Back in October of this year we lost a beloved star of the stage and screen, Angela Lansbury. Her performing career spanned 80 years in which she received six Tony Awards, six Golden Globe Awards, and one Laurence Olivier Award... Read More
From the show: Why I‘ll Never Make It
Guests
About
Back in October of this year we lost a beloved star of the stage and screen, Angela Lansbury. Her performing career spanned 80 years in which she received six Tony Awards, six Golden Globe Awards, and one Laurence Olivier Award. Despite her years in television and movies (her last film role was Glass Onion in 2022), theater was always her first love, having appeared in 14 Broadway productions and four national tours.
As you’ll hear in this special episode (with a big help from fellow podcaster Dan Delgado), it was a long and bumpy journey towards the role in Mame that would cement her Broadway career and earn her that first Tony Award. You'll hear from composer Jerry Herman and from Angela Lansbury herself in this unlikely audition story of how a character actress from the movies became a leading lady on Broadway.
Episode research and sources:
- "Look Back at Angela Lansbury in the Original Broadway Production of Mame" - Playbill
- "How Angela Became Mame" - Medium
- But Darling, I'm Your Auntie Mame! by Richard Tyler Jordan (2004)
- Anyone Can Whistle - Wikipedia
- MAME - Wikipedia
Sound bites came from these full interviews:
- Angela Lansbury Discusses Mame - Television Academy
- Broadway MAME - Sony MasterWorks
- Broadway ANYONE CAN WHISTLE - Sony MasterWorks
- Jerry Herman with Barbara Walters on 20/20 (1984)
- Lansbury with Barbara Walters (1985)
- Herman Interview for Musical Theater Guild
- Herman on NPR
- “Open a New Window” - 1971 Tonys Awards
- "We Need a Little Christmas" Piano Version - Steven C
- Opening Night of MAME in 1966 - Fred Robbins, radio reporter
At times certain reports or articles conflicted on particular details or order of events, so best efforts were made to rely on the most reliable sources and err on the side of those who knew more about the events surrounding Lansbury's journey.
SUBSCRIBE TO WINMI
Get access to Audition Stories, the Final Five questions, and other bonus content by becoming a monthly or yearly subscriber to Why I’ll Never Make It. Producing this podcast is rewarding in its own way, but I’m essentially a one-man operation. So it is both costly and time-intensive to put together each episode. By subscribing you’ll be supporting these podcasting efforts, and have access to extended conversations and other bonus content. Your financial support of this podcast is greatly appreciated!
- Subscribe to get access to bonus episodes and extra content
- Make a one-time Donation to support transcripts and podcast production
- If you’d like to support WINMI but have limited funds to do so, then contact me directly for reduced-price or even free access to the bonus content.
Follow WINMI: Website | Instagram | YouTube
Why I’ll Never Make It is an award-winning, Top Theater Podcast hosted by actor and singer Patrick Oliver Jones and is a production of WINMI Media. Background music is by John Bartmann and Blue Dot Sessions is used under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:01] Patrick Oliver Jones: Back in October of this year, we lost a beloved star of the stage and screen, Angela Lansbury.
[0:08] Patrick Oliver Jones: She was born in Central London in 1925 and moved to the United States in 1940 to study acting in New York City.
[0:17] Patrick Oliver Jones: She moved to Hollywood two years later and was cast in her first film, Gaslight in 1944 with MGM Studios.
[0:26] Patrick Oliver Jones: Her first Broadway production didn't come until 1957 with the comedic play Hotel Paradiso.
[0:34] Patrick Oliver Jones: Her performing career would end up spanning 80 years, in which she received six Tony Awards, six Golden Globe Awards, and one Laurence Olivier Award, in addition to nominations for a Grammy, three Oscars, and 18 Emmy Awards.
[0:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: That's right.
[0:54] Patrick Oliver Jones: She was nominated 18 times for an Emmy Award over the course of 33 years and didn't win one of them.
[1:02] Patrick Oliver Jones: But the theater was always her first love, having appeared in 14 Broadway productions, four national tours, and numerous other theatrical events.
[1:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: But as you'll hear in this special episode of Why I'll Never Make It, it was a long and bumpy journey towards the role that would cement her Broadway career and earn her that first Tony Award.
[1:25] Patrick Oliver Jones: Here now is Angela Lansbury's audition story for the musical MAME.
[1:34] Angela Lansbury: Between the four of us, we finally put it across with the producers that I would play it.
[1:39] Angela Lansbury: There were many very exotic ladies who were up for the part, let me tell you.
[1:43] Angela Lansbury: And uh it was an extraordinary breakthrough for me.
[1:57] Angela Lansbury: Since 1955, Auntie Mame has been the unstoppable, passionate, easily distracted yet thoroughly down to earth personification of the kind of aunt any child would want to have.
[2:10] Angela Lansbury: The novel that introduced her to the world was written by Edward Everett Tanner III, who wrote under the pseudonym Patrick Dennis, which also happens to be the name of the recently orphaned 10-year-old nephew in the book who comes to live with his aunt on the eve of the Great Depression.
[2:30] Angela Lansbury: Tanner's manuscript was actually rejected by 19 publishers before Vanguard Press finally gave it the green light.
[2:37] Angela Lansbury: And that decision really paid off.
[3:30] Angela Lansbury: And so they approached composer Jerry Herman, who was already enjoying a huge success with another musical at that time.
[3:39] Angela Lansbury: Hello, Dolly was running on Broadway, and I got a call from Lawrence and Lee, the wonderful writers of Inherit the Wind and Auntie Mame.
[3:51] Angela Lansbury: And I had never met these gentlemen, and they asked if I would mind having lunch with them.
[3:55] Angela Lansbury: And I was absolutely thrilled because I loved those two plays.
[3:59] Angela Lansbury: And we went to Sardi's, and after a few minutes of conversation, one of them said to me, How would you like to musicalize Auntie Mame?
[4:09] Angela Lansbury: And again, I didn't have to think or say, Oh, I'll call my agent or any of that business.
[4:17] Angela Lansbury: I just went, oh boy, yes.
[4:20] Angela Lansbury: It was such an instantaneous love affair that I had with this piece of work, because I honestly could have written seven or eight more songs for this character.
[4:38] Angela Lansbury: The musical was originally titled My Best Girl.
[4:42] Angela Lansbury: And from the get-go, these creatives were determined that this show wasn't going to be just Auntie Mame with music.
[4:48] Angela Lansbury: As Jerome Lawrence said, we conceived Mame as a new work and tried to tell it as lyrically and joyfully as possible with music.
[4:58] Angela Lansbury: Nonetheless, Roslyn Russell was the first offered the role of musical Mame, but she turned it down because she didn't want to eat yesterday's stew, as she put it.
[5:08] Angela Lansbury: So then it was decided that legendary leading lady Mary Martin would take on the director, but he wanted to make significant changes to the story, and other artistic differences came up between the creatives, including Ona White, who had been tapped as the show's choreographer.
[5:28] Angela Lansbury: So Logan was decided and would eventually be replaced with Gene Sacks.
[5:34] Angela Lansbury: And to complicate matters even more, Mary Martin ended up declining to do the show, offering the excuse that the score failed to captivate her, or maybe she was just ready for a break from the stage after years of back-to-back Broadway productions of South Pacific, Peter Pan, and The Sound of Music.
[5:54] Angela Lansbury: But whatever the reason, Lawrence, Lee, and Herman now had to find a new leading lady.
[6:01] Angela Lansbury: And a veritable list of who's who in show business auditioned for the role, including Betty Davis, Lucille Ball, Doris Day, Phyllis Diller, Catherine Hepburn, Lena Horne, and Dinah Shore, just to name a few.
[6:18] Angela Lansbury: But something seemed to be missing from each one of them.
[6:22] Angela Lansbury: As Jerry Herman put it, Mame is a deceptively difficult role to play.
[6:27] Angela Lansbury: She's so rich and she's so full of fun, and she has her problems and her romance and her disappointments.
[6:36] Angela Lansbury: And it was just everything that a songwriter dreams about being offered.
[6:45] Angela Lansbury: But the juxtaposition of this elegant, charming lady with an undercurrent of wild, unpredictable humor and spunk was not a combination easy to find in most actresses.
[6:57] Angela Lansbury: So after exhausting their list of leading lady contenders, Jerome Lawrence suggested an actress that lived down the road from him in Malibu, Angela Lansbury.
[7:08] Angela Lansbury: Lawrence and Lee asked me to come and have brunch with them in Malibu.
[7:13] Angela Lansbury: So I did.
[7:13] Angela Lansbury: And they were very, very I don't know, they certainly gave me the idea that they thought that I could play Mame.
[7:20] Angela Lansbury: And I all I could think of was, why would you think I could play Mame?
[7:30] Angela Lansbury: The 1963-64 Broadway season was quite an exceptional one.
[7:36] Angela Lansbury: Not only were the likes of Carol Burnett, Sammy Davis Jr., and Josephine Baker starring in hit productions, but that season also ushered in Barefoot in the Park, 110 in the Shade, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Hello Dolly, Funny Girl, and Anyone Can Whistle.
[7:55] Angela Lansbury: In fact, those last two shows were both related in some very remarkable ways.
[8:01] Angela Lansbury: Stephen Sondheim was actually approached to write the score for Funny Girl, but turned it down because their choice of leading lady, Mary Martin, wasn't Jewish.
[8:12] Angela Lansbury: But eventually she turned down the role of Fanny Brice, just like she later did with Mame.
[8:18] Angela Lansbury: For his part, Sondheim chose instead to focus on his own musical, Anyone Can Whistle, which cast Angela Lansbury in the leading role of Cora and offered the role of Faye to Barbara Streisand, who turned down that show to instead star in Funny Girl.
[8:36] Angela Lansbury: What a life-changing and career-defining choice that turned out to be, huh?
[8:41] Angela Lansbury: Well, for Angela Lansbury as well, Anyone Can Whistle was her big break because it was her very first starring role in a Broadway musical.
[8:50] Angela Lansbury: Nobody had ever seen Angela Lansbury on stage, singing, dancing, playing a leading role. And they didn't know whether I could do it. No, I could do it. Didn't know I had the capacity of a voice or anything else. Well, it turns out Lansbury did have the capacity and got favorable reviews for her part. But the show itself was not well received, and Anyone Can Whistle only lasted nine performances on Broadway. Still, even during that limited run, a certain composer by the name of Jerry Herman happened to be in attendance one night. So months later, when Jerome Lawrence suggested Lansbury for the part of Mame, Herman was ecstatic with the idea. Yet when he brought her name up to the producers, they weren't so keen on the idea.
Two of them had also seen Lansbury's performance in Anyone Can Whistle. And though they thought she was a wonderful character actress, they just didn't think she could sing the part or handle the musical comedy required for Mame. Plus, the director, John Logan, didn't want her either. But like I mentioned, he wasn't with the show for long, so eventually his opinion wouldn't matter. Still, it has to be pointed out that according to her own agent, Charles Adams Baker, at that time in Hollywood as well as on Broadway, Lansbury had a reputation as everybody's favorite co-worker, but not a ticket seller. I know it's hard to imagine now, but back then she just didn't have the star power the producers wanted.
However, Jerry Herman kept on insisting and finally convinced the producers to bring Lansbury in for an audition. I wanted Angela very much because I wanted an actress to do that role. And I sensed the need for an actress. He said, I'll do everything I can in my power to help you to audition. We'll do it together. I'll play for you, I'll be there, and I want you to get this part. I believe that you're Mame. I had Angela come to my apartment, and I taught her two songs from the score. And no other lady who auditioned had the benefit of knowing If He Walked Into My Life and It's Today. And when we went to the theater to audition, I snuck into the orchestra pit without anybody knowing, and I accompanied her audition.
One of the show's producers, John Boab, recalls that the audition showed her strong personality and pizzazz, but ultimately Lansbury didn't have the vocal range for the score. Now, sensing this, she returned to California after the audition and began vocal training to help her add more notes and expand her singing range. She was determined and wanted this role as much, if not more than anything else she had done up to that point.
[11:50] Angela Lansbury: Took me more persuasion and more time and more, well, humbling myself really to get that part. It's the one time in my career that I've done that, and I did it for Mame because I knew Mame was the key that would unlock a whole new career for me and get me out of this kind of doldrums of cameo parts that I was locked into for so many years. Lansbury would go on to audition for the role two more times, going back and forth between New York and California. And during that time, the creative team continued to audition other actresses like Lauren Bacall, Kay Ballard, Tammy Grimes, Geraldine Page, and Bea Arthur, the wife of the show's new director, Jean Sachs. Well, four months after Lansbury's first audition, she flew back to New York to meet Jean Sachs for what would be her fourth and final audition.
That's because she gave the producers an ultimatum, saying that this would be her last audition and that she needs a yes or no answer before going back to California. And so after a lengthy casting search and Lansbury's mandate, it finally came down to a vote. And thankfully, the majority wanted Angela Lansbury for the role of Mame. Mame was so joyous an experience because we had a great new star in Angela Lansbury. And everything went right. It was everything that I had envisioned for myself, accomplishing in musical theater. Because what I haven't told you is that all during the years at MGM when I was battling along, playing battle axes and so on, I was running in and watching rehearsals, all of the musical rehearsals for the great musical movies that were being made on the lot at that time with Gene Kelly, Mambo, Leslie Caron, and all those, and I knew all of the musical people involved.
And I thought, oh gosh, this is it. This is what I really want to be doing. This is what I'm gonna really love to do one day. And I really visualized myself doing it. Until I did. Found myself up on the stage, playing Mame.
[14:09] Patrick Oliver Jones: Thank you so much for joining me for this special episode. Please check the show notes for a list of the various sources, news clips, and interview sound bites used in this episode. And I certainly could not have done this episode without my friend and fellow podcaster Dan Delgado. I did the research and writing of this episode, but it was Dan who helped me edit it all together. Please check out his podcast called The Industry, which takes a closer look at some of the lesser known and forgotten stories in movie history. And just to let you know, this episode is a bit of a precursor for a new podcast Dan and I are in the beginning stages of creating. It's going to be an insider's look at Broadway musicals, The Famous, The Forgotten, and The Flops.
So stay tuned as that will be coming out sometime in 2023. Until then, there's just one more episode here in 2022 for Why I'll Never Make It, as I take a look back at the sixth season of this podcast, the highs and lows and everything in between. So please join me next week as I talk more about why I'll never make it.
[15:33] Angela Lansbury: And that's the answer. You get it right away in the theater, and you can tell how this opening night audience feels. They're on their feet. It's a standing ovation for Angela Lansbury, and Broadway has another smash hit. Now she's being presented with an enormous bouquet of roses. And still they applaud. For Beatrice Arthur, Jane Connell, Willard Waterman, Frankie Michael, and the colorful cast of Mame. And from here we move to the famous Rainbow Room at the top of the RCA building. Truly a magnificent setting for the opening night party of Broadway's newest smash, Mame.
[16:21] Barbara Walters: Well, you triumphant creature, you Angela Lansbury. What do you think? How do you feel?
[16:26] Angela Lansbury: What do I think? How do I feel? It's impossible to sum up in a couple of seconds, the work of many years. And by that I don't mean to say that I haven't had a marvelous career because I have. But somewhere in the back of my mind, I have had the thought that something like this might happen to me. And now it has. Can you imagine how I feel?
[16:51] Barbara Walters: This is, of course, a whole new horizon in your life, Angela.
[16:54] Angela Lansbury: Yes, it is. Sky's the limit now. I mean, after this, you know, movie roles and other stage roles. My goodness, what an exciting phase of your life.
[17:01] Angela Lansbury: Yes, isn't it? To be 40 and have all that in front of me. Wow. Because when you get to that point, you think, well, the best is perhaps behind, you know.
[17:09] Barbara Walters: Mm-hmm.
[17:10] Angela Lansbury: Not for me. Tonight's beginning. It's beginning. Isn't that wonderful? We're gonna have you as a resident here, aren't we?
[17:15] Angela Lansbury: Yes, I'm gonna be in New York for quite a while, I think. Family and everything, yeah.
[17:19] Barbara Walters: Oh, yes. Just wonderful. They're thrilled to death.
[17:22] Angela Lansbury: All the very best.
[17:23] Barbara Walters: Thanks.
[17:23] Angela Lansbury: As we welcome a beautiful, new talented, multifaceted star.
[17:27] Barbara Walters: Oh, thanks.
[17:29] Angela Lansbury: All the best.
[17:30] Angela Lansbury: Thanks so very, very much.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
