Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep23 - Mike Wartella - The Power Part

Mike Wartella (Wicked, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Tuck Everlasting) found theater as a kid and discovered a sense of power that would change his life, but a career in the arts is filled with uncertainty and powerlessness... Read More

From the show: The Quiet Part Out Loud

49 mins
10/16/24

Featured Shows

About

Mike Wartella (Wicked, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Tuck Everlasting) found theater as a kid and discovered a sense of power that would change his life, but a career in the arts is filled with uncertainty and powerlessness. Mike and Bobby discuss how overcompensation for fear and insecurity often lead to addictive validation-seeking that can lead us down harmful paths, and that a redefinition of personal power is essential for healthy and sustainable relationships to ourselves and others.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Bobby Steggert: I'm Bobby Steggert, and this is The Quiet Part Out Loud.

[0:14] Bobby Steggert: What do we learn about power growing up? Is it defined by superhuman strength and magical abilities, fabulous wealth and international fame, vanquished enemies and unlimited conquests? And in adulthood, well, isn't it the same? Our impending election is central to this question. Is real strength defined by these markers of power, or could it be defined by something else? Tied directly into these questions, of course, is gender and how traditionally masculine definitions of strength are being challenged and some would say threatened by the notion that strength can be expressed through empathy and compassion. Regardless of who you are, you've undoubtedly been shaped by countless stories in popular culture, as well as observing the very people who are actually rewarded with power and who we're supposed to aspire to.

It would be easy to assume that in terms of gender and sexuality, straight white men are the problem and everyone else is the victim. And in many ways, this is how the story has unfolded. But it misses a crucial point, that these men, often perpetrators of abusive power, are also harming themselves with their own rules. My guest this week is Mike Wartella. And other than sexuality, we have a lot in common. We both grew up small and intelligent, outsiders who found refuge in the theater, where finally there was safety and a newfound sense of power that was both a godsend and an addictive source of validation. Mike describes the contrast between the discovery of theater and a childhood sometimes marked by neglect and inconsistency in his home life, and how it led to a long and complex history of overcompensation, seeking validation and power as a compulsive response to a deeper sense of fear and insecurity.

And what happens when you pursue a career in acting, that very source of early power, when utter powerlessness is often a central feature of that career? Where does one turn for the validation, the safety, the sense of being when all else is uncertain? And when uncertainty is at the very core of early childhood wounds? And then what societal messages about power lead you to these choices? These are all questions that Mike answers with humility and clarity. And it is his redefinition of power that I most respect.

[3:08] Bobby Steggert: And it meant so much to me that you'd heard past episodes and that it spoke to you. And the thing I noticed in your message to me was this urgency in a way to tell your story. And I'm wondering what was inside of that urgency for you?

[3:22] Mike Wartella: I think there were a couple different things. The first one, honestly, was you was the work you're doing in the podcast. I felt like when I first heard this podcast, it was the first time where I thought, oh my gosh, that is an honest voice in our community. That is a place, a safe place, it seems like to be able to tell authentic stories, tell our truths. I've assumed this since listening to it. So maybe you'll tell me right now. But one of the things I love about what you do is in the Broadway community, a little bit different than I think like Hollywood is that we don't have the same kind of leeway, right? Broadway shows are always balancing on the head of a pin and they could close any moment.

So when we do interviews on all the Broadway channels, it's everything's great. I love everybody, show's great, it's amazing, it's great. And we never really get a chance to tell our truths and talk in depth. So there's people I've known in the business for years or known of in the business for years that I had never heard them be so honest and vulnerable and truthful until listening to the episodes they had done with you. And I think you were a large part of bringing that out. And so just immediately I thought, if I'm gonna talk honestly about anything with anyone, this is the person.

[4:33] Bobby Steggert: And oh my god, I love that. And yeah, people come here and I asked them not to talk about their work. And it was a different way of exploring.

[4:40] Mike Wartella: It's hard.

[4:41] Bobby Steggert: Yeah.

[4:41] Mike Wartella: Yeah.

[4:42] Mike Wartella: So that was one of them. And then I also think there was a little bit of something subconscious that came out. The title is The Quiet Part Out Loud. And for me, that quiet part that was this idea that for the past year or two, I had stepped away from the business, literally, figuratively, in a lot of different ways. And a lot of that was about realizing that I was hiding from the world and the business. And I had done a lot of healing and a lot of work to feel like I didn't need to hide anymore. I felt like I really knew who I was and felt really proud of who I was. And I thought, okay, for me, it's time to just say hi and make my voice heard and make my face seem to the community again. Go, hey, I'm still here and I exist, and it's not anything to be ashamed of. And that was important to me.

[5:25] Bobby Steggert: I really get that. I've felt like I had to go to school and disappear for several years before I felt like I had something to say and felt like I knew who I was outside of that environment.

[5:34] Mike Wartella: Yeah, big time.

[5:35] Bobby Steggert: Big time.

[5:36] Mike Wartella: It's been a shift like completely. This is the longest I have not been in the city. This is the longest I've not been really actively in the business or acting. I still audition, I still do projects occasionally. I just I needed a break. I just needed to turn my mind and my soul off from all of it. I wasn't feeling good. I felt poisoned by the whole thing, and I had to just walk away. And in the walking away, there's been a something I've experienced that a few other people I've talked to have experienced if they've done anything like this. Is like it feels like the real world kind of exists everywhere outside Manhattan and outside that 10 block radius that we call Broadway. And it's a very different experience just being with people who go to work from nine to five every day and have lived in maybe their hometown their whole lives.

It's a different thing. And I've really enjoyed and needed for my soul that experience of being humbled again and brought into reality of being equal with everyone. I didn't know it was what was happening, but there was a subconscious thought in the back of my head that was like, oh, because I'm a performer, I'm special. I'm a little bit different. I float above the crowd. And that is not healthy for me. And I can only speak for myself, but it wasn't good for me and it wasn't helping me in any way.

[6:48] Bobby Steggert: I'm so interested to actually talk about home. And I think about the comparison you just made between Broadway and small town living that so many of us understand through the queer lens. Like I had to get away from my hometown because I was not safe there. So I'm especially interested in hearing about your story of home and family, and frankly, from the place of someone who's heterosexual. You're a minority in our community in a way.

[7:13] Mike Wartella: Yeah, for sure. My story of home, and I guess for me, it feels like my story in general. I've been asked that question before by people what's it like to be straight in this world or this community kind of thing. And it's so funny to for me, I don't really know the answer to that because as silly as it is to say, I'm also really short and I'm really skinny and I'm really cute looking and I'm really adorable, and I'm really soft and nice and kind. And so when I grew up, the reality was I was treated as though I was queer anyway. Like I was bullied in a similar way. I was branded with that stamp right away, which is completely insane to me. That the idea is that if it looks this way, then it is this way, and I really just hate that.

But it was hard, obviously, for anyone who goes through that, but also it was different because I wasn't, and I knew deep in my heart that I was straight, and it didn't really matter to me. But what did matter was I think for anyone, it's like being told you're something you're not, no one believing you. And that was really tough for me. And so I didn't have the classic what I'd call like straight American boy experience where I was like playing football and like a jock or any of that. I was in theater, I was in band. However, I was also immediately feeling this urge to overcompensate because I was picked on in that way that I was being branded that you're not a man. And I was trying to look at examples, as we all do, from society of the sort of brainwashing that's what is a man, what is a cliché masculine figure.

And what I see around me all the time is money, power, and women. Those are the things that sort of brand masculine qualities, which again to me is very sad as an adult. So I started money wasn't going to be an option because I was in high school. Power was definitely an option because if I got more talented and more popular than other people based on my talent, then I could yield a certain amount of power. And women, or at the time girls, were definitely an option because it was like I can date a lot of beautiful girls and they'll think I'm a man.

[9:15] Bobby Steggert: Were you attracted to the creative arts partly because of what you're speaking about? Because there's so many beautiful, interesting women in that world.

[9:21] Mike Wartella: I don't think so originally, no. I think it became more attractive to me as I got into high school because I went, ooh, a little perk. But no. In the beginning, it was my family. I started acting when I was three years old. My family was all in the arts, singers, songwriters, actors in our local scene, and still are, most of them. And in some ways it was just like the family business, like jump on stage. I was Tiny Tim in a Christmas Carol when I was three years old. I liked it right away. I loved being on stage. I loved the freedom it gave me. I loved the spotlight. I think the thing that I was more drawn to about it that was subconsciously happening was attention and validation from the places that I wasn't getting it, basically.

My family was dropping the ball, and it wasn't intentional. They were, they are great people and they're all so wonderful. And they've, of course, grown and evolved and atoned for a lot of their sins when they were younger. But they were young people, they were young parents, and there was a lot going on, and it was a little chaotic. And to spare the details, but some of the patterns were like there was abandonment, there was neglect, there was addiction, all of that was circulating in the family. And it was all under a veil of love. It didn't look like any of those things. It looked like a happy, loving childhood. So I was even confused, going, Oh, they love me. But I could feel that thing that children feel from a young age that's they don't love me unconditionally.

Their love is based on a condition that A, I'd be a really good boy. B, maybe I'm funny, maybe I'm talented, maybe they can be proud of me. It's something I do. And so that combined with stepping on stage was like, this is the thing to get their love. This is the thing.

[11:01] Bobby Steggert: What was the core of that sense of lack of safety? What was the core of it?

[11:07] Mike Wartella: The word that sticks out is abandonment. There were times when I was like physically abandoned because of addiction, where people would leave the house and I'd be stuck at home alone, way too young to be alone for hours. There was abandonment in the sense of like, hey, we've got to go to work, so you're coming with me, and we'll get to dinner later. And for now, just eat this box of cereal. And hours would go by and I would just be on my own eating dry cereal out of a thing. Like little things that didn't seem odd at the time, but looking back made me feel terrified, alone, scared, and then these intermittent spurts of like wild love. Like they come in and be like, Oh, I love you so much. You're so amazing. Oh, that feels good. That feels safe. And so I was always searching for that again.

[11:47] Mike Wartella: A roller coaster of emptiness and then a rush of love and back to the emptiness.

[11:53] Bobby Steggert: Exactly.

[11:53] Mike Wartella: Put bummed.

[11:55] Bobby Steggert: Yes.

[11:55] Mike Wartella: Yeah, for sure.

[11:56] Mike Wartella: And feeling abandoned, feeling neglected. Are you saying that theater was one of the places where you started to find a sense of grounding and safety?

[12:05] Mike Wartella: Absolutely. For sure. I found it on stage. I found it backstage in the community of the other kids at the time that were doing it and the other adults treating me with respect. I got a lot of respect from the other actors at the time. I don't know if it's because they thought I was talented or brave for being up there or what, but a lot of the adult actors in particular growing up talked to me like an adult.

[12:28] Mike Wartella: There's some guy that I still have friends with who I worked with back then, and he tells a story about being like, Yeah, we were hanging out, it was you and another person, and you were four years old, and I was having trouble with my lines, and I handed you the script, like, here, can you help me with my lines? And you said, sure, yeah, no problem. And then I had my own moment of going, oh, wait, he can't read. And I had to take it back from me. And but they lost that I was a kid at times, and I loved it. I loved being treated that way. I loved being respected. And there were probably parts of it looking back that were unhealthy because I was almost like robbed of a childhood. I was forced into being an adult professional actor.

[13:00] Bobby Steggert: Yeah, I'm getting a sense that there was part of you that was parentified. Were you taking care of siblings at the same time?

[13:06] Mike Wartella: I don't have any siblings. I had a stepsister who passed a few years ago who's wonderful, but she came into my life when my parents got married in my late teens. But I didn't grow up with any siblings, and I was parenting a lot. My family and my parental figures were messy. And I had this pressure to feel like I had to take care of them a lot. And that was intense and hard.

[13:27] Bobby Steggert: And this overlining is that you became very self-sufficient.

[13:30] Mike Wartella: Absolutely. Incredibly independent. I was absolutely ready to move to New York at 17 all by myself.

[13:36] Bobby Steggert: Did you study at a conservatory or did you go right into the biz?

[13:40] Mike Wartella: I went to Circle in the Square Theater School here in New York. Yeah. I went at 17 as soon as I graduated high school, all by myself. And that's one of those cool programs where there's no dorms. You have to get a job, you have to get an apartment, and you're going to school. And it was intense and fun and hard.

[13:56] Bobby Steggert: So talk to me more about this sense of power. I so relate to that. I remember being on stage as a young kid and being like, you have to listen to me. And whatever I do, you will take in. And that for a very shy young gay kid was extremely important for me to feel. So, how did that sense of power start to land on you?

[14:15] Mike Wartella: Absolutely. I think I felt it subconsciously, like you said, it was like, oh my gosh, they're all looking at me and they're all paying attention to me. And this is great. And especially like I mentioned before, being like a small kid, I was small even back then. And it made me feel like I was out of my shell. I was larger than life. I could play any role. I've always been good at the thing I'm still good at is like big over-the-top crazy characters, but all based in truth. And I struggle a little bit when it's just me. There's no voice, there's no accent. That's hard for me to do as an actor. But back then I loved, I would jump in. I remember they were doing cabaret at one point. And the guy, I think it was my father actually, was playing the MC, and he was out for the day.

And I just stepped up on stage at seven years old and started doing all the MC stuff. And people just let me do it and laughed. And I had memorized it by hearing the play every day. And but I loved it. I loved playing like a role like that. So it was freedom as well as power. It was the only place that I truly felt safe and seen and allowed to be myself.

[15:15] Bobby Steggert: What I'm thinking about is how I too was a very small kid. I started puberty like at 16, something crazy late. And I always equate my smallness with my queerness. Because they were one and the same in childhood. And I'm so interested to hear about your experience of being a smaller person and still feeling so under the thumb of that toxic masculinity that is so horrible in our society.

[15:39] Mike Wartella: Yeah, it was bizarre. It was bizarre. It was like I said, it was like, because unfortunately they were one and the same at that time. It was like I didn't notice any of that in my early years, seven, ten, even twelve. It wasn't really happening. But as soon as all the kids hit puberty, that was the main thing, right? Was like I was one of the popular kids. Then all the kids hit puberty and I became the loser that they all kicked on and looked down. That hit me hard. I felt like a massive shift. I felt like it wasn't fair. I felt angry. I felt scared. And so I just started surviving and subconsciously doing a bunch of things to try to remedy that. And I went harder into my persona of being an artist. That was one thing. That's when I picked up this bad habit, if you will, of dating too much and just trying to find too many people to date so that I could get validation that way. And it worked.

[16:32] Bobby Steggert: Can you describe what that experience was like without judging it? What was happening when you say too much?

[16:41] Mike Wartella: Great question. One of the patterns I've had, I would say that started young is that attention and validation were the drug, so to speak. If a girl liked me, I was over the moon. I was in heaven. Oh my gosh, this is it. I can't believe it. Finally, the love I never feel like I've had, it's here. I remember that happening at 14 years old with my first love. And it was a real love. This is the other part that's important to the story is that my feelings and my reactions to love do not change the fact that a lot of people I've been with have been real loves, real relationships, real connections. But I just wasn't really able to digest them properly. So I would feel this hit of validation and safety.

I've often talked about Romeo and Juliet and how people think of it as the greatest love story ever. And I go, Oh, I think it was just two young kids feeling that first hit of validation and going, Oh my God, I'm not alone. And now my two crazy households, I don't have to worry about them. I've got you. And it's more about that. And so for me, that's what was going on. And the problem with that is that if I was happy and content in a relationship, and some new girl gave me attention or a crush, oh my god, there's that same feeling again, and there it is again. I have to be with her because there it is again. And I would make all these excuses and these thoughts, and I would self-sabotage and do things to hurt myself because I didn't understand how to digest that feeling.

And I also didn't know how to protect myself from it, especially as I got older, as I now know in life. For me, if I'm in a relationship and I sense something with someone else, like that's a boundary that has to be a boundary immediately. For a very long time, I did not know how to make those boundaries.

[18:18] Bobby Steggert: As devil's advocate, if someone like me now were to say, that's what teenagers do, that's what people in their 20s do. They date a lot and hearts are broken and people move on and breakups are messy. What would be your response to that?

[18:34] Mike Wartella: I think you're absolutely right. And I think from what I've learned, a whole group of people without self-diagnosing the world do that, and some of it's probably not so healthy and probably hurting a lot of them, and they don't realize why. And maybe years down the road, they're going, why is this still happening to me? And hopefully they get help. And then there's a whole bunch of people where that is normal, and that is phase that they grow out of. And I just didn't grow out of it.

[19:02] Bobby Steggert: You use the word addiction. Was that model something you were conscious of between your dating life and the substance abuse that you were observing as a kid, in the sense that pleasure seeking was more important than consistency. Pleasure seeking was of more value than safety.

[19:22] Mike Wartella: I really wish I could say that the answer was yes. I saw it coming in a way. Certainly saw in the messy years with my family, because I will say most of my family that had addictive issues have all since become people who are in recoveries. And that started in my late teens. And so from a pretty young age, I was also introduced to what that life looks like. And I wish I could say that I made the connection between substances and any sort of pleasure, be it spending money, going to the casino, dating, anything like that. But I didn't. I was, in my opinion, brainwashed the way a lot of other people on the planet are by society, which is dating is messy and dating is normal, and you should follow your heart and you should blah, blah, blah.

And a lot of this programming. And so it wasn't really introduced to me for a very long time that there may be addictive patterns or cycles around it until later on in life. And then I'll be honest, when I did discover that, I very much rejected it. I very much was like angry about it, did not want to admit that was me, judged it exponentially. I really remember thinking anyone with addiction issues in that department is sick and gross and perverted. And I had all those judgments and feelings. And so it really took me a long time to understand that there's a spectrum of that, and there's different ways to heal that. And it doesn't all look the same. For me growing up, a lot of the addiction I saw was like you drinking too much, you get help, you stop drinking, you never drink again.

That's what that looks like. Those are your bottom line issues. In the world, since I've been exploring, and I will say I do have obviously addictive patterns in relationships and dating. And I've been trying to deal with them through various forms of recovery, therapy, meditation, 12-steps sometimes, all of that in this department. And what I've learned is that it is a broad spectrum. And everybody's addictive patterns can look completely different than someone else's. Male, female is a big one. It's like a lot of women I've known to have some of these things. It doesn't look anything like what the men are going through. And so they confuse it often to be like, oh, I don't have that. When in actuality they might.

So I had to slowly come to terms with that. And then, like some of these other patterns, maybe like scrolling or over shopping or um eating disorder stuff, those ones are really hard to break because you have to do them on a daily basis. You can't just quit drinking in that sense. You have to eat, you have to spend money. You're encouraged to have a loving, healthy relationship. So it's taken a lot of years, and it's really obviously a continued process. I'm not perfect. I continue to work at this a lot. But I definitely think I had to face it at some point because my childhood patterns and trauma and the stuff that was put onto me helped create this monster that I very much took hold of in my teens and twenties moving on, and am responsible for all the damage I've caused.

[22:14] Bobby Steggert: We'll be right back.

[22:17] Bobby Steggert: Will you say more about the vicious cycle you found yourself in? And I'm really curious about how sex was included in that vicious cycle and how you kept on comparing apples and oranges with a new energy and an established energy, and how of that comparison got you in trouble.

[22:35] Mike Wartella: Absolutely. What you just described really was the pattern for a long time. It continued from childhood, this new attention, new validation being very appealing. The way sex plays a part in that is that as you get older, you start to incorporate sex into your life. And sex, in and of itself, even wonderful, healthy, connected, safe sex, shit ton of endorphins to the brain, the flood of things. And I've since done research to find out it's the same chemical reaction one is experiencing if doing like heroin, for example. And it can become unfortunately even more toxic of a chemical combination. If there's an element of like we shouldn't do this, because then there's something dangerous and adrenaline filled, whatever that looks like, even if it's like with your partner and you're in public, and oh, we shouldn't do this.

Wherever that phrase can be applied, there's now an extra hit in the brain of adrenaline. So if you combine those two things into a cocktail, it's a dangerous disaster. Then you add love into the mix, which is very real as well and comes with its own flood of endorphins. So this is uh there's so many things that make me think of that feeling that are just so special and pure and wonderful. But in any situation where I feel like someone can make something addictive, is your brain just likes too much of it and wants more and wants more. So if it's offered again, you take it again. If it's offered again, you chase that original hit. And then also, truth be told, sex also plays a role, as we talked about, in validation and power.

It becomes a thing, especially back to what you had originally asked about the experience of being straight in the world or certainly in this community, is like there's power in it. Oh, you were with this person? Wow, bro, look at you, man. And it's unfortunate to admit that, but there's sometimes when I've been lacking validation, that can feel good and it can just become a cycle. I guess I'm lucky in a sense that I've also always this is strange to say, knowing that I've done so many questionable things in my life, but I've always had a strong moral compass and a really strong sense of self and what's right and wrong. And so, in a weird way, in a lot of these years, when I was doing things that I knew were wrong, I was tortured inside.

[24:45] Mike Wartella: I think I've met people, and I won't speak for everyone else, but I've met guys that I sometimes look in their eyes and I go, Oh, you don't give a shit. Like you're fine. You know what I mean? And I just never had that experience. I was always tortured about it and conflicted and confused, and could feel that it wasn't right for me, but also felt at the mercy of it. And I want to be very clear in this moment too, to just say this. I am not making excuses for anything I've ever done or any of the hurt that I've caused. At the end of the day, life is a choice, and I've made a lot of choices that I've made that no one's forced me to make, that I'm not a victim of from my childhood or my addictive patterns or any of those things, I take responsibility for that.

And it's something I have to live with every day too, and I have to keep atoning for and dealing with my own shame around it. And it's difficult, but it's on me. But that said, there are other factors, and that's one of them becomes a habit. I'm also wondering in terms of the vicious cycle that you've described, something that I experienced over the years was that once in a real space of intimacy with someone, the complication is that you're fully seen. You are seen in all of your shades. And was that part of how you justified opting for the new exciting thing? The inconvenience of being fully seen by the person you're actually with.

[26:04] Mike Wartella: Absolutely. Absolutely. Well said. A term that I've heard, like sometimes we can assign magical qualities to others. That has been true for me. Like when you meet someone new, I think for all of us, you don't know them very well. So you meet someone new, and oh my gosh, they're amazing. And your brain starts filling in the blanks of their reality. Now, the flip side of that is I've also wanted magical qualities assigned to me. Right. So when I meet someone new, I've wanted them to look at me as my best self, my perfect self, my badass self, my this and that. And I get to fill in all the holes with my own shame that they don't see. And so the more I have experienced real intimacy with people and having them see all the icky parts of me, that feels so uncomfortable at times and so scary and shameful.

And immediately for me connects right back to my abandonment, which is it's conditional love. So if they see these parts of me that aren't great, they're gonna leave. They're gonna run, they're out. And so I think for years, in a subconscious effort to try to control this, I would either leave first or quit when it got too scary, or search out the thing that made me feel less vulnerable. And again, luckily, as I got older, I started to realize that was a pattern. It started to feel not so good, and I started to correct it because I could just tell it was hurting me and other people and it didn't work, but it is a thing.

[27:21] Mike Wartella: Something I'm also thinking about is how the power you're talking about seeking, even if it's superficial power, even if it doesn't bear out to be the most healthy thing, is often in contrast to how powerless we are as actors. And would you describe what that powerlessness has felt like for you as an actor?

[27:40] Mike Wartella: I love, I'm grateful. Thank you for tying in the two. Because another part of this whole thing that I've really noticed for myself over the years, that started, you can hear it probably, right? At a young age, getting on stage and feeling powerful, unseen and loved, and then that continuing into adolescence and early adulthood. Theater for me has always been very tied to this pattern because sometimes it's a marriage made in heaven where it's going really well. You're on stage, people are adoring you, and you get to, as I heard my buddy Brightman say, you get to continue that party offstage. You get to be surrounded by people who are adoring you and that you love and it's great and it can lift you up.

I've had a very long, luckily successful career in the theater arts. And what that means is that the veil got lifted years ago for me with Broadway and acting, which is that it's wonderful, it's great, it's fun, it's my dream come true. And it's also really fucking hard, really difficult, scary, a lot of pressure. The higher you go, the more eyes are on you, wanting you to be perfect. And in my mind, perfection has no place in the arts. And so it's a really hard marriage to do corporate theater. And then, yeah, and you add in auditioning and going after new roles and competing with your friends and people maybe you don't like so much, and you get close and then you don't get the role. And it never really gets easier for me.

I never really got a tougher skin. In fact, some of the worst I've felt about myself has been in the past few years because I did quote unquote make it at a certain point, maybe seven, eight years ago. I hit a point where I felt, oh, people know who I am in this business. I get a couple offers every now and then for readings here and there. The fans know me, all that stuff. And so then I thought when I walk in the room, everyone goes, Mike, there he is. Ah, we can't wait to see what you do. And it's oh, like now I've got to really make good on it. And then I wouldn't get the job, even if maybe I did a great job. Then my ego and my brain would go, oh my God, I must be terrible. Because as crazy as this sounds, my own ego at times has said, if I'm this good and I've paid my dues for this long, then I really should just get the offer.

Or maybe this should just be like a quick audition just to check some boxes and then get the offer. But sometimes I was going through eight or nine callbacks, even recently for big shows that I didn't get in the end. And that was such a blow for my ego. It was huge. And so back to how it ties in. All these years, or something else, maybe even like tech rehearsal or previews, as you know, is like you're working day and night, you're sick, there's no time for self-care, you're not seeing your family, you're really in the thick of it. It's really gritty work. It's no longer, you know, special and sparkly and fun. It's difficult. And so what I learned was that for a very long time, I soothed and eased those difficult feelings with numbing out through relationship stuff.

And sometimes it was a really easy sitch where I had a long-term kind of girlfriend and everything was going great. It was wonderful. Sometimes it was a messy love triangle and I had to figure it out. Sometimes I was single and looking, whatever it was, I always had that distraction on the side that was like my little pacifier that made me feel better.

[30:45] Mike Wartella: Can you say more about why you use terms like numbing and pacifier? Because those, other than being at home with the girlfriend, that sounds very searching and active to me. What about that was also dissociative?

[30:56] Mike Wartella: I guess for me, the reason it feels like numbing and pacifier versus having it just be a healthy dating situation and where the disassociative part comes, is that I was searching out, like you said, the feelings. I wasn't searching out the people. Sometimes I would bump into the right people, and that was a good news. But then even worse, if I bumped into the right people, as I've often talked about before, sometimes I was so intimidated by them or scared, or I wouldn't even give them a shot because I'm like, oh, they're boring. When in actuality, boring meant safe and stable and grounded, and I just didn't know that. And so those feelings felt like it was about more like the hits. And if I wasn't getting the hits from someone, I had to go find it somewhere else.

And if I was getting the hits from someone for a long time and then they started to fade, I had to find them somewhere else. And that part is the part that I think is clearly disconnected from human my own humanity and the other person's humanity and disconnected from any kind of sense of truth.

[31:57] Mike Wartella: Will you talk about, and it might have been more than one moment, of course, but the turning point into really doing something about those patterns?

[32:05] Mike Wartella: There's been like a couple different spots for me in my life. I've honestly probably been on this quote unquote self-discovery journey, especially in this department, for maybe 10 years, which is honestly hard for me to admit. Again, quiet part out loud. It's like knowing people I've seen go through AA, it's like you go in AA and you're sober, that's it, done. Hopefully. But it's not always the case, even for addicts or drug addicts or anyone. And for me, it's been an up and down back and forth. The big one for me happened a little bit before pandemic. I had been out on tour. I had gotten really messy after a breakup. I was not feeling good. I was doing a lot of questionable things that were hurting people and myself.

And I just, I saw it because I had some awareness now. As I said, I had picked up some of these tools already. So I had awareness of going, but what are you doing? Really stop. And so I just I called it all off. I said, break on everything in my life. I really became like a monk. I went into solitude. I didn't speak to a lot of people unless they were incredibly healthy or grounded in my life and safe. I did a lot of work, a lot of therapy stuff. And then by the way, that coincided, luckily, and I feel whatever sense I have of spirituality in the universe having my back, I feel like the universe stepped in, and about three to six months later was the pandemic. So I had already started the journey.

Thank God it was on my own. But the pandemic said, Yeah, let's keep you in rehab for a couple years as opposed to a couple months. And I had a chance to really go deep and evolve and find out who I was by to speak more clearly to it, so it's more specific. I just stopped dating. Like I just stopped.

[33:39] Mike Wartella: You stopped using new connections as a way to validate.

[33:44] Mike Wartella: I definitely stopped doing that, but I also just didn't allow myself the opportunity to even date healthily at all for a while until I felt like I could truly handle it, until I felt like I really knew what that was. And more importantly, to discover myself. I think the unfortunate part of these addictive patterns for me has been that I've never known who I was. I've been so distracted. I've probably been avoiding finding out who I was and looking at my imperfections, character defects, and also wonderful qualities, owning things about me that are great, but maybe other people don't like. Like all the things that are messy and human, I avoided all those years. And so I also got to a point where I realized this isn't about other people anymore.

This is about me. This is about my soul's journey to find itself and find out who I am. And as silly a thing as it is, like I got a couple years into that break and realized that up until then, I didn't know what kind of foods I liked. I didn't know what kind of movies I liked. It was like, what do you want to eat today, babe? I don't know. What do you want to eat? You know, that was my answer. It was never, what do you want? I think I want Italian. Here was a big one. A big one was I have a son who's about to be 16 any minute. And I've dated quite a bit while he was younger. And I dated women who didn't have kids. And so they were like, I hope to have more kids one day. And I just accepted for a long time that I was like, Yeah, I'll have to do that because they're gonna want it, and that's fine.

I could do that. But when I got that break, I went, I don't think I want any more kids. I love the one I have. He's amazing. I love putting my energy into him. I'm too old now. I really don't want to do it. So I'm gonna have to next time I meet a woman say, I don't think I want any more kids, and that might be a deal breaker for us.

[35:24] Mike Wartella: This is adding a whole nother layer, which I find really interesting. You've been talking about the need for validation through different experiences, a sense of safety. It also sounds like you've needed identity through these relationships.

[35:37] Mike Wartella: Hallelujah, Bobby. Yeah, absolutely. I think you're totally right. It's something I didn't notice for a long time. And it's actually probably the part of this that I still struggle with the most. As no, you know what? I'm not gonna judge it. But what I'll say is for a long time, I put my value and my identity in my looks, my tattoos, my hair, my body, my career, my way of speaking. I look back on old interviews and I really cringe because there's a way I talked as like, oh, yeah, I totally did. Like I was like in character and on all the time. And I really thought that's who I was, and I distinctly remember one of my closest friends saying once to me, you can let that all go, and we love you for who you are.

And I said, I said something like, What makes a good person? And she was like, I don't know, being a good friend, being a good father, being there for you. I said, Yeah, that's the obvious like human stuff, of course. But what and I realized in that moment that I was totally skipping over the most important stuff, and that actually all these other superficial things really didn't matter. And the reason that's important is that, and I think this is a very human struggle that's relatable. It's like I've stripped a lot of those things away. I can't strip away the tattoos. I'm very glad I still have them. But like, I've changed my hair quite a bit to try to look almost on purpose, like what I deem as less attractive, so that I can feel more comfortable in my own skin.

I've changed how I walk, how I behave. And I haven't, I won't even say I've changed, I've just naturally dropped into its authentic version. And in so doing, I've felt very vulnerable and scared and convinced that not only, you know, will my partner not find me attractive anymore or not like me, but like no one in the world will like me.

[37:18] Mike Wartella: They won't hire me, they won't want me at parties, they won't want me on Zoom calls. I've struggled with that a lot, and I still do, where I have to fight every day going, don't put it on, don't turn it on, you don't need to do that. Come as you are, you're enough. Which again, by the way, was really what drew me to you in this podcast was that everyone I hear on this sounds like they're coming from that place, and it's really refreshing.

[37:44] Bobby Steggert: We'll be right back.

[37:47] Mike Wartella: Who have you realized you are? I am someone who is imperfect and also wildly hardworking and dedicated and optimistic in the truest sense of the word. I have hope. I have a sense of hope all the time, even in the darkest moments. I have abilities to reverse the Titanic and change the energy in the wheel more so than I ever realized. I am often the person who I think of an example like my ex-wife, you know, who's the mother of my child, who I don't see a whole lot of examples out there of people who are as close as her and I are without any kind of romantic connection. We really love each other, we talk all the time, we raise him together, we have Christmases together, just the three of us sometimes, and scratch their heads at that.

Like, how the hell did you do that? And to, I don't really know the answer other than hard work, but I've always been someone who that's one of my superpowers is I can take a situation that's never been done before and do it. I do feel like I'm a natural leader and motivator. I feel like what's been really great to find in my own healing and taking care of self is that I have a lot to give and offer in terms of service and help to the world and other people. I think I'm a phenomenally depthful artist who cares about truth more than anything. Though that, though I feel like that's not always supported in the professional business, it matters to me so much, and I'm real good at it. I think I'm a phenomenal father.

And I have not always been, but at a certain point in his life, I really started to make that more of a focus. And I've become someone who is such a good influence in his life and his world, and is so there for him in a way that was never provided for me for a while. I think I've also become an incredible partner, like a wonderful, loving, attentive, boundried partner who knows how to take care of the other person without leaving myself out, who knows how to set boundaries with that person and say, hey, listen, very calmly. I don't know if this is going to work for me, maybe even long term. Can we talk about it? But then talk about it and move through it and find even deeper intimacy and connection. Yeah, I think that's a good start.

[40:06] Bobby Steggert: It's a wonderful start. It's also so apparent that the major transition you've made is to shift away from markers of self in terms of external examples. And you've gone much further inward than you ever went.

[40:22] Mike Wartella: Oh, yeah. Yeah. It's been the truth is it's been a forced process in a lot of ways. And when I say that by the universe, not by any one person. But the nitty gritty is things have not gone in my life the way I wanted them to go. My career has not gone the way I wanted it to go. And that's a tough one too, because I think a lot of people look at it and go, Oh my God, you've done so well and you've done everything you've wanted. And I go, No, quite frankly, you don't know what I've wanted. And though I'm insanely grateful for a lot of the roles I've gotten to play, again, back to this idea of being short and cute and small, I've played a lot of children on Broadway. I've played a lot of kids who are innocent and adorable or a little rambunctious.

I go and I watch something like Next to Normal, and I know that I'm only currently castable in the two young guys. But the only role I feel like I could connect with or play is the father. He's the only one I want to play. And so maybe in time that'll change and that'll be great, but that's been hard. Another part of the career that's been hard is the level at which I've achieved. Like I've played a lot of supporting roles, which has been amazing. I've done a lot of things, I've accomplished a lot of stuff. And yet, there are people either right next to me or a little above me that seem to get so many more opportunities than me. And it drives me nuts because there's this part of my head that's if I was in a corporate structure, I would have paid my dues by now to become the VP, period.

And I've paid all those dues, and yet, oh sorry, you're still a salesman. And that's not, by the way, specific to me. Our entire community goes through this. I've heard it on this podcast, the people who have had huge success and they can't get a phone call. And so it's normal, but it's a tough one. It's a tough one when you've made a plan your whole life to go a certain direction and the universe has other ideas. And for me, that's part of the forcedness. That's okay, I have two options. I either reject it and continue rejecting it forever and say, why God, why have you punished me this way? I refuse. I'm gonna keep fighting for what I want, which I did for a long time. And that's me banging my head against a brick wall.

I've often talked about this business feeling like I thought I was running a marathon for years and getting farther ahead, only to look down and realize I was on a treadmill. And it made me feel good that I was running every day, but I really wasn't controlling my fate. The agents were, the casting directors were, the directors were. That was that. And it still is. So now I have option two, which is acceptance and looking around at what I can change on the daily, recognizing for myself that my daily quality of life in New York was not fun for me. Like I didn't like it anymore. I'd been there 20 years, and so the early 20 something party atmosphere faded for me and I was sick of it. And then New York just becomes hard.

Walking to Trader Joe's, standing in line, getting on the train, going to the gym, it's too crowded. So I wanted to start to move away from that and get to a place where my daily quality of life was so rich and full that I could fill my own cup up every day and maybe be of service. And I'm doing that now, and it still doesn't always look like what I want. I would love to be on Broadway, starring in a show, winning a Tony. And I also recognize the universe has maybe sent me messages to say that's probably not gonna bring me happiness and it's not gonna matter in that sense. If it's the way I need to be of service one day for people, then I should do it. And if it's not, if right now it's something else, then I should do that. And so that's been a big shift too.

[43:43] Bobby Steggert: Would you feel comfortable sharing in relationship to this incredible growth? How you still come up the instinct to overcompensate?

[43:54] Mike Wartella: Sure. Think again, I'll speak for myself, but my experience with any kind of addictive behavior is that it's with me forever in some ways. I just did a show that's still in the works. It's about addiction. And it's one of my favorite things I've ever worked on. And without giving anything away, there's a representation in that show of addiction. And that representation at the end, when it's the happy ending and the sunshine has come out, is still with me. It's still there. It's still like in the background. It's softer, it's faded. I have a smile and I'm saying, oh no, I don't need you, but I know you're always there, kind of thing. But it's there. And so I think the thing that's made me feel the healthiest moving forward and struggled the most is realizing that I will never feel totally cured or fixed or whole in regards to not only my childhood trauma, like that whole will also never fully be healed, and that's okay.

But this sort of sense and need for validation, addictive hits, ego flaring, that will always be with me, literally on the daily. And it comes out now in like sideways weird moments. Like I have a job, I'm working in my hometown, I'm working with a wonderful theater there. I'm working in their education department, and I'm a teacher. And if a moment happens where, like, sometimes I'm directing shows of people, and if someone trumps me and says, no, we don't like that idea. My thought is like, do you know who I am? Like, do you have any clue what I could run this place? Like it'll flare, and then I have to take a breath and be like, buddy, like just breathe. And I also recognize when those moments happen that they're not a result of the moment.

They're the result of 20 years of feeling unseen or unheard in the business, or a childhood where I felt unseen or unheard. So I can talk to those parts of me and nurture them and take a breath and pause or journal or bring them. My favorite tool to use, by the way, is trusted people that I love, like a small handful of loving friends who know everything about me, so that I can go to them and get rid of the feelings and then breathe and then take the solution, like talk through the solution and take it back to my boss, my colleagues, my family, my partner. A phrase I've heard a lot that I love is take the problem to your person and the solution to your partner. You know what I mean? And that's not the same thing as being dishonest.

I'll still bring if there's conflict, I'll still bring it back to my partner and say, hey, we really got to talk about this. But what's been filtered out is all the reactive feelings. I still battle with it that way. And even sure, addictive stuff is still always on my shoulder. It comes out in small ways, social media hits or people on the street or whatever. And that's normal. The good news is I've learned that if I take my daily dose of medicine and whatever I need, it's like the symptoms are literally 5% of what they once were. Then it becomes manageable. Then I can handle it. My mistake I've made throughout this road has been in the past when the feelings felt like, oh, I'm only feeling 5% triggered. I thought, great, then I can do this all on my own and I can just handle that. And I stopped using any tools that I had. Now I'm realizing that I use those tools to keep it at 5% and then I'm fine.

[46:57] Bobby Steggert: It does.

[46:58] Mike Wartella: So final question. And this is happening on a macro level right now is the debate between who should be our leader is really about what kind of power do we value as Americans. What have you learned true power is?

[47:12] Mike Wartella: So I was lucky enough literally recently at this theater I just talked about that I work at. Kamala came and she talked at the theater. I saw her live. I was able to work this event and stand in the back and listen to her speak. And it was the first time, I know she's since used this line a lot publicly, but it was the first time I heard her say, right now, power is being valued by people in this country as how they can control others. But the way she sees it is power is really how to lift others up. And that is exactly how I feel. I of course sobbed and got emotional watching her say that in the room erupt, but it's definitely how I feel. I didn't realize I can forgive myself by saying I didn't know that what I was doing for years was having power over others and keeping them down.

I was just surviving. I was just living. But now I do know that. Now I have the grace that is hindsight. And I can look at that and go, okay, so now my option is to lift others up in whatever way I can do that. I love teaching. I love my kids and my students. I love helping them rise. I want to continue to do that in a really big way. I love being of service to people. I love taking care of my friends and my family. I love being there for my son. I love being there for my ex-wife and my partner. I love being there for people on the street. And of course, as I have found, as I hope many find when they do this, the beautiful irony is that when you really do make it about other people, you feel amazing.

Like you just get that gushy true love feeling right back. And it's also, by the way, cycled into my performance. My performance has completely changed. When I step on stage, it's really no longer anymore about check me out, look at me, watch this. It's absolutely about okay, how can I help you? How can I be of service? How can I let myself be as vulnerable and raw and honest in whatever way, even if it's a comedy or whatever, as possible, so that I can resonate some truth with you and help you heal, which by the way, has all of a sudden made me more nervous to go on stage. I never used to get stage fright until now because now I'm really being honest and vulnerable. I'm not hiding anything.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred