Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep 489- Broadway Star Rachel Potter Celebrates Her New Album "Stages!"

Theater star and Nashville recording artist RACHEL POTTER – best known for appearances on Fox TV’s “The X Factor” and the Broadway musicals The Addams Family and Evita – has signed with the innovative new label Joy Machine Records for her upcoming album Stages... Read More

From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon

27 mins
5/5/25

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Theater star and Nashville recording artist RACHEL POTTER – best known for appearances on Fox TV’s “The X Factor” and the Broadway musicals The Addams Family and Evita – has signed with the innovative new label Joy Machine Records for her upcoming album Stages. The label will release her album in streaming and digital formats and on CD on Friday, May 16. Stages, produced by David Wise, is a curated collection of reimagined Broadway classics, showcasing Rachel’s roots in musical theater and her passion for reinterpreting these iconic songs with full symphonic arrangements. An exciting full throttle listening experience that feels both classic and contemporary, Stages embraces recent stage musicals whose songs aren’t often hard outside the context of the show.

Three singles from Stages have already been released: “Come What May / The I Love You Song,” a mashup from Moulin Rouge! and The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, featuring Omar Cardona and Marty Thomas; “Pulled,” which Rachel sang on Broadway in The Addams Family; and “My Days,” written by Ingrid Michaelson for the Broadway musical The Notebook.˜

RACHEL POTTER – the acclaimed Broadway star and accomplished Nashville Recording artist – has been recognized by US Weekly as “One to Watch” and praised by The Hollywood Reporter for her “crystalline vocals.” With a successful career in both musical theater and country music, Rachel has showcased her talent on stages of all sizes.

Rachel’s impressive resume includes her turn as the ever “popular” Glinda understudy on the National Tour of Wicked. Next, she made her Broadway debut as Wednesday Addams in The Addams Family, where she shared the stage with Bebe Neuwirth and Brooke Shields as Morticia. She then went on to originate the role of the Mistress in the Tony Award-nominated revival of Evita, alongside Ricky Martin and Michael Cerveris. Her standout performance on the Original Broadway Cast Recording of the production, singing the poignant song “Another Suitcase in Another Hall,” further solidified her place in the Broadway community.

Transitioning from Broadway to Nashville, Rachel pursued her passion for country music and achieved success as a Top 12 finalist on season three of Fox TV’s “The X Factor.” Her audition with her version of Queen’s "Somebody to Love" earned international praise, and continues to amass millions of views since the season aired. The song is featured on her solo album, Not So Black and White, which showcases her unique artistry, songwriting, and musical style. Her music videos have been featured on “CMT” and “Entertainment Tonight,” and she has garnered attention from publications such as Billboard, Rolling Stone, and Huff Post.

Rachel has been featured as a guest soloist with many symphony orchestras all over the world, including the Dallas Symphony, St. Louis Symphony, Utah Symphony, among many others. She and fellow country artist, Patrick Thomas, have been celebrating the past icons of country music in their pops symphony show, “Country Legends,” for the past 10 years.

Stay connected with Rachel on social media @therachelpotter.

____________________________________________________________________

Check out "The Roundtable with Robert Bannon" here on BPN on the daily, on YouTube, Broadway World, and on social media! Like, comment, share, & subscribe!

For more info on Robert- www.RobertBannon.com

Follow Him on IG- @RobertMBannon

TikTok-@RobertMBannon

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:14] Robert Bannon: Welcome to the round table, everybody. My name is Robert Bannon. You're listening to some Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network. And you know, I love singers. I really love singers so much. And our next guest can sing. Like she sings like Broadway, and she sings like country, and she sings on TV, and she sings on stage. And I don't know if she knows this, but she has worked with Ricky Martin. Which, you know, as a little gay boy, that is quite the holy grail. That is something. So we're gonna talk about right. She has a brand new album, and it's gorgeous. I secretly heard the album. And it's gorgeous. And she's got like 186 Broadway superstars singing with, I mean, literally, everyone on Broadway is on Rachel Potter's album. And she's here to tell us all about it. Rachel is here making her round table round table. That's a tongue twister. Roundable round table debut. Rachel Potter, welcome.

[1:09] Rachel Potter: Hi. Hello, hello, yeah.

[1:11] Robert Bannon: 186 Broadway stars. Easy. So many Broadway stars. Easily 186. I am excited for you because A, you signed a record deal. B, you have an album full length, a full album. C, you have an incredible team that's behind this album that you work with, and it's gorgeous. I'm so excited. I'm so excited to talk to you about it. Um, I also love the team. Joy Machine Records is so cool, and their vision is so cool, and um how they are supporting the new um this wave of musical theater artists that want to make records like I did. Like, I just love them. They're so awesome. But you're and I love it because like you are like na like you're one of those Broadway slash Nashville slash I'm a rock star but I'm also a Broadway diva like you sing it all.

[1:56] Rachel Potter: Well, thank you. I have always tried to be a chameleon of sorts, but you know, isn't that like what we're supposed to be I guess for Broadway style stuff so that we can become the different roles that we're supposed to play? But and when I think of you, Rachel Potter, I think of you like you're not from Nashville or you're not from New York City. You're from St. Petersburg, Florida.

[2:32] Rachel Potter: That's right, the home of Wiki Wockey, the little mermaids that swim in.

[2:34] Robert Bannon: And I love so your journey to was Broadway the first dream? Was recording music the first? Like what was the dream when you were little?

[2:32] Rachel Potter: Um, you know, I uh funny enough I always dreamed of being a recording artist. Um, I used to design my album covers when I was like a little kid um and I was obsessed with country music funny enough growing up and I look back on it now and I think it was really because of the storytelling and I just wasn't exposed to musical theater but country music especially in the 90s like come on 90s country music was it and you know I used to sit in my room and like watch CMT all day and I love those music videos. And then I started writing songs when I was like 12 ish um but at that time the only thing I had to be inspired by was religion which um that's a conversation for another day. So um but you know, so I did like this Christian album.

Please don't go listen to it. It's embarrassing, but um, I did that when I was in my teens. Please never listen to it, please. If you ever see it, like just for my sake, please pass right on by. But um then uh then I went, you know, I moved over to Orlando and I was going to college and I was working at the mall, and someone was like, You should go audition for Disney World. And little Miss Christian recording artist went over there and had no idea what I was doing. My resume read, like, I work at the gap, and my job duties are folding clothes and working in the cash register. And don't worry, I put my typewriter speed on there because I Googled what a resume was supposed to look like. Like I was a completely green little naive dummy.

And somehow those casting directors didn't laugh me out of the room and they gave me a callback for the little mermaid. And so um I got my equity card, and I didn't even know what it was. Like I was a little baby angel, like fresh out of high school, like just going to college, and I got got my equity card and started working as Ariel in the Voyage of the Little Mermaid show at Hollywood Studios. And I absolutely fell in love with the theater community with all things musical theater, and I was like, oh my god, what what why didn't I know about this world? Like I, you know, I did show choir in high school, like I didn't do theater, and um, so I was so grateful that I was now exposed to this world and and these people, and um so I really didn't know how to act, and I was uh I just started putting myself into acting classes, and I'll never forget I went to a Disney audition and this I can't even remember the name of the casting director, but he was a Disney character casting director who also worked for like Terra Rubin, I think at the time.

[5:30] Robert Bannon: Okay.

[5:30] Rachel Potter: And he was like, Rachel, you can't act. But if you want to make it on Broadway, you can do it, but you gotta go figure out how to act and then come back. And I was like, okay, I will. And so I went and put myself through acting classes in school while I was also going to college and working full-time. And then when I graduated, I moved on up to New York City. And um, you know, the rest is not history. It was very hard for many years, but eventually the work paid off.

[6:02] Robert Bannon: It was. You're one of those people that just booked that first gig.

[6:06] Rachel Potter: But see, what I love about it is like that you booked. But no, I didn't. But you booked Disney, but then when you like the work didn't stop with one. People think like, if I just get one, no, the work is continuous. You're still working as an artist. You always will work as an artist. And now you're back, you've merged all the worlds because now your Broadway diva slash country diva slash recording artist slash Disney princess now puts together and comes together in one big giant beautiful project called Stages. So after you came here, so everyone streamed the album, the album uh is gonna be available for everybody May 16th, and you will be available wherever music is heard. So you gotta be ready to stream it.

[6:45] Rachel Potter: After you came to New York and you started to book, like when we found like wicked tour photos of you, and I was joking about Christine Dwyer. Look at Christine Dwyer.

[6:58] Robert Bannon: No, she was my first and last alphabet.

[7:01] Rachel Potter: And yes, there's Ricky Martin. And you want to know something crazy, he still DMs me on Instagram, and I always just want to be like, guys, it's Ricky Martin! Like, but I would be. I love them. He he's an amazing person. And oh God, what a time to be alive. And Roger Reese, may he rest in peace. What an amazing man. There's Brad Oscar as Fester. Come on. Who's amazing? Who's the funniest, sweetest human being? So, and then you know, people know you from this stuff too. From yeah, from the X Factor.

[7:38] Robert Bannon: So when you put together a recording album, how do you pick the material? Because you have your own Broadway music. You have music that you grew up listening to and love. You have pop music. So, what was the impetus behind Stages? What is the album uh about?

[7:54] Rachel Potter: So, this was the theme behind it, if you will, was that I wanted to capture like the most important stages of my life, as well as all the stages that I've actually gotten to perform on, and so that double meaning there, and so I really just wanted to honor all those different really important moments. Um, with you know, Disneyland and Part of Your World where I got my start, you know. I couldn't those and those people were that show that I worked in, those people were are my foundation in this industry, and I you know, I hope that they know how much that they still mean to me. I learned so much when I was there, and then obviously pulled from the Addams Family, my Broadway debut. I did for good with Christine, who actually was my first and very last alphabet when I played Glenda.

Um, and then you know, everything in between, there's uh there's a Matilda Medley, which incorporates my son, which is really special. Um, the waitress Medley, I've always connected so strongly to that music. Number one, because Sarah Bareilles is literally my favorite artist and has been since 2007. Um, but also because it captures, I think, what so many of us and what I truly felt, uh, becoming a mother and not recognizing myself and then falling in love with my baby and everything changes and like accepting that I am different now, and um that journey is obviously hugely pivotal for me. I have three children, so that has been uh a giant transition in my life and my identity. Um, and this has also been about me reclaiming my identity, you know, and and finding my voice again after feeling like I was buried under the confines and the weight of motherhood, motherhood and working full-time and you know, and how hard all of that is.

[9:45] Robert Bannon: Sure.

[9:45] Rachel Potter: Um, but to to make space and make time for the thing that makes me me and the thing that I love, and um I pay tribute to my time in Nashville and and with my band um in a an arrangement of House of the Rising Sun that I used to do with my my country band here, and um I lost my brother a few years ago, sadly. Um, and so there's a song dedicated to him. Uh so you know, it's just it it's definitely like every song has a very, very important meaning, and I won't bore you with the every single one, but um, you know, it's it's all just it's all very, very personal.

[10:23] Robert Bannon: It's your story, it's your stages. I love the double meaning. I love it's it's very clever and and it makes perfect sense. And while we're talking, though Rachel Potter on Instagram, and you can go to rachelpottermusic.com if you want more information and albums out and all the things we'll be we'll be sharing and tagging, but you got to follow along so you can be up to date on all the things that's to come. I I love the album because you have some of the greatest musical theater songs of all time and some of the greatest composers. And when when I look at the work that you're you're doing on this, like you you start that it's like a little Andrew Lippa, obviously Adams family party, and then you take like Alan Menken and Howard Ashman and and Marvin Hamlisch, and that's a whole like you have, you know, uh Ingrid Michaelson and Tim and Shit, like you have the best of the best writers on here. So they all have a personal meaning. Did you have fun making them your own and and playing around with how you were gonna put them out on the album?

[11:14] Rachel Potter: Yes, for sure. And um, I think one of the the most fun uh mashups that I well, I mean I I don't know, I can't really pick all of them were so so great, but the most fun that I think is the come what may I love you song mashup.

[11:29] Robert Bannon: Okay.

[11:30] Rachel Potter: Um I am obsessed with the I love you song from Spelling Bee. And I saw that that composer actually just recently passed away, which is crazy. It's so incredible, like what a prolific writer. And um, I've always been so obsessed with that song. So it was you know, building the track listing and uh and I had that on the list, but I was like, you know, out of context, this doesn't it doesn't really work to do it in its entirety, but the thing that we all love about that song is the bridge, right? Yes, and then I'm working on uh trying to piece where all my incredibly talented friends are gonna slot in this. And I was like, Okay, well, I've got Marty and I've got Omar, and I can't really pick who should I do come what may with.

And I was like, Yeah, I love you song could work in the bridge. It's so weird, but I think it could work. And then I can make this a trio and like make this a love triangle, or you know, but the deeper meaning for that is just that we will always love each other and always be there for each other. We're all you know, friends of 20 years. So um, yeah, that was super cool. And then the I was uh when I put together part of your world that goes into Disneyland you know both are sung by Jody Benson and so and obviously like both are Disney themed and I was like someone must have done this before and then I looked it up and I was like oh no one's ever done this before okay cool um this feels like it's not a unique idea but it turned out that it was and um the the mashup of Le Miz was something I wrote years ago and I've been sitting on um I did like a really kind of bad you know poorly executed version of it and I thought about putting it out and then I brought it to my producer probably five years ago when we started talking about this project um and he was like hold it just wait I think that we should you know make that special and ultimately that turned into the lame is mashup I did with Miss Natalie Weiss who's so good so good yeah on my own and I dreamed a dream is what we're talking about which is uh on the album and you talk about Natalie Weiss and you talk about uh Marty Thomas and Omar Cardona that are on the the other like all of the guests so tell me about your guests I mean there's a lot of a lot of Broadway and TV and uh superstars out here singing so who do you have on this album?

[13:41] Rachel Potter: All 138 of them, 138, get ready, hold your breath, I'm gonna list them all. Um, so Ali Stroker, who is a really good friend, I was actually on the road with her husband, David Perlowe. He was my Fiaro on the Wicked tour. So when he got together with Ali, she and I were just really fast friends, and um, we've really been there for each other through like motherhood and all of that, and all of those challenges, and I treasure her friendship so much.

[14:09] And I have always been so in love with "Some Things Are Meant to Be" from Little Women, like such a good song. And so I wanted to sing it, and I called her up. She was the first person actually I called when I decided to do this, and just to see if she'd be interested. I was like, "Do you happen to like 'Some Things Are Meant to Be'?" She's like, "Oh my god, it's one of my favorite songs." And I was like, "Oh, perfect. Okay, which part do you normally sing?" And she's like, "Um, Beth." And I was like, "Great, this is perfect. Okay, wonderful." And so I was like, "Would you want to do it?" And um, then Jason Howland wrote that, and I happened to know him from back in the day. And I wrote to him, I was like, "We're gonna do this. Is this okay?" And he's like, "Yeah, great, amazing." So, you know, that was really neat.

[14:53] And then "Life of the Party" is like a full call to my very first early days in New York City when I would go sing it, like the after party and the duplex of like all the open mic nights back in the day, like that was my go-to song. Um, you know, so "Maybe This Time" is like so special too for that reason, but anyway, I digress. Let me get back to the collaborators.

[15:22] So then there is Voctiv. Um, Vocdive may not be super well known to the musical theater world, but in the recording world, they are very well known and they are tremendous. And the lead and the arranger and the producer is my best friend since I was nine months old. His name's Jamie Ray, and um, his group has just really taken off. Octave is incredible if you haven't heard them. Um, they're not an a cappella group, sort of a la, like you know, a version of Voices of Liberty at Disney World, but more contemporary. Um, and so they are guesting with me on the Matilda Medley, which was something I dreamed up with a friend in Atlanta, and we put it together for like this little kids' show, and I was like, "Oh wait, this could be really cool if we like fully flesh this out and do this with Octave." And then my son is on that, which is cool. Um, so he's, we got a little kid moment.

[16:18] Um, then we have obviously Christine Dwyer, Natalie Weiss, whom I mentioned, who um, Natalie and I met in the early days of me being in New York City, and we were both like doing, you know, these concerts at Joe's Pub for upcoming writers or whatnot. Um, that's how we met. And so I've just known her and loved her for years, and she's obviously like, her voice is crazy. So um, picking someone who could really do that justice and us really be able to do something special, like she was a really easy choice, and I'm really glad she said yes.

[16:54] Um, and then I did the Waitress medley, and I, you know, I was like, I need to put together just like a Broadway ensemble. And it just so happens that I just have a lot of friends that are really good. So uh, the Broadway ensemble is Marty Thomas again and Omar Cardona, Matt DeAngelis, Brandon Calm, and Christine Dwyer, who all were in Waitress at one point. Our couple in there, yeah, right. Uh-huh. And uh, then I've got Brandon, uh, I'm sorry, and then Marissa Rosen. Yep. Um, who is a dear friend of mine since a long, long time ago, who just made her splashy Broadway debut in Waterfall Elephants. Yes, she did. Um, and then a dear friend named Jennifer Thigpin, who sings in Broadway Inspirational Voices. So just like a powerhouse of vocalists on that as features.

[17:42] Um, and then um, I mentioned that I lost my brother, and there's a song on there called "He Was Mine." So there's a duo here in Nashville that I'm good friends with called The Young Fables, their country duo. And the lead singer, Laurel, she had lost her sister in a car accident, and she wrote this song called "She Was Mine." And when I lost my brother in '21, I remember hearing the song and crying my ever-loving eyes out. And then when I decided to do the album, I gave her a call and was like, "Would you be okay with me doing this song? And could I change the words to 'He Was Mine'? And would you sing with me on it?" And we're gonna do it like, you know, because it was originally this very stripped-down country song, and so instead what we did was fully flesh it out, like as if it was in a Broadway play, you know, and like how would this sound if it was in a Broadway musical and I'm just like in a spotlight, you know, singing this song.

[18:44] Um, so that one is probably the most meaningful and the most special on the album for me. Um, he actually played Peter Pan at Disney World a long time ago, and that's what a lot of people knew him for. Um, and so there's a few little like references to Peter Pan in there, and so that one's um, that one and "House of the Rising Sun" are the two songs that are not Broadway. Um, let's see, did I miss any collaborations? I was going through the list with you, and I don't know, Animazement? An Amazement Trio? Yes, Jamie and EJ, go ahead.

[19:19] Yes, so Animasement Trio. Everybody pretty much knows of this song at this point. This arrangement is so, uh, it's like a cult favorite from this show called Animasement that was at Disneyland in the '90s, and Eden Espinoza was in that show as Pocahontas. Um, singing, which by singing, singing, singing. Um, Ian and I actually met for the first time, if you can believe it, um, last summer, and I told her I was doing this, and she gave me her blessing, so that's the good news. Um, and uh, I actually, I still need to reach out to her. I was gonna get her to do a little video of her saying, like, "I mean Espinoza and I approve this message." That's so funny. She will do it. I still need to get her to do that.

[20:09] Um, but anyway, so we had just randomly, you know, in like 12 years ago, Jamie somehow got his hands on like a karaoke track of this song, and we just like recorded it in his house and like went and recorded like a really bad video for it. [20:22] Um, it's all shaky and like bad. And so, uh, but it ended up being one of my best performing videos on YouTube, and people loved it. And I mean, I was in a gay bar like about a year ago, and some boy that was like 22 years old comes up to me, like, "Oh my god, your Animazement Trio changed my life." And I'm like, "You know about the Animazement Trio? Like what?" So still people will talk to me about the Animazement Trio. So it was, uh, really, uh, I really was excited to redo it and do it right, and like we had like a completely new orchestration written, full orchestra played on it, like it's entirely ours, and um, I mean, yeah, people love the Animazement Trio, Matrio.

[21:06] And what's not to love? It's such a good arrangement. That the whole album is such a good arrangement, it's just really, really beautiful, and it is so good, and you heard everybody. Like these songs are songs you know, songs you'll discover. It is a fun album to listen to from beginning. You don't need to just listen to a single or just one track. Like it's a journey, and it will give you all the joys and feels from the beginning to end. And it's so beautifully placed. The songs are each placed. So listen to the whole thing from top to bottom, and you'll find something you're gonna love for sure.

[21:33] I read that you, um, was like a dream, and you said that earlier about signing a record deal, and when you signed it, what's it mean to have a full eight-length album coming out this year with a label with some of your friends with songs that mean so much to you? And now this baby that you've been working on all these years is gonna be out in the world for everyone to enjoy. But, you know, just like when you're about to give birth to an actual physical baby, you don't feel ready then either. But at some point, it's just gotta come out.

[22:06] It's coming out. Coming out. Um, so it feels um surreal, I guess, in a way, uh, because it's so meaningful, and I feel really grateful that um that Joy Machine signed me to this record label. Like it's so ironic that I have been in Nashville pursuing a record deal since 2013. And ultimately, I think what I came to realize is like, okay, I think I've actually been kind of putting on a front to be a country singer, like that it's not truly who I ever was.

[22:49] Like it was something that I could do, but like deep in my soul, I am a Broadway artist. Like, that's just that is my home. That is my heart. I love telling stories. I love standing up for what's right. I love being loud about my opinions. And so being in the Nashville recording arts country music scene just never felt like home. Because I never felt like I could truly be who I am. Um, and not to mention, like this technique and this style, I have been working on this my whole life. Like, this has been what I've dedicated myself to.

[23:32] So isn't it silly that I had never had a Broadway album? That I only had these like country albums out? Um, so I wanted to honor that journey of mastering or at least trying to master that craft all these years, and also honor the craft that I love so very dearly, you know, and that I'm hoping that this album will, you know, inspire other artists to, you know, just feel like they can take up space in this world, and that just because you're a theater artist doesn't mean you can't also record an album, and you are worthy of that, and you are like, and I can't tell you how many times I've had to talk myself off the ledge of like, "Who the do you think you are that you are special enough to do an album? Who's gonna want to listen to this? Why do you think that you should do this? You're not good enough to do this." Like, these are the thoughts. I mean, for the, and it's so hard to overcome that and to believe in yourself, especially for a project of this weight.

[24:37] But I just decided, you know what? YOLO, yeah, like F it as you go do it, and you did it. I did it. So yeah, I'm really, I'm so nervous about how it's going to be received. And I'm, I can't wait to hear what people think of it. Um, but I am just, I just feel a lot of joy that it's worked out this way. And I'm, um, the irony of finally getting signed to a record deal when after all these years, I finally just decided to be true to my authentic self, and that that's the thing that finally got the attention of a label. You know, like wow.

[25:17] If I had just could have told myself that 10 years ago. 10 years ago. That's the lesson for all of us. And there's a lesson for everybody when you listen to this, just be you, sing your songs, and put out your art. And um, I'm sure, Rachel, you're gonna hear from so many people who are gonna love it. It's gonna blow your mind because it's gorgeous, and people need to stream it. Uh, May 16th, May 16th, "Stages" is coming everywhere you listen to music. No matter where you listen to music, you better get it, download it, share it, tell a friend. Uh, and you're gonna love it for the Broadway babies, for the singer singers out here, for the country babe, anyone who's loving music, this is for you.

[25:54] And we could follow you and stay up to date with you on Instagram and check out your website for all the things that are to come. I hope you come back when you're on the road, when you have live shows, when you're gonna do the whole album somewhere. We need the full story, so come on, dad, please.

[26:10] We're probably going to do the album release. Um, right now, the working date is August 11th in New York City. Well, we want to talk about it. So when you're ready to talk about it, please come back and be our friend.

[26:22] Okay, I will anytime. Thank you so much. Congratulations, break legs, on this new baby. Let it out, it's coming out. Woohoo!

[26:31] Baby number four.

[26:32] Oh god.

[26:34] This one might have been the most expensive one.

[26:37] Probably is.

[26:38] Thank you so much. Congrats.

[26:40] Thank you.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred