Ebony and Pamela have Joe McDonnell join their podcast this week to gossip about the very early stages of Urinetown: The Musical, as well as some scandalous happenings later on in it's run!.. Read More
From the show: Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast by Ebony Vines and Pamela Shandrow
Featured Shows
About
Ebony and Pamela have Joe McDonnell join their podcast this week to gossip about the very early stages of Urinetown: The Musical, as well as some scandalous happenings later on in it's run!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Ebony Vines: Welcome to Theatre Geeks Anonymous, the podcast about Broadway flops, scandals, and new work.
[0:08] Pamela Shandrow: I'm your host, Pamela Shandrow.
[0:10] Ebony Vines: And I'm your host, Ebony Vines.
[0:13] Pamela Shandrow: Don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe to the Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast on the Broadway Podcast Network and all your favorite podcast listening apps.
[0:23] Ebony Vines: Thank you.
[0:26] Pamela Shandrow: I just hit record, because that was, yeah, I love it.
[0:30] Ebony Vines: That's funny.
[0:32] Pamela Shandrow: Ebony and I.
[0:34] Ebony Vines: You should.
[0:35] Pamela Shandrow: Well, Ebony and I, and maybe this will lead into you repeating that, but Ebony and I started this podcast because of our mutual love for musical theater.
[0:44] Ebony Vines: And so we were wanting to tell the stories of um scandals and flops on Broadway and also new works that were coming up.
[0:52] Pamela Shandrow: But we, since the pandemic, have kind of turned our attention more to the inclusivity or lack of within theater, and also obviously the marginalization of bodies and colors and genders and all of those kinds of things.
[1:09] Ebony Vines: So a lot of that crosses over, and my dad and I have had some conversations about that as well.
[1:15] Pamela Shandrow: I'm definitely the guy to come to for flops and maybe some scandals.
[1:20] Ebony Vines: Well, we're gonna talk about a scandal today.
[1:24] Pamela Shandrow: All right.
[1:27] Ebony Vines: Well, so first of all, we have to get this out of the way.
[1:30] Pamela Shandrow: Are you ready?
[1:30] Ebony Vines: Close your ears.
[1:31] Pamela Shandrow: Welcome!
[1:33] Ebony Vines: What's up, theater geeks?
[1:35] Pamela Shandrow: What is up?
[1:36] Ebony Vines: We are so excited about this episode today, because we've got a very special guest.
[1:41] Pamela Shandrow: Um, someone that actually my father, Don Shandro, if anyone was interested in knowing that, uh, had put us in contact with Joe McDonnell.
[1:50] Pamela Shandrow: Oh shoot.
[1:52] Ebony Vines: McDonnell.
[1:52] Pamela Shandrow: I'm so sorry.
[1:54] Ebony Vines: I know.
[1:54] Pamela Shandrow: Uh but no, we're gonna we're gonna keep it in because that's important.
[1:58] Ebony Vines: Because that was my mistake, and I apologize.
[2:00] Pamela Shandrow: McDonnell, Joe McDonnell.
[2:01] Ebony Vines: Well, it'll keep my enemies at bay anyhow.
[2:05] Pamela Shandrow: There you go.
[2:07] Ebony Vines: Joe, the reason I knew about you is because you are intrinsically tied to one of my favorite shows on Broadway, Urinetown.
[2:17] Pamela Shandrow: And that's kind of the reason we're gonna pick your brain today, but I'm sure that a lot of other things are gonna come up within this conversation that our audience and also Ebony and myself are very excited to hear.
[2:28] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, yeah. I so I never got to see it on Broadway. I've actually never seen a production of Urinetown, except I did see a bootleg version last night.
[2:40] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, which one did you see?
[2:43] Joe McDonnell: It was the Broadway version. I saw the Broadway uh bootleg Broadway last night because I was like, I need to have some context for like these songs.
[2:51] Joe McDonnell: And unfortunately, a lot of the comedy was kind of cut out because of the shoddy camera work.
[2:57] Pamela Shandrow: Um and the directing.
[3:02] Joe McDonnell: And if you've seen the Broadway bootleg, you've kind of seen all three.
[3:06] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[3:07] Joe McDonnell: Oh, okay. This is yeah, this is gonna be the the kind of fun story. So, first of all, tell us how you were involved in Urinetown from the beginning.
[3:16] Joe McDonnell: Okay, from the very beginning. Well, I was born, no. Um, so in 1997, I um had both my first Broadway show and got into my uh previous long-term relationship with the one that I'm in now.
[3:32] Joe McDonnell: And the person that I was in the relationship with, a guy named Jay was an improviser from a group in New York known as Burn Manhattan, who was a very well-respected long-form improv group.
[3:44] Joe McDonnell: So at the end of my Broadway show, which was a bit of a flop, it was called Candeed, and it only ran about four months. Although I really loved being in it, and I have to tell you, there were so many great talented people in that show, of course, including the amazing Andrea Martin, who you'll never see. And I adore her as a person.
[4:06] Joe McDonnell: But anyhow, I digress. And he was calling Jay because he wanted Jay, my partner at the time, to come to uh meet with him and the composer, Mark Holman, and uh try out some songs that they had written for this new musical that they were doing.
[4:41] Joe McDonnell: And as I was talking to him, I happened to say, Well, you know, I just got out of a Broadway show. Um, yeah, I I can sing, I wouldn't, I'd be happy to come down and you know, do something for you because I love new shows and all this kind of stuff.
[4:52] Joe McDonnell: So he was like, Oh, thanks a lot. And but, you know, never said another word to me about it.
[4:58] Joe McDonnell: Okay. So then flashed to the next uh later in the year, I guess it was. I can't tell you that this is a long time ago.
[5:08] Joe McDonnell: Yeah. Um so later in the year, they decided they were going to do a recording of the show, I think was first.
[5:18] Joe McDonnell: Okay. And when, and they decided that so so Jay was playing um the sort of uh narrating character who is the officer.
[5:31] Joe McDonnell: The yes, the yes, the cop. I think that's Officer Lockstock.
[5:36] Pamela Shandrow: Correct.
[5:36] Joe McDonnell: Lockstock, yes. Officer Lockstock.
[5:38] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[5:38] Joe McDonnell: So I suppose your listeners have will have some familiarity with this.
[5:42] Pamela Shandrow: Probably a little bit.
[5:43] Joe McDonnell: Okay. So he was playing Officer Lockstock. So they asked me to do the voice of a called Caldwell because I happen to have a large sort of baritoney-based voice.
[5:55] Joe McDonnell: Um belied by my rather thin, slight frame and generally youthful looks. Um and at this time, you know, this is 25 years ago, so I was 33 years old.
[6:06] Joe McDonnell: And so I did the recording along with um some uh several other people, and it was fun. We had a great time, and that was great.
[6:15] Joe McDonnell: Then they said, Oh, we want to do a reading of the show. And um I said, okay. And so we met to start to do this reading.
[6:25] Joe McDonnell: And in the process of doing the reading, it became very clear to me. Now, mind you, although I'd only had my first Broadway show, I had been in three national tours off Broadway.
[6:35] Joe McDonnell: I had spent years doing all those things you do in the theater world, you know, staged readings and all that kind of stuff.
[6:43] Joe McDonnell: And uh, you just need to know that it in the 70s and 80s, you could do a staged reading that was literally like people sitting at a table reading and singing and get a producer.
[6:54] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.
[6:55] Joe McDonnell: But by the late 90s, you had to stage that sucker, or nobody was going to be interested in you. Somewhere along the way, they lost their imagination.
[7:05] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, yeah.
[7:06] Joe McDonnell: I mean, completely and utterly. So you have to, I said to them, you know, you need to prepare this like you're doing it for the blind.
[7:13] Joe McDonnell: Like it has to just pop so much. And then you have to say, we just threw it together this afternoon, although you've been rehearsing, but you know, that's how you play the game.
[7:22] Joe McDonnell: So they were having us with music stands sitting in chairs in like a half like a straight line, even, you know. And I if you in high school theater, they teach you no straight lines, you know.
[7:35] Joe McDonnell: So I um said I I stood up to do my song and I one of my songs, and I just was like, you know what, I gotta move.
[7:46] Joe McDonnell: So I began to perform the song the way that I would with a little bit of choreography off the top of my head and that kind of thing.
[7:51] Joe McDonnell: Um, I had a background in choreography and and those sorts of things, and I had a theater degree and that kind of stuff.
[7:58] Joe McDonnell: So I said to them, Look, you you can't do this. You have to stage this show.
[8:01] Joe McDonnell: And so what happened is I just said, I have a couple of ideas, you know, and then I began to stage the reading so that they would get some kind of interest.
[8:14] Pamela Shandrow: Like they're on the fly in the middle of the...
[8:14] Joe McDonnell: Well, yeah. I mean, because it's amazing.
[8:19] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[8:20] Joe McDonnell: Well, thank you. I'm I don't know if it's amazing because it's the only way I've ever worked.
[8:25] Joe McDonnell: And let me explain this. As a director, I don't believe that I decide anything, I don't make things up.
[8:32] Joe McDonnell: What I do is I get together in a room with a bunch of really talented people, and I set them free, and I wait for the universe to yell at me.
[8:41] Joe McDonnell: And whatever it yells, I do.
[8:44] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.
[8:44] Joe McDonnell: Yeah. That's how it works for me.
[8:46] Joe McDonnell: So there is no such thing. I mean, I it's not that I can't prepare, of course. I do research and everything, but it still requires talented people and the universe yelling to get anything done.
[8:55] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[8:56] Joe McDonnell: So in this particular situation, I had talented people all around me, and the universe began to yell.
[9:03] Joe McDonnell: So I just followed it. And it was very, very cursory because we didn't have a lot of time.
[9:08] Joe McDonnell: It was like one rehearsal, and we were going to go. So the only person that really danced was me because I could dance off the top of my head, you know.
[9:17] Joe McDonnell: Um, for like don't don't kill the bunny, that's okay. So um, anyhow, I knew I was wrong for that role.
[9:28] Joe McDonnell: So after we finished the reading, I said to them, Look, uh, it's gonna be like 20 years before I'm gonna look anywhere near old enough to play this role.
[9:36] Joe McDonnell: And really, even then, I don't think I'll physically be right because I just think there's a these are archetypes, is how I really saw it.
[9:43] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.
[9:43] Joe McDonnell: I said, But if you ever wanted someone who could direct it and choreograph it, I'm your guy.
[9:49] Joe McDonnell: So then flash forward to uh 1998, the uh fringe festival, the New York Fringe Festival, which was at that point only two years old.
[9:59] Joe McDonnell: And they said, uh, we want to do this at the New York Fringe Festival. And I said, and they we want you to direct it.
[10:07] Joe McDonnell: And I was like, okay, so at that point, the show had eight characters and wasn't complete.
[10:15] Joe McDonnell: So um I said to them, okay, here's the thing. I've done some calculations, and by my mind, the smallest group you can have on a Broadway stage, but the largest that you can have on an off-Broadway stage, is about 14 people, anything less, and you, I mean, not that you can't have one man shows on Broadway.
[10:37] Joe McDonnell: There it's been done, or even a couple people's shows, but when you're talking about a traditional musical, and really, Urinetown, for anything I might say about it, was crafted in the formula of a traditional American musical.
[10:49] Joe McDonnell: They understood. It's like a Book of Mormon is the same way. They understood and they followed it to the letter.
[10:55] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[10:56] Joe McDonnell: So at that point, there was no end to Act One.
[11:02] Joe McDonnell: There was um They didn't have the Act One finale.
[11:05] Pamela Shandrow: That's my favorite.
[11:06] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, that wasn't done yet. Awesome.
[11:08] Joe McDonnell: Um Run Freedom Run was a solo sung only by Bobby.
[11:14] Pamela Shandrow: Oh my god.
[11:15] Joe McDonnell: There was there was no uh chorus to speak of, um, except for like a little bit of like background um stuff.
[11:27] Joe McDonnell: Um the the very ending was already in there, but that was all just just the the food, the ooze and ahs, like a couple of things.
[11:36] Joe McDonnell: So you didn't have any of like the featured character roles, you didn't have Bobby's mother, you didn't have super or oh yeah.
[11:44] Joe McDonnell: Uh yes, we had Bobby's mother, so we had Bobby Hope, Cladwell, Penny Pennywise, Little Sally, Lockstock, Bobby's mother, and Bobby's mother and and one other person like doubled to be what's his name? Hot Blades Harry.
[12:05] Pamela Shandrow: Hot Blades Harry.
[12:08] Joe McDonnell: Like there were a couple people that really like covered all the other things.
[12:12] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, like two people, okay?
[12:13] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[12:14] Joe McDonnell: Which wasn't going to work for a real stage musical.
[12:17] Joe McDonnell: So I said to them, I need you to write more characters. I want, and I just gave some suggestions like I think you should split these into two, and I think you need to do like this.
[12:25] Joe McDonnell: This is how many guys I need and girls I need, and this kind of stuff that I need.
[12:29] Joe McDonnell: Um then they said to me, so they they worked, they went back and they worked on it.
[12:36] Joe McDonnell: And they came back and they said, Well, we're getting there. We've got um uh think of tomorrow, Mr. Strong, and all that stuff written, but we don't know what else to do to finish it.
[12:47] Joe McDonnell: And I said, Well, what's the opposite of think of tomorrow, Mr. Strong? And they were like, I don't know.
[12:52] Joe McDonnell: And I said, What about today? You know, it was obvious to me.
[12:58] Joe McDonnell: Obviously, it was the universe yelling. Once again, it wasn't that I was brilliant, it's that everything's out there, you know.
[13:04] Joe McDonnell: It if it just it it will it will come to you if you're I guess in the right position or something.
[13:10] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, so and listening.
[13:12] Joe McDonnell: So that anyhow, then we went to casting it, and um, they knew already at that point that they wanted, so you also need to know this. They knew they wanted Jay, and I knew I wanted Jay because Jay was brilliant. Yeah, um, they knew that they I didn't at that point know Spencer Caden, even though we went to the same college, but she was years after me, and she was the substitute improviser in my partner's group.
[13:39] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, amazing.
[13:40] Joe McDonnell: Okay, so I didn't know her, but I heard she was brilliant, and I believed them. So they knew they wanted her. And then I got, I basically cast the rest of the show, and I knew that I had wanted this woman, Louise Um Rosette, who had been one of the ensemble. Um she actually hadn't been Pope, she'd been like our ensemble woman in the in the recording and the reading, but she was so wonderfully talented and she was so intelligent that I was like, I need her. I I just felt it. Yeah. Um because I understood I felt I understood what these archetypes were supposed to be so my hope was gonna be a a woman that might look pretty but she's really an intellectual right I mean heavy duty intellectual yeah and my Bobby was gonna be in uh a strapping Iowa bred you know white boy corn fed as tall as I could get him broad shoulders and you know just you know an aweshocks kind of a guy and my caldwell cladwell was gonna be Jackie Gleason he was gonna be a fat cat you know boss in the every and my whole idea of the show was that it was in I said to them you know it's this show is really like a 30s archetypal musical so um I wanted on a proscenium stage and I had this very clear vision and I and I went Penny Pennywise I said for them you know she needs to be um kind of a cross between um I don't know if you remember there were these actresses um I think her name was Margaret Whitehead she was in like movies in the 30s and she um she she was a soprano and she was matronly and but she well but they were always flirting with her and she was and it was like she thought she was a young girl on the inside but she was majoring the outside okay and that and I and and like Brunhilde like a like a like a soaring uh I I literally said I I want at points to to imagine that she has horns on her head.
[15:49] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[15:49] Joe McDonnell: Um, and so I had I had very clear visions, and and people, so, but of course, it was the fringe festival. And they said to me, Well, we didn't get a proscenium, we got this garage. Like literally a garage on the lower east side that has a cement, like floor that's raised 12 inches off the main floor, and then this the seating that is that goes up in front of you, and it doesn't really have wings. In fact, it's because it's a garage, it has that cement thing that goes all above your head all the way around three sides with a railing. Yeah. You know, and you know, and and they've they've they've rigged it, and then off to the left, you the other half of the garage is kind of where we're gonna make dressing rooms and this other thing, and there's no air conditioning, it's the middle of summer.
Uh-huh. And and there's gonna be five shows a day in there, and you're gonna come on, you're gonna have like a half an hour turnover between shows. Oh, wow. And so, and and your budget is $500. Yeah. That's in me and make it work. Yeah, no, uh uh. The 500 hasn't changed. And so I held auditions, and I didn't get anybody really that was old enough to be in this show. Like, you know, I got the young, young, wonderful people, but I didn't care. And I got one guy, so this guy that showed up to do Caldwell Cloudwell was somebody that I graduated college with that that also was in the improv world and people knew. And so I cast him. I cast this woman who was 24 years old or something to play Penny Pennywise, but she was like five foot eleven, and she was well shaped, like she had a figure, you know.
Yeah, yeah. Um, and then I got this guy that was literally this Wilson, who was totally corn fed, and all these other young people, and Spencer Caden, who was absolutely a genius in everything that she did. And we got together and started rehearsing in this church basement, and all I said to them was look, I need you to empty out your tool chest. I believe every performer has a has a you know a toolbox of what all of their skills. And I need you to bring me every single skill that you have and throw it at me. I don't care what it is, don't be afraid, just be brilliant. I because I said every single person in the show has to have a fully formed story from beginning to end. You come from someplace and you're going someplace.
So we're gonna figure this out. And so when we did the opening of the show, I everybody had to have an activity. They had to have a job to do in their life, and they just happened to be passing through the center of town by the by the bathroom, the outhouse, singing, you know, um the urine town song. Okay, so um, then I also had them very carefully choreographed to open up to get there right when we were gonna be able to get in the theater to open up all the garage doors, and I had fans that everyone brought, and we blew all the hot air we could out of the building because I need the you know audience to be comfortable. And in in the rehearsal process, we were doing Run Freedom Run, and I was like, this is just not working for me.
So I said to the composer, can I just try something? And he said, sure. And I said, all of you organize yourselves like you're in a choir. And I said to this one girl who had a voice like a bell, I said, I just want you to sing, run freedom run, and hold the note, just hold the pitch. And she, you know, had that she had one of those voices, you know, run freedom run. It was just like right on the pitch. Yeah. And then I said, I'm going to conduct you, do whatever I tell you. And I literally just conducted them and would cut them off and whatever. And after about, you know, 15, 20 minutes of this, the composer goes, I totally see where you're going. I got it. Great, fabulous. He goes home, he writes it, and it's just beautiful what he did.
One of my favorite parts of that, like, I just loved it so much. That just what that was just something that the universe yelled at me, and I was like, Yeah, uh, okay, whatever you say, you know, and just did it. And they were all looking at me like I was nuts. But that's it's the same thing with when we were doing the end of act one, and I said to them, okay, here's what you're gonna do. Hope and Bobby, you're gonna grab onto each other, and then you're gonna grab onto him, and you're gonna re people, you're gonna take you're gonna take sides. And I said, like, um, and I told him the story of my child. So this is so dumb, but my parents were divorced, and my family didn't get along. And one of the stories from my child when I was like two, was that it was my father's birthday.
This is before my parents broke up, and my brother was maybe four and a half, and my father was a drinker, and he always came home late, and they were waiting for him to like have some sort of birthday thing, and he came in the door or something, and they wanted the kids to stay up, and she was like, This it's 8:30, it's past these small children's bedtime. And she said, It literally came to members of both of our families grabbing onto the two of you and pulling you back and forth. Oh my gosh. And so I said, This is the image that I have for this. Yeah, so I said, and it needs to all, and I said, and I had this idea, because you know, oh, by the way, Spencer Caden wanted to be on roller skates, and I said, You could be on roller skates in the show because that was from her toolkit.
So I was like, sure, little Sally can be on roller skates. So I said, It's this is gonna be, you're gonna start to pull on each other, and then you're gonna start to turn in one movement. It's gonna be like the ice capades. And Spencer's gonna be like that person. And do you know the thing I'm talking about? The ice capades where they go around in a circle and there's one that can't catch up to the outside. That's what we're doing. And they looked at me like, what are you talking about? But in fact, we did it, and it was absolutely brilliant. And every time we did it, the timing came out perfect. And I was like, I don't even know how this is working, you know. And it was always like that. The customer said, What do you want?
And I said, Well, I need Penny Pennywise to look like when the world ended, like the post-apocalyptic thing ended, that she was the madam of a whorehouse, but she went straight to a job in the toilet. So I want her, so she wore like a boustier and bloomers, and then she had a house coat, and I gave her a plunger to hold in her hand, like you know, like an opera singer, and she had like a hair net on her head. That was my image for that, and that and that was how everything went. When they they brought me the fabric for Spencer, she had all these different fabrics, and then she had this fabric that had all kinds of little dogs on it. And I was like, that's the fabric. She has to make an outfit out of the little fabric with the little dogs on it, you know.
So this is what happened with the show. So we did the show in this crazy thing, and it it with by the time we were opening, people were coming to me saying, All the other shows are talking about. I heard over at my rehearsal, how great your show is. Oh, and I was like, really? That's wonderful. And the next thing we knew, we were the biggest hit of the uh of the entire um season. They asked, they did something they'd never done. They asked us to stay over for two weeks. Wow. And we had agreed the three of us that any money we made, we would split Mark and Greg and I. And then when we decided to hold the show over, I said, look, we can't take any more money. We need to split this money between the actors.
They've already put in all this effort. This is not right. And that's in fact what we did. Awesome. So the show is held over for two weeks. It's a huge hit. Nobody can believe it. They're like, uh-huh. But there's a contract that says if you take this show from the fringe, you have to pay a fee to the fringe with for the if you take it within two years. Oh, okay. So if you do anything, anything anywhere or just Broadway? Anything anywhere. Okay. At least in New York, I think. So off Broadway too. So, oh, by the way, I didn't tell you this. When I said to them that I could figured it was 14 people, they looked me in the eye and they said to me, Well, we don't want it to go to Broadway. And I said, Don't ever say that out loud again.
No! No, what are you bringing into the fringe fest for then? Well, the only way they wanted to go to Off Broadway. And I, and you know, understand there are originally when they did um uh little shop little Little Shop, it only played off Broadway. That's right, that's right. So it wasn't a heard of thing in the 70s and 80s for a show to be off Broadway, but by the 90s, I said to them, you'll never all of these producers follow one another. You're never gonna get a producer unless you say this is a Broadway show. I don't care if it's only gonna go to Off Broadway, you have to tell them it's a Broadway show. Right, which is why it was the 14 people and everything. So indeed, there was an enormous amount of talk.
And um what happened next was that producers came in, and one of the really well known producers from Broadway was a woman named RL Tepper, who I haven't anything nice to say about. But she um, yeah, she was a witch, but she came and she said, I I I wouldn't produce this show. But these two other jokers came, um, whose names I've actually forgotten, who were not real theater producers. They had done other stuff. Okay, you know, other kinds, I don't know if they did like uh, you know, World Federation Wrestling or I don't know, but they were producers of something other than what we would know of as theater. And they came in and they decided that they wanted the show, and very quickly they met with Mark and Greg, and their lawyers they said, we don't want Joe, we want um a bigger name director, someone with more experience.
So they didn't have experience, so their experience was to just bring someone in with more experience that just had a name attached. Right. And remember, every Broadway show now is about who you got. And then the first question asked how many followers do you have on Twitter. So this was already the beginning of that kind of thing. I mean, I remember I was so shocked when I went in. I believe it was I can't remember the the number of producers we had in Candeed was just like Garth Drabinsky from Canada was the big producer, but there were like other producers already. By the time I did my second Broadway show in 2004, which was called Jumpers, there were 40 producers. 40. Wow. Wow. So this was already headed that direction. So they decided they didn't want me, and they their lawyer said to them, you must not engage him. You must never speak to him again. You must not tell him anything.
[26:21] Joe McDonnell: You must not. I mean, it was so literally Mark and Greg never spoke to me again. I did have one interaction with Mark. Mark was very, very kind. Um, but they wanted to be successful and they didn't care. Now, just a funny little side story. It does it right after this, that the next year, or this was the same summer, I guess. I directed another show that went off Broadway that I got dumped from, and they went and got a different director. Bunch of pissers. That show never made it to Broadway. But um, but yeah, it that wasn't an uncommon thing to have happen. And I would have been happy to assist and direct, but they were like, no, he won't know his place, you know, whatever. And I didn't know what was actually going to happen, which so here's another little wrinkle to this.
Okay. It is illegal to film shows in New York equity shows, except for a small little piece for promotion. Right. Okay. But I said to them, we need to have something to give these actors when they finish this work. So I had them record the entire production to give to the actors. Okay. Okay. So it's not a great video, but it's a video that you can see. So they the producers don't want to pay the fringe. So they say, we won't produce this for a year or two years, whatever it was, I think it was two, um, until that uh contract elapses. Okay. And that so it kind of goes. You guys sound like just upstanding gentlemen right now.
[27:56] Pamela Shandrow: Don't they sound wonderful?
[27:57] Joe McDonnell: Yes. It only gets holy mackerel. Oh goodness. So now, you know, I directed and choreographed that entire production. Yeah. So then they go and they do the off-Broadway show. Um, another super interesting irony. There was a woman that I was in Candide with who I was a swing in Candide, and so was she, and a really talented woman. And I said to her when I was casting the first the fringe, I think you should be in this show. You'd be fantastic. And she's like, I'm not interested. Flashed a couple years later, she was in the off Broadway production, and indeed the Broadway production. So that was um her name is Rachel uh Roger Koloff, yes. Okay, so talented, so amazing. If you're out there, God bless you.
Um, anyhow, it when they did the off Broadway production, they did invite me to come to the preview performance or whatever. And I went with a couple of people that I knew from the um my production. Let me ask you at this point in time, nothing suspicious had happened at this point. You had just kind of been let go. So when you went to go see this production, were you just going because you thought you were gonna see a great show with people that you still knew? And that you did you had had a part of the.
[29:15] Joe McDonnell: Okay. Oh, okay. They rejected everybody else. Okay, okay. Um, and I was suspicious because they didn't put in the theater, they went and they got this place that was an off Broadway space that they then like I didn't want the garage to begin with, but they redid this space to look like the garage that I didn't want to begin with. And I was like, what? So already I was like, that's so weird because this show actually would be much better in a nice little proscenium little box because it's real traditional theater. And all I remember really was that was the shock, and I remember that when the lights came up after Act One, the people around me looked at me and they said I was ashen because I was watching my blocking, my choreography, my creativity, put on people that I wouldn't have cast, not because they're not talented, but because they actually aren't really the best for the role.
So Penny Pennywise, when I did the show, I could not belt like Nancy. Okay. But she had a head voice. And so I and I said, and it it's it's better for the song, right? Um if if I can horribly offend your ears and the ears of all of your listeners, please. There's there's something to be said for someone who who sings the politicians in their wisdom saw. Because what it does is it conjures up that mature operatic woman. Yes. Rather than the Nancy is, and she does it brilliantly. Yeah. Okay. So um, but also I wanted to come the idea for me was that you don't want to look at Cladwell and Pennywise and imagine them having any kind of romance. Right. You don't want to suspect them as being attractive.
What you want to see is old, overweight, kind of not attractive people who then when they look at each other, see the young, attractive person that they were. And then when they start to flirt, it makes you uncomfortable because nobody wants to watch old people get busy. That's funny, right?
[31:35] Joe McDonnell: Yeah. When we were doing the show, um, the one thing that Jay and Spencer had that was was so extraordinary was that Spencer chose to make uh her character so brilliantly smarter than every other person on the planet, and Jay chose to make his character um very, very emotionally not aware of himself and very puffed up. And so when Sally sits, I had I purposely had Sally sit on his knee, and Spencer chose to sort of come onto him, and it was brilliantly funny, and Jay was so uncomfortable, and it was so funny. Red Codis, who had a daughter at the time, got really mad, was like, she can't do that. And I was like, Why not? Because she's a child. I said, She's not a child, she's an adult child. An adult playing a child, yes, the character's a child, but this show's ridiculous.
And they're not gonna actually get it on. She's just so smart, she's so preternaturally um mature, and it's post-apocalyptic, so she's seen a lot of crap, so she you know knows how to play the game. Well, he just hated it, but it Spencer was brilliant. So then I'm watching the show, and I see this guy who's got the bombastic part, but he's got none of the charm of Jay, and he's got none of the he and Spencer have no chemistry. I mean, Jay and Spencer loved each other, and there was so much love on the stage, it was just it was palpable. Yeah, and then I watched my Bobby, like I said, he didn't have the voice that um Hunter Hunter Hunter has, but he was tall and broad and and blonde and and and open faced, and when he uh so you felt like when hope was in his arms, you felt like she was tiny and um. And um and I had them put hope into like this really traditional flower dress, but then I had to cut it really low and push her boobs up so that she had unintentional cleavage.
[33:40] Joe McDonnell: Yeah. And she was supposed to be utterly unaware of. Yeah. But everybody else was like, holy guy, you know what I mean? Yeah. And she wasn't chesty, but it just it was effective. And so I saw this very pretty girl who played a very simple ingenue that wasn't especially anything. Yeah. And I was like, no, she needs to be the smartest person on earth, and she needs to be a woman who is so independent and so intelligent that you wouldn't expect her to fall in love and be willing to follow a guy. You know, I just so I I wanted these archetypes, and I got none of them. But I sure did get all of my work. I mean, they did the whole act end of act one thing with the them spinning around. The only thing they changed was that they lifted Bobby and Hope up over the people's heads, which was okay, but it wasn't more effective, in my opinion.
And it obviously took a lot more rehearsal. And by the way, I went backstage afterwards and I talked to my friends who were in the cast, and they were the most miserable people I'd ever seen because their experience was horrendous.
[34:40] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, that's such an awful way.
[34:42] Joe McDonnell: Because it's such a great show. Yeah, it's such a fun like as an actor, I want to be able to come to work and like love the show and love the people and love the experience. Yes, but that's awful to just and my cast had such a good time, and they were so proud of themselves, and they work in a place that was 90 degrees, and you know, it was it so these people were in an Eric Nisha place off Broadway making good money. And they were miserable. And I understood why, because you know, the the people they were working with didn't have their own talent. They were stealing mine.
[35:12] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.
[35:13] Joe McDonnell: And if you probably didn't have any kind of creative say in their characters at all, if it was kind of just taken from one video to the stage. Well, obviously John Cullum did because he completely changed. He's brilliant. I mean I will honestly say that I love John Cullum in that role. I don't know what the front what your guy that you had cast was, but John Cullum is brilliant.
[35:36] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, he totally made it his own and he's brilliant.
[35:39] Joe McDonnell: But he actually is a man that you can look at and say, I could see how he was handsome when he was. He's actually still handsome now.
[35:46] Pamela Shandrow: Oh yeah, completely.
[35:47] Joe McDonnell: And that to me sort of it tips the hand a little. You know, I think I think Nancy's fantastic, but she was she was slim and she was wearing work clothes and uh uh pants, and it was like this is not you're missing the archetypes of the 30s here that just that make the show to me it's just the more fun. Because remember, I mean the show ends with them yelling, hail malthus. It's it's it is a reference that's so obscure nobody would know what it is.
[36:18] Pamela Shandrow: I had to look it up.
[36:19] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, of course. I really didn't know. You know, um there's so much about the show that is a it is referential to something before that it doesn't oh the other thing, oh by the way, this is another example of like just life doing what remember the the song um oh what the hell is the song? It's uh sorry, so long ago. It's the song where where they're in the dark uh with flashlights.
[36:44] Pamela Shandrow: Oh uh the cop song.
[36:46] Joe McDonnell: Isn't it just called Cops?
[36:47] Pamela Shandrow: No, it's not that one, it's oh shoot. I thought it was the one where they end up at the end of the song doing bing bang, a bing, boom. That one.
[36:58] Joe McDonnell: Uh maybe.
[37:00] Pamela Shandrow: It's a snuff fat girl.
[37:02] Joe McDonnell: Uh or maybe it is the cop song.
[37:05] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, because snuff that girl's not in in flashlights.
[37:08] Joe McDonnell: I thought it was the cop song.
[37:10] Pamela Shandrow: Maybe it is the same. What do you mean what do you call it?
[37:12] Joe McDonnell: What do you call the cops? I mean it's called It's literally called Cop Song. Um, where they're ta uh where they're talking about all the different people that they've arrested that have gone to Urine Town. Because there's there was a time like they had just flashlights.
[37:26] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[37:27] Joe McDonnell: I need you to read what's the what's the opening song of act two?
[37:31] Pamela Shandrow: Uh do you have it?
[37:33] Joe McDonnell: Uh what is your in town?
[37:35] Pamela Shandrow: No, go after that.
[37:37] Joe McDonnell: Snuff that girl.
[37:39] Pamela Shandrow: It must be wait, after Snuff That Girl.
[37:41] Joe McDonnell: Run Freedom Run.
[37:43] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, okay.
[37:43] Joe McDonnell: So it must be Snuff That Girl.
[37:45] Pamela Shandrow: Well But that wasn't with flashlight.
[37:47] Joe McDonnell: Well, it wasn't on the Broadway one. Maybe it was so that this is the funny thing. So I decided I want when they're hiding out, they're like hiding out from right with an It got the girl, right?
[37:59] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[37:59] Joe McDonnell: And I wanted them to be underneath this place in the back of the stage where I was working, and there was no lighting, and I could not get the lights to focus in there. Because remember, I only got to light it in about two hours.
[38:12] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, okay.
[38:12] Joe McDonnell: Right. You know, I literally just and and and it was and the the lighting person was doing a bunch of shows and had watched my show, but but wasn't able to uh fully grasp what I needed. Sure. So I literally said to the lighting person, I want you to show me every single light you have and tell me what number it is. And it was like one through eighteen. And I memorized the numbers and I said, okay, act one, scene one, you're gonna do this lumber, this number, this number, this one at 50, this one at this, and I literally just talked about the whole show. He was like, Holy balls. I was like, hey, when you gotta do it, you gotta do it, right? You know? And so I could not get lights underneath this place on the stage, and I really wanted to do it there, and so I just said, Okay, we're gonna use flashlights.
And once again, they were like, We're gonna what? And I said, just give them flashlights, turn the flashlight on your face when it's your time to sing. And it was really funny because all you ever saw was one person at a time in a flashlight singing.
[39:11] Pamela Shandrow: Well, they do that in another in uh 42nd Street, right?
[39:15] Joe McDonnell: Do they they there is a scene in the train cars? Each car is has its own light, and it only turns on on a certain person solo.
[39:24] Pamela Shandrow: Well, what do you know?
[39:25] Joe McDonnell: So, in other words, the universe, and or I stole it from somewhere else that I was unaware of. Yeah, anyhow.
[39:31] Joe McDonnell: The thing is that I, um, it ended up being really funny too because the idea of them hiding in the dark like all the time was just stupid, and that was really like what we were going with. So, you know, here I am watching every idea that I came up with out of necessity, yeah, right? Not because I'm brilliant, because I was, I had very little time and no money, and, um, I mean, literally, the sets were painted by my friends. I had my friends paint two backdrops, wow, and that's all we had to work with. Yeah, you know, the costumes were pulled together. Well, you know how that goes. So, um, I did the hair for like some of the girls myself, like it was just, it was, you know, nuts. So, um, anyhow, that was a very painful experience. Of course, followed by eventually them doing it on Broadway, and, uh, and then winning Tonys for it.
[40:30] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[40:31] Joe McDonnell: And if you remember, Greg and Mark mentioned the cast from the, um, the Fringe Festival, but they didn't thank me. I remember them making specific acknowledgment of the Fringe Festival in that speech. And the game. But I didn't actually know your part of the story until much, much later. It was very, very hurtful.
[40:51] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[40:52] Joe McDonnell: And but you know what? I said to my, and then remember, this is one of two shows that I've directed that has gone on without me. Um, and so I'm like, well, I guess I'm learning my lesson the hard way. And at that point, I'm not thinking that, you know, uh, by this point now, the off-Broadway was 2001, I believe. The Broadway it was 2002.
[41:10] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.
[41:13] Joe McDonnell: Is that right?
[41:14] Pamela Shandrow: I think so.
[41:15] Joe McDonnell: Okay. So I've sort of let this all go. And then 2004, I'm doing, I'm performing at a Broadway show again. So I've let it all slide.
[41:27] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[41:28] Joe McDonnell: Um, so until out of the blue, I get this phone call from someone I've never met before, whose name is Tom Mullins, and he has directed the Chicago production of Urinetown, and he's being sued by the talentless rotten producers villains. No, the director and so, oh, here's the other thing I have to tell you, sorry. A little background. Once the show goes to Broadway, the director, the choreographer who don't have much of a stake in this, decide they want more percentage points, and they want them to come from Greg and Mark. And Greg and Mark are like, no, they're not coming from us. You're not taking our money. Of course, the producers aren't gonna give away anything.
[42:14] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[42:15] Joe McDonnell: So it becomes a whole thing about their creativity. And I think they may have. Even though it was your creativity.
[42:24] Pamela Shandrow: Well, exactly.
[42:25] Joe McDonnell: But so that had been some sort of issue at the time. And they were still looking to make some money off of the show. So there was a production in Ohio, like Cleveland or something like that. Which was so Hunter's wife was the dance captain. Jennifer, who I adore.
[42:40] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[42:40] Joe McDonnell: Was the dance captain off-Broadway and on Broadway, I think. I would imagine that that would be the case. And so she ended up directing the production in Cleveland.
[42:59] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[43:00] Joe McDonnell: I think it was Cleveland. I may be getting this wrong. I think because that's where she's from.
[43:03] Pamela Shandrow: So I think that you are correct.
[43:05] Joe McDonnell: Or at least where she went to college. So I haven't thought about this in a lot of years. So I apologize to everybody out there. You know, the scariest thing about this is that you, if you're me, you say to yourself, am I gonna tell the truth or am I gonna just be making up stories? Because they say that human beings, uh, their memories, when they're, their memories actually change what the truth is for them over time. So I'm doing the best I can, and I'm a rather, I try to be an honest person. But anyhow, this is how I remember it. So he calls me and he says that they're being sued by John, what's his name?
[43:39] Pamela Shandrow: Black names.
[43:41] Joe McDonnell: Yes, it's, it's, there's two Johns, John something and John Carafa, with director choreographer. Do you have that list up?
[43:48] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, give me a second.
[43:51] Joe McDonnell: We want to mention that we want to mention the villain's names.
[43:53] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, absolutely.
[43:55] Joe McDonnell: We gotta publish them on the carpet. Uh, yeah. Um, John Rando.
[43:59] Pamela Shandrow: John Rando.
[44:00] Joe McDonnell: What?
[44:00] Pamela Shandrow: And John Carafa.
[44:02] Joe McDonnell: And John Carafa. So John Rando is the director.
[44:05] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, yes, director.
[44:07] Joe McDonnell: And by the way, I don't, I think Carafa like only worked once after all this because he was so awful. People hated him so much. He and he was abusive to his performance. He was like drummed out of the next one. And I think that he had something to do with the next episode that we'll be recording, in which I'm doing it. So I think that I just did a lot of research on John Carafa. Anyhow, I've been told he's just an awful person. But we'll leave that go. He did Good Vibrations.
[44:34] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, is that where he was?
[44:35] Joe McDonnell: Okay, that's the one that I just did. So we just did an, uh, yeah, an episode on Good Vibrations where his name came up. Anyhow, of course, I've got no good feelings for these two because they had, they were really dishonorable towards me. And in what wasn't necessary because I wouldn't have sued them or stopped them from, uh, doing the show. I probably would have helped them to steal my, well, I didn't, yes, I didn't do anything. So I was like, well, okay, I'll help any way you want, because I said, well, what do you want me to do? And they said, we want you to tell people what happened. And I said, well, of course I'll tell people what happened. It's the truth. So, like, what's the difference? And then he said, I have a copy of your performance, the off-Broadway and the Broadway of videos of all.
[45:18] Pamela Shandrow: So they can.
[45:20] Joe McDonnell: Yes. Yes, and by the way, there still is a video on YouTube that has all three shows side by side so you can see all the stolen stuff.
[45:31] Pamela Shandrow: Amazing.
[45:31] Joe McDonnell: I didn't know. I kept looking and I couldn't, I didn't find that.
[45:34] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, I have to look for that.
[45:35] Joe McDonnell: I'm not sure where to find at this point, but it is there. And because I, you know, my heart stopped. Because of course, in my mind, it was like they stole my work, they stole my work, they stole my work. And then when I saw it in black and white, I was like, holy cow. You can't deny it.
[45:50] Pamela Shandrow: You can't, well, you can because they continue to.
[45:53] Joe McDonnell: So that's when I also got to meet Jen and talk to them and all that kind of stuff. And she explained to me how they literally used the video to teach people to do the show when they brought in new cast members. And I was like, ouch. That's, I mean, that's horrifying the cast watched the video and putting the show together. I was like, you know what's really hurtful about this whole thing though, too, is that I think that there is a union rule about that now that you're not allowed to teach someone in a union show from a video.
[46:27] Pamela Shandrow: I mean, that's, there was a union rule about that back then.
[46:30] Joe McDonnell: I'm sure there was, you know, they're unscrupulous and they're not clearly not talented enough. Because here's the thing I believe that what Nancy and John Cullum and Hunter did was to show you that you could reinvent these characters and it would still work. Yeah, if you believe in the piece and you have enough talent and creativity. Yeah, the notion that you had to steal what I did, because what I did wasn't the only way you could do the show.
[46:57] Pamela Shandrow: Sure, yeah.
[46:57] Joe McDonnell: I might argue that I think it's the best way, but I would think that, wouldn't I?
[47:03] Pamela Shandrow: You would have to argue that they felt that it was the best way too, because they stole it.
[47:09] Joe McDonnell: Thank you very much.
[47:10] Pamela Shandrow: You're welcome.
[47:11] Joe McDonnell: So anyhow, um, so that's where I got involved, and I did interviews, and they said it, they got people questioned them, and they said things like we've never heard of this guy. I mean, just it was unbelievable that they tried to erase me from existence, and it's like, come on, there's no way you never heard of this guy.
[47:30] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[47:31] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, you know, but they just, their whole thing was that they were told by the lawyers, don't ever mention his name, don't admit to knowing he exists, don't admit to there being a show at the Fringe Festival. And that's what they did.
[47:41] Pamela Shandrow: Goodness sake.
[47:42] Joe McDonnell: I don't think they won those court cases against the people in Cleveland and Chicago, did they?
[47:47] Pamela Shandrow: I don't really know.
[47:48] Joe McDonnell: I sure don't see, I sure don't see anything that they won. And I'm still Facebook friends with Tom Mullen, so I'm sure I could find out.
[47:58] Pamela Shandrow: I would love to get an update on this.
[48:00] Joe McDonnell: The thing is, and where I came into the story, because I was living in Chicago starting in 2003. I auditioned for that production at the Mercury Theater.
[48:09] Pamela Shandrow: Oh.
[48:09] Joe McDonnell: I made it to the callbacks, but didn't make it any further because apparently your choreography is just too hard for me.
[48:15] Pamela Shandrow: I'm sorry.
[48:17] Joe McDonnell: It's okay. But there are also, it's, Chicago is a very small community of people. So if you're all, if you're just new to the scene, you're not really probably gonna get cast for a long while, right?
[48:28] Pamela Shandrow: And that was a good thing.
[48:29] Joe McDonnell: Oh, it is so insular. I mean, I'm from Chicago. I got my equity card in Chicago at, um, Drury Lane Oakbrook.
[48:37] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, I've done a show there, and it's a great city, and it's great and incredibly talented people, but you are absolutely right. It's very difficult to get in if you're not in yet.
[48:48] Ebony Vines: Yes.
[48:48] Joe McDonnell: Um, so I did that, and you know, I was very excited I knew some people in the cast, so I was very excited to go and see it, and then all of a sudden there was just a little bit of hubbub here and there about how maybe the show is getting cancelled, and maybe they're, you know, saying, well, they can't rehearse anymore, or they can't do the show anymore, or maybe someone's getting sued, and like it was like, wait, what is going on? So there was this huge amount of scandal already involved in it, and I was like, wow, like, ooh, okay.
[49:15] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, it's crazy.
[49:16] Joe McDonnell: I don't know what to tell you about that because I once, honestly, I don't know what happens after that because all I did was do what they asked me to do to try to help them out.
[49:26] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[49:27] Joe McDonnell: And then I left it behind because once again it was the, oh, the one other thing that happened is I did finally contact a lawyer myself, but by this time it had to be, gosh, 2007, eight, nine, time, uh, seven, something like that. And oh, the lawyer said to me, I'm really sorry, but you just missed the statute of limitations. And I was like, I'm gonna be so mad because I had these videos and I could have used them, you know.
[49:57] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, so went well, but in the end, it doesn't really matter because that's the funny thing about life is that, um, it actually, even when you're in theater, it feels like that theater's your whole life, but later on in life, sometimes you find out when you're not in theater, the theater is, there's that life is bigger than theater.
[50:16] Ebony Vines: Yep, yep, yep.
[50:18] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, so I still love the show and everything, and I, and God, it's a great show, so fun. And by the way, if I can be really snarky one more second, of course. A couple years, you know, I always say that Greg and Mark should bless the day they met me because they didn't know what they had. I'm the person, I mean, I had to talk Greg into understanding his show the way I understood it.
[50:41] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[50:41] Joe McDonnell: Uh, especially Greg. Mark was very easy to work with. He was, he was willing to change anything. He did not have an ego about his stuff. But a couple years later, they tried to do another show. What was that show?
[50:51] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, do you remember that?
[50:52] Joe McDonnell: I can't remember the number. Because it, once again, I can't, I can't remember, but all I remember is saying to myself, they're number one, they're trying to do something as outrageous as Urinetown because, you know, Urinetown, I tried to get him to change the title. I said you cannot put the word urine in the title of a show. It's a great idea that's funny. I said, but change it to like Y-E-R-N Town and then it'll still sound like urine, which is also on the, if you, the poster is it? Yes, that's on the poster.
[50:54] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, well, you know what can I tell you? It's like, uh, I well, I see something called, uh, with Greg Pig Farm.
[50:54] Joe McDonnell: Pig Farm, that's what it made.
[50:54] Pamela Shandrow: Are they animals?
[50:54] Joe McDonnell: I think they, I thought they were like something else. I think that they were animals. I thought they were like, I don't know.
[50:54] Pamela Shandrow: Well, it's called Pig Farm, but that doesn't mean it's actually anything.
[50:54] Joe McDonnell: I actually think that they're like, like creatures that live on pigs or something. I don't know who knows. We could, you could, does it dot tell you the description of the show?
[50:54] Pamela Shandrow: Not there, let me look up.
[50:54] Joe McDonnell: Okay, yeah, your job is to Google your brains out, lady. The title, uh, I was working, I was still in Bloomington, Illinois at the time that it was on Broadway, and I remember that a couple of people that I knew through the community theater scene were going to New York for a visit, and they were gonna go see some shows, and they said, well, the show that we're most excited about is this show called Urinetown. And I went, wait, Urinetown? And they go, no, no, Urinetown. And I literally was like, whoa. Why is this? And the thing is, what's funny about it is that so other people have tried to capitalize on this really original brilliance.
[52:41] Joe McDonnell: I mean, I would actually argue that, uh, what's the hell town or whatever.
[52:46] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[52:46] Joe McDonnell: Oh, oh, uh, is it Yellow Town?
[52:48] Pamela Shandrow: Hades Town.
[52:49] Joe McDonnell: Hades Town. Is an attempt to try to capitalize on that kind of topic matter that is, you know, um, scandalous or, you know. And any when I saw that they were doing the pig farm thing, I just thought they're never gonna put it together because they don't even see their own brilliance as it is. Yeah, you know, they think that Urinetown works for a different reason than it works. So, and indeed, Pig Farm didn't go anywhere. So I mean, this one looks like it actually is about pig farming. The plot centers around pig farmer Tom and his wife Tina, whose troubled marriage is near the breaking point. She desperately wants a baby while he's more concerned with the imminent arrival of an environmental protection agency inspector.
[53:36] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, well, there you go.
[53:37] Joe McDonnell: So I'm wrong. It's actually about pig farming, and there are people in it. Well, if the EPA is coming, there might be something involving parasites or biological is not great.
[53:49] Joe McDonnell: Well, of course. I mean, here's the thing. So the thing about Urinetown is that it's about everything but urine. It's about, um, society and relationships and about, um, uh, uh, environmental, um, friendliness and conservation. That's what makes it wonderful. Yeah, yeah. You know, and it had that wonderful surprise, which is when the good guys win and they take over the world, they end up using up all the water and they're fucked. So I love that. I mean, it's so brilliantly told. And I'm with you as far as like the archetypes being there and the reason it's so successful and why it's so hilariously funny is because you are putting these completely ridiculous off-the-wall topics in the mouths of the ingenue and the big strapping, you know, guy, and the soubrette character, and like it because it's so ridiculous, but they're playing it straight, is why it is so successful.
[54:49] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[54:49] Joe McDonnell: And so for me, it's like what you want to do is take the characters from It's a Wonderful Life and put them in this post-apocalyptic from, you know, um, some contemporary movie or show, uh, that's like a, um, you know, Smallville or something. That's not a really good one, a good example of something contemporary. Oh, uh, Gossip Girl, Gossip Girl, that's exactly the perfect one. And so that's exactly right. That's what you want to do. Yeah, you know, and if you're gonna, and so that's why I objected, um, to a lot of what I saw in the Off-Broadway and Broadway, because I said to myself, it's not that it's not good, it's that you have performers who are so excellent that they're making these choices work.
[55:35] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.
[55:37] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, I mean, that is one thing that they did absolutely right. And I'm speaking of the two Johns right now, John Rando and John Carafa, is that they cast people who were so brilliant at what they did that they still made it work, even with the material. They didn't actually cast the show because by the time you get to the show to their place, they have, because there's money, they have casting directors who find them stars.
[56:02] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[56:02] Joe McDonnell: Well, there you go. You know, yeah, yeah. Because those two, those were established Broadway people already.
[56:09] Pamela Shandrow: Right, right.
[56:09] Joe McDonnell: And shout out to casting directors because they're the big support system behind actors in this day and age. They're the ones.
[56:16] Pamela Shandrow: Absolutely.
[56:16] Joe McDonnell: Yeah. They're the ones that see us. And I'll tell you what, I mean, I had a, uh, you know, a decent, fairly long career. I was in show business for 30 years and, um, did a couple Broadway shows, all that stuff. I, um, saw a wide variety of casting directors. And the one thing I can tell you is that in the beginning of my career, which was in the early 80s, you go into an audition and you would have the director, choreographer, casting director people right there.
[56:47] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[56:48] Joe McDonnell: By the time I was done, you had the mentally disabled third cousin of the assistant casting director for your initial audition, and you didn't get in front of the casting director until you were on the third callback, and you didn't see the director. I mean, it was nuts. It was like, how can you be putting a show together that you trust?
[57:05] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[57:06] Joe McDonnell: Because once again, too, the other thing is who can we get? So you the first thing you do is you fill it with celebrities.
[57:13] Pamela Shandrow: Not even that's the other complaint, if I can just make a Broadway complaint right here.
[57:18] Joe McDonnell: We complain about that a lot though, Joe. So go ahead.
[57:22] Joe McDonnell: So when I started in show business way, way back in the 20th century, last century, um, you people from Broadway went out to Hollywood and they were, and you brought them out to Hollywood because they were considered pros, ringers, capable of great dimensional performances. By the time you get to the 21st century, you're bringing any celebrity off a reality show to Broadway because people recognize them. And it's disgusting and it should stop.
[57:52] Pamela Shandrow: And now it's just TikTok even.
[57:54] Joe McDonnell: Yes, I was having a fight for the fight. I was having an argument with a friend just even this morning talking about. Now I'm gonna be unfair because I'm sure you guys love this and everyone else loves it. I haven't seen it. But I, we were talking about the movie West Side Story. Okay. Um, I, and my complaint was I'm sorry, but, but not unlike, um, the movie of Le Miz, there are actors, singers I know who can sing the living daylights out of it and act it. So I don't want to accept Ansel Elgort and people going, I was surprised that Baby Driver could sing. That's not good enough for me. You know, when I, when I saw Le Miz, I was, I was okay with, um, the dude that played Marius. What's his name? Famous actor.
[58:39] Joe McDonnell: Eddie Redmayne.
[58:41] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, Eddie. Talented guy.
[58:43] Joe McDonnell: Well, I think he started out in musical theater, though.
[58:45] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, yes, but he doesn't have the voice that the guy who played Angel Ross.
[58:51] Joe McDonnell: Eric Devine, right?
[58:52] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, yeah, right, right. There was no reason why they didn't just cast Aaron Devite as Marius because he would have sung and acted the daylights out of it.
[58:59] Joe McDonnell: Well, I am the first one to say I don't care who you are, what you've done before, if you are a good performer and you tell the story, I want you. And the thing is too, and we've had this discussion a lot about Russell Crowe in particular. Russell Crowe is a good actor.
[59:19] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.
[59:19] Joe McDonnell: So the fact that he ruined Le Miz surprises the heck out of me. And I'm not just talking about the auto-tuning because that was ugh. I hate auto-tuning. It's my, it's the worst thing ever. For some reason, the second he starts to sing a note, he loses all connection with the material that he's got, which is, uh, a breadth of material that has been around for I don't even know how long. It is brilliantly written and has so much depth to it, but for some reason he's nothing anymore, not even surface level.
[59:53] Pamela Shandrow: But you know what the most offensive part of that is he wasn't having to sing live, yeah.
[59:58] Joe McDonnell: He gets to record and then sing along with himself, which that's the other problem is they lip sync in movies now. In the old days when they moved maybe movie musicals, they sang along with themselves that they had to breathe properly and make the right facial expressions and stuff, and now they don't make them do that, and it drives me crazy.
[1:00:15] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, no, you know what a simple, decent director could have said, let me show you how to act a song. It's actually really, really simple.
[1:00:23] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, well, he was working with Roberta Jucek, she was doing the voice act, she's a big Chicago person, right? She does know how to do this, right? She has been a performer for ages. Do you see signs that they actually allowed her to do anything with Russell Crowe?
[1:00:39] Pamela Shandrow: I guess no, but I, I, I know.
[1:00:41] Joe McDonnell: Okay, so do you not think that she—
[1:00:41] Pamela Shandrow: No, I don't think she got within 10.
[1:00:45] Joe McDonnell: I mean, I think if she got within 10 feet of him, he didn't listen to a goddamn thing she said.
[1:00:50] Joe McDonnell: You know, which is really weird. And yeah, and I just want to say, like, I so I haven't seen Must I'm sorry, as I said, but Ariana DeBose is like talent on a stick, she's unbelievable. And that's the thing about that cast is like all the other leads came from a theater background. He's like the only one that didn't. And I was like, why? Why? There are the, and I can, I met hundreds upon hundreds of people in my time in New York who were unbelievably talented that way. They in fact were multiple threats.
[1:00:52] Pamela Shandrow: Maybe that's the case too, yeah.
[1:01:21] Pamela Shandrow: Sure.
[1:01:22] Joe McDonnell: Hugh Jackman himself. I mean, I loved him in A Boy from Oz.
[1:01:25] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:01:26] Joe McDonnell: But you need to have enough sense to know. I once did a reading of a show, and I kept saying to the director and the composer, I don't have the voice for this role.
[1:01:36] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:01:37] Joe McDonnell: Why am I in this role? You're, you know, I'm gonna be screaming and you're not gonna like it, and it's not gonna help your show.
[1:01:43] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:01:43] Joe McDonnell: And they just wouldn't listen to me. You gotta have a sense of who you are. And unfortunately, apparently, Mr. Jackman doesn't because he should never have agreed, or if he was gonna do that role, he should have had someone help him.
[1:01:57] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:01:58] Joe McDonnell: Because for all of the things I can say bad about Come Wilkinson, when it comes to Jean Valjean, he knocks it out of the damn park.
[1:02:09] Pamela Shandrow: Beautiful.
[1:02:10] Joe McDonnell: It's really beautiful. And even the greatest people can't do everything. You know, I saw Patti LuPone's One Woman show. She can't sing an up-tempo song to save her life. All she could do is tear down the walls over and over, which she can do over and over and over again all night long, and it's amazing.
[1:02:26] Pamela Shandrow: Absolutely.
[1:02:29] Joe McDonnell: Well, she's not. Listen to me now. If this gets out, hi wait, does Patti LuPone listen to your podcast? Because I'm in trouble.
[1:02:33] Pamela Shandrow: I don't know.
[1:02:35] Joe McDonnell: We've mentioned her before too.
[1:02:37] Pamela Shandrow: But like not in a bad, I mean, we mentioned her like, uh, when she's in the content of like wanting to punch people in the throat.
[1:02:45] Joe McDonnell: I understand I prove, but now I've told people where I live, including Patti now. If she's listening, she's gonna come and she's gonna beat the daylights out of me.
[1:02:54] Pamela Shandrow: Maybe she'll think it's Bloomington, Indiana.
[1:02:57] Joe McDonnell: Oh, good. Thank you for that. I mean, most people do. You know what? Honestly, she's got a lot of free time if she can be bothered. Come on looking for me, right?
[1:03:07] Pamela Shandrow: Absolutely.
[1:03:08] Joe McDonnell: No, I don't think she'll be bothered by what you're saying right now. You know, and she's someone that is just a phenomenal actor. I just, I think her acting is actually better than her singing. I think her acting is what makes her singing even work.
[1:03:15] Pamela Shandrow: I agree completely.
[1:03:18] Joe McDonnell: And I think sometimes because she's been told so many times now that she's this powerhouse voice, that the voice now, because it's what people go to see, it kind of distracts from everything else. Also, because if you actually listen to her in Evita, she has nuance. She's able to sing soft and high and pretty, which is all there. Now, we all get older, so your voice changes, but she does feel she seems to feel the need to beat every song like it's an ex-husband, if you will, although I wanna, I've listened to, I like her, uh, as Joanne in Company from what I listened to, the West End production, and I am looking forward to, uh, seeing her when she's healed from COVID. Um, at, you know, the Broadway one.
[1:04:06] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:04:07] Joe McDonnell: Uh, you know, sure. Uh, I'm just one of those people that, you know, I'm not, I tell people all the time though, people always want me to go to shows and see movies, and I say, I am not the person because I will ruin this for you. And I'm telling you, yeah, I, because I don't have the universe is extremely insistent. And so when I go to see a show, I sit there and the universe yells at me that like you is wrong, that costume is wrong, that blocking is wrong. You know what I mean? And so I come out of a show after act one with friends and they say, What did you think? And I'm like, please don't make me tell you. And so they're like, I really liked it. And they, what did you know? I want to hear, I want to hear. And then I go like cue to cue, what was wrong with the show? And they're like, Oh, I see what you're doing.
[1:04:48] Pamela Shandrow: Now the show used to. I don't really leave my apartment much anymore. But Ebony and I have been to shows together. We went to go see Pacific Overtures, we went to go see She Loves Me and a couple. I think like one of Hello Dolly would burn it at Peter's. Anyway, um, we leave the show, and both of us have this a kind of unwritten rule that we don't say anything. We just sit on the subway, and then we get back to a story, and we get to a point where we can walk safely away from other people, and then we kind of open up because I think being a part of theater, being in it and inside that world, it does ruin it for you to be an audience member because you see creatively speaking what you could have done differently, which doesn't necessarily mean that the show was bad.
Yeah, it just like it gets those creative juices going so much to the point where you're like, oh, like what if they had done this? Or like, oh, that would have been so exciting. Now, also there are shows that are just really not good.
[1:05:53] Joe McDonnell: Like, like Pippin. I never understood why anybody doesn't rewrite Pippin.
[1:05:58] Pamela Shandrow: Sure.
[1:05:59] Joe McDonnell: The composer's still alive for Christ's sake. They're working on it. That's all I'm gonna say. Because it's here's the problem. If you're listening out there, Steve, and listen to me. It's two shows, and the act one show is the good one. So all you need to do is figure out how you can make act two look like act one, like make a show that has a chorus in it in act two, you know? Give us give us a plot that makes sense because what happens is it it's this great thing, and then it unravels because it becomes this plot about a guy who inadvertently joined a show he didn't want to be in.
[1:06:37] Ebony Vines: Right.
[1:06:37] Joe McDonnell: And that's not the point at all. Yeah, so they're not gonna listen because no one ever listens to me. They just steal my work and run off.
[1:06:49] Pamela Shandrow: Well, then you just need to mount a production of Pippin in your style and hope that someone sees it and steals it.
[1:06:55] Joe McDonnell: Guess who's retired? Me. I'm not even directing here because I found people like they're gonna love you, they're gonna love you. And I what I found out was, and this is I I hate to sound ungenerous, but that there's the world is full of people who are mediocrities and are very comfortable in their mediocrity. They don't want excellence, and if you try to bring it, you either intimidate them or you um inconvenience them.
[1:07:23] Ebony Vines: Sure.
[1:07:23] Joe McDonnell: That's why I've just stopped doing theater and taken up drinking. And I'm good at it, so you know, but I I've I've seen I saw Elaine Stritch in At Liberty or One Woman Show. Oh my Lord. On Broadway. I you will never see anything that great again. Honestly, it was unbelievable. I saw Maggie Smith in Let Us in Lovage on Broadway, 1999. You'll never see anything like that again. So yeah, it's um theater's different.
[1:07:52] Pamela Shandrow: You know, you know what I think you should do uh is start a troop.
[1:07:58] Joe McDonnell: I can't wait to know.
[1:07:59] Pamela Shandrow: I know, start your own theater true.
[1:08:01] Joe McDonnell: Yeah, like almost like a not necessarily improv theater, but like like an improv group, you just have a kind of a revolving door of actors who are all kind of like-minded, and you guys just get together and you create.
[1:08:14] Ebony Vines: Girl, I love that you still have that much heart left in you.
[1:08:18] Joe McDonnell: But it's it it's be like starting a family at this point in my life. It takes too much energy, I'm too old, I can't be bothered. I mean, honestly, and the and the biggest problem, of course, now is that back in the day, whatever the day was, when I first moved to New York, which was 1990, I used to go, I lived in the Upper West Side, and I would every weekend I would walk out my door, and there was free entertainment on every corner homeless people, crazy people. It was fun. And you'd take the train downtown to the East Village, and some storefront hellhole would have a show in it, and it would be these people, and they were paying nothing for it, and they were using crap out of the out of grandma's closet, and the shows were fabulous.
[1:09:02] Today, you can't do anything without a hundred thousand dollars. You can't put on a puppet show.
[1:09:09] Ebony Vines: Yeah, it's just uh the world has gone mad, and yeah, and so that's why you can't, you know, you can't get the the costumes out of the attic and put a show up in the barn anymore. It's just not possible.
[1:09:19] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:09:20] Joe McDonnell: It makes me sad, but it's that's what I see.
[1:09:22] Ebony Vines: It is sad.
[1:09:23] Pamela Shandrow: Ebony and I talk about this constantly. We're, you know, in the 90s right now of episodes that we've put out since we first started doing this podcast. And almost every single one of those shows that we talk about, you know, will say that they put on the show for 18 million dollars or 12 million dollars, and you know, you nobody small, nobody up and coming can really get a foot in the door because they don't have the resources and they don't have the people to support them, and they don't have the money, and it's so sad and frustrating.
[1:09:58] Joe McDonnell: And part of the problem is that now 35% of every budget is marketing.
[1:10:02] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.
[1:10:03] Joe McDonnell: Which they don't honestly don't even do that well. They put signs on the show. I just went through a program and like our when when we our instructors were talking about marketing, they were talking about like um the surveys that they find that like the marketing that's happening, that's not even what audiences want to know.
[1:10:23] Ebony Vines: Right.
[1:10:23] Joe McDonnell: And it's like you can't get people, you know, there's new, there's new uh advertising and media companies coming up that are trying to change some of this, but it's like a lot of the old ones do the old same old stuff, and it's not even what audiences want to know about the show.
[1:10:40] Pamela Shandrow: Honestly, the free marketing comes from having the stars in your show that people go to see.
[1:10:44] Joe McDonnell: They're like, I don't care what the show's about. Hugh Jackman is in it. Or, you know, the the people that have millions of followers on TikTok and Twitter and Instagram who, you know, they post one video and all of their fans are like, oh, all right, let's go see that show because she's in it.
[1:10:59] Ebony Vines: Right.
[1:10:59] Joe McDonnell: Or the show is a recognizable commodity, and there's that too.
[1:11:03] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, I mean it's it's it's all of those things.
[1:11:05] Joe McDonnell: You know, Ebony, I just realized that you're not actually sitting in that room that's behind the background.
[1:11:10] Ebony Vines: I'm like, that roaring fire looks fantastic and it never changes.
[1:11:15] Joe McDonnell: Wow, I really am a genius, aren't I? Unbelievable.
[1:11:19] Pamela Shandrow: That's that's when I show my age, and I'm like, you know, how do you work this Zoom thing?
[1:11:26] Joe McDonnell: You can see that I've got a photo of my dogs and a mirror, and like this is my setup.
[1:11:31] Ebony Vines: I don't even have anything special behind me either.
[1:11:33] Joe McDonnell: Well, you know, I'm still on the Facebook, so I'm an old generation.
[1:11:40] Pamela Shandrow: Anyhow, so I I hope that that was interesting.
[1:11:44] Joe McDonnell: Like, that was really fascinating.
[1:11:46] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, it really was.
[1:11:47] Ebony Vines: It really was so much for chatting with us. We love the dirt, we love hearing the kind of scandalous stories behind stuff.
[1:11:55] Joe McDonnell: Oh well, then I we probably should get have another talk about it and I'll just un un uh unload every bit of dirt I've ever heard in all of my years.
[1:12:03] Pamela Shandrow: Do you probably because we will call you to do that?
[1:12:08] Joe McDonnell: Like, let me tell you, my first national tour was with Debbie Reynolds when I played her younger brother.
[1:12:13] Ebony Vines: No, what show?
[1:12:15] Joe McDonnell: Uh on the unsinkable Molly Brown in 1989. And the stories, girls that I have, ladies, women, wonderful people that I have from that experience are ones that should never be forgotten because it was an incredible education. It was phenomenal. And when you talk about like the old school knowing how to do it, man, they knew how to do it. They didn't even need talent because they had some other thing that was taught to them in the studio system.
[1:12:43] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, it's a formula.
[1:12:45] Joe McDonnell: Uh that just blows your mind. So it was that's amazing. A lot of great stories from that.
[1:12:50] Ebony Vines: You know, well, we will be asking you back on our podcast.
[1:12:54] Joe McDonnell: All right.
[1:12:55] Joe McDonnell: Happy to come by. Glad it's not a video.
[1:12:59] Pamela Shandrow: That didn't what made it to off Broadway, but not Broadway. I'm kind of interested in that one too.
[1:13:04] Joe McDonnell: Oh, yeah.
[1:13:04] Joe McDonnell: Well, you know what else? I also directed the reading of um It Should Have Been You. If you ever heard of it, yeah, it was.
[1:13:10] Ebony Vines: Yes, geez, I advised that current.
[1:13:13] Joe McDonnell: Okay, so I was in the room with David Hyde Pierce. It was the most exciting moment of my life at that time.
[1:13:18] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, so I got dumped off of that one too because obviously the the writer's husband was David Hyde Pierce.
[1:13:24] Joe McDonnell: Right.
[1:13:25] Joe McDonnell: But I didn't mind that because I was like, I would dump me for David Hyde Pierce as well. However, when I saw the show on Broadway, I took it back because it was so badly directed. He just had no idea what he was dealing with.
[1:13:36] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[1:13:40] Joe McDonnell: Um I didn't actually get to see it. So that was the only difference there. It was dreadful and unfortunate. And part of it was because the original conceit of it elapsed between the show being done originally and it being done off off Broadway.
[1:13:53] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[1:13:54] Joe McDonnell: And also because they didn't listen to me because I told them after the reading. Do not accept any offers from from regional theaters. You must get this sucker onto off Broadway immediately.
[1:14:07] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[1:14:07] Joe McDonnell: And they went and they took an offer from Seattle or somewhere, and that delayed its, you know, and it was just one of those situations. Um, but anyhow, and and and I can also tell you my story of how I don't like Deborah Monk so much. She's kind of a witch to me.
[1:14:21] Pamela Shandrow: So she's on Gilded Age now, and she's not nice on that show.
[1:14:27] Joe McDonnell: And it's she's not acting.
[1:14:29] Joe McDonnell: No, she's incredibly talented. And I'm being really mean for no reason because she wasn't that awful. But we we had an interaction that I felt was um not my not my favorite. And since I was also working at the same time with Harriet Harris, who was an absolute peach.
[1:14:46] Ebony Vines: I've heard that.
[1:14:47] Joe McDonnell: I love her too. You know, I say to myself, you don't have to be. I don't care how big a star you are, you don't have to be a bitch.
[1:14:55] Pamela Shandrow: Well, and that's why I like David Hyde Pierce so much because he was, you know, listen. He essentially just said, thank you for coming in goodbye after my audition for it should have been you. But he was so warm and so welcoming, and you felt the support just radiating from him.
[1:15:10] Joe McDonnell: So you were just in that room and you knew that he was listening to you. And that's really all you want as an actor.
[1:15:16] Pamela Shandrow: He I was at their apartment in New York, which is like a fabulous apartment.
[1:15:20] Joe McDonnell: I bet.
[1:15:20] Joe McDonnell: And um, and he was just so like he's just a regular person. He's a really good guy. So I don't I I wish wish him uh I think he's I really admire his work and I wish him all uh luck in the world.
[1:15:32] Pamela Shandrow: But um that was uh Well, I I have my perspective on it should have been you comes more from a place of inclusivity as far as bodies are concerned.
[1:15:43] Ebony Vines: Uh and something that we've discussed on this podcast before too is that fat bodies, black bodies, brown bodies do not get the attention that they deserve.
[1:15:55] Joe McDonnell: And it should have been you was like one of those where you saw that the the protagonist of this show is in a fat body, but it's because she's fat that she's going through this stuff, not just because she's a wonderful human being that can like tell the story and have this life and get through these things.
[1:16:13] Pamela Shandrow: It you know, everything is always because of the fact.
[1:16:17] Joe McDonnell: I had a hard time even referring to her as fat because to me well, she's an entertainment fat.
[1:16:22] Ebony Vines: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
[1:16:23] Joe McDonnell: I mean, which which means she actually just has curves, like a woman is supposed to have a few. I think she's probably like a 12. And she's like stunningly beautiful, gorgeous. That was that was the other thing. I was like, how could even this girl? So this this girl, okay, maybe she's got a couple of extra pounds, but come on, her life can't be like the they're describing the character to be because she's really, really beautiful, and yeah, you know, and any real man would look at that and say, I don't care that she's not stick thin because real men like women that have a shape.
[1:16:50] Pamela Shandrow: I I'm sure you know, so I call BS on that whole thing.
[1:16:50] Joe McDonnell: I call BS on the whole thing.
[1:16:54] Pamela Shandrow: Listen, also we are not as women running around going, Oh gosh, I hope the next guy that comes around the corner likes the way that I look. None of us are thinking that.
[1:17:03] Ebony Vines: Not a single one of us.
[1:17:06] Joe McDonnell: Oh no one. We don't dress for men, we don't talk to men because we like them. We're just, you know.
[1:17:13] Pamela Shandrow: No, that's terrible.
[1:17:14] Joe McDonnell: But like that's just it, too. It's like all of these rom coms have the same kind of formula where the woman has to change everything about herself in order to gain the acceptance of the man that she ends up being with, but the guy doesn't have to do anything to change what he's doing to get her acceptance.
[1:17:29] Ebony Vines: Because it doesn't matter.
[1:17:30] Joe McDonnell: It's all marginalized communities. Every gay man is witty.
[1:17:34] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.
[1:17:35] Joe McDonnell: You know, and rather funny.
[1:17:36] Pamela Shandrow: Or a little snarky or like.
[1:17:39] Joe McDonnell: But I gotta tell you, I know some really boring gay guys.
[1:17:42] Pamela Shandrow: Like just, ah.
[1:17:44] Joe McDonnell: You know, they're not all uh as witty as I am, shall we say?
[1:17:50] Ebony Vines: Absolutely, absolutely.
[1:17:52] Joe McDonnell: So that's just what it is, and that's our world. And I and I love that young people like you are fighting and are saying we're not going to accept this any longer.
[1:18:00] Pamela Shandrow: I mean, I don't love that cancel culture because I think that everything should be an opportunity for education, for learning, for growing.
[1:18:07] Joe McDonnell: We like call in.
[1:18:08] Pamela Shandrow: Callin, that's what we like.
[1:18:11] Joe McDonnell: Yeah.
[1:18:11] Ebony Vines: Yes.
[1:18:12] Joe McDonnell: So anyhow.
[1:18:14] Pamela Shandrow: Thank you.
[1:18:15] Ebony Vines: Thank you so much, Joe.
[1:18:17] Joe McDonnell: This was a lot of fun.
[1:18:18] Pamela Shandrow: This really was.
[1:18:19] Ebony Vines: We look forward to the next one where you come back to us because this was really a blast.
[1:18:23] Joe McDonnell: So we'll be able to do that.
[1:18:24] Joe McDonnell: Thank you.
[1:18:24] Ebony Vines: I enjoyed you very much.
[1:18:26] Joe McDonnell: Thank you.
[1:18:28] Ebony Vines: Bye.
[1:18:29] Joe McDonnell: Thank you for listening to our podcast, Theater Geeks Anonymous.
[1:18:34] Ebony Vines: You can follow us on Instagram and Twitter at T G A B Way.
[1:18:41] Pamela Shandrow: And on Facebook at Theatre Geeks Anonymous.
[1:18:44] Ebony Vines: And if you want to tell us how much you love us, or you have a great story about one of the shows we've talked about, drop us a note at T G A B Way at Gmail.com.
[1:18:57] Pamela Shandrow: Until next time, geeks.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
