On this week’s show, Jamie and Rob close season two with the final installation of their special three part mini-series looking at some of the biggest Broadway musical hits of all time... Read More
From the show: The Fabulous Invalid
Guests
Featured Shows
About
On this week’s show, Jamie and Rob close season two with the final installation of their special three part mini-series looking at some of the biggest Broadway musical hits of all time. In part three, the British Invasion lands on our shores, and a Windy City murderess, an iconic mask, a helicopter, and La Vie Bohème visit Broadway! At the top of the episode, the always fabulous Jennifer Simard stops by to check in and say farewell for the summer.
This week’s music: “Overture”, “McCavity”, “Memory”, and “Skimbelshanks" from “Cats”, “La Journée”, “I Dreamed A Dream”, “Turning” from “Les Miserables”, “Overture”, and “Wishing You Were Here” from “The Phantom of the Opera”. “Movie In My Mind”, “I’d Give My Life For You” and “American Dream” from “Miss Saigon”, Willamania” from “The Will Rogers Follies”, “Rent”, “I’ll Cover You”, “Seasons Of Love” and “Take Me For What I Am” all from “Rent”. “Overture”, “I Can’t Do It Alone”, “All That Jazz” from Chicago” “He Lives In You”, from “The Lion King”, “Overture” and “The Face” from “The Producers”. “Mamma Mia” and “The Winner Takes All”, from “Mamma Mia”, “Popular”, “For Good” from “Wicked” and “I Believe” from “The Book of Mormon”.
Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid
Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid
Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc
Email us at: info@fabulousinvalid.com
2 Jamie Du Mont
Twitter: @jamiedumont
Instagram: @troutinnyc
Rob Russo
Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC
Jennifer Simard
Twitter: @SimardJennifer
Instagram: @thejennifersimard
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:19] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important, and innovative theater makers working today, from actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.
[0:33] Rob Russo: We took our name from the title of a 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself, always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back, The Fabulous Invalid.
[0:45] Jamie DuMont: I'm Jamie DuMont.
[0:47] Rob Russo: I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with StageLeft.
[0:52] Jennifer Simard: And I'm Raspberry Picking Mogul Jennifer Simard.
[0:57] Jamie DuMont: Raspberry picking mogul.
[0:58] Rob Russo: Have you been picking a lot of raspberries?
[1:00] Jennifer Simard: I go on a lot of nature walks and it's raspberry season, so I'm in the empire business now.
[1:06] Jamie DuMont: You guys pivoted.
[1:08] Jennifer Simard: That's what I'm doing.
[1:10] Rob Russo: Well, it's good that you have at long last found something that's suited to your particular talents.
[1:14] Jennifer Simard: And it's my passion, you know.
[1:17] Jennifer Simard: I've, you know, I fought I'm following my bliss.
[1:21] Jamie DuMont: What's, uh, what are those other catchphrases?
[1:23] Jennifer Simard: I'm living authentically.
[1:24] Rob Russo: Okay.
[1:25] Jennifer Simard: You're living your best life.
[1:26] Jamie DuMont: I'm living my best life.
[1:27] Jennifer Simard: What you know.
[1:28] Rob Russo: Yeah, so there it is.
[1:30] Jamie DuMont: Well, obviously, if you're listening to us right now, you know that Jennifer Simard is back in the fold with us today.
[1:37] Jennifer Simard: Hi, Jen.
[1:38] Jamie DuMont: Hi, my friends.
[1:40] Rob Russo: I should actually say, Hi, Jennifer.
[1:43] Jamie DuMont: Hi, Jennifer Jean.
[1:45] Jennifer Simard: You know, when I was a kid, I used to, you know, kids they play with their names. They used to be Jennifer Jean, JJ, Jenny, Jennifer Simard.
[1:52] Jamie DuMont: Isn't that stupid?
[1:53] Jennifer Simard: I know.
[1:54] Jennifer Simard: And do you know, did I ever tell you this? If I had picked a stage name, do you know what it was gonna be?
[1:58] Rob Russo: No, tell us.
[1:59] Jennifer Simard: Seth Rodetsky loves it so much because it's so awful. So my name's Jennifer Jean. So my nickname was JJ. So I thought it was, but I didn't like Simard for, you know, it didn't sound good enough. So JJ Stryker.
[2:10] Rob Russo: Isn't that terrible?
[2:12] Jennifer Simard: It sounds like a 1980s detective show.
[2:15] Rob Russo: It sounds like a porn name.
[2:17] Jennifer Simard: Well, that was my first thought was porn.
[2:19] Rob Russo: Or a soccer player.
[2:20] Jennifer Simard: JJ. Actually, I wanted Striver, but I was so young. I thought, and then I looked up what striving meant. I was like, oh no, that's terrible. So I switched it to Stryker, JJ Stryker.
[2:29] Rob Russo: So is it S-T-R-Y?
[2:32] Jennifer Simard: Yes, with a Y.
[2:33] Rob Russo: I remember that.
[2:41] Jennifer Simard: I feel like it needs an exclamation point.
[2:43] Rob Russo: JJ Stryker.
[2:45] Jennifer Simard: Right.
[2:45] Rob Russo: For my porn star soccer playing detective raspberry picking future.
[2:52] Jennifer Simard: Yeah.
[2:53] Rob Russo: Wow, that's a lot of, that's that ticks so many boxes.
[2:56] Jennifer Simard: I don't know.
[2:56] Rob Russo: That's a multi-hyphenate.
[2:58] Jennifer Simard: That's what they call that.
[2:59] Rob Russo: That's what they're calling.
[3:00] Jennifer Simard: So they do.
[3:01] Jamie DuMont: How are you guys?
[3:03] Jennifer Simard: How are you?
[3:04] Jamie DuMont: You know, I'm good. It's, uh, you know, it's summer. It's summer in the city, and, uh, we can't do anything.
[3:11] Rob Russo: Wear a mask.
[3:12] Jennifer Simard: Wear a mask.
[3:13] Jamie DuMont: Hey, you know what? I'm looking for positive things these days in a sea of suck. And, uh, I will say on July 1st, I had a moment where I thought, you know, back in March during the shutdown, July seemed so far away.
[3:29] Jamie DuMont: Like to me, that seemed like the outer limit of when we might come back, and it just seemed ages away. And as I look forward to how long we're going to have to do this, I can't believe it's July already, you know? And if you look at it in terms of four-month blocks, okay, so we're, you know, we're four months in, that's good. And I just, um, and I've read that a few companies are already entering phase three of vaccine trials this month and next. And that's, you know, that's really, that's good news.
[3:59] Rob Russo: So anyway, I'm trying to see some silver lining.
[4:02] Jennifer Simard: Totally.
[4:03] Rob Russo: It's all about a vaccine.
[4:04] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, if nothing else, this pandemic has really proven the elasticity of time, right?
[4:11] Jennifer Simard: Timey whimey wibbly wobbly, as they say in Doctor Who.
[4:14] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[4:15] Jamie DuMont: I think that's a perfect summation.
[4:17] Rob Russo: Well, time is a construct, that is for sure.
[4:20] Jamie DuMont: Um, and our time for season two of the Fabulous Invalid has drawn to a close. This is our last episode before we take a short break for the summer. We will be back in the fall.
[4:31] Rob Russo: So we thought that it would be fun to get the band back together for just a quick second and check in and say hello, which we are doing.
[4:38] Jamie DuMont: And I also thought it could be fun since when we started this show, uh, two years ago on our first episode with Joel Gray, we talked a little bit about the renaming of the gypsy robe to the legacy robe ceremony. Um, and I thought it would be interesting because now we're at another crossroads, um, in the world in a variety of ways, but particularly with the new, I don't know how you would say it, the new name change of um the great white way to the great bright way, um, which has stirred up a little bit of controversy on Twitter.
[5:16] Rob Russo: I think most people seem to be, um, very pro it. I I don't remember how it got started. I think Rob does, but I just wanted to throw it out to the group and see if we had any thoughts or feelings about it.
[5:27] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, well, I yeah, I I believe it was Whoopi Goldberg on The View who mused that it's time to change that phrase. And I, you know, it seems to me that some of the controversy, you know, if you can call it that, it might be nontroversy, but some of the buzz around, uh, this phrase is that, um, of course, if you know the phrase the great white way, it doesn't refer to skin color, it refers to the lights of Broadway, which you know historically were all white, uh, because that's you know what, what, uh, electricity was like in the in the early days. Um, so you know, so some people are like, okay, does is this really, you know, helping anything? Is this one of those symbolic things that actually doesn't achieve much? Or is it a nod to the fact that you know Broadway has been tragically and traditionally a very white space in terms of you know personnel? Um, and maybe, you know, maybe it's time to change the way we we use that word.
[6:23] Rob Russo: So, um, I don't I don't feel strongly either way. So my inclination is just to say if folks want to call it the Great Bright Way, let's do it.
[6:33] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, you know to me it's sort of it's the I equate it to sort of the the addition of the stripes to the gay flag, which when that happened a few years ago, I I wasn't very pro that at the time, because for me, the gay flag, it what it represents is everyone, it includes everyone. So at the time, my original thought was well, we don't need to add any additional stripes. However, in the last two years, listening to the world and everything that's been going on, I've come to realize that look, if you feel not included, if you feel marginalized, if you don't feel like you're part of a group, and this thing helps bridge that gap or helps you feel included, then I am a hundred percent for it.
[7:18] Jennifer Simard: I think my point of view, uh, tends toward absolutely changing the name. Again, it's not up to me, the white woman, to I think say yes or no. If you're the disenfranchised party, if you're the one that's not included, then if then by all means, you know, let's make it as inclusive as possible. It sort of reminds me of the renaming of statues or, um, uh, brand names or names of towns. And I I have some, um, uh, people that I know in my orbit who are, uh, not of my political persuasion who are extremely frustrated by all of that, and like, oh, this is so ridiculous. I'm like, no, well, you're not the one who has to look at a statue of someone who subjugated, uh, your entire, uh, ancestry for hundreds of years. So why don't you STFU? Uh, because it has enough, you know. So, um, so no, I'm all for it. Absolutely. 100%.
[8:18] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I agree. I think we I think we now live in a world where we need to listen more, everyone. We need to be kinder. And, uh, we need to do everything we can, A, to make the world a better place, but B, to make everybody feel like they matter and that they're valued and that they are included. And we're not there yet. But let's hope that we can get there because it's important.
[8:42] Rob Russo: Yeah, and you know, and small gestures like this also have the, you know, capacity to make a big impact, which is what you're alluding to, you know. So, um, you know, it's easy enough to just change it. It's not written down anywhere, it's not law. It's it's a matter of, you know, how we talk and the words we use. And, you know, of course, they can be very impactful.
[9:01] Jennifer Simard: Words matter, as I love to say.
[9:03] Rob Russo: You do love to say that.
[9:04] Jennifer Simard: I do. It's my favorite saying ever.
[9:06] Jamie DuMont: Um, well, on that note, we have a Rob and I have a big show today. We're finishing out our sort of marathon look at, uh, flops and hits. Uh, today is part three of our hits. We're gonna we're gonna deal with a lot of shows in the recent years.
[9:24] Rob Russo: And, um, and I think we should get to that. But before we do, I just want to tell Jennifer Simard that I love her and that I am very excited to, um, see you again soon when the world can do that.
[9:39] Jennifer Simard: And, uh, I hope you have a wonderful summer.
[9:41] Jamie DuMont: I hope you all have a wonderful summer too. Not just the two of you, my friends, but everyone listening. And just remember take it one day at a time because each day is a challenge, mentally, physically, financially, and spiritually. And, uh, we're gonna get through it. So just stay the course.
[9:55] Rob Russo: Yay, let's hope we do.
[9:59] Jamie DuMont: All righty. Well, on that note, let's get to our show.
[10:01] Rob Russo: Let's do it.
[10:07] Jamie DuMont: Moving on to our seventh category, it is the British invasion. So in the 1980s, there was a Broadway was a host to a ton of imports from the West End, some of them not so successful, but some of them becoming like the most successful Broadway shows, if not ever, uh, certainly for a long time.
[10:27] Rob Russo: And it's interesting, I went back and compared some of the numbers. From the 1984, 1985 Broadway season to the present, annual Broadway attendance has doubled from 7.2 million to 14.7 million, uh, representing a leap in grosses that far outnumbers that from 209 million to 1.8 billion dollars. And part of that growth, both in butts in the seats and money spent on tickets, was driven by the shows that we're going to talk about right now and the ones that followed, which is the making of Broadway as a massive tourist destination twice over, right?
[11:07] Jamie DuMont: Far outstripping what A Chorus Line did in the 70s. Really taking that baton and just running with it. And of course, you know, the British invasion kind of began with Jesus Christ Superstar and Evita in the 1970s, two Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals that came to Broadway, but then was really defined in the 1980s by, uh, the shows that Cameron Mackintosh produced on Broadway, starting with, of course, Cats.
[11:53] Rob Russo: It's very close to my heart.
[11:58] Jamie DuMont: And I know that's a controversial take, uh, in today's cancel culture, so don't cancel me.
[12:35] Rob Russo: It premiered on Broadway in 1982 and ran 18 years, closing uh, in September of 2000, making it the longest-running show and musical on Broadway, a title it held from 1997 until 2006. And not only was it a huge, you know, success here, running 7,485 performances at the Winter Garden Theater, never changing theaters, and for very good reason. It ran in London from even longer from 1981 until uh 2002, I believe. So over, you know, almost nearly 9,000 performances over there. And, you know, was just a phenomenon unto itself. And to this day, I feel like no one can really explain why. I mean, Cats is sort of this mystery. Uh, it certainly was in its development. Andrew Lloyd Webber sort of the lore goes, was tired of collaborating with other people, and by other people I mean Tim Rice, and decided he wanted to write something that he could write solely on his own and returned to T.S. Eliot's old possums book of practical cats, which was a collection of poems that he had written for his um nieces and nephews about cats, anthropomorphized cats.
And they were written actually, I think Andrew Lloyd Webber discovered that T.S. Eliot had written them while listening to music. And so they lended themselves to a natural lyricism that he discovered while um setting them to, uh, to his own original, uh, music. And that was Cats.
[14:18] Jamie DuMont: You may be scared of ice. You may be as well. But when a crime's discovered, my team. When a crime's discovered, then the cavity's not there. I will say, the one thing I will slightly correct you on is I think he had, I think, I think Andrew Lloyd Weber did have a collaborator on this. I mean, he did have T.S. Elliott. The nice thing is he didn't have to deal with T.S. Elliott not liking his ideas or challenging him. He was left solely to his own devices. Yes, yes. With that. And you know, I have to say, look, I have in my life, I've gone hot and cold on Cats. I will say, one of the many gifts that you have brought to my life, Rob Russo, is I have rediscovered my love for Cats, and I will defend it.
I will die on that hill. I also understand why people drive people bad. I get both things. I will say this. We've talked to a couple of people, particularly Betty Buckley, about the creation of not only her character, but of the show. And I think the thing that everyone says about that original production and the work that they did is that they were very serious actors. And they approached Trevor Nunn was the director. I mean the RSC. I mean, what's more serious than that? And so I think what gets diluted throughout the years is the fact that Cats was a very serious piece from an actor's perspective. And that those actors all took it very seriously, as did the set designer, as did the choreographer.
Everybody who created Cats did not look at it as a joke or as something to be ridiculed. They looked at it as art and that they were creating something very important. And that I think gets forgotten.
[17:37] Rob Russo: Cats won seven 1983 Tony Awards, including Best Musical, but it lost for both choreography and set design, which are two of the most, you know, important features of the show and what make it so successful. Jillian Lynn losing to Tommy Toon for My One and Only, and John Napier losing to Ming Cho Lee for K2, because there wasn't a breakout of set design for musical, set design for play back then, right? But that changed pretty quickly.
[18:01] Jamie DuMont: I bet it did, because the set for Cats was unbelievable. As we already mentioned, 42nd Street left the Winter Garden Theater to make way for Cats. And the Schuberts had just finished a restoration of the Winter Garden Theater. And if you have seen Cats, or if you especially if you saw that original production, you know that it was somewhat of an immersive experience. And they had to paint the entire auditorium black and then cover it with trash to create the set design, which was, I mean, truly, I mean, I saw it in the 90s, and I'll never forget sitting in that auditorium. It was so cool. Well, so much so that it became part of the event, right? Eventually during the run, they would let you go up on stage during the intermission, which they didn't do originally.
Part of the success of the show, of course, you know, it's thought of as a kid's show, and for a lot of people it was their first Broadway show. It was for my brother and sister. I saw something else before I saw Cats.
[19:00] Rob Russo: Oh, well, now you have to tell us what that was.
[19:04] Jamie DuMont: Well, I saw I saw Damn Yankees with Jerry Lewis. You know, I knew that actually. That was my first Broadway show.
[19:09] Rob Russo: And wasn't it Charlotte? Wasn't Charlotte Dambois in it at that point?
[19:12] Jamie DuMont: Well, she was out that night. I saw Nancy Hess, who was—
[19:13] Rob Russo: Oh, I love Nancy Hess.
[19:18] Jamie DuMont: She had to have been great.
[19:19] Rob Russo: Okay.
[19:19] Jamie DuMont: Well, from my eight-year-old memory, yes, she was fantastic. But Cats, the thing that I, you know, I've thought about this a lot, probably longer than I probably should.
[19:29] Rob Russo: Oh, for sure.
[19:30] Jamie DuMont: And, you know, it's the reason for the show's success is best explained by a story that Bernie Jacobs would tell. Bernie Jacobs was, you know, the head of the Schubert organization at the time. And he saw the show in London with his wife, Betty, I believe, who just passed away. And they brought their grandson with them. And they were somewhat mystified by it. They were like, this is very strange and very odd, and why are all these cats singing and dancing? But their grandson was transfixed. So much so that it finished, and he said, Can we see it again? And they were like, you know what? If our grandson wants to see this show again, this is the right show to book in a Schubert house. And they gave the Winter Garden.
They forced 42nd Street to leave. They gave the Winter Garden to Andrew Lloyd Weber and Cameron Macintosh, and they put the show on Broadway because it does, I think, require a childlike willingness to get lost in the fantasy of it in order to truly enjoy it. And I think that's why a lot of adults have a hard time with it, and a lot of people ridicule it because they're unwilling to let themselves exist in a world in which Cats is the reality, right? And that's what the show does so thrillingly, whether or not you're interested in that or whether it's your taste, you can't deny that the show brings you into a different world in a way that few other musicals ever have, both before or since. And I admire that ambition.
I mean, I don't think Cats could happen today because I don't know that there would be people willing to give that artistic license and to spend that much money on something that is, you know, on its face, tremendously risky.
[21:11] Rob Russo: Well, God take that little gay grandson.
[21:15] Jamie DuMont: We don't know if he was gay, but he probably was.
[21:19] Rob Russo: Oh, I think we know.
[21:28] Jamie DuMont: They all could be fed. It was very nice to know that they wouldn't be bothered by mice. They would leave all that to the railway cat. The cat on the railway train.
[21:51] Rob Russo: Well, Cats ran for almost 18 years at the Winter Garden Theater, like I said. It grossed 407 million dollars, which makes it the 11th highest grossing show in Broadway history, but has grossed over three billion dollars worldwide. The show has been running continuously in Japan since 1983. And I was so bummed when I was in Japan three years ago that I didn't get tickets until I didn't think to get tickets until I got there. And of course, it was sold out because Cats still sells out in Japan every night because it's a sensation. Obviously, they filmed the West End production in 1998, and then there was the film in 2019.
[22:29] Jamie DuMont: I'm still back on the story that you went to Japan and didn't see Cats in Japan. To me, you've buried the lead in Osaka, and I was there for four days and I didn't see it.
[22:41] Rob Russo: Yeah, I feel I feel, yeah, I feel like I should have known the story. I feel a little um I feel uncomfortable right now. I feel like our friendship is based on a lie.
[22:51] Jamie DuMont: So well, there was that Broadway revival in 2016, which I saw again a redacted number of times.
[22:57] Rob Russo: Oh, you became a spokesperson for that show, and I have the video to prove it.
[23:02] Jamie DuMont: I was interviewed on New York One about it. That is true. I was at the final performance.
[23:05] Rob Russo: Uh and what were you wearing, Rob?
[23:07] Jamie DuMont: Cat ears.
[23:08] Rob Russo: And when we saw the 2019 film, what were we wearing, Rob?
[23:12] Jamie DuMont: Cat ears. You gotta wear cat ears. You gotta it's about it's about having that willingness to engage with the material. That's what I've always said about Cats.
[23:21] Rob Russo: Well, dear listener, I have photos of both, and I will show them to the world. We'll be on the internet before too long.
[23:27] Jamie DuMont: All righty. Well, moving on to our second mega hit of the British invasion. We're here a while, people, just so we'll keep it along in a nice clip. The second is, of course, Les Miserables.
[23:39] Rob Russo: I have to say, I have very little to contribute to this because I too have something to confess.
[23:44] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I never saw Le Miz in its original Broadway run. In fact, true. This is true. I did not see Le Miz until a friend of mine went into the tour. And I traveled to Philadelphia to see them perform in the tour. That was my first experience with Le Miz.
[24:06] Rob Russo: And it wasn't even the original production, right? It was a revised version that then came in and played Broadway, but it was not the turntable, you know, it was the revival, yeah.
[24:08] Jamie DuMont: It was the revival, but before that revival came to Broadway, it toured the country for like a year or something.
[24:23] Rob Russo: I saw it in DC.
[24:24] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. I have to say, um, and I don't mean this in a patronizing way. I feel sorry for you, Jamie, because that original Broadway production was incredible. I saw it three times. I can't believe I saw it three times, and I was like a teenager. And for a long time it was the show that I had seen the most. Le Miz is, of course, based on the Victor Hugo novel, started in Paris in 1980, and then in all French, and there's a recording of it. There's a great recording of it in all French. That's pretty cool. You can see the beginnings of what would become the musical that we all know. The idea actually came from Alain Boublil, the French lyricist and co-book writer of the musical, who was seeing Oliver in London and saw Oliver on stage, and he thought of Gavroche, the character from Le Miz, and went back to Le Miz and thought, you know what?
Let's turn this into a musical. So he and Claude-Michel Schönberg, the composer, wrote that first version, and then in 1985, after a lot of development with the Royal Shakespeare Company, they produced it in London with a little known actor named Patti LuPone starring as Fantine.
[26:18] Jamie DuMont: Obviously, she was an acclaimed superstar by then. And that production is still running. That 1985 production in London is still running. Well, not right now because we're in this hellscape of a pandemic, but prior to the shutdown, it was still running. And then of course came to New York in 1987.
[26:35] Rob Russo: Without Patti LuPone.
[26:37] Jamie DuMont: Without Patti LuPone, because she had done it, and I love that about Patti LuPone. She had already done it in London, she didn't want to do it again. Actually, I believe what she says is that it was a perfect working experience. And she didn't think it could ever be recreated again, and so she wanted to live with that memory, which I love that because God knows she would have come to New York with Sunset Boulevard if she could have. And so, which, you know, that's a whole nother podcast. But that's okay. I'm just saying that like that argument everyone always says she doesn't do anything twice, and I don't, it's not entirely true. I just want to point out that Le Miz was because it was such a beautiful experience.
And I coming from an artist saying that, I think is to be respected. And that's of course, yeah, huge. And when it arrived in New York, it had the biggest advance that any musical had ever, any show had ever had with a four million dollars. It was a 4.5 million dollar production, and they already had four million dollars in ticket sales on the day that it opened. The show very famously, I don't think got very good reviews, but—
[27:34] Rob Russo: No, it did not.
[27:40] Jamie DuMont: You know, sort of instantly. There's a story. I think it was Cameron Macintosh who read the reviews and was all depressed, and then the next day called the box office and couldn't get through because the phones were ringing off the hook and then went down to the theater and there was a line around the block. And he was like, okay, we have a hit.
[27:55] Rob Russo: And a line around the block.
[27:58] Jamie DuMont: Line around the block, yes. You know, and that original production ran 16 years and two months, 6,680 performances. It remains today the sixth longest running show in Broadway history, and it's already had two revivals. So the 2006 revival at the Broadhurst, and then the 2014 revival back at the Imperial.
[28:16] Jamie DuMont: Tiny, turning, turning through the heavy, turning to the endless, unless it's a Jesus, nothing but the common bug of God from.
[28:37] Rob Russo: Oh, I forgot about the revival at the Broadhurst.
[28:41] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, in '06.
[28:42] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[28:43] Jamie DuMont: With um was Daphne Rubin Vega in that?
[28:46] Rob Russo: I believe so.
[28:47] Jamie DuMont: Oh my God.
[28:48] Rob Russo: All right, I've lied to the world.
[28:51] Jamie DuMont: I saw that production.
[28:52] Rob Russo: Yeah, this has been a journey, Jamie.
[28:54] Jamie DuMont: Wow.
[28:55] Rob Russo: Not only did I see Daphne Rubin Vega, I went back to see Leah Salonga.
[29:00] Jamie DuMont: You saw it twice.
[29:01] Rob Russo: How about that?
[29:02] Jamie DuMont: It only ran about a year.
[29:04] Rob Russo: Maybe I was drinking and I totally blocked that memory out.
[29:07] Jamie DuMont: Oh my God, I'm a fraud.
[29:09] Rob Russo: I'm glad we could unlock it though.
[29:10] Jamie DuMont: And you know, and share it here.
[29:12] Rob Russo: That was based on the original design, but scaled down a little bit, right?
[29:16] Jamie DuMont: There was a turntable, right?
[29:19] Rob Russo: Yeah, there was a turntable.
[29:20] Jamie DuMont: It was all everything was black and blue and dark, and it was a play on light, and yeah, shit.
[29:25] Rob Russo: No projections, none of that stuff.
[29:27] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[29:28] Rob Russo: Twice!
[29:28] Jamie DuMont: Twice because I went back for Leah.
[29:30] Rob Russo: And I have to say, you know, she did that track, which I don't think Daphne did.
[29:36] Jamie DuMont: She did the track where you know you have to play all the other parts after you die.
[29:40] Rob Russo: And I she wasn't as convincing as a soldier, I will, I will say.
[29:45] Jamie DuMont: Lover as I do.
[29:46] Rob Russo: She was marvelous, but well, the story that I was told, or read, I can't remember now, is that Patti LuPone, you know, as Fantine in London, was excited about the track because you come on, you sing a killer song, and then you die, and then you don't have to come back until the end of act two.
[30:02] Jamie DuMont: And when you sing a little reprise, and it's you know, wonderful, and she was like, Oh, perfect part.
[30:07] Rob Russo: So she managed to make herself not available or not around as they were staging the rest of the show, except for one day when she happened to be in the auditorium and they were staging a barricade scene and they needed bodies, and they pulled her, and she said, Oh, fuck, no, I'm gonna have to do this every night.
[30:25] Jamie DuMont: And so that's the track that you're talking about, where you play Fantine, but also you're kind of a barricade, an anonymous barricade person for a little portion of the show.
[30:35] Rob Russo: Well, Leah Salonga just looked like a little boy, right?
[30:39] Jamie DuMont: They put like a boy wig on her, and you know, she looked like she was wearing her father's clothing.
[30:43] Rob Russo: You know, it just didn't quite work.
[30:46] Jamie DuMont: But she did nail that song.
[30:47] Rob Russo: Yeah, oh, I bet.
[30:48] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[30:49] Rob Russo: Oh my gosh.
[30:49] Jamie DuMont: Well, the subtitle of the show for a long time and all of its advertising was the world's most popular musical.
[30:55] Rob Russo: And it has grossed more than 2.7 billion dollars.
[30:58] Jamie DuMont: It's been on every continent, every language.
[31:01] Rob Russo: Um on Broadway, it was 406 million dollars in grosses, and of course, was a film in 2012 by um Tom Hooper.
[31:08] Jamie DuMont: So there's no denying that Les Mis is a phenomenon and one of the greatest hits on Broadway.
[31:13] Rob Russo: It's the longest running musical on the West End because it opened before Phantom.
[31:18] Jamie DuMont: Uh, and it's only the second longest running musical in the world after The Fantasticks, which we didn't talk about because it was an off-Broadway musical, but obviously The Fantasticks ran off Broadway from 1960 to 2002, which I mean is a record that will probably someday be surpassed by Phantom of the Opera, but we shall see.
[31:37] Rob Russo: Alrighty.
[31:37] Jamie DuMont: Well, speaking of The Phantom of the Opera, it's our third show.
[31:40] Rob Russo: Another transition.
[31:42] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, another transition, you gotta have transitions.
[31:44] Rob Russo: Phantom, right?
[31:46] Jamie DuMont: I mean, come on.
[31:47] Rob Russo: The Phantom of Broadway.
[31:48] Jamie DuMont: Uh, it's been haunting the Majestic Theater since 1988.
[32:32] Rob Russo: Over 13,370 performances, 32 years.
[32:36] Jamie DuMont: Uh, and no sign of slowing down.
[32:38] Rob Russo: I have to tell you, I see it every year as a little tribute to Hal Prince, who would be famous for checking back into the show.
[32:45] Jamie DuMont: And the last time I went to buy tickets on like a Thursday afternoon in August, there was a line at the box office.
[32:53] Rob Russo: And if that doesn't tell you all you need to know about why Phantom of the Opera remains a hit, I don't know what to tell you.
[33:00] Jamie DuMont: I'm pretty sure I was your date for that viewing, right?
[33:03] Rob Russo: Yes, yes, yes.
[33:04] Jamie DuMont: We so we had great seats, best seats I've ever had for Phantom of the Opera.
[33:07] Rob Russo: Um and I have to say the audience was, let's say, international, and they were riveted.
[33:15] Jamie DuMont: They were pretty, I mean, there were a few cell phones and people taking pictures.
[33:18] Rob Russo: But I have to say, how many years into the run? 32 years, something like that.
[33:21] Jamie DuMont: And people were wrapped.
[33:26] Rob Russo: Yeah, well, there are two things operating there, I think.
[33:28] Jamie DuMont: Um, number one, it's this show is sort of the last connection that we have to the golden age of Broadway.
[33:38] Rob Russo: Um, because Hal Prince directed it, and it still bears his fingerprints.
[33:44] Jamie DuMont: And unlike you know, other shows that have been revived that are sort of a facsimile of the original, you know, Autora's touch.
[33:52] Rob Russo: The Phantom of the Opera has remained on Broadway since 1988.
[33:54] Jamie DuMont: It is Harold Prince's production of The Phantom of the Opera.
[33:57] Rob Russo: And it's thrilling to experience a show the way that musicals used to be directed and staged.
[34:03] Jamie DuMont: And then the second thing I think is a testament to the show is that they keep that show in tip top shape.
[34:10] Rob Russo: Every crystal is shiny, every bead is in place, the orchestra sounds gorgeous.
[34:16] Jamie DuMont: The they rotate the stars in and out of the show, so they're always fresh and just so well healed and rehearsed.
[34:28] Rob Russo: I've seen it, I see it every year.
[34:30] Jamie DuMont: It's never tired.
[34:31] Rob Russo: It is never tired, whether you see it on a Tuesday night in the dead of winter or you know, uh Saturday night in the heat of summer.
[34:38] Jamie DuMont: Um, it is always, always in tip top shape.
[34:41] Rob Russo: And I think that's because you know, Harold Prince learned um from working with you know George Abbott, who never showed up.
[34:49] Jamie DuMont: Once a show opened, George Abbott was done with it.
[34:51] Rob Russo: He never showed up.
[34:52] Jamie DuMont: And Hal Prince thought, well, I'm not gonna do that when I direct or when I produce, I'm gonna be a continual force.
[34:58] Rob Russo: And so he did.
[34:59] Jamie DuMont: He showed up to see The Phantom of the Opera, I believe it was once a month at least, and was involved in casting and running rehearsals up until he passed away this past year.
[35:09] Rob Russo: So, you know, that to me is one of the most exciting things about The Phantom of the Opera is that you can still be in touch with the golden age of Broadway when you go to see it.
[35:20] Jamie DuMont: Um, and of course, you know, Andrew Lloyd Webber's score, right?
[35:23] Rob Russo: I mean, it's at this point so well known and so done that you can, you know, you can forget about how superb it is, much like Les Mis.
[35:32] Jamie DuMont: I mean, I went to see the New York Pops perform last year, and they did a suite from Les Mis, and it reminded me how gorgeous that score is.
[35:39] Rob Russo: And it's the same with The Phantom of the Opera.
[35:41] Jamie DuMont: I mean, say what you will, whether you like Andrew Lloyd Webber or not, you can't deny that um the man can write a really good tune.
[36:29] Rob Russo: Another confession, I didn't see The Phantom of the Opera until probably 2000, 2002, somewhere in there.
[36:36] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[36:37] Rob Russo: I was very late to the game.
[36:38] Jamie DuMont: I think you're sensing a theme here.
[36:40] Rob Russo: Well, I said that at the beginning of all of this, but particularly the British invasion was not like something that I was particularly warm to at the time.
[36:48] Jamie DuMont: I think as I've grown older, I have more of an appreciation for Les Mis and for Phantom in particular.
[36:54] Rob Russo: Um, I've actually seen Phantom several times um in the last few years with you most recently, and I saw it the year before that um with someone else.
[37:03] Jamie DuMont: And I agree with you.
[37:06] Rob Russo: I don't care for the score.
[37:07] Jamie DuMont: It's not a score I would ever listen to, but as an experience, as a theatrical experience, it's stunning.
[37:12] Rob Russo: And primarily for the reasons you state seeing it now, it's in tip top shape.
[37:17] Jamie DuMont: And so you're absolutely right about that.
[37:19] Rob Russo: But it is, you know, it's Phantom.
[37:21] Jamie DuMont: It's it's it's the first show for so many people.
[37:24] Rob Russo: You know, in fact, a lot of these shows, I mean, you know, that's that's another theme of these shows, these hits right, is that they're the somebody's they're they're the first show for many, many people.
[37:33] Jamie DuMont: But Phantom in particular, I think is is one of those shows that even people that don't go to the theater or don't care for the theater, they've all seen Phantom and they love it.
[37:42] Rob Russo: So it's well, and and they've sold over 18 million tickets uh on Broadway alone, 130 million worldwide.
[37:50] Jamie DuMont: The Broadway show has grossed 1.2 billion dollars.
[37:54] Rob Russo: I mean, wrap your head around that.
[37:55] Jamie DuMont: 1.2 billion dollars.
[37:57] Rob Russo: It's the third highest grossing show of all time.
[37:59] Jamie DuMont: And the show has a worldwide gross of over six billion dollars.
[38:03] Rob Russo: So it's uh there's certainly something to it.
[38:06] Jamie DuMont: Um and you know, it even spawned a sequel, which we talked about in the flops uh should never happen.
[38:12] Rob Russo: We didn't talk about Love Never Dies, uh, because I I don't actually know it at all.
[38:16] Jamie DuMont: But no, neither one of us, well, we hadn't seen a lot of the flops.
[38:19] Rob Russo: I will say I have heard from a few people that were a little disgruntled that we didn't include that.
[38:26] Jamie DuMont: Love Never Dies.
[38:27] Rob Russo: But you know, uh flops part two.
[38:29] Jamie DuMont: Well, part three.
[38:30] Rob Russo: Yeah, three and four.
[38:33] Jamie DuMont: Um we may end up doing that someday.
[38:35] Rob Russo: Yeah, right.
[38:36] Jamie DuMont: Well, moving on to our last uh major British invasion show, uh, and that would be Miss Saigon, which arrived on Broadway in the year 1991 and ran uh nine years and nine months through 2001, over 4,000 performances.
[38:50] Rob Russo: This was another musical by Claude-Michel Schönberg and Alain Boublil, collaborating with Richard Maltby Jr.
[38:56] Jamie DuMont: And this one, unlike Les Mis, which was started out written in French, this was written um in English uh to begin with and premiered on the West End in 1989, and was inspired, in fact, by uh a photograph that Claude-Michel Schönberg happened to catch in a magazine of a Vietnamese mother leaving her child uh at a departure gate at an airbase to board an airplane to the United States where uh her child's father, an ex-GI, would be basically adopting her and giving her the life she could never have in Vietnam after the war.
[39:31] Rob Russo: And he was so struck by this photo that uh it inspired him to you know go to his longtime uh collaborator and construct a musical around it.
[39:41] Jamie DuMont: And where they landed was doing an adaptation of Puccini's opera, uh Madama Butterfly, setting it during the Vietnam War.
[39:48] Rob Russo: And that photo, if you remember from the 1990s, was behind the title page in the playbill, so that audiences uh would have that same moment of connection and would understand that this isn't just some tale that they came up with or adapted, that it was real life, and that you know there are real people behind you know this this devastating story.
[40:13] Jamie DuMont: They are not nice, they're mostly noise.
[40:19] Rob Russo: They swear like men, they screw like boys.
[40:25] Jamie DuMont: I know there's nothing in there, but every time I take one in stovy in my mind.
[40:49] Rob Russo: The dream.
[40:50] Jamie DuMont: I love Miss Saigon, and I understand, particularly through the lens of twenty twenty, why it is incredibly problematic in it in its depiction of Asian characters and certainly this long time casting controversy that surrounds it.
[41:13] Rob Russo: And it's rather unfortunate, you know, fact uh surrounding the show.
[41:17] Jamie DuMont: But it was a tremendous, tremendous hit on Broadway.
[41:21] Rob Russo: That it was, and in fact, exception to my Jamie I Hate British Invasion rule.
[41:27] Jamie DuMont: I love Miss Saigon.
[41:29] Rob Russo: I loved it from the very beginning.
[41:30] Jamie DuMont: Um I saw it early on.
[41:33] Rob Russo: And and I, you know, for me personally, I love the story, and I love I love Madame Butterfly, it's it's uh source material.
[41:42] ♪ Musical number ♪
[42:28] Jamie DuMont: I respond very passionately to it. Um that said, it is problematic. And um, and and it has been from the beginning, as you reference Jonathan Price getting cast as the engineer, and and he was not an Asian uh actor, and and that was a big controversy. We've even talked about this on our show with David Henry Wong, who was um not only very vocal about it at the time, he sort of wrote a play about it. So uh, you know, it's it is not without controversy. It does have a marvelous score. Um a really, really beautiful score. It was a massive hit, and oddly, it didn't win the Tony Award for Best Musical that year. It lost to Tommy Toon's Will Rogers Follies, which is so fascinating to me.
[43:49] Rob Russo: Well, I think it's a combination of a lot of things. I mean, I think the controversies surrounding the casting had a lot to do with it. I think, you know, the I think that was a very serious uh thing, and I think that people responded to that. But I also think it's a musical about a very unpopular war, the Vietnam War, at a time where we were in the middle of another very unpopular war. And I think that juxtaposed with the Will Rogers Follies, which was just color and glitz and and pure Americana. Pure Americana at a time where, you know, a lot of people were not with the president. They were not with the war. It was a very controversial thing. And uh we were still dealing with the ramifications of the Reagan administration.
You know, Anita Hill was a thing that was happening and just shocking and horrible. So I I can see why Will Rogers Follies was such a tonic. Um and but it's it's for sure. It's also a really great musical. It is a really great musical, but but here here again we have a musical that um that didn't win best musical, but then it went on to run and run and run and run and be revived and have multiple productions all over the world, and and controversy or not, it strikes a chord with people. And yeah, and and what we'll pick, well, what we'll see, especially as we get closer to the present, is a lot of the hit shows were not critical hits and did not win awards, but went on to run a really long time.
And we'll see that increasingly, especially as we enter the 21st century, where there's a real departure between what is critically celebrated and what runs a long time. So far, pretty much every show we've talked about, with the exception of maybe you know some noise around cats and lay miz, you know, was acclaimed at its uh at the time of its arrival on Broadway.
[45:42] Jamie DuMont: What's that I smell the American sweet as a new millionaire? The American dream. Pre-packed and ready to wear my American dream fat. Like a chocolate clair. As I suck out the free luck by the tail. How can I fail? And best of all, it's for sale. Miss Saigon broke records when it opened, right? They had a record advanced ticket sale of 24 million dollars, the highest ticket price ever for a Broadway musical at a stunning 100 uh for the the front of the mezzanine, I believe, and certain orchestra seats. It was definitely the front mezzanine. Yeah, absolutely. And they were able to repay their investors in under 39 weeks, which is unheard of. I mean, that's for a huge musical that was you know millions and millions of dollars, you know, pretty stunning.
It remains today the 13th longest running Broadway show, grossed nearly 300 million dollars in that first production with a worldwide gross of over 1.6 billion. Um, there's a film that's sort of been in perpetual development. Maybe someday we'll see it. And there was a helicopter. We haven't talked about the helicopter.
[47:17] Rob Russo: Well, I was gonna ignore it because I actually think the helicopter of the helicopter. I think it's a bunch of bullshit. I the helicopter never did it for me. I it was uh it doesn't like a helicopter. We're discovering, you know.
[47:29] Jamie DuMont: No, I don't know. Um a well to wrap up our our our our British invasion. Um, you know, those are the four big ones. Of course, there were other shows as part of the British invasion, some not so successful. Um, Song and Dance, Starlight Express, Chess, huge flop, Aspects of Love, um Buddy, which came in the early 90s, which huge was a huge hit, me and my girl, um, you know, which was another big hit. So, you know, the 80s and early 90s was really a time, of course, you know, Sunset Boulevard. Um, I was gonna say I was surprised uh to see Sunset Boulevard not on this list because to me that was sort of the end of the British invasion. That was the show that that um I I think Sunset Boulevard uh look, I have a I have a history with this show, Cards on the Table.
Um, but I I think it was a magnificent show, and I realize I'm a little close to the flame on that. But I will say that I think that part of the negativity around Sunset Boulevard was the fact that we were just tired of these types of musicals with these huge sets that had a gimmick. In this case, it was you know the staircase, or the fact that the house went, you know, lifted it 30 feet into the air, and you know, I I think people we were just tired of that. Um so I think it's it's worth noting that it it sort of closed this chapter.
[48:43] Rob Russo: Yeah, and you know, Sunset Boulevard was on Broadway in 1995, and the next year, if not the next season, um, we saw a shift, and that's our next category, category eight. Um, we're dedicating this category to the year 1996, not the season, but the year. And the first show is sort of the opposite of the British invasion, right? And Jamie, what is that show?
[49:05] Jamie DuMont: That would be Rent. We're not gonna pay. We're not gonna pay. We're not gonna pay.
[49:37] Rob Russo: Again, another sort of adaptation of an opera. This time it's uh Puccini's La Bohème. Uh, I think everybody knows that it's set in the East Village in uh the late 80s, um, which I think a lot of people forget. I think a lot of people think that it's actually set around the time it came out, but it's technically the late 80s. 89 to 90, right?
[49:58] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, it's it's that's a that's a fact I think I think people forget. Again, speaking of being close to the flame, this is probably the only true hit I ever worked on in my time working on Broadway. I had the unique pleasure of holding the house seat book for about a year. Um that was my job doing house seat orders on this show, and I got to talk to a lot of um lot of cast members from the hit TV show Melrose Place would call me. I got quite a few gifts for getting people into the show, but all that aside, Rent was a real game changer in a in a this is a long list of shows that were game changers. Um, right? It's in that same vein.
[50:41] Rob Russo: Absolutely, absolutely. Again, it was uh it's a realistic look at um uh uh a group of youngsters uh dealing with uh AIDS, dealing with drug addiction, dealing with a lot of things that were very part of the culture at that time. A lot of things we were talking about or or trying to talk about. And then it had this great rock score, if you can call it a rock score. I don't think it is. I think it's actually quite a conventional musical theater score.
[51:21] Jamie DuMont: I'll cover you with a thousand sweet kisses. I'll cover you. I'll cover you. And it shook New York up. There's no other way to say it.
[51:53] Rob Russo: Yeah. And then it also had the very tragic story that coincided with its opening, which is its creator and quite frankly, the not only the man that wrote the show, but it's about him. It's about all his friends. I've met Maureen, I've met Mimi, I've met these people. They they exist to a certain extent. Um, although some of them, you know, claim they composites. Yes, absolutely. But the point is, Jonathan Larson died during the um during the preview period, I believe, at the New York Theater Workshop. I think he died um the the night before it was to open at the New York Theater Workshop. And it just kind of wrapped itself around this beautiful musical. And you can't extract one from the other anymore.
[52:45] Jamie DuMont: Well, because the show itself is through all of the challenges that the characters encounter, ultimately a celebration of life and the idea of you know, no day but today, right? Right. And to have its creator, to have his life tragically cut short on the eve of it becoming this uh runaway success, you know, it you couldn't pitch that story to you know to a Hollywood producer, right? I mean, it it's it's so tragic and self-fulfilling, you know, not self-fulfilling, but you know what I mean? It's it's sort of all of a theme.
[53:20] Rob Russo: And well, because he struggled, right? He struggled as a composer for a long time. And the show was in development for a long time.
[53:28] Jamie DuMont: Long, long time. And and and he really didn't write a whole lot beyond Rent. You know, there's tic tic boom, and and and he did he had a sort of a nightclub act that's a composite of songs that kind of became tic tic boom. But the point is, Rent was really the thing that he wrote. And there's a tragic, wonderful video out there, or there was of him his last day at uh the I think at the Moondance Cafe, where he's saying, Goodbye, um, this, goodbye, that, goodbye, Cash Register, because he's going off to create the show at the New York Theater Workshop, and he would die not that long after that. And it's just heartbreaking to see this young kid literally hanging up his waiter's apron to go, you know, pursue his dream in the musical theater world, and to have that cut so short.
[54:16] Rob Russo: And and and I think about, you know, we mentioned this earlier. We talk about the deficit of new musicals around this time period because we lost so many people to AIDS, and similarly, same thing with with Jonathan Larson. Think about all the incredible things he could have written or would have written. Right. And the talent that he had. It's tragic. It really is.
[54:39] Jamie DuMont: And part of the reason why the show, again, you know, received the reception that it did is not only because it was contemporary, right? It was it was addressing contemporary themes and issues and really, really of the now in 1996. But it also was an American musical, right? It was an American, it was an American writer making his debut on the highest platform in the theater world once it came to Broadway. And how exciting and thrilling that was for the American theater to be able to say, you know what, we got our mojo back. We're gonna, we're gonna, you know, bring American musicals to audiences again, because that really hadn't been happening in a sustained way for a long time.
[55:23] Rob Russo: Not with anything new. I mean, Crazy for You was a big deal in 1992. Um, and it was, you know, for the same reason, right? It was finally not a British musical, but that was, you know, using existing material and you know, and obviously Ken Ludwig's book was new, but using the Gershwin songbook. So it was still a bit of a nostalgia piece. This was about right now, in the same way that Hair was about right now in 1968, and A Chorus Line was about right now in 1975. This wrote a moment and it became part of the zeitgeist and then made that leap, probably the biggest leap that any musical would make until Hamilton, to being part of the popular culture, and specifically the song Seasons of Love, right? Which Stevie Wonder recorded and you know became a song that everyone knew, whether you were a theater fan or not. And that cast album, which is phenomenal, just sold like gangbusters.
[56:49] Jamie DuMont: It also had a hugely powerful fan base, right?
[56:53] Rob Russo: Yes. It, you know, kids would, it was again also, you know, the other thing I think we need to mention is that the economics of Broadway were radically shifting quickly in this time period. Ticket prices were soaring, you know, premium, although the VIP thing hadn't happened yet, but the scalper thing was really big. You know, there was a huge, um, I mean, it's sort of it's leading up to The Producers, which we'll talk about in a second, which began the whole premium seating or VIP ticketing process, but it's still very much in that moment where tickets were skyrocketing, and Rent did that thing where it had, you know, the first two rows of the orchestra were, I think, $20 tickets. And kids would camp out overnight.
[57:39] Jamie DuMont: It became kind of controversial, right? Because the overnight lines became kind of rowdy and became a party, and there was sort of a dark side to it. It got a little crazy. And I think they ended up changing that sleeping out on the street policy. But the point is, it spoke to, as you mentioned, a generation, and they responded and they rallied around it. It was the first show in many years to be on the cover of Time and Newsweek, which doesn't seem like a big thing to us now, because we don't live in that media world.
[58:11] Rob Russo: Print media.
[58:12] Jamie DuMont: Right. Quite like we did. But that was a huge deal, right? Rosie O'Donnell, who was at the height of her powers as a sort of arbiter of taste in theater and speaking to middle America had a huge influence in terms of helping Rent get into the homes of, you know, audience members that may not necessarily be drawn to it purely on its subject matter.
[58:38] Rob Russo: And we haven't even talked about that cast.
[59:07] Jamie DuMont: Or leave me.
[59:13] Rob Russo: Guess I'm leaving. I'm gone. Every single one of them gave iconic performances, so much so that I think it's kind of hampered the ability of the show to live on beyond that original production, you know, because these performers are just so indelibly caked in the mind of fans of the show. You know, I mean, Anthony Rapp and Adam Pascal, right? I mean, Idina Menzel, Taye Diggs, Stephanie Rubin-Vega, you've mentioned Jesse L. Martin. I mean, that cast, they became stars. Most of them were making their Broadway debut. Many of them, you know, Idina Menzel was not a musical theater performer. She was a, you know, she was a singer on Long Island. She sang at bar mitzvahs, right? And like she got cast in this show. She was a recording artist, she's a studio artist. She'd never been in a musical before.
[1:00:04] Jamie DuMont: Well, I think the two cast members that had the most credits were Toby Britton Parker and Jill Chasson, who were both chorus members.
[1:00:12] Rob Russo: Right, right, would not actually end up becoming hugely famous, but they were the ones who had actually done shows before. Toby Britton Parker, who was Sarah Jessica Parker's brother, for point of fact. But anyway.
[1:00:25] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, you know, and I think one other thing to mention before we move on is that Rent also signified a shift in a new producing talent, right? Jeffrey Seller and Kevin McCollum emerged with Rent. And, you know, they weren't novice producers, but they were young and not from the world of Broadway. They weren't Titans of Broadway. They weren't a corporation and they weren't Cameron Mackintosh or Andrew Lloyd Webber. They were, you know, young creative guys who got behind this really emerging artist and piece of work, championed it, got it to Broadway, and you know, would go on to produce Avenue Q and Hamilton, you know, among other things, for, you know, in Jeffrey Seller's case. And in a way, it was sort of a returning of nonprofit theaters providing the pipeline to Broadway, right? Because that has become a more fruitful model in the past 30 years.
[1:01:20] Rob Russo: But in 1996, that hadn't really happened in a bit that you had, I mean, uh, other than the Public Theater, which had sourced a lot to Broadway, for New York Theater Workshop in the East Village to be the original home of a piece that would come to Broadway. Of course, you know, since then they've done Once, Hadestown, and What the Constitution Means to Me. And you know, there's a whole long list of great works that they have championed and brought to the public. But at the time, you know, this was a big deal for New York Theater Workshop to put a show on Broadway. There's a very real fact that if it hadn't been for Jeffrey Seller and Kevin McCullum, Rent would not have happened. I think they took a chance on this in a world where no one else may have.
[1:02:01] Jamie DuMont: I also want to say, just before we move on, the thing about the cast and, um, you know, that production. I saw the 20th anniversary tour in San Francisco a couple of years ago. And what I was struck, I was struck by two things. One, they did the original set in costumes, and I thought, oh, we, which I understand why they did that, but I thought, yeah, boy, wouldn't it be great to see this with a fresh look? But what was so incredible was the cast, they were all 20-year-old unknowns, and they brought this energy to the piece that I hadn't seen since the early days of Rent on Broadway. And I think that there's a very real version of another production of Rent, hopefully not too far off, where they go back to hiring 20-year-old unknowns, they give it a fresh look, and I think it could speak to audiences again, like it did, particularly now, like it did in the 90s.
[1:03:03] Rob Russo: I agree with you. I think at some point in the future, hopefully 10, 20 years from now, um, someone else will come and visit it with new eyes, like, you know, like Daniel Fish did with Oklahoma, or Ivo van Hove did with West Side Story, you know, maybe not as radical, but someone will approach it with no preconception and will deliver a new version of Rent that will speak to audiences the way as vividly and as thrillingly as it did in 1996. And I can't wait for that. I'm still waiting for that to happen with A Chorus Line, by the way, as well, because I think that's another show that, you know, because it's, it was so of a moment and the original production was so iconic that it just keeps getting reproduced. Um, but that's just me and my soapbox. Rent ran for 5,123 performances. It won the Pulitzer Prize in 1996, uh, four Tony Awards, including Best Musical, and it remains today the 11th longest-running Broadway show.
[1:03:53] Jamie DuMont: Moving on to the fall of 1996, although that same spring, uh, it was still, but it was starting to bubble up. We received a revival of Chicago.
[1:04:03] Rob Russo: Oh, yes, which began at City Center as part of their Encore series in May 1996. And from the minute that production began, people knew. Uh, and people were whispering and saying, oh my god, this is a sensation. It's gotta come to Broadway. And, uh, Fran and Barry Weissler took that production, did some revisions and some expansions, but retained to that same, you know, spare and minimalist style that you get or you used to get with an encore's concert, right? No sets, no costumes, very, very pared down, and put it on Broadway, where it is still running. It's certainly over 24 years later.
[1:04:44] Jamie DuMont: And Chicago, I mean, this is Broadway's longest-running revival. It's the longest-running show to have premiered on Broadway, and it's the longest-running American show, because, uh, Phantom of the Opera, uh, obviously, uh, is a British show. But Chicago has an amazing story, right? Because it's a revival. And in 1975, the original production opened, the original Bob Fosse-led production, opened on Broadway to, you know, a good mix of reviews, some raves, some people less enthusiastic about it. But then was almost immediately just smothered by the runaway success of A Chorus Line. Chicago opened in June 1975, and A Chorus Line opened in July 1975. So Chicago didn't have the opportunity that perhaps it would have had in another season to spread its wings and enjoy its success and build an audience.
And as a result, that original production closed after a couple of years, only to be, and then was somewhat, you know, forgotten, at least on Broadway, until 1996 with this Encore's concert proving the genius behind that original show, terrific Kander and Ebb's score and Bob Fosse and Fred Ebb's book, which I believe is one of the best in musical theater.
[1:06:05] Rob Russo: I also think that, um, it's unfortunate that it came in the same season as A Chorus Line.
[1:06:09] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[1:06:10] Rob Russo: I think had it come a year earlier or a few years earlier, it would have been a very different story.
[1:06:15] Jamie DuMont: As originally planned.
[1:06:16] Rob Russo: As originally, that heart attack.
[1:06:18] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:06:18] Rob Russo: Yes. However, I do think that its cynical nature was a tougher sell in the 70s, particularly in the mid-70s. But I think also in the earlier 70s, it would have been tough. And I think you can't underestimate the impact of the O.J. Simpson trial and verdict on America and on our culture, having a lot to do with why audiences were so receptive to Chicago in the mid-90s. I think there's, I think that's a very clear-cut argument of what helped a brilliant, magnificent, nearly perfect show find its niche, find its audience, find its just due.
[1:07:02] Jamie DuMont: And then those two bit Johns did it up round to cheer the best attraction in town. They nearly tore the balcony down.
[1:07:12] Rob Russo: And we'd say, okay, fellas, okay, we're going home. But here's a few more.
[1:07:18] Jamie DuMont: Parton shots.
[1:07:20] Rob Russo: And this, oh, this we did in perfect unison.
[1:07:36] Jamie DuMont: Now you see me going through it. You can see there's nothing to it, but I simply cannot do it.
[1:07:55] Rob Russo: It was in that way ahead of its time.
[1:07:57] Jamie DuMont: A hundred percent.
[1:07:58] Rob Russo: And it found its time. And sadly, what that means is that American society writ large became more cynical in the intervening years and more willing to, you know, to consume Bob Fosse's worldview, which certainly in 1975 was a little bit more of an outsider's view.
[1:08:18] Jamie DuMont: Um, and you know, it was very much his response to Watergate.
[1:08:22] Rob Russo: Absolutely.
[1:08:24] Jamie DuMont: And they wrote it during that, say 1974, 1973, you know, as that scandal was sort of gripping the nation. And perhaps, you know, there was also an element of fatigue at the end of that era, um, you know, to arrive at this moment and then have to live through something that's just so cynical.
[1:08:41] Rob Russo: But the show is the show.
[1:08:43] Jamie DuMont: And I much like Phantom of the Opera, I check into Chicago every year, at least once a year. And I'm so glad that I do because every time I see it, it's even better than I remember it being. It's a superb reimagining of the original production. It's obviously not Bob Fosse's production. Walter Bobby, you know, directed this with Ann Reinking's choreography in the style of Bob Fosse. I think the hot honey rag is the only number in the show that is entirely Bob Fosse's choreography. But the minimalism of it, the spareness of it, and the opportunity to see that choreography and to hear those songs and get those line reads, you know, is I never pass it up because I think it's one of the best musicals ever written.
[1:09:27] Rob Russo: And time has proven that to be true.
[1:09:30] Jamie DuMont: Time has been very kind to it, as we've said. I agree with you that the score is fantastic, the whole conceit, the construction of it, everything about it. It really, it really is a marvelous musical. And it has stood the test of time and probably will continue to, you know, there's a lot of conversation about, you know, what shows will make it, what shows will come back when theater returns. And I don't see that we will be living in any less cynical of a world when things return.
[1:10:02] Rob Russo: And I hope there's a continued audience for Chicago. I also think it's really interesting. Um, as someone who was around in the 90s when Chicago first opened, there was a bit of criticism about the fact that they just moved the Encore production and that, you know, it's so interesting to me when you look at the end of the British invasion and people's response to, oh, no more helicopters, no more stairs flying, no more chandeliers, like enough, enough, enough. And then we get Chicago, which is about as stripped down as you can be.
[1:10:35] Jamie DuMont: And people are saying, well, there's no set and there's no costumes, and it's all off the rack, which we all know from our conversation with William Ivy Long, it is not off the rack. Those costumes are not only built for each person that goes into the show, they are of some of the most fine materials. He buys, you know, listen to our interview with William Ivy Long, and you can hear all about the brilliant costumes that go into Chicago and continue 20 years later. He still is making them each time. I'm sure Erica Girardi, who was the most recent Roxy Hart who we saw do it, I'm sure she went for her fitting in his studio and had that marvelous experience that everyone else has got. Well, you know, because it was so spare, it set the record for recovering its investment faster than any other musical in Broadway history.
And I bet that hasn't been bested yet in the years since, because it was a very, very cheap musical to put on Broadway. Um, and you know, that also has helped its longevity. It opened at the Richard Rogers Theater, which was formerly the 46th Street Theater, where the original production of Chicago opened in 1975, moved to the Schubert, which is, you know, a bigger house, and then moved to the Ambassador in 2003, the forgotten theater on 49th Street that Bob Fosse had put Dancin' in from the Broadhurst in the late 70s. That theater, very strange interior. It's a triangle. It's kind of shoehorned into the plot of land that it's on. But the show has grossed $674 million since 1996, making it the fourth highest grossing show in Broadway history.
It won six 1997 Tony Awards from eight nominations. Amazingly enough, I, this is one of my favorite fun facts. The original production of Chicago holds the record for being the biggest Tony Award loser in history with 11 nominations and zero wins, because of course A Chorus Line won them all that year. So it was vindicated in the end, of course, by running longer than A Chorus Line by winning all those Tony Awards in 1997 and becoming a hit film in 2002. The Rob Marshall film of Chicago won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, and is I think as good a film of Chicago as we would get unless Bob Fosse had been able to make his Chicago film, which I'm sure would have been better. But, you know, the success of Chicago is kind of unparalleled and really, you know, easily earns its spot among the greatest hits in Broadway history.
[1:13:14] Rob Russo: I got a thing.
[1:13:18] Jamie DuMont: Oh no one's wide pot. Oh, I love my life and all that jazz.
[1:13:39] Rob Russo: Okay, well, moving on to our ninth category. This one is a big one. So this category is just called Disney. Beyond the British invasion and the resurgence of American musicals in the 1990s, the other major thing, of course, that happened to Broadway in the 1990s was the arrival of Disney. And in the entirety of Broadway history, Disney holds claim to producing five of the top 25 highest grossing shows ever. And their shows collectively have grossed well over three billion dollars. Three billion dollars, and that's just on Broadway, not even, you know, considering worldwide. So we couldn't talk about hits without talking, of course, about Disney. And it all began with Beauty and the Beast, which arrived on Broadway in 1994 and would run until 2007, a whopping 5,461 performances. That's a 13-year run of Beauty and the Beast. It's, you know, it's an extraordinary story. I actually worked on Beauty and the Beast in Los Angeles.
[1:14:35] Jamie DuMont: I know that.
[1:14:44] Rob Russo: Yes. I worked on the second company, which ironically was the original company. So everybody, the entire company from New York came out to Los Angeles. I think it was 1995. I could be wrong about that, but they all came out. They all did six months or so at the Schubert Theater, which no longer exists, and I worked on it. I can't, I have to be perfectly honest with you, it was not a particularly happy experience for me as a press associate on the show, but also for the company. I think by then they had all been with the show for a long time. I think they all came out to Los Angeles for a variety of reasons. Some of them stayed out there, some of them still live out there. So it was a fraught, it was a fraught thing.
And however, I will say I have grown very fond of that show over the years. I wasn't that into it when I worked on it. I was sort of judgmental of it at the time. And as I've gotten older and I reflect on it and I've seen various productions of it, I saw a beautiful stripped-down version that toured a couple of years ago that was magnificent. And it, you know, it took away all the sort of the bigness of the show and really focused on the score and the story. And it was marvelous. It was such a wonderful. I'm so glad I saw that production because that's what sort of tipped the scales for me. All that aside, it was a mega hit. And it's extraordinary. Again, talk about a show that was so many people's first Broadway show.
The other thing I think is interesting about Beauty and the Beast is the fact that in 1999 it moved from the Palace Theater to the Lunt Fontaine, where they were able to reconfigure it a little bit, rework it a little, strip it down, make it less costly to run. And because of that fact, it ended up running, and there are what, like 250 less seats in the Lunt Fontaine. But with all of that, because of the brilliant producing that they did on this, that show ran eight more years. It ran almost twice as long at the Lunt than it did at the Palace. That's unbelievable. I mean, that to me is such a great story.
[1:16:56] Jamie DuMont: And the thing about Beauty and the Beast, you know, it's easy to forget now because it can be overshadowed by all of the Disney productions that have followed. But you know, when we talked to Tom Schumacher, who today, of course, is the head of Disney Theatricals, it was his word, not ours, that when Disney arrived on Broadway in 1994, they were a bit of a pariah. You know, I mean, Broadway was still a very mom and pop, you know, industry, despite, you know, Cameron Mackintosh and, you know, the big, you know, British shows, those were still, you know, produced by impresarios, and it was very much, you know, a world that was kind of had this antipathy towards a major corporation coming in and producing a show.
Now, today we would kind of laugh at that because major corporations are invested in a lot of shows, and Disney has proven its worth and is an amazing success story. But, you know, this is 1994, this is before the revitalization of Times Square, this is before the New Amsterdam Theater, this is before all of that. And Disney showed up and they put on a heck of a good show.
[1:17:55] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[1:17:55] Jamie DuMont: And it wasn't a theme park frivolity, it was a musical. It was a Broadway musical. And they had to prove their worth and they had to work very hard over, you know, the following decade to really win over the Broadway community. And you know, today Broadway, you know, is synonymous with Disney and vice versa, right? I mean, Disney is one piece of the Broadway ecosystem, but very much, you know, a part of that ecosystem. So Beauty and the Beast was an important proving ground because if it had failed, if they hadn't put up such a quality show, if they hadn't been able to, you know, win that argument, we might not have gotten all the other Disney shows that followed, nor the sort of economic impact that Disney has had on Broadway as a whole, which as far as I'm concerned, is only win-win-win-win-win, right?
If you are able to introduce a young theatergoer to a great Broadway show, or you're able to bring in someone, an old, you know, an adult who otherwise might not have gone to the theater, you might spark something in them. You might hook them to want to see more Broadway shows, to want to participate and support the theater more. And that I think is Disney's greatest contribution to Broadway beyond the shows that they've put on.
[1:19:12] Rob Russo: I agree with that. I also can't imagine a world where we don't have the New Amsterdam Theater back. I think that's a huge gift that the Disney Corporation has given to us. It's possibly the single best restoration of a theater that I know of. And it's just you sit in that theater and it's just magic. It's so, it's such a beautiful house. They've done such a gorgeous job of renovating it and repairing it and keeping it pristine. So let's talk about sitting in that theater. So the first show to open that was a little concert of King David, but the second show to play at the New Amsterdam drum roll. The Lion King, three years after Beauty and the Beast, the Lion King would open.
[1:20:03] Jamie DuMont: I was actually at that, I saw King David.
[1:20:05] Rob Russo: Oh yeah, how cool.
[1:20:07] Jamie DuMont: I was there. I took a field trip to the Circle Line in fifth grade or fourth grade, and we drove down 42nd Street. And I'll never forget passing the New Amsterdam Theater, and they had painted the street in anticipation of the Lion King coming. And it hadn't opened yet. This was just the campaign leading up to the Lion King coming to Broadway. And it was so exciting.
[1:20:29] Rob Russo: Yeah, it was exciting. I, you know, again, this is, I think, you know, we're talking about a time in New York where you have Rent a year earlier, you have Chicago, you have the Lion King. It really felt like a renaissance of Broadway.
[1:20:44] Jamie DuMont: Cabaret.
[1:20:50] Rob Russo: Cabaret. That was, I mean, that production was that, again, another show that tore up the city. Um, so yeah, I mean the Lion King was a game changer, is a game changer. There's no question about it.
[1:21:06] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:21:06] Rob Russo: Yeah, both for Disney Theatricals and also for Broadway. Um, it is the longest-running Disney theatrical production. The third longest running Broadway show, period, with 9,302 performances as of the shutdown. Um, it's been running continuously since 1997, first at the New Amsterdam and then since 2006 at the Minskoff, which another great gift. It solved the problem of the Minskoff because that theater was housing flop after flop after flop almost throughout its entire history.
[1:21:35] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, until the Lion King.
[1:21:37] Rob Russo: It's sort of like the big brother to the Marquis, right?
[1:21:40] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[1:21:41] Rob Russo: The Marquis's older sister.
[1:21:43] Jamie DuMont: Uh, yeah, yeah, that's very real.
[1:21:45] Rob Russo: Well, they're problematic houses for a number of reasons. But as you said, the Lion King fixed all that.
[1:21:52] Jamie DuMont: Yes, yes.
[1:21:53] Rob Russo: And the show, you know, is now the highest grossing Broadway show in history. It's number one, 1.7 billion dollars grossed on Broadway alone. And it's the highest grossing musical theater franchise worldwide with over 8.2 billion dollars in grosses. Over 15 million tickets sold, 100 million worldwide. Um, and since 2014, the Lion King as a property is the top-earning title in box office history across the board. So that includes film, stage, surpassing The Phantom of the Opera, which had held that title before. So there's, you know, it's the biggest hit of all the hits, if you're going by, you know, by those numbers alone.
[1:22:34] Jamie DuMont: Well, and it's so interesting too, because when you look back at the 1998 Tony Awards, you know, I think a lot of people thought Ragtime was gonna win. I think a lot of people thought, well, you know, the Lion King is the Lion King and it's this big juggernaut, and you know, but Ragtime is the artistic piece. I don't think that, but I'm just saying what they may have thought in the day. And it won Best Musical, and it was quite, I mean, you listen to go back and go to the YouTube and pull it up, and you'll hear there's quite a surprised audience reaction. Um, and look, we love Ragtime. I don't here to disparage Ragtime. I think it's, I think it's quite possibly one of the greatest scores written in the last 30 years, without question.
Um, or ever, yes. And I think it's, I think it's a marvelous musical. We could do a whole podcast just on Ragtime alone. But my point in saying all this is that, you know, that even from the get-go, the Lion King was sort of form-breaking and game-changing and surprising in so many ways. And it continues to be that to this day.
[1:23:43] Rob Russo: And we can't talk about the Lion King without talking about Julie Taymor, who obviously was the sort of singular artistic force behind translating the film to stage as director and also costume designer of the piece and sort of lending her whole aesthetic to it with, you know, the inventive use of puppetry and solving for a lot of the difficult challenges of taking something that, you know, lived on the screen and is so cinematic and, you know, is a story about animals and putting it on stage, right? I mean, there's a lot of daunting challenges from an artistic perspective of putting this story on stage.
[1:24:22] Jamie DuMont: And she did it, and boy, did she do it. And she won the Tony Award for Best Director, becoming the first woman in 1998 ever to win the Tony Award for Best Director of a Musical, which was, you know, a big moment.
[1:24:34] Rob Russo: Which when you look at it and think about it, is shocking. Like, oh, it's pathetic, it's pathetic, but it's a shame, but also I'm glad she won.
[1:24:43] Rob Russo: The Lion King operates in your mind. It invites you to be complicit in the theater making, to collaborate, to bring your imagination to it. You know, they don't hide the puppeteers, it's not about that. You see the puppeteers, and that's the exciting thing. You see the theater being made in front of you. And that was, you know, her artistic impulse, obviously encouraged by Tom Schumacher and all the folks involved in getting this show on stage and making it what it is today, which is arguably the biggest hit in Broadway history.
[1:25:15] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, and I think you make a good point. I think that at that time, certainly there's a lot of fabulous technology in The Lion King, and they certainly used all the modern conveniences, as they say. What Julie did, which was so interesting, was she actually went backwards from technology. She went back to some puppetry that is rooted in some very old theatrical traditions. And it was terribly effective.
[1:26:49] Rob Russo: We have arrived at our last category, which is category number ten, and we've titled this Twenty First Century Juggernauts.
[1:26:57] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[1:26:58] Rob Russo: So we're gonna tick through some of the most successful hits of the last 20 years, and we're gonna try to do it as quick as possible because, well, you know, we've been talking for a while. Okay, so first up is The Producers, which obviously was the first mega hit of the twenty-first century, arrived on Broadway in 2001. It had a six-year run that sort of belies the nature of its initial success, you know, because I remember very, very vividly The Producers arriving on Broadway. And it was an absolute sensation unto itself. You know, it had the largest single box office ticket sales in theater history up to that point, taking in more than three million dollars in ticket sales on the day after it opened, which was bested by the show two years later when stars Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick came back and they sold $3.5 million worth of tickets in a single day.
And it pioneered, as Jamie mentioned earlier, the idea of premium seating, charging what was then an unheard of and unprecedented amount of $480 a ticket for 50 seats in the orchestra and in the first rows of the mezzanine. That was an attempt to eat at the market for the secondhand market of scalpers, right? So that the money would be going back to the show as opposed to being scraped off the top by a scalper.
[1:28:36] Jamie DuMont: I don't think they ate, I think they devoured the scalper market. I mean, I think it really, that whole concept just devastated that market. And you know, better for the shows to get it.
[1:28:46] Rob Russo: Better for the shows to get it, but of course it only aided in a trend of Broadway ticket prices skyrocketing. You know, in 2001, the average high was $100, and that was a lot of money to pay $100 to see a Broadway show in 2001. And now, forget about it, you can't sit in an orchestra seat in a Broadway show for what, $179, $200, right?
[1:29:11] Jamie DuMont: No, and I would venture to guess that we may see the end of these premium tickets, certainly for a while. I think of the things that will return when the theater returns. This might not be one of them, or the dynamics will shift for sure. But it did all begin with The Producers, and it did, in large part, begin because of the demand of Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick. I mean, that was such a sensation. It's hard to really wrap your mind around it today because we don't really have that as much. You know, there's a lot of stunt casting, there's a lot of that sort of magic that happens, but nothing quite like the two of them. That was really a phenomenon.
[1:30:29] Rob Russo: Name a better pair in musical theater history than at the top of a Broadway musical. I mean, it's very hard.
[1:30:35] Jamie DuMont: No, you're absolutely right. And you know, Rob, you know this about me because I'm quite vocal with you. I'm not a fan, I'm not a fan of The Producers. I don't like this musical, I dislike the score. However, I did see it a couple of times, and I saw it twice with Matthew and Nathan, and it was magic. As much as I disliked it while I was watching it, it just was not for me. I could not deny how brilliant they were together, and how just you knew you were seeing something that you will never see again. You know, I mentioned this when we were talking about Hamilton. There are very few shows that live up to the hype. The Producers, for me, was one of those shows that not only lived up to the hype, but far surpassed it.
Susan Strowman, as director and choreographer, you know, at the height of her powers on Broadway with this show, which, you know, tragically had been set to be directed by her husband, Mike Ockrent, who passed away in 1999. You know, and the whole show, of course, is a musical version of the 1967 film by Mel Brooks, which had won the Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay. It was David Geffen's idea to turn it into a stage musical. And when he approached Mel Brooks, Mel Brooks's first impulse was to go to Jerry Herman and say, you know, Jerry, will you write the score for me? And a real example of Jerry Herman's modesty and his goodwill. He turned around and said to Mel Brooks, well, no, I know exactly who should write this show, and it's you.
Because Jerry rightly noticed that throughout Mel Brooks's career, he had written songs for his movies, including Springtime for Hitler, but of course, Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein, and all those films had songs in them that he had written. He had no training, but he hummed into a tape recorder and Glenn Kelly transposed everything, and Doug Besterman orchestrated it. And he wrote what I think is a great score. I know Jamie disagrees, but I think it's a classic musical theater Broadway score that holds a candle to any of the greats from the Golden Age.
[1:32:30] ♪ Musical number: "That Face" — performed by Unknown ♪
[1:33:00] Rob Russo: 15 Tony Award nominations in 12 categories, which was the record at the time, won 12 Tony Awards, which is the record to date, which means it won every single category. Not even Hamilton did that. I remember watching the 2001 Tony Awards and being so bored because The Producers just won everything. Literally everything. There wasn't a category they were nominated in that they didn't win. It remains today the 27th longest-running Broadway show and 16th highest-grossing show of all time at $288 million in box office gross. What's interesting about The Producers though is that it didn't run as long as you probably would have thought it would have in 2001 because once Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick left, they were never quite able to recapture that magic with any of the casting that they did. But the show struggled to do the same business and sustain once they left.
[1:33:48] Jamie DuMont: Well, I'm gonna probably get into trouble for saying this, but I think that's a fundamental problem with the show. The fact that the show couldn't quite go on after its two stars that it was sort of built around left. I think that's—
[1:34:02] Rob Russo: Well, it still ran six years. It still ran six years, Jamie.
[1:34:07] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, but for a show that won a record amount of Tony Awards, won every category. When we look at the length of how long all of the shows ran on this list, I would—six years is a short run for this show that is a game changer and has all these accolades. That's all. And look, look, look, look, before Twitter comes after me, I will say this that I'd be very curious for me personally to revisit The Producers and see what I thought of it. I'm older now. It came at a time in my life personally where I was going through some tough stuff, so I was not in a great place. All that aside, I'd be curious to see if I have a different reaction to it now than I did then.
[1:34:54] Rob Russo: Well, it's the only hit in the modern era, and I say the modern era starting maybe, you know, in the 70s, that was reliant on names above the title, right? None of the other shows you've mentioned, whether it was Grease, A Chorus Line, 42nd Street, any of the British Invasion shows, none of them were successful at the box office on the strength of the name above the title. So The Producers had that, right? And that sort of doomed them from running for 15 years, but it still ran for six. Okay, moving on. Mamma Mia also arrived in 2001, in the next season, the fall of 2001. Ran for 14 years, first at the Winter Garden, then at the Broadhurst Theater. 5,758 performances, obviously an original story based on the songs of ABBA.
[1:35:41] ♪ Musical number: "Mamma Mia" — performed by Unknown ♪
[1:35:58] Rob Russo: It's the longest-running jukebox musical on Broadway, the ninth longest-running Broadway show, the sixth highest-grossing Broadway show at $624 million. And a sensation unto itself. Jamie, what are your thoughts on Mamma Mia?
[1:36:12] Jamie DuMont: Well, I never saw Mamma Mia on Broadway.
[1:36:14] Rob Russo: Oh, okay.
[1:36:15] Jamie DuMont: So I have to say that right off the bat. Look, put out your cards. You know, this is a safe space, theoretically. I'm a huge fan of ABBA and I love their music. I had no interest in seeing the show initially when it first opened. I did have tickets to go when Dee Hoty took over. And for some reason I can't remember why we didn't go. But by the time I wanted to see Mamma Mia, it had become this thing. And I didn't really want to sit in an audience of people dancing in the aisles, and that didn't appeal to me. I have to say this, and this is kind of funny. A friend of mine did a production of Mamma Mia in the Bay Area a few years ago, and I went to see it because I love my friend. And I loved it.
And I totally got it. And I loved the book, I loved the story, I loved the arc, I loved everything about it. I think it's a little unfair that the lead has all those power ballads run right after the other in the second act. That seems unfair to do to anybody in any show. Eight times a week. That's tough. But I totally get it. I totally was swept up in it. I regret not seeing it early on in its run. That was a mistake on my part. That's what I have to say about Mamma Mia.
[1:37:31] Rob Russo: Yeah. I saw it a couple times on Broadway, and I agree. I mean, I think of all the jukebox musicals, that it's kind of the best one because it knows exactly what it is. It lives in a consistent world, it tells a great story, it's funny, it has great songs, and it built the story around the songs instead of the other way around, taking an existing story and trying to put the songs into it. So the songs, even if a little cheesy at times, do sort of organically grow out of the situations, and they were able to really reverse engineer because they weren't wedded to any, you know, pre-existing story. So they could do anything they wanted with it. And I think they did a great job. Now there is some controversy because the plot is very similar to a 1968 film, Buenos Aires of Mrs. Campbell, which was the source material for 1979 musical Carmelina, which I knew nothing about until I saw Carmelina at the York Theater last year.
It's this very sweet musical with a score by Burton Lane and Alan Jay Lerner, with a book by Joseph Stein, but it's essentially the plot of Mamma Mia. Now, the book writer of Mamma Mia denies this, Catherine Johnson. She says, No, I had no idea with that film and the musical. So I don't know, we'll see.
[1:38:39] Jamie DuMont: Well, you know, exactly true. I mean, look, you know, Miss Saigon is Madame Butterfly. I mean, the list goes on and on and on.
[1:38:46] Jamie DuMont: But I understand, I understand why this is a slightly more controversial than that. But no, Mamma Mia, I'm here for it. The winner takes it all.
[1:39:35] Rob Russo: Okay, moving on to 2003, Wicked, which has been running at the Gershwin Theatre since 2003, over 6,836 performances. That's now makes it having run longer than A Chorus Line as a point of reference. It's the fifth longest running show in Broadway history. It's the second highest grossing show in Broadway history with 1.4 billion dollars in box office grosses just from Broadway and a worldwide gross of over $3.5 billion. Of course, based on the 1995 Gregory Maguire novel Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West, which a friend gave to Stephen Schwartz while he was on vacation in Hawaii. And he says from the second he started reading it, he thought, this is my next project, this is my next musical.
But then he found out that Universal Pictures had already optioned it to make a film. So he had to go to them and convince them that no, no, no, they shouldn't make a film. First, they should make a stage show. It should be a musical, and it should be his musical. He won the argument, came to Broadway in 2003, opened to very, very middling reviews, if not borderline hostile. And 17 years later, it's still running.
[1:40:46] ♪ Musical number: "Popular" — performed by Wicked cast ♪
[1:41:19] Jamie DuMont: I would venture a guess that Marc Platt and Universal are very glad that they decided to go with the musical version and put their project on hold.
[1:41:29] Rob Russo: I'm sure that's, I'm sure they feel that way.
[1:41:33] Jamie DuMont: Well, because now they're gearing up to make the movie. And, you know, that I'm sure will be another phenomenon, if and or when it comes out, who knows? But Wicked, one of the biggest hits ever, second highest grossing show in Broadway history. I mean, that's pretty incredible. What I think is interesting about this is that, you know, Wicked had a sort of troubled road to Broadway. They had an out of town tryout at the Curran in San Francisco. It got mixed to negative reviews. There was a lot of sort of bad buzz about it. And yet, Stephen Schwartz, who is so smart, knew to build in time between the run in San Francisco and starting rehearsals in Broadway. And Winnie Holzman has said that that is what saved the show. The fact that they had that three months to work on what needed to be worked on and address whatever issues that needed to be addressed is what made the show ultimately work. And I think that is, and that's Stephen Schwartz, right?
[1:42:31] Rob Russo: Right.
[1:42:32] Jamie DuMont: That was his thing. And that is somebody who knows their way around making theater, who understands the business, and has an inherent sense of how to make something happen.
[1:42:44] Rob Russo: Yeah, well, and it's also a real triumphant story for Stephen Schwartz because obviously he was the Wunderkind of Broadway in the early 70s, right? He had Godspell, Pippin, and The Magic Show all running on Broadway concurrently, all big hits. And his next project, The Baker's Wife, was a disaster, and then Working was a huge flop. He worked on Rags, but he didn't have another show under his sole authorship until 2003 with Wicked. And he said, candidly in interviews, that the pressure of working on Broadway and the criticism almost drew him away from the field entirely. And that's why he went to work in Hollywood and worked on Hunchback of Notre Dame and Pocahontas and all these Disney films, because he didn't feel comfortable, he didn't feel welcome, he didn't feel like Broadway was a space for him anymore.
And I'm glad he overcame that and pushed through it to create Wicked, despite the fact that once again it didn't receive particularly positive reviews, and he didn't win a Tony Award. He's never won a Tony Award, he has a special Tony Award, but he's never won a competitive Tony Award. And yet he's penned some of the greatest songs and musicals in Broadway history. So, you know, take that for what you will.
[1:43:58] Jamie DuMont: Well, I'm not a huge fan of Wicked. I understand its success and I understand its appeal. It's not particularly a show that speaks to me. However, the score is magnificent. I love that score.
[1:44:10] Rob Russo: It really is. It's some of his best work. And I think it's a shame he doesn't have a Tony Award for actually a specific score. I think they're all of them deserve it. But in this particular case, do you know what won that year, what won best score? I don't even know.
[1:44:28] Jamie DuMont: Well, it was Avenue Q, which also won Best Musical.
[1:44:32] Rob Russo: Yeah, it was a big upset.
[1:44:34] Jamie DuMont: Oh yeah, it was a big upset. I was in the house that night. I was at Radio City for that particular Tony Awards, and I can tell you that was, no matter where you stood in terms of what show you were rooting for, and believe me, everyone had an opinion and was divided that year. The Avenue Q winning was a crazy, crazy, crazy moment.
[1:44:56] Rob Russo: Yeah, and if you haven't watched the Dori Berinstein documentary ShowBusiness, which documents the four musicals on Broadway that season, you have to, because it really captures that whole story quite dramatically.
[1:45:10] Jamie DuMont: It really does. And I'm a big fan of Avenue Q. I think interestingly, it probably doesn't hold up as well as even Wicked does.
[1:45:17] Rob Russo: It doesn't, it does not at all.
[1:45:19] Jamie DuMont: No, and I think that that's a real shame. I really do think that Wicked, I also think that Caroline, or Change should have won for score. So, you know, it's one of those it was a stacked year.
[1:45:31] Rob Russo: Yeah, it really was.
[1:45:32] ♪ Musical number: "For Good" — performed by Wicked cast ♪
[1:47:01] Jamie DuMont: Okay, so before we loop back to Hamilton and end this three-part episode, I feel like we just have to mention really briefly the one other big juggernaut of the 21st century that's sort of the precursor to Hamilton, and that was The Book of Mormon, which is still running on Broadway.
[1:47:17] Rob Russo: Well, was as of March. It's been running for nine years, and you know, was its own sensation when it opened in 2011 and grossed a ton of money. I mean, I think it's the fifth highest grossing show in Broadway history, recouped in nine months. So it felt odd for us not to mention it, although I think neither one of us has much to say about The Book of Mormon because it's The Book of Mormon, and you know, everyone knows what it is, and it's just another certifiable big hit.
[1:47:41] Jamie DuMont: What do they always say? If you don't have something nice to say, right.
[1:47:47] Rob Russo: Right, right. Well, Helen Shaw went back and re-reviewed the show last year, and all I'll say is go find that review, read it, and I agree with it a hundred percent. I co-sign Helen Shaw.
[1:47:58] Jamie DuMont: Well, I think this brings us to the end of our epic part look at hits, right?
[1:48:05] Rob Russo: So epic, yeah.
[1:48:06] Jamie DuMont: Well, it turns out Broadway has a lot of hits.
[1:48:08] Rob Russo: Well, it does. And, you know, we mentioned this a little bit earlier. The late 90s really felt like a renaissance, and it really felt like a resurgence of another sort of golden age of musicals, which is why I think we had to make this a three-part episode because clearly there was a lot to talk about in the latter part of the 20th century, but also in the early days of the 21st century, which brings us full circle back to Hamilton.
[1:48:34] Jamie DuMont: Yes, yes. You know, there is there's nothing quite like Hamilton. I mean, it's the biggest hit we've seen in what feels like decades in terms of its cross-cultural impact and its ability to really become a part of mainstream American culture, which rarely happens for a musical these days, and of course, culminating in the premiere on Disney Plus of the pro shot of the show from back in 2016 with the original cast, which of course is all anyone's talking about right now. And you know, it's funny. I feel like after Hamilton, it's like, well, there'll never be another show as big as Hamilton, right? But I'm sure people said that after Oklahoma ran five years. They were probably like, oh, there'll never be anything like Oklahoma. So I guess we're just gonna have to wait and see when the next Hamilton comes.
[1:49:24] Rob Russo: I certainly remember during Rent that a lot of people were saying there will never be another Rent. And then a few years go by and boom, there it is.
[1:49:34] Jamie DuMont: The funny thing about that is that you know, there won't be another Hamilton because the next thing will be its own thing, right? So that and you won't be able to even compare, right? It'll elevate the form even more. And what I always say, and did as I said at the top of this whole episode is that, you know, for me, Hamilton is just a triumph of the form of musical theater. And it falls in line with the tradition of all the great shows.
[1:50:01] Rob Russo: I agree with that. I also think that it's the perfect example of the title of our show, The Fabulous Invalid. This is what we've been talking about now for five full episodes, right? That the theater has its ups and it has its downs. We are sadly in a very down place right now.
[1:50:20] Jamie DuMont: Very down, yeah.
[1:50:21] Rob Russo: But we will be back. Hamilton will be back. Many of the shows that we've discussed will come back, will get revived. Who knows? Maybe we'll see Bring Back Birdie. Maybe there'll be a revival of that someday. Wouldn't that be great?
[1:50:35] Jamie DuMont: Uh-oh. Yeah. Yeah. Calling Leslie Kritzer.
[1:50:38] Rob Russo: Oh, okay. Well, that I would, I'm always here for Leslie on stage. Amazing. Okay. Well, I think we should wrap it up. And not only are we wrapping up this little miniseries, but we're wrapping up season two of The Fabulous Invalid. So we're gonna take a break for the summer and we'll be back in the fall.
[1:50:55] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, and it's been an interesting year. It's been a challenging year. It's been a tough year on everyone. But Rob Russo, I have to say that I am eternally grateful that we have been able to continue to do this. It's been a lot of fun. It will be fun to do it again in a few months. And I can't wait to see what we do for season three.
[1:51:15] ♪ Musical number: "I Believe" — performed by The Book of Mormon cast ♪
[1:52:08] Rob Russo: Well, that's our show. Thanks for listening. At this difficult time, please consider making a donation to the Actors Fund at ActorsFund.org. The Fabulous Invalid is a production of OM Etcetera and the Fabulous Invalid LLC and a proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network. Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Charles Van Kirk. Find us online at thefabulousinvalid.com and on social media at Fabulous Invalid and on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever you listen to your podcasts.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
