Rebecca De Mornay stars in John Patrick Shanley's play The Pushover at The Chain Theatre. The play is directed by Kirk Gostkowski and also stars Di Zhu, Christina Toth, and Christopher Sutton... Read More
From the show: When Lightning Strikes!
About
Rebecca De Mornay stars in John Patrick Shanley's play The Pushover at The Chain Theatre. The play is directed by Kirk Gostkowski and also stars Di Zhu, Christina Toth, and Christopher Sutton. De Mornay first gained widespread recognition with her screen debut in Risky Business and went on to deliver memorable performances in films including The Hand That Rocks the Cradle and Runaway Train, along with an extensive body of television work. In addition to her prolific performing career, De Mornay is also a writer, director, and producer.
This episode was recorded on April 17, 2026.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jeryl Brunner: From Shakespeare to Schwartz, from Fossey to Alvin Haley, from San Time to Burelis, from McNally to Faye. It happened to the greats, it still happens every day. When lightning strikes, it's the moment you know. When lightning strikes, where your mentor goes, you can stand in Chalureka. Do whatever you like. You'll never forget the moment when lightning strikes. This is Jeryl Brunner, and you're listening to When Lightning Strikes.
[0:28] Jeryl Brunner: Rebecca De Mornay stars in John Patrick Shanley's's play The Pushover at the Chain Theatre, directed by Kirk Gostkowski. Bringing her signature intensity and nuance to the stage. She first gained widespread recognition with her screen debut in Risky Business and went on to deliver memorable performances in countless films, including The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, Runaway Train, and an extensive body of television work. In addition to her prolific performing career, Rebecca is a writer, director, and producer. Well, welcome.
[1:19] Rebecca De Mornay: Hi.
[1:22] Jeryl Brunner: Thank you for that intro.
[1:23] Rebecca De Mornay: Thank you.
[1:24] Jeryl Brunner: Happy to be here, Rebecca.
[1:25] Rebecca De Mornay: Thank you.
[1:26] Jeryl Brunner: So tell me about when The Pushover came into your life, when you heard about it.
[1:30] Rebecca De Mornay: Well, um, I was part of a one-night-only benefit performance for the Lee Strasberg Theatre Institute in New York last November with Alec Baldwin. He and I are both alumni of the school, and Alec really sort of got in touch with John Patrick Shanley's, who very graciously offered to donate five of his one-act plays to a night to benefit the Lee Strasberg Theatre Institute. I got to do a play, a one-act with Alec on stage, and I met John Patrick Shanley's there, which I was just so delighted to be able to work on his words. And, you know, I love Alec Baldwin. I've known him for a while. I did a movie with him. But to be able to be on stage doing John Patrick Shanley's's work with Alec was such a delight.
I was so inspired, and I really hit it off with John Patrick Shanley's. I mean, which was a wonderful thing. I mean, I'm one of his biggest fans since Savage in Limbo and Danny in the Deep Blue Sea, which came out in the early 80s, uh, the same time as my career started, and I was fascinated by Shanley's writing, um, which really struck a nerve in me and went deep into my heart, actually. So to be able to work with him, it was just such an experience in November. And then he and I talked because we just sort of hit it off, and our minds kind of operate in a similar way, funnily enough. But he suddenly came to me and said, oh, and he's been sending me things that he's written just because I'm such a fan.
And I say, what else have you written? And he said, oh, well, this is what I'm working on now, and he sent it to me, and he sent different things. And then he sent this thing called The Pushover, which I thought was just one more of the things that he's working on. And then he sent a text saying, but we need to know this weekend if you want to do it. And I said, what? I said I had no idea it was for me. And so I actually pulled over to the side of the road. It was on a text, and I started reading it, and I was just flabbergasted by it. It's nothing like John has ever written. Um, it's so explosive, it's so unpredictable, it's so exciting and dangerous and, you know, complicated in an interesting way.
Like anybody that sees this will not be bored. That I know for sure, right? It was, you know, but when I first finished reading it, I thought I was speechless because I've never seen anything like this before. And I just said, wow, which was my response to John after I read it, and I said, let me just read it again to really see if I can deliver to this role. I mean, Evelyn is not really anything I've played before, and so I reread it again, now not from the stance of the audience, but, you know, to try and see, can I really bring something to Evelyn? And by the end of my second read, I thought, yeah, I can. I think I know what he's doing, I think I can do it. And so I said, yes, there was one small wrinkle.
At that very moment in time on that Friday, I had lost my voice. I had for the first time in my life somehow contracted both laryngitis and bronchitis at the same time. Plus, I had some sort of other thing going on in my vocal cords, and I literally couldn't speak. So I signed on saying yes, not being able to speak, and rehearsal started the following Wednesday, so like five days later. Um, so I was, you know, I had to sort of pack up. I went to an ear-nose-throat doctor in LA, then I went to another one here in New York, and we, you know, put all the pieces together so that I slowly got my voice back, and I was ready by the time we did previews. So that's my long-winded answer to your question about The Pushover.
[5:50] Jeryl Brunner: Well, what a journey. And I think about, yeah, how Evelyn is unlike any other character I've seen, you know, you play, and how these three women, you just, well, I think about how you kind of strap in and you just go on this roller coaster. You never quite, it takes you on these twists and turns, and you think you've figured it out, but you haven't, and it's exciting, and they're all very, very different. And I think, God, love is so complicated, and how they get under each other's skin and the risks they take for each other, and the pain they inflict all for love. But how do you describe the play?
[6:36] Rebecca De Mornay: Well, I think it's, you know, it is very different than anything Shanley's written, but it has that common thread of his really asking the audience to consider the moral contradictions that we all have as humans, you know, and bringing out into the open in the context of this. To me, it's like film noir plus psychological drama plus very black comedy. To me, those three things are together. But in the context of that, um, bringing out into the open the conflicts, uh, the moral ambiguities that are inside of all of us, and, you know, as well as exploring the topic of what is good and what is evil, uh, which is interesting how the characters deal with that. My character, you know, I won't give too much away.
Hopefully, people, I don't want to give it away, but you know, one character is supposedly evil but does a lot of good. One person is supposedly good, but when push comes to shove, she behaves differently than she would have thought. And one person is a very traumatized person that we don't really learn a lot about, um, who inflicts pain and inflicts deceit and lies because she seemingly has never experienced anything else, is how it comes to me. So, you know, and when they all clash into each other, yeah, it's just fascinating.
[8:19] Jeryl Brunner: Yeah, sparks fly. But look, and what do you love about Kirk's directing?
[8:26] Rebecca De Mornay: Kirk is, when I first met him over Zoom when I was still in Los Angeles, the first thing that hits you is his warmth, which I think is really, really important for a director. Not every director has warmth, and as an actor, um, it's deeply soothing to come into a project with that coming at you. Having said that, he is very accomplished and very specific about what he sees and what he wants. And I think he was very right on. A thing that struck me about him was his use of blocking. You know, he wanted to block almost immediately after we had done a table read, which I found strange because a lot of times you need to really just work on it with the actor before you start blocking where you're gonna go.
But the way he did it and the way he explained it was, I'm trying to help you. It doesn't have to stay this way, but I'm trying to help you have like an itinerary of how you're moving about in the scene to help you memorize the lines. And I thought, whoa, I'd never heard anyone actually say that. And in fact, that is a thing. It's absolutely true. Oh, your body and your instrument realize, oh, when I start walking towards that chair is when I'm saying da-da-da. And when I start, so it is very helpful, and we didn't retain all the original blocking, but I learned that from him, which I'm very appreciative of.
[10:04] Jeryl Brunner: That's wonderful. And I think about, yeah, the Chain Theatre and how they work with, of course, John Patrick Shanley's and David Rave and Eric Fagosil, and they also support emerging playwrights. What do you love about the Chain Theatre?
[10:23] Rebecca De Mornay: Well, that's wonderful, yes. Well, I feel very fortunate to be able to work on a John Patrick Shanley's world premiere. No one's ever done this play before. So that's a thrilling experience. But I also, you know, living mostly in Los Angeles, was not really aware of the New York theater scene, off-Broadway, you know, all the different theaters that exist. And I was very taken. I trusted John that if John wanted to do a play in a theater, that it was going to have great genes. And, you know, I was right. And it's a wonderful idea. And it's very risky for them. You know, because it’s, you know, the economics in all businesses are really difficult right now. But for them to really want to nurture emerging talent as well as pull in really great writers that are established great writers, you know, and to do these audience participation things they do where they give the audience a chance to understand the playwright.
Um, tonight I'm actually doing a talk back with the Lee Strasberg Theatre Institute that has bought tickets, and, you know, I, 40 over 40 years ago, I went to the school, and so they're coming, and I'm going to speak with them with Kirk after the performance tonight. You know, and the Chain is organizing those things, you know. So I have a lot of respect for them and a lot of affection.
[11:56] Jeryl Brunner: I'd love to know your lightning strikes moment when you knew in your heart you had to be an actor or an artist.
[12:05] Rebecca De Mornay: I had initially wanted, very initially wanted to be a psychiatrist. Then I had also wanted to be a singer-songwriter, um, which I'd sort of tried in London for a bit before I came back to the United States. I had never had any ambition to be an actor, funnily enough, never. It was never on my radar. I never did any theater, I never took an acting class, wasn't in any school drama club, nothing. Um, but since I grew up in Europe, and when I came back, I had sort of decided I actually didn't want to be a singer for various reasons. Um, and I didn't really know what to do. And I literally walked by the Lee Strasberg Theatre Institute in Los Angeles, and I walked in, and on the walls were framed pictures, eight by tens of, you know, Al Pacino, Robert De Niro, Marlon Brando, James Cagney, Marilyn Monroe, Dustin Hoffman, my favorite, favorite performers, because I was always a movie buff.
I never thought about acting, but I loved movies always. Um, I just thought, oh my God, like they were all trained by this guy, Lee Strasberg. And this is the, so I interviewed just on a lark to go to the school, and um, then I went, and it's a long-winded answer again to your question.
[13:34] Rebecca De Mornay: When I knew the acting was for me, was um the first thing they had you do in the acting class there was to find a monologue, any monologue, and just do it in front of the audience so they could see where the student was at. And I picked a monologue and uh I picked a monologue of a very conflicted, tormented character. Um, and when I was done with it, I had this sensation that, oh, this is what I know how to do, even though I'd never taken a class yet, and I knew that I had a lot of training that was ahead of me but something inside of me I felt I'm kind of born to do this I just feel it I know it and I got you know after you do a scene in acting class so then they give you a big critique the teacher the students you know write notes about what the teacher says so after I was done getting the notes I walked back to my seat because there were rows of seats I don't know it was like 20 people in the class um and as I walk back to my seat I looked over the shoulder of a kid that was writing in their notes from what the teacher had said and I glanced the sentence Rebecca is so good it's scary and I looked at that and this kid does not know to this day that I saw that but that gave me such confidence um that I remember to this day it was you know 43 years ago um and that's what that's what encouragement can do to people but but that's when I knew I mean that after that monologue is when I knew and I also was extremely um lucky um a lot of people aren't but you know it was only uh a year and a half after that that I went up for Risky Business and I got it you know it's like unheard of so I've been blessed I know it.
[15:46] Rebecca De Mornay: I'm grateful. But it's like the old adage, the harder you work, the better your luck so but you know, that's true. Because Paul Newman also said, like, luck is a talent. I remember he said. Ah. So what was that first monologue that you did?
[16:00] Rebecca De Mornay: It was a play called Birdbath by a really cool playwright, Leonard Melfi, who I loved reading at the time. And it was just a simple monologue of a girl that seems very edgy and very uh squirrely, and she comes home with a guy, and he's trying to pick her up, and they're talking, and he can't quite make any headway with her. And she gets more and more edgy, and then she suddenly whips out a bloody knife from her trench coat pocket, and we come to realize that she's just killed her mother. Just a little light m first monologue.
[16:38] Jeryl Brunner: Very for your debut. What would you say is so the guiding pro when you have you know a role like Evelyn in The Pushover, what do you do? What's your process? Unless that's a personal thing. How do you approach a role?
[16:54] Rebecca De Mornay: Oh no, that's not personal at all. That I mean it is personal, but I can certainly talk about it. So every role is different, you know. Um, sometimes I have to you know, I have to actually do research. I've played an attorney for Sydney Lumet, and I spent a lot uh a criminal defense attorney, so I spent a lot of time um finding criminal defense attorneys and talking with them in their offices and getting to know the vibe of of what a defense where they come from, what what's on their mind when they go to court, how they dress, da-da-da. So for Evelyn, and because I only had five days before we went into rehearsals, uh, and because I also knew that John Patrick Shanley's was going to be at the rehearsals, which he was.
So he was part of, because it was the first time his play was being created. So he really wanted to have a say in, you know, how it unfolded, which he did. So I knew that I would have some extra guidance from the person that wrote it, which gave me extra confidence.
[17:58] Rebecca De Mornay: But for this role, I think the most important I leaned into what I what I know about leadership and directing. I did direct a film once, and I have executive produced two. So the mindset of when you uh are the leader and controlling what happens on the set. Um, you know, because Evelyn is a very powerful, dynamic leader in her own way. And leaning into the, you know, the the psychological things and reasons that I could connect to, you know, she's very shut down emotionally. What made her that way? Where do I connect with that? How do I connect with that? And then her relationships with the other two women. I mean, part of the method that I learned at the institute was, you know, how to use substitutions of who are these people in in my life?
How who do they remind me of, and how do they make me feel when I deal with that person? So it was kind of like that, really. And also honestly, John Patrick Shanley's wrote in to the play um a song uh that he that is played during it. And I just listened to that song, and that song is so melancholy. And to me, it reminds me of like a melancholy western. And then that also imbued me with the tone of what we're doing in this play. What I'm doing, what we're all doing. He liked that. He said he liked that a melancholy western.
[19:35] Jeryl Brunner: Melancholy. That's a great, and you really, I don't want to give it away, but I the your transformation, even within the first scene. And when she's when she's with Pearl in the other scene, she's completely different, right?
[20:00] Rebecca De Mornay: Yeah, completely different. And which is an interesting thing, how we all are completely different depending on who we're with. You know, like we are all different people. Like I'm one way with you, right? Another way when I talk to my kids. I'm another way if I talk to somebody I'm interested in flirting with, you know, we we all are different people, but but Evelyn in the second one is really talking to someone who she loves in spite of herself.
[20:28] Jeryl Brunner: Yeah, is yeah. No, it's fascinating. And it's really is it possible to describe how it makes you feel when you're on stage, especially on stage versus oh on stage versus on the set. Um or or how you feel both, what that's like for you when you're really cooking, you're feeling like you're inhabiting this role.
[20:53] Rebecca De Mornay: The thing that the thing that I've really felt in in doing, I've mostly been in front of the camera, but I have done some very major roles on stage as well. Yeah. And what I what I always feel afterwards, after I've performed on stage, I feel tremendously that I've been given from the audience that that I've been given and that I've been blessed with something that that fills me so that when I leave, I'm usually very full up and full of energy and full of life and full of excitement. It's a very gratifying emotional experience acting on stage. You know acting on film is is gratifying in a different way but when I go to the film set everything is you know it's more military. You go there at five o'clock in the morning you get your makeup and hair done.
You know seven o'clock there's a da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da. And then you do two minutes of a scene and that's the take that you're gonna do. And then you do it again from a different angle then you do it again from a different angle. And at the end of the day you've delivered you know maybe five minutes of what's going to be your ultimate your your performance and they only can film what you brought with you to the set that day. Like what you bring is what's on camera and they take from you. That's what that's my experience. It's like the camera takes so at the end of the day shooting I feel depleted like I feel drained. Like I brought something and they took it and I'm thrilled because now it's on camera forever.
It's it's there. But it's this experience of having been taken from that's that's how I could say the difference between the two but but actually being on stage is is is a very exciting thing because Shanley was talking about how there's three there's three characters on stage always there's you your scene partner and the audience oh I love that yeah so he's so it's like the audience is part of the scene yeah and it's hard to it's hard to really articulate but that is something that happens so you're you're communing with people which is how theater began in the first place there was something communing about it something even you know spiritual of you know they they enacted a lot of you know their holy yeah holy stories you're on the live journey you know it's just so unique and it's in that moment it's really special.
[22:39] Jeryl Brunner: Is there a role you're aching to play you played so many different roles but is there one the two roles that I was always aching to play that I've now aged out of completely were um Joan of Arc and Juliet those are the two roles I always wanted to play and um yeah that didn't happen I say it's never too late you know it kind of Juliet is you know probably 16 and uh Joan of Arc is 18 so but I've never seen you know a real 16 year old play on stage on the stage so you never and and what do you yeah no that's wonderful what I would like to play um still I have a uh fascination of playing a spy.
[24:32] Rebecca De Mornay: I'd really like to play a spy. Uh yeah, I'd like to play a spy why why. Why? That would be great. I don't know. I just, you know, and and I'd like to play someone that avenges something that's wronged. Somebody who's been wronged and is a spy slash potential assassin, maybe.
[24:57] Jeryl Brunner: Oh.
[24:57] Rebecca De Mornay: Yeah. And it doesn't have to be that. I just love the idea of playing a spy of people not you're you're something other than what you're um projecting. A spy in the service of good is what I like to say.
[25:11] Jeryl Brunner: Ah sort of adjacent to Evelyn. Well, what do you hope people take away from The Pushover?
[25:19] Rebecca De Mornay: Um, I hope people um take away that they were truly entertained, um, that they weren't bored, which I know they won't be, that they that they feel gratified in some way that they saw real people, like people on stage going through really real conflicts that they can maybe on some level relate to, and that they say like what a lot of people say after the show, like, oh my god, that was so great. And they can't really even articulate why I think they're saying that, but it's um there these you know, subliminally these issues being talked about of good and evil, of what is what really makes someone good or evil, and does something absolute like that even exist? Those are that's sort of a deep under layer of the play, which I think resonates with people whether they know it or not.
[26:17] Jeryl Brunner: Yeah, and the cost of being human and for love.
[26:22] Rebecca De Mornay: Well, it's not always the best plan.
[26:26] Jeryl Brunner: Yeah, yeah. Well, it's it's such a joy to talk to you. Thank you so much so much, Gerald. You're an absolute delight.
[26:35] Rebecca De Mornay: Thank you very much.
[26:36] Jeryl Brunner: Thank you.
[26:37] Rebecca De Mornay: Thank you.
[26:40] Jeryl Brunner: It happened to the greats, it still happens every day. When lightning strikes is the moment you know, the theme song was written by Tom McGovern. This episode was produced by Alice Stroud.
[26:54] Rebecca De Mornay: Lightning strikes.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
