In every episode, the culture critics at Token Theatre Friends bring their fresh perspectives to the performing arts on their podcast and video series. You can find the podcast on Spotify, iTunes, and Stitcher (look for the all-red logo)... Read More
From the show: Token Theatre Friends
Featured Shows
About
In every episode, the culture critics at Token Theatre Friends bring their fresh perspectives to the performing arts on their podcast and video series. You can find the podcast on Spotify, iTunes, and Stitcher (look for the all-red logo). The video series* is available on YouTube. The TTF theme song is by Sean Mason (with vocals by Angela Ramos). The video animation is by Brad Ogden, with logos by Jason Simon.
In this episode, Andrew talks about his summer of theatre by looking at six shows he saw over May/June and the trends that tie them together. From revivals (Appropriate, Uncle Vanya) new plays (Sally and Tom), new musicals (The Great Gatsby) and long-running musicals (Hadestown, Six), Andrew praises the ensemble powers of live theatre and the joys of great blocking with a reminder of the power that bodies in motion have when they move on the stage.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Andrew Kendall: Hi, this is Andrew Kendall. I am a film critic and university lecturer of film, literature, and drama. And welcome to another episode of Token Theatre Friends. Today I'll be flying solo for this episode, which is a bit of a special assessment about current trends on and also off Broadway. It reflects the best of what's good about theater. I like to think of myself as the Caribbean arm of Token Theatre Friends, and I was in New York for a few months this summer and got a handful of shows, and the more I thought of them, the more I began seeing relationships between them that reflected some of the best things about what's happening in theater right now. And so today's episode is about blocking and ensembles and the power of bodies in motion on stage, and not one, not two, but six different shows that are either currently playing or recently closed on, and in one case, off Broadway.
Now, as you know, Token Theatre Friends is less of a regular review podcast, and instead we aim to offer new and creative perspectives on theatre. And although the review machine of arts these days is all about the new, especially when it comes to theater.
[1:45] Andrew Kendall: Hadestown, book, music and lyrics by Anaïs Mitchell and directed by Rachel Chavkin. The Great Gatsby, book by Kate Kerrigan, music by Jason Howland, lyrics by Nathan Tyson, and directed by Mark Bruni. Six, book, music and lyrics by Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss, and directed by Lucy Moss and Jeremy Armitage. And Uncle Vanya, an adaptation of Chekhov's play by Heidi Schreck, and directed by Lila Neugebauer. I think there's a lot of untapped value in thinking about our relationship with theatre beyond the notion of review and even beyond the notion of newness. And my primary criticism work is in film. But theatre holds a special place in my heart, and something I found myself mourning over the last decade, and maybe more in contemporary film is the weakening of the relationship between theatre and film, both in overt and covert ways.
It's there in more legible things like the fact that so few great American plays are now adapted to film when you consider how post-war American cinema was built on theatrical adaptations of, you know, Tennessee Williams and Arthur Miller and Eugene O'Neill plays. And it's also there in ways that we see less theatre practitioners moving across to film, and a hat tip to Annie Flick, who recently made the transfer as a director with her film currently playing, Janet Planet.
[3:22] Andrew Kendall: And I was at a screening of Elian May's The Heartbreak Kid at Metagraph a few weeks ago, and Elian May is, of course, one of the finest theatre-to-film back-to-theatre icons of the last 50 years. And not to essentialize theatre practitioners who turn to film, but I really think watching that film made me really value what it means when somebody who is from theatre directs a film and opts to take a value in the ensemble. Like the great thing about The Heartbreak Kid is the way that even though it's a film about this particular problematic man and his romantic fables, there are so many scenes where May gives this graciousness to the wider ensemble, even the unnamed ones, and it made me think so much about how theatre functions and how we very often, especially in musicals, but not just in musicals, have an ensemble who are not named figures but still add so much visual context for the play.
And in thinking of that as I was also turning over in my head the plays that I had seen, I started thinking so much about how these plays in juxtaposition felt like an interesting indication of what's happening in contemporary theater. Of course, Six is originally a British play, but it found great success in the US, and I think that there is something there within all these shows about what makes theatre so valuable when it comes to bodies, ensembles, and blocking.
[5:15] Andrew Kendall: So I wanted to start off my discussion by looking at the show, which put the idea of ensembles and movement and bodies into context for me, which is the currently playing musical at the Broadway Theatre, The Great Gatsby, which is an adaptation of the F. Scott Fitzgerald novel. And incidentally, The Great Gatsby was my least favorite of the six shows that I'm looking at today. And yet, part of my own relationship with theatre is about finding value and finding things that are significant even in shows that might not work on the whole. And I'll even confess to perhaps an absurd way that I engage with theatre, which is that to be very honest, it doesn't matter the quality of the show. Whenever a play ends and the curtain, you know, comes down and the cast takes their bows, there is a part of me that always feels just really moved by it.
I think there's something about the ephemeral nature of theater that always makes me so excited to be a part of it, even when it's not really satisfying me. Despite not being very critically successful, it has been running and it's been selling tickets into early 2025. The adaptation of The Great Gatsby, like I mentioned earlier, the libretto is by Kai Kerrigan. It is probably the weakest aspect of the adaptation, even though it's a challenge I understand. The Great Gatsby is a thin but very complex novel, which is narrated in novel form by the character Nick Carraway, who moved to New York City and ends up living next to this mysterious Jay Gatsby, who turns out to be the former lover of his cousin Daisy Buchanan.
And so the story in the novel is about this doomed romance between Gatsby and Daisy, who's now married to an abusive husband who's having an affair, and little by little we kind of pull back the curtain on the decadence and the excitement of the 1920s to reveal this dark underbelly of the fallibility of American dreams.
[7:37] Andrew Kendall: And that's such a rich idea. I mean, the novel celebrates its 100th anniversary next April, but I think one of the overarching criticisms of the show is that it gets more caught up in the aesthetics of the glamorous twenties than really reckoning with the darkness underlying that. And one of the weaknesses is in the way that Gatsby's character, even by the end of the play, is still very much opaque for us. So there's an element that they use in the adaptation though. Like Nick still remains the primary protagonist, which I don't think is a choice that completely works, even though I do want to give a shout out to Noah Jay Ricketts as Nick, who is doing a lot in a character that the play is hanging too much on.
But beyond Nick's narration, there is an ensemble cast of dancers and singers who perform several of the numbers, including the act one opener and the act two closer. Halfway through the show, I had an unlikely idea of thinking what the Great Gatsby librettist and lyricist even could learn from the use of the ensemble in Stephen Sondheim's A Little Night Music, which is adapted from Ingmar Bergman's Smiles of a Summer Night.
[9:08] Andrew Kendall: And if you're familiar with A Little Night Music, in that play, which is another play about not doomed romances but definitely complex ones, we have these agri chorus essentially in Little Night Music, five singers who make up a quintet, who throughout the show enter and contextualize some of what's going on with the main characters. And it's one of my favorite things about A Little Night Music. And I kept thinking how much richer The Great Gatsby would be if it recognized that Nick is a lot more compelling as a character than as a narrator, and instead had that ensemble carry the weight of so much of what Nick is doing. Like something I always tell students when we're thinking about transpositions from art form to art form is that what works in one art form might not work in another.
Really sharp moment, which I kept thinking of, where after Gatsby dies at the end of the novel, at the end of the play, Nick is at his funeral, and then the ensemble kind of breaks into, you know, speak very dismissively of him. And I really like the energy of that, but also what it promised for how we might use ensembles. Because with such a small core cast of the show, we've got Daisy and Tom, we've got Jay and Nick, we've got Jordan, a young woman that Daisy insists on setting Nick up with, and then we've got the other three somewhat more minor characters in the play who, the Wilsons, Myrtle Wilson, who Tom is having an affair with, George Wilson, her husband, and then Wolfsheim, this eerie figure from Gatsby's past, who the play does a very poor job of setting up, I might say.
[11:24] Andrew Kendall: But the ensemble. The choreography for the show is done by Dominique Kelly, who makes her debut as a main choreographer on a show. But I think the thing that kept on surfacing was the way that so much of what was going on production-wise in Gatsby was falling more in love with that kind of very embellishing on it aesthetic without thinking about the darkness underneath it. And ultimately, The Great Gatsby is a societal critique, and I really think that the adapters sort of gave up a lot of potential in not using that ensemble to full effect. However, even though the entire show isn't working completely, the things that do work in The Great Gatsby are very often dependent on particular directorial choices that are happening, and I want to identify, you know, the work from director Mark Bruni, who does have in certain moments a really sharp skill for blocking, like there's a scene where Nick goes with Tom to see his mistress, and they're in this, you know, seedy New York apartment, and they're the swingers there, and I'm not completely in love with the actual songs that they're singing there.
[12:50] Andrew Kendall: Uh, like Martel has a song "Second Hand Suit," and then there's um a later one. But the blocking there is so effective, and I think one thing that I love about theatre is the way that they're able just through blocking to make like four people seem like a room that's filled with buzz and hubbub. Every person who appears on stage gets a moment, and it's not you know a participation trophy kind of way of thinking about uh art, but having those members of the ensemble have that kind of indelible effect, and having them have these moments, um uh dance move here or little trill of the voice there, it kind of added, I think, a significant element of making this world real for those moments, and it's why I think I kept hoping that they would make a wider use of the ensemble in thinking about that.
[13:47] Andrew Kendall: And of course, one of the thrills is not just the extended nameless ensemble, it's also thinking about how the main characters themselves are part of an ensemble. Some of the moments in "The Great Gatsby" that I kept coming back to were these really lovely tableaus where most or many of the main characters would be on stage together, and there is such a thrill when a performer is able to stand in physical proximity between other characters and we were able to see the themes of the play kind of writ large in terms of how their bodies operate, and so there are two things I think about. One is the lately sort of climactic party scene in Gatsby's house where uh Tom takes Daisy, Jordan and Nick are there, and of course Gatsby is there, and there's a dance sequence where Daisy dances with Gatsby, and Tom, her husband is often the side of the stage looking on, and then they go to a hotel in Manhattan, and so we've got an improper mix of couples.
We've got Gatsby, we've got Daisy and Tom, we've got Jordan and Nick. And writing-wise, I'm not in love with what's happening in that scene, but returning to the elements of blocking and the excitement of seeing this range of characters on stage in this context.
[15:10] Andrew Kendall: There's a lot more that's coming from the actors' chemistry with each other because I don't want to show the play that the actors are doing a lot to sort of build on relationships that the actual libretto is quite vague on. Dialogue and there are those moments where you can recognize that Gatsby is Gatsby the play is cognizant of the effectiveness of having varying characters on stage in context rather than focusing or you know, floodlighting one character. We might have all the characters there in the background and having that informed so much of how we respond to them. I do think makes for a compelling dynamic of theatre. And it's something that I think made a lot of sense more for me when I was uh when I saw "Sally and Tom," which closed in May, the one off-Broadway production I'm talking about today, written by Susan Laurie Parks that played at a public theatre.
[16:34] Andrew Kendall: "Sally and Tom" is a meta-theatrical play within a play about a mixed-race couple who lead a theatre group who are putting on a production of a play about Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemmings, his enslaved lover. And the couple also plays the characters of Thomas and Sally, and they're the director and writer of the show's initial respectively. Larry Parks is a sharp contemporary writer, and I think what struck me the most after seeing the work is how much I preferred the play as a meta-theatrical text than a historical one. Of course I'm not American, so that explains a lot of what I might find resonant, and meta-theatrical themes are one of my favorite aspects of any kind of art form.
[17:19] Andrew Kendall: And I actually was thinking about another meta-theatrical work it considers race, which is Lynn Nottage's play "By the Way, Meet Vera Stark." What I love about theatre is the way that the idea of breaking the fourth wall on stage is always so more effective, I find, than in film or the novel. I mean, there are times when films or novels will speak to the audience or reader, but I think that theatre has an ability to challenge that suspension of disbelief in really, really curious ways. And "Sally and Tom," because it's the show that's I really think it's the show that serves its ensemble best. It's not my favorite production of the lot, but the work being done in the ensemble, both in the script but in the nuances of the direction, made me thrilled to watch.
[18:07] Andrew Kendall: It's a cast of eight, and they're weaving between the present-day behind-the-scenes drama and then tailing into rehearsals of the actual play, which become the play essentially when they're in full costume. So director Steve H. Broadnax III is getting a lot of mileage from the way he blocks characters, especially the non-speaking characters in certain scenes. And of course, that kind of blocking takes on such emotional resonance and the play moves back to the historical world of Monticello when there are several scenes where the performers who are playing the enslaved characters are silent but meaningfully placed in the context of the white characters. Thinking about it really kind of built on the idea and the thesis of bodies and blocking, which I kind of got from "The Great Gatsby" because I've been thinking about how even removed from any kind of academic inquiry, that that is the thrill of theatre in a great way.
[19:12] Andrew Kendall: You know, the best thing about like theatre as compared to film is always feeling the air and breathing in that real-time energy of the cast, and it's so much richer when you've got a show that's privileging that ensemble, not just in writing but in direction. And of course, Larry Parks is meaningfully giving each character their moment. So each of the eight members of the troupe, many of whom are performing double or multiple roles due to budgetary constraints. So like one character is playing Jefferson's daughter, she's also the stage manager. The other character is also the costume designer. The other guy is playing four roles because they don't have enough people.
[20:16] Andrew Kendall: Sometimes I wonder if the increased resistance to considering minor characters on film may be part of this annoying need for art to be focused on making a point rather than conveying, you know, the value of the world in the art. Because, like I've heard like in criticisms of film and TV where you know a minor character gets an important scene and somebody will say, you know, why what's the point of this? It's not moving the main story forward. And I think that the best of theatre rejects that. For example, I'm mentioning "A Little Night Music" again, but one of the best moments in that play is when the very minor character, Petra, sings the beautiful "The Miller's Son," and it's not ostensibly integral to the main romance there, but there's something so effective and valuable about extending the kind of myopic romantic craziness of the upper class in that play, and then extending it to Petra and having that moment sort of become this really sharp and resonant scene in the play.
[21:21] Andrew Kendall: And I felt I can I feel like that is so important to theatre generally, and I think that "Sally and Tom" as a play equipped itself so well. Each of those main characters feels so profound and valuable, but beyond them being written that way, the direction and the blocking of that becomes so much richer. So when we keep weaving between the present day of the play being done and then the rehearsals and then the actual play, which kind of becomes the real world because the play ends with a scene from the play within a play, which feels like the primary play rather than what we're um just watching the characters perform. And you know, that kind of elusiveness between you know truth and reality, and then recognizing how a simple movement of the hand there or a step back here can create so many waves of intentionality and significance, and I think many I've heard many actors say that you know ultimately for an actor, their body is their tool.
[22:31] Andrew Kendall: I mean, perhaps not as much as you might think a dancer's body is their tool. But every time I keep thinking about the dynamics of the ensemble and the cast in these shows, I'm recognizing how much uh value there is to be taken in thinking about rather than eclipsing the main character and a tight close-up on film, maintaining that importance of you know the main cast in the center of the stage, but still having the wider cast as part of that world and say it's seen them existing. So in a scene where um, you know, the husband and wife characters are having an argument, but we have a minor character on the side responding or listening to that, it all creates this uh richness of intentionality that I find so essential as to what about theatre makes it so compelling for audiences and resisting that myopia, I think, which says, you know, stars only. If this is not about the main character, it's not part of the world.
[23:41] Andrew Kendall: But any great work is effective, not just for the main people in it, but for the way that the smaller things orbiting that main part help the main thing to feel so much richer. And I think that's something that "Sally and Tom" is able to so effectively convey in shaping that meta-theatrical aspect into developing this ensemble of eight people playing eight and more other people in the past, and having each of those you know, collections of persons and bodies feel meaningful and really sharp on stage. And I think it is interesting that the other two plays I saw on Broadway, "Appropriate" and "Uncle Vanya" are also both pretty heavily ensemble shows. There's a main character in both of them incidentally played by generally famous TV star, Steve Carell in "Uncle Vanya," and Sarah Paulson in "Appropriate."
[24:47] Andrew Kendall: But what works about both shows, even recognizing that initially the audience was clearly there for the stars, is that as both shows go on, the vitality of what is so compelling about both of them is found in the relationship between the entire ensemble and stage.
[25:07] Andrew Kendall: So even the minor characters have their moments to shine. But beyond having moments to shine, the real dramatic marrow of both of those shows is found in utilizing and thinking about both shows as representations of entire families rather than individual characters.
[25:32] Andrew Kendall: It's premiered in 2013, but this is its Broadway premiere, and it's about a dysfunctional Lafayette family who return to Plantation Mansion in Arkansas to battle over their father's inheritance. Um and Uncle Vanya, it's a new adaptation by Heidi Schreck of Chekhov's play, which is about an elderly professor and his much younger wife who returned to the rural estate that supports their urban life, where Vanya, the professor's brother-in-law, and Sonia, his daughter, are kind of surviving day-to-day in the rural estate, but becoming increasingly psychologically dismayed by their Latin life.
[26:22] Andrew Kendall: And so it's interesting that both plays are about a return to this kind of, you know, either a rural or plantation era, and it's very much about class dynamics, and they also incidentally, like I mentioned, are both directed by Lila Neugebauer, who actually was Tony nominated for her work on Appropriate.
[26:45] Andrew Kendall: And you could tell in the early moments of both plays, especially at the entrance applause for Steve Carell and Sarah Paulson, that large thoughts of the audience were there for the stars. But as the shows both go on, as the dynamics are laid for the familial complications, you begin to realize just how much both of the plays are depending and how much Neugebauer's direction is emphasizing those fucked up family dynamics.
[27:23] Andrew Kendall: Um I was not as enthused about the direction in Uncle Vanya as I was in Appropriate. But in looking at the two shows in context, one immediate thing that I love about Neugebauer's approach to direction is her impressive blocking skill.
[27:58] Andrew Kendall: But thinking about the, I think I really like the shape of the Vivian Beaumont Theatre stage where Uncle Vanya played, and although there are moments where I feel like the general ideology of the show is a bit vague in terms of what it's trying to convey. The more formal aesthetic elements of how Neugebauer is using the stage or using the actors on the stage is such a vital part about what ultimately makes Vanya work.
[28:38] Andrew Kendall: Um I wasn't too thrilled by the sometimes over-solicitous approach to making it almost too funny. Like Uncle Vanya is at its heart a really sad tragic play. Um there are a lot of moments where it feels as if the humor is being tilled a bit too emphatically, but all of that kind of, you know, disappears in the sharpest moments of the play, which tend to be the moments where multiple characters are on stage at the time.
[29:19] Andrew Kendall: Uh there's a particular tableau that happens late in the play when Vanya in a fit of pique tries to shoot the professor, who he's very jealous of, and then there's a later scene towards the end when the professor and his younger wife Yelena are preparing to leave, and then we also have most of the cast on stage, and I keep on mentioning the just the eclectic energy that comes from being in a theater and feeling the energy emanating from the performers who are standing in juxtaposition to each other.
[29:59] Andrew Kendall: But it's also beyond that, where some of the moments in Uncle Vanya that I found just really tender and really sharp were in the ways that Neugebauer is using the depth of the ensemble to project so many conflicting sometimes themes with each other. And part of that is of course the fact that this is an incredibly cast production.
[30:30] Andrew Kendall: Um beyond Thief Girl is Vanya, we've got Anika Noni Rose as Yelena, Alfred Molina as her husband, a professor, Alison Pill as his daughter, Jane Houdyshell as Vanya's mother, William Jackson Harper as Astrov, who was Tony nominated for his work, and even the more minor characters, Mia Katigbak as Marina and Jonathan Hadary as Telegin.
[30:59] Andrew Kendall: And I keep on mentioning what I love about theater at its best, which is giving space to even the smallest role to feel meaningful, and there are two lovely moments with Marina and Telegin that are just so warm and tender, and they're happening as the main characters are on stage, but still that awareness of giving space to them as people within this world that have value.
[31:32] Andrew Kendall: Um and it's also found in looking at the way that the performers are able to intersect with each other even when they're not in conversation with each other. I think Neugebauer really is able to pull some interesting things from these performers.
[31:51] Andrew Kendall: And so even a lot of the critical moments in Uncle Vanya are about two characters talking. So this lovely scene between Anika Noni Rose and Alison Pill where Yelena and Sonia are having like a heart to heart and there's another later scene with Sonia and Vanya, which, you know, has that moving monologue at the end of the play. And even in that closing scene, even though it's focused primarily on Vanya and Sonia, we've still got the presence of the other characters on stage and it's creating such an important quality of richness dramatically, like thinking about how these characters have very little privacy even as they work through such deeply personal things the presence of minor characters on stage weaving in and out creates this sense of being overwhelmed by the idea that even in your isolation you're never really alone which is kind of paradoxically working as both a good thing and a bad thing but it's also part of what is so compelling for an audience engaging with that and thinking about the family dynamics of a dysfunctional family and the way that, you know, bodies are falling on top of bodies, I think the recurring thing in any kind of dysfunctional family is the way that there really is no escape from the people that you want to embrace but you also want to reject.
[33:39] Andrew Kendall: And I think Neugebauer is able to put that quality into even better effect in Appropriate, which is about an arguably even more dysfunctional family and which is an excellently directed play. Like I left Appropriate thinking so much about directorial choices and how even though the play is sold as, you know, this play where Sarah Paulson emerges as this, you know, amazing central character, like she won a well-deserved Tony for her performance. But I actually left Appropriate thinking not about Sarah in isolation, but thinking about how this entire ensemble is working so effectively in line with each other.
[34:27] Andrew Kendall: I think I even made the comment in passing to someone after seeing Appropriate that it felt as if it were a musical in some of the direction. Such a really rhythmically directed show, uh the scene changes are so brief and so many of the scenes have multiple characters on stage and there's almost a kind of rhythmic quality to the way that it keeps building.
[34:55] Andrew Kendall: Neugebauer is so like locked into the dynamics of these very confrontational and very different characters, and that kind of build-up to the multiple climaxes of the show is really dependent on the director who's completely attuned to how the dynamics of an ensemble are so critical to the power of live theater.
[35:25] Andrew Kendall: And the setup for Appropriate is a familiar one, I think, for a lot of plays. You know, uh patriarch dies, the children of the patriarch band together to grapple with inheritances, and then things just end up getting increasingly alright. Uh the setting of Arkansas is significant because the house where the characters spend all of the play is a plantation mansion, and there's the discovery of some relics that are tied to slavery, which precipitate an unraveling of the family dynamic.
[36:04] Andrew Kendall: So the three children, uh Tony, played by Sarah Paulson, she's the eldest of the three, and she is a single mother with a teenage son who is recently out of uh Juvy. There is the middle son, Bo, played by Corey Stoll in this production. He is married to Rachel, a Jewish woman, and they have two children, and the Jewish part is important as part of the dramatics later on in the play.
[36:57] Andrew Kendall: And over the course of three days or so, the illusion of the family begins to disintegrate.
[37:07] Andrew Kendall: And even though a lot in the advertising, and I think the conversation on the play has kind of centered on Paulson's Tony, Appropriate is an excellent example of an ensemble show. Um, we've got the three siblings, we've got the spouses or would-be spouses of both brothers. Uh, there is Tony's son, the two children of Bo and Rachel, and so it's a busy stage. Uh, the scenic design is a particular highlight. Uh, just a shout out to Dots for their Tony-nominated scenic work. And so it's an incredibly busy stage. There are only rare moments where single characters are on stage, and the sharpest moments of the drama are when all the cast is around. Uh, one of the best moments, which got a gasp from the audience, is when the younger son of Rachel and Bo comes down from upstairs the staircase with a Klansman hood on.
It's sort of an important moment in the show where things get really out of sync, and there's so many excellent moments like that directed by Neigenbauer, which I think reflect so excellently her sharp ability to direct her cast and to work on the effectiveness of the blocking. Because like I said, I didn't leave Appropriate just thinking about the primary characters, and actually I think my favorite performance in it might have actually been Natalie Gold as Rachel. Uh, she has a few moments where she's going head-to-head with either Paulson or Stahl, but she's often on the periphery of a number of scenes, and she is doing such a great job of sustaining emotion. One thing I always like in performers, whether it's on stage or screen, is seeing actors who are working in supporting roles that might not have dialogue, but that are always on.
But she is always completely in character. Um, and I think Neigenbauer is a director who looked through that in her cast, so a lot of moments in Appropriate are dependent on the central kind of crisis happening with the sibling squabble. But whether it's the children or the spouses who are not part of that central dynamic, they're orbiting that drama. And the busyness of the stage, because an initial point of Appropriate is that the family is trying to sell off all of their father's old derelict things, and so there's a lot of mess on stage initially, and towards the end, there's a great montage of the house becoming more and more broken down. And so there's this incredibly busy stage where so many things are, and then you've got these characters who are each carrying their own hurt and anger filling that stage up.
And so that promise and that value of seeing how effective a work can be when it's prioritizing that kind of constant ensemble on stage, um, is so critical in Appropriate. So many important sequences of, you know, a character hidden in a doorway, so the audience sees them, but not the characters overhearing something else or another scene where a character is on the couch downstairs and the characters coming down from the staircase looming over. And that kind of thing where wherever you're looking at on the stage, you're getting something vital. And so rather than the main character or the star pulling all the focus to the middle of the stage, there's such a sharp and thoughtful use of the entire stage platform.
And so wherever you're sitting, you're getting something really vital about that. And I think, especially thinking about theater, I mean, you know, ticket prices are so much, and audiences who are not near to the stage could sometimes feel like they're not getting the full remit of the show. And I think what's so great about a work that prioritizes that richness of the ensemble is that no matter where you're sitting, you're getting this really vital part of what's working so effectively in it. You know, you're using the space, you're using the characters, you're using the performers, and so it never feels as if anything is going to waste, and instead you're getting this really complex and rewarding dynamic of a show that is recognizing that bodies and movements and ensembles are at the crux of what makes theater so familiar and engaging for audiences.
[43:09] Andrew Kendall: And I really think some of that dynamic is partially responsible for what has made the play Hadestown such a long-running and successful play on Broadway. Hadestown, of course, is the Tony Award-winning musical that is now celebrating its sixth year on Broadway. And it's a sung-through musical. It's a retelling of the Orpheus and Eurydice myth on Broadway. Uh, it's narrated by the god Hermes, and it also intersects with the story of Hades and Persephone. So there are five primary characters in Hadestown, but there is also an ensemble of six. They are down in hell as workers in Hades, you know, oppressive steel tone. They're constantly around. They're singing so much of the refrain. Um, they're the three characters who play the Fates that are also kind of shadowing the characters in significant moments.
And I think Hadestown is the platonic good of a musical that is completely tapped into the power of the ensemble. Like every role in Hadestown feels like a vital bit. Uh, you know, they've got a moment where the spotlight is on them, or when you look at the way that Rachel Chavkin is directing them in juxtaposition to each other, or thinking about the fact that the band for the musical is prominently on stage and actually gets a call out from Persephone in one of her numbers. This idea of community, it just feels so moving and powerful there. And I know I probably sound a little, you know, susceptible to this idealistic view of theater, and obviously, theater is not like a perfect world where things are always wonderful.
Um, I'm not under any illusion that theater is inherently more socialist than film. But I did leave my showing of Hadestown thinking a lot about the role of solidarity in this show and just theater generally. Like I mentioned, it's famously a show that has its band in full view, and you know, like the cheers from the audience when they're called out. Um, thinking about how this is really a story of two people. It's about Orpheus and Eurydice. But because of the dynamics of how the show is performed, then no offense to all the wonderful one-person shows out there, but it makes it such an interesting contrast across Hadestown, which is celebrating so many years on Broadway. And thinking of how, even though it has a single narrator or it's really about this ultimate love story, this idea of the characters moving in relation to each other, like Hadestown understands bodies and motions.
It's meticulously blocked. And what's so central here is that despite having, you know, these five central or principal characters, when I think about the show, I'm almost immediately thinking about the singing ensemble in my head. And it's gaining so much mileage as a show out of these ensemble players in juxtaposition to the main ones. Like there's several scenes in the second act of the play where Eurydice or Orpheus are weaving through the ensemble, and not in a case where we're only prioritizing the named characters, but we're giving so much space to the performers who are acting in the ensemble, but also recognizing how an awareness of what those ensemble characters are doing is so vital to the larger theme of Hadestown, which is why one of my favorite moments in the play is the reprise of "Chant 2" when the members of the ensemble sort of begin to sort of lose that oppression they're feeling under Hades' rule and kind of think about themselves as in union with their other characters because one of the essential things about Hadestown, which is essentially it pre-imagines Orpheus and Eurydice as lovers in this, you know, cold, oppressive world.
Essentially, Eurydice signs her life away to Hades and begins working in a steel factory where all these characters are members of the ensemble, but they have no context for each other, they don't think of each other, and they're so isolated. And part of the show's thematic point is on encouraging the characters to recognize that they're existing in context with each other. And of course, that makes this sort of an ideal play to think about the dynamics of, you know, union and ensembles that I've been talking about over this episode. And Hadestown, the choreography, the blocking, the staging of it, is constantly emphasizing that point I made in Appropriate, where the characters are never really alone.
And part of that is meant to be something ominous. Um, there's very little privacy in that. And so the brief moments where a character actually goes off stage and closes a door where we can see them, like significantly in the moment when it's implied that Hades and Eurydice have sex, those moments are really significant because generally speaking, you have this stage where all the characters are almost always on stage, and there's that kind of overlap between the public and the private that is so integral to the journey that these characters are on.
[49:52] Andrew Kendall: I'm always a little cautious about any adaptation of the Orpheus myth, and one of my lesser favorite things about Hadestown is that I always find adaptations of the myth that don't imagine Orpheus as a stronger character a little bit weaker. But I must, you know, give a nod to Jordan Fisher, who is playing Orpheus in the production currently, and is such an incredible performer. Like in text, I'm not sure Orpheus is as indelible as a character, but as played by Fisher, he is just incredibly excellent, and he plays so well with others. And so his scenes with The Fates, the scene with Eurydice, his scenes with Persephone, his scene with Hades, they're all so vital. He's such an excellent ensemble performer. And so the text becomes even richer in terms of thinking about all these characters who might think that they're existing in isolation, are really all bound up together even when they don't want to be.
[51:09] It's funny, the other long-running musical I saw was Six, which is incidentally a musical that is about characters kind of being thrust together beyond reality. Six is the concert musical about the six wives of King Henry VIII. And the conceit of this show is that the six women are in a competition to see which of them had the worst life. Obviously, they didn't all meet in reality. Many of them died. Two of them were beheaded. I mean, that's part of what the opening number is about. And so it reimagines them as a girl group of six in juxtaposition with each other. And the thing about Six is that unlike the previous shows, it's not trying to create any semblance of reality in its scenic design.
It's very much a concert show. But with the absence of scenic design, the blocking and the actors' relationship with each other has become so much more important because it's done as a girl group show. They're almost always on stage together. And so a lot of the dramatic tension in Six is built purely from the actors' costuming or the choreography or their blocking, how they're standing in relation to each other, what the other queens are doing when one queen has their solo.
[52:52] One of the highlights of the show is the kind of mid-play number, "House of Holbein," where they kind of imagine themselves preparing Anne of Cleves for her meeting with the king as his fourth wife. And incidentally, Six is also a show that, like Hadestown, has the band on stage and they are called out by one of the cast members. And just like in Hadestown, it was so great watching the audience, you know, cheer and clap so enthusiastically when those moments happened. And again, it made me think about the brilliance and just the charm of that, like centering that aspect of solidarity in theater, centering that aspect of the ensemble working in tandem. Because of course, Six is a show that completely avoids any sense of one character standing above the other.
You know, the wonderful closing song in Six is about how these women, rather than competing to see who had the worst or who is the most significant, they band together in that beautiful closing song to talk about their community.
[54:13] And Six is actually the last of the six shows that I saw, and I left it thinking so much about how its ethos of these women as part of a whole is my ideal of how I think about any kind of theatrical work. You know, as somebody who has taught drama as literature, who studied drama as performance, who has acted in my college days, I think one of the reasons that theater will always have that pull for me is because of the promise of community that it offers, not in an idealistic way where everything is perfect, but a theatrical show is so dependent on every evening, every section of that whole coming together and coalescing into something that's so effective. Like, of course, during the show, I'm thinking about which performers are catching my attention the most, and I do want to identify Starm Lever as Anne Boleyn and Didi Romero as Catherine Howard, who I really want to see where their careers go.
They're doing such interesting things in their acting performances, even as their numbers are both fairly comedic. But every time I found myself kind of focusing on the performer that I might feel strongest about, the show keeps on, you know, resisting that kind of focus and bringing them back into context.
[55:58] And so all the sharp moments in Six are very much about forcing the audience not to be thinking in that kind of singular way and to be thinking of these women in context, and that is what I want for thinking of theater, also. It's not that I'm saying that all shows should be ensemble shows, although honestly, why not? But just recognizing how the power of the ensemble is so peculiar and valuable about theater. It's something that theater does that I think only theater can do as effectively. And I'm always or often so dismayed when that, you know, awareness of solidarity or that awareness of the power of the ensemble is kind of whittled down in other forms. Ensemble films and television have been such critical aspects of some of the best of that art form. And I do think that the success of the shows that I've mentioned, whether critically or commercially, is for the ways that audiences can come to them and retain so many different but equally valuable things from them.
[57:18] I mean, even though The Great Gatsby is not as effective as the play on its whole, there are so many things that you can pull from. Hadestown and Six, you know, they've been running for years, and I expect them to run for very much longer because they're offering so much more than a singular story. Appropriate and Vanya, as I said, is doing such a great job of representing the ensemble dynamics of family. And Suzan-Lori Parks, who incidentally, you know, her most famous play is Topdog/Underdog, which is really about two main characters, I really enjoyed watching her sort of build on the meta-theatrical element of what it means to build a community in the theatrical world in Sally and Tom.
And each of those eight characters are conveyed in such sincere and thoughtful light that you leave the show not just thinking about the title characters Sally and Tom, but about the entire community that they're existing in, both in terms of the historical play, but also the behind-the-scenes drama unfolding with the theatrical troupe.
[58:31] And so I definitely left this collection of shows wanting to see more ensemble shows on stage, wanting to see more ensemble films on screen, but also realizing and needing artists across, you know, different artistic modes, recognizing the power that comes not in isolation, but in seeing ensembles working with each other. I think it's such an important value of theater, both for the performers, which affords even the most minor character to feel weighted, but also a way of reflecting the reality of our world. We're not just living in isolation. People who we meet for a single minute can, you know, change our life or have an indelible effect on it. And just thinking about the difficulty of being in the arts right now, just on a practical level, I think having shows that are built on large or, you know, intermediate-sized ensembles is just good for the industry generally.
Having so many potential performers start off in these minor roles. Like I'm looking forward to, you know, the children in Appropriate developing. I hope some of the ensemble members in Hadestown have their big break ultimately or go on to star in many more ensembles. And I just want to recognize the value of the directors and the choreographers and the playwrights who are shaping these shows, even when they're about themes of loneliness, recognizing that the power of live theater is the energy of bodies in context with other bodies as the audience breathes the same air and is able to enjoy the wealth of that kind of communal performance on stage.
[1:00:36] So this is my little survey of what's been happening in theater, well, New York theater for the last couple of months. And just a reminder that there's so much value to be gained from thinking about ensembles in shows. You can find me online at my column, Real Encounters with Two E's, or you can find me on Twitter. My handle is DepartedAviator. You can find Token Theatre Friends on Twitter and on our website, where we continue to strive to bring you new and interesting ways of thinking about theater. Theater is life, life is theater, and we are all served best when we recognize how the value of theater is best served by us, not in isolation, but in relation with each other as ensembles and as a community. Thank you for listening.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
