With politics becoming more and more a part of our daily lives, the theater and acting profession are certainly no strangers to it influence and impact. While it can be a force for change and understanding, my guest today talks about the ways in which it can further divide as well... Read More
From the show: Why I‘ll Never Make It
Featured Shows
About
With politics becoming more and more a part of our daily lives, the theater and acting profession are certainly no strangers to it influence and impact. While it can be a force for change and understanding, my guest today talks about the ways in which it can further divide as well. In the first part of my conversation with Clifton Duncan, he shared deeply personal reflections on the complexities of the theater industry's response to the pandemic and the challenges he faced as an individual in the midst of it all.
For part two, our conversation turns to a thought-provoking exploration of "groupthink" and the influences of social media on theater and the broader society as a whole. He offers valuable insights into the impact of differing viewpoints, the blurring of what is considered extreme, and the need for open-mindedness in the arts and beyond. Also, in the latter half of this episode are some bonus conversations with Clifton, offering a powerful conclusion to an episode filled with honesty and a quest for deeper understanding and introspection.
Subscribe or Donate to WINMI
Producing this podcast is a rewarding experience, but it's also costly and time-consuming as I’m essentially a one-man operation. By subscribing you’ll be supporting these podcasting efforts, and have access to extended conversations and other bonus content. Whether you subscribe or donate, your financial support of this podcast is greatly appreciated!
- Subscribe to get early access to full episodes and bonus content
- Make a one-time Donation to support transcripts and podcast production
- If you'd like to support WINMI but have limited funds to do so, then contact me directly for reduced-price or even free access to the bonus content.
Follow WINMI: Website | Instagram | Twitter | YouTube
----------
Why I’ll Never Make It is an award-winning, Top Theater Podcast with actor and singer Patrick Oliver Jones and is a production of WINMI Media. Background music is by John Bartmann and Blue Dot Sessions is used under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: With politics becoming more and more a part of our daily lives, the theater and acting profession are certainly no strangers to its influence and impact.
[0:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: While it can be a force for change and understanding, my guest today talks about the ways in which it can further divide as well.
[0:18] Patrick Oliver Jones: In the first part of my conversation with Clifton Duncan, he shared deeply personal reflections on the complexities of the theater industry's response to the pandemic and the challenges he faced as an individual in the midst of it all.
[0:32] Patrick Oliver Jones: For part two, our conversation turns to a thought-provoking exploration of groupthink and the influences of social media on theater and the broader society as a whole.
[0:44] Patrick Oliver Jones: He offers valuable insights into the impact of differing viewpoints, the blurring of what is considered extreme, and the need for open-mindedness in the arts and beyond.
[0:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: Also, stick around for the latter half of this episode for some bonus conversations with Clifton, offering a powerful conclusion to an episode filled with honesty and a quest for deeper understanding and introspection.
[1:11] Clifton Duncan: There's always a part of it where it's like rah-rah, sispoo bomb, you know, boosted by your bass, but at the same time, I wish I were different and that I could just shut up because my life would be so much easier, Patrick.
[1:22] Clifton Duncan: But I just I can't, for whatever reason, I can't shut up about this stuff.
[1:30] Patrick Oliver Jones: Welcome to the award-winning podcast, Why I'll Never Make It.
[1:34] Patrick Oliver Jones: I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, an actor and singer for more than 30 years.
[1:40] Patrick Oliver Jones: Every other week I talk with fellow creatives who bring us stories from their own life of personal struggles and professional hardships, with lessons we can all learn from.
[1:50] Patrick Oliver Jones: The website is Why I'll Never Make It dot com, where you can subscribe, donate, and find past episodes.
[1:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: Again, that's why I'll never make it.com.
[2:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, for story number two, you wanted to talk about a particular element of the industry that we've touched on already, which has left you feeling increasingly alienated over years, and that is this groupthink and a demand for strict conformity and unspoken prerequisites for career advancement.
[2:29] Clifton Duncan: And for me, I think no matter what community we're a part of, this idea of groupthink can seep in. You know, I'm from the South. There's a certain way that Southerners go through life. I grew up in the church. There's certainly a prescription for how to live a good spiritual life. Do you see the theater community as this similar kind of insulated bubble?
[2:52] Clifton Duncan: Um, yes, but to a very extreme degree. Um, you know, once you're in a city like Atlanta, which I think is a very sort of purple city in a way, and you know, I've had all kinds of interesting conversations with professionals, um, you know, and with like Uber drivers or, you know, the clerk at Walgreens.
[3:09] Clifton Duncan: And um I just think it's absurd that uh we're in an industry where, you know, I have people who say to me, so-and-so is I'll give you actually a perfect example. There's a group of conservative actors that you can't really talk about. It's sort of like Fight Club.
[3:22] Clifton Duncan: And um, you know, it's invite only, and they are terrified of being outed or of even having their names mentioned because they know that it's going to cost them employment opportunities.
[3:36] Clifton Duncan: And for me, you know, uh I mean, we're a bunch of actors and artists or whatever. We're gonna have our opinions and our feelings about stuff, and we're gonna want to express ourselves, um, which is our right in a free and liberal society.
[3:48] Clifton Duncan: But my beef is that it's absurd to me that we can call ourselves so-called progressives, and yet we also have an industry where people are living in abject fear of expressing any sort of uh political opinions that might differ from the cultural zeitgeist of the moment.
[4:04] Clifton Duncan: And so, you know, I have a colleague named Lincoln Jones who used to run the um the American Ballet Theater in LA, who was ousted uh eventually because he didn't want to um put the um the black square uh on his social media or something when all the George Floyd unrest was um erupting.
[4:22] Clifton Duncan: Um people have called me in tears because white women who are being called Nazis by their friends because uh, you know, again, they don't hop right on the Black Lives Matter train.
[4:31] Clifton Duncan: You know, the fact of the matter is, folks, that there are a lot of people with a great diversity of opinions, but that should have no impact on whether or not they can, you know, match harmonies with you or know how to break down a script and can live moment to moment with you and create great compelling moments for an audience on stage.
[4:48] Clifton Duncan: So I guess my dream is that I mean, I would love for there to be an industry where someone could say, you know, I support BLM because of this, and someone else could say, well, I don't support BLM because of that, and it and the latter not having any impact on their career and um people just being really adult about it and and grown-ups and saying, oh, wait, well, I guess we'll have to agree to disagree, but we have a bigger, you know, there's something bigger than us at play, which is this show we have to do.
[5:14] Clifton Duncan: And um the theater community in particular, but you know, I think this applies to the industry as a whole. They can't, they can never say that they're uh that they're inclusive and that they're tolerant or open-minded until they start understanding that not everyone's a socialist, not everyone thinks progressivism is great, not everyone is a Marxist.
[5:33] Clifton Duncan: And um, and you need people, you need that diversity of opinions and viewpoints, you know, in rehearsal rooms at studios, because what's going to continue to happen is uh what I alluded to before, which is that the asylum will continue to be run by one kind of people, and that kind of people will continue to drift away from the everyday concerns of the general public.
[5:52] Clifton Duncan: And if you want the general public to be a part of your audience base, um, especially as you know, more traditional theater goers are kind of dying off, you need to be more open and uh and you need to understand.
[6:04] Clifton Duncan: I mean, you know, have any of these theaters conducted any surveys? You know, has the Broadway League conducted any surveys? You know, have they asked the people who wake up at the crack of dawn to pick up their garbage, what we know what kind of things they might want to see or what kind of issues are pressing to them?
[6:20] Clifton Duncan: Have they asked their, you know, their housekeepers or their nannies um what kinds of issues are most important to them and what they would like to see?
[6:27] Clifton Duncan: And I think that's at the end of the day, um, where our responsibility lies is to be more open and understanding that look, if people disagree with you, it doesn't mean that they're Nazis.
[6:38] Clifton Duncan: Um it just means that they have different views on the economy and and and legislation and um, you know, the best way to tackle crime and the best way to tackle um, you know, immigration reform, you know, the best way to deal with the healthcare system and that these kinds of things.
[6:51] Clifton Duncan: People have very, very good reasons for being on either side of either argument, and you need to understand that.
[6:57] Clifton Duncan: And um, I think once we are able to do that, um, you know, then we can get back to our industry and and fine art, drama, the theater, being more part of popular society and popular culture, because we'll we'll be reflecting um what people are actually dealing with, as opposed to making everything about trans rights and feminism.
[7:17] Clifton Duncan: I mean, to be blunt.
[7:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, you mentioned having opinions on one side or the other, but I would counter that and saying there's not just one side or the other, there's many sides.
[7:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: There's nuances within each of those sides.
[7:29] Patrick Oliver Jones: So there's not just one way of thinking this way or you're the other.
[7:33] Patrick Oliver Jones: There's so much in between, and there's other ideas that aren't even encapsulated in those two ideas.
[7:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: And I remember for myself, I'd never really thought about this type of culture and the political aspect of being an actor until I was um my very first show when I when I moved to New York was doing producers out in Long Island at Gateway Playhouse.
[7:56] Patrick Oliver Jones: And one of the actors in that it was, you know, maybe a year or so later, we happened to bump into each other and he said, Oh, oh, hey, you're the hey Republican.
[8:04] Patrick Oliver Jones: I was like, What?
[8:06] Patrick Oliver Jones: Oh, oh, hi.
[8:07] Patrick Oliver Jones: I said his name and then we kept on.
[8:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: But I was like, at one point I grew up in the South, and the South was heavily Republican as I grew up.
[8:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: I've since moved beyond that.
[8:16] Patrick Oliver Jones: And I'm I'm in that nuanced camp of I I'm not either side, I'm kind of in that gray area where I I'm much more centrist now.
[8:24] Clifton Duncan: But a very lonely place to be.
[8:26] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes, yes, especially nowadays.
[8:28] Clifton Duncan: Yeah, yeah.
[8:29] Clifton Duncan: Compromise is not something that people like to hear.
[8:31] Patrick Oliver Jones: But having said that, it just struck me that that's how he remembered, like you know, all these months or a year later, that that's how he he saw me.
[8:39] Patrick Oliver Jones: And I don't tend to see people in that way.
[8:41] Clifton Duncan: And it's uh the theater shouldn't be putting people in boxes, you know, that whether it's the characters that we play or the audiences that come and see us.
[8:49] Clifton Duncan: No, well, that that's the thing, you know.
[8:51] Clifton Duncan: It's um for people who are obsessed right now with non-binaries.
[8:54] Clifton Duncan: Um, they they certainly have a very binary way of looking at social cultural attitudes and politics.
[9:00] Clifton Duncan: And um a big frustration for me, you know, uh Zelda Fitchhandler, again, I reference her again, you know, she once said that the two cornerstones, two of the cornerstones of the craft of acting um are empathy and curiosity.
[9:13] Clifton Duncan: And uh in terms of politics, I see very little, very few people exercising empathy.
[9:17] Clifton Duncan: I mean, I look at the issue of abortion, for instance, which I sort of view as a litmus test for both sides.
[9:23] Clifton Duncan: You know, you you don't have to accept the premise, for instance, that abortion is child murder, which is what a lot of pro-life people think.
[9:31] Clifton Duncan: Um I understand where they're coming from.
[9:33] Clifton Duncan: I understand why they think that, yet I'm still pretty staunchly pro-choice.
[9:38] Clifton Duncan: Um, you know, it might my opinions come from a more, you know, uh freedom-minded bodily autonomy perspective.
[9:45] Clifton Duncan: Um, but the thing is that there have been some conservatives I've seen who, you know, that you can't communicate with who are just like, you support murder?
[9:53] Clifton Duncan: You know, or the fact that I'm an atheist, for instance.
[9:56] Clifton Duncan: Um, the Christians in my life have never written me off and said, you know, oh, well, we're not gonna hang out with you, and you're you're a wrong thinker and a sinner and an infidel, and you deserve not to, you know, work or have any jobs or whatever.
[10:10] Clifton Duncan: I don't have to share your belief system.
[10:12] Clifton Duncan: Um I all I care about is are you cool, are you interesting?
[10:15] Clifton Duncan: You know what I mean?
[10:16] Clifton Duncan: And and uh people kind of want to be left alone.
[10:19] Clifton Duncan: I guess the point that I'm getting at is that right now I think that the entertainment industry in the theater in particular is very, very much has very much become a victim of being just in its own echo chamber.
[10:31] Clifton Duncan: And um, and it's funny because even the idea of what a Republican is, I mean, I think Steven Sondheim once said that um, you know, he's glad that he works in an industry that doesn't have any Republicans in it.
[10:40] Clifton Duncan: And I'm thinking, you know, on one hand, I'm like, well, if they're the party of of rich people, then don't don't you want their money?
[10:45] Clifton Duncan: But also, you know, that's that there's no why be that exclusive?
[10:51] Clifton Duncan: Why be that exclusionary?
[10:52] Clifton Duncan: Um, and that's bigotry by definition.
[10:55] Clifton Duncan: You know, it's it's there's no, for my mind, like you were saying, Patrick, there's no place for that in in the theater where we're all working together.
[11:01] Clifton Duncan: It's about community and and exploring all kinds of aspects of humanity.
[11:06] Clifton Duncan: And here's the thing as well, Patrick, you know, is that I didn't even know that there was another way to think up until around 2014.
[11:11] Clifton Duncan: And ever since then, an entirely different world has opened up to me, an entirely different way of uh way of thinking.
[11:17] Clifton Duncan: And this, and just within the past few years, um, you know, just the collective IQ of my network has uh has expanded.
[11:24] Clifton Duncan: I've got friends, you know, who range from scientists and and epidemiologists to writers and journalists.
[11:30] Clifton Duncan: Um they're they're conservative, they're libertarian, they're progressive, they're socialists.
[11:34] Clifton Duncan: Um, but you know, and so there's many areas where we don't see agreement, but at the same time, I still respect these people's intellect.
[11:42] Clifton Duncan: I mean, you know, I mean, I follow the Jacques Aubin magazine um on Twitter for God's sakes.
[11:47] Clifton Duncan: I mean, they're definitely not a far-right institution.
[11:49] Clifton Duncan: Um, it's a socialist publication.
[11:51] Clifton Duncan: But I'm still interested in what they have to say.
[11:54] Clifton Duncan: I mean, one of my favorite things to do is to go to the uh the homepage on uh Real Clear Politics, which is a news aggregator and great for polling data as well.
[12:02] Clifton Duncan: And every morning uh at the top at their home page, they have op-eds from across the country and from uh across the political spectrum.
[12:09] Clifton Duncan: So you can see, you know, the sort of you know, what the tastemakers, the opinion makers are talking about, you know, where the sort of societal conversation is going.
[12:16] Clifton Duncan: That is very interesting to me.
[12:18] Clifton Duncan: You know, and I go back and read books by you know Uda Hagen or Sella Adler, and you know, they're talking about how, you know, actors they need to be educated.
[12:18] Clifton Duncan: They need to be cultured, you know, uh well-read and studied in history and and literature and all these other things, because we are serving as conduits and vessels and mirrors of various societies.
[12:37] Clifton Duncan: So we need to be um educated and we need to be open-minded, but so many artists are not.
[12:43] Clifton Duncan: And it's purely because they are so dedicated to this idea of themselves as progressives when, um, you know, there's just way, way, way is so much more exciting and more interesting.
[12:52] Clifton Duncan: And I think the art becomes better and more textured and nuanced if we allow more, uh, perspectives. It's not that people are walking around spreading, uh, Jewish conspiracies. It's just people are saying, well, you know, I have different ideas about taxes and business regulations, and you know, I'm an immigrant, but I support immigration restrictionism, for instance, or, you know, I'm a minority, and I am not a fan of diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, or I'm a woman, and I have issues with the way that some feminists conduct themselves. Um, you know, or I may, I'm a queer person and I don't like the way that, um, that trans activists are portraying my club, so to speak. These kinds of conversations are what people are talking about in society right now.
[13:30] Clifton Duncan: You know, I think we, uh, the more that we can open ourselves to the idea that people who disagree with us aren't fascists and Nazis, but, uh, actually might have very well thought out reasons for disagreeing with us, then we, we'd be doing better as a business for one. But also I think, again, I say it again that we really need to be all hands on deck right now because the divisions and resentments and everything is so strong right now that, uh, I think that artists really need to take leadership in a way and, um, try to reach out and try to build connections, you know.
[14:04] Clifton Duncan: But that's, you know, maybe all my soapbox, I suppose, in my utopian vision. Well, if one looks back in the recent history of theater in the US, like the 60s and 70s and beyond, theater has shown itself to be a place for the weird, the queer, the unheard voices in society. It's been a very progressive, inclusive environment.
[14:25] Clifton Duncan: And it's also, I would say, I would say progressive and inclusive for a certain strand of people. Well, I'm just talking about the broader history of it, about at least how it's been seen.
[14:36] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.
[14:36] Clifton Duncan: And, you know, and it's often been at the forefront of pointing out the ills of society, pushing for a better world and all these things. Do you think that theater is still a place for that?
[14:46] Clifton Duncan: Well, ideally, I mean, that's one of the reasons that I spent so long in it. I was like, oh, these people are just as weird as I am. They're weirder than I am. Um, and yet now I feel, I feel alienated from the weirdos. But I'm also in a place where, you know, one of the issues, and I've said this to right wingers, um, you know, some prominent right wingers, is that, um, you know, the more conservative-minded people, more right-leaning people, they tend to just be so coldly pragmatic that, uh, you know, that's one of the reasons they kind of self-select themselves out of the arts, you know, because it's hard to sustain a career, you know, they're very much about, um, you know, conscientiousness and industriousness and holding down a job and structure and discipline and delayed gratification and all these things which are boring to so many people in the arts, right?
[15:30] Clifton Duncan: Um, you know, oh God, get all this, all this structure and all these rules and boundaries away from me. Like, you know, we don't really, we don't really like that. Um, so you're talking about people cut from a different cloth altogether in a way.
[15:43] Clifton Duncan: But my, I think my thing is that, uh, yes, um, arts can have, uh, very much a social utility and they can be very, it has been a welcome community for like outcasts. That's why I tell people like, look, look, don't be nice to all those weirdos in your musical theater, you know, in your theater program because those are gonna be the next movie stars and directors and producers and yada yada yada.
[16:04] Clifton Duncan: So all those weirdos are gonna be controlling the stuff that your kids watch. So maybe you should, uh, you know, be a little bit kinder and more inclusive in that way. Um, so yeah, you know, it's, you know, for people who are off the beaten path, I mean, that's why I found a home in it.
[16:18] Clifton Duncan: Absolutely. Uh, and again, I don't think that, uh, it's, it's necessarily a question of either or in any society. You know, I've moved away from this idea of, um, you know, red and blue, left and right, dim and republican. I'm leaning more towards the language of idealists versus realists.
[16:35] Clifton Duncan: You're gonna find more idealists on the left and more realists on the right. And, you know, me as the idealist, I say, man, I want, I would love to start a repertory company that we can share and stream our work with the rest of the world. And, you know, we don't need stars anymore because of, you know, the online space and people are building their own followings now, and you know, there has to be a way we can make money, yada yada yada.
[16:56] Clifton Duncan: And, um, the realist will say, that sounds nice, kid. How do we pay for it? And I think one side is going to check the other side and they're gonna create, there's gonna be tension there because again, you're talking about people with different sort of constitutions trying to navigate their way through life.
[17:12] Clifton Duncan: But look, I'm happy to start a company, for instance, where, you know, I am in charge of creative and acting and performing, and I have some right-wing free market hawk to run the damn thing and keep the kids in line.
[17:24] Clifton Duncan: So while I can play and the other person can keep the lights on and everything. And this kind of collaboration, I think, is, um, really being missed out on by a lot of people.
[17:33] Clifton Duncan: And the last thing that I'll say, um, is an anecdote, which is where I was doing, um, The Piano Lesson in, uh, Hartford, and we had a talk back afterward, and, uh, it was funny because the moderator was trying to make it about black women and August Wilson. I'm like, well, I don't know if you've read his plays, but it's not really, he's not really writing about you. I'm sorry, ma'am.
[17:51] Clifton Duncan: But, uh, you know, I was talking about the character of Boy Willy, who I was playing, and, um, I saw over to the, um, kind of off to the side, there was this, uh, this white couple looked very sort of blue-collar. I felt I got the sense that this poor guy was dragged to the show with all these black people in it, and, um, you know, by his girlfriend to show how cultured he is, you know.
[18:11] Clifton Duncan: But as I was talking about the character of Boy Willie and his drive and his passion and his, his, um, ambition to build a life for himself, this guy just goes, yeah, he sees something that he wants and he goes for it. And I said to myself, that's it.
[18:26] Clifton Duncan: This play about these black people, this black man in the 1920s, this black character's journey resonated and inspired this random blue-collar white dude. And that's the thing that people need to remember is that, you know, excellence and art and all that stuff, it transcends all this partisan nonsense, it transcends all this ideological bullshit.
[18:45] Clifton Duncan: Um, we really do have an opportunity here. And I learned myself, right? I put out, you know, Shakespeare sonnets. I put out recently, uh, a video of myself singing some Rogers and Hammerstein, and the response has been overwhelmingly positive.
[18:57] Clifton Duncan: And my favorite comments are from people who are like, Yeah, you know, I have no interest in musical theater or musicals at all, but I will support this kind of work. I want to see more work like this because this is excellent. And that's the point that I need to get across is that, um, you know, the people that you're dismissing as Nazis and fascists and, you know, um, over their political differences, um, they're waiting, they're dying for you to be brought into the fold of the weirdos, at least, you know, for a glimpse at a time, and given some sort of transcendent, memorable experience that they can talk about, um, you know, for the rest of their lives, maybe, or at least for the evening.
[19:33] Clifton Duncan: So, you know, people want to see what we do. It's just a matter of the people, the practitioners and the arts and the professionals understanding that, um, you know, there's a big old audience out there and they want to be in theaters. So stop alienating them and pushing them away.
[19:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: For story number three, through social media, you have amassed more than 125,000 people following you over various platforms. And getting back to this idea of the arts bringing in more people, in what ways have you been able to use your following, you know, to introduce the arts and entertainment to those who might normally not have been interested in it?
[20:15] Clifton Duncan: Well, like I said before, you know, I, you know, again, like there was one woman who commented on my song video about, uh, she said, uh, you know, I love Broadway, but I can never make it out to see shows. So I would love to see more, uh, stuff like that. I mean, this is Rogers and Hammerstein, by the way.
[20:29] Clifton Duncan: So not any sort of pop music or, you know, the flavor of the moment. Um, people who say this was never really my cup of tea. Um, people who said, Yeah, I found you for your political commentary, but now that I know you can do all this, I want to see more of it.
[20:42] Clifton Duncan: So, you know, I truly think I've been very heartened by this discovery that it's not just a bunch of, uh, progressives in blue metros like LA and San Francisco and New York that have a sensitivity for the arts or whatever. It's that there is an entire sort of world out there.
[21:03] Clifton Duncan: And for anyone who wants to look at me and say, Well, you, um, destroyed your career and you canceled yourself, I would say, well, look, you're basically performing for a very small cluster of people in New York and LA most of the time. If you happen to reach a point where you're on a popular show, then sure, you have that machine that's pushing you into the eyes of the public.
[21:24] Clifton Duncan: But now, you know, we're in a position where, you know, and again, simply by speaking my mind, I, I sort of, you know, lucked my way into this kind of a thing. But I think now artists need to understand that, um, there is such a, uh, a sort of untapped well of followers of audience out there that you can connect with directly.
[21:45] Clifton Duncan: And I think that that gives me a sort of power and flex in a way that I would not have had if I decided to kind of stay with the traditional course and to be quiet. And it's really been heartening because, you know, for instance, um, for a long time, one of my most popular podcasts was with a conservative scholar and, uh, Greek classicist named Victor Davis Hanson.
[22:08] Clifton Duncan: And, um, we talked for a half hour about the importance of Greek tragedy. And, you know, so many of the comments were about how they usually see Victor doing, um, you know, he and he's, you know, uh, center right pundit and scholar and writer, and he's often talking about, uh, politics.
[22:23] Clifton Duncan: But to see him talk about art, people were like, Oh, this is fascinating. I want to read more now. Like, you know, and I have people who say, you know, whenever I see Clifton reference a book, I want to go or a play, I want to go read it and check it out.
[22:35] Clifton Duncan: And I say all the time, you don't need a college education or an Ivy League degree or even a high IQ to know whether or not something moves you emotionally. And I think the more that people remember that, um, the better place that that we'll be in, because, you know, you don't, you don't need to confine yourselves to only having to appeal to what I call quote unquote progressive zeitgeist, which really is a vanishingly small sect of society.
[22:59] Clifton Duncan: Um, I think people are more complex than that. People are, um, they're more open-minded than that than they're given credit for, and I think they're more sophisticated, um, believe it or not, than, uh, than they're often given credit for.
[23:09] Clifton Duncan: And, um, even though things have been very difficult for me, it's not lost on me that, um, you know, as my following continues to grow, it opens up the door for other opportunities that would not have existed if I'd stayed in the sort of traditional machine.
[23:21] Clifton Duncan: And if producers are smart, you know, if I get to the point where I'm like at one million, two million followers or whatever, then guess what? I have the chops to, you know, do a Broadway play or a Shakespeare play or something.
[23:32] Clifton Duncan: I could, I can carry that on my shoulders and bring an entirely new audience to the theater and introduce an entirely new audience to the arts. And I think that at the end of the day, if I can serve as an ambassador in some way for the arts and for artists, um, that would be fantastic.
[23:46] Clifton Duncan: The thing is the artists have to chill out and simmer down and really truly live by the sort of inclusive principles that they claim to stand for.
[23:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: You mentioned about amassing followers and certainly in TV and film, but also coming into theater as well, social media followers is now playing a role in whether some people get cast or not. And what do you think of social media's influence on the casting process?
[24:12] Clifton Duncan: Um, I think it is, um, corrosive, really, because on one hand, it drives so much of the cultural conversation. But you know, when you talk about a platform like Twitter, for instance, well, less than a quarter of Americans even use Twitter. And of that percentage, maybe 10% of active users are responsible for like 90% of the tweets or something like that.
[24:34] Clifton Duncan: So you're talking about a very, very small sect of people who are controlling this conversation. You know, I know there are actors who jeopardize themselves by liking random tweets, you know what I mean? Like if they, if they like a tweet by Candace Owens or by Ben Shapiro or something, then that could cause problems for them.
[24:49] Clifton Duncan: I think that's nonsense. Again, like you will never see me supporting a communist regime, for instance. But if, if I happen to be working with someone and I've worked with socialists and communists who are good at their jobs, I really don't care.
[25:04] Clifton Duncan: I don't care what anyone thinks on social media or what they say. You know, it's just that's just one component of our lives. And if you're a theater or if you're a producer or something and you're thinking of hiring somebody and you don't like that they sent out a certain tweet or something, or you disagree with something that they said, I mean, uh, for me, that's just people being grown-ups and having different perspectives on their life.
[25:26] Clifton Duncan: You know, uh if I'm thinking of it from a practical, you know, maybe even a business perspective, what's gonna be better for this show? What's gonna help generate more uh more revenue, more money, you know, the fact that uh I have this amazing, amazing set of performers and designers, um, or am I gonna just, you know, make sure I only pick people that everyone else in my industry thinks is safe. You know, it just doesn't really once once the hiring decisions become influenced by who is liking people's tweets versus um, you know, or sharing opinions on uh like opinions on social media versus you know their ability, then um again, it's another way of sort of enforcing this sort of rigid ideology on people, these ideological straitjackets uh on people.
[26:06] Clifton Duncan: Um now that said, you know, it's one thing, again, if you're talking about people who are, you know, spreading like Jewish conspiracies and stuff like that, and when you're like, well, I don't know if I want to I don't know if I want to deal, you know, maybe give them a copy of like Hannah Arnt or something and then have them read through that or something. But you know, I mean that that's a different sort of a thing. But I think what we're also dealing with now is that uh we have a paradigm wherein anyone who voices any sort of disagreement with um, and again, I mean, and I separate this term from liberal um ideology, but sort of a left-wing leftist sort of worldview. When you begin to cast those people as Nazis and fascists and you know, who who have dangerous opinions or whatever, um, it creates a real problem because then, you know, prospective hirers and other and your colleagues are gonna say, oh, that person liked a tweet from, you know, again, I'd just say like Ben Shapiro or a Jordan Peterson or something.
Well, you know, and then they spout a bunch of opinions that uh really are informed by what the press has written about them as a focus, like, you know, an actual examination of the ideas and character of the person. Again, I just I think it makes it just sanitizes everything for everyone's protection. And it just makes um it makes people just more boring and and it's really confining and and stifling. And again, like I said before, only a small proportion of people are even on the damn thing anyway. So you know, what do you really care? The tick-bying public is not gonna really give that much of a shit. You know what I mean? We're making ourselves slaves to, you know, these platforms that uh people aren't really really on that much, to be honest with you.
[27:42] Clifton Duncan: I'm curious how much finding this other following, these contrarians who who tend to kind of buck the status quo is as you put it, that having found that following that it makes you want to say more or speak out more. Um not really. You know, I've never been I mean, I'm kind of a weirdo, right? Because I've never been somebody who, I mean, I feel like the implication of of that is uh, you know, they call it kind of clout chasing, you're sort of playing to a base and you're you're inflaming an audience and growing a following that way. Um, I've never been a fame whore. And uh I've never been someone, I mean, even at times where I've tried to say, gosh, why am I still doing this? Well, maybe I want to be famous.
And that's, you know, I just it it never really works for me. I I prefer to be the guy who, you know, after the Broadway show or something, I'll come out a stage door, sign some play bills, and then I can just ride home anonymously on the subway and not be bothered, you know. There's always a part of it where it's like, you know, rah-rah, sispoobomb, you know, sort of boosted by your base, but at the same time, um, I wish I were different and that I could just shut up because my life would be so much easier, Patrick. But but I I just I can't, for whatever reason, I can't shut up about this stuff. And I really, you know, I I try to mean what I say, and I I in terms of like just being really specific and and clear in my thoughts.
And um, I think part of what's going on right now is that the things that I'm saying and what's resonating right now is that a lot of people agree with me, but they might be afraid to speak up about it. And that's why people like me are kind of catching on because they have what's and I try to explain it to people in this way. So right now we're in a space where think about how many people become university professors, how many people become, you know, famous rock stars, athletes, celebrities, journalists, you know, writers, whatever. So you have a small cluster of people relatively who have a very, very, very disproportionately large for reach. And they are controlling sort of public opinion. But what I'm finding increasingly is that public opinion is not really in line with what this small sector of people with a large reach is is really thinking right now.
[29:47] Clifton Duncan: So my theory is that people are calling me, you know, courageous or brave for speaking out. I'm like, no, I don't I don't think I'm being really brave. I think I'm just saying stuff that a lot of people really think, but they're afraid to really uh say anything about it because they don't want to be called, you know, racist or fascist or or whatever by disingenuous people. So I'm not I'm not really a fan, and and people will notice lately I've been sort of really more sporadic on social media because as we were saying before we got on, Patrick, you know, I just um I'm kind of really tired of the of all the culture war stuff and the and the back and war stuff and the partisan stuff. And it's sort of it's fun to indulge in every once in a while, but I don't know if it's really helpful, you know, and that kind of is what that plays into because as much as there's like a there's like a star system in play um in our industry, there's also one in these sort of alternative spaces where you know who's getting on the big podcasts and who's got the bigger followings, and you know, who's making more money on Patreon and who's getting the book deals and like and yada yada yada.
And it's just uh, you know, as I say, same shit, new toilet. So I want to shift more into just doing what I do. I mean, I'm still deeply interested in politics and current events, but like I said referenced before, you know, just putting more work out there, I think needs to be the primary focus, especially as an artist. And that's where I'd rather more, you know, I'd rather grow my following in that way than through all the sort of divisive political stuff, you know what I mean?
[31:03] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right, right. You'd you'd rather get back to artist rather than activist.
[31:06] Clifton Duncan: What would I do? Well, that that's that's exactly it, you know. But I don't think of myself as an activist, but I guess I have become one in some in certain uh aspects. And you alluded to this earlier, but in a uh recent tweet from early January, you said, and I quote, the next time some artist claims that they're standing up against the status quo, remind them that the status quo deemed them nonessential, and they zealously complied. You you definitely seem to have, and I think it's come through in our conversation, they a certain frustration with fellow actors and artists. What kind of reaction have you found calling them out and having, or at least trying to have these conversations?
[31:45] Clifton Duncan: Well, no one talks to me. So, you know, there's that. I mean, you know, I do have people that reach out to me um privately who agree with what I'm saying, but they they wouldn't dare say so publicly. At this point, though, to be honest with you, I'd really don't expect to change any minds at all. I think my biggest frustration is that um, you know, again, we've allowed people who don't care about the arts to dictate that we're not essential. And uh for me, and this is what I've been arguing, I feel like I've been uh a bigger sort of advocate for the arts in a way than a lot of artists themselves have been over the past couple of years, because I've been saying like loud and clear, like, guys, you know, we are essential, we're important, and we should be doing shows, and and you know, we we do serve a function in society.
And um, if you could look beyond the political aspect, if you could look beyond your myopic focus on this one respiratory virus, I think you'd be able to see that. And also you'd be able to see that um, you know, they they want to be in in our world and they want to be a part of our sphere. And you know, like as I was saying before, I mean, they're people are spending money on uh mixed martial arts shows and on YouTubers, but they're not spending it on Broadway. I think part of that is because of the people who run the industry, to be frank. And they've they've sort of painted themselves into a corner, and it's not just Broadway, it's uh various arts institutions. Um I think they've just they've gone too far in alienating people, and um people are responding accordingly.
And if you if you think that you're not essential, then who else is going to think that you're essential? People's standards of living are are going down, and the costs of living are increasing, and they're not going to have as much money to come and see shows. And I think you're going to rue the day that you allowed um control of your industry, your livelihood to be wrested from you by these bureaucrats. And really, and I'm going to say it, um, really for not much gain. You know, uh it's just it's it's sad to watch. And that's my frustration is that um I don't know. I mean, I I felt like I like I said before, acting kind of chose me. I never really chose it. The bug never really bit me, and yet here I am being someone, one of the few voices in the wilderness who have said, no, the arts are important, they shouldn't be closed.
And everyone else has kind of said, Oh, I mean, to hear actors who were kind of resigned to, you know, oh, I guess this show's gonna close or these theaters are gonna close, and yada yada yada. And I'm thinking to myself, like, where is our passion and why are we so passive about this? And why aren't we fighting um the way that these uh you know, these entrepreneurs are fighting to keep to keep our business alive and business and and and to keep it afloat and to keep people um you know managing their own risks, you know, you know, or whatever, you know, but but coming out because again, you gotta understand while shows were closed in New York. I was working at a nightclub, okay. The bars and the nightclubs were open in Atlanta, they were packed.
Um you could get you can get a lap dance at Magic City, but you couldn't go see a Broadway show. And um we've allowed ourselves to become non essential, uh essentially. And this is a really long way of saying it. And uh, that's been my frustration is uh why didn't we fight harder to preserve um to stand up for ourselves? I think that's that's the main point of it.
[34:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, this may be the second half of my interview with Clifton, but subscribers to Why I'll Never Make It already got the full conversation in their feeds a couple of weeks ago. They also got to hear Clifton's audition story and his thoughts on the final five questions. Well, as my gift to you on this last episode of season seven, you're actually going to hear those bonus segments with the hope that you too will consider supporting this podcast and help me produce future episodes. All you have to do is go to why I'll never make it.com and click subscribe or just look for the link in the show notes.
[35:37] Patrick Oliver Jones: Another benefit besides access to full episodes and bonus content is not having to listen to any ads either.
[35:54] Clifton Duncan: So I had just gotten back from I think I was doing the Scottsboro Boys in uh San Francisco. And uh I you know, I was like kind of jet lagged. I've been in California for like months and months and months, and I was uh called in for the role of Asagai and um in a Raisin in the Sun and Felicia Rashad was directing this production. And so, you know, I kind of I could play Asagai in my sleep, basically, and it's a role I really enjoy. And you know, so I I prepped as much as I could, and I ended up getting a call back. Uh I went in in the morning, and uh, you know, my first audition was hilarious because uh, you know, I went in and two of the readers are people that I knew, but I didn't like very much.
And then the and then the um the room itself was sort of cold and and and drab because you know, Miss Rashad, I don't know what was going on with her, but uh, you know, there was a palpable tension in the room. But then at the other end of the, you know, sitting in the corner as Tara Rubin, the casting director, with just this big smile on her face, completely in contrast to the rest of the room. And uh, I love Tara so much, but she was like, hey, you know, and so already it was kind of weird, and uh, you know, I yeah, I I remember like trying to make kind of some kind of small talk, and it just really was awkward, and I was like, whatever. I guess I I literally said, Well, all right, here I go.
You know, because it was just so weird. And by the time I got to to the end of it, um, she's she stopped me before I finished the second scene, and she goes, Thank you. Thank you. And I was like, You're welcome, I guess. You know, yeah, I didn't know what to say to that. And uh, so before I left the building, I found that I got in like I called got called back that afternoon. So I went back in the afternoon, had a little bit more prep time, so I was a little bit more solid on what I was doing. And you know, went through the first scene and there was nothing there, like there was no acknowledgement that the scene was over. I was like, I guess I'll just turn the page now, you know. And then I got to the second part, the second side.
[37:59] Clifton Duncan: And again, before I finished, she cut me off and she goes, she goes, perfection, perfection, perfection. And uh right then I knew I didn't get the part because you know, all my friends were saying, like, oh, I guess you better pack your bags, going to Connecticut. You just got here from California. Now you now you're going out of town again. And I was like, guys, I don't, I don't think so. I I just I got a feeling about this one. And sure enough, uh, another actor got it, and I said, somehow, somehow, someone found a way to improve upon perfection. They were more perfect. Somehow they were more perfect. And I just said, you know, this industry is so stupid.
[38:39] Clifton Duncan: Well, yeah, it's so subjective. You just uh yeah, you never know what they want, and a lot of times they don't know what they want until they finally see it. So yeah.
[38:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, let's get into these final five questions here. Number one, what was your very first professional experience on stage?
[38:56] Clifton Duncan: Um, well, that that depends on what you mean by professional.
[38:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: Um, I did you were paid to be there.
[39:01] Clifton Duncan: Okay, so I did an internship. Um, again, it's funny how things come full circle, but I did an internship in 2003, I think, the summertime, um, at the now defunct Georgia Shakespeare Festival right here in Atlanta, Georgia. And um, and it was funny because it was the first time that I'd really been, you know, working with professional actors, and um, and I I hate to say it, but I learned more that like not like three months of just being around these actors than I did in like you know, three years of my undergrad, my my prior undergraduate study. Um, but that was really cool, just being around those actors and seeing how they put together um scenes and and built their parts, and to see, you know, one actor uh named Chris Kaiser, who's uh very prominent in Atlanta, who, you know, one night he's playing uh Benedict in Much Ado and has the audience eating out of his hand, and then the next night he's in like School for Wives, I think, um, Molière, and then he's playing Belarius in Cymbeline, and uh to see the virtuosity of these actors, you know, and I was only 19 years old at the time, that was a really, really um that was a huge impact on me. So it was pretty awesome to be there at the time.
[40:02] Patrick Oliver Jones: Number two, how has the industry changed most since when you first started that first professional?
[40:08] Clifton Duncan: And for for this answer, we've talked about COVID enough. So, apart from COVID and because that kind of changed everybody, how would you say just the industry itself as a profession has changed?
[40:18] Clifton Duncan: You know what? And people are gonna get mad at me, but I honestly think that it's more racist now than it was, or this is at least it's more race conscious now than it was when I started out. And um, my my fear is that um, you know, we've we've left the era where you could be a CCH Pounder or a Viola Davis or an Alfre Woodard or Angela Bassett or Denzel Washington, Lawrence Fishburne, all these people, James Earl Jones, who stood out because they were extraordinary. And now we're in a position where people are being handed parts um because they happen to fit the right demographic. And my fear is that audiences are sensing that. And so now when they see someone on screen who looks like me, or or they're a woman or a sexual minority, that they're reflexively going to reject it.
I mean, it broke my heart to see Bros, for instance, do so badly because, you know, for me, again, I'm open-minded and progressive. I'm like, oh, romantic comedy about gays. I'd like that that sounds interesting to me. And then when it does poorly, um, I can't imagine how it feels to be one of the artists involved in that. It must be crushing. Um, but I also wonder if part of the backlash toward that movie was just that people are saying, you know, and I God, I hate this so much, just to put it this way, um, you know, because it it brings up um the sort of conservative bigotry in a way, but it's like, you know, just stop putting it in front of my face. You know, there's some kind of agenda behind it, and uh, I think people are becoming really cynical about it and pushing back in ways that really aren't healthy, and that's why, you know, I feel like, you know, there has to be some way to kind of reach across the aisle and and um be more open. But uh it's it sucks, but I feel like the industry has become more divisive and um really more disconnected from the sort of general public than than it was when I first started, unfortunately.
[41:57] Patrick Oliver Jones: And number three, what does success or making it mean to you?
[42:01] Clifton Duncan: You know, I've struggled with that uh a lot, but um for me, you know, my my brother came to see me in uh the The Play That Goes Wrong, and um, you know, and I had other people who were talking about, oh man, you made it, bro. Like, like you know, you're this and you're that. And for me, I had to kind of stop them because I said, you know, it's enough for me that I am working steadily and that I'm I'm able to make my living being an actor. You know, there were nights where I was doing The Play That Goes Wrong where I mean I'd be in tears, Patrick, um, because I was so grateful that, you know, I mean, I learned so much about comedy in that show. And for anyone who's ever seen it, um, just being in it, you know, I I'd never heard in my life, I've never been to a show or experienced a show where just for two hours straight, you have an audience just dying, gasping uh for air, just splitting themselves open with laughter beside themselves.
And you know, I'm in bed at night and crying because like I get to do it again tomorrow, and I get to learn something new tomorrow, and I get to try, you know, tweak this moment or try to, you know, hunt for a new laugh here, and I I get to bring all kinds of joy to people. So, you know, in that sense, I was very successful. There was a time where when we were doing Carmen Jones off Broadway, and I at the same time I was also rehearsing the um the pre-Broadway developmental lab for Secret Garden, and uh, which well, I'm not doing it now. Um and uh, you know, I I it was such a thrill to work with Warren Carlyle and Sierra Boggess and uh, you know, really feel like I was part of the process, but I was so stressed out, you know, I couldn't really enjoy the experience of working on Carmen Jones with John Doyle and Norm Lewis.
So in a way I felt more successful, so to speak, um, in that lab doing Secret Garden because I was so fulfilled by what we were doing, versus this critical and commercial hit off Broadway with all these stars in it. You know, I I I mean, there were technical aspects too. Like if you look at some early reviews, you know, before I I learned really how to sing the role, I mean, I had like three weeks to prepare that, you know, John offered it to me, and I was like, oh, this is an operatic tenor role. I'm like a bear tenor and a baritone, like uh what the fuck am I gonna do with this? So that was it was hard for me to feel as though that was a success, even though from the out from the outside, right?
Rave reviews, extensions, um, you know, Broadway buzz, all that stuff, you know. But I felt more fulfilled working on Secret Garden. So that was a success. So maybe, you know, I I've always said that um I don't need to be famous, but I do want to be rich. So maybe that's sort of my, you know, the fame was like a byproduct, I guess. But uh, you know, if I could just make a lot of money just doing shows, then that would be successful for me. But um, and I guess that's the long and the short of it.
[44:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, number four, describe a personal lesson that has taken you a while to learn, or one that you are still working on to this day.
[44:49] Clifton Duncan: Oh gosh. Um you really have to learn to be assertive, maybe A, assertive and authentic. Don't treat others disrespectfully, but also, especially for actors, learn how to be more assertive in the room. You're not just some meat puppet to be pushed around on stage by some you know, crazy director. You're not just some cog in a machine to be plugged in by some stupid network executive who doesn't know anything about art, or some shareholder who doesn't know anything. You have a reason to be there, you have your own personal power, you have a perspective that's valuable. You're the one doing the damn scene. So if something doesn't make sense, you don't you better say something. And also authenticity.
You know, be you know, you one of the paradoxes of what we do is that self-knowledge um makes for better work in terms of um playing other people. And it sort of ties back into this idea of people of the sort of ideological conformity, right? If you're sort of off always lying to yourself to protect your professional uh prospects, then you're you must be lying to yourself, to yourself in other aspects of your of your life and and of your work as well. Um, you know, my teacher Zelda once said that, you know, the work that we do and the lives we lead aren't two separate things, that they bleed into one another inevitably. And um, if you're lying to yourself in one aspect of your life, then you're lying to yourself um in your work. So, you know, that's what I would say, I guess authenticity and assertiveness. And I think we'd have a better culture if more performers especially would glom onto those things.
[46:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, lastly, number five, what is the most useful advice that you have received and how have you applied that to your life or career?
[46:27] Clifton Duncan: Um well, that presumes I've ever received any useful advice. Um yeah, that that's a that's a that's a tough one. Um what I would say myself and one of my teachers, a wonderful man named Jim Calder, um, we kind of co-coined this term together, but it's the arrogance of generosity. Um an artist has to have the arrogance to presume that whatever um he, she or they has to offer um is you know, deserves to be seen by an audience. But they also have to be generous with it and and it has to cost them something. They have to share all of it and leave nothing on stage. Um you know, Tony Kushner once told me that basically we're we're we're essentially people are paying to watch us suffer. Um you know, and even even comedy is tragedy plus time.
So, you know, yes, we do work for, you know, we we're arrogant and we're self-centered, we're narcissists, so we do the work to please ourselves and to be seen. But uh the cost of that, you know, the the price you must pay for that is to give everything that you have, all of your physical energy, all your mental emotional strength, um, you know, your temperament, just apply yourself fully and give yourself over to you know the work and to the audience. And um that is uh and that justifies being paid lots and lots of money. So arrogance and generosity, I think would be the like I guess the the main thing.
[47:54] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, uh Clifton, this has been a uh a real pleasure to meet you, but also I appreciate your candidness and openness in talking about uh what what can be difficult subjects, but but you seem to have uh have approached them with that uh both arrogance but also persistence as well.
[48:14] Clifton Duncan: Thanks, Patrick. I hope you don't get canceled for having me on now, but uh it's been it's been a pleasure. Thanks for letting me run my mouth.
[48:21] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah, it's interesting because I'm I'm so much of a person who who reads all kind of things, who listens to all kinds of people.
[48:29] Clifton Duncan: You're a curious person.
[48:30] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah. And and you know, I'm that one who goes to Chick-fil-A and says, I love their chicken. Whatever they think about gay marriage, I don't care. I love their chicken.
[48:39] Clifton Duncan: So I mean that's and you're you're a bad gay.
[48:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.
[48:43] Clifton Duncan: There are people who unfollowed me because of you know, it's all kinds of stuff. We're just like, guys, guys, come on, get off social media, stop watching the news and just start talking to people, and we'd be in a way, way better place, I think as a society.
[48:54] Patrick Oliver Jones: Oh, I do yeah, I definitely agree with that. Talk to each other rather than at each other.
[48:58] Clifton Duncan: Yeah, yeah. I I think I'm I'm sure I'm I I'm I swear that we agree as Americans on way, way, way more things than we are led to believe. And I think if people understood that, we'd be in a way, way better place right now.
[49:16] Patrick Oliver Jones: Thank you so much for joining Clifton Duncan and myself for this provocative and at times contentious conversation. I may not agree with everything he said, but I'm glad to have a podcast like this where various viewpoints and opinions and experiences can be freely expressed and understood. Don't forget you can give the gift of a Why I'll Never Make It subscription, whether it's to yourself or to someone else. Just go to whyillnevermakeit.com and click subscribe, or just look for the link in the show notes.
[49:52] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, that does it for me and season seven. I greatly appreciate you joining me each episode in 2023. Why I'll Never Make It is a production of WINMI Media, and I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, in charge of writing, editing, and producing this podcast, with Maria Clara Ribeiro as co-producer. Background music used in this episode is by Blue Dot Sessions and John Bartmann. Be sure to join me for season eight, which will begin at the end of January as we talk more about why I'll never make it.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
