Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 60: Everyone Is A Critic

On this week’s special in-depth package show, Rob and Jamie sit down with a cross section of theatre critics to talk about who they are, what they do, why they do it, and how they do it, in addition to their thoughts on the state of theatre criticism and the future of the form... Read More

From the show: The Fabulous Invalid

1 h 5 mins
1/22/20

Guests

About

On this week’s special in-depth package show, Rob and Jamie sit down with a cross section of theatre critics to talk about who they are, what they do, why they do it, and how they do it, in addition to their thoughts on the state of theatre criticism and the future of the form. You’ll hear from Ben Brantley, Helen Shaw, Jose Solís, Nicole Serratore, and Christian Lewis. Tune in and find out why “everyone is a critic”.

Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid

Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid

Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc

Email us at: info@fabulousinvalid.com

Jamie Du Mont

Twitter: @jamiedumont

Instagram: @troutinnyc

Rob Russo

Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC

Jennifer Simard

Twitter: @SimardJennifer

Instagram: @thejennifersimard

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast, where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important, and innovative theater makers working today, from actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.

[0:24] Rob Russo: We took our name from the title of the 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself.

[0:31] Jamie DuMont: Always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back, the Fabulous Invalid.

[0:35] Jamie DuMont: I'm Theater Savant, Jamie DuMont.

[0:37] Rob Russo: And I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with Stage Left at NYC.

[0:41] Jamie DuMont: Hi, Rob.

[0:41] Rob Russo: Hi, Jamie.

[0:42] Jamie DuMont: Well, this week we're doing something a little different.

[0:44] Rob Russo: That's right.

[0:45] Jamie DuMont: Back in October, we did our first big in-depth package show of the season, where we took a look at the life and work and legacies of Bob Fosse and Gwen Verdon.

[0:55] Rob Russo: But this week we're presenting our second package show, and it's all about critics.

[0:59] Jamie DuMont: Yes, it is.

[1:00] Rob Russo: Over the last month, Rob and I sat down with Ben Brantley, Christian Lewis, Nicole Serratore, Helen Shaw, and Jose Solís.

[1:07] Jamie DuMont: Yes, we reached out to these critics in particular because we wanted a nice cross-section, right?

[1:12] Rob Russo: Of folks who were at the Times, right? Like the pinnacle of the critical establishment, and then folks like Christian Lewis, who's a younger writer who's a freelancer and just starting out.

[1:22] Jamie DuMont: So we've got a nice mix of different folks that you'll hear from in this episode.

[1:26] Rob Russo: And we talk about what they do, why they do it, how they do it, who they do it with, when they do it, you know, all the do-its.

[1:26] Jamie DuMont: All the do-its.

[1:34] Rob Russo: Well, the who, what, when, where, why, I guess.

[1:36] Jamie DuMont: The essential five questions.

[1:37] Rob Russo: Um, and throughout this episode, you're mostly gonna hear their voices.

[1:41] Jamie DuMont: So, first we'll let them introduce themselves.

[1:43] Ben Brantley: I'm Ben Brantley, co-chief theater critic of the New York Times.

[1:47] Helen Shaw: Hi, I'm Helen Shaw. I'm the theater critic for Vulture and New York magazine.

[1:52] Christian Lewis: Hi, I'm Christian Lewis. I'm a freelance theater critic. Uh, most of the time on Medium, but you can find me lots of other places, including an upcoming piece in American Theater Magazine.

[2:01] Nicole Serratore: Hi, I'm Nicole Serratore. I'm a freelance critic who writes for uh The Stage, Variety, Exyant Magazine, and formerly The Village Voice.

[2:10] Jose Solís: My name is Jose Solís, I'm a freelance theater critic. I mostly write for the New York Times, for TDF Stages, for Backstage recently, and for a magazine called America, which is a Jesuit magazine that is one of my favorite things telling people that even the Pope reads this magazine. I also have a web series and a podcast called Token Theater Friends, produced by TCG and hosted by American Theater Magazine.

[2:34] Jamie DuMont: That's our cast of critics. Now on to the episode.

[2:49] Ben Brantley: So I have a master's in dramaturgy.

[2:52] Ben Brantley: And that is not necessarily a step that leads to a career, I would say.

[3:16] Ben Brantley: And so when I figured out that I could write criticism, which meant that I could go to a show every night, that was when I kind of got bitten by the bug.

[3:24] Ben Brantley: So I was an English drama double major in college at Vassar, the same double major as Meryl Streep.

[3:31] Ben Brantley: Slightly fragile.

[3:32] Ben Brantley: For those keeping note.

[3:34] Ben Brantley: For those keeping note.

[3:35] Ben Brantley: And I really couldn't decide when I was finishing my college journey, like halfway through what I wanted to do about English or theater.

[3:43] Ben Brantley: And so I came to the point of deciding I wanted to pursue graduate school in English, and I'm currently a PhD candidate, but I didn't want to give up on the theater thing.

[3:51] Ben Brantley: And I was a college student and wanted to see a lot of free theater.

[3:54] Ben Brantley: And so I like put two and two together and started writing about theater and very quickly started getting free tickets to write about theater, and then I just kept doing it.

[4:03] Christian Lewis: I knew that I wanted to be a critic since I was 10 years old.

[4:07] Christian Lewis: The reason for that was that I got a journal for Christmas, I think, where I probably just like grabbed a book and turned it into a journal.

[4:14] Christian Lewis: And I found that soon enough, my journal stopped being about me and became about my thoughts on the things that I was consuming, the art that I was consuming.

[4:23] Christian Lewis: So I became a teenager and I started a blog.

[4:26] Christian Lewis: My father was gracious enough to buy me uh my own domain when I was 14, and I started a site about movies.

[4:33] Christian Lewis: Oh, because uh all of this was happening when I was in Honduras, which is where I was born and where I lived uh till I was 18.

[4:40] Christian Lewis: Then I kept writing in my tiny blog, and people I was commenting before Twitter and before social media, I kept commenting on posts of sites that I admired, and you know, people that were based in the states, and then when I was like 15 or so, one of them was like, Do you want to write a blog post for my site?

[4:59] Christian Lewis: And I was like, sure.

[5:00] Christian Lewis: I moved to Costa Rica to go to film school.

[5:03] Christian Lewis: And in Costa Rica I found that there was theater, which is something that I didn't have in Honduras.

[5:07] Christian Lewis: So I started writing about theater in Costa Rica for local websites and a local newspaper, and in 2012, I moved to New York City with the idea of just writing about film full-time.

[5:19] Christian Lewis: But I arrive in New York City, and you know, like all of those like chorus girls from 42nd Street, I arrive, and how can you not be swallowed whole by theater in New York, right?

[5:31] Christian Lewis: And soon enough, uh, movies became my mistress, and I was married to theater.

[5:35] Christian Lewis: And now it's been seven years that I'm still doing it.

[5:38] Nicole Serratore: I am an attorney, that's my day job.

[5:41] Nicole Serratore: And I was working on a firm in Wall Street on a massive case that was taking years and years, and so many hours of my life, and I was very miserable.

[5:51] Nicole Serratore: And I suddenly wondered why was I still in New York?

[5:54] Nicole Serratore: What was I doing this all for?

[5:55] Nicole Serratore: What did I used to love to do that I had stopped doing?

[5:57] Nicole Serratore: And going to the theater was one of those things.

[5:59] Nicole Serratore: So I just started buying theater tickets because finally I could afford to.

[6:03] Nicole Serratore: And didn't always make it to the shows because of my hours at my job, but found myself really excited to be back in sort of an art space.

[6:11] Nicole Serratore: I had been in the film business before becoming a lawyer.

[6:14] Nicole Serratore: And it just kind of reinvigorated my passion for the arts, and I got on Twitter and started talking to people, and then they wanted to know more of my opinions, and so I started blogging because I needed more space to express myself.

[6:27] Nicole Serratore: And then somehow editors approached me and said, Hey, do you want to write for me?

[6:31] Nicole Serratore: And I never really considered any of this.

[6:34] Nicole Serratore: And so I just kind of found my way that through to writing.

[6:39] Ben Brantley: First interview I ever had with John after college was with John Fairchild, then the publisher of Women's Wear Daily, and he said, if you could have any job in the world, what would it be?

[6:47] Ben Brantley: And I said, theater critic of the New York Times.

[6:50] Ben Brantley: That was many years ago.

[6:51] Ben Brantley: And I don't think either of us thought it was very likely to come true.

[6:56] Ben Brantley: But uh so Women's Wear, I was there for seven years.

[6:59] Ben Brantley: I became I ended as the Paris um editor and publisher.

[7:04] Ben Brantley: Uh I quit because I thought my life should perhaps take a different direction.

[7:08] Ben Brantley: It was probably the bravest thing I ever did.

[7:10] Ben Brantley: But I did.

[7:10] Ben Brantley: I walked out without another job, but soon found work uh at uh under contract Tina Brown first for Conde Nast uh first for the Vanity Fair.

[7:19] Ben Brantley: And then she took me with her to the New Yorker.

[7:22] Ben Brantley: At the same time, I was doing it on the side, movie reviews for El Magazine.

[7:26] Ben Brantley: My first editor there was a woman named Alex Wichell, who was going out with a guy named Frank Rich.

[7:32] Ben Brantley: And when they were looking for a new second string theater critic, this was some time after she left the magazine, she said, um, maybe we should ask Ben Brantley.

[7:40] Ben Brantley: So uh Frank called and said, Do you want to audition for this?

[7:43] Ben Brantley: And I said, Oh, yeah, right.

[7:44] Ben Brantley: And then it happened very quickly.

[7:46] Ben Brantley: And that was 27 years ago.

[7:48] Rob Russo: You've been there ever since.

[7:49] Ben Brantley: Why do you write about the theater?

[7:51] Ben Brantley: Well, I write about theater because uh I'm embarrassed to admit it's really the only way I can think about theater.

[7:57] Ben Brantley: Uh I find that when I see a show, uh, if I know I'm not writing about it, I experience it in a very different way, in a much lazier way, in a much more passive way, uh, which I don't like.

[8:08] Ben Brantley: Uh I would rather be kind of leaning forward and thinking when I'm watching something.

[8:12] Ben Brantley: And I also often walk out of a show coming out and and not knowing what I think.

[8:17] Ben Brantley: I am just sort of a storm of responses and emotions.

[8:21] Ben Brantley: And the experience of writing about it, having to actually put it down on paper, I find that organization is actually when the thinking gets done and when the analysis starts to happen.

[8:31] Ben Brantley: So for me, it's that I'm addicted to going to the theater.

[8:34] Ben Brantley: That's a compulsion, and it is a possibly relationship destroying compulsion.

[8:41] Ben Brantley: Hard to stay married to somebody who wants to have dinner every night when you say, I'm gonna go to a show every night of our entire lives.

[8:48] Ben Brantley: But uh, the that compulsion is just going to lead to uh mental breakdown if I don't also have to organize that experience into writing and into thought.

[9:01] Ben Brantley: Theater was really the first thing I fell in love with.

[9:03] Ben Brantley: It's been an obsession of mine since I was pretty much since I could talk, certainly since I could read.

[9:09] Ben Brantley: Uh my granddad taught Shakespeare.

[9:11] Ben Brantley: Um probably my most natural predilection is for like writing um papers for English classes, but you can't make a living doing that all your life.

[9:24] Ben Brantley: And um, and this sort of is translating that particular skill that I owned um really all through my life.

[9:31] Ben Brantley: It's so gratifying to write about in a way.

[9:34] Ben Brantley: I mean, movies, I love movies, and obviously they affect you when you're watching them in a very visceral way often.

[9:42] Ben Brantley: But with theater, it's just so much more intense because it is living people, and it could all go so wrong in a second, or you know, just soar into the heavens in a second, too.

[9:51] Nicole Serratore: I write about theater because I feel like all of my friends, and especially in college, were always talking about theater, and we were all students who couldn't afford a lot of theater, and it was in Poughkeepsie, so we had to take a train, so it was always like had to be really worth it to go see it.

[10:04] Nicole Serratore: And I feel like none of us had like critics or reviews that we felt like if I read blank person, I'll know if I want to see it.

[10:12] Nicole Serratore: So we felt like we didn't have the kind of person to help us decide what to see.

[10:16] Nicole Serratore: And I feel like in a world of so much Broadway and so much off-Broadway, and people trying to choose what to spend their money on, critics can be really helpful about saying, like, focus on this really great art or this really diverse artist and try to see that.

[10:29] Nicole Serratore: So I'm trying to like help steer people towards things that I think are really important and maybe away from things that I think people shouldn't be spending money on.

[10:37] Christian Lewis: I always felt like the art it wasn't complete until I had a conversation about it.

[10:42] Christian Lewis: Just going to see a movie or a play with friends, if we'd walk out the door and be like, okay, where do you want to get drinks?

[10:47] Christian Lewis: And that was it.

[10:48] Christian Lewis: Just never felt wasn't my experience of the world.

[10:51] Christian Lewis: And I wanted to talk about things and I wanted to talk about them the context of my life and what was going on and why I'd spent my money and time with this work.

[11:00] Christian Lewis: So you know, it was never a kind of casual space for me.

[11:04] Christian Lewis: It was always kind of a thinky space.

[11:07] Christian Lewis: And so I think I write because I feel like the conversation needs to happen, and I want to be part of that conversation, and I'm always excited by other people's ideas about work that I didn't see that wasn't my experience of the work.

[11:21] Nicole Serratore: And so I guess that whole sort of discussion dialogue sort of space, even you know, even if it's just between critics, just between theater fans, was what was interesting to me.

[11:30] Rob Russo: What is the purpose of theater criticism?

[11:33] Ben Brantley: Criticism is often the one remnant of a production you will see.

[11:37] Ben Brantley: I mean, yes, you can read a play, you can read a libretto, you can you can look at things on a page, but in theory, it is supposed to be, you know, it is a place you can go to and understand the past and understand what has come before.

[11:51] Ben Brantley: You know, obviously, giant caveat, asterisks, it's one person's opinion at that one point in time.

[11:58] Ben Brantley: Um, and but you know, I'd like to think that it provides, you know, a conversation, a contextual conversation with that moment in time.

[12:08] Ben Brantley: And sometimes that has a value, and sometimes it's like bullshit.

[12:10] Ben Brantley: And I don't care what somebody thought in 1967 about this show because they're an idiot and time has changed, and you know, women have rights.

[12:17] Christian Lewis: So women are people.

[12:19] Ben Brantley: Right.

[12:20] Ben Brantley: It turns out.

[12:21] Christian Lewis: Surprise.

[12:21] Ben Brantley: Um, things we discovered after 1967.

[12:24] Ben Brantley: I like to think that there is a value to that conversation, and that the work should exist in conversation with people.

[12:31] Ben Brantley: Because the work can sit on a library shelf and the work can sit in an actor's heart.

[12:36] Ben Brantley: But like, you know, it also should sit in people, and you know, being able to talk about productions I've seen in the past with other people who saw those productions, it's exciting.

[12:44] Ben Brantley: Because it's like, oh, I remember this little bit, and oh, somebody else remembers something else.

[12:47] Ben Brantley: And it, you know, it brings that work back to life, and we have this conversation, and then we can see where shades of that pop up in other work.

[12:54] Ben Brantley: Criticism is an art form.

[12:56] Jose Solís: Soft power is criticism, it is a reaction to Rogers and Hammerstein.

[13:03] Jose Solís: And what is it that critics do if not reacting to the art that they either connect with or not?

[13:10] Jose Solís: So soft power is to me what criticism looks like, you know, and my joke that people laugh at often is that I tell them, like, I will be the happiest man alive the day when a review looks like a cookie.

[13:23] Jose Solís: Like, bake me a cookie that lets me know what you felt about the great comment.

[13:28] Jose Solís: Well, uh, there are uh I think there's three.

[13:32] Jose Solís: Uh one of them is um it's like all journalism, it's the first draft of history.

[13:39] Jose Solís: And it is if you have had, of course, if you've spent any time in the academy, if you've ever uh wanted to research a show, if you're ever interested in what has happened, uh you wind up reading criticism.

[13:51] Jose Solís: Uh and that is uh because the theater is very fundamentally very very much at its heart an act of witnessing, uh witnessing doesn't mean anything until you've written it into scripture.

[14:04] Jose Solís: So you uh for for me that's a big part of it, is that that is my uh, you know, one of the reasons I write criticism is it as an act of gratitude as well, to say, well, at least the one thing I can do is I can record what I saw.

[14:18] Jose Solís: The second thing is that it's a communication with audience and it's a sorting activity, it's a curation activity.

[14:25] Jose Solís: And so you have this ability, this wonderful task to try to get the right people to the right shows.

[14:33] Jose Solís: And so you obviously we are blinkered by our own selves, you know, and you have to write through that uh because we have no other choice.

[14:41] Jose Solís: But you can say, you know, if you are this kind of person or if you're intrigued by this kind of thinking, you might really uh you really might find yourself provoked and excited by this thing.

[14:51] Jose Solís: And that is uh because honest curation, curation that isn't somehow attached to the market or to or to capitalism is I think uh rare.

[15:02] Jose Solís: Uh and then the third reason uh why it exists is because we don't can have a choice.

[15:07] Jose Solís: I really think that this is one of these basic human instincts.

[15:10] Jose Solís: Theater criticism came out at the same time that theater did, and theater is one of the things that every society develops at some point.

[15:18] Jose Solís: And it is a uh, I think that we don't, I think that, you know, I said I think theater very deeply at its core is about witnessing, but it's also about judgment.

[15:28] Jose Solís: The reason that we all sit together in a group, the reason it looks so much like a trial courtroom, the reason it looks so much like an operating theater is because we are there not just to watch, but to think and to respond.

[15:39] Jose Solís: And so uh theater criticism is that everyone in the audience is a theater critic.

[15:44] Jose Solís: Uh, we're just the idiots who uh for eighty dollars a pop decide to write it down.

[15:50] Jose Solís: What do you think the job of a theater critic is when writing a review?

[15:54] Nicole Serratore: Unlike some critics, I'm really am trying to write for audiences that are gonna see it.

[15:58] Nicole Serratore: I'm from the tri-state and I went to a lot of matinees with my mom as a kid, and I feel like here in Manhattan we don't talk about that, that's so much of the audience.

[16:07] Nicole Serratore: And so I really try to write for not just like New York elites who see every single revival of a play, but like also the like Jersey, Connecticut, Westchester crowd who are coming in for matinees and musicals.

[16:17] Nicole Serratore: So I'm really trying to like be very realistic about who's gonna see it and what they're gonna get out of it, which is something I felt like came up a lot last season with King Kong, where I feel like a lot of people who want would want to see King Kong would actually enjoy it, even though it was like not great art.

[16:31] Nicole Serratore: So I think it's important to try to consider that we have lots of different audiences seeing shows.

[16:37] Nicole Serratore: My job is to be a cheerleader, and my job is to I can tell you what my job is not also, and my job is not to be the final word on any single piece of art.

[16:37] Nicole Serratore: My job is to be the yes and part, the part that says, let's build a bridge between this work of art and the audience and the people who don't have the opportunity to have you know their voice amplified, whether on a newspaper, magazine, a website, or a podcast.

[17:03] Nicole Serratore: I want people to not think of me as some like evil, you know, judge, like, you know, like hiding in some like tower or like some like unmovable, like horrid figure, you know, a marble sitting like lay on like a marble pedestal.

[17:20] Nicole Serratore: Like I want to talk to people.

[17:22] Nicole Serratore: I think that my job is to be, I love AOC, and I think the job of a critic is to kind of be like a community organizer and to talk to people and to hold town halls.

[17:32] Nicole Serratore: And that town hall can look like the comment section of a site, which I'd rather it didn't, or it can look like an open invitation for people to talk on Twitter.

[17:43] Nicole Serratore: If I had a patron who wanted to, you know, if wanted to make me like the Leonardo to their Medici, I would totally hold weekly town halls and I would go with people to the theater and I would talk to them afterwards about what we just saw.

[17:57] Nicole Serratore: Because there's an aspect of theater that's extremely uh elitist.

[18:03] Nicole Serratore: And I want that to not be the case.

[18:06] Nicole Serratore: I want everyone to be able to see theater and to talk about theater, because that's what I love doing.

[18:10] Nicole Serratore: If I had my own outlet, I would probably have like a very specific idea of the person that I would be writing for.

[18:17] Nicole Serratore: But since I'm a freelancer, that's complete that completely depends on the outlet that I'm writing for.

[18:22] Nicole Serratore: I mean, when I write for the Pope, I'm thinking of the Pope.

[18:26] Nicole Serratore: Like, no, but you know, I'm laughing, but it's true.

[18:29] Nicole Serratore: Like, for instance, to give you an example, when I'm writing for American magazine, I keep in mind the fact that this is a slightly more conservative audience than probably my readership at the Times or American Theater.

[18:41] Nicole Serratore: Uh, so I want to tell them about the art that I think is interesting without shocking them so much that they don't want to read about it and then they do not want to engage about it.

[18:53] Nicole Serratore: When I write for the New York Times, for instance, um I want to let people know that there is more to what they think is out there.

[19:07] Nicole Serratore: I want to, you know, let people, I do a lot of research every time I write something for the Times, because I want to infuse my work with historical context, and especially with my experience as a queer, let's see no immigrant.

[19:22] Nicole Serratore: I want that to be in my work, which is something that I mean, a lot of criticism is mostly white men and who are very smart and very educated, but their backgrounds are so similar that I want to make sure that they know that I'm not coming from the same background.

[19:37] Nicole Serratore: And that I have a different story, not a better story or a worse story, but it's just a different story to tell.

[19:43] Nicole Serratore: I like to think of myself as kind of a window, ideally.

[19:47] Nicole Serratore: I mean, obviously, there's, you know, there's some frame.

[19:50] Nicole Serratore: There's the lattice work, which is your perspective and what you bring to it.

[19:54] Nicole Serratore: But ideally, I'm trying to create for people who either think or thinking about seeing this, but also people who will never get a chance to see what I'm writing about.

[20:03] Nicole Serratore: I'm trying to recreate the experience of what it was like for this person to watch that at this moment in time to make it as um as much of a sensory experience as I can.

[20:15] Nicole Serratore: Okay, this is a big one.

[20:17] Nicole Serratore: What's your writing process?

[20:19] Christian Lewis: I pitched to my publications initially, even what shows I might, you know, cover for them.

[20:25] Christian Lewis: Um, you know, I for the stage, particularly, I'm focused on Broadway, but I can occasionally, you know, get their attention for some off-Broadway work too.

[20:33] Christian Lewis: Um so, you know, I'm I'm already just kind of researching for Xian.

[20:37] Christian Lewis: Since I'm the managing editor, I'm also looking to see what shows are coming up, what I think writers should be writing about.

[20:41] Christian Lewis: So I just do a tremendous amount of, you know, reading press releases, sort of seeing what's out there, seeing what's coming up, seeing playwrights' names pop up on multiple emails over time starts to make me think, oh, maybe I should go check out this person's work, what are they doing?

[20:55] Christian Lewis: Um so there's a lot of that that's already kind of happened.

[20:58] Christian Lewis: I don't, you know, read the scripts ahead of time, unless it's a classic I should know, in quotes, that I don't.

[21:04] Christian Lewis: Maybe sometimes I'll grab that and be like, oh, wait, you know, occasionally with some of the Shakespeare plays that I'm less familiar with, I'm like, let me just quickly read Coriolena's just to remind me what what it's about.

[21:14] Christian Lewis: Um, you know, Titus Andronicus, before I saw Gary, I was like, I should just skim this so I know what it's riffing on.

[21:22] Christian Lewis: Right.

[21:22] Christian Lewis: So I'm not completely, you know, out of it.

[21:25] Christian Lewis: Um, but I don't do a tremendous amount of research necessarily ahead of time.

[21:29] Christian Lewis: Um, I take a notebook with me, I take notes during the show.

[21:32] Christian Lewis: Sometimes that's just more of a focus issue.

[21:33] Christian Lewis: Sometimes it's more of a just, I'm not gonna get the script necessarily.

[21:36] Christian Lewis: It's just an ordering, like, wait, which scene came before what?

[21:39] Christian Lewis: Um, when was that big outburst scene?

[21:41] Christian Lewis: Like, you know, just so I can kind of you know refresh my own recollection when I go to sit down and write about something.

[21:47] Christian Lewis: Um and sometimes I never look at those notes.

[21:50] Christian Lewis: I mean, I take the notes and then you know, sometimes I can't even read them.

[21:53] Christian Lewis: Um it's always a mystery.

[21:55] Christian Lewis: Um and I don't know, I start writing sometimes on the subway ride home.

[21:59] Christian Lewis: I live in Queens.

[22:00] Christian Lewis: Um, it takes me a little while.

[22:01] Christian Lewis: So, you know, it's it's a good place to just start like blah on the page and get something out, so I'm gonna hit my word count.

[22:07] Christian Lewis: I'm not panicked.

[22:08] Christian Lewis: Um, and if even if that's just the plot summary, so that I can at least just get the juices flowing, um, and throwing out some adjectives and you know, descriptive pieces and bits that are sort of like the emotion, the immediate emotional reaction to something.

[22:23] Christian Lewis: Um, and then I sit down for, you know, hopefully the same night if I can, if not, then the next day.

[22:28] Christian Lewis: Um it usually takes me about four hours.

[22:30] Christian Lewis: I've never been able to get down to less than that.

[22:33] Christian Lewis: So I see a play, I controversially like don't take notes during plays.

[22:38] Christian Lewis: I've been like glared at by like other theater critics next to me.

[22:42] Christian Lewis: And I'm like, where's your notebook?

[22:43] Christian Lewis: And I'm like, I'm okay.

[22:45] Christian Lewis: Um I like have a great like semi-photographic memory.

[22:51] Christian Lewis: I can like remember a lot of things.

[22:52] Christian Lewis: If I have a playbill in front of me, I can like remember basically anything that happened.

[22:55] Christian Lewis: I'm good if there's like a line I loved, I'll write it down during intermission.

[22:58] Christian Lewis: But like I don't write things down during it, and I usually write something like the next day or the next day or two.

[23:05] Christian Lewis: Very different from my academic writing.

[23:07] Christian Lewis: I try to get like as much as I need, like I try to get a thousand words down on the page and then go back and see what I want to change about it.

[23:15] Christian Lewis: And I feel like reviews are something that come like really organically out of me.

[23:19] Christian Lewis: Like I write it, and then sometimes afterwards I'm like, oh, that came out much more positive or much more critical than I want.

[23:25] Christian Lewis: But I like that because it feels more true and organic.

[23:28] Christian Lewis: Like that's what was the review was hiding within me and it just came out.

[23:32] Christian Lewis: I never read the scripts beforehand.

[23:34] Christian Lewis: I think that's a disservice to the production that we're about to see, because it's never gonna live up to what we imagined, right?

[23:42] Christian Lewis: Because if that was the case, like every production not staring at Audra McDonald would be a disappointment, because I would be like, oh, Audrey would be great in this part, in this part, in this part.

[23:49] Nicole Serratore: You'd be casting it out.

[23:51] Christian Lewis: Yeah.

[23:51] Christian Lewis: And so yeah, I never read anything in advance, but because critics get the scripts sent to them every single time.

[23:59] Christian Lewis: I also don't take notes.

[24:01] Christian Lewis: I try to immerse myself into the production as much as I can.

[24:06] Christian Lewis: When the show is over, depending on my deadline, I either have to write something right away or not.

[24:13] Christian Lewis: And when the time comes for writing, I clean my house, I you know, clean my bathtub, I go grocery shopping, and when I'm like an hour away from my deadline, I start writing.

[24:25] Christian Lewis: You know, the other reason I'm a theater critic is because there's deadlines, and I am just rubbish at writing without a deadline, so it's quite useful that there is just deadline, deadline, deadline in this business.

[24:37] Christian Lewis: Uh I, you know, one opens one's laptop, uh, one complains to whoever is nearby that one has to write that day.

[24:50] Christian Lewis: I, you know, usually for me, um if I'm being good, I write a tiny bit the minute I see it, so on the subway, or uh the minute that I get home, and then I wake up in the morning uh as early as I can, and then I write based on those thoughts.

[25:09] Christian Lewis: Uh so for instance, in two-part plays, when I saw the inheritance, I wrote between the shows because I knew that the second half was going to really color how I experienced the first half.

[25:19] Christian Lewis: And I was very glad I did that because my my feelings changed a lot, and I was glad to have that kind of record.

[25:25] Christian Lewis: Uh so some of it is that I just have to write as quickly as I can.

[25:30] Christian Lewis: Uh there are some other kind of boring things like I get stuck a lot, or I mean, I never have writer's block, but because you can always be talking about the show.

[25:40] Christian Lewis: Uh, but there are little tricks that I have if I don't know how to approach something.

[25:45] Christian Lewis: So uh there's Goethe's three questions.

[25:49] Christian Lewis: So if I need to, I can ask myself those questions, which are uh what is the work trying to achieve, how is it trying to achieve it, and was it worth the attempt?

[25:58] Helen Shaw: Uh, and trying to answer that. So I do it to myself almost like it's a little questionnaire. What is this work trying to achieve? Uh, partially I do that because I do not want to ask myself the question, did you like it or did you not like it? Because that's so boring. Thank you for that. The other thing I do, uh, you can tell when I'm really stuck. This is a real tell of mine, is I started out as a set designer, and if I am really stuck, I start talking about the set right away. Uh, because often what I see is what I wind up thinking about. And so, uh, I will, if I think I'm not actually sure that I know what I thought about the show, what did I think? I just start describing it. And then as my eye moves around the stage, I realize what it was catching on, what it was held by, and therefore what it thought was important.

And then I can start writing my way towards an argument from there. I mean, I certainly hate everything I'm writing while I'm writing it. Uh, then the moment of turning it in is a moment of such intense shame, uh, and surrender and acknowledgement that you're just a piece of trash. Uh, and then it comes back to you with some edits, and you think, oh, you can rescue it, and then you send it out. And then if you're either, either, you become insufferable about it. I've occasionally thought, well, you know what, that was actually amazing. What a wonderful installer talent I am. Mostly though, I just forget it. Like once it's done, it's out of your life, thank God. There's not a single piece that I've ever written that I'm completely satisfied with.

I would go back and rewrite the hell out of everything. Someone tweeted this not too long ago, and I said that one of the saddest things about being a writer is that as you know, as you get older and you mature, your writing from the past really never matures with you. Like what we said 20 years ago is there forever. And people will go find it. Yeah. And people don't allow people the chance to grow anymore.

[27:58] Ben Brantley: What's hardest to write? A rave, a pan, or a mixed review? Raves are the easiest to write. I mean, unless it's a sort of an esoteric person or a group, uh, that you're trying to explain to people who might not normally venture into those surreal precincts. But, um, but generally a rave is just, oh, you feel so good doing it because you are enthusiastic. I mean, if you really feel it, I mean, I think faking it is not a good idea. I think you can always tell when a critic's faking it. The reviews I'm proudest of are probably the mixed ones where you actually said, this is interesting for this reason, it doesn't work for this reason, but it has something. Um, because it's harder to achieve that balance.

And you also know readers don't want to read mixed reviews. We're a thumbs up, thumbs down culture. Did you love it? Did you hate it? I mean, it has to be one or the other. And if we're absolutely honest with ourselves, we don't ever respond unconditionally to anything. All emotions are mixed. The easiest thing to write is a negative review, which is, uh, one of the reasons why people do sort of hate us sometimes, is you can tell, you can tell how fast the words come out when you hate something, and, uh, and that's repulsive to the people who made it because they think, you know, I spent six months of my life on this, and you clearly, you know, you were screaming this into the notes app on your cell phone probably the minute you left the theater.

And then the second easiest to write is the positive review because you just, uh, criticism is description, and so you just get to sit there and describe something that you loved. I mean, that's a thrill. Uh, and then, and then obviously the mixed review is just impossible because, uh, as you know as a writer, placement structure is everything about your argument. And so you, if you write a mixed review, let's say you have a two-paragraph mixed review. I don't write two paragraphs anymore, but at Time Out, for instance, I had to write two paragraphs all the time. So let's say you're writing a two-paragraph review and you felt totally mixed about the thing. If you write the positive thing first and the negative thing second, then it's a negative review.

If you write the negative thing first and the positive thing second, then it's a positive review. And that can be, those two paragraphs can be identical. Just exchanging their position changes the tone of the review completely. And, uh, that, uh, sitting on that knife's edge, I find really stressful. I find mixed reviews really hard to write because a mixed review usually means I'm not very passionate about it. So then I find it hard to write about because I'm like, well, this part was good, but this part was bad, and like I liked this, but this didn't work. And I feel like when I end up writing those, so many of my sentences end up with the same structure like that, where it's always like, despite a really great performance by blank, the overall direction weakened the piece.

And it's like, despite this, this, and like I just feel like I keep writing sentences where I have to pit a good and a bad, and yeah, I love writing rave reviews. Writing pans isn't great. I hate being mean to shows. I'm not one of those people who like loves making really mean puns. Like I don't think that's what criticism should be about, but I do think that like a pan and a rave are much easier to write for me. Because you just have strong opinions, and it's easy to write strong opinions. The mess stuff I think is always the hardest because you really have to kind of dig back into something that you didn't, you know, didn't come to you on sort of the initial experience of it. And I can sometimes liken it to being asked to go eat at the restaurant that gave you food poisoning.

Like you have to go back to this place that you didn't have a great time, um, and then relive everything about it to figure out like why didn't this work? Or, you know, what was wrong? Where did it all go wrong? What made me sick? Um, and you know, sometimes that can be really unpleasant when it's something you're like, I just, I don't care. I don't think you guys cared in making this work. Like, I don't know. It just wasn't, you know, it wasn't enough. It was just sitting there in the middle, and you're like, I don't know why this happened. I don't know why this got programmed, I don't know why I got invited. And so then you really have to dig in and you know, sort of that's unfortunately like your job starts there, and then you have to dig in and figure out like what, what, what was going on?

Why, why wasn't this giving you something? Um, I think also works that are so great that are just beyond compare that you love so deeply are really hard to write about because you're like, this is never gonna live up to my experience of it. And I want you to feel the way I feel about this show, and somehow I feel like my words will never get to that place to express what I'm feeling.

[32:31] Jose Solís: You have a favorite refrain that you've, um, you know, since I follow you on Twitter that you've shared multiple times, which is, you know, I've written a thousand words and all of them are wrong. You know, about like Angels in America, right? Or some great work that you love so much, and you know, but the words are just, they're there, they're there, they're just not right, right? They just, yeah, they're not Tony Kushner's, so what the hell am I doing here? Yeah, it's hard. It's hard when you're faced with something that, yeah, that you just want to express that greatness, um, and you're like, I'm not as good an artist as they are, so how am I ever gonna get there? And what I have to say. Um, so I think that can be hard too.

I mean, I don't enjoy pans, but they're sometimes easier because it's like, well, I know what was wrong, everything, you know, and you make your laundry list. Um, but sometimes they're too. You're sort of like, you know, if it's a smaller work, it's a smaller company, it's emerging artists who are just, you know, trying something new and they kind of missed the mark. You know, I'm not looking to tear people down. It's like, okay, well, how can I make this a constructive conversation then?

[33:28] Nicole Serratore: Is there a difference between a review and criticism? Yeah, I never quite know what people are arguing about when they argue at that point. It's just bullshit and semantics. Yeah, like a review can look, you know, when I talk to, because people ask me to talk to young people. I don't know why. People ask me to talk to young people about criticism and about all of that. That's all a ton of bullshit. Like, unless you're writing a PR release where it's obviously aimed for one very specific reason, uh, criticism can take any shape. Very easy. A review is for something that's open, criticism is for something that's closed. Oh. Right. So criticism is when you go, when you push into the record. A review is something which is keyed towards somebody who's trying to decide if they should go or not.

And for us, because we work in the ways that we do, we're always writing something which is a little half and half. I'm writing a review right now of Slave Play for an academic journal. And so that's been a real weird thing where sometimes editors have told me when I'm writing like a journalism piece that my writing can sometimes feel too academic. And then in grad school, I'm told sometimes your stuff feels a little too informal. So like navigating exactly what that means is really interesting. And I've just started kind of writing pieces that are less reviews and more like state of the field, bigger criticism pieces like at American Theater or like the Slave Play thing, and that's been definitely something to navigate that's less just about one single production and more about like what's happening in a season or what's happening with the art form right now.

And it's definitely something to juggle. I really like it because I feel like I get to use more like critical reasoning, grad school English vibes there to like not just talk about like a lighting designer specific actor's performance.

[35:16] Christian Lewis: So I really like that we can have both kind of genres. And they overlap. They overlap a lot. Like the Slave Play One, it's an academic piece, but it's a review just of the play, but not necessarily of the production. So it's like getting to kind of fuse it all at once. Do you think theater critics are part of the theater community? They're sort of, they're at the family reunion, but they're not the person you're most excited to see. You know, it's like a weird cousin. Uh, with a past. I think yes, certainly, of course, because we're all sort of feeding on the same Leviathan, you know, uh, that yes, certainly critics are part of the community, and really good critics, uh, I definitely do not include myself in this.

Really good critics are practitioners. So you've got people like Feingold, who was a translator, uh, David Cody, who's a librettist, Adam Feldman who sings cabaret. The, I mean, these are people who are, uh, really, um, on the one hand, you have that, that's a path to being a great seer and writer, is to actually truly know the field by being part of it. Obviously, we've also had people who are completely external to the field, like Hilton Als, who were great, great watchers. Uh, so it isn't absolutely necessary, but it is, it is, it can be kind of part of a well-rounded critic. I certainly feel very friendly towards a lot of different people who make shows. Uh, I am incredibly fond of the people who've been around for as long as I have, even if I've never exchanged a word with them.

Uh, and also theater is hugging, so we're all hugging each other all the time anyway. So it's like we're friends. Uh, but yeah, no, I think, uh, I think it's a sort of, it's a fraught question. Uh, but it's only a question because incontrovertibly they are part of the community. They're just a kind of weird part, you know, awkward part.

[37:13] Helen Shaw: And then there's Helen Shaw, weird cousin with a past. Exactly. Like standing by the punch, and everyone's like, oh God, to get to the punch, we go by her. It's so strange, because they are, but they like pretending that they're not. I think we're members of the theatrical community when it benefits us. And then we remove ourselves when it doesn't work out for us. I think they absolutely are a member of the theater community. When I was in college, it was called the drama department, and we all had to call ourselves theater makers. Like no one and no one was allowed to do one thing. Like you couldn't just act, you also like had to do some kind of design or writing or direction. And I feel like I really that I like roll my eyes at that at the time.

But I feel like I really love that model that like we're all theater makers and we're all doing a lot of things and putting things all together. I really do think critics are part of the ecosystem, they're part of a feedback loop. I think the best theater critics out there are ones that were or currently are artists. It's no surprise that Sarah Holdren was and is directing again and is one of the best theater critics in history. Like when they're all part of the feedback loop, I think it really helps. I think on the surface, theater critics come across as gatekeepers and saying what shouldn't shouldn't be happening and being produced on Broadway and Off, and what shouldn't, shouldn't audiences be going to.

I really try not to think of myself as a gatekeeper at all. I think as someone that's like standing on a highway that has a lot of lanes and kind of like pointing people in a direction that I like. But like they're gonna, they're gonna go where they want to go. I'll scream at Tootsie as long as I want, but like it stayed open for too long.

[38:52] Jose Solís: But like I can still scream about it on the side of the road and hope less cars go over there. And they did. And they did. And they did. So yeah, I'm not trying to like be a gatekeeper, but I'm trying to encourage people to go in a direction that I think is a good direction for theater.

[39:08] Christian Lewis: How has social media changed theater criticism?

[39:11] Jose Solís: I mean, I wouldn't exist as a critic but for Twitter. Um I, you know, I my work wouldn't have been found without Twitter. I wouldn't have, I would never have approached editors about like, I should write for you. Um I never would have done any of that. Uh so the Twitter sort of allowing me to kind of have my opinions live out loud was a really good kind of testing ground to then start writing to start, you know, sort of this practice. Um I mean, I've also been massively burned by Twitter. So good times, good times. Uh never let your tweets go viral. Um so yeah, I I I so I think it's a really important tool. I wouldn't I wouldn't be working in the UK in the way in which I am without Twitter. I mean, it you know, it eliminates a lot of borders and boundaries and space and limits for people.

Um, you know, and because it is a written medium, for me, it was exactly what I needed. And it was the it was it is a format and a style that suits my voice really, really well. Twitter basically makes criticism democratic.

[40:19] Jose Solís: And there's also the fact that there's paywalls, a lot of the outlets that we all write for. So I also think it's our responsibility on Twitter to not, I don't want to I need a I need a good word for this. Someone help me. Because it's not digest, but it's like maybe turn into bite-sized uh turn our larger ideas into bite-sized invitations for people to participate in dialogue with us. Twitter not only humanizes us, but it helps us be more grounded because we are very lucky to be doing what we do. And we are very privileged. We need to not only let people into the actual space, but we need to let people know that we want to talk to them. Like it's it is so uh it's not boring, but I would rather not only talk about theater with other theater people.

There's nothing that I love more than to hear people's dissenting opinions, and even that word is so ugly. Uh you know, I I love hearing people's different opinions. Like, I don't, you know, I don't like the idea of like dissenting opinions or contrarian opinions because it just pits people against each other. And the truth is that we're all just so different that I'm just like I'm just so fascinated by your worldview, regardless of your, you know what you are, and that's what I love.

[41:42] Jose Solís: So I wasn't on Twitter until like two years ago, and I got it because of being a critic, and I was told this is like a really great forum to talk about theater. I'm not on Instagram. I don't love social media that's about like visual things and like our bodies and getting likes. So I really do like Twitter that's about being like funny and witty and sharing your writing and having like conversations, not about like selfies. Um, but social media has become such a really, really big thing, and it's really helped me think about like your first question about who I'm writing for, like unexpectedly, because of the kinds of pieces I'm writing that are usually like attacking establishment. I like very quickly, very unexpectedly got a massive number of teenage and young adult followers on Twitter that are like Broadway stands and like know every understudy's name and are like obsessed, and it's like a whole world I did not know existed.

Like I thought I was a theater nerd in high school, but I was not at this level. And I love them, and I've learned so much about how young people engage with theater, and it's really informed the kind of things that I want to write.

[42:54] Jose Solís: I just wrote a piece about like young adult theater and the lightning thief, and about like a disconnect that's happening between critics and audiences and the people writing the shows and the representation we're getting. And that was so inspired by me being on social media and me learning so much on Twitter from my young fans that like my writing and I talk to a lot. But I do think that separate from just me personally, that Twitter is of such an important space for theater critics, because we're liking each other's work, we're sharing each other's work, we're subtweeting each other, we're debating about different things, and I think it's a really unexpectedly important space for theater criticism.

[43:32] Christian Lewis: If you could change one thing about the current ecosystem of theater criticism, what would it be?

[43:37] Jose Solís: I would change the demographic of who the critics are that everyone's reading and that are getting published. I think it's I'm really young, so it's easy for me to be like bitter that every all the critics are like much older than me and all the same people, and they're all getting paid a lot, and I'm not, and everyone's reading them and they're not reading me. But I really, it's just like it's not just about me, and I'd be fine if I wasn't a theater critic, but also if they weren't a theater critic. Like I think there are just too many like straight white olds or not straight, but just too many white old men that are writing theater reviews out there. I love and respect so many of the established critics, but they're all white, middle-aged men and women.

And uh, as much as I admire their education and their insight, there are worldviews that we are missing out on, not because there's no place at the table for them, but because we don't want to make a place at the table for them.

[44:37] Jose Solís: And people need to understand that it's not when we talk about representation, we're not talking about stealing people's jobs, but talking about adding an extra plate on a table. Everything's broken. It's hard to pick just one. I feel like I'm I showed up at like the end of the party, and you know, the heyday is over, and I'm there for the like last three pieces of cheese on the cheese plate. Um, and they're sad and sweaty pieces of cheese. Um so I, you know, I'm thrilled that people pay me to write, and uh editors are always apologizing to me for what the pay is, and I'm always laughing because I'm like, well, this is more than zero. So for me, it's more than I was getting when I was blogging. Um, but I know for writers who've been at it for 20 years, like these numbers are just not uh, you know, doable. And I don't, I only freelance because I have a full-time job.

[45:31] Jose Solís: Um, and I can. And I that subsidizes my ability to do that. Uh, you know, and that also sucks because the people who can work in this space then are very, you know, you're limited by who can afford to do this. And that's a problem fundamentally. I think it's also a problem that simply I don't know why you would ever encourage young people to go into this field going forward if it's a field that might not really exist in the form that it is now in five years from now. And I've had, you know, critics say, Oh, I want you to talk to this young person, talk them out of becoming a critic. And I've had multiple critics try to talk me out of becoming a critic. So, you know, it is, you know, it is a thing we're passing all along, which is sort of sad because I want criticism to exist. And I mean, that's why Xian exists, you know, it's a volunteer platform and no one's getting paid, and we're all doing it because we love it or care about it or whatever.

[46:24] Jose Solís: And for me, in my head, it's sort of well, it's a place I want people to be able to start out and be able to get some clips and move on from there, hopefully, maybe to more paid work down the road, which is what how it worked for me. Um, but I don't even know if that road exists for them in the future. So, yeah, I mean, I'd like to see it still be a career choice for people, which is such a crazy thing to say. I was able to write for as long as I did uh before getting the job I have now is a job, is a real job. Uh, and it uh is a luxury that I'm still getting used to. Um it's really, really thrilling.

[47:02] Jose Solís: But the reason I was able to uh work as a theater critic for 14 or 15 years before I got an actual job doing it, uh, was because I had a day job that I worked that entire time that paid my way. Uh I very rarely made very much money writing criticism. Uh I think the most I ever made in a year was something like $15,000, and that was uh right at the end of my the freelance career. Uh and that is uh I was able to do it and I was willing to do it, but it means that uh there are so many people who can't do it.

[47:44] Ben Brantley: So the fact that there's no jobs, uh there's only freelance opportunities is I for me the main issue because it also means that some of our best writers are having to wear two hats.

[47:56] Ben Brantley: And so uh a lot of really interesting writers are also having to edit because that's where the actual job is. Uh imagine if you know people just had the luxury to just write. They didn't also have to do the listings, they didn't also have to, you know, commission a piece. Uh and then and then because of that, that is what has led, I think, or is uh allowing to continue to exist this sort of massive age, gender, not gender so much anymore, but uh certainly age and race disparity, is that you uh have uh it's not a bargain that everyone is able to make. It's not available to everybody.

[48:37] Ben Brantley: Uh saying to a young person, you're gonna work for 15 years and you will never make any money at this, and then maybe at the end of it there will be one of the five jobs in the city. Maybe you'll get that, is uh not the way to welcome in new voices, new talent. Uh and it's and it's what has left us with um a very increasingly diverse but still quite white group of people.

[49:04] Ben Brantley: And uh and also uh people think of me as a young critic, which is hilarious because I'm 43, I'm so old. And but that's how distorted it is.

[49:17] Christian Lewis: It's because, you know, we everything has to be shifted way forward because the opportunities for actually young people are so paltry.

[49:26] Ben Brantley: I mean, to me, honestly, the way to solve it is universal health care. Because I think if you have uh if if you if a person could live on $15,000 a year, oh, that changes the whole situation. If $15,000 a year means that you live with six roommates somewhere, okay. But you can't live on $15,000 a year if it means you'll die if you're hit by a truck.

[49:51] Ben Brantley: So uh so I think that in a way I don't actually expect suddenly money to come flooding into the theater. That just that isn't that it hasn't worked that way since Syracuse, you know.

[50:02] Ben Brantley: Uh but uh the but what we could be doing is we could be actually building a New York again where you know you could be Edward Albee and you could make a living as a telegram man. Oscar Eustace talks a lot about the fact that democracy and theater were invented in the same town in the same decade.

[50:23] Ben Brantley: And uh core to Athenian democracy was the jury, not the judge, but the jury. Obviously, their juries were enormous, uh 50, 100 men. And if theater criticism were truly healthy, that's what our juries would look like too.

[50:42] Ben Brantley: When William Gibson wrote The Season, uh he William Goldman wrote The Season, William Gibson wrote Neuromancer, kind of different. Uh when William Goldman wrote the season, he there's one throwaway line in it that just kills me, in which he says, you know, I've done a quick survey of how many Broadway critics there are on any given opening night, and there's about a hundred and ten. At which point I think about throwing myself in front of the nearest bus because a hundred and ten opening night critics.

[51:11] Ben Brantley: But that's the size of an Athenian jury, right? Is that actually no, no, no, we are not judges. No. But we are jury members, as is every member of the audience. We are jury members, and so we can write down what we think, we can give our judgment to be joint put into the common group of judgments.

[51:32] Christian Lewis: Um I don't, because I I do, you know, a lot of talk recently has been about the aggression that is that is inherent in criticism. And that is true too.

[51:42] Ben Brantley: That is, uh, criticism is an aggressive act. Anytime that someone speaks to you honestly about what they think of something that you made when you were in a position of vulnerability, what they are doing is they're doing something aggressive.

[51:54] Jose Solís: Uh you get a haircut, your mother says that looks stupid, that's aggressive. Uh on the other hand, uh, you know, isn't it better to know than not to know? Uh and and also uh again, if we constantly remind ourselves that we are a member of a jury and we are not the judge, uh it is it diffuses that responsibility, and I think it actually allows us to become more honest and more specific about our responses.

[52:21] Christian Lewis: For our final question, what do you think is in store for the future of theater criticism? If we do not take the steps right now, like climate change, it won't change at all. It'll just be this removed, remote, completely classist form that people, you know, people think we're bad people. Like people are like, oh fuck critics. I'm gonna go do whatever we want. Uh, we're gonna go do whatever we want. And we need to take steps to make people know that we want them to be a part of what we're doing, that we're not writing for fucking Marie Antoinette and you know, Versailles. We are writing for everyone, and we want people to be a part of what we are doing.

[53:10] Christian Lewis: I, you know, if I put my future classes on right now, I would probably say the same things that we're doing right now, and I don't like it. I but if I put my classes on and like have a podcast shot, I would see different mediums, and I would see us respecting different mediums more. I would see critics groups and organizations allowing people without you know their idea of what they think a critic should be or look like, enter these spaces and enter these clubs. I also would like to challenge theater makers and artists to tell us stories in a different way that challenge the way that we approach our work. I want us to challenge the form more, and I want us to stop thinking that we know that we've arrived at the ultimate form of criticism. I want that motherfucking cookie review.

[54:05] Christian Lewis: I don't know. I'm really worried because I, you know, I do edit a platform that invites new writers and anyone to come and bring their opinions, and I'm not getting, you know, as many emails as I used to. Um, people aren't hitting me up for, you know, oh, I'm interested in maybe writing for you guys. And you know, that could be just me. Nobody wants to write for me. It's fine. Um, but I think it actually might be a little bit more indicative of a space where you know, people aren't really, I mean, again, are being sort of discouraged from pursuing it. And I like to think, I mean, I talk a lot about it on Twitter and I like to be transparent. I like to, you know, talk about the fact that I have three jobs.

I'm an attorney, I am a freelance journalist, and I'm an editor of a website, and I treat those as three separate jobs. Um, but they I also want people to know that like those things can coexist and do coexist, and it doesn't have to be all or nothing. It doesn't have to be I have to, you know, live on ramen and have 12,000 roommates to be able to become a journalist, and that's the only path here. Um, or I have to have a degree in this, and I have to spend all this money on a graduate degree. And I I feel very it's very important to let people know there aren't those limits, and that really, you know, it is it is about having opinions, but it's also about being able to write. And it's those two things together that make you a critic, and you can do that if you, you know, hone those skills. And I, you know, I want there to be a space for people to do this.

[55:33] Christian Lewis: And I think the difficulties around criticism has lately has a lot been about sort of professionalism and what makes a professional. And I spent years putting quotes around the word, oh, I'm a critic with quotes. I, you know, I never felt like I could just come out and say I was a critic because of all of those reasons. And, you know, I I don't want other people to feel sheepish about it. I think, you know, um, we need to encourage, I you know, I want this space to continue, I want this profession to continue, I want people to do this, and I think we need to have an understanding then that it's gonna look a lot more like what I'm doing these days than maybe what some of my, you know, sort of more senior colleagues who had a full-time newspaper job for many, many, many years look like.

[56:13] Christian Lewis: I know that a couple people, like Roxanne Gay did it a couple of times recently, that like have been like just like tweeting out reviews, like very short form, write a thread, write a single tweet review of what something is. And I, when I see shows, because I don't have time to review everything, sometimes I'm like, I could write a great thread about this. Like I don't have time for a really a thousand word polished review, but I could write a great thread about this. And sometimes I do, and sometimes I don't, because I feel like we're not there yet. But I think we're getting there, and I think that would be a really, really cool place for theater criticism to go. Theater really, I think needs to adjust.

We need to adjust how we write about theater, how we talk about theater, and what kind of theater is being produced, or like you said, like it's in danger. Like opera is really in danger, but like theater is also in danger. I think the future of theater criticism is going to be people who write uh cultural criticism, and that theater is one pillar within that.

[57:07] Christian Lewis: So let's talk about like Soraya McDonald, for instance, who writes for The Undefeated. Her areas of expertise are theater, opera, and tennis. She's a per and television, she's been writing about The Watchmen. She is, and she's very good at those four pillars. And I think that's actually the way that criticism gets healthy, is because it means that her audiences for those four different things are interlocking and braiding and reading all the different things that she has to say about the different forms. Her people who read her about Serena Williams are also reading her about Watchmen, which means they're also reading her about Oklahoma. That's good. That is good for the health of criticism.

It is also good for the health of the culture. And I think that's probably the future is that because of the way that the internet works, the internet wants us to kind of diversify and to scramble our interests and to share them as opposed to just being one trick pony like me. I think that is, I think that's what you're getting is you're getting people who can write. If you read Vincent Cunningham, for instance, he can write about film in a way that I wouldn't, I I mean, I could only dream about being able to write about uh film and music. So you get these people who are actually polymaths, and that the internet and social media is actually a very welcoming place for the polymath. Um for the monomaniac, not so much, but but for them it is, and I think that's probably I think that is if if the form's gonna keep getting healthier, then I think that's how it will do it.

[58:44] Christian Lewis: Well, with these five people writing about the theater, thinking about the theater, talking about the theater, I feel very good about the future of theater criticism.

[58:53] Rob Russo: So do I, right? I mean, you know, there's obviously a lot that folks just talked about that is alarming about the discipline itself. Um, but it's so intrinsic to doing theater, right? Theater criticism. It's it's it's a part of it. And I don't know how you can have theater without theater criticism. Um I feel pretty hopeful. And I hope what came across over the course of this episode is how much the people who write about the theater love the theater, right? Because I, you know, these critics, they're they're a bit of a mystery, I think, to most people. Um their names are bylines that you might see in passing, or you know, you look for a certain person's pieces. Um, but if they were walking down the street, or if you saw them in the theater, you wouldn't know who they are.

Um, and they're sort of anonymous, and you know, we asked that question: are you are our critics a part of the theater community? And there's, you know, some people think they are, some people think they aren't. And um, regardless of where you land on that, I think they're a very anonymous part of the theater world. And I don't know that many people would disagree with that. Um so this was a real treat. I'm glad we got to do it. And I hope that that that sense of the of love and affection for the theater came across over the course of the episode. I think if we've learned one thing in doing the show for a year and a half, is that pretty much everyone that works in the theater does it because they love the theater.

[1:00:14] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, they don't do it for the money. They don't they don't do it for the money. It's certainly not the critics. I also think it's interesting this the the anonymity that comes with being a theater critic. It reminds me sort of of a food critic, right?

[1:00:24] Rob Russo: Yeah, but totally. Nobody really knew what Frank Bruni looked like when he wrote for the Times, and I think this or much about him. Now we know a great deal about him because he's in a different capacity. Right. And as a writer, and and I think the same is true of Ben Brantley. And I feel like most of the critics, with the exception of some of the younger critics who were on Twitter, and that was something we talked about too, which is you know, the the how social media has changed that and who uses social media and who doesn't.

[1:00:51] Jamie DuMont: Right. And I just think it's interesting as we look towards the future of criticism and and how it's going to change and how that format changes, we might get to know the critics a bit more.

[1:01:02] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah. You know, um, I'm glad you just brought up Ben Brantley because if you're listening to the episode, you might have noticed that there was there was a lot more of Ben at the beginning, and there was less of him as as as time went on. Um and the reason for that is that we actually did a full sit-down interview, a a classic fabulous invalid episode interview with um with Ben Brantley that is gonna be airing later in the season.

[1:01:23] Jamie DuMont: So how could we not?

[1:01:24] Rob Russo: Exactly. Right. I mean, I think, you know, uh, with respect to everyone, you know, I I'm I'm a critic, um, and we talk to you know a bunch of different folks. Um, you know, Ben Brantley occupies sort, you know, certainly his own kind of space uh in the theater world because he's been doing it for so long, right? And doing it so for so long at the sort of top post, if you will, um, as the chief theater critic uh New York Times for 20. He's been at the Times for 27 years. It's remarkable.

[1:01:50] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, which is a longevity that, you know, um is is nearly unmatched. I mean, Brook Brooks Atkinson was was at the Times, I think for about 30 or 40 years. So, you know, he's Ben's on his way to uh to achieving that success.

[1:02:06] Rob Russo: For a long time, yeah, from the 20s to the 60s. Do you think someday there'll be a Ben Brantley Theater?

[1:02:11] Jamie DuMont: I don't know.

[1:02:12] Rob Russo: I don't know. You know, it's funny. There are there are two theaters on Broadway named after critics, and uh the Walter Kerr and the Brooks Atkinson. And there's a theater named after a publicist, uh Samuel J. Friedman. Um but it's funny, you know, it makes you wonder if if any of today's critics would get a, you know, it's it's from such an earlier era that those theaters were named.

[1:02:34] Jamie DuMont: Well, I know if you had your way, there'd be a Helen Shaw right away.

[1:02:38] Rob Russo: There absolutely would. I think I'm gonna unmask myself right here. I am a diehard Helen Shaw fan. Let's break ground on that theater now. I would I would welcome, I would I would donate money to the Helen Shaw Theater. Uh I would be delighted for that to happen.

[1:02:54] Jamie DuMont: Amazing. Um well, with that perfect setup, we're actually gonna close the episode with something uh that Helen said that we thought was quite poignant. Peter Sellers said, a show is over when you stop thinking about it. That's how long a show is. Show could be 50 minutes long, but it doesn't end until you stop thinking about it. It's like, you know, the belief that says you don't die until the last person on earth says your name for the last time. And the same goes with shows. It's that shows are the tip of the iceberg is the event in the theater. And then the bulk of that thing is actually what it does to you for the rest of your life.

[1:03:42] Rob Russo: Rob here, that's our show. Thanks for listening. You can hear us anytime on iTunes and wherever you find podcasts. And if you like what you hear, rate and review us. You can find us online at the Fabulous Invalid.com and on social media at Fabulous Invalid. The Fabulous Invalid is a production of OM etcetera and the Fabulous Invalid LLC and a proud member of the amazing Broadway Podcast Network. Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Aaron Kaufman and Charles Van Kirk. Be sure to tune in next Wednesday.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred