This episode is about money. Why we don't have enough of it, how we are enslaved by it, and how Power seems to be just out of reach due to it. Our latest release “Money Ho” (video here) is shining a giant light on the injustices women face around money... Read More
From the show: Women of Tomorrow with Laura Bell Bundy
About
This episode is about money. Why we don't have enough of it, how we are enslaved by it, and how Power seems to be just out of reach due to it. Our latest release “Money Ho” (video here) is shining a giant light on the injustices women face around money. From equal pay to the pink tax, we are fed up with working the hardest and having the least.
Our guest this week is Carol Jenkins CEO and president of the ERA Coalition. Until women are equal under the constitution, we don’t stand a chance at having equal pay. Sound the alarm, this is a wake-up call ladies, it’s time to demand equality and finally pass the ERA.
We believe every month is Women's History Month here at Women of Tomorrow. Women we see you, we feel you and we honor you!
Connect with us:
- Listen to Women of Tomorrow
- Insta: @womxnoftomorrow
- TikTok: @womxnoftomorrow
- Insta : @laurabellbundy
- insta : @sheasheacarter
Produced by Dori Berinstein and Alan Seales.
A proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:03] Laura Bell Bundy: Welcome to Women of Tomorrow.
[0:04] Shea Carter's's: I'm Shea Carter's and we are partners in Feminist Crime.
[0:10] Laura Bell Bundy: Today's episode is called Money. Let's get down to business. A look at women's equality through her pocketbook. Because she is worth it. And speaking of equality, on this episode, we are interviewing Carol Jenkins, the president of the ERA Coalition. Please stick around for that interview. Our song Money Ho is about money. Why we don't have enough of it, how we are enslaved by it, and how power seems to be just out of reach due to it. Money Ho is shining a giant light on the injustices women face around money. From equal pay to the pink tax, we are fed up with working the hardest and having the least.
[1:09] ♪ Musical number: "Money Ho" — performed by Laura Bell Bundy ♪
[4:21] Laura Bell Bundy: What will it take to even the playing field for equality? Let's get down to business.
[4:27] Laura Bell Bundy: 40,000 years ago, our first female was a natural forager, able to manage the task of gathering nuts and berries while breastfeeding her young. Hunting large prey would have been quite difficult with an infant, so the men did it. Both hunting and gathering would have been equally important to their survival, making both sexes equal in value. Then one day, a super savvy lady noticed that plants grew from little seeds, and in around 10,000 BC, crops started to be cultivated, most likely by chicks. It was now necessary to protect the crops so communities began to stay in one place. Men took over agriculture and the herding of animals, and the women developed the art of spinning and weaving wool into cloth.
[5:16] Laura Bell Bundy: These men began to accumulate property. AKA currency. AKA money. This property gave him power. If a man wanted to pass his possessions on to his kids, he would have to make sure they were his. That's when strict laws against female adultery and the seclusion of females began as an attempt to ensure the lines of legitimate offspring and establish lines of inheritance. Yeah. And how do you do this? You make her your property too. And her children. Some ancient civilizations allowed women to own property and earn money like men, and some did not. In colonial times, the rules of coverture adopted from England were the norm, setting rules and standards about women and money.
[6:13] Laura Bell Bundy: Under the doctrine of coverture, a woman was legally considered the possession of her husband. Any property she might hold before her marriage became her husband's on her wedding day, and she had no legal right to appear in court, to sign contracts, or to do any business. And although these formal provisions of the law were sometimes ignored, the wives of tradesmen, for example, might assist in running the family business, but married women technically had almost no legal identity. We can all say that capitalism rules when it comes to the way America has operated over the last several hundred years, including the capture and enslavement of Africans to build its wealth. And that included amassing wealth from all women's free domestic labor, and not allowing married women to control their wages or property, directly affecting not just her financial freedom, but her freedom. Period.
[7:07] Laura Bell Bundy: The Married Women's Property Act in 1848 and the Act concerning the rights and liabilities of husband and wife in 1860 expanded the property rights of married women. Under these set of laws, women could conduct business on their own, own property, control their own inheritance left to them by their family, earn and control their own working wage, have sole ownership of the gifts they received, and file lawsuits. They acknowledged mothers as joint guardians of their children, along with fathers. This allowed married women to finally have legal authority over their own sons and daughters. By year 1900, most women could own property.
[7:46] Laura Bell Bundy: Victoria Woodhull was the first woman to run for U.S. president. Before this, she was a fortune-teller and a financial advisor to Cornelius Vanderbilt. She and her sister Tenny, short for Tennessee, were co-founders of Wall Street's first female brokerage firm. They were also newspaper publishers, advocating radical feminist views called free love. And I guess it was radical to be against marital rape at the time. The radical view essentially consisted of her simply advocating for consensual sex and that a woman should be able to divorce if she fell out of love with her husband or if he beat her. Divorce was scandalous at the time. She was a suffragette and founder of her own political party. She ran for president and announced the abolitionist Frederick Douglass as her running mate. He never confirmed. But she ran for president 50 years before it was legal for her to vote.
[8:39] Laura Bell Bundy: Woodhull argued that women already had the right to vote. All they had to do was use it. Since the 14th and 15th Amendments granted the right to all citizens, gender was not specified in either amendment. She believed that all men are created equal applied to her and other women. But their not being allowed to vote showed us otherwise, and that is why the passing for an equal rights amendment is so necessary. The Constitution must explicitly state that it will not discriminate on the basis of sex. She was jailed on election day for publishing filth about a clergyman, and many lies have been made up about her. She's been villainized and called the devil, and we have seen this happen to almost every female politician or leader in history.
[9:23] Laura Bell Bundy: It was a commonly held belief at the time that women did not know how to handle money. But Hetty Green could certainly prove you wrong. She was called the Witch of Wall Street, also known as the richest woman in America in the Gilded Age. She was listed in the Guinness Book of World Records as the world's greatest miser. She was born in 1834 in Massachusetts, and her family was the richest whaling family in the city. She was reading financial papers to her father by the age of six, and at 13, she became the family bookkeeper. Her father sold the whaling business and invested in others and left her with a trust fund when he passed, which was the equivalent of a hundred million dollars today. She grew that money, and before marrying her husband, they had an agreement that he did not have a right to any of her money.
[10:16] Laura Bell Bundy: That would be called a prenup today. She said, "It is the duty of every woman, I believe, to learn to take care of her own business affairs. And a girl should be brought up as to be able to make her own living, whether rich or poor, a young woman should know how a bank account works, understand the composition of mortgages and bonds, and know the value of interest and how it accumulates." But Hetty could save some money, honey. Her thriftiness was legendary. It was said that she never turned on the heat or used the hot water. In fact, she would use the radiator to heat up oatmeal. She ate mostly pies that cost 15 cents. One tale claims that she spent half a night searching her carriage for a lost stamp worth two cents. She wore an old black dress and undergarments that she only changed after they'd been worn out, and she instructed her laundress to wash only the dirtiest parts of her dresses, the hems to save money on soap.
[11:19] Laura Bell Bundy: She really was a miser. But in 1905, Hetty was New York's largest lender and had bailed New York City out numerous times. She also gave boatloads of money to charity, but preferred to do so discreetly. So while she did save money, she spent money on important things that she cared about. When she died at 81 of apoplexy, she did so after arguing with a maid over the virtues of skim milk. I swear I read this in several articles, which is an insane fact. I don't know if anybody's joking, but that's what it said. Estimates of her net worth ranged from a hundred million to two hundred million, the equivalent of 2.35 billion to 4.7 billion today, making her arguably the richest woman in the world at the time.
[12:09] Laura Bell Bundy: At the end of the 19th century, in around the 1880s, there were white women working and earning a living wage, mostly single white women.
[12:19] Laura Bell Bundy: Only 7% of married white women were working.
[12:22] Laura Bell Bundy: However, about 36% of black married women were working, and 75% of black single women were working.
[12:31] Laura Bell Bundy: This is quite a lot more. You can see that the reasons for this were the expectation of a black woman to work, but also because of the discrimination against black men at the time, which resulted in lower wages and less stable employment compared to white men.
[12:48] Laura Bell Bundy: And this meant that black women had to be breadwinners as well. African Americans in this country were historically two parent incomes.
[12:57] Laura Bell Bundy: And if you're a mom, you know that that creates all kinds of complications in regards to childcare.
[13:03] Laura Bell Bundy: And this contributed to a devaluation as mothers with caregiving needs at home. During the late 19th century, women entered factories in large numbers, working 14 hours a day, six days a week in dangerous jobs for very low pay.
[13:20] Laura Bell Bundy: In response to these working conditions, young female textile workers organized America's first industrial protests, strikes, and reform groups.
[13:29] Laura Bell Bundy: Despite these efforts, women were generally excluded from the larger labor movement. Conforming to the societal view that a woman's place was in the home, the labor movement advocated for a family wage high enough that a husband could independently support his family.
[13:44] Laura Bell Bundy: But in the 20th century, the suffrage movement ideas about women's roles began to change, and hundreds of thousands of clothing workers organized the International Ladies' Garment Workers' Union.
[13:56] Laura Bell Bundy: Mary Harris Jones redefined the gender norms of the day to become one of America's most prominent labor organizers. Through unity with their male co-workers, shop floor organizing, strikes, and militancy, women demonstrated that they could secure union recognition, higher wages, and shorter work hours from their employers.
[14:16] Laura Bell Bundy: Their New York protest in 1911, after the triangle shirtwaist factory fire, which cost 146 workers their lives and led to new laws for better working conditions.
[14:27] Laura Bell Bundy: For the first time, women became powerful allies in a common cause with their union brothers. In the early 1900s, most employers would only hire black women in domestic service work, the low-wage women's jobs that involve cooking, cleaning, and caregiving.
[14:44] Laura Bell Bundy: Discriminatory public policies contributed to black women's lack of wealth. There were protective welfare policies that enabled poor lone white mothers to stay at home and provide care for their children.
[14:55] Laura Bell Bundy: They were the mothers' pensions and the Social Security Act of 1935, but black women were denied them. The state simultaneously undermined the well-being of black families by denying black mothers the cash assistance that they needed to support their children, leaving black women with no other option but to work for very low wages while they still had children at home.
[15:18] Laura Bell Bundy: During most wars, women would jump in to fill positions while men were overseas fighting. In addition to the Rosie the Riveter factory worker, many women enjoyed high paying positions at this time in a variety of fields.
[15:30] Laura Bell Bundy: They enjoyed this personal and financial independence, especially during World War II. But after losing high paying union jobs after the war, millions of women sought new opportunities in the female dominated sectors.
[15:43] Laura Bell Bundy: Retail, health, education, and service industry jobs. And in these areas, hours were long, wages were low, benefits were few, and union organization was weak.
[15:56] Laura Bell Bundy: These conditions, along with persistent patriarchal views on women in the workforce, gave rise to a second wave of feminism, which had a profound impact on labor.
[16:06] Laura Bell Bundy: When federal anti-discrimination laws were introduced in the early 1960s, organized labor under pressure from the emerging feminist movement supported sex discrimination prohibitions in both the Equal Pay Act of 1963 and the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
[16:22] Laura Bell Bundy: There were a few things that happened in the 1970s that really allowed women to join the workforce in a way that would contribute to their careers and financial freedom.
[16:34] Laura Bell Bundy: In 1972, the birth control pill became legal for unmarried women. And this is when you really saw women joining the workforce in droves.
[16:43] Laura Bell Bundy: You also saw an uptick in women going to college and university. And in 1974, it became legal for a woman to open up a credit card or take out a bank loan in her own name without the permission of her husband or her father, which had been the law prior to that.
[17:01] Laura Bell Bundy: And that law was changed by a woman named Lindy Boggs, who represented this movement in Washington. This really allowed women to be able to have financial independence and not have to ask permission for money.
[17:17] Laura Bell Bundy: Besides getting over this patriarchal view of women not being able to get a home loan without the permission of their husband or father, we were still dealing with and still do deal with discrimination when it comes to getting bank loans for people of color.
[17:34] Laura Bell Bundy: And that has largely contributed to disparities in wealth between the white community and the black community, as well as in other people of color and immigrants all over this country.
[17:52] Laura Bell Bundy: So we see large gaps there because of the inability to acquire wealth over time that comes from ownership of property. Also in the 70s, in 1978, the Pregnancy and Discrimination Act prohibited employers from treating a woman unfavorably because of pregnancy, childbirth, or a medical condition related to childbirth.
[18:15] Laura Bell Bundy: And the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993, FMLA, requires 12 weeks of unpaid leave annually for mothers of newborns or newly adopted children if they work for a company with 50 or more employees.
[18:30] Laura Bell Bundy: And both of these things are really amazing when it comes to women in the workforce because many women are mothers, or many women are caregivers of their elderly parents.
[18:43] Laura Bell Bundy: And this really did allow women to stay in the workforce and to build their career, and then thus to build their wealth. FMLA is great if you work a desk job and you have benefits, but if you're in a service job, you don't have those benefits.
[19:01] Laura Bell Bundy: They're low paying, they have inflexible hours, they lack employer provided retirement plans, health insurance, paid sick and maternity leave, and paid vacations. Here's the statistic over one third of black women workers lack paid sick leave.
[19:15] Laura Bell Bundy: And this is problematic since 80% of black mothers are breadwinners in their families. So how do women get ahead? If we're relegated to these types of positions, and we don't have these benefits, and we still have to raise children, when does the work stop, and how does the wealth get acquired?
[19:34] Laura Bell Bundy: Okay, so we're still waiting for equal pay for equal work and benefits and laws to change for our equality, but there's a whole other element. Tracy Spicer states that women spend on average two full working weeks a year.
[19:47] Laura Bell Bundy: That is, Monday through Friday, twice. Two weeks vacation, beautifying themselves. Waxing facials, drying our hair, doing our makeup, all done to fit societal expectations of a woman's appearance.
[20:01] Laura Bell Bundy: She also says that this loss of time is a loss of productivity, which can impact our ability to bring in money. Plus, women are on average paid less than men, and yet are spending more for toiletries and beauty products than men are.
[20:15] Laura Bell Bundy: This is called the pink tax. Guys, pink razors at the store cost more than the blue ones, and they are exactly the same. All of this insanity affects our bank accounts and our ability to be financially independent.
[20:30] Laura Bell Bundy: Why do I have to pay more for my blouse to be dry cleaned than my husband's? His shirt is bigger. And then there's this second shift, that unpaid domestic labor that seems to so naturally fall into the hands of women.
[20:45] Laura Bell Bundy: Child rearing, shopping, cooking, laundry, cleaning, all of this after a full day of work, we're having to take care of an ailing parent, a responsibility that also falls to women more often than men.
[20:55] Laura Bell Bundy: But what happens is women are spending time doing these things. And the time that they're spending doing these things is time that they're not spending being productive, working on their careers, and thus making money.
[21:11] Laura Bell Bundy: So there's an imbalance. Like I said in the beginning of this, we don't value women's time the way we value men's time. And there's lots of reasons for that. It's in our consciousness, it's the way our society and our government has been set up, it's the way the workforce has been set up.
[21:32] Laura Bell Bundy: It's the patriarchy. It's all of it. But what we really need is equality. And that's why we have our next guest coming on, Carol Jenkins from the ERA Coalition.
[21:41] Laura Bell Bundy: Carol Jenkins is an advocate for human, civil, and women's rights, an award-winning author, an Emmy-winning former television journalist. As a pioneering African American television reporter, Jenkins was an anchor and correspondent for WNBC TV in New York for nearly 25 years.
[21:59] Laura Bell Bundy: She earned a BA from Boston University and an MA from New York University. Previously, Carol Jenkins was founding president of the Women's Media Center, a national nonprofit organization created to increase coverage and participation of women in media.
[22:14] Laura Bell Bundy: As president, she conceived the Progressive Women's Voices Program to provide media training for women and girls, and she expanded She Source, the largest portfolio of women experts in the country.
[22:26] Laura Bell Bundy: Carol Jenkins is president and CEO of the ERA Coalition and the Fund for Women's Equality, sister organizations dedicated to the adoption of the Equal Rights Amendment. Here to talk to us today is Carol Jenkins.
[22:47] Laura Bell Bundy: First of all, Carol, thank you so much for being with us today. So a lot of people believe that equal rights for women already exist under the Constitution. What specifically are some of the biggest changes that we can expect when the ERA is finally written into law, especially in regards to equal pay for equal work?
[23:05] Carol Jenkins: Well, it's my pleasure to be here, and thanks to you both for giving us the soundtrack for our work. You are fantastic, and you know, it's just so encouraging and uplifting. You're so smart and so sharp, and you know, both the music and the podcast are terrific.
[23:23] Carol Jenkins: So I will say that most people who think that equality is written into the Constitution, it's not. And we've been working for a hundred years on the Equal Rights Amendment to actually put it into the Constitution.
[23:39] Carol Jenkins: You know, as you may know, it was written by white men, mostly slaveholding, landholding men whose concept of what equality was was different than ours would be today, for sure.
[23:54] Carol Jenkins: Certainly the enslaved people were not included. I mean, we could almost understand that because in that day they were absolutely property. And who could even think that they would have rights in our world and our society as it existed.
[24:11] Carol Jenkins: But the women, that's another thing. They left the women out as well.
[24:16] Carol Jenkins: So the Constitution was written for white slaveholding, land holding men. Now, in their, I guess, uh crystal ball looking into the future, they thought that there might need to be fixes as it went along, and those fixes are amendments to the Constitution. And our Constitution has been amended 27 times already. The equal rights amendment would be the 28th. And what it would say simply is that one cannot be discriminated against based on one's sex. So many people think let's put women in the constitution. That's what it says. Let's diminish men. It doesn't say any of that. It just says, whoever you are and whatever your sex, you cannot be discriminated against because of sex. So that's it. That's it, guys.
That's it. The president of the Equal Rights Amendment coalition just told you that's it. No discrimination because of your gender. I don't understand how that could be a threat. One of the things that I want to make sure that everyone understands is that uh Congress has already passed the Equal Rights Amendment in 1972 by a two-thirds, you know, majority, what was required. And then it went out to the states, and 38 states have now ratified it. So the only thing that we're dealing with in Congress now is the removal of a time limit that was placed on the ERA. So the ERA is passed. It's just a question of this time limit that keeps getting in our way. Congress extended that first seven years, our time limit to 10 years.
And so we believe that Congress can remove it, which is what is going on in the House that just passed it, and what will happen in the Senate. They have to do it in the same session. So we're hoping that we can we can get this done, and the begging field will be established. What happens is that the amendment in first blush affects the federal government and all states. You know, some people say, well, that's a small, I said, No, that's millions and millions of people who, because with any of the of the governments, it's anybody who has a contract with anyone who so it widens out. So that is the first step. You know, that the federal government will have to evaluate everything that they're doing.
The uh legislator legislators in every state will have to evaluate how they have not been uh rising to the equality of the ERA. And what we've seen already in the push for this is that the private corporate America, private life, private actors, as they are called, you know, will be forced into uh matching, you know, what's happening in the government federal government in the governments. So, you know, it's going to be uh that's a lot of work to do to actually undo the persecution and discrimination against uh people based on their sex. So, you know, men should be glad too. You know, Ruth Bader Ginsberg was very wise when you know several of her major lawsuits were based on rights for men as opposed to women, uh, and then made and made it better for everybody.
So I think that you know, this is going to make the world better for everybody. I also don't understand how this could ever be a partisan issue. You know, the vote to remove the deadline on the ERA passed this week in the House of Representatives. Woo-woo. 222 votes in support and 204 votes against. And these numbers were so shocking to me. One in particular is there's 13 Republican women representing represented in the House, and only four Republican votes. One of them was a woman, one woman from Staten Island, only one woman. And you'll notice what if you go back and you look at the arguments because there's time to debate pro and con on the floor, it was almost all women on both sides doing the debating.
So Republican women were against the Equal Rights Amendment. So we have a lot of work. Also, when polled, though, it appears that like 90% of Republicans support the amendment. Why do you think that's not being represented in the House with the votes? Well, yeah, it's something like the rescue plan that just uh you know is been placed in actual reality now, you know, where it was and in the House, there was not one Republican who voted for it in the Senate as well. Um so that we're talking about a small group of people, but if you do any of the polling on the rescue plan, it is tremendously favorable in the 70, 80, 90 percent category, including Republican Republicans out there, not in the House chamber or the Senate chamber.
So it is a you know, in real life, where they could understand that we need help, you know, but in the political world of this Democrat versus Republican world, the Republicans are not giving in on much. Uh so I think uh one of the things that we need to realize is that even though people are elected to office, they often do not represent their constituents. So we know that this huge number of everyone, including Republicans, supports the rescue plan. And it's the same thing with the Equal Rights Amendment. You know, score is tremendously high, the lowest we've seen recently is 80%, you know, and it goes up from there of people who say, yes, we need equality. It would be a good thing to just say out loud that women are equal to men, that we're all equal no matter what your gender, uh, we're all equal in on this earth and in this country.
Uh, but it's a battle. I I still can't believe that we're having this discussion in 2021. Speaking of the passing of the Equal Rights Amendment, how do you think that that would impact equal pay for equal work? Well, this is a uh the way this was written, and we should say written by Alice Paul and the version that we're still trying to get, you know, in published onto the Constitution, uh, it was written in 1923 by Alice Paul. So that's why we're approaching a hundred years of working on this particular version. Um so one of the things that would drastically uh change is that women and all people would be considered full constitutionally represented human beings. So what happens if you are given that right?
What I always say to people, if you we've had so many you know, protests, you know, George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, uh, you know, there's uh racism and there's sexism, certainly, you know, with all of the even the brand new Me Too allegations of men, powerful men being, you know, uh accused of sexual, you know, aggression. Um if you if you had an equal rights amendment, uh then you would have recourse. Uh what we don't have now uh is that there is a lot of yelling and screaming. But if you if you are talking about equal pay, which is what most people refer to, is that we know fully well in the marking of it in the equal pay days that happen year after year, which drives me crazy, and there's no progress made.
We know that it takes the average woman, you know, months to make what a white man made the year before, a black woman even longer than that. A Latina woman almost has to work for another year before she makes what a white man made the year before. So we have substantial uh barriers to equal pay, and we've tried everything else. Uh untold millions, trillions of dollars, and you know this from you know, reading history and uh uh diversity, you know, let's uh have equal pay in the workforce, let's work on that. It doesn't work because the root of the sexism and racism is in the constitution. And until we remove that, and until there is a cultural acceptance that there should be equality, I think we'll still be uh up against uh you know real hardcore barriers.
I've wondered this a lot. Do you think there should be transparency in like corporate America in terms of salaries? Like one of my favorite quotes is um you can't clean a house in the dark. So would transparency put the pressure on large companies to like adjust salaries for equal pay, equal work? And could we then kind of push that more once the equal Rights amendment is passed? Yeah, absolutely. And you know, we've worked with some good companies, you know, the ones who we thought and they thought were doing the right thing. Uh, we pay our women the same thing we pay our men, and when they have actually gone in, that was their intent. When they've actually gone in, they have discovered that they have to make up to the millions of dollars for what the difference between what the women and men were making.
Those are the good guys. So, yes, I do believe that transparency would absolutely help. But I think we're getting there. Many, many more corporations. I love this new proposal by NASDAQ that says that if you want to be listed on our company, you have to have a woman on the board and another, you know, a diverse person on. And something like 80% of the companies who are now listed there do not meet that criteria. So it's from the boardroom all the way down to, you know, the people pushing the cleaning carts at night who still, you know, may be suffering discrepancy in income. Mm-hmm. And what I've been made privy to too is instead of it being equal pay, equal work, businesses are getting around it by just changing the job titles of women.
So your workload is the same, your job title is different, and then that allows them to pay you less. Oh gosh, the more you know. Right. But you know what I think consistently people don't understand about America and its business is that America has become extremely profitable by uh its uh cheap labor, you know, it's women and its uh diverse population who are all consistently underpaid. So America is very wealthy. We're a rich nation, and that was built on the backs, I believe, of unfair uh paying of uh of women and others, you know, who don't qualify as white male patriarchal, you know, this is who should be working, this is who should succeed, this is who should make, I don't know what the multiple of it is now of the top uh CEO to what the employees make, but a grand, multiple, multiple, multiples of uh, and so corporate America has to be uh examined, and I think many of them are coming around to understand when you set up criteria like that.
Do you have a woman on your board? No. Do you have it can't be listed? Um, you know, those are the ways that we need to go forward. And with the Equal Rights Amendment, many more of those principles will be set in place. So people will be accountable. Right now, there is no accountability for discriminating against women. You may have a few lawsuits, but it's a lawsuit by lawsuit by lawsuit as opposed to sweeping equality for all. And I think that's where we need to be. What advice would you give women in low-wage jobs who want to enter high-paying careers? Well, I don't know, you know, I think we have seen uh during this pandemic who the low uh wage people are, the essential workers.
[36:23] Carol Jenkins: Um, I think we have to do a better job at our education system and its access to our education system. We know now that there are, we can't even count how many children haven't been in school for an entire year, who don't have Wi-Fi, who don't have parents who can afford to stay home with them to oversee their remote learning. So this huge discrepancy in poverty and in education has to be, you know, has to be addressed. So I would say the first thing that women who are trying to move up should understand is that it is not your fault. The system is rigged against you. And what you have to do is to, with all of us working together, you know, to help, you know, this mass movement upwards. But, you know, when people say to me, why would we need the ERA?
You know, we're the richest country, you know, and I say, have you really looked around? Do you know who the poor are, the impoverished? It's mostly women. And do you know who the starving are who cannot count on meals? It's mostly their children. You know, one out of three. I mean, all right, I'll say if you want to say one out of four, but that's still too many children who are food insecure in this country. And that is why people are making such a big thing over the tax credit for, you know, for children, when they say we're gonna lift half of the poor children, the impoverished children, out of poverty with this bill, you know, and I say, that's great. What about the other half? You know, we still have millions of children who are starving in this country.
So I think that's one of the reasons we need the Equal Rights Amendment. Women need to be paid, all need to be paid equally and higher and more and need to be given the access to move up the, you know, move up the ladder. And I think that what the way it's described is that many women, especially if they have children, are kicked off the ladder. You know, that rung in the ladder is removed permanently so that they never even have a rung to move up on because they're so busy working two or three jobs, you know, trying to feed their children or keep a roof over their heads. So when we say we need the Equal Rights Amendment, it's not an abstract legal concept, it is a day-to-day live or die concept of who is going to eat, who is going to live. We know in the sector workers, who's gonna survive COVID and who's not. And so much of this will be made much better by an Equal Rights Amendment.
[39:08] Carol Jenkins: So, you know, I'm gonna bring up something that I'm talking about when we talk about the history of women working and making money. And one of the things that I've mentioned was that nearly a third of 28% of black women are employed in service jobs compared to just one-fifth of white women. And many of these service jobs, they're low-paying, they're inflexible, they lack employee-provided retirement plans and health insurance and paid sick and maternity leave and paid vacations, and over a third, 36% of black women workers lack paid sick leave. So it's not just about making the same dollar amount, it's also about the fact that the jobs don't have benefits and don't have flexibility, and that the women who are mothers, their motherhood is completely dismissed.
And, you know, I think that it was back, I want to say, in the 20s when the first welfare act came for women, black women were not able to get it. And so they were made to feel like they had to be in the workplace and had to deny their being able to raise their kids and have childcare, which is why I really feel like certain things like universal pre-K, it would be so helpful to people who are, it's women who are essential workers. It would be so helpful to have childcare as a part of what we offer when we offer benefits, or I'm not sure how it could work, but I really do because I think that you, when you're talking about women in the workplace, you also have to notice that many women are moms.
[41:21] Carol Jenkins: I know. I don't know if you have any thoughts about that, but I do. It's interesting that you talk about the government because it is the government of the United States that is mostly responsible for the gap that we see now between black and white, and you know, because you know, the whole idea of owning a home was only available to whites, you know, black were not eligible to get mortgages or to, you know, we went from these sprawling plots of land where houses were being built and whites were being given the ability to get more mortgages, and the complementary picture of that, that ver that's horizontal stretch is the vertical, you know, slum that was being built. The only thing that was available to black people in this country was high sky-high rents in tiny apartments.
And that's where you see the beginning of this, you know, true discrimination. So the US government created the middle class in America and it did not include black people. So there is that we have to go again to the root of how did this happen? You know, that the wealth gap between white women and a black woman could be a white woman who has thousands of dollars based often on that home ownership that's trailed through the family. Generational wealth, generational wealth and the wealth of a black woman, I think right now is it like at five dollars or something like that. And it is because there is no opportunity to save anything or to build on anything. And we have to understand that, you know, for a woman to go to work, she has to have childcare.
And childcare is a thing that's gotten astronomically expensive, you know. So it's, you know, women are working literally two and three jobs, if not more, to try to keep their families afloat. And you know, I know a big fight over the $15 an hour wage, you know, in some places they're getting five dollars, you know, or seven dollars, you know, here in New York, I think. You know, it's like people cannot live on the expectations that were set years ago. And so we really as a people have to understand this. Again, I want to say, you know, to the people who were there and doing this, it is not your fault, you know, that you are working for five dollars an hour on four jobs to support your family.
You know, the system is broken. And, you know, and the system unfairly penalizes women. So we have to understand, all of us need to understand that what was begun in the writing of our constitution, so those hundreds of years ago is still playing out today. And it is the basic assumption that women are not people, you know, they're somehow sub-people, and that it's okay for us to be begging for equality a hundred years after this, you know, bill, this amendment was introduced. It's okay to continue to beg. And you know, what we're saying at the ERA Coalition that it's enough begging already. You know, we just as a group, as women have to say, I'm sorry, you know, that it is time for us to grow up as a country. And we can't grow up until we're all treated equally. And the only way we can get that is by fixing the constitution.
[45:01] Carol Jenkins: Yeah. That really is the key to unlock all of the other policy that needs to come after it. I mean, I know just for me, I was working as a waitress in New York City, and when all of my male counterparts could take public transportation home, I had to pay for an Uber. It's really expensive running late because I can't walk and I can't take the subways past a certain time. And it's funny, there's the pink tax, but there's so much that goes along with the pink tax. Just to keep yourself safe and not murdered, you know, there's so much to think about. I was actually wondering as you were speaking, about I sometimes wish policy could get more specific instead of the broad strokes because about minimum wage, I obviously think that we people need to have a living wage, but I wonder if we could make it specific to big companies.
Because I've been thinking a lot about small businesses and how after surviving this huge recession and COVID, how do we then expect them to give everyone a raise? But then you can have those expectations from the Walmarts and the Amazons. So is there a way to write policy and because I don't know the answer to any of this that is more specific where it won't just ruin small businesses and I think I think it exists. Most people understand that under a certain level of employees, you know, there are considerations, you know, to be made. You know, if you've got five employees, and you know, and Amazon has, you know, I don't know how, you know, so, but Amazon stepped up to the $15 an hour, but you know, they're under a huge unionization effort right now, and it may bring back unions.
I think, you know, this is the beginning of the restoration of unions to some level of respect because we see that without broad-based support, without others with you, you know, lone people arguing for more pay, simply doesn't work. So I think we're beginning to see the beginning of the rise of unions once again, you know, after falling into disfavor for so many years. But you know, everybody expected the same thing with women, you know, in the old days we used to talk about the pipeline that the reason we didn't need the ERA was because women were in the pipeline, and someday soon they would all emerge, you know, and we'd be 50% of corporations, we'd be a president, we'd be all of that. And the pipeline is still full of women, but no one has no numbers of persons ever have emerged yet to give us 50% in anything almost. So we're still in the trenches.
[47:49] Carol Jenkins: And this is still coming back around kind of to what we were talking about before, how women were voting against the extending the ERA is not only do we need to vote for women, we need to vote for women that are advocates of women. And we need to have female CEOs that are going to advocate and hire other women because we do have women that aren't supportive and aren't going to bring other people up.
[48:09] Carol Jenkins: Right, right. Um, I want to ask you just a couple more questions. There are slightly off of topic, but I'm curious. Um, has to do with the pink tax. So not only are women paid less on average, they pay more for the same products or services simply because of their gender, like razors or dry cleaning, girl toys versus boy toys, pants from Old Navy.
[48:35] Carol Jenkins: Uh this this costs women an average of $1,300 more a year. And if you do the math and someone has a long life, this is over $100,000 in their lifetime. How do you think that the passing of the ERA will help to eliminate this type of discrimination? Um, you know, I refer to this as one of the accepted invisible uh discriminatory acts that takes place because it it all, for instance, menstrual products only affect women, and and for all of life, you know, we've been paying this with most people not protesting, you know, it's just assumed. Of course we'll pay more. You know, we're women. You know, even though we're, you know, even we or though we are paid less, we will pay more for our blouses to be clean for, you know, it's just such a crazy thing.
Uh Jennifer Weiss Wolf at the Brennan Center has done a lot of work in this uh in this area. It is clearly the invisible uh discrimination that we've all gotten so used to that we don't say, wait a minute, you know, this is simply not fair and it has to change. So, you know, I think uh certainly the Equal Rights Amendment uh, you know, will you know will do away with that. Uh and uh I, you know, but again, can you imagine that something as simple as dry cleaning would go to the core of what the woman's problem is in America? Forget about everything else, you know. You have a you have a blouse, you're gonna pay more for it than a man who has a shirt, you know. I uh it's extraordinary. And we have to have 20 more blouses than he needs the one shirt because he's allowed to wear one thing every single day.
But I say this is this is this requires a woman's uprising, you know. We just have to, you know, stop. And uh one of one of our team members today was saying, you know, that when she's in the drugstore and she's she does the comparison shopping, you know, the woman's scrub brush versus the man's scrub. I'm gonna take the man's because it's half the price, you know. And who's gonna come to my bathroom, I suppose, you know, to know the difference. But it's uh that's an extraordinary um thing that we have all assumed was just the way of the world, you know, we would just have to pay this because that's what women do. And there's a million commercials geared right toward us, telling us that we need all of this for our identity.
You know, it's interesting. I'm so excited about this amendment finally being published and being in the constitution. I've had so many jobs that I was afraid to lose, where I what didn't feel like I was able to speak up for myself. I didn't feel like I was able to ask certain questions about why I was getting paid or how I was being treated, for fear of losing that job that I needed, because it's harder for me to get a job than it is for a man, it's harder for me to be taken seriously. So in to have that backing in the constitution, when it says all men are created equal, for that to actually mean all people and not just all men, is really a confidence boost, if nothing else, to go into those situations and advocate for myself as a woman and advocate for other women.
Because some people who've said, well, the ERA is only a symbol, and I say, what a great symbol. Can you imagine all of what it does for all of our little girls and all of uh, you know, just okay, so make it symbolic, you know. And another thing that people say, well, but the ERA doesn't do everything. And I say, okay, but does it have to do everything? What why can't it just improve our lives, you know, in a dramatic way? I don't think we should put the burden on the ERA that it has to solve every single problem that women have. It certainly will create a level playing field, give us a floor with uh fundamental constitutional rights. Um, and that's you know, if it's a symbol, you know, let's take it, you know. Uh it's a foundation we can build upon.
[52:48] Carol Jenkins: 100%. And protection for the future. We don't know who our future leaders are gonna be. We don't know the positions that we're gonna be in. And if this isn't embedded in the constitution, then anything can happen. So it really is. You see what we're faced with now, that the voting rights act, which was cut back by Congress. So uh that's why we are seeking an amendment uh as opposed to an act, you know, or a bill or whatever, because we want it to be permanent and a part of our uh constitution.
[53:19] Carol Jenkins: Yeah. Shelters were full, and we didn't have the protection because that act wasn't. And now, thank God the violence against women act has passed, and we have it again, and we're gonna have some support. And now the violence against women act has passed in Congress, and hopefully it will pass in the Senate, and we can finally get these women the support that they have so desperately needed.
[53:53] Carol Jenkins: Right, right. So we're we're all we thought it was just so so sweet that uh the violence against women act and the ERA were passed by the House of Representatives on the very same day. So this sort of we're it's a complementary uh way of looking uh at women and looking at our at our country. And now we're faced with the very same thing. Uh going to the Senate where it will require, because of the 60 vote requirement, we have uh 50 uh Democrats who all support the ERA. Uh, we have two Republicans, Lisa Burkowski and Susan Collins, who support the ERA, but that brings us like eight senators shy for passage uh of the drop the time limit resolution. The same thing with FAWA.
[54:39] Carol Jenkins: Uh we in this House of Representatives last year had a resounding passage of this bill, and then it just sat in the Senate along with hundreds of other good ideas that never got taken up. But now because we have a new administration who supports the Equal Rights Amendment and VAWA certainly, uh a new Senate, which is 50-50 with a vice presidential tiebreaker, uh Kamala Harris. Uh we're in a better situation, but we're not there yet because unless some roundabout way is found, whether it's drinking with filibuster or some uh maneuver, uh it at the moment we still require eight Republican votes that we are now working to uh to get.
[55:26] Carol Jenkins: We're doing a briefing uh in the Senate next week for the Senate staff uh so that uh they can take back to their bosses, you know, what this uh amendment is all about and if why and why we need it now, uh as opposed to you know uh shelving it. And once again, saying to the women of America that you don't count, you don't matter. And it doesn't matter that their constituents and you know the approval rate is sky high in the country for for the Equal Rights Amendment and the Violence Against Women Act. Uh, these particular few people you know sitting in the United States Senate are going to block uh that for millions of women, block both of those bills for millions of women. So it seems like a crazy thing to be against.
[56:15] Laura Bell Bundy: What is the most compelling argument against passing the ERA in the Senate?
[56:21] Carol Jenkins: Well, there are those who argue with uh, you know, our argument that we've met all of the requirements in Article 5. And so they're holding on to the time limit that was actually in the preamble or the introduction to the amendment, not anything that the states voted on. Uh, but they want to hold us uh, you know, to that. There are some who believe uh that because of the recent uh Supreme Court decision on uh trans and LGBTQ rights, uh, that uh that they are now included uh in this bill, and they certainly are. And then there are those who believe that uh this that the equal rights amendment gives abortion you know free to everyone. And you know, what we say is abortion is the rule of law of the land. Uh the equal rights amendment is a fundamental constitutional redoing of who is included and who cannot be discriminated against, and that people cannot be discriminated based on sex.
[57:23] Carol Jenkins: So uh so we have some substantial, you know, people and and you know what we say is that we you know we get it, we understand people have their their views and their beliefs, so we're not challenging their beliefs. The only thing we are challenging is what the Equal Rights Amendment does. Uh and you know, not that they're not, you know, they can't own their beliefs in so many areas. So um, you know, so it's a complicated situation, you know, but uh we're hopeful that uh this given the new administration the new Senate the overwhelming support in the country for this that we should be able to do this this year wow and then you know I know our song is about equal pay but really the root of getting equal pay is having a quality first and having everything from bodily autonomy to just having the same opportunities as everybody else to recognizing the unfair things like the pink tax that are existing and starting to like level all of that out all of this is one issue and it really starts with having the constitution be aware of women and I'm just so grateful for the work that you have done and your career has been so immense and to have someone as smart and as compassionate and passionate as you are like leading this coalition is just such a gift to learn you too are you kidding again for the soundtrack that you know inspires us you know and when we have those low days just let's listen well it is yours use it in whatever you want any of our songs they are free for you you just when this thing passes we'll do a big old concert we're gonna look forward to that all the more reason we get a concert if we pass the ER if we get the era published it's passed already if we can get it published that'll be fabulous you both are tremendous thank you so much thank you for being here Carol.
[59:30] Carol Jenkins: No, it's my pleasure. Thank you for the opportunity.
[59:34] Laura Bell Bundy: Money, money, money. Money, money, money. Where's my money, bitch? Thanks for listening. Hope you have enough for a catfair home tonight. I'm Laura Bell Bundy, and you can find me on Venmo at Laura Bell Bundy.
[59:52] Shea Carter's's: I'm Shea Carter's, and you can find my feet on OnlyFans. Or you can find me on Venmo or the Cash App at Shea Carter's.
[1:00:00] Laura Bell Bundy: We want to thank Carol Jenkins for being with us today. And I'll leave you guys with one last thought. When I finally die, check everywhere. There's a drawer full of cash near my underwear. And you wanna see Shay's feet.
[1:00:32] ♪ Musical number: "Breaking That Glass Ceiling" — performed by Laura Bell Bundy and Shea Carter's ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
