WE LOVE ANDY! Broadway icon Andy Karl, who is set to make his highly anticipated return to the New York stage this month in the new Michael R. Jackson musical, “Teeth,” at New World Stages. Andy joins the production as ‘Pastor Bill O'Keefe’... Read More
From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon
Guests
Featured Shows
About
WE LOVE ANDY! Broadway icon Andy Karl, who is set to make his highly anticipated return to the New York stage this month in the new Michael R. Jackson musical, “Teeth,” at New World Stages. Andy joins the production as ‘Pastor Bill O'Keefe’.
Following its sold-out, extended run at Playwrights Horizons, “Teeth” will live on at New World Stages. Based on the cult classic film, the show is a fierce, rapturous, and savagely entertaining new musical crackling with irrepressible desire and ancient rage – a dark comedy conjuring the legend of one girl whose sexual curse is also her salvation. Dawn O’Keefe is an evangelical Christian teen with a powerful secret not even she understands – when men violate her, her body bites back. That’s not a metaphor.
Andy Karl is a three-time Tony Award nominee and Drama Desk Award winner known for his Olivier Award-winning, Tony-nominated role as ‘Phil Connors’ in “Groundhog Day” which played on Broadway, at London’s Old Vic and Melbourne's Princess Theatre. He was previously seen in the Broadway revival of “Into the Woods” and leading the Broadway musical “Pretty Woman.” He earned back-to-back Tony Award nominations for 2014’s “Rocky” and the following year’s “On the Twentieth Century.” Additional Broadway credits include “The Mystery of Edwin Drood,” “9 to 5,” “Legally Blonde,” “The Wedding Singer,” “Jersey Boys,” and “Saturday Night Fever.” On television, Andy is well known for his fan-favorite role on “Law & Order: SVU” as ‘Lieutenant Mike among others. On film he appeared alongside Michael Douglas and Diane Keaton in the feature film “And So It Goes,” directed by Rob Reiner, and Christina Ricci in “Here After.”
We talk about "Teeth," his career, & so much more!
For Tickets: www.teeththemusical.com
__________________________________________________________________
Check out "The Roundtable with Robert Bannon" here on BPN on the daily, on YouTube, and on social media!
For more info on Robert- www.RobertBannon.com
Follow Him on IG- @RobertMBannon
TikTok-@RobertMBannon
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:09] Robert Bannon: Are you ready? It's the Roundtable with me, Robert Bannon. So our next guest, I don't know. I've seen like 28 Broadway shows with Andy Karl in it. I don't know about maybe there's more. I've seen him box, I've seen him box, I've seen him box. See, I repeated myself because if you know Andy Karl, then you know that he may have done. See, Broadway dad jokes. Forbidden Broadway, you have nothing on this show. I'll tell you that much. He's but he's never seen him on stage with a certain body part that eats other peas a first time forever. If you're an actor like Andy Karl, you never know what the next role's gonna be. We love him. He sings, he acts, he has the most amazing hair that I wish I had because mine's thinning away. Andy Karl, welcome.
[0:54] Andy Karl: Thank you so much, Robert. It's good to be here. Yes. I love I love how people try to talk about teeth because they have to be so careful. Um I was on a uh on a morning show and they were having trouble describing. So tell us about the show, because it's about a certain thing. I was like, yeah, I'm just like uh everybody get ready. Um, but I I think it's it's a it's a journey into uh into body parts, but also uh into ideology and uh insanity uh and hilarity. So it's a it's definitely a show unlike I've ever done before and role I've ever done before.
[1:30] Robert Bannon: Well, and you play a pastor and and and you I can say whatever I want on this show, technically, Andy. I mean it's about a ladies part, like Yeah, let's go for it. But I mean I it depends on, you know, I I'm gonna follow you down that path because uh it's your show. You say all the all the words for body parts you want. I'm pretty gay, so I have not had a man eating vagina. But you know, a vagina that eats people is unique, and there's a place for it on stage in New York City. Apparently it was at Playwrights Horizons and did very well there.
[2:04] Andy Karl: Obviously this is from the 2007 movie, horror film movie under the scene titled called Teeth, a cult classic. And it is uh it is uh it's such an interesting movie because I think it affects people differently. I certainly men and women at the end of the movie I was like God it's like that's horrifying and scary but also putting men and women in this uh like uh equal physical space like oh yeah you think you can do that well guess what I can do um that's what I sort of took away with it but also um just uh a great call out for like I don't the feminine uh being strong and powerful um and yeah I think that the musical also takes it up another level I mean it's it's really great I think Michael R. Jackson and Anna K Jacobs uh did some serious work on this.
[2:56] Andy Karl: We have banger songs but also they went there with uh what this show is about and what it means and certainly the end is very different than the movie but carries it to a further like ideology it's really great. Teeth the musical.com you can get your tickets October November and onward and it's gonna it's back I mean they sold this sucker out like they you couldn't get a ticket it was a hot ticket uh uh playwrights and now it's gonna be even be a hotter ticket your creative team I know you're about to open so Sarah Benson's the director Raja Feather Kelly if you know you know choreography has been choreography he did strange loop he he did lumpica, he's been doing a what's it like to work with this cast and this creative team to get this story told?
[3:35] Andy Karl: It's so great. Like I'll start with the cast first, because uh I I have worked with uh Elise Luis, who's playing the lead of Dawn once before, years and years and years and years ago, and it's so good to like reconnect with her. Um, and I'm going back into new world stages where I the last thing and first thing I ever performed there was Altar Boys. So it had a sort of religious undertone. Um and oh, there it is, you brought out the picks. Oh, he's got it all. Um and so uh it's great to return there, but also with this this cast, a lot of them young and and fresh and new. And it feels like like when I went there at New World Stages, that's what I was. I was sort of just making my bones in New York City, bone being the hilarious word. I want to put dad jokes on top. I'm just like you. I want to do dad jokes all day long at work, but it's it's a new world, so I gotta be careful.
[4:25] Andy Karl: Um, but it's watching this young cast be so talented and be so daring with all the stuff that they have to do with just horror film gore and body parts and and uh religious ideology and being funny and and and really like shooting through this this uh show. It's so fast. Uh, but they're very creative, they're very daring, and I'm so proud of this cast. They're they're going for it. Uh I really, I really enjoy them. So um that's one the cast that yeah, there's there's some standouts. There's like you know, Jared Lofton and uh Jason and uh Elise and I mean just those are the people that came from the original playwrights. Uh they're just so good. They're so good. I can't wait for people to see them. And come see me try and dare to do some creative stuff. I do a lot of different parts on this show, so it's it's fun. It's gonna be a lot of fun.
[5:18] Andy Karl: Um, I'll move on to the creative team. Sarah Benson is just like, she's always like, Well, let's try it today. Cause I'll throw out about four different things that are weird or you know, I think are funny, but they don't land, or or but she's always willing to try and she's always willing to experiment and what the stuff that's happening on stage with the fire and lakes and blood. I don't want to give away too much. Oh gosh, I just want people to see it because it's got it's it's insane. I'm so excited. Um, and uh Raja, who's just like so much fun, but he's they're always creative. He's always thinking about the lyric, he's always thinking about what story am I trying to tell. He's he's pushing the girls, uh the PKG girls, um, promise keeper girls, we call them in the show.
Um, and they also become something else. So he's like contorting their bodies and making it's it's so crazy and so creative and so beautiful. Um yeah, and Michael uh R. Jackson and Anna K. Jacobs. I mean, they're they're they're like I said in the beginning, they're pushing the boundaries, and I am excited to be a part of the show because not only is it like, you know, uh really interesting topic of material and and you know, talking about ideology and religion and and body, uh how people are affected by their bodies, but also how they're affected by repression and sex, but also comedy and insanity and blood, and yeah, I'm so excited. I can't wait for people to see it.
[6:46] Andy Karl: Uh if I didn't mention anybody else, uh I'm just uh I'm just too excited. It is the perfect time to see it because it's like Halloween and it's horror y, but it's but it's but it's deep and it's about what we're fighting the battle of the sexes in a lot of ways and the way women are and men are, and and when you throw in religion, you it's for everyone. You need to just take it. Yeah, I think it's, you know, religion, it's it's so strong, the spiritual idea, but uh what happens, just like what happens within between men and women in this uh play, uh also happens between ideology, between religion and what happens if you repress that, what beasts can arise from that, and how that's flipped.
[7:29] Andy Karl: Um, if you really look at it that way. And I think people people the interesting thing is it's a fun ride to the show. At the at the end, you have this. Um, I think people are gonna walk away with different things in their heads. He's either gonna, you know, whether you're a man or a woman, or just have a different way of perceiving things. You get to walk away where things are strongly suggested, but never like this is what the show is about. It's but it's mostly about, you know, what do you what do you think just happened? You're shocked and awed, and then you're uh given a certain amount of uh freedom to think about all the things that happen within the show. And and maybe you might be covered in blood. Uh at least the first row uh is a splash zone, and I think those sold out quick.
[8:16] Andy Karl: Yeah, sure. Yeah, so we've got it's it's pretty epic. I'm um like I said, I'm just super excited to be a part of it.
[8:23] Robert Bannon: Well, we gotta get your tickets. Everybody's gonna get their tickets, and while we're talking, you can of course follow Andy on Instagram at Andy underscore Carl, and you can go to Teethemusical.com, you could get your tickets, and it's being at play that's not a playwrights anymore. Being at New World Stages, being at New World, you can get a ticket that's affordable. It is cheaper than going up, you know, a block away. You can get a ticket and bring a date. It's great for a moment of Friday, Saturday night, or during the week, whatever you need to do, get a ticket. I saw it, you need to see it.
[8:49] Andy Karl: Oh, I can't wait. I did not get to see it.
[8:51] Robert Bannon: I was in Australia at the time.
[8:53] Andy Karl: You were in Australia.
[8:54] Andy Karl: I haven't even seen the show.
[8:55] Andy Karl: You've only been in it.
[8:56] Robert Bannon: He was in Australia, groundhogging his life away here. Um, which was one of the most epic Andy uh performances I've ever seen because I can't memorize the words to happy birthday. So how you knew where you were on stage, which iteration of the same day it was, I have no clue. Because if I had to start every scene with the same lines, I would just do the same scene over and over again.
[9:17] Andy Karl: Well, yeah, I mean that's it, but then you have to like you know go with a different intent each day. I probably had the easier job because each day that I had to relive, I was aware of. Whereas the people on stage with me, every actor had to replay the same day based on the exact same idea that they're coming in with, but then I'm responding differently, and they're like, What's wrong with him? So it was it's interesting, really great um practice in acting for everybody in that show. And the writing, the whole thing. But you know, when I was thinking about you, your career, I pulled some like we could go back to Legally Blonde, and we showed Ultimate and The Jersey Boys, and you and Nine to Five, and there's the queen of all things Dolly, or you in Wicked, or Edwin Drude, or Pretty Woman, and then the Tony Award nominations, like Rocky, which I talked about before, which I love so much, and 20th century with Kristen, and then Groundhog Date, like your career has come a long way from Aladdin dinner theater in Baltimore, Maryland.
[10:16] Andy Karl: Oh, yeah. Me, me cast as Aladdin. Wasn't that a good choice? Uh, I mean, so that so wouldn't pass these days. Uh, but I was just thrilled to be have it my first role. Um, that was actually my my mother made me audition for that show because um I'd gotten in trouble at school for smoking in the boys' room. I'd never done it before. I got caught and had by the vice principal after like my friend handed me a cigarette and I was the one holding it. I didn't even get to smoke it so like you know so uh yeah anyway I didn't anyway I got suspended for two weeks and my mother was furious so she's like audition for a musical why not it's like you sing you you you like to do this stuff um you take interest in it but uh that's where I found uh my family of theater my tribe of theater that you know is so uh so even to this day it means so much to me to be a part of this huge family and again with Teeth it's like walking into a room full of just super creative hilarious fun people who all want to do a tremendous show. I literally I keep thinking about it because we're it today's our first day of tech rehearsal.
[10:43] Robert Bannon: Oh, who's this? Who's your dog? Diamond, say hello.
[10:43] Andy Karl: Diamond, diamond, diamond, diamond. She's an attention I love it. I love it. I'm I'm all about the puppies. I’m actually walking uh my uh my neighbor's dog right now uh every every other day. Just just the best dogs, Birdie. But uh I am uh I'm just so excited to be on stage because uh just at New World Stages they have a couple of different shows that are gonna be there one I just saw last week uh Drag the Musical. The production value on Drag the Musical is freaking amazing. I was like this is a Broadway caliber show and we're in New World Stages which is obviously a cheaper ticket but I I commend them for doing that that amazing show it's so funny. It's so um it's so funny in a different way that ours is.
Our show Teeth is a little dark and it's a little like horror. And I think horror films are horror fans are going to be really um uh captivated by it. They're they're not gonna walk, they're gonna walk away with exactly what they wanted. It's not in your face, scary uh jump out of your seat horror. It's it's one that's like makes you think, but also makes you see some insane shit and laugh at it. Uh so I'm I again I I keep whenever I talk about it, I just get so excited to start it. But tech rehearsals are today.
[12:51] Robert Bannon: Oh, so what is it? What do you do to take care of your firstly? Your voice is so gorgeous, and we all are so grateful that you get you you stopped dinner theater and didn't become a music teacher and went on to be a Broadway star. We are all grateful for that because we love seeing you on stage. But when you have tech rehearsal, you know, the famous 12-hour days, the long nights, the the stop and the repeat and the go. How how for the people watching that are theater students, we have a lot of them watching. How do you take care of yourself when you get into the grind at eight shows a week?
[13:17] Andy Karl: Um, tech rehearsals are interesting because it makes you stop and start, and maybe you have to go back and sing a song like three or four times. So you really have to be aware of not pushing. Um you can really you can really do some uh a lot of hard work on your voice in those times. And so when it comes to actually doing the show, performing it, uh, you might be a little ragged. So um it's important obviously to hydrate. I learned that big lesson during Rocky and Groundhog Day because I was sweating so much in both of those shows that I would become dehydrated, and it affected my voice in a in tremendous ways. It made me very like have a lot of uh like a lot of uh mucus. So hydration is a big part of it, and doing those warmups every single day.
Vocal warm-ups, and I'm for me, also a physical warm-up. I just did some hot yoga this morning. Uh, I do it, you know, because it really just gets the body going, gets the blood going to all the parts of your body. Your voice is a muscle, your larynx is a muscle, uh, your tongue is a muscle. You need the blood to flow through, and you need hydration to keep that blood going. So um, yeah, it's just preparation is 90% of this business, it's keeping yourself in check. And your eyes, especially when you're in a show for eight shows a week and in tech rehearsals, your eye is always on the health and always on the health that you're you're using for your voice and your mental state and your physical state. It's uh you don't want to be hurt by the time you actually just have to start performing. So, you know, make sure you do all those practices that you need to and hydration. I don't know caffeine.
[15:00] Robert Bannon: Yes, I love on caffeine.
[15:01] Andy Karl: Yes, me too. I'm obsessed with it. And I'm gonna have a glass, a bottle of water just for you, Andy. After this, I'll just you. You your career is so fun because you can be on the road doing concerts, you can be doing uh Broadway and tele or or be in Australia doing Groundhog Day. But you know, every time I have someone on from a TV show, I ask them, you know, to get me some brownie points because my mother-in-law out in Detroit is obsessed, and and she has never been to New York, and the only reference she has to New York is SVU and Blue Bloods. So, Miss Lewis, how you watched him over and over again, didn't you? You you we know that everyone may see you and know this this Law and Order moment. So, what's it like doing television?
[15:41] Andy Karl: See, Miss Lewis, I told you I was gonna get the SVU cast here for you. Yes. What's it like? Yeah. What's it like when you do when you do TV or you go overseas and we're outside of Broadway? Is it is it a is it exciting? Is it nervous? Is it is it a refreshing break?
[15:59] Andy Karl: It's it's so exciting everywhere you go because I think the the more experience I get by I had gone to London and I had learned that you know theater is taken just as seriously. I mean I knew it was, but you don't know until you experience it. And it's and you meet all these tremendous actors who are just in love with this just as much as you are, and it makes the world a little smaller. Going to Australia, same thing happened. I show up on the first day rehearsal. I couldn't believe the talent and the love for theater is just as strong as Broadway. Broadway is this little you know uh place that everybody considers it to be the best, but it's just the industry is very strong here, but it's very strong.
There's a lot of passion in Melbourne, Australia, for the theater arts, and people are tremendously talented. I was I was blown away. Um, and certainly when you get to travel, it just opens up your mind to the idea that the world is is everybody wants uh similar things, and it also pushes you to find new ways and new ways of of working and and how to new ways of expressing yourself and seeing what people can do, but also what people can learn from you. Um and then showing up on something like Law and Order SVU, uh, I felt like that I did a crash course in television because I had never been on a series before, or at least not one that ran that long. I had like an episodic here and there, but to walk in and see my first scene is with Ice-T and Mariska Hargitay.
And I was like, my I'm trying not to freak out. Uh I'm just trying to act like a good actor. Uh, I was happy. My father was played by Peter Gallagher, who I worked on stage with right prior prior to uh getting a Law and Order. Um it's it's it's a wild, different schedule. You sit around for a long time, and then when you're it's time to go do your lines, that you're you gotta go. Whereas you go to the theater and for two and a half hours or you're on. Um, so it's a little bit of just management of energy and time. Um, all just tremendous experiences. I I value all of them highly everywhere I go. Uh off Broadway, Broadway, um Australia, London. Any I I filmed uh Jersey Boys, uh the uh live action film with Nick Jonas in um in Cleveland, Ohio, of all places.
Uh but it's you know, you can make theater anywhere. We found that out during COVID, right? Um, it's like we just turned our Zooms on and I started writing scripts and having people come on and read them. And um, you can you can make your theater anywhere, and you can have just as much passion in Cleveland, Ohio as you do on Broadway.
[18:48] Robert Bannon: Absolutely. Look, we even got the brick wall memo. So we could we could we could be creating that this is the set right now. We're somewhere right now, Andy.
[18:55] Andy Karl: Yeah, it's like some version of Rent we're doing.
[18:58] Robert Bannon: There you go. I guess I'm I'm Mark and you're Roger because you got the guitar over your shoulder, and I got the glass. Glory.
[19:06] Andy Karl: Yeah, I gotta wait for my voice up, by the way. I gotta warm up. Speaking of warming up. You gotta go. You've got to hydrate and you've got rehearsal. So we want everybody that's out here, make sure you check out Teeth. It's coming. We we love New World. We love this show. We love Michael, we love we love everybody that's a part of this. You gotta, you you have to see this. It's something like you've never seen before. Really do. I'm I'm I'm I want people to see it. I and I know they will because word of mouth is gonna be a tremendous about this show. I I I can't say enough about it. I know the people who are gonna come see it or can't say enough.
[19:34] Andy Karl: Yes, go get a raincoat and sit in the front row. Teethemusical.com is coming to you. Go to Andy underscore Karl if you want more information about what Andy's up to next. And we're always so happy to see you. You're a sweetheart. We we love you here. Thank you for being here, Andy.
[19:46] Andy Karl: Thank you so much, Robert. I really had a good time. Thank you. Break legs, let's go. Woo!
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
