Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 336: Sandy Rustin gets Broadwaysted!

We get all the CLUEs with Sandy! Play along as Sandy Rustin (@Sandyrustin_- The Cottage, Clue) joins Bryan and Kevin for rye, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and margaritas. Get tickets for The Cottage on Broadway: TICKETS HERE... Read More

From the show: Broadwaysted!

45 mins
7/11/23

Guests

Featured Shows

About

We get all the CLUEs with Sandy!

Play along as Sandy Rustin (@Sandyrustin_- The Cottage, Clue) joins Bryan and Kevin for rye, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and margaritas.

Get tickets for The Cottage on Broadway: TICKETS HERE

Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Bryan Plovsky: Did you bring wine?

[0:05] Kevin Jager: I got the glasses.

[0:07] Sandy Rustin: You guys, I made a quiz.

[0:08] Bryan Plovsky: I didn't bring anything, but I heard it's a buddy.

[0:20] Bryan Plovsky: Hello, and welcome to the official Broadwaysted podcast where we're drunk on theater.

[0:25] Bryan Plovsky: I'm your host, Bryan Plovsky, and in this small town, I'm lost in your eyes because I'm addicted to love.

[0:31] Bryan Plovsky: Well, the power of love makes me mad about you, but hold on.

[0:35] Bryan Plovsky: I'm the only one that can take my breath away.

[0:38] Bryan Plovsky: I'm never gonna give you up.

[0:40] Bryan Plovsky: So please forgive me because I need to hit me.

[0:43] Bryan Plovsky: I need you to hit me with your best shot.

[0:45] Bryan Plovsky: I think we're alone now.

[0:47] Bryan Plovsky: I'm the only one.

[0:48] Bryan Plovsky: So if all I need is a miracle, you keep me hanging on.

[0:51] Bryan Plovsky: So as I always say, nothing's gonna stop us now.

[0:55] Bryan Plovsky: Joining us today are the usual maniac Mondays who show their true colors, including Kevin "Into the Mystic Pizza" Jager.

[1:03] Bryan Plovsky: Yes, I got the good one.

[1:05] Bryan Plovsky: Uh, Kimberly, our "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" game master and unofficial babysitter for the hour, is actually on maternity leave from Broadwaysted.

[1:15] Bryan Plovsky: Um, so she's actually babysitting.

[1:18] Bryan Plovsky: She's like, I guess I don't, I don't know.

[1:20] Bryan Plovsky: I guess permanently babysitting.

[1:24] Bryan Plovsky: Like, yeah, I know, uh, we, we, uh, yeah, our original intro came true.

[1:29] Bryan Plovsky: And with us is an actress and playwright with the show The Cottage coming to Broadway July 24th.

[1:35] Bryan Plovsky: You also may have seen her adaptations of Dear World, Clue, Mystic Pizza.

[1:39] Bryan Plovsky: Let's give a big Broadwaysted welcome to friend of the show, Sandy Rustin.

[1:47] Sandy Rustin: Hey guys, that was an incredible intro of Mystic Pizza songs.

[1:47] Sandy Rustin: Yes.

[1:52] Sandy Rustin: Anyway, let's get started with what are you drinking?

[1:52] Bryan Plovsky: What are you drinking?

[1:59] Sandy Rustin: Is that the question for me?

[2:00] Bryan Plovsky: Everyone, everybody.

[2:02] Bryan Plovsky: You start, Sandy.

[2:04] Sandy Rustin: Well, I currently don't have a beverage in front of me.

[2:06] Sandy Rustin: But if I did, it would be, let's see.

[2:09] Sandy Rustin: Right now, I think I would like a Hendrix gin and tonic with a slice of lemon.

[2:09] Kevin Jager: Ooh, that's a very kind of drink.

[2:17] Sandy Rustin: She would love it.

[2:19] Kevin Jager: Kimberly's a big gin fan.

[2:21] Sandy Rustin: Yeah.

[2:22] Sandy Rustin: Um, it is summertime, so I'm back to making my picture of margaritas that I leave in my fridge, just in case.

[2:30] Sandy Rustin: Um, this was right now when I needed it.

[2:35] Bryan Plovsky: Beautiful.

[2:36] Bryan Plovsky: Um, I have bullet rye on the rocks.

[2:40] Kevin Jager: Ooh, and a fancy glass.

[2:42] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, wedding registry fancy glass.

[2:46] Sandy Rustin: Last night I was at a place and people were drinking bullet bourbon with peach puree mixed in.

[2:55] Kevin Jager: Ooh.

[2:57] Sandy Rustin: And it was delicious.

[2:58] Kevin Jager: That sounds great.

[2:59] Bryan Plovsky: Was it like a signature cocktail of this place?

[3:01] Sandy Rustin: I think it was, yeah, it had a cool name, but now I can't remember what it was.

[3:06] Kevin Jager: That sounds amazing.

[3:08] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.

[3:10] Bryan Plovsky: Um, cool.

[3:12] Bryan Plovsky: Um, so let's just start. What's your favorite musical?

[3:15] Sandy Rustin: My favorite musical is The Secret Garden.

[3:17] Sandy Rustin: No hesitation.

[3:19] Sandy Rustin: Just full on knew.

[3:22] Sandy Rustin: Oh man.

[3:22] Sandy Rustin: That was, I like remember what I was wearing and where I was when I saw the national tour when it came to Chicago.

[3:28] Sandy Rustin: I just thought it was magic.

[3:30] Sandy Rustin: The Secret Garden was my favorite book as a girl.

[3:32] Sandy Rustin: My dad read it aloud to me when I was, I think I was seven years old when he read it out loud to me, and I just love, love, loved it.

[3:39] Sandy Rustin: And then that the fact that they turned it into a musical was like astounding to me.

[3:42] Sandy Rustin: I thought it was so beautiful.

[3:43] Kevin Jager: Wow, I, it's been a while since somebody has not stuttered or hesitated before saying their favorite musical.

[3:49] Kevin Jager: That was so small, but that was awesome.

[3:52] Kevin Jager: You just really committed.

[3:54] Kevin Jager: You didn't even give, you didn't even give like the pageant pause where you're like, oh, but there's so many good ones to choose from.

[4:02] Sandy Rustin: I mean, there are so many good ones, but you asked my favorite, and that's like, that Secret Garden is like deep in my heart.

[4:07] Kevin Jager: Yeah.

[4:08] Kevin Jager: So proud of you of that.

[4:09] Kevin Jager: So here's, here's a question that we kind of ask people.

[4:12] Kevin Jager: We don't kind of, we do ask people.

[4:14] Kevin Jager: Um, do you think that it's possible that anything would ever supersede your favorite at this point in life?

[4:24] Sandy Rustin: Like because you have nostalgia, a lot associated with that.

[4:28] Sandy Rustin: Is there any way that something could like really overtake that?

[4:32] Sandy Rustin: Or you wouldn't even consider that you, it would create kind of a new memory and be separate from that.

[4:38] Sandy Rustin: That's a great question.

[4:39] Sandy Rustin: And I love that question because I have seen a million musicals since I saw The Secret Garden that I could say were my favorite musical.

[4:47] Sandy Rustin: Like I love musicals, so I could list a hundred musicals that I love, love, love.

[4:52] Sandy Rustin: But there was something about that first time of seeing The Secret Garden that just made it an unbelievable experience that I just loved.

[4:59] Sandy Rustin: So yeah, I don't know.

[5:01] Sandy Rustin: I think The Secret Garden is just like my gonna be my lifelong fave.

[5:05] Sandy Rustin: And there'll be like a million other ones that'll come my way that I'll love for different reasons.

[5:09] Sandy Rustin: But God, I loved that show.

[5:12] Kevin Jager: Yeah.

[5:13] Kevin Jager: I will say my mom, uh, we saw it on tour as well when I was younger.

[5:17] Kevin Jager: And my mom still to this day will talk about, she's like, I will never forget that scene where they passed like the red scarf to give like the call, like she was like, that was such a beautiful way to explain what was happening, but also make it like a loose to a child who's now our, she like, she loved that moment too.

[5:37] Kevin Jager: Like it really is such a great show.

[5:39] Sandy Rustin: I will remember being so struck.

[5:41] Sandy Rustin: Part of the set design when I, I don't know if they did this in the Broadway production, they probably did, but they had um, the outline shape of the mansion, and every time the characters moved to a different room or a different location, the, the it lit up in different places and it was like subtle.

[5:57] Sandy Rustin: It was like just above the action of the stage.

[6:00] Sandy Rustin: It wasn't overbearing.

[6:01] Sandy Rustin: I just thought it was so cool.

[6:05] Sandy Rustin: I love when those kind of things come together and you're just like an amazing performance and a great script, but like those little nuances behind it that just make it so powerful.

[6:13] Kevin Jager: Yeah, and then you think to yourself, like, is that stupid or is that brilliant?

[6:18] Kevin Jager: Because I like, it seems so simple that, but like it's so effective.

[6:23] Kevin Jager: Like I, how, where do I fall?

[6:25] Kevin Jager: Like, where does that fall in my brain?

[6:27] Kevin Jager: I've seen that, uh, like little, little details that you, that like someone else might miss, but you would catch.

[6:33] Kevin Jager: You're like, is this brilliance?

[6:34] Sandy Rustin: I think it is.

[6:35] Sandy Rustin: Oh, I thought it was all brilliant.

[6:37] Sandy Rustin: Yeah.

[6:38] Sandy Rustin: I was like on board with that musical.

[6:42] Kevin Jager: Totally.

[6:43] Kevin Jager: Um, well, let's talk about you.

[6:45] Kevin Jager: Um, I'm very curious because you started out as an actress and kind of more transitioned to the writing.

[6:52] Kevin Jager: Um, I guess talk about that transition, but also like are you, do you do both now?

[6:57] Sandy Rustin: Is it mostly just the writing?

[6:58] Sandy Rustin: I'd love to hear your journey because it's fascinating.

[7:01] Sandy Rustin: Sure.

[7:02] Sandy Rustin: Thanks.

[7:02] Sandy Rustin: So I grew up in Chicago and I always had a dual focus in performance and writing.

[7:08] Sandy Rustin: Like in my high school, they had an opportunity, they did a big student-written musical every year, and by the time I was a senior, I was the head writer of that musical, but I was also in it.

[7:17] Sandy Rustin: Um, same thing.

[7:18] Sandy Rustin: I went to Northwestern in Chicago and I had a dual focus there in writing and performance.

[7:23] Sandy Rustin: There's a big student-written musical there called the Wam U Show.

[7:26] Sandy Rustin: And I would be in it and also helped to write it.

[7:28] Sandy Rustin: And I was part of sketch comedy shows and improv comedy shows.

[7:31] Sandy Rustin: And that was just sort of my world growing up all the way through college.

[7:36] Sandy Rustin: And when I moved to New York, I got my first job was the week I moved, I got cast the week I moved to New York as Sandy in the National Tour of Grease.

[7:44] Sandy Rustin: Um, so that was my first job.

[7:46] Sandy Rustin: So I left New York, I did this tour for a year.

[7:48] Sandy Rustin: I moved back to New York and I was working as an actor in New York for a while.

[7:52] Sandy Rustin: And it wasn't really till I became a parent.

[7:54] Sandy Rustin: I was, I think I was 29 years old when I had my first son.

[7:59] Sandy Rustin: Um, and I was like shocked to discover that I loved something more than theater when I had this baby.

[8:06] Sandy Rustin: Like, oh no, what do I do?

[8:07] Sandy Rustin: So I took some time off.

[8:08] Sandy Rustin: I had been understudying a play, I was understudying Molly Ringwald in a play that James Lapine was directing.

[8:14] Sandy Rustin: It was a Daniel Goldfarb play called Modern Orthodox.

[8:18] Sandy Rustin: And I was supposed to go back into the show.

[8:19] Sandy Rustin: I was gonna take a little maternity leave, kind of like your friend, um, and then go back.

[8:24] Sandy Rustin: And I didn't want to after I had the baby.

[8:27] Sandy Rustin: So I stayed home for a bit, and then um, I got started to get creatively itchy when he was like six or seven months old.

[8:34] Sandy Rustin: So I went to Upright Citizens Brigade for fun, just to take improv and comedy classes again and sketch writing, and I was doing all that stuff for no reason other than to sort of scratch my own creative itch, I guess.

[8:47] Sandy Rustin: And while I was there in a sketch writing class, I started writing sketches that evolved into my first professional show, which was Rated P for Parenthood.

[8:56] Sandy Rustin: Um, and it was, uh, Rated P is a show that it's a sketch comedy musical that goes from conception to college drop off.

[9:02] Sandy Rustin: But when I first started writing it, I was just writing a bunch of sketches about being a young mom.

[9:06] Sandy Rustin: And Zach Woods, who's now famous, but at the time was just my teacher at UCB, um, was super encouraging and was like, you should, you know, go for it.

[9:16] Sandy Rustin: Um, and so that was really, it was really when my oldest son Isaac was a baby that I started to write and take myself seriously as a writer and consider that as a dual focus.

[9:29] Sandy Rustin: And now that baby is 17 and going to college in a couple months.

[9:33] Sandy Rustin: So I guess it took a little while.

[9:35] Sandy Rustin: And along the way, I, you know, I still have um, I still have a big voiceover career.

[9:40] Sandy Rustin: You know, I do a bunch of voiceover stuff.

[9:42] Sandy Rustin: And every once in a while I'll go back and do eight shows a week when the timing's right.

[9:46] Sandy Rustin: Um, and you know, maybe in a few years, once I'm totally an empty nester, I'll go back and perform again.

[9:52] Sandy Rustin: But for now, I'm really loving writing.

[9:54] Sandy Rustin: It's been a really good way to um, have the parenting schedule that I wanted and also have a life in the theater.

[10:02] Kevin Jager: How did you find your way into book writing for musicals?

[10:05] Sandy Rustin: That seems so like niche and, and I know your love for musicals, like how did you find yourself there?

[10:11] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, I mean, that was sort of where I began.

[10:14] Sandy Rustin: Like I was writing the sketches for the musical in high school, the sketches for the musical in college.

[10:20] Sandy Rustin: Then my first show that I wrote were sketches for a musical that I was writing with friends from friends that I had known in New York.

[10:27] Sandy Rustin: Um, so it just was sort of how I got my feet wet was writing the book to musicals and actually evolved from there to write plays without music.

[10:39] Kevin Jager: Well, I mean, and we have to say that so, so your adaptation of Clue is one of the top produced plays of the 2022-2023 season, which is like crazy and super cool.

[10:54] Sandy Rustin: No, like that's amazing.

[10:57] Sandy Rustin: Like, thanks.

[10:59] Sandy Rustin: It is, I don't even know the question to ask.

[11:02] Kevin Jager: Like, I know.

[11:03] Kevin Jager: I don't even know what to say about it.

[11:05] Sandy Rustin: I think Clue was sort of a perfect storm of being um, a title that's so recognizable.

[11:12] Sandy Rustin: It's a board game, it's a film that people love.

[11:15] Sandy Rustin: People know those characters.

[11:16] Sandy Rustin: It was so, the title itself is instantly recognizable.

[11:20] Sandy Rustin: The show when the show first sort of took off, it was right after the pandemic when everyone was just hungry for a stupid laugh. And that is what Clue provides. You know, it's like murder mystery comedy at its most fun, at its most heightened. Um we had a great time putting it together and putting it on. So I think it was just sort of like the confluence of a whole bunch of different things that made it the right moment in our time to put that on the stage.

[11:47] Bryan Plovsky: That's super cool. What a what a what a cool title to have. Like, like what a weird, awesome notch to have on your belt. Like, I mean, that's theater. Like your show is being like everyone is smiling because they're seeing your show. Like, what an amazing accomplishment and feeling that must be.

[12:05] Sandy Rustin: That's so nice of you to say. It has been, um, I'll tell you my most favorite part about my involvement with Clue has been over this last year. Um, it's being produced in high schools all over the world. And I have started to do Zoom sessions with the kids. Like I, you know, I love kids, and so it's been amazing. I've seen all female casts, all male casts, all you know, all sorts of interesting ways that high schools have put on this show. People put on the show with like three people and 20 people, and you know, they just make it their own. Um, all sorts of cool set designs. It's been awesome. I've loved it.

[12:41] Kevin Jager: That's very, very cool. Um, do you know where else there are lots of set designs?

[12:47] Sandy Rustin: Where?

[12:49] Kevin Jager: Dude, I'm so sorry, everyone. It's Kevin's Corner.

[13:00] Kevin Jager: Great transition, as always. Welcome to Kevin's Corner, which is my corner of the show, where I get to do whatever I want, which is why it's the best corner of the show. Um, and so today I thought since you were a mother, uh, how many children do you have?

[13:16] Sandy Rustin: I have two boys, 14 and 17.

[13:18] Kevin Jager: Ah, okay. So you have boys, so I think this will still work. Okay. So I do not personally have children, but um, I worked with kids for a lot growing up, and now my sisters both have children. Um, but mostly because of my niece and uh my two nephews, I have been exposed to a ton of children's television and like children's made for like TV movies or made for streaming movies and all these things like that. So I have some questions for you about your experience as an adult watching children programs.

[13:56] Sandy Rustin: Okay, I'll do my best. It's been a while because now they mostly just watch the Yankees.

[14:00] Kevin Jager: Oh, right, because they're adults, but like this is even better because you were watching stuff in a different time. This is great. Okay. Okay, okay. So, question number one is can you remember any music or like songs in some of their shows that like were way better than they should have been for this like 45 minute direct to video kind of situation?

[14:25] Sandy Rustin: Oh god, there was this one song. I can't believe I can't remember it right now. Um it was a spelling song. I mean I'll think I'll try to think of it before the end of the show. Um God, there were so many, all those songs were good. I mean, they're really good composers that work on those shows, right?

[14:44] Kevin Jager: It's insane because like right now, like my niece was like told me about this show that's now on um, I think it's on Netflix. Okay, and it's uh Ridley Jones is the name of the show, and it's like a cartoon show of this little girl. And Brian, correct me if I'm wrong, but the music is written by the composers of The Prom. Like it's like so it's like Broadway Tony nominated, Tony winning composers are like writing these songs for these kids' shows, and then it's uh the girl who just won the Tony for um uh uh the a lot of sports set musical.

[15:23] Sandy Rustin: Jagged Little Pill.

[15:24] Kevin Jager: Yes, the girl who won the Tony for that is like she sings the theme song. Yeah. As soon as like my I sit down with my niece to watch this show, and the scene the the song starts, and I was like, whoa, wait a minute. Why is this girl mixed belting a C right at the beginning of this song in my face? Like they're love it. They're good.

[15:42] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, they're really good. Yeah, it's it's it's really insane. And then also, like my nephew is super into um like Sonic the Hedgehog, and like some of these, some of like the stuff, it's just really really funny. My um when my younger son was little, he was obsessed with Handy Manny, like obsessed. I don't even know if Handy Manny is still on, but um day something broke in our house, and we had like a fix it man came, and so a man showed up at the door with like a tool belt on and he had a hat on, like and Charlie just stood in the doorway like starstruck, like the mo like it was a famous, and he was like, Mommy, Handy Manny is here, and he just followed the guy around as the guy fixed the stuff. It was amazing.

[16:29] Kevin Jager: Oh my god, that is incredible. Um, okay, another thing. Uh, my mom often says things to me where she's like, she says something, and five seconds later, she's like, I literally never thought that I would ever say that sentence in my life. But here we are as a mother saying, like, like as I watched a woman on the subway the other day look at her kid and say, don't lick the pole. And she just like and I like caught her eyes. She was just like, so like what are some of the things that are like the most ridiculous things that you never thought you'd have to say to another human, but you find out as a mother, you have to.

[17:05] Sandy Rustin: Oh my god, that's that's a great question. God, I don't know, but I can tell you what I say to them every single morning when they leave my house. So every morning, since they've since they've gone to school, I think. I mean, for many years, I tell them to be a mensch on their way out. That's all I say. I say, be a mensch on their way out the door. And I always feel like that is something that I never thought I would scream, literally, like scream out the door as they're on their way. But it's just like a reminder to like do good and be kind in the world every day.

[17:35] Kevin Jager: I love it. And it's on the top of your website, right?

[17:38] Sandy Rustin: I am. I do. I say I'm an actress, a writer, and I'm raising menches. I mean that's what I'm talking about. Those are my three jobs.

[17:47] Kevin Jager: Oh my god, that's incredible. Um, what is the most obscure talent that your child or one of your children like end up showing that you would never would have expected?

[17:58] Sandy Rustin: My niece is like quadruple jointed. So my sister's going to all these like gymnastics events, and she's like, I didn't do gymnastics. None of us did gymnastics. Like, where did this come from? Yeah. Um, so my older son, he has an unbelievable ability to do sound effects, vocal sound effects. It's not singing, it's like um like when he was little, he could do like he could imitate just any sort of any sound. Hear, hear a pigeon, do a pigeon, do a rocket ship, do a motorcycle, whatever. And it would always take us by surprise because it was so so wildly accurate. He doesn't do it so much anymore. I should remind him of that.

[18:38] Kevin Jager: Now it's you have to you'll have to make him watch the police academy movies.

[18:42] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, exactly. We used to joke that he was gonna be like that guy.

[18:48] Kevin Jager: That's amazing. That guy had a career. I mean, he owns a career.

[18:51] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, um, and then my last question is uh a gift to Kimberly that she'll hear since she's not with us today. But as a mother, um, what would be your big piece of advice to another creative mother in the world who's about to start navigating the creative realm while also being a mom?

[19:10] Sandy Rustin: Yeah. Um, I think the biggest piece of advice that I would share in that department is that you can have it all, but you cannot have it all at the same time. I think that's a myth and a misnomer that women are told that you can have it all. Um, I think it's actually a harmful thing to tell to young moms because uh being a parent full-time is a full-time task. And it is really hard to divide your attention and divide your attention well. So I, you know, I absolutely I think that's no mistake that my first Broadway show is opening the same week that my oldest son turns 18. Because I feel like, yeah, as long as it took to raise a whole man, that's how long it took to simultaneously try to pursue this one particular dream.

And I think um for young women who are starting out and building their families, like go for it, do it all, but give yourself time and space. It's never too late, you know. Take your time with your kids, take your time with your career, get help, you know. That those are the main things. Couldn't have done it on my own for sure.

[20:18] Kevin Jager: I love that. And with that will end a nice and sweet version of Kevin's Corner.

[20:23] Bryan Plovsky: I liked Kevin's Corner.

[20:25] Kevin Jager: You did very well.

[20:26] Bryan Plovsky: Thank you, Kevin.

[20:28] Kevin Jager: It was all those classes at Upright Citizens Brigade.

[20:30] Bryan Plovsky: You were ready for it to go through it, chat.

[20:33] Sandy Rustin: Okay. It's amazing. Um, oh, since you talked about that, can we really quick talk about like what was were you ever in a scenario where it was just like going so well, like the scene that like you just like like what was like your high point of that? Like, because I know like you know what is like a um when you're doing improv comedy, there's like like there's like a night where like everybody's on, and you just like super nail it. Do you have that like one like definitely?

[21:06] Sandy Rustin: Well, so um, I've done a bunch of improv since I've lived in New York, but the two main improv shows that I love like really just loved and relished every time I got to get go on stage. One was a show called Gravid Water, which was a monthly show at Upright Citizens Brigade that I was in the last Monday of every month, almost almost every month for like 10 years until they closed with the pandemic. And in that show, the actors would memorize um scripted lines in the order that they appeared in a scene, and then the improvisers didn't know what the scene was, and they could say anything, but you could only stick to the script and you'd have to make it make sense with whatever the and they would have celebrity guest improvisers, and um I have a million stories from those shows, like so many highlight moments.

But I think perhaps my favorite was there was a night when I was partnered with Chevy Chase on stage, and we did this scene together, and it was it was it was just like magical, where it seemed like we were finishing each other's sentences and it was very, very exciting. So that was super fun.

[22:06] Sandy Rustin: And then the other show, um, when Isaac, my older son, when he was a baby, I was in uh this show called Don't Quit Your Night Job, which we used to do in New York, which was like Saturday Night Live for the Broadway community. So it was after show time. We did it at 11 o'clock at night. Um, we did it in a bunch of different places, but one of the places was Ha Comedy Club. Um and it was so fun. We, you know, all whoever was starring in whatever Broadway show at the time would come in and be our guest. We would play games with them.

[22:35] Sandy Rustin: Um, and it was just it that was just a great show. It was such a tight knit community, and it was so much fun to be a part of that at that time. So yeah, I guess those were my two highlight improv experiences in New York City.

[22:49] Kevin Jager: So awesome.

[22:51] Bryan Plovsky: Cool.

[22:51] Kevin Jager: And you're about to have you're about to have another one.

[22:54] Sandy Rustin: Yeah.

[22:55] Kevin Jager: Improv, but a highlight New York City moment. Let's talk about that.

[22:59] Sandy Rustin: Yeah.

[22:59] Kevin Jager: Yeah.

[23:00] Sandy Rustin: So The Cottage is opening on Broadway on July 24th. Um, I don't know, like how are you feeling? Tell us a little bit about the show. I know it's being directed by uh Livingston, New Jersey native uh um Jason Alexander. Um and uh I don't know tell us a little bit about about the show, your feelings I want to hear it all.

[23:22] Sandy Rustin: Okay. Um, well my feeling is I'm so excited and so happy. It's just so much fun to have to have a dream like this come true at this age is really thrilling. So I it just feels like all good and all joy. The show I actually wrote the show about 10 years ago. I'm a huge Noel Coward fan and um I had been in a Noel Coward play in college I played Sorrel Bliss in Hay Fever and I loved it. It was such a fun experience. And so when I set out to write a play after Rated P had closed I really wanted to write a play without music and I thought well what if I tried to write a show that's sort of in the style of Noel Coward but one in which it's had a more feminist vent where the women rule the roost what would happen if I tried to do that and what would a Noel Coward genre look like through my sort of contemporary feminist lens what kind of show is that and um yeah that and so I so I wrote the first draft of The Cottage and then it's been kicking around for a long time it's a six person play uh takes place in 1923 on the British countryside um and it is like a comedy of manners I would say it's a bedroom comedy of manners.

So you know, lots of lots of couples, lots of mixing and matching. But at its core, the show is about marriage and fate and loyalty and love and feminism, I would say. Um, and though that's those are the themes that are explored in the play. So even though it does feel like a light, fun, uh hopefully laugh out loud evening for our audiences. There's also um, I think you also walk away um with some things to think about too. So that makes me happy too. But it's been amazing. And Jason Alexander's been an incredible collaborator. And um we're we have our first rehearsal a week from today.

[25:11] Kevin Jager: That's exciting.

[25:12] Sandy Rustin: Yeah.

[25:13] Bryan Plovsky: And uh, friend of the show, Lily Cooper is in it, yes.

[25:18] Sandy Rustin: Yes, yes, she is. She's amazing. She's just, I cannot wait for people to see her in this show.

[25:24] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, she's so great.

[25:26] Sandy Rustin: Yeah. And the the like uh the like home wholesome cartoon kind of like artwork that I've seen and some of the advertisement, it's so cool.

[25:37] Sandy Rustin: Oh, thanks. I can't take any credit for any of the advertisements. I'm glad that you like it. That makes me happy.

[25:43] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, it looks great. It really is very because I get a lot of like the mailers and stuff, and it looks great.

[25:48] Sandy Rustin: Oh, good. Yeah, I'm excited about it all. It's so cool. And classic musical theater diva.

[25:56] Kevin Jager: Oh my gosh, she's gonna be amazing.

[25:58] Sandy Rustin: She's playing Sylvia.

[26:00] Sandy Rustin: She's yeah, it's exciting. So it's it's Laura Bell Bundy, and she's opposite Eric McCormack, uh, who plays Bo. Alex Moffitt plays Clark. Um, Nihal Joshi plays Richard, and Dana Steingold plays Deirdre. And I think that's it. I think I've told you everybody.

[26:24] Kevin Jager: That's amazing.

[26:25] Bryan Plovsky: So, as a writer, like you've gotten to know these characters very well. They're all a part of you. Some of them are not a part of you. Like, I guess, I guess, like, what's it like on this level being able to like watch other people embody these characters who have been with you for such a long time?

[26:42] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, it's the best. I mean, I feel like because I grew up as a performer and especially in improv comedy, it to me, theater is such a collaborative sport. It it that when I'm writing, it feels really lonely. Like my least favorite part of theater making is when I'm solo in a room with my ideas by myself. And my most favorite part is when I get into the room, and it's like it's as if I've put the first layer of paint down, and that's the script. And then all these other amazing painters come in and paint on top of it and make it into an incredible mural. That's how it feels to me. Um, so I this part when walking into the rehearsal rooms for me is the most exciting stage. Um, of course, then sharing it with an audience is like the best of the best.

But yeah, I mean, it's amazing to watch people step into worlds and roles that you've crafted and make it their own and bring to it things you couldn't have imagined on your own. You know, it's like extra imaginations, the best.

[27:46] Kevin Jager: Yeah.

[27:46] Bryan Plovsky: And as the writer, what's your role in the rehearsal room?

[27:51] Sandy Rustin: So that's a great question. I think it's different for every writer, and I think for me, it's been different on every project. Um, for The Cottage, um, Jason and I have been really collaborative from the beginning um together on this. The way this project came to Jason was he was feeling ready to make his Broadway debut as a director, and we had the same agency, and he went to the agency and said, What you got? Send me some comedies that are ready for Broadway. And they did. They sent him a bunch of plays and he gravitated towards this one.

[28:18] Kevin Jager: And cool.

[28:19] Sandy Rustin: We met over Zoom or maybe we had a phone call first, and then I flew out to LA and we met in person and um we just clicked. And so since then we have been really talking through every moment and and all the different um technical components and casting and all those things has felt like a true generous collaboration between the two of us, which has been such a gift. So I think on The Cottage, I think we'll be, you know, in the room together. And of course he's directing the show, but I I think if I have ideas, he's open to hearing them and vice versa. Um, and so that feels like a really exciting, warm environment to be stepping into for my first Broadway experience, which is awesome.

[29:02] Kevin Jager: That's really cool.

[29:03] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, I think so too.

[29:05] Bryan Plovsky: So um, July 24th, go and see it. We will put a link in the description uh so you can get your tickets uh for The Cottage. Uh so check it out. We're very excited for you and very happy for you. Congrats on all this amazing success. It's so so cool.

[29:21] Sandy Rustin: Thanks, Bryan. I'm excited.

[29:22] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah. Um, should we play a game?

[29:24] Sandy Rustin: Yeah games.

[29:26] Bryan Plovsky: Let's play a game.

[29:27] Kevin Jager: Okay. Today Kevin is our game master.

[29:30] Sandy Rustin: I am.

[29:31] Bryan Plovsky: Gimberly's usually our game master and she comes up with some really awesome games. So today we're gonna see what I can do here. So um you had uh we talked earlier about how you wrote the play Clue, um, which is extremely popular this season. So I thought, why don't we take the six characters of Clue? Um, we're getting rid of Mr. Body and the butler and all those. So we're just focusing on like the six like suspect characters of Clue. And we're gonna kind of uh go in a circle and try to figure out who, like musical theater character, not musical theater actor, but like character we think is most like the clue character.

[30:12] Sandy Rustin: So this is fun.

[30:13] Bryan Plovsky: Okay. That makes sense.

[30:15] Kevin Jager: Yeah.

[30:15] Sandy Rustin: So uh Sandy, we'll start with you.

[30:18] Sandy Rustin: Okay. You can pick any of the six to start with, and we're gonna kind of like try to figure out who we think what musical theater character each of us thinks matches that person the most.

[30:28] Sandy Rustin: Okay, let's start with Mr. Green.

[30:30] Kevin Jager: Okay.

[30:31] Sandy Rustin: Mr. Green, businessman. Uh are we going with like the okay? So you can take it however you want. Let's think it. You get like five seconds to think, and then we're gonna say who we think musical theater world would be a great Mr. Green.

[30:45] Kevin Jager: Okay.

[30:46] Sandy Rustin: And we're talking characters from shows.

[30:49] Kevin Jager: Correct.

[30:50] Sandy Rustin: Characters from shows. Like that character would play Mr. Green in the stage production of Clue. Do you need me to say what the characters like in Clue?

[30:59] Kevin Jager: Yes, that'd be great.

[31:00] Sandy Rustin: For and so that people can listen and play along. Okay, so Mr. Green is oh god, I don't want to give away the play though. Uh Mr. Green presents himself as a um potentially homosexual republican who is being bribed for so that it because it's night, it's in the 1950s when he he's he uh they're they're claiming that he said that he was gonna vote Republican, but he didn't in the last election.

[31:35] Kevin Jager: So he's being bribed.

[31:37] Sandy Rustin: That's so good.

[31:39] Kevin Jager: Alright.

[31:39] Sandy Rustin: Okay, what musical theater character do you think that fits to a T.

[31:45] Sandy Rustin: Should I answer or somebody else answers first?

[31:47] Kevin Jager: Danny, you go first.

[31:48] Sandy Rustin: So we'll and then we'll go first. I think that um Seymour from The Little Shop of Horrors is my perfect Mr. Green.

[31:55] Kevin Jager: That's a really good one.

[31:58] Kevin Jager: Interesting.

[32:00] Kevin Jager: Um I would say that my perfect Mr. Green is uh Caldwell B Cladwell from uh You're in Town.

[32:16] Sandy Rustin: Okay.

[32:19] Kevin Jager: Um interesting. Um I think that mine is uh um uh maybe JB Bigley, the boss from How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.

[32:35] Sandy Rustin: I like that answer.

[32:37] Kevin Jager: Okay, okay. I like the my my reasoning is like he seems like this big tough guy, the whole thing, very, very like um very like stolid and like feared, everyone feared of him, and then at the end he's like so excited to get involved in the big like uh Brotherhood of Man song. Um so that that's kind of where I was going with that.

[32:59] Sandy Rustin: Oh, you're playing on the twist. I see how you did there, yeah, yeah.

[33:02] Bryan Plovsky: Okay, so Brian, you pick a character now, and we'll all try to figure out who we think matches that.

[33:07] Bryan Plovsky: Uh Mrs. Peacock.

[33:10] Sandy Rustin: Okay, so in the play, Mrs. Peacock is the wife of an important US senator, and she too is being blackmailed.

[33:21] Sandy Rustin: Oh, this this is easy. The answer to this one is uh Ulelei McKechnie Shin from The Music Man.

[33:31] Kevin Jager: That's good.

[33:33] Sandy Rustin: For sure.

[33:34] Kevin Jager: Uh well, this is not this is like a cop out answer, but I would say any character that Angela Lansbury has ever played.

[33:50] Sandy Rustin: I agree. She's got some name in her for sure.

[33:57] Kevin Jager: Oh god, she went so good. Um, that's a good one. Um, I'm picturing like a mayor's wife from a show.

[34:17] Sandy Rustin: Anne Horata and Shmigadoon.

[34:21] Kevin Jager: You know what? That's not what I was thinking.

[34:24] Sandy Rustin: That's exactly who I want.

[34:26] Kevin Jager: Yeah, there you go. She was so good in that show. So good.

[34:30] Bryan Plovsky: Oh god, what she got. That's excellent. That's an excellent answer.

[34:33] Kevin Jager: Oh, so good. So good.

[34:35] Bryan Plovsky: Okay, so I'm gonna say Miss Scarlet, who is always my favorite. Okay, Miss Scarlet owns her own brothel, and she too is being blackmailed.

[34:48] Kevin Jager: Um, so Sandy, you go first on this one.

[34:53] Sandy Rustin: Uh, I went first on the last one, so I think Bryan has to go first.

[34:57] Bryan Plovsky: Okay, cool. Uh, I will say Madame Morable.

[35:07] Kevin Jager: Okay, okay, Sandy.

[35:09] Sandy Rustin: I think maybe Roxy Hart.

[35:12] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, that's a great answer. Roxy's a really good choice.

[35:16] Kevin Jager: I was gonna go with Nancy from Oliver.

[35:19] Sandy Rustin: Okay. That's a good one too. She's a little grugher than Miss Scarlet is, but yeah.

[35:25] Bryan Plovsky: But I see where you're going with that. Yeah, that's a good one.

[35:29] Kevin Jager: Alright, we have a couple left. Who's next?

[35:34] Bryan Plovsky: Uh, Professor Plum.

[35:35] Kevin Jager: Professor Plum. Tell us about him.

[35:38] Sandy Rustin: Professor Plum is being blackmailed for having a relationship with the daughter of his boss, basically, who may or may not be underage, depending on if you're doing the real version or the high school version of the play.

[35:57] Bryan Plovsky: Ah, yeah. Fair, fair, fair, fair.

[36:02] Kevin Jager: Okay, Professor Plum as a character is maybe Willy Wonka.

[36:13] Sandy Rustin: Oh, alright. Yeah, no, I see that 100%. There's like a, yeah, like something's a little off about that guy.

[36:25] Bryan Plovsky: Sure. Potentially.

[36:28] Sandy Rustin: No, no, I think. Oh, I have another, a better answer. The man in the yellow from Tuck Everlasting.

[36:36] Kevin Jager: Oh, that's a good one. Yeah, he's maybe more Professor Plum.

[36:41] Bryan Plovsky: That's a good one. I was gonna say younger brother from Ragtime.

[36:48] Sandy Rustin: Oh gosh. Uh, cousin Kevin. Is that what his name is?

[36:52] Kevin Jager: No, I'm saying cousin Kevin from Tommy.

[36:56] Sandy Rustin: Oh, oh.

[36:59] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, you took the, that was a dark answer.

[37:01] Sandy Rustin: Yeah. I was gonna say Ali Hakeem first. I don't know why. And then I went darker with that one.

[37:09] Kevin Jager: You're like Rogers and Hammerstein, fun moment.

[37:12] Sandy Rustin: Nah.

[37:17] Bryan Plovsky: Great. Uh, so who's, wait, we did everybody but there's Mrs. White and Colonel Mustard.

[37:19] Kevin Jager: Mrs. White and Colonel Mustard. Alright, let's start ladies first.

[37:29] Sandy Rustin: Okay, Mrs. White. So she, um, she's had five husbands, all of whom have turned up dead.

[37:37] Bryan Plovsky: She's a socialite.

[37:39] Sandy Rustin: Yes.

[37:40] Bryan Plovsky: Okay. So is this Joanne from Company?

[37:47] Sandy Rustin: Hmm. Yeah, maybe.

[37:54] Kevin Jager: Um, husband socialite. Um, you know the Chita Rivera character from Kiss of the Spider Woman?

[38:02] Sandy Rustin: Yeah.

[38:02] Bryan Plovsky: The Spider Woman?

[38:13] Sandy Rustin: Oh yeah, thank you. Oh, you mean the Spider Woman? No, she has the name. Isn't it Aurelia or something?

[38:19] Kevin Jager: What's Aurelia?

[38:19] Sandy Rustin: Aurelia, yeah.

[38:21] Bryan Plovsky: Aurelia. Yeah. I pick Aurelia.

[38:23] Sandy Rustin: I was just thinking. I mean, you could go, I guess Velma Kelly for that one.

[38:28] Kevin Jager: Yeah, Velma Kelly. She really wasn't so slight who killed her husband.

[38:32] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Literal type guy.

[38:35] Sandy Rustin: That was Bryan.

[38:36] Kevin Jager: Yeah, a little too much, Bryan.

[38:40] Bryan Plovsky: Okay, no. Colonel Mustard's love.

[38:42] Sandy Rustin: Colonel Mustard, he is a military man, a lifelong military man who is being blackmailed. I don't want to give anything away, so let's just leave it at he's a lifelong military man who's a bit of a buffoon.

[38:58] Kevin Jager: Oh, I have two answers for this one.

[39:01] Sandy Rustin: Okay, good.

[39:02] Kevin Jager: My first answer is General Genghis Khan Schmitz from Seussical.

[39:10] Sandy Rustin: Okay.

[39:12] Kevin Jager: Uh, and my second answer is the colonel or whatever it is from Mary Poppins.

[39:20] Sandy Rustin: That was gonna be my answer.

[39:23] Kevin Jager: The guy who's like the weather, like the wind's coming from the east.

[39:27] Sandy Rustin: That guy's, yeah, uh huh. That guy, totally.

[39:30] Bryan Plovsky: So that's a good one.

[39:32] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, I'm just gonna agree with that. That was a good one. I was like trying to think of a couple more, and I was like, no, no, we're just gonna go with that guy. That guy wins.

[39:43] Kevin Jager: That's a good game, you guys. I like that. That's been Clue. Broadway Clue.

[39:50] Bryan Plovsky: Um, cool. Well, that brings us to the end of our episode. Um, thank you so much for joining us. Um, I guess I know you're working on some stuff now. Before we head out, what's next?

[40:01] Sandy Rustin: Uh, outside of obviously the big Broadway show.

[40:04] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, sure. Um, so well, Clue is gonna launch a national tour in early next year, and as is Mystic Pizza. Um, and then I have a new play that's called The Suffragette's Murder. Um, and that is gonna have its world premiere next season as well. So that's exciting too.

[40:21] Kevin Jager: So yeah, and then I'm working on a bunch of new shows as well, which is always that this is a silly question, but I really mean is the title the suffragettes as like a group commit murder, or is like the suffragettes like a suffragette was murdered?

[40:37] Sandy Rustin: Apostrophe S.

[40:39] Kevin Jager: Thank you.

[40:43] Sandy Rustin: You can take that either way. You could, you totally could. Yeah, I guess with that one, you have to see the title to really understand.

[40:50] Bryan Plovsky: And that has been one grammar corner.

[40:53] Sandy Rustin: Yeah, I think grammar corner with, I was like, that could be the suffragettes murder.

[40:59] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, that's a very reasonable question. Maybe I need to take the title.

[41:06] Sandy Rustin: Because that's a totally different play.

[41:08] Bryan Plovsky: It really is.

[41:11] Sandy Rustin: That's amazing. Is this, what is, uh sorry? That I must say, is that one a drama?

[41:16] Sandy Rustin: It's not, it's a comedy. It is, um, yeah. I was commissioned by Florida Studio Theater during the pandemic. Um, they were celebrating the 100th anniversary of um the start of the women's suffrage women's right to vote. Um, and they said, Will you write a play about suffragettes or the suffragist movement? And I said, sure, can it be a comedy? And they said, Yeah. So it also, it is, I would say it is more dramatic than some of my other work. Uh, it does, it dives into some dark, deeper topics, but at its core, it is a comedy.

[41:53] Kevin Jager: Cool. I love that. Well, that's all very exciting. We're super excited to see The Cottage. Um, you can again, you can get tickets. We put the link in the description below. Um, but thank you so much for joining us. We're really so happy that we got to spend some time with you. Your career is awesome. What you've done and carved out for yourself and the joy that you bring so many other people through your work is like truly exceptional. So thank you for taking the time to brighten our evenings.

[42:22] Sandy Rustin: Thank you. That's so nice of you. I was so happy to join you. You guys are awesome. This was super fun.

[42:26] Bryan Plovsky: Thanks for watching.

[42:27] Sandy Rustin: Thank you.

[42:27] Kevin Jager: Of course. Well, you can follow us at Broadwaysted wherever you are on social media. Uh, find us also on our Facebook group. And then, of course, there's Patreon. Um, so you can do that. Um, in addition to that, um, wherever you get your podcasts, um, whether that is uh Spotify, Stitcher or Apple Podcasts, rate and review us there.

[42:49] Bryan Plovsky: Five stars. Thank you.

[42:53] Kevin Jager: Um, and then of course, we end every episode with a quote.

[42:55] Bryan Plovsky: We do.

[42:56] Kevin Jager: Yeah, it's just another manic Monday.

[42:58] Sandy Rustin: I wish it was Sunday because that's my fun day. My I don't have to run day.

[43:03] Bryan Plovsky: It's just another Manic Monday.

[43:06] Kevin Jager: I would also argue that Sundays are not like a fun day.

[43:11] Sandy Rustin: Uh, I would argue that Saturdays are the fun day, possibly.

[43:15] Bryan Plovsky: I agree. That like the prime time of the weekend is from like 9:30 Friday evening until like 3 p.m. Saturday.

[43:25] Kevin Jager: Like that's fair.

[43:27] Sandy Rustin: That's like the time when you're not thinking like work is looming at all. But like as you get into Saturday evening, you're like, no, I have to enjoy this because tomorrow is like the only buffer.

[43:36] Bryan Plovsky: Like it up with the Bangles.

[43:42] Kevin Jager: I know.

[43:43] Bryan Plovsky: I'm writing a strongly worded letter.

[43:50] Sandy Rustin: Um, cool. Well, thank you so much for joining us. Uh, where can we find you on social media?

[43:55] Sandy Rustin: Sure. Uh, on Instagram, I'm at Sandy Rustin with a little underscore after the N. Um, and that's pretty much the only social media I use. I think I have a Twitter account, I do have a Twitter account, and I do have a Facebook account, but I don't really go on those platforms too much. So Instagram sort of, and I have a website. It's just my name, sandyrustin.com.

[44:13] Bryan Plovsky: Fantastic. Well, thank you so much for joining us. As we end every episode, we raise a glass and we say, Zoot doers.

[44:22] Sandy Rustin: Oh, you did the national tour, you might actually know that. That's from the end of those magic changes.

[44:34] Bryan Plovsky: Oh.

[44:36] Sandy Rustin: And so after our very first episode in 2016, Bryan was like, and like, let's say Zooty Wa bum. And we were like, okay. And that's just become like our cheers for the past like seven years. It's a little dose of nostalgia to end your show.

[44:49] Bryan Plovsky: I love it.

[44:52] Sandy Rustin: Exactly. Uh, thank you again. We really appreciate it.

[44:56] Sandy Rustin: Thanks, you guys. This is my pleasure.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred