My guests this week are Millie Taylor and Adam Rush, the authors of a very interesting new book titled, Musical Theatre Histories: Expanding the Narrative. Musical theatre is often perceived as being either a Broadway based art form, or as having separate histories in London and New York... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
Featured Shows
About
My guests this week are Millie Taylor and Adam Rush, the authors of a very interesting new book titled, Musical Theatre Histories: Expanding the Narrative.
Musical theatre is often perceived as being either a Broadway based art form, or as having separate histories in London and New York. This new book, however, presents the Musical as neither American nor British, but also both of those, and more!
Through their use of multiple thematic 'histories', Millie and Adam take readers on a series of journeys that include the art form's European and American origins, African American influences, discussions centering on diversity, national identity, and the globalization of the musical, as well as revivals, censorship, and the relationship of social media to the Musical in the 21st century.
As you can hear all of that intersects very directly with the focus and subject matter of this podcast so I was, of course, very captivated by the book and very eager to sit down with Mille and Adam and learn more about their unique and fascinating approach to musical theatre history.
Adam Rush is a Senior Lecturer in Musical Theatre at the University of Winchester in the UK and his research has been published in Studies In Musical Theatre and in several edited collections.
Millie Taylor began her career as a freelance music director and for almost twenty years toured the UK and Europe with a variety of musicals including West Side Story, Little Shop of Horrors, Rocky Horror Show and Sweeney Todd. She is now Professor of Musical Theatre at the University of Winchester, and Special Professor of the Musical at the University of Amsterdam. She is author, co-author or editor of 7 books, including British Pantomime Performance and Singing for Musicals: A Practical Guide.
Become A PATRON of Broadway Nation!
This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our Broadway Nation Patron Club members including Producer Level Patron, Tracy Wellans.
If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation I will information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a Patron.
If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!
For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast.
All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.
If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:
https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/
Thank you in advance for your support!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:29] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African American, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.
[0:45] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and my guests today are Millie Taylor and Adam Rush, the authors of a very interesting new book titled Musical Theater Histories: Expanding the Narrative.
[0:56] David Armstrong: Musical Theater is often perceived as being either a Broadway-based art form or as having separate histories in London and New York. This new book, however, presents the musical as neither American nor British, but also both of those and more.
[1:12] David Armstrong: Through their use of multiple thematic histories, Millie and Adam take readers on a series of journeys that includes the art form's European and American origins, African American influences, discussions centering on diversity, national identity, and the globalization of the musical, as well as revivals, censorship, and the relationship of social media to the musical in the 21st century.
[1:38] David Armstrong: As you can hear, all of that intersects very directly with the focus and subject matter of this podcast, so I was, of course, very captivated by the book, and very eager to sit down with Millie and Adam and learn more about their unique and fascinating approach to musical theater history.
[1:55] David Armstrong: Adam Rush is a senior lecturer in musical theater at the University of Winchester in the UK, and his research has been published in Studies in Musical Theatre and several other edited collections.
[2:07] David Armstrong: Millie Taylor began her career as a freelance music director and for almost 20 years toured the UK and Europe with a variety of musicals, including West Side Story, Little Shop of Horrors, Rocky Horror Show, and Sweeney Todd.
[2:21] David Armstrong: She is now professor of musical theater at the University of Winchester and special professor of the musical at the University of Amsterdam. She is author, co-author, or editor of seven books, including British Pantomime Performance and Singing for Musicals: A Practical Guide.
[2:39] David Armstrong: As always, this podcast is made possible in part through the generous support of our patrons, including producer level patron Tracy Wellans. If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation, I'll have information at the end of the episode about how you too can become a patron.
[2:55] David Armstrong: Here we go. Welcome, Millie Taylor and Adam Rush to Broadway Nation. It's my great pleasure to have you here today to talk about your new book, Musical Theater Histories: Expanding the Narrative.
[3:06] Millie Taylor: Hi, nice to see you.
[3:08] Adam Rush: So great to have you.
[3:09] David Armstrong: You know, in many similar ways to what I do on this podcast, your book relates the history of the Broadway musical, and in this case, you give equal emphasis to the British musical theater, both from their origins and their precursors right up to today, and also very much aligned with what I do. Throughout the book, you emphasize the contributions of BIPOC and other artists from marginalized groups that are too often left out of that story.
[3:35] David Armstrong: However, what's really interesting, and I found fascinating as I was reading the book, was that you've chosen not to tell that story chronologically, but rather through a series of what you call multiple histories. What was it that led you to that approach rather than the standard approach?
[3:51] Adam Rush: Well, I think there were a number of things. I mean, first of all, as a Brit, engaging in a musical theatre form that Americans regard as theirs, we wanted to make an intervention that allowed the history that is transatlantic and international to emerge. But also we were very aware that whenever you tell that canonic narrative of musical theatre that we begin the book with, that it's so partial, that it's a very small part of the story, and that is almost like the default position that everybody takes.
[4:21] Adam Rush: Oh, that's the history of musicals. I've begun working in the Netherlands now, and I'm aware that is the only story that people know. And so it was a combination of awareness of the lack of representation of British musicals, the lack of diversity and the global context of musicals that meant that what we wanted to do was to actually incorporate a lot of different stories. And you can't do that in one story.
[4:46] Millie Taylor: Yeah, I was just gonna add that I think that I don't remember how we found the framework actually, and the idea that we would add these different lenses, but I think one of the things that really interested me, and we do address in the introduction, is that as soon as you apply a different kind of lens or theme or topic to the history, the main players and the main and important shows drastically change.
[5:08] Millie Taylor: There's definitely a section in the introduction that basically says in every history up until now, Oklahoma is seen as really important. But what if we don't think about the form of the musical and we don't think about integration and we don't think about how song, dance, dialogue, and design are combined, and we think about gender or we think about revivals, then all the main players change. You know, we've offered eight different histories of which the main players, and that includes shows and people change, but you know, we could add tons more.
[5:35] Millie Taylor: We found that every time we started a new chapter, we were kind of starting again. We were writing our own way, our own new histories. One other thing about that is that of course, what we're still doing, even having written eight histories of musical theatre, we've only written a few of the potential histories. We're hoping that it's a provocation to others to write other stories about musical theatre that tell different histories.
[5:57] David Armstrong: And did you have histories that you did not end up including in the book? Obviously, you had limitations on how much you could include in the book. Were there other directions you contemplated going?
[6:07] Adam Rush: Not entirely. At one point, some of these were reduced. So, for example, the chapter, the first chapter was at one point two chapters, because that seemed like it needed to tell both the story of integration but also the story of concept musicals. And obviously, what became gender duality to diversity actually started out as the sort of more historical or traditional, these are the women, these are the men. And then we realized that that was actually a big problem because you know, we were just completely leaving out a huge body of important people.
[6:39] Adam Rush: And so we put the two together and it became one chapter. It feels like it's very compressed as a result, but at the same time, it doesn't do the thing that we didn't want to do, which was to say, this is a binary, you know, musical theatre exists within a binary. You're confronting the same issue I have in my teaching, which is how do you include everything you want to include in a course or in a book or whatever it is you're dealing with? And I think you did an exemplary job of doing that, but I can imagine the frustration of what do we have to leave out?
[7:10] David Armstrong: Speaking of which, I want to understand a little better how this book came about. You were both colleagues at the University of Winchester before you went to Amsterdam, is that correct?
[7:19] Millie Taylor: Yes.
[7:20] Adam Rush: In the introduction, you mentioned that the book was developed with and by your BA in musical theatre degree students there. Talk about that process. That sounds like an unusual way to write a book.
[7:31] Adam Rush: Sure, it had a couple of different origins. So it we started the book within months actually of me joining the university, and Millie had been at Winchester for several years, and we were starting and developing and growing a new musical theatre course. So it came with that. And we did actually teach the kind of linear history for one year. But we found in many ways we wanted to work out whether this material was going to work.
[7:54] Adam Rush: And I still teach this material to this day. And it in some ways is confusing that every couple of weeks we reset the clock and we try a different approach. But I think we took different approaches to working it with the students. One of the things that was always key to us from the start was that it was gonna not only be a student-friendly book, but it was gonna have text boxes and activities and reading, and that it was going to be focused for students that they could actually do something with it.
[8:19] Adam Rush: And it's not just something that sits on the shelf and they sort of dip in if they want to find a particular history, that it was gonna be hopefully a book that inspired students to be quite active. So all of the different tasks, for instance, in the book were trialed and altered and rewritten because of our first time using them in a classroom. We certainly have old lecture PowerPoints somewhere that are very similar to these chapters that then grew and developed, but they still grow and develop today.
[8:48] Millie Taylor: Yes, I think I think the other thing was that I did very early drafts of mine because we wrote separate chapters and then we swapped them over and reworked them and so on. I gave the students copies of them, and whatever they didn't understand, I then needed to explain, and I needed therefore to explain it in the book as well. I tested them quite deliberately on the students to see what they got, what they didn't get, what needed more explanation, what didn't, as well as you know, using tasks and you know, sort of experimenting with what appealed to them and what made them engage really with the sorts of debates that we wanted to be having with them.
[9:22] David Armstrong: Which ties right into my next question. Do you see this book primarily as a textbook? It's very accessible, I think, to the general readers. How do you view the book?
[9:30] Adam Rush: That exactly that accessibility. We designed it with and for our first year students because we were already using another book that I'd written some years earlier with somebody else in the second year. And we were aware that when we were teaching history, we were finding lots of different materials from many different places, and in exactly the same way, and for all the same reasons, we started to write this book as a text.
[9:53] Adam Rush: We'd already done it for the second year students, so they were already using a book, and we wanted something similar because we were finding that we were pulling lots of different materials together and trying to find concise histories on lots of different topics. And it's very easy to find, for example, a whole book that tells the history of the integrated musical, but you can't ask students to read a whole book every week. So we wanted something more concise, but that covered a range of materials on a topic.
[10:22] David Armstrong: I understand those concerns completely, which is why this book will be a great resource. Throughout the book, you include boxes of text that you alluded to a minute ago that focus on concepts that some people might not expect to find in a musical theatre history book, such as a section on colonialism or the Jim Crow laws, which again align so much with what I focus on, which is the way musicals always have reflected and represented our society and the culture wherever they're happening.
[10:51] David Armstrong: Why did you think this was important to include these? Why are they there?
[10:55] Adam Rush: Well, partly because if we're thinking about this as an English language textbook for around the world, then there is information that people in one country or another simply won't know. So that's part of it. But also there are some theoretical concepts that we wanted very simple explanations for that students could take on board simply so that we could start to engage and explore that concept in relation to the musicals that we're talking about in that chapter. Again, it's almost like giving a shorthand version so that you can engage in a more interactive conversation.
[11:28] David Armstrong: How does it work, Adam, for you?
[11:30] Adam Rush: I would add on to that, and I think it's maybe something that we sometimes take for granted. And I think that our approach to telling of the history of the musical was that it was always rooted in its relationship with cultural context. And you know, that central idea is to the book, but it's not always the central idea of some publications. There is lots of research out there that tells us the history of the American musical or the British musical, but it's not always tied into the wider cultural or political or social concerns of the time. I mean, we kind of gave ourselves an additional challenge there that was a challenge that we were always going to want to face. We thought it was central to really put these shows in their wider contexts.
[12:09] Adam Rush: And I kind of feel like in many ways, when we talk about the book now, we maybe take that for granted. I feel like it would be a very narrow book if those areas weren't there, and if it was just telling the stories of the shows and of the people, but really it's about how all of these movements or different things shift because of how the world changed. And so not only do we see, you know, his on time pop up in multiple chapters, we also see World War II pop up in multiple chapters because those events and those people are as significant in all sorts of stories.
[12:39] David Armstrong: Absolutely. And I thought it was fascinating the way those events affect the British musical and the American musical differently at the same time, you know, simultaneously. You say, I think in the introduction, that the aim of the book is to rethink the telling of the musical theater primarily as a transatlantic form. Why? Why was that one of your aims?
[12:58] Adam Rush: It arose from two different things. One is what I've already said about feeling like the American musical was being talked about separately from the British musical, and then the global music was starting to be discussed. There's an interesting book about producers, for example, that talks about producers in different parts of the world. There's work now on historical touring events and producers. What we were finding was that those stories are beginning to emerge, but they weren't contained anywhere. And so we wanted to first of all bring Britain and America together, because I think this absolutely is a form that has popped between our island and your continent, but also in the awareness of the changing globe.
[13:44] David Armstrong: We Americans do like to dominate the conversation and see things through our own eyes. In the book, you have eight chapters, basically, eight histories, eight ways of looking at this history, at this overall history that we're talking about. And if you don't mind, I'd like to talk about each of those individually as we go. Each we'll go through those chapters at least briefly. The first chapter is called Putting It Together from Operetta to Paparetta. And I love that you connect these dots. It's something I do as well. I think the operetta often gets left out of a lot of the discussion, partly because in America, I think rightly so, we tend to focus on vaudeville and the review and those elements that really influence the American musical, perhaps more strongly than they did the British musical.
I'm not sure if that's true or not. But we often forget about the core basis, I think, in many ways of the musical theater, which is the operetta. Again, that probably comes from your British perspective on this, because I think retained their prominence and their dominance much longer in the UK than they did in the United States. Talk about a little bit about that. How do you see that as a progression from the earliest operettas to what we have on Broadway today?
[14:56] Adam Rush: Yes, um, it is slightly different from a British perspective, I think, because as you say, the operetta hung around longer in the UK. It hung around really right through until I suppose the early 60s. There were forms that were still very similar to operetta, so we do have a stronger sense of that. But equally, the operetta toured the world. The European operetta.
[15:19] Adam Rush: This match lost at least a year. He'll say Madame achieved monsieur. But each will go his own sweet way.
[15:45] Adam Rush: It is but not the week to go. I'd never met it. No, my no, it's no my nominee.
[16:06] Adam Rush: Stop the dance. I've got to breed. Calmly, calmly, this won't do. This will never get me full.
[16:17] Adam Rush: And so it was also partly to do with putting that starting point that was much more European in there. Not just reclaiming the British space, but also reclaiming the European starting points and putting those alongside all the popular forms that then also emerged in both the UK and US. What we were trying to do was to think of the starting points and the many different starting points that are actually claimed in histories of the musical theatre. I'm trying to put those all together and demonstrate how it's so hard to talk about a single starting point, a single history, even a single form as the progenitor of something. You know, we had operetta in the title largely because the journey of this chapter goes through to the megamusicals, the paperettas.
But I mean, some people would argue that Rogerson Hammer Tatsin were writing operettas. So, you know, I mean, what is an operetta? We don't actually say that in the book. What we're talking about is just that journey and the journey of what you might call the integrated narrative, the narrative of the integrated book musical.
[17:19] Adam Rush: And so we're taking that journey because that's the canonic narrative. And the slant we're putting on it is that it's much more multinational than it often appears to be, even down to the incorporation of Irish heritage, of Jewish heritage, and so on. That it is a multinational story. And I think this chapter is the most traditional in one sense. So Millie's absolutely right that we tried to expand it beyond that traditional narrative and include other voices, but also we knew somewhere that we had to at least acknowledge the typical kind of headliners of often white men from Rosen Hammerstein to Sondheim to Android Weber and kind of similar key figures. So it wasn't that you know we wanted to kind of rewrite history and never acknowledge these key players, but we knew that we kind of had to do and present a chapter really that sort of says this is what most people think of so far. We're adding a little bit more detail here, but then we hit chapter two onwards where we really start to diversify and find new voices.
[18:16] David Armstrong: People talk about the progression of integration in the musical, which you also show us, you demonstrate, but operators were always integrated to a great extent.
[18:27] Adam Rush: Yes. And I think that's one of the things that we're trying to show that there is this story, this canonic story that integration began with Oklahoma, and then some people talk about the Black Crook as the first musical, or showboat as perhaps that was the progenitor, or the princess shows were the progenitor, or whatever. Um and I think what we were trying to show was that there is actually a multiplicity, even in that conversation. That there are all those starting points, and you can't ever say this is one starting point.
[18:55] David Armstrong: Where do you begin?
[18:56] Adam Rush: Well, we actually begin with the Florentine Camarata because you know, where do you go back to? We could have gone back to the Greeks, maybe. Because particularly from the Camarata, there was an attempt to simplify the relationship between words and text and tell stories, which is really what the integrated musical does. It tries to use music and text to tell stories, and then obviously Rogers and Hammerstein I did dance, but dance was already in musicals, it was just that they used it in a more integrated way.
[19:25] Adam Rush: I was trying to avoid that word and couldn't. There are always argument that. And what we want to do is have the argument rather than saying this is the rule. This is what happened. The way I often explain it for myself and for my students is that the genius of Rogers and Hammerstein is that they combine the operetta and the musical comedy. They put them together, and that's what created the musical play, or what we just call a musical today. Again, that's maybe an oversimplification, but it's one way to sort of bring the threads together.
[19:57] David Armstrong: That and their PR.
[19:59] Adam Rush: Oh, exactly. That's the show business part of it is make the show and then make sure people know about it.
[20:05] Adam Rush: I'm off to shame a seems to join the wording stream. When people ask what it is, I simply tell them this is low lo-do, usually.
[20:26] Adam Rush: And when it comes to kids, goodbye, my mother.
[20:50] Adam Rush: I never met it.
[21:09] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation will be back right after this quick break.
[21:18] David Armstrong: Before we leave this chapter, just talk a little bit more about the paparetta. And I always talk about it, at least in America, of this surprising resurgence of the operetta. Because basically, those British Brithits, if you want to call them that, were very, very similar, almost identical to the classic operettas, except that they have pop elements to the music.
[21:39] Adam Rush: Yes, absolutely.
[21:40] Millie Taylor: And so what changed was, I mean, we don't talk so much about this in the book, but actually another story you could tell is about technology and technology changed, you know, the kind of writing changed, the kind of instrumentation and the kind of voices changed. But they were still telling stories. I mean, Phantom of the Opera is absolutely a classic operetta. It was a resurgence of that, but it was a new voice in operetta. And it was a new sound world. In many cases, they were telling new stories. In some cases, they weren't. Phantom of the Opera's 19th century, Les Misérables's 19th century. You have that sort of historical reference that operetta also had. But then, of course, you get the Disney musicals as well, which are much more contemporary if you think about it that way.
But actually, they're based on historic folk tales. Exactly. Is there anything new under the sun? So Adam mentioned the second chapter, so let's jump to there. This is called We Are the Rhythms That Color Your Song from Ragtime to Rap. This is in some ways, at least I find in my teaching, one of the most difficult aspects of the musical theater to talk about because you can't talk about it without talking about the minstrel show. How did you approach that with your students? And in the book? How do you approach that subject as being at the center of not just the African American contribution to the musical theater, but all musical theatre is based in many elements of the minstrel show.
[23:02] Adam Rush: Yes, yeah. I'm afraid I'm going to dominate this conversation a bit as well because I wrote this chapter too. We'll come to mine in a minute. I found this a very difficult chapter to write because it felt to me like it wasn't my story to tell, but at the same time, I felt it important that we tell it because it is so fundamental. So you always have that slight awareness that you're in one sense telling somebody else's story. But nevertheless, I thought it was really important that we did. And it seemed to me that what we were trying to do was give voice to stories that hadn't been heard. And this is one of the most important stories that we felt we needed to tell. It moves us away from operetta into the popular forms that infiltrated musical theatre or that were appropriated by musical theatre, and that effectively gave it its pop, you know, that became the jazz and the syncopation and the excitement and the rhythm, but they arose from somewhere else.
Now, part of the remit of the book is that all the things we're writing about arose from many different sources. And this is also true of this chapter, that the musics that are the popular music of musical theatre arose from many sources, but there's a power imbalance, and that was the thing that we really wanted to address in this chapter the idea that music was appropriated from certain sources, and that the people who created that music were not always given appropriate recompense or recognition for it.
[24:28] Millie Taylor: And so it seemed to us it was a really important story to tell, and we tried to tell it through talking about musicals that have been to some extent misunderstood. Audiences walk out when they see The Scottsboro Boys, for example. In London, I saw people walking out leaving at the interval because it was a show that was using minstrelsy as a form. Hey, hey, hey, hey, look what we got for you. Come on, gather on. Hey, hey, hey, hey, you won't be able to keep your toes on Timby tapping over the ground. Sit back now, relay let's get comfortable. Send us out of size. King, say hello to the minstrel. Mr. Tambo, how are you feeling tonight? I spite. But I think that lady in the front row is sharp.
She just don't believe what she's seeing. Mr. Tambo, she's just not used to seeing you in those clothes. And I used to see in her in hers. Hey, hate I play all kinds of characters Tambo heaters too. And do mean man. Kingmen. White men's our specialty. Even those who know them always know who is sing alarm or tell us to want to dance alright. Hey, hey, hey, hey, joining the merriment. Everyone's a minstrel tonight. And yet the story it was trying to tell was the fact that those people were misrepresented and they had no voice. And they were telling it using a form of material and a style of performance that arose as part of that very problematic and deeply troubling history. And they're very brave composers and writers who have put that material together.
We could all play safe and not address it. But I mean, the story of Ragtime absolutely puts that story in that history front and centre. And I think it's such an important musical. And there are so many of those important stories that people are beginning to tell, you know, Shuffle Along's another one. It's our history, and we have to tell it.
[26:35] Adam Rush: In each of these chapters, and I think Ragtime is the one you used in this chapter, you select a musical that sort of embodies what you're going to talk about that not only is a product of what you're talking about, sort of tells the story of that particular history that you're speaking with. I found that very engaging and also makes it very immediate, especially for people who are immersed in the musical theatre canon. You get to dive right into the subject of the chapter with something you know so well. And I think that's also useful for students because it means that what you can do is you can introduce them to a musical which they have an immediate connection with, and then you can say, now this is why this is a problem.
Now let's have a conversation about it. And so it's a way of fully engaging with them in the debate when they've watched the musical and they want to have a conversation about all that performance or that tap dance, and you say, Yes, but let's talk about this and let's talk about this history. And I think that engages them in a very different way, and they become much more involved in the discussions and debates about ethics and morality and so on. And I think that's the experience of reading the book, which is wonderful. There's also a brief feel that's an element for me which makes students realize how much musical theatre as an art form really does reflect the real world and tell really important and significant stories.
I was teaching Pacific Overtures today, and it's also used in the book as an example of you know, it's telling a real world story. All of these shows tell these important stories that totally dismiss the idea that musical theatre is frivolous and tap dancing and jazz hands, and as Aminy says, provide these excellent kind of avenues and ways in to really rich historical discussions, despite being a Broadway or Western Church.
[28:12] Millie Taylor: Absolutely. I used to flippantly say everything I know about history I learned from Broadway musicals. But it's true, you can learn a lot as a child. Please be sure to join us next time on Broadway Nation when Millie, Adam, and I will return with the second part of our conversation about their fascinating new book, Musical Theatre Histories: Expanding the Narrative. Where have I been? How did we change? Caught in history, new music.
[30:07] David Armstrong: Here's the information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation. A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast. And all patrons will receive special shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast. That's Broadway Nation Podcast. Or click the link in the show notes to this episode.
[31:00] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong.
[31:10] ♪ Musical number: "Changing Everything" — performed by David Armstrong ♪
[31:38] David Armstrong: Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
