Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 61: The Craft And Art Of Broadway Choreography , part 2

This is the second half of my recent conversation with author Liza Gennaro, whose fascinating new book is titled: Making Broadway Dance. If you missed part one you may want to catch up on that episode before listening to this one... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

36 mins
4/7/22

Guests

Featured Shows

About

This is the second half of my recent conversation with author Liza Gennaro, whose fascinating new book is titled: Making Broadway Dance.

If you missed part one you may want to catch up on that episode before listening to this one.

Liza is currently the Dean of Musical Theater at the Manhattan School of Music and she also has had a very active and successful career as a dancer and choreographer. Interestingly, she is closely related to this subject matter of her book because her father was the Tony Award winning choreographer and star dancer, Peter Gennaro. He is profiled in the book as well as in this episode.

By the end of Part 1, we had made it to the late 1940s when Agnes de Mille was dominating the field of Broadway choreography. Between 1943 and 1945, De Mille had four hits in a row – Oklahoma!, One Touch of Venus, Bloomer Girl, and Carousel – and three of them choreographed in her signature “Americana” style. This unprecedented string of successes made her the most powerful choreographer in the commercial theater, and soon led to her becoming the first director-choreographer of the “Golden Age” with Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Allegro.

De Mille’s most significant contribution to the Broadway Musical was breaking the mold of the traditional Broadway chorus girl by insisting on hiring actor/dancers who could fully embody the characters that they were playing.

This new approach to Broadway dance, and this new kind of Broadway dancer, would be adopted by everyone who followed in her footsteps – especially Jerome Robbins – who years later would write, “Agnes broke the conception of what the Broadway dancer could be in the Broadway Musical. What they looked like, what was desired of them, and what their contribution to the show was.”

And, as you will hear, Robbins took that idea and ran with it, just as De Mille’s “Americana” style was starting to lose its luster.

That’s just the beginning Later in the episode Liza and I discuss Michael Kidd, Bob Fosse, Gower Champion, Michael Bennett, Graciela Daniele, Susan Stroman, Kathleen Marshall, Bill T. Jones, Stephen Hoggett, Lorin Latarro, Kelly Devine, Sergio Trujillo, Jerry Mitchell and more!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:24] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and I call this episode The Craft and Art of Broadway Choreography Part 2.

[0:36] David Armstrong: This is the second half of my recent conversation with author Liza Gennaro, whose fascinating new book is titled Making Broadway Dance. If you missed part one, you may want to catch up on that episode before listening to this one.

[0:49] David Armstrong: Liza is currently the Dean of Musical Theater at the Manhattan School of Music, and prior to that, she had a very active and successful career as a dancer and choreographer. And she is directly related to the subject matter of her book because her father was the Tony Award-winning choreographer and star dancer Peter Gennaro. He's also one of the subjects of Liza's book and this episode.

[1:12] David Armstrong: At the end of part one, we had made it to the late 1940s when Agnes DeMille was dominating the field of Broadway choreography. Between 1943 and 1945, DeMille had four hits in a row: Oklahoma, One Touch of Venus, Bloomer Girl, and Carousel. And three of them were choreographed in what became her signature Americana style.

[1:35] David Armstrong: This string of unprecedented success made her the most powerful choreographer in the commercial theater, and soon led to her becoming the first director choreographer of the Golden Age. As Liza noted last time, Agnes de Mille's most significant contribution to the Broadway musical was in how she broke the mold of the traditional Broadway chorus girl by insisting on hiring actor dancers who could fully embody the characters that they were playing.

[2:01] David Armstrong: This new approach to Broadway dance and this new kind of Broadway dancer would be adopted by everyone who followed in DeMille's footsteps, especially Jerome Robbins, who years later would write, "Agnes broke the conception of what the Broadway dancer could be in the Broadway musical, what they looked like, what was desired of them, and what their contribution to the show was." And as you will hear, Robbins took that idea and ran with it, just as DeMille's Americana style was starting to lose its luster. Here we go.

[2:33] Liza Gennaro: When she gets into the mid to late 40s, it starts to feel a bit dated. And by then, Robbins has taken over. And Robbins brings urbanism and jazz and Bernstein, and audiences are just overwhelmed by him.

[2:47] Liza Gennaro: And he's extremely prolific. He has so many shows so quickly. And he's working at New York City Ballet with Balanchine at the same time. And of course, mentoring with George Abbott, who he was assisting and choreographing for and co-directing with.

[3:01] David Armstrong: And who were the other choreographers who came out of that Americana movement?

[3:05] Liza Gennaro: Well, for theater, certainly Michael Kidd. I would say Michael Kidd was the other really major one. Anyone who's seen the movie of Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, you'll see that. And then the other choreographers, you know, I think of are more the ballet choreographers who I mentioned already. In musical theater, once Robbins starts doing his thing, the Americana style is not as interesting and is not as producible.

[3:31] David Armstrong: I love that you take sections of the book to profile these various choreographers, some of which we know very well and some of which we don't know well. And of course, one of those had to be your dad, Peter Gennaro, which was a delight to know more about him.

[3:45] Liza Gennaro: I don't know that there's been a lot written about your dad other than this book. Of course, you should be the expert. But was that challenging in any way to write objectively about your father in this regard?

[3:55] Liza Gennaro: It was. It was challenging. And I just finished writing another chapter for an Oxford University Press book that'll be coming out in a year on musicals and television. And I focused it on my father's dances on variety shows. So I really dug in there even more so because when I was working on Broadway dance and talking about it, it was fun for me. You know, I was enjoying doing it.

[4:18] Liza Gennaro: And what I tried to do with all the choreographers, and it was very fun to do with my father, was to really unpack what their training had been and what their exposures to dance had been, and then to see how they all brought it to the commercial theater. So that was interesting. And also just my father's relationship with the Catherine Dunham School, and then why Robbins chose him to co-choreograph West Side Story with him, and what my father brought to West Side Story that Robbins didn't have in his bag of tricks, which I think was really what my father gained from the Dunham School, which was the dances of the African diaspora, the Latin dances, the Mambo in the dance at the gym, and of course the America and the rest of the shark material.

[5:17] Liza Gennaro: Just so people know, when we watch West Side Story today, the original, whether it's the movie or see a stage production where they're recreating it, almost everything the sharks do is your father's work with Robbins supervising.

[5:29] David Armstrong: Yeah, exactly. Robbins didn't want to choreograph West Side Story, and Hal Prince told him if he didn't do it, he wouldn't produce it. So he got a co-choreographer. He asked my father to assist him first, and my father said no, because my father had begun choreographing at that point, and he said I would co-choreograph it. So that was the agreement that they made.

[5:47] Liza Gennaro: But I was interested when New York Public Library for the Performing Arts did a Google exhibit on my father's participation in West Side Story, and they had hundreds of pictures, the Martha Swope pictures from the rehearsals. And in looking at those, it was quite interesting because you could see where my father was far more involved than I ever realized. He did the Mambo, which is the Jets and the Sharks. There are pictures of him working on the prologue. And you know, I don't know if Robbins was just using him to work it out or if he was demonstrating, you know, who knows. But it was interesting that he was very much a part of that entire experience.

[6:27] Liza Gennaro: And as we know on musicals, it's a collaborative art form. You know, the costume designer may be the person who comes up with the great idea for the finale of the show. Ideas come from everywhere. So when I read scholarship that tries to parse out this person did this, that person did that, it's frustrating to me because it's a lack of understanding of how the process works, which is that everyone is going for the same thing. And when it works at its best, you've got a strong leadership and a director, and then everybody's just following suit and figuring out how to tell that story that way.

[7:03] David Armstrong: So I think that the participation of my father, though we always say it was the sharks, there's that embedding of just a person's being in a show, you can't really not tangible in a sense.

[7:15] Liza Gennaro: Absolutely. I'm sure he has a tremendous amount to do with the entire show because he's there and he's brilliant. And Robbins is going to use everything he can to make the show better, including your father's brilliance in doing that.

[7:40] David Armstrong: His expertise in Latin dance is really interesting because your father's Italian, he's not Latin, and yet he was taken into the Catherine Dunham Company as one of the company members. So clearly he just had an affinity for this that went beyond any immediate heritage.

[7:57] Liza Gennaro: Well, he was the swing on the Dunham Company and then he danced with the experimental company. He was raised in New Orleans, Sicilian immigrants, and they lived across the street from a Black Baptist church. And as a child, he would, you know, follow the jazz funerals. So he had a real feel for that kind of dancing. It made sense on his body.

[8:20] Liza Gennaro: He really didn't train completely formally until after he was out of World War II, which is when he went to the Dunham School on the GI Bill. He also studied in New Orleans when he went back at one point. Actually, my parents got married, my mother was a ballet dancer, and she said we've got to go to this class, and it was Lilia Holler who I think had been with the Ballet Russe. I'm actually just currently doing some research on her. But she was a serious ballet person, and he studied with her as well.

[8:47] Liza Gennaro: And so you can see in his dancing on the television shows that he's really fusing ballet with these Black dances coming out of the Black communities, jazz, but in a very different way than Balanchine was doing. So Balanchine is bringing the European aesthetic to it, where my father is in America learning these dances from childhood. So it's fascinating to me to see how that translates onto the body.

[9:15] David Armstrong: Well, you and I both grew up watching your father dance on the Ed Sullivan Show. You probably got to be there in person at times, but I have vivid memories of that.

[9:26] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, yeah, he probably about eight years, something like that. He was a weekly. And of course, Perry Como Show and the Kraft Musical. I mean, he did all of those variety shows. It's really interesting for any scholars to look at the periods of the variety shows.

[9:40] David Armstrong: Let's move to the director choreographers, which is a big part of your book. So it's natural that a choreographer would want to direct the show as well as choreograph it, relating to some of the things you said earlier, just in terms of being able to not have to follow the lead of the director, but to actually lead the entire show themselves. And also it was inevitable that I think producers would want them to do it because it was all about the flow of the show. It was about making the show as we move into this Golden Age where we want to integrate all the elements of the musical.

[10:17] Liza Gennaro: Yeah. And DeMille is the first of this era with Allegro, and it's not a success. Although what I found so interesting in doing the research was I had always heard, well, Allegro didn't work because DeMille was a mess and she couldn't direct, and that was the problem. And then you look at the reviews and you see actually she got very good reviews. And what she was doing was very innovative, and it was the book. It was the book as it usually is. When the book doesn't work, the choreographer gets blamed. They fire the choreographer.

[10:48] Liza Gennaro: So she had a rough time on that one. And I don't think she ever really recovered. I mean, she did direct a few more times, but never had great success. Whereas Robbins starts directing, he does Peter Pan, which he does the book and he does the rewrite, and then he's working on Pajama Game as the co-director with Abbott, and then he spells a ring by himself, and then he just takes off.

[11:11] Liza Gennaro: And because he had an outlet, a parallel career at the New York City Ballet, where he had an outlet to have his movement expression. And he was focused on that there. But on the shows, I think he was less concerned with again this idea of invented movement. He was interested in the storytelling in all aspects. So as a director choreographer, this was a perfect fit for him. It just worked for him.

[11:38] Liza Gennaro: And he went from show to show. And I think he was probably very, very good about choosing the shows that he took on. And he was getting offered everything because his shows were successful. That's a big piece that, you know, people forget. You're only as good as your material. You've got to have good material.

[11:53] David Armstrong: He got to choose.

[11:54] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, he got to choose, and she was just getting, you know, whatever was coming along, she was taking. So then coming out of Robbins, you have a very young Bob Fosse who has an incredible experience working with him on Pajama Game.

[12:08] Liza Gennaro: As I write in the book, it's kind of startling when you see the amount of the choreography that was done by Robbins.

[12:15] Liza Gennaro: And pretty much the only thing done by Bob Fosse, and I don't mean only negatively, was "Steam Heat," which was spectacular.

[12:23] Liza Gennaro: And defined him.

[12:24] Liza Gennaro: I mean, put him on the map.

[12:25] Liza Gennaro: But the rest of it, he's acting basically as Robbins' assistant or doing the first draft, and then Robbins is fixing it.

[12:32] Liza Gennaro: Exactly.

[12:32] Liza Gennaro: And he's another sponge, and he's learning and figuring it out and you know, setting his ego aside and soaking it up so that when he moves on, he just really takes off.

[12:43] Liza Gennaro: As I relate in my book, years later, Fosse's biographer Martin Gottfried told Robbins that Fosse had admitted to him that when he was hired to do "The Pajama Game," that he didn't know much about musical staging.

[12:57] Liza Gennaro: Robbins replied, "Well, he learned fast."

[13:00] Liza Gennaro: He's very like Robbins, they're very invested in a kind of Stanislavskian approach or a method approach, and they're really using that with the dances.

[13:11] Liza Gennaro: How do you approach a dance like "Whatever Lola Wants"?

[13:11] Liza Gennaro: "Whatever Lola wants."

[13:24] Liza Gennaro: And little man.

[13:26] Liza Gennaro: Little Lola wants you.

[13:30] Liza Gennaro: What is Gwen Verdon doing in that dance that's making it so complete in terms of telling us who she is and what's happening in the moment?

[13:41] Liza Gennaro: And that has always been fascinating to me because when you see revivals, it's the rare revival where you see a performance that really pops off the stage.

[13:51] Liza Gennaro: I'm always kind of looking and thinking, what's missing here?

[13:55] Liza Gennaro: And I think that a lot of times what's missing is the director.

[13:59] Liza Gennaro: What Gwen said was when she did Lola, she didn't do it sexy.

[14:04] Liza Gennaro: She did it like the ugly little fat girl that she was that sold her soul to the devil, and now she's got this new body that she's playing with.

[14:13] Liza Gennaro: I love Joe.

[14:16] Liza Gennaro: It's me.

[14:20] Liza Gennaro: He hits so far.

[14:22] Liza Gennaro: Hold on.

[14:24] Liza Gennaro: That's you.

[14:28] Liza Gennaro: And that makes the numbers so much richer.

[14:31] Liza Gennaro: When the choreographer has that kind of knowledge of acting and what is required to tell story and express ideas through the body relating to the libretto, I think is when you really get that explosion of powerful, powerful work.

[14:51] Liza Gennaro: And of course, Robbins was able to do it over and over again, as was Bennett.

[14:55] Liza Gennaro: And Gower Champion, who's kind of another thing to me because he really uses dances that are part and parcel of the Broadway lexicon of movement.

[15:06] Liza Gennaro: He's really not trying to do anything with dance.

[15:08] Liza Gennaro: He's just genius at building numbers and at making the entire production work seamlessly.

[15:16] Liza Gennaro: And making the whole show dance in a way.

[15:18] Liza Gennaro: Exactly.

[15:19] Liza Gennaro: That's a great way to put it.

[15:20] Liza Gennaro: Exactly.

[15:21] Liza Gennaro: The steps could be any steps.

[15:22] Liza Gennaro: He's gonna weave them together into this sort of magical non-stop event.

[15:27] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, I think that's a great way to say it is that the steps, they could be any steps.

[15:31] Liza Gennaro: Whereas with Robbins, they can't be any steps.

[15:34] Liza Gennaro: They have to be those steps.

[15:35] Liza Gennaro: Same thing with DeMille, same thing with Fosse.

[15:37] Liza Gennaro: It's not less good.

[15:39] Liza Gennaro: I'm just trying to show it's different, that there are different ways to approach the form.

[15:45] Liza Gennaro: And if it works, it works.

[15:47] Liza Gennaro: And it's not easy to stop a show.

[15:49] Liza Gennaro: And it's not easy to get big hands, and it's not easy to build a number.

[15:53] Liza Gennaro: So anybody who can do that, I don't take that away from Gower Champion or those choreographers.

[15:58] Liza Gennaro: That is a very special skill.

[16:00] Liza Gennaro: But it's a little bit different, is all I'm saying from what DeMille and Robbins to a degree were doing.

[16:06] Liza Gennaro: You have a paragraph in your book where you talk about the challenge of stopping a show and how that's not to be underestimated.

[16:13] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, because it's a lot to do with what's before the number and what's after the number, what's happening within the number, and then how the movement builds and the structure of the number.

[16:23] Liza Gennaro: And when you see Bennett was so good at it, you know, even like in "Coco," and I reference a wonderful YouTube clip from "Coco," where they're just walking, but the way they're walking and the way they're building and the way he's using bodies on the stage in formation, which was also a Robbins thing, where he put those bodies is so specific and is telegraphing so much information.

[16:48] Liza Gennaro: That's something that I think gets not really examined enough in terms of Broadway choreography.

[16:53] Liza Gennaro: And he was genius at it.

[16:55] Liza Gennaro: And Bennett could do the same thing.

[16:57] Liza Gennaro: And Bennett could also do it with dance dance, the way he would repeat a phrase and then change it a little and change it a little and change it.

[17:03] Liza Gennaro: And so you were just sitting on the edge of your seat.

[17:06] Liza Gennaro: That's a very difficult thing to do.

[17:08] Liza Gennaro: You also go into a great description of how Fosse defines himself with "Big Spender."

[17:14] Liza Gennaro: He has a great career prior to that, wins lots of Tony Awards.

[17:17] Liza Gennaro: He was the king of Broadway in many ways, but really, in your view, comes into his own with "Big Spender."

[17:29] Liza Gennaro: I do feel that because you know, now in dance schools, they teach the Fosse style.

[17:34] Liza Gennaro: The miniature walked in the joint.

[17:38] Liza Gennaro: I could see you were a man of distinction.

[17:43] Liza Gennaro: "Hey, big spender."

[17:47] Liza Gennaro: Good looking, sorry.

[17:51] Liza Gennaro: Say, wouldn't you like to know what's going on in my mind?

[17:56] Liza Gennaro: So let me get right to the point.

[18:00] Liza Gennaro: I don't pop my cork for every I see.

[18:08] Liza Gennaro: "Hey, Big Spender!"

[18:22] Liza Gennaro: And what they're teaching is what he really lands on with "Big Spender" and then continues doing over and over again.

[18:30] Liza Gennaro: He touches on it in "New Girl in Town" with the ballet in the bordello, which gets cut, and then they kind of sneak it back in.

[18:38] Liza Gennaro: This famous dance that we've never seen, unfortunately.

[18:41] Liza Gennaro: And if you see the pictures, and I do have a picture in the book, you see how much it's like "Cabaret," what he did with "Cabaret" with the chairs.

[18:48] Liza Gennaro: That was fascinating to me that he was doing that then, and that Abbott was saying, "No, no, no, no, you can't do that."

[18:55] Liza Gennaro: And then he was able, not too many years later, to find a way to make it work within the context.

[19:00] Liza Gennaro: And of course, you have to look at the period that it's coming out of, which is now we're in the sexual revolution, and the pill has been invented.

[19:07] Liza Gennaro: It's a whole new world, and audiences are much more able to accept the kind of objectification of the female body and the overtly sexual female body, which is what I think Fosse just latches on to, and it's sensational and it's titillating, and audiences do love it.

[19:27] Liza Gennaro: And he does it again in "Pippin," and he does it everywhere.

[19:30] Liza Gennaro: He no longer has any concern for time and place.

[19:35] Liza Gennaro: He's gonna do his thing, that movement thing, which is similar to DeMille.

[19:39] Liza Gennaro: They latched onto a movement style that worked for them and they just kept doing it.

[19:44] Liza Gennaro: They can now impose that on whatever the story is, whether it's the world of Charlemagne in the Middle Ages or the world of Chicago in the 1920s.

[19:54] Liza Gennaro: Exactly.

[19:54] Liza Gennaro: Where he purposely, I think you said didn't use any actual Charleston steps in the show.

[20:00] Liza Gennaro: He's determined not to put a Charleston in it.

[20:02] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, the wonderful dancer and choreographer Tony Stevens, who assisted him on "Chicago," said he said, "I do not want to use one Charleston in this show."

[20:11] Liza Gennaro: Which is, I mean, if that's your project, how fantastic is that?

[20:15] Liza Gennaro: It was very different from what people had done before.

[20:17] Liza Gennaro: Robbins would never have done that.

[20:19] Liza Gennaro: But the fact that Fosse was able to do it, and honestly, also that it was the same thing over and over again, but it was always new yet.

[20:28] Liza Gennaro: That's amazing that he was able to keep it within the context of the show and kind of keep doing it, but kind of keep making it new and different all the time.

[20:36] Liza Gennaro: Hard to almost describe.

[20:38] Liza Gennaro: In a way, isn't it almost like a lot of modern dance choreographers that use the same vocabulary over and over again and yet somehow create new and captivating dances?

[20:47] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, it's a modernist approach.

[20:49] Liza Gennaro: And I think Fosse really bridges the gap between DeMille and then Bennett, because he's still kind of got this modernist intent, and at the same time, he's got the method Stanislavsky thing.

[21:06] Liza Gennaro: And then Bennett comes along, and Bennett's really not particularly interested in any kind of defining movement, creating new kinds of movement.

[21:16] Liza Gennaro: He's got a vocabulary that's coming out of the social dances of the period.

[21:21] Liza Gennaro: It's jazz, he's trained as a jazz dancer and a hoofer.

[21:25] Liza Gennaro: He really then models something else that then happens.

[21:29] Liza Gennaro: Don't go away. Liza and I will be right back with Michael Bennett, Susan Stroman, and more right after this quick break.

[21:52] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, the people that didn't have the modern background.

[21:55] Liza Gennaro: You know, they might have had some, but the thrust of their training was as jazz dancers and sometimes some ballet.

[22:01] Liza Gennaro: Like with the Cassie dance.

[22:10] Liza Gennaro: That movement vocabulary, it's all a kind of 1970s jazz dance.

[22:16] Liza Gennaro: It's almost kind of jazz dancing that you would do in a jazz dance class.

[22:21] Liza Gennaro: The difference is the mirrors and the song and the dress she's wearing and the way he structures the dancing and when he turns the mirrors on her.

[22:30] Liza Gennaro: It's everything that he builds around the movement that's telegraphing the story far more so than the movement.

[22:38] Liza Gennaro: The movement is a marathon, and she's basically like Giselle dancing herself to death.

[22:44] Liza Gennaro: But really, the story is being told through all of the theatrical elements that are happening around her.

[22:50] Liza Gennaro: And that's certainly very different than if DeMille had done that dance.

[22:54] Liza Gennaro: It would have been far more focused, I think, on a choreographic expression on the body, less so than the bigger picture of the elements.

[23:03] Liza Gennaro: I think what you're saying, correct me if I'm wrong, but if DeMille had done "Music in the Mirror," the movement would have been more psychologically based, as opposed to Bennett is doing that through the whole experience, but not so much through the dancing itself.

[23:16] Liza Gennaro: Yeah.

[23:17] Liza Gennaro: Donna McKechnie might disagree with me on that.

[23:19] Liza Gennaro: Well, I think I know what you mean.

[23:22] Liza Gennaro: If you talk to Donna McKechnie, she will take you beat by beat through that dance to what each of those movements is telegraphing.

[23:29] Liza Gennaro: And I get that.

[23:30] Liza Gennaro: But the vocabulary of the movement is common vocabulary.

[23:35] Liza Gennaro: What I'm saying is that DeMille would have invented movement that told that on the body.

[23:42] Liza Gennaro: It's subtle what I'm saying, but there is a distinction there.

[23:45] Liza Gennaro: And the fact that he was drawing on these kind of jazz dance movements was new to that time.

[23:45] Liza Gennaro: These kind of jazz dance class movements.

[23:56] Liza Gennaro: And that he's using less of a psychology than like an inner monologue, I guess which could be considered a psychology, but he's kind of doing an inner monologue with her through the dancing.

[24:06] Liza Gennaro: Whereas DeMille is creating an entire dance with Lori Makes Up Her Mind in Oklahoma, in which she's exploring this one character's psychology and what's stopping this person from moving on and what she can't get through because she's got this attraction to this man that she despises. And how that all plays out in the course of the ballet and through the movement and through the postcard girls, it's a very different process of developing movement, I think, than what Bennett's doing. And I'm not saying good or bad, I'm just saying it's different.

[24:50] Liza Gennaro: One of the analogies I found fascinating was the connection between the postcard girls and Big Spender. That Fosse was clearly influenced by DeMille in that regard.

[24:59] David Armstrong: Yeah, I think he was very influenced.

[25:02] Liza Gennaro: And DeMille, who created those girls through the lens of Lori. So Laurie, who has no sexual experience, is trying to imagine in this dream what these sexualized women would be like. So DeMille has them in this kind of flaccid, droopy, broken doll kind of positions. And then Fosse takes that and kind of flips it on its ear because they're still broken dolls. But the reason they're broken dolls is not because they're through the lens of someone who doesn't understand sex. They're broken dolls because they're women who are worn out by sex. So it's an interesting upending of the idea.

[25:43] Liza Gennaro: In the section of her book about the rise of the director choreographer, I quote the critic Walter Kerr, who made the observation that as the choreographer director became more and more preoccupied with his secondary chores, we began to get a lot less dancing.

[25:59] David Armstrong: I think there's truth to that. Why was that? Do you think?

[26:03] Liza Gennaro: Well, I'll blame Robbins because Robbins was so genius at integrating the dances and making them look like they just popped out of those people at that moment and like you could jump up on the stage and join them. That I think it's very hard to do. And I think a lot of choreographers were not doing it well, and producers started to lose interest in dance. I think there's part of that's going on.

[26:29] Liza Gennaro: But I'm not sure. Well, one thing I think you say in the book, or at least I got from it, is that as a director choreographer, when you're now making the whole show dance, just focusing on dance is less important to you than it is serving the entire show. So you end up making choices that tell the story, even if it means that we don't have these big giant dance moments that take over the show. We now integrate everything through the show.

[26:56] David Armstrong: People often say there's not a lot of dancing in Fiddler on the Roof.

[26:59] Liza Gennaro: Well, there's tons of dance. The whole show dances, but I understand what they're saying.

[27:04] David Armstrong: There's not a big ballet.

[27:06] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, there's not a big ballet, but there is the ballet where the old lady comes back for, you know, exactly. But people don't think of that as a dance, even though that is entirely a genius choreographic moment. As is, of course, the bottle dance. That whole wedding, it's all choreographed. But that's what I mean about Robbins. Not many people could do that. And I think that after a few tries and shows not being successful, I think people just started to kind of not consider dance. And it's also the period of postmodernism. So you're not going to be really drawing on those Judson choreographers and Trisha Brown are not going to be particularly interested in working on a Broadway show, and they certainly don't give a crap about narrative. I think the whole thing just shifted.

[27:50] Liza Gennaro: And that's when you do get Bennett who's able to come in and push it forward. And I think the great tragedy is Bennett's death because we have no idea what musical theater would be like today if Bennett had lived and the AIDS crisis generally just took out so many of those choreographers who were trained in those systems. But I think it made a space for Bill T. Jones, and I think it made a space for Stephen Hoggett, and I think it made a space for a lot of women choreographers. And Graciela Daniele was certainly the torchbearer for many years. And she connects those two eras in a way.

[28:22] Liza Gennaro: Then Susan Stroman and Kathleen Marshall get their opportunities. Now they weren't really around prior to that, but they're in the right place at the right time to seize those opportunities. Those two women have dominated Broadway for the last 30 years to a great extent. They've done 30 shows in 30 years between them.

[28:39] David Armstrong: Yeah, it's amazing. And both of them very successful and given a lot of power because, you know, as Graciela Daniele, I quote her in the book says, what's the bottom line is who's making the money. And you know, they were able to do that.

[28:51] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, if the show made money, then you get hired again.

[28:54] David Armstrong: Opening up, letting it die.

[29:02] Liza Gennaro: We'll say hello. How you been looking at seeing the same things every day.

[29:15] David Armstrong: Hello. Take us now into this current era, this sort of new wave of non-dance choreographers becoming the choreographers of Broadway.

[29:26] Liza Gennaro: Well, Bill T. Jones, I would say, is a dance choreographer, and he brings, well, the whole show is done out of time. So he's able to do his kind of postmodernist thing without really being narrative and with it being kind of emotion-based, and working with the actors, which he did very, very well. And then you have Stephen Hoggett who comes out of Frantic Assembly and it devised practice and physical theater and has learned about choreography from Frantic Assembly, hiring these really edgy avant-garde choreographers in England. He is an English major and he develops these systems of improvisation, which he works with the actors and they create, he gives them tasks and they come up with movement phrases, and then he kind of curates it and pulls it all together and creates the number that way.

[30:15] Liza Gennaro: So a lot of times his choreography feels kind of like an essence of the idea that he's finding ways to move the body, and everyone may be doing different things, and it enhances and layers the meaning in a very interesting way. Whereas DeMille, Robbins, those people, it was legible dance. This is not that kind of legibility, nor is it trying to be that kind of legibility. So it's kind of opened up a whole new door to how to approach movement in musicals, and it gives an opportunity for everybody to dance. So you don't necessarily need a dancing ensemble because the kind of movement he's doing is very accessible to lots of people with different levels of danceability. And is actually made from those people. The performers themselves are helping to create that movement or at least contributing to it.

[31:12] David Armstrong: Exactly. And the thing I talk about in the book is the kind of lack of the button, you know, the button of a number. What is the button? Jerry Gutierrez always said it was the event of the number. And they're very hard to find and they're very hard to do. And people are not that interested in them anymore. Numbers kind of just stop now. And it's fine, it's different. It's just a different way of approaching it. I enjoy it because I like to see when it gets shaken up, people trying new things because the audience will go with whatever you're giving them until it doesn't work, and then they turn on you. But if you can keep it going, audiences are very open, I think, to new ideas, and they'll start to accept, oh, okay, that's a different thing, and they kind of process it and then the next show and the next show. And these things do change.

[32:02] Liza Gennaro: Sometimes I feel the lack of button is an arrogant sort of idea of, well, I don't want the audience's approval for what I do. If it's not coming from that sort of pretentious attitude, it actually works really well. I don't think people understand how influential Stephen Hoggett has been, especially on Lorin Latarro and Kelly Devine, two women who are really active on Broadway at this point, have been heavily influenced by that kind of thinking, but yet come from a dance background.

[32:30] Liza Gennaro: Yeah, Lorin Latarro came out of Juilliard. I think her work is very, very interesting. And Camille Brown, I think is really fascinating right now. I'm just love to see everything she does. And I'm really interested to see how she develops and where she takes all this.

[32:44] David Armstrong: So as the historian now looking forward, where is Broadway choreography going? How do we make Broadway dance into the future?

[32:52] Liza Gennaro: Well, it's dancing a lot, and I think right now what I like about it is there's lots of different things going on. You just have Sergio Trujillo doing his work, which is very difficult, very dancy dance. He's great with a book, Jerry Mitchell is great with a book, you know, they know how to tell story, they know how to do that thing. And they both come from the Michael Bennett, Jerome Robbins Legacy, basically. You could trace that path very easily from DeMille to them.

[33:21] Liza Gennaro: You really can. Absolutely. And then you have the Stephen Hoggett stuff and the Bill T. Jones stuff, and then you have these choreographers that are really coming from deep modern dance, like the person whose name is escaping me, who did the most recent Oklahoma revival. And that was very modernistic. So where will it go? You know, this is what's fun about it. Who knows? The Broadway theater, for all the people can critique it. I think that it can withstand a lot of manipulation. And it can absorb really any style. You can do a show about anything, and any kind of dance can find its way into the musical theater and be made palatable to a musical theater audience. That's one of the things I really love about it.

And as much as I've studied it, I don't really feel like I can predict it. I think post-pandemic, there's going to be a real burst of creativity and how that all plays itself out on Broadway and the most commercial of commercial theater is going to be really fascinating. I'm excited about it, always excited to see where it's going to go.

[34:27] David Armstrong: Me too. Can't wait. Thank you, Liza Gennaro, for joining me today on Broadway Nation. It's been so great to talk about your new book, Making Broadway Dance.

[34:36] Liza Gennaro: Well, thanks. This was so much fun. I so appreciate your having me on.

[34:40] David Armstrong: Hello!

[34:43] David Armstrong: Thank you. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Powell's Mox for his help with editing this episode, to KVSH 101.9, The Voice of Beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network. If you love this podcast and want to delve even deeper into the world of Broadway musicals, I invite you to become a member of the Broadway Nation Backstage Pass Club. For as little as $7 a month, members will receive exclusive access to never before heard unedited versions of every season two interview and many from season one as well. And this includes additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host, Albert Evans. Last but certainly not least, you will receive special on-air shout outs and acknowledgement of your vital support for this podcast. To join, just click the link included in the show notes for this episode on our website at www.broadway.com. That's BroadwayNation.com. Thank you.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred