Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep. 76: The Eras Tour as Theatre

In this episode, Jose is joined by fellow Swifties (and BIPOC Critics Lab alumni) Maria Paz Alegre and Octavia Washington, to discuss Taylor Swift: The Eras Tour... Read More

From the show: Token Theatre Friends

49 mins
12/12/23

About

In this episode, Jose is joined by fellow Swifties (and BIPOC Critics Lab alumni) Maria Paz Alegre and Octavia Washington, to discuss Taylor Swift: The Eras Tour. The blockbuster concert film, which has grossed over $250 million worldwide, is out on demand and for rental on December 13th (Happy birthday, TayTay!) In addition to being what Jose describes as the greatest experience he's ever had at a movie theater, Maria Paz and Octavia comment on Swift's insightful writing, and how much theatre can learn from Swift.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Jose Solis: Welcome to Token Theater Friends. I'm Jose Solis, a freelance culture critic, and today I'm joined by Maria Paz Alegre.

[0:20] Maria Paz Alegre: I am a librarian in New York City and the judge of the 2024 Caldecott Award.

[0:27] Octavia Washington: And I'm Octavia Washington. I'm a dramaturgy student at Columbia University.

[0:33] Octavia Washington: And, uh, I don't know, a Swifty.

[0:39] Jose Solis: That's a great, that's a perfect segue, Octavia, into what we're talking about today, which is we all went to the Eras Tour film, and Octavia will brag about having seen the show live in a second, but we wanted to talk about the Eras Tour film as some sort of recorded theater. If that is, you know, like even I don't, I don't even know what people are calling it nowadays. Like, do we have an official name for what people are calling recorded live performance?

[1:14] Maria Paz Alegre: No, the National Theater has their like theater at home whatever thing.

[1:20] Jose Solis: That's pretty much it. Theater at home, digital theater, the zoomies.

[1:25] Maria Paz Alegre: So Taylor at home, I guess is what we're gonna go for.

[1:29] Jose Solis: Except it wasn't at home. It was, it was still in the cinemas, but yeah. I mean, I I'm sure we're gonna end up watching it at home like many times when it comes out. Like I saw that the street merch are like having a huge like battle over who gets to own it.

[1:45] Maria Paz Alegre: So I mean, I wouldn't put it past.

[1:48] Jose Solis: What was that?

[1:50] Maria Paz Alegre: Supposed to come out on Prime.

[1:52] Jose Solis: Oh, it will be.

[1:54] Maria Paz Alegre: Huh.

[1:54] Jose Solis: So who knew Jeff Bezos 50?

[1:57] Maria Paz Alegre: Swifty.

[1:57] Jose Solis: I mean, good for him. So before we get started talking about the Eras Tour film, I want to hear your Swifty origin stories.

[2:11] Maria Paz Alegre: I can go first. I hate to say this, but I'm, uh, I'm late to the game. I'm a, uh, I am not an OG Swifty. I always liked Taylor Swift. I always found her music to be really fun. I listened to the hits, you know, "Shake It Off," "Style," "Blank Space," and I liked them. But there was nothing, there's nothing particularly deeper. But, uh, this time last year, I, uh, I got divorced, and, uh, it was a little complicated. We weren't, we weren't married, but we were, we had so many shared assets together, so we had to divorce our assets. So anyway, I've been calling it the divorce. And I don't know how this happened, but somehow her music started to kind of infiltrate my, um, my playlists, and the more and more I listened to it, the more I really just fell in love with her songwriting. She has some really, really good, uh, love stories, but she also has really, really, really good breakup music. And I, I converted, I completely converted to the Church of Swifty. "All Too Well."

[3:24] Jose Solis: Um, what happened to me? God, it was so long ago. Um, it's been a roller coaster ride. We've been on and off, I would say. Um, we're the famous, um, on and off couple, me and Taylor Swift. It started with "Speak Now." I was, uh, like I missed the "Fearless" era and then "Speak Now," the reason I started listening to it was because I found out she wrote all the songs, and I was like, "Oh, that's so cool. I wanna be a writer. Let me give her a listen." So that was when did "Speak Now" come out?

[4:00] Maria Paz Alegre: That's like 2010.

[4:01] Jose Solis: Yeah, I think so. I mean, we're gonna have to week it, yeah. Uh, yeah, so yeah. In middle school, and then I was listening to Taylor Swift "Speak Now," like in the privacy of the kitchen. Um, doing it completely alone. All my friends were in their like One Direction phase. And I just, I didn't talk about my love of Taylor Swift to anybody except myself. Although apparently my mom like was pretty much a part of my journey. Um, because I remember the other day one of her, when "Speak Now" the re-release came out and I put on "Enchanted" and she was singing some of the words, and I was like, "You know this song?" And she was like, "Duh, I grew up next to you when you were in the kitchen listening to 'Speak Now' by yourself. I was in the other room overhearing it." So that's kind of crazy.

[4:57] Maria Paz Alegre: That is so cute, and like every time you say kitchen, I keep wanting to say "by the refrigerator light."

[5:03] Jose Solis: So we're just gonna add that.

[5:06] Maria Paz Alegre: Not by the refrigerator light, no, unfortunately, but definitely watching sparks fly, you know.

[5:13] Jose Solis: Oh, I love that.

[5:15] Octavia Washington: Well done, Octavia. So I think that, you know, like for full disclosure, Maddie Up House at Octavia are current cohort members of the, uh, BIPOC Critics Lab that we're doing at the Public Theater. And I'm pretty sure that I've told you my Swifty origin story before because I actually teach it. I have to say that I came to Taylor through this very, um, gross way. Like I, you know, like being, uh, a man, I was a very gross, you know, sexist, misogynistic, I guess, man, who thought she was just this like dumb girl who kept singing about boys when all along I was also like a dumb boy thinking about boys. And then this one day I read this piece in the New Yorker called "You Belong With Me" by Lizzie Witticombe.

And I was on this, uh, you know, bus ride in Costa Rica that went on for like six hours, and I had devoured every piece in my New Yorker, except for the Taylor Swift piece, because I was, I was like, "I don't want to engage with this." But then I had nothing else to read, so I read that piece. I was so mind-blown by her work ethic, by how smart she was, by the way that she spoke about her craft and her lyrics, that by the time that I arrived at my destination six hours later, I had bought, I mean, I don't think we had Spotify back then, but I had bought every Taylor album available on iTunes, and it's been a love story ever since. So it's one of the, um, it's one of the pieces that I used to teach the power of current journalism, and you know, like good arts journalism.

So that was my Swifty origin story. And as all of you know by now, like I'm, I'm obsessed. Like, it's ridiculous. Like, I have five Taylor Swift tattoos, which is written. Like, maybe if she ever listens to this, Taylor, I don't think anyone has more Taylor tattoos than I do. So please come say hi to me sometime.

[7:27] Jose Solis: So we all went to the Eras Tour film. So who would like to tell us a little bit about what it is? Like, I don't think of, I don't know that there's a plot to it, but what is the Eras Tour film?

[7:42] Maria Paz Alegre: I can go. She, um, the Eras Tour film is a recorded live of her concert, and specifically it was her last concert on the Eras Tour in the United States at SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles, and they recorded every song, and the only difference I think was that there were a few songs that were left out, but I think the biggest reason is that, uh, the tour was so expensive, and you know, there's only a certain amount of seats that are available for people to go, and I couldn't, I couldn't get one. And when she, when she announced the movie, it was this ultimate relief because honestly, I felt so left out that I was watching every TikTok video that I could of her and all of her fans and living so vicariously. So it was so fun to actually have a live experience. And when she, uh, when she tweeted about this, she said, "When you're in the theater, go nuts." And so I was more than happy to sing my heart out and dance as everybody else did too.

[8:50] Jose Solis: Amen. Can we talk a little bit about that? Because like that's one of the things that I love the most about the Eras Tour film's experience. Like I, you know, being a big Swifty and everything, I clearly have this huge bias, but I have never had such an amazing experience at the movie theater like I did watching this film. And I don't think I've ever had such an amazing experience in community in a theater of any kind ever. And basically, what you're just saying, my past is like we broke the rules, like we got off our seats. Like I asked my friend that came with me to slow dance with me to "Lover" on the aisle. And I was like, "What the hell am I doing?" Like, this is not love that. I mean, she started crying.

She was like, "This is the most romantic thing that's happened to me in years." And I'm like, "Oh, okay, you're welcome." Like, I just wanted to dance. So can we talk about this? Like, we, you know, we are taught and we are raised, especially as people of color, to have all this like really silly etiquette rules whenever we're in performance spaces. So what was the experience of breaking the rules like for the two of you?

[10:07] Octavia Washington: Well, I want to stress first of all that the Eras Tour is like three hours long, which makes it crazy that you saw it twice. Um, when I was at the movie theater because I saw it live in person, I was like, "Okay, I think I'm, I'm gonna see half of this maybe, and then I'll wait for it to come out on streaming." Um, but it was like a pretty similar experience, like being there in person and being there at the movie theaters, which I think is kind of wild. That doesn't really happen that often. Cause there were girls who were still wearing their cowboy hats to the theater, um, wearing our, I was wearing my friendship bracelets, the ones that I got when I was at the concert at Met Life. So that was already a little bit strange coming into the movie theater in costume.

Um, and then the whole point is that you're supposed to be prepared to sing, you know, it's a musical experience. So you're supposed to participate. Really sitting there being silent is sort of the wrong etiquette.

[11:10] Maria Paz Alegre: It's not really how you're supposed to do it.

[11:13] Jose Solis: I totally agree with that. Like, did you, I mean Octavia? Since you saw it live, and please brag all you want about it right now. Since you saw it live, what was it like to, you know, to get to see the show the way Taylor wants you to see the show? Because obviously, when you're, you know, in the arena in a stadium, like you know, like you have your vantage point, like you can see what you see. But then as directed by, uh, Sam Ranch, this movie has some of the most amazing cinematography that I've seen in any live performance. Like we have all this like cameras like, you know, like flying over her, like churling over her. She's like, she does all this like magnificent winks and nods at the camera. Like I cannot even begin to imagine how it was to plan something like this. So what was it like, Octavia, to see, you know, the show the way Taylor, I guess, envisioned it?

[12:15] Octavia Washington: Yeah, it was totally different. First of all, I had like really terrible nosebleed seats, but I didn't care. I wanted to see it so badly. We had like eight people set up at different laptops when the queue was starting. So I was like making sure I had to see it no matter where I was in the stadium. So when I got to see the movie, I got to see all her expressions. Um, because I was really just participating in the moment of singing with all the people around me. Like it was much more about all the other people who were sitting next to me much more than it was about looking at Taylor because she was so far away. Um, but this time around, like I was really focused on her stage presence and what she was bringing to each performance.

Um, but there was one song, or when she's doing Reputation, I just I couldn't see it at all. But then I got to see what all the performers were doing when they're in the boxes for Look What You Made Me Do. Like I actually got to experience that performance when I saw it in the movie theaters, and I was like, oh, that's so cool. So I don't know, it's kind of different. Like I had like a distance when I saw the movie versus when I saw it in person, like the emotions were running high, and I was singing with everyone when I was in person. So it wasn't really I guess I was really all that focused on her, which is kind of weird.

[13:48] Maria Paz Alegre: Did you have any favorite songs in the film?

[13:53] I did. The well, I so I saw it twice. And the first time I saw it with a friend who is not a Swifty, but she wanted to come and it was fun. And then the next time I saw it, I saw it with two Swifties, and it made such a huge difference. And honestly, the biggest difference was that completely unplanned, there were about a hundred little girls there. And they made the experience. They were sing screaming every lyric at the top of their lungs. And they had these choreographed dances to August and a love story. And so honestly, it just made the experience so much better. It actually felt like it was a live concert. And it was, it was really fun. And you know, speaking about the um, you know, the the kind of conservative traditions of theater.

I I'm I I always follow them. I never record, I always, you know, I don't, I don't wrestle anything, but I was, you know, taking out my phone and recording these dances and singing at the top of my lungs and dancing, and it felt it felt so freeing. It felt like such a release. Something that Taylor said, I'm gonna get the exact quote wrong, but it's something like she doesn't believe in people who will ever make someone feel bad for being excited. She thinks that those are the worst kind of people. And so when these girls were singing, all of us were yelling at them, we love you, you're awesome, and we love to see it. So it was it was really cool to break that convention.

[15:38] Octavia Washington: That's really beautiful. Like I remember when I saw a very young girl just like beating her chest to all too well, and it was both the most beautiful touching thing ever. And I also kept praying inside, like I hope this poor girl never goes through anything like all too well, but it's like the way in which Taylor's you know songs touch people of all ages like we don't have to have had Jake Gyllenhaal you know shatter us in order to feel what all too well is like and I I saw it the first time with this friend of mine who I kind of like coerced into becoming a Swifty but the second time I went with my mom who doesn't really know Taylor Swift at all it's um you know she's huge but for some reason I don't think like all parents know her except for yourstavia like your mom's pretty awesome and I was so shocked that's it she does not like Taylor Swift to be fair to clarify you know like well thank you for that Octavia and I'm sorry Octavia's mom so but I was so um I kept thinking about something that my mom pointed out and she said to me that she had noticed that the movie theater was mostly you know young women and girls and how she felt that it was a safe space for them like she told me there's probably not a single girl here who feels threatened who feels like something bad can happen to her here.

And my mom's a human rights activist and she's like fighting human trafficking all the time. So she's always you know like keeping her eye on little girls and like and like women, and I hadn't thought about that, and I love that so much. So I was hoping I could hear you talk about you know about about that. But was it like was it like a safe space for you as well?

[17:46] Maria Paz Alegre: I think a hundred percent so honestly, if I had to compare, I haven't felt that level of female energy that big since um since the uh since I went to the women's march in DC. It was it was so polite, meaning that uh before we were exchanging friendship bracelets at the movie theater and complimenting each other, and uh like I love your Eras Tour costume, and we were saying all of that to each other, and then yeah, for these little girls to feel absolutely free to run uninhibited around around the cinema, you know, screaming August at the top of their lungs. It was it was a really safe space, and I actually remember this conversation because I've had I've had a couple conversations because the Eras Tour happened right before the Barbie movie came out, and I remember speaking to a few guys who were like, you know, not really my thing, and me saying, like, yeah, it's not your thing.

This is not for you. The Eras Tour is for us, the Barbie movie is for us, the Renaissance Tour is for us. Like this was very much the summer of girlhood, and it felt really good to have that again in uh in autumn. I really missed it.

[19:06] Octavia Washington: You're so right about that, because like I I keep trying to think about, you know, like I'm a huge movie guy, and I can't think of a single movie that I've seen this year. Um, I promise I will get to Past Lives at some point, Maria Paz, but it hasn't opened in Spain. Um it's so good. See it as you put up. Uh, but obviously I love Barbie, but like other than Barbie, like I couldn't think of any, you know, big movies. And the fact that the Eras Tour film feels like the um, you know, my Titanic of Twenty 23 is wild and what she's doing in terms of changing the way the distribution happens and the way in which art is produced and is like shared with people is something like wild and can we talk a little bit about the theatrical aspects of the Eras Tour? Because it's like it's like holy fuck, what a show.

[20:09] Maria Paz Alegre: Yeah, definitely. I really like that you said that, Octavia, about like sometimes you're not the intended audience for something. Um I think that's something that I like I feel like I have to point out to other people. Um like one of the reasons I really love Taylor Swift is because she talks about in the movie, she says it explicitly, but like I hope when I'm doing these songs for you, you're getting um to project some of your experience onto it. Which I guess is part of the reason why I wasn't it's not that I didn't notice her, but that I was like in thinking about something else when I was at the live tour, because I was thinking I was like thinking about my personal experience and connection to each song.

Like when she was singing 22, I was like, I'm 22. Red is the first album I ever bought with my own money. Now I'm thinking about my childhood. And she's she one of her surprise songs at the Met Life show was Holy Ground, and I was like, that's my favorite Taylor Swift song. And it always makes me think about the specific moment in middle school when I was running around with my friends. And so I was doing a lot of that. I was doing a lot of um projecting my experiences onto hers, partly because I think the experiences she's writing about are so specific that they uh sort of traverse, you know, like portions of universality. Um, that she's so specific about her own experience that you're allowed to project onto it. And so if you don't have the sort of vernacular of girlhood, then yeah, it's kind of hard to like get what she's talking about, you know.

[21:58] Octavia Washington: Yeah, I didn't um the first time I saw the movie, I didn't see it with a Swifty, but I did see it with someone who has um a master's in uh in theater direction, and so they appreciate theatricality, and especially it was really interesting hearing hearing their perspective from someone who wasn't a Swifty, like during Tolerate It, you know, and she's the table and she's laying out all the fancy shit, and she's you know, the vase, and it was so unnecessary, you know. She didn't have to lay out the table and actually do all the stuff, but she's corny, you know, she is a theater kid, she is a total witchy witch during um during her Evermore era with the sparkling balls and the opera cloaks, and it was you know, I I loved that it was uh that she leaned into it.

As cool as she was during Reputation, as sparkly as she was during Lover, she really she really leaned so heavy into into the drama like I I was living for all of the drama and I don't usually see that as much in um in in live shows I don't usually see as much performance but there was so much performance in this uh in this movie and in and in this concert.

[22:53] Maria Paz Alegre: Oh for sure there's definitely like um a cheesiness to Taylor Swift that it's one of the things I really like about her um but it is like the other like if you can't suspend your disbelief it's gonna look stupid to you um you have to be in the know you have to buy into it in order to participate so like when she's doing all of her all of her motions toward the audience when she's winking at them or when she does her classic Taylor Swift moves where she's like the thing with the hand um the one pose where she's like doing her power move that she does at like every show like you have to be willing to lean into the cheesiness with her in order to get it and if you're not doing it then it's just like it's just gonna look silly.

[24:12] Octavia Washington: I love that and you're right about that and I, you know, I did call her cheesy as well. Like, I remember especially this part in "my Tears Ricochet" where she's singing something about a ship and then a ship shows up on the screen and I'm like, Taylor, like, uh, you know, like we know, like you don't have to show us the actual ship.

[24:34] Octavia Washington: It could be a metaphor, girl.

[24:37] Maria Paz Alegre: Yeah.

[24:37] Octavia Washington: I mean, we can re we we get a metaphor girl, totally. But it's like it's cheesy, but it's at the same time it's so earnest and so sincere.

[24:48] Maria Paz Alegre: And like I feel like that kind of like really straightforward communication is so rare. And like for instance, I was obsessed with um The Last Great American Dynasty, where she was basically doing like a little play about the song. And the fact that she also talks about uh Folklore being the first album where she came up with Tetris and made up all these stories, made me dream up like what kind of musical I would want Taylor to write at some point. And I wonder if you have any dream Taylor Swift musical projects.

[25:29] Octavia Washington: I don't think I do. She already well, okay, she already has um like there's a very immersive quality to being um a Taylor Swift fan because it's like you have to participate. Um that's why she does all the all the puzzles, the the vault tracks, the re-releases, um, and then there are like references across songs that you'd only catch if you've been listening to a long career discography. That's why the Eras Tour is like fun to a person who's a Swifty, but it's like, oh, you made the reference about love being red, but now it's golden and lover and like blah blah blah, and you're following all of that. Um so maybe there's something there with like all the references that track draw her songs. My one of my friends and I were talking and we were like, God, she loves some damn green eyes, doesn't she? And she loves a London box. And I don't think anyone loves the word darling as much as Taylor Swift does, right?

[26:37] Maria Paz Alegre: Right.

[26:39] Octavia Washington: Getaway car. That's also a favorite. Um, this is such a good question. I never thought about this because I think I'm just always so grateful for whatever she puts out. But, you know, speaking of the theatricality of it all, I could totally see a musical. I would love to see her take on a musical. I don't know if it could be or should be, you know, a jukebox type of thing, you know, songs that she's already done. It would be I she's got it in her. She's so she has so much drama and theatricality to her performance. I'm really curious to see what what she would do in writing a musical. And I I hope it would be something like, you know, what Duncan Sheik did with Spring Awakening. Like I'd really like to see what she would uh what we what she would come up with.

And she mentioned Duncan Chic. And I thought about American Psycho and said, and I, you know, I was listening to the vault tracks from 1989, Taylor's friction. And now I want Taylor Swift to write a musical based on the film Drive, the Ryan Gosling movie.

[27:50] Maria Paz Alegre: Which have you seen it?

[27:52] Octavia Washington: No.

[27:54] Maria Paz Alegre: I have not seen it before.

[27:56] Octavia Washington: It's amazing. Like it's it's this incredible movie where basically like Ryan Gosling's like being Ken, you know, like but a little bit smarter and like all badass and stuff. And it's just like this dark LA neo noir movie, um, with this incredible synth pop um soundtrack. And I was listening to the vault tracks with my brother, who's uh not a Swifty at all. And he was like, are those like cobbers? Are those from like the 80s? He was like, they sound like from drive, and I'm like, yes. I'm like, yes. So I mean a straight voice said it. So please, Taylor, think about writing a drive musical at some point. I think that would be incredible.

[28:40] Maria Paz Alegre: Okay, so can we talk about I don't know if this is the right word to use here? Like, I don't want to use this word, but I I guess I'm gonna go for it. Converting non Swifties into Swifties, which I think is something that as people who love theater, we sometimes have to do that, right? Like, there's people who flat out think that theater isn't welcoming to them and it's not for them and won't want them in there. And then I feel like there's a lot of that in like Taylor Swift, um, you know, the Swiftiness, I guess, of it all, like having had that experience of like trying to convince someone, you know, like yes, theater and musicals in place, whatever, Shakespeare or whatever are for you in the same way that Taylor is.

[29:24] Octavia Washington: Yeah, I guess so. It's been uh uh it's like the ever um everlasting conflict of being a Swifty, which is the sort of and of being a theater person, which is just the sort of innate embarrassment of it all, because it is if you like step back, it seems sort of silly. Um, but then uh my issue is that like I rem and I remember I started doing this as a kid. I remember trying so hard to pick out um what of what people said to me about her was just like just sexism, um, and like what was bias and prejudice and what was like a valid critique. I remember being a kid and oh my god, it to be a middle schooler during the time when she was dating Harry Styles, I wouldn't wish that on anyone in the entire world, like not even on God's strongest soldier, because I was defending her left and right, and everyone my friends, first of all, to be fair, they were like 12.

They're like, Oh, I don't know, like she's just using him. And I was like, Ugh, I don't know what you guys are talking about. Like, I feel like you guys are using reusing sexist um stereotypes to talk about her, and sometimes I just feel like it's just a song. Like I just want to engage with the songs and the lyricism, and that's like a hard thing to do with her for some reason. Um, which I guess is part of like I guess it's part of the career that she's cultivated because her songs are kind of like diary entries, so they're about her and they invite a sort of unraveling of her person um too. But sometimes I'll sit there and I'd be like, if you guys could just like detach your connotations of like who she is, who you think she is as a person, and just look at the lyricism.

I you I'd feel like you'd find a much stronger writer, and I think you're giving her credit for. And I don't know why people, well, I know why. But like I'm waiting for the day where people treat Taylor Swift like b like they treat Bob Dylan. Like they're able to separate him, the person, um, and hit and his lyricism. And they there's a lot of grace that's offered to a lot of male artists, but that isn't offered to her, and it's kind of odd.

[31:57] Maria Paz Alegre: I completely agree with you. I was reading her reaction recently to um to Kendrick Lamar re-recording and how she couldn't believe that he said yes to re-recording and how she was so inspired by his re-recording, and she just seemed so so grateful. And at the same time, I was like, but you're Taylor Swift, you know, like you, of course he wants to re-record his work with you. You're Taylor Swift, like, yes, he's Kendrick Lamar, and you're Taylor Swift. Like you are both very much voices for voices for a generation of fans, and your work means a lot. So, you know, game recognizes game, Taylor.

[32:44] Octavia Washington: Um yeah, when it comes to when it comes to Taylor Swift and people and Swifties versus non Swifties and converting. Um when I became single, you know, and I I've been dating, um, some of the people I've been dating have had to listen to a lot about Taylor Swift because I've come into my Swifty Swift um, you know, while dating people. And um, you know, you you get a lot of reactions. I can see a lot of eyes, you know, glaze over, and that's when I realized I'm I'm 15 minutes in, and if this is too long for most people who are not fans. But um at the same time, um, uh shout out to uh to this amazing doctor I've been seeing. Uh their name's Rue, and Rue is not a Swifty by any means, but uh Rue likes me and likes seeing me happy.

And because Taylor makes me happy, uh, they are totally supportive. And actually, uh the other, I guess it was it was a month ago now, um, for no reason whatsoever, they made me a friendship bracelet. Like they, it was with my favorite color and butterflies and my name. And they've never ever made a friendship bracelet before. But they went out and bought a damn friendship bracelet kit and and made it to me. So he's they're they're not uh a Swifty, but I think I think there's room for conversion there. And it meant the world to me, and it still does.

[34:22] Maria Paz Alegre: That's basically out of love story, my defense.

[34:24] Octavia Washington: Like I love you.

[34:27] Maria Paz Alegre: Be careful.

[34:27] Octavia Washington: You kind of just proposed in Swifty.

[34:29] Maria Paz Alegre: Um we're not going there, but like this is this is a big deal. I know that you're talking about, you know, like when you were talking, both of you are talking about, you know, uh I think Bob Dylan's pretty boring, by the way. So I hope Taylor's never compared to Bob Dylan. But that's just me.

[34:46] Octavia Washington: Um you about to make a lot of people angry.

[34:53] Maria Paz Alegre: I'm here for it.

[34:55] Octavia Washington: Okay, thank you. That's my that's my brand, I guess. No, but I mean, uh uh nothing against Mr. Dylan, but it's like I, you know, I've always like identified more with like um women artists and like I find men pretty boring. But what you're saying made me think about can we think? I mean, I can't for sure. Can we think about any people like in uh in theater, like any writers in theater who are like a you know, like a theater version equivalent, I guess, of Taylor, you know, like people whose work is constantly misunderstood and criticized just because it's by you know, by women.

[35:39] Maria Paz Alegre: I guess most women would be the answer. I don't know. Help me out of this.

[35:57] Octavia Washington: Um although I think he gets some pretty valid critiques. And I think Taylor gets pretty valid critiques too. Um, but sometimes there's like a disconnect between like the repu the internet reputation that those people have of their person and then like the work on the page itself.

[36:35] Octavia Washington: Um, widely done, widely well known, but it became so iconic, you know, like the black dress, the monologues that it, you know, it's easily satirized and it kind of became like a bit of a caricature, the Vagina Monologues and other work. But you know, when you look at the work she's done and the people she's changed, I remember the first time I read that and how it changed me. It's almost like a little embarrassing to say, like, there's something cliché, but Eve Ensler meant a lot to me. And yet I don't see men flocking to her latest plays; I see women, always women, and always really, really good audience members.

[37:35] Jose Solis: With that in mind, can we talk about what theater, which is like again this art form that we love so much, what can theater learn from Taylor and the Eras Tour? You know, I've been seeing a lot of opera lately, actually, and that's, I have to say, a lot of the Eras Tour stuff that I saw kind of reminded me of opera just in that, you know, there's a move to have some more dramatic stuff in opera that's more interesting. I just saw Dead Man Walking the opera, I'm going to see Malcolm X the opera, both of them are at the Met. Also, you know, there's so much joy in seeing The Barber of Seville or La Traviata. They're silly, they're cheesy, but they're fun, and like they really, really lean into that wink at the audience, and there's so much joy to it.

So I do see comparisons in a related form. But as far as what could theater learn from Taylor, I think the storytelling of the music, I feel like not always do musicals really have storytelling within it. It's more like a device to continue the story, but actually having the story in the music is not something that I see as often. So being that she's a musician, I'd like to see that. I think that could be really interesting to have absolutely deep and powerful lyrics that you want to, you know, have in quotes above your bed.

[39:26] Octavia Washington: Well, there's the obvious one that you brought up, Jose, which is that more shows should be recorded. Like, of course, I was much more comfortable at the theater than I was when I was at the live event, just because that's just me. But I just like to sit down and just thinking about accessibility, like it's much more accessible to be at home and watching a show, having some sort of privacy, I think. Although the communal aspect is what makes theater so great. But then I think that also the other thing that the Eras Tour has, and that Taylor Swift specifically has in her cultivation of fandom is like her expectations of the spectator are different than I think most other shows are. And that's part of the reason her career is so long-lasting.

Like she invites you over to come listen to the album before it comes out. Like, that's weird. That's a weird expectation or a non-normative expectation of closeness with the spectator. I think most other shows allow. Why not be less snobby? You know, why only hold people to see your show when it's, you know, a $400 ticket, a $500 ticket, a ten thousand dollar floor seat? Why not be able to spread your work to more people? You know, the Met already kind of does that, and it's a solid system where they record live one night of the season and they project it to like a select number of theaters. Why not have that for those who can't, you know, afford to come to New York City, who can't afford a ticket at the Met? They can afford a cinema ticket to their local movie theater. Why not have that?

[41:33] Jose Solis: And I love what you said, Octavia, about having expectations of audience. One of the best shows I've ever seen is a play called Sinking Inc. by Sanggu Gam. And it was super interactive hip hop theater, like, you know, wave your hands in the air, and so much call and response. And yeah, I loved that, and I think it's so much more fresh, it's so much more innovative to do that. Yeah, there's a lot theater has to learn from Taylor Swift.

[42:10] Octavia Washington: I also do love the Met recordings because like I always say, more than the Empire State and the Statue of Liberty, the thing that I miss the most about New York City is Kelly O'Hara. And thanks to those Met recordings, I got to see her in The Hours last winter, so I'm with you on that. So hi Kelly O'Hara, if you're listening as well. And I'm thinking Kelly O'Hara as Taylor Swift and Taylor Swift the musical, but that's just me. So I want to go back to the question that I hope you won't hate me for all of eternity, but what is one song that you wish she had included in any of the eras?

[42:10] Maria Paz Alegre: Oh God, I don't know. God, well, some of them she did as like surprise songs in other cities. So like I think with 1989 coming out, I've realized that maybe my number one Taylor Swift song is "New Romantics," especially I think my favorite Taylor Swift song changes as to where I'm at in my life. And so "New Romantics," it's like, oh, we're in our 20s, like we're in the city, life is crazy, and then I'm like, okay, like that's my favorite song. But I don't know, she did it in other places, so it's not her fault. I would love to hear "Would've, Could've, Should've." The first time I'm gonna cry now. The first time I ever heard that song, when it got to that line, "Give me back my girlhood, it was mine first," I remember like my mouth dropped and just tears started streaming down my face.

And then I, you know, fiercely went to TikTok, and sure enough, there's a whole reaction video compilation of people reacting to that one line. And it's always women, it's always women and girls who just start crying uncontrollably, and then there's videos of it playing at other concerts, you know, just kind of in, I guess, background, and women and girls just screaming that line at the top of their lungs. "Give me back my girlhood, it was mine first." There's something so representative and cathartic in that line, and I wish I could have screamed that at the theater.

[45:05] Jose Solis: Thank you for sharing that. That's really beautiful.

[45:10] Maria Paz Alegre: I guess my song would be "Red." I mean, that song just takes me back to my first week living in New York, and yep, different times almost. So thank you both for surprise songs, but sorry, Jose.

[45:35] Octavia Washington: Jose, what were your surprise songs? What did you get?

[45:38] Jose Solis: I got "Holy Ground" and "False Gods."

[45:42] Octavia Washington: Ooh.

[45:43] Jose Solis: Those are nice.

[45:45] Octavia Washington: Those are very nice, Jose.

[45:47] Jose Solis: So we're gonna have to talk more about that. Like, I cannot wait for my surprise songs. Like, May next year cannot come fast enough.

[45:58] Octavia Washington: So in the meantime, we have the Eras Tour playing in movie theaters right now, literally all over the world, which is wild. It's so amazing. And also, it's gonna be on Prime soon. So thank you both for joining me today. Where can people find you online or wherever?

[46:27] Octavia Washington: Hmm. You can't find me online.

[46:35] Maria Paz Alegre: Right. You can find me on Octavia Reeds. My main Instagram profile is private. You can find me on all my socials; they're the same. It's my name, @MariaPazAlegre. There are quite a few videos of Taylor, but mostly it's pictures of my dog, Love Joy. And anytime I post a video of Love Joy versus a video of myself, I get way more hits. So oh yeah, follow that, @LoveJoy actually, which Jose follows.

[47:10] Jose Solis: I love that you're a fan of my dog, and that my dog has become like the unofficial mascot of the Public Theater's BIPOC Theater Critics Program.

[47:21] Octavia Washington: I mean, how can anyone not love Love Joy?

[47:24] Jose Solis: So please everyone follow Love Joy. Like, it's just pure, I don't know, love, joy, and joy.

[47:31] Octavia Washington: Yes.

[47:32] Jose Solis: Thank you both. And you all know where to find me. Like, I'm gonna add some more stuff to the show notes, and I hope to do this again. Maybe talk more Taylor or more theater in the future. So thank you so much, Octavia and Maria Paz, this has been a treat.

[47:45] Maria Paz Alegre: Thank you.

[47:52] Jose Solis: Maria Paz, how many versions of 1989 have you bought so far?

[47:56] Maria Paz Alegre: How many versions of what?

[47:58] Jose Solis: 1989, have you bought so far?

[48:01] Maria Paz Alegre: Oh, first I got the original, and then when it released, I downloaded that. And then when the deluxe came out, I deleted it and got like, so I guess three versions of 1989.

[48:13] Jose Solis: And what about since Friday?

[48:15] Maria Paz Alegre: Oh yeah, no, no, those are it. It's like the original and then the, oh yeah, then the Friday drop, but then there was like a deluxe after the Friday drop, so then I deleted that. So three times, three times I've downloaded 1989.

[48:27] Jose Solis: Okay, no vinyls, no cassettes, no nothing?

[48:29] Maria Paz Alegre: Oh, I see, yeah, no, I also got it on vinyl. I love vinyl, so yeah.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred