36] Jennifer Simard: Hi.

[0:37] Jamie DuMont: Hi.

[0:38] Rob Russo: Well, um, we have a fun show today.

[0:41] Jamie DuMont: We do.

[0:42] Rob Russo: In a little bit, we're gonna be joined by Theresa Rebeck, the playwright of Seared, currently at MCC Theater.

[0:49] Jamie DuMont: And uh, that's a play I'm very excited about.

[0:52] Rob Russo: Yes, yes.

[0:53] Jamie DuMont: Rob and I happened to catch a performance uh last week, and it is really, really terrific.

[0:57] Rob Russo: We were on the edge of our seats.

[0:58] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, it's great.

[0:59] Rob Russo: Hold on.

[1:00] Jamie DuMont: Looking forward to it.

[1:01] Rob Russo: And if you don't know, I mean Theresa Rebeck has had an incredible career writing for the stage, uh, but also on TV and in film.

[1:10] Jamie DuMont: So she's uh a writer with many hats, and we look forward to chatting with her about all those hats.

[1:16] Rob Russo: And in this particular case, she has a chef hat on.

[1:18] Jamie DuMont: That's right.

[1:19] Rob Russo: Oh, Jamie.

[1:20] Jamie DuMont: Look at you.

[1:21] Rob Russo: Look at me.

[1:23] Jamie DuMont: Well, we can't let uh this moment pass without acknowledging the fact that we are back in the pink room with Jennifer Simard.

[1:29] Jennifer Simard: Hey!

[1:30] Rob Russo: Missia.

[1:31] Jamie DuMont: And um, Jennifer, as we announced in our last episode, not that we broke the news, but um, has been cast in the uh upcoming revival of Company on Broadway.

[1:41] Jennifer Simard: I know, I'm so excited.

[1:42] Jamie DuMont: Yay!

[1:43] Rob Russo: So we just want to congratulate you, John.

[1:45] Jennifer Simard: Oh, thank you.

[1:46] Jamie DuMont: Yay!

[1:46] Jennifer Simard: I know it wasn't even on my radar.

[1:48] Jennifer Simard: I didn't, it, you know, that isn't that the way life works.

[1:51] Jennifer Simard: You're just kind of going along doing your thing, and then the opportunity comes up, you're like, well, I just want to give a good audition, and then all of a sudden, oh my goodness, it's happening.

[2:00] Rob Russo: So I just, yeah.

[2:01] Jennifer Simard: Apparently you did give a good audition.

[2:03] Rob Russo: Well, I think it was, you know, I think I even saw I saw you because you came to see Mean Girls and check out Renee Rap.

[2:10] Jennifer Simard: And this was before my um, this was between my initial audition and my callback.

[2:16] Jennifer Simard: And I I let you know, I was very quiet about the whole thing, and I did let you know that I was auditioning.

[2:21] Jennifer Simard: And I think I told you at the time that you really have to have an attitude of um just do your work as the actor, um uh the artist, whatever you want to call yourself, just give your interpretation of how you see the role, and it either resonates with them or it doesn't, or if it's what they're looking for or it isn't, and you can't really worry about whether or not you're gonna get it because it's all a puzzle and puzzle pieces, and that's that and I remember I had a very zen outlook about it.

[2:45] Rob Russo: Yes, I know.

[2:46] Jennifer Simard: You commented on Robert's like I think I said if it's meant to be, it'll be, and if it's not, it's not.

[2:50] Rob Russo: Well, I feel very lucky, and I'm sad to leave Mean Girls.

[2:53] Jennifer Simard: You know, those kinds of jobs don't come around very often, if ever, and I have a respect for every job I'm lucky enough to get.

[3:00] Jennifer Simard: And you know, when it rains, it pours, and so I hope when I'm I hope when the day comes when I don't have work that I won't be out of work long because uh, you know, it's just it's a really great opportunity.

[3:12] Rob Russo: Uh, so gotta keep swimming.

[3:13] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, you're never out of work.

[3:15] Rob Russo: Just keep just keep entertaining us, please.

[3:18] Jennifer Simard: I love it.

[3:18] Jennifer Simard: It's what I've always wanted to do.

[3:20] Jennifer Simard: It truly is.

[3:21] Jennifer Simard: So I'm really we're all on a clock, right?

[3:24] Jennifer Simard: So I I really want to appreciate while I have it.

[3:26] Jennifer Simard: I'm really grateful.

[3:27] Jennifer Simard: I'm excited to work with this creative team.

[3:29] Jennifer Simard: Marianne Elliott is a brilliant director, and I'm really was very fond of her at my audition.

[3:34] Jennifer Simard: And um, I think her process is gonna be one that I'm really excited to be a part of.

[3:39] Jennifer Simard: And we're opening on Sondheim's birthday, which is 90th birthday.

[3:42] Jamie DuMont: Pretty much really really exciting.

[3:44] Rob Russo: Pretty great.

[3:44] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.

[3:45] Rob Russo: There's a lot of stars aligning.

[3:46] Jamie DuMont: And you pointed out um that it's the 50th anniversary of Company, which is something I didn't even think about.

[3:51] Rob Russo: Yes, yes.

[3:52] Jamie DuMont: Which is an amazing timing.

[3:53] Jennifer Simard: Yeah.

[3:54] Jennifer Simard: And I'll and I think I because I'm not shy about myself in that regard.

[3:57] Jennifer Simard: I'm gonna it opens, we're opening it the same year that I turned 50.

[4:01] Jennifer Simard: So it's kind of for me, it's kind of full circle.

[4:05] Jennifer Simard: I'm like, am I gonna die soon?

[4:06] Jennifer Simard: Like it feels it feels very took a dark turn pretty quickly.

[4:10] Rob Russo: Do you know what I mean?

[4:11] Jennifer Simard: You're like, I do feel like I remember watching the Tony Awards when Michael Crawford won for Phantom.

[4:17] Jennifer Simard: And he said he's like, due to the law of averages, I'm due to be, or based on the law of averages, I'm due to be hit by a truck any day now.

[4:23] Jennifer Simard: Like that's what it feels like a little bit.

[4:25] Rob Russo: It's just lucky, lucky.

[4:26] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, it's almost harder to handle success sometimes than the struggle because we all know how to get along when we're struggling, but and so I'm really just trying to let myself respectfully and humbly enjoy it too.

[4:38] Jamie DuMont: You know, is that safe? Is that fair to say?

[4:40] Jennifer Simard: It's hard, it's hard sometimes.

[4:42] Rob Russo: Well, we are going to enjoy you enjoying it.

[4:43] Jamie DuMont: Yes.

[4:44] Rob Russo: Okay.

[4:45] Jamie DuMont: Well, let's get to our guest.

[4:47] Rob Russo: Let's do it.

[4:53] Jamie DuMont: Today we are delighted to be joined by Theresa Rebeck, the author of Seared, currently at MCC.

[4:59] Theresa Rebeck: Thank you so much for coming down.

[5:01] Theresa Rebeck: Oh, thank you for having me.

[5:02] Theresa Rebeck: I think my my co-host might have mentioned this while I was out of the room, but um, I spent about a decade as a professional chef in New York City.

[5:10] Rob Russo: It may have flown out of someone's mouth.

[5:12] Theresa Rebeck: Yes.

[5:12] Theresa Rebeck: Yes.

[5:13] Theresa Rebeck: And in fact, they were urging me to try your your macaroni and cheese, which I'm trying to stay away from because you know, it's the holidays and and I don't want to be involved too indulgent, but I do need to know what your secret ingredient is.

[5:26] Theresa Rebeck: Do you have a secret ingredient?

[5:27] Theresa Rebeck: I well, it's not a secret ingredient because I use onions, which are typically in mac and cheese. I I every it sounds fantastic. Everybody does it differently. Like most classically, you grate the onions into the into the roux, which is the flour in the water, the flour and the butter mixture. Um what I do is I caramelize the onions first, and then I put them in so it gives a little bit more, as they say, depth of flavor.

[5:53] Jamie DuMont: That sounds really good.

[5:55] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah. Well, it's uh it's a well, and Theresa, I made mac and cheese, obviously, because it's a reference to your play.

[6:02] Theresa Rebeck: Yes, I think I'm gonna break my rule and taste macaroni and cheese.

[6:06] Jamie DuMont: Good.

[6:06] Theresa Rebeck: Well, there's well, Theresa, what's your secret ingredient?

[6:08] Theresa Rebeck: Oh, mine's boring compared to that, but it's dry mustard.

[6:12] Jamie DuMont: Oh, okay.

[6:13] Theresa Rebeck: Oh, wow.

[6:15] Theresa Rebeck: Yes, I'll have to send you some. It's very, very it's kind of adult mac and cheese. You put a little, you have to grate a little black pepper and put dry mustard in it. And then there's also a little bit of like uh hot sauce in it. So it's but you have to be really careful with it. Because if you go a little, like if you go a little too lively, the kids won't eat it. The adults love it, and the kids are like my secret ingredient is selfishness and powdered cheese, because I get Kraft macaroni and cheese in a box, and it's my box. No one's getting part of my box.

[6:45] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I just rip open that powder.

[6:49] Rob Russo: I think this is where someone says, you do you.

[6:51] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah, well, it is a great, you know. I I don't know anyone that doesn't love mac and cheese, but it is truly the great leveler.

[6:59] Rob Russo: Yeah.

[7:00] Theresa Rebeck: So Theresa, I'm getting the sense that you know your way around a kitchen too.

[7:03] Theresa Rebeck: Well, you know, I'm not actually all that good in a kitchen. My my mac and cheese is good, and I I do about eight things well. My husband is a really beautiful chef, and he knows how to do all sorts of crazy things. And that was what I hear him talking about and listen to while I'm watching him cook. A lot of that made it into the play. Um and was sort of the one of the sources of uh knowing that, you know, I I'm I'm always interested in passion, you know, like what really puts a person like kind of across the line into another universe, and my husband has a real passion for cooking, and I found it interesting. You know, I I still find it interesting. I love watching Raul do it.

[7:41] Rob Russo: What do you find fascinating about cooking?

[7:44] Theresa Rebeck: Um, well, I'm actually a person aside from the eight things that I can cook, I I generally am just like, I'll eat anything and I don't think about it, but there's something uh ritualistic about uh people who love to cook. There's a real uh life that life slows down. Um they have a lot of, they have a kind of there seems to be a another world going on in their head that I don't participate in, uh, except for like on when I make these five or six things. And uh it seems uh mysterious to me and kind of magical. And then it turns into a meal, which is something that gets offered to everyone to kind of participate in.

[8:31] Jamie DuMont: It's also something that this is something I've just noticed because I'm you know, sometimes I I do like Theresa's study languages because I'm sort of fascinated. And it's one of the first things you learn about. Like any language you learn, the first words they teach you are like breakfast, lunch, today.

[8:48] Rob Russo: Right.

[8:48] Jamie DuMont: Like, can I have more water? You know, like it's all about I don't know. There's something, it's so uh like the center of life in a lot of ways.

[8:57] Theresa Rebeck: Absolutely.

[8:58] Jamie DuMont: So for those um of our listeners who haven't seen the play or or don't know what it's about, um, plot wise, could you give us a short overview of you know, sort of what happens in the play, so our listeners can, you know, yeah, more of a hook.

[9:11] Theresa Rebeck: Sure. Um, it's a play about uh it's actually uh a play about two guys who um uh decide have decided in the past to start a restaurant together, and they've been running this restaurant together for a couple of years, and they're really at the end of their survival uh abilities. Um one of them, Mike has put all his money into the restaurant and is it can't and has not been able to stabilize the finances of it. The other one is Harry, who's the chef, and he's a brilliant chef, and um he's one of those people who everything has to be kind of the way he likes it for him to do what he needs to do. He's a little bit of a, you know, he's not a perfect person by any means. Um, and they are um at the end of their their last nerves uh around the survival issue when uh someone comes in from uh New York magazine and gives them a pop in the best bets column for Harry's scallops, and so they they finally have caught a break, and people are starting to the crowds are starting to come to have the scallops, and um Harry decides he can't cook them anymore. And so it's all sorts of chaos ensues as they try to wrangle survival out of this moment of luck.

[10:30] Rob Russo: And I understand that all the food in the show is real, right? And just fun questions. What, you know, does it get dumped? You know, does it get eaten? Does it who does the shopping? Who does the cooking?

[10:39] Theresa Rebeck: Um it does not get dumped, it gets fed to people.

[10:42] Rob Russo: Okay.

[10:43] Theresa Rebeck: Um, it gets fed to uh stage hands. I think everybody in the theater who is working for much less money than they could make in any other field gets this really pretty delicious food.

[10:54] Rob Russo: Right.

[10:55] Theresa Rebeck: I love it.

[10:55] Rob Russo: So Raoul had to train then too.

[11:00] Theresa Rebeck: He had chops to begin with. He's somebody who knows his way around the kitchen.

[11:04] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah. Um, and he but he he worked with his chef, Ben Lippmann, who um is a really fantastic guy who used to work in a lot of different kitchens and then went on to doing uh um like private chef work, you know. He's you know, he cooked for Robert De Niro for a while. We were all like, what's he like? And he wouldn't tell us.

[11:25] Theresa Rebeck: Um days, you know.

[11:27] Rob Russo: Yeah, right.

[11:28] Theresa Rebeck: Uh and uh and now he consults, you know. Now he'll go into people's houses and say, This is what you should be, this is how you do this.

[11:40] Theresa Rebeck: And he taught Raul a lot of stuff. And Raul is very much, uh, you know, it's thrilling to work with that guy in every way. Um, and he's a perfectionist. Um, and he really wanted to do absolutely everything, uh, you know, because there is a way at one point somebody said to me, "What about how are like normal people gonna do this play?" And I'm like, you don't actually have to make everything. That's Raul. Um, and because it's part of his musical, um, his being is very, very musical. And so the truth of the sound of the performance got tied into the truth of the food.

[12:17] Jennifer Simard: That brings up something that I was struck with in the play, which is at the beginning of the second act, Raul prepares a dish, and you watch him pretty much soup to nuts, do the whole dish, and it's like a ballet. It's like a musical number. It's extraordinary how that whole thing comes off.

[12:38] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah, well, he's such a consummate artist. I, and I, you know, I don't say that lightly, but he, um, I, there was one point when I was watching him build and build that. We, uh, we had the recipe. I described the recipe, which was, uh, this thing about salmon with onion chutney, uh, that my husband used to make for me. And then they came up with another way of making it. Um, and then I watched them build the making of it with the music. Um, it's quite a long, it's longer than I, uh, envisioned. Um, but it also Raul not only was making it so precisely, he was moving all over the stage with like kind of like a really physical enjoyment of it. And then he would, he was working on the plate, you know, he was making sure that the plate was beautiful, which I thought I never even thought of that.

That it like in the creation of a dish, you would still be making sure that the visual of the plate itself was, um, it had the kind of perfection that the taste had and the movement had. It's right, you know, it's extraordinary. I think it is extraordinary what he does in that moment.

[13:51] Jennifer Simard: It is, and it's funny you talk about the plating of it because A, his plating skills are fantastic throughout the whole piece. But in that particular moment that you're referencing, it's so fascinating because we as an audience can't see the plate, right? Necessarily. I mean, uh, maybe some people that are a little bit closer, but the point is, which I think is what you're making, is it's exactly who he is as a character. I mean, that's that it wouldn't, the whole scene wouldn't work if he didn't fuss with the plate at the end, because that's what a chef would do. And I also, what I, the other thing, and I'm actually getting goosebumps when I talk about this, because it was a very moving moment for me.

And the thing that I think is so great, his character, I think is safe to say, is a prickly guy. Yeah, right. He's not, you know, he's probably not the most popular chef that people have ever worked with. But there's something about him that is very engaging. However, it isn't until that moment that we're talking about the top of the second act where you really fall in love with him. And it, and you really, or at least I did, you really see the artist that he is, and you really see the human being that he is, and you think, oh, he's really a complicated fella. And then the whole second act just falls into place so beautifully.

[14:58] Theresa Rebeck: Thank you. I agree. I just think he's amazing. Uh, you know, I would tell everybody, I obviously I love people to come see my play. I think it's really got something to say, but I'm like, what a privilege to work and with Raul and to have a chance to watch him do this. You know, you really do need someone capable of giving a tour de force, and he just keeps going. It just never stops.

[15:20] Jennifer Simard: Were you with him when he trained with, when he worked with a chef?

[15:24] Theresa Rebeck: I was not. You were not part of that process.

[15:26] Theresa Rebeck: No, I was there for a lot of the rehearsal where, and sometimes you'd go, okay, I gotta leave, because it was so much about when he would pick up the gnocchi, when he would do this. What you know, and there were some, luckily, not as much. There were some burned fingers and some slight, you know, that knife, that there's a moment in the play where it gets, I know it's nice, isn't it? Probably the test. I gasped. When she brings out the knives, there's a moment in the play, people, where the chef is presented with a series of excellent knives. Um, and if for those of you that don't know, a knife can cost anywhere from a hundred dollars to a thousand dollars, right? It's, it can be a very expensive, uh, endeavor to outfit a kitchen with knives, good knives.

[16:13] Jennifer Simard: Um, and I did, did I not, uh, did I did? Yeah, yeah.

[16:16] Theresa Rebeck: It's palpable.

[16:17] Jennifer Simard: Yeah.

[16:18] Theresa Rebeck: Sorry. But even I, as someone who doesn't cook and doesn't derive any joy from cooking whenever I do, um, in that moment could appreciate and understand what it would mean to him.

[16:29] Jennifer Simard: Right.

[16:30] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah. I know. Well that, you know, uh, also in, in a d I'm, I'm so happy to have an excuse just to sing that man's praises. I mean, because in addition to the grace and the complexity and the joy and the prickliness. Um, uh, there's the astonishing comic timing, you know, and, and that, that just fed into all those moments like around the knives. So when he, when he first sees them, it, uh, it really brings down the house most nights.

[17:01] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, it is. It's a little bit of a Sweeney Todd moment. There's a little bit of my friends. He's such a hard guy to calm down, and then she's like, yeah, look at this. And all of a sudden you see this, that like the knives soothe the savage beast, you know, the idea of, well, there's such truth in that moment too, right? And I think that's, that's, and, and, and I like that you, there's a, there's definitely a playfulness with all, with all four of the actors. I mean, they're all really, it really feels like you're in that kitchen. I mean, you are literally in that kitchen, but I mean, it feels like I felt like an employee of the restaurant. I really did at certain times.

[17:39] Theresa Rebeck: I'll agree. Um, and everything on the set works. So the stove works, I, I know several people said to me, oh, that's the, uh, they're like, so that's a hot plate under there. And I was like, oh no. No, that's gas. That's a gas stove. That's a gas stove.

[17:54] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, it's a gas stove and everything's working. And, and I do think that there's a way to do it that's simpler for people who aren't as obsessive compulsive as Raul is. Right. So there could be a production eventually of the, of your play where it isn't a full working kitchen, right? So that other theater companies can do it.

[18:12] Theresa Rebeck: Well, yes, absolutely. Uh, the, the one of the, you know, this is like the third production. Um, and I have a feeling that in San Francisco, we were just talking about, I'm pretty sure that they used hot plates underneath, like, and I know that's we did something similar to that up in Williamstown because of codes and stuff. So it was William, it was San Francisco, it was the Playhouse, Williamstown, and now MCC.

[18:37] Jennifer Simard: Yeah. Was the, was the, and how long, so you got the commission from the San Francisco Playhouse to write this play. And then what was that time frame like?

[18:45] Theresa Rebeck: It was very quick. It was, you know, nine months, something like that. It's, uh, it doesn't, um, and then, but then, uh, we worked on it. Uh, I, I worked on it quite a bit there, and it had a different ending there. Um, and so after that first production, I was like going, that's just not the right ending. You know what I mean? You could really, and then, um, Mandy Greenfield was interested in it and doing it in it, and she a lot of times she won't program something unless she's heard a reading of it. And so after that, we did a reading up at Williamstown where I worked on the ending. I mean, I already had a new ending, and then I kind of, uh, polished it up a bit. Uh, and then the following summer, we, which was last summer, no wait, not this past summer, the summer before that, we did a full production of it up there and I did some more work on it.

So, um, it's taken since I wrote it, it's been about three years, you know, with these moments in between where because sometimes like I'm working on a play right now, and I was just like, I gotta hear it. You know, you reach a point where you just you can't, uh, and I used to, I used to work at the LARC a lot, the LARC development playwriting place. Uh, and because you would, you could go in there like every Wednesday and go, here will you read these pages for me? And really good actors would just read 10 pages for you and you'd go, thanks, and then go home and be able to move on. But because sometimes just the fact that you, you can't, no matter what, you just you have to hear it every now and then.

Anyway, so after we did that one production, then it wasn't until I had a handful of actors a year later up at Williamstown, even though it was just a day and a half, I could do some more work there. I mean, it gets to a point where you just gotta stop writing and just wait until you have some because there's a lot of times what I end up doing is, you know, I have a page in front of me and I go, take these three words out, move this over here, you know, try this, try this, try this. And it's sort of like sculpting a little bit.

[20:46] Jennifer Simard: Do you find that you get to a point where the play is finished, or do you want to always keep working on it?

[20:51] Theresa Rebeck: Uh, you know, I, I'm not averse to just keep working on it. Um, depending on what your situation is. Um, there are certain things like I wrote this play a while ago called Oh Beautiful, which was about basically it was like 10 years ago, and it was you, you could the subtitle could have been How We Get to Where We're Going, because it was really about, uh, you know, it was about a small town in Delaware where it was a lot of it took place in a high school. And, um, you know, the people it was like the rise of the Tea Party, the rise of the bifurcation of the American character, you know, the, you know, the rise of really, you know, there was bullying, there's too much too many guns, there's a terrible accident with a gun, and there's a kind of rising rage between everybody in the play.

And I'd love to see that again. That one seems like that would, I don't know. Yeah, that one, but I like if I were to do it again, I would like go, what do I need to what else do I need to do right now to layer in these questions a little more? I mean, it was, um, you know, like here's another example. I wrote this play, Spike Heels, which was about sexual harassment in 1992. I was really young. And, um, and it was, you know, it did it, I don't know, it got kind of, it was sort of like, uh, dismissed by some of the New York critics because they were like, this could never happen. I mean, seriously, no one was interested in that question. People are looking at it now and going, we should revise it, revive this.

And I think, well, yeah, for sure. I mean, it was done all over the world, world, and a lot of students who have grown up on those monologues and things in that play. And so, but I kind of go, I wrote that 25 years ago. There were chunks of it I could write better now. And so I did take a pass at it and just made it better. You know, so there is kind of every now and then, um, there's, oh, I know what I was gonna say about Oh Beautiful, that there's a bunch of language in it, like because there's always language in my plays. It's kind of the way I talk. And there, so now it's often done in colleges. And some of the colleges are like, can we take the language out? And I'm like, well, you can take this language out, you can't take that language out.

I do think that there's like an advantage to being a living playwright and being able to look at every given situation and say, yeah, you can do that, you cannot do this because that ultimately, um, distorts the act, the play itself. But I'm not, I'm not like David Mamet or Edward Albee. God bless his soul, I loved that guy. Um, but he was real like, no, you must not touch a word and we're all like, oh come on, Edward, you know, this isn't. Anyway, you've also worked extensively in television and film, right? Where the writer has sort of a different, it has a different sort of, um, terrain I guess, right? I mean, there's more people involved, right? And you don't own your words. Uh, you know, so that and that's like, that has informed your willingness to be a little bit more, um, well open to edits to your work.

[22:57] Theresa Rebeck: For me, it's more about, uh, the kind of musicality of things which changes in different situations. You know, like if, and sometimes, you know, my friend Julie White, uh, told me one time that she had found this old script that was of, you know, some Terrence Rattigan play, I can't remember which one it was, but it was like the professional edition and she was like, does that mean there's an amateur edition out there? And sure enough, there's amateur editions of like straight plays which are like, okay if you're not really a professional actor don't try this monologue we're gonna take that monologue out that's too hard for amateurs. Um, you know, so but I it's sort of a little bit, I'm I yeah, I think it's funny too.

[24:37] Theresa Rebeck: We were we had a good laugh at that. Um, but there was a kind of there's a sense sometimes where I feel like if it's something that the no matter what straining is going on, the actor can't, you know, or there's some issue, then I don't I for me the important thing is the success of the each individual production. And sometimes that means a little bit of um being uh breathing with you with the present.

[25:04] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah. Uh so well I'm still stuck on something with spike heels. So I just want to go back for a second. Because you said um, and I may get your words incorrect, but you said something about you want to make the play better, right? You think you can make the play better. And is that because you think you're a better writer now, or because the dialogue around sexual harassment has changed so much?

[25:28] Theresa Rebeck: It's thanks that's a very elegant question, and it's actually both things. Uh I mean, because now there's a kind of different, there are different questions that are showing up in this discussion, uh, some of which I'm intrigued by, and you know, like in questions around things like cis the word cisgender, you know, which has never been fully addressed, you know. And there's a character in this play who has a few things to would have have a few things to say about the word the cisgender, and this seemed like too perfect an opportunity to not see if I could make that work. So there are some things that you want to uh include because they would be included in like the ongoing conundrum of of what is sexual harassment, what is the appropriate response to it?

Uh I I you know, one of the things that I've always I liked about that play is that in fact that our heroine, Georgie, colludes. I mean, she's enraged by it, but she wants to keep her job. And so she kind of colludes with what's going on, which women do all the time. I mean, I think that this story that sexual harassment means you you if you're faced with it, you have to either stand up to it and lose your job and they, you know, blah, blah, blah, or you're, or you don't get it, you don't have any rights. I think that's just not the truth of the way women live their lives and deal with this stuff all the time. And um so I think that that's still true in the play. And that's, you know, so mostly I um wanted the play to have its original integrity, but there were some sections.

The other thing that is true about, you know, because that was my first play in New York, I was very, very young. I was 27 and I had a lot of people pushing and pulling at me and I had a lot of people giving me notes and insisting on rewrites. And I was fine, and so sometimes I when I hear it or see a production of it over the years, I've thought, Jesus, you know, all that extra stuff is in there because somebody else wanted it in there. And this is, I'm at a point where I can just go, okay, I'm taking out everything that I never wanted to put in in the first place. And then I'm using this opportunity to put in some other things too because it's um you know it is to me especially that this question um is just underexplored still and uh I you know that's a woeful truth for me you know that we still aren't talking about it the way we should be.

[28:03] Jamie DuMont: Very true. Thank you for for indulging me on that. Well, and you you've talked about, you know, various plays that you've written. There's a lot of development, research and development, I assume, when you're doing these plays. So, what is the craziest thing you've learned about the culinary world since you've developed this play?

[28:20] Theresa Rebeck: Searred. Oh my God. That's a very good question. And what is the craziest thing I've learned about the culinary world? I've learned a lot, I've learned a lot of interesting little things about like how you make uh menus, how you print menus, how you um how dishes are dealt with, um, how dessert is dealt with, you know, because I always thought, you know, you go to a restaurant, you assume that everybody's making everything back there. That's turns out not to be true. Um, most restaurants ship in you you know, I'm shaking my head, is what I'm doing. Right. Yeah, I mean, you like go, oh no, you go out and you buy all that stuff and then you make this stuff. Um which is in your play. Yeah, he takes a box of pastries, right? Right. He clearly didn't make it. I think they're expensive. Yeah, it's outsourced. You outsource a bunch of things. Um, and uh I learned the things like I don't know, I learned how much donuts cost.

[29:19] Jamie DuMont: You mean how much they cost to actually make?

[29:22] Theresa Rebeck: No, or how much they cost retail.

[29:25] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, retail.

[29:26] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah, well, I'm with you. I didn't know those things you just mentioned about menus, etc. So that's new. Yeah, I mean seeing the play was itself, you know, uh a learning experience for me. It was at a window into a world that I had never really thought critically about, uh, which was fascinating. Yeah, I don't know. What else did I learn? You know, when I was writing the play, I I was exploring all this thing, and more and more than I when I got into rehearsal with it, I thought this is a divorce play. This is a play about two people getting a divorce, and one of them is desperately trying to save the marriage, and the other one doesn't know how much trouble the marriage is in. And so the first person brings in a therapist, and they also and they have a kid. I mean, there was a kind of uh you know what I mean? I love that.

[30:13] Jamie DuMont: All right. I mean, but so there was one point when we were first working on the first production of it, where I was like, guys, when those two start to fight, you have to find, you know, you have to find your corners. You have to step back the way people do when a divorcing couple takes over and cannot stop themselves from fighting, you the everybody else kind of slinks into a place to hide. Um, and so that was interesting. I I didn't fully understand uh how much this play, and I think that's one of the things that I I'm proudest of. Um, and I think that it's really a play about these people, um, and about survival and the survival of the spirit and love, you know, um, and uh the mystery of of how much we can take.

The other thing that I didn't see coming, um, that I discovered was this question of how what you have to do for your art to survive, you know, because I do feel like, you know, I've always w worried that the ending, I love the moment when Rodney says you have to bow to it big, because I thought Harry, for all of his uh perfectionism and his great gift, doesn't understand what he has to do to break his own heart, that there's something about the breaking of your own heart um that you do. You I know you know this, that you do to keep that talent alive and moving forward.

[31:42] Jamie DuMont: Isn't that true?

[31:43] Theresa Rebeck: Yes, you're making me weep. Yes yeah right yes well it's an interesting question of when does the when does the artist become an artist right because at the end of the I don't I don't yes I I don't want to give it too much away but there's a moment in which somebody sort of rises to the occasion and there's a conflict about what that actually means and when is the authorship of the right so when is when is a chef a chef is a chef a chef when they go to culinary school or when they open up their own restaurant is an artist an artist when they sell their first piece or when like it's and I feel like there's you're you're you're dabbling in that a little bit at the very end of the play.

[31:44] Theresa Rebeck: At the end of the play I think Harry has to do something he's never understood how to do or that you know and that there's something about the breaking of the self that adds you know that feels uh like an outrage or something you're not going to be able to survive or you know um when in fact it's just a another opening of a door here Harry says this thing in an early in the play about there are so many choices in life there are so many things to explore and you have to you have to there's only so much you can do uh you know he has I like oh I will say another thing I discovered was how powerful butter is and how mysterious butter is I've I heard a lot of people talk to me about that you you I'm gonna ask you to validate this that people don't fully understand how butter does what it does.

[33:15] Jamie DuMont: So I have a I have a story about this. I um I worked many years as a chef. Um, and then I I switched careers and I became an event planner for a catering company. And that catering company had a restaurant, and in that restaurant they had a takeout portion of it. So they had like a refrigerated, you know, display of like lunch foods. And which was something I had never really been a part of. You know, that the idea of I I worked mostly in I worked mostly in private homes. Um, you know, I didn't work for Janeiro, but you know, I worked for somebody for it. I'll tell you who I worked for later, because again, I I signed an NDA. Um, and this person is quite famous. But I but I spent my most of my time in catering.

My point of the story is when I came to this catering company that had the display food, they sold chicken. That was their number roast chicken was their number one seller. And I remember very clearly my first day walking past the prep table where they had all these chickens just come out of the oven, and they poured vats of melted butter over the chickens. And I couldn't believe what I was seeing. And I said to the chef, what are you doing? Is that about flavor? He said, No, the butter keeps them moist. So when the chickens sit in a refrigerated unit all day long, they dry out. And when the butter is in them and they come to room temperature, the butter softens up and moistens the chicken meat.

[34:36] Jamie DuMont: Well, I have to say, I have a friend who runs a pretty well respected like little boutique restaurant in Park Slope. And she's like, she told me it's an old restaurant trick that the last thing you you toss on whatever you're cooking is every is butter. You just toss it on there because butter, no matter what it is, butter makes it taste better.

[34:57] Theresa Rebeck: It makes it taste better, but it's weird, right? It's a lubricant. I mean, it's an emulsifier. It's unbelievable what butter does, right?

[35:09] Jennifer Simard: Yeah, you could be perplexed.

[35:10] Theresa Rebeck: I'm gonna start putting it on my skin before performances. Maybe it'll make me even better.

[35:15] Rob Russo: Yeah, they'll make you younger.

[35:16] Theresa Rebeck: But that makes you better.

[35:17] Rob Russo: It'll make your performance better.

[35:19] Theresa Rebeck: That's what I'm saying.

[35:20] Rob Russo: That's what I'm saying.

[35:20] Theresa Rebeck: All right. Salty. It's got that kind of mystery to it.

[35:23] Rob Russo: Yeah, butter will get you that Tony. That's the elusive butter trick.

[35:27] Theresa Rebeck: Um, okay, you've been very generous with your time. And I we have a couple more questions, but I can't sit here and talk to you about this play without talking about scallops.

[35:36] Jennifer Simard: Oh.

[35:36] Theresa Rebeck: So now the scallops, as you mentioned, play a big part in the show. Um, he refuses to make the dish, which you said.

[35:46] Rob Russo: What I found interesting about the scallop, because I looked up scallops because when I walked away from the play, Rob and I had a conversation about the scallops, and I said, you know, it's really interesting that Theresa chose the scallop to be the dish that is so controversial.

[35:59] Theresa Rebeck: And we had a conversation about are scallops easy or hard to prepare.

[36:02] Rob Russo: And then I said to Rob, you know, I always think of a scallop as being throughout art and antiquity, it's everywhere.

[36:10] Theresa Rebeck: And Rob said, no, no, no, you're thinking of the clamshell.

[36:12] Rob Russo: I said, no, no, no. Venus is I'm pretty sure Venus is on a scallop shell, which I looked up and she is.

[36:18] Theresa Rebeck: But what I don't think I knew, which I now know, is that the scallop is often represented as a pilgrimage or a journey.

[36:26] Jennifer Simard: Oh, did you still know that that was the secret truth that the play knew that I did not know?

[36:32] Theresa Rebeck: Wait, you did not know that?

[36:33] Jennifer Simard: I did not know that.

[36:34] Theresa Rebeck: I picked it because they're hard to cook, you know, and there are a lot of specific things. I mean, I talked to a bunch of different people about them, and there are just a lot of specific things you can do to a scallop, and that's why you don't get them very often.

[36:47] Rob Russo: Yeah.

[36:48] Theresa Rebeck: They're hard to do.

[36:48] Rob Russo: Well, they're easy to kill.

[36:49] Theresa Rebeck: I mean, it's an easy dish.

[36:50] Rob Russo: This was the conversation that we had because Rob was under the impression that they're easy to make.

[36:50] Theresa Rebeck: They're easy to make.

[36:56] Rob Russo: I was right.

[36:56] Theresa Rebeck: And well, I think they are if you know what you're doing. But you can mess them up like that.

[37:02] Rob Russo: Yes.

[37:02] Theresa Rebeck: And it's hard.

[37:03] Rob Russo: He's right.

[37:04] Theresa Rebeck: Everything Harry says is right. They're hard to source. They're, you know, they get mealy really fast. You know, when Mike shows up with the scallops near the end of the play, um, and Harry is sort of transfixed by them, it's because they're really good scallops, you know.

[37:21] Rob Russo: He Harry's not making this stuff up.

[37:24] Theresa Rebeck: Well, it's fascinating twice now. You've mentioned to us the play revealing something to you or knowing something about itself that you the writer didn't even know, right? The idea of it being sort of a divorce setup, and then this idea of the scallops.

[37:39] Jennifer Simard: Do you find that that happens as a writer? That oftentimes you think you know what you're doing, and then suddenly you step back and say, oh wow, no, this is something else?

[37:49] Theresa Rebeck: Yeah, that happens all the time. That's actually why I like writing plays. I mean, I like writing, I like writing in general.

[37:55] Rob Russo: Um, but I, you know, as opposed to like Dorothy Parker, who's like hated writing but loved having written.

[38:01] Theresa Rebeck: I'm actually somebody who I think it's fun and interesting and sometimes very difficult.

[38:08] Rob Russo: Um, but um I worry when people want to see outlines and stuff.

[38:13] Theresa Rebeck: The part of the problem with outlines and treatments and things like that is that you don't, um, you don't if you plan everything before you've written it, you don't discover the things that it's in there that you know.

[38:26] Rob Russo: So I used to want to teach, I talk about the secret subject, you know, like you really don't know what the secret subject of anything is if you outline it first.

[38:36] Theresa Rebeck: And so you have to leave some room there for it to reveal itself to you because I and Shakespeare actually talks about this, and I can't remember where about the writing teaching you what you are writing about and I think that that's why you know I like straight plays for like when they go there you know that it's um our movie films sometimes go there too you know a kind of there's this discovery where you just think it's so organic and strange you know that the storyteller didn't understand that that was gonna reveal itself.

[38:36] Jennifer Simard: Well, I have to say it was my experience of seeing Seared that I thought it was one thing when it started and in the end I walked away we had a whole deep conversation on the way to the trade about how it was so much more than just the story right that there was so much more there about art and commerce and passion and the relationship between these characters and that you know revealed itself to us through the course of watching the play.

[39:40] Theresa Rebeck: That was fascinating.

[39:40] Rob Russo: I think we've made it clear that we're a big fan of the work of the play your work and particularly of this play.

[39:48] Jennifer Simard: We have one final question for you that we ask all of our guests and that question is what was that moment or that experience that made you want to work in the theater did you have one?

[39:48] Theresa Rebeck: Oh, you know, I have to say I yeah it was for me it was um it was student matinees at Cincinnati Playhouse in the park where you know I was raised in Cincinnati in a Catholic, you know, uh in a Catholic Republican household, and I had to go to church six days a week.

[40:20] Rob Russo: I mean, I come from like a real crazy alternate I, you know, identity.

[40:26] Theresa Rebeck: Um, but every year, uh, you if for five bucks, you had to bring your five bucks and your permission slip, and they'd put you on a bus and take you down to Cincinnati Playhouse in the park.

[40:36] Rob Russo: And I saw, you know, I saw really beautiful productions of uh Arthur Miller and Tennessee Williams and Moliere.

[40:45] Theresa Rebeck: Those are the ones I remember. And a couple, a couple of Shakespeares.

[40:49] Rob Russo: And I it was truly astonishing.

[40:52] Theresa Rebeck: It just like broke me wide open.

[40:55] Rob Russo: Uh and I and I I thought they were gods.

[40:59] Theresa Rebeck: I thought the playwrights were like that was uh it was the biggest aspirational thing I could ever dream of doing.

[41:05] Rob Russo: And I didn't dream of doing it for a long time.

[41:08] Theresa Rebeck: Because it just seemed, you know, but when it finally occurred to me to maybe try to do that, uh everybody thought I was insane.

[41:15] Rob Russo: I still think I was insane, kind of.

[41:16] Theresa Rebeck: I think it, but I did. I saw it as like a mighty, a really mighty task.

[41:22] Rob Russo: Thank you so much for joining us today.

[41:24] Theresa Rebeck: Thank you.

[41:24] Jennifer Simard: Thanks, you guys.

[41:59] Rob Russo: Rob here with you may be wondering. Perhaps you notice by the background noise, but I've stepped outside of our usual studio, the pink room at OM, to record this segment at Orso Restaurant, which, in addition to a scheduling convenience, just feels right, given the subject matter of our conversation in this episode.

[42:14] Rob Russo: After all, Seared is set in the kitchen of a small restaurant in Brooklyn. The hyper-realistic and detailed set design by Tim McAbee is mesmerizing and quite transporting.

[42:23] Rob Russo: Sitting in the audience at MCC's intimate black box theater, you feel like you're actually peering into a real kitchen. That's also because the kitchen on stage works and it's used.

[42:32] Rob Russo: As Harry the Chef, actor Rallis Barza prepares some seven dishes over the course of the show, most notably at the start of Act 2, when he cooks a salmon dish from start to finish.

[42:42] Rob Russo: You can hear the oil pop on a pan, you can smell the onion sizzle, and you see the dishes come into creation as he plates them and sends them into the dining room offstage.

[42:51] Rob Russo: You may be wondering, as we were, how Raul prepared to do this real on stage cooking.

[42:55] Rob Russo: As Theresa suggested and a New York Times profile illuminates, he worked with a chef consultant, watched cooking shows, and practiced making the dishes at home as if he were in a restaurant kitchen.

[43:05] Rob Russo: Then he observed the kitchen of a midtown seafood restaurant during the dinner rush, meticulously asking the executive chef questions about every detail of how he maneuvers around the kitchen.

[43:14] Rob Russo: That eagle-eyed attention to detail pays dividends in his performance.

[43:17] Rob Russo: While Theresa jokes that they didn't actually have to cook everything for real on stage, the fact that they do adds immeasurably to the realism of the piece.

[43:25] Rob Russo: And, well, leaves many audience members hungry.

[43:28] Rob Russo: I personally was eyeing the gnocchi.

[43:30] Rob Russo: Cooking on stage can be extraordinarily impactful, especially when done as expertly as Raul does it in Seared.

[43:36] Rob Russo: I'll never forget David Kromer's magnificent production of Our Town at the Barra Street Theater.

[43:40] Rob Russo: In Act 3 of an otherwise unadorned, abstract production of the play, as is usually the case, as the deceased Emily goes back in time to relive her 12th birthday.

[43:49] Rob Russo: A curtain was pulled to reveal a realistic kitchen set with an actual stove on which Mother Webb cooked bacon, the smell wafting through the theater, hitting you as strongly and vividly as Emily's memory.

[44:00] Rob Russo: Of course, just this past season on Broadway, there was a restaurant on stage and network, though no visible cooking.

[44:05] Rob Russo: And Ann Eller prepares some cornbread in Oklahoma.

[44:08] Rob Russo: When she was on our show, we had fun asking Maritesta about her method for cracking eggs on stage.

[44:13] Rob Russo: The character of Jenna and waitress does some pie preparation, though not to completion.

[44:17] Rob Russo: In 2015, Carrie Mulligan sauteed onions in Skylight.

[44:21] Rob Russo: In 2014, Hugh Jackman famously gutted a fish in Jez Butterworth's haunting play, The River.

[44:26] Rob Russo: And in 2008, Faith Prince gutted a fish in the musical A Cater to Fair.

[44:30] Rob Russo: At least that's what it was like during previews.

[44:32] Rob Russo: By the time the show opened, she cooked an egg.

[44:34] Rob Russo: Eileen Atkins peels mushrooms in a loop in Florian Zeller's The Height of the Storm.

[44:38] Rob Russo: And earlier this month, I saw Richard Nelson's The Michaels at the public theater, which takes place in the kitchen of a family home, with the audience seated intimately in the round.

[44:47] Rob Russo: Over the course of the play, which is set almost in real time, one character prepares a quiche, pops it in an oven on stage, and takes it out when it's ready about 20 minutes later, puts it on the table for dinner, during which several other characters consume slices.

[45:00] Rob Russo: Cooking and eating are such integral parts of our lives, so it's only natural to see these activities reflected back on stage.

[45:06] Rob Russo: But much like that old show business adage to never work with children or animals, the interpolation of live cooking adds a tricky technical element to any production.

[45:14] Rob Russo: Fortunately, in Seared, Theresa Rebeck couldn't ask for a better actor than Raul Sparza, who chops, sautees, and plates like a pro.

[45:31] Jennifer Simard: Jennifer here, that's our show.

[45:33] Jennifer Simard: Thanks for listening. You can hear us anytime on iTunes, and if you like what you hear, rate and review us.

[45:38] Jennifer Simard: The Fabulous Invalid is a production of O and M, etcetera and the Fabulous Invalid LLC, and a proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network.

[45:44] Jennifer Simard: Our theme music is by Lucky Chops.

[45:47] Jennifer Simard: Today's episode was edited and engineered by Aaron Kaufman and Charles Van Kirk.

[45:51] Jennifer Simard: You can find us online at thefabulousinvalid.com and on social media at Fabulous Invalid and on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever you find your podcasts.

[45:58] Jennifer Simard: If you like what you hear, again, please rate and review us on iTunes.

[46:02] Jennifer Simard: And be sure to tune in next Wednesday.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred