Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep 7: Our "Hamilton" Congress! (Feat: Kelundra Smith and Heath Saunders)

Hamilton, Lin-Manuel Miranda's epic (and very expensive) musical has moved from the stage to screen thanks to Disney+. A musical as big as Hamilton deserves a big discussion, a cabinet battle, if you will... Read More

From the show: Token Theatre Friends

1 h 14 mins
7/10/20

Featured Shows

About

Hamilton, Lin-Manuel Miranda's epic (and very expensive) musical has moved from the stage to screen thanks to Disney+. A musical as big as Hamilton deserves a big discussion, a cabinet battle, if you will. The Friends are joined by actor and composer Heath Saunders, and theater critic Kelundra Smith. They discuss how Hamilton hits differently in 2020 than it did in 2015 when it premiered, how it's OK for art to be problematic, and whether Hamilton could win the Oscar. This episode was recorded on June 6.

Here are links to things the Friends talked about in this episode.

Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/tokentheatrefriends?fan_landing=true)

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Jose Solis: Hi, Vizdeep Tran.

[0:12] Vizdeep Tran: I'm Jose Solis.

[0:14] Jose Solis: And we're your token theater friends. Today we have like a really extra super special.

[0:19] Vizdeep Tran: Is that even a word?

[0:20] Jose Solis: Probably not. We have a special, very special episode. We have a very long episode and we want to share all the good stuff that we have for you.

[0:28] Vizdeep Tran: So we ended up deciding to, instead of like super editing our episode, we are gonna give you two episodes instead of one this week. We have part one, which is going to be an interview with George Salazar, who you know from Be More Chill, and if you were lucky enough to see him in Little Shop of Horrors in California, which is why I'm also wearing this.

[0:49] Jose Solis: I'm so excited. Which you also cannot see if this is a podcast. I'm very nerdy today, I'm sorry. Uh, but George is doing Night of a Thousand Judies on July 14th. So we're gonna be talking to him about that and what he's been doing in quarantine. And in part two, Deep, what are we doing?

[1:07] Vizdeep Tran: Part two, we have our Hamilton Congress, where we have two very special guests come in to talk to us about wait for it, Hamilton. Because we've noticed that just like in 2015, right now most of the people critiquing Hamilton are white people, which is pretty problematic because the show is written by a person of color and is starring people of color.

[1:41] Jose Solis: So why are there very few people of color who are not named Soraya McDonald writing about it? Who knows? But we decided to do something about it by bringing in two amazing guests to talk about it. First, we have Heath Saunders, who is an amazing actor and composer, and you may remember them from Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 on Broadway.

[2:07] Vizdeep Tran: And our second guest is Kelundra Smith, who is an arts journalist and friend to me and Jose. And she critiques theater in Atlanta for Arts ATL and the Atlanta Journal Constitution. It's a really long discussion, but we promise you it is worth it because we go in. We go in far. We almost didn't come out.

[2:27] Jose Solis: Will they be satisfied? I don't know. We hope you'll be satisfied, but you know, we will never be satisfied with our Hamilton discussion because we could have gone on for a long time.

[2:36] Vizdeep Tran: Oh my god, we could have, yeah. And we put in a lot of work, work. Who's Angelica in this relationship?

[2:44] Jose Solis: I guess we can both be Angelica and Peggy. Like, I don't like none of us want to be Eliza's so boring, right?

[2:52] Vizdeep Tran: Eliza, Eliza's really good at her job.

[2:56] Jose Solis: No, I mean, yeah, but I mean—

[2:56] Vizdeep Tran: Which is being a wife.

[2:59] Jose Solis: Yeah. Like, I mean, like, God bless her, but like I want to be like, you know, like I want a revolution.

[3:05] Vizdeep Tran: Yeah.

[3:06] Jose Solis: Not a revelation. Okay, enough. It sounds like in stone.

[3:11] Vizdeep Tran: Okay. Welcome to part two. This is our Hamilton Congress. The house is now in session.

[3:19] Jose Solis: Okay, we are here for our cabinet battle number one with our very special guest, Heath Saunders and Kelundra Smith. Can someone introduce themselves and tell us who you are, what you do? When didn't you see Hamilton?

[3:34] Heath Saunders: Hi, I'm Heath Saunders. Uh, I'm a composer, a writer, and an actor. Um and and what? I so I I saw Hamilton on Broadway in previews. And then I didn't see it again until the Disney Plus film. So that's I have a long-standing relationship. It's also been very interesting to me because Hamilton was one of those things that people told me I had to see because they were like, you can be the next Lin-Manuel Miranda's, because when you act and you write and you act in the things you write, there's a very limited context for what you can do when you're a person of color. Basically, like you're a person of color, you write, you act, you must be Lin-Manuel Miranda's. And I was like, so Lin and I do very different things, but you know what can what can be done. So I have a long, a long history with the Lin-Manuel Miranda's world. Deeply impressed by him as a general rule.

[4:40] Kelundra Smith: Cool. Um I'm Kelundra Smith. I am a theater critic and arts journalist based in Atlanta. Um I freelance for a number of publications around the country, including the New York Times, Food and Wine magazine, American Theater, and Arts ATL. Um I saw Hamilton in fall of 2018 in Charlotte, North Carolina, when it was on the first round equity tour. Um and funny story, actually, the reason I saw it in Charlotte is because I was unable to get press tickets to see it in Atlanta and raised a stink about it on Twitter, and had a lot of support in raising a stink about it on Twitter, uh, which led to me getting a call from the national press agent uh for Hamilton, who then said, you know, we have been trying to get more um critics of color in the room where it happens, and we are deeply sorry. Um that is how I ended up seeing it in Charlotte. Um, so that's an interesting tidbit there. And so seeing it on Disney Plus was a different kind of experience because that's not the cast I saw.

[5:56] Heath Saunders: Um, I'm not only comparing the live experience to the on-screen experience, but also the cast I saw compared to the original cast, which I have to say, there are some performances I liked better from the tour cast.

[6:16] Jose Solis: Yeah, uh, I think Jose, did you did you see at the public?

[6:20] Vizdeep Tran: No.

[6:20] Jose Solis: Okay. By the time that I wanted to go see it, it was too popular, and I never won the lottery. So I saw it for the first time on Broadway.

[6:27] Heath Saunders: Uh 2017, January 2017.

[6:31] Kelundra Smith: Yeah, I saw it at the public, and then which, you know, mood. But and then I saw I saw it again on Broadway. And it's funny that they were talking about trying to get critics of color in there because I fucking had to like practically sell my fourth firstborn in order to get a ticket. Because I mean, I'm actually writing about this. I'm not freeloading.

[6:57] Jose Solis: The first build that we're gonna introduce to the session today is let's talk about the difference between seeing the show on stage live, you know, back when we were allowed to see other people in public and brush against them and seeing it on television or your iPad or your iPhone or wherever you saw it.

[7:16] Heath Saunders: Yeah. I, you know, I I will I will offer that of the Pro Shot musicals that I've seen, uh, the Hamilton film is very effective at if not uh translating the exact experience of seeing the show live. Uh it is it does translate the sort of thrust of a live performed uh show, which I found really nice. I because as a person who like you know adores musical theater, it is interesting to like the ways that it's shot often make it seem significantly worse than it is.

[8:00] Kelundra Smith: Uh and I I didn't really feel that way with the Hamilton film, which I sort of liked. But one of the things that I I thought it lost is uh is actually it's it's both a criticism of the original show and a sort of thing that I liked about the original show, which is that the original show was it was so much information constantly. It's like I mean, act one especially is just like an assault of visual information and and uh and oral information uh that makes it quite difficult to follow at certain points, and it actually makes it so the parts of it which I think are expertly crafted really got buoyed.

[8:42] Heath Saunders: Like I we all love the helpless and dissatisfied moment. Uh I think I can't actually technically speak for you, but for me, that that that moment of stagecraft was so impressive and so uh just like stunning. I knew exactly where to look, I knew what was happening around where my eye was going. Everything about that moment was so thrilling to me. And while in the film it captures the sort of story moment of it, it doesn't really quite something about the like aggressive shifts of camera made it so I wasn't able to sort of appreciate what I consider the stagecraft of that moment.

[9:19] Kelundra Smith: Uh and so it ended up being a little bit uh like oh yeah, that happened, and less of like what happened for me in the show when I saw it when I was like out of my seat, like this is this is expertly crafted. And you know, that's so that's a little bit disappointing. But again, it's sort of a double-edged sword here that we're talking about, which is like it is not meant to be a film, so this version of it I think was a really really effective capturing of it in this new medium, and also I lost some of the things about theater that I love.

[9:54] Heath Saunders: To your point, Heath, like I actually don't think the choreography was best served through it because most of the time the camera wasn't on the ensemble who was doing a the brunt of the movement, it was on the main performers, which yes, that that's what we that's who we want to see. And uh, but like there's the moment where Hamilton gets shot, and and uh Ariana DeBose plays the bullet, and you barely even see her do that epic slow walk across the platform because you're concentrated on Lin-Manuel, and so and like the I feel like that's the thing about about film, like the camera tells you who is important, but in theater, you're allowed to look wherever you want to look and and take in the entire stage picture, and so I kind of miss a lot of the wider shots I remember in the theater because Tommy Kail was telling me I need to look right here at Lin while he's talking.

[10:55] Kelundra Smith: I'm like, no, I want to look at Ariana. I love what she was doing right there. As a general rule, I always want to look at Ariana DeBose.

[11:01] Heath Saunders: So yeah, I would agree. I think that the if anything, I think the focus of the camera helped to clarify story in some ways.

[11:15] Kelundra Smith: If you had missed it when you saw it live. And then, of course, there's close captioning on your TV. So then you know, you're like, oh, okay. Um so I think there is some clarity there. But what I really missed, in addition to, I think one of the strengths of Lin-Manuel's musicals in general is all the stuff happening in the background. He loves a street scene that looks very realistic.

[11:39] Heath Saunders: So we're not going to be on a street sidewalk in New York and there not be people going by in the background, and some folks are going to be holding umbrellas, and maybe it's raining.

[11:46] Kelundra Smith: And so that's some of the stuff that you didn't get by watching it through the screen on Disney Plus. And then I think the other thing that I miss too is the energy of the music doesn't come across through the screen because there's something about that live orchestra that that sound is all around you, and you're swallowed up by it.

[12:08] Heath Saunders: Now the numbers that did come across, like the room where it happens, still it was amazing in person, it's amazing on screen. Like you're just like, it's in your head, you're jazzing, you're singing it. But then there are other musical numbers that I really liked in person, but like the energy of that live instrumentation is what boosted them, but you didn't get on screen.

[12:31] Kelundra Smith: The movie version I feel is a great example of what you're all saying, which is you know, movies are after all like a director's medium, right? And yeah, like choosing what to focus on is I mean, I really admired this version because it must it must have been like hell, because like, yeah, Lin loves all his Easter eggs, but they're usually happening all over.

[12:49] Heath Saunders: And I thought that this would be a great uh example of a movie that remember back when DVDs had this like multi-angle option where you can choose what to look from.

[12:59] Kelundra Smith: This would benefit from that. Because if we had gotten, you know, the way that uh, you know, that standard shot that we get when uh shows are recorded to preserve them at the uh Lincoln Center Library, you know, those are like terrible. Like you we don't want to look at the whole thing all the time.

[13:17] Heath Saunders: So I was really impressed, actually. And I were did you hear that people were talking about whether this movie was gonna be eligible for Oscars or not?

[13:25] Kelundra Smith: Because like Oscars are bending the rules this year to let no, it's it's true to let movies that were originally uh no schedule.

[13:35] Heath Saunders: Wow, controversial opinion.

[13:37] Kelundra Smith: Kalandra, tell us more.

[13:39] Kelundra Smith: No, because there's going to be a film adaptation of Hamilton that is not the Broadway show. But I mean, right now this is the movie that we have. So it would be I'm all about genre busting media, right? Like I want media to be multi, multimedia. I love that we sort of blur the blur the lines.

[13:58] Heath Saunders: I think the challenge that I have with the idea of this particular, I mean, I even have a hard time calling it the Hamilton film. I'm like, it's not really a film.

[14:06] Kelundra Smith: No, it's no. And then I appraise it. It's funny because as soon as I go into the like, do you want me to appraise this as a movie? Then I go into a little bit of the like, that's there's there's camera things. I I just like I'm like, it's not like cinematically an extraordinary work beyond the idea that the job is to convey what's happening on stage.

[14:28] Heath Saunders: So I mean, I think about like you know, Lars von Trier does some movies that are like staged, and that but to me, what he's doing is a film. Like you shouldn't, they're not meant to be watched live. Hamilton remains a sh a sh it feels like a to me, the Hamilton film feels like a really, really great archival recording, more than it feels like uh a art, a piece of art on its own that stands as and again, there's that's a that's a you know, now that it's coming out of my mouth, I have a little bit more like do I really think that?

[15:02] Heath Saunders: But I think I'm, you know what, I'm gonna stand by it. I'm gonna stand by it. That's our criticism, hey, there's what comes out. I'm glad you brought up Lars von Trier, because I was gonna challenge this notion with that precisely, Manderley and Dogville. Yeah, our shard is house stage where have you, Kalundra and Deep, have you seen those movies?

[15:20] Kelundra Smith: No, but I remember the Anna Karenina, the one with Keira Knightley, and it was an adaptation that was done like a play, because there was a stage, and that was like a metaphor. And Lars von Trier's films, like Dogville and Manderley, he basically shoots them in a completely empty sound stage, and it's very Brechtian in that when he shoots from above, you can see like the outlines of what the buildings are, for instance, telling you what's there. So it's a movie without sets, without objects, without props, and you have to imagine things, and there's a few sound effects. They're like fucking fantastic. So I was at the Academy when I was talking about this, but this is a real conversation that people are having.

And if the Academy deems that Disney is right and that the movie can be eligible for Academy Awards, it will be eligible for Academy Awards. Even if it, and there's nothing we can do about that. I will not be happy about this. I think it is its own product. Because I mean, unless it's creating a new genre of film, like what category does this go under? Is it documentary? Is it feature? Is it, what is it? I mean, I'm okay if we're saying we're going to make a new category of film for Broadway or theatrical shows shot, what is that? Like, I need somebody to tell me what category it falls under because to me it is not a feature film. And I don't know that it's fair that you would put Hamilton in the same category as something that had a bigger budget and CGI.

Like, I just don't, I don't know what do you do with that? I'm curious, I'm genuinely asking. I’m not, you know, Killer Dress is just saying that isn't categorization precisely what keeps people of color from participating in all these things? You know, are they even making real theater if it's not this or that? You know, and if we go and like try to categorize even something like this where in a year where, you know, a lot of movies aren't being released at all, it would give, you know, actors of color the opportunity to compete in the Oscar race, sorry, which is usually extremely white. So why this, you know, need for categorization when being classified is how racism started, how we are kept from participating in all these very, very wide circles? Like, I don't, I don't, I don't get that.

[17:57] Heath Saunders: Our desire to remove categories from the Oscars doesn't remove categories from the Oscars. Well, they're gonna put this movie in a category. Like, it's not, I mean, I'm not saying what Kalundra wants, you know what I mean? The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is going to put this movie in a category, whether we like it or not. My question is, what category does it go in? And does that category set this film up for success? Is it fair, or is this something that we need to channel into like a Golden Globes or an Emmys if we want to award it with something to give it its best opportunity for a win? Because I can foresee the moment where there's all this hype around, oh my god, Hamilton recording is nominated for an Oscar, and then all of these people of color are like ready with their, you know, acceptance speeches, and then all of a sudden it's like, and the Oscar goes to insert name of Russell Crowe film or whatever, you know.

So I just, I think that I wanna, I mean, I'm, if we're gonna dismantle, dismantle, but I don't think the Academy will dismantle just by letting this be eligible. I think they're gonna put this in a category and be like, well, if it's good enough, it'll stand up, and it's like actually if the category itself is discriminatory, then it's not gonna stand up.

[19:09] Kelundra Smith: Yeah, I mean, there's only two categories, basically. It's nonfiction, which is documentaries, and then, you know, movies, which is like anything else. So this would be like a documentary, right? Why? Maybe? I don't know. I'm just asking.

[19:20] Heath Saunders: No, I like, you know, for instance, the movies that Heath and I were talking about, the Last Frontier movies, which were shot on soundstage with chalk outlines, were movies, you know, they're not documentaries. The intention is different. But for me, what for what for me is really important to differentiate between the Lars von Trier movie and the Hamilton film is that the Hamilton film, I mean, if we want to talk about like the flow of money and the way that things happen and why the Hamilton film was made when other shows that are put on stage are not made into movies in this way. Like this is not about Hamilton was not designed, they did not direct this musical to be the thing that it is.

That it is literally a capturing of a different category of media. And that for me is where I'm like, Lars von Trier was making a film. He was making a film using a set of techniques that were based on the act, the direction of the actors was directing them toward the idea that this thing was meant to be a film. It was the whole creation of the sound stage was designed. It wasn't like people were meant to be in watching the thing. He was making a film. And that's not to say that this piece of art, the Hamilton film, is not a film unto itself. I'm just, it feels like we're getting, we're like having step more and more steps of removal from what the thing is, right? We've created a musical, and then you like film it.

And it's like if I then if I took the recording of the movie, the Hamilton film, and then I like recut it myself, would I be making a new piece of art? Like it's a valid thing to do as an artist, but it does to me, it feels, and then for me, what becomes most disingenuous about that, in the context of like giving bodies of color opportunity to compete in these spaces, is that these actors are not performing as though they're, they're not for me as an actor, I get really worked up because I do believe that performing on film is different than performing on stage. And there are, I would argue in the Hamilton film, there are performances that are served by this new media in a way that other performances are not.

And it's not one-to-one. There are performances on the stage that I think are really, really solid musical theater or Broadway performances that I think, and again, this is not to be disparaging saying that one is better than the other, it's just they're different. And I have a, I feel like I'm a little bit with Kalundra, where I'm like, are we setting this up for success? Because who actually wins out of this? We're not giving these actors of color this opportunity to compete in this new space that they otherwise wouldn't. We're giving a bunch of white people who in fact budgeted and funded the entire thing the opportunity for clout within their white system.

[22:09] Kelundra Smith: Right. So and the Skylar Sisters, to your point, the Skylar Sisters performance is a musical theater performance. It is that, I mean, when they come out on that stage and the vocal prowess that those singers have, I mean, it's chills up your spine. I mean, the notes that they're hitting, but that performance would not be the same if this was shot to be a film. Um, then you also I wonder what that does to folks like Anthony Ramos, right? Who he is a formidable film and television actor. He's going to be in the In the Heights movie, not the film of the musical, but the actual Universal Pictures movie, right? And so then, I mean, his performance that he's giving you in the musical Hamilton is different than what he's already proven he can do in other films and in other television shows. Because I mean, he's been working, you know. So I think that there's something to be said there too.

[23:08] Heath Saunders: Yeah, I want to say that right now. I'm so happy right now because I'm imagining white people, if you're watching this or if you're listening to this, can you imagine if this was what like the actual House of Representatives and the Senate looked like and sounded like, holy shit, like what a world we would be in. I am very happy with this conversation. So thank you for being here. The second bill that we want to introduce is the difference between, you know, 2015 and 2020. You know, it's been five years since the musical first showed up anywhere.

[23:45] Kelundra Smith: Wrong. It showed up at that press dinner, right? First, uh, yeah.

[23:49] Heath Saunders: But even since like the stage version, the final version was presented. It's been five years. Let's talk about the difference between how it was received back then by us and by people, and what it feels like to be seeing this show in 2020. Who wants to go first?

[24:06] Kelundra Smith: I mean, we've switched presidents since then. Like, this is very much an Obama, the only musical that could be written in an Obama administration where we're all feeling very positive about, relatively positive. I mean, generally, I'm not talking speaking for Native Americans or immigrants in cages, but very, we're all feeling, I know in 2015, like I was feeling pretty good about the state of the country. This musical made me feel so patriotic and so represented because here's two things I love: I love period dramas.

[24:41] Heath Saunders: Yeah.

[24:42] Kelundra Smith: And it just makes me so sad that POCs are never in period dramas because they're usually with white people. And I'm just like, oh my god, there's this gorgeous black woman, and she's wearing a Regency gown. Like that is everything I have ever wanted. And you know, and I love reading about history and being able to read the musical did in 2015. I thought the musical did was successfully what it was trying to do, which is to reclaim history in our image using these figures that we were taught in school to as Americans to revere. And I think what Hamilton did was like make them seem more human. Like at the time, it was like, oh my god, how dare you portray, you know, Thomas Jefferson as someone with an actual personality.

And I think right, but I think now this is what's interesting about art. And in just five years, I mean it became something that was so revolutionary to something that's so problematic. And the thing hasn't changed, but we have. Watching it is for me, it's different now because I don't really feel particularly proud to be an American, but I do feel like things that hit differently for me this time around was a call to revolution and the notion that it's okay, it was only ever okay for white people to be revolutionaries. But this musical showed that the people who are on the streets right now are people who look like us, like we are the revolutionaries, and but at the same time, you can't disagree with the fact that it is still about white people, and so what is the next step towards representation?

[26:25] Heath Saunders: I'm not the only person here, I mean, I know that it came here very young, Deep, but I might be the only person who migrated, you know, who was born outside the US who came here as an adult.

[26:36] Vizdeep Tran: Yeah, you were.

[26:37] Heath Saunders: Okay. Yeah, it's really interesting to me because when I saw it even, you know, it is very Obama, but Obama was disastrous to the rest of the world. Obama was putting kids in cages, except the media didn't care that much. Obama was bombing Syria constantly. Obama was creating a lot of war and chaos in the Middle East. And as I've told, I've talked to you about before, Deep, Obama is in many ways the reason why I'm here. He and Hillary Clinton backed up a military dictatorship and a coup that led the Honduran president to be removed from power, established a military dictatorship, and that's how I ended up here eventually, you know, because I can't live in my home country because the number of LGBTQ murders and the violence that was caused because of that Obama-Hillary backed coup was disastrous.

So, you know, I to me even see it was musical and seeing how happy everyone was, I was like, well, maybe, you know, we should be more open to listening to all the damage that Obama caused in 2016 was so heartbroken because, you know, I saw how people had to decide between voting for this monster that's currently in the White House, or voting for the woman who was helped by the government to destroy my home country. So America for me has always been a very, I don't know, a very complex, very heartbreaking concept. So I never had this hope, even at Hamilton. Because I knew, you know, it was very much about what the idea of America tells itself, like what America says that it wants to be. And in 2020, it is the reality of America, where, you know, this is a musical that whitewashes history by using colorblind casting.

And it, you know, right now it's been so eye-opening to me. I've been telling this to a lot of people, how so many of the things that are happening right now with police brutality, with corruption in government, with immigration, obviously, with the military and the cops like unleashing their violence in people. I never thought that I would see that in America, because those are the things that America does to the rest of the world. And it is really terrifying for me to be here and recognizing some of the things that I'm seeing, you know, the fireworks and the sound torture that they're using right now, the way in which this president's family is like, you know, disregarding the constitution completely and just like emptying their pockets and so much corruption, the disaster that there is right now with COVID-19, those are things that I thought, I never thought in a million years that I would see in America.

Those are the things that America helps cause in the world. So right now every day I'm thinking, okay, if I went to the place where I was going to be saved and safe from these things, but now I'm seeing the government do these same things to its citizens.

[29:36] Heath Saunders: Where the fuck am I going to migrate next, right? Like it's uh is outer space the place for me to be in. Uh it's I I would I would just uh love to sort of one of the things that's really interesting, I think, with with blackness in America is that the the thing that you're describing about the thing that America would never do to its own citizens, that story has never been true for the black body in America. That so for me, I have a little bit of a uh a reactivity to the notion that that America would never do this to its own citizens, because that that for me is a little bit that's just a difficult thing as a concept for me. Um and one of the things that I think is uh uh very interesting about Hamilton, and this is sort of for me, specifically what's different about Hamilton in 2015 versus Hamilton now, is for me, I have I have better contextualized the American relationship to the black body in a way that makes it so when I saw Hamilton before, what I was witnessing as a black person was looking at the possibility of achievement given to the black body.

So I was witnessing black bodies achieve things, and I was like, this is a glorious coup. This is amazing. I am I am so thrilled to see Renee Elise Goldsberry on stage being a complicated and interesting character in a way that black bodies are not afforded that space. I think Leslie Odom Jr. delivers a performance of a lifetime in the show. This is an exciting thing for me. For me, within my own understanding of blackness and America, when I now look at when with this sort of newly opened, reopened eyes about the way that this country treats the black body, and I put that story on top of the story of Hamilton, and I go, oh, so what has happened in Hamilton is not a celebration of the black body.

It feels like the use of the black body to better make a story about whiteness more palatable to us. And that for me is the thing that's like very different. I have this, and again, as a person who loves the musical theater and I love well-executed musical theater, I'm like, huzzah musical theater, I love this in this thing. But then when I sort of think about the context of what I'm seeing, which the show does very little to actually acknowledge or sort of point out to us, when I think about the context of using black bodies, and I mean specifically black bodies in this context, there are spaces in which the BIPOC experience is in fact a holistic and a and a gathered experience. But within the experience of America, the experience of the black body is unique.

And the way that that this b this show specifically erases the experience of the black body at that time, I find it that the the cognitive dissonance that I have to put into the watching of the show to buy into the story to say that, yes, I can, I, a black body can be concerned with my own legacy beyond my concern with my literal survival, is a is a really hard uh it's a hard space to carry those two stories together, which to me has nothing to do with historicity of the show. I'm not interested in like whether I I I understand that this is a that that Hamilton is is that an article came out today that was talking about how it's a fan fiction, that it's a it's a deliberate reclamation of history.

The thing about fan fiction is that fan fiction is taking an established story that we know, we know and be culturally understand as a story and then reclaiming a story. The problem that I have with the history in Hamilton is that we're only just now, I feel like reckoning in a real way with the fact that history is in fact a fiction. So the relationship between the story that is Hamilton and and the story that is the fictional history, I love that people are like, yay, this is a this is wonderful. People get to sort of take apart and reclaim pieces, and like I love that. But if you tell me Harry Potter rewritten with black people, I'm like, oh sorry, not Harry Potter, we canceled that. I don't want to deal with Harry Potter.

Everything is not safe. Everything is canceled in 2020. No, but if we take, but if we take a story like, you know, let's let's take a any uh a fictional story, like oh my the only thing that I'm coming into. Like Cinderella. Like Cinderella, right? And we reclaim Cinderella and we like that for me is like we're reclaiming a fairy tale, and the power in reclaiming fairy tales is about the open power of changing the myth. And for me, we're not explicitly doing that with American history, or at least it doesn't feel like everyone is doing that. And I wanna, I'm very interested in shattering the myth of American history right now. So for me, Hamilton in 2020 doesn't actually, actively work to shatter the miss the myth of America.

And in fact, it continues to reassert the story of American exceptionalism, the story that there are individual men, always men, who impacted the change of the world in great and inspiring ways. Our founding fathers existed. And Hamilton does not confront that version of history. The thing that Hamilton confronts is that you can put a different body on stage and a different story can be told. And that for me is the thing that's like deeply Obama-era, which is like, yeah, we have a black president, and therefore we have worked to dismantle these things. Yeah, we have a black person playing Burr, therefore we have sort of moved beyond this thing. And I think right now we're in this wonderful and terrifying moment where we're able to look more deeply at that relationship and actually say to ourselves and to others, be like, wow, I don't know that history went like this.

I don't know that it's the story of these extraordinary white men who did things. I think they might have had blind spots too. And I and again, I it's not to say that Hamilton doesn't say that these people have blind spots, that they're not people. It is a great story, right? The story of Hamilton is great. But my question is, how does it, how does it contribute to what our culture is saying about ourselves, about our relationship between the bodies in our in our country right now, about uh just about life. And that for me is where the sort of difference really lies, which is like I don't want to, I don't want to talk about whether Hamilton is good or bad. Hamilton's great. Like it's just so well done.

Like the craft on display is extraordinary. But but the insidious thing, what we're actually saying, which is you know, that America is amazing in specific, specifically that America is just a genius project, is like white white people love that story. But I wonder if the way that Hamilton has been received is so much because of who had access to see it.

[37:15] Kelundra Smith: Um so I will say that I saw Hamilton in October, I believe in 2018 of 2018, but I think earlier that year I had already seen John Leguizamo's Latin History for Morons. So actually seeing Latin History for Morons before you see Hamilton, I feel like totally changes the way you see Hamilton. I should watch it. And so, and it's on it's on Netflix too. Um, but I saw it in New York on stage, um, at what was it, Roundabout at Studio 54, I think it were is where it was. And I will say that that theater experience at Latin History for Morons was the kind of theater experience I wanted to have at Hamilton because the audience at John Leguizamo's show was all brown all around, to quote Sandra Ceneros, okay.

And um it was the first time I'd ever sat in an audience on Broadway that was all brown all around like that. And then it's like John Leguizamo giving you this context and this history inside of his own personal story. So I I definitely had the experience of carrying that with me before seeing Hamilton. Now, when we talk about the world of 2015 versus the world of 2020, I think that all of you have made salient points. I will say that when I saw the musical the first time, I was impressed by the stagecraft. I mean, you can't, the technique, I mean, it's it's Western musical theater done exquisitely. Um, but I will it was always a fiction to me. I, in the way that the Skylar sister story was handled, the misogyny was just more than I could, you know, stomach for one sitting in the first time I saw it.

And I felt the same way when I watched it on Disney Plus. Um, and and even with the woman who he has an affair with and that whole bit. I mean, comedian Katherine Ryan does an excellent bit in her stand-up comedy special Glitter Room where she talks about how like this woman went to her representative because her husband was abusing her and he ends up sleeping with her. It's like, yes, this is this is only the way a my a man would write this. Like, what do you mean say no to this? Like, she's desperate. Say no. She has to sleep with you to get help. Like, stop it. So um, so that was always like problematic to me. And then the handling of the three-fifths compromise and the way it's kind of like glossed over and like sales, and it's like, but you know, Eliza redeems the legacy by being an abolitionist, and it's like, no, like the three-fifths compromise is literally what we are dealing with in the streets of every city in America right today.

So when we talk about 2015 versus now, um, I think that the only difference for me and how I view it is that looking at the revolutionary war scenes in 2020 versus the revolutionary war that's happening on the streets of America right now, the war scenes struck me differently because it seems as if we are on the verge of another sort of revolutionary war, and we don't know what our constitution and what will the Federalist papers, right, of 2020 be versus what they were in 1776. I think that's where it's a little different for me because the issues have not changed for people of color in this country between 2015 and 2020. The issue is still higher unemployment rates, inequitable access to health care, ummation detention and deportation being absolutely out of control, police brutality being out of control.

I mean, we have to remember that during I mean, police brutality against black folks has been an issue since the beginning of this country, you know. Like I mean, I mean, right. Since I mean, it's it's one of those things where it's like we had killings of unarmed black people happening in 2015 and in 2016 and 2017, and they were happening in 2000 and they were happening in 95, and they were happening in 85, and they were happening in 65. You know, so I think that we have to recognize reconcile that. Mass behind ideas today that we didn't have in 2015. I think generally speaking, we have more critical mass around the idea that ice needs to be abolished. I think we have more critical mass behind the idea that the way policing currently works in this country doesn't work, and that stand your ground laws in this country enables white people to kill people of color without consequence.

I think we have more critical mass behind that. I think we have more critical mass behind women's bodies and how women have never had full agency over their own bodies in this country. So I think we have more critical mass behind the ideas that the founding of the of this country didn't honor today than we did at 2015. But I don't see Hamilton, I guess, for me any differently today than I did in 2015 in 20 when I listened to it in 2015 or saw it in 2018, because it was always a fiction to me.

[43:16] Heath Saunders: I love comedy and manners. That's what my own.

[43:33] Kelundra Smith: Yeah. I know I I I've spoken a lot, but I want to, I want to, I I I love what you everything you've just said. I I I want to underline something that I I or or rather I I'm interested in in making sure that as I look at Hamilton, that in all of the spaces in which Hamilton is problematic, that I also think that Hamilton also happened at you know in 2015, and I think it represented a shift in a conversation that I think it was absolutely like that cannot be taken away. The importance of the shift that Hamilton did, which was which was actually about divorcing character from body, which was a defense of white American theater that for uh decades, right?

[44:23] Kelundra Smith: As long as white American theater has been around, they've been defending the fact that these characters would never look like X, Y, or Z thing. So Hamilton did an amazing, like scalpel-like attack on that particular instantiation of white supremacy. And I think that we would not be in this conversation. The beautiful conversation between the four of us wouldn't exist without the existence of these sorts of things, right? The critical mass that you're referring to. It's like Hamilton contributed to that move, if nothing else, even if it's still problematic, even if it's like in all in the face of all of those sort of it's problematic spaces that also was this is a we're we I think we're we we gotta just keep moving forward. We gotta keep thinking about the things that we can change rather than being like no Hamilton was it because I think that it's just obvious that Hamilton wasn't it. It was just a really great moment.

[45:22] Heath Saunders: Absolutely. I think that you're 100% correct. And I think that, like I said, there are things that Hamilton to me and Lynn Manuel Miranda, I would argue did this with In the Heights as well. I still love the book of In the Heights more, because I think Kiara Huda escape it in like a nice balance that is missing from Hamilton, and she's just a bang and playwright. But um, you know, I think that Hamilton raised the bar, as people of color, immigrants in particular, always do. You know what I mean? Like big shocker that as soon as you give a black and brown cast a bunch of money and investment, they raise the standard for all musical theater for the end of time. Shocking no more. It's like you we can sing, shut up.

You know what I mean? You should go to a church on a Sunday. Um, so I mean, I think we can dance, stop it. Um, you know what I mean? So I think that you know, it showed off what we are capable of when invested in 100%. And I think that's something that Hamilton does well. And I think also providing jobs is something that has done well. I mean, we can't deny the fact that when you have three touring casts going simultaneously, how many hundreds of people is that employing that otherwise would not have been employed? So I think we have to give that credit, but also acknowledge, you know, the spaces in which there are plot holes and there are um and a hero has been made of someone who did horrible things as a result of having a musical named after him.

[47:04] Kelundra Smith: Again, though that goes back to the point I made earlier of I'm not sure if a hero would have been made of him as much had the audience that had access to see it early on been more reflective of this country as opposed to of the elite who could afford the ticket. I want to say, Kalandra, that I love that you brought up the Psychogenic because like immediately after going to that show, I remember saying, like, Hamilton is for me at least the most boring, dull character in the show. And I'm like, how are all of this like super like cool, like interesting, complex women in love with this guy who's so bland? So I was like, I didn't get it from the beginning. So and it still doesn't work. I still don't know how, you know, I still don't get it, but whatever.

Um so we we are talking about how Hamilton is the perfect musical, you know, to have come out of the Obama era. Because in many ways, Lynn Manuel also is very much like Obama in that, you know, for people of color, for people who are black and non-black people of color also, we have so, you know, such few, like there's such few, such a few number of people that we can look up to that it is very difficult for us to then acknowledge that they have a bad side, that they have that problematic side that we like talking about.

[48:20] Jose Solis: And I mean, I've told Deep many, many times how much I how many problems I had with Hamilton, and it's been refreshing for me to see now that the musical is available for everyone to see how I was like, oh god, I wasn't alone all of this time. And it's important then that we address uh what is our third and final bill for today's session, and it's the uh the burden of representation. How when we have a person who's not white become, you know, be under the spotlight, by default, they end up having to represent everyone. And we are not giving them the liberty to be human beings, to be complex, to be, you know, both to have both negative and very positive sides. Like we just want them to be perfect, and this leads to poor Lynn for instance or even poor Obama to become holy cows were to question their choices we feel sometimes like we are betraying ourselves and that we are siding with the people who have oppressed us for so long.

[49:29] Kelundra Smith: It was very heartbreaking for me to see over the weekend when I am sure that for the very first time ever Lynn Manuel Miranda was reading people react negatively to a show that was received with universal acclaimer like you pointed out by mostly white press and I wonder now even if those people would have helped you know those white critics would have felt comfortable saying if they had any problems with the show. Not that I want more you know reviews by white critics by and it's it's very it's very heartbreaking because you know probably yeah this man for the first time over the weekend saw oh wow that people you know maybe don't have only a hundred percent positive feedback to say about my musical and I don't know if all of you saw that for a few hours over the weekend he made his Twitter account private and you know as a human being you can't help but be heartbroken right for someone to read bad things about themselves and uh and realize that you know it's impossible to be a holy cow it's impossible to be a saint and why we are not giving um artists who aren't white and people who aren't white basically the same opportunity that we give you know other people where we're like, okay, like let's separate the art from the artist from the Roman Polanski and like Woody Allen and all that stuff.

[50:51] Heath Saunders: And instead, we want, you know, no one's saying that Woody Allen or Roman Polansky for instance, or Harry Weinstein, or like enter like X number of problematic men, uh white men and women, right? But we expect our people to be perfect, and that is not fair. So I wonder, you know, like for the sake of transparency, if all of you would be okay with maybe answering the following question. How are we in our own way problematic? Because we are Lynn, we are Obama, we are every person who's not white who has had to carry that weight. And first of all, I was presumptuous. Do all of you feel that? Have all of you felt that at any point that you have to represent everyone from your community and everyone from, you know, like if I don't, if I you know, if I fail at my job, they're never gonna hire a Latino again, in my case.

Like, I feel that. Like if I fail at my job, they're never gonna uh hire an immigrant again. And I wonder for shortists if that's true for all of you. And if it is, would you be comfortable talking about what makes you problematic?

[51:58] Kelundra Smith: Should I go first?

[52:00] Heath Saunders: Yes.

[52:01] Kelundra Smith: Yeah, okay, I'll go first.

[52:02] Jose Solis: Okay.

[52:03] Kelundra Smith: Uh I'm extremely problematic in the many ways in which I have refused to see that I am not wanted, perhaps, in white institutions and white organizations. And instead, I have tried to bring in more people of color to join me. And perhaps not necessarily, I mean, in part because I want to see more people of color and non-white people join me in those places, right? But also I've been wondering, uh, as I've been thinking about this question, is it also because I'm just tired of being alone and I want to share my misery with these people? Like, why should I be the only one suffering? And I mean, this is in fact one of the uh things that led me to uh I've been in the process of creating like a theater critics uh institution, you know, organization, sorry, uh, for critics of color.

And I said to myself, like, stop bringing you know your people in to share the pain with you, and instead just like create something new. Like I have been very problematic in not learning that I don't need to please white people, that I can please myself and I can please you know the people who need to be pleased, actually, instead of like imposing the same rules of whiteness in all of them.

[53:27] Heath Saunders: And obviously, you know, these are things that are ingrained in all of us. I was trying to explain to someone over the weekend that uh Latinos uh are extremely problematic because we are raised on anti-blackness, and you know, we only get to see movies at TV made made in the United States, where we see, you know, we see ourselves as drug dealers, partners, we see uh Middle Eastern people as terrorists, and we see uh black people as you know criminals, and like they're always like the person who's like really bad. And because we become brainwashed by all that media that America is exporting, we aspire to be white. And I am very grateful uh to have come to the United States because I can see that how you know, that's all an illusion, it was all a myth. Like we were we're being taught to not fight with our brothers and sisters, and instead to fight for whiteness when we're we aren't white. So thank you for listening.

[54:29] Heath Saunders: I was gonna I will say that um for me I don't know that I have ever felt the need to represent my entire community and felt my carry my own whole community on my back, but I also don't know what it's like to not have been taught that I am doing that at all times anyway, you know. So I I can't even distinguish between my own feeling versus what I was brought up to know and believe, which is that you know you are always a representative of X of your community of the Black community, and and you have to you know make sure not to come off as like um unintelligent or angry or what have you, you know, you're busting up stereotypes every every door you knock down. Um so I don't know, like I can't even distinguish between my own feeling about that versus what I was taught my whole life, to be honest with you.

[55:27] Kelundra Smith: Um and then and as far as where am I problematic, um I would say that I think that I am have been problematic in, I think I can agree with you in some ways, Jose, in trying to integrate spaces where uh that didn't that claim to want integration but actually weren't willing to do the work of of integration, right? So I think that there's there's definitely some of that there. And I also think um in maybe not pushing harder for um art created by people of color to get the same type of coverage as work created by white folks. Because I think one of the sinister things about trying to come up in media um in particular, and as you all may know, is that there you as the writer of color have to prove that you can critique the white work before you're allowed to only critique the work created by people of color, right?

[56:44] Jose Solis: Um it's usually one of two experiences.

[56:47] Heath Saunders: Either you get your weight in the door by developing your voice, critiquing work and writing about people of color, or and or you have to prove that you have a knowledge of this white canon because your canon isn't enough, right?

[57:01] Kelundra Smith: Um, to be able to be taken seriously by certain publications, and so it's like, okay, if I concede my byline in as many places as possible to prove that I'm able to write about these things better than my white peers, because you can't be just as good, you have to be better.

[57:21] Heath Saunders: Then I can start to write about the Asian stuff, the black stuff, the Latin stuff, the indigenous stuff, and start to pull more of that in there. And I think buying into the idea that like those were the steps to being able to do that, this may be a place where I have been problematic.

[57:41] Kelundra Smith: Um now I will say today, right now, I think I'm just like, I'm with the rest of the world on like the F at all. And there's no more censoring.

[57:53] Heath Saunders: There's no more flague nice.

[57:55] Kelundra Smith: There's no more, it's just like whatever.

[57:59] Heath Saunders: Um, but I can I can honestly say, especially throughout my 20s, feeling like, okay, if I can get in here and get them comfortable with this, then I can be able to do this. When it's like instead of going from point C to point A to M to K, it's like just straight shot it.

[58:22] Kelundra Smith: I don't know if anything I just said made any sense.

[58:25] Heath Saunders: Yeah, I I hear you.

[58:26] Kelundra Smith: It was great.

[58:27] Heath Saunders: Okay.

[58:28] Kelundra Smith: I was like, I feel like I'm just like other than the like, thank you for following me.

[58:32] Heath Saunders: I was like, oh god, no one's gonna say anything, and then we're gonna leave.

[58:35] Kelundra Smith: We're gonna just leave having Jose be like, I'm problematic.

[58:38] Heath Saunders: We're all like, thank you, bye.

[58:39] Kelundra Smith: That's canceled.

[58:41] Heath Saunders: Guy tomorrow.

[58:42] Kelundra Smith: Yeah.

[58:43] Heath Saunders: You know, I don't we're not canceling.

[58:45] Kelundra Smith: I'm I'm not in favor of cancellation unless you don't want forgiveness or to do better.

[58:50] Heath Saunders: If people who want to do better can be redeemed, if you don't want to do better, then you're canceled.

[58:57] Kelundra Smith: Yeah, I I would connect the two questions you've asked.

[59:02] Heath Saunders: Uh, I'm gonna answer the second by answering the first. Uh, which is I think I haven't really felt a responsibility toward my identity. Uh, and I believe that that's actually one of my most problematic traits. Uh, I am very loath to lead with my identity in any context. Uh, so much so that I aggressively will not lead. For many years, uh, I I'm big on I for many years, I actually actively didn't tell people my race because in theater what I look like is the thing that mattered. I never get to play as an actor. I very rarely, if ever, play my ethnicity on stage because people see me and they see something else, and so I get called in for and cast as things that I am not, which has made me very interested in the authenticity question for many years because if the question is that if the statement is that people can only play the thing that they are, I basically have no career as an actor because nobody sees the thing I am as what I am, which becomes this whole complicated thing which actually results in my presentation being very much interested in.

I'm I've always been really interested in fluidity, and fluidity is for me, I say I use a trick that I call slippage, which is that I let somebody else define me and then I explain to them how I'm not that thing, which is very different than me stepping forward and defining myself.

[1:00:58] Heath Saunders: And the thing is what I've sort of recognized in the last month or two especially is the ways in which that story that I tell myself is actually a tool of the white patriarchy, that my ability to define to sort of dodge questions of who I am is actually about my proximity to whiteness. That because I believe that whiteness is a thing that allows people to define themselves for other people. So if you have the privilege to define yourself as by whatever you want to say you are rather than by what people see you as, I think that that's a real profound space of privilege that people have and people don't question. And it has only been very recently that I've actually been reckoning with the fact that I have played into that story by actively trying to dodge questions of my own identity.

Um, and that's been a, I mean, that's a really tough concept because on one hand, I don't want to, it's really easy for me to sort of be in a space and see myself as in the space because of my body of color or because of my sexuality or because of my gender identity or because of my neurodivergence. I can basically take all these things about myself and be like the reason I'm in this space is this thing. But what I have tended towards doing is basically pretending like those things don't matter. And pretending like those things don't matter, I think is again a tool of the ruling class. The ruling class keeps itself in power by pretending like these things don't matter. So that if somebody, if you don't get a job, it's not that you're a black person, it's that you didn't work hard enough.

That story, that's the illusion, that's the story of white supremacy that I've been told. And reckoning with the ways in which my own sense of exceptionalism, like the ways in which I'm different or better than another person, is tied to that story as told by the ruling class. And that's a deeply difficult thing to reckon with.

[1:03:22] Heath Saunders: And I like talking about it in terms of theater because it gives me a nice structure within that has language that I can use to talk about the system of theater. It is much harder to talk about that in terms of my own self, my experience of self in the world. I don't know if any, again, I too don't know if any of that made sense, but it is that's it's a challenge to be alive.

[1:03:49] Kelundra Smith: Yeah. No, it it's like it's like the difference between like what you want and what you're willing to settle for. And I think in terms of like, you know, all of us working in white spaces and working within this industry, and you know, to take you back to the Hamilton conversation, I think the reason the musical was so impactful was because we had never seen that kind of complexity from bodies of color on the stage. And so at the time it felt like something revolutionary when maybe I think, and I think that's kind of ties in what makes me problematic was the fact that for so long I've accepted incrementalism in exchange for progress. And we all thought, oh, Hamilton happened, so therefore we will get to the next phase.

And then now in 2020, I'm realizing, oh no, there's mainly only white people being produced in 2021. I'm bright right now. We are never going to get to get to the next phase. Maybe it's time to actually burn it all down. And I feel like for me especially, I've been really late to that part of turning my brain onto that part because I had been so obsessed for a long time with getting approval from white power structures and thinking I can fix things within those white power structures, and that's the only way to do it. And now I'm wondering, and now I'm thinking perhaps this Hamilton wasn't enough. Like these small steps were not enough. And we need to be asking for more. And by we, I mean me. I don't I'm not really telling you, but I don't want to tell you guys what to do.

[1:05:26] Heath Saunders: No, I think you're absolutely right. I always say I want my mansion in the sky. The cabin in the sky is not enough. I want the mansion I was promised. Like that's my thing. I I'm with you 100%.

[1:05:41] Kelundra Smith: Well, thank you all. Like I it sounds crazy, but my idea of a perfect world, I guess of a perfect America would be one in which all of us, you know, whether white or not white are allowed to be problematic and complex. And we are so far away from that that I guess we, you know, I thank Lin-Manuel Miranda's and I thank Obama and Hamilton for giving us an opportunity to have a conversation like this. It's it was it's been very moving. Thank you all for sharing. And I'm sorry that I tried that out of your life. Thank you all for having us on and sharing your platform. I'm very proud of you and what you all have done over the last few years. You have shaken up the conversation, and I think um given some artists even the inspiration to shake up the conversation where they can. So kudos to you.

[1:06:32] Heath Saunders: Yes, thank you. Thank you for having me on. I'm this has been an inspiring 90 minutes.

[1:06:39] Kelundra Smith: Yeah, I cannot believe it took 90 minutes. So many thoughts that I know, and I was like, and I was like, I have a whole list of things that we didn't even talk about. I'm like, oh, yeah, okay. Right.

[1:06:50] Heath Saunders: Yeah, we had four bills originally, but I was like, let's insert the last one because that's one I feel is very important.

[1:07:00] Kelundra Smith: What was the bill we missed? Can you tell us in this last two minutes before you hang up? What was the bill we missed?

[1:07:01] Heath Saunders: I don't even remember. Uh, like talking about the backlash, talking about like what the musical didn't address and how it could address it, or maybe not, because do you expect Lin-Manuel Miranda's to talk about slavery in a nuanced way that will satisfy everybody?

[1:07:21] Kelundra Smith: Oh no, I just I wanna I absolutely not, but I also want to clarify one of the things that we have done is we have done a slippage point where we talk about Lin-Manuel Miranda's as though he's the primary creator of this show, which he is, and Lin-Manuel Miranda's is in fact a body of color, so like go him. But the four creators of that show are in fact four cis men, three of whom are white. So I it's really important for me that in all of our conversations about how great Lin-Manuel Miranda's is, we recognize that the structure that Lin-Manuel Miranda's represents is that a group of white men have basically put him at the forefront of the structure within the context of this genius narrative to allow him to be the unique and exceptional person of color in a system that serves a set of white bodies, a set of white male bodies, a set of cis white male bodies, a set of straight cis white male bodies.

[1:08:16] Heath Saunders: And as a caveat to that, I know y'all have to hang out. But it's like it's like if we're like Kanye. We can be late. We're like Kanye and Taylor and you right now, we're like, and let's just think for a little bit. But also, I think it's worth saying that within the Latinx community, right? Lin-Manuel is a white Puerto Rican. Right. He's not of he's not Afro-Latino. He does not identify as Afro-Latino. Okay. The reason he was cast as the chimney sweep in Mary Poppins is because he's not Afro-Latino. So I think that is also just an important thing to note is that he is a person of color. He does speak from a specific lens. I like I said, not discounting the inclusion of what he's done with like Freestyle Love Supreme and In the Heights and Hamilton and blah blah blah blah blah.

But he has proximity to privilege by virtue of not being Afro-Latino. And is educated in, you know, the that in the way that many of us were, that most of us on this hall were, with the exception of Jose, you know, educated in PWIs and learned the way to navigate them. Um, you know, there's there's a set of tips and tricks that code switching gives your toolbox, you know what I mean, that that everybody doesn't have access to, where you know how to get things out of people because you've learned how, because you studied them.

[1:09:50] Kelundra Smith: You'd be surprised, Kelundra, because I went to American School in Honduras, and I know everything about the American Revolution, and I don't know who the Honduran national heroes are. I don't know, we were not taught anything about like the indigenous tribes over there. And in fact, uh, and I lived in Costa Rica when I was an adult. In fact, I had someone who lives in Costa Rica who told me black taste, there are no black people in Costa Rica. And my mouth just like, you know, my jaw felt like, yeah, you would be surprised with how how much America influences the way the rest of us all over the world educate it and what we are taught and what we are allowed to think and not think about.

[1:10:31] Heath Saunders: So thank you both again for this. It was such a pleasure. It was such a joy.

[1:10:36] Kelundra Smith: Oh, thank you all. Like, this is longer than we thought, and so I am so appreciative that you both took the time to do this with us. Now we're all gonna be like, no, you hang out. No, you hang out.

[1:10:49] Heath Saunders: Yeah, okay. I'll hang up.

[1:10:52] Kelundra Smith: All right. Bye bye.

[1:10:56] Jose Solis: Oh my goodness, the world is not wide enough for that conversation. That was so much, Jose. And we left out.

[1:12:01] Jose Solis: It's so you you don't like talking to me. You want to go talk to other people?

[1:12:01] Heath Saunders: Can you imagine if we had we left stuff out?

[1:12:01] Kelundra Smith: I know. We didn't even talk about any.

[1:12:01] Jose Solis: I know. We didn't even talk about any of the acting.

[1:12:01] Heath Saunders: Or the history, or yeah.

[1:12:01] Kelundra Smith: Yeah, but you know what? I hope what you take away from this conversation is the fact that you can like something or admire it, and you can all and it can also be problematic. And you know, it's okay, it's okay to have both. Most of the brilliant things in life have both.

[1:12:01] Heath Saunders: Yeah, we are all problematic.

[1:12:01] Kelundra Smith: Have multiple dimensions, yes, we are all problematic. Even Lin-Manuel Miranda, you know, Disney does not want you to be problematic, but you know what? We want you to be problematic. I it's good for the culture.

[1:12:01] Jose Solis: Yep. I mean, who is more problematic than Disney, right? So, anyway, thank you so much, Heath and Kelundra for joining us. It was such a joy, it's like one of my favorite episodes, I think, that we've recorded.

[1:12:01] Heath Saunders: Oh wow.

[1:12:03] Heath Saunders: No, I mean it's always so exciting because I felt like you know, like it's like the squad, you know.

[1:12:09] Kelundra Smith: Work, work, Alexandra.

[1:12:12] Jose Solis: Oh my god. Yes.

[1:12:14] Kelundra Smith: It scans.

[1:12:15] Jose Solis: It could it totally scans.

[1:12:17] Kelundra Smith: Alexandra.

[1:12:18] Heath Saunders: Il hand and Diana.

[1:12:24] Jose Solis: The Congressional Sisters.

[1:12:25] Kelundra Smith: Oh, we were missing one of them. Now I feel so bad.

[1:12:27] Heath Saunders: We're missing Rashida.

[1:12:29] Kelundra Smith: Sorry.

[1:12:30] Heath Saunders: Yes, we're missing Rashida. Sorry. She can be Aaron Burr. It's fine.

[1:12:34] Kelundra Smith: Okay. So thank you for tuning in for part two of our super Avengers Infinity War episode. We did a lot this week. And so if you would like to support us by helping us do more stuff, you can support our Patreon at Patreon slash Token Theater Friends.

[1:12:53] Jose Solis: And for as little as a dollar a month, you can help us run the show. Like run our website. Like we we do so much. And you know, help is good. You know, we are all a team. This is kind of like you know, all of the cast of Hamilton coming together to create something great. Come join our cast. And hopefully we won't be as problematic. Fingers crossed again.

[1:13:22] Kelundra Smith: So we'll see you next time. Hopefully, next week there will be only one episode. Alright, bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred