Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 89: Jerry Herman: Poet of the Showtune, Part Two

For a special, two-part show, Jamie and Rob take an in-depth look at the life, work, and legacy of Broadway composer and lyricist Jerry Herman—“the poet of the showtune”... Read More

From the show: The Fabulous Invalid

1 h 49 mins
2/3/21

Guests

Featured Shows

About

For a special, two-part show, Jamie and Rob take an in-depth look at the life, work, and legacy of Broadway composer and lyricist Jerry Herman—“the poet of the showtune”. They chat with performers Joel Grey, Florence Lacey, Lee Roy Reams, and Alix Korey, music director Andy Einhorn, producer Barry Brown, and actress and cabaret star Molly Pope. Part two focuses on his lesser known shows, “Milk and Honey”, “Dear World”, and “Mack and Mabel”, and his ultimate comeback hit: “La Cage aux Folles”. Tune in to discover why there really is no tune like a showtune!

This week’s music: “Overture”, “Milk & Honey”, Shalom”, “Let’s Not Waste A Moment”, all from “Milk & Honey, Original Cast Recording”. “Overture”, “Each Tomorrow Morning”, “I Don’t Want to Know”, “Dear World”, all from “Dear World, Original Cast Recording”. “I Promise You A Happy Ending” from “Gifts of Love”. “Look What Happened to Mabel” from “Mack & Mabel, 1995 London Cast Recording”. “Just Go to the Movies” from “A Day In Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine, Original Cast”. “Two A Day”, and “Kiss Her Now”, and “Jerry’s Girls” from “Jerry’s Girls”. “It’s Today” from “An Evening with Jerry Herman”. “Finale”, “Prelude”, “A Little More Mascara”, “The Finale”, all from “La Cage aux Folles, Original Broadway Cast”. “The Best of Times” courtesy of Molly Pope. “I Am What I Am” and “Look Over There”, from “La Cage aux Folles, Original Broadway Cast”. “Miss What's Her Name”, from “Miss Spectacular”. “I’ll Be Here Tomorrow” sung by Jerry Herman.

Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid

Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid

Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc

Email us at: office@fabulousinvalid.com

Jamie DuMont

Twitter: @jamiedumont

Instagram: @troutinnyc

Rob Russo

Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:21] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important and innovative theater makers working today, from actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.

[0:34] Rob Russo: We took our name from the title of a 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself.

[0:41] Jamie DuMont: Always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back, the fabulous invalid.

[0:45] Rob Russo: I'm Theodore Savant, Jamie DuMont.

[0:48] Jamie DuMont: And I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with Stagelet.nyc and Stage Left the Podcast.

[0:54] Rob Russo: Do you like with the authority with which I said the fabulous invalid?

[0:59] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, no, that was fun.

[1:01] Rob Russo: It uh, you know, it's well deserved because uh you can't say the word fabulous without having a little bit of uh, you know, fabulous in it, right?

[1:09] Jamie DuMont: Well, and I think Fabulous describes our two-part look at Jerry Herman.

[1:15] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah.

[1:16] Jamie DuMont: Well, we had so much fun doing this. I have to say, last time we uh took a look at uh Hello Dolly, Mame and the Grand Tour.

[1:23] Rob Russo: But this time we're gonna dive into some more of his less renowned shows like Milk and Honey and Dear World.

[1:28] Jamie DuMont: And of course, uh, we'll examine his ultimate comeback with La Cage aux Folles.

[1:42] Jamie DuMont: Yes, you'll also hear from music director Andy Einhorn, who was the music director for the 2017 Broadway revival of Hello Dolly, and just conceived and music directed the virtual review You I Like, a musical celebration of Jerry Herman for the Pasadena Playhouse.

[1:55] Rob Russo: And of course, Barry Brown, who was the executive producer of La Cage aux Folles in 1983.

[2:00] Jamie DuMont: And last but certainly not least, the great cabaret star Molly Pope.

[2:06] Rob Russo: Yes, yes. Well, to kick us off, here's a great story from the inimitable Lee Roy Reams.

[2:12] Lee Roy Reams: Jerry was honored at NYU, along with some other composers and lyricists. And he asked me, which he did often, to come and sing with him because we were joined at the hip. I mean, I can brag about it all night long if you want to hear the stories. And uh we went to this thing, and everybody, and Jerry's getting the award, and I sang with him at the piano. And then some of the other people received the award got up and played their things with their singers. And Jerry just looked at me in one point after the other people had performed and he said, Well, if that's what Broadway is going to sound like, I guess it's good. I'm getting ready to die.

[3:11] Lee Roy Reams: Uh the lesser known and the not as successful ones, it's not because of his score. Because you can take any Jerry Herman song out of context, the audience knows nothing about it, and you sing the song, and they understand the story, and they relate to the melody. And it's really such a gift that I think he is a genius, and his stuff is always going to survive because of that. He delves into a character and is able to get to the yin and the yang of the character almost at the same time, it seems to me. And that's very complicated and very profound, I think, and something that he is not given enough credit for.

[3:57] Rob Russo: Well, you ask why does Jerry's music live on? Why are these words live on? Because you can go see Bette Midler do Hello Dolly, but you can also go see your local high school do Hello Dolly, and it works every single time. It's why Fiddler works, it's why Oklahoma works. It's like the shows themselves are so sturdy. It's essential. And what I hope is years from now that people will really come to appreciate why this person lived and why this person wrote.

[4:30] Lee Roy Reams: He wanted to be an architect when he started out his career. He wanted to do that, and that's what he went to school for. Jerry got inspired when he went to see uh Ethel Merman in Annie Get Your Gun. And he came home, and he was an only child, and of course he adored his mother. And he came home and he went over the piano and he just started plunking out the songs. He had that kind of thing, and so but he didn't really study music that much. So but he had a good ear, and he and that's how he got started. And his mother, of course, when he was writing songs, and it's not when they went to summer camp, they had a summer camp that his parents ran and they did shows and he would perform and play the piano and stuff.

And so his mother said that she had a friend who had a friend who was a friend, uh, Frank Loesser, and Jerry wasn't gonna go. He said, of course you like my songs, you're my mother. But he went. She said, Waste, waste uh, waste a half an hour of your life. And he went and he played his songs, and Frank Loesser said, You're a composer. You're a you this is good. And he changed Jerry's point of view. And that's what he did then. Then when he went to school and he did theater and all of that, and then came to New York and did his little review Parade. And uh, you know, when a producer was there and said, You're gonna write my next Broadway show, and it was Milk and Honey.

[5:56] Lee Roy Reams: This is the land of Milk and Honey. This is the land of sun and song, and this is a world of a week after Jerry met with that producer, he was on a plane to the Middle East. Book writer Don Appell was a total stranger to Jerry. The show they had been hired to write had no source material, no play, no novel, no idea, no title even. Their only instructions were that it take place in Israel and quote unquote sound ethnic. Oh my god. Can you imagine getting that direction today? Right? Well, while they were on the plane together, Don came up with a charming idea of doing a story about a group of American widows who come on a tour to Israel in search of love. One meets a man, and the story takes off from there.

It would be a musical about older people finding love set against the celebration of the young state of Israel. They hired Molly Picon, a celebrated star of the Yiddish theater, to play a role that was tailor-made for her talents. And after a tryout in New Haven, Milk and Honey, as the show came to be called, opened on Broadway in October 1961.

[7:03] Jamie DuMont: Wow. You know, Molly Picon, I think, is one of those people that people don't really know. I have loved her. You know, that's the weird thing of being me, even as a young boy, I knew who she was, and I was sort of obsessed with her. And when I moved to New York and we went to the 2nd Avenue Deli for the first time, there was a at the time I they've moved locations, but at the time there was like a wall dedicated to Molly Picon, and I was like, I'm in the right city.

[7:30] Rob Russo: Well, you know, what's so fascinating to me about you know, about her and about this show, you know, is that keep in mind 1961, this is three years before Fiddler on the Roof, right? It's five years before Cabaret, it's nine years before the Rothschilds. You know, and here is this musical by a team that no one had ever heard of, right? Nobody knew who Jerry Herman was about, you know, Jews in Israel, right? Like the subject matter was not necessarily, you know, what people would think of as, you know, a setting for a big Broadway musical, right? I mean, the concern about Fiddler on the Roof, right? Nobody wanted to produce it because they thought nobody's gonna come once the Jews have seen it, you won't have an audience, right? And boy, were they wrong about that.

[8:11] Jamie DuMont: But you know, uh, after uh a very nervous opening night performance at the Martin Beck Theater, during which Jerry famously paced back and forth in the lobby, rave reviews poured in for Milk and Honey. I mean, he was only 30 years old, which is pretty amazing to think about, but he had written in 1961, you know, the newest hit musical on Broadway. And the most famous song, and the first song he wrote is the opening number, Shalom, inspired by the simple but useful word that Jerry and Don heard nonstop on their visit to Israel.

[8:48] Lee Roy Reams: Shalom, shalom, you will find shalom, the nicest greeting, you know. It means bonjour, salut and soul, and twice as much as hello.

[9:04] Jamie DuMont: It means the one that I'm so like quietly obsessed with that I don't know if it'll ever receive another production or do is Milk and Honey as well, because there again you have a story, and the irony of Jerry, like in his late 20s writing a show about widows in Israel. There's just so many things to sort of swallow when you hear all of those words in one sentence. But when you think about writing about love and second chances for anybody, I mean, who among us can't relate to that?

[10:09] Lee Roy Reams: We don't have to heal the clock remind us that there's more than half of life behind us when you fail. Despite being a hit in its time, Milk and Honey is rarely, if ever, performed. I caught Alix Korey playing the Molly Picon role of Clara Weiss in the York Theatre's musicals and Mufti concert production in 2017.

[10:38] Alix Korey: I sort of consider uh Milk and Honey my swan song. Jerry, who I think was very, very ill by that point in Florida, he actually sent us a voicemail. We were fortunate to get a copy of the voicemail that Jerry Herman left for the company of Milk and Honey. It's Jerry Herman calling to wish you all a brilliant and exciting openness. I want to thank you all for giving new life to my first Broadway baby. Shalom, everybody. And thanks for doing it.

[11:22] Lee Roy Reams: What surprised me was actually how terrific the book was. You know, we knew that the score was fabulous, but the book was funny and smart and touching, very truthful characters. We used to have talkbacks afterwards, and people would say, well, why don't they really do a revival of it and all of that? And you know, we all sort of sensed that the politics of the subject now was uh so rife with partisanship that people felt they wouldn't, you know, the audiences would not come to it with a uh an open mind.

[12:14] Alix Korey: I too was struck by how good the book is. I mean, I was prepared to cringe at it being dated. Um, but sadly, you know, perhaps given the intractable nature of politics in the region, you know, not much has really changed in the past 60 years. I mean, rather tragically.

[12:32] Lee Roy Reams: Well, that's very true. Uh, but Don and Jerry, despite their producers' wishes, didn't want to write a show that was propaganda. Their trip to Israel was a planned tour, and after a few days, they turned to each other and they confessed that they both thought they were being kept from seeing things the tour guides didn't want them to see. So they set out on their own to see some of the real people and the real sights, which I love.

[12:57] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah. Well, and and it and I I think it shows in the final product. You know, Jerry was was determined to be honest in writing this piece. And, you know, what I love is, you know, amid the title song, Milk and Honey, you have to have a title song. Um, you know, which is itself, you know, it sounds like a national anthem, right? It's this sort of patriotic love letter to the state of Israel, you know, just like gushing, gushing. But upon repetition of the chorus, if you listen closely, and it's really clear, Jerry added a counterpoint melody that is sung by a single character, Addie Gluck, who uh is sort of like the grumbler of uh of the groups on stage. And he offers a counterpoint of view, you know, that is more cynical than his fellow countrymen.

[13:39] Rob Russo: You can hear it here.

[13:46] Jamie DuMont: And then Milkselito Source. Do you know that Pebble is the state's official flower? How about the tensions, political dissentions, and no one ever mentions that the scenery is barren and Tori and Arid and Horith and how about the border when the serious attack?

[14:13] Rob Russo: As Jerry later mused, the show came out as a Valentine, but he was so proud of that quote gray shadow that made it truthful.

[14:39] Jamie DuMont: I gotta say, and I this is uh so to your credit, Rob, that like listening. I I've I you know I know that that riff that Juki does in the title song, and I've heard it before, but like until you really pointed that out to me, I never really listened to it with great intent or with with really like open ears. It's magnificent. Like it's it's actually, I think, the foundation of that entire score, that entire show. It's the whole backbone of everything that Jerry was trying to do. And again, I think it's the thing of like Jerry is so complicated. Everyone thinks it's because it's such a you know, it's such a rousing anthem, and it's so like um it's so fun to listen to, but it's like really deep. And even when you say goodbye, if your voice has I don't want to go in it. Say goodbye with a little and say goodbye.

[16:02] Rob Russo: We know Jerry's tunes. Everybody can hum these tunes, but it is because that those words are married to those tunes that we're all the better for that. And I think the tendency right now is to overwrite the lyric. You know, and it at the expense of good songwriting, because you know, when you look at a Jerry Herman song or a Sondheim song or um Alan Mencken or Rogers and Hammerstein, every note is chosen to fit every word perfectly. And there's not there's no fat around the edges. It's all right there. I think his legacy will probably be that he wrote great women's roles, and that he wrote about human beings. Where else on Broadway, you get the occasional role, uh, the the gypsy, the Fanny Bryce, but very rarely is there a show where the star is a complex, interesting, fabulous woman.

Shows that men are jealous of. You know how every woman wants to play Don Quixote. Every man seems to want to play Hello Dolly or Mame. Well, there is a Jerry Herman show that rarely gets done, where the star is a complex, interesting, fabulous woman. And that show is Dear World. This was actually the first musical that was Jerry's idea. He was hired to write Milk and Honey without there even being a plot because of his work on the mostly self-produced review parade. David Merrick hired him to write Hello Dolly because of his work on Milk and Honey. And Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee sought him out to write MAME because of the success of Hello Dolly. And he jumped to do that. So following those three hits, Jerry finally had the freedom and the power to do whatever he wanted.

And so he set out to make a musical of Jean Giraudot's play, The Mad Woman of Chayot, which uh oddly enough, he had performed in college and absolutely fell in love with. And the play, uh, if you don't know it, is about the irrepressible Countess Aurelia, who, along with her pals, Constance and Gabrielle, deviously schemed to stop businessmen from drilling for oil in the Parisian neighborhood of Chayot. You know, the typical uh plot of a musical. The show itself is um, you know, sort of like an impressionistic, almost surreal tale that meditates on idealism, materialism, and science, uh, and the power of love and poetry to to win over cynicism and greed. Um, and the lead character, Countess Aurelia, um, is an unlikely one for a musical at the time, right? She's like this this crinkly 80-year-old, you know, so-called mad woman who lives in a sewer and wears rags.

[19:07] Jamie DuMont: Oh my god, I'll never hear the word crinkly again. Thanks for that, Rob.

[19:11] Rob Russo: Well, naturally, Jerry and the producer Alexander Cohen assembled most of the same team who had made MAME such a success in 1966. We had book writers Lawrence and Lee, we had orchestrator Philip Lang, music director Donald Pippin, and then, of course, personal favorite of mine, actress Jane Connell, and then finally Angela Lansbury to star as Countess Aurelia. Dear World had the makings of a hit, but it would become Jerry's first flop. As the show was being put together, it slowly slipped away from Jerry's hands and got further and further from his original idea of an intimate chamber piece. He had imagined a small orchestration for street musicians, a concertina, a flute, maybe a fiddle, and a total ensemble of maybe 12 performers.

No chorus, no big production numbers, just an unusual look and the small sound of a Parisian street brand. But Alexander Cohen booked the Mark Hellinger Theater, the Times Square Church today, which one of the biggest theaters on Broadway, right? And then everything ended up growing to meet the size of the theater. So bigger sets, more lavish costumes, a bigger cast, a full orchestra, the works. After hiring and firing three, three directors, they finally landed on Joe Leighton, who was also a choreographer, so gradually more and more dance was added to the show. By the time it opened on Broadway in February 1969, while Jerry Herman was the undisputed king of the great White Way, the show bore almost no resemblance to the show he had in his mind.

Audiences came expecting another Hello Dolly or Mame. And what they got was a rather bizarre French fairy tale in an overwrought production. Suffice to say, critics hated it, and the very, very sensitive Jerry Herman was devastated. It was the first of three flops in a row. Uh Mac and Mabel in 1974, um, which would become celebrated, right? You know, sort of have a cult status unto itself. The Grand Tour in 1979, which would be Forgotten, and Dear World, right? His first uh flop, which for the rest of his life, Jerry would lament, never got the production that he first dreamed of. I do hope that at some point somebody will figure out a way to do the version of Dear World that Jerry wanted to do.

I know that that that was the show that Yeah, that was the show that he always really wanted to conquer and figure out how to do. And I I'm wondering if coming out of this moment is really the the time now, because when you think, I mean, I I'm such a sucker, but every time I think about what that show speaks to is like the revelation of that character, really is that she's the one in the end who sees it all. So she isn't the mad woman. You know, and that's that that's the ultimate amazing thing about that piece. And I think it was I think it was very misunderstood. And it it, you know, it it came at a moment where at that moment Angela was a star. And so you almost wonder, oh, did that almost hurt the piece, or or did it, or was it that people were excited to see Angela, and then they came and they're like, What the hell is this? You know, it's so out there.

[22:52] ♪ Musical number: "Each Tomorrow Morning" — performed by Angela Lansbury ♪

[23:26] Rob Russo: Years ago, Betty Buckley did a production of Dear World in London. Do you remember this? And um my friend Sarah Travis, who did the Sweeney Todd orchestrations for the John Doyle revival, she called me. She was like, So Betty's doing this. Would you go work with her on the material before she went to London? So I remember these meetings we went to Gillian Lynn's apartment on the Upper East Side, me and Betty Buckley and Jillian would just talk about the show. But that that actually was my real introduction to that score was working through it with Betty, and she sounded amazing. I mean, hearing her sing I don't want to know was like I just remember she was like less than two feet away from me belting, I don't want to know, and I thought to myself, well, it doesn't get better than this.

You know what's brilliant about that song is it's so classic Jerry Herman, um, in terms of you hear the lyric twice, it's the whole set of lyric twice, but really the conviction comes in the repetition of that lyric, which to me again is such perfect golden age writing. Like when you think of why do we hear a lyric twice in a song, it's because there's meant to be an emphasis on hearing that lyric again.

[24:42] ♪ Musical number: "I Don't Want to Know" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[24:42] ♪ Musical number: "I Don't Want to Know" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[25:32] ♪ Musical number: "I Don't Want to Know" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[25:32] ♪ Musical number: "I Don't Want to Know" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[25:32] ♪ Musical number: "I Don't Want to Know" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[25:32] ♪ Musical number: "I Don't Want to Know" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[25:50] Jamie DuMont: I I I uh to use an Alix Korey word, I'm cavelling. That song deserves to be a standard, and it's kind of shocking that it isn't. It's glorious, and you know, Jerry wrote it out of town. It's a classic hotel room song, which by the way, Rob, we're gonna do a show on hotel room. Just dangling that out there, because I think that's a great idea. Um, but he wrote it in a hotel room, not unlike Before the Parade Passes by.

[26:15] Rob Russo: Yeah, it's amazing what what a little pressure can do to the creative juices, right? Um, well, despite Dear World being a flop, um, it ran for 132 performances on the strength of of Jerry Herman and Angela Lanceberry's uh Star Power.

[26:30] Jamie DuMont: Oh my god. Well, and Star Power, she has. She did win the 1969 Tony Award for Best Actress in a musical for her performance as Countess Aurelia. I mean, frankly, after hearing that song, you can understand why. And if you ever look at any production photos, the makeup alone deserved his own Tony Award, you know? It's crazy. Crazy, crazy, crazy.

[26:50] Rob Russo: Yeah, and you know, listen to that cast album because the score is is full of gems, right? We mean we can't give you everything here, but check out The Tea Party, which um, you know, was Jerry's first counterpoint, because as we learned, Bob Merrill actually wrote uh Motherhood. So he he took that same idea, and um, it's an amazing scene, you know, to listen to it. You really get a sense of the bizarreness of the show. Um, but also his incredible skill as a writer. And then, you know, we're gonna play some of Kiss Her Now, which is another ballad from the show, which Leslie Oggams famously sang in Jerry's Girls.

[27:21] Rob Russo: Um, but you'll hear that later on in this episode.

[27:23] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, ballad seems like the wrong word. It's more like a call to action in its own way. Kiss her now. It's an anthem for love. Anyway, um, I digress. But uh before we close this section, we have to play the infamous title song to Dear World, which Jerry later wrote this is one of the only songs I've ever written that I wish I hadn't.

[27:48] Rob Russo: Oh, so sad.

[27:51] Jamie DuMont: But true, right? I mean, after writing three successful title songs in a row, Milk and Honey, that anthem, Hello Dolly, which I mean, come on, and Mame, right? Like the greatest title song ever. Jerry didn't want to write another one, right? And he knew that this show didn't call for it, right? He wanted that small, intimate story. It didn't, it didn't call for a big title number. But of course, he was Jerry Herman, right? It's like the burden of being Jerry Herman in 1968, right? Is that the producer and the creative team, everybody kept pushing, and unfortunately, he eventually relented. And he wrote what he himself would say is the song that doomed the show. Listen and judge for yourself.

[28:33] ♪ Musical number: "Dear World" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[29:29] Rob Russo: Yes, oh yes. And the show only ran 66 performances in 1974.

[29:34] Jamie DuMont: Right, right. It was the shortest run of any Jerry Herman musical on Broadway. But despite its failure, you know, everybody agrees the score is a knockout, right? And that original cast album captures the iconic performances of Bernadette Peters and Robert Preston as, you know, silent film star Mabel Normand and uh, you know, the acclaimed silent film director Mac Sennett and their sort of misbegotten uh love, love story.

[29:59] Rob Russo: Yeah, and I will I'm just gonna plug it. Check out that episode, which we put together around the time of the City Center Encore production last year, which shockingly, or maybe not so shockingly, was the first time that show had been done in New York since 1974. I mean, that it's crazy to me that the last version was directed by a Gower Champion. No one's no one's even tried it since in New York. Clearly, it's been done a couple of other places, right? And and that's another example of like, you know, of course, Gower Champion famously directed Hello Dolly with a book by Michael Stewart. And so, you know, you get the band back together a couple years later or a decade later to do Mac and Mabel, and it just you know, just didn't work. Um so we did a whole episode about it, check it out. Um, but we did speak to Alix Korey, Lee Roy Reams, and Andy Einhorn about the show and its troubled history.

[30:51] Alix Korey: Jerry used to say the reason it wasn't a hit was because Gower was in his blue period. It probably would have been a more upbeat show. Um if if there had been a different um leading guide to it.

[31:19] Lee Roy Reams: Um but you know, what I don't know. I don't know. Can you make the story of uh a horrible human being who becomes a very successful man and the girl that he loves but exploits, and then and then you know, the last line is and then Mabel died.

[31:41] Alix Korey: Right. So, right? So you know, what do you what do you what do you do with that? And of course, his favorite score is Mac and Mabel, which was not a hit, but uh that's his favorite score, and as he said he had to be talked into doing it, but uh the songs are really great, and the show has its problems, and but still in all people keep wanting to do the show to correct those problems, but I think it's the basic story plot that uh is difficult to overcome, and with Jerry's optimism and his, you know, get out there and carry on upward and onward with that kind of attitude he has, maybe it doesn't fit as well with the tragedy of that story.

[32:19] Lee Roy Reams: You know, my favorite song is actually a song from Mac and Mabel that nobody does, which is I promise you a happy ending. I I would say that that's my song. It's got my favorite chord in it, it's got this Jewish chord, I call it, because it's just that it elicits that kind of uh in it, uh, in I promise you, I promise you a happy ending.

[32:54] Alix Korey: Oh, I love that chord.

[33:02] Lee Roy Reams: A happy ending, like the ones that you see on the screen. So if you've had a bad beginning, love will come out winning in the closing scene, and if you find But even when you think about songs like Look What Happened to Mabel and you hear dot that it's that syncopation in there that hooks you in.

[33:42] Alix Korey: Like you feel it calling you into it. You know, or then when you look at suddenly you're like, oh my gosh, I want to lean in. So every single time he seems to do it, and you're like, how do you do this perfectly every single damn time? It's it's astonishing.

[34:03] Lee Roy Reams: I mean, it it just to me goes right here, right to the heart. He literally is like a cardiologist. He's cracking open your your chest cavity and pulling out your heart because every time he's grabbing it, it's always there.

[34:20] Alix Korey: There's no one word to describe it. It just is. Like it's a Jerry Herman is. That's why he's the poet of the show tune. I mean, he is showtune.

[34:45] Lee Roy Reams: Hold your tongue and hold your snake small than you enchant. That play little Nelly. The kid from the deli. The kid from the telly. So madle may be what happened to me.

[35:07] Jamie DuMont: Mac and Mabel really is a tricky show because it's a musical about the movies, which is really hard to capture on stage, I think.

[35:15] Rob Russo: Yeah, I mean, I think you make a good point. That's that's possibly one of the main reasons that it doesn't quite work. Um I, you know, we've now seen the Encores production. So we can sort of speak to uh, you know, they tinkered with it yet again. Um I think I think ultimately uh it was more successful uh at Encores uh with what they did with it.

[35:41] Jamie DuMont: You know, look, I'm and I'm gonna get a lot of hate mail for this. Like, I'm the guy that thinks merrily we roll along works. I'm the guy that thinks Mac and Mabel works. So like I'm a bad person to talk about it because like I don't see it's such a big deal that she does at the end, right?

[35:58] Rob Russo: Like, I don't mind a sad ending. Tap your troubles away is an example of another Jerry Herman song that doesn't get the credit it deserves. On the surface level, it's this happy go lucky number. But when you actually see it in the context of the show in performances, and this is something I didn't really appreciate, it is on par with anything Kander and Ebb ever wrote in terms of having irony and cynicism, because what you're watching during this tap your troubles away number is Mabel Norman descend into drug use and you know violence, right?

[36:30] Jamie DuMont: And she's ultimately, you know, wrapped up in this murder case, right? And all that is unfolding on stage while you're watching this peppy happy uh tap number. So it's not just a tap number to have a tap number, as Alix Korey would say. You know, he never did that. He wrote a tap number that very intentionally was ironic.

[36:49] Lee Roy Reams: Yes. And, you know, that's again another example of how Jerry's genius and his understanding of how songs work in a show is not just as simple as, you know, peppy and happy. No, he really was a dramatist, as all great songwriters really are. They're they're dramatists.

[37:05] Alix Korey: I agree with that. And I think it's I'm glad that you point that out because I that's a perfect example of I think the thing that we really want to convey here, which is the complexity of his of his of his work and his songs and of his brain. Just the just the way he thought about things is so much more complicated than get the ice out. It's today, right? Like there's a lot going on there, and it's all in every one of his scores.

[37:35] Rob Russo: Well, sadly, you know, Jerry was so devastated by the failure of Mac and Mabel. You know, he's someone who really took criticism personally, and he was so wounded by that and having two flops in a row that he left New York, right? I mean, he literally packed his bags and put himself in his own, you know, self-imposed professional exile on the West Coast. He thought he would never write again.

[37:56] Jamie DuMont: Book writer Michael Stewart, who was like a brother to Jerry, as we've mentioned, talked him into coming out of exile to write The Grand Tour in 1979, which, as we talked about in our last episode, turned out to be another big flop. The next thing Jerry would write, though, before his big comeback with La Cage, would be some special material for the 1980 musical A Day in Hollywood, A Night in the Ukraine.

[38:19] Rob Russo: Yes, I love this. Um the show itself was an import from the United Kingdom with a new director, Tommy Tune, uh, who had been brought on to, you know, bring it to American audiences. And he called Jerry while the show was out of town in Baltimore and asked, you know, if if Jerry would consider writing an opening number about the movies. He felt that's what the show really needed.

[38:36] Jamie DuMont: And Jerry said, sure, you know, sounds like fun. So he agreed to it, and then Tommy informed him that he needed it in 24 hours.

[38:44] Rob Russo: I love that. Right? So in classic form, you know, it's not a hotel room song, but it's kind of that same kind of thing. Jerry locked himself in a room. He conjured every old Hollywood image he could, and he delivered the song on time.

[39:11] ♪ Musical number: "Just Go to the Movies" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[39:54] Jamie DuMont: Yes, yes. And you know, it's pretty amazing. Only two of Jerry Herman's seven Broadway musicals have been turned into movies. Um, you know, Hello Dolly in 1969 and Mame in 1974. And it makes me wonder, you know, in addition to maybe getting uh uh updated versions of both of those, because I think they both, you know, could use uh another version. I wonder what other what other uh Jerry Herman musicals would make a good movie, you know?

[40:22] Rob Russo: Well, I think obviously the number one choice would be, or the conversation to have is would Mac and Mabel work better as a film?

[40:32] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I might, you know, you might be uh you could revisit the script and you know and and tell the story more even-handedly, right? With with getting Mabel's point of view, and then just capturing the magic of silent films.

[40:43] Rob Russo: Well, right. Yeah, I mean, you're the one that makes this point all the time, and I'm gonna I'm gonna make your point for you that part of the problem with Mac and Mabel is that the stuff you're seeing on stage is is really film stuff, right? The gags, the Keystone cops, all that stuff is, you know, that that works on that works in the cinema.

[41:01] Rob Russo: So perhaps that bridging that gap by putting it on film would help with that part of the story.

[41:08] Jamie DuMont: Perhaps the reason that Jerry Herman isn't a household name today is because of his lack of success in Hollywood, right? Like all the major composers that we know, or that are as well known to the general public, are known because of success in film and TV, let's be honest, right? And Jerry didn't have that.

[41:26] Rob Russo: No, and quite infamously in 1983, as Barbara Walters pointed out in her interview for 2020, she says, quote, no one knows who you are. Which, you know, as rude as that may seem to us in this world, it was kind of true. He wasn't a household name.

[41:45] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's certainly in 1983, right? So Jerry obviously was very shy. You know, he wanted to let the work speak for itself, so on and so on. But in his later years, you know, starting in the 1980s, and I think you know, he probably realized this. He did start to lean into his celebrity, right? Shortly thereafter that interview, Jerry's Girls, you know, came on Broadway and toured, and years later he would do An Evening with Jerry Herman, his cabaret show, and that also toured. He wrote a memoir in 1996, Show Tune, so he really did sort of lean into his celebrity in his later years and became more of a name than he probably was, you know, circa 1983.

[42:12] Rob Russo: And speaking of Jerry's Girls, we talked to Alix Korey, who was one of the original Jerry's Girls.

[42:12] Alix Korey: I did what was ended up being called the all non-star version of Jerry's Girls, which was created at Ted Hook's backstage cabaret with just four non-stars doing all of the—what ultimately became the seed for Jerry's Girls, the big tour with all the stars. It was a very exciting process in the sense that they wanted us really to do individual takes on everything, and I love that because, first and foremost, I'm an actor, and to be able to break down the songs from an actor's point of view. And yes, we still had to do, you know, We Need a Little Christmas and Chin Up, Ladies, and those things, but you know, there were all those great songs I got to do, you know, a lot of the Mabel stuff, and that was really fun.

[42:12] Alix Korey: Basically, Andrea McCardell did the stuff that I did off-Broadway.

[43:56] Alix Korey: For I was born to play the two-a-day. The hulk, the core, the empty Madine. And so I know that Vaudeville's just asleep. And so I got a key on dancing while I rake it up and dig it up and wake it up. I get no thrill from this atomic age. Upon the palace stage, well song as long as I can say, I belong to the wonderful world of the two-a-day.

[44:50] Alix Korey: When we were doing Jerry's Girls, and we were rehearsing at his home on Fire Island, which was of course spectacularly beautiful. He had all this, you know, glass and open, and he had a white piano there, a beautiful grand piano. And after the rehearsals for the show, he would, you know, we would all go into his living room, and his partner at the time would make us umbrella drinks, which is good because I hate the taste of alcohol, so I was able to party along with everybody else. And Jerry would sit down at the piano and ask us to sing individually. But he would play Irving Berlin and Jerome Kern. And every night it would be like a little, you know, piano bar, except the piano was a beautiful white grand, the view was incredible, and the pianist was Jerry Herman.

[46:12] Alix Korey: Turn your head, and you've lost her, and you spent half your life wandering her. So before you forgive how you loved her, it was terrific.

[46:30] Alix Korey: It was terrific.

[47:24] Alix Korey: We're excited and decided to be someone. Jerry to be summoned. Jerry.

[47:50] Alix Korey: A number of years I ended up being the standby for An Evening with Jerry Herman, which starred Lee Roy Reams and Florence Lacey. And I covered both of them and was very pleased that I never had to go on. It was just a wonderful experience to sing his songs. And then we did a tour, a summer stop tour. We did it first at Rainbow and Stars, Karen Morrow and myself, because Florence wasn't available. She was doing something else. And then later we did it again into the summer tour with Flo, Jerry, and myself, and it was one of the happiest moments of my life because there Jerry is playing the piano with a bass player, Flo and me. That was the show. He talked about his music. He played it the way that he hears it, the way that it sounds, and he had his two favorite singers singing the songs the way he liked them to be sung.

And it was just an overwhelming experience. I know when I would sing it today, and I'd run and jump up on the piano and start, and I would look over and see Jerry, and I would think all those times in my living room in Covington, Kentucky, when I played Jerry's music, and there he is playing for me, and I'm singing his songs. I never grew tired of being overwhelmed by having that dream become a reality.

[49:14] Alix Korey: Thank you. You can give life if you live life all the way to the grand up. Call the cops out, strike the band up, pull the stars out. Hallelujah. It's today.

[49:57] Alix Korey: Um, not like Jerry's Girls, but like something else. And um, yeah, somebody said to him, Well, why don't you just play the piano and sing some of the songs with it and tell your story the way you want it told? And he said, gee, what a great idea. I think I will. And Lee Roy Reams and I were lucky enough to be matched together to do it. And oh my god, we just—that was probably the most fun show business thing in my life. I mean, there I was with the great Jerry Herman, the great Lee Roy Reams. I was this woman, the luckiest woman in show business, being pampered and, you know, being just adored by these two fabulous men. It was great fun. Great, great fun. I got to sing If He Walked Into My Life, which I mean, come on.

That's one of the greatest songs ever written. Although, you know, I really loved singing Song on the Sand because it was written for a man, it was an unusual thing for a woman to sing it. And I got to sit on the piano bench with Jerry and really sing it about him and to him. And it was such a love story. I just, yeah. Song on the Sand was probably my favorite moment in that show.

[51:30] Alix Korey: He's such, he was such a good man. You know, there are a lot of stories about composers, but I don't think you would ever find a story that involved Jerry and any kind of malice at all. He was never cruel, he never said anything discomforting to anyone. We all knew that he had been a wild child. You know, even at that time, certainly when we were doing An Evening with Jerry Herman, he was very fragile even back then, and that's we're talking either late 80s, early 90s. But it was like he survived.

[52:24] Alix Korey: I'll Be Here Tomorrow. You know what I mean? He had been through the wars, and he survived, and he never had anything but a positive outlook. For all his incredible success in the 1960s, the 1970s had been tough for Jerry professionally. Three flops in a row proved what Jerry later came to believe. The biggest problem in writing musicals is picking the right source material. But that positive outlook kept him moving forward.

[52:54] Rob Russo: In 1978, Jerry and his friend Sheila Mack went to see the French film La Cage aux Folles one afternoon in Los Angeles. When they emerged from the dark theater and back into the sunlight of California, Jerry could not stop thinking about how this film, based on an earlier play by the same name, would make a perfect musical. The story of George and Alban, a gay couple who own a nightclub in Saint-Tropez, France, and their son, who wants to marry a girl from a very straight conservative family, struck Jerry instantly. He knew how to tell this story, he knew how to musicalize these characters, and he loved the setting. He knew after nearly a decade of searching, this was his next project.

[53:37] Rob Russo: That very day, he called his agent to inquire about the rights to adapt the material into a musical. And just 24 hours later, his hopes were dashed when he learned that someone else had already snagged them. It turned out that producer Alan Carr had beat him to the chase. Carr had hired composer Maury Yeston and writer Jerry Preston Allen to do a musical version of La Cage that would transpose the story to the French Quarter of New Orleans. Tommy Tune was attached to direct, and Jerry was devastated. But it wasn't over. Carr was running into trouble.

[54:07] Rob Russo: We spoke to producer Barry Brown, who, along with his partner Fritz Holt, would become executive producers of La Cage aux Folles. Barry told us this amazing story of how the Jerry Herman musical that we now know and love came to fruition. The road to us, us being me and Fritz, was littered with bodies who Alan had hired and fired. Alan, I guess, wasn't satisfied with whatever he was hearing from Maury and Jay Preston Allen, and I forget who was directing.

[54:43] Unknown Speaker: Maybe Tommy Tune was directing at the time. And he was about to lose his rights in the original stage production. And he, I guess, he'd heard of us. So we went and we got his rights back for him. And we looked at him and he said, "So what are we gonna do now?" And he was not happy with those people. And he said, "Well, you have to go and fire them." And we said, "We have to go and fire them." Anyway, we did. And so we looked at him and said, "Tell you what, we'll do this, but you have to go away, go back to Beverly Hills, and let us put this together the way we would put it together from the beginning. We won't do anything without your approval, but leave us alone." And I have to tell you, very much to his credit, he did.

So Fritz and I sat down and looked at each other and said, "Oh, yeah, yeah, what do we do now?" And said, "Well, who should and who should write the score?" And we both said Jerry Herman. His stuff was so upbeat and enthusiastic and optimistic and fun. And that's what this show, as far as we were concerned, should have been about and was about. We did the same thing with and who should write the book. We said Harvey Fierstein. We went to Jerry and he was thrilled because it was something that he wanted to do from the get-go. We went to his house, very lovely house, I might add, and hired him. Jerry was the right person giving his sensibilities to do the score, and Harvey was the right person to write the book.

Arthur Laurents is a whole nother story. But he was the right director because we had a first-time out book writer. And who best to protect a first-time out book writer than Arthur Laurents as a director. When I first went to Arthur, he said, "If you want me to write La Cage aux Folles, the answer is no." And I said, "No, no, that's not what we know. Can I come over?" "Yeah, come over tomorrow at 1:30, but don't expect lunch." So I came over and or I went over, and he sat back and said, "Well," and I said, "Would you be interested in directing La Cage?" And he's so smart, the very first words out of his mouth were, "Who's writing it?" And I said, "Jerry Herman's writing the score, and Harvey's writing the book."

He said, "Really, you have them? They're signed?" I said, "Yes," which I didn't. And he leaned forward and he said, "I'll do it." And that's how it got put together. Arthur and Fritz and I went over to Jerry's house and he played us a couple of songs. I think one of the first ones was "A Little More Mascara." And we just sat there, open-mouthed, and thought, "Oh my god, it's a dream come true. I mean, this is who should be writing this score."

[58:07] ♪ Musical number: "A Little More Mascara" — performed by Jerry Herman ♪

[59:40] Unknown Speaker: It's really a smashing, spectacular number. And it's very technical. It is technical, but the makeup is so designed that the things that you add bring the color in, because the basic makeup is done, but it's putting on the lip and shading your cheeks and then putting on the lashes. But uh, and it took a lot of time, and I know the first time that I did it with an audience, and I sat down, and it was, and when I took that lash, because you go, when it's a beaded lash that you look through, because everything's glorious, glamorous. Well, try doing that that fast, putting on eyelashes. And the first night I went with everything, but I got it on it probably with cockeyed. Well, I finally got it right, but uh, it's it's it's it's a thing you have to really work on, but it's and it's incredible number to do, and so fulfilling to make that change and to put on the wig and stand up and say, Zaza is here.

And of course, with Jerry, we can make the change because when I stood up, I made them do a key change. It was not done that way originally. I said, listen, you know, I'm a fucking tenor soprano, so let's let's make it work. And so just to make it here, key change here, da-da-da-da. So, you know, I love the fact that I got to do that, and of course, I I can work in high heels. I'm a dancer. So I put on those high heels baby, and I worked it. And everything's ankle straps. Maraboo Shalomar!

[1:01:12] ♪ Musical number ♪

[1:01:47] Unknown Speaker: There's the great story of the first preview of La Cage out of town, and the story goes that you know, Arthur Laurents, Harvey Fierstein, and Jerry Herman are standing in the back of the theater, and right in front of them in the back row is an elderly heterosexual couple. And I think it was it was getting to um "Song in the Sand," and this was sort of the litmus test moment for the show to see whether straight people were going to accept what was happening on stage. The elderly gentleman grabbed his wife's hand during the song, and I get choked up every time I hear it because they say that they turned to each other and they knew that it had worked because it was reaching everybody, it didn't matter at that point, and that to me is the strength of writing like that, and you know, I I sometimes get killed for saying this, but I don't know that we write as sophisticated as that today, because it wasn't going for the message.

The message was inside there, but it was just sort of taking the forest from the trees, stepping back a bit, and just celebrating it all. A favorite memory is that first night audience in Boston. It gets me teary. And the reaction was thunderous. And we knew we had something.

[1:03:44] Unknown Speaker: We asked Barry if in 1983 it felt risky or groundbreaking to be doing a musical about a gay love story. We really didn't. Well, as far as Fritz and I were concerned, we needed a hit. But we just wanted to do, you know, a big fun, entertaining Broadway musical. And I think that to politicize it would have hurt it. You know, Jerry said in in some interview at that point, um, somebody said an interview said about the message that they were sending to, we were sending to the straight community or whatever. And Jerry looked at him and said, you know what? If I want to send a message, I'll call Western Union. He said, all we were doing was putting on a show. We did get some, I wouldn't say hate mail, but some disparaging mail after we opened from members of the gay community saying that we whitewashed the whole thing, that we didn't go far enough, that we, you know, it's we should have done this, we should have done that.

And an author very succinctly um answered them and said, you know what? If we've given you the kind of show that you're asking for, we would have closed in two weeks. It was that simple. You know, maybe it sounds very naive and very Pollyanna today, but we didn't think in terms of what it would mean to the history of uh of the gay movement or or anything like that. Which it's we were putting on a show. We knew that we were doing something new by having these two men walk off arm in arm in to the metaphorical sunset. Um but it was the proper ending to the show.

[1:05:36] ♪ Musical number ♪

[1:05:50] Unknown Speaker: I hear as simple as we thought it was, because I was there on opening night as a guest of Jerry's when the show opened on Broadway. And of course, I was looking at the parts and God's such a great part. I can't wait till someday I'll be able to do it. But it and but a lot of the people who were there thought it was rather tame and not as uh you know outrageous as it should have been, or made a bigger statement, especially the gay community felt that it was rather tame, and having two straight men play the roles and all of this and that, there was a lot of controversy about it, and then they were a little concerned, and then of course later when the AIDS epidemic hit, and they had all that controversy too.

It was uh quite an interesting period to live through. We've come a long way, and I never thought in my life that I would be able to marry. But the show is great, and that's why it's done a lot, and the audiences like it. And I know that uh I got a letter from a lady, uh, and she said, Dear Mr. Reams, I'm paraphrasing, dear Mr. Reams, uh my son came out to me and my husband, that he was gay, and we stopped communication with him. And I saw your performance last night, and we called our son today. Well, I'm I mean, I'm getting all verklempt now about that because it was so wonderful that we don't know how powerful the theater can be, that people came in being homophobic. And once they got past that first number and they realized it was a show about family and about being a mother, you know. In the last scene, I know when Jean Michel says, uh, you know, he says, "Don't tell me that's your mother."

[1:08:16] Alix Korey: And he says that's exactly who he is. Every night, I mean, I'm getting all emotional now thinking about it, that it every night I never had to worry about having the tears, because knowing what a powerful statement that was, and anyone who had a heart or a mind sitting in the audience would feel that emotion. It's not about the biological thing, it's the person who assumes that role and loves the child.

[1:09:15] Unknown Speaker: Probably one of my top five favorite Jerry Herman songs is "Look Over There." Because, like, holy shit. If that isn't like an emotional space, and I, you know, I was I actually played La Cage in the house for the first time, like as loud as I wanted. No worry about neighbors. And you know, I listened to that song a million times, and I think this was the first time it struck me that the song, um, I know it's not about a biological parent, but it never even said parent. It doesn't even have to be somebody in a parental state. Uh, that that written so specifically for that show, but then also it's like, and I don't understand why more people aren't singing it every day in every show. I mean, I did once, and I cried it was a mess, so maybe that's that's why, because it tends to um provoke a lot of emotion.

[1:10:47] Lee Roy Reams: That's like that was his goal in life for his life. And uh even a song, you know, like uh the song from La Cage that I love so much is "Look Over There." It's so focused. It uh it it's it's it has a real strong intention. It's very Jewish. I know you boys aren't, but you know, it's that idea that um that uh children need to be aware that they never will be without their that that love, that love um is very strong, it's very powerful. Um you know he did I he did that in a couple things, of course, with Mame too. He did that. It's what both these shows are about a non-traditional parent raising a child and not getting the love they deserve or they think they're entitled to. I mean, I think it's a it's it's it's it's all there.

[1:11:57] Rob Russo: Yeah, it really is incredible to draw the parallel between La Cage and Mame. I've never really thought of that before. But how true, right? I mean, it's it's it's the same, it's the same emotions. It's the same, it's the same, you know, you've devoted your your life to a non-biological child, but this is your child. And suddenly that child has decided that, you know, you're not the person they they want you to be. And who can't relate to that? You don't even have to have a child to relate to the idea of somebody of not living up to someone's expectations or someone having unrealistic expectations. And I think it's I think it's part of what makes these characters so interesting.

[1:12:35] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, totally. And I think, you know, it's maybe an underappreciated part of what makes La Cage so groundbreaking, right? I mean, obviously the thing that we asked Barry about, and you know, we've talked about is how you know it was such a landmark thing to have a gay love story on on stage, you know, musicalized. And I by no means mean to minimize that, but also, you know, uh a non-traditional family structure, regardless of the genders or the sexual orientations of the characters was also, you know, something that was a little groundbreaking to do, you know. But it's it's fascinating to hear Barry say that, you know, they weren't intending to do, you know, this or they didn't think about it that way, you know, because through the lens of history, we of course see it as being, you know, such a groundbreaking thing, right?

I mean, Applause in 1970 was the first musical to have an explicitly gay character played by Leroy Reams. Um La Cage is only 13 years later, right? So, you know, Stonewall riots are 1969, right? Applause is 1970, La Cage is 1983, you know, right at the the sort of dawn of the AIDS crisis, um, you know, and Reaganism and all that, right? So the context of it really uh, you know, makes it so clearly, you know, through the lens of history, a groundbreaking show.

[1:13:47] Rob Russo: There is a huge argument to be made that La Cage is right up there in terms of moving uh the the gay rights forward. I mean, I think it's it's un, it's there's not even a question in my mind. You know, it's up there with with so many groundbreaking and landmark things. And I think that um, you know, uh because the show is so popular that people forget that. And I think it's an important thing to remember that um, you know, La Cage is one huge part of this huge this very large tapestry of the gay rights movement.

[1:14:22] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, it's there's all there's always a tension between the community itself, right? Um, and uh making overtures to the larger community. So in this case, the gay community and the straight community to set up that dichotomy, right? And there's different ways of of changing people's minds and changing people's hearts, right? Sometimes you do it through a speech or through a rally or through a march or through, you know, uh an article or an op-ed or you know, making a point stridently or you know, forcefully, but sometimes you do it in a softer way, and that's what La Cage did. And that's always controversial, right? I mean, I remember Joe Biden saying that Will and Grace did more for the gay movement than anything else he can think of because a gay character was invited into people's homes on TV, and they could see that you know, he was he was smart and fun and funny and all that.

Now, the gay community might look at Will and Grace and wince and be like, oh, Sean Hayes is playing a caricature. It's he's a he's clowning around. He's not a real human. That's not who we are. But that tension exists, right? Would you, would you rather Will and Grace didn't exist? Would you rather La Cage didn't exist because it doesn't maybe fulfill your ideal version of what gay representation looks like? Or do you take the win and say, you know what? It won some people over. It made an overture, it changed a heart, it opened a mind, and then from there you can make more progress.

[1:15:48] Rob Russo: Yeah, I tend to fall in the latter category, as does Harvey Fierstein, who wrote the book.

[1:15:52] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, well, there you go. Um yeah, you know, and look, did they get everything right? No. You also have to be appreciative of the fact that they were, you know, not only trying to get a show up, but also working with the tools in which were afforded to them at the time, etc. etc. I'm not saying it was right or wrong, I'm just saying it is what it is. I also think part of it is that the nature of drag performance has changed, right? I mean, La Cage the musical was 1983, the play it was based on was 1973 and the film 1978. You know, drag has evolved a lot since then, right? I mean, it it it really, you know, you think about like female impersonation, right? And and that sort of tradition evolving more into the artistry, you know, the sheer artistry that we see now with RuPaul's Drag Race, right?

The drag queens we see on that TV show are nothing like the drag queens that you would have seen in the 1950s and 60s, which are who Alban was, right? Alban is not, you know, uh uh someone who would be competing on RuPaul's Drag Race today. He's more of a a lounge performer, a cabaret performer, you know, a female impersonator, right? Which is is sort of where that tradition um began. So that's another fascinating thing. And I wonder how in the years to come La Cage will be um revised or revived and reimagined in the context of how drag performance has evolved. Will the show be a period piece forever stuck in the 1970s? Or will it be portrayed as happening now? And maybe those references will be changed, maybe not without changing a word, but in the costuming and the casting and the performance.

[1:17:25] Rob Russo: When we spoke to Lee Roy, he talked about how when he plays Alban, which he's done, you know, several times over the years, he chooses, you know, in consultation with his director to hearken back to the older drag traditions of you know, more reminiscent of the era of the source material itself.

[1:17:41] Lee Roy Reams: What I wanted to do with the part, and uh Arthur Laurents would not have approved, but you know, he wasn't directing it. I wanted to perform the way that Charles Pierce, who was one of my one of the great people, who was the best person at doing what he did, and called himself a male actress, but he was so divine, and I was a huge fan of his, and we were close friends. I wanted to bring into La Cage that performance thing when he was Zaza and talk to the audience and do all of that and do impersonations. And because I did Mae West Home. You know, and I put in that I did Marlene Dietrich. So I did all of those things and I wanted to put all of that in because that's what drag performers did. They did impressions, especially in that period. And so Jerry and I redesigned the number and put in all of those takeoffs.

[1:19:00] ♪ Musical number ♪

[1:20:51] Lee Roy Reams: It's an interesting story that uh uh Gene Barry. I did a little summer stock tour with Gene Barry. We did the Gobber Gross Circuit, and uh I know that Gene and George had problems because George got all the attention and the awards, and Gene did Gene was wonderful in the part, but you know, uh in this production, of course, Gene had top billing, and I had second billing, and I thought, well, uh, and I knew that he and George didn't get along because of that. And I thought, well, I you know, I hope that I'm not gonna get on the bad side of Gene. And of course, we had changed so many things, and especially making the La Cage number bigger with all those impersonations and all of that. And I thought, well, he's got the cloud over me, and if he doesn't like it, well, I just had to take it out.

Or, you know, that's not the way we did it on Broadway. So during and Nor Gerder, who was the director, wonderful guy, uh, we kept skipping over the number in the run throughs. Uh so uh, you know, Gene never got to see it, and then there was the day where we were gonna have to do it.

[1:21:57] Lee Roy Reams: So we thought, well, either he'll take it out or he won't. We'll just see what the reaction is. And we did the number, and Gene jumped up, and Gene said, that's what was missing on Broadway. You never understood why he was a star on the Riviera. Now you understand why he's a star. And it was just, I mean, we were all happily surprised, and Gene just loved that doing that in the show, and we had a lovely time doing the show together.

[1:22:34] Molly Pope: What's left of summer but a faded roll best of times is not. Actress and singer Molly Pope, who you heard from earlier talking about the song "Look Over There," is a perennial staple of the cabaret scene in New York. Her introduction to Jerry's work was being cast as Dolly Levi in her high school's production of "Hello Dolly," a role that she credits not only with changing her life, but saving her life. She later joked with us that she might have peaked in her senior year of high school when she starred as MAM. Well, we chatted with Molly about the song "The Best of Times," which she regularly performs at her cabaret shows as a sing along with the audience. It turns out that this song has a special meaning for her, following her throughout her life, from her mother to her teenage years into her high school and beyond.

Freshman year at NYU, I was at the Stella Adler Conservatory, and I had a teacher by the name of Betsy Parrish who taught acting a song. And she was amazing. I went to see Betsy's Cabaret Show. It was the first cabaret show I ever saw in New York City. And then after that, I found out Betsy Parrish is also Elizabeth Parrish who originated the role of Jacqueline in "La Cage aux Folles." And I just had no idea. So this whole like this energy swirling around that song. I love group singing. I think it's so healing. It's so helpful. So I was looking for, you know, a big final moment for a show, and you know, who knows why that song popped into my head, but it felt um it was like, oh yeah, this would be great.

Like as like a palette cleanser. Let's send them off into the evening feeling good, singing along. I think that it lends itself to a sort of back on your heels, basking in it of like let's just enjoy this. But what it became for me, it had a lot more urgency. Um almost uh almost a warning. Not not in a negative way, but it for me it felt like I most of the time don't allow video or photos during my shows because I want you to be I want all of us to be present in the room together. And that's really what that song became about for me is sort of like really begging the audience like please just be here with me, just be here with me right now. Just just even if it's just for this song, let's all be here together.

[1:23:08] Molly Pope: The best of times is now what's left of summer but a faded row. The best of times is now. As for tomorrow, well, who knows? Who knows? Who knows? So a whole moment fast and live in love as hard as you know how and make this moment last because the best of times is now is now is now not some forgotten yes. You know, I sing it halfway through and then we modulate, and then I just leave the mic on stage and go out and sing with everybody else because I'm in love with collective experiences and that's why I do cabaret and collective experiences that will never be repeated in exactly the same way. Because the best of times is now, is now is now the summer of the dream. That song is it's just I think it's probably for me one of the few times I am always present with every single word I'm singing.

Because I found that with this song in particular, that's the like if you just do what the song is about, it's just this endless discovery of um how these uh how these notions, how these phrases, how these ideas can be made very specific for the audience. And it yeah, it comes back to I'm just like please, everyone, let's just be together for this moment. Let's have this together, no matter what happens after, no matter what happened before, we're gonna be here together, we're gonna sing these words, and we're gonna mean it.

[1:27:58] Molly Pope: One of the difficulties of the past year has been I've sort of said to myself, okay, if you were gonna sing "The Best of Times" right now, could you do it and be honest? And I don't the only way I could sort of wrap my head around that was as a sort of like um, you need you need to remember this when we're through on the other side. You need to hear this because you need to remember this. But it I found it it was really hard and it made me it it did make me really sad on occasion because I couldn't I couldn't find the way into that song if I uh were to sing it somewhere. And I it it it is actually the biggest thing I miss about performing is doing that song.

[1:28:50] Rob Russo: Yeah, feelings, feelings. Do you um do you think when when you when you perform next when you return to cabaret will you have it in your act?

[1:29:00] Molly Pope: Oh, absolutely, absolutely. I I mean to me it's one of those things, you know, if I was doing an all uh show that was all Marilyn Manson, I would still have "The Best of Times" be the encore. I'm pretty partial to "I Am What I Am." When he rips off the wig and goes storming up the aisle. It's pretty theatrical.

[1:29:25] ⚠ About 4 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.

[1:33:29] Rob Russo: And there's no wasted material. It's all, you know, there's no, let's have a tap number here. You know, it's all incredibly um, it's respectful and artistic.

[1:33:49] Jamie DuMont: I have always thought that the 1984 Tony Awards featured the most stacked category ever for best original score. I mean, look at this list of nominees. David Shire and Richard Maltby Jr. for Baby, John Kander and Fred Ebb for The Rink, Steven Sondheim for Sunday in the Park with George, and Jerry for La Cage aux Folles. I mean, it's stunning. It's like the best of the best.

[1:34:06] Rob Russo: And I agree with Alex. I mean, and I take Jerry at his word uh when he wrote in his memoir that there was never a rivalry between him and Sondheim.

[1:34:17] Jamie DuMont: Oh my god, yes. And it's unfair to put it that way because he was also up against Kander and Ebb and Maltby and Shire.

[1:34:25] Rob Russo: Right, right. So, you know, him winning the Tony Award in that year for that show against those other nominees, you know, was really just an encore and a validation, right? I mean, he was proud of the fact that his music was being celebrated, and he was right to be.

[1:34:42] Jamie DuMont: Oh, absolutely, and again, just to put a finer point on it, that is a fabulous year for the Tony Awards. Go to YouTube, watch that entire show. It's magnificent. And you know, it you're absolutely right. Go, Jerry.

[1:35:00] Rob Russo: This was the last musical he'd write from then on when he wasn't touring with his cabaret act or otherwise performing. He dedicated the rest of his life to his first real passion of architecture and interior design. According to his obituary, Jerry would own and decorate over three dozen houses in his life.

[1:35:19] Jamie DuMont: That's crazy. We asked his close friend Lee Roy Reams about this unusual hobby.

[1:35:25] Lee Roy Reams: But he loved to decorate, and he's famous for buying houses, redoing them, and then selling them. And of course, there's always a big grand piano.

[1:35:36] Lee Roy Reams: Usually it's a Yamaha. So whenever he sells his property, he says, "Oh, would you like to buy my piano?" Oh, oh God, Jerry Herman's piano. He has sold so many houses and apartments with the pianos in them because everyone says, "Oh, I've got Jerry Herman's piano." He said, "Yeah, and another hundred people in the United States." I'll tell you a good story. I went out, we were working on something, I can't remember what it is. So, because he used to have me come out and sing with him, and you know, and he had gotten us a new house in California, and so I went out and we were gonna work and I was gonna sing in the house with him. And of course, Jerry was meticulous. I mean, there was a piece of dirt in the corner, he'd go over and scratch it out.

He just so you know, you were afraid to touch anything because it was so you know, it was like a Bloomingdale show window. And this house that he had, and there was a glass table in the kitchen. Of course, if you got your fingerprints on it, he'd wipe it off, you know. It was kind of that kind of he was very, you know, whatever that term is for that. But we were there, and his manservant came in and said, "Mr. Herman, the last chair has been uncrated, and now the house is exactly as you wanted. Everything is perfect." And then there was a wind blowing, and I heard and it was coming through one of the terrace doors, and Jerry looked around. Jerry said, "Time to move." And that day, he went down the block and was looking at another property, and then he sold that house right away and went into something else.

Because once the house was done, there was nothing more for him to do, and he would get bored with it. So he would buy another property. He bought Dinah Shore's old house in Palm Springs and redid it. And then once it was done, he sold it. And so he was constantly doing that. Jerry reflected later in his life that if he had lived in a different time, when his style was more in style, he might have written more musicals than the seven that he did. He loved writing show tunes more than anything, except perhaps decorating. And even when he stopped writing for the theater, he never stopped playing and singing music, whether his own or the Irving Berlin songs that he loved from his childhood, or the work of contemporaries like Candor and Ebb and Bach and Harnick.

Jerry was diagnosed as HIV positive in 1985 and lost his partner, Marty, to AIDS in 1992. But he kept going, and he did end up writing again. In the 1990s, he was commissioned by casino magnet Steve Wynne to write an original musical for the MGM Hotel in Las Vegas. The show, Miss Spectacular, was designed to be just that a Vegas spectacular built around big production numbers inspired by the fantasies of the leading character, an aspiring performer. Jerry wrote a full score, including an overture and exit music. But the show was never produced. He did, however, have a studio recording put together in 1999, proving that while La Cage may have been his last show in 1983, his songwriting powers were alive and well. And here's a taste of the opening number from Miss Spectacular.

[1:39:33] Lee Roy Reams: We would not have In the Heights if it were not or Next to Normal, like any of these great shows of the last, you know, 15, 20 years. We would not have those scores if it weren't for the likes of Jerry Herman, because he set a foundation and took what was being written fifty years before him and then pushed it a little bit forward. And that's our jobs. You know, to keep pushing the tradition forward. What's his legacy for me? I guess joy. He was joyous to work with. He used to talk about his musicals as his children. So of course, his musicals are that. But I think also his soul, his spirit was so upbeat, so positive, so encouraging, you know, that he took me from you know, living in a tiny little apartment in Los Angeles to just magically bring me to New York and give me such a big start to my career.

That shows the generosity of soul, the imagination of you know passing on his love of musical theater, his passion for it. And you know, I think that's his legacy was his passion for musical theater. Assuming Broadway continues into the next century, they'll still be doing revivals of Jerry's shows. You know, they're not they don't seem to revive Rogers and Hart very much. I just think that that they will do more revivals of Jerry's shows than they will of a lot of other people. So that's a legacy, and his kindness, I hope. You know, whenever I've talked to other writers, young writers, I talk about Jerry and the fact that he was so generous in his love of other writers and and I guess that's the legacy.

[1:41:46] Alix Korey: Don't be too cool for school. Don't be too cool for Jerry Herman. Like get over Sunday clothes is better than any antidepressant known to man, woman, or beast or or person, let's say any person. I think it's bedrock of American musical theater. I think um, you know, the greats each occupy very specific territory. They overlap, certainly, but I think that if you were like, if you wanted to have a conversation about the great American musical, you Jerry Herman has to be part of that. He's a fundamental of American musical theater. Not only in his songwriting and lyrics, but also, you know, in the subjects that he chose to tackle. And his sound is so specific, so signature. When it's a Jerry Herman song, even if it's an instrumental you've never heard, you're like, that's a Jerry Herman song.

He's written for the entire human experience in a way that I think he is very accessible, very accessible. And I think that's often mistaken for easy. Um, but I think it's it's deceptive that actually his skill is in finding a way to make these feelings uh uh put them to words in music, which honestly, I mean, isn't that what we want? Is I don't know how I don't know how to say or write the best of times as now. I need Jerry Herman to do that to say, "Oh, thank you so much for actually bringing this into the world because I needed this, but I didn't know how to do it." He really seems to be about not getting stuck. It really, as we're talking, it's about moving forward. You might not like it or be happy about it, but you're gonna move forward.

It might not be what you want it to be, but you're gonna move forward. You might never get over that person. You might never stop loving that person, but time is still gonna keep going, and you're gonna keep going. He had a style. It was a real sound. There was that Jerry Herman sound, and he managed to spin that over and over and over again. So rarely in hearing his canon, do I hear, oh, he stole that from himself. I rarely feel that way. You know, similar to Rogers and Hammerstein, like I rarely hear things like of course you hear the DNA there, but you're like, they're only, you know, 12 notes. How can you spin them out so many times and make it keep working? But he was able to do it.

[1:44:20] Lee Roy Reams: Well, one more question. Um, thinking about his legacy and you know what he leaves behind for future generations of fans and and students of musical theater. Um, what do you think are his greatest contributions to the theater?

[1:44:37] Alix Korey: Oh, well, I think well, obviously his songs, because they will keep the shows alive and they will even, you know, years from now, still try to do Mack and Mabel and make it work because of Jerry's songs. There will be a creative person and maybe someday they may find someone who can make it work. I don't know, but it's that, and also his optimism about life. I mean parade. And also I know that in the Grand Tour, when you know, when Jerry said when I wrote the song back then, I didn't know I was actually writing about myself because with the AIDS epidemic and what he fought out said, "I'll be here tomorrow." You know, and you do the lyrics, "I'll be here tomorrow alive and well and thriving. I'll be here tomorrow."

It's simply called surviving. "If before the dawn, this fragile world might crack, someone's gotta try and put the pieces back." So from beneath a rubble, you'll hear a little voice say, "Life is worth the trouble. Have you had a better choice?" So let the skeptic say tonight we're dead and gone. "I'll be here tomorrow, simply going on." And his songs are gonna be doing that. And the essence of Jerry Herman, because people are never gonna get tired of hearing those songs and believing what they say, giving you optimism and giving you hope. Look what we've been through in the past four years. Let's get out of Jerry Herman's song and start singing.

[1:46:05] Jerry Herman: I wrote this song in 1979 for Joel Gray to sing in a show of mine called The Grand Tour. But I think you'll understand why it has so much deeper meaning for me in 2003.

[1:46:28] Jerry Herman: After the dark comes the dawn, after the night comes the day. So when you are lost in the dark, have the conviction to say, "I'll be here tomorrow alive and well and thriving. I'll be here tomorrow." It's simply called surviving. "If before the dawn this fragile world might crack, someone's gotta try and put the pieces back." So from beneath the rubble you'll hear a little voice say, "Life is worth the trouble. Have you a better choice?" So let the skeptic say tonight we're dead and gone. "I'll be here tomorrow, simply going on."

[1:48:03] Jerry Herman: Simply go beneath the rubble. Say life is worth the trouble. Have you a better choice? So let the skeptics say tonight we're dead and I'll be here tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow. "I'll be here tomorrow."

[1:48:46] Jerry Herman: Simply.

[1:48:58] Jamie DuMont: That's our show. Thank you for joining us, and thank you for helping us celebrate the life, legacy, and career of Jerry Herman. Please tune in next time and check out our archive of episodes.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred