Richard Maltby Jr. is a theatre director and producer, lyricist, and screenwriter. He conceived and directed the only two musical revues to win the Tony Award for Best Musical: Ain't Misbehavin' and Fosse... Read More
From the show: The Producer's Perspective Podcast with Ken Davenport
Guests
About
Richard Maltby Jr. is a theatre director and producer, lyricist, and screenwriter. He conceived and directed the only two musical revues to win the Tony Award for Best Musical: Ain't Misbehavin' and Fosse. Other Broadway works include Baby (Director/Lyricist), Blood Knot (Producer), Song and Dance (Director/Co-lyricist), Miss Saigon (Lyricist), Nick & Nora (Lyricist), Ring of Fire (Creator/Director), The Pirate Queen (Writer/Lyricist). Off-Broadway works include Closer Than Ever, and The Story of My Life. He also wrote the screenplay for the film Miss Potter (2007) starring Renée Zellweger and Ewan McGregor.
We talk about all the huge hats he has worn over the years, as well as . . .
- Now what? (What to do when your first show out is a big fat success)
- Why the collaboration process on Miss Saigon was one of the favorites of his career.
- How the revue has morphed into the jukebox musical, and what he thinks of the current lot.
- An old idea for new writers to get attention that still works today.
- What he thinks of the new “style” of musical theater.
This week’s episode is brought to you by theaterextras.com, seat-filling audience development organization that arranges COMPLIMENTARY tickets for its members when a performance or event is in previews, under publicized, expecting the attendance of reviewers or celebrities, or would like the benefits of a full house.
Keep up with me: @KenDavenportBway
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer with a hit show on Broadway.
[0:07] Ken Davenport: You're listening to the Producers Perspective Podcast with your host, Tony Award winner, Ken Davenport.
[0:12] Ken Davenport: No one likes to have an empty seat, but that's especially true at the beginning of a run when you're trying to jumpstart that word of mouth.
[0:19] Ken Davenport: Well, if you're looking to make sure every seat in your house is filled, then check out the site theaterextras.com.
[0:25] Ken Davenport: Perfect for producers or venue managers who want to make sure they have a butt in every single seat.
[0:30] Ken Davenport: Or if you're looking to be one of those people that fill those seats, check out theaterextras.com. That's theater with an ER extras.com.
[0:43] Ken Davenport: Hello everybody, Ken Davenport here. You're listening to the Producer's Perspective podcast.
[0:49] Ken Davenport: My guest on today's podcast is none other than Tony Award winner Richard Maltby. Welcome, Richard.
[0:56] Richard Maltby: Well, nice to be here.
[0:57] Ken Davenport: So Richard won that Tony for his direction of Ain't Misbehavin', which he also conceived as well. He's had a very varied career winning many, many hats, from director to book writer to lyricist. Uh directed and wrote the lyrics for Big, directed Song and Dance, wrote the lyrics for Nick and Nora, lyrics for Miss Saigon, created and directed Fosse and Ring of Fire, book and lyrics for Pirate Queen, uh, and lots more, including the revue Closer Than Ever, which is where I first fell in love with your work. Uh, and this interesting known fact, he conceived and directed the only two musical revues to win the Tony Award for Best Musical, Ain't Misbehavin' and Fosse. I know, I thought that was kind of an interesting statistic.
[1:41] Ken Davenport: So let's start with let's start there then. Why do you think that is what what gives you why am I the king of revues?
[1:49] Richard Maltby: Yes. I I am the king of revues because I don't like revues. Uh I I don't the the standard revue that used to be a song, a comedy song, a ballad, a sketch, a comedy song, you know, that sort of thing. Or some kind of evening in which there was a compare of some sort, some, you know, a host who had sort of introduced the song and it is. I thought that was just theatrically uh boring.
[2:18] Richard Maltby: And so when um the Manhattan when Lynn Meadow, um, who was the head of the Manhattan Theater Club, who I knew because at 12 years old, she was in the chorus of a musical that David and I wrote, David Shire and I wrote at uh at Yale. And uh we we had a chorus of school kids in one number, and she was in it, and I'm afraid it changed her life. And so when she graduated from a drama school, uh she came in and was offered the Manhattan Theater Club, then a failing idea um uh that didn't have any life and nobody wanted it. She said, Well, I'll take it to theater in New York, I got it. And uh she was having some trouble uh, you know, getting it getting it going.
[3:01] Richard Maltby: Um and and I I did some benefits for her and everything. And and uh there there was this sort of um restaurant space, this bar, and she wanted to make it into some kind of cabaret space and didn't know whether or not it could have anything in there could have any kind of artistic content. And she suggested that David and I do a revue um of our songs. Um we decided to do it. I mean, a lot of them were songs from shows that had failed, and so you know, things that had never been performed, and little numbers in revues and things like that. And and um I said yes, so I had this body of songs, and uh I didn't quite know what to do. I just knew that I didn't want to have it in in uh I didn't want a narration.
[3:54] Richard Maltby: And so um when we started to stage it, I did the open, I had them sing the opening number, and I didn't know what to do, and I didn't sing it again, and I didn't know what to do, and I did this about 12 times and just sing it again. I really didn't know what to do. And and finally just helped me. It was two girls and one and and one guy. Um the guy went to one of the girls and started to sing to her, and I thought, why didn't he go to the other one? Oh my god, I've got a plot.
[4:25] Richard Maltby: So I've I put together the first six songs as a kind of a story of a guy involved with two girls, um, just going song to song to song, and you kind of you kind of followed the story. So you were following a story, it was a revue, it was just a collection of songs, but you were following a story, and um so I sort of accidentally invented the bookless book musical. Um and a year later, uh that show was was successful and moved you know off Broadway and ran for a year, and uh uh Lynn said, Well, I have an open space again. You were talking about liking all those Fats Waller songs, would you like why don't you make some kind of cabaret evening out of that?
[5:12] Richard Maltby: I thought, oh, okay, all right. Um so you know, we went into rehearsal. It's a kind of a great trajectory. We went into rehearsal on January 1st of uh uh 19 uh 78. We uh opened on February 1st, we closed on March 1st. On April 1st, we opened, we went into rehearsal for Broadway. On May 1st, we opened at Broadway, and on June 1st, we won every award you can win in New York. And I thought that's what Broadway was. You open the show, and everybody says fabulous things about you.
[5:46] Richard Maltby: That was your broader. That was my Broadway debut. I'd never done a Broadway show. It happened, you know, within within six months. And uh, and then a year later I had five productions of Ain't Misbehavin' all over the country uh touring. So it was uh it was it was kind of mind blowing. But again, Ain't Misbehavin', it has no story yet. It has all the elements of story, but all of the I've been working with on a book musical of uh of uh Fats Waller's life with Murray Horwitz, whose idea it was.
[6:20] Richard Maltby: And um there was a Fats Waller just had a really fabulous first act and no second act because he died too young. So we kind of abandoned it, but I took all the research and sort of shoved it into this revue. So even though it's a revue, it's one song after another, you know all about where he came from, you know who he is, you know his life philosophy, you know what kind of person he was, you know where he performed. Um you know the world that he had to deal with.
[6:48] Richard Maltby: I was a black artist in um in the in the excuse me 20s and 30s. Uh a hostile world in which the only way that you could probably you could survive was simply be so good that nobody could they couldn't be they couldn't ignore you. And uh and as the show shaped itself, it has the trajectory of a dramatic piece, the character the performers are not playing themselves they are playing characters they are characters who do not have consistency they don't have they don't have um uh plots but they have backstories and uh so what is that that's a play it just doesn't have a plot and uh once again I I sort of uh you know invented this thing um and I think I the only reason I did it was that I didn't like the I didn't like revues so it it didn't for to for a revue to mean something to me it has to have uh all of the things that make you you know play or a musical bigger reverberations bigger meaning some sort of context that's bigger than the play than the story itself um so I just um you know I also I realize I also had sort of invented the jukebox musical for which I should be you know pillory not given a Tony award but um at any rate um there it is well let's go back to this the revue and because every focus group that I go to of course what one of the things we always hear is we want a story we want a story we want a story and you found a way to do that without doing it and I remember your the liner notes for Closer Than Ever that I studied uh when I was oh yeah when I was singing what am I doing uh as an audition tune or 16 bars of it anyway not very well uh I remember you saying or the liner notes talking about we had these story song, story song, story songs, which we're able to make this evening.
[8:53] Ken Davenport: So my question is, can any composer, lyricist team have a revue, or is it sp does it have to be a specific type of song? Or could you take any pop artist now and say, oh, I can add story to it, or does it have to be inherent to them too?
[9:08] Richard Maltby: Well, I mean, the answer to the question is any of those things are possible depending upon the nature of the of the songs. There are certain songs that are dramatic. Some are pop, um, some of the great pop songs are dramatic. Billy Joel tends to write theater songs. That those songs go on the stage real easily. Some of them really have character characters, some of them have plots, some of them have stories, uh, you know.
[9:33] Richard Maltby: Um so but some others uh, you know, are just pop songs, and and those one, those songs have a hard time, you know, going getting getting um finding a life on the stage. You can use a story, a song that doesn't have a story in it in a storytelling way and get away with it sometimes.
[10:00] Richard Maltby: Um with Closer Than Ever, those were real character songs. There was a real person, you introduced a person, the person told you a story or her story, and uh by the end you pretty much knew everything you needed to know about that that story. That was inherently theater.
[10:21] Richard Maltby: I mean, that was those those the this the difference being that in Closer Than Ever, the five, the four people playing it can't be the same character. You can't uh take the information from this song and apply it to the next song you sing. They had to be different people as they came out, even though they didn't change their costume or anything like that.
[10:44] Richard Maltby: Um but you couldn't uh you couldn't attach them into into some form that made a uh a plot out of them. So the answer to that question is it depends on the nature of the songs or the nature of the show that you're that you're doing. Um you can fit a home dramatic song into a an evening um by making it s making it serve a plot point.
[11:12] Richard Maltby: Um, but it's not not easy, um, but you can get away with it. Um but um if you don't make it serve a plot point, then you're just doing a concert. And there's nothing wrong with a concert. Come out and do 18 great songs. I'm a happy camper, you know.
[11:32] Richard Maltby: It's just you know theater is a story.
[11:37] Ken Davenport: So we brushed over the beginning of your career. We went straight to winning that Tony Award, frankly.
[11:42] Richard Maltby: But so do I.
[11:46] Ken Davenport: Well, tell me a little bit about how you how you found the theater to begin with and why you chose to write and direct for the theater.
[11:55] Richard Maltby: Well, uh, I don't know. My father was a uh an uh musical arranger and orchestrator and ultimately a band leader. My mother trained as a ballerina and sort of gave it up. But um uh so I started with that. Uh you know, that was somewhere in my jeans, and uh oh, I wanted to be a set designer, and I uh wanted what I really wanted to do was design scenery for Radio City Music Hall stage shows.
[12:23] Richard Maltby: That was my goal in life. That's pretty specific. I just love the Radio City Music Hall. Oh, my father uh arranged an Easter show one year, and so I went in and saw the uh uh the dress rehearsal. In those days, the Radio City Music Hall did four stage shows and five movies every day, and they did it every day, which meant that when the show changed, they did it, they did their final show at you know 9.30 at night, and the new show at 10.30 the next morning.
[12:56] Richard Maltby: Scenery changed, everything changed. So the Rockets would rehearse at three in the morning, and the court of LA would release at four in the morning and they'd do a dress rehearsal at 8:30, and they'd open the house at nine, 9:30 because that was going to go. I must say the thing that killed me was that I saw the dress rehearsal, and then they padded the show on the first day, they had some extra short subjects, and then they showed the movie, and then they did the stage show, and they had rewritten it. It wasn't the same. My little 10-year-old, 12-year-old brain just exploded. I couldn't believe they would rewrite it between 8:30 and 10:30. Of course, nowadays I can't, you know, what they did was they rewrote the opening speech, which was like 30 seconds long, and probably wasn't a big deal.
But for me, it was like rewriting the whole show. So that's what I wanted to do. Oh, I did a review of some sort in my little grade school in Saia, Long Island, and then went to prep school in New Hampshire, and I wrote a musical in my senior year there. I scandalized the school doing a totally original musical. Yeah, yeah, it was, and was it good? Well, considering that there was no reason for its existence, it wasn't terrible. Did you write the music as well? I co-wrote the book and I wrote the lyrics. That was the beginning of the end for me because you can always, I could always get somebody to write the music. And I could sometimes get somebody to write the script or the story, but no one ever wanted to write the lyrics, so I always ended up writing the lyrics, and that is how I became a lyricist.
Just because no one else would do it. Nobody else wanted to do it. And so I then went to Yale and I met David Shire in our freshman year and in our sophomore, junior, and senior year. We both wrote original musicals, the first one an adaptation of Cyrano de Bergerac. The most elaborate costume show, you know, period in history, and we had no budget, but we just did it. I mean, we just did it, and the next year we wrote another one and then we came to New York after a little bit of both of us spent a semester in grad school and then we came to New York and I suddenly said, "Well, I'm a lyricist. What am I doing being a lyricist?" The last thing I want to be is a lyricist. First of all, you have no fun.
Everybody is at the theater having a good time and you're home in the hotel trying to fix those two bad lines. And which if you had any intelligence you would have written them good in the first place. If you knew how to write them, you would have written them in the first place, and so you're slogging away at it. And it was very disconcerting. Plus, when other directors were sort of dealing with our material, they tended to not direct them very well, and in fact do worse than that. Sometimes they actually did things that undercut what the song is about. So slowly I came around to the realization that what I really wanted to do is to create shell, not just like the lyrics, and that sort of meant I really want to direct the show.
So that started me on the course to that. I sort of said to myself, "Well, I have other people studied directing in school. Other people have been directing shows for, you know, five years. I haven't done that. I'm so far behind. How can I possibly think of doing this?" And then I thought, "Well, how bad could I be? Could I be worse than any of the directors who I worked with? This is a piece of cake." So I spent a lot of time just doing nightclub acts, I did benefits, I did one-man shows, I did shows that I invented so that I could direct them in small places and everything, and that led me to some performers, and I got to direct some plays and funnily enough, since all I know is musicals, the first play I was offered to direct was Long Day's Journey Into Night.
The longest, most non-musical thing there ever is. It has, I know, you know, light cues and the theatricality. It's a play which the lights go on at the beginning of the act, and maybe at the end of the act they go off. Yeah, I always, whenever I run into a stage manager who tells me they're stage managing Long Day's Journey Into Night, I always have lots of pity for them and they just sit there and call three cues. I know, I know. The fog comes in in the second act. That's the big cue. So let me ask you, there's a trend emerging in your career. I'm sensing already. Number one, you didn't know how to write lyrics, you just fell into writing lyrics. You didn't know how to create a revue, you created a revue. Directing, well, I just might as well. You just tend to do things even though you haven't done them before. What gave you the courage that you could do those things?
[18:51] Richard Maltby: Whoa. What else is there? I mean, I guess I had the impulse to, you know, the first process of creating something like that is you have to see it in your head, you know. I guess I thought theatrically. I thought of shows as things that I could see, and therefore creating them, writing them was a sort of a technical thing to do to make it come to life. Hiring actors, talking to actors, all those things were just the things you do to get the show to happen. And you know, you can't, you can write an outline, you can write a script that nobody really knows what it is unless you do it, and so I just sort of did it. And I mean, I did a musical revue in eighth grade, I mean in a school, but had no theatrical anything.
I mean, we did an Abe Lincoln pageant of my book, and that, you know, it was silly, but I sort of got the, I just started out by doing, by doing, and it never occurred to me that that wasn't a thing to do. And when you got towards the bigger stages, and all of a sudden people started chiming in with feedback, including places like the New York Times or other, did that affect you at all? Do you read reviews?
[20:30] Richard Maltby: Well, I certainly read the reviews for Ain't Misbehavin'. I mean, there wasn't a bad sentence in about a hundred reviews all around the country. You know what? It isn't that isn't the way it always works. I've heard this very recently, in fact. You may not know that, but they actually don't always say nice things about you. So at any rate, I suddenly, you know, I went from having just some off-Broadway review and a, I mean, I had a kind of reputation as a bright songwriter, but nothing of any major significance, and then I just had this blockbuster hit. So from then on, it was easier to roll on after that.
[21:23] Ken Davenport: And what happens or what happened when the first show that you did? We can't all have big fat global sensations like you did on your first.
[21:23] Richard Maltby: No, unfortunately not. I'm sorry to have to school you on this, Ken, but that's the way it is. It was shocking. I know. What happens when that occurs in your career? Was it a shock to you when something didn't go that way and how did you pick yourself up and go on to the next?
[21:43] Richard Maltby: Well, I mean, the next show that I did was Baby, which was extremely personal. David and I wrote it with Sybil Pearson who came in to write the book, and the songs were very much out of our experience in our life. The show got very nice reviews, not exactly money reviews, but a range of extremely positive reviews particularly for the score, and it did well. I mean, we were sort of scrappy considering we had no stars and nothing going for us. We were around for almost a year and every day we wondered whether or not people were coming to the theater to keep us open for another day, and they did. We just kept going. We had a little bit of a sinking fund that kept us going, and so that was not, you know, I have not been told to get out of town yet.
That show specifically is done all over the place over some of the, you know, it goes off and takes on a life of its own. Closer Than Ever, I didn't know it was, you know, it was again a show that was downtown and we were not sure that was ever going to get through this week to the next week. But the album had gone off into all the colleges, every theater program kid was going crazy for this album. I didn't know it, we didn't know it. I didn't know it until we did a revival ten, twenty years later, and then all those performers who were now almost 40 came and said, "You changed my life." My God, you can't, you know. I had that recording myself and it's interesting you say this about the college kids because I was one of those college kids.
And then, you know, we had Pasek and Paul on the podcast and they talk about how college kids got a hold of their music, and now just Joe Iconis was on last week talking about how kids are really responsible for the proliferation of new composer lyricists out there. Is this the early adopters for us?
[24:11] Richard Maltby: Well, I think they are now. I mean, you know, Closer Than Ever was, you know, '91, and Pasek and Paul are a great deal more recent than that, and Joe Iconis says the same thing. I think there are phenomena that come along, and there is one right now, which is ever since it's been growing and growing ever since High School Musical and then Glee and then all of the, it's suddenly become acceptable to be interested in musical theater. The football player can in fact come in and play Curly in the school production book and not be considered something that not be laughed at. And so, you know, that's happened, and there's a great, great school of a great quantity of kids who are interested in the theater, and they're encouraged.
It's not peripheral the way it used to be. Plus, I mean, there used to be like four colleges that had theater programs, musical theater programs. Now there are a hundred colleges that have every one of them has music, and they're all turning out talented, gifted kids who come to New York for the same number of parts, you know, and everything else.
[25:32] Richard Maltby: Um, but they and they're turning out writers and everything else. Uh, so the theater has always, uh, the theater's audience generally speaking was a grown-up audience. Um, all of the great musicals, the kids did not go to them. I mean, the kids went and sat in the second balcony and had their life changed and all of that stuff. Um, but the shows were essentially for grown-ups, that was the audience, and it still is that. And musical theater is also a little stuffy. We have not really embraced modern musical forms, and now we have, there are generations of kids who have grown up who don't know what My Fair Lady is. They're, you know, as far as that, you could be talking about The Merry Widow.
I mean, it's like, but they totally know Bruno Mars and pop artists do unbelievable shows. These, you know, these arena shows are just their Broadway musicals and they have scenery, they have dancers, they have, uh, they tell stories because the artists usually shape their evening to sell to have a kind of storytelling content. So it's not a big deal for that to come in. Basic and Ball are a perfect example of that. They are extremely smart about the history of musical theater, but their foot is definitely in the modern world. So when they do The Greatest Showman, this is like a show set in the past with numbers staged like Bruno Mars videos. I mean, the dance style is not your standard Broadway dancing, it's hip hop dancing.
What's that doing in a period show? Well, why not? I mean, musical theater has always used a foreign and has used an anachronistic musical style. You know, pop songs, the pop songs in Oklahoma are not what anybody would have sung in Oklahoma in the period of the show. Um, but, uh, you know, but that's what it's. So in a way, the kids are ahead of us. They're really saying, bring this into the theater. Shows should have this kind of excitement. Old, the other style gets to be a little stuffy, gets to be a little dull. Shows are getting a lot more exciting. Your advance is brilliant. Um, by the way, Basel and Paul, when they were in college, didn't know quite what to do, and they listened to Closer Than Ever and realized that you could have a show that didn't have a book and you can fill up an evening.
So I'm very proud of that. Yeah, that was this revue called Edges, which landed on my desk. I'm really just thinking about this now because, of course, Jason Robert Brown had a very similar thing with Songs for a New World. Robert, I bumped into him in a laundromat in the village, and we were both picking up our laundry, and he introduced himself, and he wanted to write Closer Than Ever. Songs for a New World is his Closer Than Ever in exactly the same way.
[29:14] Ken Davenport: You talked about the audience for Broadway being a little older and stuffier. Do you think an emerging musical theater composing lyricist team should write for that audience? Should they think, oh, I have an idea that will work for that crowd so I can be successful?
[29:31] Richard Maltby: Anybody, the rules of entertainment don't change, you know. The rules of grabbing you with an idea, having a melody you want to hear, um, and how you develop it, those rules remain the same, whether it's in a hip-hop vernacular or whether it's in a Rodgers and Hammerstein vernacular. Um, the rest is just sort of, you know, tree trimming. And, uh, you know, the biggest shows out there right now are incredibly fresh. Could not have been written, you know, Hamilton is of course the prime example of an actual, uh, you know, hip-hop musical, except that Lin-Manuel totally understands the history of the shape of conventional musical theater and delivers on that level totally. It is absolutely, you know, if their walk weren't hip-hop rhythms, that show would play in exactly the same way.
And, uh, it just happened that he had a vision that the founding fathers in Hamilton in particular were the equivalent of rap artists, um, and he followed it through all the way to the end and created a, you know, a earth-shaking work of art. Dear Evan Hansen is the same thing, although it's actually a conventionally structured story. Um, Come From Away is not a rock show in any way, but it's structured like no show I've ever seen. It's basically a narrative sentence. It's an expository sentence. Um, it's a paragraph with songs in it, you know. I want to tell you about what happened in the, you know, um, and, uh, oh, the, you know, Matilda is one. Groundhog Day is one. Joe O'Connor is going to have finally his big breakthrough with a show that the kids would not let go.
I just talked to friends of my grandson who came down to see Emochill. As soon as the show was announced, they got on the phone and they bought tickets, um, even though it was like for six months from now because, and I asked him where they got, how they heard about the show, and he said, "Well, somebody called me up and said, 'You've got to hear this.'" And another one said, "Well, I was just looking at what new things, and there was a show I didn't know, so I started listening to it, and I thought that was terrific." So, yes, there are kids going out. And when they do it, they become rabid. They also said, "We're gonna sit." I said, "Well, we'll meet after the show." And they said, "Well, we'll see the show, and then we're gonna go stage doing," which was a new noun I had never heard.
But apparently, kids, it's a word, which is we go and hang out and stage door and get autographs. Yeah, it's so funny. I used to do this too, and I was all alone. It was just me, nobody else. I didn't. I think it's because of the ticket prices. You spend that amount of money, you had better have your life changed for all time, you know. And you don't want it to go away. So you hang out and say hello to people that put over.
[33:04] Ken Davenport: Can we talk a little bit about your work on Saigon and how that happened and your work on a big musical coming in from overseas?
[33:12] Richard Maltby: Um, yeah, I'm sure. I, you know, I just came from Providence, where I was, the national company just went together. It is so good. Oh my god, the production is just breathtaking. It's so rich and a young cast that just gives their heart to it. That's, it's, it was great. Um, um, let's see, I, um, I was, um, a dumb, uh, baby, which, you know, has some pretty elaborate and impressive lyrics. And, um, somewhere in it, that was like '83, '84, I guess was when Les Mis opened. And after Les Mis opened, uh, Ellen and Claude-Michel Schönberg had this other idea based upon a photograph they had seen. Claude-Michel had seen this photograph of a Vietnamese woman giving her child to American soldiers so that the child would be raised in America, um, and a child that she had had by an American soldier.
But she was, you know, he thought that was heartbreaking. And from that, they sort of added pieces of Madame Butterfly and laid out the show. They write in French, and they did finish the whole first act. And it was Cameron who, Cameron Mackintosh, who decided that this show needed an American writer, needed an American presence. It wasn't a European show the way that Les Mis was. Kirby Kretzberg, who had written all of the Aznavour lyrics and who, you know, was a wonderful writer, but Cameron thought it needed an American writer. He was completely right because, um, all of the Europeans literally didn't know what Vietnam meant to America. It didn't just mean that we, you know, it was a disaster for us, and we lost the war.
But it was the end of an American mythology built in the Second World War. We are the good guys. John Wayne comes over the hill and saves the day, and we win the war. Vietnam, we were the bad guys. John Wayne did not come over the hill, and we lost. And with that went, and profoundly went something that we all needed to believe that we were. And, uh, yeah, I think the Europeans' attitude was we've been losing colonies for a hundred years, we gotta get off and come off of it. You know, that's the big deal. Um, but it was not so much a tragedy of a physical historical tragedy, but the end of a mythology. I mean, America is two things: it is what it is, and it is its mythology. The American dream, which is the sort of central image of the show, um, made lots and lots of talks about Alan growing up in Algeria and moving to Italy and then moving to France, Claude-Michel and growing up in Vienna and moving to France and then to England.
Um, from their childhood, the fantasy of what America was was gigantic. And everybody we talked to, there was always this matter. I mean, you could be the worst hater of America. You could be completely anti-American, but the American dream was a vivid and positive and growing, and that sort seems, at least, uh, at least it seemed when we were writing it then to be could to be universal. I don't know whether it's true now, but, uh, it was then. And, uh, so that was like part of the, the, I don't know that they would have come to that on their own without an American writer who could have brought that sensibility to the show. Um, and, uh, so it, the show was brilliantly laid out in terms of scenes and everything, but it wasn't, um, it wasn't written as a play really.
And so what we, and I did was, um, we, um, we just, you know, we would go to a hotel and spend three weeks there and write half of the first act. Uh, I'd type it up, was I typing? And then send it off, and then I'd forget about it for two months, and then we get another call to come back and finish the second act. So it was a, um, it was the best collaborative experience I've had thought all the way down the line. The brilliant director Nick Hytner called the show Cameron. It was absolute best. It was, uh, it was so, uh, on the money all the way through. I will say that, that, um, when Cameron called and asked me, um, to do it, he sent me this tape that Claude-Michel had made, which was the entire first act.
Claude-Michel playing at the piano and him singing it in French. Once in the old, I did not know what it was. It had these pretty melodies, and then it would have this strange restative sections. And, um, and also it, this, that was like '85, seven, ten years after Vietnam. And in the ten years since '75, every novel, movie, and play or anything about Vietnam failed. America simply didn't want to think about it. And so I turned it down. And, uh, and, uh, then I saw Les Mis, and I realized, oh, that's residue, that's storytelling residue. I get what that is. And, uh, Platoon opened and was a, you know, huge hit, and I realized, oh, maybe, maybe we are now ready to look at Vietnam. So, um, I called Cameron back and said, "Have you hired anybody?" He said, "No, no, we were waiting for you, Richard." It's not true, but I liked, uh, I liked the idea of that. So I then I met Claude-Michel, and we went to work.
[40:23] Richard Maltby: Do you have a favorite lyric of yours that you've read? Well, um, I think the lyric for, um, if I sing from Closer Than Ever is about my father and my and about David's father. We both are sons of, um, musicians, orchestra leaders, and, uh, so that would be part of it. And I guess the other is "The Story Goes On" from the end of the first act of Baby. Um, I like it when we write a song that is about something that no one has ever written a song about, you know. No one's ever quite captured that emotion. I think that's the goal, or at least that's what I'd like it to be. Um, and both of those songs are of that.
[41:25] Richard Maltby: Is there, as you listen to new writers coming up, or frankly even veteran writers, what's the most common use mistake or lack of a better word that you feel writers make? Um, not really going deeply enough into themselves. Um, genuine emotions are often, uh, contradictory, uh, unexpected, sometimes unpleasant, sometimes, uh, and but we always know when we're hearing it, it's got the ring of truth. It could be the blandest thought in the world. I mean, it could be "This Nearly Was Mine" from South Pacific, just as simple as anything, or as complicated as, um, oh, words, you know, at the end of Jeremy Hansen or anything that's in Hamilton. But if you go into your heart, you come in and you really are using your personal knowledge of humankind, the song takes on a kind of, you recognize its truth, you recognize its life, and, uh, and that is, um, that is always thrilling.
And, uh, I would say whenever I, like, go ask and judge a class or something like that, I don't, uh, the question that always, you know, the thing I always say is, where are you in this? I don't know, it's clever, I don't know where it's coming from. It's like it's an imitation of some, it's of a, of an emotion that you think you ought to have. Um, it's like when Sheldon wrote "My Teeth Ache for the Urge to Touch Your." I mean, I, okay, nobody, that's an unspeakable truth, you know.
[42:13] Richard Maltby: Okay, my last question, which is my genie question. I want you to imagine that the genie from Aladdin comes to visit you and wants to thank you for your contributions to the American musical theater by granting you one wish. What's the one thing about Broadway that drives you crazy, nuts, gets you super mad that you'd want this genie to wish away in an instant? The most frustrating thing about our business, I call it death by reading. You, um, as soon as you have something that seems to be kind of complete, we have a reading. Readings are incredibly misleading. I mean, they're very hard to tell what you've got. They can tell you big bold problems. I want, you know, I lose you here, or I lose you things.
But they're very useful. But we all know that something that plays well in a reading, you put it on the stage and suddenly everything changes. Um, hard to imagine that Gypsy was written in nine months, or that some, you know, they got the idea to do South Pacific, and the first thing they did was call up Boston and book the theater. I mean, really, and they just wrote it and it went out of town. Uh, I guess we can't, went to Philadelphia, and they didn't change anything. The only thing they did was that the colporter stood in the wings and handed Lisa Kirk extra verses to "Always True to You in My Fashion" because it was such a hit. Um, but, uh, I guess those days are gone, uh, because you couldn't possibly get a show on the basis of it just having been written.
It's too scary and it's too expensive. I guess if I, the other thing is I just wish they weren't so expensive. Broadway used to be the creative cauldron. That's where the creativity was happening. Now you have to go somewhere else and try it out. And sometimes the process of you bringing the show in, by the time it comes in, has been overworked and so thought over, and kind of some of its life goes out of it. Uh, whereas it used to have a kind of, um, uh, a buoyancy. The other thing was that in those days, in the classic musical days, um, all of those people learned they had, they had conventional storytelling playwriting skills that came from the 20s and the 30s, the well-made play. They were playwright craftsmen, they all knew what a story was and they knew how to do it.
Umer writers don't have that craft and have to learn it. They can learn it, they do learn it. I think Paul certainly learned it. Um, and, uh, you know, I'll certainly learn it. Um, it can be learned, but, um, the process of, uh, of development is, is, uh, can take the life out of things. It's also true that some of the people who are producing shows don't know a story and can kiss them on the mouth and they don't know, and they're likely to encourage things that shouldn't be encouraged and not, uh, discourage things that are fresh and strong. Um, I have certainly been around that, uh, and, and the things, they're never stupid, they're really smart, they're smart, but you shouldn't pay attention.
Um, a very interesting answer, there was a lot of answers to one simple question, it's gonna be exhausting. I just love the idea of what if we could decide, you and I, write a show right now, open it in nine months, and then try to do the same thing but with three months and compare three years and compare to see which one was actually better.
[48:17] Richard Maltby: I, yeah, I know, I bet money on the nine months or something about a deadline. Well, it depends on the show, depends on the, on, uh, you know, I thought because I think your evidence is just really, really terrific. It reads and seems like they got this idea, they sat down and wrote it in one piece, and there it is. It was an eight-year gestation period that started out as a show totally different from the one that they ended up with. Yeah, I was at one of those early workshops, and one of the things I loved, I've said to Stacy and, and to the guys, I'm amazed at the work that they did from that first workshop. It's so incredibly smart. I mean, that they were so smart to, to follow it through.
They were really lucky in their bringing Steve Levinson in, but really, you know, I don't know where he got his, uh, expertise from, but it solidly knew what a story was. Michael Grife added another completely solid level of the same thing, and the show turned into something else. Um, of course, Ben Platt's performance didn't hurt having a completely historic event happen. But those things happen. You, when the show is right, you get, you get, uh, you get presents, you know. Um, things come along to make you, uh, you know, there are times when you sit back and just watch the miracle happen, and you set it in motion. I just think it was that I did all the pieces of it and everything, and then when we hit, when we first hit an audience and the audience went crazy, I kind of went, oh, okay. I did all of that, yet I didn't do that.
[50:20] Richard Maltby: When it all comes together, there's just nothing better. I know, I know. It's, I always say it's a humiliating, pressing, discouraging process, and the most fun you'll ever have. And with that, I thank you for joining us and having fun with us today. Thanks to all of you for listening, and we will see you next time.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
